ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c <...

36
Chiral Imbalance in Heavy Ion collisions A.A. Andrianov NFQCD2018, Kyoto, YITP, 1.June 2018 1. Chiral charge generation 2. From initial stage to hadronization: chiral imbalance vacuum 3. Effective scalar and vector state lagrangians with chiral chemical potential 4. Direct observables of P(CP) parity breaking without E.-M. background 5. Shall / can we measure them? Sankt-Petersburg State University

Transcript of ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c <...

Page 1: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Chiral Imbalance in Heavy Ion collisions

A.A. Andrianov

NFQCD2018, Kyoto, YITP, 1.June 2018

1. Chiral charge generation

2. From initial stage to hadronization: chiral imbalance vacuum

3. Effective scalar and vector state lagrangianswith chiral chemical potential

4. Direct observables of P(CP) parity breaking without E.-M. background

5. Shall / can we measure them?

Sankt-Petersburg State University

Page 2: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

In search for local parity breaking in heavy ion collisions

, J.Bjorken

DETECTION: vector meson masses depending on their polarizationsA.A., V,A.Andrianov, D.Espriu, X.Planells, Phys. Lett. B 710 (2012) 230,Phys. Rev. D, 90 (2014), 034024)Polarization asymmetry in pion-gamma productionM. Kawaguchi, M. Harada, S. Matsuzaki, R. Ouyang , PHYS. REV. C 95, 065204 (2017) ……..(generalization in this talk)

Page 3: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Chiral imbalance

Induced chiral Imbalance

Page 4: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Or of less size!? (K.Fukushima, private communication)

Page 5: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)
Page 6: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

A.A., V,A.Andrianov, D.Espriu, X.Planells, Phys.Lett. B 710 (2012) 230

Topological vs. Chiral chemical potentials

Page 7: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

D.Kharzeev, L.McLerran, K.Fukushima, H.Warringa,…

Chiral magnetic effect

Page 8: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

!

Page 9: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Asymmetry comparison:STAR vs. PHENIX

Page 10: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

McLerran, Fukushima, Warringa; Voloshin….]

Etc. …..

Not in this talk!

Page 11: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Vector mesons FermionsScalars?

Split transversal polarizations in masses

= 0

Split positive and negative fermion helicities in masses

How to “measure” parity odd effects theoretically?Chiral chemical potential/chiral flow vector

Page 12: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

InitialStageAfter HI collision

Hadronization:phase with chiral imbalance inherited from quark vacuum

< 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c

Large chiral imbalance

Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Page 13: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

A.A., V,A.Andrianov, D.Espriu, X.Planells, Phys.Lett. B 710 (2012) 230

Topological vs.Chiral chemical potentials

Page 14: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)
Page 15: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Chiral chemicalpotential= time-component

of axial field

QCD inspired effective meson lagrangian (SU(2) case)current quark mass

pions

scalar mesons (isosingles + isotriplets)

Page 16: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Mass spectrum in vacuum

Take

Obtain

for

Page 17: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

mass matrixand

chiral condensate

Mass spectrum

Page 18: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

T = 0

T = 158 MeV

SU(2) effectiveLagrangianthis talk

NJL modelV.Braguta, A.Kotov.PRD, 93,105025(2016)

SU(2) QCDV.Braguta et alJHEP 06 (2015) 094)

In the above model quark condensate is governed by the decay constant v

Page 19: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Masses with chiral imbalance

When < 0

“tachyon” in flight

but no instability!

Page 20: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Effective masses of scalar and pseudoscalar states states

Massless “pions”at large chemical potentials

Page 21: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Mixing of scalars and pseudoscalars and their decays( depending on velocity )

k = 0 k = 1000 MeV

Page 22: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Decays with chiral imbalance: P-even vertices

Page 23: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Decays with chiral imbalance: P-even vertices

Page 24: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)
Page 25: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Wess-Zumino-Witten action

M. Kawaguchi, M. Harada, S. Matsuzakiand R. Ouyang, 1612.00616 [nucl-th].

More inspirations of chiral effects induced by WZW action see in:K.Fukuzhima and K.Mameda, Phys.Rev. D86 (2012) 071501

Page 26: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Decays with chiral imbalance: P-odd vertices

Page 27: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

M. Kawaguchi, M. Harada, S. Matsuzaki, R. Ouyang , PHYS. REV. C 95, 065204 (2017)

Our prediction:Scalar resonanceenhancement!

Page 28: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)
Page 29: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Effective meson theory in a medium with LPB

Page 30: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)
Page 31: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

More details in A.A., V.A. Andrianov’s, D. Espriu and X.Planells, Phys. Lett. B 684 (2010) 101; B 710 (2012) 230,…

Page 32: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)
Page 33: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Hints in dilepton excess?

Page 34: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Thus arises the question.

Can these effects somehow be registered in the experiments with heavy ion collisions and thereby assert about the existence of the local parity breaking phase?

(details see A.A. Andrianov, V. A. Andrianov, D. Espriu, and X. Planells, Phys. Rev. D, 90 (2014), 034024).

Page 35: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Observables sensitive to P-odd effects• We study the angular distributions for the polarizations in the mentioned

reactions when the angle between the two outgoing leptons in the decay of meson constrained with the laboratory frame.

In order to select the transverse polarizations in the spectrum, we will perform the different cuts for each angle and study the variations of the \rho (and \omega)- spectral function.

Page 36: ChiralImbalanceinHeavyIoncollisions A.A.Andrianovnfqcd2018/Slide/Andrianov.pdf · < 1 fm/c 1 fm/c < 7-10 fm/c Large chiralimbalance Vacuum quark-hadron continuity ( Fukushima talk!)

Conclusions and outlook

1. Topological charge fluctuations transmit their influence to hadron physics via axial chemical potential: in this way local parity breaking (LPB) occurs in hadron sector

2. LPB enhances dynamical chiral symmetry breaking in QCD:chiral condensates, critical temperature of chiral symmetry restoration are increasing with chiral chemical potential

3. Axial chemical potential triggers parity-odd condensation for large baryon chemical potential in first-order phase transitions (“chiralcatalysis”)

4. LPB modifies dispersion laws for scalar and vector mesons:lightest “pseudoscalar” mesons tend to massless states in flight, vector meson polarizations split with different in-flight masses

5. There are observables unambiguously indicating LPB (ALICE LHC?)