Children Unearthed

18
| Children Unearthed: The Inca Issue CHILDREN UNEARTHED The Incan Issue THE CHILDREN LEFT BEHIND: THE ROLE OF CHILDREN IN INCAN CULTURE Page 5 In this issue… THE CHILDREN OF THE CAPACOCHA:CHILD SACRIFICE Page 10 March 2012 WHAT CAN PHYSICAL EVIDENCE TELL US ABOUT THE LIVES OF CHILD MUMMIES? Page 15

description

This magazine takes a closer look at the child mummies found on top of Mount Lullaillaco. This magazine is looks at the children and why they ended up there from an archaeological perspective

Transcript of Children Unearthed

 

 |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  

 

CHILDREN  UNEARTHED    

The  Incan  Issue    

WHAT  CAN  PHYSICAL  EVIDENCE  TELL  US  

ABOUT  THE  LIVES  OF  CHILD  MUMMIES?    

Page  12  

THE  CHILDREN  LEFT  BEHIND:  THE  ROLE  OF  CHILDREN  IN  INCAN  CULTURE  

Page  5      

In  this  issue…  

THE  CHILDREN  OF  THE  CAPACOCHA:  CHILD  SACRIFICE  

Page  10    

March  2012  

Photo:  Giovanni    Paccaloni  

WHAT  CAN  PHYSICAL  EVIDENCE  TELL  US  

ABOUT  THE  LIVES  OF  CHILD  MUMMIES?    

Page  15  Photo:  Giovanni    Paccaloni  

 

 |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  

         

     

Image  Sources:  Cover  Image  

A  view  from  above  of  the  Andes  in  Peru.    Giovanni  Paccaloni.  Kathika:  Travel  Photo  of  the  Day  Peruvian  Andes.  Retrieved  March  18,  2012  from:  http://kathika.com/travel-­‐photo-­‐of-­‐

the-­‐day-­‐642009-­‐peruvian-­‐andes/  Images  on  next  page  

1.  The  location  of  the  highest  archaeological  site  in  the  world,  Mount  Llullaillaco.    Kim  MacQuarrie.  Kim  MacQuarrie’s  Peru  &  South  America  Blog.  Retrieved  March  18,  2012  from:  http://lastdaysoftheincas.com/wordpress/?attachment_id=195    2.  A  gold  camelid  uncovered  with  The  Llullaillaco  Boy;  he  was  sacrificed  at  age  seven  and  his  remains  are  approximately  500  years  old.    Museo  de  Arqueologia  de  Alta  Montana.  New  York  Times:  Children  of  the  Cold.  Retrieved  March  18,  2012  from:  http://www.nytimes.com/slideshow/2007/09/10/science/20070911_MUMMY_SLIDESHOW_7.html    

 

CHILDREN  UNEARTHED:  The  Incan  Issue  March  2012    

 

 |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  

Contents    

 Editor’s  Note  ………..Page  4    The  Children  Left  Behind…………………Page  5    The  Capacocha……..Page  10  Exploring  the  involvement  of  children  in  ancient  Inca  ritual    Traces  of  Life:............Page  15  What  can  physical  evidence  tell  us  about  the  lives  of  child  mummies?      

 

 |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  

   

 It’s  been  another  terrific  month  here  at  Children  

Unearthed,  and  we’ve  been  working  hard  to  bring  you  

our  latest  edition:  the  Inca  issue!  As  always,  we  try  to  

thoroughly  explore  the  contribution  of  children  to  the  

societies  of  the  past,  while  keeping  our  minds  critical,  

and  not  jumping  to  conclusions.  As  archaeologists  the  

world  over  know  all  too  well,  evidence  can  often  be  

interpreted  in  many  ways.  It  is  important  to  keep  our  

minds  open  to  even  the  most  improbable  possibilities,  

especially  when  it  comes  to  interpreting  the  remains  of  

children,  whose  societal  roles  are  not  always  clear  from  

their  burials.  

  This  issue  is  dedicated  entirely  to  the  exploration  

of  the  Incas.  The  Incan  Empire  was  a  fascinating  society  

that  spanned  many  South  American  countries  prior  to  

the  arrival  of  the  Spanish  colonists.  What  makes  this  

culture  fascinating  for  our  purposes  is  not  just  the  role  

of  children  in  Incan  society,  but  also  their  role  in  a  

captivating  ritual,  the  Capacocha.  In  this  issue  we  will  

explore  how  the  Incas  values  children  in  their  culture  

and  investigate  why  specific  children  were  chosen  for  

the  ritual,  as  well  as  take  a  look  at  some  of  the  evidence  

from  one  of  the  best  preserved  Capacocha  sites,  the  

summit  of  Mount  Llullaillaco.    

  We  hope  that  you  enjoy  reading  this  issue  of  

Children  Unearthed  as  much  as  we  enjoyed  putting  it  

together.  Happy  studies!    

 

-­‐  Katie, Annelise and Taylor    

Editor’s note…

 

 |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  

       

   

       

By: Annelise Milliken

The Children Left Behind

Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue    6  

lthough  they  are  found  often  and  make  up  a  large  percentage  of  the  archaeological  record  

children  are  often  not  studied  beyond  what  they  are  found  with  and  what  the  archaeological  record  shows  us.  Children  play  a  pivotal  role  in  growing  cultures  and  societies.  How  they  are  treated  may  not  be  shown  in  their  grave,  tell  us  how  they  are  buried  and  what  they  were  buried  with  and  this  can  show  us  the  importance  of  them  in  the  culture.  It  is  said  that  children  are  significant  social  and  economic  actors  in  their  own  right  and  that  the  organization  of  families,  communities,  and  societies  often  prioritize  the  care  and  training  of  children1.  Why  is  there  such  a  an  absence  of  children  in  the  archaeological  record,  leaving  us  to  only  make  educated  guesses  as  to  how  they  were  treated  and  used?  This  is  notable  specifically  for  the  Incan  population,  as  we  do  not  have  much  left  behind  because  there  was  no  written  record  to  tell  us  what  life  was  like,  before  the  Spanish  explorers  had  taken  their  land.  Much  of  what  we  do  have  are  Spanish  accounts  of  what  they  found  when  they  arrived  on  Incan  land.  They  may  not  have  had  the  proper  technologies  and  understandings  that  we  have  now  to  take  proper  account  of  this  unknown  culture.  While  the  Spanish  are  incompetent,  times  have  changed  since  1515.    

Children  played  a  significant  role  in  Incan  societies.  The  Incan  culture,  like  most,  valued  their  children  and  what  they  offered  to  their  family  and  society.  As  a  predominantly  agricultural  society,  the  Incans  loved  having  the  extra  set  of  hands  to  do  the  work,  and  they  

spent  a  lot  of  their  time  farming  and  producing  food  for  themselves  as  well  as  to  sell  and  trade.  The  whole  family  worked  to  produce  as  much  as  they  could  for  themselves  and  their  community.  The  boys,  however  are  not  as  important  in  Incan  culture  as  they  are  in  others.  The  production  of  daughters  was  seen  as  a  desirable  cultural  goal  for  everyone.  Holding  women  highly  in  their  culture,  as  a  matrilineal  society,  the  Incas  spent  a  lot  of  time  with  the  mother’s  side  of  the  family2.    Inca  women  were  given  in  marriage  to  provincial  elites,  giving  the  community  a  leg  up  on  others3.  They  were  seen  as  political  capital3.  The  bigger  the  family  the  more  land  to  cultivate  pleasing  the  community  and  the  Gods.  The  government  encouraged  them  to  have  more  children  and  rewarded  them  for  it  with  more  land  to  cultivate4.  This  is  just  one  of  the  many  roles  that  children  played  in  Incan  culture.  

 

 

A

Modern  Incan  Children  dressed  in  traditional  clothing;  Source  2  &  Source  1  

The Children Left Behind

Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue     7  

The  other  is  for  ritual  and  child  sacrifice.  The  Capacocha  is  a  ritual  that  the  Inca  practiced,  sacrificing  their  most  physically  beautiful  children.  They  were  dressed  and  adorned  and  treated  to  the  feasts  and  then  sacrificed  by  500  priests5.  The  children  were  sometimes  buried  with  miniature  objects  and  figurines  that  were  identically  dressed  like  the  children  themselves.  They  were  also  buried  with  ceramics  such  as  bowls  that  would  have  been  used  for  feasting5.    According  to  the  Inca  the  more  precious  the  sacrifice  the  more  likely  the  gods  were  to  respond4.    

he  current  interpretations  used  to  discuss  the  material  culture  found  and  the  life  ways  of  the  Inca  seem  to  be  one  sided;  the  children  are  raised  to  help  the  family  and  community  through  

agricultural  production.  If  you  were  able  bodied  you  would  be  put  to  work  to  please  the  gods  and  help  the  poor4.  None  of  these  interpretations  consider  that  the  children  could  be  produced  for  child  sacrifice.  It  is  true  and  incredibly  practical  that  could  be  children  are  produced  for  the  production  of  agriculture.  It  would  help  the  community  produce  higher  quantities  of  food  in  order  to  feed  the  growing  community  and  the  surrounding  communities.  However,  is  it  possible  that  the  reason  why  some  children  are  produced  specifically  for  the  inevitable  sacrifice?  There  is  a  

very  good  possibility  that  the  children  chosen  for  these  rituals  may  have  been  made  for  it.  Did  you  ever  think  it  is  possible  that  pairing  up  a  good-­‐looking  man  and  women  would  make  an  extremely  physically  beautiful  child,  producing  them  solely  for  the  purpose  of  the  Inca  ritual?  I  think  there  is  a  good  possibility  that  this  could  have  been  the  reason  that  so  many  children  were  produced.  If  they  were  not  chosen  for  sacrifice  they  could  be  

married  away  to  gain  political  capital.  It  may  seem  like  a  morbid  reason  for  producing  children  but  nowadays  we  can  genetically  modify  fertilized  eggs  to  have  the  traits  that  we  want  them  too  therefore,  why  not  try  and  produce  a  beautiful  child  to  be  seen  if  

 

 

T

Treasures  left  Behind  Some  of  the  many  Inca  items  found  with  the  children  at  Mount  Llullaillaco.  Pots  used  in  rituals,  figurines  and  bags  for  the  Gods  above.  Source;  3,  4,  5  

The Children Left Behind

Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue    8  

they  get  chosen.  Couples  were  rewarded  for  having  the  most  beautiful  child  chosen  to  be  part  of  the  sacrifice,  so  why  not  try.  It  is  apparent  that  children  were  used  in  more  innovative  ways  then  we  may  think  they  are  in  our  culture.  Not  only  are  they  handy  to  do  some  extra  plowing  to  cultivate  land  but  also  they  can  be  used  for  much  more  than  that.    

 This  idea  is  one  we  may  never  

be  able  to  tell  from  the  material  culture  found  at  the  burials,  nor  something  we  can  find  on  the  bodies  of  the  individuals  buried.  Even  with  that  we  may  never  find  a  written  record  of  what  went  on  behind  the  closed  doors  of  the  Inca.            References:    1.  Baxter,  J.  (2008).  The  archaeology  of  childhood.  Annual  Review  of  Anthropology,  37(1),  159-­‐175.  doi:10.1146/annurev.anthro.37.081407.085129    2.  Yaya,  I.  (2008).  The  importance  of  initiatory  ordeals:  Kinship  and  politics  in  an  inca  narrative.  Ethnohistory,  55(1),  51-­‐85.  doi:10.1215/00141801-­‐2007-­‐046      3.  Malpass,  M.  A.  (2009).  Daily  life  in  the  inca  empire.  Westport,  Conn:  Greenwood  Press.      4.  Hughes,  J.  D.  (1999).  Conservation  in  the  inca  empire.  Capitalism  Nature  Socialism,  10(4),  69-­‐76.  doi:10.1080/10455759909358886      5.  Andrushko,  V.  A.,  Buzon,  M.  R.,  Gibaja,  A.  M.,  McEwan,  G.  F.,  Simonetti,  A.,  &  Creaser,  R.  A.  (2011).  Investigating  a  child  sacrifice  event  from  the  inca  heartland.  Journal  of  Archaeological  Science,  38(2),  323-­‐333.  doi:10.1016/j.jas.2010.09.009                    

       Images:    1.  N, J. (Producer). (2009). Incredible inca. [Web Photo]. Retrieved from http://www.justfoodnow.com/2009/02/26/incredible-inca/  2.  Gilbert, J. (Photographer). (2012). Children in traditional dress. [Web Photo]. Retrieved from http://www.worldisround.com/articles/3352/photo3.html 3. Stenzel , M. (Photographer). (n.d.). 661811. [Web Photo]. Retrieved from http://www.nationalgeographicstock.com/ngsimages/explore/explorecomp.jsf?xsys=SE&id=661811 4. Stenzel, M. (Photographer). (n.d.). 661817. [Web Photo]. Retrieved from http://www.nationalgeographicstock.com/ngsimages/explore/explorecomp.jsf?xsys=SE&id=661817 5. (2010). Chachapoya mummies. (2010). [Web Photo]. Retrieved from http://darkdissolution.blogspot.ca/2010/05/mummys-day.html 6. Holliday, R. (Photographer). (2008). The grown-up gapper: a fit of escapism. [Web Photo]. Retrieved from http://www.telegraph.co.uk/travel/hubs/gapyear/2596054/The-grown-up-gapper-a-fit-of-escapism.html  

 

Modern  day  Gapper  Girls,  Source:  6  

The Children Left Behind

Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue     9  

 

The  15-­‐year-­‐old  “Llullaillaco  Maiden”  was  sacrificed  Source:  1  pg  14    

 

 

 

 

 

Source:  6,  pg  14  

Source:  2  pg  14  

Source:  3,  pg  14  

 

Source:5,  pg  14  

 

Source:  7,  pg  14  

 

Source:  8,  pg  14  Source:  9,  pg  14  

Figurines  found  with  child  mnummies  Source:  4,  pg  14  

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  10  

associated  with  the  Incan  

 

 

The  Children  of  the  Capacocha:  

Exploring  the  involvement  of  children  in  an  ancient  Incan  ritual  

 By  Katherine  Colwell  

 

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue   11  

Capacocha  ritual  had  captivated  both  professional  and  amateur  archaeologists,  including  myself,  since  the  first  one  was  discovered  at  the  end  of  the  19th  century.  To  date  less  than  twenty  Capacocha  sites  have  been  found,  but  since  many  are  on  high  altitude,  rarely  traveled  mountain  summits,  it  is  possible  that  more  exist  and  just  have  not  been  discovered  yet.  While  many  details  of  the  ritual  remain  unknown,  modern  dating  techniques  and  Spanish  colonial  documents  have  helped  to  shed  some  light  on  this  fascinating,  and,  to  some,  shocking,  custom.  What  has  not  been  adequately  addressed  in  the  literature,  however,  is  why  children  were  chosen  as  sacrifices  in  this  ritual.       When  discussing  the  Incan  Capacocha  it  is  important  to  clarify  that  child  sacrifice  was  not  as  common  to  the  Incas  as  it  was  to  the  Aztecs,  nor  was  it  a  defining  part  of  their  culture3.  The  Capacocha  was  an  important  religious  and  political  event  which  involved  the  ritual  sacrifice  of  animals,  objects  and  occasionally  children  3.  It  appears  that  the  ritual  had  both  religious  and  political  importance.    

Through  both  neuron  activation  analysis  of  the  pottery  found  with  the  mummies3  and  stable  isotope  analysis  of  the  mummies’  hair5,  it  has  been  determined  that  many  children  were  not  killed  in  the  regions  where  they  grew  up.  There  are  exceptions  to  this,  but  the  majority  of  children  who  were  killed  in  the  Capacocha  were  first  taken  to  Cuzco,  an  important  city,  now  in  modern  day  Peru.  Here  great  feasting  took  place  before  the  children  were  moved  again,  to  the  corners  of  the  empire  where  they  would  be  sacrificed3.  This  

movement  of  children  throughout  the  vast  empire  may  have  served  to  both  unite  and  differentiate  its  different  regions3.    This  would  have  been  part  of  the  political  importance  of  the  ritual.    

Another  main  source  of  information  of  the  ritual  is  the  account  of  the  Spanish  chroniclers,  but  these  reports  are  often  conflicting3.  Some  say  that  the  ritual  took  place  once  a  year,  to  ask  for  good  crops  and  good  health  of  the  Inca4.  In  these  cases,  the  children  would  serve  as  messengers  from  the  empire  to  the  Gods.  Others  reports  suggest  that  the  sacrifices  took  place  during  times  of  celebration,  such  as  the  birth  of  a  royal  son  or  the  passing  on  of  an  Inca3.  According  to  one  of  the  Spanish  accounts,  Emperor  Pachacuti  ordered  that  a  Capacocha  be  carried  out  as  part  of  his  funerary  ceremony.  The  emperor  wanted  a  thousand  children  from  across  the  empire  to  be  ritually  buried  as  a  married  couple  so  that  they  could  serve  him  in  the  afterlife  1.  It  has  been  suggested  that  all  Capacocha  rituals  involved  children  interred  as  married  couples,  though  this  does  not  appear  to  always  be  the  case1.  We  can  logically  assume  from  these  accounts  that  there  were  varied  meanings  behind  and  reasons  for  the  Capacocha,  which  could  explain  the  variation  in  the  ritual  burials.  However  it  took  place,  the  ritual  seemed  to  serve  as  a  way  of  connecting;  connecting  all  of  the  people  of  the  far  reaching  Inca  Empire  to  each  other,  as  well  as  to  the  Gods  that  they  worshipped3.    

The  site  of  Llullaillco,  in  modern  day  Argentina,  is  one  of  the  best  preserved  Capacocha  sites,  and  is  the  highest  archaeological  site  in  the  

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  12  

world4.    Discovered  in  1995  and      

   

   excavated  by  Johan  Reinhard  and  Constanza  Ceruti,  this  site  contained  three  mummies:  a  young  boy,  a  young  girl  and  female  who  seemed  to  have  been  around  fifteen  years  old,  and  is  often  referred  to  as  the  ‘Llullaillaco  Maiden’4.  It  is  thought  that  she  was  a  ‘chosen  maiden’,  an  Inca  girl  taken  from  her  home  at  a  young  age  and  raised  in  an  acllahuasis,  a  special  institution.  These  girls  were  raised  to  be  priestesses,  wives  of  special  nobles  or  human  Capacocha  sacrifices4.  It  was  the  frozen  temperatures  found  at  such  a  high  altitude  that  preserved  the  bodies  so  well.  This  sight  is  famous  because  of  the  exceptional  preservation,  and  interesting  because  of  the  presence  of  the  maiden.  

What  is  interesting  about  the  literature  surrounding  the  mummified  Capacocha  victims  is  that  very  little  attention  is  paid  to  why  children  were  selected  for  sacrifice  over  adults.  Many  articles  address  why  those  children  were  chosen:  they  were  the  children  of  nobles,  and  also  physically  perfect3.  But  why  were  perfect  children  selected  instead  of  perfect  

adults?  Also,  very  little  is  said  about  why  some  sacrifices  were  so  young  (two  of  the  Llullaillaco  victims  were  under  ten4),  and  why  some  were  ‘chosen  women’  (like  the  third  Llullaillaco  victim).  By  age  fifteen  this  maiden  would  probably  have  been  capable  of  bearing  children,  meaning  she  was  no  longer  a  child  herself.    

Were  children  just  selected  because  of  their  virginal  status?  This  is  a  possible  explanation.  But  if  it  were  the  case  then  why  not  sacrifice  mostly  adolescent  virgins,  such  as  the  ‘chosen  maidens’?  Why  were  there  no  ‘chosen  young  men’?  Why  did  the  virgins  have  to  be  so  young?  This  explanation  for  child  sacrifice  doesn’t  seem  sufficient  in  my  eyes.    

Another  possible  explanation  is  that  adults  made  more  of  a  contribution  to  the  economy  than  children,  and  so  loosing  a  child  was  less  devastating  economically  than  loosing  an  adult.  I  think  that  this  explanation  is  valid,  but  somewhat  under  developed.  The  contributions  that  children  make  to  a  culture  are  often  not  economical  in  nature;  instead  they  may  be  more  cultural  or  symbolic2.  Unfortunately,  these  nuances  of  a  culture  do  not  always  show  up  in  the  archaeological  record.    I  think  that  children  may  have  been  chosen  not  because  of  they  didn’t  make  a  specific  contribution,  but  rather  because  they  did  make  a  different  one.    

I  would  argue  that  the  most  convincing  argument  for  child  sacrifice  is  that  the  Incas  believed  children  to  be  closer  to  the  Gods  than  adults,  perhaps  because  they  were  closer  to  birth.  According  to  Jane  Baxter,  children  were  seen  as  being  special  in  the  Incan  culture  because  

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue   13  

they  played  with  toys.  It  was  an  Incan  belief  that  humans  learned  through  play,  and  what  they  learned  came  from  the  Gods  2.  Because  children  still  played  with  toys,  perhaps  they  were  seen  as  having  a  closer  connection  with  the  Gods.  They  were  fit  to  be  messengers  because  they  interacted  with  the  Gods  on  a  daily  basis  through  play.  The  chosen  maidens  were  taught  by  priestesses  to  prepare  special  ritual  beverages4,  which  undoubtedly  made  them  more  sacred  in  the  eyes  of  the  Inca  people.  They  were  fit  to  be  sacrifices,  although  they  were  no  longer  children,  because  of  their  ritual  knowledge,  which,  according  to  Inca  culture,  would  have  been  given  to  them  by  the  deities.    

It  is  often  difficult  to  interpret  the  ritual  traditions  of  a  culture  based  solely  on  materials  obtained  from  the    archaeological  record,  and  while  we  do  have  some  Spanish  accounts  of  the    Capacocha,  these  accounts  were  made  by  outsiders,  who  may  not  have  completely  understood  it.  I  do  not  think  it  is  fair  to  assume  that  children  virginal  or  because  they  made  less  economic  contributions  to  society.  I  

think  that  the  reason  is  more  complex  than  that.      

 

   I  believe  that  children  were  selected  for  this  ritual,  instead  of  nobles  or  priests,  because  they  were  seen  as  having  special  knowledge,  knowledge  that  was  learned  through  play.  The  Inca’s  believed  that  children  were  more  fit  than  adults  to  be  messengers  to  the  Gods.  Every  culture  has  a  unique  view  of  childhood,  and  this  is  important  to  consider  when  analyzing  rituals  such  as  the  Capacocha.    

 

       

     

                         

Figure  2:.  Human  and  llama  figurines  found  at  another  child  burial  site.  Source:  1.    

Figure  3:  Above:  a  set  of  llama  figurines  found  with  the  young  boy  at  the  Llullaillco  site.  Source:  4.    

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  14  

Reference:      1.  Andrushko,  V.  A.,  Buzon,  M.  R.,  Gibaja,  A.  M.,  

McEwan,  G.  F.,  Simonetti,  A.,  &  Creaser,  R.  A.  (2011).  Investigating  a  child  sacrifice  event  in  the  Inca  heartland.  Journal  or  Archaeological  Science,  38(2),  323-­‐333.    

 2.  Baxter,  J.  E.  (2008).  The  archaeology  of  childhood.  Annual  (2012).  ice  mummies.  (2012).  [Web  Photo].  Retrieved  from  http://www.natgeoprogramming.com/pages/inflight/search/genre/CivilisationsHistory/order/titlesort-­‐asc/prinflight/1/d//page/9      

Review  of  Anthropology,  37(1),  159-­‐175.      

3.  Bray,  T.  L.,  Minc,  L.  D.,  Ceruti.  M.  C.,  Chávez,  J.  A.,  Perea,  R.,  &  Reinhard,  J.  (2005).  A  compositional  analysis  of  pottery  vessels  associated  with  the  Inca  ritual  of  capacocha.  Journal  of  Anthropological  Archaeology,  24(1),  82-­‐100.      

4.  Ceruti,  C.  (2004).  Human  bodies  as  objects  of  dedication  at  Inca  mountain  shrines  (north-­‐western  Argentina).  World  Archaeology,  36(1),  103-­‐122.    

 5.  Wilson,  A.  S.,  Taylor,  T.,  Ceruti,  M.  C.,  Chavez,  

J.  A.,  Reinhard,  J.,  Grimes,  V.,  …  Gilbert,  M.  T.  (2007).  Stable  Isotope  and  DNA  evidence  for  ritual  sequences  in  Inca  child  sacrifice.  Proceedings  of  the  National  Academy  of  Sciences  of  the  United  States  of  America,  104(42),  16456-­‐1      Editorial  Images    1.  MacQuarrie, K. (Photographer). (2007). Inca girl, frozen for 500 years, now on display. [Web Photo]. Retrieved from http://lastdaysoftheincas.com/wordpress/?p=194 2. (2012).  ice  mummies.  (2012).  [Web  Photo].  Retrieved  from  http://www.natgeoprogramming.com/pages/inflight/search/genre/CivilisationsHistory/order/titlesort-­‐asc/prinflight/1/d//page/9        3.  WGBH  Educational  Foundation.  (Photographer).  (2011).  The  sacrificial  ceremony.  [Web  Photo].  Retrieved  from  http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ancient/sacrificial-­‐ceremony.html        4.  (2011).  Mummies  of  the  andes,  a  glimpse  into  the  past.  (2011).  [Web  Photo].  Retrieved  from  http://perudiscover.com/blog/juanita-­‐mummies-­‐of-­‐the-­‐andes/      5.  Stenzel,  M.  (Photographer).  (2008).  Retrieved  from  photography.nationalgeographic.com        6.  Openshaw,  C.  (Photographer).  (2011).  Ice  mummies  of  the  inca.  [Web  Photo].  Retrieved from  http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ancient/ice-­‐mummies-­‐inca.html      7.  Reinhard,  J.  (Photographer).  (2006).  High-­altitude  anthropoloist.  [Web  Photo].  Retrieved  from  

http://www.rolexawards.com/en/the-­‐laureates/johangjefsenreinhard-­‐the-­‐project.jsp        8.  Taylor,  H.  (Photographer).  (2011).  Explorer  v.  [Web  Photo].  Retrieved  from  http://www.alepisaball.com/child-­‐mummy-­‐sacrifice/explorer-­‐v-­‐child-­‐mummy-­‐sacrificengcus-­‐ep-­‐code-­‐4084-­‐3/        9.  (2012).  Land  of  winds.  (2012).  [Web  Photo].  Retrieved  from  http://landofwinds.blogspot.ca/2011/10/chilean-­‐andes.html      

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue   15  

 TRACES  OF  LIFE:  WHAT  CAN  PHYSICAL  EVIDENCE    

TELL  US  ABOUT  THE  LIVES    OF  CHILD  MUMMIES?  

 

Radiologic  Evidence  of  cranial  deformation  in  The  Llullaillaco  Lighting  Girl.  Source:  1  

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  16  

 Even  in  death,  people  speak  volumes.  Living  life  results  in  the  build  up  and  formation  of  many  compounds  and  characteristics  which,  when  analyzed  after  death,  can  tell  stories  about  how  individuals  led  their  lives,  where  they  lived,  and  how  they  died.  Advanced  analytic  technologies  such  as  CT  scans,  radiologic  evaluation  and  isotopic  analysis  provide  invaluable  insight  into  the  lives  of  child  mummies  who  were  sacrificed.    

The  high,  cold  peaks  of  the  Andes  have  resulted  in  the  excellent  preservation  of  excavated  children  who  were  ceremoniously  sacrificed1.  The  three  child  mummies  found  at  the  archaeological  site  of  highest  elevation  in  the  world  at  the  summit  of  Mount  Llullaillaco  are  a  great  example  of  this  extensive  preservation1.  Two  female  children  and  one  male  child  were  found  in  pit  tombs  at  the  shrine  on  this  volcano1.  These  individuals  have  acquired  nicknames:  the  oldest  female  (15  years  of  age)  is  known  as  The  Llullailaco  Maiden,  the  second  female  (six  years  of  age)  is  called  The  Llullaillaco  Lightening  Girl,  and  the  male  (seven  years  of  age)  is  known  as  The  Llullailaco  Boy2.  Extensive  radiologic  evaluation  as  well  as  isotope  and  DNA  analysis  was  performed  on  these  children1,  2.  These  three  individuals  were  so  well  preserved  that,  among  other  information  obtained,  radiologic  evaluation  revealed  brain  tissue,  organs  and  even  feces  within  their  intestines1.  Another  15  year  old  female  was  recovered  on  the  Andean  volcano,  Sara  Sara  2.  This  girl  was  named  Sarita,    

 

and  isotope  and  DNA  analysis  was  conducted  on  her  remains  in  the  same  fashion  as  was  done  to  the  Llullaillaco  children2.    The  Evidence:  What  can  it  tell  us?  • CT  Scans  

CT  Scans  can  reveal  bone  and  soft  tissues1.These  soft  tissues  include  white  and  gray  brain  matter,  fatty  body  tissues,  the  lungs,  aorta,  heart,  liver,  kidney,  pancreas,  intestines,  genital  organs  and  feces1.  Air  pockets  such  as  those  in  the  lungs  and  sinuses  may  also  be  seen  using  CT  scans1.    • Radiographs  

Radiographs  can  be  used  to  reveal  osteological  data,  including  dental  and  cranial  features1.  Dentition  can  be  used  to  estimate  age,  and  characteristics  such  as  wear  and  cavities  can  provide  insight  into  diet1.  By  analyzing  dentition,  information  about  an  individuals’  childhood  nutrition  and  thus  their  environment  can  be  obtained,  as  it  is  during  childhood  that  the  enamel  is  formed  and  remains  for  the  extent  of  one’s  life2.  As  compared  to  teeth,  bone  may  reflect  more  recent  evidence,  as  it  is  turned  over  throughout  life2.  Additionally,  Radiographs  can  help  determine  age  by  measuring  long  bones,  and  nutrition  by  looking  for  the  presence  of  Harris  lines,  which  occur  on  the  bones  due  to  lack  of  nutrients1.    

The  Maiden:  A  fifteen  year  old  female  found  on  Mount  Llullaillaco.  Source:  3.  

Traces  of  Life:    

What  can  physical  evidence  tell  us  about  the  lives  of  child  mummies?  By  Taylor  Watson    

 

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue   17  

                     

• Hair  Growing  an  average  of  1cm  a  month,  hair  

from  the  scalp  provides  an  account  of  the  past  because  each  section  of  a  strand  reflects  the  nutrition  present  at  the  time  when  it  was    being  formed2.  In  the  cases  of  Sarita,  The  Llullaillaco  Maiden,  The  Llullaillaco  Lightning  Girl  and  The  Llullaillaco  Boy,  hair  from  their  scalps  was  analyzed2.  Hair  can  be  analyzed  for  DNA  as  well  as  stable  isotopes  such  as  carbon,  nitrogen,  sulfur,  oxygen  and  hydrogen2.    The  Llullaillaco  Maiden  

CT  scans  revealed  that  there  were  feces  in  The  Maiden’s  intestines,  indicating  that  she  was  well  fed  in  the  hours  before  her  death1.  This  could  be  indicative  of  the  ceremonies  performed  surrounding  the  sacrifice.  Scans  also  showed  this  individual’s  uterus,  as  well  as  many  other  organs1.  An  abnormality  was  observed  in  the  upper  right  lung,  and  it  is  suggested  that  this  may  have  been  constrictive  bronchiolitis,  perhaps  caused  by  the  long  pilgrimage  to  the  top  of  Mount  Llullaillaco1.  Radiography  revealed  no  Harris  lines  as  well  as  good  muscle  and  fat  volume,  indicating  good  quality  nutrition1.  It  is  often  suggested  that  high  quality  nutrition  implies  high  social  status,  and  this  could  be  the  case  with  The  Maiden1.  Carbon  4  and  Nitrogen  levels  analyzed  from  scalp  hair  point  to  a  drastic  change  in  diet  beginning  about  a  year  before  death2.  This  change  indicated  an  increase  in  animal  protein  and  maize-­‐like  plants,  which  may  have  meant  a  diet  shift  from  peasant  to  high  status2.  This  implies  that,  on  some  level,  the  rituals  and  preparation  for  the  sacrifice  began  at  least  one  year  in  advance2.  Oxygen  and  Hydrogen  isotopes  from  scalp  hair  indicate  that  there  was  a  temperature  and  altitude  shift  soon  before  death,  and  this  may  have  been  due  to  the  pilgrimage  up  the  volcano2.  Analysis  of  the  remains  showed  that  there  was  no  apparent  cranial  trauma  or  evidence  of  strangulation  and  it  is  suggested  that  she  died  due  to  asphyxiation  or  was  buried  alive1.    

     

The  Llullaillaco  Lightning  Girl  As  with  The  Maiden,  CT  scans  and  

radiography  revealed  many  organs,  feces  in  the  intestines,  no  Harris  lines,  good  amounts  of  muscle  and  fat  and  no  cranial  trauma  or  strangulation1.  Therefore  it  can  be  inferred  that,  like  The  Maiden,  the  Lightning  Girl  was  fed  recently  before  death,  had  high  quality  nutrition  and  therefore  was  possibly  of  high  status,  and  likely  died  of  asphyxiation  or  was  buried  alive1.  Likely  as  a  result  of  the  pilgrimage,  isotopes  indicated  a  change  in  elevation  and  temperature  before  death2.  CT  scans  also  showed  a  disruption  in  the  left  side  of  her  chest.  This,  combined  with  observations  of  burnt  skin  and  clothing,  led  archaeologists  to  believe  that  this  young  girl  had  been  struck  by  lighting  sometime  after  death1,  hence  where  her  nickname  comes  from2.  Additionally,  radiography  indicates  that  toothwear  was  present  in  this  individual,  which  may  be  attributed  to  maize  consumption  or  teeth  grinding1.  Radiologic  analysis  of  the  cranium  of  The  Lightning  Girl  suggests  cranial  deformation,  providing  insight  into  Andean  culture1.  Cranial  deformations  may  have  been  an  effort  to  replicate  the  shape  of  volcanoes  in  the  heads  of  members  of  the  society1.  Cranial  deformation  may  be  a  further  indicator  of  high  social  status  in  this  sacrificed  child.    

 

The  Llullaillaco  Lightning  Girl,  found  on  Mount  Llullaillaco,  was  likely  struck  by  lightning  after  death.  Source:  5.    

Children  of  The  Capachoca  

           |  Children  Unearthed:  The  Inca  Issue  18  

 

to  her  death2.  This  could  be  because  foods  like  maize  may  have  been  stored  along  the  route  of  pilgrimage,  which  would  have  fed  the  people  on  their  long  trek2.  It  has  been  determined  that  Sarita  suffered  a  blow  to  the  head,  which  was  likely  the  cause  of  her  death2.       When  combined  with  radiologic  evaluation,  isotopic  and  DNA  evidence,  impressive  preservation  due  to  natural  

mummification  can  provide  many  insights  into  the  lives  of  child  mummies.  This  data  provides  a  base  from  which  many  interpretations  can  be  drawn.  However,  it  is  important  to  remember  that  interpretations  are  just  that:  assumptions  based  on  our  own  knowledge  and  experience.  Even  with  advanced  scientific  methods,  we  are  left  merely  with  traces  of  life  from  the  past.References:  1.  Previgliano,  C.  H.  et  al.,  2003.  Radiological  evaluation  of  the  Llullaillaco  mummies.  American  Journal  of  Roentgenology,  181  (6),  pp.  1473-­‐1479.    2.  Wilson,  A.S.,  Taylor,  T.,  Cerutic,  M.  C.,  Chavezd,  J.A.,  Reinharde,  J.,  Grimes,  V.,  

Meier-­‐Augenstein,  W.,  Cartmell,  L.,  Stern,  B.,  Richards,  M.P.,  Worobey,  M.,  Barnes,  I.,  Gilbert,  M.T.P.,  2007.  Stable  isotope  and  DNA  evidence  for  ritual  sequences  in  Inca  child  sacrifice.  Proceedings  of  the  National  Academy  of  Sciences,  104(42),  pp.16456-­‐16461.    Images  3.  Museo  de  Arqueologia  de  Alta  Montana.  New  York  Times:  Children  of  the  Cold.  Retrieved  March  18,  2012  from:  http://www.nytimes.com/slideshow/2007/09/10/science/20070911_MUMMY_SLIDESHOW_2.html    4.  Liesl  Clark.  Sarita’s  Land:  A  Panoramic  View.  Retrieved  March  18,  2012  from:  http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/peru/mummies/panorama1.html    5.  Museo  de  Arqueologia  de  Alta  Montana.  New  York  Times:  Children  of  the  Cold.  Retrieved  March  18,  2012  from:  http://www.nytimes.com/slideshow/2007/09/10/science/20070911_MUMMY_SLIDESHOW_4.html  6.    Museo  de  Arqueologia  de  Alta  Montana.  New  York  Times:  Children  of  the  Cold.  Retrieved  March  18,  2012  from:  http://www.nytimes.com/slideshow/2007/09/10/science/20070911_MUMMY_SLIDESHOW_3.html              

The  Llullaillaco  Boy  As  with  The  Maiden  and  The  Lightning  

Girl,  analysis  of  The  Llullaillaco  Boy  displayed  many  organs,  feces  in  the  intestines,  no  Harris  lines,  a  healthy  volume  of  muscle  and  fat  and  no  cranial  trauma  or  strangulation1.  As  with  the  other  two  individuals  from  the  Llullaillaco  site,  this  data  implies  that  he  may  have  been  of  high  status  and  that  he  likely  died  of  asphyxiation  or  live  burial1.  A  marked  increase  of  Oxygen  and  Hydrogen  isotopes  was  discovered  from  the  one  year  of  hair  growth  on  the  boy,  indicating  change  in  altitude,  as  with  The  Maiden  and  The  Lightning  Girl2.  CT  scans  also  revealed  the  penis  of  this  child1.  Similarly  to  The  Lightning  Girl,  radiography  performed  on  this  individual  showed  tooth  wear  and  cranial  deformation,  allowing  a  diet  of  maize  or  simply  tooth  grinding,  as  well  as  high  status  to  be  inferred1.    Sarita     CT  scans  and  radiologic  evaluation  were  not  conducted  on  Sarita1,  as  was  done  for  the  other  three  individuals.  However,  based  on  hair  analysis  it  was  found  that  Nitrogen  levels,  which  indicate  proportions  of  plant  and  meat  consumption,  fluctuated  seasonally  for  this  individual2.  As  with  the  Llullaillaco  mummies,  Hydrogen  and  Oxygen  isotopes  had  increased  shortly  before  death,  displaying  a  change  in  elevation  likely  due  to  the  long  trek  involved  with  the  sacrificial  ceremony2.  An  increase  in  Carbon  4  was  detected,  implying  that  she  consumed  more  lower-­‐altitude  plants  such  as  Maize  leading  up