Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike...

49
Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen

Transcript of Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike...

Page 1: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment

Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen

Page 2: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Outline of Workshop

Introduction to Binoculars

What is collimation?

Simple checks

Methods of adjustment

Methods of checking alignment

Practical session

Page 3: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Introduction to Binoculars

Construction & types of binoculars

Operation of binoculars

How to use binoculars

Page 4: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Different types of binocular

Page 5: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Inside a typical binocular

Page 6: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

What is Collimation?

Aka Alignment

Characteristics of human eye/brain

Collimation standards

Object space & image space

Conditional & full collimation

Page 7: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

3 axes to align

left opticalaxis

right opticalaxis

hingeaxis

Page 8: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Alignment tolerances (arc-minutes)

Ref Vertical Diverging Converging

At input to eye (image space)

Other 35 50 100

Soviet 15 20 60

Tonkin 15 20 45

Seyfried (X10) 4 6 10

AAMRL 3.4 3.4 8.6

Page 9: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Conditional vs Full Alignment

Conditional Alignment is alignment of the two optical axes, but not necessarily aligning with the hinge axis

Full Alignment is alignment of all 3 axes

Conditional Alignment is rather easier, but means it is only correct at one chosen binocular spacing (inter-pupillary distance)

Page 10: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Simple checks(& what can go wrong)

External damage

Look into objectives

Look into eyepieces- rotation errors- lateral displacements

Page 11: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Rotation error

Page 12: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Lateral error

Page 13: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Vertical error

Page 14: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

The heroine's dilemma

Page 15: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

The heroine's dilemma

Page 16: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Methods of adjustment

Eccentric rings

Prism adjusting screws

Eyepiece prism screws (pocket folding bins)

Page 17: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Eccentric objective rings

Page 18: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Eccentric ring adjustment

Page 19: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Eccentric rings clock diagram

121

2

3

4

56

7

8

9

10

11

Page 20: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Prism mounting

Page 21: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Prism adjustment screw locations

Page 22: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Prism adjustment screw locations

Page 23: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Folding binocular adjustment

eyepieceattachment

prismadjustment

eyepiece

prisms

Page 24: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Eyepiece focussing

Page 25: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Methods of checking alignment

Solar projection

Indoor twin-light

Optical bench- General layout- Ray diagram

Page 26: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Simple solar projection

Page 27: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Simple solar projection

Page 28: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Tracking solar projection

Page 29: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Tracking solar projection

Page 30: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Horizontal bar with pins ateyepiece spacing

Page 31: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Projected imageScreen distance from eyepieces adjusted so thatSun image diameter = Eyepiece spacing (also = pin spacing)

If binoculars correctly aligned, sun images will be: Level with the projected bar Just touching

Page 32: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Images denoting mis-alignment

Diverging optical axes→ diverging exit rays→ converging eyes

Converging objectives→ converging exit rays→ diverging eyes

Vertical and horizontalmisalignment

Page 33: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Measurement accuracy ofsolar projection method

Typical eyepiece spacing (=interpupillary distance) = 65mm

Screen to eyepiece distance for 10x50 binoculars ~ 750mm(To achieve sun image diameter = 65mm)

1mm positional error on screen = 360/(2*Pi*750) degrees= 4.6 arcmin

Arcmin (mm) Vertical Diverging Converging

Other 35 (7) 50 (11) 100 (22)

Soviet 15 (3) 20 (4) 60 (13)

Tonkin 15 (3) 20 (4) 45 (10)

Seyfried (X10) 4 (1) 6 (1) 10 (2)

AAMRL 3.4 (1) 3.4 (1) 8.6 (2)

Page 34: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

But what about the hinge axis??

Hinge wide open(73mm IPD)

Hinge midway(69mm IPD)

Hinge closed(55mm IPD)

Page 35: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

When the sun don't shineTwin lights (LEDs with cross-wires)Spaced same distance apart as objectives → Parallel rays

Rear view showing clamp

Page 36: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Autocollimator principle

mirror collimator lens

screen

lightsource

Page 37: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Binoculars under test

mirror collimator lens

screen

lightsource

binoculars

Page 38: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Effect of axis error

mirror collimator lens

screen

lightsource

binoculars

off-axisimage

Page 39: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Autocollimator screen

-120 -90 -60 -30 0 30 60 90 120

arc-minutes in eyepiece field

Page 40: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Practical implementation

mirror collimator lens

screen

red & greenlightsources

binoculars

off-axisimage

Page 41: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Steps to full collimation

Open hinge

Adjust objectives/prisms to align L & R axes

Close hinge

Use hinge axis finder to identify hinge location

Adjust both L & R axes to coincide with hinge

Page 42: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Principle of full collimation

1 – Hinge open

L&R axes adjusted to coincide

hinge axis(unknown position)

Page 43: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Principle of full collimation

2 – Hinge closed

hinge axis

hinge angle

Page 44: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Hinge axis finder

030

6090

120

150

180

210

-150

-120-90

-60

-300306090120

150

40

40

60

60

80

80

Page 45: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Dark-adapted pupil size vs. age

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 903

4

5

6

7

8

age

pu

pil,

mm

Page 46: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Large exit pupil – not fully utilised

Page 47: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

References

Initial inspiration for solar projection method:

Sun images method for checking alignmement of binoculars by Rafael Chamón Cobos

https://sites.google.com/site/rchamon/home/sun-images-method-for-collimation-of-binoculars

Good practical book on binoculars(copy now in the OASI library):

Choosing, Using & Repairing Binoculars by J.W. Seyfried

Page 48: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

References for Alignment Tolerances table

Other: Archives of an email list on the history of binoculars.http://home.europa.com/~telscope/listp200.txtBinocular List #246: 25 February 2003.(Possibibly a US Military spec)

Soviet: Ostrovskaya, M.A. et. al. Allowable Deviations From Parallelism for the Optical Axes of Binoculars. Soviet Journal of Optical Technology, 45 (10), Oct. 1978, pp613-616.

Tonkin: Binocular Astronomy, Ch. 2, ISBN 1846283086, Springer-Verlag, 2006

Seyfried: Choosing, Using & Repairing Binoculars, J.W. Seyfried, University Optics Inc, Ann Arbor, Michigan, 1995.

AAMRL: Optical Tolerances for Alignment & Image Space Differences for Binocular Helmet-Mounted Displays, Armstrong Aerospace Medical Research Laboratory, Report No AD-A174 536, May 1986.

Page 49: Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment · Checking and Adjusting Binocular Alignment Mike Whybray and Ray Larsen. Outline of Workshop Introduction to Binoculars What is collimation?

Practical session