Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
Transcript of Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
1/60
13-1
Chapter 13Chapter 13
Capital BudgetingCapital BudgetingTechniquesTechniques
© Pearson Education Limited 2004Fundamentals of Financial Management !2"e
Created #$% ®or$ '( )uhleme$er Ph(*(
Carroll College +au,esha +-
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
2/60
13-2
After studying Chapter 13, After studying Chapter 13,
you should be able to:you should be able to:
.nderstand the pa$#ac, period /PBP method of pro1ect ealuation andselection including its% /a calculation3 /# acceptance criterion3 /cadantages and disadantages3 and /d focus on liquidit$ rather thanprofita#ilit$(
.nderstand the three ma1or discounted cash flo /*CF methods of
pro1ect ealuation and selection 5 internal rate of return /-66 netpresent alue /7P8 and profita#ilit$ inde9 /P-(
E9plain the calculation acceptance criterion and adantages /oer thePBP method for each of the three ma1or *CF methods(
*efine construct and interpret a graph called an :7P8 profile(;
.nderstand h$ ran,ing pro1ect proposals on the #asis of -66 7P8 and
P- methods :ma$; lead to conflicts in ran,ing( *escri#e the situations here ran,ing pro1ects ma$ #e necessar$ and
1ustif$ hen to use either -66 7P8 or P- ran,ings(
.nderstand ho :sensitiit$ anal$sis; allos us to challenge the single<point input estimates used in traditional capital #udgeting anal$sis(
E9plain the role and process of pro1ect monitoring including :progress
reies; and :post
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
3/60
13-3
Capital BudgetingCapital Budgeting
TechniquesTechniques
Pro1ect Ealuation and =election
Potential *ifficulties Capital 6ationing
Pro1ect Monitoring Post
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
4/60
13-4
Project Ealuation:Project Ealuation:
Alternatie !ethods Alternatie !ethods
Pa$#ac, Period /PBP
-nternal 6ate of 6eturn /-66
7et Present 8alue /7P8
Profita#ilit$ -nde9 /P-
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
5/60
13-5
Proposed Project "ataProposed Project "ata
>ulie Miller is ealuating a ne pro1ectfor her firm Bas#et $onders %B$&(
=he has determined that the after
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
6/60
13-6
'ndependent Project 'ndependent Project
-ndependent-n
dependent
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
7/6013-7
Paybac# Period %PBP&Paybac# Period %PBP&
PBPPBP is the period of timerequired for the cumulatie
e9pected cash flos from aninestment pro1ect to equal
the initial cash outflo(
PBPPBP is the period of timerequired for the cumulatie
e9pected cash flos from aninestment pro1ect to equal
the initial cash outflo(
0 ! 2 4 @
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
8/60
13-8
/c!0 ) 22 ) 3( ) 4A ) @4 )
Paybac# *olution %+1&Paybac# *olution %+1&
PBPPBP D a / # < c " dD /40 < A " !0D / " !0D ( ears( ears
0 ! 2 3 4 @
-. ) !0 ) !2 ) !@ ) 1. ) A )
Cumulatie
-nflos
/a
/
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
9/60
13-9
Paybac# *olution %+/&Paybac# *olution %+/&
PBPPBP D / ) " !0) D ((
ears ears
7ote% Ta,e a#solute alue of lastnegatie cumulatie cash flo alue(
Cumulative
Cash Flows
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
10/60
13-10
PBP Acceptance CriterionPBP Acceptance Criterion
esG The firm ill receie #ac, theinitial cash outla$ in less than (@$ears( H( ears I (@ ear Ma9(J
The management of Bas#et $ondershas set a ma9imum PBP of (@
$ears for pro1ects of this t$pe(=hould this pro1ect #e acceptedK
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
11/60
13-11
PBP *trengthsPBP *trengths
and $ea#nessesand $ea#nesses
=trengths=trengths%%
Eas$ to use andunderstand
Can #e used as ameasure of liquidit$
Easier to forecast=T than LT flos
+ea,nesses+ea,nesses%%
*oes not accountfor T8M
*oes not consider
cash flos #e$ondthe PBP
Cutoff period is
su#1ectie
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
12/60
13-12
'nternal 0ate of 0eturn %'00&'nternal 0ate of 0eturn %'00&
-66 is the discount rate that equates thepresent alue of the future net cash
flos from an inestment pro1ect iththe pro1ects initial cash outflo(
CF! CF2 CFn
/!-66! /!-662 /!-66n+ . . . ++-C D
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
13/60
13-13
?!@000 ?!0000 ?A000
'00 *olution'00 *olution
?!0000 ?!2000
/!-66!
/!-662
Find the interest rate /'00 that causes thediscounted cash flos to equal ?40000(
?40000 D
/!-66 /!-664 /!-66@
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
14/60
13-14
'00 *olution %Try 1.&'00 *olution %Try 1.&
?40000?40000 D ?!0000/P8-F!0N! ?!2000/P8-F!0N2
?!@000/P8-F!0N ?!0000/P8-F!0N4 ?
A000/P8-F!0N@?40000?40000 D ?!0000/(O0O ?!2000/(2
?!@000/(A@! ?!0000/( ? A000/(2!
?40000?40000 D ?O0O0 ?OO!2 ?!!2@ ?0 ?44A D ?4!444?4!444 HH0ate is too lo2 0ate is too lo2 JJ
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
15/60
13-15
'00 *olution %Try 14&'00 *olution %Try 14&
?40000?40000 D ?!0000/P8-F!@N! ?!2000/P8-F!@N2
?!@000/P8-F!@NC ?!0000/P8-F!@N4
? A000/P8-F!@N@?40000?40000 D ?!0000/(A0 ?!2000/(A@
?!@000/(@ ?!0000/(@A2 ? A000/(4OA
?40000?40000 D ?A00 ?O0A2 ?OA0 ?@A20 ?4AO
D ?4!?4! HH0ate is too high 0ate is too high JJ
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
16/60
13-16
(!0 ?4!444
(0@ -66 ?40000 ?40
(!@ ?4!
Q ?!444(0@ ?40
'00 *olution %'nterpolate&'00 *olution %'nterpolate&
?!444Q
D
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
17/60
13-17
(!0 ?4!444
(0@ -66 ?40000 ?40
(!@ ?4!
Q ?!444(0@ ?40
'00 *olution %'nterpolate&'00 *olution %'nterpolate&
?!444Q
D
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
18/60
13-18
(!0 ?4!444
(0@ -66 ?40000 ?40
(!@ ?4!
/?!444/0(0@ ?40
'00 *olution %'nterpolate&'00 *olution %'nterpolate&
?!444Q
Q D Q D (0!@A
-66 D (!0 (0!@A D (!!@A or !!(@AN
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
19/60
13-19
'00 Acceptance Criterion'00 Acceptance Criterion
7oG The firm ill receie !!(@AN foreach dollar inested in this pro1ect ata cost of !N( H -66 I Rurdle 6ate J
The management of Bas#et $ondershas determined that the hurdle rate
is !N for pro1ects of this t$pe( =hould this pro1ect #e acceptedK
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
20/60
13-20
'00s on the Calculator '00s on the Calculator
+e ill use thecash flo registr$to sole the -66for this pro#lem
quic,l$ and
accuratel$G
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
21/60
13-21
Actual '00 *olution 5sing Actual '00 *olution 5sing
6our 7inancial Calculator 6our 7inancial Calculator
=teps in the Process=tep !% Press CF ,e$
=tep 2% Press 2nd CL6 +or, ,e$s
=tep % For C7. Press
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
22/60
13-22
Actual '00 *olution 5sing Actual '00 *olution 5sing
6our 7inancial Calculator 6our 7inancial Calculator
=teps in the Process /Part --=tep !0%For C.- Press !0000 Enter ,e$s
=tep !!%For 7.- Press ! Enter ,e$s
=tep !2%For C.4 Press A000 Enter ,e$s
=tep !%For 7.4 Press ! Enter ,e$s
=tep !4% Press ,e$s
=tep !@% Press -66 ,e$=tep !% Press CPT ,e$
6esult% -nternal 6ate of 6eturn D !!(4AN
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
23/60
13-23
'00 *trengths'00 *trengths
and $ea#nessesand $ea#nesses
=trengths=trengths%%
'ccounts forT8M
Considers all
cash flos Lesssu#1ectiit$
+ea,nesses+ea,nesses%%
'ssumes all cashflos reinested atthe -66
*ifficulties ithpro1ect ran,ings andMultiple -66s
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
24/60
13-24
8et Present 9alue %8P9&8et Present 9alue %8P9&
8P9 is the present alue of aninestment pro1ects net cash
flos minus the pro1ects initialcash outflo(
CF! CF2 CFn
/!,! /!,2 /!,n+ . . . ++
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
25/60
13-25
Bas#et $onders has determined that theappropriate discount rate /, for this
pro1ect is !N(
?!0000 ?A000
8P9 *olution8P9 *olution
?!0000 ?!2000 ?!@000
/!(!! /!(!2 /!(!
< ?40000?40000/!(!4 /!(!@
7P87P8 D
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
26/60
13-26
8P9 *olution8P9 *olution
7P87P8 D ?!0000/P8-F!CN! ?!2000/P8-F!CN2
?!@000/P8-F!CNC ?!0000/P8-F!CN4
? A000/P8-F!CN@ < ?40000?40000
7P87P8 D ?!0000/(@ ?!2000/(A ?!@000/(O ?!0000/(! ? A000/(@4 < ?40000?40000
7P87P8 D ?@0 ?OO ?!0O@ ?!0 ?0! < ?40000?40000
D < ?!42?!42
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
27/60
13-27
8P9 Acceptance Criterion8P9 Acceptance Criterion
7oG The 7P8 is negatie( This meansthat the pro1ect is reducing shareholderealth( H0eject0eject as 8P9 8P9 I . . J
The management of Bas#et $ondershas determined that the required
rate is !N for pro1ects of this t$pe(=hould this pro1ect #e acceptedK
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
28/60
13-28
8P9 on the Calculator 8P9 on the Calculator
+e ill use the cashflo registr$ to sole
the 7P8 for thispro#lem quic,l$ and
accuratel$G
Rint% -f $ou hae not cleared the cash flosfrom $our calculator then$ou ma$ s,ip to =tep !@(
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
29/60
13-29
Actual 8P9 *olution 5sing Actual 8P9 *olution 5sing
6our 7inancial Calculator 6our 7inancial Calculator
=teps in the Process=tep !% Press CF ,e$
=tep 2% Press 2nd CL6 +or, ,e$s
=tep % For C7. Press
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
30/60
13-30
=teps in the Process /Part --=tep !0%For C.- Press !0000 Enter ,e$s
=tep !!%For 7.- Press ! Enter ,e$s
=tep !2%For C.4 Press A000 Enter ,e$s
=tep !%For 7.4 Press ! Enter ,e$s
=tep !4% Press ,e$s
=tep !@% Press 7P8 ,e$=tep !% For -D Enter ! Enter ,e$s
=tep !A% Press CPT ,e$
6esult% 7et Present 8alue D
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
31/60
13-31
8P9 *trengths8P9 *trengths
and $ea#nessesand $ea#nesses
=trengths=trengths%%
Cash flosassumed to #ereinested at thehurdle rate(
'ccounts for T8M(
Considers all
cash flos(
+ea,nesses+ea,nesses%%
Ma$ not includemanagerialoptions em#eddedin the pro1ect( =ee
Chapter !4(
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
32/60
13-32
8et Present 9alue Profile8et Present 9alue Profile
*iscount 6ate /N
0 O !2 !@
-667P8S!N
=um of CFs Plot 7P8 for eachdiscount rate(T h r e e o
f t h e s e p o i n t s a r e e a s $ n o 4 G
7 e
t P r e s e n t 8
a l u e
?000s
!@
!0
@
0
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
33/60
13-33
Creating 8P9 ProfilesCreating 8P9 Profiles
5sing the Calculator 5sing the Calculator
Rint% 's long as $oudo not :clear; the
cash flos from theregistr$ simpl$ startat =tep !@ and entera different discount
rate( Each resulting7P8 ill proide a:point; for $our 8P9
ProfileG
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
34/60
13-34
Profitability 'nde %P'&Profitability 'nde %P'&
P- is the ratio of the present alue ofa pro1ects future net cash flos to
the pro1ects initial cash outflo(
CF! CF2 CFn
/!,! /!,2 /!,n+ . . . ++ -C-CP- D
P- D ! H 7P87P8 " -C-C J
II 6
Method U2%
Method U!%
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
35/60
13-35
P' Acceptance CriterionP' Acceptance Criterion
7oG The P-P- is less than !(00( Thismeans that the pro1ect is not profita#le(H0eject0eject as P' P' I 1;.. 1;.. J
P-P- D ?@A2 " ?40000
D (O4 %!ethod +1, 133-&
=hould this pro1ect #e acceptedK
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
36/60
13-36
P' *trengthsP' *trengths
and $ea#nessesand $ea#nesses
=trengths=trengths%%
=ame as 7P8
'lloscomparison of
different scalepro1ects
+ea,nesses+ea,nesses%%
=ame as 7P8
Proides onl$relatie profita#ilit$
Potential 6an,ingPro#lems
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
37/60
13-37
Ealuation *u
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
38/60
13-38
=ther Project=ther Project
0elationships0elationships
!utually Eclusie!utual ly Eclusie
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
39/60
13-39
Potential Proble
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
40/60
13-40
A; *cale "ifferences A; *cale "ifferences
Compare a small /= and alarge /L pro1ect(
7ET C'=R FL+=
Pro1ect = Pro1ect LE7* F E'6
0
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
41/60
13-41
*cale "ifferences*cale "ifferences
Calculate the PBP -66 7P8S!0Nand P-S!0N(
+hich pro1ect is preferredK +h$K
Pro1ect -66 7P8 P-
= !00N ? 2! (!
L 2@N ?2O!2 !(2O
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
42/60
13-42
B; Cash 7lo2 PatternB; Cash 7lo2 Pattern
Let us compare a decreasing cash
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
43/60
13-43
* 2N ?!O !(!A?!O !(!A
- !AN ?!O !(!A?!O !(!A
Cash 7lo2 PatternCash 7lo2 Pattern
Calculate the -66 7P8S!0N andP-S!0N(
+hich pro1ect is preferredK
Pro1ect -66 7P8 P-
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
44/60
13-44
Ea
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
45/60
13-45
7isher>s 0ate of 'ntersection7isher>s 0ate of 'ntersection
*iscount 6ate /?
0 @ !0 !@ 20 2@
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
46/60
13-46
C; Project ?ife "ifferencesC; Project ?ife "ifferences
Let us compare a long life /Q pro1ectand a short life / pro1ect(
7ET C'=R FL+=Pro1ect Q Pro1ect E7* F E'6
0
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
47/60
13-47
Q @0N ?!@ 2(@4
!00N ? ! !(2
Project ?ife "ifferencesProject ?ife "ifferences
Calculate the PBP -66 7P8S!0Nand P-S!0N(
+hich pro1ect is preferredK +h$K
Pro1ect -66 7P8 P-
A h $A th $ t
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
48/60
13-48
Another $ay to Another $ay to
?oo# at Things?oo# at Things
!( 'd1ust cash flos to a common terminal$ear if pro1ect :; ill 8=T 8=T #e replaced(
Compound Pro1ect ear ! S!0N for 2 $ears(
ear 0 ! 2
CF
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
49/60
13-49
0eplacing Projects0eplacing Projects
2ith 'dentical Projects2ith 'dentical Projects
2( .se 0eplace
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
50/60
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
51/60
13-51
Aailable Projects for B$ Aailable Projects for B$
Pro1ect -C -66 7P8 P-
' ? @00 !N ? @0 !(!0
B @000 2@ @00 2(0C @000 A @@00 2(!0* A@00 20 @000 !(AE !2@00 2 @00 !(04F !@000 2 2!000 2(40& !A@00 !O A@00 !(4R 2@000 !@ 000 !(24
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
52/60
13-52
Choosing by '00s for B$ Choosing by '00s for B$
Pro1ect -C -66 7P8 P-
C ? @000 AN ? @@00 2(!0
F !@000 2 2!000 2(40E !2@00 2 @00 !(04B @000 2@ @00 2(0
Pro1ects C F and E hae thethree largest '00s(
The resulting increase in shareholder ealth is ?2A000 ith a ?2@00 outla$(
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
53/60
13-53
Choosing by 8P9s for B$ Choosing by 8P9s for B$
Pro1ect -C -66 7P8 P-
F ?!@000 2N ?2!000 2(40
& !A@00 !O A@00 !(4B @000 2@ @00 2(0
Pro1ects F and & hae the
to largest 8P9s(The resulting increase in shareholder ealth
is ?2@00 ith a ?2@00 outla$(
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
54/60
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
55/60
13-55
*u
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
56/60
13-56
*inglePoint Esti
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
57/60
13-57
PostCo
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
58/60
13-58
!ultiple '00 Proble
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
59/60
13-59
8P9 Profile !ultiple '00s8P9 Profile !ultiple '00s
*iscount 6ate /N
0 40 0 !20 !0 200
7 e
t P r e s e n t 8 a l u e
/ ? 0 0 0 s
Multiple -66s at
,, D !2(O@N!2(O@N and !O!(!@N!O!(!@N
A@
@0
2@
0
-
8/20/2019 Chapter 13 Capital Budgeting
60/60
8P9 Profile !ultiple '00s8P9 Profile !ultiple '00s
Rint% our calculatorill onl$ find 7E
-66 5 een if thereare multiple -66s( -t
ill gie $ou theloest -66( -n this
case !2(O@N(