CHAPTER-1 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, … 1... · 1.12 liquidity versus profitability:...
Transcript of CHAPTER-1 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, … 1... · 1.12 liquidity versus profitability:...
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 1
CHAPTER -1
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT,
IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
1.1 INTRODUCTION
1.2 DEFINITIONS OF WORKING CAPITAL
1.3 CONCEPT OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
1.4 CIRCULATION OF WORKING CAPITAL
1.5 TYPES OF WORKING CAPITAL
1.6 FACTORS DETERMINING OF WORKING CAPITAL
1.7 OPERATING CYCLE
1.8 WORKING CAPITAL TERM LOAN (WCTL)
1.9 ADEQUACY OF WORKING CAPITAL
1.10 EXCESS OF INADEQUACY OF WORKING CAPITAL
1.11 OPTIMUM LEVEL OF CURRENT ASSETS
1.12 LIQUIDITY VERSUS PROFITABILITY: RISK-RETURN
TANGLE
1.13 FIXED CAPITAL VERSUS WORKING CAPITAL
1.14 FINANCING CURRENT ASSETS
1.15 TONDON COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS
1.16 CHORW COMMITTEE
1.17 S.S. MARATHE COMMITTEE
1.18 CONCLUSION
1.19 REFERENCES
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 2
CHAPTER -1
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT,
IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
1.1 INTRODUCTION
The present research seeks to study in depth the Working Capital Management
of selected paper companies in India, with special emphasis on an examination of the
management performance in regard to financial management. It hardly needs
mentioning that inventory, accounts receivables and cash and its alert administration
can go a long way in solving the problem of the efficient working capital
management. In fact, the present research of working capital management needs
special attention for the efficient working and the business. It has been often observed
that the shortage of working capital leads to the failure of a business. The proper
management of working capital may bring about the success of a business firm. The
management of working capital includes the management of current assets and
current liabilities. The present research undertakes to deal with the net concept of
working capital: excess of current assets over current liabilities.
A number of companies for the past few years have been finding it difficult to
solve the increasing problems of adopting seriously the management of working
capital. Business concerns intent on developing their business have to use to the
utmost, their available resources for the improvement and development of the
business there by enabling them to increase their profits. Working Capital and change
in working capital, especially in inventories, which is one of the components of
working capital form a very important part of the total gross-capital formation in the
paper companies. Efficient and the optimal utilization of fixed assets is very closely
related to the proper management of working capital. The present research attempts to
recognize initially the importance of working capital as a part of the total capital. It
further goals to recognize the factors influencing the working capital, its volume, and
in the process try to suggest remedial measures which might help in optimizing the
use of working capital. It also considers as to how precisely “financing working
capital” and further more what should be mix of different components of working
capital.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 3
Some important questions to which the research attempts to seek answer as
follows:-
1. Whether paper companies have planted their working capital requirement
properly.
2. Have the paper companies utilized the investment in current assets?
3. Have the paper companies controlled and utilized cash resources
effectively and profitably?
4. Whether paper companies resort to high build up of inventory.
5. How far have the paper companies been successful in collecting their
`different administration of its various components: like as inventory,
account receivable, cash, and accounts payables.
Working Capital is the life blood of every business concern. Business firm
cannot make progress without adequate working capital. Inadequate working capital
means shortage of inputs, whereas excess of it leads to extra cost. So the quantum of
working capital in every business firm should be neither more nor less than what is
actually required. The management has to see that funds invested as working capital
in their organization earn return at least as much as they would have earned return if it
invested anywhere else. At the time of increasing capital costs and scare funds, the
area of working capital management assumes added importance as it deeply
influences a firm's liquidity and profitability. A notable feature of utilization of funds
is that they are of recurring nature. Therefore, efficient working capital management
requires a proper balance between generation and utilization of these funds without
which either shortage of funds will cause obstruction in the smoother functioning of
the organization or excess funds will prevent the firm from conducting its business
efficiently. So the main objective of working capital management is to arrange the
needed funds on the right time from the right source and for the right period, so that a
tradeoff between liquidity and profitability may be achieved.
A firm may exist without making profits but cannot survive without liquidity.
The function of working capital management organization is similar that of heart in a
human body. Also it is an important function of financial management. The financial
manager must determine the satisfactory level of working capital funds and also the
optimum mix of current assets and current liabilities. He must ensure that the
appropriate sources of funds are used to finance working capital and should also see
that short term obligation of the business are met well in time.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 4
1.2 DEFINITIONS OF WORKING CAPITAL
Definitions of Working Capital, as per various management experts are as
under:
“Working Capital is the excess of C.A. over current liabilities.”
- H.G, Guthmann
“Working Capital is descriptive of that capital which is not fixed. But the more
common use of the Working Capital is to consider it as the difference between the
book value of the C.A. and current liabilities.”
- Hoglend. J. Bierman, and A. K. Mc Adams,.
“Working Capital represents the excess of C.A. over current liabilities”
- J.L. Brown and L.R. Housard.
“Working Capital to a firm’s investment in short term assets cash short term
securities, accounts, receivables and inventories.”
-Weston the Brigham
“Working Capital represents only the current capital assets.”
- Meal Baker Malott and Field.
“Working Capital means a sum of C.A”
- J.S. Mill.
“A Working Capital deficit exits if current liabilities exceed C.A.”
-Prof. C.W. Gerstoberg.55
“Working Capital equals the aggregate value of C.A. minus aggregate value of
current liabilities”
- Lincoln.
“Gross Working Capital may be used to refer to total C.A. and net working
capital refers to the surplus of C.A. over current liabilities”
- Prof. S.C. Kuchhal
1.3 CONCEPT OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
There are two concepts of working capital viz .quantitative and qualitative.
Some people also define the two concepts as gross concept and net concept.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 5
According to quantitative concept, the amount of working capital refers to
‘total of current assets’. What we call current assets? Smith called, ‘circulating
capital’. Current assets are considered to be gross working capital in this concept.
The qualitative concept gives an idea regarding source of financing capital.
According to qualitative concept the amount of working capital refers to “excess of
current assets over current liabilities.” L.J. Guthmann defined working capital as “the
portion of a firm’s current assets which are financed from long–term funds.”
The excess of current assets over current liabilities is termed as ‘Net working
capital’. In this concept “Net working capital” represents the amount of current assets
which would remain if all current liabilities were paid. Both the concepts of working
capital have their own points of importance. “If the objectives is to measure the size
and extent to which current assets are being used, ‘Gross concept’ is useful; whereas
in evaluating the liquidity position of an undertaking ‘Net concept’ becomes pertinent
and preferable.It is necessary to understand the meaning of current assets and current
liabilities for learning the meaning of working capital, which is explained below.
Current assets – It is rightly observed that “Current assets have a short life
span. These type of assets are engaged in current operation of a business and normally
used for short– term operations of the firm during an accounting period i.e. within
twelve months. The two important characteristics of such assets are, (i) short life span,
and (ii) swift transformation into other form of assets. Cash balance may be held idle
for a week or two; account receivable may have a life span of 30 to 60 days, and
inventories may be held for 30 to 100 days.”Fitzgerald defined current assets as, “cash
and other assets which are expected to be converted in to cash in the ordinary course
of business within one year or within such longer period as constitutes the normal
operating cycle of a business.”
Current liabilities – The firm creates a Current Liability towards creditors
(sellers) from whom it has purchased raw materials on credit. This liability is also
known as accounts payable and shown in the balance sheet till the payment has been
made to the creditors. The claims or obligations which are normally expected to
mature for payment within an accounting cycle are known as current liabilities. These
can be defined as “those liabilities where liquidation is reasonably expected to require
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 6
the use of existing resources properly classifiable as current assets, or the creation of
other current assets, or the creation of other current liabilities.”
1.4 CIRCULATION SYSTEM OF WORKING CAPITAL
Working capital is also known as ‘circulating capital or current capital’
Kulkarni has remarked that, “The use of the term circulating capital instead of
working capital indicates that its flow is circular in nature”.
Figure – 1.1 Circulation System of Working Capital
The funds in a business are obtained from the issue of share, the issue of
debentures, and other long-term arrangement and from operations of business. A huge
part of generated funds is used to acquire fixed assets, viz, plant and machinery, land
building and some other fixed assets, while the remaining part of the generated funds
is used for day to day operations of the business e.g. to pay wages and overheads
expenses for the raw materials processed. This makes possible the stocking of
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 7
finished goods by whose sales either accounts receivables are created or cash is
received. In this process profits are generated. A part of the profit is used to pay tax,
interest and dividends, while the remaining part is ploughed back in the business. The
circulation system of working capital may be depicted as shown in figure 1.1 as
Above page page. The cycle goes constantly throughout the life of business.
1.5 TYPES OF WORKING CAPITAL
Following diagram clear the classification of working capital Accoding to the
needs of business, the working capital may be classified into following two basis:
1) On the basis of periodicity
2) On the basis of concept
Figure -1.2 Types of Working Capital
1). On the basis of periodicity:
The requirements of working capital are continuous. More working capital is
required in a particular season or the peck period of business activity. On the basis of
periodicity working capital can be divided under two categories as under:
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 8
a) Permanent working capital
b) Variable working capital
(a) Permanent working capital:
This type of working capital is known as Fixed Working Capital.
Permanent working capital means the part of working capital which is
permanently locked up in the current assets to carry out the business smoothly.
The minimum amount of current assets which is required to conduct the
business smoothly during the year is called permanent working capital. For
example, investments required to maintain the minimum stock of raw
materials or to cash balance. The amount of permanent working capital
depends upon the size and growth of company. Fixed working capital can
further be divided into two categories as under:
(I) Regular Working capital:
Minimum amount of working capital required to keep the primary
circulation. Some amount of cash is necessary for the payment of
wages, salaries etc.
(II) Reserve Margin Working capital:
Additional working capital may also be required for contingencies that
may arise any time. The reserve working capital is the excess of capital
over the needs of the regular working capital is kept aside as reserve
for contingencies, such as strike, business depression etc.
(b) Variable or Temporary Working Capital:
The term variable working capital refers that the level of working capital is
temporary and fluctuating. Variable working capital may change from one assets
to another and changes with the increase or decrease in the volume of business.
The variable working capital may also be subdivided into following two
sub-groups.
1. Seasonal Variable Working capital:
Seasonal working capital is the additional amount which is required during the
active business seasons of the year. Raw materials like raw-cotton or jute or sugarcane
are purchased in particular season. The industry has to borrow funds for short period.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 9
It is particularly suited to a business of a seasonal nature. In short, seasonal working
capital is required to meet the seasonal liquidity of the business.
2. Special variable working capital:
Additional working capital may also be needed to provide additional current
assets to meet the unexpected events or special operations such as extensive
marketing campaigns or carrying of special job etc.
Difference Between Permenent and Variable Working Capital:
The distinction between permenent or fixed working capital and variable
working capital or temporary working capital is of great importance in operating cycle
and raising the funds. However, there is always a minimum level of current assets
which is contiuously required by the firm to carry on its business operations. This
minimum level of current assets is refered to as permenent or fixed working capital
and is permanent in the same way as the firm’s fixed asset.
Figuer – 1.3 Permenent and Temporary Working Capital
Depending on the chang in production and sales, the need of working capital,
over and above the permenent working capital, will fluctuate.
For example, extra inventory of finished good will have to be maintained to
support the peak periods of sale and investment in receivables may also increse during
the period. Both the kinds of working capital-permenent and temporary –are
necessary to facilitate production and sale through the operating cycle, but temporary
working capital is created by the firm to meet liquidity requriments that will last only
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 10
temporarily. In above figuire shows the diference between permentt and temporary
working capital.
It is sh-own in below figure that permenant working capital is stable over time,
while temporary working capital is fluctuating-some times incrasing and sometimes
decrasing. However, the permanent working capital line need not be horizonltal if the
firm’s requriment for permenent capital is incrasing or decreasing over period. For a
growing firm, the difference between permanent and temporary working capital can
be depicted the figure-1.4 as under.
Figuer 1.4 – Perment and Temporary Working Capital Can be Depicted
2) On the basis of concept:
on the basis of concept working capital is divided into two categoties as under:
(A) Gross Working Capital:
Gross working capital refers to total investment in current assets. The
current assets employed in business give the idia about the utilization of
working capital and idia about the economic postion of the company. Thus,
gross working capital the amount of funds invested in different current assets.
Gross working capital concepts is popular and acceptable concept in the field
of finance.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 11
(B) Net Working Capital:
Net working capital means current assets minus current liabilities. The
difference between current assets and current liabilites is called the net
working capital. If the net working capital is positive business is able to
meet its current liabilites. Net working capital concept provides the
mesasurement for determining the creditworthiness of compny.
1.6 FACTORS DETERMINING OF WORKING CAPITAL
Papers, with their fixed investment, appear to have the lowest requirement for
current assets. This does not mean that the problem of working capital may be
minimized in this field of enterprise, since ready funds are still essential to cover
disbursement for wages, interest on funds debt, purchase of materials and supplies,
etc. indeed, under such conditions the working capital position may become even
more strategic in character because of its relation to, and control of the large amount
of fixed assets. Thus, one of the outstanding problems of paper management in recent
years has been the maintenance of current position sufficiently strong to permit
vigorous operations. Public utilities, like the paper, have a fixed investment which
causes the current assets to constitute only a relatively small percentage of the total
assets. There is a difference between operating and holding companies, but even then
the funds required to cover current transactions are minor as compared with those
necessary to finance the long term structure.
Industrial companies, generally, require a large amount of working capital
although it various from business to business of lack of uniformity characterizing each
field of enterprise. However, the underlying determinants of the amounts of fixed
capital are required for operation; working assets may be expected to occupy a
smaller niche in the assets structure. For similar reasons, a rapid turnover of capital
will inevitably mean a large proportion of current assets. In the case of industries
with fixed investment, one of the primary uses of working capital is its conversion
into operating plant structure. In turn, it is expected that the income resized form
operations will normally replace such defections. This means that the flow of a
portion of working capital is circulating through fixed investment that its recovery is
dependent upon the income realized. Where the current assets are relatively more
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 12
important, a rapid sales turnover is usually found. Often, as a case of retail concerns,
the specific working assets constitute the object of sale and recovery is direct and
immediate. In manufacturing enterprises, a large share of working capital
management is more likely to become charged in form by conversion into finished
products, but even here, the potentiality of recovery is not delayed as long as in the
case of public utilities and paper companies. The need for working capital varies with
changes in the volume of business. A considerable proportion of current assets is
needed permanently as fixed assets. More than one production cycle may be in
process at one and the same time, for business operations on a continuing basis.
Materials are purchase and work is in progress. Finished inventory is sold. At the
same time new receivables accumulate and old ones are converted into cash. Cash is
utilized in the production process.
The following factor determine the amount of working capital
1. Nature of Companies:
The composition of an asset is a function of the size of a business and the
companies to which it belongs. Small companies have smaller proportions of
cash, receivables and inventory than large corporation. This difference
becomes more marked in large corporations. A public utility, for example,
mostly employs fixed assets in its operations, while a merchandising
department depends generally on inventory and receivable. Needs for working
capital are thus determined by the nature of an enterprise.
2. Demand of Creditors:
Creditors are interested in the security of loans. They want their obligations to
be sufficiently covered. They want the amount of security in assets which are
greater than the liability.
3. Cash Requirements:
Cash is one of the current assets which are essential for the successful
operations of the production cycle. Cash should not adequate and properly
utilized. It would be wasteful to hold excessive cash. A minimum level of cash
is always required to keep the operations going. Adequate cash is also required
to maintain good credit relation. Richards Osbom has pointed out that cash has
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 13
a universal liquidity and acceptability. Unlike illiquid assets, its value is clear-
cut and defines.
4. Nature and Size of Business:
The working capital requirements of a firm are basically influenced by the
nature of its business. Trading and financial firms have a very less investment
in fixed assets, but require a large sum of money to be invested in working
capital. Retail stores, for example, must carry large stocks of a variety of
goods to satisfy the varied and continues demand of their customers. Some
manufacturing business, such as tobacco manufacturing and construction firms
also have to invest substantially in working capital and a nominal amount in
the fixed assets. In contrast, public utilities have a very limited need for
working capital and have to invest abundantly in fixed assets. Their working
capital requirements and nominal because they have cash sales only and
supply services, not product. Thus, no funds will be tied up in debtors and
inventories. The working capital needs of most of the manufacturing concerns
fall between the two extreme requirements of trading firms and public utilities.
Such concerns have to make adequate investment in current assets depending
upon the total assets structure and other variables. The size of business also
has an important impact on its working capital needs. Size may me measured
in terms of the scale of operation. A firm with larger scale of operation will
need more working capital than a small firm.
5. Time:
The level of working capital depends upon the time required to manufacturing
goods. If the time is longer, the size of working capital is great. Moreover, the
amount of working capital depends upon inventory turnover and the unit cost
of the goods that are sold. The greater this cost, the bigger is the amount of
working capital.
6. Volume of Sales:
This is the most important factor affecting the size and components of working
capital. A firm maintains current assets because they are needed to support the
operational activities which result in sales. They volume of sales and the size
of the working capital are directly related to each other. As the volume of sales
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 14
increase in the investment of working capital-in the cost of operations, in
inventories and receivables.
7. Terms of Purchases and Sales:
If the credit terms of purchases are more favorable and those of sales liberal,
less cash will be invested in inventory. With more favorable credit terms,
working capital requirements can be reduced. A firm gets more time for
payment to creditors or suppliers. A firm which enjoys greater credit with
banks needs less working capital.
8. Inventory Turnover:
If the inventory turnover is high, the working capital requirements will be low.
With better inventory control, a firm is able to reduce its working capital
requirements. While attempting this, it should determine the minimum level of
stock which it will have to maintain throughout the period of its operations.
9. Receivable Turnover:
It is necessary to have an effective control of receivables. A prompt collection
of receivables and good facilities for setting payable results into low working
capital requirements.
10. Business Cycle:
Business expands during periods of prosperity and declines during the period
of depression. Consequently, more working capital required during periods of
prosperity and less during the periods of depression. During marked upswings
of activity, there is usually a need for larger amounts of capital to cover the leg
between collection and increased sales and to finance purchases of additional
materials to support growing business activity. Moreover, during the recovery
and prosperity phase of the business cycle, prices of raw materials and wages
tend to rise and require additional funds to carry even the same physical
volume of business. In the downswing of the cycle, there may be a brief period
when collection difficulties and declining sales together cause embarrassment
by the resulting failure to replenish cash. Later, as the depression runs its
course, the concern may find that it has a larger amount of working capital on
hand than current business volume may justify.
11. Value of Current Assets:
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 15
Decreases in the real value of current assets as compared to their book value
reduced the size of the working capital. If the real value of current assets
increases, there is an increase in working capital.
12. Variations in Sales:
A seasonal business requires the maximum amount of working capital for a
relatively short period of time.
13. Production Cycle:
The time taken to convert raw materials into finished products is referred to as
the production cycle or operating cycle. The longer the production cycle, the
greater is the requirements of the working capital. An utmost care should be
taken to shorten the period of the production cycle in order to minimize
working capital requirements.
14. Credit Control:
Credit control includes such factors as the volume of credit sales, the terms of
credit sales, the collection policy, etc. with a sound credit control policy, it is
possible for a firm to improve in cash inflow.
15. Liquidity and Profitability:
If a firm desires to take a greater risk for bigger gains or losses, it reduces the
size of its working capital in relation to its sales. If it is interested in improving
its liquidity, it increase the level of its working capital. However, this policy is
likely to result in a reduction of the sales volume, and therefore, of
profitability. A firm, therefore, should choose between liquidity and
profitability and decide about its working capital requirements accordingly.
16. Inflation:
As a result of inflation, size of the working capital is increased in order to
make it easier for a firm to achieve a better cash inflow. To some extent, this
factor may be compensated by the rise in selling price during inflation.
17. Seasonal Fluctuations:
Seasonal fluctuations in sales affect the level of variable working capital.
Often, the demand for products may be of a seasonal nature. Yet inventories
have got to be purchased during certain seasons only. The size of the working
capital in one period may, therefore, be bigger than that in another.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 16
18. Profit Planning and Control:
The level of working capital is decided by the management in accordance with
its policy of profit planning and control. Adequate profit assists in the
generation of cash. It makes it possible for the management to plough back a
part of its earnings in the business and substantially build up internal financial
resources. A firm has to plan for taxation payments, which are an important
part of working capital management. Often the dividend policy of a
corporation may depend upon the amount of cash available to it.
19. Repayment Ability:
A firm’s repayment ability determines level of its working capital. The usual
practices of a firm are to prepare cash flow projections according to its plans
of repayment and to fix working capital levels accordingly.
20. Cash Reserves:
It would be necessary for a firm to maintain some cash reserve to enable it to
meet contingent disbursements. This would provide a buffer against abrupt
shortages in cash flows.
21. Operational and Financial Efficiency:
Working capital turnover is improved with a better operational and financial
efficiency of a firm. With a greater working capital turnover, it may be able to
reduce its working capital requirements.
22. Change in Technology:
Technological developments related to the production process have a sharp
impact on the need for working capital.
23. Firm’s Policies:
These affect the level of permanent and variable working capital. Changing in
credit policy, production policy, etc are bound to affect the size of working
capital.
24. Activities of the Firms:
A firm’s stocking on heavy inventory or selling on easy credit terms calls for a
higher level of working capital for it than for selling services or making Cash
sales.
25. Attitude of Risk:
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 17
The greater the amount of working capital, the lower is the risk of liquidity.
`Whenever there is current strain, it has to be immediately diagnosed on the
basis of the red signals which manifest themselves in the operations. The restrictions
expressed as ratios of the elements of current assets and current liabilities are
frequently referred to as current position constraints and include the current ratio, the
acid test ratio, and the so-called “compensating balance” ratio. Contracts with fund
suppliers frequently provide for current-position constraints.
If stock not moving fast, and if there is an excess inventory buildup corrective
steps should be taken to sell the stock or bring down its level.
If the receivable have become sticky, effective recovery steps should be taken
to reduce the debts and to increase the collections. If the strain is allowed to continue
because of involvement in any other business or industry, the consequences may be
disastrous. In such situation, the ability to meet current demands deteriorates; short
term credits are not forthcoming; production is affected; sales decline; cash flow
decline; income may disappear; and the whole enterprise may get into the red over a
period of time. All the above points are the factors determining working capital
management in all the companies. Some factors are controlled and some factor are not
controlled by the management.
1.7 OPERATING CYCLE
The figure – 1.5 shows as under.
Figure- 1.5 Operating Cycle of Manufacturing Cycle:
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 18
The duration of time required to complete the sequence of events right from
purchase of raw material / goods for cash to the realization of sales in cash is called
the operating cycle, working capital cycle or cash cycle.
This cycle can be said to be at the heart of the need for working capital. In the
words of O.M. Joy: “The operating cycle refers to the length of time necessary to
complete the following cycle of events.”
The above operating cycle in figure relates to a manufacturing firm where cash
is needs to purchase raw materials and convert raw materials into work-in-process is
converted into finished goods. Finished goods will be sold for cash or credit and
ultimately debtors will be realized.
Figuer 1.6 Operatning Cycle of Non-Manufacturing Firm
The non-manufacturing firms, such as whole sellers and retailers, will not
have the manufacturing phase; they will have rather direct conversion of cash into
finished stock, into accounts receivables and then into cash. The operating cycle of a
non manufacturing firm is shown as under.
The non-manufacturing firms, such as whole sellers and retailers, will not
have the manufacturing phase; they will have rather direct conversion of cash into
finished stock, into accounts receivables and then into cash. The operating cycle of a
non manufacturing firm is shown as under.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 19
In addition to this, some service and financial concerns may not have any
inventory at all. Suchc firm have the shortes operating cycle as shown in figure-1.7 as
next page.
Figuer-1.7 Operating Cycle of Service and Financial Firms
1.8 WORKING CAPITALTERM LOAN (WCTL):
A working capital term loan (WCTL) should process specific characteristic as
laid down below:
Working capital term loan is a shortage “long-term surplus” or net working
capital(NWC) in a unit that a bank chooses to fund.
It is a long term need of the unit that is met by the bank though its short term
port-folio.
Working capital term loan may be either clean or secured depending upon the
margin stipulated or the amount of working capital term loan in relation to the
chargeable current assts.
It must be repaid is a prescribed maximum number of installments.
It is not sanctioned as such but segregated out of existing outstanding, when
outstanding exceed the unit’s eligibility.
It is a sort of ‘once-in-a-life-time’ loan. It is a post-facto corrective measure, it
should not be repeated normally.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 20
It should be repayable form long-term sources. If the repayment is form short
term sources, the permissible bank finance will fall correspondingly and
working capital term loan will rise there by neutralizing the process of
repayment.
Moreover, both physical and financial follow up can be used to complement each
other, if the concept of the ‘margin’ is refined and integrated into the maximum
permissible bank finance (MPBF)
MPBF = NWC + OSCL – NCCA/CCA Margin
Where NWC is net working capital, OSCL means other current liabilities less
creditors for purchases. NCCA are non-chargeable current assets on which no drawls
are permitted. CCA means chargeable current assets on which margin are proposed to
be stipulated. The application of margin would be coupled with the deduction of the
value of creditors for purchases from the advance value to arrive at the drawing
power. Once a margin is stipulated, it can be utilized as the operating thumb rule for
monitoring the borrower’s stake in the stocks charged to the bank as well as a rough
and ready method for keeping the drawings power within the MPBF limits.
1.9 ADEQUACY OF WORKING CAPITAL
N.K. Kulshrestha has observed that, “the need for maintaining an adequate
working capital can hardly be questioned. Just a circulation of blood is very necessary
in the human body to maintain life, smooth flow of funds is very necessary to
maintain the heath of the firm”. Adequate working capital becomes necessary because
of the following reasons:
It protects a business form the adverse effects of shrinkage in the values of
current assets.
It is possible to pay all the current obligations promptly and to take advantages
of cash discounts.
It ensures to a greater extent the maintenance of a company’s credit standing
and provides for such emergencies as strikes, floods, fibers, etc.
It permits the carrying of inventories at a level that would enable a business to
serve satisfactory the needs of its customers.
It enables a company to extend favorable credit terms to customer.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 21
It enable a company to operate its business more efficiently because there is
no delay in obtaining materials, etc., because of credit difficulties.
It enables a business to withstand periods of depression smoothly.
There may be operating losses or decreased retained earnings.
There may be excessive non-operating or extraordinary losses.
The management may fail to obtain funds from other sources for the purposes
of expansion.
There may be an unwise divided policy.
Current funds may be invested in non-current assets.
The management may fail to accumulate funds necessary for meeting
debentures on maturity.
There may be increasing price necessitating bigger investments in inventories
and fixed assets.
1.10 EXCESS OF INADEQUACY OF WORKING CAPITAL
The firm should maintain a sound working capital position. It should have
adequate working capital to run its business operations. Both excessive as well as
inadequate working capital positions are dangerous form the firm’s point of view.
Excessive working capital means idle funds which earn no profit for the firm. Paucity
of working capital not only impairs firm’s profitability but also results in production
interruption and inefficiencies.
When the company is inadequate, a company faces the following problem:
It is not possible for it to utilize production facilities fully for want of working
capital.
A company may not be able to take advantages of cash discount facilities.
The credit-worthiness of the company is likely to be jeopardized because of
lack of liquidity.
A company may not be able to take advantages of profitability business
opportunities.
The modernization of equipment and even routine repairs and maintenance
facilities may be difficult to administer.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 22
A company will not be able to pay its dividends because of the non-
availability of funds.
A company cannot afford to increase its cash sales and may have to restrict its
activities to credit sales only.
A company may have to borrow funds at exorbitant rates of interest.
Its low liquidity may lead to low profitability in the same way as low
profitability results in low liquidity.
Low liquidity would positively thirteen the solvency of the business. A
company is considered illiquid when it is not able to pay its debts on maturity.
It must be wound up under section 433 of the companies Act, 1956, upon its
inability to pay its debts.
An enlightened management should therefore, maintain an adequate amount of
working capital on a continuous basis. Sound financial and statistical techniques
by judgments should be used to predict the quantum of working capital.
Commercial Bank (Bank Credit):
The major part of working capital is provided by commercial bank to their
customer. Commercial banks play an important role in providing capital to its
customers. Commercial banks are an important source of working capital in India.
The rate of interest charge by the Reserve Bank of India, from time to time. Here it is
to be noted that the terms of leading of the banks are very strict. Followings SIX CS
are considered by the bank before sanctioning cedited.
1. Capital 2. Capacity
3. Character 4. Collateral
5. Condition 6. Coverage
Banks provided working capital in the form of cash credit, overdraft,
discounting bills of exchanges etc. banks take into account the several factors of the
borrowing concern before fixing credit limit. Bank credit to commercial sector was
Rs. 21, 23,363 crores at the end of March 200723
. There were 36,927 officers of
nationalized banks at the end of March 2007.
1.11 OPTIMUM LEVEL OF CURRENT ASSETS
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 23
The financial manager should determine the optimum level of current assets so
that the wealth of shareholders be maximized. In fact, optimum level for each type of
current assets should be fixed. The question of optimum investment in each type of
current assets is discussed. Here we simply discuss the basic concept involved in
determining the level of current assets.
Current Assets and Fixed Asset:
A firm needs fixed and current assets to support a particular level of output.
However, to support the same level of output, the firm can have difference levels of
current asset. As the firm’s output and sales increase, the need for current assets
increase in direct proportion to output; current assets increase at a decreasing rate with
output. This relationship is based upon the notion that it takes a greater proportional
investment in current assets when only a few units of output are produced than it does
later on when the firm can used its current assets more efficiently.
Figure – 1.8 Alternative Current Assets Polices
The help of the above graph the most conservative policy is alternative A,
where CA/FA ratio is greatest at every level of output. Alternative C is the most
aggressive policy, as CA/FA ratio is lowest at all levels of output. Alternative B lies
between the conservative and aggressive polices and is an average policy.
Other things assuming constant, a conservative policy implies greater liquidity
and lover risk and poor liquidity. The current assets policy of the most firms may fall
between these two extreme policies.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 24
The level of current assets can be measured by relating current asset to fixed
assets. Dividing current assets by fixed assets gives the CA/FA ratio. Assuming a
constant level of fixed assets, a higher CA/FA ratio indicates a conservative current
assets policy, and a lover CA/FA ratio means an aggressive current assets policy.
1.12 LIQUIDITY VERSUS PROFITABILITY: RISK-RETURN
TANGLE
The firm would make just enough investment in current assets, if it were
possible to estimate working capital needs exactly. Under perfect certainty, the
current assets holdings would be at the minimum level. A ledger investment in current
assets under certainty would mean a low rate or return investment for the firm, as
excess investment in current assets will not earn enough return. A smaller investment
in current assets, on the other hand, would mean interrupted production and sales,
because of frequent stock-outs and inability to creditor in time to restrictive credit
policy.
As it is not possible to estimate working needs accurately, the firm must
decide about the levels of current assets to be carried. The current assets holdings of
the firm will depend upon its working capital policy. It may follow a conservative or
an aggressive policy. These polices have different risk-return implications. A
conservative policy means lower return and risk, while an aggressive policy produces
higher return and risk.
The two important aims of the working capital management are: profitability
and solvency. Solvency, used in the technical sense, refers to the firm’s continuous
ability to meet maturing obligations. Lenders and creditors expected prompt
settlement of their claims as and when due. To ensure solvency, the firm maintains a
relatively large investment in current assets holdings. If the firm maintains a relatively
large investment in current assets, it will have no difficulty in paying the claims of the
creditors when they become due and will be able to fill all sales orders and ensure
smooth production. Thus, a liquid firm has less risk of insolvency; that is, it will
hardly experiences a cash shortage or stock-outs. However, there is accost associated
with maintaining a sound liquidity position. A considerable amount of the firm’s
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 25
funds will be tied up in current assets. And to the extent this investment is idle, the
firm’s profitability will suffer.
Details Company
A
Company
B
Company
C
Sales Units
Rupees
Earnings before interest and taxes
200000
3000000
300000
200000
3000000
300000
200000
3000000
300000
Current assets
Fixed assets
1000000
1000000
800000
100000
600000
1000000
Total assets 2000000 1800000 1600000
Return on total assets (EBIT/Total
assets)
Current assets/Fixed assets
15%
1.00
16.67%
0.80
18.75%
0.60
To have high profitability, the firm may sacrifice solvency and maintain a
relatively low level of current assets. When the firm does so, its profitability will
improve as less funds are tied up in idle current assets, but its solvency would be
threatened and would be exposed to greater risk of cash shortage and stock-outs. The
profitability-solvency tangle of the working capital management may further be
illustrated with the help of an example. Suppose, a firm has the following data for
future year: Sales (200000 Units) -3000000Earnings before interest and taxes-
240000.Fixed assets -1000000The three possible current assets holdings of the firm
are: Rs. 1000000 Rs. 800000 and Rs.600000. it is assumed that fixed assets level is
constant and profit do not very with current assets levels. The effect of the three
alternative current assets polices is shown as above page28:
The calculation in table indicate that alternative A, the most conservative
policy, provides greatest liquidity to the firm, but also the lowest return on total
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 26
assets. On the other hand, alternative C, the most aggressive policy, yields highest
return but provides lowest liquidity and thus, is very risky to the firm. Alternative B
demonstrates a moderate policy and generates a return higher than alternative A but
lower than alternative C and is less risky than alternative C but more risky than
alternative A. this is a simple example of risk-return trade off. In practice, things are
more difficult. Risk and returns are affected differently by different assets and,
therefore, generalization is not easy to make. The problem of the level of each type of
current asset is discussed in subsequent chapters.
The Cost Trade-off:
A different way of looking into the risk-return trade of is in terms of the cost
of maintaining a particular level of current assets. There are two different kinds of
costs involved26
. First there is the cost of liquidity. If the firm carries too much
liquidity, the firm’s rate of return will be low. Funds tied up in idle cash and excess
inventory earn nothing, and receivables levels that are too large also reduce the firm’s
profitability. Thus, the cost of liquidity increases with the level of current assets.
There is the cost of liquidity, which is the cost of having too little invested in
current assets. If the firm carries too little cash, it may not be able to pay bills
promptly at they mature. This may force the firm to borrows at high rates of interest.
This will also adversely affect the credit-worthiness of the firm and it will face
difficulties in obtaining funds in future. This all may force the firm into insolvency.
If the firm’s inventory level too low, sales may be lost and customers may
shift to competitors. Also, low level of book debts may be due to tight credit policy,
which would impair sales further. Thus, the low level of current assets
involves cost which increases as this level falls.
If selecting an optimal level of current assets, the firm should balance the
profitability solvency tangle by minimizing the total cost of liquidity and cost of
illiquidity.
In the above all points are discussed by the researcher on the view point of
management of current assets in paper companies.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 27
Figure-1.9 The Cost Trade off
1.13 FIXED CAPITAL VERSUS WORKING CAPITAL
The maximization of the rate of return on capital employed is the ultimate goal
of every company. The issue of fixed capital versus working capital could be
examined appropriately only in the light of the role played by them in the attainment
of this objective. In the maximization of the rate return, the fixed and working capital
play functional, complementary and proportional and technical roles. As regards the
functional role, it may be fairly well placed that fixed capital represents the products
component of the business, it is utilized with or act upon the current or circulating
capital to produce revenue or income for the enterprise; this it self is not expected to
be held or produce revenue or income for enterprise. The expenditure of this class of
capital is expected to be recovered only over a period of years through depreciation
charge which are an element of cost. On the other hand, investment in working capital
are relatively temporary in nature since the invested values are capable of being
recovered within a short period of time depending upon the manufacturing as well as
the collection cycles. In other words, it is the working capital, which after its
transmutation into saleable product actually generated revenue for business.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 28
Moreover, a low profit ratio could be geared to a high one by quickening the pace of
working capital cycle, which, besides providing the will-springs for newer cycle, also
increased the total realizable profit of a business organization. The complementary
relationship between working capital and fixed capital is readily apparent. A fully
equipped industrial company without a supply of material to process or without cash
to pay for workmen’s wages and other current expenses or a store without
merchandise to sell, is virtually useless. Consequently the working capital position of
any company may readily become the controlling factor for determining the scope and
character of its operation.
The proportional relationship between fixed and working capital is very
important in the maximization of the rate of return. Inadequate working capital may
mean that the fixed assets purchased form permanent capital cannot be utilized
effectively. Shortage of materials or labour may mean that the machine can be used
for only part of the available time.
On the other hand, if efficient use is not being made of current assets and
working capital. Because working capital requirements are excessive there may be no
resources left for the assets. If the low state of efficiency persists, the position may
become aggravated still further. Assets wear out or become very costly to operate and
profits are depleted, thereby making even the maintenance of adequate working
capital quite a problem.
A business unit can maximize its rate of return on the capital employed
provided it keeps pace with the scientific and technological developments taking
place in the field to which it pertains. It is common to suggest that as soon as some
technological and scientific development takes place, a business unit, in order to
accelerate its profitability, should immediately introduce the same to its productive
processes. In reality, however, the sufficiency of working capital determines the
course of decision in this regard.
According to Professor N.K. Sharma- “Innovation is regarded by many
economists and accountants as the mainspring of profit earnings; there is no doubt
that this is true for many industries. If new ideas, products, methods and techniques
are not germinated and brought into existence, a company will fail to keep its place in
the competition. Innovation implies among other things, research sound organization
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 29
and the willingness to undertake risks. Without adequate cash there can be no
progress. Research and development would be at a standstill and the essential
innovation would fail to appear.”
A comparison between the fixed and working capital could be made on the
basis of their investment relationship with each other.
It is found that in both the private and public sector Company’s working
capital, as a proportion of working capital employed share almost equal honors with
fixed capital. In the fifteen important industries of India the proportion of fixed
working capital and variable working capital was the show on next page. In table
form. It is evident from the table that with the exclusion of the industries had working
capital is very high proportions in their capital employed.
Sr.
Number
Company name Fixed capital (% to
total capital employed)
Working capital (% to
total capital employed)
1. Electricity Generation 75% 25%
2. Shipping Company 70% 30%
3. Aluminum Company 69% 31%
4. Paper Company 60% 40%
5. Iron and Steel Company 60% 40%
6. Cement Company 55% 45%
7. Chemicals Company 51% 49%
8. Tea Company 50% 50%
9. Mineral Oils Company 47% 53%
10. Coal Company 45% 55%
11. Cotton Textile Company 42% 58%
12. Sugar Company 35% 65%
13. Engineering Company 33% 67%
14. Jute Company 32% 68%
15. Trading Company 15% 85%
Proportion of fixed and working capital to the total capital employed in fifteen
important companies in India as under. The electricity industry had fixed capital in
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 30
very high proportions because by its very nature this industry needs less of working
capital and its business operate on what it has installed as permanent capital.
In time with the situation prevailing in the fifteen important Indian industries,
the percentage of working capital to fixed capital in the total capital employed by the
running companies of the Central Government is found both high and ascending
during the years 2006 to 2010. The percentage of working capital to the capital
employed for these companies was 36.3 in 2006. It rose to 42.2 percent in 2010.
According to the Annual Survey of industries for the year 2010, the percentage of
working capital to the total capital employed in the case of all the registered factories
on an average was 69. Thus, it is clear that the size of working capital in industrial
companies tends to predominate the total capital employed by them. This sufficiently
indicates that the prime object of making a profit in industrial companies must depend
on the manner in which they administer their working capital.
1.14 FINANCING CURRENT ASSETS
The firm must find out sources of funds to finance its current assets. It can
adopt difference financing policies. Three types of financing be distinguished: long
term financing, short-term financing and spontaneous financing. The important
sources of long term financing are shares, debenture, preference share, retained
earnings and debt form financial institutions. Short-term financing refers to those
sources of short term credit that the firm must arrange in advance. These sources
included short-term bank loans, commercial papers and factoring receivable. The firm
must find out the sources of funds to finance its current assets. In the words of O.M.
Joy: “in comparing financing plans we should distinguish between three different
kinds of financing: long-term financing, negotiated short-term financing and
spontaneous short-term financing”. The major source of spontaneous short-term
financing is trade credit and outstanding expenses. Therefore, a firm would like to
finance its current assets with spontaneous source of the fullest extent. Every firm is
expected to utilize spontaneous sources to the fullest extent. Thus, the real choice of
financing current assets is between short-term and long term sources. The following
three important approaches are applied in practice.
A. ) Matching Approach:
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 31
The firm can adopt a financial plan which involves the matching of the
expected life of assets with the expected life of the source of funds raised to finance
assets. Thus, a ten years loan may be raised to finance a plant with an expected life of
ten years; stock to be sold thirty day may be financed with a thirty-day bank loan or
so on. Thus, when the firm follows matching approach, long-term financing will be
used to finance fixed assets and permanent current assets.
In Figure-1.10 shows the firm’s investment and financing patterns over time
under a matching plan. As the firm’s fixed assets and permanent current asset levels
increase, the long term-term financing level also increases. When temporary current
assets level increase, short-term negotiated financing increase, and when the firm has
no temporary current assets, it is also has no short-term negotiated financing.
B) Conservative Approach:
Conservative finacing plasare those plans that use more long-term finacing
than is needed under a matching approch. The above figure-1.11 illustrates this
approch. The firm is financing a protion of its temporary current assets requriments
with long-term finanging. Also, in periods when the firm has no temporary current
assets, the firm has exess finacing available that will be invested in marketable
securities.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 32
These plans are called conservative because they involve relatively heavy use
of long-term financing.
Figuer-1.11
C) Aggressive Approach:
Figuer- 1.12
A firm may be aggressive in financing its assets. An aggressive policy is said
to befollowed by the firm when it uses more short-term financing than warranted by
the matching plan. Under an aggressive policy, the firm finances a part of its
permenent current assets with short-term financing.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 33
Some exxtemely aggressive firms may even finance a part of their fixed assets
with short-term financing. The relatively more use of short-term financing makes the
firm more risky. The aggeressive financing policy is illustrated in above Figure- 1.12.
1.15 TONDON COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS
The Reserve Bank of India set up in 1974 a study group to frame guide lines
for follow up of bank credit under the chairmanship of P.L.Tandon. The study group
reviewed the system of working capital financing and identified its major shortcoming
as follows:
The cash credit system of lending wherein the borrower can draw freely within
limits sanctioned by the banker hinders sound credit planning on the part of the
banker and induces financial indiscipline in the borrower.
The security-oriented approach to lending favored borrowers with strong financial
resources and also led to diversion of funds, borrowed against the security of
current assets, for financing fixed assets.
Relatively easy access to working capital finance led to large inventory levels with
industry.
Working capital finance provided by banks, theoretically supposed to be short
term in nature, tended to be, in practice, a long-term source of finance. For the
regulating bank credit, the study group made comprehensive recommendations
which have been made by and large accepted by the Reserve Bank of India. These
recommendations relate to:-
(A) Norms for inventories and receivables:
It is suggested for major industries. These norms have been based, inter alia,on
company finance studies made by the Reserve Bank of India, process period in
different industries, discussions with industry experts and feedback received on the
interim report.
1. For raw materials (including stores and other materials used in process of
manufacture):- maximum stock should not be more than by 2-3/4 times
consumption of raw material in the industry in a month.
2. For stock in process (work-in-process):- should not be more than by half of the
cost of production of a month.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 34
3. For finished goods:- it should not be more than by the two times of cost of
goods sold off a month.
4. For receivable:- it should not be more than by 1-1\4 times of a month sales.
The norms suggested may not be viewed as rigid or inflexible. Under certain
circumstances like bunched receipt of raw materials, this may be permitted.
(B) Quantum of permissible bank finance:
Three methods have been suggested for determining the maximum permissible
amount of bank finance:-
1. 75 percent of excess of current assets over non-bank current liabilities.
2. 75 percent of current assets as reduced by non-bank current liabilities.
3. 75 percent of excess of current assets over core current assets as reduced by
non-bank current liabilities.
In method 3 the core current assets means a part of current assets which should
be permanent component of working capital.
The study group suggested that borrowings in excess of what is permissible
under the first method should be converted into a working capital term loan repaid
over a period of time. The borrowers should gradually move to the third method.
(C) Style of lending:
The study group suggested that overall credit limit may be bifurcated into a
loan component, which would represent the minimum level of borrowing throughout
the year and a demand cash credit, which would take care of the fluctuating
requirements, both to be reviewed annually.
The demand cash credit should be charged a slightly higher interest rate than
the loan component. This approach will give the borrower an incentive for good
planning.
(D) Information and reporting system:
The study group suggested comprehensive information and reporting system
which seeks to:
1. Induce the borrower to plan his credit need carefully and maintain a greater
discipline in its use.
2. Promote free flow of information between the borrower and the banker so that
latter can monitor the credit situation better.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 35
3. Ensure that credit is used for intended purposes.
The study group suggested submitting quarterly information regarding profit
or loss, current assets and current liabilities.
1.16. CHORE COMMITTEE
The Reserve Bank of India constituted in April, 1979 a six member working
group under the chairmanship of K. B. Chore to review the system of cash credit and
credit management policy by banks. The committee report as considered by the R.B.I.
is as follows:-
1. The net surplus cash generation of established industrial unit should be
utilized partly at least for reducing borrowing for working capital purpose. In
assessing maximum permissible bank finance, bank should adopt the second
method of lending, recommended by the Tandon study group, according to
which the borrower’s contribution from owned funds and term finance to meet
the working capital requirements should be equal to at least 25 percent of the
total current assets. In cases where the borrowers may not be in a position to
comply with this requirement immediately, the excess borrowing should be
segregated and treated as working capital loan, repayable in half yearly
installment (maximum five year) and rate of interest should not be less than
the rate sanctioned for cash credit limit.
2. The existing system of lending (cash credit, loan and bill) should continue but
wherever possible the use of cash credit should be supplemented by loans and
bills. However, there should be scrutiny of the operation of the cash credit
accounts at least once in a year.
3. Bifurcation of cash credit in demand loan for corporation and fluctuation cash
credit component and to maintain a differential interest rate between these two
components is withdrawn.
4. Banks should appraise and fix separate limits for the “normal nonpeak level”
and for the “peak level” credit requirements for all borrowers in excess of Rs.
Ten lakhs indicating the relevant periods.
5. Drawal of funds to be regulated through quarterly statements within the
sanctioned limit, borrower should intimate his need of funds in advance.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 36
6. Borrowers should be discouraged from frequent seeking adhoc or temporary
limits in excess of sanctioned limits to meet unforeseen contingencies.
Additional interest of one percent should normally be charged for such limits.
7. Advances against the book-debts should be converted to bills wherever
possible and at least 50 percent of the cash credit limit utilized for financing
purchase of raw material inventory should also be changed to this bill system.
According to the committee, the major plank of the cash credit system to be
applied by the commercial banks is that commercial banks should assess the
maximum permissible working capital limits to a borrower by adopting the seconf
method of lending or Prakash Tondon Committee. Thus means that borrower’s
contribution form his own funds and long-term resources for meeting working capital
needs should be at least 25 percent of total current assets.
1.17 S.S. MARATHE COMMITTEE
The Reserve Bank of India appointed in November 1982 a committee under
the chairmanship of Shri S.S. Marathe to review the working of the credit
authorization scheme form the point of view of its operational aspects. The terms of
reference of the committee were:
I. To examine the objective, scope and content of the scheme and make
suggestion with regard to the changing economic situation;
II. To examine the adequacy or otherwise of the credit appraisal
machinery/procedures in the commercial banks;
III. To study the existing set-up for compliance with the requirements of the
scheme within the commercial banks both at the head and regional office
levels;
IV. To examine the existing data base for recommendations by banks to the
RBI for authorizing a given level of credit for a particular period;
V. To examine the existing format for submitting applications for banks to the
RBI in respect of seeking authorization and suggest modifications therein;
and
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 37
VI. To study the desirability of introducing time-bound guidelines to be
observed within the guidelines of the Reserve Bank for speeding up the
processing and disposal of applications.
The committee submitted its report to the Reserve Bank in July, 1983. The
recommendations of the committee were accepted with some modifications by the
Reserve Bank. The banks have been advised to implement the following procedural
changes in the administration of the credit Authorization scheme with effect from
April 1, 1984 as indicated below:
1) Banks may release credit up to a maximum of 50% of the additional limits for
which RBI authorization is sought wherever credit proposals satisfy certain
stipulations;
2) As a measure of further incentive for predominantly export oriented units
coming under the purview of CAS, RBI authorization is up to a maximum of
75% of the additional limits for which authorization is sought, subject to their
satisfying the prescribed requirements;
3) All other credit proposals should be referred to the Reserve Bank of India for
prior authorizations as at present;
4) In case the borrower is an urgent of funds, banks may grant facilities, as at
present, on ad hoc basis over a period of three months to any of the CAS
borrowers under exceptional circumstances not exceeding 25% of the existing
working capital. This is subject to an overall ceiling of Rs.75 lakhs:
5) Banks need not refer to RBI for prior authorization for letters of credit
facilities covering acquisition of capital as well as non capital goods, provided
that the conditions prescribed are complied with before opening the letters of
credit. The exemption of letters of credit facility form CAS is allowed on
experimental basis:
6) The banks are advised that the discipline in use of bank credit employed in
the credit authorization scheme has to be accepted as a permanent feature and
that, for borrowers readily willing to between the submissions of a credit
proposal and actual disposal recommendations of the Marathe Committee,
substantial discretionary powers are vested in commercial banks to facilitate
faster release of funds to parties covered by CAS without prior approval of
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 38
RBI provided that banks are satisfied with the proposal being fully in
conformity with the norms laid down by the Reserve Bank.
Recommendations:
(1) Banks may release credit up to a maximum of 50% of the additional limits for
which RBI authorization is sought wherever credit proposals satisfy certain
stipulations. As a measure of further incentive to the predominantly export-
oriented units, banks can deploy funds before receipt of RBI authorizations up
to a maximum of 75% of the additional units for which the authorizations is
sought;
(2) All other credit proposals would continue to be referred to RBI for prior
authorizations;
(3) In case the borrows is an urgent need of funds, banks may grant facilities on
an ad hoc basis for a period of 3 months to any of CAS borrowers under
exceptional circumstance, not exceeding 25% of existing working capital
limits. This is subject to an overall ceiling of Rs.75 lakhs as against Rs.50
lakhs earlier.
(4) Banks need not refer to RBI for prior authorization in proposal for letters of
credit facilities covering acquisitions of capital as well as non-capital goods,
provided the conditions prescribed are complied with before opening the
letters of credit.
1.18 CONCLUSION
The relative liquidity of the firm’s assets structure is measured by the current
assets to fixed assets ratio. The greater this ratio, the less risky as well as less
profitable will be the firm and vice versa. Similarly, the relative liquidity of the firm’s
financial structure can be measured by the short-term financing to total financing
ratio. The lower this ratio, the less risky as well as less profitable will be the firm and
vice versa. In shaping its working capital policy, the firm should keep in mind these
two dimensions – relative asset liquidity and relative financing liquidity of the
working capital management. A firm will be following a very conservative working
policy if it combines a high level of current assets with a high level of long-term
financing. Such a policy will not be risky at all and would be less profitable. An
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 39
aggressive firm, on the other hand, would combine low level of current assets with a
high level of long-term financing. .This will have high profitability and high risk. In
fact, the firm may follow a conservative financing policy to counter its relatively
illiquid assets structure in practice. The conclusion of all this it that the considerations
of assets and financing mixes are crucial to the working capital management.
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 40
1.19 REFERENCES
1. Praveen Kumar jai, Working Capital Management, (R B S A Publishers:
Jaipur) First Edition-1993, Page no-1 to 2.
2. H. G. Guthmann, analysis Of Financial Statements,(New Yourk: Prentice
Hall) IV Edition-1953,
3. Hoglend. J. Bierman, and A. K. Mc Adams, Management Decisions for Cash
and Marketable Securities,( New York : Graduate School of Business, Cornell
University), 1962.
4. J. L. Brown and L.R. Howard. Principle and practice of management
accountancy. ( London: Mac Donald & evans Ltd.,) 1975 , Page
5. J. Fred Weston and F. Eugene Brigham, Managerial Finance,(New York:
Dryden Press) First Edition-1975,
6. Prof. J. J. Jani & others, Accounting & finance-2 (Finance
Section)(Ahmedabad: C. Jamnadas & Co.) First edition-2009-2010,
7. S.C. Kuchhal, Financial Management – An Analytical and Conceptual
Approch, (Allahabad: Chaitanya publishing House) – 1982.
8. Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, (New York, Modern Library Inc., 1937),
pp.262-263.
9. H.G. Guthman, Analysis of Financial Statements (New York, 1953), p.63.
10. R.D. Kennedy and McMullen, Financial Statements – Form Analysis and
Interpretations, (1968), pp. 265-266.
11. Parasanna Chandra, Financial Management Theory and Practice (New Delhi:
Tata McGraw Hill Publishing Company Ltd., 1984), p.260.
12. V.L. Gole, Fitzerald’s Ananysis and Interpretation of Financial Statement.
13. Ibid., p.51
14. P.V. Kulkarni, financial Management – A Conceptual Approach (with
problems and review questions) (Bomby: Himalaya Publishing
House),Seventh Edition 1996,
15. R. D. Kennedy and S. V. McMullen, Financial statement: Form, Analysis and
Interpretation, (Homewood; Richard D. Irwin Inc.,) 1964
16. I. M. Pandey Financial Management, (New Delhi: Vikas Publishing House
Pvt. Ltd), 1979
www.examisthan.com
WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT: CONCEPT, IMPORTANCE AND OBJECTS
CHAPTER - 1 PAGE 41
17. P. V. Kulkarni, op.cit, page 377 to 381.
18. M. Y. Khan and P. K. Jain, Financial management, (New Delhi: Tata McGraw
Hill Publishing Company Ltd.) ,1989
19. S. N. Mittal, Management Accounting & Financial Management. (New Dilhi :
Shree Mahavir Book Depot), 1986 Part-II, Chapter- II.
20. O. M. Joy, introduction to financial management, (Homewood: Richard D.
Irwin, Inc., Illinois,) 1977, Page-406
21. P. V. Kulkarni op.cit, page 393.
22. N. K. Kulshrestha. Theory and practice of Management Accounting., (
Aligarh: Navman Prakashan, ) 1985-86 page – 40.
23. Statistical Outline of India 2007-2008 page 178, 180
24. Van Horne, James C. financial management and Policy, (New Dehli: Prentice-
Hall Of India Pvt. Ltd) , 1982, Page.390,
25. Cossaboom, Roger A., let’s Reassess the Profitability-liquidity Trade-off,
Financial Executive (may 1971) Page- 46-51(I.M. Pandey)
26. O. M. Joy, op. cit page- 408.
27. I. M. Pandey, op. cit page- 294.
28. Nand K. Sharma, Advance Financial Management, ( Jaipur: DND
Publications) First edition-2011, Page -115-118
29. O. M. Joy, op. cit page-417.
30. I. M. Pandey, op. cit page- 295
31. Todon Committee Report, Published By Government of India, New Delhi,
1975.
32. Chore Committee Report, Published By Government of India, New Delhi,
1979.
33. S.S. Marathe Committee, Published By Government of India, New Delhi,
1983-1984.
www.examisthan.com
14
CHAPTER II
TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES OF FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
The body of information describing even the smallest firm
is enormous, spaning the company's internal operations and
its relations with the outside world. To be useful this infor-
mation must be organised into an understandable, coherent and
sufficiently limited set of data. Financial statement analysis
can be very helpful in this respect because it highlights the
performance of the business.
The purpose of financial analysis is to diagnose the current
and past financial condition of a firm and to give some clues
about its future condition1.
Eugene F. Brigham opines that "from an investor's standpoint
predicting the future is what financial statement analysis
is all about; from management's standpoint financial statement
analysis is useful both as a way to anticipate future conditions
and more important as a starting point for planning actions
that will influence the future course of events2.
1. Gup E. Benton, principles of Financial Management John Willeg & Sons, New York, 1983, p.348.
2. Eugene F. Brigham, Op.Cit. p.196
www.examisthan.com
15
Analysis of financial statements is an exercise in the
re-arrangement of complex accounting reports into simplified
information3.
The analysis and interpretation is essential to bring
out the mystery behind the figures in financial statements4.
DEVICES USED IN ANALYSING FINANCIAL STATEMENTS :
Various methods are used to study the relationship between
different statements. An effort is made to use those devices
which clearly analyse the financial position of the enterprise.
The following methods of analysis are generally used.
1. Comparative financial statements
2. Trend analysis
3. Common size statements
4. Ratio analysis
5. Funds Flow Analysis.
3. Murthy Guru Prasad Management Accounting, Himalaya Publishing House, Bombay, 1987, p.453.
4. Sharma R.K. and Shashi K. Gupta, Management Accounting, Kalyani Publishers, New Delhi, 1987, p.75.
www.examisthan.com
16
COMPARATIVE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS :
The comparative financial statements will provide a compari-
son between two stipulated periods for an organisation. It
will also provide a comparison for two or more enterprises
for one or more accounting periods. These statements are de-
signed to disclose (i) Absolute figures, (ii) Changes in absolute
figures, (iii) Absolute data in terms of percentages and (iv)
Changes in terms of percentages.
Comparative figures will indicate the trend and direction
of financial position and operating results. The two comparative
statements are Balance Sheet and Income statement of an or-
ganisation.
COMPARATIVE BALANCE SHEET :
It represents not merely the balance of accounts drawn
on two different dates but also the extent of their increase
or decrease between these two dates. It focuses on the changes
that have taken place in one accounting period. The changes
are the direct outcome of operational activities.
www.examisthan.com
17
COMPARATIVE INCOME STATEMENT :
The comparative income statement gives an idea of the
progress made of a business over a period of time. The changes
in absolute money values and percentages can be determined
to analyse the profitability of the business.
TREND ANALYSIS :
The financial statements may be analysed by computing
trends of series of information. This method determines the
direction of change over the period. It involves the comput-
ation of the percentage relationship that each item in the
statement bears to the same item in the base year. The infor-
mation for a number of years is taken up and the first year
is taken as the base year. The figures of base year are taken
as 100 and trend ratios for the subsequent years are calculated
on the basis of base year. The analyst is able to ascertain
the trend of figures upward or downward.
Trend analysis includes the selection of a representative
period as a base and expressing all items in the financial
statements of the periods studied in terms of an index5.
5. Murthy Guruprasad Op.Cit, p.454.
www.examisthan.com
COMMON-SIZE STATEMENTS :
When the balance sheet and income statement items are
shown in analytical percentages i.e., the percentages that
each item bears to the total of the appropriate item such as
total assets, total liabilities, capital and net sales, the
common base for comparison is provided. The statements compiled
in this form are termed as commnnsim statements.
Common-size income statement shows each item as a percent-
age of sales and a common size balance sheet shows each item
as a percentage of total assets. The significant advantage
of common size statements is that they facilitate comparisons
of balance sheets and income statements overtime and across
. 6 compan/es .
RATIO ANALYSIS :
Ratio analysis is a powerful tool of financial analysis.
Its application to financial statements however appears to
be of recent origin. The construction of ratios is a major
analytical tool in the hands of financial executives. The
18
6. Eugene F. Brigham Financial Management Theory and Practice, Rinchart and Winston Saunders College Publishing, 185, p.891
www.examisthan.com
19
ratios facilitate the analysts in pointing out the relative
importance of the various items appearing in the financial
statements. Each major item in the balance sheet and profit
and loss account has a relationship with one or more items
in either or both statements which can be expressed in ratios.
But using ratios comparison with financial statements of other
firms are facilitated and comparison of a firm's financial
performance can too be made over a period of time.
RATIO :
Ratiois simply one number expressed in terms of another.
It is an expression of relationship spelt out by dividing one
figure into the other. The relationship between two figures
expressed mathematically is called a ratio.
As per the Dictionary meaning Ratio represents the relation
of one thing on another of which the quotient is the measure.
According to J.Batty, the term accounting ratio is used
to describe the significant relationship between figures in
a balance sheet, profit and loss account in a budgetary control,
system or any other part of accounting organisation7.
7. Batty J. Op.Cit, p.408.
www.examisthan.com
20
Financial ratios portray relationships that exist between
various items appearing in balance sheets and income accounts
and occasionally other items. They may be expressed in simple
mathematical terms. They are used to measure and evaluate
the financial condition and operating effectiveness of a business
. 8 enterprise .
•
Ratios provide the analyst with a set of summary which
measures of the firm's debt burden, operating efficiency and
profitability9.
Financial ratios are no substitute for a crystal ball.
They are just a convenient way to summarise large quantities
of financial data and to compare firm's performance 1?
ROLE OF RATIO ANALYSIS :
Ratio analysis means the process of computing, determing
and presenting relationship of items and groups of items in
the financial statements. It is a device to diagnose the fin-
ancial discease of an enterprise.
8. The Encylopedia of Management, Edited by CARL Heyel Manage-ment Counsel, Van.Nostrand Reinhold Company, New York, 1973.p.247.
9. Schall D. Lawrence and Haley W. Charles, Introduction to Financial Management, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1977, p.435.
10. Richard Brealey/Stewart Myers Op.Cit. p.569.
www.examisthan.com
21
A single ratio in itself is meaningless - it does not
furnish a complete picture. It becomes meaningful only when
compared with other ratios or the same ratios over a period
of time/
The ratios are diagnostic tests. A single diagnostic
test does not provide adequate information about a company
to evaluate its current conditions. Therefore, many diagnostic
tests are used to obtain a complete picture11
.
Ratio analysis is a convenient means of focussing the
attention of the analyst on specific relationships which require
further investigation. Ratio analysis of business enterprises
centers on efforts to derive quantitative measures or guides
concerning the expected capacity of the firm to meet its future
financial obligations
The final accounts for any period
'bring to light many figures which some times appear to be quite
unconnected with one another, but if brought together in a
particular manner, they reveal many interesting relations with
one another. These results show peculiar trends in business.
Ratio analysis is the best available means to relate these
figures together.
11. Gup E. Benton OixCit, p.352.
12. Archer A. Stephen And D'Ambrosio A. Charles Business Finance Theory and Management. The Macmillon Company, New York and Collier, Mac Millan Limited, London, 1971, p.498.
www.examisthan.com
22
Ratio analysis is also defined as the process of establish-
ing and interpreting various ratios for helping in making certain
decisions13.
ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF RATIOS :
Analysis is the dissection of a complex statement into
elements and varied compartments. Whereas Interpretation brings
out the meaning of such statements with the help of analysis.
There are four different ways in which ratios may be interpreted.
1. The individual ratio, by itself may have significance
of its own. Thus, if the current ratio falls constantly
and even goes below one, it may indicate that the liqui-
dity position of the concern is not encouraging.
2. Ratios may be interpreted by expanding the analysis
and considering a group of several related ratios.
In this way, the ratios whose significance is not fully
understood are made more meaningful by the computation
of additional ratios like the profitability ratios.
13. Sharma R.K. and Shasi K. Gupta, Op.Cit. p.113.
www.examisthan.com
23
3. The ratios may be compared over time. Moreover the
same ratio or a group of ratios is studied over a period
of years which indicates significant trends like increase
or decrease in stability, etc.
4. The ratios of any given firm may be compared with the
ratios of other firms in the same industry known as
interfirm comparison. Such comparisons are significant
as members of the same industry face similar financial
problems.
MERITS :
Ratios give a better idea than the absolute figures placed
side by side. Ratios become meaningful when compared with
other ratios or with ratios of similar firms. It is an effective
tool in controlling the entire business and planning for the
future needs.
The merits of ratio analysis are :
1. Ratio analysis simplifies the comprehension of financial
statements.
2. Ratios portray the whole story of changes in the financial
position of the business.
www.examisthan.com
24
3. It provides data for interfirm comparison by which
one firm can improve its financial standing and compete
successfully with another.
4. Ratios highlight the factors associated with successful
and unsuccessful firms.
5. Ratio analysis also makes possible comparison of the
performance of the same unit over a period of time.
They are helpful in deciding about the efficiency or
otherwise, in the past and likely performance in the
future.
6. Ratio analysis helps in planning and forecasting the
future activities of the firm.
7. Over a period of time, a firm or industry develops
certain norms that may indicate future success or failure.
Ratios are effective clues as to whether success may
result if the same norms are followed.
www.examisthan.com
25
LIMITATIONS OF RATIO ANALYSIS :
Ratio Analysis conducted in a mechanical manner is dangerous.
However, used intelligently and with good judgement ratios
can provide useful insights into a firm's operationi*.
Quantitative relations of the kind represented by ratio
analysis are not ends in themselves, but are only means provided
for understanding a farm's financial position. Quantitative
ratio analysis is not capable of providing precise answers
to all the problems faced by a financial manager or a potential
fund supplier unless several ratios often related to one another
are computed and compared.
Various limitations of ratios are as follows :
1. Ratios are meaningless by itself and acquire significance
only when they are studied along with other ratios.
2. Ratio analysis focuses on the accounting data some
of which at times turnout to be mere estimates. Any
analysis based on the estimated figures, lacks precision
which is very essential for the successful implement-
ation of the physical as well as monetary targets.
14. Campsey B.J. and Eugene Brigham F. Introduction to Financial Management. The Dryden Press Holt Rinchart and Winston Saunders College Publishing, 1985, p. 173.
www.examisthan.com
26
3. Ratios provide only a part of the information needed
in the process of decision-making. The infrmation
derived from the ratios must be used with that obtained
from other sources so as to ensure a balanced approach
in solving the problems.
4. Ratio analysis suffers from the serious limitations
of the statistical concepts such as determination of
proper standard for comparison, absence of the homogeneity
of the data and danger of fallacious conclusions.
5. Financial analysis based on accounting ratios will
give misleading results if the effects of changes in
price level are not taken into account.
6. The qualitative factors which are important for the
successful functioning of the organisation are completely
ignored by the ratio analysis and hence, the conclu-
sions drawn may get distorted.
Ratio analysis is indeed, a double edged sword which requires
a great deal of understanding and sensitivity of the management
process rather than mechanical financial skill. But even with
these limitations and problems the use of ratios to indicate
future trends in business has increased to a great e:xtent.
www.examisthan.com
27
Ratios calculated from the available data in the financial
statements may be classified as follows :
1. PROFITABILITY RATIOS :
Profitability ratios measure the efficiency of
the company's activities and its ability to generate
profits. Poor performance indicates the failure of
the business which may lead to liquidation of the company
in the long run.
2. SOLVENCY RATIOS :
These ratios examine the adequacy of funds and
the company's ability to pay its obligations when it
becomes due. These ratios measure the short-term solven-
cy of the company.
3. EFFICIENCY AND PERFORMANCE RATIOS :
These ratios indicate the effective utilisation
of various assets and funds invested by the creditors
and shareholders. The better the management of funds
and assets the larger the amount of sales, and hence
the profits of the company.
www.examisthan.com
FUNDS FLOW ANALYSIS :
The limitations of financial statements forced the need
for a seperate additional financial statement to highlight
on the major financing and investment activities of a firm
known as funds statement. It summarises various sources from
which funds are obtained and uses to which they have been applied.
The concept of 'Funds' refers to 'Net Working Capital'.
Any increase in the net working capital is a source of fund
and any decrease in working capital becomes an application
of fund. The various sources from which funds derived are:
1. Operations of business
2. Income from investments
3. Sale of fixed assets and long-term investments
4. Subscription by shareholders
5. Increase in long-term debts.
The funds so derived by a business concern are applied
in the following ways :
1. Operating losses
2. Redemption of long-term loans and debentures
3. Redemption of Redeemable preference share capital
4. Payment of cash dividend
5. Acquisition of fixed assets
6. Purchase of investments.
28 www.examisthan.com
29
The flow of funds refers to movement of funds involving
'Inflow' and 'Outflow' in the working capital. This happens
when changes occur in non-current accounts such as fixed assets,
long-term debts etc., and are offset by corresponding changes
in current accounts such as current assets or current liabilities.
The funds flow statement which is popularly known as
'Statement of Sources and Application of Funds' focuses on
the flow of funds between various assets and equity items during
an accounting period. It reveals the manner in which the fin-
ancial resources have been obtained and ueaised during an account-
ing period. •
Funds flow statement provide an additional perspective
on the nature of the financial condition of a company.
Funds flow analysis is a decisional display of managements
disposition of short and long-term funds available for oper-
ations and investment15.
15. Erich A. HelFert,Techniques of Financial Analysis, Dow- Jones-Irwin Inc,Homewood Illinois, 1972, p.36.
www.examisthan.com
30
A statement of changes in financial position is a deri-
vative financial statement that shows the amount by which each
item on successive balance sheets have changed and in addition
identifies the reason for the change16.
A more accurate and useful analysis of changes in the
distribution of resources between balance sheet dates is found
in the statement of the sources and application of funds17.
USES OF FUNDS FLOW STATEMENT :
It is through analysis of this statement a proper under-
standing of the changes in the distribution of resources between
the two balance sheets can be had.
The funds statement shows the financial consequence of
business operations. It is quite possible that a concern may
operate profitably without any improvement in the liquidity
position. This is wholly due to the fact that all economic
values do not possess the same financial flexibility as cash
and related resources. The fund flow statement reveals such
irreconcilable situations.
16. Ramesh K.S. Rao Financial Management concepts and Appli- cations, Macmillan Publishing Co. New York, Collier Mac- millan Publishers, London, 1987, p.119.
17. Robert H.Wessel Principles of Financial Analysis. The Macmillan Company, New York, 1961, p.59.
www.examisthan.com
31
This statement is useful to the lenders such as banks
and other financial institutions, as it indicates them the
liquidity position of the firm and its ability to pay interest
regularly and return the principal sum.
It serves as an instrument for allocation of resources
when the business concerns launch their future expansion as
well as diversification programmes, the need for arrangement
of the funds arises. The amount of funds made available through
normal business operations is ascertained through the projection
of the funds flow analysis.
The funds flow statement shows the urgencies of operation-
al issues and facilitates settlement of priorities in a phased
manner.
This statement indicates the effectiveness of the manage-
ment in the handlingpf the working capital during the accounting
period. It also helps the management in deciding whether to
issue more of equity shares or increase long-terms debts.
In short, the funds statement helps the .management in the de-
cision-making process in case of expansion, diversification
or conservation of more funds for profitable utilisation on
sound projects in subsequent years.
www.examisthan.com
32
LIMITATIONS :
While the managerial uses of the funds statement cannot
be underestimated the use of it as tool by the financial analyst
should be done with utmost care and caution.
Though the funds statement furnishes factual information
not supplied by the traditional financial statements the fact
that it ignores non-fund transactions, makes it a dangerous
tool for application in financial analysis.
The funds statement is prepared on the basis of the figures
from financial statements already prepared and hence, does
not introduce an element of original evidence to the financial
change or status.
Any projection of flow statement based on the figures
from the two balance sheets deals with the past and becomes
historical in nature.
Inspite of the above limitations the funds flow statement
is of immense use to the management, in providing the information
not furnished by the traditional financial statements and helps
in the decision making process affecting the success of any
business unit.
www.examisthan.com
33
STATEMENT OF CHANGES IN WORKING CAPITAL :
In the funds statement the difference between the total
of sources and the total of applications constitutes either
increase or decrease in the working capital for the accounting
period under review. This variation in working capital is
verified through a seperate statement depicting changes in
working capital. This statement shows the current assets and
current liabilities at the beginning and end of the accounting
period and the net effect of their changes between two periods
on the working capital.
The primary prupose of this Chapter is to discuss the
techniques used by investors, creditors and managers to analyse
the financial statements of a business. Financial analysis
is designed to determine strengths and weaknesses of a firm-
whether the firm is financially sound and profitable relative
to other firms in its industry and whether its position is
improving or deteriorating overtime. The study of financial
analysis of SIVL concentrated on a set of ratios designed to
highlight the key aspects of its operations. Funds Flow state-
ment analysis was also included to assess the changes in finan-
cial position of the unit under study.
www.examisthan.com
1
Chapter-1
Conceptual Framework of Social Responsibility Accounting
o Introduction
o Conventional and Social Responsibility Accounting
o Meaning of Social Responsibility Accounting
o Nature of Social Responsibility Accounting
o Objective of Study
o Scope of Study
Introduction
Business activity in our country greatly affects the economy of that country-higher the degree of the business activity in an economy higher the degree of the development in that economy as business activity and development are directly related to each other. Development of the economy means creation of the new employment opportunities in the economy, establishment of large number of industries increase of commercial activities, avoidance unfruitful competition and increasing of standard of living of the people living in the economy.
So far as business concerns it is an economic activity which is engaged in the production and distribution of goods and services to earn profit or to serve the society. So basically there are two activities which constitute business –production activity and distribution of the product. Production is concerned with the industries and distribution is concerned with the commerce. Any unit or bushiness or firm which is engaged in the production of goods or services is called an industry and activity which is engaged in distribution goods from producers to customers is commerce. So Industry is concern with production of goods and commerce is concerns with the services only.
First activity is industry; it may be of different kinds. For example, manufacturing industry is engaged in giving particular form or shape to raw-materials by utilizing the services of expert and skilled personnel or workers. It may include analytical, processing or assembly industry. Genetic industry is concerned with the exploration of new and advance technique of production or new variety of
www.examisthan.com
2
seeds and fertilizer so that production can be increased upto the highest efficiency level. There may be construction industry very much engaged in the construction activities. And extractive industry is concerned with the extraction of minerals, metals, coal or oil from the earth or from water. So industry is concerned with the production of goods or giving a particular shape of form to raw materials so that consumer can make use of it.
Second activity is commerce. Commerce is generally a link between the producers and consumers. Producer is different person though at the same time producer may be also consumer and consumer is different person. There is no link between these two. Production function is done where raw material, cheap labour, suitable climate, power and energy are easily available and consumer live generally at a place where all kinds of civil amenities are available to them. So there is a need of common place where both producers and consumers can meet so that producer can know very well the habits and the choice of consumers and consumer can know very well about the products to be produced by the industry and at the same time its quality and applicability. Commerce provides a market to both producers as well as consumers. It makes the buying and selling function easy. It creates time utility by storing and warehousing the goods when goods are not demanded, creates place utility by transporting goods from one place to another place where those goods find demand and gives information of new products or of existing products to consumers through advertisement or through sales agents. In this way commerce helps the consumers. So it shows that production and distribution are related, similarly industry and commerce are also closely related to each other.
But the success of industrial and commercial activity depends on the society. It is society which gives importance to this activity. Society is the organization and composition of the people leaving under different customs and tradition .But in economic since society means the group of consumers. Society greatly affects the business activity of a country and it is a belief that if business activity is too flourishes, then society should be developed and get advanced. There should be educated society and there should be awareness in the society Business and society are very closely related to each other. Both have no existence without each other. On the other hand it can be said that they are the two sides on one coin and success of both depends on their success themselves. If society is undeveloped and people are not very much aware and conscious, business cannot flourish and if there is lack of business activity then society cannot developed.
As far as objectives of business is concerned ,it main object is to earn profit because without earning profit how can a business serve the society , So profit is
www.examisthan.com
3
very much necessary for the development of the society . The object of business isto supply goods and services to the customers-the part of the society, to provide employment and income to people, to give incentives and motivation for the satisfaction of employees-at the same time part of society, payment of fair wages and bonus to it employees, donation to education and community welfare programs, housing and medical facilities to employees and payment of taxes to local, state and central government etc.
So business and society are very closely related .Business units have to performvarious responsibilities towards the internal as well as external users as both live in the society. Internal member are share holders, managerial staff, board of directors, employee, etc. and external party which are affected by business activities are creditor’s debenture-holders, consumers, government etc. Individually, a person may be classified as internal or external parties, but as a human being he is supposed to be the part of society and therefore, each and every person should be very much careful about performing his activities which affects the society. Business activities should always satisfy the society’s welfare program. It should be careful about environment i.e. Air pollution, water pollution, solid waste discharged by it, which very badly affect the social life and adversely affect the health of persons leaving in the society.
Another important social responsibility of the business in the relation between the government and business as both are supposed to be caretaker of the society’s welfare. There should be clear cut rules and regulations, and good understanding between the government and business activities.
Another area of responsibilities is consumers. All Business activities depend solely on the consumer’s interest. Success and failure of business depends on consumer’s taste, preferences, choices, habits etc. consumer is very important part of the society. Individually he turns as member of the society and is also affected by the atmosphere in which he lives by the facilities provided to him in general as an employee in the business concern. The moment individual purchases the different communities produced by the concerns of takes the services he become consumer. Business activities should be very much careful about consumer’s satisfaction. Consumerism is growing in every economy. Business is essentially requires to protected the consumer’s right to meet the challenge of consumerism.
Similarly, business should fulfill its responsibilities towards its employees by providing various facilities like, medical, housing, transportation, Entertainment, educational facilities, promotion of art and culture etc.
www.examisthan.com
4
Shareholders or owners of the business concern who bear risk and invest theircapital in the business, are also a part of society, so business concern should be careful to provide them proper rate of return on their investment to satisfy them and ultimately satisfy the society itself.
So, business is an economic activity to produce and distribute the goods and services. Though its primary objective is to earn profit, yet it should satisfy both economic and social needs. Business must earn profit because without having sufficient amount of profit it cannot fulfill the various social obligations. It is an important social and economic institution, established to safeguard the interest of employees, Shareholders, Creditors, Debenture-holders, suppliers, customers, government and general public.
Conventional and Social responsibility Accounting
The primary function of conventional accounting is measurement of economic consequences in terms of money, whereas social accounting seeks to determine important variable of social consequences in terms of socio-economic non monetary effects along with economic consequences.
Modern accounting theory and information economics are directed towards general assumptions capable of deriving accounting structure from specific information goals. Such a structure insists on more and more emphasis on fulfilling the role of control mechanism, not merely internally and for shareholders but for the society at large. Social responsibility accounting is a branch of accounting dealing with the functioning of economic system as a whole. It may be considered as the accounting for community. Social responsibility accounting includes the area like ‘pollution control’, ‘equal employment opportunity’, ‘charitable-contributions’, ‘community relations’, ‘product-quality’, ‘plant-safety’, ‘employee benefits’, and responsiveness to ‘consumer complaints’.
The function of social responsibility accounting is to measure and disclose the ‘costs’ and ‘benefits’ to society created by the production related activities of a business enterprise. Attributes of social concern are usually recognized in annual reports. They include product and quality improvement, fair business practices, human resources, environment and community involvement.
Conventional accounting and social accounting systems differ from each other in the following common respects-
www.examisthan.com
5
Time of evaluation
Conventional accounting is the oldest concept of accounting. It was evolved about 510 years ago in 1494 by Lucapacioli, a Greek mathematician. But social responsibility accounting is a new concept of accounting. The macro sense of social responsibility accounting is national accounting which is used by economists was first introduced by De Queng in France in 1758 and micro sense of social responsibility accounting which is used by accountants was developed in early 1970s in the USA.
Basis of accounting
Conventional accounting is concerned with the measurement of economic consequences in terms of money. But in social responsibility accounting both monetary and non-monetary factors recognized.
Accounting System
Conventional accounting is based on double entry system. Despite it in certain cases single entry system or incomplete recording may be followed whereas no such specific well known system is followed for social accounting. Social accounting remains at the developing state and as a result deferent approaches are now using in different countries of the world like narrative method, social statement, value added, and method and so on.
Books of Accounts
In conventional certain specific book of account like journal, ledger, and so on are maintained systematically together with some statistical books. But in social accounting no such specific books of accounts are maintained. However, under social cost-benefit (Social statement) method accounts can be prepared on some predetermined bases.
www.examisthan.com
6
Preparation of annual statement
In Conventional accounting final or annual statement are prepared in specific format and in systematic manner whereas in social accounting the annual social statement are prepared not as per specific format and not in systematic way.
Nature of data
The data used in conventional accounting I objective in nature. As a result, the arithmetic accuracy can be judged at different stages of this accounting and there is a little scope of arising inter-personal variation but the data used in social accounting is very subjective in nature. The arithmetic accuracy cannot be judged here moreover, the figures vary person to person.
Purpose
Conventional accounting aims judging whether and how far the financial and personal objectives of equity have been fulfilled while social accounting aims at judging whether and how far the social objective have been fulfilled in view of the performance of social responsibilities and so on.
As far as corporate annual reporting is concerned, it is based on British policy but later on it was greatly influenced by the international professional group. The Indian Companies Act 1956 played the key role in the development of corporate annual reports. According to section 165 of the Indian Companies Act 1956, statutory reporter should include – Profit and Loss Account, Balance Sheet Director’s Report, and Auditor’s Report. It has been also observed that Indian profit and loss account and balance sheet is less innovative and informative. Generally Indian financial statement is prepared within the legal framework to comply with the legal requirements. Even Section 227 (4A) of Indian Companies Act 1956, which requires the auditor to make a report and express an opinion , whether the corporation’s profit and loss account and balance sheet, exhibits ‘true and fair’ view of companies state of affairs, does not mention about corporate social reporting.
It seems that Indian financial reporting is defensive. It includes only statutory reports and non-statutory reports are not prepared in Indian corporations. The various neglected factors in Indian balance sheet are human resources of the organization, social responsibilities etc. Though this act has been amended
www.examisthan.com
7
number of times, but no provision has been enacted for the disclosure of social responsibilities in corporate annual reports.
Later on, various seminars and conferences were organized and sponsored by various agencies to create awareness among various corporate sectors about their social responsibilities and how to discharge their social obligation. Attempts were also made to make disclosure of social responsibilities mandatory also.
The real effort came in when the Sachaar Committee was appointed by the government, under the chairmanship of Justice Rajindar Sachaar to accelerate the process in respect of corporate social reporting. The committee was constituted to consider and report on the changes which are necessary in the form and structure of the act. The committee has made various recommendations regarding accounts, audit, social responsibilities etc. The committee recommended the inclusion of particulars in the director’s report.
Meaning of Social Responsibility Accounting
Meaning
In, earlier times, when economy was not very much developed, large number of small scale business units were operating in the form of sole trading and partnership firms requiring less amount of capital, labour and entrepreneurship skills and experience. These business units were not required to present their annual report showing profit and loss account and balance sheet. Then industrial revolution took place and large number of large scale business units came into existence, producing and distributing goods and services in huge quantities and huge amount of capital and labour were required to establish and run these business units. These business units took the company form of organization, having separate legal entity from individuals managing the hole business activities, these business units were legally required to publish its annual reports describing its total expenditure and income during the period in the form of prescribed profit and loss account and the actual financial position of the business at that date through balance sheet. So, this was the concept of presenting annual reports including chairman’s and director’s report. There was no mention about social reporting.
Accounting was being considered as means and not an end and this means should be determined according to the ends rather; ends should not be determined according to the means. The ‘end’ of accounting means according of few
www.examisthan.com
8
analyses – “As process of communicating economic information to permit informed judgments and decisions by the users of information.” “Thus, it provides the users a source of financial information to guide to future course of action.”1 So, conventional financial reporting was mainly concentrated to report only about profit and loss account and balance sheet of the concern. This technique is being used as tool to focus and measure real financial position of the concern and repots of financial results were used to be given only to owners and investors. But it is not supposed to be the end of accounting process. The accounting report should consist of financial results as well as social results showing social performance of that business unit.
Generally, it is found that traditional financial reporting remains silent and ignores reporting regarding social activities of the business. It does not report about social economic conditions under which that business operates. The annual report does not mention about social responsibilities like housing facility, medical facility, educational facility, canteen facility, local tax payments, environmental protection, job facilities etc. but now this concept is changing and growth and development of corporate organization and their important role in the society have given rise to reporting on social responsibilities in their annual report. Government has also made binding in this regard.
The term social responsibility accounting is generally confused with number of terms as social audit, social information system, social reporting, socio- economic accounting, social accounting social disclosure, corporate social performance, etc., but all these terms have the same meaning and these terms are used interchangeably for one another.2 In fact these terms are in the process of evolution and crystallization. They underline that corporate enterprises have a responsibility to maintain and promote quality of life of the community.3
As far as meaning of social responsibility accounting concerned, it is an accounting report of social activities performed by business units for the welfare of society. As business cannot exist without society, therefore each and every business unit is required to give accounting report of its social activities. Social responsibility accounting means reporting of various social responsibilities of the business, i.e. accounting repot of the expense incurred on education facilities, medical facilities, canteen facilities, housing facilities, transportation facilities, water and electricity facilities, job opportunities for minorities, entertainment facilities, tax paid to local or state government, donation and charity for social welfare etc.
www.examisthan.com
9
So, social responsibility accounting is an accounting report of social expense and social benefits of that business unit. “Social reporting or social accounting is a rational assessment of and reporting on some meaningful definable domain of business activities to the public as well as other interested parties regarding its social performances, measuring either in monetary or non- monetary terms, being beneficial or baneful by the activities of the concern both to the concern or those affected by the concern.”4
According to this definition, it is very clear that social responsibility accounting is assessment and at the same time reporting on the social activities of business units either in monetary terms, i.e., quantitatively or in non- monetary terms, i.e., qualitatively which is useful or useless to both, i.e., to concern itself and the society under which that business unit operates. According to true blood committee report, “An objective of financial statement is to report on those activities if enterprise affecting society, which can be determined and described or measured and which are important to the role of enterprise and its social environment.”5
This definition is concerned with the need and function of social accounting. It says that financial reporting statement should contain the details about the social activities in accounting form and should settle the conflicts and disputes of interested parties. The social responsibility accounting information’s are communicated to socially interested groups within and outside the organization. Social accounting reporting is expression of a corporate, social responsibility in accounting terms. It is associated with the study and analysis of those activities of an organization which are done for the welfare of society and to measure the effects of such activities on the society and also on the enterprise itself.
Technology of an economic system and its trade activities influences the social responsibility and well being of the society as a whole. Therefore a major limited to economic consequences is the cause-effect relationship of the total system. It cannot neglect the social effects.
Accounting as traditionally well-known is highly associated with credits and debits .It is essential to recognize accounting for the social responsibilities also.
“It is important to realize that accountants have special abilities that are needed if contemporary society is going to solve its ever growing problems.”
www.examisthan.com
10
Social accounting is newest field of accounting there have been increasing demand of the profession for measurement of social cost and benefit which have been considered to be immeasurable.
The accounting profession has been altered to therefore research in accounting for social goals and is ready to accept the challenges. There have been increasing demands on the profession for measurement of social cost and benefit which have previously been considered to be immeasurable.
The terms social accounting has been used by many authors in different shapes such as:-
Social Accounting (sethi-1971, Gambling-1974), Social Responsibility Accounting (Elliot-1975), Socio-economic-accounting (Linowes-1968 sethi-1973, Abt 1977, Beasealy & Evans 1978), Social Reporting (Bi Desinmen & Thomas 1976)
Social Accounting deals with communication of information and the measurement about the impact of activities on the society. It is an assessment and reporting on definable domain of enterprise activities that have impact (either in monetary or non-monetary units) the social accounting measuring favorable and unfavorable effects of such activities both on the entity and society. It is concerned with the social human and environmental properties on enterprise behavior. Hence social Accounting deals with measurement and reporting of information concerning the impact of a concern and its activities on society.
Dimensional meaning of social responsibility accounting
A business is a social organization and a unit of nation, the owners of business concerns have dual role in the society. They invest money or capital into the business to fulfill their own interest, i.e. mainly for earning profit on the one hand and to provide goods and services for the benefit of the society on the other. The society creates a suitable atmosphere for a business for which it can perform all the functions smoothly and regularly. As a result, the society and nation is required to incur something for the creation of business atmosphere. In return the business should fulfill certain obligations towards the society
As per classical economists there should not any social responsibility of a business-the only objective the maximization which leads to the optimization of the wealth of the owners or the equity share holders. The only social
www.examisthan.com
11
responsibility is to use the resources and to provide the output to the society. But in modern age the business concerns, especially corporate organizations put greater emphasis on the fulfillment of social responsibilities. Because the modern business concerns wish to adopt the principal of fulfillment of social responsibilities smoothly besides earning a standard profit regularly throughout its long period of existence, instead of earning maximum profit by any means within a very limited period of existence.
The concept of social accounting can be apples in two senses-
Macro sense Micro sense
Macro sense
The social accounting deals with the measurement of social and national income and national wealth of nation. It involves in accounting for all economic activities occurred in the entire economic phase of a nation. The social accounting in this sense or model is termed ‘national accounting’ or ‘national income accounting’.
This concept of social responsibility accounting is used by the economists, statisticians and so on. This accounting deals with the total national functions or macro variables-such as, national productions, national consumptions, national savings, and national investments and so on. Practically social accounting is an accounting of national welfare growth, prosperity and finally the well being of the entire community. The idea of macro sense of social accounting was first introduced in 1758 in France by De Quency in his ‘table economique’.
The famous chemist Levoisier referred to the principals of accounting for the municipality of Paris in 1791 almost in the same pattern as the accounting system is followed now days for a nation. Thereafter, it suggested that social accounting should be included as an introductory principle in the study of economics.
Micro sense
The social accounting deals with the measurement of performance of the responsibilities of a business concern, especially of a corporate enterprise, towards the society. While the macro sense of the social accounting is viewed from the side of the nation or society. The micro sense is developed from the aspect of the business. The concept of the social accounting is used by mangers,
www.examisthan.com
12
accountants and so on. This accounting is the recent origin and not developed at all before 1970. As the result, different concerns of different countries spent earlier on different accounts of social accounting. There was no such attempt for social accounting them.
In 1971 the public affair council of Washington prepared a check-list of the objectives, tasks and activities to identify the focus on social accounting. In earlier years of decade, different American companies like manufacturing concerns, bank, insurance and so on companies put their emphasis for preparation of social reports through analysis of social costs and social benefits besides maintenance of conventional accounting.
Definitions
National Association of Accountants (USA) Committee on accounting for corporate social performance in its report (1974) has described aspects of social performance and identified community involvement, human resource, physical resources and environmental contributions. Community involvement includes all social oriented activities intended to benefit the general public. Human resource includes activities intended to benefit the employees. Products and service contribution include activities intended to social benefit and total environment of the firm.
Social reporting or social responsibility accounting is a national assessment of and reporting on some meaningful domain of business activities to the public as well as other interested parties regarding its social performances measuring either in monetary or non-monetary terms, being beneficial or baneful by the activities of the concern both to the concern or those affected by the concern.
“Social Responsibility Accounting is basically a socio-economic accounting. It is the modification and application of skills, techniques and disciplines of conventional accounting to the problems of social interest.”
According to Ahemad Belkaoni Socio-economic accounting in the social sciencesit refers to the recording, meaning, analysis and disclosure of the social and economic consequences of governmental and entrepreneurial behavior. It includes these activities at the macro and micro level.
At the micro level its purpose is the measurement and reporting of the impact of organizational behavior of firms, on macro level its purpose is the measurement and disclosure of the economic and social performance of the nation. At the
www.examisthan.com
13
micro level socio-economic accounting includes, therefore, financial and managerial social accounting and reporting and social auditing. At the macro level socio-economic accounting includes, therefore, social measurement social accounting and reporting and the role of accounting in economic development.
According to The National Association of Accountancy (N.A.A.) Committee, “designed social accounting as the identification, measurement, monitoring and reporting of the social and economic effects of an institution on society…. It is intended for internal managerial and external accountability purpose and is an outgrowth of changing values that have led society to redesigned its notion of a corporate social responsibility”6
Sybil Mobley While stabilizing the need socio economic accounting defined same as “it refers to the ordering majoring and analysis of the social and economic consequences of government and entrepreneurial behavior.”7
According to Ralph Estes” Social accounting is the measurement and reporting, internal and external, of information concerning the impact of an entity and its activity on society. ”8
As defined in dictionary of accounting “Reporting the cost and benefits relating to socially responsible action by business enterprises. This may be carried out in a number of ways, e.g. publication in the annual report of a list of socially responsible action., Publication of a list together with disclose of the cost to the enterprises of each activity, publication of a list together with discloser of the extent to which the objective of actions have been achieved, publication of a list together with the costs and benefits of each activity.”9
K.V. Ramnathan has defined social accounting is” the process of selecting firm level social performance variable , majors and measurements procedures systematically developing information useful for evaluating firm’s social performance and communicating such information to concerned social groups both with and outside the firm. ”10
David Linows used the term “Socio economic accounting” In a border since .as per him it is “the application of accounting in the field of social sciences.”
Elliot uses the term “Social responsibility accounting as per him it is a systematic assessment of and reporting on those part of a companies’ activities that have social impact. It describes the impact of corporate decisions on environmentalpollution the consumption of non-renewable resources and ecological factors on
www.examisthan.com
14
the rights of individuals and groups, on the maintenance of public services, on public safety, on health and education and many other social concerns.”As per Patricia Dazler, Social responsibility is defined as a voluntary expenditure or activity by a corporation with charitable intent, for which marginal returns are less than those available from other alternative activities.
As per F.E.Perry’s dictionary of banking, “ Social accounting is the reporting of the cost incurred in complying with anti pollution , safety and health and other society beneficial requirements, and more general;;y the impact of business entity on its Endeavour to protest society , its amenities and environment, ”11
G.C.Maheshwari has define is as, Identification , Measurement ,recording and reporting of corporate activities which may permit informed decision making with respect to social activities of the firm having direct and indirect effect on the very fabric of the society at large. While social audit would mean inquiry into the corporate social accounting records by an outside agency that can open with a view to attestation and authentication of such records and reports.
According to Kohler’s Dictionary for Accountants, the systematized treatment of social indicators which represents quality of life conditions in a country, region or other geographical units.
According to Epstein, Flantioltz and Mc Donough, social accounting is an extent ion of the traditional concept of accounting and accountability to a different domain social rather than financial performance.
“Socio-economic accounting aims at measuring and reporting the impact of exchanges between a firms and its social environment.”
Mobley said, the technology of an economic system imposes a structure on its society which not only determines its economic activities but also influences its social relationship and well being.
Johnson defines it as, “ The accountants would do well to recognize that cost of operating business is something more than what is being disclosed in public accounts, e.g., pollution of environment (noise, water, air), spread of disease, dislocation of inhabitants of a locality, local housing and transport problems, closure of cottage industries, social tensions and several other social evils. This is on the liability side. What it does, providing roads, schools and colleges, dispensaries, railway lines, employment etc. is the asset side. Hence, instead of income, we should measure the benefit cost of a venture project. 12
www.examisthan.com
15
As per Dr. Sawalia Behari Verma, “Social Accounting is associated with the study and analysis of accounting practice of those activities of organization which are undertaken by the enterprise itself in quantitative as well as qualitative terms. It also tries to analyze and evaluate the organizational behavior in the light of such activities.”13
The credit for sponsoring social welfare activities besides employee welfare activities, by commercial undertakings goes to socialist countries, where public undertakings have to fulfill some social responsibilities, besides undertakings, commercial and productive activities. In other countries of the world, the initial motivation for social involvement by business might have come from a scare of socialism, later on various movements and social welfare organizations such as consumer protection groups, civil rights movement, environmental protection and ecological conservation groups and so, on have contributed towards this phenomenon.
It is clear that social accounting is concerned with the external and internal reporting of social benefits and costs both in quantitative and qualitative term by a business enterprise.14
Thus, in brief each and every definition gives much emphasis to that as business is a component of society, it is affected by society and it also affects the society, therefore. It has been also described in some of the definitions that business enterprise should be very much careful about environmental pollution, medical and education facilities to society in which it exist, about social disputes, evils, crimes, etc. This reporting should be in accounting form, showing social costs benefits and what is the real degree of advantage availed by the society through its activities. This social reporting should be presented and communicated in such a way, so that it can be useful to both internal management and external parties.
So, social reporting is an accounting report of various social responsibilities of an enterprise to assess whether enterprise has achieved the target fixed or not, and also to find out whether an enterprise is working efficiently in providing various facilities to its workers and society or not.
Conclusion is that “Social responsibility accounting is such an accounting concept which indicates how and how far as well as in what efficiency a corporate organization or simply a business concerns performs its social obligations towards the interest groups of society. It is the accounting which attempt to measured different cost involved in proving the benefits to the society
www.examisthan.com
16
directly and indirectly as well as different benefits enjoyed from different parties of the society. It is concerned also with the development and measurement system to monitor social performance. So it is an expression of a firm’s social responsibilities and requirements for general corporate accountabilities.
Social responsibility accounting is an integration of management accounting with the national economics. Practically it is an accounting of national welfare, growth, prosperity and finally the well- being of the entire community.
Nature Of Social Responsibility Accounting
The primary objective of social reporting is to disclose the amount (accounting data) incurred on social welfare and to find out how much concern is fulfilling its social responsibilities. Generally, accounting report, i.e. financial statement is demanded by shareholders, creditors, government and others. These are the parties which are very much affected by company’s activities. Their interest may be positively or adversely affected but due to rapid industrial development and social awareness in the society the whole concept has been changed and now financial statement not confined only to proprietors as is it said “Accounting is social activity engaged in by (i) corporate managers who perform in activities that are recorded by the accounting system, (ii) corporate account who gather data and compile the reports, (iii)auditors who scrutinize and attest to the fairness of the reports, (iv) outside government and private agencies, investors, employees, customers etc., who read these reports, and (v) college and university personnel who train their student in accounting.”15
Thus according to this statement, accounting report is concerned with the member of parties for different purpose, having their interest in the activities of the concern. These parties may be classified into internal parties and external parties. Internal party is concerned with the reporting process, exercised by the management for internal planning and control, whereas external party is concerned with the reporting process useful for shareholders, money lenders, debenture holders, creditors, government, consumers and society large.
Thus, internal reporting is concerned with financial and non-financial data of enterprise necessary for management to take decisions and to have information for future planning and control and external reporting is concerned with the accounting data, useful to outside parties of organization, very much interested in enterprise’ activities. As the members of external reporting, are not found to be homogeneous in their purpose, therefore, there is a lot of differences in their
www.examisthan.com
17
requirements. Each and every party has different objective, and external reporting is required to fulfill all these different objectives. Corporate reporting should be presented in such a way so that it can satisfy needs of different parties, going to be effected by the activities of the enterprise. So, the main purpose of corporate social reporting is to provide various information to various users.
Ramanathan 16 tried to develop a theoretical framework for corporate social accounting. He gave three objectives of corporate social accounting which distinguish from financial accounting:
-To identify and measure the periodic net social contribution of a individual firm consisting of cost and benefits internalized to the firm and externalities affecting different social segments.
-To help determine whether individual firms strategies and practices which directly affect the related resource and power status of individuals, communities social segments, generations consistent with widely share social priorities on the one hand and individual’s legitimate aspirations on the other.
-To provide the optional information to all the constituents of the society to enable them to make decision regarding allocation of social resource where optimality implies a cost/benefit effective reporting strategy which also optimally balance potential information conflicts among the various social constituents of a firm.
The objective of social accounting is to inform the general public about social welfare measures taken by the enterprise, and their effects on the society. How far the enterprises are successful in fulfilling the social obligations also comes to light through social accounting.
Objectives of Social Responsibility accounting
During these days it is recognized that corporate activities have economic and social impact. The corporate economic impact measured by financial accounting but up till now no proper system and slandered has been developed for measuring social impact of industries.
The objective of social accounting is,” to internalize the social cost and benefits to determine a more relevant and exhaustive result that represents the socio-economic profit of a firm.”
www.examisthan.com
18
The objective of social accounting is to evaluate and to disclose the cost and benefit to society created by the production related activities of a firm more precisely, the objective is to consider the social cost and benefit with in a concern in order to determine a more relevant and exhaustive and business result. This is generally known as socio-economic profit of a firm.
According to Chen,” as a steward management responsibility should be evaluated in terms of both profit and the accomplishment social objectives.”The major objective of accounting from social performance is to identify and measure the contribution of an individual entity of a firm to the aggregate social benefits and sacrifices.
Social accounting are considered to be the measurement of (a) Social cost (b) Impact of business decision entities of society (c) Effectiveness of public programme (d) Human resource utilization it’s extents and limits (e) The corporate responsibility towards society and ultimately, (f) To measure the response in terms of public satisfaction and upliftment of physical and mental standard.
In, today’s world, it has been universally recognized that corporate activities have economic as well as social impacts. Business and society are so much closely related to each other that their activities cannot be neglected. The basic objectives of social reporting are:
To know the contribution of individual banks towards the society.
To determine the bank’s strategies and practices directly effecting the relative source.
To aware the society about bank’s objectives and policies.
To present the models of quantification and proper presentation expenses of a bank.
But broadly objectives of social responsibility accounting can be classified into two classes: (a) Social contract, (b) objective based on quality of life.
(a) Objective based on social contract: The corporate social responsibility accounting which is mainly based on the argument of social contract, the main objects of social reporting are as under:
www.examisthan.com
19
- To specify and measure the periodic net social contribution of individual business enterprise towards the society.
- To help and assist in ascertaining whether public enterprises are consistent with widely shared social priorities or not.
- To make available relevant information about firm’s goals, policies, programmes and contributions towards social goals.
Economic indicators or financial reports report only on the economic health of the nation, i.e., whether nation is economically sound or not, in terms of national income or GNP etc. But social reporting indicates towards the social health of nation, etc., what are the effects of economic activities on the society, whether it is in welfare of the society. Social scientists are also doing their best to explore new techniques and measures for social reporting to know the real social contribution of various business units operating within the society.
(b) Objective based on quality of life: under the approach, corporate social responsibility has been related with the quality of life. It quality of life or standard of living is increasing, and then banks are performing their social responsibilities properly. In banks management the social cost of economic development is increasing day-by-day, affecting the various aspects of quality of life.
It is also very well known fact that if a bank does not perform its social responsibilities its activities have negative impact on the society. Hence, society also reacts negatively to the negative approach of the banks and ultimately banks have to lose its existence in the market or in an economy. Negative approach creates uncertainty towards the role of banks in the society.
Therefore, bank management should be very much careful towards the social responsibility and should recognize the reality and sharp reactions of the society. There should be proper co-operation and co- ordination between bank management and society. Bank management should provide relevant information to outsiders or its users with regard to the discharge of their social responsibility.
The primary objective of accounting is to provide true and fair financial information useful to investors, creditors, and public for making economic decisions. In the same way the social accounting aims to measure and evaluate the social cost within a firm in order to determine the business results in a more
www.examisthan.com
20
relevant and exhaustive fashion and benefits offered to the employees and to the society. The crucial objectives of accounting of social information are as follows:
(a) Positive image motive: in order to the purpose of creating positive image, several firms report social information. The management would not like to be perceived as a destroyer of the social environmentand non-contribute onto social activities. The management of the enterprise would like the consumers and society to perceive the firm as a responsible citizen. Always it tries to concentrate to report the social information on all their activities which contribute the welfare of the society.
(b) Meeting the information needs: with the increasing social awareness, several public interest groups are closely watching the activities of banks. Consumers are concentrating about the quality of the products and services. In these situations, it is the primary responsibility of the banks to provide social activity information to the interested parties.
(c) Meeting the disclosure requirements: in several countries like Germany, Britain, France, the Netherlands and the USA are strictly following the social accounting concept as mandatory requirements. In India a handful of organizations are following the social accounting concept. In our country there is no legal obligation to provide information on social costs and social benefits in their annual financial statements. But banks are now starts disclosing the social responsibility accounting information in many fields like healthcare, education, staff welfare, social and community welfare, loans and advances and many other social care programmes.
Scope of Social Responsibility Accounting
Organization has to perform various responsibilities towards the society. Scope means various responsibilities areas of business because it is not possible for a business unit to perform each and every type of social activities required by community at a large or by society. So it is necessary that various social responsible areas should be defined. Generally social responsibility expressed in terms of charity, donations, and community welfare. But charity is not the real social responsibility because charity is exercised only for a tax evasion. It is only a device to be saved from tax payments.
www.examisthan.com
21
Scope of social reporting depends upon the identification of the dimension of social responsibilities of organization. Social responsibilities can be discharge either legally, politically or voluntarily. If the organization follows all the rules and regulations enacted by the respective government then it is discharging it social responsibility legally. Similarly, when an organization discharges its social responsibilities in accordance with the prevailing political systems and should not do anything in against of political system or should not do anything which creates political instability in a country, it is discharging its social responsibility politically. When organization discharges various social responsibilities due to moral ground then it discharges its social responsibility voluntarily.
Goyder and Singhania have classified the various business activities in two groups:
Primary activities
Secondary activities
The primary activity of a socially responsible enterprise is to earn a reasonable amount of profit to have its commercial viability in the market and also for the interest of the various shareholders, employees and workers. It has been said that profit is not only the primary activity, but it also comes under secondary activities, because without becoming financially sound an enterprise cannot discharge its social responsibility. As Goyder says “A reasonable level of profit is not only for its primary objectives but also necessary for the discharge of social obligations and responsibility. He described these objectives as secondary one like, to enhance labour welfare, to enhance costumer’s services and goodwill, to help in developing and promoting the activities in the locality, to help in developing industry of which the firm is member and to contribute to national goals.” 17
So according to this view, profit is not only economic phenomenon but it is also a social phenomenon and serves the society. Profit is very much necessary to discharge various social responsibilities. If a concern is earning huge amount of profit it means that shareholders are getting much dividend, employees and workers are also getting sufficient remuneration for their labour and efforts and consumers are getting the goods and services at a reasonable price and also standard quality products and services. So profit and social responsibility must go together on the principle that higher the profit, higher the social responsibility or vice-versa. Mr. Khandelwal has classified various social activities into two groups- purely social activities legal social activities. Purely social activities consist of philanthropy services, community education and health services etc.
www.examisthan.com
22
legal social activities include air and water pollution control, labour safety and insurance of labour. 18
According to this classification, purely social activities mean the activities which are not legally required. It depends on the enterprise whether to perform or not. It comes under moral responsibility of the concern and there is no legal binding. On the contrary legal social activities mean that these activities are legally bound and should be performed to fulfill legal formalities.
Brumet 19 also discussed about the social responsibilities areas and he has classified five distinct areas of social reporting. These areas are:
i. Net Income Contribution, ii. Human Resource Contribution,
iii. Public Contribution, iv. Environment Contribution v. Product or Service Contribution.
i. Net Income Contribution
The growing attention towards social objectives is not reducing the importance of income objective. There is no denying of profit seeking as the fundamental objective of a business enterprise. A corporate enterprise must earn enough costs of its survival. To discharge various social responsibilities, it is necessary that the business unit should earn maximum possible profit. A business unit cannot survive without having adequate return on capital employed. It is also true that shareholders invest their capital in the shares, in this expectation that they will earn profit regularly and they will also earn capital gain from the appreciation of share values.
So, social responsibility cannot be fulfilled without having adequate income or profit. Similarly, investors rank these business enterprises the best in terms of both risk and price-earning ratio, which are discharging its social responsibility regularly. Poor profit earning means concerns failure to recognize social problems like employee’s problem, i.e., employee’s health. For example, excessive working hours under bad working conditions may have an adverse affect on the employee’s health which may lead to production of poor quality goods and services. Consequently, these poor quality goods are found to be unsold in the market and results in less profit.
www.examisthan.com
23
ii Human Resource Contribution
It reflects the effect of organization activities on the human resource of the organization. Organization have many activities as: recruitment policies and practices, selection, induction, placement, training and development, experience building, job enrichment, wage and salary, trade union relations, employees attitude, performance appraisal, congruence of organizational and individual goals, job safety, mutual trust and confidence- building, motivational programmes , transfer and promotion etc. proper and adequate attention should be given to all these activities for the well being of human resource of that business organization. Human resource accounting practices should be adopted in this regard, which tries to measure the contribution of human resource in terms of money.
iii Public Contribution
This area considers the effect of organizational activities on individuals generally outside the organization. Public contribution means the business enterprise contribution towards the general public who live in the society. This area is concerned with the impact of organizational activities on the individuals or the group of individuals outside the company like debenture holders, creditors, debtors, consumers etc., very much interested in company’s activities. It deals generally with general philanthrophy, public transportation services, public health services, urban housing, equal employment opportunity, training and development of handicapped persons, payment of tax to government, community problems solutions etc. The creation of jobs and the provision of employment are important public contributions. As well as the development of local services which offer companies corporate expansion in the community.
iv Environmental Contribution
This area relates to the measurement of effect of corporate activities on the ecological balance. Environmental contribution means a business enterprise’s efforts to maintain and improve the physical resource of the country. Under this area reporting has to be done in respect of pollution control as air pollution, water pollution, noise pollution, due to activities of business enterprises. Generally industrial production and manufacturing process causes pollution which leads to environmental degradation. So care and attention should be taken on pollution control by industrial processes, research and development activities should be encouraged to explore the method of production which may reduce
www.examisthan.com
24
environmental hazards. Proper attention should be taken for energy conservation, raw material conservations and its recycling and business activities should support the public and private actions designed to protect the environment.
v Product Or Service Contribution
This area is concerned with the qualitative aspect of products or services, being produced by business enterprises. The qualitative aspects of product or service means product utility, durability of product produce safety, service ability as well as the welfare role of the product or service. It also includes customer’s satisfaction, honest exposure in advertising, completeness and clarity of labeling and packaging provisions responding to consumer’s complaints etc.
Social accounting is concerned only with the quantitative aspects of social responsibilities and not with the qualitative aspects of social responsibilities. Quantitative aspects mean how much a business enterprise is incurring on various social overheads or what percentage of profit is being incurred on the social overheads. But up to what extent various concerned parties are being benefited by these social expenses, is not concerned with the social reporting. So social reporting gives only accounting report of social responsibility and it ignores qualitative aspects. So it can be said that business enterprise should discharge its social responsibilities towards the following:
a. The society,b. The government,c. The employees, andd. The customers.
a. It is the society which gives recognition to various business enterprises. Business cannot escape from the society and society cannot exist without the business. So it is the first and foremost duty of business to discharge its responsibilities towards the society. The respective areas towards which business should discharges its responsibilities are – pollution control air, water, and environmental pollution, public health, public transportation, community development, educational facilities, industrial development, energy conservation, raw material conservation, employment of minority community, employment of women, equal job opportunity, job to physically handicapped persons, to help the victims of natural calamities like earthquake, floods, etc. or manmade calamities like riots, explosion etc., family planning programmes, uplift of rural areas, literacy programmes, public hospitals etc.
www.examisthan.com
25
b. Each and every business enterprise works and functions under definite rules and regulations enacted by the law of that country. These variousrules and regulations are framed by the responsible government of an economy to have proper administrative control over the various business units operating in that economy. The government is an authority to save the society from being exploited. The government is also a party, badly engaged in the various activities of business enterprises. Business enterprises are required to discharge their responsibilities towards the government by paying taxes imposed on them, by obeying the various rules and regulations and by fulfilling various legal formalities.
c. Employees are the human resource of a business organization that render their services and spend time for the functioning of that organization. The business enterprise is ought to discharge various responsibilities towards its employees who are workers during working period and the member of the society after the working hours. Except salary and wages, the workers or the human resource also expect some more facilities like medical, canteen, housing, entertainment, transportation, training, educational facilities and healthy relations. The business enterprise should fulfill all these obligations and it should adopt human resource accounting.
d. Success of a business enterprise depends on the availability of customers who purchase the goods and service produced/provided by it. So business enterprise should be very much careful in fulfilling its responsibilities towards the customers. It is the customer who creates demand for the product in the market. The customer always wants to maximize his satisfaction. He can get maximum satisfaction only when he gets high quality goods and services at cheaper price. The product should not be harmful to them and they should not be exploited by the business enterprise. Business enterprise should provide high quality of product or standard products at reasonable and cheaper price which should be equal to their satisfaction.
An enterprise should incur research and development expenses to find out the changing moods and fashion of the customers and also to explore new methods and technique to reduce cost of production, so that goods and services produced can be sold at cheaper and reasonable prices.
www.examisthan.com
26
Responsibility of an Organization Towards Society
Business as it created by society anticipating would aid society. Society expects a lot of responsibilities and obligations although profit earning is essential for the survival of entity. It would spend certain amount of its earnings for the betterment of society and community. Responsibility of an organization towards society is as following chart:
Stakeholders Responsibility of business
A) Equityshareholders
(owners)
B) Employees:
1) air and adequate rate of return
2) Steady capital appreciation to the
shareholders for their investment.
3) Regular & up to date information about
working of a company.
4) Maximum disclosure about progress and
achievement of the company.
5) It must ensure planned growth, solvency and
optimum utilization of resources.
1) Higher wages
2) Security of jobs
3) Full employment
4) Better working conditions
5) Opportunities for self development and
promotion.
6) Social security
7) Welfare
8) Grievance settlement process
9) Sharing of excess profit.
10) Job satisfaction
11) Health & trade union practices
www.examisthan.com
27
C) Consumers
D) Community
E) Suppliers
1) Quality goods and services at reasonable
prices.
2) Regular supply of high quality products and
services to customers.
3) Manager must meet the need of the
consumers of different classes, tastes and
with different Purchasing power at the right
time, place, price and in right quantity.
4) Business has to protect consumers invest at
any cost.
5) Honest advertisement.
6) Right weight of goods.
7) Business must handle the complaints of
consumers more carefully and efficiently.
1) Respect to human right.
2) Promote human development through
harmonious relations between business and
other segments of society.
3) Schools and colleges.
4) Free hospitals and medical facilities.
5) Social integration.
6) Protection of local culture.
7) Charitable donation
1) Fairness and truthfulness in all activities
including pricing licensing to sell and right
to sell.
2) Ensure business activities are free from
litigations.
3) Develop long term stability in the suppliers
relationship.
4) Pay suppliers on the time their dues.
5) Supply information on reasonable time.
www.examisthan.com
28
F) Investors 1) Disclosure of all information about the
affairs of the company.
2) Conservation of assets by the way of
protection.
3) Respect investor’s request, suggestions etc.
4) Timely payment of all dues of investors.
5) Apply professional management to
maximize efficiency.
G) Competitors
H) Nations
1) Foster and develop open market for free trade
and investment.
2) Promote healthy competitive behavior.
3) Respect tangible and intellectual property
rights.
4) Foster ethical means and methods in business.
5) Maintain healthy competition.
1) Use property the national scare resource.
2) Abet pollution.
3) Proper assessment and right payment of taxes.
4) Pay tax on time.
5) Abiding the laws and respecting the acts.
6) Environmental protection
7) Respect to community and citizens of the
country.
Conclusion
A business enterprise is a social unit. It uses the society resources and produced goods and services for which the society is the ultimate consumer. The society provides the infrastructure and the facilities without which a business unit cannot function at all. Thus a business enterprise owes its very existence and survival to the society. It is therefore necessary that a business unit should operate within the
www.examisthan.com
29
overall parameters determined by the society. The main emphasis for evaluation of a business unit is profitability. The social aspect has so far been ignored. Business today cannot strictly adhere to only one objective of maximizing profit. The public opinion is now critical of the traditional emphasis of business on making profit.
Society is aware that business must be carried on not only for its own sake but also without prejudicing public interest. Business should strive to secure the interest of society by available quality and harmless products keeping the environment free of pollution by recycling waste and making proper arrangements for proper disposal of waste. It should also provide welfare and security to its employees. Business must not only report to its shareholders but also to the society as to the steps it has taken in terms of its obligation to the community at large. This extension to the traditional accounting responsibility towards society is variously called as social responsibility accounting, social audit, socio-economic accounting, report on corporate social policies, social information system, social reporting and so on.
……………………………………………………………………………………
References
1. Chamber’s Accounting Evaluation and Economic Behaviour, Prentice Hall, 1966.
2. Gandhi, S.K., The Management Accountant, May 1995, p.35, ICWAI.
3. Singh, Gurjeet, “Social Accounting in India and Abroad, A comparative study,” Indian Journal of Commerce, December 1989, p.48.
4. Jawahar Lal, Contemporary Accounting Issues, Vision Book Pvt. Ltd., 1988, p.245.
5. American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, Objectives of Financial Statements, AICPA, October 1973, p.155.
6. National Accounting Association committee, Report on Accounting for Corporate Social Performance, part-I, 1976, p.2.
www.examisthan.com
30
7. Mobley Sybil, “Challenges of Socio-Economic Accounting, “Accounting Review, October 1970, p.762-68.
8. Eates Ralph, Corporate Social Accounting, John Willey and Sons, New York, 1973.
9. Abrol, P.N., dictionary of Accounting, Anmol Publication, 1993, p.231.
10. Ramnathan, K.V., “Towards a Theory of Corporate Social Accounting,” Accounting Review, July 1976, p. 528.
11. Perry F.E., Dictionary of Banking, M.C. Donald and Evance, Great Britain, 1989, p.300.
12. Johnson, H.C., “Disclosure of Corporate Social Performance,” 1975, Accounting Review, Supplement to volume XIXI, 1976, p.38-39.
13. Dr. Sawalia Bihari Verma, “Social Accounting Practices in Public Undertakings in India,” The management Accountant, ICWAI, Calcutta, June 1997, p.445.
14. Ibid.
15. Dopuch. H, The Accountung Riview, January 1980, p.1-21.
16. Ramnathan, K.V., “Towards a Theory of Corporate Social Accounting,” Accounting Review, July 1976, p.516-28.
17. Cited in F. Chenunilal, Business Environment, Himalya Publishing House, Mumbai, 1986, p.16 and 41-45.
18. Kandelwal, N.M., “Social Audit – A New Challenge to Accounting Profession,” the Chartered Accountant, Vol. XXV, No.8, February 1977, p.524.
19. Brummet, L.R., “Total Performance Management,” Management Accounting, November 1973.
www.examisthan.com
AUDITING (PART-4) (UNIT-1)
MEANING AND OBJECTIVE OF AUDITING (PART–1)
1. INTRODUCTION
Dear students I welcome you on the lecture series of auditing under
auditing we should start up with unit one and we will discuss in detail
about the subject. It’s the introductory part of auditing where we are
going to learn its meaning and the objective of auditing. So our
primary objective to learn from today’s lecture is to appreciate the
meaning of auditing that means what do we mean by auditing, why
there is the need doing the auditing, what does auditing tells us.
Secondly understanding the functional classification of auditor, Auditor
is a person a we know who is conducting the audit so as we will
advance in our lecture we will learn about auditor and how auditor is
being classified.
Thirdly we are going to do the appreciation our understanding of
essential qualities of auditors that means what are the essential
features or qualities which are being required for a auditor to conduct
the audit in an appropriate manner then we will learn the objective of
audit in the light SA’s being issued from time to time. The revise SA’s
in relation to objective audit is to be understood in our lecture. So first
of all we will start up our lecture with meaning of auditing.
2. MEANING OF AUDITING
According to the general guidelines on internal auditing issued by ICAI
i.e. Institute of Chartered Accountant of India, auditing is defined as a
systematic and independent examination of data, statements, records,
operations and performances, financial or otherwise of an enterprises
were stated purpose. Now net us highlights certain important terms
which are been used in the definition. First of all it’s a systematic and
independent examination, when we say it’s a systematic it means that
www.examisthan.com
certain procedures and plans are being executed so when we conduct
an audit there should be a audit plan, there should be a certain
specific procedure to be followed for conducting the audit. It should
be independent that means auditor should give its opinion or express
its opinion on a very clear manner, it should not be biased, it should
not be effected by the person on behalf whom the audit is been
conducted.
Now what we are going to examine under audit, we are going to
examine the data or statements or records that means the financial
statements are being recorded and various evidences that is audit
evidences are to be examined to be gathered there should be
sufficient and appropriate so that the auditor can express its opinion
on the financial statements of an enterprise. Now again we are going
to examine the operations and performances when we examine
operations we will also look into the internal controls which are going
installed in a operating system of any enterprise. So in all it’s a big
exercise to be conducted so that the auditor can express his opinion on
the financial statement of an enterprise where a true and fair view of
an business activities can be analysed now why auditor is required to
express his opinion on the financial statements because financial
statements is a data which is going to impact the decision of the user
of those information.
Now let us understand certain essentials of audit. The first one is
auditing is an independent examination of financial information of an
entity that means it should not be biased it should move by any
specific purpose so that we can understand that the financial
statements of an organization are depicting a fair view. Now such
auditing is to be conducted for an entity whether it is for profit or not.
So second essential is whether is profit oriented or not audit has to be
conducted for that enterprise and irrespective size of legal form.
When we says that irrespective of the size of the organization on legal
form it means that whether it’s a sole proprietor or a company or a
partnership if its meeting up the requirement which is being given
under the statute it is required to carry out the audit.
www.examisthan.com
Fourthly when such an examination is conducted with a view to
expressing an opinion there on which we have already discussed. Again
the fifth point is same systematic and independent examination which
is being carried out with the specific procedures to be followed there
should be proper documentation of what we are doing under audit it
does not confined to financial aspect only because we say that it’s a
examination not only of data statements but operations and
performances. So what happens that rather than restricting ourself to
the financial aspect we need to look into the internal controls also so
both substantive and the compliance test are to be carried by a
auditor.
Now who is auditor? A question comes to us. The person conducting
audit is known as auditor. He makes a report to the person appointing
him after due examination of accounting records and the accounting
statements in the form of an opinion. His duty is to express his opinion
as to whether financial statements reflect true and fair view so as to
influence the opinion of interested group of persons. So here again we
can conclude that the person who is a auditor that means who is
conducting the audit has to do such careful examination of the records
of the enterprises and he is being appointed either by the authorities
concerned or the enterprise itself. so depending on the functional
aspect for which a auditor is being appointed he has to carry out his
audits and the main premises of conducting an audit when auditor is
that he has to express his opinion.
3. FUNCTIONAL CLASSIFICATION OF AUDITOR
Now let us understand how the functional classification of auditor is
being done so there are two types of auditor’s external auditor and
internal auditor. Now let us understand who shall be external auditor
and who shall be internal auditor. So what we are going to do is that
we will find out certain basis of differences so that we can understand
the difference between the two. We have prepared a table where we
can understand the point of differences between the functional aspect
of internal auditor and external auditor.
First of all meaning of internal auditor and external auditor is to be
understood. Internal auditor is internal to the organization that means
www.examisthan.com
he is the part of the organization while external auditor is external to
the organization. That means he is an outsider being appointed to
carry out certain audit function. Now what’s the status internal auditor
is considered as an employee of the enterprise while the external
auditor is wholly independent of the enterprise audited not an
employee that means when we say that a person is internal auditor he
has to work with the enterprise and his roles are altogether different
form the external auditor. To understand external auditor more clearly
we can say that being appointed is considered to be an external
auditor because he is a independent person being appointed by the
company to carry out the statutory audit so that he can express his
opinion in regard to the taxation provision or any other legal provision
and expresses opinion as to the compliance to the certain important
aspect and he also express his opinion as to the truth and fairness of
the financial statements.
Now what’s the scope of the work? Internal auditors scope of work is
determined by management while the scope of work of external
auditor is being determine by statute that means legal aspect has to be
considered. The law going to take care of these scope of work of
external auditor so wherever there is legal requirement or legal
provisions external auditor has to be abide by the legal requirement to
conduct the audit of the enterprise.
Now what’s the approach of internal auditor and that of the external
auditor? When we talk about the internal auditor his main concern is to
ensure the compliance with the policies, procedures, rules of
enterprises. Then he has to also take care of legal and govt.
regulations that means from time to time the legal requirement of an
enterprise has to be complied with so it’s the responsibility of internal
auditor to ensure that legal compliances are being done.
Thirdly generally accepting accounting principles have to be taken care
by the internal auditor when there is a finalization of the financial
statement of enterprise. Now when we come to external auditor his
main concern is to collect, adequate and reliable evidence to support
his opinion regarding truth and fairness of financial statement. So he is
not going to look into the legal and govt. regulations i.e. day to day or
www.examisthan.com
the regular compliance is to be carried out by the internal auditor
while such compliances are being carried out or not it’s the concern of
external auditor to collect such data’s for example there is a
requirement to collet TDS to deposit TDS all time so the requirement
of doing the compliance is to be carried out by internal auditor while
the external auditor will look after the compliance being carried out or
not is there required evidences that means is there proper filing up
there returns, proper records are being maintain by the enterprise or
not such work is to be carried out by external auditor so approach of
both auditors are quite different.
Now the next one is appointment. Internal auditor is being appointed
directly by management or the person directly responsible to the
management that means board of directors or the directors or
management can appoint an internal auditor while the external auditor
is appointed by the owners or the person directly responsible to the
owners.
4. QUALITIES OF AUDITOR
Now let us understand other important feature of auditing i.e.
qualities of auditors. What should be the qualities of auditor when he
conducts the audit so these are the general qualities and not the
person specific every auditor should have these peculiar characteristics
of qualities so that he can be independent integrated and skilful and
competent auditor.
So first is independence, when we shay independence it means that he
should not be biased by any opinion he should be straight forward in
his approach and should take care of the legal compliance.
Objectivity: - objectivity means that he should be very particular as to
what is right and what is wrong and should rationally give his opinion
on the financial statements of an enterprise. Integrity means honesty
and straight forwardness and sincerity means professional approach.
He should be cautious that means any changes or amendments which
are being carried out he should be very much aware about it he should
be cautious about the compliance procedures to be conducted, clear
headedness that means there should not be any scope of ambiguity
www.examisthan.com
professional approach as well his hope of work. The person who is
conduction the audit should be very clear about the scope of this audit
and he should be independent in his approach.
Reliability: - when we say that a specific quality of auditor is that he
should be reliable that means he should not be dishonest or he should
not give the confidential information to any other person unless
required by any legal authority or any such person for whom it is
responsibility for the auditor to given him such information.
Next one is having thorough knowledge of general principles of law,
ignorance of law is not a excuse that means a auditor should be well
equipped and well versed with all the legal compliances and he should
apply the legal requirement as an when required. He should hold a
position of trust that means neither the property of the enterprise
should be misused by the auditor nor any important information or
confidential data is being leaked by him.
Alertness of mind that means he should be aware about the various
environmental changes whether such changes are external or internal
to the enterprise concerned. He should be expert; expert here means
again that professional knowledge and up gradation of the latest
changes should be very much with him.
Skill and competence, when we say that skill and competence he
should have adequate skill, he should have adequate qualification as to
be an auditor and with his competence he should carry out the audit
on time and his professionalism and governance aspect should be very
high. Confidentiality we have already discussed and knowledge of the
business & industry should be there because the person who is
conducting the audit of an enterprise he should be very much clear
about the trends, about the knowledge of the business for which he is
conducting the audit. For example there is a handicraft industry for
which a auditor is being appointed so he should have the knowledge of
the entire handicraft business turnover the exporting whole
procedure, what are the requirements for taking up the license, how
the foreign exchange is going to be converted what are the FEMA
provisions which are being governed or which are being attracted
under the such industry so these are the things which a auditor should
www.examisthan.com
have in mind when he conducts an audit he should be analytical and
patient in doing the audit.
Now let us understand the objective of conducting an audit or we can
say that they are the objective of auditing so as per SA 200 which is
revised one basic principle governing and audit it’s the nomenclature
of SA 200 basic principles governing an audit which is now read as
overall objective of the independent auditor and conduct of audit in
accordance with standard of audit. This is the heading under which
objective of auditor is being defined. Here we say that objective of
auditor is to obtain reasonable assurance whether the financial
statement as a whole are free from material misstatement and to
report on the financial statements as communicates as required by SA
in accordance with auditor finding.
5. OBJECTIVE OF AUDITING & ERRORS OF AUDITOR
Now again when we talk about objective of auditing there are two
objectives one is the primary another is the subsidiary or secondary
objective. Primary objective is again the same expressing opinion such
opinion should be on the truth and fairness of the financial statement
of the enterprise while the subsidiary is that detection of errors and
frauds and making recommendation to prevent them. So here we can
say that primary objective of auditor is not to detect errors in the
financial statement his primary objective is to express the opinion as
to truth and fairness, however while conducting an audit they can be
detection of errors and he can suggests or prevent such sort of errors
and recommend the preventive aspect to the management.
Now what sort of errors are there when an audit is being conducted so
auditor come across various errors now let us understand what are
these errors. The term error refers to an unintentional misstatement in
the financial statement by way of clerical mistake on record or
misinterpretation of facts or stake in application of accounting
principles so what happens that when accounting data’s are being
recorded there can be clerical mistakes in recording the transaction,
there can misinterpretation of facts, misinterpretation of facts means
that if there was certain goods in transit and we considered as goods
and there is not proper interpretation of the fact whether the sale has
www.examisthan.com
taken place or not. Such sort of errors are known as misinterpretation
of facts. Mistakes in application of accounting principle there are
certain accounting principles which we need to abide by so while
applying such accounting principle if there is a mistakes, such mistakes
are also known as errors and they are unintentional nobody is going to
intentionally make such errors they are inherent in the nature of audit
to some extent they can be avoided also.
Now let us understand the types of errors first one is error of omission,
the word omission in its little term is that we have forgotten or
omitted to do something where certain accounting aspect is not at all
been recorded or partially recorded it is known error or omission. Now
error of commission is the second types of error, commission means to
do where certain thing is being done in a wrong way, a wrong entry
can be passed or wrong posting can be done so such errors are known
as errors of commission both errors of omission and commission can be
prevented by careful analysis of the data and there we can cross check
that the posting is not being done properly. Now error of duplication
that means two times entry is being passed so such errors can also be
prevented where control check sheets are being used.
Compensating error is the next sort of error by compensating error we
mean that one error has compensated the effect of other error. For
example a sales transaction is recorded by rupees hundred extra while
the purchase transaction is being recorded on a lower side by Rs 100 so
both on debit and credit side the similar sort of mistake has taken
place as to record transaction by Rs 100 on a lower side so both the
errors have compensated each other while there is no effect on the
final transaction however the transaction is being recorded incorrectly.
The next one is error of principle means that there is an importer
classification of the transaction which amounts to capital or revenue
that means capital expenditure is being recorded as revenue
expenditure or vice versa so wherever there is improper classification
between capital items and revenue items we consider them as error of
principle. So these sort of errors are coming across to an auditor when
he conducts the audit and his duty is to suggest the management to
prevent such sort of errors by guiding the proper methodology to find
www.examisthan.com
out such errors by careful analysis of the balance sheets and the
proper books of accounts as well as doing the analysis of subsidiary
books of account from where such entries is being posted and in a way
he can help to prevent the data entry errors.
Now next one is fraud: - it’s not that only errors will be there in the
financial statements sometimes there are chances of fraud so let us
understand what the difference between error and fraud. Fraud means
the intentional act while error was an unintentional act. So when there
is a intention act it amounts to fraud. Now what does it includes it is
wilful misrepresentation, wilful means willingly certain thing is being
misrepresented, second is the deliberate concealment of material
pact. There was a material transection but it has been concealed so
that its impact will not common the financial statement. For example
there is a certain expenditure or a big loss is being incurred on certain
items but it has been concealed so that profits could be reflected on a
higher side such concealment of material fact and that to deliberate
would amount to fraud on the part of the enterprise. C is failure to
disclose the material fact for the purpose of inducing another person
or putting him at a disadvantage. Here C point is different from B
because here another person is being put in disadvantages position by
cancelling the data;
Now another of fraud is misappropriation of cash, misappropriation of
cash means there is certain dis-calculation of cash or various certain
stealing in the cash let us understand what exactly misappropriation of
cash means it can take place in the following manner by acknowledging
less amount than actually received so what happens that such amount
which is being received certain part is being misappropriated and
lesser amount is being shown. By omission of receipt the receipt is not
being given and there is defalcation or misappropriation of cash by
inclusion fictitious payment that means if the payments are being not
made but they are being shown just in the form of a book entry so that
defalcation of the cash and misappropriation of cash can be covered up
such amounts to misappropriation of cash by recording more payments
then actual if we record more payments then actual what happens that
outflow would be reflect more while we can say that such amount is
being spended or expended and cash can be misappropriated. Now how
www.examisthan.com
to detected it by careful comparison of records in the cash book with
other subsidiary books and original vouchers.
6. SUMMARY
Now we are summing up our lecture of today certain other features in
relation to the fraud will be continued in our next lecture. In today’s
lecture we have learned about the meaning of auditing and objective
of auditor as well as the functional classification of auditor. With this
we are ending up our lecture of today.
Thank you
www.examisthan.com
Auditing Internal Control https://www.tutorialspoint.com/cgi-bin/printpage.cgi
1 of 3 22-Aug-18, 9:20 PM
www.examisthan.com
Auditing Internal Control https://www.tutorialspoint.com/cgi-bin/printpage.cgi
2 of 3 22-Aug-18, 9:20 PM
www.examisthan.com
Auditing Internal Control https://www.tutorialspoint.com/cgi-bin/printpage.cgi
3 of 3 22-Aug-18, 9:20 PM
www.examisthan.com
CHAPTER - 711
SOCIAL AUDITING
This chapter attempts to pro ride an objective asse
ssment of the concept, significance, growth and status of
the social audit which is developed as the principal in
strument for evaluating corporate social performance. It
also identifies the various difficulties in making social
audit and suggests some principles to overcome than. The
maintenance of an effective social performance system
squarely depends upon the Social Assessment system of the
enterprise which integrates the processes of accounting,
midi ting and reporting of the social responsibility per
formance of the enterprise. It facilitates the building
up of a detailed and accurate account of information in a
classified manner, to test and prove its authenticity
through certification and helps report to various user
groups the relevant performance results in a concise, con
sistent and constructive manner. Thereby, it creates an
opportunity for a meaningful interaction among all the
members concerned with company and society, and furnishes
the basic foundation for sound planning.and execution of
the social responsibility.
CONCEPT OF SOCIAL AUDIT
There is considerable, agreement, at high level of
www.examisthan.com
227
abstraction, that the business social audit is a report of
social performance in contrast to the financial report which
is concerned with economic performance. But there ends the
consensus. In practice, however, the social audit has
created considerable confusion, causing one observer toodescribe it as "the-great-what-is-it."
Semantics trouble!
There are several titles employed in preference to
the tern ’Social Audit*, Among other terms, the widely
used ones are: 'Social Statement', 'Social Report', 'Business
Response to Social Priorities', 'Report on Corporate Social
Poli ci es and Action s', * So eio- economic Accoun ting', ’ So cial
Accounting', 'Social Responsibility Accounting', 'Social
Information System', 'Societal Accounting*, 'Socially Responsible Accounting* etc.^
To understand the nature of these terms, an examination
of the different view points is necessary. Robert K. Elliot
1 Steiner, George A.n Business and Society. (New York;Randam House, 1971)* p*19&.
2 Corson, John J#,'Nation's Business' 'Quoted in Halal, Willi an E., 'A Return-on-Resources Model of &>rporate Performance, California Management Review. Vol.XIX, No.4, 1977, P.2^.
3 Steiner, George A.,op.cit.« p.196., Blake, David. H.,Frj|der, William C., and Myers, S Mildred., Social Auditing. (New Yorks Praeger Publishers, 1976), p.3., Estes, Ralph, Corporate Social Accounting. (New Yorks John Wiley & Sons, 1976), p.3 and Report of the High Powered Expert Committee on Companies & MRTP Acts, Department of Company Affairs, Government of India, New Delhi, 1978, p.97.
www.examisthan.com
228
employs the term Social Responsibility Accounting. To him
it is a systematic assessment of and reporting on those
parts of a company* s acti-pities that have a social impact.
Social Responsibility Accounting would therefore, describe
*the impact of corporate decisions on environmental pollution,
the consumption of non-renewable resources and ecological
factors; on the rights of the individuals and groups; on
the maintenance of public service; on public safety; on health and education and many other such social concerns.*^
Ralph Estes prefers the use of Social Accounting and
defines it as: ’The measurement and reporting internal and
external, of information concerning the impact of an entity
and its activities on society,
Social Audit according to Sethi, is a means 'to
"breakdown all or large part of the broad term social respon
sibility of business, into indentifyable components and to develop scales that can measure these constituents.*^ (Hark C.
Abt opines: ’The mission of social audit is to provide more
objective, accurate and comprehensive information about an7performance that is usually compiled.'f
ELiot, Robert K,, Social Accounting and Corporate Decision making, Management Controls. January, 197?.
? Estes, Ralph, Qp.cit.. p.3,6 Sethi, S. Prakash, ’Corporate Social Audit: An Emerging
Trend in Measuring Corporate Social Performance’, in Votaw, Dow and Sethi, S.P., The Corporate Dilemma: Traditional Values 7s Contemporary Problems, (Ehglewood Cliffs N.J.: Prentice-Hall;, Inc., 1973, p.219.
7 Abt, dark C.,' The Social Audit for Management. (New York; A Division of American Management Association, 1977).
www.examisthan.com
229
Beesely and Evans writes 'But the tern Social Audit
has “been used rather more commonly, to denote any form of
retrospective review of the impact or contribution of the
company in recogiised social dimensions. (It is) a tool of
the socially responsible company, undertaken by itself or
admitted groups for the purpose of planning, control or accountability.*8
All these definitions give us to understand that the
controversy is limited to the use of the title. The purpose,
one way or other is to reveal in true and full perspective, .
with greater accuracy, the performance details of the company
in the areas of social responsibility.
Those who prefer the terras other than accounting
and auditing suggest that qualitative and descriptive ana
lysis is the only possible means for evaluation and reveal-
ation, as methods for quantification are yet to be deve
loped. George A. Steiner is prominent among those who be
lieve that the tern audit and accounting carry a connotation
of quantification and argues that the teim 'social audit
should not be used because measurement of performance does
not now and probably xcill never approach In accuracy and acceptability the accountant's audit of economic performance'.^
8 Beesley, Michael and Evans, Tom, Corporate Social Responsibility: A Reassessment. (London: Cromhelra Rtd.,1978),pp.167-168.
9 Steiner, George A., 'Making Social Responsibilities Operational in Business', in Steiner, George A (ed), The (Slanging Business Role in the Modem Society. (Los Angels: Graduate School of Management, UCLA, 197*0 , p.10p.
www.examisthan.com
230
The term Social Accounting has already gained peculiar con
notations in the International accounting terminology.
According to Kohler, ’ Social Accounting Is the application
of double entry book-keeping to socio-economic analysis of
national or international income, national sad internationalinbalance sheets and design for system of component accounts.
The term, Social auditing, has been treated as synonymous
with * Social Accounting*. The term 1 Socially Eesponsible
Accounting* may be interpreted as social responsibility of
Accounting profession, as the profession has developed its
own social norms. Taking into consideration the conceptual
frame work, scope and contents of social responsibility
Accounting, the terms Socio-economic accounting sejpns to11be more appropriate one. However, in business world, so
cial audit has become popular and it will be only wise to
stick to it by prefacing it with the word 'business’ to
avoid any confusion that is likely to arise.
G-BOVJTH OF SOCIAL AUDIT
The concept of the social audit for monitoring, measu-
, ring or appraising social performance is at least forty years
10 Kohler, A., ’Government Spending, its Tasks and Limits,» Social Research. YE, 1939.
11 Murao, Bahadur, 'Accounting of Social Responsibilities of Business’, The Management Accountant. Yol.-I^, No.1, January 1979, PP.9-13.
www.examisthan.com
231
old. The -use of this concept has evolved through three stages,
as detailed in Chart VII.. 1.
The first stage envisioned a governmental evalua
tion by. an outsider, and defined social performance largely
in economic terms. The second stage was the concept of theI
management evaluating itself aid the organisation* s social
performance. In the third and current stage, audits cover
a wider range of activities and serge multiple purposes,
such as satisfying the corporate conscience, improving so
cial programs, enhancing public relations and increasing12the credibility of the firm.
The development of Comprehensive form of social
audit is due to the following reasons.
1) Openness - Hall mark of civilisation:
Post-industrial society is come to be regarded as a
modem and civilised one aid organizations are viewed as
organic-innovistic - open-creative systems and not as the
mechanistic - rigid-closed-bureaucratic systems. The success
and progress of pluralistic organisations is dependent on
the ability of the organizations to communicate effectively
with other constituents in the society and function in a
12 Caroll, Archie B. and Beiler, George W., landmarks in the Evolution of the Social Audit* , Academy of Management Journal. Wo.18, September 1975, PP.589-5>99.
www.examisthan.com
232
Mea
sure
men
t of C
ompa
nies
' prog
ress
to
war
d, so
cial
goal
s
The F
irm's e
valu
atio
n of i
ts so
cial
pe
rfor
man
ce
Satis
fyin
g the
corp
orat
e con
scie
nce;
Im
prov
ing f
inan
cial
wisdo
m of
soci
al
prog
ram
s; Pub
lic re
latio
ns to
enhan
ce
cred
ibili
ty of
the bu
sine
ss fir
m
Com
pany
perf
orm
ance
ins
Pollu
tion/
envi
ronm
ent, M
inor
ity ma
ploy
- m
ent; W
orki
ng co
nditi
ons;
Comm
unity
re
latio
ns; Ph
ilant
hrop
ic an
d C
onsu
mer
ism
issu
es.
Div
ided
betw
een tw
o scho
ols o
f tho
ught
. O
ne gro
up fe
els i
t shou
ld be
only
for
oian
agaa
ent1
s use
. Anoth
er gro
up fe
els
it sh
ould
be a
publ
ic do
cum
ait.
Mon
itor, m
easu
re, an
d app
rais
e all
aspe
cts o
f soci
al pe
rform
ance
usin
g va
rious
techn
ique
s-co
st vs
bene
fit,
acco
untin
g etc
.,In
tern
al pe
rson
nel o
r con
sulta
ntIn
tern
al .p
erso
nnel
or an
In
dust
rial ag
ency
Judg
emei
tal ap
prai
sal o
f co
mpa
ny po
liey
Com
pany
polic
y tow
ards
pric
es;
Wag
es; Be
sear
ch an
d dev
elop
men
t; A
dver
tisin
g; Pu
blic
rela
tions
; H
uman
rela
tions
; Com
mun
ity
rela
tions
; Econ
omic
stabi
lisat
ion
By m
anag
emen
t to as
sess
its
perf
orm
ance
Eval
uatio
n of th
e per
man
ce of
bu
sine
ss fro
m a
soci
al po
int o
f vi
ewTh
e Firm
' s ev
alua
tion o
f its
so
cial
perf
orm
ance
Brin
g soc
ial p
oint
of vi
ew to
m
anag
emen
t
Eval
uatio
n of p
ublic
in
form
atio
n em
ploy
ing
econ
omic
indi
ces
A Go
vern
men
t bur
eau
Aci
d tes
t of b
usin
ess
perf
orm
ance
Gov
ernm
ent ev
alua
tion o
f so
cial
busi
ness
's pe
rfor
man
ceEs
tabl
ish c
riter
ia fo
r fu
ture
eval
uatio
ns,
Esta
blis
h the
techn
ique
fo
r soci
ety to
influ
ence
bu
sine
ss pe
rfor
man
ceQ
uant
ifiab
le are
as*
Bap
loym
ait; p
rodu
ctio
n;
Con
sum
er ef
fort c
omm
ande
d;
Con
sum
er fu
nds a
bsor
bed;
Pa
yrol
ls; D
ivid
ends
; In
tere
st.
By so
ciet
y to a
sses
s bu
sine
ss pe
rfor
man
ce
By w
hom
oo
nduc
tad
Met
hodo
logy
Use
Mat
ure o
fis
sues
audi
ted
App
aren
tM
otiv
es
SnbJ
eet
Def
initi
on
Purp
ose
Toda
y's A
udit
Bow
en's A
udit
Kre
pp*
s 19*K
) Aud
it
Qia
rt 7TI
.1Ev
olut
ion o
f Soc
ial A
udit -
Cbne
epts
flour
eet Ca
roll.
Arch
ie B,
and B
eile
r, Geo
rge W
., 'Lan
cfaa
rics in
tile Ev
olut
ion o
f the
Soci
al Au
dit*
A
f»ri
*mv o
f Man
aem
eant
Jour
nal. S
epte
mbe
r 18, 197
5* P.5
98.
www.examisthan.com
233
coordinated and purposeful manner. A systematic appraisal
and reporting therefore,. are indispensable to channalise
energies into new avenues of endeavour*
2) Gain -public approval and rapport;
Society has become less tolerant and more demanding.
In many a case* society views the process of performance
too slow, not because implementation is not carried but be
cause aspirations outrun the ability to perform,
nAt any given mom ait the public must have in mind some criteria, however imprecise, of what constitutes a satisfactory performance by business. The public keeps raising standards - as, in an achieving society, it should. Trouble develops because the public is not aware of how rapidly it raises its standards. Because it believes its standards are unchanging it tends to perceive business performance as moving backward."1^
’•Also, society appears to be changing the ’rules of the game* for business organisations. No longer
' will effectiveness be measured exclusively in terms of economic performance for example, there is growing interest in the development of national social indicators and a program of social system accounting, ”^
13 Ways, Max; , ’Business Needs Do a Better Job of Explaining Itself’, Fortune. September 1972, p.86.Bauer, Raymond A., Social Indicators. (Cambridge Mass:The MIT Press, 1966).
www.examisthan.com
234
It is evident that the expectation - performance gap,
if not convincingly explained to public, it causes a serious
damage to the standing and reputation of the socially res
ponsible enterprises.
3) Preserve autonomy:
If business remains unresponsive to the demands for
disclosure of information and tries to evade by making state
ments, advertisements etc;, in a flattering, flowery, and
descriptive language, the society forces upon the business
community by government the ’social reporting system’ in the
form of some what blunt, inflexible and mandatory regula-
tions. x On the other hand, if corporations take active
lead in the definition of this evolving pardign, they can
seize the opportunity to develop a system of accountability
which is best suited to .the needs of business and society
and thereby regain the public confidence which is essential
to the success of the free enterprise system. Of course, there
are many technical, social and political obstacles to the
development of a workable social reporting system, including
difficulties in method and measuranent of information, the
lack of various types of information, and problaas involving
in certification, dissemination and implementation of auditI
15 Hills, Roderick, 'Business Warned on Ethics’, Washington Post. February 19, 1976 and 'Wader Galls for Federal Charter of Business, Washington Post. January 25, 1976.
www.examisthan.com
235
results. Difficulties are nothing but natural to any system
particularly in its offing stage. As the system grows the
elemental parts, in the case, the social information system,
the social accounting systan, and social auditing system
leam through experience, ways to overcome than and become
capable of fulfilling the objective of providing fair and
true information to all stakeholders.
b) Systematised and sophisticated communicating tool:
Depending upon the degree of willingness of company
to communicate openly, the reporting methods vary from
flashy public relations brochures to detailed status re
ports. The recognised means are:
1. Publicising involvement in social affairsthrough news letters and other reporting
16means.2. Local meeting^ and3. Social report/audit.18
The publication of the company’s concern and involve
ment in the social areas help create awareness among the
public of the company's posture toward social responsibility
and build favourable image for it. It may be considered akin
16 Caro11, Barbara H., 'Firms Try to Grade Social Action Efforts' . Industry Week. May 20, 197^, pp.15-16,
17 Mukharji, P.B., Social Be soon sibili ties of Business. Report of the study Group of the Calcutta Seminar, (Hew Delhi: Oxford & IBS Co., 1969), PP.13-1^.
18 Bowen, H.R., Social Responsibilities of Businessman, (New York: Harper & Bros., 1953).
www.examisthan.com
236
to the Institutional advertising that highlights the Issues -
of concern to society and philosophy of company with regard
to it. It can not he a primary and exclusive communication
device. At hest it can act as a remainder or persuader to
keep public infoimed and seek their active support and
co-operation in making company effort more meaningful. .
The local meeting should be a regular annual feature
and open to representatives of the consumers, the workers,
the community and the shareholders and should be advertised
well in advance in the local press. Its object should be
to enable the directors and the management of the industry,
to give a fair report on
(a) general position of business
(b) prospects of expansion and growth
( c) €Bnployer-employee relations
(d) Consumer affiars
(e) Community improvement programs etc..
It can be very useful step, particularly in the early
stages, when the enterprise embarks on social responsibility
programs, What is however necessary is the avoidance of
wild and irresponsible criticism, and the mischief-maker s’
propensities, so current in a developing country like India,
to seise such an opportunity to create confusion and
pandemonium. The meeting therefore, should be confined to
the respectable and knowledgeable who can effectively grasp
comment and suggest measures.
www.examisthan.com
237
The lasts but more useful approach to reporting is
social audit. Though it is in embryonic stage at present,
it seems to grow in scope, sophistication of measurement
and frequency of use among business films,
Bauer and Fenn, the major proponents of using the
social audit for auditing internal decision making emphasise:
’the corporate social audit should permit firms to report
their performance on issues of current social concern with
the same regularity that they report financial performance*
SI mi FI CANGE OF SOCIAL AUDIT
The significance of social audit can be estimated
from the multiple purposes it serves in the organisation.
The number of purposes, Sir Geoffery Yickers suggests to
organisational communication are equally applicable to
social audit,
"One purpose is to convey information about what is happening both outside and inside the organisation; a. second purpose is to improving rules about, how various types of situations should be handled..,.,
A third purpose is to form aid render acceptable collective decisions... A fourth purpose is to move to action,,, A fifth purpose is to create, confirm ot modify the attitudes of individuals
19 Bauer, Raymond. A, and Fenn Jr., Dan. H., The Corporate Social Audit. (New York: Russel Sage Foundation, 1972).
www.examisthan.com
238
within the organisation itself, to each other to the work and so far as necessary to the outside wo rid*20
Ralph Sates gives the following classification of
the purposes of social audit#
A# Internal
1. Improve the decision-making process toys
a# Assisting in the process of establishing goals, objectives and priorities in planning, the use of monetary, physical and human resources#
b. Educating the motivating managers to think through the social consequences of all decisions#
2# Provide a basis for the continuing internal appraisal of social performance.
B. External1# Ultimately to provide consistent bases and
reasonable uniformity for companies to measure social performance and to report to the public,
2. Ultimately to provide a basis for independent attestation of corporate reports on social
91performance#1”
20 Vickers, Geoffery. * Communication in Economic System1 in Mo Rae, T*W#f (ed), Managaaent Information Systems. (Londons Penguin, 1071)> P*30#
21 Estes, Ralph, op.cit.. pi16. ^. * . . i- ■ l
www.examisthan.com
239
SCOPE illfD METHODS
The new dim^isions of social audit are not only
concerned with the foms and structures of accounts hut
are also largely influenced hy the changing ideology of
social and economic responsibilities in the gzmtiJig .
conciousness of the modern age, where new and perplexing
problem is that some one is using and controlling somebody 22else1 s money*. As such, the scope of social audit depsids
on many factors like public pressures, government direct
ions, managers' responsiveness, methodology for identifying
social concerns, sophistication of measures, the .develop
ment of acceptable format etc. More significantly, the
social audit at any point of time, reflects the state of
the arts and willingness of siterprise to disclose infor
mation to user groups.
If the social audit is to include all activities,
it embraces everything a corporation is doing or not doing.
If the social audit is to verify, the various costs entailed
and the benefits produced, it becomes an impossible task .
and the information which might be produced would likely to
be indigestible. On the other hand, if a social.audit
includes only a cataloguing of activities which top managers
are interested, in pursuing and/or those activities whichWM0HWMM*aiai
22 Mukharji, P.B*, op,cit.« p.4-3.
www.examisthan.com
240
might improve the public image of the company if publicised,
the principal function of social audit will not be performed.^
Because of the inchoate state of the social audit
various approaches to its interpretation and implementation
have been Iburishing, For instance, they may be,
superficially,, hastily conducted, one-time ’surveys’ of
company practices bearing upon one or more social issues,
internally generated so.cial reports prepared for public
relations purposes and often the poorly informed ’audits’
of various alleged corporate abuses conducted by outsider
groups utilising adverse publicity as primary techniques.okAn elaborate classification of the social audit
may. be as follows.
1. Nature j (i) ^Qualitative - Simplynarrative objective analysis with the help of qualitative social
. indicators.
(ii) Quantitative - descriptive in terms of quantifiable social economic terms. Objective description in
' ' terms of goals and resultsin quantified terms*
23 Steiner, George A., op.cit.. p.201.24- Blake, Frederick & Myers, op,cit., pp.2r53s>Estes,Ralph,
op.cit., p.2$, and Butcher, Bernard L.,' ’The program Management Approach to the Corporate Social^Audit’, California Management Review. Fall 1973> pp. 11-16*
www.examisthan.com
241
2. Coverage ; (i) Partial - analysis of one ormore constitutonts.
(ii) Total - Analysis of whole enterprise*
3* Audience z (i) Useful for Company managers'
(ii) Useful for one or moreconstituents and management.
(iii) Useful to all.
4-. Source of data : (a) Micro-audit - if only companydata is employed.
(b) Micro-Macro audit - if company as well as the data at national level is employed.
5. Initiative s (i) Internal: Individually/Jointly-the company takes initiative and organises audit either individually or jointly with external agencies.
(ii) External: Individually/Jointly-outside organisations like the social organisation, Academic Institution or Governmental organisation may conduct the audit either with or without the involvement of the company.
Chart 1/11-2 provides at - a - glance understanding of
the various approaches to social audit in vogue;
www.examisthan.com
Sour
ce* A
eo*p
ound
ed and
mod
ified
Ver
sion
of A
bt, da
rk C.
t The S
ocia
l Aud
it for
Man
ages
ai
(New
Yor
k* A
Div
isio
n of A
mer
ican
Man
agem
ent A
ssoc
iatio
n, 197
5) end
Bro
oks J
r., Le
onar
d J an
d Dav
is, W
illia
m R.
, 'Som
e App
roac
hes to
the C
orpo
rate
Sofa
l Aud
it',
CA
Mag
azin
e, fol
.110
. No.
3, Ma
rc* 1
977,
p.3&
.
ro f\2
i •l 1
' 1 '
: i:
• *
Kh
o m+ 5*
5?3tiO »1
/* St
t
ato n
% •«* *ti» •35 .
V 1t ,1 lf 1y& ' w■ 1 Q> |WI at l4** iH *
1 at im; n ;
i i■ ii i
Mis
lead
ing;
No tar
gets
; N
o resu
lts; D
iffic
ult
to com
pare
£
njfc&
is-d*■3
&£
O «)H ►*d » 8fi 4*885S 8®g Si Clas838SSS
f. i8 .• 1Sg '11 :
§1 :
P* •m -p ie <a«-« i
Soci
al Au
dit M
odel
s
i i* s '1 bp |at1 -P 11 l 1
( <
1 1| i
& G Ti Os »3 Sss80413(83
1?
3-p
3 «
>• <m at4 O'O
*» a* •8i?{?
SSPlff
tig33d o « o r-j Vi ® ® p Si i~»H ► ® jO ®w P.OCO
A |m► iit».-*it* ,
•833 iass ,
Boao ® iOo»
1 1
1 t1 £ 1* % «
' % '
' & 11 fn 1hi1 11 «
1 1I 1
•a•
8
.to
<Has3
£ CM•8&
CO r-
0>attil
S3•3*•P M a) in
® -H CM ■P SIN S3 2 ONH ® «“
Jto-
g CN • « CO
g-s&~H ®
fuss
w sia* flj atm O «- o
A 1■Pat■h c- •■a Onk ;
-3 iM ■ '
3S :
1 11 1
1 1
a>• -Si •
' i '» 85 11 11 1
1 1 Qua
litat
ive c
heck
lists
, D
escr
ipriv
e for
mat
, pa
rtial
disc
losu
reLi
stin
g inp
uts o
nly,
Q
uant
ified
form
at,
parti
al di
sclo
sure
Ass
igni
ng pe
rfor
man
ce
goal
s. Mone
tary
form
at,
parti
al di
sclo
sure
Inte
grat
ed So
cial
/ fin
anci
al au
dits
, co
mpl
ete d
iscl
osur
e
• 1• ti '• % •
1 a •
1 t
• • •rO
•j* i
Cha
rt VII
. 2
www.examisthan.com
243
'INVMTQBI' APPROACH/' CHECK-LIST* APPROACH involves
the cataloguing of what the company is doing in each major
social program or not doing in Social areas xdiere there is
social expectation that it should he active. Ibr each
identified area this approach calls for data and/or narrative
description of what, is or is not being done. The effort is
only to explain activities hut not to evaluate them in
terms of 'impacts'*
As it involves calculation of expenditures made
xdthout any concern for the impro van aits effected, it is
the simplest of all the methods. The major limitation of
this method, no matter how comprehensive, detailed and
elaborate it is, and no matter how many dimensions of it
are expressed in some matrix - is that there is no logical
way of determining whether or not there is any net social
benefit resulting from the company's social performance.
Pbr a firm to start with, this can be a useful one. It
serves a kind of 'consciousness raising' function for
executives who employ it, thus taiding to mobilize their
commitment to exploring more sophisticated and precise
measures. As one can make a long list of ' good* things the
company has done, a short list of the 'bad* things, and
make it look as if one has done more good than bad, it can
be at best a public relations device and certainly is no
great aid to management decisions in capital budgeting or
other resource allocation.
u
www.examisthan.com
244
A second one, ’INPUT ANALYSIS* APPBOACH which seeks
to identify and measure the expenditures -which have been
made for social programs and/or describes in qualitative
teims what has been done. The trouble is that expenditures
measure only the inputs to social activities and not the
outputs; there is no measure of efficiency or effectiveness.
And the mere fact that company is spending a lot on social
action program does not mean it is getting its money* s
-worth and that the -whole program is torthwhile. It is
therefore, a basic step toward evaluation and provides a
erode basis for budgeting: but offers no clues for optimising
investment.
The third one, ’PERFORMANCE GOALS* APPROACH is
concerned with setting up of goals in the diverse social
responsibility areas for aehievemmt by the company. It
encourages management by objectives and makes evaluation
easy as actual performance can be measured against' the goals
set. The limitation is the company cannot compare the social
worth of differait social projects as the goals are not
established on the basis of a Socio-economic cost-benefit
analysis.
This can be carried through valuation of human assets.
The audit is concerned with valuations of the productive
capabilities of company’s human organisation, the valuation
www.examisthan.com
245
of shareholder loyalty, hanker or community goodwill,
customer loyalty and so on. J
The impact of Social programs can he measured hy either opinion poll method or hy surrogates. Opinions ofindividuals about how they perceive the impact of social
!program on themselves can he a useful measure. An example is hlum’ s poll made to determine the extent to which a company was satisfying the basic human needs of its employees.2^
The other way of measuring impact is through use of surrogates. A surrogate is a substitute which is believed to approximate the underlying phenomenon. Employee satisfaction can he measures through absenteeism, labour turnover, output, etc.
The 'COST-BMEBTT ESTIMATE* METHOD is variously referred to as social process audit,^ program management
28 pqaudit, and Input-output matrix approach. y It is a
25 Likert, Rensis, Boumal, Villi am J., Likert, Rensis Wallich and McGown, John. J., A Hew Rationale for Corporate Social Policy. (New York; Committee for Economic Developm ont, 1971).
26 Blum, Fred, H., ’Social Audit of the Enterprise’, Harvard Business Review. Mar eh-April 1958, pp. 77-86.
27 Bauer, Raymond, A, and Fenn Jr*, Dan H,, loc.clt.28 Butcher, Bernard L., loc. cit.29 Elliot - Jones* M.F^’Matrix Methods in Corporate Social
Accounting - Some extensions of Input - Output Economics’ Presented at Seminar on Corporate Social Accounts,Battelle Seattle Research Centre, November 10-11, 1972.
www.examisthan.com
246
description and quantitative and nonquantitltive analysis
of a specific program activity, intended to provide manage
ment with systematically developed information for purposes
of review of program effectiveness in achieving the company's
stated goals. It deals not with the entire company and its
overall social performance, but only with clearly identifiable
and specific programs. It does not attempt to compare
program, performance in one area with program performance in
another area, although in course of time a sufficient base
for doing so might be built up within a given organisation.
This type of Social Audit has several advantages:
1. It minimises the problems of methodological difficulties and shortcomings that characteristically plague this new field of social measurement and evaluation.
2. It can be applied to any and all realms of organisational activity whether they are undertaken voluntarily or required by the government regulations, whether related
. positively or negatively modest in magnitude and expenditure, whether quantifiable or only partially so or not at all, and whether comprising an'adjunct, ’Social* program or consisting of a 'main stream* business operation.
www.examisthan.com
247
The obvious st^mgths of this method are of its
limitations as well:
1. The difficulty in setting goals, is the major limitation. Various pressures that operate on business may force management to establish objectives based upon short-run, so daily constructive, or self-serving considerations.If that has occured then a social process audit, will run risk of perpetuating organisational practices, attitudes, and policies, xdiich will be considered unwise and undesirable by some groups within the society.
2'. By focusing upon explicit, discreet programmes and activities, the social process audit does
■ not provide the organisation* s management with a comprehensive view of the. total range of social consequences that may result from company operations.
3. Because the standards developed are specific to a given social program or activities,there is no yard stick of social performance, no common denominator, comparable to that used in economic
• and financial performance to make inter program comparisons.
If companies are to continue to be brought before
the bar of Social judgement - and particularly if social
evaluation is to be based on social analysis rather than
pure emotion and bias - then this absence of tools for
comparison of inter-program effectiveness will have to be
remedied. Such a dilemma cannot be resolved by reliance
www.examisthan.com
upon the discreet, program-by-program analysis represented
by the Social process audit.
The * COMPREHENSIVE AUDIT* reflects the highest level
of sophistication in measurement at which the social
benefib^cost approach is integrated with financial accounts
and financial statements. It allows to make" direct trade
offs between Social and financial investment and social and.
financial returns and maximise both. It focuses attention
on »Consumers'. of Social activities - society as a whole,
a community, or groups and individuals etc., - with respect
to either their broad needs or specific needs. Measurement
may be in teims of values received or benefits related to .
costs incurred.
Most ambitious one is that of Abt. He lists In
financial terms, in a sort of modified and combined
balance sheet and income statement, social assets of a
company, social commitments, obligations and equity, and
social benefits and costs j-ni to staff, to the community
and to the general public and comes to a net social income
to clients. This method would be prohibitively expensive for a company of even moderate size.^
30 Blake, Frederick & Myers, op. cit.. p.20*31 Steiner, George A., op.cit.. pp.202-205.
www.examisthan.com
249
Linowes proposes a ’Socio-economic operating
statement’ which calculates in dollars, for a specific :
major program, the ’Social improvements’ and ’detriments’
that are involved. He •winds up, like Abt, with an aggregate
plus or minus for society. While simpler than Abt’s, Linowev'sop \
method is still complex for practical applications. \P
A Return-On-Resource (RQR) model, of the social audit,
enlarges the traditional concept of corporate accountability
into a matrix describing various aspects of corporate
perfoimance for various constituent groups. It provides a
structured system incorporating explicit social costs and
benefits, and helps to resolve the many problematic questions
concerning corporate' activities in the social sphere which
have here to forth been treated as externalities, excludedfrom the financial and economic system.33
/
Making Social Auditing Effective;
\;\i\\\
\
The development of social audit is by no means an
easy task.. As stated earlier social audit is not a mere
description of activities of an enterprise in the choicest
areas of social action but, ”a commitment to systematic
assessment of and reporting on some meaningful, definable
32 Ibid.. p.205.33 Halal, William E., op. cit,«, pp.23-2^-.
www.examisthan.com
250
okdomain of the company* s activities that have social impact”.
Among the foremost difficulties cited are *the problem of
developing acceptable measurements of social factors,
difficulty in obtaining cost ratios of some sort, a lack of
consensus regarding activities to evaluate and the absence
of agreed format to organise the information into useful^k
technique for corporate decision*
Difficulties:
. The various difficulties, an enterprise may face in
course of the development of a social audit, are outlined
here.
1. Conflict of Interests:
A firm is a hub of a complex social system
involving a variety of constituencies all of which are
essential to its operations. It has to reconcile
diverse interests of the various social groups to
form a workable coalition engaged in creating value
for distribution, among members of the coalition.
34 Bauer R.A. and Fenn Jr., D.H., *What is a Cbrporate Social Audit?*, Harvard Business Review. Vol,51, Ho.1, January-February 1973* p.38.
35 Corson, John, J. and Steiner, George, A., Measuring Business* Social Performance: The corporate SocialAudit. (Hew York: Committee for Economic Development. 1974-).'
www.examisthan.com
251
It is opined, therefore, that although measurement
problems are difficult, it is organisational politics ,
rather than technical difficulties that inhibit the
use of social audits. This v±e\i highlights the
fact that measurement or reVLexj carries emotional
and other overtones that intum affect the behaviour .
that is being measured*’,
2* Divergent Objectives:
Concerning with the objectives of the Social
audit there are differing view points. While some
consider that it is to be made for the use of
executives, others argue that it must be made to meet the information needs of the publics as well”.^
As corporate controllers are aware of, the composition
and structure of the two sets of information requirements
are far from identical and can be standardised within
a single system, only x-jith some gross adjustments.
3. Amorphous Objectives;
Effective social policy and performance require
continual adaptation to changing social needs and
opportunities for responses. This is the alleged
36 Myers, Mildred S,, <The.Hidden Politics of Social Auditing*, Business and Society Review. Autumn, 197^«
37 Anshen, Melvin. Managing the Socially Responsible Corporation. (Wex* York: Macmillan, 197^-)*
www.examisthan.com
252
•Moving target* nature! of social requirements. It is
argued that, what is social today being economic
tomorrow, there is a tendency to account for such
activities, in economic terms said a tendency not to
worry too much about separating socially related
actions from purely economic ones, since in all
probability they will.'either go away or blend into the economic mainstream of the firm'*.^8 It. is. why
many feel against the need for social accounting systan
to augment- the regular economic accounting system.
4. Management Apathy:
Many are of the strong opinion that social
• accounting cannot obtain the precision of financial
accounting. Daniel Gray of Arthur D. Little Inc.,
emphatically states* ‘traditional corporate accounting
owes its rigor to what it excludes. To try to
stretch it to measure all social costs and benefits is to violate its very foundation*.^ Yet another
point, that accounts for management apathy for
developing' social audit is the alleged small and ancillary
38 Churchill, Neil C., * Toward a Theory for Social Accounting*, sloan Management Review. 197!?, p.27.
39 Gray, Daniel, ‘Methodology: One Approach to the Corporate Social Audit*, in Sethi S.P. (ed).*, Unstable Ground: Corporate policy in a Dynamic Society. (Los Angels:Mel veil! Pub. Co., 197*f). :
www.examisthan.com
level of expenditure. Hell C. Churehill argues that
controllers or managers do not perceive the value of
having detailed information on such expenditures
because the potential, savings from more rational
allocations do not seem to warrant examining them in detail.^
5. Time. Expense and Skills:
The preparation of social audit is a time
consuming and expensive process. It takes an
interdisciplinary team to accomplish a social audit,
atieast a period of four months. It requires the
deployment of the combined skills of an economist,
an accountant, engineer, social scientist, besides
the coordinating skills of a-generalist corporate 1+1manager.
Because of the several practical difficulties
in making a social audit, many enterprises do not
consider it a worthwhile exercise* However, the
difficulties are not insuimountable. If proper steps
. are taken, the exercise will not only be constructive
but also be emulative to other enterprises. CertainN
basic principles which can be of help -to enterprises
intending to develop social audit, are summarised belovr
40 Churchill, Hail. C.. loc.cit.Vi Aht, dark G., oo.cit.. p.113.
www.examisthan.com
2 54
1. Principle of Assurance of Objectives:
The purpose of Social audit is to
systematise information relevant for making at
meaningful evaluation of enterprise performance,
from various stakeholders* point of view. It should
not become 'an avenue' to attach any particular
function of management, and fears that this might
happen, should be anticipated and allayed by making
it clear that the social audit is a management
infoxmation system designed primarily to improve
the efficiency of investment decisions at all
levels, in the organisation. In the absence of
such a clear statement of objectives, the social
audit will become the breeding ground for conflicts
and misunderstandings.
2. Principle of Employee Participations
Participation of managers at all levels .is
a key element in making any programme work. Company
wide participation in the decision to measure social
performances and in the definition of objectives and
gains to be achieved would certainly facilitate the proeess^aaking an effective social audit greatly.
Probably, it is the most effective way of dealing
with the attitudinal and behavioural problems on
the part of middle-management.
www.examisthan.com
255
3. ‘ Principle of Social Area Selection;
Fbr effectiveness in their social pro grammes,
companies need identify and select high leverage
areas of social action.’ High leverage areas of social
action are those, over which company has a high degree
of control, those which hold high promises of being
socially productive and those activities that have
a high degree of potential for replication. Choices
as such enthuse the operating managers to participate
and contribute to the success of programme.
4. Principle of Effective Measures;
The purpose of measurements is to help the
user groups, appreciate the company effort, evaluate
and suggest improvements. As such, measures should
be developed in such a way that they serve the
intended purpose. To ensure that, it is to be checked,
■vdiether the measures so developed possess the
characteristics likes Simplicity, Objectivity,
- Reliability, Acceptability and Feasibility.
Principle of Research Utilisations
The tendency to 1 reinvent the wheel* in
developing measurements, without regard to what
others have already done, will lead to unnecessary
delay, dissatisfaction, and waste of resources.
www.examisthan.com
256
Just as prof esionally competent measursnents of
financial results use the latest accounting
methods micro economics and statistical sampling,
professionally competent measurements of social
performance should make use of the relevant methods
and findings from the social sciences such as
survey research, group psychology, and evaluation
of educational and health programmes impact.
6. Principle of Standards: ’
An issue of paramount importance is setting
up of company wide standards for uniformity of
practices and comparability of results. Standardisation
of measures of social performance is necessary to
compare on a fair basis the performance of one
division with that of other divisions and with its
own previous performance. In the absence of common
standards, inconsistent interdivisional standards
will be applied, which will destroy incentives to
good performance.
7. Principles of Appropriate Method; '
Methods of social audit are many and every
company has to make its own choice. Depending upon
the amounts committed to social programmes
undertaken, availability of financial resources and
www.examisthan.com
257
state of the arts in developing social audit,
a suitable method is to be chosen. If better
measures are not available, there is no way to go
but to prepare description scenarios of what
constitute acceptable performance.
8. Principle of Leadership:
The more effective the leadership is, the
greater will be the contribution of subordinates
to the predetermined goals. The leader of the
social audit team, should therefore, be a man
known for integrity and having high status,
preferably from within the company. Also, it is •
not advisable to select the head of public
relations as team leader. It will lead to serious
misunderstandings among public. If you buy public
relations, you get only public relations. Social
accounting and auditing are not public relations.
It is preferable to choose either Chief financial
officer or a senior manager, with vast
administrative experience.
9. Principle of Training Managers:
Except in those businesses that make
extensive use of social science for market and
opinion research for detailed behavioural and econometric
www.examisthan.com
258
studies, operating di-vision managers are unlikely
to have staffs who are well trained in both the
methods and the findings of .contemporary social
science. The problem can be solved by providing
brief training to managers to acquaint than with
the basic tools of social research necessary for
developing measurements.
10. Principle of Double Evaluation;
Internal social audits, -voluntarily undertaken
by management, tend to- be optimistic, quick,
efficient and comprehensive. However, the
reliability of these can also be questioned on thet
basis of self-serving bias. The external audits
are supposedly critical and unfavourable to company
as they tend to have negative bias. Thus, the
most comprehensive and precise social audit requires
both internal and external auditing - internal for-
comprehensiveness and external for reduction of\
bias. Much the same double approach has been found
effective in financial auditing and cost
effectiveness evaluations.
11. Principle of Balanced Reporting:
The issue of disclosure of audit findings
raises however, the very delicate and controversial
www.examisthan.com
259
question of - how far the social audits and
accounts should he open to public and of what
exactly are spheres aid areas in which the public
should reasonably taken into confidence. The
social audit has its utility as well as its dangers.
Its utility lies in accepting the social
responsibilities of modem business whereby members
share atleast some confidence with the public
which business serves. Its dangers are that a
wholesale disclosure may lead to irresponsible
criticism and trade handicaps of various kinds.
The enterprise has to take, therefore, the needs
of various user groups into account and develop a
need based report that may satisfy all groups.-
12. Principle of Continuing Developments
The more an enterprise is committed to social
responsibility, the more it requires its managers
to develop the methods and measures of social
auditing. The social audit should be conducted as
consistently as possible, from year to year. As
new, more comprehensive and sensitive measures of
social impact are added - and they should be added
as they become available - the required precision
and sophistication can be achieved.
www.examisthan.com
CONCLUSION
In the new setting of society, companies which
adhere to the traditional -views like profit-maximisation,
bureaucratic-mechanistic, and closed systems, private
entity, individual good is public good, and laissez-faire,
cannot succeed in their endeavours. They have to develop
a style of operating based on the views like quality of
life, organic-innovistic-humanisti c-open systems, public
good is individual good and government direction.
Business organisations have to shift their loyalty from the
owners or stockholders to society or stakeholders and
attempt to discover new methods, techniques and tools to
make their reporting practices more rational, realistic
and meaningful. It implies that social reporting is to
be developed into a science and art of disclosing in
qualitative as well as quantitative terms, both social
costs and social benefits, of actions as well as
non-actions of the company.
Though the development of comprehensive audits is
mostly desirable, due to the difficulties in measurement,
they are dubbed as abstract and complicated. Further the
high costs involved discourage many films from attempting
to make such type of audits, imong the described methods,
www.examisthan.com
social, process audit seems to have gained more popularity
iflith many companies in TJ.S.&, as its specific focus is
accounting of cost/benefits of social programmes only*
www.examisthan.com
Journal of Business Management & Social Sciences Research (JBM&SSR) ISSN No: 2319-5614 Volume 5, No.6, June 2016
© The Author © Blue Ocean Research Journals www.borjournals.com Open Access Journals Blue Ocean Research Journals 193
Budgets and Budgetary Control
Dr. Abhijit Pandit, Professor Genesis Institute of Management and Technology, Kolkata Abstract This study deals with budget, budgeting and budgetary control. Also pros and cons of budgetary control, steps of prepar-ing budget and finally different types of budgets are discussed.
Keywords: budget, budgetary control
Budget A budget is a formal expression of policies, plans, objec-tives and goals laid down for a definite period in the fu-ture. The budget expresses revenue goals in the sales budget and expense limitations in the expense budgets that must be attained in order to realize the desired profit objective. The Institute of Cost and Management Accountants, London, defines budgets as, "Financial and/or quantita-tive statements, prepared prior to a definite period of time, of the policy to be pursued during that period for the purpose of attaining a given objective." The basic elements of a budget are: a) It is a future plan of activity for a specified period of
time. b) It is expressed in physical or monetary units or in
both. c) It is prepared in advance, i.e., before the period dur-
ing which it is to operate. d) The objectives to be attained and the policy to be
pursued to achieve those objectives are required to be laid down before its preparation.
Budgetary Control Budgetary control involves the use of budgets and bud-getary reports throughout the period of budget to co-ordinate, evaluate and control day-to-day operations in accordance with the goals specified by the budget. Bud-getary control involves a constant checking and evalua-tion of actual results compared with the budgeted goals, which should result in corrective action where indicated. The Institute of Cost and Management Accountants, London, defines budgetary control as, "The establish-ment of budgets relating the responsibilities of execu-tives to the requirements of a policy, and the continuous comparison of actual with budgeted results, either to secure by individual action the objective of that policy or to provide a basis for its revision." The process of budgetary control involves the following steps:
a) Defining and specifying the objectives to be achieved by the business.
b) Preparing business plans in order to ensure that the desired objectives are accomplished.
c) Translating the plans into budgets, and relating the responsibilities of individual executives and manag-ers to particular sections of the budget.
d) Continuous comparison of actual results with the budget, and the calculation of differences between the budgeted and actual performance.
e) Investigating major differences in order to establish the causes.
f) Presentation of the information to management in a suitable form, relating the variances to individual re-sponsibility.
g) Corrective action by the management in order to avoid a repetition of any wastage or over-expenditure. Alternatively, where it is not possible to achieve the budgeted targets due to change in cir-cumstances, the revision of the budget.
Difference between Budget, Budgeting and Budgetary Control The difference between budget, budgeting and budgetary control may be stated thus — Budgets arc the individual objectives of a department, etc. whereas budgeting may be said to be the act of setting budgets. Budgetary con-trol embraces ail and includes the science of planning the budgets themselves and utilisation of such budgets as an overall management tool for the business planning and control. Thus, the term budgetary control is wider in meaning and it includes both budget and budgeting. Objectives of budgetary control are a) To Compel Planning. This is the most important
feature of budgetary control, because management is forced to look ahead, set targets, anticipate problems and give the organisation purpose and direction.
b) To communicate ideas and plans to everyone af-fected by them. It is necessary
c) To have a formal system to make sure that each per-son is aware of what he is supposed to be doing.
www.examisthan.com
Journal of Business Management & Social Sciences Research (JBM&SSR) ISSN No: 2319-5614 Volume 5, No.6, June 2016
© The Author © Blue Ocean Research Journals www.borjournals.com Open Access Journals Blue Ocean Research Journals 194
d) To Co-ordinate the Activities of different depart-ments or sub-units of the organisation. This concept of co-ordination implies, for example, that the pur-chasing department should base its budget on pro-duction requirements, and that the production budg-et should in turn be based on sales expectations.
e) To Establish a System of Control by having a plan against which actual results can be progressively compared.
f) To Motivate Employees to improve their perfor-mance.
Requisites of an effective system of Budgeta-ry Control a) A clearly defined organisational structure, which
emphasizes areas of responsibility. b) Adequate accounting records and procedures, so that
measurement of performance may be relied on. c) Participation by individuals within the budgeting
process. d) Awareness by management of the uses of the budge-
tary control system. e) Awareness by the top management of the problems
of budgetary control, and especially of the reaction of individuals to budgets.
f) Flexibility, so that plans and objectives may be re-vised.
Advantages of Budgetary Control The advantages of a budgetary control system are as follows: a. It defines the objectives of the organisation as a
whole, and within this overall framework, it defines the results which each department should achieve.
b. It reveals the extent by which actual results have exceeded or fallen short of the budget.
c. It indicates, with variances or other measures of performance, the reasons why actual results differ from those budgeted, and establishes the magnitude of the differences.
d. As a result of reporting on actual performance along with variances and other performance measures, it provides a basis for guiding executive action to cor-rect adverse trends.
e. It provides a basis for the revision of the current budget, or for the preparation of future budgets.
f. It provides a system whereby the resources of the organisation are used in the most efficient way poss-ible.
g. It indicates the efficiency with which the various activities of the organisation have been co-ordinate.
h. It provides some centralizing control where activi-ties and responsibilities are decentralised.
i. Where the activities of an organisation are subject to seasonal variations, it provides a means of stabiliz-ing the organization’s activities.
j. It establishes a basis for internal audit by means of regular examination of departmental results.
k. It enables standard costs to be used. l. It provides a basis for measuring productive effi-
ciency with a view to paying a bonus to employees.
Limitations of Budgetary Control The principal limitations of budgetary control are: a. Estimates are used as a basis for the budget plan. b. A budgetary programme must be continually
adapted to fit changing circum- I stances. Normally it takes several years to attain a reasonably good budgetary I programme.
c. Execution of a budget plan does not occur automati-cally. All levels of the management must participate enthusiastically in the programme.
d. No budgetary control system will eliminate the ne-cessity of having a management and administration. It does not take the place of management, but is ra-ther a tool of the management.
Steps in Preparing a Budget Preparing a budget involves the following steps: a. Establish budget centres (for the purposes of budge-
tary control) b. Prepare a clearly defined organisational chart stating
the functional responsibilities of each member of the management team.
c. Prepare a budget manual (specifies in detail the pro-cedures to be followed)
d. Form a budget committee.(for co-ordinating and reviewing the budget programrne)
e. Determine the limiting or key factor f. Select the budget period. (period of time for which
the budget is prepared and employed) g. Set objectives to be reached by the end of the budget
period. h. Prepare forecasts for the period. i. Determine enterprise policies (e.g., product range,
normal hours of work per week, channels of distri-bution, stocks, research and development appropria-tion, investments).
j. Compute from the forecasts the requirements in terms of the economic quantities needed to meet the objectives while complying with the policies — and subsequently convert these quantities into monetary values. This results in an initial provisional budget.
k. Review this initial budget with respect to the planned objectives and amend objectives or policies or both repeatedly until an acceptable budget emerges.
l. Formally accept the budget which then becomes the master budget and as such is an executive order.
www.examisthan.com
Journal of Business Management & Social Sciences Research (JBM&SSR) ISSN No: 2319-5614 Volume 5, No.6, June 2016
© The Author © Blue Ocean Research Journals www.borjournals.com Open Access Journals Blue Ocean Research Journals 195
Distinction between Forecast and Budget A forecast has been defined as the prediction of relevant future factors affecting an entity and its environment as a means to facilitate the preparation of planning decisions. A forecast is a prediction of what is likely to happen, whereas a budget is a plan of what organisation has set itself as a target for what should happen. A forecast is a judgment can be made by anybody, whereas a budget is an enterprise objective that may be made only by the authorized management. A forecast forms the basis for the budget. A budget statement of planned events gener-ally evolved from the forecast. The forecast of a function need not necessarily be well co-coordinated. Budgeting involves a good co-ordination and functions of an orga-nisation to attain the desired results. The forecasts may cover a period ranging from one to five years, or longer in the case of certain types of businesses. The budgets, however, are rarely projected for more than a year in advance, except in the case of capital expenditure budg-et, and often are projected for only three months. Bud-geting involves the control of variations from the ap-proved plan in order that the desired results may be achieved. Forecasting does not involve any such control. Types of budget Functional Budget A functional budget is a budget which relates to a major function of the business. The usual functional budgets are : a. Sales Budget : The budget shows sales in terms of
quantity and value, analysed by the product, by month, by region, by channel of distribution and by salesman.
b. Selling Expenses Budget : The budget inchnlcs salesmen's salaries, commission, expenses, and re-lated administrative costs.
c. Distribution Expenses Budget: The budget is made/up of transportation, freight charges, stock control, warehousing, wages, expenses, and/elated administrative costs.
d. Marketing Budget : Apart from details of all adver-tising, promotional activities, public relations, mar-keting research, customer service, and so forth, the marketing budget can also include a summary of the sales, selling expenses and distribution expenses budgets.
e. Research and Development Budget: The budget covers materials, equipment and supplies, salaries, expenses, and other costs relating to design, devel-opment and technical research projects.
f. Production Budget : The aim of the production func-tion is to supply finished goods of a specified quali-ty to meet marketing demands. The distribution budget specifies finished goods stock levels, and this can be related to the sales budget to give de-
tailed production requirements. Following from this, it is necessary to consider a series of subsidiary budgets :
i. Raw Materials Budget. ; It paying appropriate atten-tion to the desired stock levels.
ii. Labour Budget: It ensuring that the plan will make available at the right times the required number of employees of suitable skills
iii. Manufacturing Overheads budget: It covering items such as consumable materials and waste disposal.
g. Manpower Budget: The budget must take an overall view of the organization’s needs of manpower for all areas of activity — sales, manufacturing, admin-istrative, executive, and so on — for a period of years. Based on the manpower budget and policies, training expenses budget and recruitment expenses budget can be formulated.
h. Purchasing Budget: Raw materials, consumable items, office supplies and equipment, and the whole range of an organization’s requirements, must be considered while preparing this budget, along with the answers to the questions when, where, at what price, and how often to buy.
i. Administration Expenses Budget: The budget deals with such expenses as office salaries and upkeep, depreciation, stationery, management salaries, tele-phones, postage, etc.
Financial Budget The financial budget which summarizes the whole pack-age of budgets is made up of five individual budgets: a. Cash Budget: It is concerned with liquidity. It shows
the requirements of cash in respect of various func-tional budgets as well as anticipated cash receipts.
b. Budgeted Profit and Loss Account: It is concerned with profitability. It reflects the matching of bud-geted revenues during the period with budgeted costs during the same period.
c. Budgeted Balance Sheet: It is concerned with the structure of assets and the pattern of liabilities.
d. Budgeted Funds Flow Statement: It is concerned with the sources of funds and their application in the organization’s objective-striving endeavors.
e. Capital Budget: It is concerned with the questions of capacity and strategic direction. It deals with the evaluation of alternative dispositions of capital funds as well as with the choice of the best capital structure.
Cash Budget The cash budget, as its name implies, summarizes the estimated cash receipts and the estimated cash payments over the budget period. Its object is to ensure a balance between liquidity and profitability. The cash budget is
www.examisthan.com
Journal of Business Management & Social Sciences Research (JBM&SSR) ISSN No: 2319-5614 Volume 5, No.6, June 2016
© The Author © Blue Ocean Research Journals www.borjournals.com Open Access Journals Blue Ocean Research Journals 196
closely related to the sales forecast, expense budgets, and capital expenditure budget. The cash budget is concerned with the timing of receipts and payments of cash (cash basis), whereas the other budgets are concerned with the timing or incurrence of the transactions themselves (accrual basis). Purposes of Cash Budget The principal purposes of the cash budget may be out-lined as follows: a. It indicates the probable cash position as a result of
planned operations. b. It indicates cash excess or shortages. c. It indicates the need to arrange for short-term bor-
rowing, or the availability of idk cash for invest-ment.
d. It makes provision for the co-ordination of cash in relation to
i. total working capital, ii. sales,
iii. investment, iv. debt.
e. It establishes a sound basis for obtaining credit. f. It establishes a sound basis for current control of the
cash position. Methods of Preparing Cash Budget There are two methods of preparing a cash budget: (a) receipts and payments method and (b) funds flow mcthod Distinction between Cash Budget and Cash Flow Statement Following are the important points of distinction be-tween a cash budget and a cash flow statement: a. A cash budget is futuristic in approach. It is pre-
pared in advance and is based on future plan of ac-tion. A cash flow statement is based on past data.
b. Cash budget relates to objectives to be achieved and is a plan for future inflows id outflows of cash. A cash flow statement is a post mortem analysis of ac-tual flows and outflows of cash.
c. The period of a cash budget is usually short (may be a week, fortnight, month or quarter). A cash budget may be prepared covering a long period also (say, a year) but divided into short sub-budget periods (say a month or quarter). The time span to be covered by a cash budget will vary from one firm to another, depending on the nature of its business and the de-gree of accuracy with which estimates can be made. A cash flow statement covers a relatively longer pe-riod, usually an accounting year, and it is not di-vided into sub-periods.
d. A cash budget requires previous data only for the purpose of judicious forecasting. A cash flow state-
ment is prepared from accounting data at the begin-ning and end of an accounting year.
e. A cash budget is a tool for budgeting and controlling cash. A cash flow statement is an analysis of the working of the concern for the past accounting year.
f. A cash budget usually serves the purposes of man-agement only. A cash flow statement may serve the purposes of management as well as external parties.
Flexible Budget In some businesses it is extremely difficult to estimate future levels of activity with any accuracy because of external uncontrollable influences. For example, a busi-ness providing luxury goods and services may be very sensitive to changes in the economic climate. Some businesses are affected by weather, and weather condi-tions are difficult to predict. The main requirement of a flexible budget is that ex-penses should be analyzed into three distinct categories: (a) Fixed expenses, i.e., expenses which would remain the same irrespective of levels of activity? (b) Variable expenses, i.e., expenses which would change in proportion to levels of activity. (c) Semi-variable expenses, i.e., expenses which would need to be analyzed into the fixed and variable elements. The advantage of flexing a budget, as already stated, is that actual performance can be compared with the flexed budget for purposes of control and performance apprais-al. Zero-Base Budgeting (ZBB) As a modern technique of budgeting, considered ideal for planning and decision making, ZBB was first applied by the United States department of agriculture as early as in 1964. The conceptual framework and structural devel-opment of ZBB was made by Peter A. Pyhrr who applied it in Texas Instruments, a multinational company of United States in 1969. Peter A. Pyhrr is regarded as the "father of zero-base budgeting owing to his contribution towards the development of the technique and making of the conceptual framework. President Jimmy Carter, while in the presidential chair of the U.S.A., issued an official order in 1979 for using the technique by all fed-eral government agencies throughout the United States. The technique was then gradually adopted by various countries all over the world. ZBB Concept Traditionally budgeting is done on the basis of the tar-gets set in the last year. Certain additions and deductions are made in the last year's budget figures- to arrive at the figures for the current budget. Thus, in traditional budget making we depend on the last year's targets and on the principle of increment or decrement to decide upon the
www.examisthan.com
Journal of Business Management & Social Sciences Research (JBM&SSR) ISSN No: 2319-5614 Volume 5, No.6, June 2016
© The Author © Blue Ocean Research Journals www.borjournals.com Open Access Journals Blue Ocean Research Journals 197
additions and deletions required to the incorporated in the previous budget figures to arrive at the current budg-et figures. In case of ZBB it is assumed that there was no previous year's budget and the current budget proposals are inde-pendently evaluated in the light of expected benefits and costs involved. ZBB, therefore, refers to formulating a budget without making any reference to previous plans and achievements, but making particular reference to the justification of the proposed allocation of resources. This is not once. Every time a budget is to be prepared, the process of budgeting should start from zero and the pro-posed allocation of resources should be justified in terms of cost-benefit analysis. ZBB Defined I.C.M.A., London, defined ZBB as "a method of budget-ing whereby all activities are re-evaluated each time a budget is formulated. Each functional budget starts with the assumption that the function does not exist and is at zero cost. Increments of cost are compared with incre-ments of benefits culminating in the planned maximum benefit given by budgeted cost." Peter A. Pyhrr, the father of ZBB, defined ZBB as "an operating planning and bbudgeting process which re-quires each manager to justify his entire budget request in detail from scratch. Each manager states why he should spend any money at all. This approach requires that all activities be identified as decision packages which would be evaluated by systematic analysis and ranked in order of importance." Zero-base budgeting becomes ideal in case of planning and decision making. Development planning includes undertaking of various types of work of which there is no previous experience. Budgets in these cases can not be based on past targets modified by certain additions and deletions. Every budget proposal has to be evaluated on the basis of cost-benefit analysis. All proposed activi-ties are to be identified as decision packages to be eva-luated by systematic analysis and ranked in order of priority. Decision making depends on priority list. Main Features of ZBB The following are the principal features: a. Zero (or scratch) is taken as the basis of budgeting
and not the targets of previous budgets. b. Management of each decision unit must have to
justify the fund demanded. c. All proposed activities are grouped into various de-
cision packages. d. All decision packages are adequately evaluated and
arranged according to priority.
e. Alternative decision packages are also taken into consideration after evaluating properly.
f. Final allocation of resources is done on the merits of evaluation of all decision packages including the al-ternative decision packages.
How ZBB differs from Traditional Budget-ing The following are the points of distinction between tradi-tional budgeting and zero-base budgeting: a. In traditional budgeting previous level of expendi-
ture is given emphasis, whereas, in ZBB new eco-nomic appraisal is made every time a budget is pre-pared.
b. Traditional budgeting is an accounting oriented function, whereas, ZBB is project (or decision) oriented function.
c. For preparing a traditional budget existing pro-gramme need not be rejuslified, whereas, for prepar-ing a zero-base budget the existing and new projects are to be justified in the light of benefits and costs.
d. In case of a traditional budget the top management of ihe organisation justifies why a particular amount of expenditure is decided upon for a particular deci-sion unit, whereas, in case of ZBB it is the manager of the decision unit (and not the top management) who justifies the amount of expenditure.
e. In case of traditional budgeting how much is to be added with or deleted from the previous budget fig-ures is only taken into account, whereas, in case of ZBB appraisal of the existing level of expenditure is done and the future proposal for expenditure is justi-fied from different angles.
f. Preparing a traditional budget is a simple job mono-tonously done year after year, whereas, preparing a zero-base budget requires logical approach and it involves many complex steps to establish logic be-hind a proposal.
Applicability of ZBB ZBB is very suitably applicable in planning and devel-opment areas particularly of the government and local bodies. Projects of every ministry are thoroughly ex-amined with reference to costs and benefits. Which projects of which ministry shall enjoy priority in respect of allocation of resources depends upon the report of cost-benefit examination by persons competent to do so. Where the resources are limiled but there are many de-velopment works' to be done as in case of educational institutions, local bodies etc. ZBB becomes ideal, be-cause efficient use of limited resource is almost guaran-teed. In manufacturing concerns there are many devices like standard cost technique, work and motion study etc. to control cost. These techniques help controlling the prime
www.examisthan.com
Journal of Business Management & Social Sciences Research (JBM&SSR) ISSN No: 2319-5614 Volume 5, No.6, June 2016
© The Author © Blue Ocean Research Journals www.borjournals.com Open Access Journals Blue Ocean Research Journals 198
costs and production overhead, because in these cases there is direct relationship between cost and output. But in manufacturing concerns there are various other ex-penditure which supports production function, but no relationship between cost and output can be established in these cases. This area of expenditure is a suitable field for application of ZBB. This area is covered by expendi-ture like accounting, research, development, mainten-ance, advertisement, postage, electricity, rent of adminis-trative office and many others. Merits of ZBB The following merits of ZBB are claimed: a. All projects — current and future are examined
carefully with reference to cost and benefits and the most efficient project is accepted. Thus, ZBB is al-ways a technique based on logic. The current projects are continued only if they are logically sound and efficient.
b. Amongst the available alternatives the most efficient ones are chosen on the cost-benefit acceptability for rational planning. ZBB requires the managers of de-cision units to find out cost effective ways of im-plementing the plans. Thus, ZBB helps making best planning and it also helps controlling cost.
c. Cost-benefit analysis is done in respect of both ex-isting and future projects. On the basis of the result of the analysis ranking of projects is done and funds are allocated in order of priority. Thus, ZBB helps efficient allocation of funds.
d. In zero-base budgeting most useful alternatives are found out for using the available resources of the organisation. In performing an activity also, alterna-tive ways lire taken into consideration and alterna-tive quanta of efforts to be put in are also consi-dered. These help promoting new ideas for perform-ing an activity in (lie best possible way.
e. Appraisal of existing activities and new projects is done, with equal importance, with regard to justifia-bility of continuing new undertaking on the basis of cost-benefit analysis.
f. In ZBB the managers of all decision units are to submit reports on their claims of funds and justifica-tion of the claims. Thus, in zero-base budget mak-ing, participation of all managers of decision units becomes compulsory. This promotes forthcoming of new ideas in allocation and utilisation of funds.
g. Since appraisal of the existing activities is done carefully in ZBB, activities failing to give desired results may be discontinued and thus unproductive expenditure may be saved.
h. ZBB technique being adopted all managers are ob-liged to make self-evaluation of projects under their command. Loopholes, if any, in the working progress are automatically detected and remedial measures are adopted. Managers' awareness in re-
spect of detection of errors and their rectification helps attaining efficiency in performance.
i. ZBB creates automatic motivation and helps form-ing a management team of individuals having talents and skills.
j. ZBB helps linking up top management with medium and lower level management. Thus, speedy commu-nication is ensured which helps expediting appropri-ate decision-making.
k. ‘Management by objectives' (or MBO) can be intro-duced and implemented with the help of ZBB. ZBB can be used for fulfilling the objectives of traditional budgeting, as it can be used for fulfilling other ob-jectives as well.
Demerits of ZBB The following demerits of ZBB are apprehended: a. Collection and analysis of data of alternative future
projects as well as existing activities requires time, money and energy.
b. Implementation of ZBB technique becomes diffi-cult, if full co-operation amongst management staff is not forthcoming.
c. Evaluation often becomes very difficult, as ideal standard of evaluation is not available. Evaluation in a desired manager requires technical knowledge which may not be available.
d. Managers are to undergo continuous training. If basic idea and objectives of ZBB are not crystal clear to the managers, implementation of ZBB sys-tem in a right way can not be expected.
e. In care of ZBB projects are to be ranked according to priority. Ego of top management may lead to irra-tional ranking of projects (i.e., if the top manage-ment favors a projects, irrespective of its merits it may be ranked high). Moreover, confusion may arise among the management staff regarding the me-thod of ranking to be adopted.
f. ZBB requires involvement of a good number of in-dividuals. This may create complications in com-munication system, difficulty in managing the huge volume of data, involvement of voluminous paper work etc.
References: [1] Batty, J. (1963), “Management Accounting including Financial Management and Control”, Macdonald and Evans. [2] Batty, J. (1979), “Accounting for Managers”, Hei-nemann Publishers, 2nd Edition. [3] Buyers and Holmes, G. (1984), “Principle of Cost Accounting”, Cassell Ltd. 4th edition. [4] Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (2000), “Management Accounting Official Terminolo-gies”, CIMA
www.examisthan.com
Journal of Business Management & Social Sciences Research (JBM&SSR) ISSN No: 2319-5614 Volume 5, No.6, June 2016
© The Author © Blue Ocean Research Journals www.borjournals.com Open Access Journals Blue Ocean Research Journals 199
[5] Frank Wood (1988), “Business Accounting” Pitman Pubishing, 8th edition. [6] Hongren, C.T. and Foster, G. (1985), “Cost Account-ing: a managerial emphasis”, New Jersey, Prentice Hall Inc. [7] Koontz, Donnel, H and Cyril (1979), “Principle of Management: An analysis of managerial functions”, New York, Mc Graw Halls Book Co. [8] Lockyer, K. (1983), “Fundamental of Budget prepo-sition ethics: A Development”.
[9] Lucey, T. (2003), “Management Accounting”, New York, DP Publication [10] Lucey, T. (2008), “Costing”, New York, DP Publi-cations [11] Miller and Earnest, C. (1966), “Objectives and Standards: An approach to planning and control”, AMA Research Study 74, American Managers Association Inc [12] Pandey, I.M., (1985), “Element of Management Accounting”, Vikas Publishing House Limited.
www.examisthan.com