Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and...

69
PRESENTATION TO HPAE Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the Impact on Health Care Workers Plenary Session, October 6, 2016 Fred Hyde, M.D. Fred Hyde & Associates, Inc.

Transcript of Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and...

Page 1: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

PRESENTATION TO HPAE Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the Impact on Health Care Workers Plenary Session, October 6, 2016 Fred Hyde, M.D. Fred Hyde & Associates, Inc.

Page 2: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Corporations Follow the Money

Legislation, the 20th Century and the beginning of the 21st in America

• Social Security, 1935

Page 3: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Corporations Follow the Money

Legislation, the 20th Century and the beginning of the 21st in America

• Social Security, 1935 • Medicare and Medicaid,

1965

Page 4: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Corporations Follow the Money

Legislation, the 20th Century and the beginning of the 21st in America

• Social Security, 1935 • Medicare and Medicaid,

1965 • Fiddling with Medicare

and Medicaid, 1965-2010

Page 5: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Corporations Follow the Money

Legislation, the 20th Century and the beginning of the 21st in America

• Social Security, 1935 • Medicare and Medicaid,

1965 • Fiddling with Medicare

and Medicaid, 1965-2010 • PPACA, 2010

Page 6: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Corporations Follow the Money

Legislation, the 20th Century and the beginning of the 21st in America

• Social Security, 1935 • Medicare and Medicaid,

1965 • Fiddling with Medicare

and Medicaid, 1965-2010 • PPACA, 2010 • Fiddling with PPACA,

2010-2016 .

Page 7: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Corporations Follow the Money

Legislation, the 20th Century and the beginning of the 21st in America

• Social Security, 1935 • Medicare and Medicaid,

1965 • Fiddling with Medicare

and Medicaid, 1965-2010 • PPACA, 2010 • Fiddling with PPACA,

2010-2016 • Big repair, big

replacement, 2017 ff.

Page 8: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Where is the money?

Page 9: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

ork, The and N w II ~ : stry hi · hest em loyment : ry s ate

. acturln RJ t~ll t ( ~

.1990

I D.

sn

Okla.

ZDll

Page 10: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 11: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 12: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 13: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 14: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 15: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 16: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 17: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 18: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 19: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 20: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 21: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 22: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 23: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 24: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 25: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 26: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 27: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 28: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 29: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 30: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 31: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 32: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 33: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 34: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 35: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 36: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 37: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 38: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 39: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 40: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 41: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 42: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 43: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 44: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 45: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Where is the money?

IT: example, “Optum” now a $80 billion annual revenue company, foresees a world-wide market of $1.2 trillion

Page 46: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Where is the money?

IT: example, “Optum” now a $80 billion annual revenue company, foresees a world-wide market of $1.2 trillion Pharma: pricing entirely out of control, largely due to government actions

Page 47: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 48: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 49: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 50: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Where is the money?

IT: example, “Optum” now a $80 billion annual revenue company, foresees a world-wide market of $1.2 trillion Pharma: pricing entirely out of control, largely due to government actions Finance: Steward arranges placement of $1.2 billion with Medical Properties of Alabama

Page 51: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Where is the money?

IT: example, “Optum” now a $80 billion annual revenue company, foresees a world-wide market of $1.2 trillion for data Pharma: pricing entirely out of control, largely due to government actions Finance: Steward arranges placement of $1.2 billion with Medical Properties of Alabama Executive compensation throughout the health field: ‘nuf said

Page 52: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

What does this mean for negotiation?

Page 53: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

What does this mean for negotiation?

Larger and more powerful adversaries

Page 54: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

What does this mean for negotiation?

Larger and more powerful adversaries Greater sophistication among negotiators

Page 55: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 56: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 57: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is
Page 58: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

What does this mean for negotiation?

Larger and more powerful adversaries Greater sophistication among negotiators Less access to “the top” in larger health systems

Page 59: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

What does this mean for negotiation?

Larger and more powerful adversaries Greater sophistication among negotiators Less access to “the top” in larger health systems Potential for conflict among locals or representatives

Page 60: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

What does this mean for negotiation?

Larger and more powerful adversaries Greater sophistication among negotiators Less access to “the top” in larger health systems Potential for conflict among locals or representatives More “issues”

Page 61: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

Page 62: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

• Scoundrels

Page 63: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

• Scoundrels • Underserved

communities

Page 64: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

• Scoundrels • Underserved

communities • Dis-served patients

Page 65: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

• Scoundrels • Underserved

communities • Dis-served patients • Unhappy doctors

Page 66: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

• Scoundrels • Underserved

communities • Dis-served patients • Unhappy doctors • Occasional tragedy

Page 67: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

• Scoundrels • Underserved

communities • Dis-served patients • Unhappy doctors • Occasional tragedy • Higher public cost

Page 68: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

• Scoundrels • Underserved

communities • Dis-served patients • Unhappy doctors • Occasional tragedy • Higher public cost • Higher private cost

Page 69: Challenging Corporate Health Care: Health Care Trends and the … · 2016. 10. 1. · Medicare and Medicaid, 1965 . ... 2010-2016 • Big repair, big replacement, 2017 ff. Where is

Some New Jersey Issues

How these changes in hospitals and health care will “show up” in New Jersey

• Scoundrels • Underserved

communities • Dis-served patients • Unhappy doctors • Occasional tragedy • Higher public cost • Higher private cost • Challenges to you