Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe...

24
Show Me The Evidence: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting By Julia Belluz, Vox Nov. 9, 2019

Transcript of Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe...

Page 1: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Show Me The

Evidence:

Challenges in

Evidence-

based

reporting

By Julia Belluz, Vox

Nov. 9, 2019

Page 2: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Jack Taylor/Saul Loeb/Getty Images

Page 3: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Tom Pennington/Getty Images

Page 4: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Infowars

Page 8: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...
Page 9: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Fighting the health bunk:

● What we’ve learned about evidence-

informed health comms

● The challenges and pitfalls

● How you can get involved

Page 10: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Show Me The Evidence

Page 11: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

A clear bottom line

Page 12: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Communicate research methods

Page 13: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...
Page 14: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Show Me The Evidence approach:

● Studies in Context

● Prioritize higher quality evidence

● Communicate uncertainty

● Instead of debunking, how you know

● Transparent about methods

● Accurate, thorough, clear!!!

Page 15: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

The

Challenges

Page 16: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

The oxygen probelm

Jaap Arriens/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Page 17: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

When there is no evidence

Page 18: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Navigating COI

Javier Zarracina/Vox

Page 19: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...
Page 20: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Navigating controversy

Page 21: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Getty Images

Finding the the story in the science

Page 22: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

How you can help?

● Collaborations

● New tools for helping journos evaluate science

● Join the conversation! Twitter, op-eds, blogs

● Start conversations with reporters/editors you trust

● When you spot bunk, hold bunk peddlers to

account — including journalists

Page 23: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

For sources, my colleagues suggest:

● “One thing I would like more scientists to do is be

available to talk about the foundations of their

fields rather than new findings.”

● “I don’t just want to know the findings, I want to

know why you’re interested in asking the question

in the first place.”

● “I always appreciate it when a scientist directs me

to talk to other people, and those other people

aren’t just white men.”

Page 24: Challenges in Evidence- based reporting€¦ · Presentazione standard di PowerPoint Author: Gimbe Created Date: 11/9/2019 3:42:49 PM ...

Keep in touch!

[email protected] @JuliaofTorontoContact