Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The...
Transcript of Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The...
![Page 1: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI surveys
Martin Zwaan - ESO
![Page 2: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
HI mass functions…
![Page 3: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
The problem…
• Complications:
• Complicated completeness limit (Speak, W, profile shape, freq)
!
• Large scale structure⨂
![Page 4: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
The methods
1/V ML
𝜑/𝛷 C
![Page 5: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
The 1/Vmax method
• The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method
• Calculate maximum distance Dmax out to which the galaxies can be detected
• Convert Dmax into a Vmax
• Used for early Arecibo surveys
• Advantages: simple and automatically normalised
• Disadvantage: sensitive to large scale structure
Zwaan et al 1997
✗
✔
![Page 6: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Maximum likelihood methods
• Defined by Efstathiou et al 1988, Sandage et al 1979
• Find θ that yields maximal joint probability of detecting all sources in sample
minimal detectable HI mass at distance Di
generally not defined for HI selected samples
![Page 7: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
2D Stepwise Maximum likelihood method
• Solution: multi-dimensional stepwise maximum likelihood methods
• Find θ(MHI,W)
• Collapse to find HIMF
• (Or, find ML-based effective volume accessible to each galaxy individually)
• Used for HIPASS and ALFALFA
• Advantage: robust against LSS
• Disadvantage: slow
✔
✗
![Page 8: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
The Turner or 𝜑/𝛷-method
• Introduced by Turner (1979) for 3C and 4C quasar catalogues
• Calculate the ratio of number of galaxies in interval dMHI and number of galaxies brighter than MHI
!
!
• Advantage: fast and robust against LSS
• Disadvantage: correlated errors ✗
✔
![Page 9: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
The C- method
• Developed by Lynden-Bell (1971) for quasars
• Maximum likelihood procedure. Does not require any binning.
• Estimates the cumulative luminosity function (CLF).
• Does not require any assumptions about the distribution of objects within the data-set.
![Page 10: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
The C- method
• then differentiate to obtain
!
• advantage: independent of clustering effects and fast✔ ✔
![Page 11: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Dealing with gradual drop off in completeness (as opposed to sharp flux limits…)
• All these methods are designed for optical galaxy samples with sharp magnitude limits (mlim)
• The 2DSWML, Turner, and C- method are easily adaptable to work for complicated completeness limits
![Page 12: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Normalising the HIMF
• Most methods (apart from 1/Vmax) lose the normalisation of the HIMF
• Various methods for recovering the normalisation
• n3: integral over selection function
• n1: calculating number of galaxies in redshift shells
• n: “minimum-variance” - weighting by selection function and second moment of correlation function
• counts: compare real and expected number of galaxies
_
(HIPASS)
(ALFALFA)
![Page 13: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Simulations to test HIMF recovery
• Millennium Simulation (Springel et al 2005)
• 9 million galaxies in the full simulation box (500 Mpc/h on a side)
• Stitch several cubes together
• Assume a HIPASS HI mass function
• Low mass (log MHI<8.5) cluster around larger ones
![Page 14: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Simulations
• Rotational velocity - HI mass relation from Obreschkow & Rawlings (2009)
• Random inclinations -> velocity widths
• Realistic scatter on all parameters
• Select galaxies from simulated boxes, assuming ‘optimal smoothing’
input catalogue selection method simulated sky
![Page 15: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Simulated HI skies
“Wallaby”all sky shallow
“Dingo”30deg2 deep
![Page 16: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Testing the methods
• Using Wallaby ‘early science’ fields
Simulate 10 times
![Page 17: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
No large scale structure
![Page 18: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
10 ASKAP pointings - contiguous
![Page 19: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
10 ASKAP pointings - widely spaced
![Page 20: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Results of testing methods on shallow HI survey
As expected. Sensitive to
LSS
Not better than 1/Vmax
Performs well. Robust
against LSS
As good as 2DSWML.
Faster!
![Page 21: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Full Wallaby
• HIMFs based on 1/Vmax method
factor 3 variation!
![Page 22: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Full Wallaby
• C- performs very well
• SWML takes too much processing time
• HIMF slope accurate to ~0.01
![Page 23: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
DINGO Ultradeep: 0.1 < z < 0.2
![Page 24: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
DINGO Ultradeep: 0.2 < z < 0.3
![Page 25: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
DINGO Ultradeep: 0.3 < z < 0.4
• Dingo:
• measure HIMF above MHI* out to z~0.3
• C- method performs well
![Page 26: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Testing normalisations
• Normalising using ‘counts’ is very reliable
![Page 27: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
HIPASS and 40% ALFALFA in Millennium
Thanks to Danail Obreschkow
![Page 28: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
HIPASS and 40%-ALFALFA inside Millennium simulation box (S3-SAX)
Thanks to Danail Obreschkow
![Page 29: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Cosmic variance in HIPASS and ALFALFA (40%)
8 9 10 11log(MHI/Msun)
−3
−2
−1
0lo
g(re
lativ
e va
rianc
e)
8 9 10 11
−3
−2
−1
0
HIPASS more robustALFALFA more robust
HIPASS
ALFALFA
![Page 30: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Compare HIPASS and ALFALFA (40%) HIMF
• Based on Millennium and C- method
HIPASSALFALFA • At high HI
masses HIPASS and ALFALFA are equally accurate
![Page 31: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Ignored…
• Peculiar motions
• Noise bias
• Confusion
• Inclination bias
• Eddington effect
• HI self-absorption
![Page 32: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
HIMFs from next generation HI surveys
• Use the C- method
• Robust against LSS
• Works with ‘soft’ completeness limits
• Fast
![Page 33: Challenges in calculating galaxy space densities from HI ... · The 1/Vmax method • The ‘classical’ Schmidt (1968) method • Calculate maximum distance D max out to which the](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040603/5ea149a0db5f6849f9357ee2/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)