Challenges facing computing teachers in Guyana - Raspberry Pi · Networking 1 1 1 0 3 Pseudocode...

1
Challenges facing computing teachers in Guyana Sue Sentance, King’s College London Lenandlar Singh, University of Guyana Penelope De Freitas, University of Guyana KEY MESSAGES Guyana is the only English-speaking South American country with a population of 750,000. Information Technology is taught in most secondary schools using a national syllabus, and then can be taken as an elective, including problem solving, algorithms and programming, hardware devices, as well as the use of applications software. Computer Science can be taken at advanced level. We carried out a small-scale mixed-methods study with 48 teachers in two areas of Guyana, which accompanied a workshop covering a range of interactive activities. Data from teachers included free text writing about their experiences, a short survey, and focus group notes. Teachers reported that they found programming hard to learn and teach, and hardware devices easy to learn and teach. Teachers reported a keen interest in the teaching of Information Technology and a desire to improve the opportunities for their students but they described a range of challenges including: lack of computers; lack of subject knowledge; and lack of support. THE STUDY FINDINGS (CONTD) Facilitators made written notes noting key points raised by teachers in the focus groups. These were coded by the researchers and summarised under themes. Through focus groups, teachers articulated a need for teacher training, support and more resources to support teaching and to engage students. Teachers' confidence was not as much of an issue as expected. However, where confidence was described as an issue it was around programming. See Table 3 for key themes emerging and their frequencies. DATA COLLECTION The study was designed around a workshop, with data collected before and after the workshop. Three separate instruments/ approaches were used: 1. An initial writing task about experience of teaching 2. A post-workshop exercise on challenges and opportunities in teaching IT and related subjects 3. A set of focus groups with workshop facilitators to allow exploration of the topics raised in the second exercise The initial task was sufficiently open for teachers to be able to describe their experience. They were also asked about their experience of the curriculum and what they found easy/hard to learn and easy/hard to teach. After the workshop, teachers were asked to reflect by selecting three statements from a set of 7 provided and using these to reflect on the challenges and opportunities of being a computing teacher. We held small focus groups where the choices made in the second task were explored with the facilitators. The intention of all activities was to be useful as reflection for the teachers, In addition to providing data for analysis. Ethical guidelines from King’s College London were adhered to and appropriate permissions were obtained from all participants. WHAT’S NEXT? These workshops were facilitated by the second and third authors and supported by the Regional Education Office for Berbice. These workshops introduced teachers to the Python programming language and to pedagogical approaches to teaching programming. Programming in Python was requested by the teachers as they are now preparing to deliver the new CSEC IT syllabus which will allow them to teach Python as well as Pascal. Guyana – key facts CONCLUSIONS There is now a need to educate young people in a range of skills that will help them to participate in and drive forward an increasingly technology-driven world. This brings with it many challenges, which are particularly apparent in countries that are classified as having developing economies. This poster describes the first study relating to computing education in Guyana. We found that professional development opportunities and resources for the teaching of computing are emerging more slowly in Guyana than in other countries reported on in the literature. From our conversations with teachers in Guyana, we suggest that we need to hear the voices of teachers all around the world. We conclude that more research is needed to establish the best use of resources to support computing as a truly global subject. FINDINGS In March 2018 we designed an intervention for teachers of IT and Computing in two areas of Guyana: Berbice and Georgetown. The intervention took the form of an all-day workshop for teachers of ICT and Computing in the area. 47 teachers participated in the workshop, although we only have a full set of data from 42 teachers. Teachers in the study all taught Information Technology and ranged from trainee teachers to those with more than 20 years' experience. Teachers had a range of experience and taught on the following courses: Information Technology, Computer Science, Electronic Document Preparation and Management, Mathematics. The session that the teachers participated in included a session on unplugged approaches to learning computer science concepts, physical computing with the micro:bit, and approaches to programming pedagogy. Help needed (theme) Num Curriculum 7 Resources 6 Pedagogy 6 Teacher training 6 Support 5 Knowledge 5 Students 5 Motivation 5 Enjoyments 4 Class activities 4 Confidence 3 Qualifications 3 Workshops 2 Capital: Georgetown Official language: English Currency: Guyanese dollar Population: 777,000 Famous for waterfalls and gold mines! 70% of Guyana uninhabited. ... “I enjoy teaching about the contents of the curriculum since a lot of concepts are involved in the practical aspect. It brings out students involvement on the content also … though I am excited to teach the topics as a teacher I am very disappointed in the lack of resource that public schools are given. This also motivates me to try different approaches in order to overcome the lack of resources” (Teacher 13). [email protected] [email protected] uk Penelope. [email protected] Topics Easy to teach Easy to learn Hard to teach Hard to learn Total refs Computer architecture 20 12 1 0 33 Programming 2 0 15 10 27 Software applications 10 4 3 3 20 Spreadsheets 3 1 7 2 13 Binary numbers 2 1 6 2 11 Input and output devices 7 3 0 0 10 Databases 0 0 6 3 9 Word processing 5 3 0 0 8 Information processing 2 0 2 0 4 Problem solving 0 0 1 2 3 Networking 1 1 1 0 3 Pseudocode and flowcharts 1 0 1 0 2 Computers in society 2 0 0 0 2 File Management 0 0 1 1 2 Ethics 0 0 1 0 1 Presentation software 0 0 1 0 1 Teacher working with a micro:bit The workshop included both cup robotics algorithmic-thinking activities and physical computing Table 1: Summary of responses from teachers to the first task Teachers were asked what topics they found easy or hard to teach and which students found easy or difficult to teach. The free-text task elicited a range a range of topics across information technology and computer science. The majority of teachers reported that programming was hard to teach and hard to learn, whereas the teaching and learning of computer architecture was thought to be easy (see Table 1). In a questionnaire, 94% teachers said they would like to improve their subject knowledge in IT and Computing. 63% said they would like more support in teaching the topics in the curriculum and 58% said that students are not always engaged in the subject matter. Only 15% said that they lacked confidence in what they were teaching (see Table 2). Statement % teachers I would like to improve my subject knowledge in IT and Computing 94% I would like some more support in teaching the topics in the curriculum 63% Students are not always engaged in the subject matter 58% I enjoy teaching the topics in the curriculum 42% Students are very engaged in the way that I teach and the subject matter 25% I would like to teach different topics than those in the curriculum 23% I don’t have a lot of confidence in teaching the topics in the curriculum 15% Since these two workshops, two additional workshops specifically focusing on Python programming and methods of teaching programming were conducted in January 2019 with the same group of teachers from Berbice. Table 3: What teachers are looking for (from focus groups) Table 2: Statements agreed with (choose maximum of 3)

Transcript of Challenges facing computing teachers in Guyana - Raspberry Pi · Networking 1 1 1 0 3 Pseudocode...

Page 1: Challenges facing computing teachers in Guyana - Raspberry Pi · Networking 1 1 1 0 3 Pseudocode and flowcharts 1 0 1 0 2 Computers in society 2 0 0 0 2 File Management 0 0 1 1 2

Printing:This poster is 48” wide by 36” high. It’s designed to be printed on a large

Customizing the Content:The placeholders in this formatted for you. placeholders to add text, or click an icon to add a table, chart, SmartArt graphic, picture or multimedia file.

Ttext, just click the Bullets button on the Home tab.

If you need more placeholders for titles, make a copy of what you need and drag it into place. PowerPoint’s Smart Guides will help you align it with everything else.

Want to use your own pictures instead of ours? No problem! Just rightChange Picture. Maintain the proportion of pictures as you resize by dragging a corner.

Challenges facing computing teachers

in GuyanaSue Sentance, King’s College LondonLenandlar Singh, University of GuyanaPenelope De Freitas, University of Guyana

KEY MESSAGES

• Guyana is the only English-speaking South American country with a population of

750,000.

• Information Technology is taught in most secondary schools using a national syllabus,

and then can be taken as an elective, including problem solving, algorithms and

programming, hardware devices, as well as the use of applications software. Computer

Science can be taken at advanced level.

• We carried out a small-scale mixed-methods study with 48 teachers in two areas of

Guyana, which accompanied a workshop covering a range of interactive activities.

• Data from teachers included free text writing about their experiences, a short survey,

and focus group notes. Teachers reported that they found programming hard to learn

and teach, and hardware devices easy to learn and teach.

• Teachers reported a keen interest in the teaching of Information Technology and a desire

to improve the opportunities for their students but they described a range of challenges

including: lack of computers; lack of subject knowledge; and lack of support.

THE STUDY

FINDINGS (CONTD)

Facilitators made written notes noting key points raised byteachers in the focus groups. These were coded by theresearchers and summarised under themes. Through focusgroups, teachers articulated a need for teacher training,support and more resources to support teaching and toengage students.

Teachers' confidence was not as much of an issue asexpected. However, where confidence was described as anissue it was around programming. See Table 3 for keythemes emerging and their frequencies.

DATA COLLECTION

The study was designed around a workshop, with data collectedbefore and after the workshop. Three separate instruments/approaches were used:

1. An initial writing task about experience of teaching

2. A post-workshop exercise on challenges and opportunities in

teaching IT and related subjects

3. A set of focus groups with workshop facilitators to allow

exploration of the topics raised in the second exercise

The initial task was sufficiently open for teachers to be able todescribe their experience. They were also asked about theirexperience of the curriculum and what they found easy/hard tolearn and easy/hard to teach.

After the workshop, teachers were asked to reflect by selectingthree statements from a set of 7 provided and using these to reflecton the challenges and opportunities of being a computing teacher.

We held small focus groups where the choices made in the secondtask were explored with the facilitators. The intention of allactivities was to be useful as reflection for the teachers, In additionto providing data for analysis. Ethical guidelines from King’s CollegeLondon were adhered to and appropriate permissions wereobtained from all participants.

WHAT’S NEXT?

These workshops were facilitated by the second and third authorsand supported by the Regional Education Office for Berbice.These workshops introduced teachers to the Python programminglanguage and to pedagogical approaches to teachingprogramming. Programming in Python was requested by theteachers as they are now preparing to deliver the new CSEC ITsyllabus which will allow them to teach Python as well as Pascal.

Guyana – key facts

CONCLUSIONS

There is now a need to educate young people in a range of skills

that will help them to participate in and drive forward an

increasingly technology-driven world. This brings with it many

challenges, which are particularly apparent in countries that are

classified as having developing economies.

This poster describes the first study relating to computingeducation in Guyana. We found that professional developmentopportunities and resources for the teaching of computing areemerging more slowly in Guyana than in other countriesreported on in the literature. From our conversations withteachers in Guyana, we suggest that we need to hear the voicesof teachers all around the world. We conclude that moreresearch is needed to establish the best use of resources tosupport computing as a truly global subject.

FINDINGS

• In March 2018 we designed an intervention for teachers of ITand Computing in two areas of Guyana: Berbice andGeorgetown. The intervention took the form of an all-dayworkshop for teachers of ICT and Computing in the area.

• 47 teachers participated in the workshop, although we onlyhave a full set of data from 42 teachers. Teachers in the studyall taught Information Technology and ranged from traineeteachers to those with more than 20 years' experience.Teachers had a range of experience and taught on thefollowing courses: Information Technology, Computer Science,Electronic Document Preparation and Management,Mathematics.

• The session that the teachers participated in included asession on unplugged approaches to learning computerscience concepts, physical computing with the micro:bit, andapproaches to programming pedagogy.

Help needed (theme) Num

Curriculum 7

Resources 6

Pedagogy 6

Teacher training 6

Support 5

Knowledge 5

Students 5

Motivation 5

Enjoyments 4

Class activities 4

Confidence 3

Qualifications 3

Workshops 2

Capital: GeorgetownOfficial language: EnglishCurrency: Guyanese dollarPopulation: 777,000Famous for waterfalls and gold mines!70% of Guyana uninhabited. ...

“I enjoy teaching about the contents of the curriculum since a lot of concepts are involved in the practical aspect. It brings out students involvement on the content also … though I am excited to teach the topics as a teacher I am very disappointed in the lack of resource that public schools are given. This also motivates me to try different approaches in order to overcome the lack of resources” (Teacher 13).

[email protected] [email protected] uk [email protected]

Topics Easy to

teach

Easy to

learn

Hard to

teach

Hard to

learn

Total refs

Computer architecture 20 12 1 0 33Programming 2 0 15 10 27Software applications 10 4 3 3 20Spreadsheets 3 1 7 2 13Binary numbers 2 1 6 2 11Input and output devices 7 3 0 0 10Databases 0 0 6 3 9Word processing 5 3 0 0 8Information processing 2 0 2 0 4Problem solving 0 0 1 2 3Networking 1 1 1 0 3Pseudocode and

flowcharts

1 0 1 0 2

Computers in society 2 0 0 0 2File Management 0 0 1 1 2Ethics 0 0 1 0 1Presentation software 0 0 1 0 1

Teacher working with a micro:bit

The workshop included both cup robotics algorithmic-thinking activities and physical computing

Table 1: Summary of responses from teachers to the first task

Teachers were asked what topics they found easy or hard toteach and which students found easy or difficult to teach.The free-text task elicited a range a range of topics acrossinformation technology and computer science. The majorityof teachers reported that programming was hard to teachand hard to learn, whereas the teaching and learning ofcomputer architecture was thought to be easy (see Table 1).

In a questionnaire, 94% teachers said they would like toimprove their subject knowledge in IT and Computing. 63%said they would like more support in teaching the topics inthe curriculum and 58% said that students are not alwaysengaged in the subject matter. Only 15% said that theylacked confidence in what they were teaching (see Table 2).

Statement % teachers

I would like to improve my subject knowledge in IT and Computing 94%

I would like some more support in teaching the topics in the curriculum 63%

Students are not always engaged in the subject matter 58%

I enjoy teaching the topics in the curriculum 42%

Students are very engaged in the way that I teach and the subject matter 25%

I would like to teach different topics than those in the curriculum 23%

I don’t have a lot of confidence in teaching the topics in the curriculum 15%

Since these two workshops, twoadditional workshops specificallyfocusing on Python programmingand methods of teachingprogramming were conducted inJanuary 2019 with the samegroup of teachers from Berbice.

Table 3: What teachers are looking for (from focus groups)

Table 2: Statements agreed with (choose maximum of 3)