CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A...

20
July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH, Berlin, Germany [email protected]

Transcript of CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A...

Page 1: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

July 11 -14, 2016

CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP

INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS

Jan HESSE

CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Berlin, Germany

[email protected]

Page 2: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Introduction

Numerical simulation results of a dry scroll vacuum

pump (DSVP) in comparison to measurements of Li et

al. (2010)

Applications of a DSVP

» In food industry for packing

technology or freeze-drying

» In metallurgy for degassing

of melt or inside a coating line

» In research vacuum technology

is used for electron microscopes

or mass spectrometer

July 11-14, 2016 2 Purdue Conferences

View into the working chamber of a DSVP

Page 3: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Introduction

DSVP is complex from the fluid dynamics view

» Orbiting scroll wrap relative to the fixed scroll wrap

time changing working chamber volume

» Small radial gaps between the wraps and axial gaps

between wraps and casing

» Compressible fluid

» Properties of the vacuum

have to be taken into account

July 11-14, 2016 3 Purdue Conferences

Page 4: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Geometry

The geometry is modelled as specified in (Yue et al.,

2015)

» In addition axial gaps are included (30 microns)

July 11-14, 2016 4 Purdue Conferences

Geometry of the scroll wraps (Yue et al., 2015) Simulation domain

Page 5: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Meshing

Chamber modelling

» Immersed solid

– Simple mesh generation (+)

– Many restrictions in solver modelling (-)

» Remeshing

– Automatic mesh generation (+)

– High number of elements and mesh (-)

quality issues

» Manual generation

– Best mesh and numerical quality (+)

– High manual effort (-)

July 11-14, 2016 5 Purdue Conferences

Page 6: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Meshing

Stator domain meshed with ANSYS Meshing

» Number of elements: 360 000

Rotor domain meshed with TwinMesh

» Number of elements: 1.6 Mio.

July 11-14, 2016 6 Purdue Conferences

Page 7: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Meshing

Animation of the mesh movement

July 11-14, 2016 7 Purdue Conferences

Page 8: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Setup

Commercial CFD solver ANSYS CFX

» Stator-rotor connection GGI (Generalized Grid Interface)

» Fluid: Air ideal gas

» Turbulence model: SST (Shear Stress Transport)

Inlet

» Absolute Pressure (17 kPa, 42 kPa, 95 kPa)

» Temperature (20°)

Outlet

» Absolute Pressure (95 kPa)

Rotational speed (1704 rpm)

July 11-14, 2016 8 Purdue Conferences

Inlet

Outlet

Page 9: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Setup

Time step

» Calculated from the rotational speed and the angle step

» Angle step is 1 degree

Flow regime

» Boundary condition set to no slip wall (Knudsen < 0.01)

Discretization

» Advection scheme: high resolution

» Transient scheme: second order backward Euler

Simulation wall clock time

» 1 day per rotation on 8 core computer (Intel(R) Xeon(R)

CPU E5-2637 v2)

July 11-14, 2016 9 Purdue Conferences

Page 10: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Results

Reference data

» Comparison between Yue’s CFD

and Li’s measurement results

July 11-14, 2016 10 Purdue Conferences

Working process (suction pressure 17kPa, 1704 rpm) (Yue et al., 2015)

Remarks:

1. Different outlet

pressure

2. Pressure offset in

working chamber

3. Angle shift in

pressure drop

location

4. Discontinuity in

pressure curve

1

2

3

4

Page 11: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Results

Our CFD results in comparison with Yue’s CFD results

» Same setup except the outlet pressure

July 11-14, 2016 11 Purdue Conferences

Comparison of our simulation results with the CFD results of Yue et al. (2015)

Page 12: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Results

Our CFD results in comparison with Li’s measurement

results

» Measurement data is shifted to get the correct pressure

drop position

July 11-14, 2016 12 Purdue Conferences

Comparison of our CFD results with measurements of Li et al. (2010, Vacuum 85)

Page 13: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Results

Our CFD results in comparison with Li’s measurement

results

» Change the post-processing method from measurement

point to measurement circle with a location away from

the wrap

July 11-14, 2016 13 Purdue Conferences

Nearly the same gradient

Page 14: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Results

Animation of the pressure on a slice plane

in the axial gap on discharge side

July 11-14, 2016 14 Purdue Conferences

Page 15: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Results

Cross-sectional view of the pressure, velocity and

temperature with suction pressure of 17 kPa and

rotational speed of 1704 rpm

July 11-14, 2016 15 Purdue Conferences

180°

360°

Pressure Velocity Temperature

Page 16: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Results

Comparison of theoretical approach of Li et al. (2010,

Vacuum 85) with our CFD results using a wall

temperature of 65°C and an adiabatic wall

» The effects of wall heat transfer have a strong influence

on the working process

July 11-14, 2016 16 Purdue Conferences

Temperature of 65°C Adiabatic

Page 17: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Simulation Results

Animation of the flow velocity

July 11-14, 2016 17 Purdue Conferences

Page 18: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Summary

Presentation includes CFD results of a dry scroll

vacuum pump calculated with ANSYS CFX

CFD results are compared with measurement data

and other CFD results

TwinMesh is used to realize the mesh movement

The CFD results are in good agreement with the

measurements

The effects of wall heat transfer have a strong

influence on the working process

July 11-14, 2016 18 Purdue Conferences

Page 19: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

Outlook

Perform CFD simulations with realistic temperature

boundary conditions or CHT solid.

Get more detailed measurement data and compare it

with CFD results

July 11-14, 2016 19 Purdue Conferences

Page 20: CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING ... · July 11 -14, 2016 CFD SIMULATION OF A DRY SCROLL VACUUM PUMP INCLUDING LEAKAGE FLOWS Jan HESSE CFX Berlin Software GmbH,

For More Information

Contact:

» CFX Berlin Software GmbH

» [email protected]

Live demonstration of TwinMesh in room STEW 313

» Tuesday, July 12th, 2016 – 4:00-6:00 pm

» Wednesday, July 13th, 2016 - 3:30-5:30 pm

– Exclusive demonstration of the TwinMesh software,

– Showing the fast & easy workflow,

– Explaining the benefit of this solution, and

– Answering your specific questions

July 11-14, 2016 20 Purdue Conferences