CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th...

21
CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION Scheduled for Hearing from 14 th Jan 2019 to 25 th January 2019 Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal Benches, All High Courts, & CAT, PB S No Case No. & Title Advocate & Division Case summary Action Due and Compliance by CPCB SUPREME COURT OF INDIA ( 12 Cases) 1. Writ Petition (Civil) No. 4677 of 1985 M.C. Mehta Vs Union of India & ors (Intially dealing techinical Division was WQM-I, presentaly UPC-I & UPC-II division is also dealing with this issue). Adv. Vijay Panjwani WQM-I (I/c Shri A. Sudhakar) The matter is relates to Pollution by industries in Delhi, presently Hon'ble Court dealing with the sealing issues in Delhi. Reply filed. Listed on 14.01.2019 2. Civil Appeal No. 10611 of 2018 The State Coordination Committee Of Coal Owners Miners Dealers Forum Vs All Dimasa Students Union, DIMA Hasao District Committee & Ors .(CPCB is R. 06) Adv. Aruna Mathur IPC-II (Sh. Nazim) The matter related to appeal preferred against banning of coal mines. Reply to be filed. (Observation of division handed over to Adv.) Listed on 15.01.2019

Transcript of CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th...

Page 1: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD

LAW DIVISION

Scheduled for Hearing from 14th Jan 2019 to 25th January 2019 Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal Benches, All High

Courts, & CAT, PB

S No

Case No. & Title Advocate & Division

Case summary Action Due and Compliance by

CPCB

SUPREME COURT OF INDIA ( 12 Cases)

1. Writ Petition (Civil) No. 4677 of 1985 M.C. Mehta Vs Union of India & ors (Intially dealing techinical Division was WQM-I, presentaly UPC-I & UPC-II division is also dealing with this issue).

Adv. Vijay Panjwani WQM-I

(I/c Shri A. Sudhakar)

The matter is relates to Pollution by industries in Delhi, presently Hon'ble Court dealing with the sealing issues in Delhi.

Reply filed. Listed on 14.01.2019

2. Civil Appeal No. 10611 of 2018 The State Coordination Committee Of Coal Owners Miners Dealers Forum Vs All Dimasa Students Union, DIMA Hasao District Committee & Ors .(CPCB is R. 06)

Adv. Aruna Mathur IPC-II

(Sh. Nazim)

The matter related to appeal preferred against banning of coal mines.

Reply to be filed. (Observation of division handed over to Adv.) Listed on 15.01.2019

Page 2: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

3. Civil Appeal No. 10907 of 2018 Garo Hills Autonomous District Council Vs All Dimasa Students Union, DIMA Hasao District Committee & Ors .(CPCB is R. 06)

Adv. Aruna Mathur IPC-II

(Sh. Nazim

The matter related to appeal preferred against banning of coal mines.

Reply to be filed. (Observation of division handed over to Adv.) Listed on 15.01.2019

4. Civil Appeal No. 10720 of 2018 The State Of Meghalaya Vs All DIMASA Students Union Hasao District Committee & Ors.(CPCB is R. 05)

Adv. Aruna Mathur IPC-II

(Sh. Nazim

The matter related to appeal preferred against banning of coal mines.

Reply to be filed. (Observation of division handed over to Adv.) Listed on 15.01.2019

5. CIVIL Appeal No. 9154 of 2018 (Poultary Farmers and Breeders Association & Anrs Vs. Gauri Maulekhi & others.)

Adv. Aruna Mathur IPC-V

(I/c Shri D.S. Kharat)

This Civil Appeal is related to the guideline issued by Central Pollution Control Board, dated 20 the October 2015 for Poultry farms.

Reply filed. Listed on 16.01.2019

6. Civil Appeal No. 8560 of 2018 (Birendra Singh Vs. Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MOEF) and Others.

Adv. Aruna Mathur UPC-I

(I/c Sh. N.K. Gupta)

This Civil Appeal relates to the ongoing construction of an expensive resort and villa township in a deemed forest area in the Nainital,Uttrakhand.

Reply filed. Listed on 16.01.2019

7. Civil Appeal No. 11929 of 2018 (Volkswagen India Private Limited & Ors. Vs Saloni Aailawadi & Ors.)

Adv. Vijay Panjwani

AQM (I/c Sh. V.K.

Shukla)

Related to cheat devices installed in the Diesel cars by the manufacturers

Reply under process. Listed on 21.01.2019

Page 3: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

8. CIVIL APPEAL No. 11928 of 2018 (Volkswagen India Private Limited & Ors. Vs. Satwinderjeet Singh Sodhi & Ors.)

Adv. Vijay Panjwani

AQM (I/c Sh. V.K.

Shukla)

Related to cheat devices installed in the Diesel cars by the manufacturers

Reply under process. Listed on 21.01.2019

9. Writ petition (C) No.657 of 1995 with SLP(C) No.16175 of 1995 and CA No.7660 of 1995 Research Foundation Vs Union of India & ors

Adv. Sh. Vijay Panjwani

WM-I (I/c Sh. B.

Vinoda Babu)

Related to Disposal of Toxic Waste. +(Taged) Regarding Import of hazardous Waste

Reply filed. Listed on 21.01.2019

10. Writ Petition No. 728 of 2015 Arjun Gopal Vs U.O.I & Ors.

Adv. Vijay Panjwani

AQM (I/c Sh. V.K.

Shukla)

it pertain to ban the use of fire crakers.

Reply filed. Listed on 21.01.2019

11. W. P. (C) No- 899 of 2016 (Anirudh Suri Vs UoI) connected with W. P. (C) No 213 of 2017 Vasundhra Trivedi Broota Vs UoI

Adv. Vijay Panjwani

AQM (I/c Sh. V.K.

Shukla)

it pertain to ban the use of fire crakers.

Reply filed. Listed on 21.01.2019

12. Writ Petition (C) 895 of 2016, Indian Medical Association Vs. Union of India & Ors. Regarding air pollution in Delhi & NCR. Respondent No. 6.

Adv. Vijay Panjwani

AQM (I/c Sh. V.K.

Shukla)

it pertain to ban the use of fire crakers.

Reply filed. Listed on 21.01.2019

NGT, Principal Bench, New Delhi ( 42 Cases)

13. OA No. 183/2018 Subhash v. MoEF & Ors.

UPC- I (I/c Shri. N.K.

Gupta)

Related to illegal flyover in Baghpat District, U.P. CPCB is not party respondent.

Inspection report has been filed. Listed on 14.01.2019

Page 4: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

14. OA No.481/2017 Bharat BhushanMalviyaVs UOI & Ors

Adv. Satish Kumar UPC- I

(I/c Shri. N.K. Gupta)

This matter is related to cutting of trees, village of ThariDulampur P.S. Kunda District Deogarh Jharkhand subject matter does not lie in the jurisdiction of CPCB.

Reply/Report filed. Listed on 14.01.2019

15. OA No. 646/2018 Ram Ji Vyas vs UOI. .CPCB is not the party.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-II (I/c Shri.

Nazimuddin)

Related to illegal mining in Jodhpur.

Court Commissioner report has been filed. Listed on 14.01.2019

16. OA No. 161/2018 Jagan Nath Huria &Anr. Vs. Union of India & Ors.

Adv. Sharmila Upadhyay

IPC- III (I/c Shri P.K.

Mishra)

Related to illegal textile industry factory in residential area.

CPCB reply filed 09.05.2018. Inspection report has been filed. Listed on 15.01.2019

17. OA No. 187/2017 Ridhima Pandey Vs. UOI & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

UPC-I (I/c Shri. N.K.

Gupta)

Related to adverse impact of climate change.

CPCB reply already filed. Listed on 15.01.2019

18. EX. Ap. 18/2017 In OA No. 16/2014 Sh. Hazi Arif Vs. State of U.P. & Ors.

UPC-I (I/c Shri N.K.

Gupta)

Related to constructions at Sahibabad District Ghaziabad.

Ready to be filed. Listed on 15.01.2019

19. Appeal No.18/2018 IVL Dhunseri Petrochem Industries Pvt. Ltd. Vs. CPCB & Ors.

Adv. Shlok Chandra WQM-II

(Shri A.K. Vidyarthi)

Related to Quashing of closure direction given by CPCB dated 23/29.01.2018 U/S E (P) Act, 1986.

CPCB Reply filed on 15.03.2018. CPCB Inspection report filed on 21.03.2018 Joint inspection report filed on 19.05.2018. Appellant has to file objections to joint inspection report. Report has been filed. Listed on 15.01.2019.

Page 5: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

20. OA No. 324/2015 Jubair &Ors. Vs. State of UP &Ors. (Clubbed with 85/2016 Irfan Aleem vs. Meem Agro Foods Pvt. Ltd. &Ors.)

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-IV (I/C Shri NK

Gupta)

Related to Slaughter House in Kairana, District Shamli.

Re- Inspection report of CPCB & UPPCB has been filed on 21.07.2018 CPCB has been impleaded as a party on 05.12.2018. Listed on 15.01.2019

21. OA No.621/2018 Mahendra Pandey v. Union of India & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar WM-I

(I/c Sh. B. Vinod Babu)

Related to removal of waste on the banks of River Ramganga. 16.10.2018

SOP prepared by CPCB filed on 11.01.2019 by email. Listed on 16.01.2019

22. OA No.111/2018 Kachchh Camel Breeders Association Vs. UOI &Ors.

UPC-I (I/c Shri N.K.

Gupta) CPCB is not the

party

Copy of OA not received. . Related to construction and other activity going on which is leading to destruction of mangroves.

Joint Inspection of CPCB & GSPCB filed on 27.04.2018 Listed on 16.01.2019

23. OA No.509/2015 Saloni Ailawadi Vs UOI & Ors

Adv. Rajkumar AQM

(I/c Sh. V.K. Shukla)

Related to cheat devices installed in the Diesel cars by the manufacturers.

Report filed on 24.12.2018 by email. Listed on 16.01.2019

24. OA NO. 527/2015 Satwinder Singh Sodhi Vs. Volkswagan (I) Pvt. Ltd. & ors

Adv. Rajkumar AQM

(I/c Sh. V.K. Shukla)

Related to cheat devices installed in the Diesel cars by the manufacturers.

Report filed on 24.12.2018 by email. Listed on 16.01.2019

25. O.A. No. 651/2017 Ummed Ali &Anr. Vs. M/s International Agro Foods &Ors.

Adv. Sharmila Upadhyay

IPC-IV (I/c Shri N.K.

Gupta)

Related to illegal slaughter houses in UP.

Reply is filed on 10.01.2018. Listed on 17.01.2019

26. OA NO.105/2018 Indian Council for Enviro Legal Action Vs. MoEF& CC &Ors.

Adv. Sharmila Upadhyay

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

Related to Brick kilns situated in Dish Palghar and thane, Maharashtra.

CPCB reply filed on 04.04.2018. Listed on 17.01.2019

Page 6: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

27. OA NO.324/2016 Shailesh Singh Vs. State of UP &Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-III (I/c Shri P.K.

Mishra)

Related to groundwater extraction by distillery unit of Radico Khaitan, Rampur, U. P.

Joint Inspection report is ready to be filed. Listed on 17.01.2019

28. OA No. 154/2018 Society for Protection of Environment and Biodiversity Vs. UOI &Ors.

Adv. Shlok Chandra

IPC-V(SSI) (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

Related to stone crusher units in and around district Banda and Mahoba in UP.

CPCB reply filed on 28.05.2018 Listed on 17.01.2019

29. Ex. App. 48/2018 OA No. 606/2018 Compliance of Municipal solid Waste Management Rules, 2016

UPC-II (I/c Shri. S.K.

Nigam)

Related to implementation of Municipal Solid Waste Management Rules, 2016.

Listed on 17.01.2019

30. OA No. 24/2018 Shailesh Singh Vs. State of UP &Ors.

Adv. BalenduShekha

r WQM-II

(I/c Shri A.K. Vidhyarti)

Related to the condition of River Gomti which has become polluted due to poor drainage system and severe water logging in the capital of U.P.

CPCB reply already filed on 8.03.2018. Listed on 17.01.2019

31. OA No. No. 436 of 2018 Rashtriya Manvadhikar Sanrakshan Parishad Vs. Union of India & Ors.

Adv. Balendu Shekhar

IPC-II (I/c Shri

Nazimuddin)

Related to mining of minor mineral in Dist-Mahendergarh, Haryana.

CPCB reply has been filed. Listed On 17.01.2019

32. OA No. 820/2017 Mustafa Hussain vs. MoEF & CC

NA CPCB is not respondent. (only for Joint Inspection)

Joint Inspection done, Report will be filed by MoEF & CC. Listed on 17.01.2019

33. OA No,328/2018 Shailesh Singh Vs State of UP &Ors

Adv. Shlok

Chandra IPC-II

(I/c Shri. Nazimuddin)

Related to Steel plants. CPCB reply filed. Clubbed with OA No. 1084/2018 Listed on 17.01.2019

34. OA No.1084 /2018 Shailesh Singh Vs State of UP &Ors

Fresh matter Fresh matter Listed on 17.01.2019

Page 7: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

35. OA No.361/2017 Court on its own motion vs. Ministry of Environment & Forests & Climate Change & ors.

Adv. Rajkumar WQM-II

(I/c Shri. A. K. Vidhyarti)

Copy of OA not received. CPCB has been impleaded as the party by the direction of the court.

Inspection report/Reply has been filed. Listed on 18.01.2019

36. Execution Application No. 09 of 2016 In Original Application No. 177/2013 Sushil Raghav Vs. State of U.P. &Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

WQM-I (I/c Shri A. Sudhakar)

Related to discharge of untreated sewage & industrial effluent in Sahibabad drain in Eastern Yamuna canal ultimately polluting River Yamuna.

CPCB reply already filed Listed on 18.01.2019

37. OA NO.145/2015 Umashankar Patwa & Anr. vs Union of India &Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar WQM-I

(I/c Shri A. Sudhakar)

Related to STP in Agra.

CPCB already filed reply. Listed on 18.01.2019

38. OA NO. 418/2015 Ferozpur Welfare Society (Regd.) Vs. State of Haryana &Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

Unauthorized polluting industries setup in the agricultural land, causing damage to the crops, drains water by hazardous chemicals waste.

CPCB reply already filed on 15.12.2015. Listed on 18.01.2019

39. OA NO.613/2016 Ram Niwas Goel vs Commissioner, East Delhi Municipal Corporation.

Adv. Satish Kumar UPC-II

Dr. S.K. Nigam

Related to noise pollution & MSW Copy received on 02.07.2018

CPCB reply already filed Listed on 18.01.2019

40. Original Application No. 32(THC)/2014 Kishan Paryavaran Sangaharsh Samiti, Jaipur Vs. State of Rajasthan & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar IPC-VII

(I/c Ajay Aggarwal)

Matter related with proper functioning and pollution created by CETPs in Pali, Rajasthan.

Report filed Listed on 18.01.2019

41. OA No. 427/2018 Manikesh Chaturvedi v. International Society of Krishna Consciousness (ISKON) & Anr.

Adv. Sharmila Upadhyay

UPC-I (I/c Sh. N. K.

Gupta)

Related to halt construction of Chandrodaya Mandir to protect the river bed of Yamuna.

Report filed by CPCB by email on 24.12.2018 Listed on 18.01.2019

Page 8: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

42. Original Application No. 608/2018 Prafulla Samantra Vs. Union of India & Ors.

Adv. Sharmila Upadhyay

IPC- II (I/c Sh. Nazim)

Fresh Matter Reply under process. Listed on 21.01.2019

43. OA No.212/2018 Ajay Dubey Vs Union of India & Ors.

Adv. Satish Kumar IPC-II

(I/c Shri. Nazimuddin)

Fresh Matter Court directed applicant to rectify the name of respondent No.2

CPCB reply filed. Listed on 21.01.2019

44. OA No.326/2018 Shailesh Singh vs. State of UP & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-IV (I/c Shri. N. K.

Gupta)

Related to slaughter house in UP.

CPCB reply has been filed. Listed on 21.01.2019

45. OA No.718/2017 Anil Kumar Vs. Union of India & Ors.

Adv. Shlok

Chandra IPC-V

(I/c Shri D.S. Kharat)

Related to Brick Kilns in Haryana, UP and Uttarakhand.

CPCB reply filed on 16.02.2018. Listed on 22.01.2019

46. MA No.1126/2017 in OA No.35/2014 Bhanwara Ram Mirdha Vs. State of Rajasthan &ors

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC -V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

CPCB is not the party. Related to stone crusher. Tribunal gives some directions to the authority who inspected stone crushers in January 2017 to present reports and documents before the Hon’ble Tribunal.

Joint inspection report filed by CPCB. Listed on 22.01.2019

47. OA No.47/2018 Shailesh Singh vs. Environment Pollution (Prevention & Control) Authority (E.P.C.A) & ors.

Adv. Sharmila Upadhyay

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat) For EPCA

IPC-IV (I/c Shri N.K.

Gupta)

Related to the worst air quality index because of heavy emission from the industries and unorganized sectors like Brick Kilns located in Delhi NCR.

Reply on behalf of EPCA already filed on 14.03.2018. CPCB reply filed on 04.04.2018 Listed on 22.01.2019

Page 9: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

48. OA NO.15/2014 Him JagritiUttanchal Welfare Society vs. U.O.I.&ors.

Adv. Alpana Poddar UPC-II

(I/c Shri S.K. Nigam)

Related to plastic waste management.

Reply Filed. The Hon’ble Tribunal directed that Respondents may file brief notes of their case. Listed on 22.01.2019

49. OA No. 681/2017 Gauri Maulekhi Vs Union of India &Ors.

Adv. Sharmila Upadhaya IPC-V(SSI)

(I/c Shri D.S. Kharat)

Related to indiscriminate disposal of waste and distribution and administration of antibiotics by the poultry farms.

CPCB reply already filed on 10.01.2018. No Direction for CPCB. Listed on 22.01.2019

50. OA No.824/2017 Dharam Singh &ors. Vs. Venco Research

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

Related to the establishment of new poultry farm by Venco Research R-1 in the residential area in village Rampur, U.P.

Reply filed on 16.02.2018. Listed on 22.01.2019

51. OA No. 81/2018 Raghunath Singh Vs. UOI&Ors.

Adv. BalenduShekha

r IPC-I (I/c

ShriGurnam Singh)

Related to the Air, Noise and Water pollution caused by the illegal discharge of toxic chemical waste by color paint industries in the village of Chirhada, Haryana.

CPCB report filed on 31.10.2018 Listed on 24.01.2019

52. OA No.102/2018 Nagavelli Rajalingamurth VS. Singareni Collieries Company Ltd. &ors.

Adv. Balendu Shekhar

IPC-II (I/c Shri

Nazimuddin)

Related to coal mining in Bhupalpally District of Telangana.

CPCB reply filed on 12.04.2018 Listed on 24.01.2019

53. OA NO. 521/2016 Hotel & Restaurant Association of Uttaranchal Vs. MoEF & Ors.

Adv. Rajkumar

IPC-III (I/c Shri P.K.

Mishra)

Categorization of Hotels, Dharamshalas and Guest houses in red, orange, green, white.

CPCB reply already filed 04.01.2017 Listed on 24.01.2019

Page 10: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

54. Appeal No. 112/2018 University of Delhi Vs. MoEF& CC &Ors.

Adv. Balendu Shekhar UPC-I

(I/c Shri. N.K. Gupta)

Related to construction of multi-storied apartment in north campus area. Copy of M.A not received.

CPCB reply filed. Listed on 24.01.2019

Delhi High Court (02 Cases)

55. WP(C) 1346/2015 & 2115/ 2015 Court on its own Motion (air pollution in Delhi) Vs. Union of India & Sudhir Mishra Vs. Ministry of Health & Family Welfare & Ors. (regarding Air Pollution)

Adv. Saqib AQM-I

(Shri V.K. Shukla)

Related to Air Pollution in Delhi NCR Region.

No compliance for CPCB. Hon’ble Court directed to State of Haryana, Uttar Pradesh & Punjab to submit status report on Stubble Burning. Listed on 22.11.2018

56. W.P. No.12054/2015 Nain Singh vs UOI & ANR.

Adv. Saqib DH-AO(P)

Shri R.D. Pandey

Related to balance of arrears. WP is filed against Hon’ble CAT order challenged by Shri Nain Singh. Itcomes under regular senior citizen category list of Hon’ble Court. CPCB received early hearing application on 13.12.2018. Comments of CPCB including Statement of payments demanded and released to Shri Nain Singh has been sent to CPCB’s Advocate on 02.01.2019.

Reply filed. Likely to be listed on 17.01.2019.

NGT WESTERN BENCH, PUNE ( 13 CASES)

Page 11: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

57. Appeal No 82 of 2017(WZ) (M/s.Manisha Construction Co. vs MPCB & ors. CPCB is respondent no. 2.

Adv. Aniruddha Kulkarni

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

This is an appeal against the closure direction issued by MPCB. The matter is related to Stone Crushing activities, which are located out skirts of Pune city.

Reply Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

58. Application 128/2017(WZ) Kanabhai Sevra & Ors. V/s The CPCB & Ors.

Adv.Rahul Andhale IPC-III

(I/c Shri.P.K. Mishra)

Pollution due to Respondent No.8 (Industry Junagadh District, Gujarat), groundwater pollution, affecting soil fertility, productivity etc.

Reply Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

59. Application No.114/2015 Protection of Environment & Public Service Committee Vs Indian Rayon & Ors

Adv.Rahul Andhale

IPC-I (I/c

Shri.Gurnam Singh)

Pollution due M/s Indian rayon & EC related issues

Reply Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

60. OA No.35/2018 Jijab Salunkhe & Anr. Vs Shree Bhimseshwari Ispat Pvt.Ltd.

Adv.Aniruddha Kulkarni

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

Related to air pollution caused by M/s Bhimeshwari Ispat Pvt.Ltd.

Reply Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

61. O. A. No. 182/2017 Patel Rameshbhai Laxmanbhai & 78 others v/s. State of Gujarat

Adv.Aniruddha Kulkarni

I/c R.D(Vadodara)

Paddy crop damage in the nearby farms and pollution issue from M/s Vraj Integrated Textile Park, Bidaj, Ta-Dist- Kheda.

Report Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

62. O.A. No 148 of 2017 Vanashakti Public trust Vs MPCB & Ors

Adv.Aniruddha Kulkarni IPC-VII

(I/c Shri.Ajay Aggarwal)

CETP’s issue in Dombivali and Ambernath Area.

Quaterly Report Filed. Listed on 15-01-2019

63. OA NO. 2/2017 Tarun Patel Vs MoEF & CC & Ors. Respondent No. 3

Adv.Rahul Andhale IPC-VII

(I/c Shri.Ajay Aggarwal

Regarding reassessment of MoEF & CC Notification dated 01st January, 2016 for removing scientific flaws and anomalies in achieving the objects of Environment Act 1986 and Water Act, 1974.

Reply Filed. Listed on 17-01-2019

Page 12: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

64. OA No. 99/2017, Tarun Patel Vs MoEF& CC & Ors

Adv.Rahul Andhale IPC-VII

(I/c Shri.Ajay Aggarwal

Related betterment of environment in the Coastal Sea shore area and connecting estuaries' from Tadgam beach to Tithal beach of Bulsar district along with the jampore and Devka beach of Daman.

Reply Filed. Listed on 17-01-2019

65. OA no. 77 of 2016 in OA no. 33 (THC) of 2013 (WZ) Janardan Chandar Patil Vs Union of India & ors

Adv. Shri Rahul

andhley (I/c IPC-VII

Sh. Ajay Aggarwal)

Related to CEPT Tarapur.

Action Plan & Subsequent Progress Report has been submitted Listed on 23.01.2019

66. Application No 197/2017 In Re Vanashakti&Anrs vs Municipal Corporation of Mumbai &Ors

Adv. Shri

Anniruddha Kulkarni

(I/c UPC-II Sh.S.K. Nigam)

This application is filed to stop sewage from entering the sea along with solid waste.

CPCB reply sent to RD on 04.07.2018 by mail. Listed on 23.01.2019

67. Execution Application 58/2016(WZ) M.A 48/2016 & M.A. 274/2016 In Application 68/2014 (WZ). Disposed 19-05-2015 Sh. Ashok Kajale & Ors vs M/s Godawari Bio Refineries & Ors.

Adv. Shri

Anniruddha Kulkarni IPC-III

(I/c P.K. Mishra)

Related to Pollution in Godawari river

CPCB has submitted first quarter progress report. CPCB has submitted progress report. Listed on 23.01.2019

68. O.A. 20/2017 Babubhai Ramubhai Saini Vs. GPCB & Ors. O.A. 42/2017 Babubhai Ramubhai Saini Vs. GPCB & Ors.

Adv. Shri

Anniruddha Kulkarni

IPC-V (I/c Dr. D.S.

Kharat)

Pollution and related issues of Gasifiers at Ceramic industries in Morbi-Wankaner Area, Gujarat..

Report filed Listed on 24.01.2019

Page 13: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

69. Original Application No. 70/2017 (WZ) Karim Shaikh V/s SahakarMahars hiShivajiraoNara yanraoNagawad eSahakariSakha rKarkhana Ltd. &Ors.

Adv. Shri

Anniruddha Kulkarni IPC-III

(I/c P.K. Mishra)

Pollution caused by Shrigonda SSK (distillery unit). CPCB is not the party respondent in this case.

Listed on 24.01.2019

NGT CENTRAL BENCH, BHOPAL ( 04 CASE)

70. OA no. 18/2017 (CH Institute of Management and Commerce & Anr. Vs State of M.P. & Ors.)

Adv Yadvendra Yadav IPC-III

(I/c Shri. P.K.Mishra)

Related to pollution due to poultry farm at and around the campus of complainant C.H. Institute of Management located near Indore.

Reply Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

71. 05 of 2018 Irfan Khan Vs. State of MP & Others

Adv Yadvendra Yadav WQM-I

(I/c Shri. A. Sudhakar)

Related to construction of illegal Rapta over River Pench at Chhindwara.

Reply Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

72. Application No. 34 of 2015 Nityanand Mishra Vs State of M.P.& Ors

Adv Yadvendra Yadav WQM-I

(I/c Shri. A. Sudhakar)

Related to pollution in river Paysuni & Saryu.

Reply Filed. Listed on 16-01-2019

73. Application No. 30 of 2018 CPCB Vs Madhya Bharat Phosphate

Adv Yadvendra Yadav

Related to noncompliance of directions

Listed on 17.01.2019

NGT EASTERN BENCH, KOLKATA ( 15 CASES)

74. OA No.70 of 2016 (EZ) Tribunal on its Motion Vs State of West Bengal & ors.

Adv. Surender Kumar UPC-I

(I/c Shri. N.K. Gupta)

Regarding dumping of Garbage at Rajiv Nagar North, 24-Pargaanas, West Bengal

Reply Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

75. O.A.No. 71/2017 & M.A. No. 347/2017/EZ, M.A. No. 31/2018/EZ Sh. Krishna Parua & Ors. Vs WBPCB & Ors.

Adv. Surendra kumar IPC-V

(I/c Shri D.S. Kharat)

Matter is related to Siting Policy.

Reply Filed. Listed on 14-01-2019

Page 14: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

76. OA No.43/2018(EZ) Ashish Thakur & Ors Vs UOI & Ors.

R.D(Kolkata) Related to coal mining activities i.e.Ramnagar Colliery in the process of which they have been cutting earth and blasting dynamites with 100 metres of residential areas.

Vide order dated 20.11.2018, NGT,PB through video conferencing constitute a joint team of Director General of Mines Safety, EZ, DM, Paschim Bardhaman West Bengal and CPCB to inspect the area in question within a period of two weeks from 20.11.2018. WBPCB shall be the nodal agency. Upon inspection, if it is found that the statements contained in the applications are factually correct, appropriate action may be taken for mitigation. Action taken report shall be filed by Committee within a period of one month from hence. Report be filed by email. Report put up for consideration on 14.01.2019.

77. O.A. No. 474/2018 (Earlier/ Origanally O.A. No. 30/2014/EZ) Joydeep Mukherjee Vs Chief Secretary of WB & Ors.

Adv. Surender Kumar WQM-I

(I/c Shri A. Sudhakar)

Related to installation of STP’s

Reply Filed. Through video conferencing Listed on 15-01-2019

Page 15: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

78. OA No.33/2014/EZ Subhash Dutta Vs State of WB & Ors

Adv. Surender Kumar AQM

(I/c V.K. Shukla)

Related to Air pollution in the cities of Kolkata and Howrah.

Reply Filed. Through video conferencing Listed on 15-01-2019

79. O.A. No. 172 of 2016 Sanjay Laloo Vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.

Adv. Surender Kumar WQM-I

(I/c Shri A. Sudhakar)

Related to severe disruption and degradation of the environment being done to the River Myndtu and its surrounding areas.

Reply Filed. Listed on 17-01-2019

80. O.A. No. 93/2017/EZ, Pending Before Hon'ble NGT, Kolkata in the matter of Greater Laban Community Development Society (GLCDS) VS State of Meghalaya & Ors.

Adv. Surender Kumar IPC-VII

(I/c Shri.Ajay Aggarwal)

Related to environment degradation due to C&D Activity.

Reply Filed. Listed on 17-01-2019

81. O.A. No. 24/2018/EZ (Ambarnath Sengupta Vs State of West Bengal & Ors.)

Adv. Surendra Kumar WQM-I

(I/c Shri A. Sudhakar)

Matter is related to water pollution due to immersion of idol.

No action is pending for the CPCB. Listed on 21.01.2019

82. OA 10/2016/EZ Joydeep Mukherjee Vs UOI & Ors

Adv. Surendra Kumar WQM-I

(I/c Shri A. Sudhakar)

In the matter of Pollution of R. Mahananda, R. Jorpani, R. Phuleswari.

Listed on 22.01.2019

83. O.A. no. 51/2016, Ambernath Sen Gupta vs State of West Bengal & Ors.

Adv. Surendra Kumar WQM-I

(I/c Shri A. Sudhakar)

Matter is related to Idol Immersion.

Listed on 22.01.2019

84. OA No.43/2018(EZ) Ashish Thakur & Ors Vs UOI & Ors.

Adv. Surendra Kumar IPC-II

(I/c Sh. Nazim)

Related to coal mining activities i.e.Ramnagar Colliery in the process of which they have been cutting earth and blasting dynamites with 100 metres iof residential areas.

Listed on 22.01.2019

Page 16: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

85. O.A No. 23/2017/EZ Syed Arshad Naskar Vs Union of India & amp; Ors. Respondent No. 10

Adv. Surendra Kumar IPC-VII

(I/c Sh.Ajay Aggarwal)

Illegal stone crusher units in Jharkhand Areas.

Reply field. Listed on 23.01.2019

86. OA 55 of 2017, Sh. Tako Olo Vs Union of India & Ors.

Shri Surendra Kumar UPC-II

(Sh. S.K. Nigam)

The present matter is pertaining to Highway Construction Work in the sate of Arunachal Pradesh

Reply field. Listed on 24.01.2019

87. O.A. No. 172/2017/EZ (Satya Narayan Samanta & Anr. Vs State of Odisha & Ors.)

Sri. Ashok Prasad IPC-II

(I/c Sh. Nazim)

The matter is related to Fly Ash dumping in the government forest land by M/s GMR Kamalanga Energy Ltd., Dhenkanal.

Reply filed, hearing postponed due to administrative reason. Listed on 24.01.2019

88. O.A. No. 110 of 2013/PB/85/2016/EZ & M.A. No. 97/2017/EZ Subhash Dutta vs. Union of India & Ors.

Adv Surender Kumar IPC-VII

(I/c Sh.Ajay Aggarwal)

Matter is related to Municipal Solid Waste & Discharge of Sewage. and monitoring health of the aquifer/ sweet water in Puri area.

Listed on 25.01.2019

Bombay High Court (05 Cases)

89. W.P. No. 3549 of 2018, Shri Laxmi Saw Mills & Ors Versus State of Maharashtra & Ors

Adv C.M. Lokeshappa

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

Petitioners are running their business of Saw Mills Dist. Kolhapur, Maharashtra

Counter Affidavit has been submitted on 12.04.2018 Listed on 14.01.2019

90. W.P. No. 3550 of 2018 Ashapura Saw Mills Versus State of Maharashtra

Adv C.M. Lokeshappa

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

Petitioners are running their business of Saw Mills Dist. Kolhapur, Maharashtra

Counter Affidavit has been submitted on 12.04.2018 Listed on 14.01.2019

91. W.P.No. 3548 of 2018 Hindustan Saw Mills & Ors. Versus State of Maharashtra & Ors

Adv C.M. Lokeshappa

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

Petitioners are running their business of Saw Mills Dist. Kolhapur, Maharashtra

Counter Affidavit has been submitted on 12.04.2018 Listed on 14.01.2019

Page 17: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

92. W.P.No. 3551 of 2018 Kolhapur Timber & Furniture Mart & Ors. Versus State of Maharashtra & Ors.

Adv C.M. Lokeshappa

IPC-V (I/c Shri D.S.

Kharat)

That the Petitioners are running their business of Saw Mills District- Kolhapur, Maharashtra

Listed on 14.01.2019

93. PIL No 106 of 2018 Sharad Baburao Patil Vs Union of India & ors.

Mr. C.M. Lokeshappa

IPC-III

(Sh. P.K. Mishra)

Related to breach of environmental norms by sugar industries located in District Kolhapur, Maharashtra.

Counter affidavit filed on 25.09.2018. Pre- admission Listed on 23.01.2019

NGT SOUTHERN BENCH, CHENNAI ( 08 CASES)

94. Appln. 191 of 2015 Sh. S.P. Muthuraman Vs UOI, New Delhi & 7 Ors Respondent No. 2

Adv. D. Ekambaram

WQM-I (I/c Shri.

A.Sudhakar)

Regarding pollution of Tambraparani River in Tamilnadu due to discharge of sewage waste and illegal dumping of municipal solid waste.

Reply Filed. Listed on 16-01-2019

95. OA 337 of 2018 (through video conference) K. Hiroji Rao Vs Union of India & Ors.

IPC-V(SSI) (I/c Shri.

D.S.Kharat)

Regarding joint inspection done with APPCB for 22 stone crusher units and related mining areas.

Report Filed. Hearing through video conference Listed on 16-01-2019

96. Appln. No 77 of 2016 Smt. Padma Kodali Vs Karnataka State Pollution Control Board & Ors. Respondent No. 4

Adv. D. Ekambaram

IPC- II (I/c Sh. Nazim)

Regarding pollution caused due to sponge iron industries, Bellary.

Reply filed. Listed on 21.01.2019

97. Appln No. 234 of 2017 Meena thanthai K R Selvaraj Kumar Meenavar Nala Sangam Vs The Director, MoEF&CC, New Delhi & 11 Ors CPCB is respondent No.3

Adv. D.S. Ekambaram (I/c IPC-IV Sh. N. K. Gupta)

Regarding Sea food industry is operating without any consent.

Listed on 22.01.2019

Page 18: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

98. Appln No. 214 of 2017 Meena thanthai K R Selvaraj Kumar Meenavar Nala Sangam Vs The Director, MoEF&CC, New Delhi & 9 Ors CPCB is Respondent No. 3

Adv. T N C Kaushik

(I/c IPC-VII Sh. Ajay

Aggarwal)

Regarding violation of EC conditions by M/s NCTPP, Thiruvallur.

Reply filed. Listed on 22.01.2019

99. Application No.256 of 2017 (SZ) Central Pollution Control Board Vs M/s. Shree Halasiddanath SSK Ltd and 19 ors

Adv. D.S. Ekumbaram

(I/c IPC-I Sh. Gurnam

Singh)

CPCB has filed the case against eight industries on violation of closure directions issued under E(P) Act, 1986

Listed on 23.01.2019

100. OA No.08/2018(SZ) Shahul Hameed Vs Puducherry Pollution Control Committee

UPC-I Sh. N.K. Gupta

Related to the emission of coal dust from coal yards operated by Koraikal Port Private Ltd.

Listed on 23.01.2019

101. O.A No. 335 OF 2018 Sri Vengapally Surender Rao Vs State of Telangana & Ors. CPCB is Respondent No. 12

Adv.P.Jayalakshmi

(I/c UPC-II Sh. S.K. Gupta)

Related to effects and health hazards on usage of Poly Vinyl Chloride(PVC)

Reply filed. Listed on 23.01.2019

Central Administrative Tribunal, PB, New Delhi (02 Cases)

Page 19: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

102. OA NO.1289/2016 MA NO.1281 of 2016 Vijay Ram Joshi vs Central Pollution Control Board (Respondent no.1 Chairman & respondent NO.2 Member Secretary)

Adv. Saqib DH-AO(P) Shri R.D. Pandey

Related to service matter (for quashing & set aside the compulsory retirement of Applicant, which was imposed by CPCB against Shri Vijay Ram Joshi, Assistant for keeping Govt. money with him for personal use/ gain for a long time during the period 2006-2008.

Reply filed. Listed on 14.01.2019

103. OA No.3007 of 2015 Suman Bala vs Moef & cc

Adv. Rajkumar DH- Sr. AO (R)

Shri Jugesh kumar

Related to promotion in PH quota. (service matter)

Reply filed. Listed on 17.01.2019

Munsiffs Court Kuthuparamba (District court Kannaur, Kerala) (01 Case)

104. OS 199/2017 CM Muhammad Ashraf vs PV Jayachandran

Adv Surendran Karattu

DH-(IPC-I) Shri Gurman

Singh

Related to liquid/ solid waste oily substance petrol & diesel from Petrol Pump

Listed on 16.01.2019.

Gurgaon civil court (01 Case)

105. CS

No.22116/2014

Col. Sarvdaman

Singh Oberoi vs

State of Haryana

Gurgaon civil court)

Adv S.S.Rao

DH-UPC-IShri

N.K.Gupta

Suit for Declaration with consequential relief of permanent injunction and mandatory injunction.

Listed on 23.01.2019

Page 20: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

Law Division

Scheduled for Hearing from 14th January 2019 to 25th January, 2019

S No.

Name of Court No. of Cases

Action to be taken /Important Case

Remarks

1. Supreme Court of

India.

12 Action required in 05 Cases.

Reply/Report filed in other cases

2. NGT-Principal Bench, New Delhi

42 Action required in 02 Cases.

Reply/Report filed in other cases

3 NGT Western Bench, Pune

13 No action required. Reply/Report filed.

4 NGT Eastern

Bench, Kolkata

15 No action required. Reply/Report filed.

5 NGT Central

Bench, Bhopal

04 Action required in one case

Reply/Report filed in other cases

6 NGT Southern

Bench, Chennai

08 No action required. Reply/Report filed.

7. Delhi High Court 02 No action required Reply Filed.

8 CAT, PB Delhi 02 No action required Reply Filed.

9 Bombay High Court

05 No action required Reply Filed.

10 Gurgaon Civil Court

01 No action required Reply Filed.

11 District court,

Kannur Kerala

01 No action required NA

Page 21: CENTRAL POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD LAW DIVISION th …cpcb.nic.in/NGT/Fortnightly_Report_on_Legal_Cases(14-Jan-25-Jan... · Supreme Court of India, NGT, PB, New Delhi all NGT, Zonal

Law Division Cases Scheduled for Hearing from 14th Jan 2019 to 25th January 2019

S No. Name of Court No. of Cases

Action to be taken /Important Case

Remarks

S No. Name of Court No. of Cases

Action to be taken /Important Case

Remarks

1. Supreme Court

of India

12 No action required Reply filed

2. NGT, PB, New Delhi

42 Action required in 04 Cases. Reply/Report filed in other

cases

3. NGT Western Bench, Pune

13 No action required. Reply/Report filed.

4. NGT Central Bench, Bhopal

04 No action required. Reply/Report filed.

5. NGT Eastern Bench, Kolkata

15 Action required in one case Reply/Report filed in other

cases

6. NGT Southern Bench, Chennai

08 No action required. Reply/Report filed.

7. Delhi High

Court

02 No action required Reply Filed.

8. Bombay High

Court

05 No action required Reply Filed.

9. CAT, PB Delhi 02 No action required Reply Filed.

10. District Court, Kannur, Kerala

01 No action required NA