CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHIccimindia.org/meeting_file/pdf/pdf/ec_18-11-2013.pdf ·...

1184ec

CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE

NEW DELHI

MINUTES OF THE 184th MEETING OF EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE HELD ON

18.11.2013 AT NEW DELHI

PRESENT

1. Dr. Rashidullah Khan, President I/C Chairman 2. Dr. V Stanley Jones, Vice-President (Siddha) Member

3. Dr. Prasanna Rao Member

4. Dr. Chandrakant Kolte Gangaram Member 5. Dr. Bhirgupati Pandey Member

6. Dr. V.G. Udayakumar Member

7. Dr. Mohd. Shafique Member

8. Dr. Shuhabuddin Member 9. Dr. B. Muthukumar Member

Dr. Shamshad Bano Assistant Registrar (Unani), CCIM

At the outset, a discussion was held in respect of complaints received

against CCIM members, and constitution of Enquiry Committee in the

matter.

After discussion EC decided that in future, if any compliant is received

against President, EC members, members of CCIM, Secretary and

Assistant Registrar(s) of CCIM, it should be discussed in the EC first and EC shall decide the next course of action.

It is also decided that in case of complaint against the CCIM members, the

chairmen of enquiry Committee should be Vice-President of the respective

System.

Agenda Item No. 1. Confirmation of minutes of the 183rd meeting of

Executive Committee held on 22.10.2013 at New

Delhi.

It was noted that 183rd meeting of Executive Committee was held on 22.10.2013

at New Delhi. The minutes of the same have been circulated to all the members of

the Executive Committee by post vide letter No. 5-1/2013 (183rd EC) dated 29.10.2013 to suggest addition/deletion in respect of correctness of the minutes, if

any within 21 days from the issuance of the minutes.

Executive Committee confirmed the minutes of 183rd meeting of EC with

following modification in addl. Agenda Item No. 19.

Earlier Decision Modified Decision

Executive Committee noted that reply sent Executive Committee noted that reply sent

2184ec

to Govt. of India by CCIM is as per IMCC Act, 1970 in respect of election of President, CCIM. EC further directed to obtain the latest status of WP No. 1852 of 2013 from

Madras High Court filed by Dr. Vanitha Muralikumar for further action in the matter.

to Govt. of India by CCIM is as per IMCC Act, 1970 and Regulation 5 (2) of Central Council of Indian Medicine (General) Regulations, 1976 in respect of election of

President, CCIM. EC further directed to obtain the latest status of WP No. 18520 of 2013 from Madras High Court filed by Dr. Vanitha Muralikumar for further action in the matter

Agenda Item No. 2. Regarding mediclaim Bill of BAMS Doctors.

It was noted that a letter written by Ayurved Doctors and addressed to Dr. S.P.

Mohite (CCIM member) is received wherein it has been stated that Mediclaim

Insurance Companies are refusing to reimburse the claim if treatment is taken by

the patient from the Ayurveda practitioners.

Executive Committee decided that an opinion be asked from Insurance

regulatory authority of India and on receipt of same, matter be placed in

next meeting.

Agenda Item No. 3. Problems of Integrated Medical Graduates –

request to amend IMCC, Act,1970.

It was noted that the Government of India, Department of Ayush, New Delhi vide

their letter No. Z 28015/14/2013 EP (IM-2) dated 16/08/2013 forwarded the letter

of National Integrated Medical Association, Mumbai regarding to sort out the

problem of integrated medical graduates to make the amendment in the IMCC Act,

1970. The letter is self-explanatory. The matter was placed before EC on its

meeting held on 22.10.2013. Which deferred the matter to next meeting.

It was further noted that the representation of NIMA citing the problems faced by

Graduates and Post Graduates of Ayurveda and Unani while practicing in far flung

areas of Maharashtra State was also forwarded by Directorate of AYUSH,

Maharashtra State vide letter No. DAMS/Ayurveda/practitioner‟s/

problem/2013/8777 (v) dated 16.07.2013 for guidance in the concerned matter.

It was also noted that “many of them had completed Post Graduate courses in

various clinical subjects like Kayachikitsa, Shalya Chiktisa, Stree-Roga Prasuti

Tantra, Manasroga, Vikiran Sangyaharan etc. which are approved by CCIM.

However due to lack of proper provision for these Ayurved and Unani practitioners,

they often have to face medico legal hurdles in the following matters-

Employing Standard Allopathic Emergency Management Protocols and administering life-saving intervention in case of medical/surgical cases

despite having adequate requisite knowledge of the same.

Registration of Hospitals of Operation theaters.

3184ec

Active participation in Government Health Schemes like Jeevandayi Yojna,

Family Welfare, Blindness Prevention and Control etc. Judicial and Police investigations in Medico legal matters arising due to

unavoidable circumstances and Emergency Critical care.

It is then humble request that the requisite provisions be made in the existing MMP Act 1961 so that the legal hurdles faced by them are minimized.”

The Executive Committee constituted a committee comprising of Dr. Udaykumar, Dr. Mohd. Shafique and Dr. B. Muthukumar to look into the

matter and to give its report within one month.

Agenda Item No. 4. Consideration of post of Clinical Registrars as

Assistant Professor (Clinical).

It was also noted that representations have been received from Clinical Registrars

of Jamia Hamdard, Delhi and HSZ Govt. Unani Med. College, Bhopal in respect of

the consideration/ re-designate of post of Clinical Registrar as Assistant Professor (Clinical), where they have stated that they take clinical classes (bedside

demonstration) and training of interns in the concerned Hospitals and their

experience rendered as clinical registrar be considered as teaching experience and to re-designate them as assistant professor (Clinical) retrospectively.

In this regard it was noted that there are no such provisions in the regulations

prescribed by CCIM to consider the hospital/clinical experience of clinical registrars as teaching experience and tenure of a clinical registrar is only for three years.

Further there is no designation of assistant professor (Clinical) prescribed by

Central Council of Indian Medicine. Moreover clinical registrar is treated as hospital staff.

Executive Committee deferred the matter to next meeting. However, it has

been decided that in the meantime a letter be written to all such Universities where post of Clinical Registrar exists in Hospital of the ASU

College to furnish the norms, duties and other conditions followed for the

post of Clinical Registrar.

Agenda Item No. 5. To establish the eligibility of the candidate of

Uzbekistan admitted in RA Podar Ayurved

College, Mumbai passing the General

Secondary School Certificate Examination in

the year 2000 and Diploma from an

accredited Medical College on Uzbekistan

from 2003-2006.

It was noted that MUHS, Nasik vide letter No. MUHS/C.3/UG/2845/2013 dated

28.08.2013 had asked about eligibility of one candidate from Uzbekistan for

admission in BAMS Course. The contents of the letter were reported as under:-

4184ec

“The student has been admitted by R.A. Podar Ayurved College, Mumbai for the

BAMS course in the academic year 2012-13 under the AYUSH Scholarship Scheme

2012-13. The said student has passed the General Secondary School Certificate

Examination in the year 2000 which represents 10 years of school education in

Uzbekistan. The said candidates after completion of 10 years of school education

has pursued 3 years Diploma from an accredited Medical College of Uzbekistan

from 2003-2006.

The Association of Indian Universities vide letter dated 30.10.2012 has observed

that a combined assessment of 10+3 qualifications of said student can be accepted

as she has completed 3 years Diploma in the field of Medicine. In view of AIU

letter, the department of AYUSH vide letter dated 30.05.2013 has informed to the

University. Accordingly University has allowed the said student to appear

University examination, however result of the student is kept withheld till such

time the final eligibility granted by the University.

Meanwhile, the AIU vide letter dated 19.03.2013 has communicated to the College

that, the AIU is unable to issue equivalence certificate to Miss Ashurvoa Nooirahon

Mulla Jonavna as her school education in earlier USSR and now CIS countries is of

11 years duration for which AIU do not issue Equivalence Certificate as the

corresponding school education in India is of 12 years, which is the minimum

eligibility requirement for admission to Bachelor Degree Programme.

The matter was placed before EC in its meeting held on 22.10.2013 alongwith

admission qualification for admission to BAMS Course as per concerned regulations

which is reproduced below:

“2. ADMISSION QUALIFICATION

12th standard with science or any other equivalent examination recognized by

concerned State Governments and Education boards, provided the candidate passes

the examination with 50% aggregate marks in the subjects of Physics, Chemistry

and Biology.

For foreign students any other equivalent qualification to be approved by the

University will be allowed.”

After going through the details, EC decided as under:-

“Executive Committee decided that as the candidate does not have

minimum requirement for admission therefore, she is ineligible for

admission to BAMS course and same may be informed to GOI/ MUHS,

Maharashtra.”

5184ec

As per decision of EC, the reply was sent to Registrar, MUHS as well as copy to

Deptt. of AYUSH vide letter No. 28-14/2012 UG Regulation dated 31.10.2013. However in pursuance of Council‟s letter, JS (Bala Prasad) from Deptt. of AYUSH

called up and showed his displeasure on the letter sent by Council considering

the Student from Uzbekistan.

Joint Secretary further stated that in order to promote Indian System of

Medicine, CCIM should encourage Foreign Nationals to be admitted to the ISM

courses and such letters will make a bad impression at International level. He further asked to withdraw the above letter.

The matter was again placed before President I/C, CCIM and as per direction of

President, CCIM a letter was sent to Deptt. of AYUSH informing that the matter will

be placed before next EC.

Executive Committee decided that as per UG Regulation dated 25.04.2012

the admission qualification to BAMS course is as under:-

“12th standard with sciences or an equivalent examination recognized by

concerned state government and education board, provided the candidate

passes the examination with 50% aggregate marks in the subjects of

Physics, Chemistry and Biology.

For foreign students any other equivalent qualification to be approved by

the University will be allowed.

In view of the above regulations, if candidate fulfills the eligibility criteria

then CCIM has no objection to admit the candidate in BAMS course.

Agenda Item No. 6. Reporting of changes in the

recommendation for Government Siddha

Medical Colleges for 2013-14.

It was noted the visitation reports and assessment sheets have been scrutinized

by the Screening Committee on 23.08.2013 in respect of Government Siddha

Medical College & Hospital, Chennai and Government Siddha Medical College &

Hospital, Palayamkottai. Subsequently the same had been placed before the

Executive Committee on its meeting held on 23.08.2013. But while sending the

recommendation to the Government of India, difference in the number of PG seats

were observed by the office and the same have been brought to the notice of

screening committee. The screening committee agreed to the corrections done by

the office in respect of number of seats.

Therefore the recommendations for the aforesaid colleges have been sent to GOI

vide Ref. No. 18-12/2013 Siddha (C-02) & Ref. No. 18-12/2013 Siddha (C-01) on

16.9.2013.

6184ec

The details of the earlier recommendation and revised recommendation are as

follows.

S. No. Name of the College Earlier recommendation Revised recommendation

1 Government Siddha

Medical College &

Hospital, Chennai

Recommended for UG 50 seats &

PG 29 Seats (5 Subjects)

1.Maruthuvam-9 Seats,

2.Gunapadam- 6 Seats, 3.Sirappu

Maruthuvam -5 Seats,

4.Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -5 Seats,

5.Noi Nadal-4



1.Maruthuvam -9 Seats,

2.Gunapadam-5 Seats, 3.Sirappu

Maruthuvam -5 Seats, 4.Kuzhanthai


5.Noi Nadal -4 Seats

2 Government Siddha

Medical College &

Hospital, Palayamkottai

Recommended for UG 100 seats

& PG 53 seats (6 Subjects)

1.Maruthuvam-10 Seats,



4.Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -10 Seats,

5.Noi Nadal- 8 Seats, 6.Nanjunoolum

Maruthuva Neethinoolum-7 Seats



1.Maruthuvam -10 Seats,


Maruthuvam -7 Seats, 4.Kuzhanthai


5.Noi Nadal -7Seats, 6.Nanjunoolum

Maruthuva Neethinoolum-7 Seats

Executive Committee noted the same.

Agenda Item No. 7. Reporting of Decision of Government of

India in respect of LOP.

It was noted that Government of India has conveyed the decision in respect of

following Ayurved and Unani colleges permitted/not permitted for the session

2013-14 so far in response of the recommendations of the CCIM for LOP.

Ayurved

Sl

No.

Name of the College Recommendation of CCIM for LOP Decision of

Govt. of India for the Year 2013-14

Letter no. &

date

1 Dayanand Ayurved College & Hospital

SIWAN 841266 (Bihar)

to issue LOP to the college to start PG course in Drayaguna – 04 seats.

However, it is not recommended to issue LOP to the college to start PG course in

Kayachikitsa for the session 2013-14 due to non availability of higher faculty for PG

and lecturers are not having 05 years teaching experience.

Permitted to start new PG course of study in 03

subject viz. (i) Kayachiktisa (ii) Kaumarbritya and (iii)

Dravyag8una with 04 seats in each subject

R. 14011/43/201

2-EP (IM-1) dated

25.10.2013.

2 JS Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, Nadiad (Gujarat)

to issue LOP to the college to start PG

course in following subjects for the session 2013-14-

1. Kayachikitsa –05 seats. 2. Bahishjya Kalpana -05 seats.

permitted for start new PG

course in Kayachikitsa-05

Bhaishajya Kalpna-05

R.

14011/11/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 24.10.2013

7184ec

3 NK Jabashetty

Siddharudh Math Ayurved Medical College

Manhalli Road, BIDAR-585103

to issue LOP to the college for increasing

intake capacity from 50 to 60 seats and to start PG course in following subjects for

the session 2013-14:- (i) Rog Nidan– 04 seats

(ii) Rasashastra – 04 seats (iii) Dravyaguna– 04 seats

However, it is not recommended to issue LOP to start PG course in Shalakya Tantra

for the session 2013-14 due to non availability of additional lecturer in

proposed PG Department.

Permitted to start new PG

Courses in 03 subjects namely

(i) Rognidan (ii) Rasashastra

(iii) Dravyaguna with admission capacity of

04 seats in each subject and also withdrawal of letter

of Intent to start new PG course in Shalakya Tantra

with 04 seats

R.

14011/03/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 25.10.2013.

4 KVG Ayurveda Medical

College & Hospital, Sulliya


course in Agadtantra – 04 seats (Five seats may not be granted due to lecturers

are not having 05 years teaching experience).However, it is not

recommended to issue LOP to the college to start PG course in Kayachikitsa (Five

seats) for the session 2013-14 due to non availability of higher faculty for PG and

lecturers are not having 05 years teaching

experience.


Course in 02 subject namely (i) Agadtantra and (ii)

Kayachikitsa with admissiion capacity of 05

seats in each subject

R.

14011/48/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 25.10.2013.

5 Shri Jagadguru Gavisiddeshwar

Sansthan, GAVIMATH KOPPAL – 583231

Permitted to start new PG courses in 05 subjects

namely (i) Rog Nidna (ii) Kaumarabhritya (iii)

Swaasthavritta (iv) Pancharma and (v)

Rasashastra with admission capacity of 05 seats in each

subject and to increse in admission capacity from 40

to 50 seats in UG courses

R. 14011/41/201

2-EP (IM-1) & R.

13011/27/2012-EP (IM-

1)dated 25.10.2013

6 Ashwini Ayurvedic Medical

College & Research Centre,

Ring Road, Maralur

TUMKUR 572105

to issue LOP to the college for increasing intake capacity from 50 to 60 seats and to

start PG course in following subjects for the session 2013-14:-

(i) Dravyaguna – 04 seats (ii) Kayachikitsa– 04 seats

(iii) Shalakya– 04 seats

However, it is not recommended to issue LOP to start PG course in Panchakarma for

the session 2013-14 due to non

availability of higher faculty in proposed

PG Department

Permitted to start new PG courses in 04 subjects

namely (i) Dravyaguna (ii) Kayachikitsa (iii) Pancharma

and (iv) Shalakya tantra

with admission capacity of 04 seats in each subject

and to increase admission capacity from 50 to 60

seats (10 additional seats ) in UG course

R. 14011/56/201

2-EP (IM-1) & R.

13011/28/201

2-EP (IM-1)dated

25.10.2013

7 Vaidyaratnam Ayurved

CollegeOLLUR ThalkkattusseryhTRICHU

R 680322

to issue LOP for increasing UG intake

capacity from 40 to 50 seats. However, it is not recommended to start PG in

Kayachikitsa due to deficiency of 1 higher

faculty in proposed PG department for the session 2013-14.


course of study in Kaychikitsa with 04 seats

Permitted to increse the

admission capacity in existing UG course

R.

14011/47/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated

28.10.2013.R. 13011/24/201

2-EP (IM-1) dated

29.10.2013.

8 Parrasianikkadavu

Ayurved College PO Parassiaikkadavu,

Distt. KANNUR

to issue LOP to the college for increasing

UG intake capacity from 50 to 60 seats and to start PG course in Rasashastra &

Bhaishajya Kalpana (06 seats) for the session 2013-14.


course in Rasashastra and Bhaishajya

Kalpana-06

R.

14011/46/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 28.10.2013

8184ec

9 Amrita Ayurveda Medical

College Kulesekharapuram,

Vallikavu Distt. Kollam 690525

to start PG course in following subjects for

the session 2013-14.

(i) Ayurved Samhita - 04 seats (ii) Dravyaguna Vigyana - 04 seats

(iii) Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana -04 seats (as per PG Regulation, 2012, both

have been merged and maximum 6 seats may be given in a PG Department).

(iv) Swasthavritta - 04 seats (v) Kayachikitsa - 04 seats

(vi) Shalya Tantra (Samanya) - 04 seats (vii) Panchakarma - 04 seats

However, it is not recommended to issue

LOP to start PG course in Prasuti Tantra & Stri Roga and Shalakya Tantra (Netra Rog

Vigyan) for the session 2013-14 due to non availability of additional lecturer in

proposed PG Department.


course pof study in 10 subjects viz. (i) Ayurved

Samhita (ii) Dravyaguna Vigyana (iii) Rasashastra

(iv) Bhaishajya Kalpana (v) Swasthavritta (vi) Prasuti

Tantra (Netra Rog Vigyan) and (x) Panchakarma with 4

seats in each course

R.

14011/02/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 24.10.2013.

10 Rani Dhullaiya Ayurved

College & Hospital,

Bhopal


course in following subjects for the session

2013-14- 1. Panchakarma – 05 seats.2.

Dravyaguna– 05 seats.3. Rasa Shastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana– 05 seats.4. Shalya

Tantra– 05 seats.


Course in Panchkarma-

05Dravyaguna-05Rasa

Shastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana-05Shalya Tantra-

05

R.14011/42/2

012-EP (IM-1)

dated

30.10.2013.

11 Maharashtra Arogya Mandal‟s

Sumati Bhai Shah Ayurved Mahavidyalaya

Malawadi, HADAPSAR 411028 PUNE

To issue LOP to the college to increase intake capacity in Ayurved Siddhant- from

3 to 6 Seats, Dravyaguna- from 3 to 6 seats, Rasashastra from 5 to 6 Seats,

Rognidan from 3 to 60 seats and Agadtantra from 3 to 6 seats for the

session 2013-14

Permitted to increse the admission capacity in five

existing PG courses namely (i) Ayurved Siddhant- from

3 to 6 seats (ii) Dravyaguna- from 3 to 6

seats (iii) Rasashastra- from 5 to

6 seats (iv) Rognidan- from 3 to 6

seats and (v) Agadtantra- from 3 to 6

seats

R. 13011/18/201

2-EP (IM-1) dated

25.10.2013.

12 Vasant Kusum Rural Yoga & Ayurved

Sansthan Siddhakala Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,

Sangamner

to recommend to Govt. of India to issue LOP to the college to start PG course in

Roganidan & Vikruti Vigyan – 06 seats for the session 2013-14.


LOP to start PG course in Samhita

Siddhant for the session 2013-14 due to

non availability of higher faculty in proposed PG Department.

Permitted to Start new PG in 02 Subject

Sanskrit Samhita Siddhant -06 Seats and

Roganidan & Vikruti Vigyan -06 Seats

R. 14011/59/201

2-EP (IM-1) dated

25.10.2013

13 PDEA College of Ayurveda & Research

Centre, Akurdi

to issue LOP to the college to start PG in Agadtantra with 06 seats and for

increasing intake capacity in following PG subjects for the session 2013-14

Permitted to start new PG course

R. 13011/06/201

2-EP (IM-1) and R.

14011/35/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 28.10.2013

9184ec

14 Chhatrapati Sahu

Maharaj Shikshan, Sansthan Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya,Kanchanwadi, Paithan Road,

AURANGABAD 431003


course in Samhita Siddhant-06 seats, Rognidan -06 seats, Agadtantra -06 seats

and to increase seats in Sharir Rachana from 4 to 6 seats.However, it is not

recommended to issue LOP to the college to start PG course in Drayaguna for the

session 2013-14 due to non availability of higher faculty for PG and lecturers are

not having 05 years teaching experience


Course in Samhita Siddhant-06Rognidan-

06Agadtantra-06Dravyaguna-06and to

increase the admission capcity in 01 existing PG

course in Sharir Rachana- 4 to 6 Seats

R.14011/16/2

012-EP (IM-1) and R.

13011/30/2012 -EP (IM-2)

dated 28.10.2013

15 Yashwant Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Kodoli

to issue LOP to the college to increase intake capacity in Rog Nidan – from 2 to 6

seats, Shalakya Tantra– from 2 to 6 seats & Agadtantra – from 2 to 6 seats and to

start PG course in following subjects for the session 2013-14.

(i) Kriya Shareer – 06 seats

(ii) Panchakarma– 06 seats (iii) Sangyaharan– 06 seats


LOP to start PG course in Dravyaguna Vigyan for the session 2013-14 due to non

availability of higher faculty in proposed PG Department.


R. 13011/13/201

2-EP (IM-1) & R.

14011/21/2012-EP (IM-

1)dated 25.10.2013.

16 Yerala Medical Trust & Ayurved College Sector

No.4, Kharghar Station, Navi Mumbai, Distt.

Raigad, MUMBAI – 400 614

to issue LOP to the college to start PG course in following subjects for the session

2013-14- 1. Samhita Siddhant – 04 seats.2. Rog Nidan & Vikruti Vigyan– 04

seats.3. Agadtantra & Vidhi Vaidyaka– 04 seats.


R. 14011/36/201

2-EP (IM-1) dated

25.10.2013

17 Padamshri Dr. Vitthal

Rao Vikhl Patil, Foundation Ayurved

College Shevgaon Distt.

AHMEDNAGAR



1. Rachana Sharir -06 seats 2. Ayurved Samhita – 05 Seats ( six seats

may not be granted due to lecturers are not having 05 years teaching experience).

3. Rasahastra – 05 seats ( six seats may not be granted due to lecturers are not

having 05 years teaching experience).


course of study in three subjects viz. Rachana

Shareer, Rasashastra and Ayurved Samhita with 6

seats in each course

R.

14011/38/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 24.10.2013.

18 Manjara Ayurved College & Hospital, Latur

to issue LOP to the college for increasing UG intake capacity from 50 to 60 seats.

Permitted from 50 to 60 seats in existing UG

R. 13011/16/201

2-EP(IM-1) dated

25.10.2013

19 Mahatma Gandhi

Ayurved College, Hospital & Research

Centre, Swangi, (Meghe) (Salod

Hirapur Mousa Area), WARDHA (MS)



1. Samhita Siddhant – 04 seats. 2. Rachana Shareer – 04 seats.

3. Dravyaguna – 04 seats.


course

R.

14011/25/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 29.10.2013.

20 Padamshri Dr. DY Patil

College of Ayurved & Research Institute,

Narul, Navi Mumbai


course in following subjects for the session 2013-14- 1. Drayaguna –04 seats.2.

Shalakya - 03 seats (instead of 04 seats).3. Agadtantra & Vidhi Vaidyaka - 04

seats.4. Kaumarbhritya- 03 seats (instead of 04 seats).5. Kayachikitsa -04 seats

(instead of 06 seats).6. Bhaishajya Kalpana-06 seats.


course of study in 07 subjects viz. (i)Dravyaguna

(ii) Shalakyatantra- Netra Roga(iii) Agadtantra & Vidhi

Vaidyaka (iv) Kaumarbhritya with 4 seats

in each and (v) Kayachikitsa (vi) Ayurved Siddhant and

(vii) Bhaishajya Kalpana

with 6 seats

R.

14011/37/2012-EP (IM-1)

dated 24.10.2013

10184ec

21 Babe Ke Ayurved

College & Hospital Village & PO Dudhar,

MOGA 142053

to issue LOP to the college to increase UG

seats from 50-60 seats and to start PG course in following subjects for the session

2013-14-

1. Samhita avam Siddhanta – 04 seats (

six seats may not be granted due to lecturers are not having 05

years teaching experience). 2. Kaumarbhritya – 01 seat

3. Dravyaguna - 06 seats 4. Rachana Shair -05 seats ( six seats may

not be granted due to lecturers are not having 05

years teaching experience).

Permitted to start new Pg

course Samhita Sanskrit Evam

Siddhanta-06 Seats Kaumarbhritya-01

Dravyaguna-06 Rachna Sharir-06 and

increase in admission capactiy from 50 to 60

seats in BAMS

R.13011/12/2

012-EP (IM-1) dated

28.10.2013

22 Sri Sairam Ayurved College & research

Centre, Leo Nagar, Tambaram West,

CHENNAI – 600044(TM)

to issue LOP to the college to increase intake capacity from 40 to 50 seats in

BSMS course for the session 2013-14.

Permitted to increse of intake capacity in the BAMS

course from existing 40 to 50 seats

R. 13011/05/201

2-EP (IM-1) dated

25.10.2013.

23 Ayurved Sevak Sangha

(Socitety), Contai, Distt.

Purba Madinipur, West Bangal

Permitted to start new

college UG course with 50

seats

R.

14011/48/201

2-EP (IM-1) dated

25.10.2013.

24 Pt. Khushilal Sharma

Government Ayurved

College & Hospital,

Bhopal


course in Swasthavritta -04 seats for the

session 2013-14.

Permitted to start 02 new

PG cpirses

Rachana Sharir-06

Swasthavritta-04

R.14011/10/2

012-EP (IM-1)

dated

25.10.2013

Unani S. No

Name of the College Recommendation by CCIM for LOP Decision of GOI for 2013-14

GOI Letter No. and

dated

1. Hakim Rais Unani Medical

College, Sambhal, Moradabad (UP)

Recommended for start new college UG

Course (BUMS) with 50 Seats

Permitted for start new

college UG Course (BUMS) with 50 Seats

R.12012/02/2

012-EP(IM-I) dated

25.10.2013

2. Jamia Tibbia Deoband Unani Medical College,

(Saharanpur)

Recommended for increase of intake capacity in UG from existing 50 to 60

Seats and to increase of intake capacity in PG Course Moalajat from existing 02 to 04

seats

Permitted for increase of intake capacity in UG from

existing 50 to 60 Seats and to increase of intake

capacity in PG Course Moalajat from existing 02 to

04 seats

R.13012/01/2012-EP (IM-I)

dated 25.10.2013


Addl. Agenda Item No.1. Stay order on suspension of Dr. P.R Sharma,

Secretary, CCIM and Ms. Kiran, OS by

Hon’ble Central Administrative Tribunal, New

Delhi.

It was noted that in view of Legal Opinion dated 19.10.2013 received from Legal

Axis, the Executive Committee in its meeting held on 22.10.2013 decided to

withdraw its decision of revocation (taken on 23.8.2013 in 181st meeting of E.C.)

of suspension in respect of Dr. P.R. Sharma, Secretary and Ms. Kiran, O.S. and

11184ec

decided to suspend both the employees with immediate effect pending enquiry

proceedings. Accordingly, both the officials were suspended vide Ref. No.12-1/92-

Estt.(Part III) Enquiry dated 22.10.2013 (A.N.).

However, both the employees approached to Central Administrative Tribunal and

an order dated 31.10.2013 was received on 01.11.2013 from Hon‟ble Central

Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in respect of O.A.

No.3862/2013, in which the operation of the impugned order dated 22.10.2013

has been stayed. Accordingly, Ms. Kiran was allowed to attend the office vide

Office Order No.30-5/2013-CC(41) dated 01.11.2013. Ms. Kiran submitted her

joining on 01.11.2013.

Dr. P.R. Sharma, Secretary also got his suspension stayed by the CAT, Principal

Bench, New Delhi vide order passed in O.A. No.3904/2013 and reported to his

duty on 04.11.2013.

Accordingly, Dr. P.R. Sharma, Secretary was allowed to attend the office vide

Office Order No.30-5/2013-CC(42) dated 04.11.2013 along with the said order

dated 01.11.2013. He joined his duty w.e.f. 08.11.2013.

However, in this connection, it was noted that a representation dated 28.10.2013

was also received from Dr. PR Sharma with the appeal to the Executive Committee

to restore his suspension within 10 days. The said appeal of Dr. PR Sharma was

under process and consideration but in the mean time he approached to CAT,

Principal Bench at New Delhi and got his suspension stayed as stated above.

Moreover, in view of legal opinion of legal consultant of the office, President I/C, CCIM directed not to allot any work to both the employees upto next hearing i.e.

13.11.2013 later on extended upto 20.11.2013 and files be routed through

Assistant Registrar (Unani) in the case of Secretary and Mr. Mazhar-e-Islam in case of O.S.

Further, it was also noted that charge sheets have been issued to both the employees with the approval of President I/C, CCIM vide No. 12-1/92-Estt. (Part-

III) Enquiry dated 06.11.2013 and No. 12-35/82-Estt. (Part-III) Enquiry dated

11.11.2013 to Dr. PR Sharma and Ms. Kiran respectively.

In this connection, it was further noted that although Dr. PR Sharma has been

allowed to attend the office in view of order of CAT but no work has been allotted

to him. Since, Dr. PR Sharma being the Registrar-cum-Secretary of the Council, was the DDO but no work was allotted to him due to which the obligatory work and

duties envisaged in him, were not being discharged and all financial matters were

stagnated and even normal routine work was hampering. It was, therefore, decided that in the present circumstances, it would be appropriate, if a senior

officer of the Council is authorized to discharge the powers and duties of the

Registrar-cum-Secretary/DDO.

12184ec

Executive Committee after detailed discussion and taking the present

situation, while ratifying the action taken by the President I/c, CCIM agreed that at the given circumstances as aforesaid, Dr. Shamshad Bano,

Assistant Registrar (Unani) may be authorized to discharge the duties of

the D.D.O. till further order and also authorized the President I/c to take

any action as per regulation and within the rules in the matter.

Addl. Agenda Item No.2. Letter No.3924/SHO/HN dated 31.10.2013

received from SHO, Hari Nagar, New Delhi

regarding criminal complaint.

It was noted that a letter No. 12-35/82-Estt.(Part-III) Enquiry dated 06.11.2013 was sent to the Deputy Commissioner of Police, (West District), New Delhi referring Criminal Complaint dated 17.4.2013 lodged by the Council at Police

Station, Hari Nagar, N.D. and against tampering of official records in CCIM in which

it was requested to look in the matter personally as the complainants/informants

are sufferers of grave illegalities committed by the accused persons in complete disregard of the law and order.

In this connection, it was noted that a letter No.3924/SHO/HN dated 31.10.13 has

been received from SHO, Hari Nagar regarding criminal complaint against

tampering of official records in CCIM in which office letter No.F.No.12-35/82-Estt

Part III/15569 dated 25.10.2013 is referred.

It was stated in the letter that “as per direction of Senior Officers, legal opinion on

the matter was sought and direction of prosecution/Delhi opined that matter be

kept pending till the finding of civil court are received. Hence, no further action till

them.

It is requested to intimate regarding the final order of Civil Court for further

action.”

In this connection, it was noted that no case in any Court with regard to criminal

charges/complaints as referred to above has been filed by the Council.

Executive Committee noted the same and authorized the President I/c to

take any action as per regulation and within the rules in the matter.

Addl. Agenda Item No.3. Charge to the Post of Registration

Officer to Mr. BK Raju.

It was noted that as per orders of the President I/c, CCIM, the charge of the post

of Registration Officer has been given to Mr. BK Raju, UDC w.e.f. 11.11.2013.

Executive Committee ratified the same.

13184ec

Addl. Agenda Item No.4. Reporting of decision of Govt. of India in

respect of Ayurved and Unani colleges

permitted/not permitted by Govt. of India for

the session 2013-14.

It was noted that Government of India has conveyed the decision in respect of

following Ayurved and Unani colleges permitted/not permitted for the session

2013-14 so far in response of the recommendations of the CCIM.

Ayurved

Sl.No.

Name of the college Recommendation Permission Letter no

1. Dr. BRKR Ayurved College,

SR Nagar HYDERABAD

Recommended for UG 50

seats and PG in Dravyaguna-6 seats,

Prasuti Tantra-4 seats, Kayachikitsa-10 seats,

Shalya-4 seats, Shalakya-3 seats &

Panchakarma-5 seats Not recommended in PG for

Samhita due to deficiency of lower faculty.

Permitted for UG 50 seats and

37 seats in 07 PG course (i) Dravyaguna-6 seats,

(ii) Prasuti Tantra-4 seats, (iii) Kayachikitsa-10 seats,

(iv) Shalya-03 seats, (v) Shalakya-3 seats,

(vi) Panchakarma-06 seats & (vii) Samhita -05 seats

(instead of 06 seats)

R. 17011/01/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

2. Dr. NR Sastry Govt.Ay. College

Besides VK Super Bazar, Bandar Road, VIJAYAWADA

Not recommended Permitted for UG 30 seats and

Not permitted for PG course in Rasashastra

R. 17011/02/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

3. Sri Venkateswara Ayurvedic College, SVIMS Campus,

TIRUPATI

Not recommended s Permitted for UG 40 seats and 29 seats in 05 PG course

(i) Ayurved Siddhanta (05 instead of 06),

(ii) Dravyaguna -06 seats, (iii) Rasashastra -06 seats,

(iv) Panchakarma-06 seats & (v) Shalya -06 seats.

Not permitted for PG course in

Kaumarbhritya

R. 17011/03/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

4. Vagdevi Ayurved Medical College

Bollikunta WARANGAL

not visited Not Permitted R. 12011/23/2005-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14 Dated

25.10.2013

5. Shree Vaageswari Ayurvedic

Medical College, Thimmapur, Karimnagar

not visited Not Permitted R. 12011/12/2007-EP

(IM-1) for 2013-14 Dated 25.10.2013

6. MNR Ayurved Medical College & Hospital,

Fasalwadi, Sangareddy, MEDAK

not visited Not Permitted R. 12011/32/2007-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14 Dated

25.10.2013

7. Government Ayurvedic College, Jalukbari

GUWAHATI 781004

Not recommended Permitted for UG 60 seats and 06 seats in 01 PG course

(i) Samhita Siddhanta -06 seats

Not permitted for PG course in

Kayachikitsa.

R. 17011/05/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

8. Government Ayurved College

Post-graduate Training &

Not recommended Not Permitted R. 17011/06/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

14184ec

Research Institute, Kadam

Kuan, PATNA

9. Ravindranath Mukherjee

Ayurved College, Motihari, Champaran


(IM-1) dated 25.10.2013

10. Rajkiya Ayodhya Shivkumar Ayurved College & Hospital,

Lohiyanagar, BEGUSARAI


11. Shri Motisingh Jageshwari

Ay. College & Hospital, Baratelpa, CHHAPRA

841301, Distt. Saran (Bihar)


(IM-1) dated 25.10.2013

12. Chhatisgarh Ayurved

Medical College, GE Road, Manky, RAJNANDGAON

491441 (Chhatisgarh)


seats

Permitted for UG 60 seats R. 12011/03/2005-EP

(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

13. Shri Dhanwantry Ayurved

College & Dabur Dhanwantry Hospital,

Chandigarh


seats

Permitted for UG 50 seats R. 17011/14/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

14. Ayurved & Unani Tibbia

College, Ajmal Khan Road, Karol Bagh

NEW DELHI

Not recommended Permitted for UG-40 seats and

03 seats in 01 PG courses 1. Kayachikitsa -03 seats

R. 17011/17/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

15. Govt. Akhandanand

Ayurved Mahavidyalaya Opp. Victoria Garden

Bhadra, AHMEDABAD


in 02 PG courses 1. Kayachikitsa -06 seats &

2. Panchakarma -05 seats.

R. 17011/19/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

16. Govt. Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya Ajwa Road, Vadodara

Not recommended Permitted for UG 35 seats R. 17011/21/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

17. Shri Balahanuman Ayurved Mahavidyalaya

At & Post Lodra, TAMANSA, GANDHINAGAR


18. Ayujyoti Ayurvedic college & Hospital,

Jodhpuria, Sirsa- 125055 ,Haryana

Recommended for UG 50 Seats

Permitted for UG-50 seats. R. 12011/11/2009-EP (IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

19. Govt. Ayurvedic College Dhanwantri Road,

BANGALORE

Not recommended Permitted for UG 60 seats and in 06 PG courses

(i) Shalakya Tantra -07 seats, (ii) Rognidan-06 seats,

(iii) Dravyaguna -07 seats, &

(iv) Panchakarma -07 seats, (v) Shalya Tantra -07 seats &

(vi) Rasashastra -06 seats.

R. 17011/40/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

20. Karnataka Liberal Education

Society Shri Karnataka B.M.

Kankanwadi Ayurved Mahavidyalaya

Shahapur BELGAUM- 590003

Recommended for UG

75 seats and PG in Dravyaguna-04 seats,

Rasashastra-05 seats, Bhaishajya Kalpana-06

seats, Agad Tantra-06 seats,

Kaumarbhritya-06 seats, Kayachikitsa-03 seats,

Shalya-03 seats, & Panchkarma-06 seats

Permitted for UG 75 seats and

42 seats in 08 PG course (i) Dravyaguna -05 seats,

(ii) Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana -11 seats,

(iii) Agadtantra-06 seats, (iv) Kaumabhritya -06 seats,

(v) Kayachikitsa -03 seats, (vi) Shalya Tantra-03 seats,

(vii) Sangyaharan -02 seats & (viii) Panchkarma-06 seats

R. 17011/44/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

21. DR BNM Rural Ayureda Medical College,Bijapur

(Karnataka)

Not recommended Not permitted R. 17011/46/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

22. TMAE Society‟s Ayurved

College

Not recommended Not Permitted R. 17011/52/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

15184ec

NIDIGE P.O. SHIMOGA-

577222, KARNATAKA

23. Amrutha Ayurved Medical College


24. Indian Institute of Ayurvedic Medicine &

Research, Jaya Mahal Road, BANGALORE

Not recommended Permitted for UG 45 seats. R. 17011/59/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

25. Taluka Shikshana Prasarak Sahakara Mandal Ayurvedic

College, Sindhagi, Bijapur

Not recommended Not Permitted R.17011/64/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 24.10.2013.

26. Shri SBS Ayurved College MUNDARGI Distt. GADAG –

582118 (Karnataka)

Not recommended Permitted for UG 60 seats R. 17011/70/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

27. Kannada Balag Society

Rural Ayurved Medical College ,Ram Nagar

Belgaum Karnataka

Not recommended Not permitted R. 17011/73/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

28. Muniyal Institute of

Ayurved Sciences 34-C, Shivally Industrial

Area Manipal (Karnataka)


seats, and PG in Dravyaguna -5 seats,

Rasashastra -4 seats, Bhaishajya Kalpna -5 seats,

Kayachikitsa -5 seats, Shalya Tantra -5 seats.

& Panchakarma -5 seats

Permitted for UG-40 seats and

05 PG courses (i) Rasashastra & Bhaishajya

Kalpana -09 seats, (ii) Dravyaguna -05 seats,

(iii) Kayachikitsa -05 seats, (iv) Shalya Tantra -05 seats &

(v) Panchakarma- 05 seats.

R. 17011/77/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

29. Atreya Ayurvedic Medical

College Kodigehalli, Doddaballapura

Tq. BANGALORE

Not recommended Not permitted Letter No. R.

12011/05/2005-EP(IM-1) for 2013-14 dated

24.10.2013

30. Sri Siddharameshwara

Ayurved Medical College, Bidar

Not visited Not permitted Letter No. R.

17011/88/2013-EP(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

31. PN Panicker Sauhruda

Ayurved Medical College, Kasaragod

Not recommended Permitted for UG 50 seats. R. 12011/01/2007-EP

(IM-1) for 2013-14 dated 24.10.2013

32. Vaidyaratnam Ayurved College

OLLUR Thalkkattusseryh TRICHUR 680322


Permitted for UG 50 seats R. 17011/92/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 27.09.2013

33. Govt. Ayurved College MG Road

THIRUVANATHAPURAM

695001

Recommended for UG 70 Seats and PG in

Siddhanta-06 Seats,

Rasashastra-06 Seats, Bhaishajya Kalpana-06

Seats, Prasuti Tantra & Striroga-06 Seats, Shalya-

03 Seats & Shalakya-03 Seats,

Not recommended for PG

in Dravyaguna & Kayachikitsa due to

deficiency of lower faculty and

Swasthavritta, Agadtantra,

Kumarbhritya & Panchkarma due to

deficiency of higher faculty

Permitted for UG 70 seats and 63 seats in 11 PG course

(i) Siddhanta-06 Seats,

(ii) Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana-(12 Seats bieng

merged), (iii) Kumarbhritya-05 seats,

(iv) Panchkarma-05 seats, (v) Shalakya-03 Seats,

(vi) Dravyaguna-06 seats, (vii) Kayachikitsa- 06 seats,

(viii) Swasthavritta-06 seats, (ix) Shalya-03 Seats,

(x)Prasuti Tantra & Striroga-06 Seats, &

(xi) Agadtantra -05 seats.

R. 17011/95/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

34. Ahalia Ayurvedic Medical Not recommended Permitted for UG-50 seats. R. 12011/02/2009-EP

16184ec

college,

Kozhipara, Palakkad,

(IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

35. Govt. Auto. Ayurved College

& Hospital, Amkho Lashkar, GWALIOR


not permitted for PG in Kriya Sharir.

R. 17011/99/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

36. College of Ayurved Medical College & Hospital Bara

Ghat, Jhansi Road GWALIOR 474001

Not visited Not Permitted R. 12011/47/2006-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14 dated

25.10.2013

37. Govt. Dhanwantri Ayurved College & Hospital,

Mangalnath Road UJJAIN 465001

Not recommended Permitted for UG-40 seats and not permitted for

1. Kayachikitsa, 2. Rachana Sharir - &

3. Dravyaguna

R. 17011/101/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

38. Pt. Shivshaktilal Sharma Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, 497, Katju Nagar

RATLAM

Recommended for UG 50 Seats and PG in Samhita -06

Seats, Panchakarma -06 Seats &

Kayachikitsa 06 Seats

Permitted for UG-50 seats and18 seats in 03 PG course

1. Ayurved Samhita -06 seats 2. Kayachikitsa -06 seats &

3. Panchakarma -06 seats.

R. 17011/102/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

39. Smt. Dhariya Prabhadevi

Sajotiya Ayurved Medical College,

Neemthur, BHANPURA 45J8775

Not visited Not Permitted R. 12011/39/2006-EP

(IM-1) for 2013-14 dated 25.10.2013

40. Pt. Shivnath Shastri Govt. Auto. Ayurved College &

Hospital, Shikarpura, BURHANPUR


41. Acharya Gyan Ayurved College

278, Jawahar Marg Malganj

Choraha INDORE

Not visited Not Permitted R. 17011/105/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 25.10.2013

42. Ajivan Swasthya Samvardhan

Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Chitrakoot, SATNA (MP)

Not visited Not Permitted 12011/08/2007-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14

dated 25.10.2013

43. Om Ayurved College, Jamthi, PO Bharat Bharati

BETUL 460001 (MP)

Not visited Not Permitted R. 17011/112/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 25.10.2013

44. Bharti Vidyapeeth‟s College

of Ayurved Katraj-Dhanakwadi, Distt. Pune

411043


seats & for PG (i) Samhita-04, (ii) Rachna Sharir-04,

(iii) Kriya Sharir-04, (iv)Dravyaguna-04, (v)

Bhaishajya Kalpana-04, (vi) Rognidan-03, (vii)

Swasthavritta-05, (viii)

Agadtantra-04, (ix) Prasuti

tantra-05, (x) Kaumarbhritya-04, (xi)

Kayachikitsa-05, (xii) Shalakya Tantra-04 & (xiii)

Panchakarma-03 seats

Not recommended for PG in Shalya Tantra

Permitted for UG 100 seats

and 57 seats in 14PG course (i) Samhita-04 seats,

(ii) Rachana Sharir-04 seats, (iii) Kriya Sharir-04 seats,

(iv) Dravyaguna-04 seats, (v) Bhaishajya Kalpana-04

seats,

(vi) Rognidan-03 seats,

(vii) Swasthavritta-05 seats, (viii) Agadtantra-04 seats,

(ix) Prasuti tantra-05 seats, (x) Kaumarbhritya-04 seats,

(xi) Kayachikitsa-05 seats,

(xii) Shalakya Tantra-04 seats, (xiii) Panchakarma-03 seats &

(xiv) Shalya Tantra- 04 seats. And 12 seats in 06 seatsPG

diploma course namely (i) Panchakrama -02 seats,

(ii) Ayurvedic Sangyaharan -02 seats,

(iii) Ayurvedic Cosmetology & Skin Diseases -02 seats,

(iv) Prasuti Tantra -02 seats,

(v) Prasuti Tantra -02 seats &

R. 17011/113/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

17184ec

(vi) Netraroga -02 seats.

45. Tilak Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, Rasta Peth, Pune


seats & in PG (i) Samhita-03, (ii) Rachna Sharir-05,

(iii) Agadtantra-04, (iv) Kayachikitsa-06, (v) Shalya

Tantra-04, (vi) Panchakaarma-04 &

(vii)Sangayaharan-03 Not recommended for PG

in (i) Kriya Sharir, (ii) Rasashastra, (iii)

Swasthvritta, (iv) Ragnidan, (v)

Kaumarbhritya, (vi) Shalakya Tantra, (vii)

Dravyaguna & (viii) Prasuti Tantra

Permitted for UG 100 seats

and 55 seats in 14 PG course (i) Samhita-03 seats,

(ii) Rachana Sharir-05 seats, (iii) Kriya Sharir-04 seats,

(iv) Dravyaguna-03 seats, (v) Rasashastra-05 seats,

(vi) Rognidan-04 seats, (vii) Swasthavritta-02 seats,

(viii) Agadtantra-04 seats, (ix) Prasuti tantra-04 seats,

(x) Sangyaharan-03 seats, (xi) Kayachikitsa-06 seats,

(xii) Shalakya Tantra-04 seats, (xiii) Panchakarma-04 seats &

(xiv) Shalya Tantra- 04 seats.

R. 17011/114/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

46. Shri Gangadhar Shastri Gune Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya,

Vishrambaug

AHMEDNAGAR


47. Maharashtra Arogya Mandal‟s

Sumati Bhai Shah Ayurved Mahavidyalaya

Malawadi, HADAPSAR 411028 PUNE

Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in

Samhita-3 seats, Rachana Sharir-6 seats,

Kriya Sharir-6 seats, Dravyaguna-3 seats,

Rasashastra-5 seats, Rognidan-3 seats,

Prasuti Tantra-6 seats, Agadtantra-3 seats,

Kayachikitsa-6 seats & Shalya-6 seats

Permitted for UG 60 seats & 47 seats in 10 PG courses

(i) Samhita-3 seats, (ii) Rachana Sharir-6 seats,

(iii) Kriya Sharir-6 seats, (iv) Dravyaguna-3 seats,

(v) Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana-5 seats,

(vi) Rognidan-3 seats, (vii) Prasuti Tantra-6 seats,

(viii) Agadtantra-3 seats, (ix) Kayachikitsa-6 seats &

(x) Shalya-6 seats. And 10 seats is 02 PG diploma

course (i) Ayurvedic Pharmaceutics -

Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana-05 seat &

(ii) Prasuti Tantra -05 seats.

R. 17011/120/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

48. Ganga Education Society‟s

Ayurved College, C/o Ganga Hospital, New

Building, RANKALAVES, Distt. Kolhapur


(IM-1) dated 30.10.2013

49. Dada Saheb Surupsingh

Naik Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Nangaon,

Dhule


(IM-1) dated 28.10.2013

50. RA Podar Ayurved Medical

College, Worli, Mumbai


42 seats in 12 PG courses (i) Ayurved Samhita -03 seats,

(ii)Kriya Sharir-02 seats, (iii) Dravyaguna-02 seats,

(iv) Rasashastra -03 seats, (v) Kayachikitsa-08 seats,

(vi) Shalya Tantra-04 seats, (vii) Panchakarma-04 seats,

(viii) Shalakya-04 seats. (ix) Prasuti Tantra -05 seats,

(x) Rachna Sharir-04 seats, (xi) Swasthavritta -02 seats &

(xii) Rognidan -02 seats.

R. 17011/136/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

18184ec

51. Yerala Medical Trust &

Ayurved College Sector No.4, Kharghar

Station, Navi Mumbai, Distt. Raigad,

MUMBAI – 400 614

Recommended for UG-80

seats and PG in (i) Rachna Sharir-04, (ii)Kriya Sharir-

04, (iii) Dravyaguna-04, (iv) Rasashastra-04, (v)

Bhaishajya Kalpana-04, (vi) Kayachikitsa-04, (vii) Shalya

Tantra-04, (viii) Shalya (Anusastra)-04, (ix)

Shalakya-04 and (x) Panchakarma-04 seats

Permitted for UG-80 seats and

34 seats in 08 PG courses (i) Rachna Sharir-04 seats,

(ii)Kriya Sharir-04 seats, (iii) Dravyaguna-04 seats,

(iv) Rasashastra & Bhaishajya Kalpana-08 seats,

(v) Kayachikitsa-04 seats, (vi) Shalya Tantra-04 seats,

(vii) Shalya (Anusastra)-04 seats,

(viii) Shalakya-04 seats.

R. 17011/139/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 26.09.2013

52. Shri Ayurved

Mahavidyalaya, Hanuman Nagar, Nagpur


09 seats in 02 PG courses (i) Rasashastra -06 seats &,

(ii) Kriya Sharir -03 seats,

Not permitted for 11 course in PG course

(i) Samhita,

(ii) Rachana Sharir,

(iii) Dravyaguna,

(iv) Kayachikitsa , (v) Swasthavritta ,

(vi) Shalya Tantra, (vii) Rognidan,

(viii) Shalakya Tantra, (ix) Agadtantra,

(x) Kaumabhritya, (xi) Panchakarma.

R. 17011/144/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

53. Shri Radha Krishna Toshniwal

Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Station Road

AKOLA 444001

Not recommended Permitted for UG 50 seats and 05 seats in 02 PG courses

(i) Samhita -02 seats &, (ii) Shalya Tantra -03 seats,

Not permitted for PG course

(i) Rachana Sharir & (ii) Kayachikitsa.

R. 17011/145/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

54. Gramin Ayurved Mahavidyalaya

PATUR – 444501, Distt. Akola (MS)

Recommended for UG 50 Seats

Permitted for UG 50 seats. R. 17011/150/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 25.10.2013

55. Dr. DY Patil Pratishtan Ayurved College, Pimpri,

Pune (MS).

Recommended for UG 75 seats and

PG in (i) Samhita-04, (ii)

Rachana Sharir-04, (iii)

Kayachikitsa-04, (iv) Prasuti

Tantra-04 and (v) Shalya Tantra-04 seats.

Not Permitted R. 17011/156/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 28.10.2013

56. SSUD Ayurved Medical College & Hospital, Karanja

(LAD), Distt. WASHIM

Not recommended not permitted R. 12011/10/2007-EP (IM-1) dated 29.10.2013

57. Gopabandhu Ayurveda

Mahavidyalaya, PURI


04 PG course (i) Prasuti Tantra & Striroga-01

Seats, (ii) Rasashastra -02 seats,

(iii) Kayachikitsa- 07 seats, (iv) Shalya-03 Seats.

And not permitted for PG course in

(i) Kaumabhritya

R. 17011/166/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

58. Indira Gandhi Memorial

Ayurved College, &


(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

19184ec

Hospital, JAGUMARA

BHUBNESHWER 751030

59. Kaviraj Ananta Tripathy

Sharma Ayurved Mahavidyalaya,

Ankushpur, GANJAM


(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

60. Govt. Ayurved College, AT

Tulsi Nagar BOLANGIR


(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

61. Desh Bhagat Ayurvedic College &

Hospital, Dist. Fategarh Sahib, Punjab

Recommended for UG 60 Seats and PG in Kayachikitsa

-05 Seats, Rasashastra & Bhaishajya

Kalpana -05 Seats

Permitted for UG 60 seats and 02 PG course

(i) Kayachikitsa -05 seats & (ii) Rasashastra -05 seats.

R. 17011/173/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

62. Shri Laxminaryan Ayurved College

Sant Tulsidas Marg AMRITSAR 147001

Not recommended Not Permitted 17011/178/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

63. Smt. Urmila Devi Ayurvedic College & Hospital, VPO

KHARKHAN, Una Road, HOSHIARPUR 146001

(Punjab)

Not recommended Permitted for UG 50 seats R. 17011/181/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

64. Saint Sahara Ayurved

Medical College & Hospital, Kot

Shamir, BHATINDA


(IM-1) dated 20.09.2013

65. JR‟s Tantia Shri Ganganagar College of Ayurvedic

Sciences,

SRIGANGANAGAR (Rajasthan)

Not recommended Permitted for UG 50 seats R. 12011/58/2013-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14 dated

24.10.2013

66. Punjab Medical, Technical and General Educational

Society, Patiala‟s Punjab Ayurved Medical

College & Hospital, SRI GANGANAGAR (Rajasthan)

Not recommended Permitted for UG 50 seats C. 11011/10/2006-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14 dated

09.10.2013

67. Shekhawati Ayurved Medical College, Pilani


Permitted for UG 50 seats. R. 12011/08/2008-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14 dated

27.09.2013

68. Shri Shirdi Sai Baba

Ayurved College & Hospital Mundiyagarh kishangrh

,Renwal Jaipur Rajasthan

Not recommended not permitted R. 12011/12/2009-EP

(IM-1) for 2013-14 dated 24.10.2013

69. Government Ayurveda Medical College & Hospital,

Kottar, Nagercoil

Not recommended UG-50 seats R. 12011/20/2009-EP (IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

70. Govt. Gurukul Ayurved

College Gurukul, Kangari,

HARIDWAR

Not recommended not permitted R. 17011/191/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

71. Uttaranchal Ayurved

College, Rajpur, Dehradun


20 seats in 04 PG courses (i) Maulik Siddhanta -05 seats,

(ii) Swasthavritta -05 seats, (iii) Dravyaguna -05 seats &

(iv) Agadtantra -05 seats.

R. 17011/193/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

72. Himalayiya Ayurved Yoga

Avam Prakartic Chikitsa Sansthan,

Shampur, DEHRADUN

Not recommended Permitted for UG 50 seats R. 12011/13/2005-EP

(IM-1) for 2013-14 dated 24.10.2013

73. Rajkiya Lalit Hari P.G. Ayurvedic College &


20184ec

Hospital, PILIBHIT

74. Bundelkhand Govt. Ayurved

College & Hospital, JHANSI


(IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

75. JD Ayurvedic Medical

College & Hospital, Aligarh, Uttar Pradesh


seats

Permitted for UG 50 seats. R. 12011/31/2013-EP

(IM-1) for 2013-14 dated 09.10.2013

76. Major SD Singh Ayurved Medical College & Hospital,

Farrukhabad


Permitted for UG 50 seats. R. 12011/07/2005-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14 dated

27.09.2013

77. Faculty of Ayurveda Institute Of Medical Science

Banaras Hindu University Varanasi -210005 Uttar

pradesh


Shalya-03 Seats & Sangyaharan -01 Seats

Not Recommended for PG in

Samhita, Ayurved Siddhanta, Rachana Sharir,

Kriya Sharir, Rognidan, Swasthavritta,

Kaumarbhritya & Shalakya tantra due to deficiency of

higher faculty and Dravyaguna, Rasashastra &

Prasuti Tantra, due to deficiency of lower faculty

and Manasroga & Kayachikitsa due to

deficiency of lower & Higher Faculty

Permitted for UG 50 seats and 25 seats in 14 PG courses

(i) Ayurved Samhita-02 seats, (ii) Kaumabhritya -02 seats,

(iii) Shalakya Tantra -01 seat, (iv) Rasashastra -02 seats,

(v) Rachana Sharir -01 seats, (vi) Kriya Sharir -01 seats,

(vii) Dravyaguna -02 seats, (viii) Kayachikitsa -04 seats,

(ix) Swasthvritta -01 seats, (x) Rognidan -01 seats,

(xi) Shalya Tantra -03 seats, (xii) Prasuti Tantra -03 seats,

(xiii) Manasroga-01 seats & (xiv) Sangyaharan -01 seats.

R. 17011/204/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

78. Mahesh Ayurvedic College, Ashti,Beed, Mahasrashtra

not visited not permitted R. 12011/37/2006-EP (IM-1) dated 30.10.2013

79. Islamia Zakaria Ayurveda College, Gulbarga,

Karnataka

Not recommended not permitted R. 17011/83/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 24.10.2013

80. Mahaganapati Ayurvedic Medical College, Halyal

Road, Distirct-Dharwad, Karnataka


81. Bhanwar Lal Nahata Samriti Sansthan's Mandsaur

Institute of Ayurved Education & Research,

Mhow-Neemuch Road, Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh

Not recommended permitted UG 50 seats R. 12011/10/2009-EP (IM-1) for 2013-14 dated

09.10.2013

82. Parasurampuria Ayurved College, Sikar Rajasthan


83. Bharti Vidyapeeth‟s College

of Ayurved, Pune

Screening Committee did not

mentioned in respect of

Diploma subjectc. Hence, recommendation not sent.

Permitted in Panchkarma-02

Ayurvedic Sanguaharan-02

Ayurvedic Cosmetology & Skin Diseases-02

Prasuti & Stri Roga-02 Balroga-02

Netraroga Vigyan-02

R-17011/113/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 10.10.2013

84. Maharashtra Arogya

Mandal‟s Sumati Bhai Ay. Mahavidyalaya, Hadapsar

Permitted in Ayurvedic

pharmaceutics & Bhaishajya Kalpana-05

Prasuti & Stri roga-05

R-17011/120/2013-EP

(IM-1) dated 09.10.2013

Unani

S.No Name of the College Recommendation by CCIM

for 2013-14 session

Decision of GOI for 2013-14

1. Z.H. Unani Medical Not Recommended Not Permitted

21184ec

College, (Siwan) Bihar

2. Nizamia Unani Medical College, Gaya (Bihar)

Not Recommended Permitted for UG 40 Seats

3. Mohsin-e-Millat Unani Medical College, Raipur

(CG)

Not Recommended Permitted for UG 40 Seats

4. A&U Tibbia College,

Karolbagh (New Delhi)

Not Recommended Permitted for UG – 40 UG seats and 01 PG course

Iilmul Saidla 03 seats and denial to 03 PG courses i) Moalijat 3 seats ii) Munafeul Aza 2 seats and iii)

Amraze Niswan wa Qabalat-2 seats

5. Institute of Asian Medicine Sciences, (Srinagar) J & K

Not Recommended Permitted for UG – 40 Seats

6. Kashmir Tibbia College & Hospital, (Srinagar) J & K


7. Govt. Unani Medical College, Bangalore

(Karnataka)


8. Al-Farooque Unani Medical

College, (Indore)

Recommended for UG – 50

Seats

Permitted for UG – 50 Seats

9. MIJ Tibbia Unani Medical

College, Mumbai


10. Rajasthan Unani Medical

College, Jaipur (Rajasthan)


11. State Unani Medical College, Himmatganj,

Allahabad


12. Ajmal Khan Tibbia College, Aligarh (UP)

Not Recommended for UG & PG Permitted for UG-60 Seats and PG Course in Kulliyat-04 Seats, Ilmul Advia-04 Seats, Moalijat-04 Seats,

TAhafuzi wa Samaji Tib -01 Seats, Qabalat wa Amraze Niwan-01 and Jarahat -02 Seats

Siddha S.

No.

Name of the college Recommendation to GOI Decision of the Govt. of India Letter No and

Date

1. Govt. Siddha Medical

College, Palayamkottai,

TN

Recommended UG-100 Seats and

PG-49 Seats (6 Specialities) 1.Maruthuvam-10 seats

2.Gunapadam-10 seats 3.Sirappu Maruthuvam- 7 seats

4.Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -8 Seats

5.Noi Nadal -7 seats 6.Nanju Noolum Maruthuva

Neethi Noolum -7 seats

Permitted for UG-100 Seats and

PG-60 Seats (6 Specialities) 1.Maruthuvam-10 seats

2.Gunapadam-10 seats 3.Sirappu Maruthuvam- 10 seats

4.Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -10 Seats

5.Noi Nadal -10 seats 6.Nanju Noolum Maruthuva

Neethi Noolum -10 seats

R-17013/03/2013 -EP(IM-1) dated

9.10.2013

2. Govt. Siddha Medical

College, Chennai, TN

Recommended

UG-50 Seats and

PG - 28 Seats (5

Specialities)

1.Maruthuvam-9 seats

2.Gunapadam-5 seats

3.Sirappu Maruthuvam- 5seats

4.Kuzhanthai Maruthuvam -5

Seats

5.Noi Nadal -4 seats

Permitted for

UG-50 Seats and

PG - 34 Seats (5 Specialities)

1.Maruthuvam-10 seats

2.Gunapadam-10 seats

3.Sirappu Maruthuvam- 5 seats


Seats

5.Noi Nadal -4 seats

R-17013/02/2013

-EP(IM-1) dated

9.10.2013

3. Akila Thiruvithamcore

Siddha Vaidya Sangam

Siddha Maruthuva Kallory

& Hospital, Munchirai,

Not recommended Not permitted R-

17013/04/2013-

EP (IM-1) dated

10.10.2013

22184ec

KANYAKUMARI. TN

4. Santhigiri Siddha Medical

College,

Thiruvanathapuram.

Kerala

Not recommended Permitted for 50 UG Seats R-

17013/01/2013-

EP (IM-1) dated

27.09.2013

5. National Institute of

Siddha, Tambaram,

Chennai 106. TN

Recommended for PG 36

seats

(6 Specialities)

1.Maruthuvam-5 Seats

2.Gunapadam-8 Seats

3.Sirappu Maruthuvam -5

Seats


Seats

5.Noi Nadal-7 Seats

6.Nanjunoolum Maruthuva

Neethinoolum-6 Seats

Permitted for

PG -46 seats (6 Specialities)

1.Maruthuvam-8 Seats

2.Gunapadam-8 Seats

3.Sirappu Maruthuvam -8 Seats


Seats

5.Noi Nadal-7 Seats

6.Nanjunoolum Maruthuva

Neethinoolum-7 Seats

R-

14013/01/2004-

EP(IM-1) for

2013-14 dated

01.09.2013

6. Sivaraj Siddha Medical

College, Salem

Recommended for 50 UG

Seats

Permitted for 50 UG Seats R-

12013/01/2008-

EP(IM-1) for

2013-14 dated

9.10.2013

7. Sri Sairam Siddha Medical

College & Research

Centre, Chennai


Seats


17013/05/2013-

EP(IM-1) dated

23.09.2013

8. RVS Siddha Medical

College and Hospital


Seats


12013/01/2006-

EP (IM-1) for

2013-14 dated

14.10.2013

9. Velumaiula Siddha

Medical College and

Hospital, T.N.

Not recommended Permitted for 40 UG Seats R-

17013/06/2013-

EP(IM-1) dated

17.10.2013


Addl. Agenda Item No.5. To review the syllabus of Post Graduate

course in Ayurveda in 22 specialties:-

It was noted that the meeting for preparing syllabus of final year Post Graduate

subjects in Ayurveda (22 specialties) was convened on 24-25.10.2013 in the office of CCIM under the convenorship of Dr. Prasanna N. Rao and co-convenership of

Dr. Udaykumar.

Executive Committee approved the syllabus and decided to circulate the

syllabus to all concerned as well as hosting the syllabus on CCIM website.

Addl. Agenda Item No.6. Policy prepared by screening committee for

the eligibility of the teachers

It was noted that the meeting of Screening Committee consisting of following

members was held on 31.10.2013 & 01.11.2013 namely Dr. Prasanna Rao, Dr.

23184ec

Udaykumay, Dr. BP Pandey, Dr. Ragini Patil and Dr. Srinivas K. Bannigol. The

policy decided by the Screening Committee regarding eligibility of the teacher is as under: Sl.

No.

Reasons for ineligibility of teachers Policy for eligibility of teachers.

1. Non-PG Joining after 01.07.1989

Not Eligible as per regulation 1.07.1989

2. Overage (beyond 65 yrs) Not Eligible as per Amended MSR

21.05.2013

3. Appointed in Non-Allied subjects against Regulation 1.07.1989, 2.04.2011, 25.04.2012 & CCIM circular F-28-

13/2004-Ay. Dated 9.10.2004.s

Not Eligible

4. Non-Ayurvedic Degree holder except Sanskrit Not Eligible

5. Teacher having PG Diploma (After 1995) Not Eligible as per 156th EC decision Agenda No.2 and 178th EC Agenda No.2

6. Teacher joined after age of 45/40 yrs as per MSR-2012 and Amendment 2013 And UG regulation Amendment 2013

respectively.

Not Eligible

7. Found in Duplicity Considered eligible teacher in one

college only after confirmation with teacher.

8. Teacher not having requisite period of teaching experience

for the post held.

Teacher having minimum 5 yrs

teaching experience for reader and 10 yrs teaching experience for professor

including non cadre/ carrier advanced promotion posts.

9. Teacher submitted previous teaching experience in later date. May be confirmed after verification of relevant documents.

10. Working as teacher with undergraduate qualification after 1989, subsequently obtained PG qualification & considered

before PG teaching experience to total teaching experience for propose of promotion

Post PG teaching experience will be considered and cadre will be as per the

required teaching experience.

11. Teacher having UG qualification of before 1989 submitted previous teaching experience in later date but not reflecting

in the visitation report of concerned college

After confirming the relevant documents may be consider eligible.

12. Teacher applied to the post before 1989 with UG qualification

and appointed/reported to the post after 1989 by the competent authority / Govt.

After confirming the relevant

documents may be consider eligible.

13. Teacher appointed with UG qualification before 1989 but

frequently changed the subject of teaching as per written direction of competent authority / Govt. (Transfer/ promotion

etc.)

Considered Eligible in the subject

having maximum experience / after confirmation from teacher

14. The appointment of the teacher in Ayurveda but subject of

teaching not mentioned.

Consider eligible after confirmation

from teacher.

15. Teacher appointed with UG qualification before 1989

continued service with gap of years.

Consider Eligible ( Gap period will not

be considered as teaching experience)

16. Teacher with PG qualification continued service after gap of few years:-

i) Deputation to other than AYUSH institutions. ii) Deputation to Universities for Non-teaching Posts

iii) Short appointment in Research organizations. iv) Deputation for Phd.

v) Deputation to Drug Controller under AYUSH department. vi) Deputation to college Pharmacy as Deputy Superintend.

Consider Eligible after deleting the Gap period.(Refer MSR & regulations)

17. Teacher continued service with gap of few years for

Physiological reasons (Maternity and health related personnel reasons).

Consider Eligible after verifying relevant

documents issued by competent authority.

18. Teacher having certain years of teaching experience deputed to Non-Teaching/ administrative post in the same

organization & rejoined to the teaching post after retirement.

Consider Eligible after deleting the non teaching experience.

19. Medical officer/AMO deputed/ transferred/ re-employed to Consider Eligible those appointed before

24184ec

the post of teacher after cut-off age.(40/45 yrs-MSR 2012 &

amendment 2013)

2012 MSR (Refer Regulations

20. Teacher appointed as Demonstrator/clinical registrar/ Tutor/

Junior Lecturer/ Technical assistant/Senior Resident/Service senior Resident/JRF/SRF/Ayurved Expert appointed by

Universities / Govt. organizations after 1989 with PG qualification & teacher appointed or deputed to AYUSH chairs.

Consider eligible .The teaching

experience issued by a competent authority can be included in total

experience.

21. Teachers appointed without having supportive documents for qualification & experience mentioned in UG-PG regulations.


22. Teaching experience shown by teacher is not confirmed / tallied in concerned visitation report of the college


23. Experience shown by the teacher is overlapping. Consider eligible after deleting the

overlapping experience in confirmation with teacher / relevant document.

24. Teacher showing experience of following Ayurved colleges:- i)Ayurved college Buxar

ii) Ayurved college Motihari iii) PNB Ayurved college

iv) Vekatraman Ayurved College

Considered eligible till the date of passing of last student duly confirmed

by concerned universities.

25. Teacher with PG qualification appointed in non allied subject

having teaching experience and later acquired pg qualification in concerned subject.

Considered eligible to those teacher

appointed before notification of PG regulation2012.

26. Teacher with PG qualification appointed in one allied subject & promoted to another allied subject.

Consider Eligible teacher as one time basis as per the provision made in MSR.

27. Deployed teachers Not-eligible.

28. Teacher with total change in experience. Not-Eligible after 2012.

On the basis of above mentioned policy, following teachers have been cleared by the screening committee:

Sl.no. Name of teacher Department Designation Remarks of screening

committee

1. Dr. Lalitha Amruth AMC, Kollam

Rognidan Reader Eligible

2. Dr. Mahesh Krishna Rao Ghughari Dada Saheb Sarupsingh AMC, Dhule

Samhita Professor Eligible

3. Dr. Tomy George

Nangelil AMC, Kollam

Shalya Lecturer Eligible

4. Dr. Sanjay Manikrao Thatte

Hanuman Shikshan AMC, Kolhapur

Kriya Sharir Professor Eligible

5. Dr. Rakshpal Gupta

Govt. AMC, Raipur

Dravyaguna Reader Eligible

6. Dr. Harjpal

Govt. AMC, Raipur

Samhita Reader Eligible

(i) Executive Committee approved the policy except in respect of point No.

20 decision on which is as under:-

Sl.

No.

Reason for ineligibility of teachers Decision of EC

20. Teacher appointed as Demonstrator/clinical registrar/ Tutor/

Junior Lecturer/ Technical assistant/Senior Resident/Service senior Resident/JRF/SRF/Ayurved Expert appointed by

Universities / Govt. organizations after 1989 with PG qualification & teacher appointed or deputed to AYUSH chairs.

Consider eligible if the teacher

appointed as Demonstrator/ Tutor/ Junior Lecturer after 1989

with PG qualification.

(ii) The reasons which are not covered in this policy but mentioned in

criteria approved by EC in its meeting held on 26.06.2013 will be taken

into consideration in clearing the pending of eligibility of teachers.

25184ec

(iii) The relevant points of the policy be adopted in clearing eligibility

issues of Unani/ Siddha teachers if there is any.

(iv) Executive Committee further agreed to consider the teachers eligible

whose eligibility has been cleared on the basis of above policy.

Addl. Agenda Item No.7. Reporting in respect of Faculty of Ayurveda,

Institute of Medical Sciences, Banaras Hindu

University, Dist. Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh & Govt. Ayurveda College, M.G Road, Taluke &

District Thiruvanathapuram, Kerala.

It was noted that while sending the recommendation of Faculty of Ayurveda,

Institute of Medical Sciences, Banaras Hindu University, it was observed that

Screening Committee reduced the number of UG seats from sanctioned seats. The

matter was placed before 182 EC in its meeting held on 9.09.2013 and EC decided

that “recommendations be revised by the office in view of the policy of Govt. of

India and thereafter be sent to Govt. of India”. Accordingly the recommendation of

the colleges have been sent with the approval of President, CCIM.

Sl. No.

Name of college Number of sanctioned seats Observation of scrutiny committee

Recommendation sent to GOI

1. Dean, Faculty of Ayurveda, Institute of

Medical Sciences, Banaras Hindu

University, Dist. Varanasi, Uttar

Pradesh.

UG -78 seats PG in Sidhanata-1,Basic

principal-1, Kriya sharir-1, Rachna Sharir-1, Dravyaguna-

2, Rashsastra-2, Rog nidana-1,Swasthvrita-1, Prasuti& stri

rog-3, Kaumarbhritya-2, Kayachikitsa-4,Manasrog-

1,Shalaya-3,Shanghyaharan-1,Shalakaya-1

Recommended for UG 60 seats and PG in Samhita -1

seat, Ayurved Siddhanta -1 seat, Dravyaguna -2 seats,

Rasashastra -2 seats , Prasuti Tantra -3 seats,

Kayachikitsa -4 seats, Manasroga – 1 seat,

Sangyaharan -1 seats, Shalya Tantra – 3 seats

and NOT recommended for PG in Rachana Sharir, Kriya

Sharir , Rognidan, Kaumarbhritya, Shalakya

Tantra, Swasthavritta.


Shalya-03 Seats & Sangyaharan -01 Seats

Not Recommended for PG

in Samhita, Ayurved Siddhanta, Rachana

Sharir, Kriya Sharir,

Rognidan, Swasthavritta, Kaumarbhritya &

Shalakya tantra due to deficiency of higher

faculty and Dravyaguna, Rasashastra & Prasuti

Tantra, due to deficiency

of lower faculty and

Manasroga & Kayachikitsa due to deficiency of lower

& Higher Faculty

2. Govt. Ayurveda College,

M.G Road, Taluke & District

Thiruvanathapuram Kerala

UG -70 seats PG in Samhita-06,

Dravyaguna-06, Rasashastra-06, Bhaishjya Kalpana-06 ,

Prasuti & Striroga-06, Kayachikitsa-06,

Swasthavritta-06, Shalya-03, Shalakya-03, Panchkarma-05

& Agadtantra-03 seats

Recommended for UG 60 Seats and PG in Samhita -

06 Seats, Dravyaguna -06 Seats, Rasashastra -06

Seats, Bhaishajya Kalpana -06 Seats, Prasuti Tantra &

Striroga -06 Seats, Kayachikitsa -06 Seats,

Swasthavritta 06 Seats, Shalya 03 Seats, Shalakya

03 Seats, Panchakarma 05 & Agadtantra 03 Seats,

Kaumarbhritya 05 Seats.


Siddhanta-06 Seats, Rasashastra-06 Seats,

Bhaishajya Kalpana-06 Seats, Prasuti Tantra &

Striroga-06 Seats, Shalya-03 Seats &

Shalakya-03 Seats,

Not recommended for PG in Dravyaguna &

Kayachikitsa due to

deficiency of lower faculty

26184ec

and Swasthavritta,

Agadtantra, Kumarbhritya & Panchkarma due to

deficiency of higher faculty


Addl. Agenda Item No.8. Reporting in respect of Pt. Shivshaktilal

Sharma Ayurved Medical College, Ratlam, Madhya Pradesh

It was noted that the visitation report of Pt. Shivshaktilal Sharma Ayurved Medical College, Ratlam, Madhya Pradesh was placed before Screening Committee and the

Screening Committee decided not to recommend the college due to serious

irregularity found in the documents.

As per the decision of 182 EC under additional agenda item no 3. “Executive

Committee referred the matter to Screening Committee for further

consideration and also decided that observations of the Screening

Committee be forwarded to Govt. of India with the approval of President,

CCIM.” The matter was placed before Screening Committee and the Screening

Committee decided to recommend the college. With the approval of President,

CCIM, recommendation was sent to GOI.


Addl. Agenda Item No.9. Clarification sought regarding Break during

internship training.

It was noted that a letter has been received from the Tamil Nadu Dr. MGR Medical

University in respect of break during internship mentioned in regulations. It is

further stated to furnish the following particulars.

1. Whether the internship training in BUMS should be done continuously (or)

any break in Internship training is allowed by Central Council of Indian

Medicine.

2. If allowed, is there any duration of break in internship training which is

allowed by Central Council of Indian Medicine.

3. Whether the candidate is eligible for any leave period during Internship

training. If yes, the period of leave entitled may kindly be clarified.

4. If the break is allowed, whether the Internship training period can be

extended for the period of break in training.

27184ec

5. Whether piecemeal Internship training in various departments is permitted

by Central Council of Indian Medicine.

6. If the piecemeal Internship training is not permitted, then whether the

student who has done piecemeal training for more than two departments

and not obtained prior condition order from the University, has to re-do the entire Internship training or not.

In this regard it is further submitted that there are no details regarding break

during Internship period in the notified concerned UG regulations.

Executive Committee decided to defer the matter to next meeting.

Addl. Agenda Item No.10. Visitation of College in view of proposals

received under Section 13A of IMCC Act,

1970 for LOI.

It was noted that according to the “Establishment of New Medical College, Opening

of New or Higher Course of Study or Training and Increase of Admission Capacity

by a Medical College Regulations, 2003” dated 15th March, 2004, for making an application under sub-regulation (2) of regulation 4 (copy enclosed), a medical

college shall be eligible if, -

(a) has obtained the permission of the concerned State Government or the Union

Territory Administration (Form- 4);

(b) has obtained the concurrence of the University established under any Central

or State Statute (Form- 5);

Some Colleges had initially sent the NOC & Consent for Affiliation issued before

2010 without mentioning the validity. When asked to furnish latest NOC & Affiliation, they have again forwarded the same documents on behalf of

compliance stating that there is no provision of issuing new NOC/ Consent in

their State. Four such examples are listed below:

1. Shree Ram Charitable Trust, Dhanvantri Ayurved College, Kajiya(Koydam)

Gujarat

2. Pacific College of Ayurved & research Centre, Gorakhpur, U.P. 3. Govt. Akhandanand Ayurved Mahavidyalaya, Ahmedabad.

4. Shubhdeep Ayurvedic Medical College & Hospital, Village-Datoda, Khandwa

Road, Indore, Madhya Pradesh.

Some Colleges have requested for 60 days time to furnish the latest NOC and

Consent for Affiliation. Two such examples are listed below:

1. Hon. Shri Annasaheb Dange Ayurved Medical, and Post Graduate Training

Research Centre, Ashta, Sangli, Maharashtra

28184ec

2. Loknete Rajarambapu Patil Ayurvedic medical College, Hospital, PG Institute

& Research Centre, Sangli, MS

In case of Government Colleges, they have not submitted the land papers of

land likely to be allotted in near future (ex. Govt. College, Bilaspur).

Executive Committee decided as under:

(i). state NOC and consent for affiliation that have been issued without

mentioning any validity period on it, be considered as valid as in many States, it is issued only once.

(ii) If number of seats are not mentioned in NOC/affiliation then number

of seats as mentioned in proposal forwarded by Govt. of India be considered.

Addl. Agenda Item No.11 . Regarding Permission to continue PhD.

It was noted that a representation has been received from Dr. Shamshad Bano,

Assistant Registrar (Unani) stating that she joined the CCIM on 23.06.2009 as Unani Expert. Before joining in CCIM, she was working as Senior Researcher on a

consolidated salary for CIUI, R&D Extension Projects Office (HNF), Jamia Hamdard,

New Delhi and simultaneously was enrolled for pursuing PhD in interdisciplinary studies. She had already completed about one and half year of PhD before joining

the CCIM. Now, she intends to continue her PhD. She has submitted that all

necessary research work for PhD will be done after office hours, during Saturdays

& Sundays and other holidays. Further, the office work will not hamper by doing so. Therefore, she has requested to allow her for the same and issue NOC in this

regard.

Executive Committee agreed to allow the Assistant Registrar (Unani) to

continue her Ph.D. and NOC to be issued as requested for.

Addl. Agenda Item No.12 . Disciplinary/Penal Actions to be taken

against the false experience of teaching

staffs.

It was noted that letter dated 11.06.2013 received from Dr. Surendra S. Wadikar

requesting same information under RTI Act 2005, regarding the Disciplinary/Penal

Actions to be taken against the teachers and the colleges, if on perusal of the

records, it is found that a given teacher is shown by colleges as teaching staff

(regular, temporary or on contract basis) at the time of inspection without he / she

actually working there and appearing only at the time of inspection or is drawing

salary without teaching there just to lend his/her name for the college for the

inspection purpose only.

Kindly also furnish the authenticated copies of the rules and regulations and the

Acts (Central and/or State in this case Maharastra) and notifications and orders

29184ec

regarding the disciplinary/penal actions to be taken against the defaulter teachers

and colleges.

Executive Committee referred the matter to teachers’ Screening

Committee.

Addl. Agenda Item No.13 . Adoption of self-certification provision for

attestation of documents furnished for

obtaining registration/enrolment

certificates.

It was noted that an OM No.Z.28015/66/2013-P&C(AYUSH) dated 01.7.2013 has

been received from Under Secretary to the Government of India, Ministry of

Health & Family Welfare, Deptt. of AYUSH, New Delhi regarding Self-certification

of documents in which the undersigned enclosed a copy of Department of

Administrative Reforms & Public Grievances for necessary action and

compliance.

The enclosed O.M. No.K.11022/67/2012-AR dated 10.5.2013 of Govt. of India,

Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Department of

Administrative Reforms & Public Grievances regarding Self-certification reads as

under:

“The Second Administrative Reforms Commissions in its 12th Report titled “Citizen

Centric Administration - The Heart of Governance”, has recommended adoption of

self-certification provision for simplifying procedures. (www.darpg.gov.in)

2. Taking a cue from this some Ministries/State Governments have adopted the

provision of self-certification of documents like marksheet, birth certificate etc. by

the applicants/stakeholders instead of asking for an attested copy of the

documents by the Gazetted Officer or filing of affidavits. Under the self attestation

method, the original documents are required to be produced at the final stage.

3. You will appreciate that the above methods is citizen friendly and obtaining

either an attested copy or affidavit not only cost money but also involves wastage

of time of the citizens and the Government officials.

It is requested to kindly review the existing requirements of attested copy of

affidavit in various application forms in a phased manner and wherever

possible make provision for self-certification of documents, after obtaining

the approval of the competent authority.

Therefore it was noted that, a provision for self-certification of documents may be

adopted for the attestation of copies of certificates/documents furnished by the

practitioners while applying for registration/enrolment certificate.

30184ec

Executive Committee agreed to adopt the self-certification provision for

attestation of documents furnished for obtaining registration/enrolment

certificates.

Addl. Agenda Item No.14. Request to allow Asst. Registrars to

participate in various seminar, conference,

etc. of respective systems.

It was noted that a representation has been received from all the three Asst.

Registrars of Ayurveda, Siddha & Unani stating that they are working in the CCIM

as Asst. Registrar and dealing with all technical matters of the respective systems

of Indian Medicine. Along with technical matters, there are other works of

administrative nature allotted to them by the office. As in general, there are CME

programme, ROTP programme conducted by several institutions for AYUSH doctors

throughout the country for proper updating of knowledge in respective systems

and medical science. Apart from that, there are several conferences, seminars,

symposiums and workshops at National and International level in ISM. As it will be

better to update knowledge in respective systems and general medical science and

research etc., they wish to participate in the said programmes as a representative

of CCIM.

Executive Committee decided to allow to all the three Assistant Registrars

of Ayurved/Unani/Siddha to participate various seminars, conferences,

workshops etc. upto a limit of three per year. However, limit can be

extended subjects to the approval of EC. Further, all Ayurveda, Unani and

Siddha Experts are allowed to attend the seminar upto the limit of one per

year.

Addl. Agenda Item No. 15. Consideration of Research experience at par

with Teaching experience for recruitment of

teaching posts in different academic

institutions and Universities of

Ayurveda/Siddha/Unani-reg.

It was noted that a representation vide No. 09/2013 dated 01.11.2013 from the

President of “CCRAS Scientist Welfare Association” has been received in the office

of CCIM requesting to take necessary steps to include the Research Experience at

par with the Teaching Experience as being practiced by the premier organizations

of the country as referred to above for the betterment of the Indian Systems of

Medicine as well as to provide the enhancement of the opportunity to the students

to build up their acumen by getting highly experienced teacher in their respective

fields.

Executive Committee referred the matter to Regulation Amendment

Committee.

31184ec

Addl. Agenda Item No.16 . Request to consider work experience of

Asst. Registrar as teaching experience in

respective systems.

It was noted that a representation has been received from all the three Asst.

Registrars of Ayurveda, Siddha & Unani stating that they are working in the CCIM

as Asst. Registrar and deal with all technical matters regarding education in

respective systems of Indian Medicine. Though, they deal with all technical matters

in respective system, their work experience in this Council was not taken into

account either teaching or research. They requested to consider their work

experience at par with teaching experience.


Committee.

Addl. Agenda Item No.17. Disclosure of personal details of the

teaching Staffs and certified copies under

RTI Act 2005.

It was noted that there are several RTI applications requesting to provide teaching

staff details or visitation reports of ASU Colleges. In this connection, as per RTI Act

2005, the personal details of the persons such as PAN card No, Bank Account No,

Phone No. / Mobile No. may not be disclosed. This may be implemented if agreed.

It was further noted that the Council receives several RTI applications to provide

certified copies of documents from various sections of this office, therefore the

Head/Incharge of the Sections i.e., Assistant Registrar (Ayurveda), Assistant

Registrar (Unani), Assistant Registrar(Siddha), Assistant Secretary (Admn),

Registration Officer I/C may be authorised to certify the copies of documents

supplied from their respective sections to establish the authenticity of the

documents.

Executive Committee decided to follow the relevant Section of RTI Act,

2005 in respect of not disclosing the personal details. A letter may also be

written to Central Information Commission for clarification

Addl. Agenda Item No.18. Introducing Residency programme in

Ayurveda Vachaspati Course (MD

Ayurveda)-reg.

It was noted that Introducing Residency programme in Ayurveda Vachaspati

Course (MD Ayurveda) was discussed in the 46th meeting of Ayurved Committee

held on 04.04.2013 as under:-

32184ec

“I appreciate the efforts made by the CCIM to improve the standard of Ayurveda

education under your esteemed leadership. As you are aware lot of changes are

happening in the field of Medical Education especially in the specialty health care.

The things which are beneficial to our system shall be introduced so as to go along

with the developments in the education system.

Recently a new system of Residency Programme is introduced by IMC and the

same has implemented in the Medical College of Kerala. The crux of the

programme is „Learning by Doing. The Post Graduate scholars will be considered as

the first level managers of the specialty health care and they are given emergency

duties, continuous patient care, on-call duties, and duties as junior consultant to

other departments, conduct teaching programmes to undergraduate medical,

nursing and paramedical staff etc. They are also permitted to issue Death

Certificates, Medical Certificates and Treatment Certificates. In emergency

situations they can admit, treat and discharge the patients without having any

consultation with the senior faculties, and full responsibility of the treatment of the

patients under their care shall vest with the residents in this regard.

The residency programme the individual patient care is considerably increased and

confident level of the PG‟s also improved. It is also noted that the manpower

shortage is one of the major issues in our institutions. The teaching and training

also need improvement. So a similar programme shall be introduced in our system

also.

In Kerala all Post Graduate students were given same stipend but after

implementing Residency programme the modern medicine PG‟s were given higher

pay and declared that the same will be given to Ayurveda as and when CCIM

suggests the new programme.

So it is a necessity in Ayurveda to implement Residency programme in Ayurveda

Vachaspati course. Hence you may please take necessary steps to place the matter

before the council to included the programme in the PG regulation.

Ayurveda Committee unanimously passed the above resolution.”

However, as per representation of Dr. VG Udayakumar, EC Member, the matter

was re-submitted for consideration.


Committee.

33184ec

Addl. Agenda Item No.19. University Grace Marks given for National

Service Scheme (NSS) in final BAMS examination-reg.

It was noted that University Grace Marks given for National Service Scheme (NSS)

in final BAMS examination was discussed in 46th Ayurved Committee in its meeting

held on 04.04.2013 as under:-

“It was noted that Many Universities are granting “Grace Marks‟ to the students

those who are participating NSS activities in the final examinations. But most of

the Universities are not granting this mark to BAMS students stating that there is

no specific instruction from CCIM. Few Universities such as Maharashtra University

of Health Science, University of Kerala, and Mahatma Gandhi University are giving

the same to BAMS students. This will cause major disparities among students.

As we are in the field of health service the aptitude in social service is essential for

all medical students. So participation in the NSS activities should be promoted in

national level. If the University statute allows grace marks for NSS activities, the

Ayurveda/Siddha/Unani students those who are attending the same should also

get benefited. So I request the council to pass appropriate direction to all

Universities in this regard.

Ayurveda Committee decided to write to the State Universities about their

existing practice in awarding grace marks/moderation marks relative with

NSS activities and opinion in this regard.”

However, as per representation of Dr. VG Udayakumar, EC Member the matter was

re-submitted for consideration.


Committee.

Addl. Agenda Item No.20. Regarding representation forwarded by

Prof. K.K. Sijoria, Principal, A & U Tibbia

College & Hospital, Karol Bagh, New Delhi

for clarification regarding Non-PG teachers.

It was noted that letter reference F.5(6)/2013-CO/755 dated 29.08.2013 received

from Principal of Ayurvedic & Unani Tibbia college, Karol Bagh regarding Non- PG

teachers. College asked for following clarification:-

a. Whether Non-PG teacher can teach the PG scholars at present.

b. Whether Non-PG teacher can be promoted in higher posts as present.

c. Whether PG qualification are essential for the teacher appointed before 01.07.1989 & possessing only graduate qualification for their promotion

/appointment after 01.07.1989.

34184ec

In this regard the legal opinion was taken and legal consultant advised as under:-

1. In letter dated 29.08.2013 of Principal, A & U Tibbia college & Hospital

clarification has been sought over certain points mentioned therein.

2. In respect of point „a‟ of letter dated 29.08.2013 there is no mention in

Regulation 1989 as to whether non PG teachers can teach PG scholars or not,

however on view of specific mention of application of 1989 Regulation to teaching

staff appointed after 01.07.1989 only, non PG teachers appointed prior to

01.07.1989 may be considered to teach PG scholars considering their experience in

the subject concerned.

3. In respect of points „b & c‟ of letter dated 29.08.2013, it was noted that non

PG teacher appointed prior to 01.07.1989 can be promoted to higher posts as per

their experience. Clause 14 of regulation 1989 speaks about qualification &

experience for teaching staff having caption therein “applicable for recruitments

made after 01.07.1989”. Therefore it is clear that regulation 1989 is applicable is

respect of appointments and promotions made after 01.07.1989. Thus for

promotion PG qualification is not essential for teachers appointed before

01.07.1989.

Further, the matter was placed before screening committee held on 31.10.2013 &

01.11.2013. Comments of screening committee are as under:- “while verifying this matter the Non PG teachers appointed prior to 01.07.1989 can

be promoted to higher posts as per their experience mention in the regulation (UG)

2012, and may be considered to teach PG scholars considering their continuous

experience in concern subject”.

Executive Committee directed to defer the matter to next meeting.

Addl. Agenda Item No.21. Matter related to grant of permission to

Govt. Ayurved Medical College, Moti Bagh,

Patiala (Punjab) for the academic session

2013-14 –reg.

It was noted that letter with reference no 17011/172/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 11.11.2013 and 12.11.2013 received from Govt. of India regarding grant of

permission to Govt. Ayurved Medical College, Patiala (Punjab) for the academic

session 2013-14 in which Govt. of India requested that CCIM may clarify that intake capacity of the said college is for only UG or UG along with PG course and

also clarify that as to why the recommendation in respect of only UG course are

sent to Department and what are the recommendations of the CCIM regarding PG courses for the session 2013-14.

35184ec

In this regard, with the approval of President, CCIM, the letters with reference no

4-61/2013-Ay. dated 12.11.2013 and 13.11.2013 have been sent to the Govt. of India as under respectively:-

“With reference to your letter no. 17011/172/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 11.11.2013, I am

directed to say that the intake capacity for UG seats of above said college is 40 seats and

08 seats in 02 PG courses i.e. Rasashastra -04 seats & Dravyaguna -04 seats as per the

record available. However, status of the said college for the last five years is as under:-

Sl.

No.

Session Recommendation by CCIM Permission by GOI

1. 2008-09 Not Recommended with ref. no. 4-

61/2008 Ay. dated 25.06.2008

Decided not to grant permission for admission

to the UG course with ref. no. R. 17011/179/2006-EP dated 29.08.2008.

2. 2009-10 Recommended for UG 40 seats with ref. no. 4-61/2009 Ay. Dated 22.04.2009

Granted conditional permission for taking admission to BAMS course 40 seats with ref.

no. R. 17011/172/2009-EP dated 10.08.2009.

3. 2010-11 Not recommended for UG & PG. with ref. no. 4-61/2010-Ay. Dated

01.07.2010

Granted conditional permission for taking admission to BAMS course 40 seats with ref.

no. R. 17011/172/2009-EP dated 22.09.2010.

4. 2011-12 Not recommended for UG & PG. with

ref. no. 4-61/2011-Ay. Dated 30.05.2011

Denial of permission for taking admission to

BAMS course 40 seats and 08 seats in 02 PG courses namely Rasashastra -04 seats &

Dravyaguna -04 seats with ref. no. R. 17011/172/2011-EP (IM-1) dated 29.08.2011.

5. 2012-13 Not recommended for UG with ref. no. 4-61/2012-Ay. 12.04.2012

Denial of permission for taking admission to BAMS course 40 seats and 02 PG course

namely Rasashastra -04 seats & Dravyaguna -04 seats with ref. no. R. 17011/172/2012-EP

(IM-1) dated 16.07.2012.

Moreover, in respect of session 2013-14 CCIM has “Not recommended for UG course” and the decision of Govt. of India is awaited.”

“In continuation to letter reference no. 4-61/2013 –Ay. Dated 02.07.2013 & 12.11.2013

and your letter reference no. 17011/172/2013-EP (IM-1) dated 12.11.2013, I am directed

to say that as per record available in the CCIM office of the said college the college has not

been permitted by Govt. of India for PG course from the session 2007-08 onwards.

Further, as college does not fulfill the criteria for granting conditional permission for UG &

PG course, therefore, the college is not recommended for PG for the session 2013-14 due

to following reasons:-

1. Bed occupancy is only 15.2 % against the requirement of 50% for PG College.

2. There is no teaching faculty in 4 departments. 3. There are 210 instruments against the requirement of 311.

4. Higher faculty is only in 4 departments against the requirement of 11 departments.

5. 116 per day OPD patients are available from 19.07.2012 to 31.12.2012 against the requirement of 120 per day.

This issues with the approval of Competent Authority.”


36184ec

Addl. Agenda Item No.22. Teacher considered eligible in screening

committee held on 30.07.2013

It was noted that matter regarding eligibility of teachers was placed before

Executive committee in its 181th meeting under agenda item no. 9.

On the basis of decision of EC, files seen by Screening Committee were marked to

President, CCIM and President directed to put the matter before EC:

Sl.

No.

Name of teacher Department Designation Remarks of screening

committee

1. Dr. Pallavi Prabhakar Jamnekar

(N-154)

Rasashastra Lecturer Eligible from 21.09.2011

2. Dr. Lalit Chaudhary

(N-183)

Shalya Tantra Lecturer Eligible from 01.05.2007

3. Dr. Sandhya Madhukar

Yannawar (N-133)

Prasuti Tantra Reader Eligible

4. Dr. Arvind Kumar (N-182)

Kayachikitsa Lecturer Eligible from 01.05.2007

5. Yogendra Nath Pandey Kayachikitsa Reader Eligible

Executive Committee approved the decision of Screening Committee in

respect of above teachers.

Addl. Agenda Item No.23. Audit Report for the year 2012-13 -Reg.

It was noted that the Accounts of the CCIM, New Delhi for the year 2012-13 were

audited by the team of the Director General of Audit Central Revenues, New Delhi

from 11.9.2013 to 17.09.2013. The Audit Report and the Audit Certificate has been

received.

In this connection, it is further submitted that the Audit Certificate has to be

incorporated in the Annual Report of the Council to be placed before both the

Houses of Parliament.

The Executive Committee noted and approved the same.

Addl. Agenda Item No.24. Enhancement of consolidated salary of

Ayurveda, Unani and Siddha Experts.

It was noted that a representation dated 04.11.2013 has been received from Dr.

Rasik Javaid, Senior Unani Expert stating that he joined the Council on 29.04.2013

and after 03 months, the contract was renewed for further 11 months i.e. upto

30.06.2014. He has also referred to the minutes of 163rd Meeting of EC (Addl.

Agenda Item No. 01) and requested to enhance his consolidated salary with an

enhancement of Rs. 10,000/- PM after competition of 06 months.

37184ec

In this connection, it was noted that Dr. Rasik Javaid has completed 06 months on

contractual service in October, 2013 and as per decision of 163rd meeting of EC as

referred to above, an enhancement of Rs. 10,000/- PM will be due from the month

of Nov. 2013. President I/c, CCIM directed to process and act in accordance with

the aforesaid decision of the EC.

Executive Committee deferred the matter to next meeting with all details

in respect of time to time increase in emoluments of Experts.

Addl. Agenda Item No. 25. To establish the eligibility of the candidate of

Uzbekistan admitted in RA Podar Ayurved

College, Mumbai passing the General

Secondary School Certificate Examination in

2000 and Diploma from an accredited Medical

College on Uzbekistan from 2003-2006.

In continuation of Agenda Item No. 5, it is further submitted that a letter is

forwarded by Govt. of India alongwith representation of MUHS, Nasik regarding the

letter forwarded by Association of Indian University with reference No.

EVIII(5)/2012 dated 30.10.2012 mentioning that “the candidate has passed the

General Secondary School Certificate Examination in 2000 which represents 10

years of school education in Uzbekistan. The candidates after completion of 10

years of school education are eligible to pursue Diploma duration for which is 3-5

years. The candidate pursued 03 years of diploma from an accredited medical

college, Uzbekistan from 2003-2006 after secondary school education. Making a

combined assessment of her qualifications i.e. 10+3 her candidature can be

accepted. As regards her eligibility and equivalence with +2 level qualification, her

candidature can be decided by the admission giving University/college keeping in

mind her 3 years of Diploma in the field of Medicine.

Further, a letter of AIU with reference No. EV/VIII(5)/2013/2339 dated 19.03.2013

in which AIU mentioned that “as per information available with us, the school

education in earlier USSR and now CIS countries is of 11 years duration for which

AIU do not issue Equivalence Certificate as the corresponding school education in

India is of 12 years, which is the minimum eligibility requirement for admission to

Bachelor Degree programme.”

Further, in this regard a letter is forwarded by Govt. of Maharashtra issued by

Director of Lal Bhadur Shastri Centre for Indian Culture Embassy of India,

Tashkent. In which mention as under:-

“ 1. Ms. Nodirahon Ashurova passed the class ten exam in the year 2000 which in

the old Soviet System is equivalent to 10+2 all over the world.

38184ec

2.After that she has completed 3 years of Specialized College (High School) thus

she has completed 10+3 years of School in this manner, which is even better than

10+2.

In light of these it is clear that she fulfills the criterion for admission which is 10+2.

Also, the equivalence of school qualification is determined by Department of

Personnel Ministry of Home Affairs or CBSE and not by AIU or CSIM.”

Please refer the decision of EC at Agenda item No. 5.

Addl. Agenda Item No.26. To introduce file tracking system in office of

CCIM-reg.

It was noted that files and daks of the office remain in movement between the

officials in the channel. Sometimes, files in the movement are not traceable and a

considerable time is wasted in finding the exact location of file and hence delaying

in the disposal of the matter.

Therefore, it was suggested that a file tracking system may be introduced in the

office of CCIM for smooth functioning of the office.

Executive Committee agreed to introduce the File Tracking System (FTS)

in the office of CCIM.

Addl. Agenda Item No.27. Interim court order by the Punjab and

Haryana High Court.

It was noted that an interim order has been passed by the Punjab and Haryana High

Court, Chandigarh on 14th November 2013 for the CWP-23288-2013, Shree Lakshmi

Narayan Ayurvedic College Vs the Union of India and others stated that, the

inspection team members namely Dr. Jageshwar Prasad Chaurasia, Dr. B.

Sreenivasa Prasad and Prof. K. Shankar Rao constituted by the respondent 2(CCIM)

are to be present in the Court on 22.11.2013 in order to confirm the authenticity of

their signatures available in the OPD registers of the petitioner college. The

expenses of their travelling by air, lodging and boarding at Chadigarh shall borne by

the petitioner. The the amount, if any, shall be paid on 22.11.2013. The copy of the

court order may be petitioner is directed to deposit a tentative amount of Rs.

70,000/-, as an interim measure, with the counsel of respondent no. 2 forthwith for

the aforesaid purpose.

Executive Committed note the same.

Meeting concluded with a vote of thanks to the Chair.

CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHIccimindia.org/meeting_file/pdf/pdf/ec_18-11-2013.pdf ·...

Documents

Transcript of CENTRAL COUNCIL OF INDIAN MEDICINE NEW DELHIccimindia.org/meeting_file/pdf/pdf/ec_18-11-2013.pdf ·...