Causes of Extremism in South Asia
Transcript of Causes of Extremism in South Asia
-
8/8/2019 Causes of Extremism in South Asia
1/3
Causes of extremism in South Asia-Pakistan
News & ArticlesAdd commentsFeb 142008
Muhammad Munir
The Oxford Advanced Learners Dictionary describes extremism as political, religious etc.
ideas or actions that are extreme and not normal, reasonable or acceptable to most people. Inother words, extremism is a term used to describe the actions or ideologies of individuals or
groups outside the perceived political center of a society; or otherwise claimed to violate
common standards of ethics and reciprocity. It is typically used in reference to political and
social ideologies seen as irrational, counterproductive, unjustifiable, or otherwise unacceptable toa civil society. The term indicates the illegitimacy of certain ideas or methods. According to
Merriam Webster dictionary, Extremism is a quality or state of being extreme, especially
advocacy of extreme political measures .It can also be described as a, political theory favouring
immoderate, uncompromising policies.Extremism is closely associated with terrorism, as the rise of extremism can also lead to increase
in terrorist agendas. It is not a religion. It is not Islam. . It may be better defined as a politicalagenda seeking justification in religion. Normally extremism and terrorism are considered
exchangeable words. In reality they are not. Terrorism is a physical act, whereas extremism is a
state of mind. Terrorists resort to violence in order to achieve their objectives. Extremist preachand convince others to follow their thoughts.
There exists a clear linkage between the lack of human security and the phenomenon of
extremism. Rise in extremism can lead to human insecurity and vice versa. The governments of
South Asian states have not been able to provide their people with the basic, minimum humansecurity since these states became independent. Governments and ruling classes, instead of
focusing on dealing with the issues of human survival and development, embarked uponperpetuating their power and influence. Subsequently, no South Asian country has been able tofree itself from discriminatory and exploitative policies, which increased insecurity and led to the
rising number of communal and terrorist outfits. Despite the problems these outfits have created,
no serious efforts were made by the governments or the civil society to curtail the rise inextremist trends at the initial stages. All of the regional states are facing the menace of
extremism and terrorism in one or other form.
The South Asian region currently faces grave security threats due to the increasing extremism
and terrorism. There are various factors that have led towards this situation.The politics of violence and extremism in South Asia is mainly the result of faulty national
policies and interference of external powers. The regions vast potential is hostage to unresolved
inter-state and intra-state conflicts. In most of the states, the governments (either democratic ormilitary) have failed in providing good governance and solving social problems such as
unemployment, social injustice, and poverty. The political culture in these states was unable to
meet the imperatives of globalization. In addition, instead of promoting unity and integration(both at national and regional levels) it led to ethnic solidarities and identification with religion
and culture. The main causes of Extremism are appended below: Extra-regional actors are
primarily responsible for the ongoing wave of terrorism and rising extremism. To counter Sovietintervention in Afghanistan in 1979, the United States supported and sponsored the Pakistani
http://www.opfblog.com/433/causes-of-extremism-in-south-asia-pakistan/http://www.opfblog.com/category/news-articles/http://www.opfblog.com/433/causes-of-extremism-in-south-asia-pakistan/#respondhttp://www.opfblog.com/category/news-articles/http://www.opfblog.com/433/causes-of-extremism-in-south-asia-pakistan/#respondhttp://www.opfblog.com/433/causes-of-extremism-in-south-asia-pakistan/ -
8/8/2019 Causes of Extremism in South Asia
2/3
government and also the Jihadi groups during the period 1979-1989, which in post-1990 period
became a threat for the security and stability of Pakistan. After Soviet withdrawal and
diminishing of US interests in the region, Pakistan was left in a complete lurch for dealing withthe menace of terrorism and extremism spread over the decade of its war against Soviets. With
the 9/11 incident, Pakistan once again became a frontline state in the war against terrorism. The
renewed interference by US in Pakistan, and Pakistans support against Taliban and Al-Qaeda inAfghanistan once again aggravated the extremist and anti-US elements, having extensive
implications on internal security situation. The extremist trends have been boosted in the South
Asian countries due to the interference by the by neighboring and extra-regional countries in theinternal affairs of the states. The separatist and ethnic movements have also been supported from
across the border, by the governments or any particular group, for its interests. Like the Tamil
rebels group in Sri Lanka, is known to have links and has received support and been sponsored
by the Indian government and the ethnic Tamil population in India. Similarly the Maoist inNepal is known to have collaboration and sponsorship from India. The Kashmiri separatist
movement in India has received support from the Pakistan. And the Bangla national movement,
which, resulted in partition of Pakistan and formation of Bangladesh, was also strongly aided by
Indian government.Poor economic growth along with high population growth has led to the problems of mass
unemployment, hunger and income inequality. The economic inequalities and deprivation hascreated frustration and insecurity among the masses, leading to an increasing criminalization of
society in which there are available targets for exploitation by the extremist elements in and
outside the governments. Along with the deteriorating economies of South Asia, governmental
policies have accentuated the extremist trend in all these states. Governments, in these countries,whether civil or military, have used the religion and ethnic card, in order to prolong and
strengthen their rule, further strengthening the fundamentalists and extremists in the society.
There were several factors and events that have led to extremism, sectarianism and terrorism inPakistan. These factors include : First the impact of regional events like Iranian revolution,
Afghan Jihad and emergence of Taliban; second Islamisation process by general Zia-ul-Haq in
the late 70s and 80s; third impact of Freedom Struggle in Kashmir and Palestine issue; fourth9/11 and events thereafter like US war on terror including Pakistans u-turn on its policy towards
Taliban and joining Coalition/US forces as a Frontline state in war on terrorism; fifth Pakistans
Arms Forces operations in FATA and US strikes in these areas including Lal Masid Operationand backlash in terms of increased number of suicide attacks on Armed Forces, Police and VIPs,
extensions of Taliban infiltration and influence in settled areas-Swat in NWFP and sectarian
crisis in Parachinar
Short term and long term strategies have been put in place to control extremism. The short termmeasures include: first, eviction of foreign elements brought by USA and other countries to fight
USSR and pacification of local supporters, of then the mujahiddin , and now referred to as
militants; second ban on militant organizations, third, ban on hate material and check on misuseof mosque and loudspeaker. The long term strategy focuses on Madrassah reforms, revision of
curriculum to bring it in line with the values of Islam and national discourse on real essence of
Islam. Pakistan needs to adjust her policies regarding extremism and terrorism keeping in viewcurrent realities. Perhaps minimum use of force with more focus on political and economic
components would be an appropriate strategy. The action reaction and reaction-action kind of
activities will never end until the strategy of fighting terror does not change.Closing down
madrassas will not prevent extremism. It would only trigger more hatred and furious reaction.
-
8/8/2019 Causes of Extremism in South Asia
3/3
The best solution would be to bring madrassas back into the mainstream, where students are
allowed to get both religious education as well as a modern education.
The way out of the current impasse as suggested by President Musharraf is EnlightenedModeration which is essentially a strategy of social reforms. On the one hand, Muslim countries
should assume the responsibility for internal reforms, avoid extremism and confrontation and
ensure economic and social development, through ensuring respect for human right and payingspecial attention to human resource development programmes. The West particularly the United
States on the other hand should seek to resolve all political disputes that become breeding
grounds of terrorism, reject equating Islam with terrorism and assist the Muslim world in povertyalleviation and socio-economic development.
The writer works for Islamabad Policy Research Institute (IPRI)
Courtesy: Pakistan Observer, 14/2/2008
Ref: http://www.opfblog.com/433/causes-of-extremism-in-south-asia-pakistan/
http://www.opfblog.com/433/causes-of-extremism-in-south-asia-pakistan/http://www.opfblog.com/433/causes-of-extremism-in-south-asia-pakistan/