Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics...
Transcript of Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics...
![Page 1: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Case Studies of Fraud in China
Behind the Financials
17 November 2014
![Page 2: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
■ Brief Introduction
■ Setting the Scene
■ Overview of Red Flags for China Companies
■ Risk Groups
■ How to Mitigate Risk
Agenda
− 2 −
![Page 3: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
FTI Consulting: A Leader Among Leaders
3
FCN Publicly traded
$2.2 BLN NYSE listed enterprise value
1982 Year founded
4,200+ Employees worldwide
450+ Senior Managing Directors
2 Nobel Laureates
10/10 Advisor to the world’s
top 10 bank holding
companies
95/100 Advisor to 95 of the
world’s top 100 law
firms
55/100 55 of Fortune 100
corporations are clients
16 Experts in 16 industry
specialties
78 Offices in 78 cities around
the globe
![Page 4: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Advising Across a Global Economy
4
We deploy more than 3,100
professionals in 26 countries from
every major financial centre to every
corner of the globe so that we can
serve our clients wherever
challenges and opportunities arise.
Asia Pacific
Australia
Brisbane
Gold Coast
Melbourne
Perth
Sydney
China
Beijing
Guangzhou
Hong Kong
Shanghai
India
Mumbai
New Delhi
Indonesia
Jakarta
Japan
Tokyo
Philippines
Manila
Singapore
Europe, Middle
East, Africa
Belgium
Brussels
France
Paris
Germany
Berlin
Frankfurt
Ireland
Dublin
Qatar
Doha
Russia
Moscow
South Africa
Cape Town
Johannesburg
Spain
Madrid
United Arab
Emirates
Abu Dhabi
Dubai
United Kingdom
London
Stirling
Latin America
Argentina
Buenos Aires
Brazil
Rio de Janeiro
São Paulo
Caribbean
British Virgin Islands
Cayman Islands
Colombia
Bogotá
Mexico
Mexico City
Panama
Panama City
North America
Canada
Calgary
Toronto
Vancouver
United States
Annapolis
Atlanta
Baltimore
Boston
Brentwood
Charlotte
Chicago
Coral Gables
Dallas
Denver
Great Neck
Houston
Indianapolis
Los Angeles
McLean
Miami
Mountain View
New York
Oakland
Pasadena
Philadelphia
Phoenix
Pittsburgh
Portland
Princeton
Red Bank
Rockville
Roseland
Saddle Brook
San Francisco
Santa Barbara
Seattle
Tucson
Walnut Creek
Washington, D.C.
Wayne
West Palm Beach
Winston-Salem
![Page 5: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Global Risk and Investigations
FTI Consulting’s Global Risk and Investigations Practice is the leading provider of comprehensive business risk solutions including
reputational due diligence and other business intelligence, fraud and corporate investigations, data forensics and electronic evidence
recovery, brand protection, the strategic management of intellectual property and crisis containment services in Asia.
Whether the task is to determine the reputation and suitability of a business partner, untangle a complex fraud scheme, investigate
allegations of bribery or contain a business crisis, the aim of FTI Consulting is to provide our clients with critical information, insight and timely
solutions for informed decision-making.
The teams of seasoned professionals of our Global Risk and Investigations Practice in Asia are drawn from backgrounds in senior law
enforcement, academic and economic research, forensic accounting, information technology and investigative journalism.
What We Do
“Most corporate
investigators are
privately held and
publish little
financial
information…But
these days many
consider the best
in the business to
be FTI Consulting,
which also
happens to be the
only publicly
traded firm of any
size.”
Corporate intelligence:
The bloodhounds of
capitalism
The Economist
5 January 2013
Business Intelligence
Investigative due diligence
Pre-IPO due diligence
Political and business risk
assessments
Competitor assessments
Business intelligence in
corporate contest situations
Post transaction monitoring
Other business intelligence
and analysis
Fraud and Corporate
Investigations
Fraud investigations
FCPA and other corruption
related investigations
Asset searching
Data forensics & electronic
evidence recovery
Conflict of interest
investigations
Litigation support
Cyber crime investigations
Pre-employment integrity
investigations
Insurance claim investigations
Brand Integrity
Strategic management of
intellectual property
Investigations into IP losses
Investigations into licensing
disputes
Counterfeit investigations
Grey-market and parallel
trading investigations
Market surveys
Coordination of IP
enforcement
Printer packaging forensic
investigations
Royalty audits
Trademark agency
Other Risk Mitigation and
Consulting Services
Crisis containment consulting
Ethics hotline management
Employee exit risk
management
Threat assessments
Contingency planning
Security risk audits
Anti money laundering
consulting
5
![Page 6: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Setting the Scene
![Page 7: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Country Risks
7
…But Really Fraud is Everywhere
![Page 8: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Common Methods Overview
Definition of occupational fraud
■ “The use of one’s occupation for personal enrichment through the deliberate misuse or misapplication of
the employing organisation’s resources or assets.”
■ Asset Misappropriation
■ Bribery and Corruption
■ Financial Statement Fraud (e.g. earnings manipulation, fictitious transactions etc.)
8
Source: Association of Certified Fraud Examiners
![Page 9: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Common Methods Overview
Overstatement of revenue
■ Revenue overstatement may be from different forms of collusion, timing and recognition issues or outright
fake sales.
9
38%
12% 12% 8% 7% 7%
4%
12%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
Re
ve
nu
e R
eco
gn
itio
n
Ma
nip
ula
tio
n o
f
Exp
en
se
s
Imp
rop
er
Dis
clo
su
res
Ma
nip
ula
tio
n o
f
Lia
bilit
ies
Ma
nip
ula
tio
n o
f A
sse
ts
Ma
nip
ula
tio
n o
f
Re
se
rve
s
Bri
be
ry &
Kic
kb
ack
s
Oth
er
Types of Fraud Schemes
Source: Deloitte Review of SEC Enforcement Releases 2000-2008
![Page 10: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Common Methods
■ Creating excessively complicated and hard to untangle related-party transactions
■ Deliberately opaque companies in general, particularly in regards to corporate governance and internal
controls
■ Reporting phony bank balances (occasionally with the collusion of the bank itself) or using short-term
transfers to mislead auditors
■ Inflating the value of assets
■ Creating fake customers
■ Creating fake facilities, offices and staff numbers
10
Substantive fraud typically requires collusion with third
parties, from other companies to regulatory authorities
![Page 11: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Overview of Red Flags for China Companies
![Page 12: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Comparisons
■ Companies with a short track record – although beware of potentially misleading comparisons
■ Unusually high margins in comparison to peers
■ Unusually fast growth
■ Insufficient tax paid in comparison to reported profits
12
Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014
![Page 13: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Business Model
Overly complex management structures and unclear shareholder relationships
13
![Page 14: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Concerns Over Auditors and Quality of Financial Statements
Why audit doesn’t work
■ Auditors are a watchdog, not a bloodhound
■ Specific set of limited procedures to verify balances, not investigate potential misconduct
■ Audits seen as a commoditised, cheap, limited value adding process
Send out the debtor confirmation Check bank statements for receipts Verify against company records
14
Orient Power Electronic Ltd HKD JOURNAL LISTING Page *** Printed 01/01/2006 16:20
Journal Type: ALL Journal Source: ALL Journal Number: ALL Entry Period: 01/2004
To: 12/2004
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lne Account Account Name Trans Date Debit Credit Account A n a l y s i s C o d e s
No. Code Reference Due Date Description Amount Amount Period CO/BK TRANX CUST Model CUTY
Asset Asset Name Sub Code V/I/D
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Journal Number: 0024761 Type: BKRF Name: Entry Date: 24/03/2004 Source: G13
3 12017A C/A-Standard Chartered 26/03/2004 3,568,720.00DR 03/2004
BR0400230 26/03/2004 ADVICE SALES OF MATERIAL
4 8L010S Lucky Way Enterprise Ltd. 26/03/2004 3,568,720.00CR 03/2004
BR0400230 26/03/2004 ADVICE SALES OF MATERIAL
![Page 15: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Risk Groups
![Page 16: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Operational Risk
Corporate Governance
■ Close examination of the ownership of the company is crucial
■ Are they related? What is the full extent of the personal and professional connections between
management, directors and shareholders etc.?
■ Are they qualified?
■ How and why did they get into the industry?
■ Where did their first million come from?
■ Have there been several changes to management over time?
■ Any sudden changes?
■ What other business interests do management have?
16
![Page 17: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Operational Risk
Business models and financials
■ Continual shifting of investors’ focus by changes in business lines and new ventures
■ Serial acquisitions of other firms, particularly if these appear to be designed to make it difficult for an
independent observer to trace company acquisitions over time
■ Discrepancies between State Administration of Industry and Commerce (“SAIC”) filings and overseas
filings…READ the small print!
■ Filings that are delayed or entail different auditors
17
![Page 18: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Reputational and Regulatory Risks
■ Has the company been involved in any civil litigation, past or present?
■ Has the company been involved in any disputes with industry peers, local enterprises, associations,
industrial parks etc.?
■ What about disputes with staff? Or customers?
■ Has the company been involved in any environmental disputes?
■ Trademark and patent infringements?
■ Are key principals at the company currently under investigation by local regulatory authorities? Or more
seriously, the Party itself?
■ Have any fines or sanctions been levelled against the company and/or its key principals?
18
![Page 19: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
How to Mitigate Risk
![Page 20: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Risk Evaluation System
20
![Page 21: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
Risk Evaluation System (Cont.)
![Page 22: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
Risk Evaluation System (Cont.)
![Page 23: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Comprehensive Due Diligence
Investigative research and public records checks
■ There is a lot of information available in the public and semi-public domain in China
■ Press reports, trade journals, industry associations, corporate postings, local and provincial government
announcements etc.
■ Social media: industry-specific blogs, forums, profiles (professional and personal), advertisements etc.
■ Corporate records from the SAIC
■ Court records from district level up to Supreme Court
■ Bribery and Corruption database
■ Patents, land registration, tax payments, even hotel stays
23
Reputational DD
Financial Statements Review Commerical & Legal DD
![Page 24: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Comprehensive Due Diligence
Discreet inquiries
■ So-called human intelligence – can be invaluable in getting information between the lines
■ Industry associations, regulatory authorities, local bureaus
■ Industry peers, competitors, clients, suppliers, logistics partners
■ Former employees, industry analysts, journalists
■ (Discreet) site visits are often a crucial element of inquiries and can be extremely useful in verifying the
existence of facilities and assets, and establishing levels of activity within
24
![Page 25: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Comprehensive Due Diligence
Site Visit Example One
25 Confidential – Not For Further Dissemination
![Page 26: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Comprehensive Due Diligence
Site Visit Example Two
26 Confidential – Not For Further Dissemination
![Page 27: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
First Discreet Visit Overt Visit Follow up Discreet Visit
We observed that the signage of the
gas station reads Gas Station in our
initial discreet visit
During our overt visit, we observed
the gas signage was covered with a
banner which reads the name of the
Company
We identified the same gas station
in our subsequent discreet visit. We
note that the banner has been
removed
Comprehensive Due Diligence
Confidential – Not For Further Dissemination
Site Visit Example Three
27
![Page 28: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
First Discreet Visit Overt Visit Follow up Discreet Visit
A close up photograph
A close up photograph
A close up photograph
Confidential – Not For Further Dissemination
Site Visit Example Three
Comprehensive Due Diligence
28
![Page 29: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
First Discreet Visit Overt Visit Follow up Discreet Visit
We observed CNPC signage at the
office building next to Gas Station 1
Similar to the roof of gas station,
the office building adjacent to the
gas station has a banner which
reads the name of the Company
The banner had been removed
during our subsequent discreet visit
Confidential – Not For Further Dissemination
Comprehensive Due Diligence
Site Visit Example Three
29
![Page 30: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
First Discreet Visit Overt Visit Follow up Discreet Visit
We note that the gas pumps had
company stickers placed on them
during our overt visit; no Company
stickers were observed on the gas
pumps during both our discreet
visits
Confidential – Not For Further Dissemination
Comprehensive Due Diligence
Site Visit Example Three
30
![Page 31: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
First Discreet Visit Overt Visit Follow up Discreet Visit
Five of Gas Station 3’s official
documents hanging on the back
wall
Observed different set of
documents were found on the office
wall
No picture available
Confidential – Not For Further Dissemination
Site Visit Example Three
Comprehensive Due Diligence
31
![Page 32: Case Studies of Fraud in China - Association of Certified ...€¦ · Source: Anonymous Analytics Tianhe Report – September 2014 . Business Model Overly complex management structures](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022042209/5eacb9098216b03eb201f510/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
First Discreet Visit Overt Visit Follow up Discreet Visit
We observed business permits
hanging on the lobby wall
During our overt visit, the business
permits were removed from the
same wall
No photograph in office interior
available
Confidential – Not For Further Dissemination
Site Visit Example Three
Comprehensive Due Diligence
32