Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10...

29
Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement through Connecting Early Learning with Graduate Contexts Dr Sharon Darlington & Dr Louise Green (Clinical Science Educators Team) Faculty of Medicine, The University of Queensland ITaLI’s Teaching Masterclass Series

Transcript of Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10...

Page 1: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Case-basedLearning(CBL):ImprovingStudentEngagementthrough

ConnectingEarlyLearningwithGraduateContexts

DrSharonDarlington & DrLouiseGreen(ClinicalScienceEducatorsTeam)

FacultyofMedicine,TheUniversityofQueensland

ITaLI’s TeachingMasterclassSeries

Page 2: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Overview of Session

• WhatisCBL?WhyuseCBL?

• PracticalImplementationofCBL

• ChallengesandPotentialSolutions

Page 3: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

What is Case-based Learning (CBL)?

‘CBLisalearningandteachingapproachthataimstopreparestudentsforclinicalpractice,throughtheuseofauthenticclinicalcases.Thesecaseslinktheorytopractice,throughtheapplicationofknowledgetothecases,andencouragetheuseofinquiry-basedlearningmethods.’Theeffectivenessofcase-basedlearninginhealthprofessionaleducation, Thistlethwaite Jetal.MedicalTeacher,2012;34(6)e421-e444. www.bemecollaboration.org

?DoesCBL=Group-basedlearning

Page 4: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Why use Case-based Learning (CBL)?

Page 5: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

• Placesearlylearninginaclinical(graduate)context• Facilitatesintegrationofexistingknowledgewithnew

knowledge• Facilitatesintegrationofknowledgefrommultipledisciplines• Developclinical(critical)reasoningskills• Developskillsforworkingeffectivelyinhealth-careteams• Preparationforclinicalpractice• Themajorityofhealthprofessionalstudentsandteachersreport

thattheyenjoylearningviaCBL

Why use Case-based Learning (CBL) in the Medicine Program?

Page 6: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

CBL in the Medicine Program

• Graduateentry,4-year,DoctorofMedicine(MD)Program• CBListhecornerstoneofthecurriculuminyears1&2• 500studentsperyear->50CBLgroups• Groupsmeettwiceaweekfor2-2.5hourseachtutorial• Facilitatedbyanindustry-qualifiedtutor

Page 7: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Tutorial1

Commenceclinical‘case’relevanttoKLIs

ofweek

Groupidentificationof8-10‘FQ’s

Learningresources

Tutorial2

PresentationofFQs

Finalcasetriggersfordiscussionand

closure

CBL

PBL

Tutorial1

‘Main’clinical caserelevanttoKLIsof

week

RAPsessionwithidentificationof2-3

‘GIFT’s

Learningresources

Tutorial2

PresentationofGIFTs

2‘Additional’,related,pre-

preparedcases

Learningresources

CBL Cycle

RAP: Reflection&PlanningGIFTs:GroupIdentifiedFocusTasksFQs: FocusQuestions

Page 8: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Trigger 1• YouaretheinternondutyintheEmergencyDepartmentata

metropolitanhospitalwhenamaninhisearly30sisbroughttoyou.Helooksdistressedandisbendingoverwithbotharmswrappedaroundhisabdomen.HeapparentlyspeaksnoEnglish,butisaccompaniedbyamalefamilymemberwhopointstothepatient'sabdomenandsays“bellyache!"

Page 9: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

General ProcessCUES HYPOTHESES MECHANISMS NEEDTOKNOW GIFTS

MaleApprox.30yrsAbdopain

NoEnglishAccompaniedbyfamilymember

Systems/OrgansStomach;Smallintestine;Largeintestine;Liver;Gallbladder;Pancreas;Heart/Aorta;Kidneys;Reproductive

PathologicalprocessesVascular– ischaemiccolitisInfective- gastroenteritisInflammatory– Crohn’sNeoplastic– bowelcancer

Etc.

Location,nature,timing,severityAssociated- diarrhoea?- vomiting?- fever?- bleeding?PastmedicalhxMeds/allergies?Social&culturalbackgroundInterpreter?

Etc.

Neoplasticgrowth

Obstructedbowellumen

Build-upofgas/fluidproximally

Stimulationofstretchreceptors

Pain

Page 10: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Discussion Starters• Whatsystems/organsmayberesponsibleforthispatient’spain?• Howdoesvisceralpaindifferfromsomaticpain?• Whatshouldweaskwhentakingahistorytohelpusworkout

whattheproblemis?• Whatconstraintsareplacedonthehistory-takingprocessbythe

factthatthepatientisunabletospeakEnglish?• WhatadditionaldifficultiesfacepatientsofCALD(culturallyand

linguisticallydiverse)backgroundswhopresentformedicaltreatment?

Page 11: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

What our students say about CBL

Page 12: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

What our students say about CBL• “CBLsgetyouthinkingandapplyingprincipleslearnedinlecturesand

inlearningmaterials.Ilikethatmental/cognitiveexercise.”• “TheCBLcaselearninglinkedtothetopicsoftheweekallowed

practicalapplicationoftheweek’scontent.”• “CBLtutorialswerefantastic;agreatlearningopportunityandan

excellentwaytodevelopclinicalreasoning.”• “TheCBLsetupisbrilliant.Suchagoodenvironmentforlearning.”• “TheCBLsessionswereveryhelpfulfordeepeningmyunderstanding

ofthecoursematerial…”• “IreallyenjoyedtheCBLasIfeltithelpeddrawtogetherallthatwe

werelearningintotheclinicalenvironment.”

Page 13: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

What our students say about CBL

• “(CBL)seemedtoputintopracticewhatwelearnedinourlectureswhichisverydifferenttomostundergraduatecourses,asitmadeuscollateallthematerialinourmindswhichnotonlyhelpedthelearningbutalsostartedmakingusfeellike‘realdoctors’andasenseofwhatwe’reworkingtoward.”

Page 14: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

What our students say about CBL

• Removesthe‘tunnelvision’effectofPBL

• Moreopportunitiesfordevelopmentofclinicalreasoningskills

• Moreefficientutilisationoftime

• Enhancedstudentengagementandenjoyment“CBListhebestthingever!” Studentpreference

(n=225)

Page 15: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Alternate CBL settings?

• Individualstudentformat?Online?

Page 16: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers
Page 17: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Alternate CBL settings?

• Individualstudentformat?Online?• Team-basedLearningmodel?(TBL)

Page 18: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Team-based Learning

6

66

6 6 6

6 6 6

66

• Inlecture• Studentsine.g.10x

teamsof6• Triggerspresented

fromthefront• 2-3“roving”

facilitators

Page 19: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Practical Implementation of CBL

Page 20: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

1. Decide your setting• Learningenvironment

ØTutorial,lecture,online….

• GroupsizeØIndividual,pairs,smallvs.largegroup….

• FrequencyØ‘1plus2’model,weekly,endofcourse‘module’….

• FacilitationØLecturer,tutors,peer-led,written….

• Timeallocation

Page 21: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

2. Identify your objectives … and therefore your case

• “Startwiththeendinmind”• ConsiderLearningOutcomes• Considerpriorknowledge– pre-requisites,earlierlearninginthe

samecourse,whatpreparationwillbeset• Consideropportunityforintegration– withinowncourse,with

othercourses/disciplines• Considercommonandimportantgraduatescenarios

Page 22: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

For consideration …• Willyoumandateparticipation?• Willyouassess?

Page 23: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

3. Writing Your Scenario - Triggers • Keeptimeallocationinmindfromthestart

– MDprogramusuallyaround4triggersperhourinsmallgrouptutorialsetting

• Haveanoverallideaofthescenario:thinkobjectives&relevance– startwiththeskeleton,thenfleshitoutwiththedetails

• Keepinitialtriggerbroad;dripfeedwithsubsequenttriggers• Don’toverloadthetriggerswithinformationbutensureenough

isprovidedforstudentstoaddressobjectives(andisrealistic)• Providesomeformofscenarioclosure

– Expected/unexpectedoutcome?Scenariotobepickedupagainatalaterdate?

• Review andreviewagain!– Contentexperts,typosandgrammaticalerrors….

Page 24: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

4. Writing Your Scenario – Discussion Process / Discussion Questions• GeneralProcess– whatdo“hypotheses”and“mechanisms”

meaninyourdiscipline?• ConsiderthepurposeofDiscussionQuestions• RememberBloom’sTaxonomy• Posequestionsthatpromotedeeplearning

Page 25: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Finish Well – Reflection and Planning (RAP)Attheendofeachsession:

• reflectongroupprocessanddynamics– anyareastoimprove?

• identify“gaps”inlearningandhowthesewillbeaddressed

Page 26: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Challenges? Questions?

Page 27: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

Some Challenges and Potential SolutionsChallenges PotentialSolutions

Largecohort,resourcelimitations StudentfacilitatedCBL,Team-basedCBLor“debrief”format

Tutordiversity Tutortraining;facilitationratherthan”contentexpert”approach

Integrationwithothermodulesandcourses

Effectiveacademicteamwork

StudentParticipation Considerparticipationassessmentoptions

Difficultgroupdynamics Studenttrainingin teamwork; havetutors facilitateCBLs;tutortraining

Page 28: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

10 TIPS

• Ourowntop tipsfromourownCBLimplementationexperienceforyoutotakeaway!

• Pleasecontactuswithanyqueries:[email protected] or [email protected]

Page 29: Case-based Learning (CBL): Improving Student Engagement … · of week Group identification of 8-10 ‘FQ’s Learning resources Tutorial 2 Presentation of FQs Final case triggers

References and ResourcesDavidA.Cohen,LoriR.Newman&LaurieN.Fishman(2017)Twelvetipsonwritingadiscussioncasethatfacilitatesteachingandengageslearners,MedicalTeacher,39:2,147-152,DOI: 10.1080/0142159X.2017.1266315http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/0142159X.2017.1266315

JillE.Thistlethwaite,DavidDavies,Samilia Ekeocha,JaneM.Kidd,ColinMacDougall,PaulMatthews,JudithPurkis &DianeClay(2012)Theeffectivenessofcase-basedlearninginhealthprofessionaleducation.ABEMEsystematicreview:BEMEGuideNo.23,MedicalTeacher,34:6,e421-e444,DOI:10.3109/0142159X.2012.680939http://dx.doi.org/10.3109/0142159X.2012.680939

LouiseGreen:[email protected]:[email protected]


CBL chocobite

CBL chocobite

Difference between Problem Based Learning PBL and Case Based Learning CBL

Difference between Problem Based Learning PBL and Case Based Learning CBL

CBL DE flip

CBL DE flip

Cbl –stomach & duodenum

Cbl –stomach & duodenum

Competence based learning - stowarzyszeniestop.plstowarzyszeniestop.pl/.../2/2016/12/Competency-based-learning.pdf · To acquire knowledge of new CBL concepts ... Problem based learning,

Competence based learning - stowarzyszeniestop.plstowarzyszeniestop.pl/.../2/2016/12/Competency-based-learning.pdf · To acquire knowledge of new CBL concepts ... Problem based learning,

to the FQS Special Issue Qualitative Content and ... · FQS 20(3), Art. 38, Margrit Schreier, Christoph Stamann, Markus Janssen, Thomas Dahl & Amanda Whittal: Qualitative Content

to the FQS Special Issue Qualitative Content and ... · FQS 20(3), Art. 38, Margrit Schreier, Christoph Stamann, Markus Janssen, Thomas Dahl & Amanda Whittal: Qualitative Content

Cbl Ceo Pres

Cbl Ceo Pres

How Do Learners Respond to Computer Based Learning ... · 1.2.1 My role in education 3 1.2.2 CBL in Smart Schools 4 1.3 Courseware design 7 ... 8.9.1 CBL revisited 246 8.9.2 CBL in

How Do Learners Respond to Computer Based Learning ... · 1.2.1 My role in education 3 1.2.2 CBL in Smart Schools 4 1.3 Courseware design 7 ... 8.9.1 CBL revisited 246 8.9.2 CBL in

Global fqs new2

Global fqs new2

FQS Question Compile

FQS Question Compile

Case Based Learning (CBL) Training Slides 1. Contents 1.What is CBL? 2.The Structure of CBL 3.The Role of the CBL Tutor 4.Before the CBL Session 5.During.

Case Based Learning (CBL) Training Slides 1. Contents 1.What is CBL? 2.The Structure of CBL 3.The Role of the CBL Tutor 4.Before the CBL Session 5.During.

Cbl Final Report

Cbl Final Report

FQS Admissions Policy 2015 - fullquiveracademy.weebly.com · Title: FQS Admissions Policy_2015.pdf Author: Studio19 Created Date: 9/29/2015 1:58:24 AM

FQS Admissions Policy 2015 - fullquiveracademy.weebly.com · Title: FQS Admissions Policy_2015.pdf Author: Studio19 Created Date: 9/29/2015 1:58:24 AM

FEMA Qualification System (FQS) Evaluator’s Guide › media-library-data › 20130726...FEMA Qualification System (FQS) Evaluator’s Guide i Contents ... C9. Ethics & Integrity

FEMA Qualification System (FQS) Evaluator’s Guide › media-library-data › 20130726...FEMA Qualification System (FQS) Evaluator’s Guide i Contents ... C9. Ethics & Integrity

Data cbl radio

Data cbl radio

Experiential Learning in Sociology: Service Learning and ... we critically review the CBL literature, identifying six distinct types of CBL options and their characteristics. The result

Experiential Learning in Sociology: Service Learning and ... we critically review the CBL literature, identifying six distinct types of CBL options and their characteristics. The result

TUTORIAL 1 Introduction to Service-Learning (Community-Based Learning/CBL) and its Connection to Jesuit Ideals

TUTORIAL 1 Introduction to Service-Learning (Community-Based Learning/CBL) and its Connection to Jesuit Ideals

CBL Corporation Group - Credit Surety, Financial Risk Analysis · 2014-04-06 · CBL Corporation Group Introduction CBL Insurance Limited (CBL) is the largest and oldest provider

CBL Corporation Group - Credit Surety, Financial Risk Analysis · 2014-04-06 · CBL Corporation Group Introduction CBL Insurance Limited (CBL) is the largest and oldest provider

CBL Training Package

CBL Training Package

Cbl Presentation

Cbl Presentation