Case 1:12-cv-21778-PAS Document 105 Entered on FLSD · PDF fileCase 1:12-cv-21778-PAS Document...

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

CASE NO. 12-21778-C1V-SElTZ/S1M ONTON

LOUIS VUITTON MALLETIER, S.A.,

Plaintiff,

VS.

IOOW HOLESALE.COM , et aI.,

Defendants. /

ORDER GM NTING PLAINTIFF'S M OTION FOR ENTRY OF

FINAL DEFAULT JUDGM ENT AND CLOSING CASE

THIS M ATTER is before the Court upon Plaintiff s M otion for Entry of Final Default

Judgment (DE 102). Plaintiff, Louis Vuitton Malletier, S.A. (tilaouis Vuitton'), moves for final

default judgment against Defendants, the Partnerships and Unincorporated Associations

identified on Schedule tiA'' attached hereto (collectively Srefendants'), for alleged violations of

the Lanham Act, codified at 15 U.S.C. jj 1 1 14, 1 125(a), and 1 125(d). As Defendants have failed

to appear, plead or otherwise defend this action, and given the documentary evidence submitted

in support of its motion, the Court shall grant Plaintiffs M otion for Final Default Judgment.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Plaintiff is a company organized under the laws of the Republic of France with its

principal place of business located in Paris, France. (Second Amended Complaint kdtsecond

Amend. Compl.''l ! 3 (DE 464.) Plaintiff is the registered owner of the following trademarks on

the Principal Register of the United States Patent and Trademark Oftsce (colledively, the dltaouis

Vuitton Marks''):

Case 1:12-cv-21778-PAS Document 105 Entered on FLSD Docket 03/28/13 14:03:17 of 42

Registration RegistrationTrademark Classtes) / Relevant GoodsNumber Date

IC 18 - trunks, valises, traveling bags, satchels, hatSeptember0

,297,594 boxes and shoe boxes used for luggage, hand bags,20, 1932 and pocketbooks.

August 10, ,LOUIS VUITTON 1,045,932 IC 18 - luggage and ladies handbags.1976

IC 18 - trunks, valises, traveling bags, satchels, hatJO YQ'V 10, b

xes and shoe boxes used for luggage, hand bags,1,519,828 o1989

and pocketbooks.

November IC 14 - jewelry, watches, and straps for mist1,938,808 28

, 1995 watches.

IC 14 - watches and straps for wrist watches.

IC 16 - catalogues featuring luggage and travelaccessories, bags, small leather goods, and gannents;

notebooks, anthologies, and pamphlets referring to

travel; calendars; telephone indexes; fountain pens,

ballpoint pens, nibs, covers for pocket and desk

diaries, and checkbook holders.

IC 18 - trunks; traveling tnzrlks; suitcases; traveling

bags; luggage; garment bags for travel; hat boxes forAugust 6, travel; shoe bags for travel; umbrellas; animalLOUIS VUITTON 1

,990,760 j rs; rucksacks; haversacks; leather or textile1996 carr e

shopping bags; beach bags; handbags; vanity cases

sold empty; attache cases; tote bags, travel satchels;

clutch bags; briefcases; wallets; pocket wallets;

credit card cases; business card cases; bill and cardholders; checkbook holders; key cases; change

purses; briefcase-type portfolios.

IC 24 - travel blankets

IC 25 - shirts; sweatshirts; polo shirts; T-shirts;

headwearijackets; ties; belts; shawls; scarves.

2



IC 14 - goods made of precious metals, namely, sho

ornaments, omnmental pins; jewelry, nnmely, rings,ear rings, cufflinks, bracelets, charms, necklaces;

horological instruments, straps for watches, watches

and wrist-watches, and cases for watches.

IC 18 - goods made of leather or imitations ofleather are not included in other classes, namely,boxes made from leather; trunks, valises, traveling

bags, luggage for travel, garment bags for travel,vanity cases sold empty, rucksacks, hand bags,A

ugust 4,2,177,828 beach bags, shopping bags, shoulder bags, attache1998

cases, briefcases, and fine leather goods, namely,

pocket wallets, purses, leather key holders, business

card cases, calling card cases, and credit card cases,and umbrellas.

IC 25 - clothing and underwear, nnmely, sweaters,shirts, suits, waistcoats, raincoats, skirts, coats,

pullovers, trousers, dresses, jackets, shawls, stoles,sashes for wear, scarves, neckties, pocket squares,

gloves, belts, socks, bath robes, shoes, boots, and

sandals.

3



IC 014 - goods made of precious metals, namely,

shoe ornaments, ornamental pins, jewelry, namely,rings, belt buckles, ear rings, cufflinks, bracelets,

channs, necklaces, horological instruments, strapsfor watches, watches, and wrist-watches, and cases

for watches.

IC 18 - goods made of leather or imitations ofleather are not included in other classes, namely,

boxes made from leather; trunks, valises, traveling

bags, luggage for travel, ganuent bags for travel,

August 18, vanity cases sold empty, rucksacks, hand bags,. 2,181,753 1998 b

each bags, shopping bags, shoulder bags, attachecases, briefcases, and fine leather goods, namely,

pocket wallets, purses, leather key holders, businesscard cases, calling card cases, credit card cases, and

um brellas.

IC 25 - clothing and underwear, namely, sweaters,shirts, suits, waistcoats, raincoats, skirts, coats,

pullovers, trousers, dresses, jackets, shawls, stoles,sashes for wear, scarves, neckties, pocket squares,gloves, belts, socks, bath robes, shoes, boots, and

sandals.

IC 18 - goods made of leather or imitations of

leather not included in other classes, namely, boxesof leather principally used for travel pup oses,trunks, valises, traveling bags, traveling sets forA

ugust 22,LOUIS VUITTON 2 378,388 containing cosmetics and jewelry, rucksacks,P

ARIS handbags, beach bags, shopping bags, shoulder bags,

brief cases, pouches, fine leather goods nnm ely,

pocket wallets, purses, key cases, business card

cases, credit card cases, and calling card cases.

IC 25 - Clothing, nnmely, sweaters, shirts,

sweatshirts, polo shirts, t-shirts, suits, waistcoats,raincoats, skirts, coats, pullovers, trousers, dresses,J

une 27,Y 2,361,695 atlt)tl jackets, shawls, stoles, scarves, neckties, pocketsquares, pocket handkerchief squares for wear,gloves, ties, belts, bathing suits, shoes, boots and

sandals, and hats.

4


Registration RegistrationTrademark Classtes) / Relevant GoodsNum ber Date

IC 018 - Goods made of leather or imitations of

leather not included in other classes, namely valises,traveling bags, traveling sets for containingJ

ZZVWV 16, i s handbags, shopping bags, shoulder bags,2,421,618 cosmet c ,2001

brief cases, pouches; fine leather goods, nmnely,pocket wallets, purses, key cases, business card

cases, credit card cases.

IC 14 - Jewelry including rings, belt buckles ofprecious metals, earrings, cuff links, bracelets,channs, brooches, necklaces, tie pins, omamental

pins, and medallions; horological and chronometric

instruments and apparatus, namely, watches, watch

cases and clocks; nutcrackers of precious metals;

candlesticks of precious metals, jewelry boxes ofprecious metals.

IC 18: Travel bags, travel bags made of leather;

luggage tnmks and valises, garment bags for travel,vanity-cases sold empty; nzcksacks, shoulder bags,

handbags; attache-casess briefcases, drawstringOctober 14, pouches, pocket wallets, purses, umbrellas, business

. 2,773,107 2003 card cases made of leather or of imitation leather,

credit card cases made of leather or of imitation

leather; calling card cases made of leather or ofimitation leather; key holders made of leather or of

im itation leather.

IC 25 - Clothing, namely, underwear, sweaters,shirts, T-shirts, suits, hosiery, belts, scarves, neck

ties, shawls, waistcoats, skirts, raincoats, overcoats,

suspenders, trousers,jeans, pullovers, frocks,jackets, winter gloves, dress gloves, tightss socks,bathing suits, bath robes, pajamas, night dresses,shorts, pocket squares; highheeled shoes, low-heeled

shoes, sandals, boots, and slippers.

December 6, c ()9 . spectacles, sunglasses, and spectacle cases.0. 3 ,023,930 ztlt)j I

JO I'IZTY 24, Ic 09 - spectacles, sunglasses, and spectacle cases.. 3,051,235 2006

(See Declaration of Nikolay Livadkin in Support of Plaintiff s Second Ex Parte Application for

Entry of Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary lnjunction rçlaivadkin Decl. in Support

5


of Second TRO'') ! 4 gDE 43-11.) The Louis Vuitton Marks are used in connection with the

manufacture and distribution of, nmong other things, handbags, wallets, shoes, belts, scarves,

sunglasses, watches, and jewelry. (1d.)

Defendants, through the Internet websites operating under the domain names identified

on Schedule CCA'' hereto (the lûsubject Domain Names'), have advertised, offered for sale, and/or

sold handbags, wallets, shoes, belts, scarves, sunglasses, watches, and jewelry bearing

counterfeits, reproductions, and/or colorable imitations of the Louis Vuitton Marks. (Second

Amend. Compl. ! 23; see also Livadkin Decl. in Support of Second TRO (DE 43-1) !! 9-15;

Declaration of Nikolay Livadkin in Support of Plaintiff's Ex Parte Application for Entry of

Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction gsiivadkin Decl. in Support of TRO''j

gDE 4-11 !! 9-15; Declaration of Malerie Maggio in Support of Plaintiff s Ex Parte Application

for Entry of Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary lnjunction gslMaggio Decl. in Support

of TRO''j (DE 4-32) !! 4-5; Declaration of Malerie Maggio in Support of Plaintiff's Second Ex

Parte Application for Entry of Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction

(tsMaggio Decl. in Support of Second TRO''1 gDE 43-251 ! 4; and relevant web pages from

Defendants' Internet websites operating under Subject Domain Names (çsDefendants' Websites'')

(DE 4-3 through 4-271; (DE 8-2 through DE 8-31; (DE 21-21; (DE 43-3 through 43-201; (DE 74-

3 through 74-91; (DE 93-31.) Defendants are not now, nor have they ever been, authorized or

licensed to use, reproduce, or make counterfeits, reproductions, and/or colorable imitations of the

Louis Vuitton Marks (Livadkin Decl. in Support of Second TRO (DE 43-1) ! 9.)

Plaintiff retained Malerie Maggio (1'Maggio''), an officer of Investigative Consultants,

lnc., a licensed private investigative firm, to investigate suspected sales of non-genuine,

counterfeit versions of Plaintiff s products through the Subject Domain Names. (Livadkin Decl.


in Support of TRO (DE 4-11 ! 9; Livadkin Decl. in Support of Second TRO (DE 43-1) ! 10.)

M aggio placed an order for the purchase of six wallets, six handbags, and two belts, each bearing

at least one of the trademarks at issue in this action through the Internet websites operating under

the Subject Domain Names louivuittonreplica.net, u ockoff-louisvuittonhandbags.com, buy-

top-replicas.org, hotlouisvuittonreplicabags.com , Iouisvuittonreplicahandbags4u.com ,

Ivoutletonlineusvcom , Iove-replicasvnet, erm obags.com , louisvuittonreplicaau.com , Iouis-

vuittonreplicas.org, and Iouisvuittonreplicaa.com, to be shipped to her address in the Southern

District of Florida. (See M aggio Decl.in Support of TRO (DE 4-321 !! 4-5; Maggio Decl. in

Support of Second TRO gDE 43-25j ! 4.)

Thereaher, Plaintiff s representative reviewed and visually inspected the web page

listings, including images, for the items bearing Plaintift's trademarks purchased by M aggio and

detennined the items to be non-genuine versions of Plaintiff s products. (See Livadkin Decl. in

Support of TRO (DE 4-11 ! 12; Livadkin Decl. in Support of Second TRO (DE 43-11 ! 12.)

Additionally, Plaintiff s representative reviewed and visually inspected the items bearing

Plaintiff s trademarks offered for sale through the Internet websites operating under each of the

Subject Domain Nnmes, and determined the products to be non-genuine versions of Plaintiff s

products. (See Livadkin Decl. in Support of TRO (DE 4-11 ! 13; Livadkin Decl. in Support of

Second TRO (DE 43-1)

Supplemental Brief in Support of Its Ex Parte Application (DE 8-51 ! 5; Declaration of Nikolay

Declaration of Nikolay Livadkin in Support of Plaintiff s

Livadkin in Support of Plaintiff s M otion to Add Domain Nnmes to the Ex Parte Application For

Entry of Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary Injunction (DE 21-4) ! 6; Declaration of

Nikolay Livadkin in Support of Plaintiffs Motion to Amend Preliminary Injunction to Add New


Domains Names (DE 74-1) ! 10; Declaration of Nikolay Livadkin in Support of Plaintiff's

Motion to Amend Preliminary lnjtmction to Add New Domains Names (DE 93-11 ! 1 1.)

On May 10, 2012, Plaintiff filed its Complaint gDE 1j, and subsequently filed its First

Amended Complaint in this action against Defendants 1-38 1 (the dtGroup l Defendants'') on May

2012, for trademark counterfeiting and infringement, false designation of origin,

cybersquatting, common law unfair competition, and common law civil conspiracy (DE 7j. On

May 1 1, 2012, Plaintiff filed its Ex Parte Application for Entry of Temporary Restraining Order

and Preliminary Injunction (DE 4) against the Group I Defendants. On May 17, 20 12, Plaintiff

filed its Supplemental Brief in Support of the Ex Parte Application for Entry of Temporary

Restraining Order gDE 8j. The Court issued an Order Granting Temporary Restraining Order Ex

Parte gDE 10j on May 17, 2012, and temporarily restrained the Group I Defendants from

infringing the Louis Vuitton M arks at issue. On M ay 28, 2012, Plaintiff filed its M otion to Add

Domain Names to Application for Entry of Temporary Restraining Order and Preliminary

lnjunction (DE 2 11, which the Court granted on May 29, 2012 (DE 22q. Additionally, on May

29, 2012, the Court entered an Order granting Plaintiff's Application for Preliminary Injunction

(DE 231. On July 20, 20 12, Plaintiff tsled its Motion for Order Authorizing Altemate Service of

Process on Defendants Pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(9(3) (DE 392. On July 23,

2012, the Court entered an Order Granting Motion for Alternate Service (DE 40J authorizing

Plaintiff to serve the Summons, Complaint, and all subsequent pleading and discovery in this

case upon Defendants via e-mail, and via publication by posting copies of the same on the

Internet website appearing at the URL http://servingnotice.com/lvmsep/index.html. The Order

Granting Motion for Altemate Service (DE 40J further authorized Plaintiff to continue to

effectuate service of process against any newly added Defendants pursuant to the tenus of the

8


Order Granting M otion for Alternate Service through the submission of an Affidavit or sworn

Declaration confirming any new Defendants are not residents of the United States and their

addresses are unknown.

On July 26, 2012, Plaintiff filed its Ex Parte M otion for Leave to File its Second

Amended Complaint (DE 42), and subsequently filed its Second Amended Complaint against

Defendants 382-674 (the çtGroup 11 Defendants'') on August 1, 2012 (DE 461. On July 26, 2012,

Plaintiff filed its Second Ex Parte Application for Entry of Temporary Restraining Order and

Preliminary Injunction (DE 43) against the Group 11 Defendants. On August 8, 2012, the Court

issued an Order Granting Plaintiffs Second Ex Parte Application for Entry of a Temporary

Restraining Order (DE 552, temporarily restrained the Group 11 Defendants from infringing the

Louis Vuitton Marks at issue, and referred Plaintiff s Application for Preliminary Injunction to

M agistrate Judge Andrea M . Simonton. 0n August 16, 2012, M agistrate Judge Simonton issued

a Report and Recommendation, recommending the Application for Preliminary Injunction be

granted (DE 60j, and this Court ratified, afûrmed, and adopted the same on August 23, 2012 (DE

63j. Subsequently, Plaintiff filed the Declaration of Stephen M. Gaffigan (DE 80-1J on

November 1, 2012, confirming the newly added Group 11 Defendants are not residents of the

United States and their addresses are unknown, in accordance with the Court's July 23, 2012

Order Granting Motion for Altemate Service (DE 40j. On October 19, 2012, Plaintiff filed its

Motion to Amend the Second Preliminary Injunction (DE 741. On November 30, 2012, the Court

issued an Order granting Plaintiff's Motion to Amend the Second Preliminary Injunction (DE

92J and entered an Amended Preliminary Injunction gDE 91J. On November 30, 2012, Plaintiff

filed its Second Motion to Amend the Second Preliminary Injunction (DE 93j. On January 4,

2013, the Court issued an Order granting Plaintiffs Second M otion to Amend the Second

9


LzlmaplAa uv Eplocaz uo s! couaplaa I/puossa aI.I) IIv gJgIIM 'sa:/uz':p apgdoldd? oulllTlapp

ISRI.u Nnoa aII; ugtl; <X;!I!qE!I lIS!Iq2;S3 mpldttloa papuaulv puoogs atI3 u! SDEJ P3:7IttIP?

otl; Jl *100: '/I.'I 'G'S) IITI $f If l PJ 'ddns *.4 9f f Gtuoomodpn, 'a 'oul '&.OJtJA'.'#' JIJI/Z/JJ

t(186l 'JID tI111) I9f <6f E PT'.'I 0T8 GMDIIZMOR 'A &17&&1/.7/8 JJS 'POSIIRIPP P=ttI33P 3.12 mlzldtuoa

papugtuv puooas atl; u! suolp:allz pold-lpM sglllulvld JO IIC CSInCJ3P E II3nS Xg 'Sulp/ald

M lsuodsal Xlatlzp 1) aIg m pallcg iglatl slutpuagoq aqll çotlM gluzpuolap pga-lzs Xl-lzdozd = lsup:v

mgtu:pnf lln/gap v Jawa m unoo v sozllolgnv (z)(q)çç ampcaold I!A!a Jo olnzl Imapa.tl

(IXVIINVJ.S VIYDHQ 'II

'Puodsol 0) paI!2J OSIZ JAUII SItIPPU:J3G II3ItIM 03 (mgtuspnf IIIWJ3P ICII!J JO

Alwa .loJ uopotu mmsu! 0tl) paMas ptm pplg JJ!w!2Id Qf I0J <JJ X.lfn.lqa,tl uo 'uollov S!tI$ pUJJ3P

pu= Jgoddc aslMlpljm zo qnggap gtI) a)1)a/a m ltl:nos mu JA/II swmpuogoq iopp o-t .(66 H(1l

(9r Jgqttlaogc uo uolp/ sltl) pua-pp aslMlolgo Jo Gpcald <lcaddv m glnllvl JoJ smvpuo-pqJ10f

11 dnolo atll lsulvc qncgop palawa Xlwanbasqns pu= :(1: l'J(1l rIOr <z JaqtlzaaoN uo uollo?

sltl) pupgap gslMlotlm Jo <pvzld ç-mcdd? m :JnI!vJ JoJ swvpuz-pc I dnolo atll Tsup:v qnv-pp

palalu: Iolnpaoold I!A!a go solnx Imapa.tl atp Jo @)çç clnzl m m/nslnd çunoa Jo 4JoIa aljJ. ('ç

lk E::'I3?Cl u?:BJ?0,,1 Smzpualaq Ssulev matuSpnf Slnugz(I pul..l go Apu:q JoJ uonow sggllulvld

Jo uoddns u! uv:luvo 'w uatldais Jo uolpzvloac oas) .(06 aq puc <68 ('Rq (8s :'R(1) rl0r Kf'l

JJMIIIJAON. uo uolpollqnd JO IIEttI-J P!A sulzldl1loa Pzpuattlv Pu033S PIIP Suottltlms 3A!)3pdSaJ

J!pII) JO SJ!d03 tl;!M STIICPIDJJG 11 dnolD :11) PIIP

I1O!)2O!Iqnd JO 112ttI-1 C!A stlluldI,tloa P3PU3IIIV PuO33S PlI2 Suoluttms JAID3IISJJ J!3lI) J0 S:!d03

Ij)!M smzpuag3q I dnolD gII) PJAJJS JJIIU!KId '(0h JG1 J3PJO SuNnoa JtI$ 0; wlmslnd

'(f1 /q pu= zL Hq1 rIOr '0r isn:nv uo

-

EO0I

r,Rcj uopounful Imullzzlpld papuatuv puoaas / polalu: puc EI O I gcj uopounful Ilcultlzllold


hearing on damages is not required. See SEC v. Smyth, 420 F.3d 1225, 1232 n.13 (1 1th Cir.

2005) (''Rule 55(b)(2) speaks of evidentiary hearings in a permissive tone . . . We have held that

no such hearing is required where all essentialevidence is already of record.'') (citations

omitted); see also Petmed Express,336 F. Supp. 2d at 1223 (entering default judgment,

permanent injunction and statutory dnmages in a Lanham Act case without a hearing). ln this

case, a hearing on damages is unnecessary as Plaintiff is not seeking damages.

111. LIABILITY

A. Tradem ark Infringement

The allegations in Plaintiff's Second Amended Complaint, in conjunction with record

evidence, support a finding of liability against Defendants for trademark infringement. ''(T)o

prevail on a trademark infringement claim a plaintiff must demonstrate that (1) its mark has

priority; (2) defendant used its mark in commerce gwithout consent); and (3) defendant's mark is

likely to cause consumer confusion.'' Petmed Express, 336 F. Supp. 2d at 1217-18 (citing Int'l

Cosmetics Exch, Inc. v. Gapardis Health dr Beauty, Inc. , 303 F.3d 1243 (1 1th Cir. 2002) and

Frehling Enten, lnc. v. Int'l Select Group, lnc. , 192 F.3d 1 330 (1 1th Cir. 1 999:. Plaintiff has

established each of these elements because: (1) Plaintiff s ownership and registration of the

trademarks at issue precede Defendants' infringing conduct (Second Amend. Compl. ! 16;

Livadkin Decl. in Support of Second TRO (DE 43-1) ! 4); (2) Defendants advertised, offered for

sale and/or sold goods bearing Plaintiffs marks in interstate commerce without Plaintiff's

consent (Second Amend. Compl. ! 28;Livadkin Decl. in Support of TRO gDE 4-1J !! 9-15;

Livadkin Decl. in Support of Second TRO (DE 43-1j !! 9-15); and (3) the marks used on the

goods Deftndants advertised, offered for sale and/or sold are so similar to Plaintiff's marks that

consumer confusion is likely. (Second Amend. Compl. !! 30, 3#; Defendants' Websites (DE 4-3


through 4-271; (DE 8-2 through DE 8-3); (DE 21-24; (DE 43-3 through 43-20j; (DE 74-3 through

74-91; gDE 93-31.)

B. False Designation of Origin

Plaintiff alleges false designation of origin tmder j 43(a) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. j

1 125(a). That section provides as follows:

Any person who, on or in connection with any goods or services, or any container

for goods, uses in commerce any word, term, nnme, symbol, or device, or any

combination thereof, or any false designation of origin, false or misleading

description of fact, or false or misleading representation of fact, which-

(A) is likely to cause confusion, or to cause mistake, or to deceive as to theaffiliation, connection, or association of such person with another person,

or as to the origin, sponsorship, or approval of his or her goods, services,

or comm ercial activities by another person, or

(B) in commercial advertising or promotion, misrepresents the nature,characteristics, qualities, or geographic origin of his or her or another

person's goods, services, or commercial activities, shall be liable in a civil

action by any person who believes that he or she is or is likely to be

damaged by such act.

15 U.S.C. j 1 125(a)(1).

The same set of facts

recovery under j 1 125. See Babbit Elecs., 38 F.3d at 1 18 1 (1 1th Cir. 1994) (citing Marathon

Mfg. Co. v. Enerlite Prods. Corp., 767 F.2d 214, 217 (5th Cir. 1985)); see also Clairol lnc. v.

allowing Plaintiff to prevail under j 1 1 14(1)(a) will result in

Save- r'fzrtzy Indus., Inc., 2 10 U.S.P.Q. 459, 469-70 (S.D. Fla. 1980).tt-rhis is because Section

1 125(a) is broader than Section 1 1 14 in that it covers false advertising or description whether or

not it involves trademark infringement.'' Babbit Elecs., 38 F.3d at 1 181 (citing Silverstar Enters.,

Inc. v. Aday, 537 F. Supp. 236 (S.D.N.Y. 1982)). As with trademark infringement claims, the test

for liability for false designation of origin under j 43(a) is also çiwhether the public is likely to be

deceived or confused by the similarity of the marks at issue.'' Fwt? Pesos, lnc. v. Taco Cabana,

12


Inc., 505 U.S. 763, 780 (1992). As discussed above, Plaintiff has sufficiently shown there is a

strong likelihood of confusion that arises because of the use by Defendants of the Louis Vuitton

Marks. Thus, Plaintiff is entitled to defaultjudgment on its false designation of origin claim.

C. Cybersquatting

The Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act (1çACPA''), 15 U.S.C. j 1 125(d),

imposes liability upon a person for the bad faith intent to profit from a protected mark by

registering or using a domain name that is identical or confusingly similar, or dilutive of, that

mark. Petmed Express, 336 F. Supp. 2d at 1218. To prevail under 15 U.S.C. j 1 125(d), a plaintiff

must demonstrate that ût(1) its mark is distinctive or famous and entitled to protection; (2) the

defendant's domain name is identical or confusingly similar to the plaintiff s mark; and (3) the

defendant registered or used the domain name with a bad faith intent to profit.'' Bavaro Palace,

S.A. v. Vacation Tours, Inc., 203 Fed. App'x 252, 256 (11th Cir. 2006). In this case, the well-

pled allegations demonstrate Plaintiffs M arks are distinctive and famous, that the infringing

domain names are confusingly similar, and that Defendants registered the cybersquatting domain

names with the bad-faith intent to protk from them. As such, Defendants are liable for

cybersquatting under 15 U.S.C. j 1 125(d).

D. Com m on Law Unfair Com petition

W hether a defendant's use of the plaintifps trademarks created a likelihood of confusion

between plaintiff's and defendant's products is also the determining factor in the analysis of

unfair competition under the common 1aw of Florida. Rolex Watch L(S-d., lnc. v. Forrester, No.

83-8381-Civ-Paine, 1986 WL 15668, at *3 (S.D. Fla. Dec. 9, 1987) Ci-l-he appropriate test for

determining whether there is a likelihood of confusion, and thus trademark infringement, false

designation of origin, and unfair competition under the common 1aw of Florida, is set forth in


John H Harlan4 Inc. v. Clarke Checks, Inc. , 71 1 F.2d 966, 972 (1 1th Cir. 1983.)5) Plaintiff has

established there is a likelihood of confusion regarding Defendants' use of the Louis Vuitton

Marks on their counterfeit and infringing products. Accordingly, Plaintiff has succeeded on the

merits of its common law unfair competition claim

IV. INJUNCTIVE RELIEF

Plaintiff is entitled to the requested injunctive relief pursuant to 15 U.S.C. j 1 1 16. A

plaintiff seeking a permanent injunction must demonstrate that ( 1) it has suffered an irreparable

injury; (2) remedies at law, such as monetary damages, are inadequate to compensate for that

injury; (3) considering the balance of hardship between plaintiff and defendant, a remedy in

equity is warranted;and (4) that the publicinterest would not be disserved by a permanent

injtmction. See eBay, Inc. v. MercExchange, L L C, 547 U.S. 388, 391 (2006).

Here, the well-pled allegations and record evidence demonstrate that Plaintiff has

developed goodwill among the consuming public which would be undennined if Defendants are

not prohibited from further infringement. Defendants' counterfeit products will create irreparable

harm and confusion, particularly because the counterfeit products bear identical markings as

Plaintiff s genuine merchandise, and are not manufactured to Plaintiff s quality standards.

Furthermore, Defendants willfully infringed the Louis Vuitton M arks, and several of the

Defendants continued to do so even after service of the Second Amended Complaint in this

matter upon them. Such willful conduct demonstrates a likelihood that Defendants would

continue to harm Plaintiff s trademarks if the Court declined to issue an injunction. Petmed

Express, 336 F. Supp. 2d 1222-23 (entering permanent injunction under 15 U.S.C. j 1 1 16 to

prevent further infringement of federally-protected trademarks).


V. CONCLUSION

For the reasons stated above, it is hereby

ORDERED THAT

Plaintiff s Motion for Entry of Final Default Judgment (DE 1021 is GRANTED.

(2) The Court shall concurrently enter Final Judgment against Defendants.

(3) This case is CLOSED. W

XJday of , 2013.DONE AND ORDERED in Miami, Florida, this .

PAT ICIA A. SEITZUNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

cc: All Counsel of Record

15


42 bestknockoftba s.com

43 bestlouisvuittonba .com

44 bestlouisvuittonre lica.or

45 bestsun lassessaler.com

46 bestsun lassessaler.net

47 brandshandba sale.com

48 busline ress.com

49 bu ba slouisvuitton.com

50 bu chea ra1 hlauren.com

51 bu -handba re lica.com

52 bu handba st les.com

53 bu louisvuitton.biz

54 bu louisvuittonsho s.com

55 bu louisvuittons eed 35.com

56 bu lvhandba s4u.com

57 bu -lvonline.com

58 bu -to ba .com

59 bu o handba s.net

60 bu o -ba s.com

61 bu -to -re licas.or

62 bu -to re lica.com

63 calouisvuitton urses.com

64 canadalouisvuittonoutlet.com

65 chea authenticlouisvuittonoutlet.com

66 chea ba s2012.com

67 chea ba 2012.com

68 chea brandhandba sstores.com

69 chea handba szsale.com70 chea handba scom.com

71 chea handba s-stores.or

72 chea louisvuittonzo.com73 chea louisvuitton3o.com

74 chea louisvuittongo.com

75 chea -louisvuittonba ssale.net

76 chea louisvuittonba sus.com

77 chea louisvuittonba sus.net

78 chea louisvuittonhandba sale.com

79 chea louisvuittonhandba sus.net

80 chea louisvuittonhandba us.com

81 chea louisvuitton-onsale.com

82 chea louisvuittonoutlet.info

83 chea louisvuitton-outlet.or

84 chea louisvuitton-sales.com

85 chea louisvuitton-sales.net

86 chea louisvuitton-store.net

17


87 chea louisvuitton-stores.net

88 chea lthandba soutlet.info

89 chea luxu outlet.co

90 chea shoes laza.com

91 chea shox laza.com

92 chea slouisvuitton-outlet-sales.net

93 chea slouisvuitton-outlet-sales.or

94 chic-now .com

95 fallinlovewithba s.com

96 clothin mallsale.com

97 m allsalesho .com

98 clothin webstore.com

99 clothin webstore.net

1 colahandba s.com

2 commande aschere.com

3 deluxehandba s.or

4 desi nerba smallhomezolz.com

5 destocka e- aschere.com

6 destocka e- ascher.com

7 destocka e- ascher.net

8 destocka esacenli ne.com

9 di ba .com

10 discountba s360.net

1 1 discountba szu.com

12 discountlouisvuittonhandba sus.com

13 discountlouisvuittonhandba sus.net

14 discountlouisvuittorlhandba us.com

15 discountlvba s.or

16 eba ascher.com

17 eluxu s-handba .com

18 eluxur s-handba .net

19 ermoba s.com

20 est lefocus.com

21 etohandba .com

100 fakelouisvuittonbelts.or

101 fake-louisvuittonhandba s.com

101 fakelouisvuittonhandba ssale.com

101 louisvuittonre licashandba szu.com

102 fakelouisvuitton-handba s.com

102 louisvuittonre licashandba s4u.com

103 fakelouisvuittons.net

104 fakeslouisvuittonba s.com

105 fashionba zsale.com

106 fashion-louisvuittondiscount.com

107 fashionlouisvuittonsale.net

18


107 fashionlouisvuittonsale.or

108 fauxlouisvuitton.net

109 findcoachhandba s.com

1 10 forchea ersale.com

1 1 1 enuinelouisvuittonsale.com

1 1 1 louisvuittonoutletssenter.net

1 12 o otrademall.com

1 13 or eousitem s.com

1 14 reatest-re licas.com

1 14 reatest-re licas.net

1 15 rossiste- aschere.or

1 15 rossistes aschere.com

1 16 rossistesoldes.com

1 17 rossistes- aschere.or

1 18 handba s-luxu sale.net

1 19 handba swholesaleoo7.net

120 handtaschensho berlin.com

121 hermes-coach-handba .com

122 hervele eu.com

123 hklvoutlet.com

124 hone luxur ba s.com

124 xcba s.com

125 hotba s2012.com

126 hotba sm e.com

126 hothandba sme.com

127 hotlouisvuittonre licaba s.com

128 hotlvba s.com

129 houseofdesi ner.com

130 h -re lica-ba s.com

131 hulantradin .biz

132 ihaveba .com

133 ilouisvuittonhandba s.com

134 ilvba .com

135 imitation-watches4u.com

136 itlouisvuittonoutlet.com

136 uslouisvuittonba .com

137 'a anlouisvuittons.com

138 knockoff-louisvuittonhandba s.com

139 louishandba soutlet.net139 lvba susaoutlet.com

140 louiss eed .com

141 louis-vittonsho .net

142 louisvuitonba sho .com

142 louisvuitonba ssho .com

143 louisvuitonoutlet.com

19


143 louisvuitononline.com

144 louisvuittonl7.com

145 louis-vuittonz.com

146 louisvuitton-36os.com

147 louisvuitton-arts .net

148 louisvuittonarts mm .net

149 louisvuittonaustralia rices.com

150 louisvuitton-ba -esho .com

151 louisvuittonba sesho s.com

152 louisvuittonba s eed s.com

153 louisvuittonba sre licawholesale.com

154 louisvuittonba ssho s.com

155 louisvuittonbindi.com

156 louisvuitton-boston.com

157 louisvuitton-briefcases.com

158 louisvuitton-canadas.com

159 louisvuitton-chea handba soutlet.com

160 louisvuittonchile.com

161 louisvuitton-e-ba s.com

162 louisvuittonenvente.com

163 louis-vuitton-e-store.net

164 louisvuittonfr.or

165 louisvuitton aschenor

166 louisvuitton alliera m.com

167 louisvuittonhadba soutlet.com168 louis-vuittonhandba s2012.com169 louisvuittonhandba s7v.com

170 louisvuittonhandba s7v.net170 louisvuittonhandba swalletsus.com171 louisvuittonhandba simitation.com172 louisvuittorlhandba sre licaoutlet.com

173 louisvuittonhandba ssho .net

174 louisvuittonhandba sukoutlet.com

175 louisvuitton-hawaii.com

176 louisvuittonhomme aris.com

176 sacvuitton aris.com

177 louisvuittonhon kon rices.com

178 louisvuitton-irene.com

179 louis-vuitton-knockoffs.biz

180 louisvuittonlabelusa.com

18 1 louisvuittonlabelinusa.com

182 louisvuittonluxu ba s.com

183 louisvuittonlvchea .com

184 louisvuittonlvhandba s.net

1 84 lv-louisvuitton-au.com

20


185 louisvuittonlvsho .com

186 louisvuittonmanchester.com

187 louisvuitton-m en-ba s.com

188 louis-vuitton-news.com

189 louisvuitton-nordstrom .com

190 louisvuiûonofscialdeals.com

191 louisvuittonofscialoutlets.or

192 louisvuittonoffcialoutletus.com

193 louis-vuitton-offcial-website.com

194 louisvuittononline36o.com

195 louisvuittononlinebu in .com

196 louisvuitton-onsales.or

197 louisvuittonoutleteluxur .com

198 louisvuittonoutlethot.or

199 louisvuitton-outletonlinesale.net

199 louisvuitton-outletonlinesale.or

200 louisvuittonoutlet-onlinesho .com

201 louisvuitton-outletonsale.com

202 louisvuittonoutletsaleo.com

202 louisvuittonoutletsalea.com

203 louisvuittonoutletsaleo.or

204 louisvuittonoutletsaleszolz.com

205 louisvuittonoutletsenter.com

206 louisvuittonoutletso.net

206 louisvuittonhandba so.net

207 louisvuittonoutletssho .com

208 louisvuittonoutlets-sites.net

208 louisvuittonoutlets-sites.or

208 louisvuittonsoutlet-site.com

209 louisvuittonoutlets-store.or2 10 louisvuilonoutlet-stores.info

2 1 1 louis-vuittonoverstock.com

2 12 louisvuitton a.com

2 13 louisvuitton ass ort.or

2 14 louisvuitton ortu al.net

2 15 louisvuitton ursesstores.com

216 louisvuittonre licaba ssale.com

2 17 louisvuittonre licaba swholesale.com2 18 louisvuittonre licahandba s4u.com

219 louis-vuittonre licalu a e.com

220 louisvuittonre licashandba soutlet.com

220 louisvuittonre licaoutletsale.com

220 louisvuittonre licasoutlet.com

221 louisvuittonre licathebest.com

22 1 louisvuitton-re licathebest.com

21


222 louisvuittonre licausasho .com

222 re licalouisvuittonba sho .com

223 louisvuiûonsacsamainfrance.com

223 louissvuittons ascher.eom

224 louisvuittonsale-m art.com

225 louisvuittonsalesoutlet.com

226 louisvuitton-sale-uk.com

227 louisvuitton-saumur.com

228 louisvuittonshandba sonsale.com228 louisvuittonshandba sonsale.net

229 louisvuittonsite.biz

229 louisvuitton-siteoftkiel.or

230 louisvuitton-soldes.com231 louisvuittonsstores.com

232 louisvuittonstockists.com233 louis-vuitton-storesale.com

234 louis-vuitton-storesale.net

234 louis-vuitton-storesale.or

235 louisvuittonsuk.com

235 louisvuittonsuk.or

236 louisvuitton-sun lass.com

237 louis-vuittonswitzerland.com

238 louisvuittonswitzerland.eu

239 louisvuittontaskedk.com

24O louisvuittonthailand.net

241 louisvuittonubelts.com

241 louisvuttion-belts.com

242 louis-vuitton-us.com

243 louisvuittonuuu.com

244 louisvuittonvietnam.com

245 louisvuittonvi sho .com

246 louisvuittonwalletsl.info

246 louisvuittonwalletsz.info

247 louisvuittonwebsitedeals.com

248 louisvuittonxmas4.com

249 louiszvuitton.com

250 louivuittonba s.net

251 louivuittonoutlet.biz

252 louivuittonre lica.net

252 louivuitton-re lica.com

253 loveba ssale.net

254 loveco watches.com

255 love-re licas.net

256 lthandba s.net

257 luttonhandba s.info

22


258 luxe-acheter.com

259 luxemar uesoldes.com

260 luxuriesline.com

261 luxurious36s.com

262 luxu ba sonlinesho .com

263 luxu handba -online.com264 luxur handba s-sale.com

265 luxu lvba soutlet.com

266 luxu o sale.com

267 lv-201 l.biz

268 lv-ba -outlet.com

269 lvba s-2012.com

270 lvba s4sales.com

271 lvba scn.com

272 lvba soutlet.net

272 lvba s-outlet.net

273 lvbelt-outlet.com

274 lvcanadaoutlet.com

275 lvdiscounthandba s.com

276 lvdiscount-handba s.com

277 lv-handba .biz

278 lvhandba s4discount.com

279 lvhandba s4u.com

280 lvhandba sdiscounted.com

281 lvhandba sus.com

282 lvmono ram canvas.or

283 lvmontreal.net

284 lvonlines.com

285 lv-onlinesho s.com

286 lvoutlet4sale.com

287 lvoutletonlineus.com

288 lv-outletsale.net

289 lvoutletsandals.com

290 lvoutlet-uszolz.com

290 lvoutletzool.com

291 lv urse.biz

292 lvsale.biz

293 lvsouthafrica.com

294 lvsoutletba .com

295 lvstockholm .com

296 lvsun 1asses2012.com

296 fakesun lass2012.com

297 lvsun lassworld.com

298 lvwalletform en.com

299 lvwallets.com

23


300 lvwwwcom .com

301 mar uesacsdeluxe.com

302 mono ramlouisuzittonwallets.com

303 mono rnm lvarts .com

304 m lvoutlet.com

305 neverfulllouis-vuitton.com

306 DISM ISSED

307 ne orklouisvuitton.com

308 olouisvuittonhandba s.com

309 onelouisvuitton urses.com

310 online rou on.com

3 1 1 onlinelvoutlet.com

3 12 ori inal-louisvuitton.com

3 13 outletforlouisuzittonba .com

3 13 outletforlouisvuitlonsba s.com

313 outletforlouisvuittonsba .com

314 outletlouisvuittonba .net

3 15 outletlouisvuittonmilr o.com

3 16 outletsforlouisvuittonba .com

3 17 outletstoreshoes.com

318 owermall.com

3 19 ascherma asinfr.com

320 ickaaahandba s.com

321 icklvba s.com

322 DISM ISSED

323 reallouisvuittonba s.or

324 re licaba ssho 2u.com

325 re licahandba shome.com

326 re licalouis-vuittonba s.com

327 re licalouisvuittonchea .or

328 re licalouisvuittonchea ba s.com

328 re licalouisvuittonchea ba .com

329 re licalouisvuittonhandba ssales.com

330 re licalouisvuittonusaoutlet.com

330 re licalouisu ittonusaoutlets.com

331 sacamainluxesho fr.com

332 sacdem ar ue aschere.com

333 saclouisvuitton-fr.or

334 sac-louisvuitton-fr.or

335 saclouisvuittonfrance.or

336 sac ascherl3.com

337 sac aschere.or

338 sacsluxesiteoffciel.com

338 sacslvsiteofficiel.com

339 sacsma asinfr3.com

24


339 sacsma asinfr4.com

340 sacsslvuitton.com

340 frsacsslvuitton.com

341 sacvuitton- ascher.net342 sacvuittonsolde rix.com

342 saclivraison ratuits.com

343 sale4 ifts.com

344 salefashionshoes.com

345 salemallonline.com

346 seasonaihandba s.com

347 seba s.com

348 sellto ba s.com

349 sho brandba s.com

349 sho brandhandba .com

350 sho louisvuittonon.com

351 sin a orelouisvuitton.com

352 solde aschere.com353 soldesm oinscher.com

354 soldes rix aschere.com

355 soldes rix aschere.net

356 sun lassesoutlet4u.com

357 su ercoolre licas.com

358 swisswatch-sho .com

359 DISM ISSE D

360 tiesonlinestore.com

361 to hotonline.com

362 uchea louisvuittonoutlet.com

363 ukchea louisvuitton.com

364 uklouisvuittonsalese.com

365 usaba saleoutlets.com

365 usba sonlinesho .com

366 usaba saless.com

366 usaba sho .com366 usaba sho s.com

367 usalouisvuittonofficial.net

367 louisvuittononlineretailer.com

367 louisvuitton ursesales.com

368 usba salesoutlets.com

368 usaba salesoutlets.com

369 uslouisvuittonwallet.com

370 vgbrand.com

371 vi -handba s.or

371 vi -handba s.biz372 vo uebrandba s.com

372 vo uebestba s.com

25


373 vre licahandba s.co.uk

374 vuittonsac ascher.biz

374 ascherlouissacs.com

375 vuittonsre licas.com

375 louisvuittonre licasn .com

376 vuitton--store.com

377 wbrandba .net

378 weblouisvuittonoutlet.com

379 wholesalelouisvuittonsite.com

380 wholesalere licadesi ner.com

381 zebrafishstudios.com

382 18541ove.net

382 alouisvuittonoutlet.or

382 alouisvuittonoutlets.net

382 alouisvuittonoutlets.or

382 asaclouisvuitton.com

382 asacochelouisvuittonfr.com382 asacochelouisvuittonfr.net

382 authenticchanelba s.or

382 authentic- ucci-handba s.com382 authenticlouisvuidonoutletzol3.com

382 ba 147.com

382 ba s-2012.com

382 ba szwallet.com

382 ba sbid.com382 bestlouisvuittonoutlet4u.com

382 bestlouisvuittonoutlet4u.net

382 b newshow.com

382 blackchanel ttrse.com382 bolvn.com

382 borselvdorma.biz

382 borselvdolme.com

382 borsesitooutlet.com

382 brandba onlinestore.com

382 bu 102.com

382 bu louisvuittonsre lica.com

382 cand ba s4u.com

382 chanelba rice.or

382 chanelba s201 l.or

382 chanel-ba s-2012.or

382 chanel-coco-ba s.com

382 chanel-on-sale.or

382 chaneltoteba .or382 chanel-usa.or

382 chea ba sonline.or

26


382 chea -handba s-online.or

382 chea -leather-handba s.or

382 chea louisvuittonoutlet4u.net

382 chea louisvuittonoutlet4u.or

382 chea lvba s.or

382 clouisvuittonoutlet.com

382 clouisvuittonoutlet.net

382 clouisvuittonoutlet.or

382 DISM ISSED

382 desi ner-handba s-sale.info

382 discountlouisvuittonoutlets.com

382 discountlouisvuilonoutlets.net

382 discountlouisvuittonoutlets.or

382 e-ba s-mall.com

382 irlba ssho .com

382 ucci-handba s-2012.com

382 handba fans.com

382 handba s2012.or

382 handba s7mcom

382 handba smcom

382 handba slouisvuittonoutlets,com

382 handba slouisvuittonoutlets.net

382 handba slouisvuittonoutlets.or

382 handba slouisvuittonoutlett.com

382 handba slouisvuittonoutlett.net

382 handba ssho sales.com

382 DISM ISSED

382 DISM ISSED

382 iba szu.com

382 italialvborsa.com

382 lenvv.com

382 liketheba .com

382 llouisvuittonoutlets.net

382 louis-sho -online.com

382 louissvuittonnoutlet.com

382 louissvuittonoutlets.com

382 louisvuittnuba s.com

382 louisvuittnuba s.net

382 louisvuittonaonline.com

382 louisvuittonba soutlet4u.com

382 louisvuittonba soutletss.or

382 louisvuittonba soutlett.or

382 louisvuittonba soutlett4u.com

382 louisvuittonba soutlett4u.net

382 louisvuittonba soutlett4u.or

27


382 louisvuittonba soutletu.or

382 louisvuittonba soutletus.com

382 louisvuittonba soutletus.net

382 louisvuittonborseitaliait.com

382 louisvuittonborseoutlet.net

382 louisvuittonborseoutleta.com

382 louisvuittonborseoutleta.or

382 louisvuittonborseoutleti.com

382 louisvuittonborseoutlet-italia.com

382 louisvuittonborseoutlets.com

382 louisvuittonborseoutlets.net

382 louisvuittonborseoutlets.or

382 louisvuittonborseoutlett.com

382 louisvuittonborseoutlett.net

382 louisvuittonborseoutlett.or

382 louisvuittonborses.net

382 louisvuittonbrasil.com

382 louisvuittonbrasils.com

382 DISMISSED

382 louisvuittoncouk.com

382 louisvuittoneonline.net

382 louisvuittonhandba s-hot.com

382 louisvuittonhandba sok.com

382 louisvuittonhandba soutlet4u.net

382 louisvuittorlhandba soutlet4u.or

382 louisvuittonhandba soutletu.com

382 louisvuittonitaliaonline.com

382 louis-vuitton-montreal.com

382 louis-vuitton-new-zealr d.com

382 louis-vuitton-nz.com

382 louisvuittonoutlet4us.or

382 louisvuittonoutletonline4u.or

382 louisvuittonoutletonlinei.com

382 louisvuittonoutletonlines4u.com

382 louisvuittonoutletonlines4u.or

382 louisvuilonoutletsale4u.com

382 louisvuittonoutletsale4u.net

382 louisvuittonoutletsale4u.or

382 louisvuittonoutletsalee.net

382 louisvuittonoutletsaless.or

382 louisvuittonoutletssale.or

382 louisvuittonoutletstores4u.or

382 louisvuittonoutlett.net

382 louisvuitton uick.net

382 louis-vuitton-sr -frr cisco.com

28


382 louisvuittonsold.com

3 82 DISM ISSED

3 82 DISM ISSED

382 louisvuittontonline.com

382 louisvuittontoronto.com

382 louis-vuitton-vancouver.com

382 lovelvs.net

382 lovel wiz.com

382 lovetheshoes.info

382 luxu louisvuitton4u.net

382 luxu louisvuitton4u.or

382 luxu louisvuitton4us.com

382 luxu louisvuitton4us.net

382 luxu louisvuittonoutletmcom

382 luxu louisvuittonoutleta.net

382 lux louisvuittonoutletss.com

382 luxu louisvuittonoutletss.net

382 luxu louisvuittonoutletss,or

382 lvba soutlets.or

382 lvba ssale.net

382 lvcoo.com

382 lvout.com

382 lvoutletstores.or

382 m ium iuba s.eu

382 mlouisvuittonoutlet.com

382 m louisvuittonoutlet.net

382 mlouisvuittonoutlet.or

382 m closhow.net

382 m discountba .net

382 m -discount-ba s.com

382 outletba s.or

382 outletlouisvuittolm.net

382 outletlouisvuittolm .or

382 outlet-louisvuitton-vendiu.com

382 radaba s2012.com

382 ursesfl .com

382 ueen-handba s.com

382 re lica-louis-vuitton.net

382 re lica-louisvuittonoutlet.com382 re licalouisvuitton-s.com

382 re lica-shoes-ba s.com

382 re licaslouisvuittons.net

382 saclouisvuitton4u.com

382 saclouisvuitton4u.net

382 saclouisvuitton4u.or

29


382 saclouisvuittona.net

382 saclouisvuittona.or

382 saclouisvuittonn.com

382 sac-louisvuittonn.com

382 saclouisvuittonn.net

382 sac-louisvuittolm.net

382 saclouisvuittonn.or

382 sac-louisvuittonn.or

382 sacochelouisvuittonfr.net

382 sacochelouisvuittonfr.or

382 sacochelouisvuittonfrance.com

382 sacochelouisvuitton-fr> ce.com

382 sacs-louisvuitton.biz

382 sacslouisvuittonfr.net

382 sacslouisvuittonfra.com

382 sacs-louisvuilon-france.com

382 sacslouisvuittonfrr.com

382 sacs-louisvuittorm.com

382 sacslouisvuitton aris.com

382 sacslouisvuitton aris.net

382 sacslouisvuitton aris.or

382 sacs-louisvuittons.biz

382 sacslouisvuittons.com

382 sacs-louisvuittons.com

382 sacslouisvuittons.net

382 sacs-louisvuittons.net

382 sacslouisvuittons.or

382 sacs-louisvuittons.or

382 DISM ISSE D

382 sho bar ainba s.com

382 s eed lvoutlet.com

382 s eed lvoutlet.net

382 s eed lvoutlet.or

382 ssacslouisvuittonfr.net

382 ssacslouisvuittonfr.or

382 DISM ISSE D

382 tnsui.com

382 u forsalezolz.com

382 vo ueinstore.com382 www-swissre licaswatch.com

382 essaintlaurentba s.eu

383 asho ke .com

383 ba steam.com

383 bellstim e.com

383 DISM ISSED

30


383 em acka e.com

383 hootltd.com

383 'avoot.com

383 lv laza.com

383 kava .com

383 lavoot.com

383 lvowner.com

383 lvstorecc.com

383 mobelts.com

383 mvnto.com

383 oco .com

383 oco .com

383 ba sonsell.com

383 te ot.com

383 tradebases.com

383 brandbases.com

3 8 3 DISM ISSE D

383 watchesa .com

383 watestore.com384 zolzlouisvuittonoutletsale.com

38 5 DISM ISSE D

386 8thstore.com

387 achatlouisvuitton.com

388 alihi h.com

389 allherba s.com

390 am oursacs.com391 authenticlouisvuittonoffcialsite.com

392 authenticlouisvuittonoutletzolz.net

392 authenticlouisvuittonoutlet4u.net392 chea authenticlouisvuittonoutletz.com

392 louisvuittonbeltsale.net

392 louisvuittonoffcialwebsitezu.com392 louisvuitton ursesoutletus.net

393 azati htin .com

394 ba sdi .com

395 ba sfi ht.com

396 ba sforofficialwebsite.com

396 louisvuittonoutlets reatsale.com

396 ba soutletonlinesho .com

396 ba ssho outlet.us

396 bestlvtimes.com

396 colorfulstores.com

396 fonnallouisvuitton.com

396 louisvuittonbeltm all.com

396 louisvuittonconsi nstore.com

31


396 louisvuittonlu a eofficialwebsite.com

396 louisvuittonoutletonlinesite.com

396 ofsciallouisvuittontimes.com

396 discountlouisvuittonstoremall.com

396 louisoutletstoreonlinesho .com

396 louisa ittonconsi nwebsite.com

396 louisvuittonlu a emall.com

396 louisvuiûonoutletsalemall.com

396 outletsforlouisvuittonsba .com

396 oodhandba sforlouisvuitton.com

396 louisvuittonhandba kindom .com

396 louisvuittonhandba skindom.com

396 louisvuitton urseszone.com

397 ba s-francel l.com

398 ba sonlinebu .com

399 ba s-outlet-onlinesale.com

400 ba sra .com

400 bu ba sra .com

401 ba s-watch-re lica.net

401 ba s-watch-re lica.or

401 handba -base.or

401 re lica-ba s88.com

402 bestfendihandba s.com

403 besthandba szsale.com

403 re licahandba s-au.com

404 bouti uesmalls.com

404 louisvuittonloutlet.com

404 theauthenticlouisvuitton.com

404 b elouisvuittonoutletonline.com

404 b elouisvuittonus.com

404 authenticlouisvuittonhandba ssale.com

404 dreamlouisvuittonoutletonline.com

404 dreamluxu louisvuitton.com

404 oodlouisvuittonba small.com

404 bestlouisvuittonhandba soutlets.com

404 bestlouisvuittonshoes.com

404 bestlouisvuitton ursesoutlet.com

404 bestlouisvuitton ursesoutlets.com

404 bouti uessho s.com404 louisvuittononeba .com

404 louisvuittonoutletoffcialsho .com

404 louisvuittonoutletoffcialsho s.com

405 bestlouisvuittonmall.com

406 louisvuittonm all-outlet.com

407 bestlouisvuittonmart.com

32


408 bnbelts.com

409 bolots.com

410 borselvsito.com

41 1 outletborselvsito.com

41 1 louisvuittonarts mm-us.net

41 1 louisvuittonarts mm2012.com

41 1 louisvuittonarts m-usa.net

41 1 louisvuittonarts -usa.net

41 1 louisvuitton-australia.or

41 1 louisvuitton-australia-vi .com

41 1 louisvuitton-australia-online.com

41 1 louisvuitton-australia-vi .net

41 1 louisvuittonba sonlineuk.com

41 1 louisvuitton-canada.or

41 1 louisvuittoncanada urses.com

41 1 louisvuittonoutletcr ada.net

41 1 louisvuitton-denmark.net

41 1 louisvuitton-denm ark.com

41 1 louisvuittonoutlet-' .com

4 1 1 louisvuittonoutlet-' .net

41 1 louisvuittonoutlet- laza.net

41 1 louisvuittonoutlet- laza.com

4 1 1 louisvuittonoutletukzolz.net

4 1 1 louisvuittonoutletukzolz.or

4 1 1 louisvuitton-ukin dom .com

4 1 1 uklvarts rnm .com

4 1 1 uklvarts mm .net

4 12 bowenco .com

4 12 ofever uest.com

413 bu chea louisvuittononline.com

413 bu chea louisvuittononline.net

4 14 bu -louisvuittonhandba s.com

4 15 bu louisvuittonhandba schea .com

4 16 chaneloutlethot.com

4 17 chea beltsstore.com

4 17 chea beltsstore.net

418 chea coolba .com418 wholesale'ewelr ba s.com

418 wholesale'ewelr ba ss.or

419 chea desi nerhandba ss.com

420 chea -handba -outlet.com

420 re lica-louisvuitton-onsale.com

421 chea handba sre licas.com

422 chea handba strade.com

423 chea knockoffhandba s.net

33


423 chea knockofthandba s.or

424 chea louisvuitton7o.com

424 chea louisvuitton8o.com

424 chea louisvuittonuszo.com

425 chea louisvuittonesale.com

426 chea louisvuittonhandba soutletstore.com

427 fashionhandba s2012.com428 chea lvba sonline.com

429 chea lvhandba s.us

429 favorlouisvuittonba s.com

430 chea lvhandba soutlet.net

431 onlineoutletba s.or

432 chea re licahandba sus.com

433 chea slouisvuitton.net

434 chea storestradezolz.com

434 chea storestrade888.com

434 vi louisvuitton.com

435 chinaonlinesale.net

436 chinasho brands.com437 alllouisvuittonhandba soutlet.com

437 alllouisvuittonhandba s-outlets.com

437 attendlouisvuittonclub.com

437 beaut loveslouisvuitton.com

437 besatissedwithlouisvuitton.com437 bestdesi nof erfectlv.com

437 bestsalefashionhandba s.com

437 bolsasmall.com

437 bossesmall.com

437 bu -luxuriouslouisvuitton.com

437 charmin lv roducts.com

437 classicallouisvuitlonbu .com

437 clearancelouisvuittormom com

437 discounthermesbelts.com

437 discounthermesbeltsus.com

437 discount-hermesonline.com437 discountlouisvuittonofscial.com

437 discountredbottomshoeshere.com

437 fashionshoescloutlet.com437 handba slvmalls.com

437 herebu louisvuitton.com

437 hermesbeltshotsale.com

437 he= esbeltsofûcalwebsite.com

437 hermes-hennesonlinesale.com

437 hermesofficalbeltsoutlet.com

437 hermesoffcaloutlet.com

34


437 hermesofficalstores.com

437 hermesoffcalwebsite.com

437 hi h raiseotlouisvuitton.com

437 im ortantlouisvuittonsho .com

437 louisvuittonaresoldhere.com

437 louisvuittonauthenticsale.com

437 louisvuittonba sa enc usa.com

437 louisvuittonba soutletssho s.com

437 louisvuittonchea tobu .com

437 louisvuittonclearance-usa.com

437 louisvuittoncoco.co.uk

437 louisvuittoncollectionstore.com

437 louisvuittoncoloursworld.co.uk

437 louisvuiloncolou- orld.co.uk

437 louisvuittondirectfactor .com

437 louisvuittondiscounted rice.com

437 louisvuittonfo oushow.com

437 louisvuittonfromusa.com

437 louisvuitton reatsale.com

437 louisvuittonhandba -outlet.com437 louisvuittonha ime.com

437 louisvuittoninstock.com

437 louisvuittonmos o ular.co.uk

437 louisvuittonnecesso o ou.com437 louisvuittonoffcaldiscor t.com

437 louisvuittonoffcalonlineweb.com

437 louisvuittonoffcalzoneus.com

437 louisvuittonoftkiala enc .com

437 louisvuittonofficialsalesho .com

437 louisa ittonomofscialwebsite.com

437 louisvuittonoutletrelax.com

437 louisvuittonout-lets.com

437 louisvuittonoutletwebusa.com

437 louisvuitton art sonline.com

437 louisvuitton ueensonline.com

437 louisvuittonsaleba s.com

437 louisvuittonsho s-outlet.com

437 louisvuittontruesale.com

437 louisvuittonukm all4u.co.uk437 louisvuittonuksalezolz.co.uk

437 louisvuittonukvi sho s.co.uk

437 louisvuittonusaoffcaloutlet.com

437 louisvuittonusawebhere.com

437 louisvuittonwebonline.com

437 louisvuittonwebsonline.com

35


437 louisvuittonwholesalem all.co.uk

437 louisvuitton-wholesalemalls.com437 louisvuittonwidedelive .com

437 lowest ricelouisvuittonsho .com

437 luxu louisvuittoutlet4u.com

437 lvattract ou.com

437 lvforselectin herefor ou.com

437 lvforselectin hereto ou.com

437 lvinbest ricestore.com

437 lvrealiableonline.com437 lvsho in outlethere.com

437 lvwarm ourhearhere.com

437 mallfashionlv.com

437 newarrivalsoiouisvuilon.com

437 offerslouisvuitton.com

437 ofûcallouisvuilonusaoutlet.com

437 ofscalslouisvuittonusaoutlet.com

437 ofscaltodsoutlet.com

437 officaltodsussho .com

437 ofsciallouisvuittons.or

437 officiallouisvuittonsho .com

437 officiallouisvuitton-sho s.com

437 ofscialsitelouisvuitton4u.com

437 officialtodsforsale.com

437 o uln holesalelouisvuitton.com

437 rofessionalhermesoutlet.com

437 redbottomshoesclonline.com

437 salelouisvuittonforcustomers.com437 scszonelol .com

437 sho discountedlouisvuittonba s.com

437 thenewestlouisvuittonsale.com

437 to levellouisvuittonsho .com

437 uni ueba slouisvuitton.com

437 variousdesi nslouisvuitton.com

437 websitesofsciallouisvuidon.com

437 wholesale-louisvuittons.com

437 oucanaffordforlvnow.com

438 cnre licalouisvuitton.com

439 cnto wholesale.com

440 coachs ursesforchea .com

441 co luxur .biz

442 co re licawatches.com

443 cristin .com

444 DISM ISSED

445 cvtoo.com

36


446 desi nba 4sale.com

447 desi nerimitation-handba s.com

447 discountlouisvuittonoutlet4u.com

448 desi nerscarveszu.bz

449 discountlouisvuittonsales.com

449 eluxu lvbrand.com

449 re licalvlu a e2012.com

450 discountlvlouisvuitton.com

451 eas ohandba s.com

451 eas ohandba ss.com452 eba szu.com453 eba louisvuittonba s.com

454 edenwatches.net

455 elouisvuittonsale.com456 eluxu ba soutlet.com

457 eluxu on.com

458 eluxu o 4ba .com

459 factor coachoutletstore.com

460 fakedesi ner.net

461 fakeknockofthandba s.com

462 fakelouisvuittonsun lasses.com

463 fakescoachs urses.net

464 fashionlvhandba s.com

465 fasttwooutlet.com

466 flouisvuittonoutlet.com

467 francelvstore.com

468 francesaclouisvuitton.com

468 louisvuiûonsiteoffcielfr.com

469 frsaclouisvuittonsac.net

470 etwatchdiscount.com

471 oodchinawholesale.com

472 oodscoachhandba .com

473 handba .vc

474 handba slouis-vuitton.or

475 handba soutletonlines.com

475 handba soutletonlines.net

476 handba sto ou.com

477 heaven-markets.net

477 heaven-markets.or

478 hi h-ore lica-handba s.com

478 hi h- re lica-handba s.com

479 hiwholesalesun lasses.com

479 to wholesalein.com

479 wholesalesun lassesin.com

480 hot orteroluxu .com

37


481 hotshandba s.com

482 iknockoffhandba s.com

483 ilouisvuittonba s.com

484 ins ired4ba s.com484 mono ram chea .com

485 knockoff-online.com

486 1ad sfields.com

487 link-lv.com

488 liousvuittonsale.com

488 louisvuittonsaleu.com

489 DISM ISSED

490 louievuitton.net

491 louisba sale.su

492 louis o.com

493 louisok.com

494 louissac ascher.com495 louisvuitonsaleoutletuk.com

495 re licalouisvuittonlu a eus.com

495 re licalouisvuittonlu a eusa.com

495 re licalouisvuittonsaleus.com

495 re licalouisvuittonsaleusa.com

495 re licaslouisvuittonuk.com

496 louisvuittonzolzba s.com

497 louisvuittonba sab.com

497 louisvuittonba schea est.com

497 louisvuittonhandba sab.com

497 lvoutlet ro.com

498 louisvuittonba sell.com

499 louisvuittonba sonlines.com

500 louisvuittonba sonsale l.net

501 louisvuittonba ssale-usa.com

501 louisvuittonba ssale-usa.net

502 louis-vuitton-ba s-store.com

503 louisvuittonba s-usmcom

504 louisvuittonbrasil.or

505 louisvuittonchea online.com

506 louisvuitton-chea outlet.com

507 louisvuittonclubl.com

507 louisvuittonclub4.com

507 louisvuittonclub8.com508 louis-vuitton-for-chea .com

508 louis-vuitton-for-sale.com

509 louisvuittonforchea on.net5 10 louisvuittonhandba s2012.net

5 1 1 louisvuittonhandba s-chea .net

38


512 louisvuittonhandba schea sale.com

512 louisvuittonchea handba ssale.com

513 louisvuittonhandba s-for-sale.com514 louisvuittonhandba sonsa1e2012.or514 louisvuittolahandba sonsale-usa.or

514 louisvuittonhandba susa2012.net514 louisvuitton-handba sus.net

514 louisvuittonhandba sonsalestore.net

515 louisvuittonhandba ssac.com516 louissvuittonshandba susa.us

516 louisvuittonhandba susa.us517 louisvuitton-ital .net

518 louis-vuitton-knockoffs-ba s.com

519 louisvuittonlu a eba s.com

520 louisvuittonlvfacto .net

521 louisvuittonm ono ramoutlet.com

52 1 lvusastore.com

522 louisvuittonnz.eu

523 louisvuittonoffcialoutletszolz.com

524 louisvuittonoffcialwebsite.us

525 vuittonsho onlinesaletaschen.com

525 louisvuittononlinekaufen.com

526 louisvuittononlinen.com

526 louisvuittononlinen.or

526 louisvuittonoutlet-mi.com

526 louisvuittonlines-outlet.com

526 louisvuittonoutletusm all.net

527 louis-vuitton-onlinesho .com

527 louis-vuitton-onlinesho .or

528 louisvuitton-online-store.com

529 louisvuittonoutletzol4.com

530 louisvuittonhandba s-australia.com530 louisvuidonoutlet-australia.net

531 louisvuittonoutletax.com

532 louisvuittonoutletba sa.net

532 louisvuittonoutletba sn.com

532 louisvuittonoutletba scanada.com

533 louisvuittonoutletcou on.us

534 louisvuittonoutletfonz.com

535 louissvuittonoutlethandba s.net

535 louisvuitton-outlet-handba sz.net

536 louisvuittonoutletli.com

537 louisvuittonoutletlover.us

538 louisvuittonoutlet urse.com

538 ba ssho in zone.com

39


539 louisvuittonoutletsales.com

540 louisvuittonoutletsba .com

541 louisvuittonoutletsiteonline.com

542 louisvuitton-outletstore.co

543 louisvuitton acka e.or

544 louisvuitton ascherde.com

545 chea lv urse2012.com

545 louisvuitton urse2012.net

545 louisvuitton urses2012.net

546 louisvuitton tlrses-australia.net

547 louisvuitton ursesonline.net

547 louisvuitton urses-online.net

547 louisvuitton urses-online.or

548 louisvuitton urse-outlet.or

548 louisvuitton urses-outlet.or

549 louisvuitton- ursesvi .com

549 louisvuitton- lzrsesvi .net

550 louisvuittom'e licaa.com

551 louisvuittonre licaau.com

552 louisvuittonre lica-ba s.com

553 louis-vuittonre licas.net

553 re licalouisvuittons.net

553 louisvuitton-s.net

553 1ux -louisvuitton-ba s.com

553 needlvhandba s.com

554 louis-vuittonre licas.or

555 louisvuittonsacamain.net

556 louisvuittonsacenli ne.com

557 louisvuittonsacoche.biz

558 louisvuittonsacsale.com

559 louisvuittonsacsonline.com

560 louisvuittonsale.us561 louisvuittonsaleonline.com

562 louisvuitton-saleonline.com

562 saclouisvuitton-solde.com

563 louisvuittonsale-usa.com

564 louis-vuitton-sho .it

565 louisvuittonsho official.com

566 louisvuittonstorefr.net

566 louisvuittonstorefr.or

567 louisvuittontoteoutlet.com

568 louisvuitton-v.com

569 louisvuittonvinta e.com

570 louivuitton-ba .com

571 louivuittonba s.or

40


572 louivuittonsacszolz.com

573 lovershandba s.com

574 lovin uccisho .com

575 luisvuitton.biz

576 lurehandba s.net

576 lure-handba s.net

577 luxelouis.com

578 luxur louisvuittonsho .com

579 luxu re licahandba s.net

580 lv4shoes.com

58 1 lvba outlet.net

582 lvba s1854.com

583 lvba s2012.net

584 louisvuitton urseswallet.info

584 lvba swallet tlrses.info

585 lvba thin .com

586 lvhandba soutlet-zolz.com

586 lvhandba soutlet2012.or

587 lvhandba sre licas.com

587 lvoutletchea sale.com

588 lvlouisvuitton-ba s.com

589 lvlouisvuittondeals.com

590 lvlouisvuittononline.com

591 lvonlineba s.com

592 lvoutletlux .com

593 lvoutletsale.net

593 uklouisvuittonn.com

593 uklvsho s.com

593 louisvuittonsalesmall.com

593 uslouisvuittonstore.net

594 lvoutletsale.or

594 sho lvoutlets.com

595 lv-outlet-storel.com

596 lvoutletsus.com

597 lv-re lica.biz

598 lvuittonhandba s.com

599 lvuittonoutletonline.com

600 lvukhandba .com

601 m axchea er.com

601 m ilanns.com

602 m v 'eweller .com

602 DISM ISSED

603 m xscc.com

604 m ba outlet.com

605 m chea ucci.com

41


606 m ha ba s.com

607 net-lv.com

608 n louisvuittonbelts.com

609 ohtimes.com

6 10 oka win.com61 1 olhand.com

612 onlinechea handba .com

613 ourslouisvuittonoutletwells.com

613 ourslouisvuittonoutletzone.com

614 outletlouis-vuitton.com

614 outletslouis-vuitton.net

615 outletlouis-vuitton.net

616 oout.com

617 o handba sonsale.com

618 rofessionallouisvuitton.com

619 remise-sacs.com

619 remisesacs-zolz.com

620 re licaba sin.com

621 re lica-ba sus.com

622 re licabrands.or

623 re licachea louisvuittonba s.com

624 re licahandba sca.com

625 re licahandba sstock.com

626 re lica-handba store.com

627 re licahandba store.or

628 re licalouisvuittonl8s4.com

629 re licalouisvuittonau.com

630 re licalouisvuittonbb.com

630 re licalouisvuittonlvba .com

631 re licalouisvuittonlu a eoutlet.com

632 re licalouisvuittonwholesale.com

633 re licalvba szone.com

634 re lica-sho e.com

635 re licaslouisvuittonchea .com

636 rmba .com

637 louisvuittonsacc.info

637 sac- ucci ascher.info638 sacllouisvuitton4 .com

638 sacsslouisvuittonfr.com

639 saclouisvuitton-france.net

640 saclouisvuittonhommes.com

641 saclvfrancevendre.com

641 saclvma asin.com

642 sacm ono ram .com643 sacochelouisvuitton ascher.net

42


644 sac ascher4u.net

645 sacsvuitton.com

646 frvuittonsacs ascher.com

646 sacvuittons eed rix.com

646 chezmaevasavoie.net

646 sacvuittons eed rix.net

647 shoestm lasses.com

648 sho toba s.com

648 sho tohandba s.com

649 sho o .com

650 luck emall.com

650 st 1in ba s.com651 sun lassesonlinezolz.net

65l usasun lassesoutlet.net

651 usasun lassesoutlets.com

651 thelouisvuittonoutlets.net

651 uslouisvuittonoutletzu.net

652 stm lassho in .com

652 sun lassho in .net

653 taschenhandtaschensho .com

654 thelouisvuittonba soutlet.or655 outlets-louisvuitton-ba s.com

655 to louisvuittonoutlets-usa.com

656 to -luxu handba .com657 to ualit louisvuitton.com

658 to re licahandba sbu .com

658 wholesalechea re licahandba s.com

659 to -re licaluxu .net

660 totall urse.com

661 touba .com

662 uchea louisvuittonzozo.com

663 luxsho .su664 eluxur collections.com

664 uk-eluxu .com

665 uklouishandba s.com

666 ushandba soutlets.com667 uslouisvuittonwebsite.net

668 vi chea handba s.com

669 vo uefemale.com

670 vuittonsoldessac.com

671 watchesxx.com

672 wholesalefob.com673 oun handba s.com

674 DISM ISSED

43


Case 1:12-cv-21778-PAS Document 105 Entered on FLSD · PDF fileCase 1:12-cv-21778-PAS Document...

Documents

Transcript of Case 1:12-cv-21778-PAS Document 105 Entered on FLSD · PDF fileCase 1:12-cv-21778-PAS Document...