Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
-
Upload
northeast-wind-resource-center-nwrc -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
0
Transcript of Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 1/17
Perspectives on Impacts of Land-based
Wind Energy Developmentin New England
New England Wind Energy Education ProjectConference and Workshop
Marlborough, MA
7 June 2011
Carol R. FossNew Hampshire Audubon
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 2/17
Direct vs. Indirect Impacts
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 3/17
Direct Impacts
• Impact type: Mortality
• Mechanism: Collisions with turbines
• Affected organisms: Birds and bats• Documentation methods: Mortality surveys
– Carcass searches
– Searcher efficiency trials
– Scavenger removal trials
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 4/17
Factors included in fatality estimates
• # of carcasses found
• Searcher efficiency rate
•
Carcass removal rate by scavengers• Proportion of turbines searched
• Correction factor for non-searchable areas in
turbine search plots• Search interval (e.g., daily, weekly)
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 5/17
Studies included in fatality summary(J. Costa, 2011. Post-construction wildlife monitoring and results at terrestrial wind
farms. Wind Energy and Wildlife Forum, Orono, ME, 5 May 2011)
• Maine – Mars Hill (2007, 2008)
– Stetson Mountain I (2009)
– Stetson Mountain II (2010)
•New Hampshire – Lempster (2009)
• New York – Bliss (2008)
– Clinton (2008)
Cohocton and Dutch Hill (2009, 2010) – Ellenburg (2008)
– Maple Ridge (2006, 2007, 2008)
– Munnsville (2008)
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 6/17
Uncorrected proportions of bird and bat fatalities at
New England and New York
Wind Energy Facilities
Birds
Bats
(J. Costa, 2011. Post-construction wildlife monitoring and results at terrestrial wind farms.
Wind Energy and Wildlife Forum, Orono, ME, 5 May 2011)
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 7/17
Passerine
Unidentified
GameRaptor
Shorebird
Waterfowl
Owl
Seabird
Uncorrected bird fatalities reported from
New York and New England wind energy facilities
(J. Costa, 2011. Post-construction wildlife monitoring and results at terrestrial wind farms.
Wind Energy and Wildlife Forum, Orono, ME, 5 May 2011)
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 8/17
Golden-crowned Kinglet
Red-eyed Vireo
Magnolia Warbler
European Starling
Ruffed Grouse
Black-throated Blue
Warbler
Predominant bird fatalities at wind energy facilities
in New England and New York
(J. Costa, 2011. Post-construction wildlife monitoring and results at terrestrial wind farms.
Wind Energy and Wildlife Forum, Orono, ME, 5 May 2011)
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 9/17
(J. Costa, 2011. Post-construction wildlife monitoring and results at terrestrial wind farms.
Wind Energy and Wildlife Forum, Orono, ME, 5 May 2011)
Uncorrected bat fatalities reported from
New York and New England wind energy facilities
Hoary bat
Little brown bat
Silver-haired bat
Eastern red bat
Big brown bat
Northern long-eared
bat
Tri-colored bat
Unidentified
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 10/17
Min
Max
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
New
England (4)New York (6)
Mid-Atlantic
and
Southeast
(3)
Midwest (3) Southwest
and West (9) Northwest
(9)
Min
Max
(J. Costa, 2011. Post-construction wildlife monitoring and results at terrestrial wind farms.
Wind Energy and Wildlife Forum, Orono, ME, 5 May 2011)
Regional comparison of estimated
minimum and maximum bird mortalities(individual per turbine per study period)
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 11/17
(J. Costa, 2011. Post-construction wildlife monitoring and results at terrestrial wind farms.
Wind Energy and Wildlife Forum, Orono, ME, 5 May 2011)
Regional comparison of estimated
minimum and maximum bat mortalities(individual per turbine per study period)
Min
Max
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
New EnglandNew York
Mid-Atlantic
and
Southeast
MidwestSouthwest
and West Northwest
Min
Max
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 12/17
Indirect Impacts
• Impact types: Habitat loss, fragmentation, anddegradation
• Mechanisms: Forest clearing, human activity,
turbine noise• Affected organisms: Forest-dependent species
• Documentation methods: Before-after-
control-impact studies
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 13/17
Indirect Impacts
• Indirect impacts in northeastern forests have
received little study to date
• Studies of impacts on American marten and
Bicknell’s thrush are currently underway at the
Granite Reliable Power project in Coos County, New
Hampshire
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 14/17
• Standardization of methods and metrics is
needed to enable regional analyses of
mortality data
• Collaborative studies involving multiple sites
will be critically important in understanding
indirect impacts on wildlife
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 15/17
Habitat Loss
• Habitats of greatest concern
– High elevation spruce-fir forest
• Limited supply on the landscape
• Support a number of habitat specialists
• Loss of area can lead to local extirpations if remaining
patch size is insufficient to support breeding population
– Ridge-top mast stands
• Provide important resource for wide-ranging species
• Loss of area can impact populations over large areas
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 16/17
Habitat Degradation
• Habitats of greatest concern
– High elevation spruce-fir forest
• Cleared patches expose adjacent forest to increased
winds, which leads to progressive wind-throw onshallow soils
• Cleared patches expose adjacent forest floor to dryingeffects of sun and wind, decreasing invertebratepopulations that support insectivorous species
– Headwater streams and seeps• Roadcuts interrupt natural hydrology, create run-off
and siltation that degrade water quality
8/11/2019 Carol Foss Slides 6.7.11
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/carol-foss-slides-6711 17/17
Noise Impacts
• Essentially nothing is known about wildliferesponse to turbine noise in eastern forests
• Areas for research include
– Potential impacts on predator-prey relationships• Target species for study – owls
– Potential impacts on intra-species communication
• Target species for study – songbirds
– Potential impacts on large mammal winteringconcentrations
• Target species for study – moose and deer