Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

11
MARKSTRAT SIMULATION MKT 6339 UTD SPRING 2014 BUFFALO Team TaunTaun Paul Flesher Zhaodi(Jodi) Liu Tanachai Thosapornvichai Michael Stone

Transcript of Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

Page 1: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

MARKSTRAT

SIMULATION

MKT 6339

UTD SPRING 2014

BUFFALO

Team TaunTaun

Paul Flesher

Zhaodi(Jodi) Liu

Tanachai Thosapornvichai

Michael Stone

Page 2: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

STARTING POSITION & STRATEGY

• Sonite Market – 20% Market Share

Initial Position

• Vodites are the KEY

• Be first to Vodites

• Maintain position in Sonites

• Avoid spreading to thin

Initial Strategy

Page 3: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

OBJECTIVES & ACTUAL PERFORMANCE

0

200

400

600

800

1,000

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

TaunTaun

Legend

Resolute

Marvelus

Sharks

• WIN

• 50% Vodite Market Share

• 10% Sonite Market Share

Objectives

• Cum Net Contribution = $904M

• 55% Vodite Market Share

• 8% Sonite Market Share

Actual Performance

Page 4: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

STRATEGY: TRIAL ROUNDS R&D Queries vs. Feasibility Studies

Sonite Feasibility Studies Never Profitable

Determine Required Budget for first Vodite

Page 5: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

STRATEGY: PERIODS 1 & 2

Target profitable segments

TOPS – Maximize penetration

TONE – Maintain market presence

Needed $6.4 M, Period 2 Budget = $8.1

Expected Loss of NC in Period 2

Cut Advertising & CT to $1.7 M

Page 6: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

STRATEGY: PERIOD 3 & 4TEEK Period 3 Period 4

Target Innovators Innovators

Price $2,000 $1,850

Production 111,000 140,000

Sales 95,000 168,000

Net Contribution $63 M $107 M

Price Semantic 6.5 6.5

Period 3 Results TEEK TOPS TONE

Net Contribution 63,471 12,590 3589

Marketing Expenses 4,227 1,662 993

Return on Marketing Investment

15.0 7.6 3.6

• Market

Size?

• Price?

• Production?

Vodite

• ROMI

• Drop TONE Sonite

Page 7: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

STRATEGY: PERIOD 5

New Competition

Launch 2 Vodites

TEMOC

TEMAK

Cancel Sonite for Savers

Page 8: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

STRATEGY: PERIOD 5 & BEYOND

Reposition TEEK (Adopters)

Market Growth??

Theory: Pricing is King

Set as close to ideal point as possible

Estimated Actual

Period 4 72+66+20= 158 74+71+23= 168

Period 5 84+110+77= 271 49+70+58= 177

Page 9: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

POSITION GOING FORWARD

Meet Customer Preferences

Research & Development

P9 Update for TEMOC/TEMAK

New Sonite for Savers?

Vodite pricing now optimal

Top ROMI Brands

Sonite: 5.74 vs. 4.56 (R, 2nd)

Vodite: 8.72 vs. 3.17 (R, 2nd)

• $849

• 4.24 - Perception 4.37 - Ideal

TEMOC

#1 Vodite

23.9% Mkt Share

• $899

• 4.64 - Perception 4.37 - Ideal

TEMAK

#3 Vodite

16.3% Mkt Share

• $999

• 4.96 - Perception 4.91- Ideal

TEEK

#4 Vodite

14.9% Mkt Share

Page 10: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

IMPORTANT LESSONS LEARNED

• First mover has a big advantage

• Always consider ROI

• Brand awareness is vital

• Pricing matters

• Be organized & have defined roles

• Study the competition

• Be decisive

Page 11: Capstone Decision Making —— Taun Taun Team Presentation

QUESTIONS?