Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in...

53
Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation 2013 Louisiana Transportation Conference Section 68 Public Works Randy Denmon, P.E., Denmon Engineering Bradley Sticker, P.E., DOTD

Transcript of Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in...

Page 1: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Cane River Lake

Spillway Rehabilitation

2013 Louisiana Transportation Conference

Section 68 – Public Works

Randy Denmon, P.E., Denmon Engineering

Bradley Sticker, P.E., DOTD

Page 2: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Topics

Background & Purpose

Spillway Data

Spillway History

Spillway Rehabilitation

Gate Rehabilitation

Concrete Rehabilitation

Page 3: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Cane River Lake Information

Located in Natchitoches Parish

A relic Red River Channel

Classified Significant Hazard

16,000 Acre-Feet Storage

1,350 Acre Surface Area

• Approximately 34 miles long

Page 4: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Cane River Lake Information

Two embankments

• North embankment near Natchitoches (part of Red

River Levee)

• South embankment near Derry under LA 484

One spillway structure

• LA 484 passes over spillway structure

North

Embankment South

Embankment

Page 5: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 6: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway Purpose

Lake and Spillway have multiple roles

Irrigation water supply

• Several thousand acres irrigated

Recreation

Drainage

Page 7: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway Data

LA 484 passes over spillway structure

Three sided weir inlet @ elev. 98.0’

(96’ total weir length)

Two 10’ wide by 5’ deep drawdown gates in

weir

Four 6’x6’ RCB conduits

56’ long with inlet invert

at elev. 90.0’

(conduit slope 27%)

Four 6’x6’ sluice gates

on RCB outlets

Page 8: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway Inlet

Page 9: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway Outlet

Page 10: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway History

Spillway designed by DPW in 1947

Cane River Levee and Drainage District

Awarded spillway contract July 20, 1948

Award amount $70,366.97

Completed July 8, 1949

Page 11: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Spillway History

Embankment slides in early 1980s

Repaired 1983 with H piles and bulkhead

No record of replacement of drawdown

gates

Minimal maintenance over structure life

Page 12: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

DOTD Involvement

RS 38:306 D.

DOTD provides engineering work for Levee

Boards

Responsibilities:

NLDD responsible for earthen embankments

NLDD operates outfall gates on spillway

RS 34:3262 CRWC responsible for

establishment, operation and maintenance of

navigable waterway

DOTD responsible for LA 484 over spillway

Page 13: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Why Was Rehab Needed?

Page 14: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Why Was Rehab Needed?

Loss of the management gates:

Impact local farmers

Close lake to recreation

Impact riparian property value

Impact City of Natchitoches Festival of Lights

Page 15: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

DOTD Involvement

Provided historical documents

Provided review and consultation of

proposals

Page 16: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

SPILLWAY

REHABILITATION

Page 17: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

MAP

Page 18: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 19: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 20: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 21: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 22: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 23: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 24: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 25: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

SOIL TYPE - CLAY

LIQUID LIMIT: 71

P.I.: 24

Page 26: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

OLD PLANS

Page 27: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 28: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 29: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 30: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 31: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 32: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 33: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 34: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

EPOXY GROUTING

Page 35: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 36: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 37: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 38: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 39: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 40: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 41: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 42: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

PROBLEMS

350 LINEAR FEET CRACKS

2200 SQUARE FEET EXPOSED

CONCRETE

NEEDED TO GROUT AND SEAL

CRACKS

ALSO, COAT THE SPILLWAY WITH A

CORRISION INHIBATOR

Page 43: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

SPECIFICATIONS

STRUCTURAL REPAIR OF CONCRETE

CRACKS BY INJECTION OF EPOXY

RESIN ADHESIVE – LTRC, 1989

EVALUATION AND REPAIR OF

CONCRETE STRUCTURES, USACE, EM

1110-2-2002, 1995

STRUCTUAL CRACK REPAIR BY

EPOXY INJECTION, ACI, 2003

Page 44: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

PRODUCTS

Page 45: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

SPECIFICATON - ACI

Page 46: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 47: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 48: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 49: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

Up close injection

Page 50: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 51: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 52: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet
Page 53: Cane River Lake Spillway Rehabilitation of the... · Cane River Lake Information Located in Natchitoches Parish A relic Red River Channel Classified Significant Hazard 16,000 Acre-Feet

EPOXY GROUTING

COST: $85/FOOT (CRACK REPAIR)

$3.35/SQ. FT. (COATING)

TOTAL COST: $39,120

VERY QUICK AND ECONOMICAL

REPAIR

MANY LAKES IN LOUISIANA ARE 50 TO

80 YEARS OLD WITH LITTLE OR NO

MAINTENANCE