7/30/2019 Can Grease Cleanliness Be Defined

1/2

Current Issue

Archive

Subscribe

Search:

Can Grease Cleanliness Be Defined?

Chuck Coe, NLGITags: greases

Grease cleanliness is a common topic of discussion among grease suppliers, bearing

manufacturers and end users, all of whom tend to hold strong opinions on the subject.

Numerous technical papers as well as magazine articles have addressed both the importance

of cleanliness in greases as well as the frustration over the lack of an industry-accepted

definition or measure of cleanliness.

The Draft Definition

To address these concerns, a joint working group has met at both NLGI and ELGI annual

meetings for the past several years. Recently, in light of the various ways of defining and

measuring grease cleanliness, the group has agreed on a draft definition to ensure focused

efforts.

Before defining the term, the group had to sort through a series of cleanliness classifications

based on specified levels of filtration and/or packaging. Other definitions were derived from

existing ASTM, DIN or other test method standards - some of which count and size particles

in the grease, measure noise in bearings caused by particles in grease, measure the amount(weight) of particles and evaluate the abrasiveness of particles.

The draft definition of grease cleanliness was defined by the working group as:

A measure of the absence of particulate matter that has the potential to cause damage

in certain applications.

A measure of the suitability of a grease for applications in which contamination by

particulate matter would cause damage to the pieces in contact with the lubricant. The

extent of contamination can be measured by the size, number and/or hardness of the

particulate matter.

Note: The types of particulate contamination could include scale and wear metals from the

manufacturing process, burned soap and additives, and dirt and sand.

Test Method Evaluation

To meet this definition, the working group reviewed various standardized test methods for

their applicability, simplicity, cost and availability of test equipment and level of precision (if

available). During the ELGI annual meeting in April of 2006 (Prague), a proposal was made

to combine two standardized test methods, the ASTM D1404 and Hegman gauge methods;

therefore the number, size distribution and hardness of the particulate matter in a grease

sample could be measured.

The ASTM D1404 "Deleterious Particles" method provides a means to count the number of

hard particles in a specified sample size. In this method, the number of scratches that

appear on the surface of highly polished acrylic plates under specified test conditions are

counted. Greases would then be rated 1 through 3 as follows: 1 = less than 10 scratches, 2

= 11 to 40 scratches and 3 = more than 40 scratches.

The second test is the Hegman gauge, in which particles are counted and sized from 0 to 100

microns using a machined depth gauge. The greases would then be rated as follows: A =

clean (0 particles > 100 microns), B = moderate (1 to 5 particles > 100 microns) or C =

dirty (more than 5 particles > 100 microns).

The results of the two tests are combined into a 3x3 grid, and the grease is given one of

nine ratings, from 1A to 3C. The ratings indicate both the number and size of particulates in

Related Articles

Step-by-Step Grease Selection

Putting Too Much Faith in Multipurpose Grease

Grease Basics

Controlling Degradation in BiodegradableGreases

White Papers

When Do Synthetic Lubricants Make Sense?

An Introduction to the SPM HD Method

Waste Water Treatment Solutions

Continuing Evolution of Food Grade Lubricants

Buyers Guide

Grease Guns

Cleaners and Degreasers

Maintenance Services and Products

Poll

Thanks for completing this survey.

Which type of isolation valve do youprefer for hydraulic pump intake lines?

Response

Percent

Ball Valve 69.2%

Butterfly Valve 15.4%

Both 6.2%

Neither 9.2%

Results for open-ended questions are not displayed.

Home | Buyers Guide | Glossary | Events | Bookstore | Newsletters | Browse Topics

GREASES HYDRAULICS INDUSTRIAL LUBRICANTS SYNTHETICS FILTRATION STORAGE/HANDLING OIL ANALYSIS

Grease Cleanliness Be Defined? http://www.machinerylubrication.com/Read/1100/grease-cleanliness

2 30/05/2012 13:40

7/30/2019 Can Grease Cleanliness Be Defined

2/2

the grease as well as the hardness of the particles.

Data from a number of samples is being evaluated on a mini round-robin basis to assess how

different labs compare for both clean and contaminated greases. So far, data has been

collected from three participating labs, and no conclusions will be drawn until data is

received from three more participants.

Machinery Lubrication (9/2007)

Related Articles

Step-by-Step Grease Selection

Putting Too Much Faith in Multipurpose Grease

Grease Basics

Controlling Degradation in Biodegradable Greases

NORIA CORPORATION MACHINERY LUBRICATION | RELIABLE PLANT

Services Subscribe | Contact Us | Privacy Policy | RSS | Advertise

Quick Links Home | Buyers Guide | Glossary | Events | Bookstore | Newsletters | Browse Topics

Grease Cleanliness Be Defined? http://www.machinerylubrication.com/Read/1100/grease-cleanliness

2 30/05/2012 13:40