Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

14
Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014 CASE SERIES Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical Periodontitis : A Case Series Mithun Jith.K 1 , Jerry J 2 Sathyanarayanan R 3 ABSTRACT: A common sequlae to pulp disease is development of periapical lesions. Chronic periapical lesions mostly occur without any episode of acute pain and are discovered on routine radiographic examination. It’s a well accepted fact that all inflammatory periapical lesions should be initially treated with conservative nonsurgical procedures. Studies have reported a success rate of up to 85% after endodontic treatment of teeth with periapical. lesions. With various biologic properties, calcium hydroxide has been widely used in endodontics from its introduction in 1920. Large size of a chronic periapical lesion does not always mandate its surgical removal, and that even cyst-like periapical lesions heal following a conservative endodontic therapy with long term calcium hydroxide therapy. This case series highlights the importance of calcium hydroxide being used as intracanal medicament with standard proctocols and time frame and also on different non surgical treatment strategies for management of chronic apical periododontitis patients. Keywords: Calcium hydroxide, Chroinc apical periododontitis, endodontic therapy, calcium hydroxide therapy T he outcome of the endodontic therapy depends on reduction or elimination of bacteria from the root canal space. The major factor associated with endodontic failure are the persistence of microbial infection in the root canal system and/or the periradicular area 1,2 . The most essential step in aiming at complete disinfection of the root canal space is the chemo mechanical preparation. However, total elimination of bacteria is difficult to accomplish 3,4,5 . For the elimination of the surviving bacteria, calcium hydroxide is placed as an intracanal medicament between appointments 5 . Apical periodontitis is caused by bacteria within the canal space 6,7 . The treatment of apical periodontitis should, therefore, aim at bacterial eradication. Since cleaning and shaping alone do not completely and effectively eliminate bacteria 8 , it seems 24 Scan the QR code with any smart phone scanner or PC scanner software to download/ share this publication

Transcript of Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Page 1: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

CASE SERIES

Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical Periodontitis : A

Case Series

Mithun Jith.K 1 , Jerry J2 Sathyanarayanan R3

ABSTRACT: A common sequlae t o pulp disease is development of per iapical lesions. Chron ic

per iapical lesions most l y occur without any episode of a cute pain and are discovered on

rout ine r adiograph ic examination . I t ’s a wel l accepted fact that a l l in flammatory per iapical

lesi ons should be in i t ial ly t r eated with conservat ive nonsurgical procedures. Studies have

repor ted a success r a te of up to 85% after endodon t ic tr eatmen t of teeth with per iapical .

lesi ons. With various biologi c proper t ies, calcium hydroxide has been widely used in

endodon t ics from i ts in t roduct ion in 1920. Large size of a ch ron ic per iapical lesion does not

a lways mandate i ts surgical r emoval , and that even cyst - l ike per iapical lesions heal fol l owing

a conservat ive endodon t ic therapy with long term calcium hydroxide therapy. Th is case ser ies

h ighl igh ts the impor tance of calcium hydroxide being used as in tracanal medicament with

standard proctocols and t ime frame and also on differen t non surgical tr eatmen t str ategies for

management of ch ron ic apical per iododon t i t is pat ien ts.

Keywords: Calcium hydroxide, Chroinc apical per iododon t i t is, endodon t ic therapy, calcium

hydroxide therapy

T he outcome of the endodontic therapy

depends on reduction or elimination of

bacteria from the root canal space. The major

factor associated with endodontic failure are

the persistence of microbial infection in the

root canal system and/or the periradicular

area1,2. The most essential step in aiming at

complete disinfection of the root canal space

is the chemo mechanical preparation.

However, total elimination of bacteria is

difficult to accomplish3,4,5. For the elimination

of the surviving bacteria, calcium hydroxide is

placed as an intracanal medicament between

appointments5.

Apical periodontitis is caused by bacteria

within the canal space6,7. The treatment of

apical periodontitis should, therefore, aim at

bacterial eradication. Since cleaning and

shaping alone do not completely and

effectively eliminate bacteria8, it seems

24

Scan the QR

code with any

smart phone

scanner or PC

scanner software to download/

share this

publication

Page 2: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

logical to medicate canals with an intracanal

antibacterial medicament after biomechanical

preparation. A success rate of 80.8%9 has

been reported with calcium hydroxide, when

used for endodontic treatment of teeth with

periradicular lesions.

Calcium hydroxide has been widely used in

endodontics from the time it was introduced in

Endodontics by Herman in 1920. With a pH

of approximately 12.5 it is a strong alkaline

substance. In an aqueous solution, calcium

hydroxide dissociates into calcium and

hydroxyl ions. Various biological properties

have been attributed to this substance, such as

antibacterial activity 4, tissue-dissolving

ability10, inhibition of tooth resorption11, and

repairing ability by hard tissue formation12. At

present, calcium hydroxide is acknowledged

as one of the most effective antibacterial

intracanal medicament during endodontic

therapy.

This case series highlights the importance of

calcium hydroxide being used as a intracanal

medicament in persisting non healing chronic

apical periodontitis.

CASE REPORT 1: (Fig 1)

Patient reported with loose failing bridge on

left bottom teeth. Clinical examination

revealed cantilever bridge with crown in 36 as

abutment for pontic 35. Radiograph revealed

root treated 36 with deficient lateral

condensat ion and huge per iapica l

radiolucency with radio opaque border

suggestive of a chronic lesion. (Fig 1A)

Conventional retreatment as the first line of

treatment was planned. Bridge was removed

and root canal was re entered under cotton roll

isolation. Mesial canal was intentionally over

instrumented with 25 no K file. 25 no. K file

was extended till approximately the centre of

the lesion which was about 2 mm beyond

apex. Upon instrumentation profuse bleeding

was present. Copious irrigation was done with

normal saline and plain cotton dressing was

placed and temporary coronal seal was done

with zinc oxide eugenol. One week later,

Calcium hydroxide mixed with glycerin was

coated in the canal with lentulo spiral and the

access cavity was sealed with reinforced glass

ionomer restorative material, as the patient

was not available for next three months.

Temporary bridge was fabricated and

cemented with zinc phosphate. (Fig 1B)

Four months later patient reported with no

complaint and the bridge was removed. The

coronal seal was intact with good marginal

seal. Radiograph revealed questionable

evidence of root formation. As the patient was

travelling again for four months, the same

calcium hydroxide therapy was planned. This

time calcium hydroxide was mixed with

virgin coconut oil (based on unpublished

research study by the author) and coated with

lentulo spiral and temporary coronal seal was

done with reinforced glass ionomer (fuji GC

Type IX). The temporary bridge was

recemented with zinc phosphate. (Fig 1C)

Patient reported after three months. Clinically

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

25

Page 3: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

asymptomatic and radiologically there were

some signs of bone formation and reduction in

periapical radiolucency (Fig 1D). Patient was

rescheduled for obturation. Root canals were

obturated after three weeks with guttapercha

and zinc oxide eugenol sealer in lateral

condensation technique. Post operative

radiograph revealed satisfactory obturation

with little sealer and questionable GP

extending beyond apex of mesial canals. (Fig

1E)

Patient reported after three years for

26

Fig– 1: Case report 1

1A: Preoperative status of 36 showing large periapical raiolucency involving apex of 36.

1B: Overinstrumentation beyond the apex towards the centre of the lesion.

1C: Calcium hydroxide dressing with virgin coconut oil.

1D: Three months review showing signs of healing.

1E: Obturation of 36 with mild extrusion of sealer beyond apex.

1F: Five years follow up showing complete healing.

1B

1D

1F

1A

1C

1E

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 4: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

maintenance check up. Clinically 36 was

normal and radiologically the periapical lesion

reduced considerably. There was evidence of

periodontal involvement with furcation and

inter dental bone loss. Periodontal therapy was

done. Five years follow up revealed excellent

bone healing with stable periodontal condition

for past two years.(Fig 1F)

The factors strongly associated for the success

of this case would be:

1 . Decompress ion o f le s ion by

overinstrumenting to the center of the lesion.

2. Calcium hydroxide therapy with virgin

cocoanut oil.

3. Glass ionomer coronal seal.

4. Unintentional three months interim period

between appointments.

CASE REPORT 2: (Fig 2)

Patient reported with mild discoloration in

maxillary front tooth .History revealed that

root canal treatment was done two year

back .Radiograph revealed improper

obturation in 21 and 22. Periapical

radiolucency were seen in relation to 11, 21

and 22. Vitality test with electric and heat

gave negative response. 11 was diagnosed as

nonvital tooth and scheduled for root canal

treatment (Fig 2A). Retreatment was planned

in 21 and 22.

Root canal of 11 was opened without local

anesthesia. Old GP were removed with H files

from 21 and 22. Canals were irrigated with

normal saline and shaped till 60/80 and 30 K

files with hand instrumentation in 11,21 and

22 respectively (Fig 2B). Powder Calcium

hydroxide was mixed with glycerin and

coated with lentiulospiral in the root canal.

Temporary coronal seal was given with plain

cotton seal and thick mix of zinc oxide

eugenol. Patient was rescheduled after four

weeks for further management.

Patient was reviewed and was asymptomatic.

Clinical examination revealed sinus in relation

to 21. Canals were reentered, irrigated and

redressed with calcium hydroxide. Temporary

coronal seal was given.

Patient was rescheduled after ten

days .Clinically patient was asymptomatic and

the sinus had disappeared. All there tooth was

obturated with 2% guttapercha with zinc

oxide sealer and cold lateral condensation

technique. Immediate post operative

radiograph revealed satisfactory obturation in

21, 11 and sealer beyond apex in 22. (Fig 2C)

Permanent coronal seal was done with glass

ionomer. Patient declined to go for the crown

because of cost and minimal discoloration.

Patient reported after 15 years with complain

for increased discoloration and wanted to

know whether the anterior tooth was under

control. Clinical patient was asymptomatic,

with no pathological change in relation to

11,21 and 22. Radiograph revealed

satisfactory periapical status in relation to

11,21 and 22. The obturation in 21 showed

deficient lateral seal and residual very

minimal periapical radiolucency even after 15

years suggestive of apical scar. (Fig 2D) The

inference of this follow up confirms the

27

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 5: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

importance of cleaning and shaping and the

long term intracanal medicament with calcium

hydroxide.

CASE REPORT 3: (Fig 3)

Patient reported with pain in relation to the

upper right front tooth with evidence of pus

discharge in relation to the same. Clinical

examination revealed discolored 11 with sinus

opening in relation to 11. Radiograph revealed

root treated 11 with deficient lateral and apical

seal and a large periapical radiolucency

around the open apex of 11. (Fig 3A)

Old GP were removed with H files from 11.

Canals were irrigated with normal saline and

shaped till no.80 at the estimated working

length. Calcium hydroxide mixed with

glycerin was loaded with lentiulospiral in the

root canal. As there was no apical stop, the

calcium hydroxide extruded into the periapical

lesion. Temporary coronal seal was given with

plain cotton seal and thick mix of zinc oxide

eugenol. Patient was rescheduled after three

weeks for further management. (Fig 3B)

Patient was reviewed and was asymptomatic.

Clinically patient was asymptomatic but the

tenderness on percussion still persisted .

Canals were reentered, irrigated and redressed

with calcium hydroxide. Temporary coronal

seal was given. Patient was rescheduled after

28

1B

1D

1A

1C

Fig– 2: Case report 2

2A: Preoperative status of 11, 21 and 22.

2B: Complete GP retrieval and working length assessment.

2C: Satisfactory obturation of 11, 21 and 22.

2D: 15 years follow up showing complete healing.

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 6: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

three weeks for further management.

Patient was reviewed and was clinically

asymptomatic. There was no tenderness on

percussion. Radiographically, there was

complete resolution of the periapical lesion

with the concomitant resorption of the

calcium hydroxide placed periapically.. (Fig

3C)Temporary coronal seal was removed and

the master cone was checked and obturation

was done using an inverted cone technique

(Fig 3D) using zinc oxide as sealer and cold

lateral condensation technique with accessory

cones. Immediate post operative radiograph

revealed satisfactory obturation in 11. (Fig

3E) Permanent coronal seal was done with

glass ionomer and post endodontic restoration

was given after a week. Patient was reviewed

after 18 months, Clinically 11 was normal and

radiologically the periapical lesion reduced

considerably with fully formed apex. (Fig 3F)

CASE REPORT 4: (Fig 4)

Patient reported with pain in relation to the

upper left front tooth with diffuse swelling

intraorally relation 21 region. Clinical

examination revealed discolored 21,22 with

29

4B 4A 4C

Fig– 4: Case report 4

4A: Preoperative status of 21, 22.

4B: Completed BMP and matercone fit assessment.

4C: Metapex intracanal medicament.

4D: Immediate post obturation radiograph.

4E: Eight months follow up.

4E 4D

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 7: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

an opened access in 21. Radiograph revealed

root canal attempted in 21 with deficient root

filling. The root canal treatment was left

incomplete as the patient has discontinued

treatment from the previous dentist.

Radiograph revealed a large periapical

radiolucency around the apex of 21 and 22

with an opened access cavity in 22. (Fig 4A)

Root canal of 21, 22 was opened without local

anesthesia. Canals were irrigated with normal

saline and shaped till 80 and 60 K files with

hand instrumentation in 21 and 22

respectively and the master cone was selected

(Fig 4B). Calcium hydroxide in propylene

glycol base (metapex) was loaded with

lentiulospiral in the root canal. Temporary

coronal seal was given with plain cotton seal

and thick mix of zinc oxide eugenol. Patient

was rescheduled after two weeks for further

management. (Fig 4C).

Patient was reviewed and was clinically

asymptomatic. Radiograph shows complete

resorption of the calcium hydroxide which

was extruded into the periapex.

Obturation was done with lateral condensation

and with zinc oxide as sealer. Immediate

postoperative shows satisfactory obturation.

(Fig 4D). Permanent coronal seal was given

with GIC.

Patient was reviewed after eight months,

Clinically 21, 22 was normal and there was a

complete resolution of the periapical lesion.

(Fig 4E).

CASE REPORT 5: (Fig 5)

Patient reported with pain in relation to the

upper right front tooth. Clinical examination

revealed discolored 12, 13. Radiograph

revealed a large periapical radiolucency

around the apex of 12 and 13 with mild

displacement of 13. The radiolucency was

well circumscribed with corticated margins.

(Fig 5A).

Non surgical management was first planned

and the access was opened. The canal was

intentionally over instrumented with 25 no K

file. 25 no. K file was extended till

approximately the centre of the lesion which

was about 2 mm beyond apex. Upon

instrumentation profuse pus discharge was

evident through the canal and the active non

surgical decompression was done through the

canal using a canal aspirator and a high

volume suction.

Canals were irrigated with normal saline and

shaped till 60 K files with hand

instrumentation in 12 and 13 respectively and

the master cone was selected (Fig 5B).

Calcium hydroxide in propylene glycol base

was mixed with glycerin and coated with

lentiulospiral in the root canal. Temporary

coronal seal was given with plain cotton seal

and thick mix of zinc oxide eugenol. Patient

was rescheduled after two weeks for further

management.

The pat ient was rev iewed and

radiographically there were signs of healing,

but still weeping was persistent, Canals were

re-entered, irrigated and redressed with

calcium hydroxide. Temporary coronal seal

was given (Fig 5C). Patient was rescheduled

30

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 8: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

after eight weeks for further management.

The patient was reviewed and when the

criteria’s of obturation was met which

includes getting a dry canal, obturation was

done with lateral condensation and with zinc

oxide eugenol as sealer. (Fig 5D).

Patient was reviewed after 6 months,

Clinically 12, 13 was normal and there was a

drastic reduction of the periapical lesion. (Fig

5E).

CASE REPORT 6: (Fig 6)

Patient reported with dull pain in relation to

the lower left back tooth for the past two

months. Patient gave prior history of root

canal being performed by a general dentist a

year back.

Clinical examination revealed intact metal

ceramic crown with leaky margins.

Radiograph revealed a large periapical

radiolucency around the apex of the mesial

root of 36 with silver points obturation with

poor apical and lateral seal. (Fig 6A)

Conventional non surgical retreatment was

31

Fig– 5: Case report 5

5A: Preoperative status of 12, 13.

5B: Over instrumentation beyobnd apex and master cone selection.

5C: Calicun hydroxide intracanal medicament.

5D: Immediate post obturation follow up.

5E: Six months review.

5B 5A 5C

5E 5D

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 9: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

planned , crown was removed and the silver

points was removed using ultrasonics.

Cleaning and shaping was done with

intentional working beyond the apex with

small sized K files. Copious irrigation was

done with 5.2% sodium hypochlorite and final

rinse was done with 2% chlorhexidine. Two

week calcium hydroxide dressing was given

and when all criteria for obturation was

achieved, obturation was done with protaper

gutta percha points and zinc oxide eugenol

sealer using cold lateral condensation

technique. Excess calcium hydroxide extruded

through the apex was left behind for healing.

(Fig 6B).

Patient was reviewed after 6 months, where

patient was completely asymptomatic and

Radiograph revealed complete healing of the

lesion. Core build up was done using fiber

post in the distal canal and all ceramic full

coverage restoration was given. (Fig 6C)

DISCUSSION:

Antibacterial activity of calcium hydroxide is

directly proportional to the release of

hydroxyl ions in an aqueous environment.

Hydroxyl ions being highly oxidant free

radicals shows extreme reactivity, reacting

with several other biomolecules 13. The

bactericidal effect of calcium hydroxide on

32

Fig– 6: Case report 6

6A: Preoperative status of 36.

6B: Immediate post obturartion with extruded calcium hydroxide beyond apex.

6C: Six months follow up with complete healing with post endodontic restoration.

6B 6A

6C

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 10: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

bacterial cells are probably due to the

following mechanisms:

1. Damage to the bacterial cytoplasmic

membrane.

2. Protein denaturation.

3. Damage to the DNA.

The bactericidal effects of calcium hydroxide

were observed only when the substance was in

direct contact with bacteria in suspension.

Because of the high availability of hydroxyl

ions, the survival of the bacteria would be

nearly impossible. Clinically, this direct

contact of the calcium hydroxide with the

bacteria present in the canal is not always

possible. Apart from the antibacterial effects

of hydroxyl ions, rendering a high pH values

in the environment is a prerequisite to destroy

microorganisms. Complete elimination or

killing of bacteria depend solely on the

availability of hydroxyl ions in solution,

which is much higher where the paste is

applied. The antibacterial effects exerted in

the root canal will be continuous as long as

calcium hydroxide retain a very high pH. If

calcium hydroxide diffuses to tissues and the

hydroxyl concentration is decreased as a result

of the contact with buffering agents

(bicarbonate and phosphate), proteins, acids

its antibacterial effectiveness gets declined or

impaired . 14, 15

Souza et al 16 suggested that the action of

calcium hydroxide beyond the apex may be

four-fold: (a) anti-inflammatory activity, (b)

neutralization of acid products, (c) activation

of the alkaline phosphatase, and (d)

antibacterial action. Çalişkan and Türkün17 in

his case report demonstrated success with

apical closure and simultaneous periapical

healing in a large cyst-like periapical lesion

following non-surgical treatment with calcium

hydroxide and a calcium hydroxide–

containing root canal sealer. In our case series,

case II showed remarkable healing inspite of

calcium hydroxide being extruded beyond

apex.

Active non surgical decompression of large

periapical lesions can be done using a

commercially available Endo-eze vacuum

system (Ultradent, Salt Lake, Utah) or any

other micro syringe with a high vacuum

suction to create a negative pressure, which

would result in the decompression of large

periapical lesions. The high volume suction

aspirator is connected to a micro gauge

needle, which is inserted in the root canal and

when activated creates a negative pressure,

which results in aspiration of the exudates/

contents of the cystic cavity. The extudate is

aspirated till the weeping stops through the

canal and an intracanal medicament of

calcium hydroxide is given which usually

helps in reducing the bacterial load. Unlike

the surgical decompression technique, which

involves placing drains directly into the

lesions through the labial mucosa, this

technique is minimally invasive as the entire

procedure is done through the root canal and

has good patient compliance and causes less

discomfort for the patient18. In our case series,

33

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 11: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

case V was managed by non surgical

decompression through the canal followed by

the calcium hydroxide therapy.

Bhaskar has suggested that whenever a

periapical lesion persisted on a radiograph

instrumentation should be carried 1 mm

beyond the apical foramen . This may result in

transient inflammation and ulceration/

disruption of the epithelial lining resulting in

resolution of the lesion.19 Bender on Bhaskar’s

hypothesis added that penetration of the apical

area to the center of the lesion would result in

drainage and relieving pressure accumulated

within the lesion. Fibroblasts begin to

proliferate once the drainage stops and starts

depositing collagen; which would compresses

the capillary network. Thus the epithelial

cells gets completely deprives of nutrition and

they undergo degeneration, which are finally

engulfed by the macrophages.20 In our case

series, case I, case IV was managed by

intentionally working beyond the apex to

puncture at the centre of the lesion to relieve

pressure and to obtain drainage followed by

two week calcium hydroxide therapy.

Healing of large cysts like well-defined

radiolucencies following conservative root

canal treatment has been reported. Although

the cystic fluid contains cholesterol crystals,

weekly debridement and drying of the canals

over a period of two to three weeks with long

term calcium hydroxide therapy , followed by

obturation has led to a complete resolution of

lesions by 12 to 15 months 21.

The vehicles with which the calcium

hydroxide powder is mixed/ used have an

important role in the overall dissociation of

hydroxyl ions. Its only the vehicle in which

calcium hydroxide is delivered determine the

velocity of ionic dissociation causing the paste

to be highly soluble and resorbable at various

rates by the periapical tissues or from within

the root canal. The viscosity is indirectly

proportional to degree of ionic dissociation.

The calcium hydroxide when used in these

viscous vehicles tends to remain in place for a

longer period time as these vehicles are high

molecular weight substances. 22

There are three main types of vehicles:

1. Water-soluble substances such as saline,

w a t e r , c a r b o x y m e t h y l c e l l u l o s e ,

methylcellulose, Ringers solution and

anaesthetic solutions

2. Viscous vehicles such as propylene glycol ,

glycerin, and polyethylene glycol (PEG)

3. Oil-based vehicles such as silicone oil,

olive oil, camphor (the oil of camphorated

parachlorophenol), some fatty acids (including

linoleic, oleic, and isostearic acids), &

metacresylacetate 25

Calcium hydroxide should be always be

combined with a liquid vehicle as using dry

calcium hydroxide powder alone is difficult to

deliver and to handle, and for the release of

hydroxyl ions an aqueous medium becomes

mandatory for calcium hydroxide. The most

commonly used carriers are sterile water or

saline. Though dental local anaesthetic

34

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 12: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

solutions have an acidic pH (between 4 and

5), they are used as adequate vehicle because

calcium hydroxide is a strong base with a pH

of around 12.5 which is affected minimally by

acidic nature of the local anesthesia . Rapid

ionic dissociation occurs only with the

aqueous medium whereas ionic dissociation

will be slower in viscous and oil based

mediums.

The effects of glycerin and propylene glycol

vehicles on the pH of calcium hydroxide were

investigated using conductivity testing23. They

reported that a concentration of the vehicles

was inversely proportional to the effectiveness

of calcium hydroxide as a root canal

medicament. As the concentration of the

vehicle increases the effectiveness or efficacy

of calcium hydroxide decreases.23 But the

availability of hydroxyl ions would drastically

reduce in a aqueous medium wherein the

availability of hydroxyl ions would be long

lasting if its used in a viscous vehicle24. As in

our cases, since most of the lesions were large

sized and availability of hydroxyl ions for a

longer period of time was required viscous

vehicle was selected rather than a aqueous

one. A viscous vehicle may remain within

root canals for several months, and hence the

number of appointments required to change

the dressing will be reduced 25. In our case

series propylene glycol and glycerin based

vehicles were used .

Oily vehicles have restricted applications as

intracanal medicaments as they are difficult to

remove from the canal space and leave a

residue on the canal walls. Leaving remnants

of oil on the canal walls will adversely affect

the adherence of sealer or other materials used

to obturate the canal 25.

Extrusion of calcium hydroxide beyond the

apex was suggested as a factor for the lack of

early healing of periapical lesions initially. 26

However, many researchers advocated that

when calcium hydroxide comes in direct

contact with the periapical tissues it is

beneficial for the inductive action of the

calcium hydroxide.27,28 Many authors have

reported high degree of success by using

calcium hydroxide beyond the apex and into

the lesions in cases with large periapical

lesions 29,30. Calcium hydroxide readily

resorbs and its the barium sulphate that is

added to the calcium hydroxide paste for

radiopacity, which is not readily resorbed

when the paste extrudes beyond the apex.

Several authors have stressed on the

importance of a long observation time for the

teeth treated with large periapical lesions31, 32.

In review by Çalişkan, a follow-up

examination ranged from two to ten years. 32.

Shah 33 suggested that patients should be

recalled at periodic intervals of three months,

six months, one year, and two years, to assess

the healing of periapical lesions. There is

always a chance for the quiescent epithelial

cells to be stimulated by instrumentation in

the apical area, with resultant proliferation and

cyst recurrence/ formation. Hence, follow-up

becomes extremely essential and mandatory

for a period of at least two years to assess the

35

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

Page 13: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

success of the treatment.

CONCLUSION:

Non surgical management of periapical

lesions have shown high success rate. With

employing correct treatment strategy and with

the use of long term calcium hydroxide as an

intracanal medicament even large sized

periapical lesions can heal satisfactorily

without any surgical intervention. Periodic

follow-up examinations are essential and

various assessment tools can be used to

monitor the healing of periapical lesions.

36

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

REFERENCES:

1. Lin LM, Skribner JE, Gaengler P. Factors associated

with endodontic treatment failures. Journal of

Endodontics 1992;18:625–7.

2. Nair PNR, Sjögren U, Krey G, Kahnberg K-E,

Sundqvist G. Intraradicular bacteria and fungi in root-

filled, asymptomatic human teeth with therapy-

resistant periapical lesions: a long-term light and

electron microscopic follow-up study. Journal of

Endodontics 1990;16:580–8.

3. Bystrom A, Sundqvist G.Bacteriologic evaluation of

the efficacy of mechanical root canal instrumentation

in endodontic therapy. Scandinavian Journal of Dental

Research 1981;89: 321-8.

4. Bystrom A, Claesson R, Sundqvist G .The antibacterial

effect of camphorated paramonochlorophenol,

camphorated phenol and calcium hydroxide in the

treatment of infected root canals. Endodontics and

Dental Traumatology 1985;1: 170-5.

5. Siqueira JF Jr, Uzeda M. Intracanal medicaments:

evaluation of the antibacterial effects of chlorhexidine,

metronidazole, and calcium hydroxide associated with

three vehicles. Journal of Endodontics 1997; 23: 167-9.

6. Moller AJ, Fabricius L, Dahlen G, Ohman AE, Heyden

G . Influence on periapical tissues of indigenous oral

bacteria and necrotic pulp tissue in monkeys.

Scandinavian Journal of Dental Research 1981; 89:

475–84.

7. Kakehashi S, Stanley H, Fitzgerald R .The effect of

surgical exposures of dental pulps in germ-free and

conventional laboratory rats. Oral Surgery, Oral

Medicine, Oral Pathology 1965;20:340–9.

8. Dalton BC, Ørstavik D, Phillips C, Pettiette M, Trope

M .Bacterial reduction with nickel-titanium rotary

instrumentation. Journal of Endodontics 1998;24:763–

7.

9. Çalişkan MK, Şen BH. Endodontic treatment of teeth

with apical periodontitis using calcium hydroxide: A

long-term study. Endod Dent Traumatol 1996;12:215-

21.

10. Andersen M, Lund A, Andreasen JO, Andreasen

FM .In -vitro solubility of human pulp tissue in

calcium hydroxide and sodium hypochlorite.

Endodontics and Dental Traumatolology 1992; 8:104-

8.

11. Tronstad L.Root resorption etiology, terminology and

clinical manifestations. Endodontics and Dental

Traumatology 1988; 4:241-52.

12. Foreman PC, Barnes F .A review of calcium

hydroxide. International Endodontic Journal

1990;23:283-97.

13. Freeman BA, Crapo JD . Biology of disease. Free

radicals and tissue injury. Laboratory Investigation

1982; 47, 412-24.

14. Siqueira JF Jr, Lopes HP, Uzeda M . Recontamination

of coronally unsealed root canals medicated with

camphorated paramonochlorophenol or calcium

hydroxide pastes after saliva challenge. Journal of

Endodontics 1998; 24:11-4.

15. Siqueira JF Jr, Uzeda M .Influence of different

vehicles on the antibacterial effects of calcium

hydroxide. Journal of Endodontics 1998;24:663-5.

16. Souza V, Bernabe PF, Holland R, Nery MJ, Mello W,

Otoboni Fiho JA. Tratamento nao curugico de dentis

com lesos periapicais. Rev Bras Odontol 1989;46:36-

46.

17. Çalişkan MK. Prognosis of large cyst-like periapical

lesions following nonsurgical root canal treatment: A

clinical review. Int Endod J 2004;37:408-16.

Page 14: Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Persistent Chronic Apical ...

Journal of Scientific Dentistry, 4(1), 2014

26. Vernieks AA, Messer LB. Calcium hydroxide induced

healing of periapical lesions: A study of 78 non-vital

teeth. J Br Endod Soc 1978;2:61-9.

27. Ghose LJ, Baghdady VS, Hikmat BY. Apexification of

immature apices of pulpless permanent anterior teeth

with calcium hydroxide. J Endod 1987;13:285-90.

28. Rotstein I, Friedman S, Katz J. Apical closure of

mature molar roots with the use of calcium hydroxide.

Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 1990;70:656-60.

29. Souza V, Bernabe PF, Holland R, Nery MJ, Mello W,

Otoboni Fiho JA. Tratamento nao curugico de dentis

com lesos periapicais. Rev Bras Odontol 1989;46:36-

46.

30. Çalişkan MK, Türkün M. Periapical repair and apical

closure of a pulpless tooth using calcium hydroxide.

Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 1997;84:683-7.

31. Sjogren U, Hagglund B, Sundqvist G, Wing K. Factors

affecting the long-term results of endodontic treatment.

J Endod 1990;16:31-7.

32. Çalişkan MK. Prognosis of large cyst-like periapical

lesions following nonsurgical root canal treatment: A

clinical review. Int Endod J 2004;37:408-16.

33. Shah N. Nonsurgical management of periapical

lesions: A prospective study. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral

Pathol 1988;66:365-71.

18. Mejia JL, Donado JE, Basrani B. Active non-surgical

decompression of large periapical lesions- 3 case

reports. J Can Dent Assoc 2004;70:691-4.

19. Bhaskar SN. Nonsurgical resolution of radicular cysts.

Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 1972;34:458-68.

20. Bender IB. Commentary on General Bhaskar’s

hypothesis. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol

1972;34:469-76.

21. Al-Kandari AM, Al-Quoud OA, Gnanasekhar JD.

Healing of large eriapical lesions following

nonsurgical endodontic therapy: Case eports.

Quintessence Int 1994;25:115-9.

22. Athanassiadis B, Abbott PV, Walsh LJ .The use of

calcium hydroxide, antibiotics and biocides as

antimicrobial medicaments in endodontics. Australian

Dental Journal 2007; 52(Suppl.):S64–82.

23. Safavi KE, Nakayama TA . Influence of mixing

vehicle on dissociation of calcium hydroxide in

solution. Journal of Endodontics 2000;26: 649–51.

24. Gomes BP, Ferraz CCR, Vianna ME et al. In vitro

antimicrobial activity of calcium hydroxide pastes and

their vehicles against selected microorganisms.

Brazilian Dental Journal 2002;13:155–61.

25. Fava LR, Saunders WP .Calcium hydroxide pastes:

classification and clinical indications. International

Endodontic Journal 1999; 32:257–82.

How to cite this article: Mithunj ith K, Jer ry J , Sa thyanara yanan R.Calcium Hydroxide Therapy for Pers i s tent Chronic Api ca l Per iodont i t i s : A Case Series . Journal of Scient i fi c Dent i st ry, 4(1) , 2014:24 -37 Source of Support : Ni l , Conf l i c t of Interest : None declared

Address for correspondence:

Dr .Mithun Jith.K

Sen ior Lecturer ,

Depar tment of Conser vat ive Den t istry and

Endodon t ics, IndraGandhi Inst i tute of Den tal Sciences,

Sr i Bajai Vidapeeth Univer si t y

Puducher ry

[email protected]

Authors: 1 Senior Lecturer, 3Professor,

Department of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics,

IndraGandhi Institute of Dental Sciences,

Sri Bajai Vidapeeth University Puducherry 3Private praticioner,

Krupa dental Clinic,

Kuvembu road,

Shimoga, Karnataka

Calc ium Hydroxide Therapy Mi thun Jith.K e t a l

37