Building an “Asia Capable” Treasury - Finance &...
Transcript of Building an “Asia Capable” Treasury - Finance &...
Byron Gardiner - Executive Director
SCB Treasury Solutions and Advisory
Building an “Asia Capable” Treasury
FTA Annual Congress 2016
3
What are the top three priorities for your Company over the next 12 months (pick 3) ?
(N: 841) N of TB
Corporate N of TB
Corporate N of TB
Corporate % of
Corporate % of
Corporate % of
Corporate
Whole Market
South East Asia
North Asia Whole Market
South East Asia
North Asia
(N: 841) (N: 493) (N: 348)
Rationalising the overall number of accounts or banks 713 423 290 85% 86% 83%
Setting up a regional treasury centre 686 402 284 82% 82% 82%
Improving payment or procure-to-pay processes 271 154 117 32% 31% 34%
Implementing new banking or treasury systems 204 124 80 24% 25% 23%
Setting up a Shared Service Centre 202 121 81 24% 25% 23%
Improving collections, invoice reconciliation, or order-to-cash processes
198 120 78 24% 24% 22%
Changing banks to improve cash management processes
93 51 42 11% 10% 12%
Moving sales or supplier management to electronic channels
89 50 39 11% 10% 11%
Setting up a procurement or sales hub 67 34 33 8% 7% 9%
Note: no significant variance by country
Source: Recent survey conducted by East & Partners for corporate across Asia
82% of Asian corporate treasurers responded “Setting up a regional treasury” as a high priority in a recent survey
4
2.38
2.65
3.01
3.21
3.23
3.34
3.35
3.41
3.43
2 3 4
Company credit rating
Capital structure
Tax
Banking relationship
Funding
Working capital management
Supporting management and business units
Financial risk management
Cash and liquidity management
Score
Source: PwC’s Asia Corporate Treasury Survey 2014
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25%
Retaining and recruiting treasury talent
Monitoring regulatory changes (Basel III, etc. ) and impact on business
Implementing technology for treasury management or bank connectivity
Compliance with tax requirements
Rationalizing the number of accounts/banks
Domestic or international cash pooling
Minimizing interest expenses
Yield enhancement
Enhancing cash and treasury management processes and automation
Optimizing working capital
Minimizing and mitigating risk
Improving visibility of balances and cash forecasting
Source: Asia Pacific Treasury Management Barometer 2015
When asked to define specific areas of focus, here is what Treasurers said in Asia
Treasuries are evolving in different ways to generate efficiency benefits while also providing support to a global business
6
International Focus
Global CCY
Drive Global Compliance
Head Office
Global Standard
Highly Centralised
Centrally
Local Focus
Local CCY
Stay Across Local Needs
Operating Business
Local Driven
Moderate With Local Flexibilities
Locally
Customer Orientation
Dominant Currency
Location Proximity
Regulation Approach
Banking Services
Level of Standardisation
Policy / Strategy Execution
7
And as companies expand their operations into Asia, they often reach a point where they would like to centralise treasury activities
Leverage Centralised Model 1 Establish Treasury as Centre of Excellence Develop consistent framework across business
Drive Efficiency 2 Consolidate / rationalise bank accounts Leverage common processes / resources
Improve Liquidity Management 3 Release trapped cash Facilitate interco lending where possible
Proactively Manage Risks 4 Perform analytics to understand exposures Manage FX, liquidity, interest rates, etc.
Reduce Costs 5 Reduce overall cost of doing business Leverage group buying, automate processes
8
However, companies typically encounter a number of unique risks in the emerging markets of Asia, including……
Trapped cash
Higher incidence of
frauds
Counterfeit currency Cyber security
Supply chain risks
Sovereign risks
Regulatory Reputational/ sanctions
“...new realities are demanding new approaches. Most notably, the need to be proactive in the management of these risks”
Source: Putting risk into perspective...Treasury Today September 2016
9
How are companies responding and what is the major challenge?
To improve efficiency, visibility and operating control more treasurers are moving to centralised decision making models within their global headquarters. More than 80% of treasury teams have already chosen to centralise strategic decision making around global treasury policies, cash management, key investment operations, funding and hedging.
Source: BCG, Corporate Treasury Insights , 2015
However, the big challenge is:
How does your company extend the centralised framework and model to cover emerging markets in Asia, which often have unique regulatory challenges and market practices?
11
A harmonised treasury governance framework is the starting point to reduce variability and therefore mitigate business risks
One policy One process One platform One organisation
• Centralise decisions: - Account opening/closing - Core banks and limits
• Standardise and streamline via: - An unified liquidity
structure - Intercompany netting - On-behalf-of hedging
and investment - Funding planning/
evaluation - Cash flow forecasts.
• Guidelines cover: - Bank and bank account
management - Cash/liquidity
management - Funding/working capital
management - Risk management - Investment management
• Control via: - Compliance reporting - Bank service reviews - Treasury activity review - Treasury audit.
• Clear roles and responsibilities within treasury and across departments
• Operate as one team globally
• Credible partner internally and externally
• Deepen expertise that suits business needs and career preferences.
• ERP: Industrial grade, same version
• Netting: use ERP or third-party providers
• TMS: ERP-based vendors or third party
• Trading: Automate execution and confirmation
• Market data: Auto-feed to TMS
• Host-to-host connectivity.
47% of treasurers interviewed were working on a single ERP project in emerging markets. Source: Deloitte 2015 Corporate Treasury Survey
TMS: Treasury Management System ERP: Enterprise Resource Planning
CENTRALISED
The treasury model will then be shaped by the degree of centralisation achievable, after assessing the following key factors
12
DECENTRALISED
13
The key to a harmonised treasury governance framework is a unified technology architecture
40% of treasurers interviewed listed inadequate treasury systems infrastructure as a strategic challenge.
Source: Deloitte 2015 Corporate Treasury Survey
AP/AR data
(e.g. Treasury settlements, hedge position, MTM, etc.)
Cash forecast Banking partners
(Treasury payments, funding, LC issuance, etc.)
ERP
c
Market data
c
ERP
c TMS
Trading
Matching
Instructions
Data Account entries
Execute
Confirm Visibility
Controls
Data sanctity
Cyber security
TMS: Treasury Management System ERP: Enterprise Resource Planning AP: Accounts Payable AR: Accounts Receivable
14
However, specific regulatory and tax issues need to be factored in before centralised structures are extended to Asia
Dividend deeming
Conduit financing (US Firms)
Thin capitalisation
Withholding tax on bank/related party
interest
Transfer pricing re intercompany loans/fees
Intercompany tax position
(profit/cost centre, location, incentive)
Stamp duty /other taxes
Foreign exchange controls
ROBO/POBO allowed ?
Intercompany lending/ netting allowed?
Non-resident account restrictions
Treatment on local/cross-border
payments
Tax
Regulatory
IHB as a financing operation allowed?
Approval / paperwork
POBO: Payment on behalf of ROBO: Receipts on behalf of IHB: In house bank
15
Companies need to draw up a hierarchy of regulatory ease when implementing centralised treasury structures across geographies
Standard Chartered core footprint
Europe Croatia | Lithuania Serbia | Ukraine Americas Argentina | Bolivia Brazil | Colombia Ecuador | Guatemala Uruguay | Venezuela
Europe Bulgaria | Czech Republic Hungary | Poland | Romania Russia | Slovakia | Turkey Americas Mexico | Paraguay | Peru Asia Kazakhstan | Philippines Taiwan
Europe Austria | Belgium | Denmark Denmark | Finland | France Germany | Ireland | Italy Luxembourg | Netherlands Norway | Portugal | Spain Sweden | Switzerland United Kingdom Americas Canada | Chile United States
Europe Greece Asia China | Indonesia | Korea Malaysia | Sri Lanka Middle East & Africa Cameroon | Ghana | Kenya Nigeria | Saudi Arabia South Africa | Uganda | Zambia
Least Restricted Moderately Restricted* More Restricted Highly Restricted Asia Australia | Hong Kong Japan | New Zealand Singapore Middle East & Africa Bahrain | Botswana Jordan | Kuwait | Mauritius | Oman | Qatar | UAE
Asia Bangladesh | India Pakistan | Thailand Uzbekistan | Vietnam Middle East & Africa Angola | Côte d’Ivoire Egypt | Ethiopia Mozambique | Tanzania Zimbabwe
16
Liquidity
Cash
Risk Funding
Working capital
Netting
The most common approach is to establish a Regional Treasury Centre, acting as a “Service Provider” to the business
Potential range of services: • Provide strategic advice • Negotiate credit facilities e.g. loans • Facilitate intercompany lending • Analyse financial needs/exposures • Execute deals/trades e.g. foreign exchange • Process financial services to business units.
• Leverage group buying power and scale to lower costs
• As a centre of excellence to ensure professional advice and execution.
Banks Group companies
Process transactions on-behalf-of business
Procure services on-behalf-of business
Treasury
While this works very well for the developed world – the challenge is to make it work in emerging markets.
17
Deliver banking services internally,
maximise / optimise control over liquidity, risk
positions, transaction flows
Centralise payments / collections;
Leverage SSCs and drive higher
efficiency
Actively manage debt, FX, liquidity
structures Coordinate/
Facilitate cash mgt, funding, FX
needs basic / limited visibility over
positions
ROB
Local Function
In-House Bank
Coordination Centre
Full Service Centre
Payment / Collection
Factory
Objective
Target operating model for most companies
Increasing popular with large US/Asian corporates
Degree of Treasury Sophistication Visi
bilit
y
C
ontr
ol
Opt
imis
e
However there is no single “Best Fit” Treasury model and many companies are evolving towards more sophisticated models
So, where should Corporates locate their Asia Treasury Centre? The general selection criteria is outlined below
19
1
5
3
2
4
Regulatory Environment Transparency of government policy making, efficiency of legal framework, burden of regulation, etc
Market Efficiency Taxation regime, availability of double tax treaties, etc
Financial Market Development Availability and affordability of financial services, easy access to financing, soundness of banks, etc
Infrastructure / Telecommunications Quality of air / road transport and telecommunication services
Availability of High Skilled Professionals Pay and productivity, Availability of research and training services, reliance on professional management, etc
Data Source: The Global Competitiveness Report 2013-2014 by World Economic Forum
It is clear why Singapore and HK are the most popular locations to manage Asia needs, but Malaysia and Shanghai are moving up
20 Data Source: The Global Competitiveness Report 2013-2014 by World Economic Forum, country ranking is used to convert into ranking percentile. Tax rates are sourced from Deloitte International Tax Highlight 2014. The highest rate is used as 100% benchmark
22
There is a cost of doing business in Asia, especially in the emerging markets...residual challenges
1
5
3
2
4
There will always be some trapped cash...this requires a pay-off analysis because dividend pay out is expensive and other options are limited
Expensive to manage risks but organisations need higher risk tolerance in some emerging market locations
There will always be some measure of manual processes, paper processes...do the best you can to reduce – you can’t eliminate these
Regulations are still evolving in some of these countries...staying close to banks will help you to keep pace
Some proprietary bank systems and local banking partners will be required...see how you can manage them more effectively.
Disclaimer This material has been prepared by Standard Chartered Bank (SCB), a firm authorised by the United Kingdom’s Prudential Regulation Authority and regulated by the United Kingdom’s Financial Conduct Authority and Prudential Regulation Authority. It is not independent research material. This material has been produced for information and discussion purposes only and does not constitute advice or an invitation or recommendation to enter into any transaction. Some of the information appearing herein may have been obtained from public sources and while SCB believes such information to be reliable, it has not been independently verified by SCB. Information contained herein is subject to change without notice. Any opinions or views of third parties expressed in this material are those of the third parties identified, and not of SCB or its affiliates. While all reasonable care has been taken in preparing this material, the SCB and its affiliates make no representation or warranty as to its accuracy or completeness, and no responsibility or liability is accepted for any errors of fact, omission or for any opinion expressed herein. You are advised to exercise your own independent judgment (with the advice of your professional advisers as necessary) with respect to the risks and consequences of any matter contained herein. SCB and its affiliates expressly disclaim any liability and responsibility for any damage or losses you may suffer from your use of or reliance on this material. SCB Treasury Solutions team would be pleased to consult with you regarding the bank’s services and capabilities. In any consultation, SCB does not provide accounting, legal, regulatory, tax or investment advice or treasury management advisory services. Any statements regarding those matters would be for discussion purpose only. No such statements, or any forecasts, modelling, or other projections, should be relied on by you. SCB or its affiliates may not have the necessary licenses to provide services or offer products in all countries or such provision of services or offering of products may be subject to the regulatory requirements of each jurisdiction. This material is not for distribution to any person to which, or any jurisdiction in which, its distribution would be prohibited. You may wish to refer to the incorporation details of Standard Chartered PLC, SCB and their subsidiaries at http://www.sc.com/en/incorporation-details.html. © Copyright -Standard Chartered Bank. All rights reserved. All copyrights subsisting and arising out of these materials belong to Standard Chartered Bank and may not be reproduced, distributed, amended, modified, adapted, transmitted in any form, or translated in any way without the prior written consent of Standard Chartered Bank.