BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf ·...

51
S I I Carla J. Dove, Ph.D. Birdstrike Committee 2018 Baltimore, MD BSI B S I S I C

Transcript of BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf ·...

Page 1: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Smithsonian Institution Feather Identification Lab

Carla J. Dove, Ph.D.Birdstrike Committee 2018Baltimore, MD

BSI Bird Strike InvestigationSpecial Identification Cases

Page 2: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Faridah Dahlan Genetics Specialist

Jim WhattonResearchAssistant

Carla DoveProgramManager

Marcy HeackerResearch Assistant

Smithsonian Institution Feather Identification Lab

Sarah Luttrell Research Assistant

Page 3: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot
Page 4: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Filemaker Pro® Programmer – Bailey Kessing

Page 5: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Identification ToolsMorphology:Whole Feathers

Page 6: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot
Page 7: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Morphology:Microscopy

Page 8: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot
Page 9: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Molecular:DNA Barcoding

Page 10: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Laboratory of Analytical Biology - LAB

Page 11: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot
Page 12: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

19 January 2017

Page 13: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

NAS Meridian, MS

19 January 2017T-45Class A

Page 14: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Samples collected from inside the right air intake, T-45 Goshawk by USDA biologists(Jon Leddon and Matt Overstreet)

Page 15: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Black Vulture (DNA, Micro, Whole)

Black vulture vs Turkey Vulture• Hunt by sight but exploit food-finding skills of Turkey Vultures• More aggressive, and often displace Turkey Vultures from carcasses• Fly higher than Turkey Vultures for visual foraging• May fly earlier than Turkey Vultures if returning to a carcass

Page 16: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

26 April 2017

Page 17: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

ARLINGTON, VA (WUSA9) - An American Airlines flight from Reagan National hit a flock of birds during takeoff Wednesday evening.Flight 4411 was headed to Fort Myers, Fla., but diverted to Dulles International to make an emergency landing. The plane touched down safely after sustaining the bird strike.There were 56 passengers on board. No one was hurt.American Airlines is sending a standby aircraft from Reagan to Dulles to pick up the passengers and fly them to Florida. They're expected to arrive Thursday morning.The bird strike damaged the plane, but it’s not known at this time how extensive it is, an American Airlines spokesperson said.© 2017 WUSA-TV

Page 18: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

• Dulles Airport, 26 April 2017

• Emergency landing at 1818

•• 2000 ft at 1654

• Flying up the Potomac River

• Pilot reported Pelican

• 12” divot in right wing slat

Page 19: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Snarge

Page 20: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Microslide

Page 21: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Sandhill Crane (Antigone canadensis) 7-10 lbs

Dulles Airport - Virginia

Page 22: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Birds of North American on-line: https://birdsna.org/Species-Account/bna/home

Page 23: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

E-bird: https://ebird.org/explore

Page 24: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Graph provided by R.Dolbeer 4/2017

Page 25: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

17 May 2017

Page 26: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

• JetBlue Flight 1808 9:11 pm

• Struck bird on takeoff

• Plane in the air for 40 minutes

Page 27: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Eyewitness NewsWednesday, May 17, 2017NEW YORK (WABC) --A JetBlue flight en route to New York's JFK Airport may have hit a bird.

The captain on the flight from Washington Dulles Airport to JFK reported the possible bird strike on Wednesday.

The plane landed safely back in Washington just before 10 p.m.

There are no reports of any injuries.

JetBlue flight makes emergency landing at Dulles after possible bird strike

Passengers said it “was a really an emotional experience”

Page 28: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

AIRCRAFT DAMAGE TO #2 ENGINE, FAN AND STATOR BLADES, ENGINE OUTER CASING PERFORATED, NO EVIDENCE THAT ENGINE PARTS PASSED THROUGH OUTER CASING, UPON LANDING AIRCRAFT LEAKED APPROXIMATELY 200 GALLONS OF FUEL FROM DAMAGED ENGINE BEFORE FLOW WAS MITIGATED.

Airport Operations recovered remains from departure runway at 5,100' remaining. USDA Biologist recovered remains from the #2 engine and transferred both sets of remains to the Smithsonian.

Ryan Stewart, USDA biologist Dulles Airport

Page 29: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

DNA gender typing:

Male: Ave. wt. = 1154 g (2.5 lb)Range = 724 – 1460 g (1.5 – 3.2 lb)

Female: Ave. wt. = 1555 g (3.4 lb)Range = 801 – 2046 g (1.7 – 4.5 lb)

One engine sample One airfield sample

Both samples = Male

Great Horned OwlBubo virginianusAve. wt. = 3.1 lbs

Page 30: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

• Observed an increase in owl strike frequency over past 10 years

• Trap/Relocation Program (Fall 2014); 25 total relocated

• No GHOW returns• Catch per effort is declining

Page 31: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

21 June 2017

Page 32: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

F-16 Houston, Texas – Ellington Field Joint Reserve Base$11 M • 21 June 2017• ANG pilot ejected shortly after takeoff, treated for injuries• Training mission carrying military explosives• Area was evacuated• Two vials received from engine cowling and windscreen

Page 33: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Barn Swallow (Hirundo rustica)19 g (.67 ounces)

Id confirmed with DNA and microscopy

Distraction by birds caused high speed abort –birdstrike did not cause crash.

Page 34: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

19 November 2017

Page 35: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

3 killed in medical helicopter crash in Arkansas County, 19 November 2017

• A witness stated she saw the helicopter go into a spin, heard geese getting loud and saw the Pafford Medical Services helicopter go up in flames.

• “A large flock of geese may have caused the helicopter to downward spiral and crash, according to a sheriff report”.

Page 36: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot
Page 37: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Before Wash After Wash

Page 38: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Ross’s Goose 2.7 lb.

Snow Goose 5.3 lb.

Page 39: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Ross’s Goose or Snow Goose

Page 40: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Photo 2: Photo left: Cleaned feather samples received on 27 November compared with museum study skins to identify bird species. Photo right: Dark primary wing feather (at arrow) from the wreckage compared with museum specimen of Snow Goose. In this case, the large size of the feathers matched the Snow Goose and excluded the closely related but smaller Ross’ Goose.

Page 41: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

…Because Snow Geese often occur together in flocks with the closely related but much smaller Ross’s Geese, bird species designation in this case was based on the size of the feathers (Photo 2); population status of the two species in Arkansas; and investigator observations of many large-billed and ‘big’ birds at the crash site. If many different individual birds were involved in this event, however, it is possible that some were Ross’ Goose.

Feather Lab Report to NTSB:

Location: Stuttgart, ARAccident Number:

CEN18FA033

Date & Time: 11/19/2017, 1855 CST Registration: N620PA

Aircraft:BELL HELICOPTER TEXTRON CANADA 407

Injuries: 3 Fatal

Flight Conducted Under:

Part 91: General Aviation - Positioning - Air Medical (Discretionary)

National Transportation Safety BoardAviation Accident Preliminary Report

Page 42: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Photographs!!!

Page 43: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

20 April 2016

Page 44: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Former NTSB investigator was pilot in crash that killed 4 near Chugiak

Alaska, north of Anchorage – 20 April 2016Cessna 172 ; post-crash fire consumed most of the fuselage4 fatalities

Page 45: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot
Page 46: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Feather found on ground

Samples from aircraft

Page 47: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Bald Eagle, immature bird

Page 48: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot
Page 49: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Bald Eagle Reference Sample Unknown Sample

Page 50: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

National News

Agency: Eagle hit Alaska plane before crash that killed 4

Alaska, north of Anchorage – 20 April 2016Cessna 172 ; post-crash fire consumed most of the fuselage4 fatalities

Page 51: BSI Bird Strike Investigation Special Identification Cases › 2018-presentations › P5.pdf · landing at 1818 • • 2000 ft at 1654 ... • Pilot reported Pelican • 12” divot

Questions?