Brookings Analysis Paper Feb12 [the Middle East Quartet -- A Post-Mortem]

8/3/2019 Brookings Analysis Paper Feb12 [the Middle East Quartet -- A Post-Mortem]

1/78

THE MIDDLE EASTQUARTET:

A Post-Mortem

Khaled Elgindy

A N A L Y S I S P A P E R

N u m b e r 2 5 , F e b r u a r y 2 0 1 2


2/78


3/78

T B I - z. I -q, ,

, , . T

B (), I, , .

B z q, . A

.

C 01

177 M A, N.W., W, D.C. 006..
http://www.brookings.edu/http://www.brookings.edu/


4/78

T H E C H A L L E N G E O F G A Z A : P o l i c y O p t i o n s a n d B r o a d e r I m p l i c at i o n s

T h e S a b a n C e n t e r a t B O O k I N G S

Executive Summary. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

he Author. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1

Background and Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

he Quartets rack Record . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9

Why the Quartet Does Not Work. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 34

Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52

Appendixes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54

able o Contents


5/78



v

he Quartets rack Record

O ,

Q

R Q P,

q

. T R A 00 -

O

1990. I (

q )

-

, R

. W

R

f, ,

.

T I ,

Q, j R

. A , -

Q

, G W. B -

.

H S -

,

B I

R P . S-

, f

, Q-

.

I -

M E -

U S, E U,

R, U N

Q. F

S I 000 , Q-

I

P. I

,

-

.

Y, -

, , Q -

. I

P ,

-

, Q

. M-

, Q

,

A A. H

-, P

UN

S 011, Q

.

Executive Summary


6/78



v

-

PA, B W H

. T U.S. EU 006 -

,

A ,

. T,

I -

(VA)

P 60

70 PA ,

W B Gz S.

O ,

, Q-

f -

,

f. T f

, U.S. /

R

H

, EU -

A UN

R . D -

U.S. EU ,

U S E U : E

-

P , U S

. T

Q P,

,

-

. I, H

Gz J 007 Q

-

.

f

Q

: M

010 Q

. F ,

I, I j -

,

U S -

. A ,

-

z

Q .

T R

B Q-

I Gz D

P, j z

Q . T U

S Q -

R EU,

UN, R q

. T R

Q , -

q . T

R . A

f

U S

Q , -

.

W I

Gz S, Q -

P-

I H

P A (PA) J 006. I

, U S, E U,

U N, R -

, I,

H- -

. W QP

, j -

.

D A S, UN -

,


7/78



v

Why the Quartet Does Not Work

T Q -

: , ;

; . T

-

-

. W

f-

,

-

:

-

. T

Q - ,

U S,

f

.

All hings to All People

A ,

Q -

UNS C. T , -

Q , z -

. T Q

, -

, . W

Q

, , -

,

. T Q

, U

S,

q

U.S. .

Q

M 010 I -

Gz,

q I

Gz. A UN- A-

f

Q

Q . T ,

, Q

,

Q P

Q

Gz. T -

Q j :

.

T

Q , -

B B. T

W B J

W, S

S Czz R A 00

Gz . A

W B -

P -,

f.

W W

, B

. D

f , -

:

Q .

O, Q , -

B, A

Q I

EU, UN, R

z

Q .


8/78



v

j -

, Q

j 00

Iq. T U S

Q , ,

U.S. , -

I. W

U S I-

, -

Q . T -

B

O ,

Q

S 010.

A Q

, ,

E U, U N,

R q U S,

. T,

U N, R,

E U

U.S. ,

Q- sans trois. E

A ,

f , E

U.

A P A-

I ,

E U

, U- S

. T U N,

A-

I 1968

,

Imbalanced Membership

T Q q

. I -

UN S C (

U S R)

z ( U N E-

U), -

I-P .

I , , U S

E U, -

. T -

, -

S I

. T Q E

U, U N, R

U S

U.S. .

D

UN j R-

L

A , E , UN -

Q f f , -

. T

-

Q U S,

. T

f

. T, U S,

E U, U N, R

, , , -

j f

I-P .

F U S, Q

. I


9/78



v

Q. B

R, -

Q

j, ,

. I,

. A ,

Q

.

A

,

Q -

R

Q P,

. E Q -

R ,

Q P.

A

S C (UNSCR 11),

q- .

I ,

Q -

. A , , f Q-

-

. I R, -

Gz .

W

Q P, ,

. I,

H F

Gz 007,

Q P, Q , -

.

W Q z, -

, illu-

sory

. F, R

-

E A

. I,

-

A Q.

T

E U

U N ,

U S f

. T -

, ,

U-

S, j

, z

. I -

, Q

A

U.S. , -

EU, UN, R

Q. A -

. W I

, , P

. T,

Q U

S I

.

Consensus or Its Own Sake

T Q

q

, . I z

, -

-

. T , ,

, not


10/78



x

he Bottom Line

I , Q

would . I

, Q

.

T , -

, . I

Q, U S, E

U, U N, R

q

. I , Q

/ . I

, , q U

S ,

,

q-

j, ,

P I,

-

, , -

. O (-

1991 M C),

01,

Q , (-

E, J, S A, -

Q M),

(.., N, ,

W B, .).

. L,

Q ,

f,

. I,

.

T P UN S

011 Q -

,

Q

EU UN -

. D

A E U,

-

Q EU -

. O ,

-

.

I Q

,

. T Q

, U S, -

f

. O -

,

A .

T Q -

f

P. I ,

j .


11/78



x

W S K

S C V F . I -

A A-

j.

Acknowledgements


12/78



x

P Sf M H I-

R C 00

P A U.S. C I-

R F 000 00.

H P A C

A A I (AAI) 1998

000 M E P O N D I I A-

199 1997. E M.A.

A S G U

B.A. P S I U-

B.

K E V F S

C M E P B. H

E A

R L A. H

P R-

I

00 009, A-

N 007. P , E

-

W, DC,

,

he Author


13/78



1

Introduction

O

011

M E Q, -

U S, EU, U N, R. T Q-

O

I-P-

P

-Aq I. I

M E

. I , UN

, .1 Y

z . D

, Q

-

.

N

,

,

Q

. I -

I -

00809 Gz W. T

Q , -

R,

A 00,

. T Q -

Q P,

P A

(PA) H J

006,

Gz PA.

W

Q

I-P ,

j. D -

, Q -

f,

P -

-

. M,

Q

A A 011.

1 A S, E M R, M 007, . , .
http://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2007/06/12/DeSotoReport.pdfhttp://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2007/06/12/DeSotoReport.pdfhttp://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2007/06/12/DeSotoReport.pdfhttp://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2007/06/12/DeSotoReport.pdf


14/78



2

. A -

, P

UN

S 011

Q

.

C, O 011 -

j M E -

, -- -

I P

1991 M P C. A Q

,


15/78



3

Background and Description

P 197. I

A-I ,

1967 W - J M.

I 197 W A-

. T UN S-

C R (UNSCR) 8,

,

,

-

M E G D

197.

A , U.S.

G Sz -

A-I

S C. A-

Sz z,

M C

1991, -

I-

A . S O

W

Q,

? I

, Q -

M E

U S, E

U, U N, R

I-P .

P , ,

, . E

, Q

A-I ,

. I , ,

,

f

.

I

A J H L

P M-

L N 19,

U N

I I A , U N S C R (N , 1967) S R j . T D. G J, S S U, N 1968. T J M UN M E, U S.

I G P C (UNSCR ), UNSCR 8 , UN 197 (UNSCR 9), U N E F (UNEF I II) (UNSCR 0, 1).


16/78



4

A-I , P B

. T

I-P

, O

. T F 6 -

L A S

I B -

. S

. Cq,

U.S.

U S

.

A .

T P,

I,

-

P

UN -

q .

H, U S I

q UN . A -

, P B C -

- ,

S j G M, .

D U.S. M 001 S-

C UN

, -

j

, P -

. B M

C M

001, P -

M -

. T

A 199, S C

M C

A H L C (AHLC), -

-

P. A

Q

,

.

Origins and Formation

O M 9, 00, P-

I, I D-

F (IDF) j f-

P W B. T

f, W

B 1967 W, IDF -

P , -

, -

P A

, P Y-

A q R. I

, A 10, 00, U.S.

C P EU, UN, R

M

Q. W I f ,

Q -

,

-Aq I 000

001.

I 001, I

W B Gz S,

q

j -

. O J 0, G W. B U S. U -

, -

E - f J 1, B , . A , j S D W.


17/78



5

A J 1

U S

. I

, UN R-L G

, J F,

P Y A -

f -

. T R-L F

U.S.

,

P. W

A ,

, B -

CIA G

.

j ,

. N,

W P

-

P .

T PA ,

S

. E , -- , z

U.S. P

-

. T P

-

-

.8

U S, E-

U, U N, R, E,

J, , N (

M C). T

J-E

-

j E, J-

, U S, E U,

U N, R.6

T

. I

U.S. , E -

I P. I -

.7 A

,

U S

- . T f

UN

M E j R-L EU -

M M. T

, R

A, -

. H, f

U S. W -

S S P

S D, ,

f B -

.

B -001,

. A H

J C, T P M I-P C, Te International Spectator, A 00.6 T J-E R, . T MW .

7 K B, T M E Q M: U M M M E P P, (P.D., U D, A 009), . 10, .

8 J C, T P M I-P C.
http://www.mideastweb.org/jordanegypt.htmhttp://www.mideastweb.org/jordanegypt.htm


18/78



6

Q j A-

.

Aims o the Quartet

A , Q

j: I-

P

,

-

. T

, R,

I-P-

. A , Q

-

,

, , ,

- . T,

, Q -

: (1) (); ()

(, , , -

); ()

R, .

T ,

, . A

,

j

U S. T

Q, , . EU,

UN, R f

U S

-

U.S. .

(I, U

S Q.)

B 001, -

. I z U S -

9/11

q I

z -

A PA.9 A

, I

R Z P

P F L

P (PFLP) I -

PFLP M

Z ( A A M), I

PA. T

B ,

P E,

R, f -

A, ,

. T f O ,

001, U.S., EU, UN, R -

j A R

,

Q.10

T Q, , -

: (1)

I I-P , ()

B -

M E

. T

, .

T E U

U N U S

P -

z . O

,

I, EU UN ,

9 U.S.-I S S E P N, Te Jewish Week, O 6, 001.10 T EU M M, US - R S, R A

V, UN j R-L. S S R M. j R-L, U N S C M E P P (UNSCO), O , 001, : .
http://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/9a798adbf322aff38525617b006d88d7/fc33d890b2b968a785256af100662c08?OpenDocumenthttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/9a798adbf322aff38525617b006d88d7/fc33d890b2b968a785256af100662c08?OpenDocumenthttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/9a798adbf322aff38525617b006d88d7/fc33d890b2b968a785256af100662c08?OpenDocumenthttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/9a798adbf322aff38525617b006d88d7/fc33d890b2b968a785256af100662c08?OpenDocument


19/78



7

Q G

I, P A S

f.1

B UN

S C -

Q R N 00,

, UNSCR

11, S

z -

, j .16

Structure and Composition

T Q

, -

C W. L ,

- [ ]

, [UN S-

] C UN .17

A ,

()

, . I ,

, Q

, B

C G.18 Q

, - U

N G A G E (G8)

Authority and Legitimacy

T UN,

Q , -

, -z, S

C .11 I Q,

UN . S

U.S., EU, UN, R

j O 001,

S C .1

T S C

M 00, UNSCR 197,

S, I P-

, [] -

z . W Q,

f U S

A, R F, E

U U N S C-

.1

F Q

M A 00, S

C j -

.1 S , S 00,

S C - Q UNSCR

1, f

11 Q R. Q, A I W: T R S C G U I L. Chicago-Kent Journal o Internationaland Comparative Law7, (007): . 11.

1 U N, P S S C P M E,O , 001, : .

1 UN S C, R 197, S C D I C A V M E; A V O S, I A P, M 1, 00, : .

1 U N, S P S C, A 10, 00, : .

1 UN S C, R 1, S , 00, : .16 UN S C, R 11, N 19, 00, : . UNSCR 11 S C Q.

17 J P, I G S UN S C, International Organization 9 (S 00): . 99. B, U N - . S W, A C F: G F, U N R C S S I 1 (C I C, J 00).

18 W, Friends Indeed? Te United Nations, Groups o Friends, and the Resolution o Conict(W, DC: U S I P, 007), . 8.
http://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/3c542e959522ce5285256af100526e1c?OpenDocumenthttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/3c542e959522ce5285256af100526e1c?OpenDocumenthttp://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2002/sc7326.doc.htmhttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/e7d71a18d1d8ba4e85256b98004caf2a?OpenDocumenthttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/e7d71a18d1d8ba4e85256b98004caf2a?OpenDocumenthttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N02/601/58/PDF/N0260158.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N02/601/58/PDF/N0260158.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N03/621/85/PDF/N0362185.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N03/621/85/PDF/N0362185.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N03/621/85/PDF/N0362185.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N03/621/85/PDF/N0362185.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N02/601/58/PDF/N0260158.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N02/601/58/PDF/N0260158.pdf?OpenElementhttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/e7d71a18d1d8ba4e85256b98004caf2a?OpenDocumenthttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/e7d71a18d1d8ba4e85256b98004caf2a?OpenDocumenthttp://www.un.org/News/Press/docs/2002/sc7326.doc.htmhttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/3c542e959522ce5285256af100526e1c?OpenDocumenthttp://unispal.un.org/unispal.nsf/eed216406b50bf6485256ce10072f637/3c542e959522ce5285256af100526e1c?OpenDocument


20/78



8

z . W

S C

(P-), - z, -

, Q - -

.

O , U S, E

U, U N, R -

I-

P ,

j f. T -

,

E U U.S. -

9/11

. F , Q f -

- --

,

.

, .0 I

,

.1 I -

, Q Q-

( Q

), .

W

, Q -

. I -

f j

. F UN j R-L,

Q ,

U.S. ,

EU , UN . T

Q

, ,

. I q

The QuarTeT

Pincipls envoys

U S S S H C S E19 D H ()

R F M S L S R A S

E U H R. FASC C A S R H S

U N S-G B K- S C R S

Q R ( B)

19 F U.S. G M U.S. M E M 0, 011. P M J 009, U.S. N E f.

0 W, , D 010.1 T M 1, 010 Q M, R, Q

. M . A , q

, Q .


21/78



9

he Quartets rack Record

Q -

q

( A I). W

Q , -

. O , -

Q

R Q P-

, q

. -

f Q

: M 010 -

Q .

he Roadmap (April 23)

T R A 00

Q

. F

197 UN P P, -

, ,

A-I

, -

P . I

,

R q S-

C (UNSCR 11)

. I ,

R

O 1990. T R

: parallel q-

(.., ) , monitor-

ing , end

game. W

R f, ,

.

T R -

9/11

U.S.- Iq 00. I

I P,

00. M -

, R

Q P B

J 00

P M E

. I

, , P

R-L R 00: I [A S S] B B P B . W , road map, . H, - M C , S-G K

A M 001. B A 00, , J-E (CBM)

j E, J, U S, E U, U N, R, G J F.


22/78



1 0

-

z D.

T R

Q . I

- , . I ,

R, ,

z. T

R-

. T , ,

,

z. A R U.S. ,

F L, , B -

,

,

, J, P

I-P . W-

, -

, ,

.

T

,

,6 R

, -

. E

R, -

Q

I,

P

. T

R A P

I (API),

M 00 A

L B. A ,

API I z-

- A

1967 j

P

.

B

E, A ,

, -

j- z

Q. A

, Q B

P

. T

R D,

EU ,

A 00 EU -

. S , U N

R .I A -

. S,

A- ,

R

E U U N, -

. A R -

S 00,

W H, O P S, P B C N P L, J , 00, : < ://-..///00/06/0006-.>.

F L H M L, A R M N, Foreign Policy, J 1, 009, : .

6 T R : T Q . I , , . Q R, A 0,00.
http://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2002/06/20020624-3.htmlhttp://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2002/06/20020624-3.htmlhttp://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2009/07/01/a_legal_mis_settlement?page=fullhttp://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2009/07/01/a_legal_mis_settlement?page=fullhttp://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2009/07/01/a_legal_mis_settlement?page=fullhttp://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2009/07/01/a_legal_mis_settlement?page=fullhttp://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2002/06/20020624-3.htmlhttp://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2002/06/20020624-3.html


23/78



1 1

,

.8 I , R

P-

S , U.S. -

.9 S R-

D 00, I

- Q -

,

, , -

, -

f USA

j I .0

T q (.., -

)

Q B -

. D I

W H ,

Q

R.1

T S D, -

R,

Q

. K N- S C (NSC), ,

S I ,

z -I-

, PA

Q

. I

q A 00, Q

:

W immediate,

parallel and accelerated movement

- ,

, z

, I -

, .

T Q -

,

M ,

a third-party mechanism,

.7

O

, ,

Q ,

Q q R

.

Y , - , U S.

T I ,

Q, j R -

7 Q S, A 10, 00. E .8 I , I Q qua Q,

. S Q, R . S , O, Q ! D ! T []

. Q C MGS D EU P Ef, Te Guardian, J 0, 00. S R G

... T . S G EN, A P, J 0, 00.

9 D Kz, U.S. , , J 010.0 I UN , J 010.1 T Q R, , S 00: T Q

, - . C . T , , , . Q S, S. 17, 00.

T U.S. R A S S B B D A S D S S D F L N S C.


24/78



1 2

, -

P I (

R, A II).6 T U

S -

R . W R

z D 00, Q-

UN

q .7

B R

A 00, , B

. A M A-

PA

j U.S. I

f PA U S

,

E U, U N,

R.8 I , f

-

, Q ,

,

U

S ( A III

. A -

R

q

, R -

, U.S.

I not -

P

. N,

R , U S I

.

T ,

O ,

Q . I , Q

R,

R Q -

. E R ,

-

Q

00 00. A U

S -

,

--

D Kz, , J 010; S D , J 010; UN, J 010.

T B A N 007, R . T , , O , Q R . S Q S, S, 009 M 19, 010.

T j I 000, M C -001. W E , U S, I , -, A. I N 001, , P U

S , . S S S C L. P, MC C PL U L, K, N 19, 001. N, . T Q A 00 M , R: T Q , M , - , . Q S, A 10, 00.

6I UN , J 010.7I.8I.


25/78



1 3

B W

f

U.S. : H R .

W ?... T -

f . S, -

. T ,

, I .

B ,

. S, ? S?

A W , P q

Q. S P-

L Oz (PLO) S

E Q

. A E, T A

[ Q] , -

A. W

J 008, PB

L. G. W F U.S.

R . F -

- I-P -

A P C N-

007

U S j

.

B F , L. G. P S, U.S. -

z

Q . F,

R-

, P

I

R M ... []

UN).9 I

I U S

-

, B

R .

I J 00,

Aq P M S -

P M M A -

R, P B

A J W U.S. C-

M M M

E . T E U, U-

N, R -

. N W -

, Q

,

f

U S,

Q, , ,

, .0

W -

. N

,

,

W -

.1 O O 1, 00,

, W

W, f . S

9 O UN, , UN, EU, U.S. M C, f Q . D

( R M M M: D //0).0 Q S, J , 00.1 G K, R M S H U.S. P, Washington Post, O 6, 00. W - J 00, EU,

A 00. E A, , , S 010. S E, q J W A M M, A S F F R M, Washington Post, A 8, 00. I PLO J U US P G W. B A C. S

U.S. D S, P B A A C, N 7, 007, :
http://2001-2009.state.gov/p/nea/rls/rm/2007/95695.htmhttp://2001-2009.state.gov/p/nea/rls/rm/2007/95695.htmhttp://2001-2009.state.gov/p/nea/rls/rm/2007/95695.htmhttp://2001-2009.state.gov/p/nea/rls/rm/2007/95695.htm


26/78



1 4

U S I

.0 O

, U.S. - Jf F -

j

, ,

, .1 O

Q

U S

R.I ,

R -

, B -

.

A R z

D 00, U S -

I

I J-

00, S -

. A S

, , B -

R

Iq . F,

U.S. B

B, Iq f -

I-P ,

B R

PA . A

, U.S.

R -

R M.6 P

, S C

A j ,

, ,

R -

Q U S.7

T ,

R -

, Q

-z.8 D

R

, EU UN

. A

EU M O, -

Q

,

U.S. .9 T

,

z I, P, -

NGO ,

,

.

R, ,

.

B R

A 0, 00,

6 T W H, P B N S A S H I-P P P, J 10, 008, : .

7 A S, UN , , J 010.8 A B EU B D O R M E, EU Observer, M , 00. S M P W R M S, B

S I I, Te Forward, A 11, 00.9 M O, EU , , J 010.0 T R M 00 P I,

- , j E , z P , P .

1 M M J W A, M P F L; R M D I, P A H D, Washington Post, M 1, 00.

I UN , J 010. I, M 16 Az S U S, B, S, P, B

B, S J M Az P J D B R.O P B , R. F B B R, B,A Journey: My Political Lie, (N Y: A A. K, 010), . .
http://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2008/01/20080110-7.htmlhttp://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2008/01/20080110-7.html


27/78



1 5

I S f, D W-

, z.

T z

A 00 W -

Czz R,

R z[ ] -

( -

), I j

.6

O M , P R j -

I ,

: T U S

G I -

,

P J , 00.7 T

, S R-

,8 I

. I , , I

:

T G I

the steps set out in R. T G-

I , in ac-

cordance with J 00

P B, ,

I

P.9

,

.

S , U

S I, f-

R. T I,

Q

R,

j

. I

,

- A I -

W

J, B

,

, U S

I j R

,

S H. P-

I N Y

W -

-

R.

I R

, . I -

-, I j

R ,

. A R ,

D N S A S H

NSC f E A

S H, , , J 010. I E H U.S. L A R M, A F P, M , 00.6 T , S D. 00, U.S. I:

T , ,

. S I M F Af, L D W, C PM B, N S A, D. Czz R, A 18, 00, : .

7 W H, O P S, S S S C L. P N S A Czz R,M , 00, : .

8 I M F Af, S PM S B, M, 00, : .

9 I M F Af, G M P M S R, M , 00, :.E .
http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Letter+Weissglas-Rice+18-Apr-2004.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Letter+Weissglas-Rice+18-Apr-2004.htmhttp://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2003/05/20030523.htmlhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Communiques/2003/Statement+from+PM+Sharon-s+Bureau+-+23-May-2003.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Communiques/2003/Statement+from+PM+Sharon-s+Bureau+-+23-May-2003.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/government/communiques/2003/goverment%20meeting%20about%20the%20prime%20minister-s%20statehttp://www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/government/communiques/2003/goverment%20meeting%20about%20the%20prime%20minister-s%20statehttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Communiques/2003/Statement+from+PM+Sharon-s+Bureau+-+23-May-2003.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Communiques/2003/Statement+from+PM+Sharon-s+Bureau+-+23-May-2003.htmhttp://georgewbush-whitehouse.archives.gov/news/releases/2003/05/20030523.htmlhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Letter+Weissglas-Rice+18-Apr-2004.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Letter+Weissglas-Rice+18-Apr-2004.htm


28/78



1 6

. T R -

P -

O 00 M

A PA . T U

S A-

J W

PA

.6 M, q

, U.S. -

P

R P

.6 T, -

j R

, U S .

T -

P

R, q-

, M A,

z.

A E A, T R

f 00 A

-

.6 A J 00, , R-

, Q

. I,

P I . T

P

, q-

, P

. H, , T q

, I .

T ,

P .6 L,

I , T q

B R-

, I -

R -

q. T B J 00

A I

, , S-

- . I ,

R j

-

.

A I

I -

R, ,

, I -

P

.60 A B -

,

-

R .

C ,

I

, ,

U.S. . I -

W

, P B

P M S A 00.61

E J 00,

R

.

W EU Q

- ,

U S

60 I M F Af, I R R, A P K W, M , 00, : .

61 S, I M F Af, L P B P M S L US P G W. B P M A S, A 1, 00, : .

6 L L, FBI M PA,Jerusalem Post, O 1, 00.6 A D Kz P , , A 00; NSC E A P

, , S 00 ( ).6 E A, , S 010.6 J W A P W O P P S; S C N A O-S, Washington Post, J , 00.
http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Israel+Response+to+the+Roadmap+25-May-2003.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Israel+Response+to+the+Roadmap+25-May-2003.htmhttp://fpfsc02/UserData%20I-K/Users/kelgindy/My%20Documents/-%20Papers/(8)%20Quartet%20(Dec%202011)/drafts/draft%207/%3chttp:/www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Exchange+of+letters+Sharon-Bush+14-Apr-2004.htmhttp://fpfsc02/UserData%20I-K/Users/kelgindy/My%20Documents/-%20Papers/(8)%20Quartet%20(Dec%202011)/drafts/draft%207/%3chttp:/www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Exchange+of+letters+Sharon-Bush+14-Apr-2004.htmhttp://fpfsc02/UserData%20I-K/Users/kelgindy/My%20Documents/-%20Papers/(8)%20Quartet%20(Dec%202011)/drafts/draft%207/%3chttp:/www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Exchange+of+letters+Sharon-Bush+14-Apr-2004.htmhttp://fpfsc02/UserData%20I-K/Users/kelgindy/My%20Documents/-%20Papers/(8)%20Quartet%20(Dec%202011)/drafts/draft%207/%3chttp:/www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Exchange+of+letters+Sharon-Bush+14-Apr-2004.htmhttp://fpfsc02/UserData%20I-K/Users/kelgindy/My%20Documents/-%20Papers/(8)%20Quartet%20(Dec%202011)/drafts/draft%207/%3chttp:/www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Exchange+of+letters+Sharon-Bush+14-Apr-2004.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Israel+Response+to+the+Roadmap+25-May-2003.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Peace+Process/Reference+Documents/Israel+Response+to+the+Roadmap+25-May-2003.htm


29/78



1 7

I

P.70 A

, U.S. -

q ,T

j S . I

.71

S, U

S Q

R . T E U,

U N, R -

U.S.

I . W R

z Q -

U.S. , EU

. I U S

, -

z .7 T R

U

S UN

S C I

P R.7

D ,

, E U, U N,

R U

S D P. I M 00,

Q -

,

,

. B -

.66 T -

R . I ,

R

.67

P Q

-z

I D P

R

Q

P . U D P,

I

Gz S68

E J

W B. S

D P D-

00 B

,

W H

S

. A, N, Czz

R S f D W

- W , I -

P

PA

R.69 I

, S P

f ,

66 I.67 M E N , W S E U D N M E, CEPS B . 11 (C

E P S, S 00).68 A D P W B,

. A 00 ( 0,000 W B ), P .

69 P M E,Mideast Mirror, N 8, 00.70 A S, S Hz C, D 18, 00.71 G D M E : R P D M, Financial imes, J 1, 00.7 R W C L, U.S. P R M P P; U.N., E, R E A, Washington Post,

J 7, 00.7 I.


30/78



1 8

R Q

.

I , UN -

- K A R

, Q: W

,

z -

O -

, , . I

.78

T R

Q ,

. T -

R

. A f -

. I, -

U S

Q ,

.

A U S

Q R,

,

q . W R

j . H-

,

-

. T E U,

U N, R

Q,

.

M E

-

.7 F

, Q

,

R M, I-

1967,

S, I , ,

, P-

, .7

D , Q

z

, 00

.

A Q ,

S , D W,

: T

q [.., -

] . I -

[J

00]

. T -

. I

- P.76 S

D P

P,

[ ]

.77 L O ,

f I P

, Q

R

. S , ,

7 Q S, M , 00.7 Q S, S , 00.76 Q , A S, W: D F P P, Haaretz Magazine, O 8, 00.77 A B, PM S H H A C A H B, Haaretz, A 6, 00, q A L M K

K: F D P S, International Afairs81 (00): . 98199.78 UN S C, R S-G M E, D 11, 006, : .
http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N06/651/88/PDF/N0665188.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N06/651/88/PDF/N0665188.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N06/651/88/PDF/N0665188.pdf?OpenElementhttp://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N06/651/88/PDF/N0665188.pdf?OpenElement


31/78



1 9

O , I

-

I

-

B F

A . S,

q I -

-

I .

A , -

I

-

- .

T H , Q

P

, -

P -

.80 T

Q

. A -

I, P, A , Q

PA

. I J 0 ,

Q

-

, -

I, -

, R.81

T , Q P-

, Q H -

PA .

W

R

A I ,

,

z, .79 W f

Q

. O , Q

,

. I

, Q -

,

E U, U N, R

j -

.

he Quartet Principles(January 2)

O J 6, 006, P I -

H F ,

, 7 1

P L C (PLC)

, PA ,

. I H

PA (

). H j O A-

PLC J 199 PA

J 00. H -

006

Q, I, F, A .

79 K B, T M E Q M: U M M M E P P, . 166.80 Q S, J 6, 006.81 Q S, J 0, 006.


32/78



2 0

.

, ..,

[H I] H

H j -

z C,

. A

UN ,

. I UN

-

.8

D S Q P

,

-

.8 A A :

I [G

A] M [EU

J] S, ,

Q

, very

. A

U.S.

EU; UN

f .86

S EU A

EU .87 N,

U N R -

A

. A A , , -

PA,

A -

, -

, A I

,

. T Q P,

Q ,

. T -

Q -

J 0 .

A UN A S,

U.S. -

P

. T U

N , . I

,

S j

A S S D W

D N S A E A,

U.S.

UN .8 I ,

.

D S Q P

P-

.

8

A S , UN

q :

T f,

. T

8 A S, E M R, M 007, . 18, : < ://.../-/G//007/06/1/DSR.>.

8 I., . 01.8 E A, , S 010.8 T q Q P

. F : T Q . Q S, M 0, 006. L: T

P A . Q S, M 9, 006.

86 E A, , S 010.87 F , J S, q T W S H M C K R EU F, A

P, J 1, 006.S ,J S, E U S P P,Al Hayat, A , 006, :.
http://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2007/06/12/DeSotoReport.pdfhttp://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2007/06/12/DeSotoReport.pdfhttp://www.reliefweb.int/rw/RWB.NSF/db900SID/EGUA-6P6SAD?OpenDocumenthttp://www.reliefweb.int/rw/RWB.NSF/db900SID/EGUA-6P6SAD?OpenDocumenthttp://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2007/06/12/DeSotoReport.pdfhttp://image.guardian.co.uk/sys-files/Guardian/documents/2007/06/12/DeSotoReport.pdf


33/78



2 1

I PA.

[T] f I ,

Q .89

T A S -

Q-

. A Q -

H ,

J 0 , q

.

O , P -

PA, U

S, E U, U N,

R q f

,

f. T f

U S / -

R H

-

, EU

A UN

R. T

Q -

.

90

D ,

U S

E U . L

U S, E U

H z, -

PA. N,

E U

P

U.S. EU

.

I , q M

7, 006, U S E

U

PA. S 199, PA

, q

00. T -

,

A ,

. I -

(VA)

P ,

60 70 PA , -

.

I , P

6

006. I , -

PA -

,

.

88

U PA , VA

P ,

I

PA , P . A-

E U U N-

I VA

, S Q

U.S.

88 I M FT W B, W B Gz E D 006A F A, M 007, : .

89 A S, E M R, . .90 Cz M, T M Q: A Ef I M? ( Gz, S

L G8, R I I R, N P S I Af C U, F E S G8 R G, B, M , 007), . 1 : .
http://www.imf.org/external/np/wbg/2007/eng/032607ed.pdfhttp://www.g7.utoronto.ca/conferences/2007/musu2007.pdfhttp://www.g7.utoronto.ca/conferences/2007/musu2007.pdfhttp://www.g7.utoronto.ca/conferences/2007/musu2007.pdfhttp://www.g7.utoronto.ca/conferences/2007/musu2007.pdfhttp://www.imf.org/external/np/wbg/2007/eng/032607ed.pdf


34/78



2 2

T Q P j

;

Q -

. T E U , ,

. A EU

f U S,

E U -

- U.S. . S

z E U

P, E U

P .9T

UN q , -

. W A

Q P, , B K-,

, S.9

T R -

. I

R

f f P-

H f

U S W E-9 Q-

-

.9

F,

F M S L:

R , P

P: P-

,

,

PA E

.

Cq, E U -

(IM)

PA ,

H- PA,

P -

.

T Q -

, A , W B,

, U S I

IM (

). T

Q A 7, 006

Q L,

IM. A , W

U.S. -

PA

H-

F .91 A U S -

IM,

Q

. I , A 006, W

B J W -

Q , -

I Gz. S

-

P, -

PA,

W -

.

91 A E, W B D D P, Haaretz, M , 006.9 S, , J S, M E P P, Palestine imes, N 0, 006.9 A S, , J 010. A S, B

UN M 007.9 P F,P S R, U.S. Df H W, Washington Post, F 1, 006.9 Q S, J 0, 006.


35/78


36/78



2 4

, I

.

T

[] , W G B

. [A Q ]

j A -

.10

T M A ,

Q ,

. I, Q -

, -

. A , J 007,

,

H F- PA

z Gz S.

T

Q P

PA

.10 T

B C G 1990 f

- Q: T G

,

,

.10 A

B,

q Q. T Q

E

U J S, -

- .10 A B :

Q

, U S, .

T

Q -

-

. T U.S.

H- PA

Q-

. H, f-

Q.

I ,

Q,

.

W Q

,

. W -

Q

, U S

. T B

, A

:

W

. B Q P, .

T U.S. T

R

K M,

. T E ,

F M. O

H ,

M. Y -

-

, Q z

10 E A, , S 010.10 A H, Q L C E A, Haaretz, M , 006 (H).10 H L-P, T C G ( ) B, International Journal(S 1998): . .10 K B, T M E Q M: U M M M E P P, . 19.


37/78



2 5

C L Gz

, z-

Q P

z P-

, -

. A , P

,

- -

, ,

. T,

Q ,

P -

-

,

f,

P .

T H-F ,

C M , 011,

-

q. T

, -

Q P,

Q . W

, P- , I

$89

PA, U.S. EU

. A

J 01, Q

. B

00607 ,

. T , U

S Q

, E- U .108 B U

T EU -

Q,

f

, .

EU

US

Q

. S EU

Q, -

.106

I, H Gz

Q -

. S

H z Gz, A

S F, U S

E U

PA W B. A

Gz, Q z -

, . S

, Q

W B -

Gz. M , -

H . I

.

W S -

z . B

Gz W (O C

L) 00809,

1,00 , 1,000

, 0,000 P.107 A

106 I., . 199.107 U N H R C (UNHRC), H R P O A : R U

N F F M Gz C, S 1, 009, : .

108 S, , A R, EU E B R H, EU Observer, M , 011, : .
http://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/specialsession/9/docs/UNFFMGC_Report.PDFhttp://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/specialsession/9/docs/UNFFMGC_Report.PDFhttp://euobserver.com/24/32261http://euobserver.com/24/32261http://euobserver.com/24/32261http://euobserver.com/24/32261http://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/specialsession/9/docs/UNFFMGC_Report.PDFhttp://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/specialsession/9/docs/UNFFMGC_Report.PDF


38/78



2 6

j , EU

M A. L,

z ,

q-

. F,

-, -

A , F -

-

q :

.

he Flotilla Crisis: he QuartetAt its Best

T Q, ,

f

. O -

q A, E, UN -

Q

I Gz M

010 I -

Gz. T

I , Q

I .

O f U N,

Q

. I M 1, 00 -

q, Q Gz

,

Gz, U N S C

N R ,

EU F,

PA $1

f I .109

A Q

,

P

E-

U, U N, R,

. I -

H Gz

, j

R

D P. Y,

-

U S q -

, E U, U-

N, R .

F , Q

.

W Q, Q-

P . T

U S, E U, U

N, R - f

. E ,

U S I S

C UN . W U

S I

PA

H ,

. E E

109 F U P A I H F, A F P, M 9, 011.


39/78



2 7

I , I -

Q

inac-

tion ; Q

Gz ,

,

.

T I B N-

Q

B11 I

Q ,

.

T , -

, Q j :

. W

, ,

U S, E U, U

N, R -

. T

shape

Q , -

Gz , H -

, 00809 Gz W, . A,

,

Q , . I

, R 00

Q

1860 (009).110 U

, U.S.

I

Gz

,

U N -

. I

, , U S

UN

,

Q B.

A UN- A

, f

Q ,

Q . T ,

,

. I ,

Q -

,

Q P

U.S.- PA

006. M ,

, Q

Gz. A - Gz

,111

M M

010, Q

,

I ,

f

.

110 Q S, M 1, 010.111 T Q Gz S 007,

j P , . Q S S , 007.

11 S I M F Af, R PM N B, Q E M E, J 0, 010, : .
http://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Speeches+by+Israeli+leaders/2010/Remarks_PM_Netanyahu_and_Quartet_Envoy_Tony_Blair_20-Jun-2010.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Speeches+by+Israeli+leaders/2010/Remarks_PM_Netanyahu_and_Quartet_Envoy_Tony_Blair_20-Jun-2010.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Speeches+by+Israeli+leaders/2010/Remarks_PM_Netanyahu_and_Quartet_Envoy_Tony_Blair_20-Jun-2010.htmhttp://www.mfa.gov.il/MFA/Government/Speeches+by+Israeli+leaders/2010/Remarks_PM_Netanyahu_and_Quartet_Envoy_Tony_Blair_20-Jun-2010.htm


40/78



2 8

.11 A -

, W

B

Q j .

W I-

Gz ,

. L, B P-

- f -

I Gz

-010

.

I

Q -

Q

. H, -

U.S. j

. O,

Q ,

B, EU, UN, R

.

I A

, z Q

I. T ,

. N -

Q

-.11 A UN ,

OQR j ;

.116

W OQR

Q, ,

,

-.

he Quartet Representative: heException that Proves the Rule

T Q

: Q -

, B

B. L Q ,

. T

A 00 U.S.

Czz R

W B J W

Q (QSE). O

, W

I A 00

Gz,

A M A (AMA).

W , ,

H -

. W Gz

,11

B , W-

A 006. T

J 007, P

B B , Q

(OQR).

W B, U.S. ,

-

P , -

, -. B OQR

QSE, Q , q

- ,

E J, f,

11 J D. W, S, F R C, Post-Palestinian Election Challenges in the Middle East, ,M 1, 006, :.

11 OQR f, QSE, z Q , W B , -Q A, I P f, W B. T A, - S D.

11 W, , O 010.116 I UN , J 010.
http://foreign.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/WolfensohnTestimony060315.pdfhttp://foreign.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/WolfensohnTestimony060315.pdf


41/78



2 9

B

. B W

B -, -, -

-

. B -

. T

. O W,

--

, ,

. O B, q-

,

,

, -

. W W z

U.S.

, B, ,

U.S. .

F , W

-

. S ,

W W B

.119

W , -

, f

- .10

T I

, -

A M A

00, I

f , U.S.

Q .117 T -

Q

U S. A /

Q

, -

. R,

,

U.S. . U W

B, -

Q ,

f -

. I , ,

O , OQR

f .

T Q

P

-

. A ,

- ,

W B, A H L

C,

. P -,

, Q-

. N, W B ,

, -

,

B .118 A ,

Q j

Q

, R -

.

117 I U.S. Q , f .118 F OQR , O Q R, O Q R

S E C O H, J 1, 010, : .

119 A , : O , I D P J 6 P P , . A - - . S, T W B, D, P E S, J ,00, : .

10 N R, W B W B/Gz, , J 010.
http://www.tonyblairoffice.org/quartet/news-entry/office-of-the-quartet-representative-secures-extension-of-tarkumiya-crossin/http://www.tonyblairoffice.org/quartet/news-entry/office-of-the-quartet-representative-secures-extension-of-tarkumiya-crossin/http://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWESTBANKGAZA/Resources/psannexdiseng.pdfhttp://siteresources.worldbank.org/INTWESTBANKGAZA/Resources/psannexdiseng.pdfhttp://www.tonyblairoffice.org/quartet/news-entry/office-of-the-quartet-representative-secures-extension-of-tarkumiya-crossin/http://www.tonyblairoffice.org/quartet/news-entry/office-of-the-quartet-representative-secures-extension-of-tarkumiya-crossin/


42/78



3 0

q -

.1 A ,

P

Q .1 T

Q

. N

J W,

B :

M B

. I ,

P, -

. I

, -

I , .... I

-

, .

I I -

, , -

I . T

Q ,

Q A . I Q

. T

A -

, I

E A

S D , I

.1

A. A W

, U.S. -

. E-

S R

W

. H,

-

, W

- .11

A

,

W

Gz . I , -

B, q

,

. B J

007

Q,

B

. I

B

, -

.1 S Q

B z

Q. H, -

z. T B Q,

B

.

I -z 007 , E-

B

R

11 I W L?, Haaretz, M 1, 006.1 S C Uq, J B, I B P C B R I P I P, Te Guardian, J 11,

007; S L, U.S. R P E B M M, A F P, J 1, 007.1 T B, C, S, F, G, I, M, P, R, S. F ,

O L B M F Af M M S E U, P LM N, J 10, 007, : .

1 L S E Q P, J 9, 007. (D .) S C Uq, J B, I B, G B R, P, Te Guardian, J 11, 007, : .1 A D W H A N G, Haaretz W, J 19, 007. S W S N B-Y

H C, F Af C, G S, Te Middle East: Eighth Report o Session 200607, , , , O H C J , 007, : .
http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/3ED826E1434F0EF785257354006F433Bhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/jul/11/israelandthepalestinians.tonyblairhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/jul/11/israelandthepalestinians.tonyblairhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/jul/11/israelandthepalestinians.tonyblairhttp://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2007/jul/11/israelandthepalestinians.tonyblairhttp://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/3ED826E1434F0EF785257354006F433B


43/78



3 1

, , -

. M , , B

, , S

011 P UN . A -

z Q , B

. I

O , B

f

P UN -

.

I , Q

P

, f. A

O 10, 011 PLO

B -

j ,

.10

T q U S

Q

-

U S, E U, U

N. T

, W

00. A W Gz ,

R Q

z . T

U S

B

A S

Q. W W

M B

z f , .

K

B

W . F

, W

,

,16

U.S. . S B -

,

S D

. A

, B B

, U.S. .17

L W, B

,

. W

, B ,

, -

.18 T

U.S.

B ,

B

, OQR f

, I -

.19

A OQR

, B

. S

B Q

, - . M,

B

W . T

16 W : [1] M , . [] E - P , . S, Q S, A1, 00.

17 I U.S. , A 010.18 I.19 I OQR f , M 010.10 M M, B U P ,Arab News, O 10, 011.


44/78



3 2

O , , , -

,

. T

, U.S.

, [B]

.1 A

A L M:

G I -

q ,

-

raison dtre (

two )

(-

, -

-

one o the two ),

-

. A

(

),

. I, -

P-

.1

D ,

. F,

,

Q ,

R, Q .

A W-

. A B

q , -

U S.

I , B

B f

-

S H 00. M ,

B.

P , B

P f D

00 -B

P

F P R

(FPR).11 L OQR, FPR

Q

U S

P f

P . I, OQR

Q , -.1 B

OQR ,

, .

I U.S. -

, B

11 T FPR Q N, J, W B I M F.1 A A L M: R, -00,

z PA ,

P , , U S I, A. F , f . I P

. N , f q . S A LM, K K: F D P S, . 99.

1 I US , A 010.F , M K, A LM, R L, .,Aid, Diplomacy and Facts on the Ground: the Case oPalestine(L: C H, 00).

1 A L M K K: F D P S, . 98.


45/78



3 3

Q-

R

. A,

- -

-

. A

,

U.S.- -

,

. I, W B -

D-

P R

H

PA. T B

-

,

U.S. , ,

- P UN ,

U S.

O, Q , -

B,

A

Q I

EU, UN, R

z

Q .

-

, U.S. -

(.., ) ,1 EU

-

, UN .

S, j ,

Q

( )

f P. T -

, -,

z (

EU, UN, R ) -

z IP , L M

, - -

q

.16 T ,

R ,

A I -

z Q ,

-

. A - , ,

- -

z .

D f -

, W B :

1 A P -, PA . A YzS, P : T W j W B [P A SF] . S Yz S, P P, B S: A W B Gz, C P, F 011, . 1, : .

16 I., . 99.
http://carnegie-mec.org/publications/?fa=42924http://carnegie-mec.org/publications/?fa=42924http://carnegie-mec.org/publications/?fa=42924http://carnegie-mec.org/publications/?fa=42924


46/78



3 4

Why the Quartet Does Not Work

-

. T Q R, , -

Q P,

PA

Gz.

S, should Q? U,

Q

. H, -

Q -

.

: H Q

?

E , Q ,

U S -

B

R. S , Q

. W - Q f

q . T

H 006

. I -

, Q P

A

,

Q

-

,

-

. E ,

,

Q-

. A

Q ,

, -

- P I . G -

Q

,

,

.

M U.S., EU, UN, R ,

Q , -

. H

Q, , R, ,

P ; ,

P

- f, Gz -

, . , ,

Q


47/78



3 5

T

Q ,

z

-

. D

, -

z Q . A

-

,

Q -

.

T

,

q Q -

. , , E U -

J

,18 UN

- -

I ,

U.S. . L,

U S , E

U,

H, -

z, R -

.

P Q U S -

,

. M, ,

E U

U N

( )

Q nor-

matively

U S

R , - E U, j Q

P

P A

007, z P

.

T Q :

, ;

; -

. T -

Q

, ,

- f

, -

. T

Q

,

U S,

f

.

All hings to All People

O

Q

-

S C. U- , j

,

, -

, ( )

.17 I

Q, , ,

- . W Q

, ,

,

.

17 S J P, I G S UN S C, . 99.18 C E U, C C M E P P, 98 F Af C , B,

D 8, 009, : .
http://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/en/foraff/111829.pdfhttp://www.consilium.europa.eu/uedocs/cms_data/docs/pressdata/en/foraff/111829.pdf


48/78



3 6

, q

Q. W

f -

UN , S

C,10 Q -

S C -

I-

P ,

. T P

U N S 011 -

,

.11

T Q

.

O , Q -

-

Q

P. O , -

R. D

-

Q. T

U S I, UN

,

S C.

Lopsided Membership

T Q q

. W -

, f

, -

U N.19 W

, ,

Q -

.

T -

Q ,

, ,

. S

, Q

lowest common denominator. T, -

,

-

. T

( )

,

Q . I -

, -

-

, , P-

I .

D , Q

. W Q E J,

, H

Q. M, -

Q

, ,

j .

T Q

S C

19 S, , Q S, M 1, 010, I E J.

10 S J P, I G S UN S C, . 8.11 F UN P , A S, P UN Cf, T N , Foreign

Afairs, S 1, 011, : .
http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/68289/alvaro-de-soto/palestineshttp://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/68289/alvaro-de-soto/palestines


49/78



3 7

jz A .16 T

MSC

, A -

, ,

( U

S R) q f

Q. U MSC, , Q

top-down.

I MSC,

Q -

. N R-L -

, Q -

z

f

, .

T -

Q U

S,

,

f , -

.

Missing: Regional Actors

T Q

-

,

. T

.1 T -

P- , ,

,

. T Q-

, ,

I PA ( U S E-

U),

.

UN S C ( U

S R), .1

T -

. T Q

, -

M S C (MSC),

1991 M C-

.1 T I, P-

,

MSC,

z ( )

(

)

. M , Q

.1

T f-

,

E U

1 W, A C F: G F, U N R C S S I 1(C I C, J 00), .10.

1 A W : A S C []

UN. I.1 T MSC, , J 199,

1991 M P C (O./N. 1991). I U S, R, C, EC, J, S A,, I, E, J, PLO (S L j ). : UN , N, .

A MSC I A , AHLC, 199 O ( q ), P Q .

1 I UN , J 010.16 D D K, M F F: T M E M, Washington Quarterly0 (1997): . 17.


50/78



3 8

T API,

R, q

f

-

-

f. W A

z

,

, -

. H Q ,

, A

-

API,

.

A -

S L

, Q-

. A

, S L-

R q,

U.S., EU, UN, R-

, Q-

j I-P . N , ,

Q 006 L W,

, , ,

S C.

he Quartet Sans rios

T U S

Q

E J,

I

P. I ,

(

)

Q .17 I , UN --

K A

E J ,

z.18

T -

-

Q

.19 T -

z

.10I

Q z

,11

. M-

, , A

, - (J-

, E, S A) j (S-

, L, .) ,

. T

A

P.

T A Q-

A f, -

A P I (API) 00.

17 T J-E A 001, , R . S M M, Te Arab Center: Te Promise o Moderation (N H: Y U P, 008).

18 W, Friends Indeed? Te United Nations, Groups o Friends, and the Resolution o Conict(W, DC: U S I P, 007).

19 I S D , J 010; UN , J 010.10 K A, R S-G M E, D 11, 006, : .11 W, A C F: G F, U N R C, . .
http://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N06/651/88/PDF/N0665188.pdf?OpenElementhttp://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N06/651/88/PDF/N0665188.pdf?OpenElementhttp://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N06/651/88/PDF/N0665188.pdf?OpenElementhttp://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/N06/651/88/PDF/N0665188.pdf?OpenElement


51/78



3 9

U.S.

A-I -

M E . T

: I ,

,

,

- G,

. T

9/11 , Q

,

I U.S. Iq,

U.S.-

. T

U.S. -

Q

j,

U.S.

Q .

T U.S. j

Q , J

00 I z Karine A,

P -

, B J 00 -

J 00

P M E .A B S

H :

T ,

Karine A, A ,

-

. A, ,

, I A. I

, I

. A A 00 ,

. I ,

U S ,

, M E

.

T Q

-

E U, U N,

R.1 I,

, Q

A

. A ,

Q

, U

S .

Y,

, ,

. A EU, UN, R -

, U S q -

, ,

Q . T

Q-

P B

Q

R Aq S J 00

O S-

010. D

U.S. ,

Q

.

I Q, A

j -

. I q

1 A Q q: T UN, EU R S S P , I P A f . Q S, A 10, 00. T P M , 00 Q : I M 10 A, I I M E P B M E. R U.S. S S C P UN S-G K

A, M , 00.


52/78



4 0

Q . K

N S C, -

, P, ,

U.S. I-

.

T I, ,

B ,

P.

T -

U.S. -

I. T

U.S.-I ,

-

,

U.S.

. B B

, ,

A S

. S,

U S, E U,

U N, R , , ,

j -

I-P .16

F U S , Q

-

. I

P -

J 00 ,

. S,

, [] -

A

A.1

B J 00

U.S. M E . W

B S

, - -

P I

-

.1 F S

B U.S.

: E N

A-I

M E. B

Iq , -

f A-

I .1

W

B P , U.S. -

, P

, -

-

E -

,

P A . T

U.S.

, f -

S D W H.

P U.S. -

1 S H, , J 010.1 I A 00, U.S. P B

S - . I , : Y q S -j , I B W-, , S , . N S I. S L P B U.S.D, A 0, 00, : < ://..//00/0/06_-_. >.

1 Q R G. K B S N I M P, Washington Post, F 9, 00.16 K B, T M E Q M: U M M M E P P, . 1.
http://www.wagingpeace.org/articles/2004/05/06_letter-diplomats_print.htmhttp://www.wagingpeace.org/articles/2004/05/06_letter-diplomats_print.htm


53/78



4 1

,

I. T

Q ,

U-

S I , ,

j ,

Q. T Q

J W -

Q

U S I:

T - -

I U S,

-

. A -

Q,

R, E-

U, UN

I f-

f

U.S. I

M E. A

Q

-

,

. I U S . I

q - . B

,

A .160

D S US -

[ Q] ,

US

M E, Iq I.161

, Q

-

j, M 00

Iq.17 I

U.S. Q.

S, P, Q

,

9/11

J 00. A

E A, J

00 W H

S D;

P M

E .18 A A :

O P

Q . W

Q ,

S D

W H

, S D-

Q, A-

.19

I , Q

P,

, , E

UN

U S.

A Q

, U-

S, ,

.

Cq, Q

U.S.

17 F B US Iq, MM, Te Arab Center: Te Promise o Moderation (N H L, Y U P, 008), . 166. S MEB, Te Age o Deception: Nuclear Diplomacy in reacherous imes(N Y: M B H H & C, 011), . 67.

18 E A, , S 010.19 I.160 J W, , J 010.161 A S, E M R, . .


54/78



4 2

P UN .

B J,

, U.S.

O

M 19, 011 .16

I ,

Q W

; -

, I

-

W B. N,

A A-

Q;

U S , ,

, -

Q

U.S. . T

Q sans trios.166 I,

E U, U N,

R A -

Q.

T E U, j Q,

,

U S. A

P A

I ( -

, ), E U

T B -

. D z

-

, O

Q. Q

-

,

. A

, O

Q -

S 010

-

. I W

, S S H C

E J, Q -

B,

E U, U N, R,

Q .16 T -

Q ,

E.16

D q

, Q

011. D

U.S. -

UN F 011

A , B, F,

G

.16 T U

S , ,

Q

16 S S S H R C, R W I P M Bj N, P A PM A, S , 010, : .

16 T F, , q U.S. Q . F

B K EU , C A, , . S A S U A M P , A F P, A 9,010.

16 S CT M EP D RJ S U K, F G, F 18, 011.

16 F J 1, 011 Q , D L, A A QS, Foreign Policy, J , 011, : .

166 T A L A M EU , C P. S C P, Not Quite the Diplomat: Home ruths about World Afairs(N Y: P, 00), . 109.
http://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2010/09/146701.htmhttp://mideast.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/07/22/palestine_israel_the_un_and_america_s_attempted_quartet_sophistryhttp://mideast.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/07/22/palestine_israel_the_un_and_america_s_attempted_quartet_sophistryhttp://mideast.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/07/22/palestine_israel_the_un_and_america_s_attempted_quartet_sophistryhttp://mideast.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2011/07/22/palestine_israel_the_un_and_america_s_attempted_quartet_sophistryhttp://www.state.gov/secretary/rm/2010/09/146701.htm


55/78



4 3

A-I . F ,

UN -

-

,171 P-

U N R

W A P R N

E (UNRWA) UN ,

. A

W, T [Q]

P R, j R-L,

S-

001, [ S-

-G]

UN

.17

I Q A

, R-L

U.S. , EU ,

UN R.

A -

S U

, R

. T Q

R -

E-W . A-

A M ,

I, R

. E , -

Q

M E W,

. W -

-

, ,

. A

,

009 L ,167 E

,

P

011.168 E

I E -

P.I

A

I,169 Q f E U

z

-

EU

.170

T U N

I E-

U. UN Q

- -

,

G A SC. I , UN

-

, P

M E . T Q-

UN - -

167 U L , , EU Q : (1) f , () , () EU .

168 T O 1, 011 U N U N E, S C Oz (UNESCO)

P . I , 107 , 1 , .H, EU 11 (A, B, C, F, F, G, I, L,M, N, S), (Cz R, G, H, L, S), 11 (B, D,E, I, L, P, P, R, S, M, U K).

169 Cz M, T M Q: A Ef I M?, . 6.170 Cz M, European Union Policy owards the Arab-Israeli Peace Process: Te Quicksands o Politics(N Y: P M, 010), . 79.171 I U N I F L (UNIFIL), UN ,

U N S Oz (UNSO), 199 A A I A , U N D O F (UNDOF), O W 197.

17 W, A C F: G F, U N R C, . 7.


56/78



4 4

. B j

EU -f. T

US

. I

I . I E-

U M,

E

.17

F UN A S -

UN Q,

UN

: -

A .176 A

S, UN Q

. B

U.S. , -

PA Gz,

U N -

,

S M 007.177 A

, S U

N Q.

D Q

, . A

S-G K

A -

, UN A S,

S

H PA, -

U.S. . I -

E M , S

A,

z .17 T

Q R -

,

I, ,

. T

Q-

,

H.17

O , A -

Q

q U

S

. T

U.S.

, ,

-

. T

U-

S,

, -

, , . W

, Q

E U U N.

T E U,

-

U S. F

Brookings Analysis Paper Feb12 [the Middle East Quartet -- A Post-Mortem]

Documents

Transcript of Brookings Analysis Paper Feb12 [the Middle East Quartet -- A Post-Mortem]