Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf ·...

28
by Greg Nurnberg, [email protected] Technical Support Engineer Fluent Inc. www.fluent.com Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling: Coupling RELAP5- 3D © & FLUENT Relevant Applications

Transcript of Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf ·...

Page 1: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

by

Greg Nurnberg,[email protected]

Technical Support Engineer

Fluent Inc.www.fluent.com

Breaking the Barrier Between System andComponent Modeling: Coupling RELAP5-

3D© & FLUENT

Relevant Applications

Page 2: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Outline◆ FLUENT & RELAP5-3D© Coupling◆ Introduction to Fluent Inc.◆ What is CFD?◆ Case Studies◆ FLUENT

Capabilities◆ Summary

Contours of Pressure

Page 3: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Need for Fluent & RELAP5-3D© Coupling

◆ Enable an entire system tobe modeled using 1dimensional features ofRELAP5-3D©

◆ Model some components ofthe system in detail usingthe 3 dimensional featuresof FLUENT

Page 4: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

◆ The performance of thesystem depends on the flowthrough each component,and vice versa

◆ Boundary conditioninformation is transferredback and forth between thetwo codes

◆ Both the system andcomponent behavior ismore accurately predicted

Benefits of Fluent &RELAP5-3D© Coupling

Courtesy of Center for Multiphase Research, RPI

Page 5: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Coupling◆ A 1-D model of

the powertrainsystem isconstructed

◆ The intakemanifold isrepresented as a“CFD component”

Contours of Exhaust GasRecirculation 18.9 ms intothe cycle

Courtesy of Cummins Inc..

Page 6: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Coupling◆ The coupled solution

shows the transientflow in the manifolddue to continuouslyupdated boundaryconditions

◆ The systemperformance is moreaccurately predictedas well Contours of Exhaust Gas

Recirculation

Courtesy of Cummins Inc..

Page 7: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Introduction to Fluent Inc.

◆ Fluent Inc. develops and markets fluiddynamics software for the analysis ofengineering processes

◆ Software can be used for studying:�Fluid flow and heat transfer�Complex reactions, materials, processes

◆ Largest CFD vendor in the world

Page 8: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Worldwide

ATES, Korea SFI and Aavid, Taiwan

Fluent India

CFD - RES , Australia

Fluent UKFluent FranceFluent GermanyFluent ItalyFluent SwedenFluent Benelux

Fluent Inc. HQ - Lebanon, NHEvanston, ILSanta Clara, CAAn Arbor, MIMorgantown, WV

N. AmericaEurope Asia/Pacific

Fluent Asia-Pacific, JapanTokyo and OsakaFluent India

Hi-Key, China

Page 9: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Major Markets Served•Aerospace•Turbomachinery•Power Generation/Nuclear•Chemicals/Petrochemical•Automotive•Computers/Semiconductors•Materials/Metallurgy•HVAC

Page 10: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Computational FluidDynamics

◆ Fluid flow, heat and masstransfer, phase change,chemical reaction, mechanicalmovement, and deformation ofrelated solid structures

◆ Navier Stokes Equations

◆ Numerical Solution Techniques� Finite Difference� Finite Elements� Finite Volume

φφρφρφ Sgraddivt

+Γ=+∂

∂ )div()()( u

Page 11: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

How CFD Analysis Works

1. User definesthe problem...

2. A mesh isconstructed

3. Model is set up in Fluent

4. Solution iscomputed and viewed in Fluent!

Page 12: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Case Studies

◆ Tube and Shell Heat Exchanger◆ Steam Generator Flows◆ Coolant Control Valve

Page 13: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Heat Exchanger PerformanceImprovement

◆ Problem:� Under-performing 324

tube heat exchanger� 700mm x 2500mm long

vertical with 200mmnozzles on the tube side

� Tube side flow90757kg/hr at 69.5 C

◆ Solution:� Replace the device� German Chemical

company retains CalGavin Engineers toperform analysis

Courtesy of Cal Gavin Ltd.

Page 14: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Axial Velocities Across the Outlet

Look for local hot spots andtemperature uniformity

Maldistributed Improved

Courtesy of Cal Gavin Ltd.

Page 15: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

◆ FLUENT is used tosimulate the flow in asteam generator following asevere loss of coolantaccident

◆ Due to blockage in thecoolant loop and seals,cooling is impaired

Severe Accident Steam GeneratorFlows

◆ The simulation is used to determine the extent of thecooling failure – whether it is restricted to the coolantpiping or extends into the steam generator tubing

Courtesy of the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Page 16: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

◆ Temperature contours onthe symmetry plane (top)show hot coolant on thetop of the pipe

◆ Velocity vectors (bottom)show the directions of thehot and cool liquid flows

◆ The predicted average hotand cold temperatures arewithin 1.5 – 2K of themeasured values

Severe Accident Steam GeneratorFlows

Courtesy of the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Page 17: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Severe Accident Steam GeneratorFlows

◆ Predictions of the number oftubes carrying hot flow arecompared to data

◆ FLUENT overpredicts theregion of hot flow by 16tubes, or 7% of the totalbundle

◆ Overall, the CFD results arein very good agreement withdata and provide moreinformation than a limitednumber of thermocouples can

Courtesy of the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

Page 18: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Coolant Control Valve◆ Dual control valve is used for

automotive HVAC coolantcontrol

◆ Driver and passenger cancontrol temperaturesindependently

◆ Valve motion is simulated usingthe moving mesh feature

◆ Time-varying profiles describethe motion of the valve spools

Courtesy of Robert Bosch Corporation

Page 19: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Coolant Control Valve◆ Deforming mesh

capability has beendemonstrated with thecoolant control valve

◆ When compared tosteady-state analyses,a deforming meshanalysis produces amore realisticrepresentation of flowthrough componentssuch as valves andpumps

Courtesy of Robert Bosch CorporationContours of Velocity Magnitude

Page 20: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Capabilities◆ Model Building◆ Physical Models◆ Multiphase Models◆ Dynamic Mesh

Adaption◆ Moving and

Deforming Mesh◆ Visualization

Courtesy of BASFContours of Solid Phase

Page 21: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Capabilities

◆ Model Building� Fully integrated� Solid geometry

modeling

� Geometry and meshimport from CAD/CAE

� Meshing� Mesh visualization and

quality diagnostics

Page 22: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

◆ Physical Models� Heat transfer, species transport and reacting flows� Multiple reference frames, sliding mesh and mixing

plane model� Inviscid, laminar

or turbulent

Fluent Capabilities

Courtesy of General Electric

Page 23: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

◆ Multiphase Modeling� Particle Tracking� Free Surface Flows� Mixture Model� Fluid-Fluid, Fluid-Solid

Fluent Capabilities

Bubble Column

Page 24: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Capabilities◆ Dynamic Mesh Adaption

� Improve accuracy• Refine the grid based on flow solution gradients or geometric details

for higher resolution of flow details.� Increase model efficiency

• Add grid resolution only where it is needed

Mesh Coloured by Contours of Static Pressure

Page 25: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Capabilities◆ Moving and Deforming Mesh

� The moving mesh uses three possible techniques:• moving nodes while preserving connectivity, localized re-

meshing, dynamic layering� The result is a high quality mesh at all times during the

calculation

Velocity Magnitude ContoursMesh Deformation

Page 26: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Capabilities◆ Parallel Computing

� Parallelization available on networksof workstations or multiple processorworkstations

� Partitioning done automatically

Grid partitions on a utility boilerGrid partitions on a utility boiler

FL5M2 Benchmark on Linux Cluster

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16Number of Processors

Ben

chm

ark

Thro

ughp

ut

Linear Scaling

Intel Xeon 2GHz 8x2 Cluster,Fast Ethernet InterconnectIntel Xeon 2GHz 8x2 Cluster,Myrinet Interconnect

Page 27: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Fluent Capabilities◆ Visualization

� 3D visualization tools� Animation� Quantitative reports� Integrals and

averages� Customized reports

Plume Dispersion

Page 28: Breaking the Barrier Between System and Component Modeling ... Documents/nurnburg.pdf · Under-performing 324 tube heat exchanger 700mm x 2500mm long ... The result is a high quality

Summary◆ A number of

industrial applicationshave been identifiedwhich may benefitfrom the coupling ofFLUENT & RELAP5-3D©.

◆ Overall predictions ofthe system andcomponentperformance areexpected to be moreaccurate

Volume fraction of vapor during film boiling