BRC Risk Assessment
-
Upload
gaganpreet -
Category
Documents
-
view
225 -
download
0
Transcript of BRC Risk Assessment
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
1/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Safefood 360 provides food safety ana!eentsoft"are for ind#stry leadin! food b#sinessesevery"$ere in t$e "orld
Methods & Models forConducting RiskAssessments Underthe BRC Standard
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
2/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
WHAT IS RISKASSSSM!T"
%$y is ris& iportant in food safety'
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
3/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
What is Risk Assessment#RA$" (rocess or tool for identifyin! a $a)ard and
estiatin! t$e ris& presented by t$at $a)ard
%idely #sed in t$e *eld of food safety
+t ay be #antitative or #alitative
-#antitative .1 deat$ per year in !ivenpop#lation fro $a)ard / in prod#ct
-#alitative .i!$ ris&
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
4/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
What is Risk Assessment#RA$" -#antitative preferred b#t seldo possible at site level
ore often c$aracterised by "$at "e don4t &no" t$an"$at "e do &no"
Str#ct#red approac$
S#pports decision a&in! and reso#rce allocation ris&ana!eent
Contrib#tes to better #nderstandin! of $a)ards and foodsafety
pproac$ adopted internationally e! 78, %O9:rae"or&;
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
5/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Risk %rameork
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
6/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste's of Risk Assessment
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
7/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Risk Assessments Used in %oodSafet(
(roliferation of ris& assessents in t$efood sector
CC(
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
8/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
What is Risk"
(robability > Severity ?Ris&
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
9/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
RISK ASSSSM!T A!)TH BRC
o" to address re#ireents #nder t$e BRC
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
10/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Risk Assessment and the BRC
.=$e BRC li&es ris& assessent@
Ae*nitions in t$e BRC
Ris& =$e li&eli$ood of occ#rrence of $ar fro a
$a)ard Ris& analysis process consistin! of t$ree
coponents ris& assessent, ris& ana!eent andris& co#nication
Ris& assessent =$e identi*cation, eval#ation andestiation of t$e levels of ris& involved in a processto deterine an appropriate control process
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
11/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
BRC %ood Issue *
Referred to no fe"er t$an D ties in t$eStandard
Re#ired doc#ented ris& assessent E 1F
ties
+plied doc#ent ris& assessent E 20ties
ost refer to (R(4s and ana!eentprocesses
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
12/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
When does BRC Re+uire RiskAssessment"
Got al"ays clear "$en and "$at is re#ired
pplication of lan!#a!e and terinolo!y not al"aysconsistent
.=$e scope and fre#ency@s$all be establis$ed in relation
to t$e ris&s
.=$e fre#ency of t$ese inspections s$all be based on ris&
.=$e copany s$all #nderta&e a doc#ented ris&assessent
.@dependent on ris& assessent
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
13/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
When does BRC Re+uires a RiskAssessment"
.@at a predeterined fre#ency, based on ris&assessent
.eliinate potential ris&s to prod#ct safety
.prevent any ris& of prod#ct containation .iniise t$e ris&
.accordin! to ris&
.=$e site s$all carry o#t an assessent .on t$e basis of ris& assessent
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
14/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Challenges
%$en is ris& assessent re#ired'
S$o#ld it be doc#ented'
S$o#ld it be str#ct#red'
%$at is t$e diHerence bet"een .=$e Copanys$all #nderta&e a doc#ented ris& assessentand .=$e site s$all carry o#t an assessent'
%$at is t$e diHerence bet"een .eliinate
potential ris&s to prod#ct safety and .prevent anyris& of prod#ct containation
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
15/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Re+uired and Im'lied RiskAssessment in the BRC Standard
+nterpretation
=$e standard operates on t"o levels
Re#ired or +plied Re#ired E .=$e Copany s$all #nderta&e
a doc#ented ris& assessent
+plied .@s$all be based on ris&
Seantics'
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
16/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Re+uired Risk Assessment , -.areas
!/ R0UIRM!T RISK
ASSSSM!T
R0UIRM!
TS
23 =7 :OOA S:7= (IG CC(J
24*3 I+S= II (O=7G=+I LRAS SSOC+=7A %+= 7C (ROC7SS S=7(, COGA8C= LRA GIS+S GACOGS+A7R G 7S8R7S =O COG=ROI +A7G=+:+7A LRAS COA7/ I+7G=R+8S S=7( 6, (R+GC+(I7 1 Aoc#entedR re#ired24*4- =$e CC( food safety tea s$all cond#ct a $a)ard analysis to identify $a)ards "$ic$ need to be prevented,
eliinated or red#ced to acceptable levels
Aoc#ented
R re#ired54.3 +G=7RGI 8A+=SJ
54.4- =$e scope and fre#ency of t$e a#dits s$all be establis$ed in relation to t$e ris&s Aoc#ented
R re#ired54.4. =$e fre#ency of t$ese inspections s$all be based on ris& 9$y!iene and fabrication; Aoc#ented
R re#ired5464- GM77G= O: S8((I+7RS O: R% =7R+IS GA (CNM+GM
5464-4-
=$e copany s$all #nderta&e a doc#ented ris& assessent of eac$ ra" aterial or !ro#p of ra" aterialsincl#din! pac&a!in! to identify potential ris&s to prod#ct safety, le!ality and #ality
Aoc#entedR re#ired
5464-4
2
=$e approval and onitorin! proced#re s$all be based on ris& Aoc#ented
R re#ire546424
-
=$e copany s$all $ave a doc#ented proced#re for t$e acceptance of ra" aterials and pac&a!in! on
receipt based #pon t$e ris& assessent 9cla#se 3511;
Aoc#ented
R re#ired
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
17/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Re+uired Risk Assessment , -.areas!/ R0UIRM!T RISK
ASSSSM!T
R0UIRM!
TS
5464. GM77G= O: O8=SO8RC7A (ROC7SS+GM GA (CN+GM
5464.4
.
=$e copany s$all establis$ inspection and test proced#res for prod#cts "$ere part of t$e processin! or
pac&in! $ave been o#tso#rced, incl#din! vis#al, c$eical andor icrobiolo!ical testin!, dependent on ris&
assessent
Aoc#ented
R re#ired
.423 S7C8R+=
.424- =$e copany s$all #nderta&e a doc#ented assessent of t$e sec#rity arran!eents and potential ris&s to
t$e prod#cts fro any deliberate attept to inPict containation or daa!e reas s$all be assessed
accordin! to ris&Q sensitive or restricted areas s$all be de*ned, clearly ar&ed, onitored and controlled
+denti*ed sec#rity arran!eents to red#ce ris&s s$all be ipleented and revie"ed at least ann#ally
Aoc#ented
R re#ired
.4-73 :OR7+MGEBOA A7=7C=+OG GA R7O
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
18/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Re+uired Risk Assessment , -.areas
!/ R0UIRM!T RISK
ASSSSM!T
R0UIRM!
TS
.4-.3 (7S= COG=ROI
.4-.4
2
=$e fre#ency of inspections s$all be deterined by ris& assessent and s$all be doc#ented Aoc#ented
R re#ired6453 GM77G= O: II7RM7GS
64545 doc#ented ris& assessent s$all be carried o#t to identify ro#tes of containation and establis$
doc#ented policies and proced#res for $andlin! ra" aterials, interediate and *nis$ed prod#cts to ens#re
crossEcontaination is avoided
Aoc#ented
R re#ired
64.3
(ROA8C= 8=7G=+C+=, CI+S GA C+G O: C8S=OA
64.42 doc#ented v#lnerability assessent s$all be carried o#t on all food ra" aterials or !ro#ps of ra"
aterials to assess t$e potential ris& of ad#lteration or s#bstit#tion
Aoc#ented
R re#ired
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
19/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Im'lied Risk Assessments , 27areas
!/ R0UIRM!T RISKASSSSM!T
R0UIRM!T
S
-4-3 S7G+OR GM77G= CO+=7G= GA COG=+G8I +(RO
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
20/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Im'lied Risk Assessments , 27areas
!/ R0UIRM!T RISK
ASSSSM!TR0UIRM!TS
.493 S=:: :C+I+=+7S
.494- Aesi!nated c$an!in! facilities s$all be provided for all personnel, "$et$er staH, visitor or contractor =$ese s$all be sited to allo"
direct access to t$e prod#ction, pac&in! or stora!e areas "it$o#t reco#rse to any e>ternal area %$ere t$is is not possible, a ris&
assessent s$all be carried o#t and proced#res ipleented accordin!ly 9e! t$e provision of cleanin! facilities for foot"ear;
Aoc#ented R
iplied.4-745 7=I A7=7C=ORS GA /ER 7-8+(7G=
etal detector c$ec&in! proced#res s$all be based on !ood practice and s$all as a ini# incl#de t$e follo"in!
T 8se of test pieces incorporatin! a sp$ere of etal of a &no"n diaeter selected on t$e basis of ris& =$e test pieces s$all be ar&ed
"it$ t$e si)e and type of test aterial contained
Aoc#ented R
iplied.4-748 COG=+G7R CI7GI+G7SS MISS URS, CGS GA O=7R R+M+A COG=+G7RS
.4-7484
-
Based on ris& assessent, proced#res s$all be ipleented to iniise forei!nEbody containation ori!inatin! "it$ t$e pac&a!in!
container 9e! ars, cans and ot$er preEfored ri!id containers; =$is ay incl#de t$e #se of covered conveyors, container inversion
and forei!nEbody reoval t$ro#!$ rinsin! "it$ "ater or air ets
Aoc#ented R
iplied
.4--3 O8S7N77(+GM GA M+7G7
=$e fre#ency and et$ods of cleanin! s$all be based on ris&
Aoc#ented R
iplied.4-.3 (7S= COG=ROI
.4-.4: n inEdept$, doc#ented pest control s#rvey s$all be #nderta&en at a fre#ency based on ris&
Aoc#ented R
iplied.4-63 S=ORM7 :C+I+=+7S
.4-64- Aoc#ented proced#res to aintain prod#ct safety and #ality d#rin! stora!e s$all be developed on t$e basis of ris& assessent, Aoc#ented R
iplied64-3 (ROA8C= A7S+MGA7
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
21/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Im'lied Risk Assessments , 27areas!/ R0UIRM!T RISK
ASSSSM!T
R0UIRM!
TS
6484- (ROA8C= +GS(7C=+OG GA =7S=+GM
6484-4
-
=$ere s$all be a sc$ed#led pro!rae of testin! coverin! prod#cts and t$e processin! environent, "$ic$
ay incl#de icrobiolo!ical, c$eical, p$ysical and or!anoleptic testin! accordin! to ris& =$e et$ods,
fre#ency and speci*ed liits s$all be doc#ented
Aoc#ented
R iplied
6484-4
5
=$e site s$all ens#re t$at a syste of on!oin! s$elfElife assessent is in place =$is s$all be based on ris&
and s$all incl#de sensory analysis and, as applicable, icrobiolo!ical testin! and relevant c$eical factors
s#c$ as p and a" Records and res#lts fro s$elfElife tests s$all verify t$e s$elfElife period indicated on t$eprod#ct
Aoc#ented
R iplied
84-3 COG=ROI O: O(7R=+OGSJ
84-4. %$ere variation in processin! conditions ay occ#r "it$in e#ipent critical to t$e safety or #ality of
prod#cts, t$e processin! c$aracteristics s$all be validated and veri*ed at a fre#ency based on ris& and
perforance of e#ipent 9e! $eat distrib#tion in retorts, ovens and processin! vesselsQ teperat#re
distrib#tion in free)ers and cold stores;
Aoc#ented
R iplied
84.
CI+BR=+OG GA COG=ROI O: 7S8R+GM GA OG+=OR+GM A7
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
22/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
HACC; & Ra Materials
odels "ell de*ned
8se a siple atri> odel based onprobability and severity
:oc#s of speci*c $a)ards Biolo!ical,C$eical, ($ysical and ller!ens
:oc#s on speci*c processes, aterials andprod#cts
Based on Code> principles
CC(4s
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
23/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
/'erational and
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
24/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Intrinsic >s Inherited Risk
=raditional R4s and CC( foc#s on a speci*c$a)ard at a speci*c process step
Clear line bet"een $a)ard analysis,c$aracterisation, e>pos#re and ris&
=$e ris& is +ntrinsic
:or (R(4s t$e foc#s is on t$e potential fail#re of t$eactivity based on t$e in$erited ris& identi*ed inCC(
ore a&in to :7 9:ail#re ode 7Hect nalysis; not a tool norally #sed by tec$nical staH in foodind#stry
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
25/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
I!TRI!SIC ?S I!HRIT)RISK
7>aple E Calibration
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
26/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Cooking , cooked meat RT#HACC;$
a)ard 7Coli O15D
(robability 9S#rvival d#e to inade#ateteptie; edi# (robability
Severity i!$ +pact
Ris& Ratin! i!$ Ris&
Control teperat#re and tie, core prod#ct
+n t$is case t$ere is a clear line bet"eena)ard +denti*cation, Ris& ssessent andana!eent
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
27/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Cooking , cooked meat RT#;R; , Cali@ration$
Aevice teperat#re probe
(R( calibration
(robability 9of bein! o#t of calibration; edi#
Severity i!$ 9+n$erited fro t$e CC( ris&assessent;
Control fre#ency and scope of calibration
+n t$is case t$e R is based on t$e fail#re and eHect
odel
=$e probability of failed calibration stat#s cobined"it$ t$e in$erent ris& of e>pos#re to t$e cons#er
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
28/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
RISK ASSSSM!T M/)
Ris& ssessent for GonECC( re#ireents
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
29/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
!eed for Clear RA Model for!onHACC; Assessments
AiHerent odels re#ired for nonECC( R4s
%or&boo& provided for cond#ctin! R4s on Safefood360 "ebsite
+nternal #ditin!
Calibration
Cleanin!
(est Control
etal Aetection (ac&a!in! aterials
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
30/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Construction of RA Models
Step 1 Ae*ne t$e R atri>
Step 2 Ae*ne (robability criteria
Step 3 Ae*ne Severity criteria
Step F Ae*ne O#tcoe and Aecisions Criteria
Step 5 Ae*ne Special (oints of ttention
Step 6 Iist all identi*ed points activities tas&s pro!rasetc
Step D Aescribe eac$ point activity
Step V Aescribe t$e ris&
Step Rate t$e probability and severity to prod#ce ris& ratin!
Step 10 Ae*ne o#tcoes and decisions
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
31/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
am'le RA for InternalAuditing ;rograms
BRC Cla#se 3F +nternal #dits .=$e scopeand fre#ency of t$e a#dits s$all beestablis$ed in relation to t$e ris&s
+nterpretation a ris& assessent of eac$a#dit pro!ra is re#ired and t$e scopeand fre#ency of a#dits s$all beestablis$ed based on t$is Aoc#entedris& assessent to s#pport a#dit of t$isre#ireent
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
32/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
am'le RA for InternalAuditing ;rograms
Ris& ssessent odel
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
33/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste' - )eDne the RA Matri
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
34/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste' 2 , )eDne ;ro@a@ilit(Criteria
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
35/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste' 5 )eDne Se>erit( Criteria
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
36/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste' .E )eDne /utcome and)ecisions Criteria
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
37/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste' 6E )eDne S'ecial ;oints ofAttention
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
38/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste' 8E ist all identiDed 'oints Facti>ities F tasks F 'rograms etc4
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
39/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste' *E )escri@e each acti>it( F Ste'9E )escri@e the risk F Ste' :E Rating
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
40/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Ste' -7E )eDne /utcomes anddecisions
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
41/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
HIT/! %//)S
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
42/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Hilton %oods
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
43/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
BRC Re+uirement Cleaning
F11 .=$e fre#ency and et$ods ofcleanin! s$all be based on ris&
+plied re#ireent to cond#ct a
doc#ented ris& assessent on allcleanin! pro!ras
8ndertoo& a f#ll Ris& ssessent based on
ne" odel
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
44/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
)eDned the risk assessmentmodel
8sed a siple 3 by 3 atri>
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
45/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
)eDned 'ro@a@ilit( and se>erit(re+uirements
:or eac$ ratin! t$e c$aracter of t$e ratin!"as de*ned
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
46/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
)eDned the fre+uenc( and sco'e of >eriDcation
re+uired for HighG Medium and o ratings
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
47/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
)eDned all 'rogramsG risks andratings
Iisted all cleanin! pro!ras and describedeac$ and t$e associated ris&s
Rated eac$ pro!ra (robability of fail#re to cond#ct cleanin!
correctly
Severity of ipact if fail#re occ#rred
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
48/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
)eDned all 'rogramsG risks andratings
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
49/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
)eDned /utcomes
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
50/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
Summar( of RA
R identi*ed t$at cleanin! pro!ras bet"een species posed t$e !reatestris&
+n partic#lar cleanin! pro!ras on lines and contact s#rfaces bet"eenspecies c$an!e overs
Criteria "as establis$ed for $i!$ ris& pro!ras to incl#de@
Clear and detailed cleanin! proced#res for line c$an!e over bet"een species
#toatic noti*cation of copleted cleanin! to s#pervisors
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
51/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
)igital Control Record
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
52/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
/utcome
Str#ct#red approac$ to ris& assessent
Cleanin! activities and pro!ras based on
R Si!ni*cant red#ction in fail#res and reE
cleans
Ai!ital recordin! and ana!eent of t$eprocess
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
53/54
BRC Conference Barcelona, October 2015
/;;/RTU!ITIS
BRC and Ris& ssessent
-
7/26/2019 BRC Risk Assessment
54/54
/''ortunities
(roliferation of odels@ developent ofne" odels
BRC consistency in #se of t$e ter ris&and clarity on "$at is re#ired, "$en, $o"and "$ere
ore !#idance on ris& assessent