Bravado (Red Hot Chili Peppers) v. Does TRO Memo

8/2/2019 Bravado (Red Hot Chili Peppers) v. Does TRO Memo

1/22

SOEZCJ YZHZCY JEYZÊIZ IGS^Z

LG^ Z@C JEYZÊIZ GL BHYYHI@SYCZZY

WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW

%

N^H\HJG EOZCÔHZEGOHA M^GS[ %BCÎ@HOJEYEOM YC^\EICY! EOI/! %

%

[aheozell! % IE\EA HIZEGO OG/ 8>"i|"8;"i|"8;


2/22

8

E / EOZ^GJSIZEGO/

[aheozell N~h|hjg Eozc~ohzegoha M~gs{ Bc~i`hojeyeom Yc~|eicy! Eoi/ (.[aheozell.%

ysnbezy zèy Bcbg~hojsb eo ys{{g~z gl ezy Cp [h~zc H{{aeihzego lg~6 h Zcb{g~h~u

^cyz~heoeom G~jc~4 h Ycevs~c G~jc~4 hoj ho G~jc~ zg Y`g} Ihsyc ^cmh~jeom ]ù H

[~caebeoh~u Eofsoizego hoj Ycevs~c G~jc~ Y`gsaj Ogz Eyysc (z`c .G~jc~.%/ [aheozell yccdy

zèy G~jc~ zg yzg{ z`c yhac hz igoic~zy gl sohsz`g~evcj bc~i`hojeyc! hoj ycevc z`c yhbc

`c~c hy }caa hy ohzego}ejc! }èi` nch~y z`c lcjc~haau ~cmeyzc~cj z~hjcbh~dL8L!aedcocyycy!

agmgy! hoj'g~ gz c~ eojeieh gl z`c {g{sah~ bsyeiha m~gs{ ^CJ @GZ I@EAE

[C[[C^Y zg igbnhz z`c hize|ezecy z`hz }eaa zhdc {ahic `c~c hy }caa ohzego}ejc! yebeah~

zg goc m~hozcj nu zèy Igs~z z}eic lg~ z`c m~gs{y {~c|egsy zgs~y/ Ycc Cpènez H zg z`c

Ic~zeleihzc gl Igsoyca leacj igois~~cozau `c~c}ez`! ohbcau N~h|hjg Eozc~ohzegoha M~gs{

Bc~i`hojeyeom Yc~|eicy! Eoi/ |/ Jgcy! cz ha/! Ihyc Og/ ;< i|88=3> ^]V (J/ BH >;;;;


3/22

>

EE/ YZHZCBCOZ GL LHIZY/

Go Bhu =! >;8>! hz z`c ZJ Mh~jco eo Ngyzgo! Bhyyhi`syczzy! z`c {g{sah~ bsyeiha

m~gs{ ^CJ @GZ I@EAE [C[[C^Y (z`c .M~gs{.% }eaa {c~lg~b/ Ycc z`c Jciah~hzego

gl Z`gbhy Jgoocaa (.Jgoocaa Jcia/.% hoj z`c Ic~zeleihzc gl Igsoyca {s~yshoz zg L/^/I/[/

^sac 3/

Nggzacmmc~y `h|c {ahmscj {~c|egsy zgs~ nu zèy hoj gz`c~ h~zeyzy/ Zg igbnhz zèy!

[aheozell `hy gnzheocj lg~ h~zeyzy l~gb zèy Jeyz~eiz (hy ogzcj hng|c% hoj gz`c~ Jeyz~eiz

Igs~zy! zcb{g~h~u ~cyz~heoeom hoj ycevs~c g~jc~y! hoj z`c~chlzc~ {~caebeoh~u eofsoizegoy

hoj ohzego}ejc ycevs~c g~jc~y zg ycevc z`c soah}lsa bc~i`hojeyc gl ysi` jclcojhozy/ Ycc

Ic~zeleihzc gl Igsoyca hoj ezy cpènezy/

[aheozell chyeau bcczy z`c ~cxse~cj y`g}eom hoj z`c~c ey og jclcoyc zg z`c iaheby

n~gsm`z nu [aheozell/ [aheozell ey z`c cpiasye|c aeicoycc gl z`c M~gs{! hoj z`c ygac

bc~i`hojeyc~ lg~ z`c M~gs{y hsz g~evcj bc~i`hojeyc }èi` }eaa nc ygaj js~eom z`c

M~gs{y zgs~/ Jgoocaa Jcia/ :/ [aheozell `hy z`c~clg~c jcbgoyz~hzcj h ysnyzhozeha

aedcae`ggj z`hz ez }eaa ysiiccj go z`c bc~ezy/ Z`c Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc `h~by [aheozell

hoj z`c {snaei eo osbc~gsy }huy/ Chi` yhac gl Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc nu Jclcojhozy ey

ho e~~cig|c~hnau agyz yhac lg~ [aheozell/ Hnycoz z`c ~caecl ~cxscyzcj `c~ceo! [aheozell-y

bgoczh~u agyycy igsaj hmm~cmhzc eo z`c `soj~cjy gl z`gsyhojy gl jgaah~y/ Bg~cg|c~! z`c

agyy hoj jhbhmc zg z`c mggj}eaa gl ngz` [aheozell hoj z`c M~gs{! z`~gsm` z`c jeyz~enszego

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


4/22

9

gl eolc~eg~ bc~i`hojeyc }èi` }eaa ocicyyh~eau nc ycco hy hyygiehzcj }ez` z`cb! ihoogz nc

ihaisahzcj g~ ~cbcjecj/ Jgoocaa Jcia/ 8:">94 Ns~oy Ic~z/ :/

Z`c occj lg~ ho cp {h~zc g~jc~ ey bhoelcyzau c|ejcoz/ Jclcojhozy- hizegoy h~c

igb{aczcau sohsz`g~evcj! hoj Jclcojhozy `h|c ngz` z`c bchoy hoj bgze|hzego zg jcyz~gu

|ezha c|ejcoic nclg~c h ogzeicj `ch~eom hoj h|gej yc~|eic/ Yebeah~ g~jc~y `h|c ncco

gnzheocj zg {~gzciz z`c ~em`zy gl bc~i`hojeyc~y hoj jeyz~enszg~y z`c~cgo hmheoyz

nggzacmmc~y hoj z`ce~ sohsz`g~evcj mggjy/ Eo ~cy{goyc zg z`cyc g~jc~y! haz`gsm` z`gsyhojy

gl nggzacmmc~y `h|c ncco yc~|cj! jclcojhoz nggzacmmc~ jg ogz i`haacomc z`cyc g~jc~ yeoic

h{{h~cozau z`cu dog} z`ce~ hize|ezecy h~c soaeicoycj hoj soah}lsa/ Ycc Ns~oy Ic~z/

Hiig~jeomau! [aheozell ~cxscyzy z`hz zèy Igs~z eyysc z`c ~cxscyzcj g~jc~/

EEE/ JCLCOJHOZY Y@GSAJ NC COFGEOCJ L^GB YCAAEOM!

JEYZÊNSZEOM! HOJ BHOSLHIZSÊOM EOLÊOMEOM BCÎ@HOJEYC/

Z`c yzhojh~j lg~ m~hozeom h {~caebeoh~u eofsoizego ey }caa"yczzacj eo zèy Ie~isez/ Eo

g~jc~ zg gnzheo h {~caebeoh~u eofsoizego! ez bsyz nc jcbgoyz~hzcj z`hz6

(8% {aheozell `hy cpènezcj h aedcae`ggj gl ysiicyy go z`c bc~ezy4 (>% {aheozell}eaa ysllc~ e~~c{h~hnac eofs~u el z`c eofsoizego ey ogz m~hozcj4 (9% ysi` eofs~ugsz}cem`y hou `h~b }èi` m~hozeom z`c eofsoizego }gsaj eolaeiz go jclcojhoz4hoj (:% z`c {snaei eozc~cyz }eaa ogz nc hj|c~ycau hllcizcj nu z`c m~hozeom gl z`ceofsoizego/

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


5/22

:

IINB/igb! Eoi/ |/ i"ihaa!Eoi/ =9 L/ Ys{{>j 8;

Eoz-a Z~hjeom Ig~{/! 000 L/>j >83! >>; (8yz Ie~/ 8505%/ [aheozell bcczy zèy yzhojh~j/

Bg~cg|c~! goic h |egahzego gl z`c Aho`hb Hiz ey jcbgoyz~hzcj! eofsoize|c ~caecl y`gsaj eyysc/

N~gidsb Ig/ |/ Nahuagid! =>5 L/Ys{{/ :90! ::3 (C/J/ [h/ 855;%/

H/ Z`c~c Ey H Ysnyzhozeha Aedcae ggj Z`hz [aheozell ]eaa [~c|hea Go Z`c

Bc~ezy Ncihsyc Jclcojhozy @h|c \egahzcj 83 S/Y/I/ Ycizego 88>3(h%/

Igs~zy `h|c ~c{chzcjau `caj z`hz z`c syc gl ~cmeyzc~cj hoj so~cmeyzc~cj ohbcy!

ebhmcy hoj agmgy gl bsyeiha h~zeyzy nu nggzacmmc~y ihsycy e~~c{h~hnac eofs~u hoj |egahzcy

ycizego :9(h% gl z`c Aho`hb Hiz/ N~gidsb Ig/ |/ Nahuagid! =>5 L/Ys{{/ :90! ::: (C/J/

[h/ 855;% (z`c~c ey og ocicyyezu sojc~ :9(h% z`hz z`c bh~dy eo xscyzego nc ~cmeyzc~cj%4

YDY Bc~i`! AAI |/ Nh~~u! >99 L/ Ys{{/ >j 0:8! 039"03: (C/J/ Du >;;>% (yhacy nu Jgc

Jclcojhoz Nggzacmmc~y gl bc~i`hojeyc nch~eom z`c so~cmeyzc~cj bh~dy gl z`c h~zeyz Zgnu

Dcez` |egahzcy ycizego 88>3 (h% hoj h ohzego}ejc ycevs~c g~jc~ }hy eyyscj%4 ]eozc~ahoj

Igoicyyegoy Ig/ |/ Yeacg! 3>0 L/Ys{{/ 8>;8 (O/J/ Eaa/ 8508%! bgj/ go gz`c~ m~gsojy! =93

L/>j >3= (=z` Ie~/ 850:%4 Oeic Bho Bc~i`hojeyeom! Eoi/ |/ Agmgi~glz! Azj/! >9 S/Y/[/X/

>j 8>5; (C/J/ [h/ 855>% (syc gl z`c ohbcy! z~hjcbh~dy! agmgy hoj aedcocyycy gl bsyeiha

m~gs{y go jclcojhozy- bc~i`hojeyc }ez`gsz {c~beyyego l~gb {aheozell bc~i`hojeyc~ .ey

aedcau zg ihsyc igolsyego! zg ihsyc beyzhdc hoj zg jcice|c/ Ysi` igolsyego hoj'g~

jcic{zego }eaa igozeosc zg ~cysaz eo ebbcjehzc hoj e~~c{h~hnac eofs~u zg {aheozell/.%

Z`c {s~{gyc gl z c Aho`hb Hiz ey .zg {~gzciz {c~ygoy comhmcj eo / / / igbbc~ic

hmheoyz solhe~ igb{czezego. hoj .zg {~c|coz l~hsj hoj jcic{zego eo ysi` igbbc~ic/. 83

S/Y/I/ 88>=/ Zèy n~ghj {~gènezego hmheoyz .solhe~ igb{czezego. ig|c~y ogz goau

igolsyego hy zg ygs~ic g~ y{goyg~yè{ ncz}cco Jclcojhozy- Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc hoj

[aheozell-y bc~i`hojeyc! ez hayg {~gènezy z`c beyh{{~g{~ehzego gl z`c cllg~zy gl gz`c~y/ Ycc

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


6/22

3

^/@/ Jgoocaacu Ig~{/ |/ Eaaeogey Ncaa Zcac{`goc/! 353 L/Ys{{/8>;>! 8>;< (O/J/ Eaa/ 850:%

(.z`gyc }`g eo|cyz zebc! bgocu hoj coc~mu eozg z`c jc|cag{bcoz gl h {~gjsiz hoj ezy

hiigb{houeom mggj }eaa y`gsaj nc haag}cj zg ~ch{ z`c hj|hozhmcy gl z`ce~ eo|cyzbcoz.%4

Ngyzgo Hz`aczei |/ Ysaae|ho! 0j >>! 99 (8yz Ie~/ 8505% (.h {h~zu ihoogz ~ch{ }`c~c

ez `hy ogz yg}o.%/

Zg cyzhnaey` h |egahzego gl ycizego :9(h% h {aheozell bsyz jcbgoyz~hzc (8% z`hz ez ey

z`c {~eg~ g}oc~ gl z`c z~hjcbh~d! hoj (>% z`hz z`c jclcojhoz hjg{zcj h z~hjcbh~d z`hz ey

z`c yhbc g~ igolsyeomau yebeah~! yg z`hz igoysbc~y aedcau }eaa nc igolsycj hngsz z`c

{~g{c~ g~emeo gl z`c mggjy g~ yc~|eicy! ysi` z`hz h igoysbc~ ey aedcau zg ncaec|c z`hz

jclcojhoz-y mggjy g~ yc~|eicy h~c nceom ygaj }ez` z`c igoycoz g~ hsz`g~evhzego gl z`c

{aheozell! g~ z`hz jclcojhoz ey hlleaehzcj }ez` g~ igoocizcj zg z`c {aheozell/ Gicho Neg"

I`cb! Eoi/! =:8 L/ Ys{{/ hz 833: (iezhzego gbezzcj%4 Ohyyhs |/ Soebgzg~iuiaeyzy Ygi/ gl

Hbc~eih! Eoi/! 35 L/ Ys{{/ >j 8>99! 8>9

Ig/ gl Ihaelg~oeh! Eoi/! 353 L/>j 885:! 8>;8 (5z` Ie~/ 85=5% (lg~ {s~{gycy gl eofsoize|c

~caecl! ez ey ogz ocicyyh~u zg y`g} hizsha igolsyego g~ jcic{zego! nsz bc~cau z`c aedcae`ggj

gl ysi`%/ Z`cyc cacbcozy h~c iach~au {~cycoz `c~c/ Z`c bc~i`hojeyc h~c mggjy! z`c

Jclcojhozy z~h|ca l~gb yzhzc zg yzhzc hoj cllciz z`c yhac gl [aheozell-y bc~i`hojeyc js~eom

z`c zgs~ hoj! ncihsyc gl z`c syc gl [aheozell-y bh~dy! z`c~c ey z`c lhayc jcyemohzego }`ei` ey

aedcau zg igolsyc/

Z`c Le~yz Ie~isez `hy ejcozelecj |h~egsy lhizg~y zg igoyejc~ }`co jczc~beoeom

}`cz`c~ h aedcae`ggj gl igolsyego cpeyzy6 (8% z`c zu{c gl bh~d! (>% z`c yebeah~ezu gl z`c

bh~dy! (9% z`c yebeah~ezu gl z`c {h~zecy- {~gjsizy g~ yc~|eicy! (:% z`c yebeah~ezu gl z`c

{h~zecy- ~czhea gszaczy hoj isyzgbc~y! (3% z`c yebeah~ezu gl z`c hj|c~zeyeom bcjeh sycj! ("i|"8;


7/22

8: S/Y/[/X/ 800 (O/J/ Eaa/!

8508%/ Hy ycz lg~z` nu z c Jeyz~eiz Igs~z eo N~gidsb Ig/ |/ Nahuagid6

Jclcojhoz TNggzacmmc~R ihoogz gnzheo h .l~cc~ejc. hz z`c Tcpiasye|caeicoyccyR cp{coyc/ Ezy y`e~zy h~c jcyemocj zg zhdc hj|hozhmc gl z`c cllg~zy

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


8/22

=

hoj cp{cojezs~cy gl z`c {aheozell hoj ncoclez l~gb z`c mggj}eaa hyygiehzcj}ez` z`c ^gaaeom Yzgocy! z`ce~ 8505 zgs~! hoj z`c {~gbgzego gl z`c c|cozi~chzcj g~ sojc~zhdco nu z`c {aheozell hoj z`c ^gaaeom Yzgocy/ Ysi`soaeicoycj syc gl z`c ^gaaeom Yzgocy- ohbc }gsaj {c~bez z`c jclcojhoz zg~ch{ }`c~c ez `hj ogz yg}o/ Ngyzgo Hzàczei Hyy-o |/ Ysaae|ho! 0j

>>! 99 (8yz Ie~/ 8505%/ Jclcojhoz-y h~msbcoz z`hz z`c Z"yè~z eo xscyzegobc~cau icacn~hzcy ho .c|coz. ey ie~isah~ ~chygoeom! hz ncyz! me|co z`c lhizz`hz z`c~c }gsaj nc og .c|coz. zg icacn~hzc! }c~c ez ogz lg~ z`c `h~j }g~dhoj leohoieha gszahu {~g|ejcj nu z c {aheozell/ =>5 L/ Ys{{/ hz :::/

Jclcojhozy `h|c bhoslhizs~cj Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc lg~ z`c ygac {s~{gyc gl ycaaeom ez

hz z`c M~gs{y igoic~zy/ Ez ey ncugoj jey{szc z`hz Jclcojhozy `h|c hoj }eaa igozeosc zg

dog}eomau szeaevc [aheozell-y bh~dy zg jcice|c z`c {snaei hoj i~chzc z`c h{{ch~hoic z`hz

Jclcojhozy- Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc ey y{goyg~cj nu g~ g~emeohzcj l~gb [aheozell g~ z`c

M~gs{! hoj [aheozell `hy og igoz~ga g|c~ z`c xshaezu gl z`c bc~i`hojeyc/ Jclcojhozy- yhac

gl Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc ey eozcojcj zg .l~cc ~ejc. go z`c bh~dy! ebhmcy hoj aedcocyycy

gl z`gyc z c M~gs{! z hz `h|c hixse~cj |hasc z`~gsm` z`c cpzcoye|c cllg~zy gl z`c M~gs{/

Zèy ey {~cieycau z`c igojsiz Ycizego :9(h% }hy jcyemocj zg yzg{/

N/ Jclcojhozy @h|c \egahzcj Ycizego 888:/

Sojc~ 83 S/Y/I/ 888:! [aheozell bsyz y`g} z`hz Jclcojhozy `h|c sycj z`c

~cmeyzc~cj z~hjcbh~d6 (8% }ez`gsz igoycoz4 (>% eo igoocizego }ez` z c yhacy gl mggjy4 hoj

(9% }`c~c ysi` syc }hy aedcau zg ihsyc igolsyego g~ zg jcice|c {s~i`hyc~y hy zg z`c ygs~ic

g~ g~emeo gl z`c mggjy/ Mgajco Jgg~! Eoi/! |/ Gjey`g! :9= L/Ys{{/ 53"0= L/ 9j 0;;>%/

[aheozell ey aedcau zg {~c|hea go ezy 888: iaheb! lg~ z`c yhbc ~chygoy z`hz ez ey

aedcau zg {~c|hea go ezy iaheb sojc~ 88>3(h%/ Oc} ]cyz Ig~{/ |/ OUB IG/ gl

Ihaelg~oeh! 353 L/ >j hz 8>;8/ (Z`c aedcae`ggj gl igolsyego zcyz hayg ey sycj lg~ iaheby gl

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


9/22

0

z~hjcbh~d eol~eomcbcoz sojc~ 83 S/Y/I/ 888:/%/ Yeoic z`c Jclcojhozy syc z`c lcjc~haau

~cmeyzc~cj bh~d go Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc hoj ycaa ysi` mggjy hz z`c |c~u {ahicy }`c~c

z`c Zgs~ }eaa nc {c~lg~beom! z`c~c iho nc og jgsnz hy zg z`c igolsyego hoj eozcoz gl z`c

Jclcojhozy/

I/ [aheozell ]eaa Ysllc~ E~~c{h~hnac Eofs~u/

E~~c{h~hnac eofs~u ey {~cysbcj eo z`c ihyc gl z~hjcbh~d eol~eomcbcoz hoj Aho`hb

Hiz |egahzegoy/ Ihbca @he~ hoj Ihy`bc~c |/ Hyygiehzcj J~u Mggjy! =55 L/>j

Ie~/8505%(Z`c~c ey igoyejc~hnac hsz`g~ezu lg~ z`c |ec} z`hz z`c e~~c{h~hnac eofs~u

~cxse~cbcoz ey yhzeylecj goic ez ey y`g}o z`hz z`c jclcojhoz ey }~gomlsaau z~hjeom go z`c

{aheozell-y ~c{szhzego/% C/ ^cbu Bh~zeo , Ig/ |/ Eozc~ohzegoha Eb{g~zy! Eoi/! =3< L/ >j

83>3! 839; (88z` Ie~/ 8503%4 YDY Bc~i`! AAI! >99 L/ Ys{{/ >j hz 0:= (haz`gsm`

e~~c{h~hnac eofs~u ey {~cysbcj goic z~hjcbh~d eol~eomcbcoz ey y`g}o! [aheozelly `h|c

eojc{cojcozau cyzhnaey`cj z`hz z`cu }eaa nc e~~c{h~hnau `h~bcj hnycoz h [~caebeoh~u

Eofsoizego cofgeoeom z`c yhac gl nggzacm bc~i`hojeyc ~cahzcj zg Zgnu Dcez` z`~gsm`gsz z`c

ohzego/%4 Oeic Bho Bc~i hojeyeom |/ Agmgi~glz! Azj/! ys{~h4 @h~j ^gid Ihlc Aeicoyeom

|/ [hielei M~h{`eiy! ==< L/ Ys{{/ 8:3:! 8:"i|"8;


10/22

5

J/ Z`c Z`~chzcocj Eofs~u zg [aheozell Gsz}cem y [gzcozeha @h~b zg Jclcojhozy/

[aheozell `hy jcbgoyz~hzcj z`hz z`c z`~chzcocj eofs~u zg [aheozell gsz}cem`y z`c

{gzcozeha `h~b zg z`c Jclcojhozy/ @h~j ^gid Ihlc! ==< L/ Ys{{/ hz 8:0 (Y/J/O/U/%! hll-j!

:9> L/>j =0: (>j Ie~ 85=;%/ [snaei eozc~cyz ey cy{ciehaau yz~gom }`co h lcjc~ha yzhzszc

cp{~cyyau lg~nejy z`c igojsiz eo xscyzego/ @c~c! Jclcojhozy hiz eo lahm~hoz jey~cmh~j gl

z`c ah}y/ Eo ysb! [aheozell ey cozezacj zg eofsoize|c ~caecl/

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


11/22

8;

\E/ [AHEOZELL EY COZEZACJ ZG CP [H^ZC ^CAECL IGOYEYZEOM GL H

ZCB[G^HÛ ^CYZ^HEOEOM G^JC^ HOJ H YCEVS^C G^JC^/

H/ Ho Cp [h~zc G~jc~ Ey Ocicyyh~u Zg Igbnhz Jclcojhozy- Hize|ezecy/

Igs~zy `h|c eyyscj zcb{g~h~u ~cyz~heoeom g~jc~ hoj g~jc~y gl ycevs~c eo hj|hoic

gl igoic~zy zg yzg{ z`c yhac gl Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc/ Ycc Ns~oy Ic~z/ hoj Cpènezy

z`c~czg/ Zèy {~gicjs~c ey y{cieleihaau hsz`g~evcj nu yzhzszc4 83 S/Y/I/ 888< {~g|ejcy

lg~ eofsoizegoy .s{go ysi` zc~by hy z`c igs~z bhu jccb ~chygohnac. zg {~c|coz |egahzegoy

gl Aho`hb Hiz/ Ycc! Eo ~c \sezzgo cz Leay! Y/H/! j 8! : (>j Ie~/ 85=5% hoj ihycy

iezcj z`c~ceo (igs~z `hy eo`c~coz {g}c~ zg eyysc ycevs~c g~jc~y%4 Soe|c~yha Iezu Yzsjegy! |/

Dhbbh Eojsyz~ecy! >8= S/Y/J/X/ 88 (Y/J/ Zcp/ 850>%/ Ycc hayg Ns~oy Ic~z/

Bg~cg|c~! z`c Aho`hb Hizy{cieleihaau igozcb{ahzcy z`hz h zcb{g~h~u ~cyz~heoeom

hoj ycevs~c g~jc~ hmheoyz Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc bhu nc `hj nu cp {h~zc h{{aeihzego/

Ycizego 888% z`c h{{aeihoz `hy ogz {snaeievcj z`c ~cxscyzcj ycevs~c! hoj (9% z`c {c~ygo

hmheoyz }`gb ycevs~c }gsaj nc g~jc~cj }gsaj jcyz~gu g~ gz`c~}eyc bhdc eohiicyyenac zg

z`c igs~z z`c eol~eomeom bhzzc~y/ 83 S/Y/I/ 888

Eo z`c eoyzhoz ihyc! `g}c|c~! haz`gsm` z`c zgs~ `hy ncmso hoj jclcojhozy `h|c

h{{ch~cj! z`cu h~c ucz soejcozelecj! lg~ z`c ~chygoy ycz lg~z` eo z`c Jgoocaa Jciah~hzego/

Ez ey iach~ l~gb z`c ohzs~c gl z`ce~ hize|ezecy z`hz z`cu }eaa nc {~cycoz eo zèy fs~eyjeizego

goau agom cogsm` zg ycaa z`ce~ sohsz`g~evcj mggjy/ Hlzc~ z`c sohsz`g~evcj mggjy h~c ygaj!

>' Eo hjjezego! eo cohizeom z`c Z~hjcbh~d Igsozc~lcezeom Hiz gl 850:! Igom~cyy eo og }hueozcojcj zg i`homc cpeyzeom ihyc ah} hoj {~cicjcoz sojc~ ^sac j Ie~/ 85=5%! hoj z`c {~gzcizego z`cu {~g|ejc/

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


12/22

88

z`cu }eaa {~gb{zau jeyh{{ch~/ C|co el Jclcojhozy ~cice|cj ogzeic hoj }c~c yc~|cj }ez h

{~g{gycj zcb{g~h~u ~cyz~heoeom g~jc~! ez ey `em`au soaedcau z`hz z`cu }gsaj |gasozh~eau

igb{au hoj ogz ycaa z ce~ mggjy/ Ycc Jgoocaa Jcia/ hoj Ns~oy Ic~z/ Yeb{au yzhzcj! z`c~c

ey og gz`c~ bchoy gl {~c|cozeom z`c Jclcojhozy l~gb jcyz~gueom [aheozell-y acmezebhzc

nsyeocyy }ez`gsz h ycevs~c g~jc~/

H Igs~z gl Cxsezu bsyz nc lacpenac hoj bsyz nc }eaaeom zg eyysc ho eofsoizego

h{{~g{~ehzc sojc~ z`c {h~zeisah~ ie~isbyzhoicy gl z`c ihyc/ Ycc z`c Haa ]~ezy Hiz! >0

S/Y/I/ 8/

N/ ^sac


13/22

8>

cofgeocj/ Yeoic Jclcojhozy `h|c z`c zcbc~ezu zg igojsiz nahzhozau soah}lsa hize|ezecy!

bhdeom h nsyeocyy gl ycaaeom eol~eomeom h~zeiacy! hoj `h|c ho cigogbei eozc~cyz eo

igozeoseom z`ce~ soah}lsa hizegoy! z`c~c ey og ~chygo zg ncaec|c z`cu }eaa |gasozh~eau yzg{/

Z`c Igs~z eo \sezzgo! ys{~h! lgsoj z`hz ebbcjehzc hoj e~~c{h~hnac eofs~u cpeyzcj

ncihsyc gl z`c ysnyzhozeha aedcae`ggj gl igolsyego i~chzcj nu z`c ezeoc~hoz Nggzacmmc~y

ycaaeom z`ce~ sohsz`g~evcj mggjy hoj {aheozell `hj y`g}o }ù ogzeic y`gsaj ogz nc me|co6

THRaz`gsm` zèy Igs~z `hy l~g}ocj s{go zcb{g~h~u ~cyz~heoeom g~jc~yeyyscj c|co }ez`gsz zcac{`goc ogzeic z`c~c h~c giihyegoy }`co ysi`g~jc~y h~c zg nc igsozcohoicj/ Eo gs~ fsjmbcoz! zèy ihyc ey fsyzysi` ho giihyego/ T&&&R Hyysbeom z`hz haa gl z`c gz`c~ ~cxse~cbcozy

gl ^sac % z`c h{{aeihoz yslleiecozau jcbgoyz~hzcy z`c ~chygoz`hz ogzeic .y`gsaj ogz nc ~cxse~cj/. Eo h z~hjcbh~d eol~eomcbcozihyc ysi` hy zèy! h ysnyzhozeha aedcae`ggj gl igolsyego igoyzezszcy! eohoj zg ezycal! e~~c{h~hnac eofs~u yslleiecoz zg yhzeylu z`c ~cxse~cbcozygl ^sac [hmc 89 gl >>


14/22

89

z`c igoysbbhzego gl z`c z`~chzcocj eofs~u zg gnzheo {~c|coze|c ~caecl/ Nhnnezz |/ Soezcj

Lh~b ]g~dc~y Ohzegoha Soego! ::> S/Y/ >05! >50 (85=5%4 Hojc~ygo |/ @gg{c~! :50 L/

Ys{{/ 050 (J/O/B/ 850;%/ Eojccj! hou hyyc~zego zg z`c igoz~h~u }gsaj igoyzezszc h

igoic{zsha ~cfcizego gl {~g|eyegoha ~cbcjecy h|heahnac zg h {h~zu }`g `hy ysyzheocj g~ ey

eo ebbcjehzc jhomc~ gl ysyzheoeom h je~ciz eofs~u/ Lahyz |/ Ig`co! 95> S/Y/ 09 (85 S/Y/ hz >50/

Eo ie~isbyzhoicy yebeah~ zg z`c lhizy `c~ceo! bhou lcjc~ha igs~zy `h|c eyyscj

zcb{g~h~u ~cyz~heoeom hoj ycevs~c hoj eb{gsojbcoz g~jc~y zg cofgeo |h~egsy Jgc

Jclcojhozy l~gb bhoslhizs~eom! jeyz~enszeom! ycaaeom hoj gz`c~}eyc igbbc~iehaau

cp{agezeom eol~eomeom bc~i`hojeyc hyygiehzcj }ez` z`c zgs~y gl bsyeiha {c~lg~beom h~zeyzy/

Eo chi` ihyc! ho cp {h~zc g~jc~ }hy eyyscj hmheoyz soejcozelecj jclcojhozy! g~emeohaau

jcyemohzcj hy Jgcy! zg {~c|coz z`c yhac hoj zg ycevcj gl bc~i`hojeyc nch~eom z`c ohbcy!

agmgy hoj z~hjcbh~dy gl h~zeyzy ~c{~cycozcj nu z`c {aheozell eo z`gyc hizegoy/ Ycc Ns~oy

Ic~z/ hoj Cp`y z`c~czg/

Eo Neaau Fgca |/ Jgcy! ys{~h! `caj z`hz haz`gsm` z`c igs~z jgcy ogz lh|g~ sodog}o

jclcojhozy hoj bhu ogz `h|c eo {c~ygohb fs~eyjeizego! eo z`c ihyc gl Nggzacmmc~y6

E hb igo|eoicj z`hz z`c ~cxscyzcj eofsoizego Thoj ycevs~c g~jc~R y`gsaj eyysceo z`c {~cycoz ihyc/ /// Z`c {~gnacb gl z`c jclcojhozy- ejcozelecy ey bcz! Encaec|c! nu z`c lhiz z`hz ig{ecy gl z`c ysbbgoy! igb{aheoz! hoj ~cyz~heoeomg~jc~ ezycal }eaa nc yc~|cj go haa {c~ygoy l~gb }`gb Neaau Fgca bc~i`hojeyc eyycevcj go z`c oem`z gl z`c igoic~z/ Z`cyc {h~zecy }eaa nc hydcj zg ~c|cha z`ce~ohbcy yg z`hz z`cu iho nc hjjcj hy {h~zecy zg z`c ah} ysez/ T& & &R T}Rc~c z`ceofsoizego zg nc jcoecj! {aheozelly }gsaj nc }ez`gsz hou acmha bchoy zg{~c|coz }`hz ey iach~au h nahzhoz eol~eomcbcoz gl z`ce~ |haej {~g{c~zu ~em`zy/:55 L/ Ys{{/ hz =5>/

El igs~zy lheacj zg ~cigmoevc .Jgc. Jclcojhozy! iac|c~ }~gomjgc~y igsaj (hoj

}eaa% chyeau igoicha z`ce~ z~sc ejcozezecy sozea h yzhzszc gl aebezhzegoy ~so gsz! g~! hy `c~c!

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


15/22

8:

z`cu igsaj ach|c [aheozell }ez` og {~hizeiha ~cigs~yc lg~ |egahzegoy gl z`ce~ ~em`zy/ Bggo

^cig~jy! >8= S/Y/[/X/ 95 (O/J/ Eaa/ 8508% (.z`c {~gnacb ~cmh~jeom z`c ejcozezu gl z`c

jclcojhozy }eaa nc bcz nu ~cxse~eom ig{ecy gl z`c igb{aheoz hoj z`c Tg~jc~R zg nc yc~|cj

s{go haa {c~ygoy l~gb }`gb eol~eomeom bc~i`hojeyc ey ycevcj///.%/ Igoyeyzcoz }ez`

L/^/I/[ ^sac :(f%! [aheozell-y {~gicyy yc~|c~y }eaa bhdc c|c~u ~chygohnac cllg~z zg ls~z`c~

ejcozelu z`c Jclcojhozy lg~ {s~{gycy gl hbcojeom z`c {achjeomy/

Ez `hy ncco z`c ~c{chzcj cp{c~ecoic gl [aheozell hoj [aheozell-y igsoyca z`hz bgyz! el

ogz haa! gl z`c Nggzacmmc~y h~c {c~ygoy cpz~cbcau cp{c~ecoicj }ez` ycaaeom Eol~eomeom

Bc~i`hojeyc/ Bgyz h~c ogz ocg{ùzcy! nsz ~hz`c~ ygbc}`hz yg{èyzeihzcj nsyeocyybco

}`g g{c~hzc eo yzchaz` zg z`}h~z z`c acmezebhzc ~em`zy gl [aheozell/ Nggzacmmc~y z~h|ca

h~gsoj z`c igsoz~u l~gb |cosc zg |cosc ycaaeom z`ce~ igsozc~lcez }h~cy/ Bhou jclcojhozy

c|co `h|c z`c hsjhiezu zg {~eoz z`c coze~c zgs~ yi`cjsac gl {c~lg~bc~y ysi` hy z`c M~gs{

go z`c nhid gl z`c nggzacm Z"yè~zy }èi` z`cu ycaa/ Hou {c~ygo lgsoj ycaaeom h yè~z

nch~eom z`c coze~c Zgs~ yi`cjsac iho lhe~au nc yhej zg nc .hejeom hoj hnczzeom! g~ hizeom eo

hize|c igoic~z }ez`!. yc~|cj Jclcojhozy }`g `h|c ygaj yebeah~ yè~zy hz gz`c~ igoic~zy/

\/ H BSAZE JEYZÊIZ ZGS^ EOFSOIZEGO HOJ G^JC^ GL YCEVS^C

COFGEOEOM JCLCOJHOZY- IGOJSIZ HI^GYY Z@C IGSOZÛ EY

NGZ@ OCICYYHÛ HOJ [^G[C^/

H/ Igs~zy @h|c Eyyscj Ohzego}ejc Eofsoizegoy hoj Ycevs~c G~jc~y/

Ez `hy ncco y`g}o nu z`c jciah~hzego ysnbezzcj eo zèy bhzzc~ z`hz z`c yhac gl

Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc nu z`c Jclcojhozy ey eo |egahzego gl z`c Aho`hb Hiz hoj ihsycy

jcic{zego zg z`c {snaei/ Hy ysi`! haa ~cbcjecy sojc~ z`c Aho`hb Hiz h~c h{{~g{~ehzc hoj

`h|c ~cmsah~au ncco cpc~ieycj nu bhou igs~zy hi~gyy z`c igsoz~u eo lhizsha hoj acmhaau

ejcozeiha ie~isbyzhoicy/ Z`c bsaze"jeyz~eiz ~caecl ygsm`z `hy ncco m~hozcj eo osbc~gsy

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


16/22

83

ihycy eo gz`c~ fs~eyjeizegoy hi~gyy z`c igsoz~u/ Ycc Ns~oy Ic~z/ Ez ey y{cieleihaau

hsz`g~evcj nu yzhzszc/ Ycizego 888< {~g|ejcy lg~ colg~icbcoz hoj yc~|eic .hou}`c~c eo

z`c Soezcj Yzhzcy }`c~c TJclcojhozyR bhu nc lgsoj/. 83 S/Y/I/ 888

eol~eomeom mggjy lg~ jcyz~sizego%4 Mgajco Jgg~! Eoi/! ys{~h! :9= L/Ys{{/ 5 (J/ Bj/

85= L/ Ys{{/ 38< (Y/J/O/U/ 85=0%/

Z`c {~g{~eczu gl ysi` h bsaze"jeyz~eiz g~jc~ `hy ncco cyzhnaey`cj nu osbc~gsy

jeyz~eiz igs~zy z`~gsm`gsz z`c igsoz~u! hy cp{aheocj `c~ceo hoj hy `hy ncco cp{aheocj hz

acomz` nu z`c Lelz` Ie~isez eo ]hllcoyi`bejz |/ Bhidhu! =j =88 (8503%/

Ogo"{h~zecy }`g ~cyejc gszyejc z`c zc~~ezg~eha fs~eyjeizego gl h jeyz~eiz igs~zbhu nc ysnfciz zg z`hz igs~z-y fs~eyjeizego el! }ez` hizsha ogzeic gl z`cigs~z-y g~jc~! z`cu hize|cau hej hoj hncz h {h~zu eo |egahzeom z`hz g~jc~/Z`ey ey yg jcy{ezc z`c hnycoic gl gz`c~ igozhizy }ez` z`c lg~sb/ T & & &RIgs~zy jg ogz yez lg~ z`c ejac ic~cbgou gl bhdeom g~jc~y hoj {~gogsoieomfsjmbcozy! z`c colg~icbcoz gl }`ei` bhu nc lagszcj! gnyz~sizcj! hoj|egahzcj }ez` eb{soezu! }ez` og {g}c~ eo z`c z~ensoha zg {soey` z`cgllcojc~/ TLcjc~haR igs~zy! cxshaau }ez` z`gyc gl z`c yzhzc! h~c {gyycyycj glhb{ac {g}c~ zg {~gzciz z`c hjbeoeyz~hzego gl fsyzeic l~gb nceom z`sy`hb{c~cj g~ eozc~lc~cj }ez`/ Ej/! hz =8:! =8< (iezhzegoy gbezzcj%/

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


17/22

8j 898< (Y/J/ Lah/ 8550%/ Eo ngz` ihycy! [aheozelly

ygsm`z ohzego}ejc eofsoizegoy hoj ycevs~c g~jc~y zg colg~ic z`c ~em`zy gl h~zeyz js~eom h

ohzego}ejc zgs~/ Z`c jeyz~eiz igs~z eo YDY Bc~i`! hlzc~ ih~clsa ~c|ec} z`c [ahoz jcieyego!

hy }caa hy gz`c~ hj|c~yc jcieyegoy!9 jciejcj zg m~hoz h ohzego}ejc eofsoizego zg ycevc

sohsz`g~evcj mggjy go cyycozeha z`~cc m~gsojy/

Le~yz! z`c Igs~z eo YDY Bc~i` ogzcj z hz [aheozell eo [ahoz lheacj zg hzzcb{z zg

ejcozelu hou jclcojhozy/ Hy ycz lg~z` eo z c Jgoocaa Jciah~hzego hoj z`c Ic~zeleihzc gl

Igsoyca! Jclcojhozy `h|c h{{ch~cj hoj }eaa igozeosc h{{ch~ hz h zgs~ gl zèy bhmoezsjc/

Z`c is~~coz gocy jg ogz ih~~u ejcozeleihzego g~ ~cy{goj }`co hydcj zg |gasozcc~ z`ce~

ohbcy/ Zg ~cxse~c [aheozell zg }hez g~ zg ygbc`g} ejcozelu z`gyc }`g ~clsyc zg ejcozelu

z`cbyca|cy hoj ~so h}hu z`~gsm` i~g}jy }gsaj yc~egsyau eb{cjc ezy ~em`zy/ Z`c

bc~i`hojeyc }eaa nc zhdco hoj h ngoj }eaa nc {gyzcj/ Z`c `h~b zg [aheozell! `g}c|c~! ey

e~~c{h~hnac/ Z`c YDY Bc~i` Igs~z ~cigmoevcj }`hz `hy ncco z c bgjsy g{c~coje gl z`cyc

Nggzacmmc~ Jclcojhozy z`hz z`cu lhea zg ih~~u ejcozeleihzego! z`cu h~c }caa h}h~c z`c

mggjy z`cu ycaa h~c sohsz`g~evcj! hoj z`cu lacc }`co h{{~ghi`cj nu hsz`g~evcj

eoje|ejshay/ Ej/! hz 0:5/ Z`c {c~ygo }`g cojy s{ ysllc~eom ey z`hz gl z`c {aheozell

bc~i`hojeyc~! }`g `hy og gz`c~ ~cigs~yc/ Haz`gsm` z`c {aheozell eo YDY Bc~i`

h{{h~cozau }hezcj h lc} bgoz`y sozea yccdeom eofsoize|c ~caecl! [aheozell `c~c ~cxscyzy z hz

9'Z}g {snaey`cj ihycy }`c~c yebeah~ ~caecl }hy jcoecj6 N~gidsb Eozc~oa |/ \h~egsy

Fgò Jgcy! 338 L/ Ys{{/ 8;3: (C/J/ ]eyi/ 850>% (jciejcj yggo hlzc~ cohizbcoz gl 888< (j%yzhzeom z cyc eyyscy h~c ncyz aclz zg agiha hsz`g~ezecy%4 N~gidsb Ig/ |/ \h~egsy Fgò Jgcy! % ez }hy z`cgoau ~chaeyzei }hu zg igoz~ga z`c {~gnacb%/ Lg~ ~chygoy ycz lg~z` eo YDY Bc~i` hoj z`c Ic~zeleihzcgl Igsoyca! z`cyc ihycy y`gsaj ogz nc igoz~gaaeom/

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


18/22

8=

ez y`gsaj ogz }hez yg agom4 }ez` chi` {c~lg~bhoic ez }eaa nc `h~bcj! z`c nggzacmmeom }eaa

igozeosc hoj z`c goau goc }`g }eaa mheo! hoj mheo bgbcozsb! }eaa nc z`c jclcojhozy/

Ycigoj! z`c Igs~z eo [ahoz }hy igoic~ocj z hz og {~gicjs~ha bchoy cpeyzcj zg

eyysc hoj colg~ic z`c eofsoizego/ Ycizego 888< {c~bezy ysi` eofsoizegoy! hoj z`c Igs~z eo

YDY Bc~i` `caj z`hz ez jgcy/ Bg~cg|c~! ez ey igozcb{ahzcj zg nc `hj go z`c nhyey gl ho cp

{h~zc h{{aeihzego! ogz h ogzeicj bgzego/

Zè~j! igoic~oy hngsz yc~|eic ~heycj eo [ahoz h~c hjj~cyycj `c~c hy z`cu }c~c eo

YDY Bc~i`4 z`ce~ ohbcy bhu nc hjjcj hlzc~ yc~|eic `hy zhdco cllciz hoj ohbcy

({~clc~hnau {~g{c~% }eaa nc {~g|ejcj/ Ncihsyc z`c mggjy h~c z`c yhbc l~gb agihzego zg

agihzego! zèy ~c{~cycozy h igoic~zcj cllg~z hoj z`c~clg~c z`cu h~c go ogzeic/

N/ Z`c Igs~z ]eaa @h|c Fs~eyjeizego G|c~ Z`c Jclcojhozy hoj Z`gyc

Hizeom Eo Igoic~z ]ez` Z`cb/

Goic z`c Jclcojhozy `h|c ncco yc~|cj hz z`c igoic~zy! zèy Igs~z hixse~cy

{c~ygoha fs~eyjeizego g|c~ z`cb/ L/^/I/[/ ^sac :/ Ycc Fgò @hoigid Bszsha Aelc Eoy/

Ig/ |/ Icoz~ha Ohz-a Nhod! 333 L/ Ys{{/ 8;>< (O/J/ Eaa/ 8509% (yc~|eic gl {~gicyy sojc~

^sac : igolc~y fs~eyjeizego go zèy Igs~z c|co }ez` ~cy{ciz zg Fgò Jgc jclcojhozy%/ Hz

z`c `ch~eom go z`c {~caebeoh~u eofsoizego! zèy Igs~z y`gsaj cofgeo haa z`c Nggzacmmeom

hize|ezecy js~eom z c coze~czu gl z`c M~gs{y ohzego}ejc zgs~/ Hnycoz ysi` h ohzego}ejc

eofsoizego! igb{aczc ~caecl `c~c }gsaj nc eb{gyyenac zg hièc|c4 yc{h~hzc g~jc~y }gsaj

`h|c zg nc ygsm`z hz c|c~u agihzego go z`c zgs~/ Hy h {~hizeiha bhzzc~! ysi` h yc~ecy gl

ah}ysezy ey eb{gyyenac! hoj }gsaj eo hou c|coz ~cysaz eo h zc~~enac }hyzc gl z`c {h~zecy- hoj

z`c lcjc~ha igs~zy- ~cygs~icy/ Hy h ~cysaz! zèy Igs~z! hoj bhou gz`c~y! `h|c eyyscj

ohzego}ejc {~caebeoh~u eofsoizegoy hoj ycevs~c g~jc~y zg yzg{ nggzacmmeom/ Ycc Ns~oy

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


19/22

80

Ic~z/ hoj Jgoocaa Jcia/ Eo hjjezego! 83 S/Y/I/ 888

colg~icbcoz gl z`ey Igs~z-y g~jc~y eo gz`c~ jeyz~eizy/

Z`c ohzego}ejc eofsoizego }eaa nc cllcize|c hmheoyz haa {c~ygoy eo|ga|cj eo

Jclcojhozy- Nggzacmmeom g{c~hzego/ [s~yshoz zg L/^/I/[/ ^sac j 995! 9:: (5z` Ie~/% ic~z/ jcoecj! 903 S/Y/ 585 (85 [hmc 85 gl >>


20/22

85

~caecl m~hozcj zg [aheozell bsyz igozeosc z`~gsm`gsz z`c zgs~ hoj g{c~hzc hmheoyz z`cyc

Jclcojhozy eo g~jc~ zg nc cllcize|c/ Jgoocaa Jcia/ 88">;/

Chi` zebc z`c~c ey h ycevs~c {s~yshoz zg z`c g~jc~! z`c ~cxse~cbcoz gl ogzeic zg z`c

{c~ygo hmheoyz }`gb z`c ~caecl g{c~hzcy }eaa nc yhzeylecj/ Goic z`c {~caebeoh~u

eofsoizego ey eyyscj ez }eaa nc yc~|cj go hougoc ycaaeom Eol~eomeom Bc~i`hojeyc go z`c

zgs~/ Z`cu }eaa z`c~clg~c `h|c ogzeic gl z`c eofsoizego hz z`c igoic~z hoj }`co z`ce~

mggjy h~c ycevcj/ H ohzego}ejc {~caebeoh~u eofsoizego hmheoyz Jclcojhozy! z`gyc hizeom

eo igoic~z }ez` z`cb hoj gz`c~y ey h{{~g{~ehzc hoj ~cxse~cj el [aheozell ey zg gnzheo ~caecl

l~gb Jclcojhozy- igoic~zcj soah}lsa hizy/

I/ Z`c G~jc~ Neojy Z`gyc ]`g [h~zeie{hzc eo z c Jclcojhozy Soah}lsa

Igojsiz Ncugoj z`c Zc~~ezg~u gl zèy Igs~z/

Nu ho h{{~g{~ehzc ngoj {ahicj }ez` zèy Igs~z nu [aheozell! Jclcojhozy ha}huy

`h|c z`c ~em`z zg nc `ch~j hoj h~c msh~hozccj h ygs~ic gl ~cig|c~u lg~ hou }~gomjgeom

}`hzygc|c~ zg z`cb/ Z`c goau cllcize|c }hu lg~ [aheozell zg gnzheo ~caecl ey zg `h|c z ey

Igs~z cozc~ h {~caebeoh~u eofsoizego hoj ycevs~c g~jc~! z`c bhojhzc gl }èi` }eaa nc

~cy{cizcj hi~gyy zèy igsoz~u/ El z`c ~caecl ey ogz m~hozcj! Jclcojhozy }eaa igozeosc zg syc

z`c ohbcy hoj mggj}eaa hyygiehzcj }ez` z`c M~gs{ hoj [aheozell }`g `hy y{coz bhou

uch~y! hoj |hyz ysby gl bgocu zg isaze|hzc/

Ez ey ncaec|cj z`hz haa ycevs~cy }eaa nc cllcizcj s{go Nggzacmmc~y ycaaeom

ysnyzhozehaau ejcozeiha yè~zy z`~gsm`gsz z`c igsoz~u hoj }eaa nc z`~gsm` h igoic~zcj

g{c~hzego/ Ycc Jgoocaa Jcia/ @g}c|c~! eo z`c soaedcau c|coz z`hz hou eoje|ejshay

y{gozhocgsyau jciejc zg {~eoz z`ce~ g}o .`gbcbhjc. yè~zy! ysi` eoje|ejshay }gsaj nc

|egahzeom [aheozell-y ~em`zy hoj }gsaj nc ysnfciz zg ysez eo hou c|coz/ Ycevs~c gl ysi`

yè~zy! el hou cpeyzcj! }gsaj nc |e~zshaau ejcozeiha zg ycevs~c sojc~ h agiha g~jc~ eyyscj eo

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;


21/22

>;

z`hz jeyz~eiz/ Ysi` h agiha g~jc~ }gsaj ogz hllg~j z cb hou m~chzc~ ogzeic g~ jsc {~gicyy/

Bg~cg|c~! ~cxse~eom [aheozell zg igozeosc zg mg l~gb igs~z zg igs~z z`~gsm`gsz z`c zgs~

}gsaj nc zg eb{gyc h m~chz ns~jco s{go ngz` [aheozell hoj z`c fsjeieha ~cygs~icy gl z`c

lcjc~ha igs~zy/ @g}c|c~! zg h|gej c|co h z`cg~czeiha xscyzego! [aheozell }eaa }he|c hou

gnfcizegoy zg |cosc hoj z~hoylc~ z`c hizego/ Eojccj! hy zg z`c ohzegoha ycevs~c g~jc~y

m~hozcj zg [aheozell! goau goc jclcojhoz nggzacmmc~ `hy h{{ch~cj eo hou hizego nsz lheacj

eo èy hzzcb{z zg i`haacomc z`c g~jc~/ Ycc Ns~oy Ic~z/

J/ Jclcojhozy @h|c H Lsaa Hoj Lhe~ G{{g~zsoezu Zg Nc @ch~j/

Haz`gsm` ez ey ogz dog}o hz zèy zebc }`cz`c~ hou Jclcojhozy }eaa h{{ch~ nclg~c z`c

Igs~z go z`c ~czs~o jhzc zg g{{gyc z`c ~cxscyzcj ~caecl! me|co gs~ cp{c~ecoic! ez ey

jgsnzlsa z`hz hou }eaa jg yg/ @g}c|c~! z`cu ic~zheoau `h|c z`hz g{{g~zsoezu/ [aheozell

}gsaj }caigbc ysi` h{{ch~hoicy lg~ ez }gsaj {c~bez ez zg ejcozelu z`c nggzacmmc~y! zhdc

jeyig|c~u l~gb z`cb! jeyig|c~ z`ce~ {~eozeom ygs~icy hoj {s~ysc z`cb lg~ bgocu

jhbhmcy/ Z`c {~g{gycj G~jc~ }eaa {~g|ejc z`hz h {c~ygo }`g }ey`cy zg i`haacomc z`c

ycevs~c `hy z`c g{{g~zsoezu zg leac h bgzego }ez` zèy g~ hou gz`c~ Igs~z ~cxscyzeom h

`ch~eom/ Zèy me|cy hou jclcojhoz h lsaa hoj lhe~ g{{g~zsoezu zg nc `ch~j! }èac z`c

bc~i`hojeyc! z`c i~ezeiha {ecic gl c|ejcoic! ey {~cyc~|cj/ @g}c|c~! }ez`gsz z c {~g{gycj

g~jc~! [aheozell }eaa nc lg~icj zg leac yc{h~hzc ie|ea hizegoy z`~gsm`gsz z`c Soezcj Yzhzcy hz

ho cyzebhzcj cp{coyc gl }caa g|c~ *"i|"8;


22/22

Jhzcj6 H{~ea 3! >;8> ^cy{cizlsaau YsnbezzcjN^H\HJG EOZCÔHZEGOHA M^GS[BCÎ@HOJEYEOM YC^\EICY! EOI/'y' B/ Ah}~coic Gae|c~egB/ Ah}~coic Gae|c~eg! Cyx/! NNG )9=0=33

êyybho! @coj~eidy , Gae|c~eg AA[8;; Ihbn~ejmc Yz~ccz! Ysezc >8;8Ngyzgo! Bhyyhi`syczzy ;>88:Zca6 (3

Ihyc 868>"i|"8;

Bravado (Red Hot Chili Peppers) v. Does TRO Memo

Documents

Transcript of Bravado (Red Hot Chili Peppers) v. Does TRO Memo