Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu. Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth,...

16
KIDNAPPING Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu

Transcript of Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu. Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth,...

Page 1: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

KIDNAPPINGBrandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu

Page 2: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

The Case Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth,

Klein, and Burshowski July 14, 1998 in an underground parking garage Recorded by a surveillance camera Louise Emerson was helping a couple whose car wouldn't

start. When she returned to her car to get jumper cables she

was hit on the head by a large, blunt object. Suspects pushed Louise into her own car and drove away. Suspect: William Klein, brother of Arthur Klein

Page 3: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Abandoned Vehicle Report  On July 19, 1998, Cicero Police Officer, Conner, was called

to investigate a possible abandoned car (1978 Montecarlo, silver) parked outside of a laundry mat (Suds & Duds) located on the corner of Milner and Trotter Streets.

The store manager told Officer Conner that the car had not been moved from the current location for 5 days and nights.

Officer Conner conducted a visual inspection of the vehicle from the outside and observed dark red stains on the steering wheel, dash area, glove box, and door handle on the driver side. The car was impounded and towed to the Cicero garage for further forensic examination.

Page 4: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Other Information Nobody filed a missing persons report

for her. Pale band on her finger indicates she

usually wears a wedding ring or school ring.

Page 5: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Rag Evidence The rag found in the trunk of the car

was found to have traces of chloroform, a chemical that causes dizziness, fatigue, and headaches when inhaled.

Vapor causes a  profound narcosis. Mortality is 1 in 3000.

Page 6: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Fingerprint Evidence Fingerprints from inside the vehicle, fast

food wrappers, side mirror, trunk, door handles, steering wheel, and evidence bag matched the owner of the vehicle (William Klein).

No other discernible prints were identified.

Page 7: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

DNA Evidence The victim’s cells were found at the

scene of the crime. Sperm found in the suspect’s car

matches the suspect's DNA.

Page 8: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Fiber Evidence Fibers from floorboard(1), and offices of Worth,

Klein, and Burshowski (where Louise works) (2), and trunk(3) are very similar.

Sample #1: lots of red carpet containing traces of alcohol.

Sample # 2: trilobal nylon fibers are typically found in carpet used for high traffic areas

Sample #3: carpet fibers consist with fibers found in the architect firm in addition to silk fibers commonly found on a blouse or scarf

Page 9: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Hair Evidence Ten hairs were found from carpet in

trunk; the hairs were damaged - did not fall out naturally

Sample of hair from car and hair from victim's hairbrush match

Page 10: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Soil Evidence Soil from car matches soil from

suspect's garden Soil found in interior looks like it is from

a coastal area, possibly Gulf Coast of Texas

Sawdust was found in soil left by suspect; there is a nearby lumber yard

Page 11: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Handwriting Evidence Tall upper strokes are reaching towards

goals and ambitions or, if they are very extended, there may be unrealistic expectations of what the person feels they must achieve

Wide spaces between words are saying - 'give me breathing space‘

Maybe she was doing better than him and he was jealous

Page 12: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Blood Evidence Low velocity spots indicate blood was dropping Splatter stains indicate that blood was flying from a

source Traces of Type B negative blood from steering

wheel, dash area, and glove box area matches Arthur Klein’s blood type

Testing indicates type A blood was on the seat and floorboard of the back seat of the car, and on the back window and in the trunk. This matches Louise Emerson's blood type.

Page 13: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Possible Scenario 1 Louise Emerson was in a relationship

with William Klein. Arthur Klein was jealous, and decided to kidnap her.

Evidence: Possibly inebriated Carpet fibers from their office Blood matches Arthur Klein

Page 14: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Possible Scenario 2 William Klein kidnapped her. Evidence

Fingerprints His car, carpet fibers could be from him

visiting his brother or from Louise Sperm in back of car and chloroform on rag

indicates rape

Page 15: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Possible Scenario 3 William and Arthur Klein worked

together to kidnap Louise Possible motive: She is becoming too

successful Evidence

Both are related to the crime scene – blood and fingerprints

Page 16: Brandon Mustin, James Sun, Serena Xu.  Victim: Louise Emerson, partner of architect firm: Worth, Klein, and Burshowski  July 14, 1998 in an underground.

Possible Scenario 4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ff-tiU

8uam0&feature=related