Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant...

148
Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling SASP 990kW installed at Daff Works, near Inverkip Prepared by: Kiwa GASTEC at CRE Prepared for: Shield On-Site Services Report number: 30344 Date: 14 November 2013

Transcript of Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant...

Page 1: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Boiler Performance and

Emissions Testing for the

Topling SASP 990kW installed at

Daff Works, near Inverkip

Prepared by: Kiwa GASTEC at CRE Prepared for: Shield On-Site Services Report number: 30344 Date: 14 November 2013

Page 2: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 1 of 29

Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling SASP

990kW installed at Daff Works, near Inverkip

Prepared by: Kiwa Ltd (t/a Kiwa GASTEC at CRE)

Address: The Orchard Business Centre Stoke Orchard Cheltenham GL52 7RZ UK Telephone: +44 (0)1242 677877 Fax: +44 (0)1242 676506 E-mail: [email protected] Web: www.kiwa.co.uk Prepared for: Shield On-Site Services

Address: 10 Broad Lane Moldgreen Huddersfield HD5 9BX Telephone: 0845 0349 360 Fax: 01484 545 577 Web: www.shieldon-siteservices.com Author: James Thomas

Position: Energy Consultant Approved by: Iain Summerfield

Position: Principal Consultant Signed: Test engineers: N Hardy, J Thomas Tested on: 01-02 October 2013 Date of report: 14 November 2013 Report number: 30344

Commercial in Confidence This report shall only be reproduced in full All opinions and interpretations expressed herein are outside the scope of our UKAS accreditation

Page 3: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 2 of 29

Executive Summary

Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW

biomass boiler and associated fuel feed system installed at Daff Works, near Inverkip on

01-02 October 2013.

The average particulate emission was 22.9 g/GJ when the boiler was fired with wood chip

and 239.1 g/GJ when fired with straw.

The average NOx emissions were 63.3 g/GJ when the boiler was fired with wood chip and

135.2 g/GJ when fired with straw.

The efficiency was calculated to be 87.8% net (80.0% gross) when the boiler was fired with

wood chip and 87.8% net (79.8% gross) when fired with straw.

The differences in results obtained using various test methods and the uncertainty issues

discussed in the report make it difficult to make a general statement about the energy

output from the boiler during these tests. It is likely that the Topling SASP 990kW biomass

boiler and associated fuel feed system installed at Daff Works, near Inverkip, achieved 85%

of its rated output of 990kW when fired with wood chip. It is not however possible to extend

this statement to cover the same boiler installed elsewhere.

Page 4: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 3 of 29

Table of Contents

1 Introduction .................................................................................................................. 5

2 Description of appliance ............................................................................................... 5

3 Test work ..................................................................................................................... 7

3.1 Test appliances ..................................................................................................... 7

3.2 Test equipment ..................................................................................................... 7

3.3 Test fuel ................................................................................................................ 7

3.4 Test procedures .................................................................................................... 8

4 Results and discussion ................................................................................................. 9

4.1 Results .................................................................................................................. 9

4.2 Discussion ........................................................................................................... 10

5 Conclusions ................................................................................................................ 11

6 References ................................................................................................................. 11

Appendix A: Emission rate calculations for the RHI ........................................................... 12

Appendix B: BS845 boiler efficiency calculations............................................................... 16

Appendix C: Enclosures .................................................................................................... 30

Page 5: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 4 of 29

1 Introduction

Shield On-Site Services, on behalf of their client, contracted Kiwa Ltd to perform

independent testing of the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated fuel feed

system installed at Daff Works, near Inverkip, with a view to Kiwa issuing a Renewable

Heat Incentive emissions certificate.

The test work was carried out on-site at Daff Works. The boiler was test fired at high fire

with wood chip fuel on 01 October 2013, and at high fire with straw fuel on 02 October

2013.

The particulate and NOx emissions were measured using the Standard Reference Method

(SRM) for all parameters as listed in the Environment Agency Technical Guidance Note

TGN M2. In summary, the methods were:

Total Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 or ISO9096;

CO BS EN 15058;

CO2 ISO 12039;

O2 BS EN 14789;

H2O BS EN 14790;

Temperature & Pressure BS EN 13284 & ISO 10780;

NOx BS EN 14792.

In addition to this, the fuel was sampled and analysis of the Calorific Value (gross and net),

Moisture, and Ash were undertaken.

Measurements were also taken to calculate the output and efficiency of the boiler by the

indirect (or losses) method described in BS EN 845: part 1.

2 Description of appliance

Name of appliance Topling SASP 990kW

Nominal Output 990kW

Boiler type Low temperature hot water boiler

Continuous or Batch fed Continuous

Feedstock Wood chip and/or straw

Grate type Ram stoker and gasifier burner

Abatement system Cyclone

Abatement System Status On

Air systems 1 x primary forced draught (on)

1 x secondary forced draught (on)

1 x tertiary forced draught (off)

1 x induced draught (on)

Page 6: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 5 of 29

Figure 1: Topling SASP 990kW Biomass Boiler and associated

fuel feed system installed at Daff Works, near Inverkip

Page 7: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 6 of 29

3 Test work

3.1 Test appliances

The unit supplies low temperature hot water (LTHW) from the boiler to an accumulator.

Water from the accumulator is also circulated through a fan driven water-to-air heat

exchanger in the boiler house. The hot air produced is blown into adjacent rooms for drying

wood or wood chip. There is no backup system present in the boiler house. For the test

programme, the unit was operated by site staff in a routine manner.

3.2 Test equipment

The ambient temperature and pressure surrounding the unit was measured throughout the

test runs, along with the flue gas temperature.

The flue gas was sampled close to the exit of the flue for continuous measurements of CO2,

CO, O2, and NOx by the methods described in ISO 12039:2001, BS EN 15058:2006,

BS EN 14789:2005, and BS EN 14792:2005 using a probe, sample line and gas

conditioning system.

CO2 and CO were analysed using a multi-range infra-red analyser, O2 using a galvanic cell,

and NOx using a chemiluminescence analyser.

In addition, total particulate matter was sampled to the procedure described in

BS EN 13284-1 using an Andersen Universal stack sampler with quartz micro-fibre filter

element of collection efficiency of 99.91% > 0.1 micron.

Details of the actual equipment used are provided in Appendix C.

3.3 Test fuel

The test fuels were wood chip and straw. The fuel was supplied from a fuel store with a

walking floor, via an auger and hydraulic ram, into the combustion area.

Three samples of wood chip were taken at the end of the first day and three samples of

straw at the end of the second. The first two samples of each fuel were fully analysed by

Knight Energy Services (an EN 17025 accredited analytical laboratory) and the results are

shown in Appendix C. The third sample of each fuel was given to Shield On-Site Services.

It was not feasible to stop the automatic fuel feed system, therefore a method of measuring

the fuel feed rate was devised.

Under normal operation the auger and hydraulic ram run for a (pre-programmed) number of

cycles, before pausing and starting again after approx. 1 minute. Fuel samples were taken

by diverting the flow of fuel from the end of the auger into a sample bag for the duration of

Page 8: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 7 of 29

one set of cycles (i.e. approx. 1 minute). The sample was weighed and the corresponding

number of turns made by the auger in this period was recorded.

These measurements were used to estimate an average mass of fuel delivered by

complete turn of the auger.

To determine the fuel feed rate, the auger was monitored during the tests by a video

recording system. The number of turns completed in each test was then used to determine

the total mass of fuel delivered.

3.4 Test procedures

The boiler was tested as per the Kiwa procedures for Boiler Efficiency Testing to

BS 845-1:1987.

The unit was test fired at high for a total of 10 hours each day. Each day three or four

replicate tests were conducted, lasting 30 minutes each.

The gas analysis was logged at 15 second intervals throughout the test. Raw gas data is

available on request. Other measurements were taken at nominal 5 minute intervals.

The boiler output and efficiency were calculated for each 30 minute period by Kiwa

according to the method given in BS 845-1:1987 (the indirect or losses method). Kiwa is

accredited by UKAS to carry out boiler efficiency test work and calculations to this standard.

The radiation, convection and conduction losses from the boiler were calculated according

to Appendix C of BS 845-1:1987.

Continuous measurements of CO2, CO, O2, and NOx were made by Shield On-Site Services

using the methods described above in Section 3.2. Shield On-Site Services is accredited by

UKAS to carry out stack emissions measurements to these standards.

Page 9: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 8 of 29

4 Results and discussion

4.1 Results

Table 1: Boiler performance

(a) Using fuel feed rate

Performance (net) Performance (gross)

Input Output Efficiency Input Output Efficiency

kW kW % kW kW %

Wood chip 705 619 87.8 780 623 80.0

Straw 800 703 87.8 887 708 79.8

(b) Using carbon balance method

Performance (net) Performance (gross)

Input Output Input Output

kW kW kW kW

Wood chip 1158 1026 1281 1033

Straw 697 612 773 617

Output calculated using efficiency derived from BS 845-1:1987 method

(c) Using on-site heat meter

Performance

Output

kW

Wood chip 759

Straw 629

Table 2: Emission rates

Particulate Emission NOx Emission

g/GJ g/GJ

Measured Limit Measured Limit

Wood chip 22.9 30.0 63.3 150.0

Straw 239.1 30.0 135.2 150.0

Summaries of the results for each test are given in Appendices A-B. The emissions report

from Shield On-Site Services and the full chemical analysis of the fuel are given in

Appendix C.

Page 10: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 9 of 29

4.2 Discussion

The emission rates (Table 2) were calculated using the carbon balance method. The wood

chip results are the average of four half-hour tests and the straw results are the average of

three half-hour tests. These values were consistent and reproducible – the relative standard

deviation in the particulate emission values was 14%, and in the NOx emission values was

2%.

The efficiency (calculated using BS 845-1:1987) is also relatively unaffected by small

changes in the estimated energy input, so is suitable for estimating the boiler efficiency

during the tests. The greatest energy losses were due to losses in the flue gas, especially

losses associated with the enthalpy of the water vapour and the sensible heat.

The differences in boiler output obtained with the three methods used (fuel feed rate,

carbon balance and heat meter measurement), make it difficult to make a general

statement about the heat output from the boiler during these tests. Using an average of the

carbon balance output and heat meter measured output for wood chip (the values for which

we have the most confidence), an estimated output of 894kW is yielded.

Therefore, it is likely that the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated fuel feed

system installed at Daff Works, near Inverkip, achieved 85% of its rated output of 990kW

when fired with wood chip.

However, it is not possible to extend this statement to cover the same boiler installed

elsewhere. The reasons for this are:

1. The fuel feed rate method (Table 1a) of calculating the energy input and therefore

the energy output from the boiler is subject to large uncertainties due to the

unpredictable nature of the flow of wood chip and straw fuel through the auger. This

was compounded by the arrangement of the feed auger parallel to the end of the

walking floor. These figures are therefore not suitable for assessing the output of the

boiler.

2. The carbon balance method (Table 1b) is strongly dependent on a number of

measured variables, notably the flue gas composition, the flue gas volume flow rate

and the fuel composition. Small changes in the measured values cause large

variations in the predicted boiler output.

3. The heat meter (Table 1c) was a Kamstrup Multical 602 (MID Class 2) meter and

was connected before the accumulator. However, two issues were noted with the

heat meter:

a. The return temperature sensor lead had been cut and extended with

electrical flex.

b. The flow sensor showed no or reduced flow for the first 10 minutes of the

fourth wood chip tests, which is inconsistent with the pump setting.

Page 11: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 10 of 29

An analysis of the wood chip determined an ash content of only 0.1% (as received), so any

ash formed was neglected. An analysis of the straw determined an ash content of 4.1%.

Although this was higher, the set-up of the boiler meant it was impractical to collect the ash,

so it was also neglected.

5 Conclusions

The Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated fuel feed system installed at Daff

Works, near Inverkip, met the RHI emissions limits of 30 g/GJ (net fuel input) particulate

matter and 150 g/GJ (net fuel input) NOx when fuelled with wood chip.

When fuelled with straw, the boiler met the emission limit for NOx, but exceeded the

emission limit for particulate matter.

It is likely that the boiler achieved 85% of its rated output of 990kW when fired with wood

chip. It is not however possible to extend this statement to cover the same boiler installed

elsewhere.

6 References

BS 845:1987 Parts 1 and 2 Assessing thermal performances of boilers for steam, hot water

and high temperature heat transfer fluids

BS EN13284-1: Stationary source emissions – Manual determination of mass concentration

of particulate matter

Page 12: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 11 of 29

Appendix A: Emission rate calculations for the RHI

Test 1 Wood chip

Test 2 Wood chip

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14628 kJ/kg

O2 VO2 10.77 %

Theoretical flue gas produced 6.77 m3/kg *

Particulate emission 54.10 mg/m3 *

98.80 g/h

NOx emission 134.76 mg/m3 *

N/A g/h

* Reported at reference conditions: 0°C, dry, 10% O2, 101.3 kPa

Particulate emission 25.0 g/GJ

Particulate emission - authorised limit 30 g/GJ

NOx emission 62.4 g/GJ

NOx emission - authorised limit 150 g/GJ

CARBON BALANCE METHOD

Fuel input

Flue gas properties

Emission rates

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14628 kJ/kg

O2 VO2 11.37 %

Theoretical flue gas produced 6.85 m3/kg *

Particulate emission 40.30 mg/m3 *

75.40 g/h

NOx emission 133.96 mg/m3 *

N/A g/h

* Reported at reference conditions: 0°C, dry, 10% O2, 101.3 kPa

Particulate emission 18.9 g/GJ

Particulate emission - authorised limit 30 g/GJ

NOx emission 62.7 g/GJ

NOx emission - authorised limit 150 g/GJ

Flue gas properties

Emission rates

CARBON BALANCE METHOD

Fuel input

Page 13: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 12 of 29

Test 3 Wood chip

Test 4 Wood chip

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14628 kJ/kg

O2 VO2 11.25 %

Theoretical flue gas produced 6.86 m3/kg *

Particulate emission 54.80 mg/m3 *

130.10 g/h

NOx emission 139.32 mg/m3 *

N/A g/h

* Reported at reference conditions: 0°C, dry, 10% O2, 101.3 kPa

Particulate emission 25.7 g/GJ

Particulate emission - authorised limit 30 g/GJ

NOx emission 65.3 g/GJ

NOx emission - authorised limit 150 g/GJ

Flue gas properties

Emission rates

CARBON BALANCE METHOD

Fuel input

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14628 kJ/kg

O2 VO2 12.03 %

Theoretical flue gas produced 6.82 m3/kg *

Particulate emission 47.60 mg/m3 *

80.30 g/h

NOx emission 134.79 mg/m3 *

N/A g/h

* Reported at reference conditions: 0°C, dry, 10% O2, 101.3 kPa

Particulate emission 22.2 g/GJ

Particulate emission - authorised limit 30 g/GJ

NOx emission 62.9 g/GJ

NOx emission - authorised limit 150 g/GJ

Flue gas properties

Emission rates

CARBON BALANCE METHOD

Fuel input

Page 14: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 13 of 29

Test 5 Straw

Test 6 Straw

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14260 kJ/kg

O2 VO2 11.69 %

Theoretical flue gas produced 7.14 m3/kg *

Particulate emission 476.30 mg/m3 *

873.60 g/h

NOx emission 262.70 mg/m3 *

N/A g/h

* Reported at reference conditions: 0°C, dry, 10% O2, 101.3 kPa

Particulate emission 238.4 g/GJ

Particulate emission - authorised limit 30 g/GJ

NOx emission 131.5 g/GJ

NOx emission - authorised limit 150 g/GJ

Flue gas properties

Emission rates

CARBON BALANCE METHOD

Fuel input

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14260 kJ/kg

O2 VO2 11.74 %

Theoretical flue gas produced 7.17 m3/kg *

Particulate emission 448.50 mg/m3 *

750.70 g/h

NOx emission 287.68 mg/m3 *

N/A g/h

* Reported at reference conditions: 0°C, dry, 10% O2, 101.3 kPa

Particulate emission 225.5 g/GJ

Particulate emission - authorised limit 30 g/GJ

NOx emission 144.7 g/GJ

NOx emission - authorised limit 150 g/GJ

Flue gas properties

Emission rates

CARBON BALANCE METHOD

Fuel input

Page 15: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 14 of 29

Test 7 Straw

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14260 kJ/kg

O2 VO2 11.81 %

Theoretical flue gas produced 7.21 m3/kg *

Particulate emission 500.90 mg/m3 *

933.80 g/h

NOx emission 256.00 mg/m3 *

N/A g/h

* Reported at reference conditions: 0°C, dry, 10% O2, 101.3 kPa

Particulate emission 253.4 g/GJ

Particulate emission - authorised limit 30 g/GJ

NOx emission 129.5 g/GJ

NOx emission - authorised limit 150 g/GJ

Flue gas properties

Emission rates

CARBON BALANCE METHOD

Fuel input

Page 16: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 15 of 29

Appendix B: BS845 boiler efficiency calculations

Test 1 Wood chip

Test length T 1800 seconds

Fuel burnt in test Mf 85 kg

Average fuel feed rate 169 kg/h

Fuel temperature tf 16.6 °C

Calorific value, as received (gross) Qgr 16177 kJ/kg

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14628 kJ/kg

Air humidity 48 %

Ambient air temperature 16.6 °C

Barometric pressure 990 mbar

Temperature of air entering combustion zone ta 16.6 °C

CO CO 116.05 ppm

CO VCO 0.012 %

CO2 VCO2 10.58 %

O2 VO2 10.77 %

Temperature of gases leaving the boiler t3 130.00 °C

Average surface temperature 30.6 °C

Rated useful heat output 1.00 MW

Heat meter 358 kWh

Mass of fuel in Mf 85 kg

Heat supplied by solid fuels (gross) Qi gr 760 kW

Heat supplied by solid fuels (net) Qi net 688 kW

EFFICIENCY TESTING OF BOILERS TO BS845:Part 1:1987 Version 3.1, 12/08/13

Flue gas (dry basis)

MEASUREMENTS

Heat

Fuel CV

Useful heat out

Case surface temperatures

HEAT IN

Page 17: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 16 of 29

Siegret Constant kgr 0.65

knet 0.72

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (gross) L1 gr 6.98 %

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (net) L1 net 7.72 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (gross) L2 gr 10.63 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (net) L2 net 1.80 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (gross) L3 gr 0.07 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (net) L3 net 0.08 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (gross) L4 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (net) L4 net 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (gross) L5 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (net) L5 net 0.00 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (gross) L6 gr 1.63 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (net) L6 net 1.80 %

Total losses (gross) Lt gr 19 %

Total losses (net) Lt net 11 %

Radiation and Convection loss (BS845 % method) QRC 12.39 kW

Radiation and Convection loss (case temperature method) QRC 5.53 kW

Thermal Efficiency (gross) Egr 80.69 %

Thermal Efficiency (net) Enet 88.60 %

Heat meter QN 358 kWh

Heat output from heat meter 716 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (gross) Qc 614 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (net) Qc 609 kW

Calculated Measured Closure

Heat out (gross) 614 716 117%

Heat out (net) 609 716 117%

CLOSURE CHECK

LOSSES METHOD

HEAT OUT

EFFICIENCY

Flue gas loss

Radiation and Convection loss

Page 18: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 17 of 29

Test 2 Wood chip

Test length T 1800 seconds

Fuel burnt in test Mf 85 kg

Average fuel feed rate 169 kg/h

Fuel temperature tf 18.3 °C

Calorific value, as received (gross) Qgr 16177 kJ/kg

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14628 kJ/kg

Air humidity 44 %

Ambient air temperature 18.3 °C

Barometric pressure 991 mbar

Temperature of air entering combustion zone ta 18.3 °C

CO CO 138.94 ppm

CO VCO 0.014 %

CO2 VCO2 9.84 %

O2 VO2 11.37 %

Temperature of gases leaving the boiler t3 129.14 °C

Average surface temperature 35.4 °C

Rated useful heat output 1.00 MW

Heat meter 373 kWh

Mass of fuel in Mf 85 kg

Heat supplied by solid fuels (gross) Qi gr 760 kW

Heat supplied by solid fuels (net) Qi net 687 kW

EFFICIENCY TESTING OF BOILERS TO BS845:Part 1:1987 Version 3.1, 12/08/13

Flue gas (dry basis)

MEASUREMENTS

Heat

Fuel CV

Useful heat out

Case surface temperatures

HEAT IN

Page 19: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 18 of 29

Siegret Constant kgr 0.65

knet 0.72

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (gross) L1 gr 7.34 %

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (net) L1 net 8.11 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (gross) L2 gr 10.59 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (net) L2 net 1.77 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (gross) L3 gr 0.09 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (net) L3 net 0.10 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (gross) L4 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (net) L4 net 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (gross) L5 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (net) L5 net 0.00 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (gross) L6 gr 1.64 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (net) L6 net 1.81 %

Total losses (gross) Lt gr 20 %

Total losses (net) Lt net 12 %

Radiation and Convection loss (BS845 % method) QRC 12.45 kW

Radiation and Convection loss (case temperature method) QRC 7.15 kW

Thermal Efficiency (gross) Egr 80.34 %

Thermal Efficiency (net) Enet 88.21 %

Heat meter QN 373 kWh

Heat output from heat meter 747 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (gross) Qc 611 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (net) Qc 606 kW

Calculated Measured Closure

Heat out (gross) 611 747 122%

Heat out (net) 606 747 123%

CLOSURE CHECK

LOSSES METHOD

HEAT OUT

EFFICIENCY

Flue gas loss

Radiation and Convection loss

Page 20: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 19 of 29

Test 3 Wood chip

Test length T 1800 seconds

Fuel burnt in test Mf 89 kg

Average fuel feed rate 177 kg/h

Fuel temperature tf 17.6 °C

Calorific value, as received (gross) Qgr 16177 kJ/kg

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14628 kJ/kg

Air humidity 51 %

Ambient air temperature 17.6 °C

Barometric pressure 990 mbar

Temperature of air entering combustion zone ta 17.6 °C

CO CO 142.06 ppm

CO VCO 0.014 %

CO2 VCO2 9.95 %

O2 VO2 11.25 %

Temperature of gases leaving the boiler t3 137.14 °C

Average surface temperature 38.0 °C

Rated useful heat output 1.00 MW

Heat meter 378 kWh

Mass of fuel in Mf 89 kg

Heat supplied by solid fuels (gross) Qi gr 798 kW

Heat supplied by solid fuels (net) Qi net 721 kW

EFFICIENCY TESTING OF BOILERS TO BS845:Part 1:1987 Version 3.1, 12/08/13

Flue gas (dry basis)

MEASUREMENTS

Heat

Fuel CV

Useful heat out

Case surface temperatures

HEAT IN

Page 21: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 20 of 29

Siegret Constant kgr 0.65

knet 0.72

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (gross) L1 gr 7.82 %

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (net) L1 net 8.65 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (gross) L2 gr 10.67 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (net) L2 net 1.85 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (gross) L3 gr 0.09 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (net) L3 net 0.10 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (gross) L4 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (net) L4 net 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (gross) L5 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (net) L5 net 0.00 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (gross) L6 gr 1.57 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (net) L6 net 1.74 %

Total losses (gross) Lt gr 20 %

Total losses (net) Lt net 12 %

Radiation and Convection loss (BS845 % method) QRC 12.52 kW

Radiation and Convection loss (case temperature method) QRC 8.76 kW

Thermal Efficiency (gross) Egr 79.84 %

Thermal Efficiency (net) Enet 87.66 %

Heat meter QN 378 kWh

Heat output from heat meter 757 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (gross) Qc 637 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (net) Qc 632 kW

Calculated Measured Closure

Heat out (gross) 637 757 119%

Heat out (net) 632 757 120%

CLOSURE CHECK

LOSSES METHOD

HEAT OUT

EFFICIENCY

Flue gas loss

Radiation and Convection loss

Page 22: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 21 of 29

Test 4 Wood chip

Test length T 1800 seconds

Fuel burnt in test Mf 89 kg

Average fuel feed rate 178 kg/h

Fuel temperature tf 17.2 °C

Calorific value, as received (gross) Qgr 16177 kJ/kg

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14628 kJ/kg

Air humidity 52 %

Ambient air temperature 17.2 °C

Barometric pressure 989 mbar

Temperature of air entering combustion zone ta 17.2 °C

CO CO 106.88 ppm

CO VCO 0.011 %

CO2 VCO2 9.20 %

O2 VO2 12.03 %

Temperature of gases leaving the boiler t3 139.50 °C

Average surface temperature 38.9 °C

Rated useful heat output 1.00 MW

Heat meter 407 kWh

Mass of fuel in Mf 89 kg

Heat supplied by solid fuels (gross) Qi gr 801 kW

Heat supplied by solid fuels (net) Qi net 724 kW

EFFICIENCY TESTING OF BOILERS TO BS845:Part 1:1987 Version 3.1, 12/08/13

Flue gas (dry basis)

MEASUREMENTS

Heat

Fuel CV

Useful heat out

Case surface temperatures

HEAT IN

Page 23: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 22 of 29

Siegret Constant kgr 0.65

knet 0.72

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (gross) L1 gr 8.65 %

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (net) L1 net 9.57 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (gross) L2 gr 10.70 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (net) L2 net 1.88 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (gross) L3 gr 0.08 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (net) L3 net 0.08 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (gross) L4 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (net) L4 net 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (gross) L5 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (net) L5 net 0.00 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (gross) L6 gr 1.58 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (net) L6 net 1.75 %

Total losses (gross) Lt gr 21 %

Total losses (net) Lt net 13 %

Radiation and Convection loss (BS845 % method) QRC 12.66 kW

Radiation and Convection loss (case temperature method) QRC 9.41 kW

Thermal Efficiency (gross) Egr 79.00 %

Thermal Efficiency (net) Enet 86.72 %

Heat meter QN 407 kWh

Heat output from heat meter 815 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (gross) Qc 633 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (net) Qc 628 kW

Calculated Measured Closure

Heat out (gross) 633 815 129%

Heat out (net) 628 815 130%

CLOSURE CHECK

LOSSES METHOD

HEAT OUT

EFFICIENCY

Flue gas loss

Radiation and Convection loss

Page 24: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 23 of 29

Test 5 Straw

Test length T 1800 seconds

Fuel burnt in test Mf 101 kg

Average fuel feed rate 202 kg/h

Fuel temperature tf 15.7 °C

Calorific value, as received (gross) Qgr 15818 kJ/kg

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14260 kJ/kg

Air humidity 66 %

Ambient air temperature 15.7 °C

Barometric pressure 987 mbar

Temperature of air entering combustion zone ta 15.7 °C

CO CO 344.67 ppm

CO VCO 0.034 %

CO2 VCO2 8.86 %

O2 VO2 11.69 %

Temperature of gases leaving the boiler t3 123.67 °C

Average surface temperature 36.3 °C

Rated useful heat output 1.00 MW

Heat meter 331 kWh

Mass of fuel in Mf 101 kg

Heat supplied by solid fuels (gross) Qi gr 889 kW

Heat supplied by solid fuels (net) Qi net 801 kW

EFFICIENCY TESTING OF BOILERS TO BS845:Part 1:1987 Version 3.1, 12/08/13

Flue gas (dry basis)

MEASUREMENTS

Heat

Fuel CV

Useful heat out

Case surface temperatures

HEAT IN

Page 25: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 24 of 29

Siegret Constant kgr 0.65

knet 0.72

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (gross) L1 gr 7.90 %

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (net) L1 net 8.76 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (gross) L2 gr 10.91 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (net) L2 net 1.82 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (gross) L3 gr 0.25 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (net) L3 net 0.28 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (gross) L4 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (net) L4 net 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (gross) L5 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (net) L5 net 0.00 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (gross) L6 gr 1.42 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (net) L6 net 1.57 %

Total losses (gross) Lt gr 20 %

Total losses (net) Lt net 12 %

Radiation and Convection loss (BS845 % method) QRC 12.57 kW

Radiation and Convection loss (case temperature method) QRC 8.80 kW

Thermal Efficiency (gross) Egr 79.52 %

Thermal Efficiency (net) Enet 87.56 %

Heat meter QN 331 kWh

Heat output from heat meter 662 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (gross) Qc 707 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (net) Qc 701 kW

Calculated Measured Closure

Heat out (gross) 707 662 94%

Heat out (net) 701 662 94%

CLOSURE CHECK

LOSSES METHOD

HEAT OUT

EFFICIENCY

Flue gas loss

Radiation and Convection loss

Page 26: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 25 of 29

Test 6 Straw

Test length T 1800 seconds

Fuel burnt in test Mf 101 kg

Average fuel feed rate 202 kg/h

Fuel temperature tf 16.3 °C

Calorific value, as received (gross) Qgr 15818 kJ/kg

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14260 kJ/kg

Air humidity 65 %

Ambient air temperature 16.3 °C

Barometric pressure 987 mbar

Temperature of air entering combustion zone ta 16.3 °C

CO CO 256.07 ppm

CO VCO 0.026 %

CO2 VCO2 8.78 %

O2 VO2 11.74 %

Temperature of gases leaving the boiler t3 117.71 °C

Average surface temperature 36.2 °C

Rated useful heat output 1.00 MW

Heat meter 302 kWh

Mass of fuel in Mf 101 kg

Heat supplied by solid fuels (gross) Qi gr 887 kW

Heat supplied by solid fuels (net) Qi net 799 kW

EFFICIENCY TESTING OF BOILERS TO BS845:Part 1:1987 Version 3.1, 12/08/13

Flue gas (dry basis)

MEASUREMENTS

Heat

Fuel CV

Useful heat out

Case surface temperatures

HEAT IN

Page 27: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 26 of 29

Siegret Constant kgr 0.65

knet 0.72

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (gross) L1 gr 7.48 %

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (net) L1 net 8.30 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (gross) L2 gr 10.85 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (net) L2 net 1.75 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (gross) L3 gr 0.19 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (net) L3 net 0.21 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (gross) L4 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (net) L4 net 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (gross) L5 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (net) L5 net 0.00 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (gross) L6 gr 1.41 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (net) L6 net 1.56 %

Total losses (gross) Lt gr 20 %

Total losses (net) Lt net 12 %

Radiation and Convection loss (BS845 % method) QRC 12.49 kW

Radiation and Convection loss (case temperature method) QRC 8.44 kW

Thermal Efficiency (gross) Egr 80.07 %

Thermal Efficiency (net) Enet 88.17 %

Heat meter QN 302 kWh

Heat output from heat meter 603 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (gross) Qc 710 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (net) Qc 705 kW

Calculated Measured Closure

Heat out (gross) 710 603 85%

Heat out (net) 705 603 86%

CLOSURE CHECK

LOSSES METHOD

HEAT OUT

EFFICIENCY

Flue gas loss

Radiation and Convection loss

Page 28: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 27 of 29

Test 7 Straw

Test length T 1800 seconds

Fuel burnt in test Mf 101 kg

Average fuel feed rate 202 kg/h

Fuel temperature tf 17.0 °C

Calorific value, as received (gross) Qgr 15818 kJ/kg

Calorific value, as received (net) Qnet 14260 kJ/kg

Air humidity 65 %

Ambient air temperature 17.0 °C

Barometric pressure 987 mbar

Temperature of air entering combustion zone ta 17.0 °C

CO CO 377.94 ppm

CO VCO 0.038 %

CO2 VCO2 8.65 %

O2 VO2 11.81 %

Temperature of gases leaving the boiler t3 119.86 °C

Average surface temperature 40.4 °C

Rated useful heat output 1.00 MW

Heat meter 310 kWh

Mass of fuel in Mf 101 kg

Heat supplied by solid fuels (gross) Qi gr 886 kW

Heat supplied by solid fuels (net) Qi net 799 kW

EFFICIENCY TESTING OF BOILERS TO BS845:Part 1:1987 Version 3.1, 12/08/13

Flue gas (dry basis)

MEASUREMENTS

Heat

Fuel CV

Useful heat out

Case surface temperatures

HEAT IN

Page 29: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 28 of 29

Siegret Constant kgr 0.65

knet 0.72

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (gross) L1 gr 7.71 %

Loss due to sensible heat in dry flue gases (net) L1 net 8.55 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (gross) L2 gr 10.85 %

Loss due to enthalpy in the water vapour in the flue gases (net) L2 net 1.76 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (gross) L3 gr 0.28 %

Loss due to unburned gases in the flue gases (net) L3 net 0.31 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (gross) L4 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in ash and riddlings (net) L4 net 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (gross) L5 gr 0.00 %

Loss due to combustible matter in grit and dust (net) L5 net 0.00 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (gross) L6 gr 1.42 %

Radiation, convection and conduction losses (net) L6 net 1.57 %

Total losses (gross) Lt gr 20 %

Total losses (net) Lt net 12 %

Radiation and Convection loss (BS845 % method) QRC 12.54 kW

Radiation and Convection loss (case temperature method) QRC 10.31 kW

Thermal Efficiency (gross) Egr 79.74 %

Thermal Efficiency (net) Enet 87.81 %

Heat meter QN 310 kWh

Heat output from heat meter 621 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (gross) Qc 707 kW

Heat output using thermal efficiency (net) Qc 701 kW

Calculated Measured Closure

Heat out (gross) 707 621 88%

Heat out (net) 701 621 88%

CLOSURE CHECK

LOSSES METHOD

HEAT OUT

EFFICIENCY

Flue gas loss

Radiation and Convection loss

Page 30: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Shield On-Site Services 30344 / 14 November 2013

© Kiwa Ltd 2013 Page 29 of 29

Appendix C: Enclosures

Enclosure

number Description Pages

1 Emissions measurements: wood chip

Partner’s report: Shield On-Site Services

Enc. 1–57

2 Emissions measurements: straw

Partner’s report: Shield On-Site Services

Enc. 58–114

3 Fuel analysis: wood chip and straw

Subcontractor’s report: Knight Energy Services

Enc. 115–118

Page 31: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 1 of 57

Client Topling LtdArchway OfficeWoodendDunsBerwickshireTD11 3QW

Part 1: Executive Summary

Report for the Periodic Monitoring of Emissions to Air.

Site InverkipPlant Biomass Boiler Main Stack - WoodchipSampling Date 1st October 2013Report Date 6th November 2013Job Number EMGJ02486Permit Number N/A

Report Prepared by: Print Derek Myers

MCERTS No. MM 02 115 Level 2 TE: 1,2,3,4

Report Approved by: Sign

Print Derek Myers

MCERTS No. MM 02 115 Level 2 TE: 1,2,3,4

10 Broad LaneMoldgreenHuddersfieldHD5 9BX

Tel: 0845 0349 3601783 Fax: 01484 545 577

Shield On-Site Services - Industrial Emissions

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00001

Page 32: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 2 of 57

Page 1 Part 1: Executive SummaryPage 2 ContentsPage 3 Monitoring ObjectivesPage 3 Special Monitoring RequirementsPage 3 Summary Of MethodsPage 4 Summary Of ResultsPage 5 Results, ContinuedPage 6 Operating InformationPage 6 Comments On Monitoring Procedures

Page 7 Part 2: Supporting Information

Page 8 Appendix 1Page 9 Emission Monitoring Procedures and InstrumentationPage 10 Sampling PersonnelPage 10 Equipment ReferencesPage 10 Subcontracted Analysis

Page 11 Appendix 2Page 12 Prelimanary Velocity Traverse & Moisture DataPage 13 Exhaust Gases - Continuous Analysis DataPage 14 Exhaust Gases - Continuous Analysis Data, ContinuedPage 15 Exhaust Gases - PlotPage 16 Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data, Test 1Page 17 Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data, Test 2Page 18 Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data, Test 3Page 19 Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data, Test 4Page 20 Total Particulate Matter - Emission Results Test 1 to 3Page 21 Condensable Particulate Matter - Emission Results Test 1 to 3Page 22 Total Particulate Matter - Emission Results Test 4 Page 23 PM2.5 - Sampling Data, Test 1Page 24 PM2.5 - Emission Results, Test 1Page 25 PM2.5 - Sampling Data, Test 2Page 26 PM2.5 - Emission Results, Test 2Page 27 PM2.5 - Sampling Data, Test 3Page 28 PM2.5 - Emission Results, Test 3Page 29 PM10 - Sampling Data, Test 1Page 30 PM10 - Emission Results, Test 1Page 31 PM10 - Sampling Data, Test 2Page 32 PM10 - Emission Results, Test 2Page 33 PM10 - Sampling Data, Test 3Page 34 PM10 - Emission Results, Test 3

Page 35 Appendix 3Page 36 Diagram of Sampling LocationPage 37 Generic CalculationsPage 38 Flow CalculationsPage 39 Concentration CalculationPage 40 Uncertainty Estimate Calculations - Maunual TechniquesPage 41 Uncertainty Estimate Calculations - Instrumental Techniques

Page 42 Appendix 4Page 43 Uncertainty Estimates:- OxygenPage 44 Uncertainty Estimates:- Carbon DioxidePage 45 Uncertainty Estimates:- Carbon MonoxidePage 46 Uncertainty Estimates:- Oxides of NitrogenPage 47 Uncertainty Estimates:- TOCPage 48 Uncertainty Estimates:- Total Particulate Matter, Test 1Page 49 Uncertainty Estimates:- Total Particulate Matter, Test 2Page 50 Uncertainty Estimates:- Total Particulate Matter, Test 3Page 51 Uncertainty Estimates:- Total Particulate Matter, Test 4Page 52 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM2.5, Test 1Page 53 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM2.5, Test 2Page 54 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM2.5, Test 3Page 55 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM10, Test 1Page 56 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM10, Test 2Page 57 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM10, Test 3

Contents

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00002

Page 33: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 3 of 57

The monitoring was undertaken to check compliance with authorised emission limits.

Monitoring was undertaken for the listed emissions from the following sampling positions:

ParticulatesPM2.5PM10Condensable ParticulatesOxygenCarbon dioxideCarbon monoxideOxides of nitrogenTotal organic carbon

There were no special requirements for this monitoring campaign.

Particulate BS ISO 9096 : 2003Particulate - PM10 & PM2.5 US EPA Method 201aGas velocity BS EN 13284 : 2002Water vapour BS EN 14790 : 2005Oxygen BS EN 14789 : 2005Carbon dioxide ISO 12039 : 2001Carbon monoxide BS EN 15058 : 2006Oxides of nitrogen BS EN 14792 : 2005TOC BS EN 12619 : 2013Condensable Particulates US EPA Method 202Based on TPM50N

TPM/13TPM/41

TPM/37TPM/39TPM/15TPM/40

TPM/05TPM/22TPM/01

Emission Method number Method standard

Summary of Methods

Biomass Boiler Main Stack - Woodchip

Special Monitoring Requirements

All monitoring procedures were carried out to the MCERTS requirements under Shield On-Site Services qualitysystem to ISO 17025: 2005.

Sampling Location Emission

Monitoring Objectives

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00003

Page 34: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 4 of 57

The table presents the atmospheric emissions from the tests undertaken on behalf of Topling LtdThe results were measured from the sample positions downstream of the arrestment plant.

Emission Authorised Uncertainty Detection Result Limit +/- Limit

Date Start End mg/m3* mg/m3* mg/m3* mg/m3*

Carbon monoxide 01/10/13 10:05 17:51 200.8 0 11.1 0.4Oxides of nitrogen 01/10/13 10:05 17:51 133.6 0 7.8 1.1TOC 01/10/13 10:05 17:51 9.5 0 1.2 0.2Particulate (Test 1) 01/10/13 11:05 11:35 54.1 0 2.4 2.55Particulate (Test 2) 01/10/13 12:35 13:05 40.3 0 1.8 1.48Particulate (Test 3) 01/10/13 15:20 15:50 54.8 0 2.5 1.23Particulate (Test 4) 01/10/13 16:55 17:25 47.6 0 2.4 1.61Condensable Particulate (Test 1) 01/10/13 11:05 11:35 21.9 0 2.4 2.55Condensable Particulate (Test 2) 01/10/13 12:35 13:05 17.2 0 1.8 1.48Condensable Particulate (Test 3) 01/10/13 15:20 15:50 12.5 0 2.5 1.23PM10 (Test 1) 01/10/13 11:05 11:35 46.9 N/A 2.8 1.36PM10 (Test 2) 01/10/13 12:41 13:11 24.6 N/A 1.6 1.18PM10 (Test 3) 01/10/13 13:58 14:28 12.7 N/A 0.8 1.14PM2.5 (Test 1) 01/10/13 14:15 14:45 18.5 N/A 1.2 1.18PM2.5 (Test 2) 01/10/13 15:30 16:00 50.9 N/A 3.1 1.32PM2.5 (Test 3) 01/10/13 17:12 17:42 27.6 N/A 1.9 1.34

Date Start End % vol % vol % vol % volOxygen 01/10/13 10:05 17:51 11.3 - 0.4 0.10Carbon dioxide 01/10/13 10:05 17:51 9.8 - 0.4 0.10

* at reference conditions Stack Gas Weight 0 oC

29.00 Kg/kmol 101.3 kPa Oxygen %

Where applicable Oxides of nitrogen results are expressed as nitrogen dioxideTOC results are expressed as total carbon

Throughout Report: * Reference conditions (see above) Nm³ 273 K, 101.3 kPa** Analysis not required # - UKAS accredited onlyND Non detectable ## - Not Accrediteds - Subcontracted laboratory analysis N/A Not applicable

The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor k=2, providing a 95% confidence level. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

46.2

All tests included in this report are accredited under UKAS and MCERTS accreditation schemes unless otherwise stated. Opinions and interpretations expressed herein are outside the scope of MCERTS and UKAS accreditation.

58.7

1783

kg/h-

373.5

Dry Gas

Summary Of Results

10

44.9

73.8

106.0

80.3

129.3

40.032.329.7

18.498.875.4130.1

392.4259.1

Biomass Boiler Main Stack - Woodchip

MassInverkip Time Emission

Emission at Sampling

g/h

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00004

Page 35: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 5 of 57

The table presents the atmospheric emissions from the tests undertaken on behalf of Topling LtdThe results were measured from the sample positions downstream of the arrestment plant.

Emission Authorised Uncertainty Detection Mass

Result Limit +/- Limit Emission

Date Start End mg/m3* mg/m3* mg/m3* mg/m3* g/h

Carbon monoxide Test 1 01/10/13 10:05 11:05 142.3 0 8.1 0.4 259.7

Carbon monoxide Test 2 01/10/13 11:05 12:05 159.3 0 8.7 0.4 290.7

Carbon monoxide Test 3 01/10/13 12:05 13:05 176.2 0 9.7 0.4 330.2

Carbon monoxide Test 4 01/10/13 13:05 14:05 381.2 0 20.9 0.4 714.2

Carbon monoxide Test 5 01/10/13 14:05 15:05 191.5 0 10.4 0.4 454.3

Carbon monoxide Test 6 01/10/13 15:05 16:05 221.6 0 11.8 0.4 525.7

Carbon monoxide Test 7 01/10/13 16:05 17:05 164.4 0 9.0 0.4 277.7

Carbon monoxide Test 8 01/10/13 17:05 17:51 169.9 0 9.7 0.4 287.0

Oxides of nitrogen Test 1 01/10/13 10:05 11:05 143.5 0 8.1 1.1 261.9

Oxides of nitrogen Test 2 01/10/13 11:05 12:05 131.6 0 7.5 1.1 240.2

Oxides of nitrogen Test 3 01/10/13 12:05 13:05 134.7 0 7.9 1.1 252.4

Oxides of nitrogen Test 4 01/10/13 13:05 14:05 131.6 0 8.2 1.1 246.5

Oxides of nitrogen Test 5 01/10/13 14:05 15:05 129.7 0 7.6 1.1 307.8

Oxides of nitrogen Test 6 01/10/13 15:05 16:05 133.9 0 7.9 1.1 317.6

Oxides of nitrogen Test 7 01/10/13 16:05 17:05 132.9 0 7.6 1.1 224.4

Oxides of nitrogen Test 8 01/10/13 17:05 17:51 131.2 0 7.9 1.1 221.6

TOC Test 1 01/10/13 10:05 11:05 7.2 0 1.2 0.2 13.2

TOC Test 2 01/10/13 11:05 12:05 6.1 0 1.2 0.2 11.2

TOC Test 3 01/10/13 12:05 13:05 7.6 0 1.2 0.2 14.2

TOC Test 4 01/10/13 13:05 14:05 29.4 0 1.3 0.2 55.1

TOC Test 5 01/10/13 14:05 15:05 8.3 0 1.2 0.2 19.6

TOC Test 6 01/10/13 15:05 16:05 7.0 0 1.2 0.2 16.6

TOC Test 7 01/10/13 16:05 17:05 4.9 0 1.2 0.2 8.3

TOC Test 8 01/10/13 17:05 17:51 5.6 0 1.2 0.2 9.4

Date Start End % % % % kg/h

Oxygen Test 1 01/10/13 10:05 11:05 11.1 - 0.4 0.1 -

Oxygen Test 2 01/10/13 11:05 12:05 10.9 - 0.4 0.1 -

Oxygen Test 3 01/10/13 12:05 13:05 11.3 - 0.4 0.1 -

Oxygen Test 4 01/10/13 13:05 14:05 12.1 - 0.5 0.1 -

Oxygen Test 5 01/10/13 14:05 15:05 11.3 - 0.4 0.1 -

Oxygen Test 6 01/10/13 15:05 16:05 11.4 - 0.4 0.1 -

Oxygen Test 7 01/10/13 16:05 17:05 11.0 - 0.4 0.1 -

Oxygen Test 8 01/10/13 17:05 17:51 11.7 - 0.5 0.1 -

Carbon dioxide Test 1 01/10/13 10:05 11:05 10.3 - 0.4 0.10 367.7

Carbon dioxide Test 2 01/10/13 11:05 12:05 10.4 - 0.4 0.10 372.0

Carbon dioxide Test 3 01/10/13 12:05 13:05 9.9 - 0.4 0.10 363.6

Carbon dioxide Test 4 01/10/13 13:05 14:05 9.0 - 0.4 0.10 332.3

Carbon dioxide Test 5 01/10/13 14:05 15:05 9.7 - 0.4 0.1 454.0

Carbon dioxide Test 6 01/10/13 15:05 16:05 9.7 - 0.4 0.1 451.6

Carbon dioxide Test 7 01/10/13 16:05 17:05 10.0 - 0.4 0.1 333.2

Carbon dioxide Test 8 01/10/13 17:05 17:51 9.4 - 0.4 0.1 313.2

* at ref Stack Gas Weight 0 oC Dry Gas

Conditions 29.00 Kg/kmol 101.3 kpa Oxygen 10 %

Where applicable Oxides of nitrogen results are expressed as nitrogen dioxide

TOC results are expressed as total carbon

Throughout Report: * Reference conditions (see above) Nm³ 273 K, 101.3 kPa

** Analysis not required # - UKAS accredited only

ND Non detectable ## - Not Accredited

s - Subcontracted laboratory analysis N/A Not applicable

The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor k=2, providing

a 95% confidence level. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Summary Of Results

Biomass Boiler Main Stack - Woodchip

All tests included in this report are accredited under UKAS and MCERTS accreditation schemes unless otherwise stated. Opinions and interpretations expressed herein are outside the scope of MCERTS and UKAS accreditation.

1783

Emission at Sampling

Inverkip Time

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00005

Page 36: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 6 of 57

The tables below shows details of the operating information on each sampling date for: Biomass Boiler Main Stack - Woodchip

Date Process Fuel Feedstock Loadduration

01/10/2013 N/A

A waste gas homogeneity test to BS EN 15259:2007 (MID) is not required:-The homogeneity test is not applicable to duct areas less than 1m2.All monitoring was performed in accordance with the relevant procedures. Except PM10 and PM2.5 which were sampled from a centre point.

The velocity and temperature profile at the sampling location met the requirements of BS EN 13284-1: 2002.

The calculated particulate emission level was greater than the control blank.

Sampling was conducted from a single point in the duct due to the limited clearance and scaffolding restrictions.

85%

The particulate monitoring was within the required 95 to 115 % isokinetic rate as stated in BS EN 13284-1: 2002

Operating Information

Comments & Monitoring Deviations

When the results that are expressed as non-detected the mass emission has been calculated from the detection limit and therefore they are worscase results.

Process type Abatement

Biomass Boiler Continuous Woodchip Cyclone

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00006

Page 37: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 7 of 57

Part 2: Supporting Information

Report for the Periodic Monitoring of Emissions to Air.

Client Topling LtdSite InverkipPlant Biomass Boiler Main Stack - WoodchipSampling Date 1st October 2013Report Date 6th November 2013Job Number EMGJ02486Permit Number N/A

Report Prepared by: Print Derek Myers

MCERTS No. MM 02 115 Level 2 TE: 1,2,3,4

Report Approved by: Sign

Print Derek Myers

MCERTS No. MM 02 115 Level 2 TE: 1,2,3,4

10 Broad LaneMoldgreenHuddersfieldHD5 9BX

Tel: 0845 0349 3601783 Fax: 01484 545 577

Shield On-Site Services - Industrial Emissions

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00007

Page 38: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 8 of 57

APPENDIX 1

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00008

Page 39: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 9 of 57

Gas velocity and temperature

Water vapour

Total particulate matter

Oxygen

Carbon dioxide

Carbon monoxide

Oxides of nitrogen

Total organic carbon

Emission Monitoring Procedures And Instrumentation

Documented in-house procedure TPM/05 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN ISO 9096:2003. Stackgases are extracted from representative sampling points at isokinetic flow rates through a sharp-edged nozzle.Particulate matter is collected on a pre-weighed filter conditioned at 180oC. Deposits upstream of the filter are alsorecovered and weighed. The increase of mass of the filter and mass collected upstream of the filter is divided by thevolume sampled to determine the mass concentration.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/01 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 13284:2002. Velocity andtemperature measurements are performed using a calibrated Pitot tube, as described in BS ISO 10780:1994 and acalibrated thermocouple. Velocity and possible flow deviation measurements are carried out at selected,representative points in the gas stream.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/37 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 14790:2005. A measuredvolume of gas is extracted from the gas stream through a moisture trapping unit. The mass gain of moisture trappedis divided by the volume of gas sampled to determine the mass concentration of water vapour. For water saturatedstacks the temperature of the gas stream is measured and the water vapour concentration is determined using liquid-gas equilibrium tables. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/39 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 14789:2005. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line, gas conditioning system, and a paramagnetic, zirconium cell, or electrochemicalcell analyser. The analytical equipment detailed above is calibrated before and during the tests using certified gasmixtures of nitrogen and oxygen. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/15 to the main procedural requirements ISO 12039:2001. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line, gas conditioning system, and multi range infra-red analyser. The analyticalequipment detailed above is calibrated before and during the tests using certified gas mixtures of nitrogen andcarbon dioxide. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259 assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/13 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 12619:2013. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line and multi range Flame Ionisation Detector (FID) analyser. The analyser iscalibrated before and during the tests using certified gas mixtures of nitrogen and propane. Sampling points areselected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259 assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/40 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 15058:2006. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line, gas conditioning system, and multi range infra-red analyser. The analyticalequipment detailed above is calibrated before and during the tests using certified gas mixtures of nitrogen andcarbon monoxide. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259 assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/41 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN14792:2005. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line, gas conditioning system and multi range chemiluminescent analyser. Theanalytical equipment detailed above is calibrated before and during the tests using certified gas mixtures of nitrogenand NO. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259 assessment.

PM10 & PM2.5Documented in–house procedure TPM/22 to the main procedural requirements of US EPA Method 201A using anAndersen universal stack sampler, with an in-stack quartz micro-fibre filter and PM10 or PM2.5 separator cyclone.Stack gases sampled at a constant flow at calculated dwell times across the duct. Stack gas sampled through asharp edged nozzle into a particulate separator cyclone, PM10 or PM2.5 collected on a filter with a collectionefficiency of 99.91 % > 0.1 micron.

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00009

Page 40: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 10 of 57

MCERTS No Level 1 Level 2 TE1 TE2 TE3 TE4Report prepared by: Derek Myers MM 02 115 - 30/11/2013 31/05/2018 30/11/2018 30/11/2013 30/11/2013

Report authorised by: Derek Myers MM 02 115 - 30/11/2013 31/05/2018 30/11/2018 30/11/2013 30/11/2013

Team leader: Gary Thackray MM 02 078 - 31/10/2014 31/03/2018 30/10/2014 31/08/2015 31/08/2015

Team leader: Chris Rhodes MM 02 117 - 31/08/2013 28/02/2018 28/02/2018 31/08/2013 31/12/2013

Team leader: Derek Myers MM 02 115 - 30/11/2013 31/05/2018 30/11/2018 30/11/2013 30/11/2013

CA21VC17

HLB01P50, P58 & P52

TP50, TP58 &TP52TS50, TS58 & TS52

CU16 & CU9ST30MET

PT137, PT114 , PT47CV14

TV17 & TV06Laptop

CU16/03 & CU09/03CU16/1 & CU09/1

BL20W33 & W34

Laboratory: Scientific Analysis Laboratories

Parameters: Particulates ( Gravimetric 5 decimal) Condensable Matter ( Gravimetric )

Accreditation: UKAS Accredited testing laboratory number 1549

ManometerBalanceWeights

Subcontracted Analysis

Impinger ThermocoupleSample Rate Calculation Equipment

Thermometer

Timer / StopwatchBarometer

PitotCallipers

ProbeProbe ThermocoupleStack Thermocouple

Control Box

Gas AnalyserFID

Heated Line

Sampling Project Personnel Competency And Expiry Dates

Equipment References

Equipment Reference Number

Shield On-Site Services has, with your approval, used the following sub-contracted laboratories for the laboratory analyses referencedbelow:

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00010

Page 41: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 11 of 57

APPENDIX 2

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00011

Page 42: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 12 of 57

Date 30/09/2013 Barometric pressure 99.6 kPa Stack Diameter (circular) 0.54 m

Time 17:40 Duct static pressure 0.01 kPa m

Pitot Cp 0.77 Stack Area 0.229 m2 m

Oxygen 11.3 % Carbon dioxide %

Traverse Traverse Depth ΔP T Angle velocity Traverse Depth ΔP T Angle velocity

Point Line cm mmH2O oC o m/s Line cm mmH2O oC o m/s

1 A 5.0 0.9 90 <15 3.2 B 5.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4

2 A 5.0 0.9 90 <15 3.2 B 5.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4

3 A 6.4 0.8 90 <15 3.0 B 6.4 0.9 90 <15 3.2

4 A 9.6 0.5 90 <15 2.6 B 9.6 0.6 90 <15 2.8

5 A 13.5 0.9 90 <15 3.2 B 13.5 1.0 90 <15 3.4

6 A 19.2 1.2 90 <15 3.8 B 19.2 1.6 90 <15 4.4

7 A 34.8 1.0 90 <15 3.4 B 34.8 1.8 90 <15 4.7

8 A 40.5 1.3 90 <15 4.0 B 40.5 1.9 90 <15 4.8

9 A 44.4 1.1 90 <15 3.6 B 44.4 1.3 90 <15 4.0

10 A 47.6 1.2 90 <15 3.8 B 47.6 1.1 90 <15 3.6

11 A 49.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4 B 49.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4

12 A 49.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4 B 49.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4

Average Pitot DP 1.04 mmH2O

Average Temperature 363.2 K

Average Velocity 3.6 m/s

Average volumetric flow rate 0.82 m3/s at stack conditions

Average volumetric flow rate 0.60 m3/s (wet STP)

Average volumetric flow rate 0.51 m3/s (dry STP)

Average volumetric flow rate 0.45 m3/s (dry, STP, reference oxygen concentraion)

Sampling plane requirements Re: BS EN 13284-1:2001 5.2

a Angel of gas flow less than 15o with regard to duct axis YES

b No local negative flow YES

c Minimum pitot greater than 5Pa YES

d Ratio of highest to lowest local gas velocity less than 3:1 YES

Minimum local gas velocity 2.6

Maximum local gas velocity 4.8

Ratio of highest to lowest local gas velocity 1.90

Prelimanary Velocity Traverse Data

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00012

Page 43: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 13 of 57Date 01/10/2013

From 10:05 to 11:05 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 102.68 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 63.05 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 4.05 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide vppm, dry 10.26Oxygen %, dry 11.08

From 11:05 to 12:05 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 116.80 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 58.76 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 3.49 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide vppm, dry 10.38

Oxygen %, dry 10.92

.

From 12:05 to 13:05 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 124.06 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 57.72 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 4.14 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 9.88Oxygen %, dry 11.32

From 13:05 to 14:05 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 246.63 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 51.81 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 14.79 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide vppm, dry 9.03Oxygen %, dry 12.10

Sampling Detection Limits

Carbon dioxide % 0.10

Oxygen % 0.10

Carbon monoxide vppm 0.26 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm 0.47 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm 0.10 mg/m³*

Reference Gas Details

Species Units Value Uncertainityk = 2

Carbon dioxide* % 7.41 5701338 20 ± 2

Carbon monoxide vppm 411.00 236924 1000 ± 2

Oxygen* % 10.35 5701338 25 ± 2

Nitrogen % 99.999 VC035033 - ± 2Oxides of nitrogen vppm 417.00 236924 500 ± 2Volatile organic compounds vppm 10.10 195025 1000 ± 2

* Gas divider used

Zero And Span Gas Details

Species units Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.02 7.43

Carbon monoxide vppm 0.00 411.00 -2.00 410.00

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Oxides of nitrogen vppm 0.00 417.00 0.00 418.00

Volatile organic compounds vppm 0.00 10.10 0.10 10.20

Exhaust Gas Continuous Analysis Data

0.20

Cylinder Reference Analyser Range

29.39

0.361.07

381.20131.57

134.707.56

6.12

176.23

7.22

159.27131.64

142.27143.52

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00013

Page 44: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 14 of 57Date 01/10/2013

From 14:05 to 15:05 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 135.00 mg/m³*

Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 55.68 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 4.53 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 9.74

Oxygen %, dry 11.31

From 15:05 to 16:05 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 155.24 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 57.09 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 3.82 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 9.69

Oxygen %, dry 11.37

.

From 16:05 to 17:05 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 119.78 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 58.93 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 2.79 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 10.04

Oxygen %, dry 10.98

From 17:05 to 17:51 47 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 115.54 mg/m³*

Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 54.31 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 2.94 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 9.44

Oxygen %, dry 11.65

Sampling Detection Limits

Carbon dioxide % 0.10

Oxygen % 0.10

Carbon monoxide vppm 0.26 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm 0.47 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm 0.10 mg/m³*

Reference Gas Details

Species Units Value Uncertainityk = 2

Carbon dioxide % 7.41 5701338 20 ± 2

Carbon monoxide vppm 411.00 236924 1000 ± 2

Oxygen % 10.35 5701338 25 ± 2

Nitrogen % 99.999 VC035033 - ± 2

Oxides of nitrogen vppm 417.00 236924 500 ± 2Volatile organic compounds vppm 10.10 195025 1000 ± 2

Zero And Span Gas Details

Species units Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.02 7.43

Carbon monoxide vppm 0.00 411.00 -2.00 410.00

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Oxides of nitrogen vppm 0.00 417.00 0.00 418.00

Volatile organic compounds vppm 0.00 10.10 0.10 10.20

Exhaust Gases - Continuous Analysis Data, Continued

0.20

Cylinder Reference Analyser Range

0.361.07

131.245.55

4.93

169.94

7.01

164.43132.91

8.26

221.57133.87

191.49

129.74

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00014

Page 45: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topl

ing

Ltd,

Inve

rkip

, R13

- 52

97,v

1Vi

sit

1of

2013

Page

15

of57

Cha

rt 1

- G

as D

ata

Boi

ler O

utle

t - 0

1/10

/201

3 - W

oodc

hip

0.0

200.

0

400.

0

600.

0

800.

0

1000

.0

1200

.0

1400

.0

1600

.0

1800

.0

2000

.0 09:1

309

:28

09:4

309

:58

10:1

310

:28

10:4

310

:58

11:1

311

:28

11:4

311

:58

12:1

312

:28

12:4

312

:58

13:1

313

:28

13:4

313

:58

14:1

314

:28

14:4

314

:58

15:1

315

:28

15:4

315

:58

16:1

316

:28

16:4

316

:58

17:1

317

:28

17:4

317

:58

18:1

3Ti

me

mg/m3 at reference conditions

0.0

2.0

4.0

6.0

8.0

10.0

12.0

14.0

16.0

18.0

20.0

%

CO

NO

x (a

s N

O2)

TOC

Oxy

gen

(%)

CO

2 (%

)

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00015

Page 46: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 16 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P58/PT137 Nozzle Diameter (d) mm 8.00Pitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.84 In-stack Filtration Y/N NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.976 Leak check OK Y/N YBarometric Pressure kPa 99.8 Meter ID No CU/09Duct static Pressure kPa 0.01 Initial Gas Meter Reading m³ 9.930Date 01/10/2013 Final Gas Meter Reading m³ 10.163Start Time hh:min 11:05 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter m³ 0.233End Time hh:min 11:35 Sampled Vol, Dry STP Nm³ 0.211Sampling Duration hh:min 00:30 Moisture content of stack gas % v/v 14.7

Isokinetic % 97.2

Impinger 1 2 3 4 5Initial mass (g) 392.9 790.8 836.6 671.7 1017.6Final mass (g) 412.1 793.4 838.2 673.0 1022.0

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Reading Sample Gas Filter Meter OrificePoint Time Temperature Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (h) (Ts) (Tm) (Dh)hh:min mm w.g °C °C °C mm w.g

B 00:00:00 1.0 95 156 16 4.300:05:00 1.0 95 158 16 4.300:10:00 1.0 96 161 16 4.300:15:00 1.0 96 161 17 4.300:20:00 1.0 98 154 18 4.300:25:00 1.0 99 155 18 4.300:30:00 99 158 18 4.3

Averages 1.0 97 158 17 4.3

Average velocity 3.84 m/sAverage flow rate 0.88 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.51 m³/s*

Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data Test 1

Temperatures

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00016

Page 47: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 17 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P58/PT137 Nozzle Diameter (d) mm 10.00Pitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.84 In-stack Filtration Y/N NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.976 Leak check OK Y/N YBarometric Pressure kPa 99.8 Meter ID No CU/09Duct static Pressure kPa 0.01 Initial Gas Meter Reading m³ 0.199Date 01/10/2013 Final Gas Meter Reading m³ 0.627Start Time hh:min 12:35 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter m³ 0.428End Time hh:min 13:05 Sampled Vol, Dry STP Nm³ 0.385Sampling Duration hh:min 00:30 Moisture content of stack gas % v/v 6.4

Isokinetic % 104.0

Impinger 1 2 3 4 5Initial mass (g) 395.7 718.0 696.1 673.0 1022.0Final mass (g) 415.7 718.9 695.5 671.5 1024.4

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Reading Sample Gas Filter Meter OrificePoint Time Temperature Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (h) (Ts) (Tm) (Dh)hh:min mm w.g °C °C °C mm w.g

B 00:00:00 1.0 102 158 19 17.800:05:00 1.0 103 159 19 17.800:10:00 1.0 102 160 19 17.800:15:00 1.0 102 160 20 17.800:20:00 1.0 98 161 20 17.800:25:00 1.0 100 161 20 17.800:30:00 102 161 20

Averages 1.0 101 160 20 17.8

Average velocity 3.86 m/sAverage flow rate 0.88 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.52 m³/s*

Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data Test 2

Temperatures

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00017

Page 48: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 18 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P58/PT137 Nozzle Diameter (d) mm 10.00Pitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.84 In-stack Filtration Y/N NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.976 Leak check OK Y/N YBarometric Pressure kPa 99.8 Meter ID No CU/09Duct static Pressure kPa 0.01 Initial Gas Meter Reading m³ 1.192Date 01/10/2013 Final Gas Meter Reading m³ 1.704Start Time hh:min 15:20 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter m³ 0.512End Time hh:min 15:50 Sampled Vol, Dry STP Nm³ 0.460Sampling Duration hh:min 00:30 Moisture content of stack gas % v/v 9.3

Isokinetic % 99.5

Impinger 1 2 3 4 5Initial mass (g) 396.8 727.6 689.7 671.9 1024.4Final mass (g) 424.8 728.2 692.0 672.8 1030.6

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Reading Sample Gas Filter Meter OrificePoint Time Temperature Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (h) (Ts) (Tm) (Dh)hh:min mm w.g °C °C °C mm w.g

B 00:00:00 3.0 96 160 20 52.000:05:00 3.0 97 159 20 52.000:10:00 1.0 103 160 20 17.800:15:00 1.0 103 160 20 17.800:20:00 1.0 104 161 20 17.800:25:00 1.0 105 160 20 17.800:30:00 103 161

Averages 1.7 102 160 20 29.2

Average velocity 4.98 m/sAverage flow rate 1.14 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.66 m³/s*

Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data Test 3

Temperatures

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00018

Page 49: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 19 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P58/PT137 Nozzle Diameter (d) mm 10.00Pitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.84 In-stack Filtration Y/N NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.976 Leak check OK Y/N YBarometric Pressure kPa 99.8 Meter ID No CU/09Duct static Pressure kPa 0.01 Initial Gas Meter Reading m³ 1.798Date 01/10/2013 Final Gas Meter Reading m³ 2.221Start Time hh:min 16:55 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter m³ 0.423End Time hh:min 17:25 Sampled Vol, Dry STP Nm³ 0.381Sampling Duration hh:min 00:30 Moisture content of stack gas % v/v 9.0

Isokinetic % 106.6

Impinger 1 2 3 4 5Initial mass (g) 800.1 784.1 609.0 931.1Final mass (g) 825.7 785.6 609.3 934.1

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Reading Sample Gas Filter Meter OrificePoint Time Temperature Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (h) (Ts) (Tm) (Dh)hh:min mm w.g °C °C °C mm w.g

B 00:00:00 1 105 156 19 16.600:05:00 1 107 159 19 16.600:10:00 1 106 159 18 16.600:15:00 1 106 160 18 16.600:20:00 1 108 160 19 16.600:25:00 1 102 160 19 16.600:30:00 99 160 19

Averages 1.0 105 159 19 16.6

Average velocity 3.88 m/sAverage flow rate 0.89 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.47 m³/s*

Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data Test 4

Temperatures

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00019

Page 50: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 20 of 57

Blank Filter Weight Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)

Filter No X10841 29/10/2013 0.77569 0.77556 0.00013

Washings 9769 28/10/2013 51.74421 51.74382 0.00039

Filter Weight Test 1 Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)

Filter No X10833 29/10/2013 0.77126 0.76544 0.00582

Washings 9773 28/10/2013 49.58992 49.58418 0.00574

Filter Weight Test 2 Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)

Filter No X10834 29/10/2013 0.79621 0.78765 0.00856

Washings 9774 28/10/2013 45.46205 45.45611 0.00594

Filter Weight Test 3 Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)Filter No X10836 29/10/2013 0.77601 0.75955 0.01646Washings 9775 28/10/2013 43.65781 43.65096 0.00685

Sample Hopper Or Total weights (g)

Number Filter No After Before Collected

Blank X10841 52.51990 52.51938 0.00052 -0.00042

Test 1 X10833 50.36118 50.34962 0.01156 0.01062Test 2 X10834 46.25826 46.24376 0.01450 0.01356Test 3 X10836 44.43382 44.41051 0.02331 0.02237

0.00094 <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 2.55 mg/m3*Particulate Emission -2.14 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 1

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Particulate Emission Results Test 1

Detection Limit 2.55 mg/m3*Particulate Emission 54.14 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 2

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Particulate Emission Results Test 2

Detection Limit 1.48 mg/m3*Particulate Emission 40.26 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 3Species Units ValueNitrogen % 99.999Oxygen % 10.35Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final SpanOxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Particulate Emission Results Test 3Detection Limit 1.23 mg/m3*Particulate Emission 54.84 mg/m3*

Total Particulate Matter Tests 1-3 - Emission Results

5701338

VC035033

5701338

Cylinder ReferenceVC035033

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Cylinder Reference

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance Acetone Residue Weight

Control Blank Corrected

Comments

1.8

% of FilterTare Weight

3.1

Tare Weight

1.5

% of Filter

Tare Weight

% of Filter

Tare Weight

0.1

% of Filter

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00020

Page 51: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 21 of 57

Blank Weights Sample Number Date of analysis Collected (g) Before (g)

Hexane Wash EMGJ02486/AB17 16/10/2013 0.0005Impinger EMGJ02486/AB18 16/10/2013 0.0016

Test 1 Sample Number Date of analysis Collected (g) Before (g)

Hexane Wash EMGJ02486/B21 16/10/2013 0.0011Impinger EMGJ02486/B22 16/10/2013 0.0032Condensate EMGJ02486/B23 16/10/2013 0.0018

Test 2 Sample Number Date of analysis Collected (g) Before (g)

Hexane Wash EMGJ02486/B26 16/10/2013 0.0021Impinger EMGJ02486/B27 16/10/2013 0.0037Condensate EMGJ02486/B28 16/10/2013 0.0010

Test 3 Sample Number Date of analysis Collected (g) Before (g)Hexane Wash EMGJ02486/B31 16/10/2013 0.0005Impinger EMGJ02486/B32 16/10/2013 0.0046Condensate EMGJ02486/B33 16/10/2013 0.0023

Sample Hopper Or Total weights (g)

Number Filter No Collected Before

Blank GJ02486/AB17 0.00210 0.00000 0.00210

Test 1 MGJ02486/B21 0.00430 0.00000 0.00430Test 2 MGJ02486/B26 0.00580 0.00000 0.00580Test 3 MGJ02486/B31 0.00510 0.00000 0.00510

Condensable Particulate Emission Results Blank

Detection Limit 2.55 mg/m3*Condensable Particulate Emission 10.71 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 1

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Condensable Particulate Emission Results Test 1

Detection Limit 2.55 mg/m3*Condensable Particulate Emission 21.92 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 2

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Condensable Particulate Emission Results Test 2

Detection Limit 1.48 mg/m3*Condensable Particulate Emission 17.22 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 3

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Condensable Particulate Emission Results Test 3

Detection Limit 1.23 mg/m3*Condensable Particulate Emission 12.50 mg/m3*

Condensable Particulate Matter Tests 1-3 - Emission Results

% of Filter

Tare Weight

#DIV/0!

% of Filter

Tare Weight#DIV/0!

% of Filter

Tare Weight#DIV/0!

% of FilterTare Weight

#DIV/0!

Control Blank Corrected

Comments

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00021

Page 52: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 22 of 57

Blank Filter Weight Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)

Filter No X10841 29/10/2013 0.77569 0.77556 0.00013

Washings 9769 28/10/2013 51.74421 51.74382 0.00039

Filter Weight Test 4 Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)

Filter No X10838 29/10/2013 0.79200 0.78274 0.00926

Washings 9776 28/10/2013 49.08808 49.08161 0.00647

Sample Hopper Or Total weights (g)

Number Filter No After Before Collected

Blank X10841 52.51990 52.51938 0.00052 -0.00042

Test 4 X10838 49.88008 49.86435 0.01573 0.01479

0.00094 <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.61 mg/m3*Particulate Emission -1.35 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 4

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

Particulate Emission Results Test 4

Detection Limit 1.61 mg/m3*Particulate Emission 47.57 mg/m3*

Total Particulate Matter Tests 4 - Emission Results

% of Filter

Tare Weight

0.1

% of Filter

Tare Weight

2.0

Control Blank Corrected

Comments

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance Acetone Residue Weight

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00022

Page 53: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 23 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P58/PT137 Nozzle Diameter (d) 6.10 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.84 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.976 Meter ID No CU09Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 0.839 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 1.162 m³Date 01/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.323 m³Start Time 14:15 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.290 Nm³End Time 14:45 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 7.5 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 119.3 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g

B 00:00:00 3.5 102 20 10.000:05:00 3.5 106 20 10.000:10:00 3.5 104 20 10.000:15:00 3.5 103 20 10.000:20:00 3.5 99 20 10.000:25:00 3.0 99 20 10.000:30:00 99 20 10.0

Averages 3.4 102 20 10.0

Average velocity 7.1 m/sAverage flow rate 1.6 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.9 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM2.5 Cyclone 2.25 2.75

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM2.5 Cyclone 2.3 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.00 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 119.3 PASS

PM2.5 - Sampling Data Test 1

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00023

Page 54: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 24 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1637 31/10/2013 0.15458 0.15489 -0.00031

Washings 9790 02/11/2013 47.32875 47.32780 0.00095

Mass of filterable PM2.5 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1624 31/10/2013 0.14616 0.14193 0.00423

Washings 9797 04/11/2013 44.06804 44.06661 0.00143

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 47.48333 47.48269 0.00064 -0.00030

Mass of filterable PM2.5 44.21420 44.20854 0.00566 0.00472

0.00094 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.18 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission -1.18 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 1

Detection Limit 1.18 mg/m3*

Filterable PM2.5 Emissions 18.54 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 1 11.3 %

Reference Gas Details Test 1

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.02 7.43

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

PM2.5 - Emission Results Test 1

Sample No.

Comments

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/AB1

EMGJ02486/AB2

EMGJ02486/B3

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

EMGJ02486/B4

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00024

Page 55: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 25 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P52/ PT47 Nozzle Diameter (d) 8.20 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.83 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.961 Meter ID No CU11Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 1.240 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 1.568 m³Date 01/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.328 m³Start Time 15:30 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.283 Nm³End Time 16:00 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 7.5 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 113.6 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g

A 00:00:00 1.5 103 23 10.000:05:00 1.5 104 25 10.000:10:00 1.0 104 27 10.000:15:00 1.0 105 28 10.000:20:00 1.0 103 29 10.000:25:00 1.0 104 30 10.000:30:00 103 29 10.0

Averages 1.2 104 27 10.0

Average velocity 4.1 m/sAverage flow rate 0.9 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.6 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM2.5 Cyclone 2.25 2.75

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM2.5 Cyclone 2.3 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.00 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 113.6 PASS

PM2.5 - Sampling Data Test 2

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00025

Page 56: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 26 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1637 31/10/2013 0.15458 0.15489 -0.00031

Washings 9790 02/11/2013 47.32875 47.32780 0.00095

Mass of filterable PM2.5 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1618 31/10/2013 0.16347 0.15116 0.01231

Washings 9798 04/11/2013 47.45120 47.44942 0.00178

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 47.48333 47.48269 0.00064 -0.00029

Mass of filterable PM2.5 47.61467 47.60058 0.01409 0.01316

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.32 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission -1.12 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 2

Detection Limit 1.32 mg/m3*

Filterable PM2.5 Emissions 50.91 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 2 10.9 %

Reference Gas Details Test 2

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.02 7.43

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

PM2.5 - Emission Results Test 2

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

EMGJ02486/B6

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/AB1

EMGJ02486/AB2

EMGJ02486/B5

Sample No.

Comments

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00026

Page 57: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 27 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P52/ PT47 Nozzle Diameter (d) 8.20 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.83 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.961 Meter ID No CU11Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 1.5920 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 1.9030 m³Date 01/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.311 m³Start Time 17:12 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.270 Nm³End Time 17:42 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 7.5 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 117.1 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g

A 00:00:00 1.0 108 21 10.200:05:00 1.0 103 21 10.200:10:00 1.0 99 25 10.200:15:00 1.0 101 26 10.200:20:00 1.0 102 28 10.200:25:00 1.0 100 28 10.200:30:00 1.0 10.2

Averages 1.0 102 25 10.2

Average velocity 3.8 m/sAverage flow rate 0.9 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.5 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM2.5 Cyclone 2.25 2.75

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM2.5 Cyclone 2.5 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.00 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 117.1 PASS

PM2.5 - Sampling Data Test 3

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00027

Page 58: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 28 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1637 31/10/2013 0.15458 0.15489 -0.00031

Washings 9790 02/11/2013 47.32875 47.32780 0.00095

Mass of filterable PM2.5 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1635 31/10/2013 0.15971 0.15443 0.00528

Washings 9799 04/11/2013 46.39096 46.38938 0.00158

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 47.48333 47.48269 0.00064 -0.00029

Mass of filterable PM2.5 46.55067 46.54381 0.00686 0.00593

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.34 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission -1.35 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 3

Detection Limit 1.34 mg/m3*

Filterable PM2.5 Emissions 27.62 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 3 12.3 %

Reference Gas Details Test 3

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.02 7.43

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

PM2.5 - Emission Results Test 3

Sample No.

Comments

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/AB1

EMGJ02486/AB2

EMGJ02486/B7

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

EMGJ02486/B8

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00028

Page 59: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 29 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P52/ PT47 Nozzle Diameter (d) 6.86 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.83 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.961 Meter ID No CU11Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 0.053 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 0.360 m³Date 01/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.307 m³Start Time 11:05 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.268 Nm³End Time 11:35 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 8.59 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 117.7 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g

A 00:00:00 1.5 95 19 12.500:05:00 1.5 95 20 12.500:10:00 1.5 96 22 12.500:15:00 2.5 96 24 12.500:20:00 2.5 98 25 12.500:25:00 2.5 99 27 12.500:30:00 99 27

Averages 2.0 97 23 12.5

Average velocity 5.4 m/sAverage flow rate 1.2 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.8 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM10 Cyclone 9 11

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM10 Cyclone 10.68 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.00 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 117.7 PASS

PM10 - Sampling Data Test 1

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00029

Page 60: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 30 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1637 31/10/2013 0.15458 0.15489 -0.00031

Washings 9790 02/11/2013 47.32875 47.32780 0.00095

Mass of filterable PM10 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1579 31/10/2013 0.16601 0.15353 0.01248

Washings 9800 04/11/2013 49.46894 49.46684 0.00210

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 47.48333 47.48269 0.00064 -0.00029

Mass of filterable PM10 49.63495 49.62037 0.01272 0.01179

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.36 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission -1.15 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 1

Detection Limit 1.36 mg/m3*

Filterable PM10 Emissions 46.89 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 1 10.7 %

Reference Gas Details Test 1

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.02 7.43

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

PM10 - Emission Results Test 1

EMGJ02486/B9

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/B10

Comments

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/AB1

EMGJ02486/AB2

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00030

Page 61: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 31 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P52/ PT47 Nozzle Diameter (d) 6.86 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.83 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.961 Meter ID No CU11Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 0.393 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 0.751 m³Date 01/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.358 m³Start Time 12:41 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.309 Nm³End Time 13:11 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 8.59 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 114.7 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g

A 00:00:00 2.5 101 21 12.500:05:00 2.5 103 25 12.500:10:00 2.5 102 26 12.500:15:00 3.0 102 27 12.500:20:00 3.0 100 29 12.500:25:00 3.5 101 30 12.500:30:00 102 30 12.5

Averages 2.8 102 27 12.5

Average velocity 6.4 m/sAverage flow rate 1.5 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.8 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM10 Cyclone 9 11

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM10 Cyclone 9.7 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.01 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 114.7 PASS

PM10 - Sampling Data Test 2

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00031

Page 62: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 32 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1637 31/10/2013 0.15458 0.15489 -0.00031

Washings 9790 02/11/2013 47.32875 47.32780 0.00095

Mass of filterable PM10 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1629 31/10/2013 0.14832 0.14047 0.00785

Washings 9801 04/11/2013 45.39006 45.38856 0.00150

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 47.48333 47.48269 0.00064 -0.00029

Mass of filterable PM10 45.53838 45.52903 0.00749 0.00656

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.18 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission -1.09 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 2

Detection Limit 1.18 mg/m3*

Filterable PM10 Emissions 24.57 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 2 11.5 %

Reference Gas Details Test 2

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.02 7.43

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

PM10 - Emission Results Test 2

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/AB1

EMGJ02486/AB2

EMGJ02486/B11

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/B12

Comments

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00032

Page 63: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 33 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P52/ PT47 Nozzle Diameter (d) 6.86 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.83 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.961 Meter ID No CU11Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 0.848 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 1.212 m³Date 01/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.364 m³Start Time 13:58 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.322 Nm³End Time 14:28 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 8.59 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 103.0 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.gA 00:00:00 4.0 104 25 12.5

00:05:00 4.0 105 18 12.500:10:00 4.0 105 19 12.500:15:00 4.0 105 18 12.500:20:00 3.5 106 19 12.500:25:00 3.5 105 19 12.500:30:00 105 19

Averages 3.8 105 20 12.5

Average velocity 7.5 m/sAverage flow rate 1.7 m³/sAverage flow rate 1.0 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM10 Cyclone 9 11

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM10 Cyclone 9.4 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.01 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 103.0 PASS

PM10 - Sampling Data Test 3

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00033

Page 64: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 34 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1637 31/10/2013 0.15458 0.15489 -0.00031

Washings 9790 02/11/2013 47.32875 47.32780 0.00095

Mass of filterable PM10 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1634 31/10/2013 0.16032 0.15499 0.00533

Washings 9802 04/11/2013 49.70585 49.70469 0.00116

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 47.48333 47.48269 0.00064 -0.00029

Mass of filterable PM10 49.86617 49.85968 0.00463 0.00370

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.14 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission -1.00 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 3

Detection Limit 1.14 mg/m3*

Filterable PM10 Emissions 12.70 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 3 11.0 %

Reference Gas Details Test 3

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 09:02 Final Time 18:23

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.02 7.43

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.08 10.44

PM10 - Emission Results Test 3

EMGJ02486/B13

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/B14

Comments

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/AB1

EMGJ02486/AB2

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00034

Page 65: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 35 of 57

APPENDIX 3

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00035

Page 66: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 36 of 57

Diagram of sampling points across the cross section of the duct (not to scale).

Traverse length = 0.54 m

Point % of D Locationcm

1 45.0 24.3

Diagram Of The Sampling Location

XA

B

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00036

Page 67: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 37 of 57

Stack area:

D = Diameter (m)π = 3.142 Pressure conversion: 1mmH2O = 0.00980665 kPa 1mmH2O = 9.80665 Pa 1 mar = 0.1 kPa Water vapour concentration: From reference calculations (taken from BS EN 14790):

VWC (%) = Water vapour content on wet basis, in volume % (m3 of water vapour in m3 of wet gas)Vm(std) = Dry gas volume measured, corrected to standard conditions (m3)mWC = Mass of water collected in the impingers (g) Mw = Molecular weight of water, 18.01534 rounded to 18 (g/mol)Vmol(std) = Molar volume of water at standard conditions = 0.0224 (m3/mol) Gas meter volume at standard conditions (STP) From reference calculations (taken from BS EN 14790):

Vm(std) = Dry gas meter volume at standard conditions (m3) yd = Gas meter calibration coefficient (V2-V1) = Dry gas meter volume at actual conditions (m3) Tm = Actual Temperature (K) Tstd = Standard temperature (273 K)pm = Absolute pressure at the gas meter (kPa)pstd = Standard gas pressure (101.3 kPa)

Isokenetic Ratio (%): From reference calculations (taken from EA TGN M2):

Estimating Measurment UncertaintyUncertainty estimates are calculated using the general rule of uncertainty propagation. Guidance is taken from publications including UKAS document M3003 and ISO 20988:2007.

General Calculations

100.

.

)()(

)(

(%) ×+

=

stdmW

stdmolWC

W

stdmolWC

WC

VMVm

MVm

V

std

m

m

stddstdm p

pTTVVyV ××−×= )( 12)(

( ) 100% ×=gasstacktheofVelocitynozzlesamplingtheatVelocityRatioIsokinetic

4. 2DcircleaofArea π

=

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00037

Page 68: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 38 of 57

Velocity: From reference calculations (taken from ISO 10780):

Average velocity (m/s) C = velocity calculation constant = 129Ts = Average stack temperature (K)Ms =K = Pitot calibration coefficient Pe = Absolute gas pressure (kPa)

Average pitot tube pressure differencial (kPa)

Volume flow rateFrom reference calculations (taken from ISO 10780):

qva = Average flow rate (m3/s) Average velocity (m/s)

A = Stack cross-sectional area (m2)

Volume flow rate corrected for moistureFrom reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096):

qm = Corrected volume flowrate (m3/s)qva = Volume flow rate at actual conditions (m3/s)Ha = Moisture at actual conditions (%volume)Hm = Reference moisture (%volume)

Volume flow rate corrected for temperature and pressureFrom reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096):

qm = Corrected volume flowrate (m3/s)qva = Volume flow rate at actual conditions (m3/s)Ta = Temperature at actual conditions (K)Tm = Reference Temperatue (K)pa = Absolute gas pressure at actual conditions (kPa)pm = Reference pressure (kPa) Volume flow rate corrected for oxygenFrom reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096):

qm = Corrected volume flowrate (m3/s)qva = Volume flow rate at actual conditions (m3/s)O2,m = Actual oxygen concentration (%)O2,ref =Reference oxygen concentration (%)

Molar mass of gas; assume 29 kg/kmol unless the molar mass is < 27 kg/kmol or > 31 g/kmol

Flow Calculations

=v

=v

Avqva =

( ))100(

100

m

avam H

Hqq−−

=

se

s

MppTKCv Δ

=

( ))( ma

amvam pT

pTqq =

( )( )m

refvam O

Oqq

,2

,2

9.209.20

−=

=pΔ

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00038

Page 69: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 39 of 57

Concentration: From reference calculations (taken from BS EN 13284-1):

c = Concentrationm = Mass of substaneV = Volume sampled

c = Concentrationq = Volume flow rate Concentration corrected for oxygen: From reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096):

cm = Concentration at reference conditionsca = Actual concentrationO2, ref = Reference oxygen (%)O2, a= Actual Oxygen (%) Concentration corrected for moisture: From reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096): Convert wet gas to dry gas

Convert dry gas to wet gas

cwet = Concentration wet gascdry = Concentration dry gasHa = Water vapour content (%vol) Conversion of parts per million (ppm) to mg/m3

From reference calculations (taken from EA TGN M2):

molar volume at 273K = 22.4 litres

When Converting TOC

molar volume at 273K = 22.4 litres

Mass Emission

Concentration Calculations

Vmc =

a

refam O

Occ

,2

,2

9.209.20

−−

×=

awetdry H

cc−

×=100

100

100100 a

drywetHcc −

×=

etemperaturgivenaatlvolumemolargweightmolecularppmionConcentratmmgionConcentrat

)()()()/( 3 ×

=

etemperaturgivenaatlvolumemolarggasspanincarbonofweightmolecularppmionConcentratmmgionConcentrat

)()()()/( 3 ×

=

mqcemissionMass ×=

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00039

Page 70: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 40 of 57

Where:C m = the measured concentration in mg/m3

Q m = mass concentration collected in absorber solution and filter in mgv s = the volume of the sample solution in lV std = volume sampled at standard conditions in m3

T m = mean temperature of gas meter in KT std = standard temperature = 273Kp=prel+Patm = absolute pressure = gas meter pressure + atmospheric pressure in kPaP std = standard pressure = 101.325 kPaV T.p = volume sampled as indicated by the gas meter in m3

Expression for calculation of the combined uncertainty of the measured concentration

Expression for calculation of the combined uncertainty of the gas volume

Assuming that uncertainties associated with the standard quantities T std and Pstd are negliableExpression for calculation of the combined uncertainty of the measured concentration

Overall expanded uncertainty (k = 2)

Uncertainty of the measured concentration at oxygen reference concentration

Where:

u(Cm,O2,ref) = in mg/m3

Cm,O2,ref = mass concentration at O2 reference concentration in mg/m3

O2,meas = O2 measured concentration in % volumeu((O2,meas)dry) = uncertainty associated to the measured O2 concentration in % (relative to O2 meas)

uncertainty associated with the mass concentration at O2 referenceconcentration

Calculation of Uncertainty Estimates - Manual Monitoring Techniques

std

stdpTstd P

pT

TVV ××= .

stdm

stdpTstd P

pTT

VV ××= .

std

mm V

QC =

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

std

std

s

s

m

m

m

m

VVu

vvu

QQu

CCu

++=

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )2

2

2

2

2

2

2.

.2

2

2

2

2

2

2

ppu

ppu

TTu

VVu

vvu

QQu

CCu atmrel

pT

pT

s

s

m

m

m

m +++++=

( ) ( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )22

2

2

2

2

2

2.

.2

2

2

2

2

matmrel

pT

pT

s

s

m

mm C

ppu

ppu

TTu

VVu

vvu

QQu

Cu ×⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛+++++=

( ) ( ) kCuCU mm ×=

( ) ( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( ) ( )2,,2

,,2

,,22

2

2

2

2

2

2

2.

.2

2

2

2

2

, 2,2 21 refOmdrymeas

drymeasatmrel

pT

pT

s

s

m

mOm C

OOu

ppu

ppu

TTu

VVu

vvu

QQuCu

ref×⎟

⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

−++++++=

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00040

Page 71: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 41 of 57

Model equation

Where:C ,ppm = concentration in ppm Corr rep = correction of repeatability of measurementC NO,reading = concentration given by analyser Corr adj = correction of adjustmentCorr fit = correction of lack of fit Corr inf = correction of influence quantitiesCorr 0,dr = correction of zero drift Corr int = correction of interferentsCorr s,dr = correction of span drift

Calculation of partial uncertainties

u(Corrfit) = Where:Xfit,max is the maximum allowable deviation from linearity

Expressed as % of the range and calculated by applying a rectangular probability distribution

u(Corr0,dr) = u(Corrs,dr) =

u(Corrrep) = max (S0,rep ; Ssrep) = Srep

Where:Sr,0 is the standard uncertainty at zero levelSr,s is the standard uncertainty at span level

u(Corradj) = u(Corrloss) + u(Corrcal) Where:u(Corrloss) is the uncertainty due to losses in sample line

u(Corrloss) = u(Corrcal) is the uncertainty due to losses in sample linecj,loss is the concentration of sample loss at span level

u(Corrcal) = Ucal is the expanded uncertainty of the calibration gas

u(Corr inf ) =

Where:cj is the sensitivity coefficient of the influence quantityxj,min is the minimum value of the influence quantity during monitoringxj,max is the maximum value of the influence quantity during monitoringxj,adj is the value of the influence quantity during adjustment

u(Corr int ) =

and Where:cj is the sensitivity coefficient of the interferent j

u( ΣCorr int ) = Intj,test is the concentration of the interferent j used to determine c j

Intj,min is the minimum value of the interferent j quantity during monitoringIntj,max is the maximum value of the interferent j quantity during monitoringIntj,adj is the concentration of the interferent j in the cal gas used to adjust the analyserS int,p is the sum of interferents with positive impact S int,n is the sum of interferents with negative impact

Combined uncertainty

u(C, ppm ) =

Overall expanded uncertainty (k = 2)

Uncertainty of NOx measurements Where:

u(C NOx , conv ) = CNOx is the concentration of NOx measured by the analyserR is the ratio of NO:Nox in the stack gasη is the NOx converter efficiency

Combined uncertainty NOx measurements

u(C NOx , stack ) =

Uncertainty of mass concentration at oxygen reference concentration

u(C, O2 ref ) =

Where:u(C,O2,ref) = uncertainty associated with the mass concentration at O 2 ref. concentration in mg/m3

C,O2,ref = mass concentration at O2 reference concentration in mg/m3

O2,meas = O2 measured concentration in % volumeu((O2,meas)dry) = uncertainty associated to the measured O2 concentration in % (relative to O2 meas)

Calculation of Uncertainty Estimates - Instrumental Monitoring Techniques

int1

inf,,0 CorrCorrCorrCorrCorrCorrCorrCCp

iadjrepdrsdrfitreadingppm +++++++= ∑

=

3100

max,⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛× range

X fit

3,0 drX

3,drsX

3,lossjC

2calU

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )3

2,min,,max,,min,

2,max, adjjjadjjjadjjjadjjj

j

xxxxxxxxc

−+−×−+−

3

2min,max,min,

2max,

,

jjjj

testj

j IntIntIntIntInt

c +×+

3η×× RCNOx

( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )convNOxIntadjvolttemppressavfsrepdrsdrfit corruScorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorru ,22222

,2

,22

,2

,022 ++++++++++

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

( ) ( ) kCuCU mm ×=

( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )( ) ⎟

⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

−++++++++++ 2

,,2

,,22

2222,

2,

22,

2,0

22

21 drymeas

drymeasIntadjvolttemppressavfsrepdrsdrfit O

OuScorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorru

( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) 2222,

2,

22,

2,0

22Intadjvolttemppressavfsrepdrsdrfit Scorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorru +++++++++

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00041

Page 72: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 42 of 57

APPENDIX 4

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00042

Page 73: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013Page 43 of 57

Analyser Type/Model Horiba PG250

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value % N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/AMeasured concentration % 11.1 10.9 11.3 12.1 11.3 11.4 11.0 11.7Calibration gas % 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4Full Scale % 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0

Value of partial standard uncertainty at limit value in % volumeCorrection of Lack of FitLack of fit % volume 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30

u(Corr,fit) 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift* (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift (Residual) % volume

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift (Residual) % volume

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04

u(Corr,rep) 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0

u(Corr,loss) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Uncertainty of calibration gas % volume 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,cal) 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.12 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.12

Correction of Influence of InterferentsTotal of interferent influences % range 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,flow) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070

u(Corr,temp) -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026Sensitivity to electrical voltage % volume 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.1735% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009

Interferent Concentration Variationsmg/m3 Minimum Maximum Value at cal Performance UnitsNO range 0 300 0 300 mg/m3

NO2 range 0 30 0 30 mg/m3

CO2 range 0 10 0 10 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 51 66 60 10 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99.00 101 100 2 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 278 313 285 10 kPaSensitivity to electrical voltage 104.5 115.5 110 10 V

Measurement uncertaintyTest 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8

Measured value 11.08 10.92 11.32 12.10 11.31 11.37 10.98 11.65Combined uncertainty as % volume 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.23 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.23Combined uncertainty as % of ELV N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/ACombined uncertainty relative to measured value, % 2.01 2.03 1.98 1.88 1.98 1.97 2.02 1.94

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8

Measured value 11.08 10.92 11.32 12.10 11.31 11.37 10.98 11.65Expanded uncertainty as % volume 0.45 0.44 0.45 0.46 0.45 0.45 0.44 0.45Expanded uncertainty as % of ELV N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/AExpanded uncertainty relative to measured value, % 4.02 4.06 3.95 3.77 3.96 3.94 4.04 3.87

Note: Values of standard uncertainty that are less than 5% of the maximum uncertainty are not includedThe uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Oxygen BS EN 14789:2005

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00043

Page 74: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013Page 44 of 57

Analyser Type/Model Horiba PG250

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value % N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/AMeasured concentration % 10.3 10.4 9.9 9.0 9.7 9.7 10.0 9.4Calibration gas % 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4Full Scale % 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0

Value of partial standard uncertainty at limit value in % volumeCorrection of Lack of FitLack of fit % volume 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30

u(Corr,fit) 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift* (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift (Residual) % volume

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift (Residual) % volume

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20

u(Corr,rep) 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.5

u(Corr,loss) 0.09 0.09 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.08 0.09 0.08Uncertainty of calibration gas % volume 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,cal) 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.09 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.09

Correction of Influence of InterferentsTotal of interferent influences % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,flow) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040

u(Corr,temp) 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012Sensitivity to electrical voltage % volume 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.1735% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009

Interferent Concentration VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

NO range 0 300 0 300 mg/m3

NO2 range 0 30 0 30 mg/m3

CO2 range 0 0 0 0 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 51 66 60 10 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99.00 101 100 2 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 278 313 285 10 kPaSensitivity to electrical voltage 104.5 115.5 110 10 V

Measurement uncertaintyTest 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8

Measured value 10.26 10.38 9.88 9.03 9.74 9.69 10.04 9.44Combined uncertainty as % volume 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.21 0.22 0.22 0.22 0.22Combined uncertainty as % of ELV N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/ACombined uncertainty relative to measured value, % 2.18 2.16 2.23 2.37 2.25 2.26 2.21 2.30

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8

Measured value 10.26 10.38 9.88 9.03 9.74 9.69 10.04 9.44Expanded uncertainty as % volume 0.45 0.45 0.44 0.43 0.44 0.44 0.44 0.43Expanded uncertainty as % of ELV N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/AExpanded uncertainty relative to measured value, % 4.36 4.33 4.47 4.74 4.51 4.52 4.42 4.60

Note: Values of standard uncertainty that are less than 5% of the maximum uncertainty are not included in the combined uncertaintyThe uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Carbon Dioxide

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00044

Page 75: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013Page 45 of 57

Analyser Type/ModelReference Oxygen % ( 0 = No correction)

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value mg/m3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Limit value ppm 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0Measured concentration ppm 102.7 116.8 124.1 246.6 135.0 155.2 119.8 115.5Measured concentration mg/m3 128.4 146.0 155.1 308.3 168.7 194.0 149.7 144.4Concentration at O2 ref. concentration mg/m3 142.3 159.3 176.2 381.2 191.5 221.6 164.4 169.9

Calibration gas ppm 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0Calibration gas mg/m3 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8Analyser range ppm 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0Analyser range mg/m3 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0

Correction of Lack of FitLack of fit % range 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,fit) 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift % range

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift % range

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2

u(Corr,rep) 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,loss) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Uncertainty of calibration gas % range 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00

u(Corr,cal) 1.03 1.17 1.24 2.47 1.35 1.55 1.20 1.16

Correction of Influence of InterferentsN2O % range

u(Corr,N2O) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CO2 % range

u(Corr,CO2) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CH4 % range

u(Corr,CH4) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Total of interferent influences % range 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,flow) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05

u(Corr,temp) 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05Sensitivity to electrical voltage % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 1.03 1.17 1.24 2.47 1.35 1.55 1.20 1.165% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.05 0.06 0.06 0.12 0.07 0.08 0.06 0.06

Oxygen reference concentrationMeasured oxygen % 11.1 10.9 11.3 12.1 11.3 11.4 11.0 11.7Overall uncertainty of O2 measurement U (O2,meas) 2.2 2.2 2.3 2.6 2.3 2.3 2.2 2.4

u(Corr,O2) 2.55 2.80 3.26 7.81 3.54 4.12 2.92 3.28

Interferent Concentration VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

CH4 range 0 10 0 50 mg/m3

N2O range 0 0 0 20 mg/m3

CO2 range 8 12 0 15 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 55 65 60 5 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99 100 99 1 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 278 313 288 10 KSensitivity to electrical voltage 218.5 241.5 230 5 V

Measurement uncertainty Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Combined uncertainty ppm 2.01 2.08 2.13 3.01 2.19 2.32 2.10 2.08Combined uncertainty mg/m3 2.51 2.61 2.66 3.76 2.74 2.90 2.63 2.60Combined uncertainty at oxygen reference mg/m3 4.06 4.37 4.87 10.47 5.20 5.91 4.49 4.85

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty ppm 4.0 4.2 4.3 6.0 4.4 4.6 4.2 4.2Overall uncertainty mg/m3 5.0 5.2 5.3 7.5 5.5 5.8 5.3 5.2Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 3.9 3.6 3.4 2.4 3.2 3.0 3.5 3.6Overall uncertainty relative to range % 5.3 5.5 5.6 7.9 5.8 6.1 5.5 5.5

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty mg/m3 8.1 8.7 9.7 20.9 10.4 11.8 9.0 9.7Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 5.7 5.5 5.5 5.5 5.4 5.3 5.5 5.7Overall uncertainty relative to range % 8.5 9.2 10.2 22.0 10.9 12.5 9.5 10.2Overall uncertainty relative to ELV % #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0!

The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Horiba PG25010

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Carbon Monoxide 15058:2006

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00045

Page 76: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 46 of 57

Analyser Type/ModelReference Oxygen % ( 0 = No correction)

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value mg/m3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Limit value ppm 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0Measured concentration ppm 63.1 58.8 57.7 51.8 55.7 57.1 58.9 54.3Measured concentration as NO2 mg/m3 129.5 120.7 118.5 106.4 114.3 117.2 121.0 111.5Concentration at O2 ref. concentration mg/m3 143.5 131.6 134.7 131.6 129.7 133.9 132.9 131.2

Calibration gas ppm 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0Calibration gas mg/m3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3Analyser range ppm 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9Analyser range mg/m3 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0Ratio of NOx/NO2 % 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0

Correction of Lack of FitLack of fit % range 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,fit) 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1

u(Corr,rep) 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20

u(Corr,loss) 0.44 0.41 0.40 0.36 0.39 0.40 0.41 0.38Uncertainty of calibration gas % range 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00

u(Corr,cal) 0.63 0.59 0.58 0.52 0.56 0.57 0.59 0.54

Correction of Influence of InterferentsNH3 % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,NH3) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CO2 % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,CO2) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Total of interferent influences % range 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,flow) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18

u(Corr,temp) 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17Sensitivity to electrical voltage % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Converter efficiencyConverter efficiency % Abs 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0Converter efficiency u(Corr,conv) 0.18 0.17 0.17 0.15 0.16 0.16 0.17 0.16

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.705% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04

Oxygen reference concentrationMeasured oxygen % 11.1 10.9 11.3 12.1 11.3 11.4 11.0 11.7Overall uncertainty of O2 measurement U (O2,meas) 2.2 2.2 2.3 2.6 2.3 2.3 2.2 2.4

u(Corr,O2) 1.57 1.41 1.52 1.64 1.46 1.52 1.44 1.54

Interferent Concentration VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

NO range 100 150 0 300 mg/m3

NO2 range 0 20 0 20 mg/m3

CO2 range 8 15 0 15 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 55 65 60 5 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99 100 99 1 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 283 313 285 10 KSensitivity to electrical voltage 218.5 241.5 230 5 V

Measurement uncertainty Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Combined uncertainty ppm 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.1 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.1Combined uncertainty as NO2 mg/m3 2.5 2.4 2.4 2.3 2.4 2.4 2.4 2.4Combined uncertainty at oxygen reference mg/m3 4.1 3.8 3.9 4.1 3.8 3.9 3.8 3.9

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty ppm 2.4 2.4 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.4 2.3Overall uncertainty mg/m3 3.0 2.9 2.9 2.8 2.9 2.9 3.0 2.9Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6 2.5 2.5 2.4 2.6Overall uncertainty relative to range % 2.4 2.4 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.3 2.4 2.3

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty mg/m3 8.1 7.5 7.9 8.2 7.6 7.9 7.6 7.9Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 5.7 5.7 5.8 6.2 5.9 5.9 5.7 6.0Overall uncertainty relative to range % 6.5 6.0 6.3 6.5 6.1 6.3 6.1 6.3The overall expanded uncertainty for this method (k=2) must be lower than 10% relative to the daily ELV (dry and before correction to oxygen).

The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Horiba PG25010

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Oxides Of Nitrogen BS EN 14792:2005

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00046

Page 77: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 47 of 57

Analyser Type/ModelReference Oxygen % ( 0 = No correction)

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value mg/m3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Limit value ppm 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0Measured concentration ppm 4.1 3.5 4.1 14.8 4.5 3.8 2.8 2.9Measured concentration mg/m3 6.5 5.6 6.7 23.8 7.3 6.1 4.5 4.7Concentration at O2 ref. concentration mg/m3 7.2 6.1 7.6 29.4 8.3 7.0 4.9 5.6

Calibration gas ppm 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1Calibration gas mg/m3 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2Analyser range ppm 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3Analyser range mg/m3 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0

Correction of Lack of FitLack of fit % range 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,fit) 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0(Not reported) u(Corr,rep) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,loss) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Uncertainty of calibration gas % range 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,cal) 0.04 0.03 0.04 0.15 0.05 0.04 0.03 0.03

Correction of Influence of InterferentsN2O % range

u(Corr,N2O) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CO2 % range

u(Corr,CO2) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CH4 % range

u(Corr,CH4) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Total of interferent influences % range 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60

u(Corr,flow) 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40

u(Corr,temp) -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28Sensitivity to electrical voltage % range 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10

Oxygen reference concentrationMeasured oxygen % 11.1 10.9 11.3 12.1 11.3 11.4 11.0 11.7Overall uncertainty of O2 measurement U (O2,meas) 2.2 2.2 2.3 2.6 2.3 2.3 2.2 2.4

u(Corr,O2) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.15 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.115% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01

Interferent Concentration Variations Minimum Maximum Value at cal Performance UnitsCH4 range 0 10 0 50 mg/m3

N2O range 0 0 0 20 mg/m3

CO2 range 8 12 0 15 mg/m3

Oxygen effect variations Minimum Maximum Value at cal Performance UnitsOxygen effect 0 20 0 2 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 55 65 60 5 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99 100 99 1 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 278 313 288 10 KSensitivity to electrical voltage 187 250 230 5 V

Measurement uncertainty Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Combined uncertainty ppm 0.37 0.37 0.37 0.39 0.37 0.37 0.37 0.37Combined uncertainty mg/m3 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.63 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59Combined uncertainty at oxygen reference mg/m3 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.63 0.59 0.59 0.59 0.59

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty ppm 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.8 0.7 0.7 0.7 0.7Overall uncertainty mg/m3 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.3 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 18.1 21.0 17.7 5.3 16.2 19.2 26.2 24.9Overall uncertainty relative to range % 7.9 7.9 7.9 8.4 7.9 7.9 7.8 7.8Overall uncertainty relative to ELV % 7.3 7.3 7.3 7.8 7.3 7.3 7.2 7.2

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty mg/m3 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.3 1.2 1.2 1.2 1.2Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 18.1 21.0 17.7 5.3 16.2 19.2 26.2 24.9Overall uncertainty relative to range % 7.9 7.9 7.9 8.4 7.9 7.9 7.8 7.8

The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Sick Maihak10

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Organic Carbon BS EN12619:2013

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00047

Page 78: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 48 of 57

Total Particulate Matter Test 1

Symbol Mass concentration of TPM UnitsCm 50.33 mg/m3 Filter mgCm at O2 ref 54.14 mg/m3 Washings mg

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO2,ref (0=No Correction) 10 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911u (mass)/mass Relatve 10.620 mg - - - 0.0018

u (mass)2/mass2 0.000003

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0010 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0005u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0001 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0001u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0006 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0003u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0006u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.211 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 290.0 K Normal - - 0.0032

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000010Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017

u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003Relative DGM Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40u (Prel)/P Measured pressure 99842 - - - - 0.0004

u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002Oxygen reference concentration

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of oxygen 0.22 % Normal 1 1 0.2226

Uncertainty of oxygen correction - - - - - 0.0218Measured Oxygen 10.8 % u (Orel)2/O2 0.000474

Measurement uncertaintyu(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.27 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.21 mg/m3

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.54 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.1 %

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.43 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 4.8 %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2), providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1

0.0

5.825.74

Daily emission limit value

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00048

Page 79: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 49 of 57

Total Particulate Matter Test 2

Symbol Mass concentration of TPM UnitsCm 35.25 mg/m3 Filter mgCm at O2 ref 40.26 mg/m3 Washings mg

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO2,ref (0=No Correction) 10 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911u (mass)/mass Relatve 13.560 mg - - - 0.0026

u (mass)2/mass2 0.000007

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0019 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0009u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0010 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0006u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0011u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.385 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 292.6 K Normal - - 0.0031

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000010Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017

u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003Relative DGM Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40u (Prel)/P Measured pressure 99975 - - - - 0.0004

u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002Oxygen reference concentration

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of oxygen 0.22 % Normal 1 1 0.2226

Uncertainty of oxygen correction - - - - - 0.0218Measured Oxygen 10.8 % u (Orel)2/O2 0.000474

Measurement uncertaintyu(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.21 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.91 mg/m3

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.42 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.2 %

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.82 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 5.2 %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2), providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1

0.0

8.565.94

Daily emission limit value

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00049

Page 80: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 50 of 57

Total Particulate Matter Test 3

Symbol Mass concentration of TPM UnitsCm 48.63 mg/m3 Filter mgCm at O2 ref 54.84 mg/m3 Washings mg

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO2,ref (0=No Correction) 10 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911u (mass)/mass Relatve 22.370 mg - - - 0.0019

u (mass)2/mass2 0.000004

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0023 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0011u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0012 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0007u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0014u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.460 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 293.0 K Normal - - 0.0031

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000010Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017

u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003Relative DGM Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40u (Prel)/P Measured pressure 100086 - - - - 0.0004

u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002Oxygen reference concentration

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of oxygen 0.22 % Normal 1 1 0.2226

Uncertainty of oxygen correction - - - - - 0.0218Measured Oxygen 10.8 % u (Orel)2/O2 0.000474

Measurement uncertaintyu(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.26 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.23 mg/m3

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.52 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.1 %

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.46 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 5.1 %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2), providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1

0.0

16.466.85

Daily emission limit value

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00050

Page 81: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 51 of 57

Total Particulate Matter Test 4

Symbol Mass concentration of TPM UnitsCm 38.79 mg/m3 Filter mgCm at O2 ref 47.57 mg/m3 Washings mg

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO2,ref (0=No Correction) 10 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911u (mass)/mass Relatve 14.790 mg - - - 0.0023

u (mass)2/mass2 0.000006

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0019 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0009u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0010 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0006u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0011u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.381 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 291.7 K Normal - - 0.0031

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000010Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017

u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003Relative DGM Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40u (Prel)/P Measured pressure 99963 - - - - 0.0004

u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002Oxygen reference concentration

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of oxygen 0.22 % Normal 1 1 0.2226

Uncertainty of oxygen correction - - - - - 0.0248Measured Oxygen 12.0 % u (Orel)2/O2 0.000616

Measurement uncertaintyu(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.22 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.21 mg/m3

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.45 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.1 %

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.42 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 6.2 %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2), providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1

0.0

9.266.47

Daily emission limit value

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00051

Page 82: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 52 of 57

PM2.5 Uncertainty Estimate Test 1

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 16.29 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 4.720 mg - - - 0.0056u (mass)2/mass2 0.000031

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0014 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0007u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0001 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0001u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0008 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0005u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0009u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.290 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 374.7 K Normal - - 0.0024

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99898 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.036

Relatve 11.3 - Normal - - 0.0363u (Prel)2/P2 0.0013178

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.15 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.29 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.8 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 16.29 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.59 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.18 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 7.3 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

4.231.43

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00052

Page 83: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 53 of 57

PM2.5 Uncertainty Estimate Test 2

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 46.57 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 13.160 mg - - - 0.0020u (mass)2/mass2 0.000004

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0014 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0007u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0001 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0001u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0008 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0004u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0008u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.283 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 376.7 K Normal - - 0.0024

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99898 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.033

Relatve 10.9 - Normal - - 0.0330u (Prel)2/P2 0.0010896

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.24 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.47 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.0 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 46.57 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.54 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 3.07 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 6.6 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

12.311.78

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00053

Page 84: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 54 of 57

PM2.5 Uncertainty Estimate Test 3

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 21.95 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 5.930 mg - - - 0.0042u (mass)2/mass2 0.000017

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0013 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0007u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0001 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0001u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0007 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0004u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0008u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.270 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 375.2 K Normal - - 0.0024

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99900 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.043

Relatve 12.3 - Normal - - 0.0427u (Prel)2/P2 0.0018220

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.16 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.32 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.5 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 21.95 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.94 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.87 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 8.5 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

5.281.58

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00054

Page 85: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 55 of 57

PM10 Uncertainty Estimate Test 1

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 43.99 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 13.650 mg - - - 0.0021u (mass)2/mass2 0.000004

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0013 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0007u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0001 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0001u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0007 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0004u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0008u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.268 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 369.9 K Normal - - 0.0025

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99923 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.031

Relatve 10.7 - Normal - - 0.0315u (Prel)2/P2 0.0009910

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.23 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.46 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.0 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 43.99 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.38 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.77 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 6.3 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

12.482.10

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00055

Page 86: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 56 of 57

PM10 Uncertainty Estimate Test 2

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 21.23 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 8.420 mg - - - 0.0043u (mass)2/mass2 0.000018

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0015 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0008u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0008 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0005u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0009u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.309 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 374.6 K Normal - - 0.0024

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99923 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.037

Relatve 11.5 - Normal - - 0.0370u (Prel)2/P2 0.0013713

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.16 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.31 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.5 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 21.23 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.79 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.57 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 7.4 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

7.851.50

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00056

Page 87: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5297,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 57 of 57

PM10 Uncertainty Estimate Test 3

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 11.49 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 5.560 mg - - - 0.0079u (mass)2/mass2 0.000063

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0016 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0008u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0009 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0005u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0010u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.322 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 378.0 K Normal - - 0.0024

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99923 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.035

Relatve 11.0 - Normal - - 0.0354u (Prel)2/P2 0.0012509

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.14 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.28 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.4 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 11.49 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.41 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.81 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 7.1 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

5.331.16

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00057

Page 88: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 1 of 57

Client Topling LtdArchway OfficeWoodendDunsBerwickshireTD11 3QW

Part 1: Executive Summary

Report for the Periodic Monitoring of Emissions to Air.

Site InverkipPlant Biomass Boiler Main Stack - StrawSampling Date 2nd October 2013Report Date 6th November 2013Job Number EMGJ02486Permit Number N/A

Report Prepared by: Print Derek Myers

MCERTS No. MM 02 115 Level 2 TE: 1,2,3,4

Report Approved by: Sign

Print Derek Myers

MCERTS No. MM 02 115 Level 2 TE: 1,2,3,4

10 Broad LaneMoldgreenHuddersfieldHD5 9BX

Tel: 0845 0349 3601783 Fax: 01484 545 577

Shield On-Site Services - Industrial Emissions

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00058

Page 89: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 2 of 57

Page 1 Part 1: Executive SummaryPage 2 ContentsPage 3 Monitoring ObjectivesPage 3 Special Monitoring RequirementsPage 3 Summary Of MethodsPage 4 Summary Of ResultsPage 5 Results, ContinuedPage 6 Operating InformationPage 6 Comments On Monitoring Procedures

Page 7 Part 2: Supporting Information

Page 8 Appendix 1Page 9 Emission Monitoring Procedures and InstrumentationPage 10 Sampling PersonnelPage 10 Equipment ReferencesPage 10 Subcontracted Analysis

Page 11 Appendix 2Page 12 Prelimanary Velocity Traverse & Moisture DataPage 13 Exhaust Gases - Continuous Analysis DataPage 14 Exhaust Gases - Continuous Analysis Data, ContinuedPage 15 Exhaust Gases - PlotPage 16 Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data, Test 1Page 17 Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data, Test 2Page 18 Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data, Test 3Page 19 Total Particulate Matter - Emission Results Test 1 to 3Page 20 Condensable Particulate Matter - Emission Results Test 1 to 3Page 21 PM2.5 - Sampling Data, Test 1Page 22 PM2.5 - Emission Results, Test 1Page 23 PM2.5 - Sampling Data, Test 2Page 24 PM2.5 - Emission Results, Test 2Page 25 PM2.5 - Sampling Data, Test 3Page 26 PM2.5 - Emission Results, Test 3Page 27 PM10 - Sampling Data, Test 1Page 28 PM10 - Emission Results, Test 1Page 29 PM10 - Sampling Data, Test 2Page 30 PM10 - Emission Results, Test 2Page 31 PM10 - Sampling Data, Test 3Page 32 PM10 - Emission Results, Test 3Page 33 PM10 - Sampling Data, Test 4Page 34 PM10 - Emission Results, Test 4

Page 35 Appendix 3Page 36 Diagram of Sampling LocationPage 37 Generic CalculationsPage 38 Flow CalculationsPage 39 Concentration CalculationPage 40 Uncertainty Estimate Calculations - Maunual TechniquesPage 41 Uncertainty Estimate Calculations - Instrumental Techniques

Page 42 Appendix 4Page 43 Uncertainty Estimates:- OxygenPage 44 Uncertainty Estimates:- Carbon DioxidePage 45 Uncertainty Estimates:- Carbon MonoxidePage 46 Uncertainty Estimates:- Oxides of NitrogenPage 47 Uncertainty Estimates:- TOCPage 48 Uncertainty Estimates:- Total Particulate Matter, Test 1Page 49 Uncertainty Estimates:- Total Particulate Matter, Test 2Page 50 Uncertainty Estimates:- Total Particulate Matter, Test 3Page 51 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM2.5, Test 1Page 52 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM2.5, Test 2Page 53 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM2.5, Test 3Page 54 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM10, Test 1Page 55 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM10, Test 2Page 56 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM10, Test 3Page 57 Uncertainty Estimates:- PM10, Test 4

Contents

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00059

Page 90: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 3 of 57

The monitoring was undertaken to check compliance with authorised emission limits.

Monitoring was undertaken for the listed emissions from the following sampling positions:

ParticulatesPM2.5PM10Condensable ParticulatesOxygenCarbon dioxideCarbon monoxideOxides of nitrogenTotal organic carbon

There were no special requirements for this monitoring campaign.

Particulate BS ISO 9096 : 2003Particulate - PM10 & PM2.5 US EPA Method 201aGas velocity BS EN 13284 : 2002Water vapour BS EN 14790 : 2005Oxygen BS EN 14789 : 2005Carbon dioxide ISO 12039 : 2001Carbon monoxide BS EN 15058 : 2006Oxides of nitrogen BS EN 14792 : 2005TOC BS EN 12619 : 2013Condensable Particulates US EPA Method 202

All monitoring procedures were carried out to the MCERTS requirements under Shield On-Site Services qualitysystem to ISO 17025: 2005.

Sampling Location Emission

Monitoring Objectives

Biomass Boiler Main Stack - Straw

Special Monitoring Requirements

Emission Method number Method standard

Summary of Methods

TPM/05TPM/22TPM/01TPM/37TPM/39TPM/15TPM/40TPM/41TPM/13

Based on TPM50N

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00060

Page 91: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 4 of 57

The table presents the atmospheric emissions from the tests undertaken on behalf of Topling LtdThe results were measured from the sample positions downstream of the arrestment plant.

Emission Authorised Uncertainty Detection Result Limit +/- Limit

Date Start End mg/m3* mg/m3* mg/m3* mg/m3*

Carbon monoxide 02/10/13 08:50 16:50 429.6 0 23.2 0.4Oxides of nitrogen 02/10/13 08:50 16:50 285.9 0 15.7 1.3TOC 02/10/13 08:50 16:50 24.6 0 1.3 0.2Particulate (Test 1) 02/10/13 10:08 10:38 476.3 0 23.7 1.49Particulate (Test 2) 02/10/13 11:40 12:10 448.5 0 22.3 1.65Particulate (Test 3) 02/10/13 13:26 13:56 500.9 0 24.9 1.44Condensable Particulate (Test 1) 02/10/13 10:08 10:38 15.5 0 23.7 1.49Condensable Particulate (Test 2) 02/10/13 11:40 12:10 22.4 0 22.3 1.65Condensable Particulate (Test 3) 02/10/13 13:26 13:56 25.6 0 24.9 1.44PM10 (Test 1) 02/10/13 09:10 09:40 31.1 N/A 2.2 1.09PM10 (Test 2) 02/10/13 10:30 11:00 326.3 N/A 22.0 1.13PM10 (Test 3) 02/10/13 11:40 12:10 313.8 N/A 21.2 1.12

02/10/13 13:50 14:20 285.1 N/A 18.0 1.17PM2.5 (Test 1) 02/10/13 15:05 15:35 250.7 N/A 15.9 1.34PM2.5 (Test 2) 02/10/13 15:55 16:25 241.7 N/A 16.1 1.26PM2.5 (Test 3) 02/10/13 16:57 17:27 241.1 N/A 14.5 1.26

Date Start End % vol % vol % vol % volOxygen 02/10/13 08:50 16:50 11.9 - 0.5 0.10Carbon dioxide 02/10/13 08:50 16:50 8.6 - 0.4 0.10

* at reference conditions Stack Gas Weight 0 oC

29.00 Kg/kmol 101.3 kPa Oxygen %

Where applicable Oxides of nitrogen results are expressed as nitrogen dioxideTOC results are expressed as total carbon

Throughout Report: * Reference conditions (see above) Nm³ 273 K, 101.3 kPa** Analysis not required # - UKAS accredited onlyND Non detectable ## - Not Accrediteds - Subcontracted laboratory analysis N/A Not applicable

The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor k=2, providing a 95% confidence level. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Biomass Boiler Main Stack - Straw

MassInverkip Time Emission

Emission at Sampling

g/h

773.8516.644.2873.6750.7933.8

81.5

28.337.547.7

Summary Of Results

10

534.2

855.8

PM10 (Test 4)

469.9

1783

kg/h-

306.5

Dry Gas

980.71015.4

All tests included in this report are accredited under UKAS and MCERTS accreditation schemes unless otherwise stated. Opinions and interpretations expressed herein are outside the scope of MCERTS and UKAS accreditation.

621.5

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00061

Page 92: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 5 of 57

The table presents the atmospheric emissions from the tests undertaken on behalf of Topling LtdThe results were measured from the sample positions downstream of the arrestment plant.

Emission Authorised Uncertainty Detection MassResult Limit +/- Limit Emission

Date Start End mg/m3* mg/m3* mg/m3* mg/m3* g/hCarbon monoxide Test 1 02/10/13 08:50 09:50 308.1 0 18.6 0.4 565.1Carbon monoxide Test 2 02/10/13 09:50 10:50 508.9 0 26.8 0.4 933.4Carbon monoxide Test 3 02/10/13 10:50 11:50 400.2 0 21.7 0.4 734.0Carbon monoxide Test 4 02/10/13 11:50 12:50 380.3 0 20.4 0.4 636.6Carbon monoxide Test 5 02/10/13 12:50 13:50 565.6 0 30.1 0.4 946.8Carbon monoxide Test 6 02/10/13 13:50 14:50 367.5 0 19.7 0.4 685.1Carbon monoxide Test 7 02/10/13 14:50 15:50 425.1 0 22.8 0.4 792.5Carbon monoxide Test 8 02/10/13 15:50 16:50 481.0 0 25.2 0.4 896.6Oxides of nitrogen Test 1 02/10/13 08:50 09:50 357.1 0 21.4 1.3 655.0Oxides of nitrogen Test 2 02/10/13 09:50 10:50 262.7 0 14.2 1.3 481.8Oxides of nitrogen Test 3 02/10/13 10:50 11:50 278.3 0 15.2 1.3 510.4Oxides of nitrogen Test 4 02/10/13 11:50 12:50 287.7 0 15.5 1.3 481.5Oxides of nitrogen Test 5 02/10/13 12:50 13:50 256.0 0 14.0 1.3 428.5Oxides of nitrogen Test 6 02/10/13 13:50 14:50 275.0 0 14.9 1.3 512.7Oxides of nitrogen Test 7 02/10/13 14:50 15:50 283.4 0 15.4 1.3 528.3Oxides of nitrogen Test 8 02/10/13 15:50 16:50 286.7 0 15.3 1.3 534.4TOC Test 1 02/10/13 08:50 09:50 3.5 0 1.2 0.2 6.4TOC Test 2 02/10/13 09:50 10:50 31.2 0 1.3 0.2 57.2TOC Test 3 02/10/13 10:50 11:50 13.7 0 1.2 0.2 25.2TOC Test 4 02/10/13 11:50 12:50 23.9 0 1.2 0.2 39.9TOC Test 5 02/10/13 12:50 13:50 41.4 0 1.4 0.2 69.3TOC Test 6 02/10/13 13:50 14:50 40.8 0 1.4 0.2 76.1TOC Test 7 02/10/13 14:50 15:50 7.7 0 1.2 0.2 14.4TOC Test 8 02/10/13 15:50 16:50 34.9 0 1.3 0.2 65.0

Date Start End % % % % kg/hOxygen Test 1 02/10/13 08:50 09:50 12.8 - 0.5 0.1 -Oxygen Test 2 02/10/13 09:50 10:50 11.7 - 0.5 0.1 -Oxygen Test 3 02/10/13 10:50 11:50 11.9 - 0.5 0.1 -Oxygen Test 4 02/10/13 11:50 12:50 11.7 - 0.5 0.1 -Oxygen Test 5 02/10/13 12:50 13:50 11.8 - 0.5 0.1 -Oxygen Test 6 02/10/13 13:50 14:50 11.7 - 0.5 0.1 -Oxygen Test 7 02/10/13 14:50 15:50 11.8 - 0.5 0.1 -Oxygen Test 8 02/10/13 15:50 16:50 11.6 - 0.5 0.1 -Carbon dioxide Test 1 02/10/13 08:50 09:50 7.9 - 0.4 0.10 285.5Carbon dioxide Test 2 02/10/13 09:50 10:50 8.9 - 0.4 0.10 319.1Carbon dioxide Test 3 02/10/13 10:50 11:50 8.7 - 0.4 0.10 313.5Carbon dioxide Test 4 02/10/13 11:50 12:50 8.8 - 0.4 0.10 288.8Carbon dioxide Test 5 02/10/13 12:50 13:50 8.6 - 0.4 0.1 284.3Carbon dioxide Test 6 02/10/13 13:50 14:50 8.7 - 0.4 0.1 320.1Carbon dioxide Test 7 02/10/13 14:50 15:50 8.7 - 0.4 0.1 317.8Carbon dioxide Test 8 02/10/13 15:50 16:50 8.8 - 0.4 0.1 322.7

* at ref Stack Gas Weight 0 oC Dry GasConditions 29.00 Kg/kmol 101.3 kpa Oxygen 10 %

Where applicable Oxides of nitrogen results are expressed as nitrogen dioxideTOC results are expressed as total carbon

Throughout Report: * Reference conditions (see above) Nm³ 273 K, 101.3 kPa** Analysis not required # - UKAS accredited onlyND Non detectable ## - Not Accrediteds - Subcontracted laboratory analysis N/A Not applicable

The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor k=2, providing a 95% confidence level. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

1783

Emission at SamplingInverkip Time

Summary Of Results

Biomass Boiler Main Stack - Straw

All tests included in this report are accredited under UKAS and MCERTS accreditation schemes unless otherwise stated. Opinions and interpretations expressed herein are outside the scope of MCERTS and UKAS accreditation.

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00062

Page 93: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 6 of 57

The tables below shows details of the operating information on each sampling date for: Biomass Boiler Main Stack - Straw

Date Process Fuel Feedstock Loadduration

02/10/2013 N/A

A waste gas homogeneity test to BS EN 15259:2007 (MID) is not required:-The homogeneity test is not applicable to duct areas less than 1m 2.All monitoring was performed in accordance with the relevant procedures. Except PM10 and PM2.5 which were sampled from a centre point.

The velocity and temperature profile at the sampling location met the requirements of BS EN 13284-1: 2002.

The calculated particulate emission level was greater than the control blank.

Sampling was conducted from a single point in the duct due to the limited clearance and scaffolding restrictions.

PM10 Test 1 results not reported due to damaged filter paper.

Process type Abatement

Biomass Boiler continuous Straw Cyclone

When the results that are expressed as non-detected the mass emission has been calculated from the detection limit and therefore they are worst case results.

Operating Information

Comments & Monitoring Deviations

85%

The particulate monitoring was within the required 95 to 115 % isokinetic rate as stated in BS EN 13284-1: 2002

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00063

Page 94: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 7 of 57

Part 2: Supporting Information

Report for the Periodic Monitoring of Emissions to Air.

Client Topling LtdSite InverkipPlant Biomass Boiler Main Stack - StrawSampling Date 2nd October 2013Report Date 6th November 2013Job Number EMGJ02486Permit Number N/A

Report Prepared by: Print Derek Myers

MCERTS No. MM 02 115 Level 2 TE: 1,2,3,4

Report Approved by: Sign

Print Derek Myers

MCERTS No. MM 02 115 Level 2 TE: 1,2,3,4

10 Broad LaneMoldgreenHuddersfieldHD5 9BX

Tel: 0845 0349 3601783 Fax: 01484 545 577

Shield On-Site Services - Industrial Emissions

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00064

Page 95: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 8 of 57

APPENDIX 1

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00065

Page 96: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 9 of 57

Gas velocity and temperature

Water vapour

Total particulate matter

Oxygen

Carbon dioxide

Carbon monoxide

Oxides of nitrogen

Total organic carbon

Documented in-house procedure TPM/39 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 14789:2005. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line, gas conditioning system, and a paramagnetic, zirconium cell, or electrochemicalcell analyser. The analytical equipment detailed above is calibrated before and during the tests using certified gasmixtures of nitrogen and oxygen. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/15 to the main procedural requirements ISO 12039:2001. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line, gas conditioning system, and multi range infra-red analyser. The analyticalequipment detailed above is calibrated before and during the tests using certified gas mixtures of nitrogen andcarbon dioxide. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259 assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/13 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 12619:2013. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line and multi range Flame Ionisation Detector (FID) analyser. The analyser iscalibrated before and during the tests using certified gas mixtures of nitrogen and propane. Sampling points areselected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259 assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/40 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 15058:2006. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line, gas conditioning system, and multi range infra-red analyser. The analyticalequipment detailed above is calibrated before and during the tests using certified gas mixtures of nitrogen andcarbon monoxide. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259 assessment.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/41 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN14792:2005. Continuousanalysis using probe, sample line, gas conditioning system and multi range chemiluminescent analyser. Theanalytical equipment detailed above is calibrated before and during the tests using certified gas mixtures of nitrogenand NO. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259 assessment.

PM10 & PM2.5Documented in–house procedure TPM/22 to the main procedural requirements of US EPA Method 201A using anAndersen universal stack sampler, with an in-stack quartz micro-fibre filter and PM10 or PM2.5 separator cyclone.Stack gases sampled at a constant flow at calculated dwell times across the duct. Stack gas sampled through asharp edged nozzle into a particulate separator cyclone, PM10 or PM2.5 collected on a filter with a collectionefficiency of 99.91 % > 0.1 micron.

Emission Monitoring Procedures And Instrumentation

Documented in-house procedure TPM/05 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN ISO 9096:2003. Stackgases are extracted from representative sampling points at isokinetic flow rates through a sharp-edged nozzle.Particulate matter is collected on a pre-weighed filter conditioned at 180oC. Deposits upstream of the filter are alsorecovered and weighed. The increase of mass of the filter and mass collected upstream of the filter is divided by thevolume sampled to determine the mass concentration.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/01 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 13284:2002. Velocity andtemperature measurements are performed using a calibrated Pitot tube, as described in BS ISO 10780:1994 and acalibrated thermocouple. Velocity and possible flow deviation measurements are carried out at selected,representative points in the gas stream.

Documented in-house procedure TPM/37 to the main procedural requirements of BS EN 14790:2005. A measuredvolume of gas is extracted from the gas stream through a moisture trapping unit. The mass gain of moisture trappedis divided by the volume of gas sampled to determine the mass concentration of water vapour. For water saturatedstacks the temperature of the gas stream is measured and the water vapour concentration is determined using liquid-gas equilibrium tables. Sampling points are selected in accordance with the findings of any BS EN 15259assessment.

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00066

Page 97: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 10 of 57

MCERTS No Level 1 Level 2 TE1 TE2 TE3 TE4Report prepared by: Derek Myers MM 02 115 - 30/11/2013 31/05/2018 30/11/2018 30/11/2013 30/11/2013

Report authorised by: Derek Myers MM 02 115 - 30/11/2013 31/05/2018 30/11/2018 30/11/2013 30/11/2013

Team leader: Gary Thackray MM 02 078 - 31/10/2014 31/03/2018 30/10/2014 31/08/2015 31/08/2015

Team leader: Chris Rhodes MM 02 117 - 31/08/2013 28/02/2018 28/02/2018 31/08/2013 31/12/2013

Team leader: Derek Myers MM 02 115 - 30/11/2013 31/05/2018 30/11/2018 30/11/2013 30/11/2013

CA21VC17

HLB01P50, P58 & P52

TP50, TP58 &TP52TS50, TS58 & TS52

CU16 & CU9ST30MET

PT47 /PT114 / PT137CV14

TV17 & TV06Laptop

CU16/03 & CU09/03CU16/1 & CU09/1

BL20W33 & W34

Laboratory: Scientific Analysis Laboratories

Parameters: Particulates ( Gravimetric 5 decimal) Condensable Matter ( Gravimetric )

Accreditation: UKAS Accredited testing laboratory number 1549

Shield On-Site Services has, with your approval, used the following sub-contracted laboratories for the laboratory analyses referencedbelow:

Sampling Project Personnel Competency And Expiry Dates

Equipment References

Equipment Reference Number

Gas AnalyserFID

Heated LineProbe

Probe ThermocoupleStack Thermocouple

Control BoxTimer / Stopwatch

BarometerPitot

CallipersImpinger Thermocouple

Sample Rate Calculation EquipmentThermometerManometer

BalanceWeights

Subcontracted Analysis

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00067

Page 98: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 11 of 57

APPENDIX 2

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00068

Page 99: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 12 of 57

Date 30/09/2013 Barometric pressure 99.6 kPa Stack Diameter (circular) 0.54 m

Time 17:40 Duct static pressure 0.01 kPa m

Pitot Cp 0.77 Stack Area 0.229 m2 m

Oxygen 11.9 % Carbon dioxide %

Traverse Traverse Depth ΔP T Angle velocity Traverse Depth ΔP T Angle velocity

Point Line cm mmH2O oC o m/s Line cm mmH2O oC o m/s

1 A 5.0 0.9 90 <15 3.2 B 5.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4

2 A 5.0 0.9 90 <15 3.2 B 5.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4

3 A 6.4 0.8 90 <15 3.0 B 6.4 0.9 90 <15 3.2

4 A 9.6 0.5 90 <15 2.6 B 9.6 0.6 90 <15 2.8

5 A 13.5 0.9 90 <15 3.2 B 13.5 1.0 90 <15 3.4

6 A 19.2 1.2 90 <15 3.8 B 19.2 1.6 90 <15 4.4

7 A 34.8 1.0 90 <15 3.4 B 34.8 1.8 90 <15 4.7

8 A 40.5 1.3 90 <15 4.0 B 40.5 1.9 90 <15 4.8

9 A 44.4 1.1 90 <15 3.6 B 44.4 1.3 90 <15 4.0

10 A 47.6 1.2 90 <15 3.8 B 47.6 1.1 90 <15 3.6

11 A 49.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4 B 49.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4

12 A 49.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4 B 49.0 1.0 90 <15 3.4

Average Pitot DP 1.04 mmH2O

Average Temperature 363.2 K

Average Velocity 3.6 m/s

Average volumetric flow rate 0.82 m3/s at stack conditions

Average volumetric flow rate 0.60 m3/s (wet STP)

Average volumetric flow rate 0.51 m3/s (dry STP)

Average volumetric flow rate 0.42 m3/s (dry, STP, reference oxygen concentraion)

Sampling plane requirements Re: BS EN 13284-1:2001 5.2

a Angel of gas flow less than 15o with regard to duct axis YES

b No local negative flow YES

c Minimum pitot greater than 5Pa YES

d Ratio of highest to lowest local gas velocity less than 3:1 YES

Minimum local gas velocity 2.6

Maximum local gas velocity 4.8

Ratio of highest to lowest local gas velocity 1.90

Prelimanary Velocity Traverse Data

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00069

Page 100: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 13 of 57Date 02/10/2013

From 08:50 to 09:50 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 184.79 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 130.37 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 1.62 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide vppm, dry 7.92

Oxygen %, dry 12.75

From 09:50 to 10:50 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 344.67 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 108.31 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 16.44 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide vppm, dry 8.86

Oxygen %, dry 11.69

.

From 10:50 to 11:50 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 265.67 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 112.46 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 7.10 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 8.70

Oxygen %, dry 11.87

From 11:50 to 12:50 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 256.07 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 117.91 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 12.49 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide vppm, dry 8.78

Oxygen %, dry 11.74

Sampling Detection Limits

Carbon dioxide % 0.10

Oxygen % 0.10

Carbon monoxide vppm 0.26 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm 0.47 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm 0.10 mg/m³*

Reference Gas Details

Species Units Value Uncertainityk = 2

Carbon dioxide* % 7.41 5701338 20 ± 2

Carbon monoxide vppm 411.00 236924 1000 ± 2

Oxygen* % 10.35 5701338 25 ± 2

Nitrogen % 99.999 VC035033 - ± 2Oxides of nitrogen vppm 417.00 236924 500 ± 2Volatile organic compounds vppm 10.10 195025 1000 ± 2

* Gas divider used

Zero And Span Gas Details

Species units Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Carbon monoxide vppm 0.00 411.00 0.00 415.00

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

Oxides of nitrogen vppm 0.00 417.00 0.00 420.00

Volatile organic compounds vppm 0.00 10.10 0.20 10.20

Exhaust Gas Continuous Analysis Data

308.13357.14

3.47

508.88262.7031.21

400.17278.2913.74

380.30287.6823.85

0.431.290.24

Cylinder Reference Analyser Range

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00070

Page 101: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 14 of 57Date 02/10/2013

From 12:50 to 13:50 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 377.94 mg/m³*

Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 104.11 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 21.51 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 8.65

Oxygen %, dry 11.81

From 13:50 to 14:50 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 247.90 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 112.92 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 21.40 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 8.74

Oxygen %, dry 11.73

.

From 14:50 to 15:50 60 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 284.67 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 115.52 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 4.01 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 8.68

Oxygen %, dry 11.79

From 15:50 to 16:50 47 minute mean

Carbon monoxide vppm, dry 327.76 mg/m³*

Oxides of nitrogen vppm, dry 118.91 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm, dry 18.49 mg/m³*

Carbon dioxide %, dry 8.81

Oxygen %, dry 11.63

Sampling Detection Limits

Carbon dioxide % 0.10

Oxygen % 0.10

Carbon monoxide vppm 0.26 mg/m³*Oxides of nitrogen vppm 0.47 mg/m³*Volatile organic compounds vppm 0.10 mg/m³*

Reference Gas Details

Species Units Value Uncertainityk = 2

Carbon dioxide % 7.41 5701338 20 ± 2

Carbon monoxide vppm 411.00 236924 1000 ± 2

Oxygen % 10.35 5701338 25 ± 2

Nitrogen % 99.999 VC035033 - ± 2

Oxides of nitrogen vppm 417.00 236924 500 ± 2Volatile organic compounds vppm 10.10 195025 1000 ± 2

Zero And Span Gas Details

Species units Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Carbon monoxide vppm 0.00 411.00 0.00 415.00

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

Oxides of nitrogen vppm 0.00 417.00 0.00 420.00

Volatile organic compounds vppm 0.00 10.10 0.20 10.20

Exhaust Gases - Continuous Analysis Data, Continued

565.64

255.9841.39

367.52275.0440.80

425.14283.43

7.71

480.96

286.6734.88

0.431.290.24

Cylinder Reference Analyser Range

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00071

Page 102: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topl

ing

Ltd,

Inve

rkip

, R13

- 52

98,v

1Vi

sit

1of

2013

Page

15

of57

Cha

rt 1

- G

as D

ata

Boi

ler O

utle

t - 0

2/10

/201

3 - S

traw

0.0

200.

0

400.

0

600.

0

800.

0

1000

.0

1200

.0

1400

.0 08:4

408

:59

09:1

409

:29

09:4

409

:59

10:1

410

:29

10:4

410

:59

11:1

411

:29

11:4

411

:59

12:1

412

:29

12:4

412

:59

13:1

413

:29

13:4

413

:59

14:1

414

:29

14:4

414

:59

15:1

415

:29

15:4

415

:59

16:1

416

:29

16:4

416

:59

17:1

417

:29

17:4

4Ti

me

mg/m3 at reference conditions

0.0

2.0

4.0

6.0

8.0

10.0

12.0

14.0

16.0

%

CO

NO

x (a

s N

O2)

TOC

Oxy

gen

(%)

CO

2 (%

)

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00072

Page 103: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 16 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P58/PT137 Nozzle Diameter (d) mm 10.00Pitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.84 In-stack Filtration Y/N NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.976 Leak check OK Y/N YBarometric Pressure kPa 99.8 Meter ID No CU09Duct static Pressure kPa 0.01 Initial Gas Meter Reading m³ 2.773Date 02/10/2013 Final Gas Meter Reading m³ 3.198Start Time hh:min 10:08 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter m³ 0.425End Time hh:min 10:38 Sampled Vol, Dry STP Nm³ 0.386Sampling Duration hh:min 00:30 Moisture content of stack gas % v/v 8.8

Isokinetic % 106.2

Impinger 1 2 3 4 5Initial mass (g) 794.6 737.2 670.2 674.0 1043.1Final mass (g) 820.9 737.0 671.2 673.6 1046.5

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Reading Sample Gas Filter Meter OrificePoint Time Temperature Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (h) (Ts) (Tm) (Dh)hh:min mm w.g °C °C °C mm w.g

00:00:00 1.0 93 160 16 17.000:05:00 1.0 94 160 16 17.000:10:00 1.0 93 160 16 17.000:15:00 1.0 94 160 16 17.000:20:00 1.0 95 159 16 17.000:25:00 1.0 94 160 17 17.000:30:00 93 160 17

Averages 1.0 94 160 16 17.0

Average velocity 3.82 m/sAverage flow rate 0.87 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.51 m³/s*

Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data Test 1

Temperatures

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00073

Page 104: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 17 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P58/PT137 Nozzle Diameter (d) mm 10.00Pitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.84 In-stack Filtration Y/N NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.976 Leak check OK Y/N YBarometric Pressure kPa 99.8 Meter ID No CU09Duct static Pressure kPa 0.01 Initial Gas Meter Reading m³ 3.207Date 02/10/2013 Final Gas Meter Reading m³ 3.629Start Time hh:min 11:40 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter m³ 0.422End Time hh:min 12:10 Sampled Vol, Dry STP Nm³ 0.383Sampling Duration hh:min 00:30 Moisture content of stack gas % v/v 9.0

Isokinetic % 105.0

Impinger 1 2 3 4 5Initial mass (g) 394.6 716.5 688.7 673.6 1046.5Final mass (g) 414.6 718.6 688.7 674.0 1054.6

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Reading Sample Gas Filter Meter OrificePoint Time Temperature Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (h) (Ts) (Tm) (Dh)hh:min mm w.g °C °C °C mm w.g

A 00:00:00 1.0 91 157 16 17.000:05:00 1.0 91 158 17 17.000:10:00 1.0 91 159 16 17.000:15:00 1.0 90 160 16 17.000:20:00 1.0 90 159 17 17.000:25:00 1.0 89 160 17 17.000:30:00 91 160 18

Averages 1.0 90 159 17 17.0

Average velocity 3.80 m/sAverage flow rate 0.87 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.46 m³/s*

Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data Test 2

Temperatures

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00074

Page 105: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 18 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P58/PT137 Nozzle Diameter (d) mm 10.00Pitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.84 In-stack Filtration Y/N NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 0.976 Leak check OK Y/N YBarometric Pressure kPa 99.8 Meter ID No CU09Duct static Pressure kPa 0.01 Initial Gas Meter Reading m³ 4.620Date 02/10/2013 Final Gas Meter Reading m³ 5.049Start Time hh:min 13:26 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter m³ 0.429End Time hh:min 13:56 Sampled Vol, Dry STP Nm³ 0.384Sampling Duration hh:min 00:30 Moisture content of stack gas % v/v 11.4

Isokinetic % 107.9

Impinger 1 2 3 4 5Initial mass (g) 394.0 709.0 673.2 674.6 1054.6Final mass (g) 418.9 712.0 675.7 675.6 1062.7

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Reading Sample Gas Filter Meter OrificePoint Time Temperature Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (h) (Ts) (Tm) (Dh)hh:min mm w.g °C °C °C mm w.g

00:00:00 1.0 87 157 21 17.000:05:00 1.0 88 159 21 17.000:10:00 1.0 89 160 21 17.000:15:00 1.0 91 160 21 17.000:20:00 1.0 92 160 21 17.000:25:00 1.0 93 160 21 17.000:30:00 93 160 21

Averages 1.0 90 159 21 17.0

Average velocity 3.80 m/sAverage flow rate 0.87 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.52 m³/s*

Total Particulate Matter - Sampling Data Test 3

Temperatures

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00075

Page 106: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 19 of 57

Blank Filter Weight Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)

Filter No X10837 29/10/2013 0.76661 0.76660 0.00001

Washings 9765 28/10/2013 49.95446 49.95365 0.00081

Filter Weight Test 1 Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)

Filter No X10840 29/10/2013 0.97507 0.82020 0.15487

Washings 9766 28/10/2013 50.07572 50.06940 0.00632

Filter Weight Test 2 Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)

Filter No X10850 29/10/2013 0.96083 0.83063 0.13020

Washings 9767 28/10/2013 45.87889 45.87192 0.00697

Filter Weight Test 3 Date of analysis After (g) Before (g) Collected (g)Filter No X10851 29/10/2013 0.97690 0.80920 0.16770Washings 9768 28/10/2013 48.59054 48.58312 0.00742

Sample Hopper Or Total weights (g)

Number Filter No After Before Collected

Blank X10837 50.72107 50.72025 0.00082 -0.00012

Test 1 X10840 51.05079 50.88960 0.16119 0.16025Test 2 X10850 46.83972 46.70255 0.13717 0.13623Test 3 X10851 49.56744 49.39232 0.17512 0.17418

0.00094 <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.49 mg/m3*Particulate Emission -0.36 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 1

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

Particulate Emission Results Test 1

Detection Limit 1.49 mg/m3*Particulate Emission 476.30 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 2

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

Particulate Emission Results Test 2

Detection Limit 1.65 mg/m3*Particulate Emission 448.49 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 3Species Units ValueNitrogen % 99.999Oxygen % 10.35Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final SpanOxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

Particulate Emission Results Test 3Detection Limit 1.44 mg/m3*Particulate Emission 500.92 mg/m3*

Total Particulate Matter Tests 1-3 - Emission Results

% of Filter

Tare Weight

0.1

% of Filter

Tare Weight

19.7

% of Filter

Tare Weight

16.5

% of FilterTare Weight

21.6

Control Blank Corrected

Comments

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance Acetone Residue Weight

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Cylinder ReferenceVC0350335701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00076

Page 107: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 20 of 57

Blank Weights Sample Number Date of analysis Collected (g) Before (g)

Hexane Wash 16/10/2013 0.0005Impinger 16/10/2013 0.0018

Test 1 Sample Number Date of analysis Collected (g) Before (g)

Hexane Wash 16/10/2013 0.0014Impinger 16/10/2013 0.0038Condensate EMGJ02486/SB23 16/10/2013 0.0033

Test 2 Sample Number Date of analysis Collected (g) Before (g)

Hexane Wash 16/10/2013 0.0005Impinger 16/10/2013 0.0063Condensate EMGJ02486/SB29 16/10/2013 0.0029

Test 3 Sample Number Date of analysis Collected (g) Before (g)Hexane Wash 16/10/2013 0.0016Impinger 16/10/2013 0.0073Condensate EMGJ02486/SB34 16/10/2013 0.0035

Sample Hopper Or Total weights (g)

Number Filter No Collected Before

Blank GJ02486/SB17 0.00230 0.00000 0.00230

Test 1 GJ02486/SB21 0.00520 0.00000 0.00520Test 2 GJ02486/SB27 0.00680 0.00000 0.00680Test 3 GJ02486/SB32 0.00890 0.00000 0.00890

Condensable Particulate Emission Results Blank

Detection Limit 1.49 mg/m3*Condensable Particulate Emission 6.84 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 1

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

Condensable Particulate Emission Results Test 1

Detection Limit 1.49 mg/m3*Condensable Particulate Emission 15.46 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 2

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

Condensable Particulate Emission Results Test 2

Detection Limit 1.65 mg/m3*Condensable Particulate Emission 22.39 mg/m3*

Reference Gas Details Test 3Species Units ValueNitrogen % 99.999Oxygen % 10.35Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final SpanOxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

Condensable Particulate Emission Results Test 3Detection Limit 1.44 mg/m3*Condensable Particulate Emission 25.60 mg/m3*

Condensable Particulate Matter Tests 1-3 - Emission Results

EMGJ02486/SB27EMGJ02486/SB28

EMGJ02486/SB32EMGJ02486/SB33

EMGJ02486/SB17EMGJ02486/SB18

EMGJ02486/SB21EMGJ02486/SB22

5701338

VC035033

5701338

Cylinder ReferenceVC035033

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Cylinder Reference

Control Blank Corrected

Comments

#DIV/0!

% of FilterTare Weight

#DIV/0!

Tare Weight#DIV/0!

% of Filter

Tare Weight

% of Filter

Tare Weight#DIV/0!

% of Filter

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00077

Page 108: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 21 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P50 /PT114 Nozzle Diameter (d) 7.51 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.81 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 1.000 Meter ID No CU16Barometric Pressure 99.6 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 8.693 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 8.987 m³Date 02/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.294 m³Start Time 15:05 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.272 Nm³End Time 15:35 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 5.5 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 94.6 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g00:00:00 4.0 93 17 12.200:05:00 1.0 91 17 12.200:10:00 1.0 92 17 12.200:15:00 1.0 91 18 12.200:20:00 1.0 92 18 12.200:25:00 4.0 92 19 12.200:30:00 92 19

Averages 2.0 92 18 12.2

Average velocity 5.2 m/sAverage flow rate 1.2 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.7 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM2.5 Cyclone 2.25 2.75

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM2.5 Cyclone 2.6 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.00 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 94.6 PASS

PM2.5 - Sampling Data Test 1

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00078

Page 109: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 22 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1633 31/10/2013 0.15299 0.15288 0.00011

Washings 9803 04/11/2013 45.46635 45.46541 0.00094

Mass of filterable PM2.5 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1614 29/10/2013 0.21113 0.15275 0.05838

Washings 9810 04/11/2013 50.59944 50.59819 0.00125

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 45.61934 45.61829 0.00105 0.00012

Mass of filterable PM2.5 50.81057 50.75094 0.05963 0.05870

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.34 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission 0.51 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 1

Detection Limit 1.34 mg/m3*

Filterable PM2.5 Emissions 250.70 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 1 11.5 %

Reference Gas Details Test 1

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

PM2.5 - Emission Results Test 1

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

EMGJ02486/SB4

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SAB1

EMGJ02486/SAB2

EMGJ02486/SB3

Sample No.

Comments

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00079

Page 110: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 23 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P50 /PT114 Nozzle Diameter (d) 7.51 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.81 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 1.000 Meter ID No CU16Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 9.288 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 9.602 m³Date 02/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.314 m³Start Time 15:55 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.288 Nm³End Time 16:25 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 5.5 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 119.6 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g00:00:00 4.0 94 20 12.200:05:00 1.5 94 20 12.200:10:00 1.0 94 20 12.200:15:00 1.0 95 20 12.200:20:00 0.5 94 21 12.200:25:00 0.5 96 21 12.200:30:00 94 21

Averages 1.4 94 20 12.2

Average velocity 4.4 m/sAverage flow rate 1.0 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.5 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM2.5 Cyclone 2.25 2.75

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM2.5 Cyclone 2.5 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.00 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 119.6 PASS

PM2.5 - Sampling Data Test 2

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00080

Page 111: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 24 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1633 31/10/2013 0.15299 0.15288 0.00011

Washings 9803 04/11/2013 45.46635 45.46541 0.00094

Mass of filterable PM2.5 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1610 29/10/2013 0.20690 0.15121 0.05569

Washings 9811 04/11/2013 48.18124 48.17979 0.00145

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 45.61934 45.61829 0.00105 0.00012

Mass of filterable PM2.5 48.38814 48.33100 0.05714 0.05621

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.26 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission 0.52 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 2

Detection Limit 1.26 mg/m3*

Filterable PM2.5 Emissions 241.70 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 2 12.1 %

Reference Gas Details Test 2

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

PM2.5 - Emission Results Test 2

Sample No.

Comments

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SAB1

EMGJ02486/SAB2

EMGJ02486/SB5

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

EMGJ02486/SB6

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00081

Page 112: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 25 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P50 /PT114 Nozzle Diameter (d) 7.51 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.81 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 1.000 Meter ID No CU16Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 0.206 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 0.515 m³Date 02/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.309 m³Start Time 16:57 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.282 Nm³End Time 17:27 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 5.5 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 113.6 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g00:00:00 1.0 94 22 12.200:05:00 1.0 94 22 12.200:10:00 1.0 95 22 12.200:15:00 1.0 95 23 12.200:20:00 1.0 95 23 12.200:25:00 4.0 96 23 12.200:30:00 96 22

Averages 1.5 95 22 12.2

Average velocity 4.5 m/sAverage flow rate 1.0 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.6 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM2.5 Cyclone 2.25 2.75

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM2.5 Cyclone 2.5 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.00 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 113.6 PASS

PM2.5 - Sampling Data Test 3

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00082

Page 113: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 26 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1633 31/10/2013 0.15299 0.15288 0.00011

Washings 9803 04/11/2013 45.46635 45.46541 0.00094

Mass of filterable PM2.5 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1608 29/10/2013 0.20918 0.14779 0.06139

Washings 9812 04/11/2013 52.60333 52.60147 0.00186

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 45.61934 45.61829 0.00105 0.00012

Mass of filterable PM2.5 52.81251 52.74926 0.06325 0.06232

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.26 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission 0.46 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 3

Detection Limit 1.26 mg/m3*

Filterable PM2.5 Emissions 241.08 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 3 10.9 %

Reference Gas Details Test 3

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

PM2.5 - Emission Results Test 3

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

EMGJ02486/SB8

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SAB1

EMGJ02486/SAB2

EMGJ02486/SB7

Sample No.

Comments

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00083

Page 114: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 27 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P50 /PT114 Nozzle Diameter (d) 6.86 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.81 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 1.000 Meter ID No CU16Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 7.106 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 7.466 m³Date 02/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.360 m³Start Time 09:10 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.335 Nm³End Time 09:40 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 7.3 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 116.7 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g00:00:00 3.0 98 15 15.400:05:00 3.0 98 15 15.400:10:00 3.0 99 16 15.400:15:00 3.0 98 16 15.400:20:00 3.0 96 17 15.400:25:00 3.0 98 17 15.400:30:00 98 18 15.4

Averages 3.0 98 16 15.4

Average velocity 6.4 m/sAverage flow rate 1.5 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.7 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM10 Cyclone 9 11

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM10 Cyclone 9.55 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.01 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 116.7 PASS

PM10 - Sampling Data Test 1

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00084

Page 115: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 28 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1633 31/10/2013 0.15299 0.15288 0.00011

Washings 9803 04/11/2013 45.46635 45.46541 0.00094

Mass of filterable PM10 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1605 29/10/2013 0.14945 0.14576 0.00369

Washings 9613 04/11/2013 45.88835 45.88144 0.00691

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 45.61934 45.61829 0.00105 0.00012

Mass of filterable PM10 46.03780 46.02720 0.00874 0.00781

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.09 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission 0.48 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 1

Detection Limit 1.09 mg/m3*

Filterable PM10 Emissions 31.14 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 1 12.8 %

Reference Gas Details Test 1

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

PM10 - Emission Results Test 1

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SAB1

EMGJ02486/SAB2

EMGJ02486/SB9

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SB10

Comments

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00085

Page 116: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 29 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P50 /PT114 Nozzle Diameter (d) 6.86 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.81 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 1.000 Meter ID No CU16Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 4.481 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 4.828 m³Date 02/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.347 m³Start Time 10:30 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.323 Nm³End Time 11:00 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 7.3 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 118.9 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

Number (Δp) (Ts) (Tm) (ΔH)hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g

B 00:00:00 2.0 95 15 15.400:05:00 2.5 102 15 15.400:10:00 3.0 94 16 15.400:15:00 3.0 93 16 15.400:20:00 3.0 91 17 15.400:25:00 2.5 92 17 15.400:30:00 93 18 15.4

Averages 2.7 94 16 15.4

Average velocity 6.0 m/sAverage flow rate 1.4 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.7 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM10 Cyclone 9 11

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM10 Cyclone 9.8 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.01 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 118.9 PASS

PM10 - Sampling Data Test 2

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00086

Page 117: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 30 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1633 31/10/2013 0.15299 0.15288 0.00011

Washings 9803 04/11/2013 45.46635 45.46541 0.00094

Mass of filterable PM10 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1627 29/10/2013 0.23205 0.14704 0.08501

Washings 9814 04/11/2013 45.76698 45.76556 0.00142

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 45.61934 45.61829 0.00105 0.00012

Mass of filterable PM10 45.99903 45.91260 0.08457 0.08364

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.13 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission 0.47 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 2

Detection Limit 1.13 mg/m3*

Filterable PM10 Emissions 326.29 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 2 12.3 %

Reference Gas Details Test 2

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

PM10 - Emission Results Test 2

EMGJ02486/SB11

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SB12

Comments

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SAB1

EMGJ02486/SAB2

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00087

Page 118: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 31 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P50 /PT114 Nozzle Diameter (d) 6.86 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.81 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 1.000 Meter ID No CU16Barometric Pressure 99.6 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 7.884 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 8.225 m³Date 02/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.341 m³Start Time 11:40 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.316 Nm³End Time 12:10 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 7.3 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 94.7 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g00:00:00 4.0 92 17 15.400:05:00 4.0 91 17 15.400:10:00 4.0 97 17 15.400:15:00 4.0 91 17 15.400:20:00 4.0 91 17 15.400:25:00 4.0 90 18 15.400:30:00 90 18 15.4

Averages 4.0 92 17 15.4

Average velocity 7.4 m/sAverage flow rate 1.7 m³/sAverage flow rate 0.9 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM10 Cyclone 9 11

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM10 Cyclone 9.9 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.01 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 94.7 PASS

PM10 - Sampling Data Test 3

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00088

Page 119: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 32 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1633 31/10/2013 0.15299 0.15288 0.00011

Washings 9803 04/11/2013 45.46635 45.46541 0.00094

Mass of filterable PM10 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1615 29/10/2013 0.23151 0.15150 0.08001

Washings 9815 04/11/2013 45.96340 45.96233 0.00107

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 45.61934 45.61829 0.00105 0.00012

Mass of filterable PM10 46.19491 46.11383 0.07922 0.07829

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.12 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission 0.48 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 3

Detection Limit 1.12 mg/m3*

Filterable PM10 Emissions 313.76 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 3 12.3 %

Reference Gas Details Test 3

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

PM10 - Emission Results Test 3

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SAB1

EMGJ02486/SAB2

EMGJ02486/SB13

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SB14

Comments

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00089

Page 120: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 33 of 57

Probe/Pitot ID No P50 /PT114 Nozzle Diameter (d) 6.86 mmPitot Calibration Factor (Cp) 0.81 Leak check OK Y Y/NGas Calibration Factor (Y) 1.000 Meter ID No CU16Barometric Pressure 99.8 kPa Initial Gas Meter Reading 8.251 m³Duct static Pressure 0.01 kPa Final Gas Meter Reading 8.590 m³Date 02/10/2013 Sampled Vol, Dry at Meter 0.339 m³Start Time 13:50 hh:min Sampled Vol, Dry STP 0.316 Nm³End Time 14:20 hh:min Moisture content of stack gas 7.3 % v/vSampling Duration 00:30 hh:min Isokinetic 94.8 %

Sample Line Sampling Pitot Sample Gas Meter OrificePoint Time Reading Temperature Temperature Pressure

hh:mm:ss mm w.g °C °C mm w.g00:00:00 4.0 95 15 15.400:05:00 4.0 102 15 15.400:10:00 4.0 94 16 15.400:15:00 4.0 93 16 15.400:20:00 4.0 91 17 15.400:25:00 4.0 92 17 15.400:30:00 93 18 15.4

Averages 4.0 94 16 15.4

Average velocity 7.4 m/sAverage flow rate 1.7 m³/sAverage flow rate 1.0 m³/s*

Required Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μm Minimum MaximumPM10 Cyclone 9 11

Actual Particle Cut Diameter (D50), μmPM10 Cyclone 9.9 PASS

Cunningham Slip Factor Acceptance CriteiaCunningham Slip Factor Acceptance, Z = 1.01 PASS

Isokinetic Sample Rate Criteria, %Isokinetic Sample Rate, % 94.8 PASS

PM10 - Sampling Data Test 4

Temperatures

0.99 ≤ Z ≥ 1.01

80 to 120%

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00090

Page 121: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1

Visit 1 of 2013

Page 34 of 57

Field Blank Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1633 31/10/2013 0.15299 0.15288 0.00011

Washings 9803 04/11/2013 45.46635 45.46541 0.00094

Mass of filterable PM10 Analysis Date Final (g) Initial (g) Collected (g)

Filter No W1613 29/10/2013 0.21583 0.15043 0.06540

Washings 9816 04/11/2013 46.69787 46.68280 0.01507

Total weights (g)

Final Initial Collected

Field Blank 45.61934 45.61829 0.00105 0.00012

Mass of filterable PM10 46.91370 46.83323 0.07861 0.07768

0.00093 Acetone Residue Weight <1ppm

Particulate emission results Blank

Detection Limit 1.17 mg/m3*

Particulate Emission 0.44 mg/m3*

Particulate emission results Test 4

Detection Limit 1.17 mg/m3*

Filterable PM10 Emissions 285.08 mg/m3*

Oxygen Concentration Test 4 11.5 %

Reference Gas Details Test 4

Species Units Value

Nitrogen % 99.999

Carbon Dioxide % 7.41

Oxygen % 10.35

Calibration Details Initial Time 08:02 Final Time 17:27

Units Initial Zero Initial Span Final Zero Final Span

Carbon Dioxide % 0.00 7.41 0.06 7.30

Oxygen % 0.00 10.35 0.04 10.34

PM10 - Emission Results Test 4

EMGJ02486/SB35

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SB36

Comments

Sample No.

EMGJ02486/SAB1

EMGJ02486/SAB2

5701338

Washings Control Blank Weight Variance

Control Blank Corrected

Cylinder Reference

VC035033

5701338

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00091

Page 122: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 35 of 57

APPENDIX 3

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00092

Page 123: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 36 of 57

Diagram of sampling points across the cross section of the duct (not to scale).

Traverse length = 0.54 m

Point % of D Locationcm

1 45.0 24.3

Diagram Of The Sampling Location

X

A

B

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00093

Page 124: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 37 of 57

Stack area:

D = Diameter (m)π = 3.142 Pressure conversion: 1mmH2O = 0.00980665 kPa 1mmH2O = 9.80665 Pa 1 mar = 0.1 kPa Water vapour concentration: From reference calculations (taken from BS EN 14790):

VWC (%) = Water vapour content on wet basis, in volume % (m3 of water vapour in m3 of wet gas)Vm(std) = Dry gas volume measured, corrected to standard conditions (m3)mWC = Mass of water collected in the impingers (g) Mw = Molecular weight of water, 18.01534 rounded to 18 (g/mol)Vmol(std) = Molar volume of water at standard conditions = 0.0224 (m3/mol) Gas meter volume at standard conditions (STP) From reference calculations (taken from BS EN 14790):

Vm(std) = Dry gas meter volume at standard conditions (m3) yd = Gas meter calibration coefficient (V2-V1) = Dry gas meter volume at actual conditions (m3) Tm = Actual Temperature (K) Tstd = Standard temperature (273 K)pm = Absolute pressure at the gas meter (kPa)pstd = Standard gas pressure (101.3 kPa)

Isokenetic Ratio (%): From reference calculations (taken from EA TGN M2):

Estimating Measurment UncertaintyUncertainty estimates are calculated using the general rule of uncertainty propagation. Guidance is taken from publications including UKAS document M3003 and ISO 20988:2007.

General Calculations

100.

.

)()(

)(

(%) ×+

=

stdmW

stdmolWC

W

stdmolWC

WC

VMVm

MVm

V

std

m

m

stddstdm p

pTTVVyV ××−×= )( 12)(

( ) 100% ×=gasstacktheofVelocitynozzlesamplingtheatVelocityRatioIsokinetic

4. 2DcircleaofArea π

=

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00094

Page 125: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 38 of 57

Velocity: From reference calculations (taken from ISO 10780):

Average velocity (m/s) C = velocity calculation constant = 129Ts = Average stack temperature (K)Ms =K = Pitot calibration coefficient Pe = Absolute gas pressure (kPa)

Average pitot tube pressure differencial (kPa)

Volume flow rateFrom reference calculations (taken from ISO 10780):

qva = Average flow rate (m3/s) Average velocity (m/s)

A = Stack cross-sectional area (m2)

Volume flow rate corrected for moistureFrom reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096):

qm = Corrected volume flowrate (m3/s)qva = Volume flow rate at actual conditions (m3/s)Ha = Moisture at actual conditions (%volume)Hm = Reference moisture (%volume)

Volume flow rate corrected for temperature and pressureFrom reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096):

qm = Corrected volume flowrate (m3/s)qva = Volume flow rate at actual conditions (m3/s)Ta = Temperature at actual conditions (K)Tm = Reference Temperatue (K)pa = Absolute gas pressure at actual conditions (kPa)pm = Reference pressure (kPa) Volume flow rate corrected for oxygenFrom reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096):

qm = Corrected volume flowrate (m3/s)qva = Volume flow rate at actual conditions (m3/s)O2,m = Actual oxygen concentration (%)O2,ref =Reference oxygen concentration (%)

Molar mass of gas; assume 29 kg/kmol unless the molar mass is < 27 kg/kmol or > 31 g/kmol

Flow Calculations

=v

=v

Avqva =

( ))100(

100

m

avam H

Hqq−−

=

se

s

MppTKCv Δ

=

( ))( ma

amvam pT

pTqq =

( )( )m

refvam O

Oqq

,2

,2

9.209.20

−=

=pΔ

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00095

Page 126: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 39 of 57

Concentration: From reference calculations (taken from BS EN 13284-1):

c = Concentrationm = Mass of substaneV = Volume sampled

c = Concentrationq = Volume flow rate Concentration corrected for oxygen: From reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096):

cm = Concentration at reference conditionsca = Actual concentrationO2, ref = Reference oxygen (%)O2, a= Actual Oxygen (%) Concentration corrected for moisture: From reference calculations (taken from BS ISO 9096): Convert wet gas to dry gas

Convert dry gas to wet gas

cwet = Concentration wet gascdry = Concentration dry gasHa = Water vapour content (%vol) Conversion of parts per million (ppm) to mg/m3

From reference calculations (taken from EA TGN M2):

molar volume at 273K = 22.4 litres

When Converting TOC

molar volume at 273K = 22.4 litres

Mass Emission

Concentration Calculations

Vmc =

a

refam O

Occ

,2

,2

9.209.20

−−

×=

awetdry H

cc−

×=100

100

100100 a

drywetHcc −

×=

etemperaturgivenaatlvolumemolargweightmolecularppmionConcentratmmgionConcentrat

)()()()/( 3 ×

=

etemperaturgivenaatlvolumemolarggasspanincarbonofweightmolecularppmionConcentratmmgionConcentrat

)()()()/( 3 ×

=

mqcemissionMass ×=

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00096

Page 127: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 40 of 57

Where:C m = the measured concentration in mg/m3

Q m = mass concentration collected in absorber solution and filter in mgv s = the volume of the sample solution in lV std = volume sampled at standard conditions in m3

T m = mean temperature of gas meter in KT std = standard temperature = 273Kp=prel+Patm = absolute pressure = gas meter pressure + atmospheric pressure in kPaP std = standard pressure = 101.325 kPaV T.p = volume sampled as indicated by the gas meter in m3

Expression for calculation of the combined uncertainty of the measured concentration

Expression for calculation of the combined uncertainty of the gas volume

Assuming that uncertainties associated with the standard quantities T std and Pstd are negliableExpression for calculation of the combined uncertainty of the measured concentration

Overall expanded uncertainty (k = 2)

Uncertainty of the measured concentration at oxygen reference concentration

Where:

u(Cm,O2,ref) = in mg/m3

Cm,O2,ref = mass concentration at O2 reference concentration in mg/m3

O2,meas = O2 measured concentration in % volumeu((O2,meas)dry) = uncertainty associated to the measured O2 concentration in % (relative to O2 meas)

uncertainty associated with the mass concentration at O2 referenceconcentration

Calculation of Uncertainty Estimates - Manual Monitoring Techniques

std

stdpTstd P

pT

TVV ××= .

stdm

stdpTstd P

pTT

VV ××= .

std

mm V

QC =

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )2

2

2

2

2

2

2

2

std

std

s

s

m

m

m

m

VVu

vvu

QQu

CCu

++=

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )2

2

2

2

2

2

2.

.2

2

2

2

2

2

2

ppu

ppu

TTu

VVu

vvu

QQu

CCu atmrel

pT

pT

s

s

m

m

m

m +++++=

( ) ( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )22

2

2

2

2

2

2.

.2

2

2

2

2

matmrel

pT

pT

s

s

m

mm C

ppu

ppu

TTu

VVu

vvu

QQu

Cu ×⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛+++++=

( ) ( ) kCuCU mm ×=

( ) ( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( )

( )( ) ( )2,,2

,,2

,,22

2

2

2

2

2

2

2.

.2

2

2

2

2

, 2,2 21 refOmdrymeas

drymeasatmrel

pT

pT

s

s

m

mOm C

OOu

ppu

ppu

TTu

VVu

vvu

QQuCu

ref×⎟

⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

−++++++=

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00097

Page 128: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 41 of 57

Model equation

Where:C ,ppm = concentration in ppm Corr rep = correction of repeatability of measurementC NO,reading = concentration given by analyser Corr adj = correction of adjustmentCorr fit = correction of lack of fit Corr inf = correction of influence quantitiesCorr 0,dr = correction of zero drift Corr int = correction of interferentsCorr s,dr = correction of span drift

Calculation of partial uncertainties

u(Corrfit) = Where:Xfit,max is the maximum allowable deviation from linearity

Expressed as % of the range and calculated by applying a rectangular probability distribution

u(Corr0,dr) = u(Corrs,dr) =

u(Corrrep) = max (S0,rep ; Ssrep) = Srep

Where:Sr,0 is the standard uncertainty at zero levelSr,s is the standard uncertainty at span level

u(Corradj) = u(Corrloss) + u(Corrcal) Where:u(Corrloss) is the uncertainty due to losses in sample line

u(Corrloss) = u(Corrcal) is the uncertainty due to losses in sample linecj,loss is the concentration of sample loss at span level

u(Corrcal) = Ucal is the expanded uncertainty of the calibration gas

u(Corr inf ) =

Where:cj is the sensitivity coefficient of the influence quantityxj,min is the minimum value of the influence quantity during monitoringxj,max is the maximum value of the influence quantity during monitoringxj,adj is the value of the influence quantity during adjustment

u(Corr int ) =

and Where:cj is the sensitivity coefficient of the interferent j

u( ΣCorr int ) = Intj,test is the concentration of the interferent j used to determine c j

Intj,min is the minimum value of the interferent j quantity during monitoringIntj,max is the maximum value of the interferent j quantity during monitoringIntj,adj is the concentration of the interferent j in the cal gas used to adjust the analyserS int,p is the sum of interferents with positive impact S int,n is the sum of interferents with negative impact

Combined uncertainty

u(C, ppm ) =

Overall expanded uncertainty (k = 2)

Uncertainty of NOx measurements Where:

u(C NOx , conv ) = CNOx is the concentration of NOx measured by the analyserR is the ratio of NO:Nox in the stack gasη is the NOx converter efficiency

Combined uncertainty NOx measurements

u(C NOx , stack ) =

Uncertainty of mass concentration at oxygen reference concentration

u(C, O2 ref ) =

Where:u(C,O2,ref) = uncertainty associated with the mass concentration at O 2 ref. concentration in mg/m3

C,O2,ref = mass concentration at O2 reference concentration in mg/m3

O2,meas = O2 measured concentration in % volumeu((O2,meas)dry) = uncertainty associated to the measured O2 concentration in % (relative to O2 meas)

Calculation of Uncertainty Estimates - Instrumental Monitoring Techniques

int1

inf,,0 CorrCorrCorrCorrCorrCorrCorrCCp

iadjrepdrsdrfitreadingppm +++++++= ∑

=

3100

max,⎟⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

⎛× range

X fit

3,0 drX

3,drsX

3,lossjC

2calU

( ) ( ) ( ) ( )3

2,min,,max,,min,

2,max, adjjjadjjjadjjjadjjj

j

xxxxxxxxc

−+−×−+−

3

2min,max,min,

2max,

,

jjjj

testj

j IntIntIntIntInt

c +×+

3η×× RCNOx

( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )convNOxIntadjvolttemppressavfsrepdrsdrfit corruScorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorru ,22222

,2

,22

,2

,022 ++++++++++

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

( ) ( ) kCuCU mm ×=

( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )( ) ⎟

⎟⎠

⎞⎜⎜⎝

−++++++++++ 2

,,2

,,22

2222,

2,

22,

2,0

22

21 drymeas

drymeasIntadjvolttemppressavfsrepdrsdrfit O

OuScorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorru

( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) ( ) 2222,

2,

22,

2,0

22Intadjvolttemppressavfsrepdrsdrfit Scorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorrucorru +++++++++

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00098

Page 129: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 42 of 57

APPENDIX 4

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00099

Page 130: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013Page 43 of 57

Analyser Type/Model Horiba PG250

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value % N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/AMeasured concentration % 12.8 11.7 11.9 11.7 11.8 11.7 11.8 11.6Calibration gas % 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4 10.4Full Scale % 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0 25.0

Value of partial standard uncertainty at limit value in % volumeCorrection of Lack of FitLack of fit % volume 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30

u(Corr,fit) 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift* (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift (Residual) % volume

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift (Residual) % volume

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04 0.04

u(Corr,rep) 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010 0.010

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5 0.5

u(Corr,loss) 0.04 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.03Uncertainty of calibration gas % volume 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,cal) 0.13 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.12 0.12

Correction of Influence of InterferentsTotal of interferent influences % range 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56 0.56u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081 0.081

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,flow) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070 -0.070

u(Corr,temp) -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026 -0.026Sensitivity to electrical voltage % volume 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.1735% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009

Interferent Concentration Variationsmg/m3 Minimum Maximum Value at cal Performance UnitsNO range 0 300 0 300 mg/m3

NO2 range 0 30 0 30 mg/m3

CO2 range 0 10 0 10 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 51 66 60 10 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99.00 101 100 2 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 278 313 285 10 kPaSensitivity to electrical voltage 104.5 115.5 110 10 V

Measurement uncertaintyTest 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8

Measured value 12.75 11.69 11.87 11.74 11.81 11.73 11.79 11.63Combined uncertainty as % volume 0.23 0.23 0.23 0.23 0.23 0.23 0.23 0.23Combined uncertainty as % of ELV N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/ACombined uncertainty relative to measured value, % 1.84 1.95 1.93 1.94 1.94 1.95 1.94 1.96

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8

Measured value 12.75 11.69 11.87 11.74 11.81 11.73 11.79 11.63Expanded uncertainty as % volume 0.47 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46 0.46Expanded uncertainty as % of ELV N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/AExpanded uncertainty relative to measured value, % 3.67 3.90 3.86 3.89 3.87 3.89 3.88 3.92

Note: Values of standard uncertainty that are less than 5% of the maximum uncertainty are not includedThe uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Oxygen BS EN 14789:2005

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00100

Page 131: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013Page 44 of 57

Analyser Type/Model Horiba PG250

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value % N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/AMeasured concentration % 7.9 8.9 8.7 8.8 8.6 8.7 8.7 8.8Calibration gas % 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4 7.4Full Scale % 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0 20.0

Value of partial standard uncertainty at limit value in % volumeCorrection of Lack of FitLack of fit % volume 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30

u(Corr,fit) 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift* (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift (Residual) % volume

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift (Residual) % volume

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20

u(Corr,rep) 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0

u(Corr,loss) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Uncertainty of calibration gas % volume 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,cal) 0.08 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09

Correction of Influence of InterferentsTotal of interferent influences % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,flow) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040 0.040

u(Corr,temp) 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012 0.012Sensitivity to electrical voltage % volume 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.173 0.1735% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009 0.009

Interferent Concentration VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

NO range 0 300 0 300 mg/m3

NO2 range 0 30 0 30 mg/m3

CO2 range 0 0 0 0 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 51 66 60 10 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99.00 101 100 2 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 278 313 285 10 kPaSensitivity to electrical voltage 104.5 115.5 110 10 V

Measurement uncertaintyTest 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8

Measured value 7.92 8.86 8.70 8.78 8.65 8.74 8.68 8.81Combined uncertainty as % volume 0.19 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20 0.20Combined uncertainty as % of ELV N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/ACombined uncertainty relative to measured value, % 2.46 2.25 2.28 2.26 2.29 2.27 2.28 2.26

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8

Measured value 7.92 8.86 8.70 8.78 8.65 8.74 8.68 8.81Expanded uncertainty as % volume 0.39 0.40 0.40 0.40 0.40 0.40 0.40 0.40Expanded uncertainty as % of ELV N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/AExpanded uncertainty relative to measured value, % 4.92 4.49 4.56 4.52 4.58 4.54 4.57 4.51

Note: Values of standard uncertainty that are less than 5% of the maximum uncertainty are not included in the combined uncertaintyThe uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Carbon Dioxide

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00101

Page 132: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013Page 45 of 57

Analyser Type/ModelReference Oxygen % ( 0 = No correction)

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value mg/m3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Limit value ppm 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0Measured concentration ppm 184.8 344.7 265.7 256.1 377.9 247.9 284.7 327.8Measured concentration mg/m3 231.0 430.8 332.1 320.1 472.4 309.9 355.8 409.7Concentration at O2 ref. concentration mg/m3 308.1 508.9 400.2 380.3 565.6 367.5 425.1 481.0

Calibration gas ppm 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0 411.0Calibration gas mg/m3 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8 513.8Analyser range ppm 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0 76.0Analyser range mg/m3 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0

Correction of Lack of FitLack of fit % range 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,fit) 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88 0.88

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift % range

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift % range

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2 0.2

u(Corr,rep) 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 0.49 0.49 0.49 0.49 0.49 0.49 0.49 0.49

u(Corr,loss) 0.52 0.97 0.75 0.72 1.06 0.70 0.80 0.92Uncertainty of calibration gas % range 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00

u(Corr,cal) 1.85 3.45 2.66 2.56 3.78 2.48 2.85 3.28

Correction of Influence of InterferentsN2O % range

u(Corr,N2O) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CO2 % range

u(Corr,CO2) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CH4 % range

u(Corr,CH4) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Total of interferent influences % range 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90 2.90u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48 1.48

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,flow) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05

u(Corr,temp) 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05Sensitivity to electrical voltage % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 1.85 3.45 2.66 2.56 3.78 2.48 2.85 3.285% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.09 0.17 0.13 0.13 0.19 0.12 0.14 0.16

Oxygen reference concentrationMeasured oxygen % 12.8 11.7 11.9 11.7 11.8 11.7 11.8 11.6Overall uncertainty of O2 measurement U (O2,meas) 2.8 2.4 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.4

u(Corr,O2) 7.00 9.97 8.03 7.50 11.27 7.24 8.45 9.35

Interferent Concentration VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

CH4 range 0 10 0 50 mg/m3

N2O range 0 0 0 20 mg/m3

CO2 range 8 12 0 15 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 55 65 60 5 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99 100 99 1 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 278 313 288 10 KSensitivity to electrical voltage 218.5 241.5 230 5 V

Measurement uncertainty Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Combined uncertainty ppm 2.58 3.97 3.26 3.17 4.29 3.10 3.42 3.81Combined uncertainty mg/m3 3.23 4.96 4.07 3.96 5.36 3.88 4.28 4.77Combined uncertainty at oxygen reference mg/m3 9.32 13.41 10.83 10.18 15.07 9.84 11.39 12.62

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty ppm 5.2 7.9 6.5 6.3 8.6 6.2 6.8 7.6Overall uncertainty mg/m3 6.5 9.9 8.1 7.9 10.7 7.8 8.6 9.5Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 2.8 2.3 2.5 2.5 2.3 2.5 2.4 2.3Overall uncertainty relative to range % 6.8 10.5 8.6 8.3 11.3 8.2 9.0 10.0

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty mg/m3 18.6 26.8 21.7 20.4 30.1 19.7 22.8 25.2Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 6.1 5.3 5.4 5.4 5.3 5.4 5.4 5.2Overall uncertainty relative to range % 19.6 28.2 22.8 21.4 31.7 20.7 24.0 26.6Overall uncertainty relative to ELV % #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0! #DIV/0!

The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Horiba PG25010

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Carbon Monoxide 15058:2006

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00102

Page 133: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 46 of 57

Analyser Type/ModelReference Oxygen % ( 0 = No correction)

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value mg/m3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Limit value ppm 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0Measured concentration ppm 130.4 108.3 112.5 117.9 104.1 112.9 115.5 118.9Measured concentration as NO2 mg/m3 267.7 222.4 230.9 242.1 213.8 231.9 237.2 244.2Concentration at O2 ref. concentration mg/m3 357.1 262.7 278.3 287.7 256.0 275.0 283.4 286.7

Calibration gas ppm 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0 417.0Calibration gas mg/m3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3 856.3Analyser range ppm 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9 60.9Analyser range mg/m3 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0 125.0Ratio of NOx/NO2 % 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0 90.0

Correction of Lack of FitLack of fit % range 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,fit) 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70 0.70

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1 0.1

u(Corr,rep) 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06 0.06

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,loss) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Uncertainty of calibration gas % range 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00 2.00

u(Corr,cal) 1.30 1.08 1.12 1.18 1.04 1.13 1.16 1.19

Correction of Influence of InterferentsNH3 % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,NH3) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CO2 % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,CO2) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Total of interferent influences % range 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20 1.20u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57 0.57

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,flow) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18 0.18

u(Corr,temp) 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17 0.17Sensitivity to electrical voltage % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Converter efficiencyConverter efficiency % Abs 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0 95.0Converter efficiency u(Corr,conv) 0.38 0.31 0.32 0.34 0.30 0.33 0.33 0.34

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 1.30 1.08 1.12 1.18 1.04 1.13 1.16 1.195% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.07 0.05 0.06 0.06 0.05 0.06 0.06 0.06

Oxygen reference concentrationMeasured oxygen % 12.8 11.7 11.9 11.7 11.8 11.7 11.8 11.6Overall uncertainty of O2 measurement U (O2,meas) 2.8 2.4 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.4

u(Corr,O2) 4.94 3.13 3.40 3.46 3.10 3.30 3.43 3.39

Interferent Concentration VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

NO range 100 150 0 300 mg/m3

NO2 range 0 20 0 20 mg/m3

CO2 range 8 15 0 15 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 55 65 60 5 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99 100 99 1 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 283 313 285 10 KSensitivity to electrical voltage 218.5 241.5 230 5 V

Measurement uncertainty Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Combined uncertainty ppm 1.6 1.5 1.5 1.5 1.4 1.5 1.5 1.5Combined uncertainty as NO2 mg/m3 3.4 3.0 3.1 3.2 2.9 3.1 3.1 3.2Combined uncertainty at oxygen reference mg/m3 10.7 7.1 7.6 7.8 7.0 7.4 7.7 7.7

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty ppm 3.3 2.9 3.0 3.1 2.8 3.0 3.0 3.1Overall uncertainty mg/m3 4.1 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.6 3.7 3.8 3.9Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 1.5 1.6 1.6 1.6 1.7 1.6 1.6 1.6Overall uncertainty relative to range % 3.3 2.9 3.0 3.1 2.8 3.0 3.0 3.1

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty mg/m3 21.4 14.2 15.2 15.5 14.0 14.9 15.4 15.3Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 6.0 5.4 5.5 5.4 5.5 5.4 5.4 5.3Overall uncertainty relative to range % 17.1 11.4 12.2 12.4 11.2 11.9 12.3 12.2The overall expanded uncertainty for this method (k=2) must be lower than 10% relative to the daily ELV (dry and before correction to oxygen).

The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Horiba PG25010

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Oxides Of Nitrogen BS EN 14792:2005

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00103

Page 134: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 47 of 57

Analyser Type/ModelReference Oxygen % ( 0 = No correction)

Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Limit value mg/m3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Limit value ppm 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0Measured concentration ppm 1.6 16.4 7.1 12.5 21.5 21.4 4.0 18.5Measured concentration mg/m3 2.6 26.4 11.4 20.1 34.6 34.4 6.5 29.7Concentration at O2 ref. concentration mg/m3 3.5 31.2 13.7 23.9 41.4 40.8 7.7 34.9

Calibration gas ppm 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1 10.1Calibration gas mg/m3 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2 16.2Analyser range ppm 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3 9.3Analyser range mg/m3 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0 15.0

Correction of Lack of FitLack of fit % range 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,fit) 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.11

Corrections of Zero and Span Drift (*All drift is calculated for ∴ the residual is assumed to be < 5% u(max) )Zero Drift % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,0dr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Span Drift % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,sdr) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of Repeatability of MeasurementRepeatability SD at span level % range 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0(Not reported) u(Corr,rep) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Correction of adjustmentlosses in the line % range 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

u(Corr,loss) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Uncertainty of calibration gas % range 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 2.0

u(Corr,cal) 0.02 0.16 0.07 0.12 0.22 0.21 0.04 0.18

Correction of Influence of InterferentsN2O % range

u(Corr,N2O) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CO2 % range

u(Corr,CO2) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00CH4 % range

u(Corr,CH4) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Total of interferent influences % range 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50 2.50u(ΣCorrint) = u(ΣCorr int ) 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16 0.16

Correction of Influence QuantitiesSensitivity to sample volume flow % range 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60 1.60

u(Corr,flow) 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09 0.09Sensitivity to atmospheric pressure % range(Not reported) u(Corr,press) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00Sensitivity to ambient temperature % range -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40 -2.40

u(Corr,temp) -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28 -0.28Sensitivity to electrical voltage % range 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50 0.50(Not reported) u(Corr,volt) 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10

Oxygen reference concentrationMeasured oxygen % 12.8 11.7 11.9 11.7 11.8 11.7 11.8 11.6Overall uncertainty of O2 measurement U (O2,meas) 2.8 2.4 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.4

u(Corr,O2) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00

Maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,max) 0.11 0.16 0.11 0.12 0.22 0.21 0.11 0.185% of maximum standard uncertainty u(Corr,5%) 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01 0.01

Interferent Concentration Variations Minimum Maximum Value at cal Performance UnitsCH4 range 0 10 0 50 mg/m3

N2O range 0 0 0 20 mg/m3

CO2 range 8 12 0 15 mg/m3

Oxygen effect variations Minimum Maximum Value at cal Performance UnitsOxygen effect 0 20 0 2 mg/m3

Influence Quantitiy VariationsMinimum Maximum Value at cal Performance Units

Sensitivity to sample volume flow 55 65 60 5 l/hSensitivity to atmospheric pressure 99 100 99 1 kPaSensitivity to ambient temperature 278 313 288 10 KSensitivity to electrical voltage 187 250 230 5 V

Measurement uncertainty Test 1 Test 2 Test 3 Test 4 Test 5 Test 6 Test 7 Test 8Combined uncertainty ppm 0.37 0.40 0.37 0.39 0.42 0.42 0.37 0.41Combined uncertainty mg/m3 0.59 0.64 0.60 0.62 0.68 0.68 0.59 0.66Combined uncertainty at oxygen reference mg/m3 0.59 0.64 0.60 0.62 0.68 0.68 0.59 0.66

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty ppm 0.7 0.8 0.7 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.7 0.8Overall uncertainty mg/m3 1.2 1.3 1.2 1.2 1.4 1.4 1.2 1.3Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 45.2 4.9 10.5 6.2 3.9 4.0 18.3 4.4Overall uncertainty relative to range % 7.8 8.6 8.0 8.3 9.1 9.1 7.9 8.8Overall uncertainty relative to ELV % 7.2 7.9 7.4 7.6 8.4 8.4 7.3 8.1

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2Overall uncertainty mg/m3 1.2 1.3 1.2 1.2 1.4 1.4 1.2 1.3Overall uncertainty relative to measured value % 45.2 4.9 10.5 6.2 3.9 4.0 18.3 4.4Overall uncertainty relative to range % 7.8 8.6 8.0 8.3 9.1 9.1 7.9 8.8

The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Sick Maihak10

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Organic Carbon BS EN12619:2013

[ ]nIntpInt SS ,, ;max

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00104

Page 135: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 48 of 57

Total Particulate Matter Test 1

Symbol Mass concentration of TPM UnitsCm 414.82 mg/m3 Filter mgCm at O2 ref 476.30 mg/m3 Washings mg

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO2,ref (0=No Correction) 10 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911u (mass)/mass Relatve 160.250 mg - - - 0.0002

u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0019 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0009u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0010 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0006u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0011u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.386 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 289.3 K Normal - - 0.0032

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000010Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017

u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003Relative DGM Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40u (Prel)/P Measured pressure 99967 - - - - 0.0004

u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002Oxygen reference concentration

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of oxygen 0.23 % Normal 1 1 0.2341

Uncertainty of oxygen correction - - - - - 0.0244Measured Oxygen 11.4 % u (Orel)2/O2 0.000597

Measurement uncertaintyu(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.95 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 11.85 mg/m3

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 3.90 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 23.71 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 5.7 %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2), providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1

0.0

154.876.32

Daily emission limit value

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00105

Page 136: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 49 of 57

Total Particulate Matter Test 2

Symbol Mass concentration of TPM UnitsCm 355.68 mg/m3 Filter mgCm at O2 ref 448.49 mg/m3 Washings mg

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO2,ref (0=No Correction) 10 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911u (mass)/mass Relatve 136.230 mg - - - 0.0003

u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0019 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0009u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0010 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0006u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0011u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.383 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 289.7 K Normal - - 0.0032

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000010Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017

u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003Relative DGM Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40u (Prel)/P Measured pressure 99967 - - - - 0.0004

u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002Oxygen reference concentration

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of oxygen 0.23 % Normal 1 1 0.2341

Uncertainty of oxygen correction - - - - - 0.0244Measured Oxygen 11.4 % u (Orel)2/O2 0.000597

Measurement uncertaintyu(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.67 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 11.16 mg/m3

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 3.35 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 22.32 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 6.3 %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2), providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1

0.0

130.206.97

Daily emission limit value

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00106

Page 137: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 50 of 57

Total Particulate Matter Test 3

Symbol Mass concentration of TPM UnitsCm 453.96 mg/m3 Filter mgCm at O2 ref 500.92 mg/m3 Washings mg

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO2,ref (0=No Correction) 10 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911u (mass)/mass Relatve 174.180 mg - - - 0.0002

u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0019 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0009u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0010 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0006u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0011u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.384 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 294.0 K Normal - - 0.0031

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000010Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017

u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003Relative DGM Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40u (Prel)/P Measured pressure 99967 - - - - 0.0004

u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002Oxygen reference concentration

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of oxygen 0.23 % Normal 1 1 0.2341

Uncertainty of oxygen correction - - - - - 0.0244Measured Oxygen 11.4 % u (Orel)2/O2 0.000597

Measurement uncertaintyu(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 2.12 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 12.46 mg/m3

Expanded uncertainty expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 4.24 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Expanded uncertainty at oxygen reference conditions expressed with a level of confidence of 95%, k=2U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 24.93 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 5.5 %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2), providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Total Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1

0.0

167.707.42

Daily emission limit value

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00107

Page 138: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 51 of 57

PM2.5 Uncertainty Estimate Test 1

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 216.08 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 58.700 mg - - - 0.0004u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0013 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0007u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0001 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0001u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0007 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0004u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0008u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.272 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 364.9 K Normal - - 0.0025

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99600 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99720 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.037

Relatve 11.5 - Normal - - 0.0367u (Prel)2/P2 0.0013472

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.94 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.88 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 216.08 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 7.93 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 15.86 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 7.3 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

58.381.25

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00108

Page 139: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 52 of 57

PM2.5 Uncertainty Estimate Test 2

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 195.06 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 56.210 mg - - - 0.0005u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0014 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0007u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0001 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0001u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0008 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0004u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0009u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.288 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 367.4 K Normal - - 0.0025

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99920 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.041

Relatve 12.1 - Normal - - 0.0412u (Prel)2/P2 0.0016971

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.85 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.69 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 195.06 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 8.04 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 16.07 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 8.2 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

55.691.45

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00109

Page 140: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 53 of 57

PM2.5 Uncertainty Estimate Test 3

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 221.26 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 62.320 mg - - - 0.0004u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0014 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0007u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0001 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0001u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0008 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0004u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0008u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.282 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 368.0 K Normal - - 0.0025

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99920 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.033

Relatve 10.9 - Normal - - 0.0327u (Prel)2/P2 0.0010687

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.96 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.91 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 221.26 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 7.23 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 14.47 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 6.5 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

61.391.86

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00110

Page 141: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 54 of 57

PM10 Uncertainty Estimate Test 1

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 23.30 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 9.670 mg - - - 0.0039u (mass)2/mass2 0.000015

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0016 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0008u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0009 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0005u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0010u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.335 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 370.9 K Normal - - 0.0025

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99951 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.047

Relatve 12.8 - Normal - - 0.0471u (Prel)2/P2 0.0022148

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 0.16 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.33 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 1.4 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 23.30 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.10 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.19 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 9.4 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

3.696.91

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00111

Page 142: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 55 of 57

PM10 Uncertainty Estimate Test 2

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 258.86 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 85.500 mg - - - 0.0004u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0016 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0008u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0009 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0005u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0010u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.323 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 367.3 K Normal - - 0.0025

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99951 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.042

Relatve 12.3 - Normal - - 0.0424u (Prel)2/P2 0.0017989

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.12 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.23 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 258.86 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 10.98 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 21.96 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 8.5 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

85.011.42

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00112

Page 143: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 56 of 57

PM10 Uncertainty Estimate Test 3

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 247.91 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 80.150 mg - - - 0.0004u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0015 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0008u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0009 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0005u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0009u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.316 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 364.7 K Normal - - 0.0025

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99600 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99751 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.043

Relatve 12.3 - Normal - - 0.0427u (Prel)2/P2 0.0018238

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.07 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.14 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 247.91 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 10.59 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 21.17 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 8.5 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

80.011.07

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00113

Page 144: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

Topling Ltd, Inverkip, R13 - 5298,v1Visit 1 of 2013

Page 57 of 57

PM10 Uncertainty Estimate Test 4

Mass concentration of total particulate matter Mass of particulate collectedSymbol Mass concentration of TPM Units Filter mg

Cm 246.08 mg/m3 Washings mgReference Oxygen

Symbol Reference Oxygen Units Symbol UnitsO 2 ,ref 10.0 % DELV mg/m3

Mass of ParticulateSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calBal) Calibration 0.1180 mg Normal 2 1 0.0590u (repBal) Repeatability Filter 0.0110 mg Normal 1 2 0.0220u (repBal) Repeatability Washings 0.0300 mg Normal 1 2 0.0600u (driftBal) Drift 0.0312 mg Rectangular 1 0.0180u (resBal) Resolution 0.0050 mg Rectangular 1 0.0029u (aceBal) Residual acetone 0.0400 mg Normal 2 1 0.0200u(buoBal) Air buoyancy 0.0015 mg Normal 1 1 0.0015u (mass) Combined Uncertainty - Normal - - 0.0911

u (mass)/mass Relatve 79.540 mg - - - 0.0004u (mass)2/mass2 0.000000

Volume of sampled gasSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u (calVT.p) Calibration 0.0015 m3 Normal 2 1 0.0008u (repVT.p) Repeatability 0.0002 m3 Normal 1 1 0.0002u (driftVT.p) Drift 0.0009 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0005u (resVT.p) Resolution 0.0002 m3 Rectangular 1 0.0001

u (VT.p) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.0009u (VT.p)/VT.p Relatve 0.316 m3 - - - 0.0030

u (Vm)2/Vm2 0.000009Temperature of the DGM

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (calTim) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (calTcm) Calibration 1.0 K Normal 2 1 0.5000u (resTm) Resolution 0.1 K Rectangular 1 0.0577u (driftTm) Drift 1.0 K Rectangular 1 0.5774

u (Tm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.9147u (Tm)/Tm Relatve 367.3 K Normal - - 0.0025

u (Tm)2/Tm2 0.000006Atmospheric Pressure

Symbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Patm) Metrological Office 300 Pa Normal 1 173u (Patm) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 173

u (Patm)/P Relatve 99800 - Normal - - 0.0017u (Patm)2/P2 0.000003

Relative DGM PressureSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Uiu (Prel) DGM Pressure 40 Pa Normal 1 1 40u (Prel) Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 40

u (Prel)/P Relatve 99951 - Normal - - 0.0004u (Prel)2/P2 0.0000002

Oxygen reference concentrationSymbol Source of Uncertainty Value Units Probability Distribution Divisor ci Ui

u ((O2,meas)dry)rel Measurement of Oxygen 6 % Normal 2 1 0.1200Combined Uncertainty - - Normal - - 0.037

Relatve 11.5 - Normal - - 0.0366u (Prel)2/P2 0.0013399

u(Cm) Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 1.06 mg/m3

U(Cm) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 2.12 mg/m3

U(Cm,rel) Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 0.9 %

Cm,O2,ref Mass Concentration Particulate at O2 ref ± 246.08 mg/m3

u(Cm) at ref O2 Combined Standard Uncertainty ± 9.01 mg/m3

U(Cm) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 18.02 mg/m3

U(Cmrel) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± 7.3 %

U(Cm,rel,ELV) at ref O2 Expanded Combined Uncertainty k = 2 ± N/A %The reported expanded uncertainty is based on a standard uncertainty multiplied by a coverage factor (k = 2 ),providing a level of confidence of approximately 95%. The uncertainty evaluation has been carried out in accordance with UKAS requirements.

Limit valueDaily emission limit value

N/A

Uncertainty Estimate For The Measurement Of Particulate Matter BS EN 13284 - 1Applied to USEPA M201A - Determination of PM10 and PM2.5

65.4015.07

3

3

33

3

33

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00114

Page 145: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00115

Page 146: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00116

Page 147: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00117

Page 148: Boiler Performance and Emissions Testing for the Topling ... · Boiler efficiency and pollutant emissions tests were carried out on the Topling SASP 990kW biomass boiler and associated

KIWA GASTEC AT CRE

ENCLOSURE NO: 00118