Boeing 787 Case Study

download Boeing 787 Case Study

of 17

description

Case study from 2013 about the Boeing 787 and potential solutions to experienced problems.

Transcript of Boeing 787 Case Study

  • Boeing 787 Dreamliner: A Marketing Plan

  • Executive Summary

    Boeing has long enjoyed its many successes of its mid-size aircraft, the 737. Many

    airlines are faced with aging 737s in their fleets and with the advent of many low cost carriers

    (LCCs) and their associated point-to-point systems; the hub-and-spoke method is believed to be

    a thing of the past. With this vision in mind, Boeing set its sights and efforts on an aircraft that

    would revolutionize the point-to-point system and tailored its marketing strategies in what was

    believed to be a flawless method. According to Boeings marketing department, the three

    fundamental areas demanded in its targeted customer market were: speed not size, decreasing

    demand in first class, and low cost carriers. The Boeing 787s design and anticipated technology

    aimed to align with these ideals and be the home run needed to regain its market share from its

    rival Airbus.

    With an order backlog in excess of 800 aircraft, the success enjoyed by Boeings 787

    and the rate of orders broke all records made the Dreamliner Boeings fastest-selling airliner

    (Kingsley-Jones, 2012). However, Boeings marketing of the 787 failed because the

    implementation stage of its marketing strategy was flawed from the start. Each step of its

    marketing strategy was impractical because accountability was lacking. Strategy implementation

    is not only more significant than the strategy itself, but the accountability needed to ensure each

    step is carried out properly is required.

    Companies fall prone to not upholding accountability when it comes to their executives,

    managers, and employees. Responsibility for completing each stage of the execution phase of the

    companys marketing plan often gets left behind and in Boeings situation, this is exactly what

    happened. When dealing with a multi-faceted company such as Boeing, one must analyze the

  • strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats using SWOT analysis to effectively break down

    each phase and identify the missing or broken component.

    Analysis

    Based on the lack of accountability, failure to execute what Boeing marketed, and after in

    depth studying of SWOT analysis for Boeings 787 Dreamliner, there are some changes that

    must be made to the marketing strategy in order for success to be realized. Boeing has already

    differentiated their product and positioned them to be unique in the aviation industry and market

    segment while still focusing on particular dimensions that customers value.

    The Boeing 787 Dreamliner is the youngest family from Boeing; it is an important

    project for Boeings attempt in regaining its dominant market position with its major

    manufacturing competitor Airbus (WikiJournal, 2010). The goal of this marketing plan is to

    introduce proposed changes to Boeings marketing plan that must be made in the wake Boeings

    troubles with the initial production run of the 787. This should reinvigorate their desire to fly on

    the most advanced airplane in the commercial aviation market.

    Strengths

    Boeings largest strength is that its one of the largest and most well-known aircraft

    manufacturers in the world. They have worked diligently to create a solid reputation for

    themselves while developing cutting edge aircraft for the commercial air travel industry as well

    as the military. Boeing is known as an industry leader, consistently making technical

    advancements with the aircraft they are producing, which is an attractive factor to the people that

    purchase, as well as travel on these aircraft. The 787 aimed to increase the pressure and humidity

    in the cabin of the airplane, through the use of materials other than the traditional aluminum in

  • the construction (Denning, 2013, p. 37). Through the design of the cabin, the airplane would also

    cost less to operate, due to fuel savings, which is a huge attractive factor to operators.

    Weaknesses

    However, Boeing repeatedly manages to experience coordination costs well above

    budget. Key stakeholders were integrated into the design and manufacturing teams for the 777,

    the predecessor of the 787, making the process much more costly and overcomplicated. There

    were more than forty people attending status meetings, which proved to be more than the number

    required. Boeing also went overboard on their propulsion engineers, almost doubling the amount

    that was working on the project within the engine manufacturers operation already (Sorscher,

    2013). The 787 program was designed to skip the steps described above, which should have

    resulted in a more streamlined process, but instead created problems.

    Apart from the late delivery, the Dreamliner has also failed to offer as much as they had

    promised with the new aircraft making technologies. It appeared that the major reason of delay

    was because the aircraft had difficulty achieving its weight target and increased efficiency did

    not make a significant difference (WikiJournal, 2010).

    Coordination issues were also to blame for the poor decision making that occurred during

    the manufacturing and design of the 787, as well as not knowing what other stakeholders were

    doing regarding the program (Sorscher, 2013). This was also complicated by the heavy

    outsourcing of the project, leaving some of the decision making with the companies involved

    with the supply chain (Sorscher, 2013).

    Opportunities

    With the use of the 787, many airlines announced new routes, connecting cities that had

    not been connected previously. Seeking to capitalize on opportunities presented in the aviation

  • market, Boeing realized this framework was not possible with the current aircraft that airlines

    operated, but would be more than achievable with the new 787. The Dreamliner was also

    planned to employ new technology with the electrical system, as well as the external design of

    the airframe (Denning, 2013, p. 37), which gave Boeing the opportunity to increase their market

    share through their continued leaps in technology.

    Threats

    Boeing was threatened by the success of the Airbus A380, which was created to directly

    compete with the 787. Since its creation, the A380 has been successfully produced and put into

    service. This continues to be a major threat to Boeing, since the 787 has had numerous problems

    since its entry into air service. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has stepped in, to

    make things worse for Boeing, and grounded the 787 until the safety issues that it has

    encountered are addressed adequately (Sorscher, 2013). The 787 has developed a reputation for

    catching fire in the back of the aircraft, due to a battery issue, and the FAA is not allowing the

    airplane to fly until that problem is remedied.

    Boeing has also lost a few of its suppliers for the 787, Vought and Global Aeronautics,

    when they decided that the program was not working for them, sold their facilities to Boeing and

    walked away from the program (Sorscher, 2013). This could send a message to other suppliers,

    some of which might be reluctant to work with Boeing in the future because of this development

    further providing weakness to the company and threatening the overall success of the 787.

    Differentiation

    The 787 is the first airliner in the world to use composite materials as the primary

    construction material (Norris, Thomas, Wagner, & Forbes Smith, 2005). The 787 was not

    designed in direct competition with another companys aircraft, but rather as an improvement to

  • the 767 and 747 designs, in which orders had slowed (Gunter, 2002). This gave Boeing the

    freedom to design the features that would make the airplane meet their own goals, rather than to

    out-do a competitors airplane. This led to industry leading developments, with the composite

    airplane design, allowing the aircraft to be more fuel efficient.

    Positioning

    The advancements that the 787 had were a major draw to the airlines, garnering 237

    aircraft orders by the end of 2004 (Marsh, 2010). Boeing was able to position its product

    favorably in the minds of customers relative to competitive products. These advancements over

    the previous versions of Boeings commercial aircraft created an impression of a large leap in

    technology, and made the 787 very desirable to airlines that could benefit from the improved fuel

    savings that were offered. Since the 787 was a new design, there was no immediate competition

    with other companies. That changed when Airbus developed the A350, in response to the 787.

    Airbus was playing catch-up at that point, so Boeing still held the markets attention as the

    innovator.

    Marketing Strategy

    The Product

    Boeing is the leading aerospace and defense manufacturer earning the highest revenues

    over any other company (PwC, 2012). Boeings global market expands to 150 countries (Boeing,

    2013). With such a large market, narrowing the target market for the 787 is of extreme

    importance to ensure success. This section will discuss marketing the 787 to the target market,

    the best places to target, the recommended promotion and ensuring competitive pricing.

    The 787s definition as a product is a passenger-carrying, mid-sized, wide-body, long-

    range aircraft. Defining the 787 with such characteristics greatly reduces the target market to

  • passenger carrying airlines. Furthermore, the market is reduced to those airlines operating with

    long-haul flights ranging from 3,000 miles to a maximum of 8,500 miles (the max range of the

    787-9) (Boeing, 2013). The number of non-stop, city pairs greater than 3,000 miles has doubled

    since 1990 providing a greater demand for mid-sized, long-range aircraft for which the 787 was

    designed for (Babej & Pollak, 2006).

    The 787 is unlike any airplane currently carrying passengers. The aircrafts composite

    structure, newly-designed wings, electric architecture, and powerful top-of-the-line engines make

    the 787 20% more fuel-efficient and produces 20% less fuel emissions than that of similar sized

    aircraft (Boeing, 2013). The 787 also offers 20-45% increase in cargo revenue (compared to

    competitors) for extra space built within the cargo holds of the aircraft (Boeing, 2013). As fuel

    prices increase and airlines looking to reduce operating costs and increase revenue, the 787

    appears as the most viable option.

    Boeing has been building aircraft since 1915 and, as previously discussed, provides

    products and services to 150 countries. The Boeing brand name is known world-wide for

    creating reliable, high-quality aircraft. Just like the early aviation days, Boeing is one of few

    aircraft manufacturers who still name their aircraft. Usually, Boeing determines the name

    through a series of, naming workshops: however, they decided to let the public, the

    consumers, choose the name (Tinseth, 2011). The public chose Dreamliner over four other

    options. Allowing the general public to name the 787 can subconsciously create a bond with the

    public and the aircraft; aiding in the thought process that the 787 is their airplane.

    For Boeing to market the 787 appropriately, the aircraft must be classified and marketed

    as an organizational good. 787 sales and promotions must be geared toward the organization that

    will be using them. With the setback of the lithium-ion battery issues which grounded the aircraft

  • for some time, Boeing needs to promote the reduced operating costs, their service support for the

    aircraft, and the main selling point of organizations increasing revenue by using the 787 over the

    competitors. Also, there needs to be guarantees to the airlines that the new boxes created for the

    batteries are fail-proof. The airlines job in promoting their use of the 787 will fall under a

    different category; mainly promoting the passenger comfort and environmental considerations.

    The warranty options for the aircraft dont need to change from what is already in place.

    Per the existing warrant, the company must continue to replace the previous batteries and

    enclosures with the new batteries and enclosures that have many more safeguards in place.

    Boeing has the replacements ready and support in place with personnel and equipment to allow

    for expedited replacement of the possibly faulty parts (Sinnett, 2013). When disclosing the

    warranty with current or new customers, Boeing must emphasize the safeguards in place to

    prevent the 787 from being grounded for the battery and enclosure issues; subsequently placing

    the customer in a position where millions of dollars are lost in revenue.

    The product life cycle correlating to the Boeing 787 is similar to that of any aircraft.

    Innovations in technology and manufacturing will promote growth in engineering more efficient,

    cost effective aircraft. The 787 is the first of large commuter aircraft of its kind. Combining the

    composite structure, fuel-efficient engines, fly-by-wire electrical flight control system, interior

    comfort and design, and cost effectiveness, the 787 is the only aircraft having all these

    characteristics in one aircraft. Therefore, the 787 will lead the market until competitors (i.e.

    Airbus), introduce similar aircraft into the mix. Airbus plans to unveil the A350-800, the 787

    equivalent, near the end of 2014 (Teresko, 2007), so in the meantime, Boeing owns the market

    for composite, passenger-carrying aircraft. Boeing must use this time to promote the aircraft and

    place as many orders as possible before competitors enter the market. Subsequently, Boeing

  • must also be working on innovations to the 787s to be able to offer variants that competitors

    will still not have once they have entered the market.

    The Place

    The ideal market exposure for the 787 exists for those airlines who operate long-haul

    flights; those consisting of non-stop distances between 3,000 to 8,000 miles. The number of

    cities that offer non-stop flights greater than 3,000 miles has doubled since 1990 which shows

    customers prefer more point-to-point flights (Babej & Pollak, 2006). Boeing can use its good

    standing service with its current market, comprising mostly of the U.S. and Europe to ensure 787

    sales; however there are two other places, largely dominated by Airbus, which Boeing needs to

    penetrate their market. Two growing markets that make for ideal exposure for the 787 are Asia

    and the Middle East.

    Within the Asian market, 44% of scheduled flights using wide-body style passenger

    aircraft come from the region (Reuters, 2013). There are agreements in the works within

    Southeast Asia for allowing less regulation to aircraft operating within the region (Association of

    Southeast Asian Nations-ASEAN, 2013). Once the Open Skies policies take place, Asian

    aviation growth is expected to increase dramatically providing more routes within the region

    (Association of Southeast Asian Nations-ASEAN, 2013). By the year 2030, it is expected that

    Asia will add a minimum of 2.5 billion people to the middle classes which will lead to more

    people traveling (Asian Aviation: exponentional change and innovation with global impact,

    2010-2012). The middle class will tend to travel more; however, they are still somewhat

    discerning of ticket prices. This is an advantage for the 787 and its cost effectiveness and overall

    efficiency within the Asian and Indian markets.

  • The second area that specifically needs to be targeted is the Middle Eastern Market. In

    the past 10 years, traffic to and from the Middle Eastern region has grown by 236% (Amin,

    2013). Amin, further states that, traffic in the Middle East will increase by 6.2 percent annually

    over the next 20 years, with airline fleets expected to grow three times by 2031, (Amin, 2013).

    An increase of seven percent in passenger traffic over the next 20 years sets the stage for a

    requirement of over 800 twin-aisle aircraft and over 300 large transcontinental aircraft (Amin,

    2013). These numbers indicate the booming market in the Middle East for aviation. Boeing must

    promote the 787 to a largely Airbus dominated region. As discussed, the main selling points are

    that, overall, everyone is looking to save money; that goes for the airlines who are buying the

    aircraft, to the passengers who are buying tickets to fly on them. The price advantage is where

    Boeing can potentially dominate the market.

    Promotion

    When it comes to promoting the B787, Boeing should focus on consumer promotions

    since that Boeing is selling directly to the consumer and not retailers. The consumer buying

    process for acquiring aircraft is a long and tedious process. Before there are any decisions made

    on the specific aircraft, consumers generally start with pre-acquisition decision making: should

    the aircraft be new or used, what is the specific mission of the aircraft, the analysis of the

    performance, cockpit and cabin, and budget of the aircraft, and market analysis (Aircraft

    Acquisition Process). The best way to promote the 787 to ensure it is the best option once the

    decision is made as to which aircraft to buy.

    In the first step of the aircraft acquisition process, the consumer must determine whether

    to buy a new aircraft versus a used aircraft (Aircraft Acquisition Process). Boeing must get the

    consumer to choose to buy a new 787. The way they can accomplish this is promote the warranty

  • on the aircraft, the products and services available for buying a brand new 787 (customer

    support), the latest state-of-the-art equipment and amenities on-board the aircraft, and the

    promotional standpoint for the company to get passengers to fly on-board the, latest and

    greatest, aircraft on the market (Aircraft Acquisition Process).

    In the next step, the 787 must meet the mission requirements for the airline (Aircraft

    Acquisition Process). The 787 is meant for those long-haul flights and the seller must be in a

    position where they are trying to fly longer distances, or replacing/upgrading to new equipment

    with long-haul routes already in place. Boeing must also be able to provide those services and

    support to regions outside the country along with training on maintenance and piloting. If the

    company has limited long-haul routes, there should be emphasis on growth and expansion

    possibilities by using the 787 to reach those further destinations.

    The 787 is a passenger-carrying aircraft. The mission requirements for this aircraft are

    narrow, so the amenities must be promoted. Those amenities include, but are not limited to,

    interior passenger comfort, increased cargo space for ancillary revenue, various seat numbers per

    the different variants, and the extra overhead baggage space (Aircraft Acquisition Process). Also,

    there must be analysis on the budget and whether the 787 will meet that requirement.

    Next, the consumer will analyze the aircraft in extreme detail. During this step, Boeing

    can promote the 787s performance. This is a key selling point for the 787 being the only aircraft

    made out of composites resulting in greater aerodynamics, improved fuel-efficiency, reduced

    maintenance costs, and fewer harmful emissions (Boeing, 2013). Also, Boeing can promote the

    range differences between the 787 variants to better suit the needs of the consumer (Aircraft

    Acquisition Process). If the aircraft has less time being down for maintenance, that means there

    is more time for it to be in the air providing revenue for the company.

  • Further analysis in the aircraft is the cockpit and cabin (Aircraft Acquisition Process).

    Primary selling points over competitors in this area are the luxurious cabin with the three

    different classes available for passengers. The 787 humidifies the air on-board the aircraft and

    has reduced the common cabin-pressure altitude during the flight by 2000; thus reducing

    headaches and general discomfort during flights (Boeing, 2013). Passengers frequently complain

    about the limited leg space, cabin height, and baggage space on-board most aircraft; therefore,

    using the new improvements the 787 offers to passenger comfort is a key to marketing the

    aircraft. In regards to cockpit innovations, not necessarily new, the fly-by-ethernet system on

    board that allows for reduced weight and components on-board the aircraft, and all new state-of-

    the-art glass cockpit avionics (Boeing, 2013).

    The final part of aircraft analysis is probably the most important to consumers: the budget

    (Aircraft Acquisition Process). According to the Boeing website, the base price for the 787-8 (the

    cheapest variant) is $211.8M (2013). According to the Airbus website, the cheapest variant of

    the A350 (A350-800) is priced at $287.7M (2013). This is one leg up on the competitor by

    offering a cheaper price. This base price does not include multiple orders, orders for existing

    customers, or upgrading options. By giving discounts to existing customers and orders

    containing a certain amount of aircraft, Boeing will maintain their current consumer base, as well

    as, earn new clients in the process. Boeing must also advertise the reduced maintenance costs,

    which lower budgets, and total operating costs (Boeing, 2013).

    The final step before the aircraft is selected is market analysis (Aircraft Acquisition

    Process). As previously discussed, the increase in people flying on those long-haul flights, and

    the rise in the markets in Asia and the Middle East show that the market for the mission of the

    787 is on the rise. The 787 will meet the needs of consumers as long as Boeing can deliver the

  • products promised: aircraft on time, support, training, and services. Analyzing all the

    components, the 787 is the most viable choice for airlines seeking to upgrade or introduce long-

    haul flights and the least amount of costs to the passenger and airline.

    Implementation and Control

    For implementation of the marketing plan, Boeing sales representatives will divide into

    the two regions previously listed: Southeast Asia and the Middle East. Each sales associate will

    obtain cultural training for each region to promote new partnerships and build upon existing

    partnerships with the perspective airlines. Once sales meetings are in place, prices can be

    negotiated on a specific range for the 787.

    The Southeast Asian region sales representatives will be divided by countries and acquire

    training on each perspective culture with a brief, overall region culture training. There will be

    two sales representatives per country. The countries will China, Malaysia, India, and Korea.

    Once the sales representative complete training, the pairs will contact the perspective airline(s)

    for the region. For China, the airlines targeted will be Air China, Cathay Pacific, China Eastern

    Airlines, and China Southern Airlines. The Malaysian airlines targeted will be AirAsia X,

    Malaysia Airlines, Thai Airways, and Singapore Airlines. The Korean airline targeted is Korean

    Air.

    The Middle Eastern Airlines sales representatives will also receive training on specific

    countries, be divided into pairs, and obtain brief training over the target region. The countries

    include Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, United Arab Emirates (UAE), Saudi Arabia, and Dubai. In

    Bahrain, the targeted airline is Gulf Air. Kuwaits target airline is Kuwait Airways. Qatars

    airline is Qatar Airways. UAEs targeted airlines are Etihad Airways and Air Arabia. Saudi

  • Arabias targeted airline is Saudi Arabian Airlines, also called Saudia. Finally, the airline for

    Dubai is Emirates.

    After training is complete, sales representatives will arrange meetings with their

    perspective air carriers. The goal is to establish 787 sale orders with long-term contracts to each

    airline. Air carriers placing orders for a minimum of 5 aircraft, and/or establishing contracts for a

    maximum of five years to obtain 10 or more aircraft can buy the aircraft at a base price of

    $116M. All others can be negotiated prices from $164M to $288M (listed price for 787-10)

    (Boeing, 2013). For added incentives on sales, sales groups (each respective pair) will be able to

    earn .1% commission on each aircraft sold, before taxes.

  • References Airbus. (2013, January). Airbus Aircraft 2013 Average List Prices (mio USD). Retrieved from

    Airbus: An EADS Company: http://www.airbus.com/presscentre/corporate-

    information/key-documents/?eID=dam_frontend_push&docID=14849

    Aircraft Acquisition Process. (n.d.). Retrieved from Hangar Ten Aircraft Sales:

    http://www.dailystar.com.lb/Business/Lebanon/2013/Jun-28/221828-middle-east-

    aviation-sector-set-for-growth.ashx#axzz2h4btAgm2

    Amin, M. E. (2013, June 28). Middle East aviation sector set for growth. Retrieved from The

    Daily Star: http://www.dailystar.com.lb/Business/Lebanon/2013/Jun-28/221828-middle-

    east-aviation-sector-set-for-growth.ashx#axzz2h4btAgm2

    Asian Aviation: exponentional change and innovation with global impact. (2010-2012).

    Retrieved from Airline Leader: http://www.airlineleader.com/this-months-

    highlights/asian-aviation-exponential-change-and-innovation-with-global-impact

    Association of Southeast Asian Nations-ASEAN. (2013, March 12). Study looks at Southeast

    Asian aviation industry. Airline Industry Information. Retrieved October 07, 2013, from

    http://search.proquest.com.ezproxy.libproxy.db.erau.edu/docreview/1315834967?account

    id=27203

    Babej, M. E., & Pollak, T. (2006, May 24). Boeing Versus Airbus. Retrieved from Forbes:

    http://www.forbes.com/2006/05/23/unsolicited-advice-advertising-

    cx_meb_0524boeing.html

    Boeing. (2013). 787 Dreamliner. Retrieved from Boeing:

    http://www.boeing.com/boeing/commercial/787family/programfacts.page?

    Boeing. (2013, January). About Us. Retrieved from Boeing:

    http://www.boeing.com/boeing/companyoffices/aboutus/index.page?

    Boeing. (2013). Commercial Airplanes: Jet Prices. Retrieved from Boeing:

    http://www.boeing.com/boeing/commercial/prices/

    Denning, S. (2013, Vol. 41 No. 3). What went wrong at Boeing. Strategy & Leadership, pp. 36-

    41.

    Gunter, L. (2002). Boeing's Sonic Cruiser Team Focuses on the Future. Boeing Frontiers, 1.

    Kingsley-Jones, M. (2012). Flight Global: The Boeing 787 Dreamliner. Retrieved from

    http://www.flightglobal.com/features/787dreamliner/market/

  • Marsh, G. (2010). Boeing's 787: trials, tribulations, and restoring the dream. Reinforced Plastics.

    Norris, G., Thomas, G., Wagner, M., & Forbes Smith, C. (2005). Boeing 787 Dreamliner

    Flying Redefined. Aerospace Technical Publications International.

    Peter, J. P., & Donnelly, J. H. (2011). Marketing Management: Knowledge and Skills (10th ed.).

    New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.

    PwC. (2012). Aviation Week Top Performing Companies. Retrieved from pwc:

    http://www.pwc.com/us/en/industrial-products/aerospace-defense/aviation-week-top-

    performing-companies.jhtml

    Reuters. (2013, September 25). Chinese launch seen for 'Rgeional' version of Airbus A330.

    Retrieved from The Economic Times:

    http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international-business/chinese-launch-seen-

    for-regional-version-of-airbus-a330/articleshow/23014162.cms

    Sinnett, M. (2013, April). Certification of 787 Battery Solution. Retrieved from Boeing:

    http://www.boeing.com/787-media-resource/docs/787-battery-certification.pdf

    Sorscher, S. (2013, January 23). Market Discipline for the Boeing 787. Retrieved from AFL-

    CIO: http://www.aflcio.org/Blog/Corporate-Greed/Market-Discipline-for-the-Boeing-787

    Teresko, J. (2007, December). The Boeing 787: A Matter of Materials. Industry Week, 256(12),

    34-38. Retrieved October 07, 2013, from

    http://search.proquest.com.ezproxy.libproxy.db.erau.edu/docview/219749827

    Tinseth, R. (2011, March 28). Randy's Journal: Behind the Scenes Story on Naming the

    Dreamliner. Retrieved from Boeing:

    http://www.boeingblogs.com/randy/archives/2011/03/behind_the_scenes_story_on_nam.

    html

    WikiJournal. (2010). Boeing 787: Dreamliners Market. Retrieved from

    http://aviationknowledge.wikidot.com/aviation:an-introduction-of-the-b787-dreamliner