Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB...

44
Blind Areas Around Construction Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment Equipment Equipment Equipment Presented b Presented by David E. Fosbroke NIOSH, Division of Safety Research Traffic Management and Work Zone Safety C f Orlando, Florida Conference March 10, 2009

Transcript of Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB...

Page 1: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Blind Areas Around Construction Blind Areas Around Construction EquipmentEquipmentEquipmentEquipment

Presented bPresented by David E. Fosbroke

NIOSH, Division of Safety Research

Traffic Management and Work Zone Safety C f

Orlando, FloridaConference

March 10, 2009

Page 2: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

The findings and conclusions in this presentation have not been formally di i t d b th N ti l I tit t fdisseminated by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health and should not be construed to represent any agency p y g ydetermination or policy.

Page 3: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

The mention of any company name or product does not constitute endorsementproduct does not constitute endorsement by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health.

The photographic display of any productThe photographic display of any product, label, or logo does not constitute endorsement by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health.

Page 6: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Evaluating Roadway Construction Work Zone InterventionsZone Interventions

A Research Project Conducted by the National Institute for

Occupational Safety and HealthOccupational Safety and Health

Page 7: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.
Page 8: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Project OrganizationRoadway Work Zone Intervention Evaluations

Morgantown, WV Pittsburgh, PA Spokane, WAWorker Exposure Measurement

Blind Area Determination

Internal Traffic Control Plans

HASARD

Work Zone Analysis System

Proximity Warning Devices

Detection Zones

S T i DSite Access / Partnering

Case Definition

HSRB/OMB/Photo Release

State Transportation Departments

Construction Companies

Engineering ConsultantsHSRB/OMB/Photo Release

Research Staff Safety

g g

Labor Unions

Construction Trade Associations

Equipment Manufacturers

FHWA, OSHA

Page 9: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Fatality Investigations

http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/face/faceweb.html

Page 10: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Fatality Assessment and Control Evaluation States Participating in the

ProgramProgram

Page 11: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Laborer Run Over by Dump Truck at Roadway Resurfacing Operation in

Vi i iy g p

Virginia

Two lane County Road Four lane State HighwayTwo-lane County Road -- Four-lane State Highway

Page 12: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Flagger

RollerTruck

Victim

Victim’s Work

Trees

Paving Machine

Area

Machine

Page 13: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

View from the Street

Page 14: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

View from Inside the Cab Stickers

Bug Shield

Fan Mirror

Air Cleaner and Door Post

Page 15: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Characterizing the HazardDefining equipment blind areas

Page 16: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Definition of Blind Area

A blind area is the area around a vehicle or piece of construction equipment that is not visible to the operators, either by direct line-of-sight or indirectly by use of internal and external mirrors.

Page 17: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Area of fullyyobstructed view

Page 18: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Blind Area Mapping Methods

International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 5006Standardization (ISO) 5006 Manual methods

Light barLight barOperator

Computer methodsDesign drawingsg gLaser scansPhotographsPhotographs

Page 19: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Manual Light Bar Methodg

Page 20: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

900mm

G d L lGround Level

1500mm

Page 21: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Manual Light Bar Example - Blind Area Diagrams - Ford 880ag a s o d 880

Ground level Construction barrel ~3 feet

Worker partially bent over ~5 feetbarrel ~3 feet bent over ~5 feet

Page 22: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Manual Light Bar Example – Euclid EH4500 Blind Area at Ground Level

Page 23: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Manual Light Bar Example – Hitachi EX5500 Blind Area 1500mm above

Ground LevelGround Level

Page 24: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Manual Operator MethodManual Operator Method

Page 25: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Manual Operator Method - Marking Blind p gAreas Within a Polar Grid

Page 26: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Manual Operator Example - Caterpillar 672CH Blind Area at 900mm above

Ground PlaneGround Plane

Page 27: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Comparison of Operator and Light Bar Methods for Blind Area Mappingpp g

Operator Method Light Bar Method

Page 28: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Computer Method – Design Drawings

Engineering CAD and 3D modeling g g gsoftwareLocate machine in modeling softwareGenerate eye-point light sourceSimulate light blockagesg gSimulate mirror image projections

Page 29: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Design Drawing Example – Caterpillar CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level

Page 30: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Virtual Reality Method - Machine Projected Around Subjectojected ou d Subject

Page 31: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Digital Photographic Modeling Method

Page 32: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Contract Deliverable

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention

Contract 200-2002-00563

“Construction Vehicle and Equipment Blind Area Diagrams”Blind Area Diagrams

2003 & 2004 Final Reports2003 & 2004 Final Reports

Page 33: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Sample Pages

Page 34: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

WWW.CDC.GOV/WWW.CDC.GOV/NIOSH/TOPICS/NIOSH/TOPICS/

HIGHWAYWORKZHIGHWAYWORKZONESONESONESONES

Page 35: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.
Page 36: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.
Page 37: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.
Page 38: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.
Page 39: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.
Page 40: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Detection Zones

Generator

Page 41: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.
Page 42: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

Blind Area Diagram Usage

Page 43: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.
Page 44: Blind Areas Around Construction Equipment · 2018-02-20 · CB 534D Blind Area at Ground LevelCB 534D Blind Area at Ground Level . ... Projectedojected ou d Subject Around Subject.

David E FosbrokeDavid E FosbrokeDavid E. FosbrokeDavid E. Fosbroke

NIOSHNIOSH

Division of Safety Research Division of Safety Research Morgantown WVMorgantown WVMorgantown, WVMorgantown, WV

(304) 285(304) 285--60106010

[email protected]@cdc.gov