Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60...

62
CHALLENGES AND CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES RELATIVE OPPORTUNITIES RELATIVE TO INCREASED USAGE OF TO INCREASED USAGE OF ALUMINUM WITHIN THE ALUMINUM WITHIN THE AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY TMS 2010 Annual Meeting TMS 2010 Annual Meeting Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim Schroth, David Sigler, and Mark Verbrugge (speaker) General Motors R&D, Warren, MI

Transcript of Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60...

Page 1: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

CHALLENGES AND CHALLENGES AND

OPPORTUNITIES RELATIVE OPPORTUNITIES RELATIVE

TO INCREASED USAGE OF TO INCREASED USAGE OF

ALUMINUM WITHIN THE ALUMINUM WITHIN THE

AUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRYAUTOMOTIVE INDUSTRY

TMS 2010 Annual MeetingTMS 2010 Annual Meeting

Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski,

Anil Sachdev, Jim Schroth,

David Sigler, and

Mark Verbrugge (speaker)

General Motors R&D, Warren, MI

Page 2: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

OutlineOutline

• Societal trends

• Automotive drivers

• Aluminum technology in automotive– Closure panels

– Body structure

– Chassis

– Powertrain

– Joining

– Corrosion

• Open questions and potential enablers

• Societal trends

• Automotive drivers

• Aluminum technology in automotive– Closure panels

– Body structure

– Chassis

– Powertrain

– Joining

– Corrosion

• Open questions and potential enablers

Page 3: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

World Population and Vehicle ParcWorld Population and Vehicle Parc

Page 4: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;
Page 5: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

American Scientist, Nov-Dec 2009

Per-capita passenger-

kilometers traveled (PKT) is

correlated with economic

development, shown as

growth in per capita gross

domestic product.

The 11 regional trajectories

represent the years 1950 to

2005. The upper point of the

shaded section is the

theoretical highest mobility

level, achieved when a

population relies exclusively

on the fastest mode of

transport (aircraft) over the

entire travel time budget (1.2

hours per person per day).

Page 6: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

American Scientist, Nov-Dec 2009

The amount of time people

around the world spend

traveling is startlingly

consistent, no matter

whether they live in African

villages, Europe, or the

most affluent regions of

Asia.

People in the industrialized

world spend a larger share

of their traveling time for

leisure activities—about

half—but they travel similar

amounts of time on average

each day nonetheless.

Page 7: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

7

2005 Global Human2005 Global Human--Activity Energy FlowsActivity Energy Flows

Hydro

10

Geothermal

2.5

Wind

0.22

Solar0.02

Coal110

Natural Gas107

Residential50

Vehicle 39

Freight 40Air 12

Re

jecte

d E

nerg

y2

16

Oil

172

Nuclear

27Industrial

167

Commercial25

Use

ful E

nerg

y2

20

Electricity Generation

160

Biomass

7.4

Source: Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory

Units are Quadrillion (1015) BTUs1 Quad BTU is equivalent to 0.5 MBD

TransportationTransportation

Total: 436

Fo

ssil

: 38

9

US Non-Transport

Residential: 11.7

Commercial: 8.5

Industrial: 24.3

� Transportation the only major industry dependent on only 1 energy supply chain� Electricity serves as unifying energy carrier for diverse energy resources

US TransportVehicle: 17.0Freight: 7.6

Air: 3.4

Page 8: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Global Energy Concerns (for every nation

state)

Global Energy Concerns (for every nation

state)

Energy security

Secure

Environmental health

Clean

Economic competitiveness

Affordable

To some extent, we can reduce demand, but the ultimate solution will come out of advancements in science and technology.

Energy security

Secure

Environmental health

Clean

Economic competitiveness

Affordable

To some extent, we can reduce demand, but the ultimate solution will come out of advancements in science and technology.

Sustainability &

National Security

Page 9: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

GM Advanced Propulsion StrategyGM Advanced Propulsion Strategy

Page 10: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

GM VEHICLE ELECTRIFICATION STRATEGYGM VEHICLE ELECTRIFICATION STRATEGY

Petroleum and Biofuels (Conventional and Alternative Sources)

Electrification

GM Hybrid

2-Mode2-ModePHEV

Voltec

Electricity – ZEV Fuel

BatteryElectric

Fuel Cell

Portfolio of solutions for full range of vehicles that provide cPortfolio of solutions for full range of vehicles that provide customer choiceustomer choice

Page 11: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

ConventionalConventional

PowertrainPowertrain

Electric PowerElectric Power

Equinox Fuel CellEquinox Fuel Cell

GMGM’’S PATH TO ELECTRIFICATIONS PATH TO ELECTRIFICATIONF

UN

CT

ION

AL

ITY

FU

NC

TIO

NA

LIT

Y

Baseline 15-20% 30% RWD

50% FWD

FWD: 100% for 20 Miles,

50% After

40 Miles

Pure EV

30 Miles

Pure EV

Mid Hybrid

Full Hybrid

Plug-in Hybrid

Extended Range Electric Vehicle

Battery Electric Vehicle &Fuel Cell

All All ElectricElectric with Mechanical

Assist

Mechanical with Electric Mechanical with Electric Assist

DR

IVE

S

YS

TE

MD

RIV

E

SY

ST

EM Mechanical

Conventional

Powertrain

INCREASING LEVELS OF ELECTRIFICATION AND INCREASING LEVELS OF ELECTRIFICATION AND

EFFICIENCYEFFICIENCY

Page 12: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

• Key: Current and future vehicle architectures benefit from

lightweighting

�Systems engineering: comprehensive look at metrics like $/∆∆∆∆mpg to

balance imperatives across all vehicle systems!

Page 13: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Energy Efficiency of VehiclesEnergy Efficiency of VehiclesEnergy Distribution: Typical MidEnergy Distribution: Typical Mid--Size VehicleSize Vehicle

Page 14: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Energy Efficiency of VehiclesEnergy Efficiency of VehiclesEnergy Distribution: Typical MidEnergy Distribution: Typical Mid--Size VehicleSize Vehicle

vmgfP RW )(cosθ=

vmgPg )(sinθ=

0for

0for

<=

≥=

amavP

amavP

da

aa

λ

λ

3

air2

1vACP Dv ρ=

agWv PPPPP +++=traction

Key point: power

losses are

effectively

proportional to

vehicle mass

(momentum mv)

Page 15: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Potential Weight Reduction vs. Steel Potential Weight Reduction vs. Steel

(%)(%)

Page 16: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Safety• ABS

• Airbags • Crash Structure

Extras• Convertibles

• Power Accessories• Electronics Devices

NVH

• Stiffness• Insulation

Performance• 4W Drive

• Traction Control• Powertrain Features

Vehicle Weight is Increasing(Customer, Performance, Regulations & Safety)

Vehicle Weight is Increasing(Customer, Performance, Regulations & Safety)

Average Light Vehicle Weight in Pounds

4000

2000

0

Aluminum Association

Page 17: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

MATERIALS IN A TYPICAL MATERIALS IN A TYPICAL

VEHICLEVEHICLEPolymer/CompositePolymer/Composite

5%5%

Other18%

Low-CarbonFerrous

71%

AluminumAluminum

3%3%

Hi/MedHi/Med--

StrengthStrength

SteelSteel

3%3%

19771977

TodayTodayPolymer/CompositePolymer/Composite

8%8%

Other20%

AluminumAluminum

8%8%

MagnesiumMagnesium

1%1%

Hi/MedHi/Med--

Strength SteelStrength Steel

11%11%

Low-CarbonFerrous

52%

Page 18: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

METALLIC MATERIAL TRENDSMETALLIC MATERIAL TRENDSBody and Closure Content by TypeBody and Closure Content by Type

Source: Ducker WorldwideSource: Ducker Worldwide

Page 19: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

VEHICLE MASS AND FUEL ECONOMY

VEHICLE MASS AND FUEL ECONOMY

• About a 6% improvement in fuel

economy for a 10% mass reduction

– 0.4 mpg improvement per 100 lb

for 3500 lb vehicle

– 0.5 km/L improvement per 100 kg weight

reduction for 1500 kg vehicle

• About a 6% improvement in fuel

economy for a 10% mass reduction

– 0.4 mpg improvement per 100 lb

for 3500 lb vehicle

– 0.5 km/L improvement per 100 kg weight

reduction for 1500 kg vehicle

Page 20: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Closure PanelsClosure PanelsVehicle mass contribution: ~5%

Mass correlation coefficient: ~0.02

• 100 kg reduction in vehicle mass leads to another 2 kg

reduction in closure mass

• 20 kg reduction in closure mass leads to another (nearly)

20 kg reduction in the vehicle mass

• 100 kg reduction in vehicle mass leads to another 2 kg

reduction in closure mass

• 20 kg reduction in closure mass leads to another (nearly)

20 kg reduction in the vehicle mass

Page 21: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Aluminum Closure StatusAluminum Closure Status

• Aluminum has been used extensively for “simple” closure

panels like hoods on most large/luxury vehicles

• Industry standard for Al doors is multi-piece assembly

• Hot blow forming technologies are attractive at low volumes

• Significant redesign of steel panels is necessary to utilize conventional stamping

• No process is currently available to make high volume

complex aluminum panels

• Aluminum has been used extensively for “simple” closure

panels like hoods on most large/luxury vehicles

• Industry standard for Al doors is multi-piece assembly

• Hot blow forming technologies are attractive at low volumes

• Significant redesign of steel panels is necessary to utilize conventional stamping

• No process is currently available to make high volume

complex aluminum panels

Page 22: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Preform AnnealingPreform Annealing

Preform Annealing is a GM patented (US

7,260,972) process to enhance formability

which includes an annealing step between a

draw and redraw operation.

Preform Annealing is a GM patented (US

7,260,972) process to enhance formability

which includes an annealing step between a

draw and redraw operation.

Anneal

3500C

Preform Final Form

Forced

Air Cool

Page 23: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Rapid Annealing To Enable High

Volume

Rapid Annealing To Enable High

Volume

Exposure Time (sec)

0 5 10 15 20 25

Yie

ld S

tren

gth

(M

Pa)

0

50

100

150

200

250

300316

343

371

385

399

413

427

454

10 % Prestrained strength

O temper strength

Temp (C)

AA5182

Page 24: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

FEM to locate annealing needs

FEM to locate annealing needs

• End of first draw

stage; stopped 24

mm from the

bottom of the die.

• Thickness strain

depicted

• Regions outlined:

reset to O temper

properties with

annealing

• End of first draw

stage; stopped 24

mm from the

bottom of the die.

• Thickness strain

depicted

• Regions outlined:

reset to O temper

properties with

annealing

Page 25: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Induction Coils Developed for Critical

Regions

Induction Coils Developed for Critical

Regions

Location Specific Coils Manufactured Infrared Camera Monitors Heat Cycle

Page 26: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Annealing Fixture Clamps/Heats

Preform

Annealing Fixture Clamps/Heats

Preform

O temper strength can be recovered in a matter of seconds

Page 27: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Preform Annealing OpportunitiesPreform Annealing Opportunities

• Identify optimum preform shape and annealing

locations using FEM

• Build flexible coils & system to work in a press

line and allow for quick die change between

various parts

• Construct forming limit diagrams as a function of

prestrain, annealing, and strain path

• Apply process to 6xxx series alloys

• Identify optimum preform shape and annealing

locations using FEM

• Build flexible coils & system to work in a press

line and allow for quick die change between

various parts

• Construct forming limit diagrams as a function of

prestrain, annealing, and strain path

• Apply process to 6xxx series alloys

Page 28: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Aluminum Sheet OpportunitiesAluminum Sheet Opportunities

Short term

• Global large sheet (2 m) capability for both 5xxx and 6xxx alloys providing acceptable class A surface quality

• Optimized recycling streams to capture maximum value from engineered scrap

Long term

• Joining technologies enabling mixed material structures (bonding Al to steel, magnesium, and composites)

• Low cost lubricants for elevated temperature forming processseswhich are compatible with painting and joining technologies

• 6xxx type alloy for elevated temperature forming

Short term

• Global large sheet (2 m) capability for both 5xxx and 6xxx alloys providing acceptable class A surface quality

• Optimized recycling streams to capture maximum value from engineered scrap

Long term

• Joining technologies enabling mixed material structures (bonding Al to steel, magnesium, and composites)

• Low cost lubricants for elevated temperature forming processseswhich are compatible with painting and joining technologies

• 6xxx type alloy for elevated temperature forming

Page 29: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Body StructureBody StructureVehicle mass contribution: ~23%

Mass correlation coefficient: ~0.25

• 100 kg reduction in vehicle mass leads to another 25 kg

reduction in body-structure mass

� Significant new challenge to Al alloys: Mg alloys

• 100 kg reduction in vehicle mass leads to another 25 kg

reduction in body-structure mass

� Significant new challenge to Al alloys: Mg alloys

Page 30: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Steel Tube Overcast Steel Tube Overcast

with Alwith Al

OVERCASTING WITH OVERCASTING WITH

DISSIMILAR MATERIALSDISSIMILAR MATERIALS

Page 31: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

(Source: Alcan/(Source: Alcan/ContechContech))

High-pressure die casting

(Blisters after heat-treating )

Vacuum die casting (60-300

mbar)

(No blisters after heat-treating)

VACUUM DIE CASTING: VACUUM DIE CASTING:

HEATHEAT--TREATABLE AND WELDABLE TREATABLE AND WELDABLE

Al HighAl High--QQ--CastCast(<60 mbar)(<60 mbar)

(Source: USAMP)(Source: USAMP)

(<60 mbar)(<60 mbar)Mg Super VacuumMg Super Vacuum

Page 32: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Traditional Traditional

BodyBody--inin--WhiteWhite

(Mild Steel Sheet)(Mild Steel Sheet)

Audi A2 (Al Intensive)Audi A2 (Al Intensive)

BMW 5/6 SeriesBMW 5/6 Series

(Mixed Materials)(Mixed Materials)

GM MidGM Mid--Size CarSize Car

(AHSS(AHSS--Intensive)Intensive)

AluminumAluminum SteelSteel

BODY STRUCTUREBODY STRUCTURE

Page 33: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

INSTRUMENT PANEL BEAMINSTRUMENT PANEL BEAM

Page 34: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

HydroformedHydroformed

Al Frame RailsAl Frame Rails

Carbon FiberCarbon Fiber

Floor PanFloor Pan

Mg Engine CradleMg Engine Cradle

Ti Intake Valves andTi Intake Valves and

Connecting Rods (505 hp)Connecting Rods (505 hp)

Mg Roof FrameMg Roof FrameHydroformedHydroformed

Al Roof BowAl Roof Bow

CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z060 to 60 mph in 3.7 s0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s

Page 35: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

MgMg--Intensive Intensive

FrontFront--endend

AHSS Passenger CompartmentAHSS Passenger Compartment

Steel: 79 Parts; 84 kg

Mg: 35 Parts; 46 kg

(Eliminate 44 Parts and Save 38 kg - 45%)

Castings (15): 31

kg

Extrusions (3): 9

kg

Sheet Parts (17): 6

kg

MULTIMULTI--MATERIAL BODY MATERIAL BODY –– THE THE

FUTUREFUTURE

Composite Floor PanComposite Floor Pan

Page 36: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

ChassisChassisVehicle mass contribution: ~20%

Mass correlation coefficient

Suspension: ~0.3 (mostly metal

components)

Steering, tires, wheels, electrical have lower

mass correlation coefficients• 100 kg reduction in vehicle mass leads to another 46 kg

reduction in chassis mass

• 100 kg reduction in vehicle mass leads to another 46 kg

reduction in chassis mass

Page 37: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Critical Chassis StructureCritical Chassis Structure

FRONT CRADLEFRONT CRADLE

Page 38: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

16 kg16 kg

2008 AFS Casting of the Year 2008 AFS Casting of the Year

Honorable Mention AwardHonorable Mention Award

¶¶ Large hollow casting with Large hollow casting with

welded extrusionswelded extrusions

¶¶ Steel 27 kg; Al 16kgSteel 27 kg; Al 16kg

ALUMINUM CRADLE ALUMINUM CRADLE –– CADILLAC CADILLAC

CTS CTS

Page 39: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

¶¶ One piece; first in industryOne piece; first in industry

¶¶ 10.4 kg; 35% weight 10.4 kg; 35% weight

reduction compared reduction compared

to aluminumto aluminum

DIE CAST MAGNESIUM ENGINE DIE CAST MAGNESIUM ENGINE

CRADLECRADLE

AE44 AlloyAE44 Alloy

Aluminum Isolation Washers Aluminum Isolation Washers for Cradlefor Cradle--toto--Body Body

AttachmentAttachment

2006 International Magnesium Association Application Award2006 International Magnesium Association Application Award

Page 40: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

PowertrainPowertrainVehicle mass contribution: ~25%

Mass correlation coefficient

Engine: ~0.2 Transmission: ~0.1

Fuel system and balance: lower correlation

• 100 kg reduction in vehicle mass leads to another 30 kg

reduction in engine + transmission mass

• 100 kg reduction in vehicle mass leads to another 30 kg

reduction in engine + transmission mass

Page 41: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

ENGINE BLOCKSENGINE BLOCKS

Al ~50% weight reduction

Al ~50% Al ~50% weight reductionweight reduction

Mg ~25% weight reduction

Mg ~25% Mg ~25% weight reductionweight reduction

AlGM Die Cast Al Block

(~26 kg)

Cast Iron Block

(~68 kg)

GM Lost Foam

Cast Al Block USCAR Mg Block

BMW Mg/Al BlockMg

Page 42: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

LinerlessLinerless Al Al

enginesengines

Benefits�Improved heat transfer �Higher combustion volume�Eliminate liner mass and cost

BenefitsBenefits

��Improved heat transfer Improved heat transfer

��Higher combustion volumeHigher combustion volume

��Eliminate liner mass and costEliminate liner mass and cost

Liner

Liner lnterface

lnterface

Page 43: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

PROTOPTYE DIE CAST MAGNESIUM PROTOPTYE DIE CAST MAGNESIUM

OIL PAN FOR V8 ENGINEOIL PAN FOR V8 ENGINE

AluminumAluminum

(6.1 kg)(6.1 kg)MagnesiumMagnesium

(4.2 kg; 30% (4.2 kg; 30%

Reduction)Reduction)

AE44 AlloyAE44 Alloy

Page 44: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

JoiningJoining• Because of difficulties in spot welding of Al, many

manufacturers have shied away from its use for high volume manufacturing, and instead have used rivets,

adhesive, etc., to join aluminum structures.

• Properly implemented, spot welding may offer cost,

productivity, and design flexibility advantages that are very

attractive to auto manufacturers.

• Because of difficulties in spot welding of Al, many

manufacturers have shied away from its use for high volume manufacturing, and instead have used rivets,

adhesive, etc., to join aluminum structures.

• Properly implemented, spot welding may offer cost,

productivity, and design flexibility advantages that are very

attractive to auto manufacturers.

Page 45: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Energy Generated During RSW of Aluminum Compared to Steel

Energy Generated During RSW of Aluminum Compared to Steel

• Steel: heating within sheets

• Aluminum: heating at interfaces due to surface oxides

• Steel: heating within sheets

• Aluminum: heating at interfaces due to surface oxides

Steel Welding

Energy produced primarily within the

sheets

Aluminum Welding

Energy produced primarily

at interfaces

Page 46: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Conventional vs Macro-Featured Electrodes for Aluminum Welding

Conventional vs Macro-Featured Electrodes for Aluminum Welding

• Radial strain following indentation as proxy for oxide fracture and penetration– 75-mm radius electrode: strains <3%

– Featured electrode: local strains >20%

• Radial strain following indentation as proxy for oxide fracture and penetration– 75-mm radius electrode: strains <3%

– Featured electrode: local strains >20%

Page 47: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

• FEA predictions of surface strains at the aluminum sheet surface

• FEA predictions of surface strains at the aluminum sheet surface

-20%

-10%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

0 2 4 6 8

Radial Plastic Strain

Distance From Electrode Center Along Sheet Face (mm)

Ridged

76-mm Radius

Conventional vs Macro-Featured

Electrodes for Aluminum Welding

Conventional vs Macro-Featured

Electrodes for Aluminum Welding

Page 48: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

• Narrow range of conditions to achieve satisfactory weld size (>4.5mm)

• Behavior degrades with poor fit-up and offangle conditions

• Narrow range of conditions to achieve satisfactory weld size (>4.5mm)

• Behavior degrades with poor fit-up and offangle conditions

Aluminum Welding Behavior with Conventional Electrodes

Aluminum Welding Behavior with Conventional Electrodes

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

20

00

0

21

00

0

22

00

0

23

00

0

24

00

0

25

00

0

26

00

0

27

00

0

28

00

0

29

00

0

30

00

0

31

00

0

32

00

0

WE

LD

SIZ

E (m

m)

WELD CURRENT (amps)

Flange Lobe

Min/Exp

Offangle 6 deg

Min/Exp

Gap 0.8 mm

Min/Exp

6111 2.0-mm/5182 1.1-mm5 cyc/1000 lb15.9-mm face dia., truncated76.2-mm R, as-received

Page 49: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

• Broad range of conditions to achieve adequate weld size (> 4.5mm)

• Behavior insensitive to poor fit-up and off-angle conditions

• Enablers for macro-featured welding system: scale implementation of mid-frequency DC welding and rotary electrode dressing systems.

• Broad range of conditions to achieve adequate weld size (> 4.5mm)

• Behavior insensitive to poor fit-up and off-angle conditions

• Enablers for macro-featured welding system: scale implementation of mid-frequency DC welding and rotary electrode dressing systems.

Aluminum Welding Behavior with Macro-Featured Electrodes

Aluminum Welding Behavior with Macro-Featured Electrodes

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

20

00

0

21

00

0

22

00

0

23

00

0

24

00

0

25

00

0

26

00

0

27

00

0

28

00

0

29

00

0

30

00

0

31

00

0

32

00

0

WE

LD

SIZ

E (m

m)

WELD CURRENT (amps)

Flange Lobe

Min/Exp

Offangle 6 deg

Min/Exp

Gap 0.8 mm

Min/Exp

+6111 2.0-mm/5182 1.1-mm8 cyc/800 lb12-mm face dia., truncatedSemtorq S-16-1, ridged

Page 50: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

2008 Hybrid Tahoe Aluminum Liftgate2008 Hybrid Tahoe Aluminum Liftgate

• Liftgate is resistance spot welded with macro-featured electrodes

• Electrode surfaces maintained with a rotary dressing operation

• Liftgate is resistance spot welded with macro-featured electrodes

• Electrode surfaces maintained with a rotary dressing operation

Page 51: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

2009 Cadillac CTS-V Aluminum Hood2009 Cadillac CTS-V Aluminum Hood

• Narrow front flange (10.5-mm weld flat) is resistance spot welded with macro-featured electrodes

• Conventional aluminum RSW not capable for this geometry

• Narrow front flange (10.5-mm weld flat) is resistance spot welded with macro-featured electrodes

• Conventional aluminum RSW not capable for this geometry

Page 52: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Macro-Featured Electrodes Weld Both Aluminum and Steel

Macro-Featured Electrodes Weld Both Aluminum and Steel

• Common electrode can be used for Al/Al and Fe/Fe welding

• Required aluminum currents reduced vs historic RSW

• Common electrode can be used for Al/Al and Fe/Fe welding

• Required aluminum currents reduced vs historic RSW

0.8 to 1.0 mm

6111-T4 Al

2.0 to 2.0 mm

5754-0 Al

0.75 to 0.75 mm

HDG (hot dip

galvanized) low

carbon steel

1.5 to 1.5 mm

HDG low carbon

steel

Page 53: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

CorrosionCorrosion• Filiform Corrosion is of concern for closure panels

• Dissimilar joints (Al-Steel) …concern over

galvanic coupling

• Alternative fuels (e.g., E85) can induce corrosion

in Al engines

• Filiform Corrosion is of concern for closure panels

• Dissimilar joints (Al-Steel) …concern over

galvanic coupling

• Alternative fuels (e.g., E85) can induce corrosion

in Al engines

Page 54: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Filiform CorrosionFiliform Corrosion

Photo from Leth-Olsen & Nisancioglu, 1998

• Filiform corrosion…most common

corrosion challenge for Al panels

• Another current manufacturing

challenge…cross-contamination of steel to Al during metal

finishing of closures

• Cathodic intermetallic particles

(Al3Fe) increase corrosion rate. Conversion coatings can provide

protection but are costly.

• Filiform corrosion…most common

corrosion challenge for Al panels

• Another current manufacturing

challenge…cross-contamination of steel to Al during metal

finishing of closures

• Cathodic intermetallic particles

(Al3Fe) increase corrosion rate. Conversion coatings can provide

protection but are costly.

Page 55: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Aluminum – Steel InterfacesAluminum – Steel Interfaces

• Adhesive typically

used as isolation

strategy

• Patchy adhesive

layers can lead to

poor phosphate &

electro-coat (ELPO)

corrosion protection

• Adhesive typically

used as isolation

strategy

• Patchy adhesive

layers can lead to

poor phosphate &

electro-coat (ELPO)

corrosion protection

Page 56: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

E85 Induced Corrosion between

Valve Seat & Al 319 Cylinder Head

E85 Induced Corrosion between

Valve Seat & Al 319 Cylinder Head

Pressed in Steel

Valve Seat

Galvanic

Interdendritic

Page 57: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Opportunities for Aluminum in

Structures

Opportunities for Aluminum in

Structures

Short term

• Large, thin wall, and hollow castings

• High strength/toughness and weldable castings in load

paths

Long term

• Linerless engines

• Mixed materials subsystems, including joining

• Galvanic corrosion mitigation

Short term

• Large, thin wall, and hollow castings

• High strength/toughness and weldable castings in load

paths

Long term

• Linerless engines

• Mixed materials subsystems, including joining

• Galvanic corrosion mitigation

Page 58: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Future enablersFuture enablers

Page 59: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

In-Situ Nanoindentation inside a

Transmission Electron

Microscope

Indenter Si substrate

e-

Al film ~ 500 nm

SampleDiamond indenterWall and Dahmen, Microscopy and Microanalysis, 3, 1997

Pillar Fabrication• 160-200 nm diameter

• 600-800 nm long

• 3-5º taper

Al Thin film

Diamond indenter

National Center for

Electron Microscopy

Work of LBL and colleagues

Page 60: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

Grain Boundaries in pure Al and Al-Mg

High angle boundaries are

mobile since there are no

solutes to pin them

Pure Al

Al-2%Mg

Mg pins the high angle

boundaries and make them

immobile. Dislocations thus

accumulate inside the grain

to cause hardening

Work of LBL and colleagues

Page 61: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

MULTIMULTI--SCALE MODELING OF SCALE MODELING OF

ELEVATED TEMPERATURE DEFORMATIONELEVATED TEMPERATURE DEFORMATION

Philosophy Philosophy nmnm µµµµµµµµmm mmmm mm

log(Lengthlog(Length scale)scale)

EngineeringEngineering

MaterialsMaterials

ScienceScience

ChemistryChemistry

PhysicsPhysics

CompetencyCompetency

Mg flowMg flow

Electronic

Atomistic

Microstructural

Continuum

Page 62: Blair Carlson, Paul Krajewski, Anil Sachdev, Jim … · Al Roof Bow CHEVROLET CORVETTE Z06 0 to 60 mph in 3.7 s. Mg-Intensive Front-end AHSS Passenger Compartment Steel: 79 Parts;

¶ GM’s focus…design, build and sell the world’s best

vehicles

¶ Mass-reduction technologies are key to reinventing

the automobile for tomorrow

¶ Affordable, formable/castable, and robust

aluminum components and subsystems are of

great interest for automotive applications

SUMMARYSUMMARY