Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

download Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

of 7

Transcript of Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

  • 8/9/2019 Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

    1/7

    ANEK

    IRKP

    ATRICK

    ,

    1926

    -200

    6

    LAUDIA

    AND

    ERSO

    NNO

    RMAN

    POD

    HORETZ

    WARRIORS

    FOR HIREMark Hemingwayon Blackwater USA and

    the rise of

    private militarycontractors

    DECEMBER 18, 2006 $3.95

  • 8/9/2019 Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

    2/7The Weekly STandard / 23December 18, 2006

    Warriorsfor Hire

    Blackwater USA and the rise of private military contractors

    Moyock, N.C.

    F

    or obvious reasons, the location o the headquar-

    ters o Blackwater USA isnt well-publicized.

    Ocially, the only public trace o the worlds

    largest private military training acility is a postoce box in Moyock, North Carolina, an unre-

    markable rib-shack pit-stop on the way to the Outer Banks.

    But the place isnt hard to nd. From Washington, D.C.,

    head south. As soon as you cross the state line, ollow the

    sound o gunre until you nd an armed compound hal

    the size o Manhattan. Which is not to say the place sticks

    outits just very, very big. Blackwater is a company most

    Americans rst heard o when our o its contractors were

    murdered in Falluja, Iraq, in March 2004, and their bod-

    ies desecrated on camera. It is the most prominent o the

    private security contractors in Iraq. You might think o the

    North Carolina acility as Blackwaters Fort Benning orQuantico.

    Still largely subsumed by the swampland it occupies, the

    compound is mostly au naturel except or odd aircrat lying

    around. The company name sounds mysterious, but its just

    the name o the region. I you dig a ew eet underground,

    the hole will quickly ll with the thick, dark peat water just

    under the surace. The only building o any real size houses

    the companys brand new 60,000-square-oot corporate

    oces, a low prole building with a massive stone entry-

    way that blends into the surroundings nicely. (The massive

    double-door handles made rom .50 caliber machine gunbarrels get noticed, however.) In act, the company logoa

    target sight superimposed over a bear clawisnt entirely

    gurative. Black bearsat least one o which tops 800

    poundsroam reely all over the property.

    O course, running into a bear is probably the least o

    your saety concerns at Blackwater. Firing ranges abound on

    the property. For years, the companys bread and butter was

    its multimillion-dollar business designing and manuactur-

    ing targets and shooting ranges. From its original product

    a patented, reactive, reinorced steel targetthe company

    now makes everything rom modular, endlessly congu-

    rable shoothouses, with doors and rooms that simulate

    urban combat, to concrete, reinorced shipping containers

    that can be set up anywhere in the world as sel-contained

    ranges. (A personal avorite is the Dueling Treeanupright stand with three targets on each side. Hit the target

    and it gets knocked over to your opponents side where he

    can knock it back. The rst shooter with all six targets on

    his side loses. Think o it as tetherball with guns.)

    But were only scratching the surace. Though the com-

    pany is less than ten years old, its already become the alpha

    and omega o military outsourcing. The target systems

    remain a multimillion-dollar business, but now the corpo-

    rate fagship is just one part o a very large feet. Indeed, it

    would be hard to understate Blackwaters capabilities:

    A burgeoning logistics operation that can deliver 100-

    or 200-ton sel-contained humanitarian relie responsepackages aster than the Red Cross.

    A Florida aviation division with 26 dierent platorms,

    rom helicopter gunships to a massive Boeing 767. The

    company even has a Zeppelin.

    The countrys largest tactical driving track, with multi-

    surace, multi-elevation positive and negative cambered

    turns, a skid pad, and a ram pad or drivers learning how to

    escape ambushes.

    A 20-acre manmade lake with shipping containers that

    have been mocked up with ship rails and portholes, foating

    on pontoons, used to teach how to board a hostile ship. A K-9 training acility that currently has 80 dog teams

    deployed around the world. Ever wondered how to rappel

    down the side o nine stacked shipping containers with a

    bomb-sning German shepherd dog strapped to your

    chest? Blackwater can teach you.

    A 1,200-yard-long ring range or sniper training.

    A sizable private armory. The one gun locker I saw

    contained close to 100 9mm handgunsmostly mili-

    tary issue Beretta M9s, law enorcement avorite Austrian

    Glocks, and Sig Sauers.

    ByMarkHeMingway

    Mark Hemingway is a writer in Washington.

  • 8/9/2019 Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

    3/724 / The Weekly STandard December 18, 2006

    An armored vehicle still in develop-

    ment called the Grizzly; the prototypes

    angular steel plates are erocious-look-

    ing. The suspension is being built by one

    o Blackwaters North Carolina neigh-

    borsDennis Anderson, monster truck

    champion and the man responsible or the

    Grave Digger (the ne plus ultra o mon-ster trucks).

    And theres much, much more. Sitting

    in his second-story oce with expansive

    views o the grounds, Blackwater vice pres-

    ident or strategic initiatives and ormer

    recon Marine Chris Taylor makes a sound

    business case or the Blackwater acil-

    ity. One o the single greatest actors that

    makes us who we are today is, one, we are

    always complete, correct, and on time with

    our services and, two, this acilitythis isthe greatest barrier to entry in the market

    o doing training and security operations; nobody else has

    this. Taylor continues: To build this acility today$40

    or $50 million, and nobodys got that kind o coin. Nobody

    wants to invest that, especially i you are going into a mar-

    ket where there already is a big dog.

    Still, at a certain point touring their acilities, the

    immensity o the place seems like, well, overkill. O all the

    curiosities littered throughout the gargantuan property, its

    hard not to be taken aback by R U Ready Higha ring

    range modeled ater a high school, as well as an old school

    bus used or training in tactical hostage situations.Taylor patiently explains that the company built it

    immediately ater Columbine and that local police orces

    and SWAT teams oten have woeully inadequate training

    or such situations even to this day. Sure enough, shortly

    ater my tour o the acilities, there were two school hostage

    situations within days o each other, again in Colorado and

    in Pennsylvania. Neither ended well.

    It may seem callous that Blackwater is making a buck

    preparing police to deal with such horric events. But

    somebody has to be in the business o worst case scenar-

    ios. Its not their ault that everywhererom Colorado toIraqbusiness is so good.

    While Blackwaters training and logistics operations

    might be the heart o their operation, thats not

    the reason the company is on the verge o becom-

    ing a household name. Among its initial government con-

    tracts was one or antiterrorist training in the wake o the

    USS Cole bombing. A single marksman could have taken

    out the approaching bomb-laden boat, but most soldiers on

    deck werent even carrying loaded weapons at the time. Rec-

    ognizing a major weakness, the Navy awarded an urgent

    and compelling need contract to Blackwater to train

    20,000 sailors in orce protection. The company still exe-

    cutes that contract to this day. And rom that start, it gradu-

    ally expanded its roster o services available to the military.

    Enter the war on terror, and the military began looking or

    something beyond training and support servicesactual

    manpower.

    Blackwater is now one o the largest and most respected

    suppliers o private military contractors in Iraq. The

    company has carried out high-prole assignmentssuchas their exclusive contract to guard Ambassador L. Paul

    Bremer when he was the top U.S. civilian in Iraqwhose

    perormance by a private company would once have been

    unthinkable.

    The companys work in Iraq has not been with-

    out incident. The our American contractors killed in

    Falluja in March 2004 were providing transport security

    or a Kuwaiti ood service company under a Blackwater

    Security Consulting contract. Their bodies were dragged

    through the streets and the disgured corpses were even-

    tually strung rom a bridge with an electrical cord. Theamilies o the our menone o them a revered ormer

    SEAL instructorare suing Blackwater, alleging that they

    were rushed out on the mission without adequate prepara-

    tion or protection.

    Aside rom providing one o the most demoralizing

    images o the war, the killing o the our Blackwater employ-

    ees did two major things. It was the catalyst or the Battle o

    Falluja, a brutal but ultimately successul attempt to reclaim

    the city rom insurgents, which resulted in 83 additional

    U.S. troops killed in action. And it drew national attention

    Firing ranges were Blackwaters original business.

    The

    Virginian-Pilot/Polaris

  • 8/9/2019 Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

    4/7The Weekly STandard / 25December 18, 2006

    to the use o private contractorsmercenaries to their

    more vehement detractorsin Iraq.

    In the rst Gul war, the ratio o private contractors to

    military personnel was one to sixty. This time its approach-

    ing one to one. The Washington Post last week reported that

    the Pentagon counts about 100,000 contractors in Iraq. Pri-

    vate contractors are being used to supply everything rom

    pizzas to porta-potties; still the decidedly larger ratio is nodoubt the result o the 20,000 or so serving in a quasi-mili-

    tary rolealmost three times the number o British mili-

    tary orces currently in Iraq.

    Blackwater objects to the use o the m-word or its

    employees, preerring the term private military contrac-

    tors. For one thing, mercenary is not accurate. Private

    military contractors in Iraq do not execute oensive opera-

    tionsthey only provide security, and their rules o engage-

    ment are to use proportionate orce only when attacked.

    Nonetheless, private military contractors in Iraq are known

    or their aggressive behavior. Retired Marine colonelThomas X. Hammes is a vocal critic o Blackwater, having

    seen them guarding Bremer. The problem is, in protect-

    ing the principal they had to be very aggressive, and each

    time they went out, they had to oend locals, orcing them

    to the side o the road, being overpowering and intimidat-

    ing, at times running vehicles o the road, making enemies

    each time they went out, Hammes said in a PBS interview.

    However, Hammes noted, Blackwaters an extraordinarily

    proessional organization, and they were doing exactly what

    they were tasked to do.

    In act, Blackwater objects to its personnel being tarred

    as mercenaries mainly because they regard it as an assaulton their character and their proessionalism. Were in

    nine dierent countries, says Chris Taylor, probably have

    about 2,300 people deployed today, another 21,000 in our

    database, and these are people the majority o whom have

    already had a career in public service, either military or law

    enorcement, who are honorably discharged, who have any

    number o medals or heroism. Yet we still have to ace crit-

    ics who say everybody is a mercenarytheyre only out or

    a buck.

    Blackwater insists the money is exaggerated. Thething that gets all the attention is that its a business,

    a going concern. But there are nowhere near the

    prots that everybody thinks, Taylor says. They are quite

    serious about the moral importance o their work, a mes-

    sage that starts at the top. Blackwater CEO Erik Prince, the

    companys ounder, believes to his core that this is his lies

    work, says Taylor. I youre not willing to drink the Black-

    water Kool-aid and be committed to supporting humane

    democracy around the world, then theres probably a better

    place to go work, because thats all we do.

    Though his military career was brie, as a ormer Navy

    SEAL platoon commander, Prince is no dilettante. He

    attended ocer candidate school ater nishing college in

    1992, and the next year he joined SEAL Team 8 based out

    o Norolk. Prince eventually deployed to Haiti, the Middle

    East, and Bosnia, among other assignments. He is blond,

    handsome, and ridiculously all-American looking. His pos-

    ture is ramrod straight, and his clipped sentences are trueto his martial roots. At only 37, he remains in impeccable

    shape and looks as ready to step onto the battleeld as into

    a boardroom.

    He hardly ts the soldier o ortune archetype. He is a

    staunch Christianhis ather helped James Dobson ound

    Focus on the Familyand his politically conservative views

    are well known in Washington, where Prince supports a

    number o religious and right-leaning causes. He attended

    Hillsdale College in Michigan, a ont o conservative ideol-

    ogy, where he is remembered or being the rst undergradu-

    ate at the small liberal arts school to serve on the local vol-unteer re department. (The only book on the shel in the

    boardroom o Blackwaters Northern Virginia oces is a

    copy o the eminent conservative historian Paul Johnsons

    A History O The American People.)

    Nobody can say Prince is in it or the money, either. His

    ather Edgar started a small die-cast shop in Holland, Mich-

    igan, in 1965. Along the way he patented the now-ubiqui-

    tous lighted vanity mirror in automobile visors; a year ater

    his 1995 death, the amily company sold or over $1 billion,

    an enormous inheritance or Erik and his sisters.

    The next year Erik let the Navy and ounded Black-

    water. It was the end o the Cold War. The Clinton admin-istration and Congress had been eagerly downsizing mili-

    tary acilities and trainingmuch to the consternation o

    many ocers, Prince included. Prince knew there would

    be a market or the kind o training Blackwater would pro-

    vide; his initial purchase o 6,000 acres in Moyock does not

    suggest his vision or the company was modest. (Its cur-

    rently 7,500 acres; the company has plans to relocate the

    Florida aviation division to North Carolina near its head-

    quarters, as well as open training acilities in Caliornia and

    the Philippines.)

    Regardless o his inheritance, Princes subsequent shep-herding o Blackwater has proved him as adept a business-

    man as his ather. And there you have it. Erik Princemer-

    cenary mogul and liberal Americas worst nightmare. Not

    only can he buy and sell you, he can kill you beore you

    even know hes in the room.

    For a conservative like Prince, you cant make the

    world a better place without harnessing the power

    o ree markets. He sounds more like an MBA than

    a mercenary. Prince believes that an entrepreneurial spirit

  • 8/9/2019 Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

    5/726 / The Weekly STandard December 18, 2006

    and the military go naturally together: This goes back to

    our corporate mantra: Were trying to do or the national

    security apparatus what Fed Ex did or the postal service,

    Prince says. They did many o the same services that the

    Postal Service did, better, cheaper, smarter, and aster by

    innovating, [which] the private sector can do much more

    eectively.

    O all the charges leveled at Blackwater, one o the mostdamning is that they are war proteers. And its a charge

    the company is eager to deend against, especially in light o

    the act that it has been awarded numerous CIA and other

    no-bid urgent and compelling need contracts by the gov-

    ernment, the terms o which are oten shrouded in secrecy.

    Blackwater prides itsel on its cost-eectiveness. The

    DoD has lots o great people trapped in it. They are trapped

    in between stratied layers o bureaucracy that destroy

    innovation and eciency. The private sector can do many

    o those things, whether its training or logistics or airlit

    a lot o those kinds o peripheral issues. And we do it in amarket-based manner and drive those eciencies. So when

    they say Ah, we need about 100 guys to do that job, we say,

    Actually, you only need about 10 to do that job, Prince

    explains.

    Proving cost-eectiveness is nearly impossible as there

    are no comprehensive data on private military contractors

    and institutional savings. It is not clear that outsourcing

    always saves money, Brookings Institution scholar Peter

    Singer states in his book Corporate Warriors: The Rise o the

    Privatized Military Industry. In act, as Singer pointed out in

    a cover story inForeign Aairs, military contracts are seldom

    set up to achieve cost-eectiveness. Too oten, the costplus arrangement has become the deault orm or all con-

    tracts. But this setup, in eect, gives companies more prot

    i they spend more. When combined with inadequate over-

    sight, it creates a system ripe or ineciency and abuse,

    Singer says.

    Blackwaters position on expensive military contracts

    seems to be that they didnt start the re. It seems that strat-

    ied layers o bureaucracy in military contracts are ound

    both within and outside the DoD. A cursory examination

    o the circumstances surrounding Blackwaters inamous

    Falluja casualties shows why. On the surace, it looked likea simple contract to protect a Kuwaiti ood service company

    transporting ood and kitchen supplies. But as outlined

    in journalist Robert Young Peltons thorough new book

    Licensed to Kill: Hired Guns in the War on Terror, heres how

    the nancial arrangement really worked.

    Blackwater was contracted to provide transport secu-

    rity or Regency Hotel and Hospitality. The Kuwaiti ood

    service company itsel was a subcontractor o a German

    company, Eurest Support Services. ESS in turn was a sub-

    contractor o Kellogg, Brown and Root, which is itsel a

    subsidiary o Halliburton. KBR has an exclusive $7.2 bil-

    lion contract with the military or managing the Logistics

    Civil Augmentation Program, or LOGCAP, which han-

    dles global support unctions or the military, e.g., ood.

    How much anyone gets paid at any point along this long

    and winding paper trail is unknown, as KBR considers

    all LOGCAP billing condential, something each o its

    subcontractors must agree to in writing. Violation o thisprivacy clause is punishable by $250,000 in nes. However,

    it can be saely assumed that at each level o subcontract-

    ing, the companies mark up their costs, bloating the price

    to the taxpayer. These massive contracts are easier or the

    government to manage than multiple smaller ones. Prince

    says thats a problem.

    One o the best ways the U.S. government overall, par-

    ticularly the DOD, can get better value or the taxpayers

    is by improving the training, standards, and competence

    o their own contracting ocers, he says. When you go

    to sell to a Fortune 500 company, their purchasing ocerknows more about your process than you dothey really

    drill down; they know the best value and they expect execu-

    tion complete, correct, and on time. With government con-

    tracting ocers thats not always the case; thats seldom the

    case. Theres a lot more shortcomings that are allowed that

    go unpunished.

    So i private military contractors are considered cost

    eective, thats no doubt partly because theyre being graded

    on a curve set by the Department o Deensehome o the

    $200 hammer and $500 toilet seat. Blackwater has earned

    $505 million in publicly identiable contracts since 2000

    its no wonder private military contractors jokingly reer tothemselves as the Coalition o the Billing.

    As or the individual contractors on the ground, pay

    varies, but $600-$700 a day would not be out o line or a

    qualied armed guard, and higher gures are commonplace,

    depending on qualications and experience. The good pay

    is a bit o a joke within the industry. Circulating on the mes-

    sage boards and email lists o contractors or some time has

    been this tongue-in-cheek but nonetheless revealing Con-

    tractors Creed:I care not or ribbons and awards or valor. I do

    this job or the opportunity to kill the enemies o my country, and

    to fnally get that boat Ive always wanted. In any combat zone, Iwill always locate the swimming pool, beer, and women, because I

    can. I will deploy on my terms, and i it ever gets too stupid, I will

    simply fnd another company that pays me more.

    Despite the ethical perils inherent in such work,

    Prince insists not just that the uture o warare

    depends on private companies driving market e-

    ciencies, but that this is the way o the world. I would go

    back to a deeper view o history. The idea o private contrac-

    tors doing this kind o work is not a recent phenomenon,

  • 8/9/2019 Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

    6/7The Weekly STandard / 27December 18, 2006

    he says. He can rattle o any number o examples o merce-

    naries being used throughout historymany o whom were

    beloved gures in U.S. history, rom Revolutionary hero

    Laayette to the Flying Tigers in World War II.

    That may be the deeper view o historybut it glosses

    over the recent history o mercenaries, which is horriy-

    ing. Blackwater is trying to emerge as a credible and ethi-

    cal company in an industry with a reputation o being any-thing but. Most notorious in this respect is Executive Out-

    comes, a mercenary company that started in South Arica in

    1989, drawing personnel rom the remnants o the outgoing

    apartheid regimes shady military and internal intelligence

    operations.

    Clients included Texaco and DeBeers, but Executive

    Outcomes wasnt exactly discriminating about whose money

    it took. In 1996, one o EOs principals, Simon Mann, a or-

    mer SAS ocer and heir to a substantial brewing ortune,

    created a subsidiary called Sandline. Mann recruited a or-

    mer lieutenant colonel in the Scots Guards, Tim Spicer, tohead up the operation. Creating a subsidiary with a dier-

    ent name was also an attempt in part to remove the stink

    that Executive Outcomes had acquired in its seven years o

    existence. It was Spicer and Mann who came up with the

    term Private Military Company and began rebranding mer-

    cenaries in earnest.

    Sandlines rst big contract came in January 1997$36

    million rom the government o Papua New Guinea, to help

    it regain control o a copper mine that had been seized by

    rebels. This did not go well; Spicer was arrested as soon as

    Sandline orces attempted to enter the country and reed

    only ater the British government intervened. Public outcryover Sandlines contract very nearly destabilized the Pap-

    uan government, orcing the prime minister to resign.

    I Spicer and Mann were chastened by the incident, they

    didnt show it. By 1998 Sandline was embroiled in a much

    bigger scandalallegedly violating a U.N. arms embargo

    in Sierra Leone on behal o an Indian client accused o

    embezzling millions rom a Thai bank. Executive Out-

    comes dissolved in 1999 in response to anti-mercenary leg-

    islation introduced in South Arica, but Sandline operated

    until 2004.

    Sandlines closing in 2004 was not incidental. That

    same year, Mann was sentenced to seven years

    imprisonment in Zimbabwe. He had been arrested

    along with a planeload o mercenaries and ormer EO and

    Sandline colleagues en route to oment a coup in Equatorial

    Guinea, a tiny despotic country in the armpit o Arica that

    happens to have substantial oil reserves o the coast.

    Manns ailed coup made a huge splash internationally,

    in part because one o the people allegedly bankrolling the

    operation was Mark Thatcher, son o the ormer British

    prime minister. Weirder still, the coup attempt was likely

    inspired by Frederick Forsyths 1974 bestseller The Dogs oWar, about a band o mercenaries who attempt to overthrow

    the government o a ctional Arican country clearly mod-

    eled ater Equatorial Guinea. As i that werent enough, it is

    quite credibly reputed that Forsyth himsel bankrolled an

    unsuccessul 1972 coup attempt in the same country with

    unds rom his rst novel, The Day o the Jackal, and that

    Forsyths real-lie exploits were the basis o his allegedly c-

    tionalDogs o War published two years later. The pice de

    rsistance to this whole saga? Forsyth is one o a small num-

    ber o private investors in the current business venture

    o Manns good riend and ormer business partner, TimSpicer.

    While Mann began rotting in jail, Spicer was busy posi-

    tioning himsel and his new company, Aegis Deense Ser-

    vices. Despite the act that he was called in or questioning

    by the British government and suspected o being involved

    in some capacity with Manns 2004 coup attempt, in May

    o that year Aegis was awarded a $293 million contract

    rom the U.S. government to provide security or the Army

    Corps o Engineers and the Iraq Project and Contracting

    Oce, the two U.S. agencies most directly responsible or

    Blackwater parachuting demo at a military trade show in JordanPolaris

  • 8/9/2019 Blackwater - Warriors for Hire

    7/728 / The Weekly STandard December 18, 2006

    Iraqi reconstruction. This despite the act that the com-

    pany had no previous experience in Iraq and clearly didnt

    have the resources to ulll the contract. The contract is

    shrouded in controversy; as head o security or the Project

    Management Oce (precursor to the Project and Contract-

    ing Oce), British Brigadier General Tony Hunter-Choat

    wrote the terms o the contract. Hunter-Choat and Spicer

    were contemporaries in the British military and are knownto have worked together previously in the Balkans. Another

    British general, James Ellery, who worked with Hunter-

    Choat at the Project Management Oce and on the con-

    tract specications, now works or Aegis.

    The Aegis contract got the attention o Congress, and

    eventually the Pentagon admitted that its contracting o-

    cer was completely unaware o Spicers background. Aegiss

    rst DOD audit in 2005 was damning, including the charge

    that the company was trying to ramp up so ast to meet the

    contract requirements they were hiring poorly vetted Iraqis

    and giving them passes to the Green Zone. The companyalso came under scrutiny when videos o Aegis contrac-

    tors indiscriminately ring at civilian cars suraced on the

    Internet. Despite this, Aegis is carrying out extensive con-

    tracting operations in Iraq to this day.

    The larger question or Erik Prince and Blackwater

    has to be: How to remove the stink that clings to

    their industry? How can they convince the world

    that they are committed to supporting humane democracy

    when everyone else in their industry has been eager to sell

    it out? With a Democratic Congress and talk o withdrawal

    rom Iraq, most private military contractors are wonderingwhats next.

    Blackwater thinks it has the answer. I just got back rom

    Darur, says Chris Taylor, the vice president or strategic

    initiatives. I called Erik on my sat phone and said, I was in

    Juba; theres 300 U.N. vehicles in a motor pool, theres any

    number o NGOs driving within a one-mile radius within

    Juba, and nothings getting done. The only time you see

    people in their vehicles is when they were going to the tent

    cities, because theres a bar in every tent city.

    Prince and other key Blackwater leaders have also vis-

    ited war-torn Darur. While there may be other private mili-tary contractors that are larger, most o them support and

    conduct operations through a patchwork o subcontracts.

    By contrast, Blackwater can oer every conceivable service

    its people might need, so when they go into an area their

    resources are entirely sel-contained, making them ideally

    suited to humanitarian work in dicult conditionsthey

    have the resources to provide both supplies and security

    with military precision. Were not big outsourcers, which

    is kind o ironic because we play a big role in the outsourc-

    ing market. The more layers o subcontracting, the harder

    it is or you to get a straight answer and get something cor-

    rected, Taylor says.

    Blackwater vice-chairman Coer Black, a or-

    mer CIA agent and State Department coordinator or

    counterterrorism, made waves at a conerence in Amman,

    Jordan, earlier this year saying the company is ready to pro-

    vide brigade-size orces (1,500-3,000 soldiers) or peacekeep-

    ing missions around the world. Refecting on his experiencein Darur, Taylor says the solution to the situation is obvi-

    ous. Im not really good at math but it seems like a pretty

    simple equation to solve. Get more people, skilled people, in

    there. Even in Darur today, [there are only] 7,000 Arican

    Union troops in a place the size o France, Taylor says. So

    why not send us?

    Well, or one thing, the humanitarian world has seen

    the ravages o mercenary activities in Arica or decades,

    and they have reason to be suspicious. Even Sandline hid

    behind the excuse o humanitarian work. When it was shut-

    tered in 2004, the ocial reason given was that, owing toa lack o governmental support, the ability o Sandline

    to make a positive dierence in countries where there is

    widespread brutality and genocidal behaviour is materially

    diminished.

    Blackwater insists it is dierent. Prince and Black-

    water have been involved in charities on the margins o the

    humanitarian world or some time now. But the resistance

    is erce. Coer and I have been speaking about our abil-

    ity to help in Darur ad innitum, and that just pisses o

    the humanitarian world, Taylor says. They have prob-

    lems with private security companies, not because o peror-

    mance but because they think that in some cases it removestheir ability to cross borders, to talk to both sides, to be neu-

    tral. And thats great, but the age-old questionis neutral-

    ity greater than saving one more lie? Whats the marginal

    utility on one more lie?

    It would also require the humanitarian world to come

    to terms with one o its greatest ailings. Time and again

    humanitarian eorts are oiled and set back because o the

    inability to provide the security that enables relie eorts to

    go orward in dangerous areas.

    Currently the U.N. Department o Peacekeeping Opera-

    tions has an annual budget o $7 billion, to say nothing othe billions in private charities and oreign aid pouring in

    to the worlds worst places. Even those suspicious o Black-

    waters motives must realize it makes good business sense

    that they would be interested in the work. Why chase ater

    shady corporate clients when the mother lode is in helping

    people?

    Its true there may be no good way to calculate the mar-

    ginal utility o one more lie. But just in case the world

    needs them, in the swamps o North Carolina, a ew thou-

    sand rough men stand readyor a price. t