Biological Implications of Pesticides in Small Urban Streams...Biological Implications of Pesticides...
Transcript of Biological Implications of Pesticides in Small Urban Streams...Biological Implications of Pesticides...
Biological Implications of Pesticides in Small Urban Streams
Dean Wilson
King County Department of Natural Resources and ParksWater and Land Resources Division
November 2003
Study Purpose
Assess the biological effects of pesticides present in small streams
Analyze for over 150 different pesticides
Analyze for metals
Assess toxicity using 3 different test species
Develop effects thresholds
Seattle
Study Area
2,4-D
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
Jan
A
2,4-D
Study Design
DIAZINON
0500
1000
1500200025003000
35004000
JAN
_97
FEB
_97
MA
R_9
7
AP
R_9
7
MA
Y_9
7
JUN
_97
JUL_
97
AU
G_9
7
SE
P_9
7
OC
T_97
NO
V_9
7
DE
C_9
7
Diazinon
Laboratory AnalysesPesticides
Dissolved insecticides (USGS schedule 2010)Chlorinated insecticides (DDT)(Manchester)Chlorinated herbicides (2,4-D)Triazine compounds (atrazine)Organophosphorus insecticides (Diazinon)Glyphosate (Roundup)
Metals
Threshold Effects Levels
2,4-D 2,6 Dichlorobenzamide4-Nitrophenol BromacilCarbaryl CarbofuranDicamba DichlobenilDichloroprop DiuronEthofumesate MCPAMCPP MetolachlorMetalaxyl NapropamidPentachlorophenol PrometonSimazine TebuthironTrifluralin
Toxicity
Green algae Selenastrum capricornutumDuck weed Lemna minorWater flea Ceriodaphnia dubia
ResultsPesticides
Frequency of Detection All
05
10152025303540
Carb
ofur
anEt
hofu
mes
aM
etal
axap
ropa
mid
Oxa
diaz
4,4-
DDD
4,4-
DDE
4,4-
DDBr
oma
ylat
razi
nDi
chlo
ropr
Met
olac
hlTr
iflur
alDi
urho
sph
Chlo
rpyr
ifG
lyph
osM
alat
hiM
CPut
hiur
robe
nzam
idDi
cam
bAt
razi
roph
enCa
rba
Sim
azi
Diaz
inDi
chlo
be MCP 24
phen
Prom
etTr
iclo
p
N = 53
Freq of Detection Storm
05
10
15
20
25
30
Car
bofu
ran
hofu
mes
ate
Met
alax
ylO
xadi
azon
hano
l pho
sh
Bro
mac
ilra
zine
*M
etol
achl
orN
apro
pam
ide
4,4-
DD
D*
4,4-
DD
E*4,
4-D
DT
iflur
alin
Diu
roph
...C
hlor
pyrif
osD
ichl
orop
rop
Tebu
thiu
ron
orob
en...
Atr
azin
ely
phos
ate
Mal
athi
onM
CPA
maz
ine
Dic
amb
phen
ol*
Car
bary
lch
lobe
nil
Dia
zino 24
DM
CPP
met
onro
phen
olTr
iclo
pyr
N = 32
Freq of Detection Baseflow
02468
101214
2-bu
toxy
eth
anol
pho
spha
te4,
4-D
DE*
hlor
opro
pN
apro
pam
ide
4,4-
DD
D*
Car
bofu
ran
hofu
mes
ate
Mal
athi
onM
etal
axyl
Oxa
diaz
on4,
4-D
DT
Dic
amb
MC
PA...
Bro
mac
ilC
arba
ryl
orpy
rifos
hyla
traz
ine*
Gly
phos
ate
Met
olac
hlor
Trifl
ural
inD
iuro
zam
ide*
4-N
itrop
heno
l*A
traz
ine
Dia
zino
nbu
thiu
ron
Dic
hlob
enil
MC
PP2
4D
met
onSi
maz
ine
roph
enol
Tric
lopy
r
N = 21
Threshold Effects LevelsExceeded
Diazinon 7Copper 3Simazine 2DDT 2Lead 1Malathion 1
Total 16
Observed Toxicity
47 % (25 times total)
59 % Storm (19)
29 % Baseflow (6)
What does it all mean?
Acute Toxicity was observed in 2 samples.
Toxicity was observed in 4 samples and thresholds were exceeded.
In an additional 4 samples no toxicity was observed,yet thresholds were exceeded.
Uncertainty
Toxicity was observed in 19 samples yet no thresholds were exceeded.
Chemicals not testedOther pesticidesSurfactantsOther chemicals
Other Issues
Mixtures
Test Durations
Acknowledgements
King County USGS
Helle Andersen Lonna FransJim Buckley Sandy EmbreyJulie Aliamo Jim EbbertGary Yoshida Joe GilbertFran Sweeney Ragaen HuffmanGeorge PerryColin ElliottMary SilvaMelinda FergusonDoug Henderson Manchester LaboratoryDeb LesterJonathan Frodge Stuart MagoonDave Funke Pam Covey
Karin FeddersenBob CarrelWill White
Http://dnr.metrokc.gov/wlr/waterres/streams/pestindex.htm