8/3/2019 Billings - Juridical Exceptional Ism

1/39

KUYLGLCBN EQCE]WL@FBNLSO LF BUSWYBNLB

Nbz. F`swbnjlb bfg wae Eqcnusl`f `d @waeys

]ewey Ilnnlfjs+

Degeybn j`teyfoefw lfweytefwl`fs gesljfeg w` bggyesslyyejunby obylwloe byyltbns bfg s`cl`/ec`f`olc c`fglwl`fs lf}bywlcunby Lfgljef`us c`oouflwles lf wae F`ywaeyf Weyylw`y|abte ieef cabybcweylseg i| kuylglcbn eqce}wl`fbnlso wae}bywlbn sus}efsl`f `y zlwagybzbn `d wae kuylglcbn `ygey&]eycelteg eoeyjefcles iy`bgn|. i`ygey !lf,secuylw| bfg}a|slcbn !lf,secuylw| abte yesunweg lf wae cyebwl`f `d nejbns}bces lf zalca @waeys bye c`fswlwuweg zlwalf bfg zlwa`uw wae kuylglcbn `ygey i| wae s`teyeljf& Wals bywlcne cylwlcbnn| eq}n`yeswaese eqce}wl`fbn s}bces `ddsa`ye eqclseg }nbces.looljybwl`f gewefwl`f cefwyes bfg }yescylieg }byws `d waeF`ywaeyf Weyylw`y| bfg lfteswljbwes wae ewalcbn. }`nlwlcbn bfgalsw`ylcbn ybwl`fbnlwles ufgey}lfflfj waeo& Cyuclbnn|. walslfcnuges c`fslgeybwl`f `d a`z s`clbn oeo`yles abte lfdnuefcegwae yejunbwl`f `d lyyejunby obylwloe byyltbns bfg wae cyebwl`f `deoeyjefc| yes}`fse nbzs lf wae F`ywaeyf Weyylw`y|& Lw ls byjuegwabw s`clbn. j`teyfoefwbn oeo`yles bi`uw wae eddlcbc| bfgnejbc| `d nbz}`nlc| yes}`fses w` i`ygey lfsecuylw| bfg waes`cl`/ec`f`olc }y`ineos dbclfj Lfgljef`us c`oouflwles abte.w` b gejyee. ieef lfdecweg i| f`swbnjlb& Wals |ebyflfj d`y waeyesw`ybwl`f `d }bsw eq}eylefce ls bss`clbweg zlwa b sefse `dn`ss. lfcnuglfj b n`ss `d swbwe s`teyeljfw| gue w` lyyejunbyobylwloe byyltbns. b n`ss `d c`fwy`n `tey !c`fglwl`fs lf,Bi`yljlfbn c`oouflwles bfg b n`ss `d fbwl`fbn uflw| bfglgefwlw|& Wals n`fjlfj abs bcwltbweg }`nlwlclbfs yewy` lgebs bfgwae yedbsal`flfj `d nejbn yes}`fses w` cuyyefw s`clbn glneoobs&

Byjubin|. suca swybwejles ylsh glsc`ufwlfj `y eqcuslfj waedblnlfjs `d }bsw s`clbn }`nlcles. nebtlfj lfgltlgubns w` ieby waebgteyse eddecws `fce o`ye&

Degeybn j`teyfoefw lfweytefwl`fs gesljfeg w` bggyess c`o}neq s`clbnglneoobs lf Buswybnlb fboen|. lyyejunby obylwloe byyltbns 2 bfg nltlfj

+Sefl`y Necwuyey. WC Ielyfe Sca``n d Nbz. Uflteyslw| d Rueefsnbfg& L wabfh Bnnbf

Byglnn. Obycenne Iuyfs. Bfwa`f| Cbsslobwls. ]bun Aby}uy bfg wae bf`f|o`us yedeyees d`y

waely aen}dun c`ooefws `f wals Bywlcne bfg jybwedunn| bchf`znegje wae yesebyca bsslswbfce

}y`tlgeg i| Kunle @bwes. Zbnwey Abyyls`f Nbz Nliyby|& L bns` eqwefg wabfhs w` o| yesebyca

bsslswbfw. Obylssb G``yls. bfg seteybn `waey `uwswbfglfj swugefws; Swbce| Nu. C`ylf

O`yc`o bfg Sbo T`nnlfj za` lgefwldleg s`oe d wae sec`fgby| s`uyces yenleg f lf wals

bywlcne& Wae usubn glscnbloey b}}nles&2

Lf c`oo`f }bynbfce. lyyejunby obylwloe byyltbns bye weyoeg bs|nuo seeheys. lnnejbn

efwybfws y i`bw }e`}ne& Buswybnlbs yes}`fse w` suca byyltbns ls }bywlbnn| dyboeg i| aey

8/3/2019 Billings - Juridical Exceptional Ism

2/39

9:9 JYLDDLWANBZYETLEZ!9=22, T@N 9= F@9

c`fglwl`fs lf }bywlcunby Lfgljef`us c`oouflwles lf wae F`ywaeyf Weyylw`y| abte ieef cabybcweylseg i| kuylglcbn eqce}wl`fbnlso& S}ecldlcbnn|. b }bywlbnsus}efsl`f `d wae kuylglcbn `ygey abs cabybcweylseg waese o`geyf swbwes `deqce}wl`f. ybwaey wabf b s}bce get`lg `d nbz. b {`fe `d bf`ole&9 ]eyceltegeoeyjefcles iy`bgn|. i`ygey !lf,secuylw| bfg }a|slcbn !lf,secuylw| abteyesunweg lf wae cyebwl`f `d nejbn s}bces lf zalca @waeys bye c`fswlwuwegzlwalf bfg zlwa`uw wae kuylglcbn `ygey i| wae s`teyeljf; slounwbfe`usn|suikecw w` nbzs c`oobfgs bfg c`fswyblfws zalne `dwef ie|`fg lws }y`wecwlteyebca& C`fweo}`yby| c`fdljuybwl`fs `d wae swbwe `d eqce}wl`f bye. f`wbin|.`ddsa`ye eqclseg }nbces d`y bs|nuo seeheys. bfg }yescylieg byebs `d wae

F`ywaeyf Weyylw`y| s}bces wabw bye }`}unbweg nbyjen| i| Lfgljef`us }e`}nes& Waese bye {`fes zaeye yejunby nbz abs ieef sus}efgeg !`yzlwagybzf, bfg wae yune `d nbz !erubnlw| ied`ye wae nbz bfg bccess w` kuswlce,ey`geg. bfg waely debwuyes lfcnuge b c`fcefwybwl`f `d eqecuwlte }`zeys bfgaeljawefeg suytelnnbfce `tey }bywlcunby suikecws& Wae alsw`y| `d c`n`flsbwl`fabs obge suca. eqce}wl`fbn wecaflrues `d j`teyfbfce }`ssline bcc`yglfj w`O`yew`f/Y`ilfs`f;

Dy`o wae nbwe flfeweefwa cefwuy| yeseytes. }yltbwen| `zfeg }bsw`ybnswbwl`fs bfg olssl`fs zeye wae }nbces zaeye wae obk`ylw| `dLfgljef`us }e`}ne lf Buswybnlb nlteg ufgey wae c`fwy`n `d zalwe

obfbjeys bfg olssl`fbyles b}}`lfweg i| j`teyfoefw& Lfgljef`us

}e`}ne. zalne nltlfj lf }`teyw|. zeye wyebweg glddeyefwn| w` zalweBuswybnlbf clwl{efs bfg zeye suikecw w` s}eclbn nbzs. yejunbwl`fs bfg

}`nlcles wabw zeye ybclsw&3

Lfgeeg. Oung``f cnblos wabw wae sw`y| `d wae c`olfj `d nbz w` Buswybnlbiylfjs lfw` saby} yenled wae eqce}wl`fbn fbwuye `d s`teyeljf }`zey. gybzlfj`f Bjboiefs A`o` Sbcey; S`teyeljf ]`zey bfg Ibye Nlde !2

8/3/2019 Billings - Juridical Exceptional Ism

3/39

ILNNLFJS; KUYLGLCBN EQCE]WL@FBNLSO LFBUSWYBNLB 9:3

Slfce lf wae kuylglcbn o`gen. wae s`teyeljf g`es f`w slo}n| efd`yce

wae nbz. iuw c`fswlwuwes lws tey| c`fglwl`f `d }`sslilnlw|. lw ls. lfBjboiefs z`ygs. bw wae sboe wloe. `uwslge bfg lfslge wae kuylglcbn`ygey !}& 25,& Lw bcws bs wae jy`ufg `dnbz. iuw ls f`w lwsend jy`ufgeg

lf nbz& Lf wae cbse `d wae c`n`flbn s`teyeljf. wals }bybg`qlcbn }`slwl`fbs wae ufjy`ufgeg jy`ufg obfldesw lwsend i`wa lf wae bcw `d swbweeswbinlsalfj wae c`n`f| bfg bdweyzbygs lf wae bcw `d sus}efglfj wae

nbz ufgey ceywblf eqce}wl fbn clycuoswbfces&7

Bcc`yglfjn|. cylwlcbn yednecwl`fs `f wae sus}efsl`f `d nbz ufgey fecesslw`usclycuoswbfces lf c`fweo}`yby| Buswybnlb ousw ie slwubweg lf wae c`n`flbnc`fweqw. zaeye }`zey abs bnzb|s ieef eq}yesseg bs }`zey `tey nlde. bfgzaeye c`fwy`n nles f`w lf wae yune `d nbz. iuw lf wae yune `d eqce}wl`f&5

Alsw`ylcbnn|. eqce}wl`fbn j`teyfbfce byybfjeoefws cabybcweylseg i| wae w`wbn`y }bywlbn sus}efsl`f `d nbz. s}bf glddeyefw suikecws. lfcnuglfj Lfgljef`us}e`}nes. lfgefwuyeg nbi`uyeys dy`o tbyl`us ]bcldlc Lsnbfgs. oljybfws. cltlnlbfzbywloe lfweyfees bfg bs|nuo seeheys&4

Yewuyflfj w` wae }bywlcunbylwles `d o`geyf j`teyfoefw lfweytefwl fs. waenbz `dwef obhes lwsend hf`zf lf weyos `d zaeye lw ls !`y }uy}`yws w` ie,lfb}}nlcbine& Wae s`teyeljf nbz efwlwnes lwsend w` eddecwlten| wybfsjyess lwsnbz lf wae cyebwl`f `d {`fes `d eqce}wl`f zaeye wae nbz g`es f`w `}eybwe& :Bcc`yglfjn|. wa`se bs|nuo seeheys efweylfj Buswybnlb bw bf `ddsa`ye eqclseg

}nbce bye cnbssldleg bs bf ufnbzdun f`f/clwl{ef. b gesljfbwl`f wabw waedegeybn Nbi`y j`teyfoefw olswbhefn| ienleteg seteyeg bs|nuo seeheys dy`ocylwlcbn }y`tlsl`fs lf wae Oljybwl f Bcw 2

8/3/2019 Billings - Juridical Exceptional Ism

4/39

9:7 JYLDDLWANBZYETLEZ!9=22, T@N 9= F@9

bjblfsw oebsuyes wabw zeye ybclbnn| glscylolfbw`y|,. nlolws `f bccess w`kuswlce !yljaws w` bgolflswybwlte yetlez ied`ye wyliufbns zeye zlwagybzf, bfgb glddeyefwlbweg s`clbn secuylw| yejloe !wabw rubybfwlfeg zendbye }b|oefws`d n`cbn yeslgefws,& Waese nejbn obf`eutylfjs zeye geeoeg fecessby|

iecbuse `d wae eqljefcles `d s}eclbn slwubwl`fs c`fdy`fwlfj waeC`oo`fzebnwa&

Wals bywlcne cylwlcbnn| eq}n`yes waese eqce}wl`fbn s}bces. lfabilweg i|obylwloe byyltbns !bs|nuo seeheys, seehlfj }y`wecwl`f lf Buswybnlb bfg i|

}yescylieg c`oouflwles lf wae F`ywaeyf Weyylw`y| yes}ecwlten|. bfg eqbolfeswae o`ybn. }`nlwlcbn bfg alsw`ylcbn ybwl`fbnlwles wabw ufgey}lf waeo& L bggyesswae boiltbnefw fbwuye `d s`clbn oeo`y|. bfg a`z wae lfwey}nb| iewzeef }bswbfg }yesefw lfdnuefces wae nejbn bfg bgolflswybwlte yejunbwl`f `d lyyejunbyobylwloe byyltbns bfg ceywblf Lfgljef`us c`oouflwles&1

L iejlf i| eqbolflfj wae }y`ineobwlslfj `d lyyejunby bs|nuo seeheysbfg obne Bi`yljlfes bs wae efeo| zlwalf < Buswybnlb& L waef eq}n`ye waeewalcbn gloefsl`fs su}}`ywlfj waese c`fweo}`yby| secuylw| }y`kecws& Waefeqw secwl`f yetebns a`z wae iefljf bfg iefedlclbn nbfjubje `dauobflwbylbflso abs dufcwl`feg w` su}}`yw i`wa cabfje bfg c`fwlfulw| lfoljybwl`f nbz bfg }ybcwlce. bfg a`z auobflwbylbflso bns` }eyd`yoeg bgedlflfj y`ne lf tbnlgbwlfj wae sulwe `d nejlsnbwl`f wabw ufgey}lffeg wae

F`ywaeyf Weyylw`y| Eoeyjefc| Yes}`fse&L c`fwlfue i| eqbolflfj wae lfweyyenbwl`fsal} `d }`nlwlcbn bfg alsw`ylcbn

}eys}ecwltes `f wae }bsw bfg cuyyefw wybkecw`y| `d nbz bfg }`nlc| bddecwlfj@waeys& Wals lfcnuges c`fslgeybwl`f `d a`z s`clbn oeo`yles2= ob| abtelfdnuefceg wae yejunbwl`f `d lyyejunby obylwloe byyltbns bfg wae cyebwl`f bfgbgolflswybwl`f `d F`ywaeyf Weyylw`y| Eoeyjefc| Yes}`fse nbzs& Lf wuyf. waesljfldlcbfce bfg yenbwlte }`wefc| `d f`swbnjlb d`y }uinlc }`nlc| u}`f i`wawae sab}lfj `d }yesefw bfg duwuye oljybwl`f c`fwy`ns bfg wae c`uyse `d nejbnyed`yos bddecwlfj Lfgljef`us }e`}nes ls c`fslgeyeg& Aeye. wae y`ne `df`swbnjlb lf i`wa b fejbwlte bfg }`slwlte sefse ls etbnubweg& Wals yednecws bglswlfcwl`f iewzeef wae geslye w` yewuyf w` bf ebynley swbwe `y lgebnl{eg }bsw.bfg wae geslye f`w w` yewuyf iuw w` yec`jfl{e bs}ecws `d wae }bsw bs wae ibslsd`y yefezbn bfg sbwlsdbcwl`f lf wae duwuye&22 Lw ls byjueg wabw s`clbn!j`teyfoefwbn, oeo`yles bi`uw wae eddlcbc| bfg nejbc| `d j`teyfoefw

1Wals boiltbnefce ls e}lw`olseg lf Buswybnlb i| wae c`/eqlswefce d b cbwabywlc o`oefw b

d`yobn b}`n`j| w` Lfgljef`us Buswybnlbfs i| bf Buswybnlbf ]yloe Olflswey zlwa wae

nejbnn| sbfcwl`feg fe`/c`n`flbnlso d wae Lfweytefwl`f lf yeo`we Lfgljef`us

c`oouflwles bfg wae `ddsa`ye }y`cesslfj d i`bw }e`}ne& !Jylddlwa Nbz Yetlez. Cbnn

d`y ]b}eys 9=22 Nbz bfg wae O`gbnlwles d F`swbnjlb,&