Bharath BK

download Bharath BK

of 69

Transcript of Bharath BK

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    1/69

    1

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    A DIAGNOSTIC STUDY ON

    APPLICATION OF COMPUTERISED MARKETING DSS IN

    SELECT CORPORATE ENTERPRISES IN BANGALORE

    A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILMENT OF THEREQUIREMENTS FOR THE AWARD OF MBA DEGREE OF

    BANGALORE UNIVERSITY

    BY

    Mr. BHARATH B. K.Register Number: 06XQCM6016

    Under the guidance and supervisionOf

    Dr. K V PRABHAKARSenior Professor

    M P Birla Institute of ManagementBangalore

    M P BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENTAssociate Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan

    Race Course Road, BANGALORE - 560001

    APRIL 2008

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    2/69

    2

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    DECLARATION

    I, Mr. Bharath B.K. bearing the Reg. Nos.- 06XQCM6016 hereby

    declare that this dissertation entitled - A Diagnostic Study of the

    Application of Computerized Marketing DSS in select

    Corporate Enterprises in Bangalore is the result of my own

    research work carried out under the guidance and supervision of

    Dr. K. V. Prabhakar, Senior Professor, M P Birla Institute of

    Management, Bangalore. I also declare that this dissertation has

    not been submitted earlier to any Institute/organization for the

    award of any degree or diploma.

    Place: Bangalore

    Date: (Mr. Bharath B.K.)

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    3/69

    3

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    PRINCIPALS CERTIFICATE

    This is to certify the project report entitled A Diagnostic Study

    of the Application of Computerized Marketing DSS in select

    Corporate Enterprises in Bangalore has been prepared by

    Mr. Bharath B.K. bearing the Reg. Nos. 06XQCM6016 under

    the guidance ofDr. K. V. Prabhakar, Senior Professor M.P.Birla

    Institute of Management (Associate Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan),

    Bangalore. This has not formed the basis for the award of any

    degree/ diploma or similar title by any University or Institution.

    Place: Bangalore Principal

    Date: (Dr. N. S. Malavalli)

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    4/69

    4

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    GUIDES CERTIFICATE

    This is to certify that the Project report entitled A Diagnostic

    Study of the Application of Computerized Marketing DSS in

    select Corporate Enterprises in Bangalore by BHARATH B.K.

    bearing Reg. No. 06XQCM6016 is a bonafide work done under

    my guidance during the academic year 2007-08 in partial

    fulfillment of the requirements for the award of MBA degree by

    Bangalore University. To the best of my knowledge this report has

    not formed the basis for the award of any other degree/diploma or

    similar title by any University/Institution.

    Place: Bangalore (Dr. K.V. Prabhakar)

    Date:

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    5/69

    5

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

    The Dissertation is truly an enriching experience. This activity involves the

    immense contribution and guidance of many people. Hence I script this page

    to extend my sincere gratitude to all those who have always encouraged and

    assisted me in this endeavour.

    A heartfelt thank you to all my respondents, who spent their valuable time

    replying to my questionnaire.

    Dr. Nagesh. S. Malavalli,Principal, M. P. Birla Institute of Managementfor his constant and dedicated service to brighten our careers.

    Dr. K V Prabhakar, my internal guide and my professor, to whom I am

    deeply grateful for his constant support and guidance.

    I thank Priyashree S. my MENTOR for her constant support and

    encouragement through out my career.

    I thank my friend Vinay K.P. whose encouragement has made me a true

    management professional. My heartfelt gratitude to him.

    To all my faculty, friends and classmates for being a constant source of

    encouragement and support.

    To my family for always having stood by my convictions and encouraging

    me to perform better.

    Thank You.

    BHARATH B K

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    6/69

    6

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    C O N T E N T S Page. No

    EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 03

    Chapters

    PART A (THEORITICAL SETTING) 09

    1. INTRODUCTION 10

    1.1. Background of the study. 11

    1.2. Statement of the problem. 12

    2. REVIEW OF LITERATURE 13

    2.1 Purpose of review. 142.2 Methodology. 14

    2.3 Conclusion. 38

    3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 39

    3.1 Type of Research. 40

    3.2 Sampling Technique. 41

    3.3 Sampling size. 41

    3.4 Instrumentation Techniques. 41

    3.5 Actual collection of data. 42

    3.6 Research Limitations. 42

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    7/69

    7

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    PART B (SURVEY FINDINGS) 43

    4.1. DATA ANALYSIS AND INFERENCES. 44

    PART C (CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS) 54

    5.1. Major conclusions emerging from the study. 55

    5.2. Specific Recommendations 56

    ANNEXURE: 57

    1. Select bibliography including websites used. 58

    2. Questionnaire 59

    3. Directions for further research 63

    TABLES AND CHARTS

    Table 1: Awareness about MDSS tools in marketing 45

    Table 2: Level of Management Where MDSS Is Implemented 47

    Table 3: Necessity of an MDSS that is evolved out of Industry

    Best Practices 49

    Chart 1: Graph showing the level of awareness about MDSS tools 46

    Chart 2: Level of Management where MDSS is implemented 47

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    8/69

    8

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

    EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

    A decision is a reasoned choice among alternatives. Making decisions is part

    of the broader subject of problem solving. The decisions made by managers

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    9/69

    9

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    and knowledge workers have a great impact on corporate success. In

    organizations, with the availability of rich information, making decisions is

    the foundation for the success. Decision Support System is a computer-based

    system that is used by managers for decision-making. It is a set of tools, data,

    models and other resources that managers and analysts use to understand,

    evaluate and solve problems that are useful in making unanticipated semi-

    structured and unstructured decisions. DSS can also be defined as a class of

    computer-based information systems designed to help managers select one

    of the best alternative solutions to a problem. It helps the managers in

    decision processes when decision-making is semi-structured, and improves

    the effectiveness of decision-making by giving interactive information

    support to managers.

    The decision support system is a model based set of procedures for

    processing data and judgments to assist the manager in his/her decision

    making. In real sense a DSS is an approach/methodology for supporting the

    solution for a specific non-structured management problem. It makes use of

    data, provides an easy use interface and can incorporate the decision maker's

    own insights. Additionally a DSS usually makes use of an interactive

    process. It supports all phases of decision making and may include a

    knowledge component. A DSS can be web-based for use by many people at

    several locations. The application of DSS in the marketing domain assumes

    enormous significance because most of the marketing problems are ill

    structured and for which the algorithm are not easily available.

    Research Focus

    1. Utility of Marketing Decision Support System

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    10/69

    10

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    An emerging trend in the realm of marketing has been the increased

    application of decision support system (DSS) technology to aid with

    decision-making. The concept of a MDSS addresses this need for decision-

    making support. Developing a sound and robust marketing strategy has

    never been an easy task. The success or failure of a companys marketing

    effort depends on the interaction of numerous internal and external factors,

    combined with the knowledge and intuition of the decision-makers

    themselves.

    Marketing decision-making requires a comprehensive analysis of

    environment both inside and outside the firm. It requires a wide range of

    strategic information, including hard and soft information, and it requires

    managers to deal with issues that involve a high degree of uncertainty,

    subjectivity, and ambiguity. Marketing also involves managers intuition,

    judgment, and personal vision.

    2. Application of DSS in strategic/tactical/operational marketing

    decisions

    The way in which marketing professional utilize DSS in taking decisions

    depends on whether he is a part of strategic/tactical/operational level of

    management.

    A person at strategic level needs to take unstructured decisions where it is

    not possible to supply most of the decision procedures that are to be

    followed, in advance.

    A person at tactical level focuses on monitoring and controlling operation

    and providing information to the higher levels of the organization. Here, the

    scope of the decision is contained within the business; the function is

    complex; and it has a time limit of a few days to few months. Managerial

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    11/69

    11

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    level decision-making is referred to as semi-structured decision-making

    because solutions and problems are clear and often require judgment and

    expertise for semi-structured decisions. Some procedures can be specified in

    advance but not to the extent where a specific recommendation can be made.

    A person at operational level focuses on structured decision where in the

    procedures to follow for a given situation can be specified in advance.

    At an operational level, the routine day-to-day business process occurs.

    Information systems at this level are designed to automate repetitive

    activities and improve the efficiency of business process. The decisions at

    this level are day-to-day, highly structured and recurring.

    Our research investigation seeks to analyze how marketing professional at

    various level of management utilize DSS in decision making.

    Research Objectives

    To find out the awareness of using MDSS tools in marketing. Level of management where MDSS is implemented To identify the barriers to the application of MDSS to the marketing

    problems

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    12/69

    12

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    To prepare a road map for the application of MDSS to the marketingproblems

    Research technique used

    The data for the study are collected both from the primary source and the

    secondary source. The project employs systematic, objective and

    quantitative Research techniques using a well structured questionnaire,

    which form the primary information collected. The secondary data sources

    are management journals and websites. Using the primary data, separate

    tables have been furnished under specific headings; have been analyzed with

    the help of descriptive analysis and percentage, and interpreted. Detailed

    charts have been developed showing the data obtained from the respondents,

    the data collected from the respondents were organized, processed and

    tabulated to depict the results. The sample size comprises of 30 respondents.

    Major Research Findings

    67% of the Respondents knew about MDSS. Around 27% of the respondents

    felt that MDSS would be used at the Top management level, 60% believed

    that MDSS is useful at Middle management level and only 13% felt it is

    used at the operational or lower management level.

    Recommendations

    There is need to create awareness among the marketing professionals about

    the usage of MDSS for better decision making. A need for training them on

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    13/69

    13

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    such tools holds key to success of any companies marketing strategies. A

    need to monitor the usage of MDSS tools so as to improve it.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    14/69

    14

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    PART 'A'

    THEORETICAL

    SETTING

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    15/69

    15

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    CHAPTER-1

    INTRODUCTION

    1.1. BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY.

    IMPORTANCE OF DSS IN MARKETING

    Developments in computer industry, has made it possible that several tasks

    could be carried out much more easily. Automating the collection and

    analysis of marketing information would result in timely marketing and sales

    decisions and their quality would be largely improved. Later on information

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    16/69

    16

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    technology also facilitated the automation of the sales and marketing support

    in a Management Information System. This would lead to improved

    efficiency of the marketing and sales staff.

    Hardware and software costs continually decrease and the computer

    programs become more and more powerful. Its main barriers such as

    computer power (for PCs) and software compatibility have largely

    disappeared.

    However, does information technology provide the required return on

    investment?

    Which added value has been created by this new technology?

    Realizing the advantages of a DSS is difficult. Substantial productivity

    benefits such as cost reductions can be properly measured. It is evident that

    the use of a DSS also has soft benefits. For example, it is reasonable to

    assume that this marketing tool is able to make more effective and better

    founded decisions, because marketers have information to their disposal that

    is more recent, more comprehensive and more reliable. The importance of

    information in commercial processes is largely recognized.

    Unanswered remains the question to what extent information provided by

    the DSS can improve a marketers performance.

    1.2. STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM.

    Are Computerized Decision Support Systems helping

    marketers in their decision-making apparatus?

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    17/69

    17

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    18/69

    18

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    CHAPTER-2REVIEW

    OF

    LITERATURE.

    2.1 PURPOSE OF REVIEW.

    The purpose of literature review is to explore the historical and current

    scenarios in Computerized Decision Support Systems. The literature survey

    is done to understand what is a DSS? To understand the different levels of

    decision making in an organization. To understand the conceptual

    framework of a Decision Support System, understand the various decision

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    19/69

    19

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    models and the architecture of Decision Support Systems. Over and above,

    the purpose of the literature review is to understand in totality the foundation

    of the research problem.

    2.2 METHODOLOGY.

    The Book DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM in the 21st

    Century by George

    M. Marakas has been referred to understand the above mentioned concepts

    and is presented below.

    2.2.1 INTRODUCTION

    A decision is a reasoned choice among alternatives. Making decisions is part

    of the broader subject of problem solving. The decisions made by managers

    and knowledge workers have a great impact on corporate success. In

    organizations, with the availability of rich information, making decisions is

    the foundation for the success. Decision Support System is a computer-based

    system that is used by managers for decision-making. It is a set of tools, data,

    models and other resources that managers and analysts use to understand,

    evaluate and solve problems that are useful in making unanticipated semi-

    structured and unstructured decisions. DSS can also be defined as a class of

    computer-based information systems designed to help managers select one

    of the best alternative solutions to a problem. It helps the managers in

    decision processes when decision-making is semi-structured, and improves

    the effectiveness of decision-making by giving interactive information

    support to managers.

    A majority of DSS research is focused on the application of new technology

    to managerial tasks at the operational and tactical levels. Though DSS is

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    20/69

    20

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    used to solve semi-structured problems at all levels of an organization,

    resources are deployed or structured at any given moment. DSS provides

    support to the selection process and allows managers who are directly

    responsible for the outcome to make the final selection.

    DSS helps in making the organization more effective by giving it a

    competitive advantage. In today's environment, managers will be

    empowered to make their own decisions based on the organized feedback

    from peers, customers or from top management and hence knowledge-based

    organizations depend heavily on the computer-based DSS. It clearly offers

    management a powerful tool in meeting demands of managerial work. They

    are also known as business intelligence systems or analytics.

    DSS helps human decision-making performance and problem solving by

    enabling the users to examine alternative solutions using the `what if '

    analysis. This analysis helps to make changes to the data associated with a

    problem and observe how these changes influence the results.

    2.2.2 DECISION - MAKING LEVELS OF AN ORGANIZATION

    Each level of an organization has different responsibilities and therefore

    needs different information.

    Structured Decisions

    These decisions involve situations where proper structuring of the procedure

    to be followed when a decision is needed can be specified in advance. At an

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    21/69

    21

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    operational level, the routine day-to-day business process occurs.

    Information systems at this level are designed to automate repetitive

    activities and improve the efficiency of business process. The decisions at

    this level are day-to-day, highly structured and recurring. Structured decision

    are those in which the procedures to follow for a given situation can be

    specified in advance.

    Semi-structured Decisions

    Some decisions can be pre-specified but they are not bad for a definite

    recommended action. At the managerial level of the organization, the

    functional managers focus on monitoring and controlling operation actuaries

    and providing information to the higher levels of the organization. Here, the

    scope of the decision is contained within the business; the function is

    complex; and it has a time limit of a few days to few months. Managerial

    level decision-making is referred to as semi-structured decision-making

    because solutions and problems are clear and often require judgment and

    expertise for semi-structured decisions. Some procedures can be specified in

    advance but not to the extent where a specific recommendation can be made.

    Unstructured Decisions

    These decisions involve situations where it is not possible to supply most of

    the decision procedures that are to be followed, in advance. At the executive

    level of the organization, managers focus on long term strategic issues

    facing the organization. Managers at this level are the CEO, President, Vice-

    president and the Board of Directors. This level deals with complex

    problems with broad and long-term requirements of the organization. The

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    22/69

    22

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    decisions here are unstructured because the problems are complex and non-

    routine. For unstructured decisions, few or no procedure can be specified in

    advance.

    A highly structured decision includes easily determined objectives that are

    not subject to conflict, are clearly defined, or those selecting alternative

    courses of action and ascertainable outcomes. In a highly unstructured

    decision, the objectives of the situation often conflict, the alternatives

    available to the decision-maker are difficult to implement and the effect of a

    particular course of action or selection of an alternative carries with it a high

    degree of uncertainty.

    The decisions at three levels of organization are as follows:

    Decision-makers at the strategic level require the more summarized ad hoc

    unscheduled reports, forecast and internal intelligence to support their

    unstructured planning. The strategic decision is one which will affect the

    entire organization for a long period of time. They affect organizational

    objectives and policies. Data are generally in the unstructured form. It is

    necessary for a firm to develop successful decision strategies to confront in

    order to survive and succeed. In the long run, these strategies force the shape

    and the structure of competition in the industry, in addition to cost leadership,

    differentiation, innovation growth and alliance. There are many other

    competitive strategies that are implemented with information systems. It

    attempts to use the information system in customer and supplier relation

    systems. In a customer and supplier relationship, the focus is on significantly

    improving the quality of service to customer and suppliers in a firms

    actuaries. A major emphasis on Strategic Information System (SIS) has been

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    23/69

    23

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    to find ways to build switching costs into the relationships between a firm

    and its customers or suppliers.

    The primary objective of strategic managers is to maximize the value

    delivered to all the enterprise's stakeholders. This objective is accomplished

    by establishing and maintaining a unifying vision and strategic direction.

    The conflicting objectives of asset managers and value chain managers must

    be reconciled. Competitive advantage must be identified and exploited for

    the enterprise to win and grow (Reid et al., 1996). To support the

    competitive position of the enterprise, the following strategic management

    processes are operated (Reid et al., 1996):

    1. Provide situational awareness-both internal and external2. Facilitate decision-making3. Develop and deploy plans-at both strategic and operational

    performance levels

    4. Manage enterprise performance5. Establish the required performance management infrastructure. This

    activity is generally performed only for a particular enterprise.

    6. Monitor performance7. Communicate performance8. Evaluate performance9. Improve performance

    Two important factors determine strategic planning decisions: Time and

    Uncertainty. This has led to recent investigation of Strategic Planning

    models that enable the decision-maker to adopt strategic policies which

    hedge against uncertainty, and respond to events as they unfold in time.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    24/69

    24

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Decision-makers at the operational level require specified internal reports

    with detailed current and historical data comparisons. A tactical decision

    will affect the manner in which a part of organization does business for a

    limited period of time in the future. These decisions are made by middle

    managers to determine how an entire category of future decisions will be

    taken. An operational decision is one that affects a particular activity

    currently taking place in the organization. These decisions relate to activities

    whose tasks, goals, and resources have already been defined by strategic and

    tactical decisions.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    25/69

    25

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    2.2.3 CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK OF DECISION SUPPORT

    SYSTEM

    A decision support system is a computer based procedure that allows a

    manager to directly interact with data using various methods of analysis to

    integrate, and analyze and interpret information; The heart and soul of DSS

    is datadifferent types of data from a wide variety of sources. Decision

    Support Systems couple the intellectual resources of individuals with the

    capabilities of the computer to improve the quality of decisions. Typically, a

    DSS contains data describing the market, consumers competitors, economic

    and social trends and the organization performance. The DSS has methods

    for analyzing data. These methods range from simple procedure such as

    computing ratios to drawing graphs to sophisticated statistical techniques

    and mathematical models. By combining personal computers and user-

    friendly software, the DSS allows managers to independently retrieve data,examining the relationships, and even create unique reports to meet their

    specific needs. The DSS clearly offers management a powerful tool and is

    rapidly becoming an integral component of managerial work. The speed

    with which todays information becomes yesterdays news continues to

    increase at a staggering rate. The leveraging of technology that will allow

    the manager to be effective in such a high speed environment is what

    decision support all about. DSS is expected to extend the decision makers

    capacity of processing the mountain of information involved in making a

    decision.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    26/69

    26

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    The following chart describes the simple mechanism of DSS:

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    27/69

    27

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Common DSS Characteristics

    1. Employed in semi structured or unstructured decision context

    2. Intended to support decision makers

    3. Supports all phases of the decision-making process

    4. Focuses on the effectiveness of the decision making process

    5. Utilizes underlying data and models

    6. Facilitates learning on the part of the decision maker

    7. Provides support for all levels of management from top executives to line

    managers

    8. Can support for multiple or interdependent decisions

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    28/69

    28

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    ADVANTAGES OF DSS USAGE

    Various authors have investigated the assumed benefits of Decision Support

    Systems.

    1. Administrative advantages (time and labor savings),

    2. More efficient use of management time,

    3. Better decision making, handling more complex problems,

    4. Better judgment of problems, superior trust in decisionmaking,

    5. Better data usage (recency, accuracy, access and availability),

    6. Better planning and control,

    7. Possibility to research more alternatives,

    8. Communication advantage.

    Thus DSS is a truly dynamic system that requires knowledge beyond that of

    the Typical Information System professional. The decision makers of

    tomorrow will rely on this technology to support their daily activities and to

    assist them in managing the ever-growing knowledge base necessary to

    make informed and effective decisions.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    29/69

    29

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    2.2.4 DECISION MODELS

    Decision models can be classified into a number of ways. One common

    high-level classification divides the models in terms of their explicit

    inclusion of time as an element. Models that do not explicitly acknowledge

    time are called static models and those that do are referred to as dynamic

    models. Another widespread method of classification is by technique or

    logical focus.

    Abstract Model Types:An abstract model focuses on the mathematical precision with which various

    outcomes can be predicted. Theoretically, this type of model can determine

    which alternative should result in the most favorable outcome. Based on this

    prediction, a decision-maker then develops a strategy for implementing the

    proposed alternative and thus solves the problem.

    Deterministic Models:In the deterministic model, no variable can take more than one value at any

    given time. The same output value will always result from any given set of

    input variables. Most of the traditional models of the normative economic

    theory are deterministic as are many of the common models used in financial

    analysis. These model types are particularly useful when a problem structure

    contains a large number of elements and complex relationships. Common

    deterministic models include linear programming, nonlinear programming,

    and differential equations.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    30/69

    30

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Stochastic Models:In a stochastic model, at least one of the variables is uncertain and must be

    described by some probability function. These model types are often referred

    to as probabilistic models because they explicitly incorporate uncertainty

    into their structure. When constructing a stochastic model, the decision-

    maker distributes the input value of one or more variables around some

    mean value and the output variables take the form of a frequency

    distribution rather than a discrete set of value.

    Domain-specific Models:The advances in the science disciplines prompt the need for highly specific

    types of decision-making techniques and contexts. In these cases, each

    discipline develops its own set of abstract mathematical modeling techniques

    to serve its needs. Models of supply and demand are unique to the toolbox of

    economists. Other well-known domains such as operations research,

    sociology, medicine and meteorology rely on their own unique abstract

    modeling techniques. In the design of DSS for a specific problem domain,

    the designer must be aware of any domain specific models available for

    inclusion in the model base.

    Conceptual ModelsConceptual models can be identified as analogies to the problem in context.

    Implicit in this perspective is the notion that even though all problems are

    unique, no problem is completely new. Experience from a past problem can

    be used to assist in forecasting events and outcomes in the new context.

    Using this method, decision-makers can recall and combine a variety of past

    experiences and contexts to create an accurate conceptual model of the

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    31/69

    31

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    current situation and to assign probabilities to those event components that

    remain uncertain.

    Tools and Technologies of DSS

    Decision Support System includes many key terms the meaning of which

    helps us to get a good result.

    Extraction, Transformation, and Loading (ETL)

    During the ETL (Extraction, Transformation, and Loading) process, the

    desired data is identified and extracted from many different sources,

    including database systems and applications. Depending on the source

    system's capabilities (e.g., operating system resources), some

    transformations may take place during this extraction process. After

    extracting data, it has to be physically transported to the target system or an

    intermediate system for further processing. Depending on the chosen way of

    transportation, some transformations can be done during this process, too.

    For example, an Structured Query Language (SQL) statement, which

    directly accesses a remote target through a gateway, can concatenate two

    columns as part of the SELECT statement; this leads the manager to take a

    particular decision.

    Online Analytical Processing (OLAP)

    Online Analytical Processing is a significant improvement of the model-

    based management, which manipulates data from a variety of sources that

    has been stored in a static data warehouse. The software can cause various

    views and representations of the data and this helps in making the context

    explicit. OLAP can pull the data, create pictures and make the user see the

    model running. It creates various models and helps in finding out the best. It

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    32/69

    32

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    allows the users to analyze information that has been summarized into

    multidimensional views and hierarchies.

    Relational Online Analytical Processing (ROLAP)

    When we need to handle large data and try to leverage functionalities

    inherent in the relational database, we need Relational Online Analytical

    Processing. This methodology relies on manipulating the data stored in the

    relational database to give the appearance of the traditional OLAP's slicing

    and dicing functionality. In essence, each action of slicing and dicing is

    equivalent to adding a `WHERE' clause in the SQL statement.

    Multidimensional Online Analytical Processing (MOLAP)

    This is the more traditional way of OLAP analysis. In MOLAP, data is

    stored in a multidimensional cube. It effects excellent performance and can

    perform complex calculations. In a Management Decision Support system,

    managers need to look into the summary rather than the detail report. Hybrid

    Online Analytical Processing (HOLAP) technologies attempt to combine the

    advantages of MOLAP and ROLAP. For summary-type information,

    HOLAP leverages cube technology for faster performance. When detail

    information is needed, HOLAP can "drill through" from the cube into the

    underlying relational data. Web based DSS deliver decision support

    information or decision support tools to a manager or business analyst using

    a "thin-client" Web browser like Netscape Navigator or Internet Explorer

    that is accessing the global Internet or a corporate intranet. Web-based DSS

    can be communications-driven, data-driven, document-driven, knowledge-

    driven, model-driven or hybrid. Web technologies can be used to implement

    any category or type of DSS. Web-based means the entire application is

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    33/69

    33

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    implemented using Web technologies; Web-enabled means key parts of an

    application like a database remain on a legacy system, but the application

    can be accessed from a Web-based component and displayed in a browser.

    Using a web infrastructure for building DSS improves the rapid

    dissemination of the best practices analysis and decision-making framework

    and it should promote more consistent decision-making on repetitive

    decision tasks across a geographically distributed organization.

    Data Warehouse

    Data Warehouse is a collection of integrated, subject oriented databases

    designed to support DSS function, where each unit of data is non-volatile

    and relevant. Data Warehouse is a batch updated and structured for rapid

    online queries and management solutions. So it has become an important

    component in DSS. DW contains a large amount of data that are subject-

    oriented, integrated, and time-variant as well as a huge stable collection of

    data that supports the decision-making process of managers.

    Dialogue Management

    This refers to the hardware and software components that create the user

    interface for the DSS. Software support for dialogue is in terms of packages

    that can be accessed via high-end languages and is used to construct user

    interface and data definition language, which describes the dialogue

    component of DSS architecture. It also focuses on command language and

    menu dialogues that create a restrictive context for building DSS.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    34/69

    34

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Database Management

    DBM (Database Management System) is a key component of DSS because

    it reduces the cost of building and using DSS, by increasing data control and

    sharing and reducing data redundancy. There are five different data models

    for the database component of DSS: Record, relational, hierarchical,

    network and rule model. The record of flat file model is common in DSS

    that uses time series data. DSS database ware is limited in scope and

    definitely not integrated because of the problems with data processing

    efficiency and storage overload that degrade the performance.

    Model Base Management

    The modeling component gives decision-makers the ability to analyze the

    problem and moves a Management Information System (MIS) to full DSS.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    35/69

    35

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    2.2.5 DECISION SUPPORT SYSTEM ARCHITECTURE

    DSS Architecture

    DSS architecture refers to the mechanism and structure for the integration of

    the dialogue, database and model management components of a DSS. There

    are four types of architectures for building and integrating the DSS software

    system: The DSS Network, with multiple dialogue, modeling and database

    components that can communicate with each other through a component

    interface; the DSS Bridge, which provides a standard interface with local

    dialogue and modeling components that link to remote modeling and

    database components; the DSS Sandwich, which integrates multiplemodeling components by using single dialogue and database components;

    and the DSS Tower, where data extraction is used to integrate diverse

    database components and other components are similar to the network

    architecture.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    36/69

    36

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Components of DSS

    The components of DSS include Management Decision Support System,

    Management Information System, Executive Information System, File

    Drawer System and Knowledge Management.

    DSS is a competitive knowledge-rich world in which managers take

    decisions about what to do with their organizations' resources. Large number

    of decisions are made every day and range from those that are simple to

    those that are very complex. Every one of these decisions involves the use of

    knowledge of varying kinds and amounts, and many of them can benefit

    from (or even require) the use of a component known as Knowledge

    Management. Knowledge management is the basis of any decision-making

    process. First, one should know which information should be put where and

    how to manage them. Preparing a databank from information is a part of

    knowledge management. DSS basically starts from creating a correct and

    proper database. So, the first component for any DSS is knowledge

    management. From databases, executives draw the information they need in

    a refined way. The process of raw data converting to useful information for

    the executives is known as EIS (Executive Information Systems). EIS is

    there to support the senior management. It helps organizations to enhance

    their knowledge processing and their ability to learn and adapt. EIS enables

    the use of interactive information exchanges by access to electronic

    networks. It can provide quantitative diagnostics to monitor the progress of

    decisions. In terms of organizational impact, EIS can improve the

    managerial decision-making process because it naturally will support, or

    create pressure for, a formal planning system, for it is known that an

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    37/69

    37

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    advantage of formal planning is that it fosters lateral communication, formal

    reporting, and rationality.

    When information passes from executives to the managers, it is already a

    refined one. But to make decisions more simple and result-oriented, middle

    level managers tune them to fine information. This process is called as MIS

    (Management Information System). After going to MIS, top level managers

    use the DSS components and take the final decision, which is known as

    management decision support system.

    With the tools, technology, models and components of DSS, today it is

    essential to capture the trend of outsourcing.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    38/69

    38

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    2.2.6 GAINING COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE WITH

    COMPUTERIZED DECISION SUPPORT

    Many companies have isolated decision support capabilities that are hard to

    use or hard to access. For example, a data mart may have been built for

    accessing customer data, a project management system may exist for

    tracking large-scale projects, or Excel analyses may be routinely used in a

    specific business decision process. In general, managers are experiencing

    information overload and are having difficulty finding the right information

    when it is needed. Potentially, innovative Decision Support Systems can

    yield competitive advantage for an organization or at least maintain an

    organizations competitive position.

    Evidence indicates managers can now use sophisticated data-driven and

    document-driven DSSs to obtain information that was buried for many years

    in filing cabinets or archived on computer storage systems. Model-driven

    DSSs can reduce waste in production operations and improve inventory

    management. Knowledge-driven DSSs can help managers evaluate

    employees or help technical staff diagnose problems. Communications-

    driven DSSs can support teams working all over the world. Inter-

    organizational DSSs can support a companys suppliers and customers.

    Real-time decision support systems are now possible for tactical decision

    support.

    A decision support system creates a competitive advantage if three criteria

    are met. First, once the DSS is implemented, it must be used and it must

    become a major or significant strength or capability of the organization.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    39/69

    39

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Second, the DSS must be unique and proprietary to the organization. Third,

    the advantage provided by the DSS must be sustainable until an adequate

    payback is received, usually at least three years. Managers who are

    searching for strategic investments in information technology need to keep

    these three criteria in mind. Just because a vendor says a product will create

    a competitive advantage doesnt make the claim true. A competitive

    advantage means an organization does something important much better

    than its competitors.

    The widespread use of computer technology has changed the way companies

    do business. Information technology has altered relationships between

    companies and their suppliers, customers and rivals. Porter and Millar

    (1985) discuss two specific ways that information technology can affect

    competition: by altering industry structures and by supporting cost and/or

    differentiation strategies. A common approach used to identify opportunities

    to change the structure and profitability of an industry is to examine five

    competitive forces. Michael Porter (1979) argued that the power of buyers,

    the power of suppliers, the threat of new entrants, the threat of substitute

    products and the rivalry among existing competitors determines the

    profitability of an industry. How a company uses information technology

    can affect each of the five competitive forces and can create the need and

    opportunity for change. For example, information technology has altered the

    bargaining relationships between companies and their suppliers, channels

    and buyers. Today it is easy for information systems to cross company

    boundaries. These inter-organizational systems have become common and,

    in some instances, they have changed the boundaries of the participating

    industries. Decision support systems can reduce the power of buyers and

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    40/69

    40

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    suppliers. Decision support systems can erect new barriers that reduce the

    threat of entrants. Decision support systems can help differentiate products

    and services and reduce the threat from substitutes. Also, decision support

    systems can help managers reduce the cost of rivalry actions and, in some

    cases, reduce the need for competitive actions and reactions.

    Decision support systems can potentially help a firm create a cost advantage.

    Decision support systems can provide many benefits including improving

    personal efficiency and reducing staff needs, expediting problem solving and

    increasing organizational control. Managers who want to create a cost

    advantage should search for situations where decision processes seem slow

    or tedious and where problems reoccur or solutions are delayed or

    unsatisfactory. In some cases, DSSs can reduce costs where decision makers

    have high turnover and training is slow and cumbersome, and in situations

    where activities, departments and projects are poorly controlled.

    Also, DSSs can create a major cost advantage by increasing efficiency or

    eliminating value chain activities. For example, a bank or mortgage loan

    firm may reduce costs by using a new DSS to consolidate the number of

    steps and minimize the number of staff hours needed to approve loans.

    Technology breakthroughs can sometimes continue to lower process costs,

    and rivals who imitate an innovative DSS may nullify or remove any

    advantage.

    Decision support systems can potentially create a differentiation advantage.

    Providing a DSS to customers can differentiate a product and possibly

    provide a new service. Differentiation increases profitability when the price

    premium charged is greater than any added costs associated with achieving

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    41/69

    41

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    the differentiation. Successful differentiation means a firm can charge a

    premium price, and/or sell more units, and/or increase buyer loyalty for

    service or repeat purchases. In some situations, competitors can rapidly

    imitate the differentiation, and then all competitors incur increased costs for

    implementing the DSS.

    Finally, decision support systems can be used to help a company better focus

    on a specific customer segment and hence gain an advantage in meeting that

    segments needs. Management information systems and decision support

    systems can help track customers, and DSSs can make it easier to serve a

    specialized customer group with special services. Some customers wont pay

    a premium for targeted service, and larger competitors also target specialized

    niches using their own DSSs.

    It is important to recognize that some firms have no competitive advantage.

    Firms can achieve a competitive advantage by making strategic changes, and

    firms can lose a competitive advantage when competitors make strategic

    changes. Implementing computerized decision support does not necessarily

    create a competitive advantage. In fact, most decision support does not have

    such a broad enterprise-wide impact.

    Decision support systems can be important and useful and very necessary,

    and yet not provide a competitive advantage. Many consulting firms and

    vendors focus on gaining competitive advantage from a data warehouse or abusiness intelligence system, and that can happen. Many DSS projects do

    not, however, deliver such results and the projects probably were not

    intended to create competitive advantage.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    42/69

    42

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    A study identified a number of companies that had gained an advantage

    from information systems. Some of those systems were decision support

    systems, but most were transaction processing systems. The following DSS

    examples are from their paper: Air Products, a vehicle scheduling system;

    Cigna, a risk assessment system; IBM, a marketing management system;

    Owens-Corning, a materials selection system; and Procter & Gamble, a

    customer response system. Most companies wisely do not provide many

    details on their success with computerized decision support. Competitive

    responses and technology have had a negative impact on how some of the

    aforementioned systems are perceived today.

    If a company is trying to develop a decision support system that provides a

    competitive advantage, managers and analysts should ask how the proposed

    DSS affects company costs, customer and supplier relations, and managerial

    effectiveness. Managers should also attempt to assess how the proposed

    strategic system will impact the structure of the industry and the behavior of

    competitors. Finally, companies must continuously improve their

    information and decision support technology to gain and maintain any

    competitive advantage.

    Harbridge House (a Boston Firm) has conducted a survey and ranked clear-

    cut decisions needed as the most important of 10 management practices. Asthe trends are changing, it is very difficult to rely upon trial and error

    approach to management; in case of decision is unstructured/ill-

    structured/semi-structured decision making situations. Managers must learn

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    43/69

    43

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    sophisticated new tools and techniques. Using these technological tools, its

    extremely rewarding in making effective decision

    2.3 CONCLUSION.

    Thus from the literature survey conducted, a good understanding of

    DSS model, advantages of DSS and Competitive Advantage of using

    have been understood.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    44/69

    44

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    CHAPTER-3RESEARCH

    METHODOLOGY

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    45/69

    45

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    3.1 TYPE OF RESEARCH.

    Our research investigation adopted a systematic, objective and quantitative

    research techniques using a well-structured questionnaire. The questionnaire

    is designed keeping in mind the various features offered by DSS. The

    research investigation is restricted to the various marketing managers and

    business development mangers in the Bangalore. The primary data was

    collected using a well structured questionnaire. The questionnaire was meant

    to know the knowledge of DSS of the managers. The level at which they had

    been exposed to the Decision Support System.

    There are three alternative types of evaluation procedures for DSS

    performance: subjective judgment, expert observation and objective

    measurement.

    A subjective judgment requests from users to assess their experiences.

    In most cases this means that a user has to fill out a questionnaire.

    Expert observation also uses a subjective judgment, however in this case of

    non-participating observers and experts in the field of DSS to judge DSS

    users.

    Objective measurement is usually related to empirical experiments and

    comparison.

    Objective, empirical measurement is considered as the most reliable and

    consequently most preferred way to acquire data. Unfortunately, this is a

    very expensive method and in practice it is often selected for expert

    observation and subjective judgment. In representing the results of the

    investigations to DSS performance, in each case we will report the method

    used. This will enable the reader to estimate such a method at its true value.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    46/69

    46

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    3.2 SAMPLING TECHNIQUE

    POPULATION: The information is generated from the marketers whose

    company implements DSS in various operations in Bangalore.

    SAMPLING UNIT: Marketers are selected from the companies in

    Bangalore.

    SAMPLING METHOD: The selection of Marketers is non-probability

    (convenience).

    3.3 SAMPLE SIZE:

    30 Marketers from various companies in Bangalore were chosen and

    interviewed. The number of corporate entities choosen for this purpose is

    12 ( twelve). These include Banks, FMCG companies, Industrial

    Marketing Companies and IT Companies.

    3.4 INSTRUMENTATION TECHNIQUES.

    QUESTIONNAIRE: The research instrument used here is a questionnaire,

    which helped us to generate the database adequately. The questionnaire has

    close-ended questions, as the study is very specific.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    47/69

    47

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    3.5 ACTUAL COLLECTION OF DATA.

    A. SECONDARY DATA:

    Secondary data is gathered from numerous sources. A tedious and time-

    consuming library research gave desired information. The secondary data is

    collected from the internal research, such as journals and internet.

    B. PRIMARY DATA:

    Survey research: Questionnaire has been used to gather data. Survey has

    been designed to capture wide variety of information. This research has

    helped to identify the satisfaction levels of the Marketers in using DSS tools.

    It has also helped to learn about the awareness and expectations of the

    marketers and also answered an important question

    Do you think MDSS tools can help you in taking better decisions which

    would hence increase the productivity of the company?

    3.6 RESEARCH LIMITATIONS:

    Time and resource constraints Effective decision making is dependent on several other factors like

    environmental factors which we have not considered due to lack of

    time and resources

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    48/69

    48

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    PART BSURVEY FINDINGS

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    49/69

    49

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    DATA ANALYSIS

    AND

    INFERENCES

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    50/69

    50

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    RESEARCH OBJECTIVE 1:

    To find out the awareness of using MDSS tools in marketing

    Table 1: AWARENESS ABOUT MDSS TOOLS IN MARKETING

    Sl. Nos. Level of Awareness Respondents Percentage(%)

    1 YES 29 67

    2 NO 11 33

    TOTAL 30 100

    Source: Field Investigation

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    51/69

    51

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Chart 1:

    CHART SHOWING THE LEVEL OF AWARENESS

    ABOUT MDSS TOOLS

    AWARENESS LEVEL OF MDSS TOOLS

    YES

    67%

    NO

    33%

    YES

    NO

    Inference: This table is designed to identify the awareness of

    MDSS tools in marketing domain.

    a) 67% of the respondents are aware of the MDSS tools.

    b) 33% of the respondents are unaware of the MDSS tools.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    52/69

    52

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    RESEARCH OBJECTIVE 2:

    TABLE 2:

    LEVEL OF MANAGEMENT WHERE MDSS IS IMPLEMENTED

    SL.NO. LEVEL OF MGMT RESPONDENTS

    PERCENTAGE

    (%)

    1 STRATEGIC 8 26.67

    2 TACTICAL 18 60

    3 OPERATIONAL 4 13.33

    TOTAL 30 100.00

    Source: Field Investigation

    CHART 2:

    LEVEL OF MANAGEMENT WHERE MDSS IS IMPLEMENTED

    8

    26.67

    18

    60

    4

    13.33

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    LEVEL OF MANAGEMENT WHERE MDSS IS IMPLEMENTED

    RESPONDENTS 8 18 4

    PERCENTAGE (%) 26.67 60 13.33

    STRATEGIC TACTICAL OPERATIONAL

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    53/69

    53

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Inference:

    This table is designed to identify various levels of management where

    MDSS are implemented.

    a) 26.67% of respondents use MDSS tools in strategic level

    b) 60% of respondents use MDSS tools in tactical level

    c) 13.33% of respondents use MDSS tools in operational level.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    54/69

    54

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    TABLE 3

    NECESSITY OF AN MDSS THAT IS EVOLVED OUT OF

    INDUSTRY BEST PRACTICES

    SL NO. OPTION RESPONDENTS

    PERCENTAGE

    (%)

    1 YES 18 60

    2 NO 12 40

    TOTAL 30 100

    Source: Field Investigation

    Inference:

    The above table identifies the need for MDSS to be evolved out of the

    industry best practices

    a) 60% of the respondents felt that it would be better if the MDSS is

    evolved out Industry Best Practices.

    b) However 40% of the respondents felt there was no need for such

    thought.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    55/69

    55

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    RESEARCH OBJECTIVE 3:

    To identify whether MDSS helps the marketers in making better

    decisions this would increase the productivity of the company.

    Null Hypothesis:

    H0: DSS cannot find total solutions to the marketing problems

    Alternate Hypothesis:

    H1: DSS can find total solutions to the marketing problems

    Test Statistics used here is Z-test

    Formula

    Z = | P Ps |

    _________

    (P*Q)/N

    P -> Assumed population mean

    Ps -> sample population

    Q = 1-P

    N -> Total number of samples

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    56/69

    56

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    Do you think MDSS tools can help you in taking better

    decisions which would increase the productivity of the

    company?

    Number of Respondents who said YES: 19 (nineteen only)

    Number of respondents who said NO: 11 (eleven only)

    Assumption: Population Mean = .5

    Calculations:

    N = 30

    Ps Sample population = 19 / 30 = .634

    P = .5

    Q = 1-.5 = .5

    Test statistics = Z = | P Ps |

    ________

    (P*Q)/N

    Z = | .5 - .634 |

    ________ = .134/.091 = 1.472

    (.5*.5)/30

    Tabulated value for 95% level of significance is 1.96

    Calculated value = 1.472

    Cal value < tabulated value,

    Hence we reject Ho

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    57/69

    57

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    INFERENCE:

    Since calculated value is less than tabulated value we reject our null

    hypothesis and accept the alternate hypothesis.

    Hence we conclude there is significant difference in the productivity of

    the company after implementing MDSS. Hence we can conclude that

    DSS can find total solutions to the marketing problems.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    58/69

    58

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    PART C

    CONCLUSIONS

    ANDRECOMMENDATIONS

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    59/69

    59

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    CHAPTER 5

    CONCLUSIONS

    AND

    RECOMMENDATIONS

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    60/69

    60

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    5.1. MAJOR CONCLUSIONS EMERGING FROM THE STUDY

    1. Most of the respondents have an average awareness about the MDSStools.

    2. It is found that implementation of DSS system in marketing domainhelps in taking better decisions for the marketers which would lead to

    increase in productivity of the company.

    3. On an average MDSS tools have been extensively used in operationallevel.

    4. Most of the respondents have found DSS tools as user-friendly.

    The type of marketing problem can be subdivided into strategic, technical

    and operational problems. Action strategy of the company in terms of user

    friendliness, flexibility has a pronounced effect on the success of DSS.

    The use of a DSS by a marketer reduces his time to come to a decision. As

    far as the effectiveness of DSS usage by marketers is concerned DSS usage

    implies that various alternatives are taken into account and evaluated and,

    consequently, a better decision is made. We can also conclude that DSS is

    required mostly in operational level and helps the marketers in taking better

    marketing decision. Apart from the characteristics User friendliness,

    Marketers rate the DSS tools on their flexibility, reliability, and response

    time and data storage capacity.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    61/69

    61

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    5.2. SPECIFIC RECOMMENDATIONS

    1. Create awareness among the Marketers about the DSS tools whichwould help them in making better decisions.

    2. Give training in the DSS tools which would make it more userfriendly and hence would reduce time and increase speed.

    3. Monitor the working of the tools performance and effectivenesswhich would help in improving the performance.

    Implementation of an information system does not automatically lead to an

    increase of the performance of the decision-maker. The performance

    depends on a number of factors:

    1. The marketing decision-maker or the characteristics of the Individual

    2. The DSS

    3. The type of marketing problem

    4. The environment

    5. Organizational characteristics

    6. The action strategies of the enterprise.

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    62/69

    62

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    ANNEXURE

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    63/69

    63

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    1. SELECT BIBLIOGRAPHY

    (a) Books

    1. Decision Support Systems in the 21st

    Century by George M. Marakas,

    Prentice-Hall of India Publication, 2nd

    Edition, 2003.

    2. MDSS Principles, Tools and Implementation, Gary L Lilien; Arvind

    Rangaswamy; Gerrit H Van Bruggen; Katrin Starke, Information Systems

    Research; Sep 2004

    3. Database Systems Design, Implementation & Management by Bob

    Coronel, Thomas Course Technology publications, 2006

    4. Decision Support Systems & Intelligence Systems by Efrain Turban and

    Jay E Aronson, PHI Publications, 2007

    5. Data Analysis, Data Modeling & Classification, by Modell Martin,

    McGraw Hill Publications 2000

    (b) Websites

    1. www.mdssworld.com/2. www.mdss.com3. www.mdss.net4. www.rbac.com/methods/mdss.htm

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    64/69

    64

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    2. QUESTIONNAIRE

    Sir/Madam,

    I, Mr.Bharath B K, am conducting research on Computerized Marketing Decision

    System. The research survey is a sequel to project report/dissertation required in partial fulfillment of the Degree of Master of Business Administration. In this

    connection, I need some information from you. Below is the questionnaire on the

    various facets of Computerized Marketing Decision System. Kindly give your

    valuable responses to the questions thereon. I humbly assure you that your responses

    will be kept confidential and shall only be used for academic purpose.

    Mr.Bharath B K

    1) Are you aware of the concept of MDSS (Marketing decision support

    system) Tools used in the marketing?

    a) Yes

    b) No

    2) Does your company utilize technical tools for decision making?

    a) Yes

    b) No

    3) Please choose the Level of Management where MDSS s implemented:

    a) Top Level Manager/Strategic Level

    b) Middle Level Manager/Tactical Level

    c) Low Level Manager/Operational Level

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    65/69

    65

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    4) Do you think MDSS tools can help you in taking better decisions which

    would enhance the productivity of the company?

    a) Yes

    b) No

    If no, Please state the reasons:

    5) Does DSS match the Human Intuitive Nature and Analytical Ability in

    Decision Making?

    a) Yes

    b) No

    6) Please mention the decision support tools you use in marketing?

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    66/69

    66

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    7) How do you take Decisions?

    a) Based on Gut Feel (Random Decision Making)

    b) Intuitive Decision making (Predictive Decision Making)

    c) Based on computer generated results/ reports

    d) Mix of the above mentioned options

    8) Do you find the necessity of an MDSS that is evolved out of Industry best

    Practices?

    a) Yes

    b) No

    9) How important are the following factors in determining the efficiency of

    an MDSS?

    Rate on a scale of 1-5

    LOW HIGH

    1 2 3 4 5

    a) User friendliness

    1 2 3 4 5

    b) Flexibility

    1 2 3 4 5

    c) Response Time

    1 2 3 4 5

    d) Data storage capacity

    1 2 3 4 5

    e) Reliability

    1 2 3 4 5

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    67/69

    67

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    10) On a scale of ten, rate these MDSS TOOL expectations/perceptions:

    1. Increase speed.2. Increases marketers productivity.3. Increases control of sales process.4. Reduces marketing costs.5. Increases customer satisfaction.6. Better Documentation.

    11) What are the limitations of MDSS tools? Check the appropriate one.

    1. Expensive2. Making a perfect tool mix3. Learning Curve4. Lack of awareness5. Others6. (please mention).

    ....

    12. If your company is already using MDSS, Please state your experiences

    with the usage of MDSS:

    .

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    68/69

    68

    ________________________________________________________________________

    M.P.BIRLA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT

    THANK YOU FOR SPARING YOUR VALUABLE

    TIME IN GIVING THE RESPONSES. I SHALLGREATLY APPRECIATE YOUR COOPERATION IN

    THIS REGARD.

    Mr. Bharath B K

    3. DIRECTIONS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH

    The above study has taken into consideration marketing managers and

    business development managers of various companies like Banks, FMCG,

    IT, Industrial marketing.

    1. The interested researchers can conduct a detailed survey as to how theMDSS is helping, considering the above mentioned sectors

    individually. They can obtain a rationale as how each sector uses

    MDSS individually.

    2. A research w.r.t the cost-benefit analysis of implementation of MDSScan be conducted

  • 8/3/2019 Bharath BK

    69/69

    69

    ________________________________________________________________________