BEYOND COMPLIANCE & ODEP · “beyond compliance”? •in spite of all the registry and other...
Transcript of BEYOND COMPLIANCE & ODEP · “beyond compliance”? •in spite of all the registry and other...
BEYOND COMPLIANCE & ODEP
KEITH TUCKER
PHIL LEWIS
RICHARD ARMSTRONG
RICHARD PARKINSON
OUR DISTINGUISHED PANEL AND
YOU!
New Orleans 2014
AIM OF MEETING FOR MANUFACTURERS
• TO PRESENT BEYOND COMPLIANCE
• TO PRESENT OUR UP GRADED ODEP HIP GUIDELEINES
• TO DISCUSS NICE FOR HIPS
• TO DISCUSS ODEP FOR KNEES
• ANYTHING YOU WOULD LIKE TO DISCUSS
• TO ARRANGE ONE ON ONE MEETINGS
New Orleans 2014
BEYOND COMPLIANCE
New Orleans 2014
WHY HAVE WE DEVELOPED “BEYOND COMPLIANCE”?
• IN SPITE OF ALL THE REGISTRY AND OTHER SYSTEMS THERE ARE STILL EXAMPLES OF UNDERPERFORMING IMPLANTS GETTING INTO THE MARKET
• WE FEEL A MORE PROACTIVE SYSTEM OF SURVEILLANCE MIGHT HAVE ADVANTAGES
New Orleans 2014
MoM Conventional Hip replacement
New Orleans 2014
REJUVENATE HIP (STRYKER) WITHDRAWN
New Orleans 2014
Novel implant
New Orleans 2014
WHY “BEYOND COMPLIANCE”?
• IF THE CE MARK IS “COMPLIANCE”
• BOA, ABHI, MHRA HAVE ALL SUGGESTED IT IS SOMETIMES APPROPRIATE FOR MANUFACTURERS TO GO
“BEYOND COMPLIANCE”
• AND SUBMIT THEIR NEW IMPLANT TO A MORE RIGOROROUS ASSESSMENT AND SURVEILLANCE
• IS NOT A RE-RUN OF THE CE MARK ASSESSMENT
New Orleans 2014
STEERING COMMITTEE CHAIR STAKEHOLDERS PETER KAY
• INDUSTRY 3 MEMBERS
• NOTIFIED BODIES
• MHRA
• PROMS
• DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
• BASK
• BHS
• BOA
• CHAIRMAN ADVISORY GROUP
• NHS SUPPLY CHAIN
New Orleans 2014
IMPORTANT LEGAL NOTE FOR BEYOND COMPLIANCE (AND ODEP)
• NO BARRIER TO TRADE
• CANNOT BE USED IN TENDERING PROCESS
• ILLEGAL FOR A GROUP SUCH AS BOA, ABHI, ODEP ETC TO INSIST THAT BEYOND COMPLIANCE HAS TO BE USED
New Orleans 2014
WE SEE 3 FUNCTIONS FOR BC
• ADVISORY
• DATA COLLECTION
• DATA ANALYSIS AND REPORT
New Orleans 2014
THE ADVISORY GROUP AND THEIR ROLE
• INITIALLY MEMBERS OF ODEP, PLUS OTHER EXPERTS
• ADVISES MANUFACTURER AND CHAMPION SURGEONS
• SUPERVISE DATA COLLECTION
• ORGANISES DATA ANALYSIS AND REPORTING
New Orleans 2014
ADVISORY GROUP (ODEP PLUS OTHERS)
• *Colin Esler, FRCS • * Peter Kay FRCS • *Richard Parkinson FRCS • * Martin Pickford PhD ODEP
Northgate *Andrew Porteous FRCS
• Andy Smallwood NJR Founder ODEP
• *Evert Smith. BSc. FRCS • *Ian Stockley MD FRCS • *Andrew Toms MSc FRCS • *Timothy Wilton MA FRCS • *Keith Tucker FRCS (Chairman) • Phil Lewis PhD NHS supply chain,
Orthopaedic Project Manager ODEP
• Ben Bolland • *Tim Board • *Malcolm Glasgow • George McLauchlan • Ian Mcnamara • Michael Rigby • Tim Harrison
• * Denotes involvement (Past or present) with the design and introduction of a joint replacement
New Orleans 2014
BIO-ENGINEERS... HAVE AGREED TO BE AVAILABLE
GORDON BLUN RICHIE GILL JULIA SHELTON TONY MILES CHRISTINA DOYLE TOM JOYCE JOHN FISHER ANNE NEVILLE ANDREW AMIES TONY UNSWORTH
New Orleans 2014
THE ADVISORY GROUP (WORKING WITH THE MANUFACTURER AND THE SURGEONS)
• ASSESSES LEVEL OF RISK
• TAKE ADVICE WHERE REQUIRED
• ADVISE RATE OF RELEASE INTO THE MARKET
• MAINTAIN SURVEILLANCE WITH REGULAR MEETINGS
• AIM AT LINKING WITH ODEP LEVEL 3
• (ALL UNPAID)
New Orleans 2014
RISK STRATIFICATION
LEVEL 1 RISK NO MAJOR CHANGE FROM BENCHMARK PREDICATE (Eg. Line extension) Rate of introduction:- No restriction Monitoring:- Through BC process. LEVEL 2 RISK ONE CHANGE FROM BENCHMARK PREDICATE Rate of introduction:- To be decided along the tripartite lines Monitoring:- Through BC process, initially 3 monthly with tripartite meetings LEVEL 3 RISK 2 SIGNIFICANT CHANGES FROM BENCHMARK Rate of introduction:- Limited Monitoring:- Full BC programme LEVEL 4 RISK PAUCITY OF BENCHMARK DATA, > 3 MAJOR CHANGES FROM THE PREDICATE Rate of Introduction:- Limited Monitoring:- Close monitoring
New Orleans 2014
THE ADVISORY GROUP RATE OF INTRODUCTION
OPTION 1:-
STEP BY STEP OPTION 2:-
BIGGER NUMBERS, STOP AND WAIT
• MUST BE BACKED BY SURGICAL TRAINING
• APPROACH DIFFERENT FOR DIFFERENT CIRCUMSTANCES
• ADVISE REVIEWED AT JOINT MEETINGS
New Orleans 2014
THE BC PROCESS
• MAKE CONTACT
• STAGE 1 MEETING
• PREPARATION OF DATA BY MANUFACTURER
• STAGE 2 MEETING
• REPORT BY RAPPORTEURS
• CONTRACT
• UPLOAD
• RECEIVE REPORTS New Orleans 2014
CONFLICTS
• SURGEONS AND OTHER EXPERTS ALL COMPLETE A COI FORM
• MOST OF OUR EXPERTS HAVE OR HAVE HAD THEIR NAMES ASSOCIATED WITH ONE OR MORE IMPLANT
• WE NEED INTEREST! WE DISCLOSE CONFLICTS!
• MANUFACTURERS ALL HAVE THE FINAL SAY AS TO WHO BECOMES RAPPORTEUR FOR THEIR PRODUCT
New Orleans 2014
CONFLICTS NHS SUPPLY CHAIN (OWNED BY DHL)
• NHS SUPPLY CHAIN HAVE BEEN RUNNING ODEP AND THERE HAS NEVER BEEN AN ISSUE
• NHS SC DO NOT SEE ANY OF THE PRE STAGE 2 DATA SETS
• NHS SC DO NOT SEE THE ASSESSMENT FOLLOWING THE LEVEL 2 MEETING
• MOST OFTEN THE COMPANY WHO HAS COME TO SUBMIT PREFERS TO HAVE THE BENEFIT OF THE EXPERIENCE AND KNOWLEDGE OF OUR NHS SC AND NHS WALES IN THE ROOM
• IMMUNE FROM FOIs
New Orleans 2014
POTENTIAL CONFLICTS
• THE ADVISORY GROUP DO NOT RECEIVE A SALARY. THEY ARE ALL VOLUNTEERS
• THE ADVISORY GROUP ARE PAID EXPENSES BY NHS SC
• NHS SC ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR THE INDEMNITY OF THE GROUP
• THE ADVISORY GROUP WILL NOT BE PAID OR RECEIVE EXPENSES FROM INDUSTRY
New Orleans 2014
CONSENT
• OUR AMBITION TO PRODUCE A ONE SIDE CONSENT FORM FOR BC HAS BEEN REALISED
• BC IS A ‘SERVICE EVALUATION’ (NHS RESEARCH AUTHORITY)
• WE HAVE APPROVAL FOR THE USE OF PROMS
• THE PATIENTS WILL SIGN 3 FORMS AS LONG AS WE HAVE ONE CONTRACT PER IMPLANT
New Orleans 2014
DATA COLLECTION
• UNIQUE DATA COLLECTION SYSTEM
• USING NJR
• CHEAP
• A` LA CARTE DATA ADD IN
• COLLATED BY NORTHGATE
• AVAILABLE TO RAPPORTEUR MANUFACTURER AND SURGEONS
DATA COLLECTION
New Orleans 2014
LEVELS OF DATA THAT CAN BE COLLECTED
• LEVEL 1 PATIENT DATA
• LEVEL 2 IMPLANT DATA
• LEVEL 3 PROMS
• LEVEL 4 X.RAYS AND RESULTS OF OTHER INVESTIGATIONS
• LEVEL 5 EXPLANT DATA
New Orleans 2014
DATA FROM OTHER SOURCES
• LEVEL 1 IS NJR ON NJR
• SUPPORTIVE EVIDENCE WELCOME BUT CANNOT BE A SUBSTITUTE FOR NJR
• LOOP MUST CLOSE
• REGISTRIES WITH > 90 COMPLIANCE AND COVERAGE MAY BE APPROPRIATE
New Orleans 2014
REPORT ON UPTAKE
• 17 COMPANIES ARE EITHER WAITING FOR APPOINTMENTS OR HAVE STARTED
• 8 HAVE HAD LEVEL 2 MEETINGS / PRESENTATIONS
• 3 COMPANIES ARE LOADING UP DATA AND ALL HAVE HAD THEIR FIRST REPORTS
New Orleans 2014
COMPANIES ENGAGED
• 4 OF THE BIG 5 INTERNATIONAL COMPANIES
• 5 OTHERS
• SOME ARE ABHI MEMBERS AND SOME ARE NOT
AWAITING DATES:-
4 COMPANIES
New Orleans 2014
SOME RULES!
• ALL SURGEONS MUST UNDERGO SPECIFIC TRAINING (BACK TO THE DAYS OF CHARNLEY!)
• NO PLACE FOR DABBLERS
• CHAMPION SURGEONS HAVE TO BE PREPARED TO SHARE THEIR DATA WITH THE REST OF THE GROUP
WE HOPE THAT GOOD SURGEONS WILL BE ATTRACTED TO USING BC IMPLANTS
New Orleans 2014
EXPLANTS
• WE EXPECT EVERY EXPLANT TO BE RETRIEVED
• MANUFACTURER TO COLLECT AND ORGANISE ANALYSIS
• MANUFATURER TO REPORT BACK RESULTS
• ? LOOK FOR CHANGES IN PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL PROPERTIES
New Orleans 2014
COST
• NHS SUPPLY CHAIN PAYS FOR ADMINISTRATION AND INDEMNITY
• COMPANIES PAY FOR RENTING SPACE IN THE DATABASE
• ADVISORY GROUP NOT PAID
• NEEDS TO BE FINANCIALLY COMPETITIVE
New Orleans 2014
BEYOND COMPLIANCE “PROTECTING PATIENTS........ SUPPORTING INNOVATION”
www. Beyond compliance.org.uk
New Orleans 2014
ISAR 14 31ST MAY TO 2ND JUNE BOSTON USA
New Orleans 2014