Beyond Bilateral Approaches: Regionalizing Japan-Korea Tensions by T. J. Pempel

8/3/2019 Beyond Bilateral Approaches: Regionalizing Japan-Korea Tensions by T. J. Pempel

1/19


2/19

_|gaeng + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + qcc

Fgehckm }cvd Kb|vd @b|ge9 Ve`ckm ^vbn` ba


3/19

^dcavckm ^v|evgmcn ekf _bhcvcneh \ghevcbk~ }cvd vdg @b|ge~ 553

LGSBKF LCHEVG\EH E__\BENDG^9

\GMCBKEHCYCKM IE_EK*@B\GE VGK^CBK^

V+ I+ _gjpgh)

NBKVGKV^

C Ckv|bfwnvcbk

CC Ndekmckm ^gnw|cvs _b~vw|g~

CCC E ]es Ab|}e|f29 Jbqckm lgsbkf Lchevg|ehc~j

CQ Nbknhw~cbk

) V+ I+ _gjpgh c~ e p|bag~~b| ba pbhcvcneh ~ncgkng ev vdg Wkcqg|~cvs ba Nehcab|kce(

Lg|`ghgs+


4/19

5


5/19



6/19

5 _e~~ckm hgmc~hevcbk }e~ bavgk a|w~v|evckm ekf nbjphcnevgf( lwv }dgk

vdg ndcp~ }g|g fb}k vdg HF_ ehjb~v eh}es~ def vdg |guwc|gf qbvg~ vb gk~w|g

pe~~emg ba cv~ p|bm|ej~ Vdg jeib| bppb~cvcbk pe|vs( vdg Iepek ^bncehc~v _e|vs$I^_#( }e~ pe|vcnwhe|hs n|cvcneh ba Iepek~ fgagk~g pb~vw|g( cv~ nhb~g vcg~ }cvd vdg

Wkcvgf vevg~( ekf eksvdckm vdev ndehhgkmgf vdg ~b*nehhgf pgeng nbk~vcvwvcbk Lwv

vdg I^_ kgqg| meckgf nbkv|bh ba e~ jeks e~ bkg*vdc|f ba vdg ~gev~ ck pe|hcejgkv(

je`ckm vdg pe|vs e a|guwgkvhs vbbvdhg~~ bppb~cvcbk $_gjpgh 53340 ^ndgckg|


7/19


ckg~nepelhg qwhkg|elchcvs vb gnbkbjcn ~dbn`~ a|bj el|bef $_shg ekf Dgmcklbvdej


8/19

5


9/19



10/19

5


11/19

^dcavckm ^v|evgmcn ekf _bhcvcneh \ghevcbk~ }cvd vdg @b|ge~ 5( ekf ab| |bwmdhs

vdg st|~v vd|gg sge|~ ba kgmbvcevcbk~( vdg|g }e~ qc|vwehhs kb |geh mcqg b| ve`g e~

vdg Wkcvgf ^vevg~ ekf vdg F_\@ nhwkm ~vwllb|khs vb sttgf pb~cvcbk~( }cvd gend

~cfg g~~gkvcehhs fgjekfckm kbkkgmbvcelhg p|gnbkfcvcbk~ ab| vdg bvdg| lgab|g eksbvdg| jbqgjgkv }e~ pb~~clhg Vdg \B@( }dchg bavgk n|cvcneh ba vdg F_\@( }e~

ev hge~v e~ n|cvcneh ba vdg Wkcvgf ^vevg~ ekf bavgk abwkf cv~gha ~cfckm }cvd Ndcke

ekf \w~~ce emeck~v vdg Wkcvgf ^vevg~ ekf Iepek

W^*\B@ jchcve|s vcg~ ~dcavgf e~ W^ jchcve|s pbhcncg~ ndekmgf Jb~v ngkv|ehhs(

vdg Wkcvgf ^vevg~ |gfwngf cv~ kwjlg| ba v|bbp~ ~vevcbkgf ck @b|ge ls elbwv

5


12/19

5


13/19



14/19

5>? W+^+@b|ge Enefgjcn ^sjpb~cwj

CCC+ E ]es Ab|}e|f2 Jbqckm lgsbkf Lchevg|ehc~j

@b|gek ekf Iepekg~g hgefg|~ deqg pg|cbfcnehhs ~db}k ek elchcvs vb ~cfghckg

qgtevcbw~ c~~wg~ ekf vb gknbw|emg ~jbbvdg| lchevg|eh |ghevcbk~ _g|dep~ vdg lg~vgtejphg nejg ck 5334 }cvd vdg @cj*Blwndc ~wjjcv Vdg v}b hgefg|~ em|ggf bk

vdg nbjjbk wkfg|~vekfckm vdev ck b|fg| ab| Iepek ekf vdg \gpwlhcn ba @b|ge

vb lwchf ~bhcf( mbbf*kgcmdlb|hs ekf a|cgkfhs |ghevcbk~ ck vdg v}gkvs*st|~v ngkvw|s(

cv }e~ cjpb|vekv vdev lbvd nbwkv|cg~ ~uwe|ghs aeng vdg pe~v ekf fgqghbp |ghevcbk~

le~gf bk jwvweh wkfg|~vekfckm ekf v|w~v $JAE*I 5334# @cj p|bjc~gf vb e~~g~~

Iepek hg~~ bk pe~v dc~vb|s ekf jb|g bk awvw|g lgdeqcb| Blwndc ck vw|k baag|gf

e p|babwkf epbhbms vb @cj bk lgdeha ba vdg @b|gek pgbphg ab| vdg jc~fggf~ ba

vdg Iepekg~g mbqg|kjgkv ekf jchcve|s fw|ckm vdg p|g}e| pg|cbf Ehvdbwmd vdg

nhcjevg cjp|bqgf uwcn`hs e~ e |g~whv( |ghevcbk~ fgvg|cb|evgf emeck fw|ckm vdg@bcywjc sge|~ ab| vdg |ge~bk~ kbvgf elbqg

Ab| vdev |ge~bk( C }c~d vb ~wmmg~v bkg cjpb|vekv fc|gnvcbk baag|ckm jb|g dbpg

ab| hbkm*vg|j |g~bhwvcbk ba nw||gkv lchevg|eh vgk~cbk~ Vdg pevd edgef( C }bwhf

nbkvgkf( hcg~ ck jbqckm lgsbkf \B@*Iepek lchevg|ehc~j bk vdg |gehhs ~gk~cvcqg

ekf bavgk kbkkgmbvcelhg c~~wg~ ekf ~dcavckm vdgj ckvb e jwhvchevg|eh nbkvgtv

Ck gaagnv( ndekmg vdg qgkwg ekf ndekmg vdg c~~wg~ Fbckm ~b }bwhf ehhb}

nw||gkvhs qgtevcbw~ c~~wg~ vb lgnbjg pe|v ba e he|mg| emgkfe }cvd jb|g vdek

v}b ~cfg~ pe|vcncpevckm ]cvdbwv e fbwlv( |gmcbkehc~j ck Kb|vdge~v E~ce de~ lggk~hb} vb fgqghbp( gqgk nbjpe|gf }cvd gjl|sbkcn |gmcbkeh vgkfgkncg~ ~ggk ck

^bwvdge~v E~ce Jb|gbqg|( Iepek ekf @b|ge deqg epp|bendgf vdg el~v|env mbeh

ba |gmcbkehc~j }cvd qg|s fcaag|gkv gkf mbeh~ ck jckf $_gjpgh


15/19

^dcavckm ^v|evgmcn ekf _bhcvcneh \ghevcbk~ }cvd vdg @b|ge~ 5>5

ck Lehc( vdg phw~ vd|gg nbwkv|cg~ c~~wgf e ibckv fgnhe|evcbk ecjgf ev

p|bjbvckm v|chevg|eh nbbpg|evcbk $E^GEK # Vdg fgnhe|evcbk phgfmg~ aw|vdg|

nbbpg|evcbk ekf fcehbmwg bk gnbkbjcn( nwhvw|eh( gfwnevcbkeh( gkqc|bkjgkveh(

pbhcvcneh*jchcve|s( ekf ~gnw|cvs c~~wg~0 ekf vdg hgefg|~ eh~b em|ggf vb ~gv wp ev|chevg|eh nbjjcvvgg vb p|bjbvg ekf cjphgjgkv vdg nbbpg|evcqg em|ggjgkv~ Vdc~

ck~vcvwvcbkeh e||ekmgjgkv( ehbkm }cvd vdg |epcf gtpek~cbk ba gnbkbjcn gtndekmg~(

de~ hecf e ~v|bkm abwkfevcbk ab| v|chevg|eh nbbpg|evcbk

Ev vdg ~gqgkvd ~wjjcv ba vdg hgefg|~ ba ^bwvd @b|ge( Ndcke( ekf Iepek( dghf ck

Nglw ck Iekwe|s


16/19

5>< W+^+@b|ge Enefgjcn ^sjpb~cwj

lgnbjg vdg hbmcneh gtvgk~cbk ba vdg ~ct*pe|vs p|bng~~ ca ekf }dgk cv |g~bhqg~ vdg

nw||gkv bwv~vekfckm c~~wg~ ~w||bwkfckm vdg F_\@ kwnhge| p|bm|ej ekf jwvweh

~gnw|cvs mwe|ekvgg~ ekf gnbkbjcn fgqghbpjgkv e~~c~vekng Iepek ekf vdg \B@

deqg de|fhs lggk nhb~g ck vdgc| jbqg~ fw|ckm vdg ~ct*pe|vs p|bng~~( ~b emeck vdg|gc~ kb |ge~bk vb e~~wjg vdev e jwhvchevg|eh ab|wj ehbkg }chh ~bjgdb} g|efcnevg

nw||gkv lchevg|eh c~~wg~ Lwv emeck( vdg ndekng~ gtc~v ab| ~bjg qg|~cbk ba e m|ekf

le|meck b| pg|dep~ e nbkng|v ba pb}g|~ vdev( ca ~v|wnvw|gf gaagnvcqghs ekf jekemgf

ne|gawhhs( nbwhf dbhf vdg p|bjc~g ba ~bavgkckm nw||gkv a|cnvcbk~ Ng|veckhs( e kg}

e|ndcvgnvw|g ab| ~gnw|cvs ck Kb|vdge~v E~ce }bwhf ehhb} ab| e fchwvcbk ba ~bjg ba

vdg nw||gkvhs a|envcbw~ c~~wg~ ck vdg he|mg| nbkvgtv ba |gmcbkeh ~gnw|cvs ckqbhqckm

kbv iw~v Iepek ekf vdg \B@ lwv eh~b abw| kgcmdlb|ckm nbwkv|cg~( gend }cvd vdgc|

b}k emgkfe~ lwv( pbvgkvcehhs( vdgc| b}k ~bhwvcbk~

CQ+ Nbknhw~cbk

^ckng vdg gkf ba vdg Nbhf ]e|( Iepekg~g*\B@ |ghevcbk~ deqg lggk je|`gf ls

nbjpgvckm pwhh~bavgkvcjg~ jbqckm vdg v}b nbwkv|cg~ nhb~g| vbmgvdg| lwv ev

bvdg| vcjg~ pw~dckm vdgj }cfghs epe|v Vdc~ pepg| gtejckg~ vdg~g nbjpgvckm

pw~dg~ ekf pwhh~( e|mwckm vdev vdg v}b nbwkv|cg~ nbwhf pbvgkvcehhs |g~bhqg ~bjg

ba vdgc| jb|g nbkvgkvcbw~ c~~wg~ ls jwhvchevg|ehcyckm vdgj Ev vdc~ ~vemg( Ge~v

E~ce de~ pwv ck pheng e kwjlg| ba ~wnd jwhvchevg|eh lbfcg~ Ca @b|ge ekf Iepek

nek v|ek~ag| ~bjg ba vdg jb|g p|blhgjevcn c~~wg~ a|bj vdg lchevg|eh emgkfe vdev

~b bavgk hgeqg~ lbvd nbwkv|cg~ ev femmg| pbckv~ ckvb vdg~g jwhvchevg|eh ab|wj~(

vdg|g c~ ~bjg dbpg vdev vdg nw||gkv vgk~cbk~ nek lg |gfwngf ekf vdg c~~wg~ ~ggk

ck e jb|g nbjp|gdgk~cqg nbkvgtv vdev jcmdv ckfwng gkdekngf nbbpg|evcbk


17/19

^dcavckm ^v|evgmcn ekf _bhcvcneh \ghevcbk~ }cvd vdg @b|ge~ 5>>

HC^V BA \GAG\GKNG^

E^GEK $E~~bncevcbk ba ^bwvdge~v E~cek Kevcbk~# Ibckv Fgnhe|evcbk bk vdg _|bjb*vcbk ba V|cpe|vcvg Nbbpg|evcbk ejbkm vdg _gbphg~ \gpwlhcn ba Ndcke( Iepek ekf vdg\gpwlhcn ba @b|ge Lehc( Ckfbkg~ce( = Bnvblg| }}}e~gek~gnb|m"57


18/19

5>6 W+^+@b|ge Enefgjcn ^sjpb~cwj


19/19

Beyond Bilateral Approaches: Regionalizing Japan-Korea Tensions by T. J. Pempel

Documents

Transcript of Beyond Bilateral Approaches: Regionalizing Japan-Korea Tensions by T. J. Pempel