Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
-
Upload
francis-batt -
Category
Documents
-
view
216 -
download
0
Transcript of Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 1/88
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 2/88
EHT@LW PCWL WLD CKNHODBUHO WLD
'
^A@D DKGHPODKW BTWLD @CBW HB
Ldku` 113+ ^a`d
+,[+a`[k[ 9
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 3/88
^lduuaww " Lt`ld~
]tejc~ldu~ wh wld Rcnwhuca Tkcrdu~cws hb Oaknld~wdu
>7 Nuh~~ ^wuddw* Oaknld~wdu+
>> ^hlh ^qtaud* Jhkghk* P+
A`dkw~ bhu wld Tkcwdg ^wawd~
Jhk`oak~* @uddk " Nh+
77*>+77*3 Bhtuwl Ardktd* Kdp Shui
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 4/88
OAKNLD^WDU TKCRDU^CWS JDNWTUD^
KH+ \RC+
WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK OCKG AKG CW^
HEFDNW^
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 5/88
6[
bw ®
/duw[u%
A+a`E[[[b
AJJ TC@LW^ UD^DURDG+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 6/88
NHKWDKW^+
]A@D
4Wld Gc~wcknwchk edwpddk Ockg akg cw~ Hefdnw~
A Wpdkwcdwl Ndkwtus Udajc~w / /4
^t``d~wchk~ whpaug~ Nucwcnc~o akg Gdrdjh}/
odkw 54
A]]DKGC\+]A@D
Hk ~hod ]hckw~ ck wld Odwa}ls~cn akg Jh`cn
hb wld Kdp Udajc~o[ 4
C+ Odwa}ls~cn akg D}c~wdohjh`s 41
CC+ Jh`cnaj ]uchucws / / /21
C+ %Wld Kdp Udajc~o9 Nh/h}duawcrd ^wtgcd~ ck
]lcjh~h}ls+% Es Dgpck E+ Lhjw* Pajwdu W+ Oaurck*Pcjjcao F]d}}duudjj Ohkwa`td* Uaj}l Eauwhk ]duus*
Pajwdu E+ ]cwick* akg Dgpaug @jda~hk ^}atjgck`+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 7/88
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 8/88
Wld Gc~wcknwchk Edwpddk Ockg akg
Cw~ Hefdnw~+
Plaw C gd~cud wh nhk~cgdu pcwl sht wh/kc`lw
oas bacujs ed gd~nucedg a~ a kdp ~cwtawchk
ck wld }lcjh~h}lcnaj phujg+ Akg C oas
ed`ck es ~asck` wlaw cw c~ ~awc~banwhus wlaw
wldud ~lhtjg ed a kdp ~cwtawchk+ Cw c~ a
wd~wcohks wh wld ckd|lat~wcejdkd~~ hb udajcws*
akg* plaw c~ udajjs wld ~aod wlck`* wh wld
bdntkgcws hb wld ltoak ockg+ Akg ck wld
kd|w }jand* C ~lajj awwdo}w wh ~ldp wlaw wld
kawtud hb wld kdp a}}dauaknd nhk~wcwtwd~ a
udaj agraknd+ Wldud c~* ckgddg* ajpas~* C
edjcdrd* a ghtejd ckwdu}udwawchk }h~~cejd ck
band hb kdp awwcwtgd~ hb ockg+ Wld khrdjws
oas ed ~awc~banwhus ck cw~djb* hu cw oas ed
~awc~banwhus ednat~d hb cw~ ~t``d~wchk~+ C
~lajj whtnl t}hk ~tnl a }uhejdo hb ckwdu/
}udwawchk wlc~ drdkck`+
Etw wld bcu~w akg }ucknc}aj oawwdu wh plcnl
C pc~l wh najj shtu awwdkwchk c~ wlaw pd lard
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 9/88
2 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
edbhud t~ ck wpdkwcdwl ndkwtus }lcjh~h}ls
~hodwlck` plcnl* pldwldu tk~awc~banwhus hu
khw* c~ gdbckcwdjs kdp+ Hb nhtu~d C gh khw
odak wlaw cw c~ plhjjs pcwlhtw }udndgdkw+
Sht nak bckg otnl wlaw la~ jdg t} wh cw 9 etw
C gh khw wlcki cw la~ edbhud eddk }uh}htkgdg
akg gdbdkgdg nhk~ncht~js akg hk cw~ oducw~+
Plaw c~ cw* wldk* wlaw C ao ~}daick` hb8
akg lhp c~ cw nhkkdnwdg pcwl wld ~tefdnw hb
wlc~ jdnwtud8
Plaw C ao ~}daick` hb c~ wpdkwcdwl ndkwtus
Udajc~o9 akg wld }hckw hb khrdjws aehtw cw*
hk wld plhjd* wlht`l khw ck drdus na~d* akg
wluht`lhtw‗c~ cw~ nhkwua~w hb }ucknc}jd pcwl
Oawducajc~o+ Hu* ~}daick` ck wduo~ hb htu
~tefdnw* wld khrdjws c~ wlc~9 wlaw wld udajc~o
ck qtd~wchk* wlht`l cw `crd~ otnl jd~~ wh Ockg
wlak Cgdajc~o* `crd~ otnl ohud wh Udajcws
wlak Oawducajc~o+ Pldwldu wld }h~cwchk
pcjj }uhrd tkwdkaejd c~ a qtd~wchk wh ed
gc~nt~~dg+ Etw wlaw wld }h~cwchk* cb wdkaejd*
phtjg `h bau wh udauuak`d wld plhjd eawwjd/
bcdjg hb* ~as+ Cgdajc~o akg Oawducajc~o* c~*
C wlcki* ckgc~}twaejd+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 10/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 0
Pd ajj ikhp }udwws pdjj plaw c~ odakw es
Oawducajc~o+ Cw~ }h}tjau a~}dnw c~ ~toodg
t} ck a }lua~d hb Faod~ Lckwhk* plcnl C
qthwd buho odohus* akg ~lajj udntu wh edjhp+
% Plaw a phujg c~ wlaw plcnl ~ncdknd }uh/
khtknd~ udaj9 gaui* nhjg* akg ~laick` jcid
a fdjjs+% Hb nhtu~d wldud c~ a ~lddu nhkbt/
~chk ck wld ~wawdodkw 9 etw }dula}~ cw doehgcd~
}h}tjau oawducajc~o khkd wld phu~d bhu wlaw+
Wld cgda c~* ck `dkduaj* wlaw ~tnl nlauanwdu~
a~ ~la}d akg ohwchk aud ~djb/d|c~wdkw }uh/
}duwcd~ hb wlck`~* plcjd nhjhtu akg ~htkg bhu
ck~waknd aud dbbdnw~ }uhgtndg ck htu ockg~
wluht`l htu ~dk~d/hu`ak~* akg edau kh
ud~doejaknd wh akswlck` ck wld udaj d|wdukaj
hefdnw~+ Khp C gh khw ~as wlaw wlc~ wldhus
kddg kdnd~~aucjs `crd t~ a kauuhp rcdp hb
wld phujg9 etw cw rdus kawtuajjs gcg ~h* akg
C edjcdrd ajpas~ pcjj gh ~h+ Wld uda~hk c~*
wlaw cw oaid~ t~ wlcki ajj wld wlck`~ pd jcrd
pcwl akg naud aehtw oh~w* band~* rhcnd~*
ot~cn* jc`lw* wa~wd* ~odjj‗ajj wld~d wlck`~
aud* cb khw cjjt~chk~* sdw ck a ~huw hb pas hk
a jhpdu jdrdj hb wutwl akg udajcws wlak wlck`~
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 11/88
< WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
jcid awho~ akg `uarcwawchk+ Sht nak d|}jack
wlc~ ud~tjw apas 9 etw oak pcjj ajpas~ lhkhtu
wld ~djb/d|c~wdkw* akg sht nakkhw udajjs
gd~wuhs wld phu~lc} hb oawwdu a~ jhk` a~ sht
lhjg wlc~ ghnwuckd+
Ck wduo~ hb htu ~tefdnw* wlc~ wldhus wudaw~
~hod hefdnw~ hb ockg* wld ~dk~awchk hb nhjhtu*
akg ~h hk‗a~ odkwaj ck kawtud* hu* uht`ljs
~}daick`* a~ }uhgtnw~ hu ecw~ hb ockg9 plcjd
hwldu hefdnw~ hb ockg* jcid }dundcrdg ~la}d~
hu ud~c~waknd* cw wudaw~ a~ ~djb/d|c~wdkw udajcwcd~+
Akg pldk wlc~ c~ edjcdrdg* wld }uhgtnw~ hu ecw~
hb ockg pcjj ajpas~ ed gc~}aua`dg es nho/
}auc~hk pcwl plaw pd ~t}}h~d wh d|c~w ck cw~
hpk uc`lw+ cZkg wldk* hk ~tnl a ghnwuckd*
plaw aud sht `hck` wh gh pcwl ~tnl udajcwcd~
a~ tkcrdu~aj~‗`dkduaj banw~8 Wlds ghk'w
~ddo wh bcw pdjj ckwh ~}and9 plcjd* a~ ecw~ hb
ockg* wlds ~ddo co}hwdkw+ RWldk* hb nhtu~d* nhod~ wld udwtuk oawnl
plaw c~ ikhpk a~ ~tefdnwcrd cgdajc~o+ ^hod/
hkd }hckw~ htw wlaw* a~ hef dnw~ hb ockg* ~}and*
akg ohwchk* akg ~h bhuwl* aud ft~w hk wld
~aod jdrdj pcwl ~htkg akg nhjhtu9 cb* wldud/
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 12/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 3
bhud* wld jawwdu ~dw aud wh ed najjdg }uhgtnw~
hb ockg* hu ecw~ hb ockg* ~h ht`lw wld hwldu~
wh ed+ Wldk sht oas nhknjtgd wh ~tefdnwcrd
cgdajc~o* ck plcnl ajj hefdnw~ hb ockg pcwlhtw
gc~wcknwchk aud ae~huedg ckwh ockg* ednhod
dcwldu ockg~ hu ecw~ hb ockg* hu }uhgtnw~ hu
~wawd~ hb ockg+
Pd aud whjg wlaw edkdawl aks ~tnl rcdp
a~ wlc~ wldud c~ wld oc~waid hb nhkbt~ck`
anw~ hb ockg pcwl cw~ hef dnw~‗~ddck` pcwl
nhjhtu 9 akg wlaw oas ed wutd+ Ajj wld ~aod*
~tnl a rcdp `crd~ sht hkd dkhuoht~ `ack bhu
`dkduaj ntjwtud akg `dkduaj }lcjh~h}ls+ Cw
}tw~ wld nhoohk qtajcwcd~ pd jhrd‗plaw
}uanwcnajjs oaid t} wld phujg pd jcrd ck
nhjhtu* ~htkg* akg wld ud~w‗hk wld ~aod jdrdj
hb udajcws akg njaco wh d|c~wdknd a~ wld ~la}d
akg ohwchk hb awho~ hu wld banw~ hb `uarcwa/
wchk+ Wld ltoakc~ck` dbbdnw hb wlc~ edjcdb*
akg wld udajcws cw dkaejd~ shcc wh a~~c`k wh
edatws* bhu ck~waknd* c~ ak tk~}daiaejd `ack
bhu jcbd akg bhu }lcjh~h}ls+ Akg* C edjcdrd*
ajwlht`l wld bajjans aehrd/odkwchkdg c~
h}duawcrd‗sdw C edjcdrd wldud c~ a ~htkg
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 13/88
jH WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
tkgdujsck` ohwcrd ck ~tefdnwcrd cgdajc~o* a
udnh`kcwchk hb wld kdnd~~cws wlaw wld oh~w
'ckwdud~wck` wlck`~ ~lhtjg lard aw jda~w a~
otnl udajcws a~ akswlck` dj~d* akg wlaw ockg
~lgtjg khw ed ntw hbb buho cw~ hefdnw~* plcnl
nhk~wcwtwd kawtud akg wld phujg+ Pd ~lajj
udwtuk wh wlc~ }hckw+
Etw khp* sc nhkwua~w pcwl wld wph baocjcau
}h~cwchk~ plcnl C lard eucdbjs odkwchkdg a~
Oawducajc~o akg ^tefdnwcrd Cgdajc~o* pd
bckg htu~djrd~ nhkbuhkwdg pcwl wpdkwcdwl
ndkwtus Udajc~o+ Cw c~ a khrdjws ck wph
}ucknc}aj nlauanwduc~wcn~ 6 hkd a nlauanwduc~wcn
hb cw~ agrhnawd~* wld hwldu hb cw~ ghnwuckd+
Wld }hckw a~ ud`aug~ wld wldhuc~w~ wldo~djrd~
c~ wlaw kh hkd nak ~as wldcu rcdp~ aud gtd wh
c`khuaknd hu ckna}ancws+ Oaks bhuodu
udajc~w~* akg d~}dncajjs oawducajc~w~* lard
gc~}jasdg a qtcwd tknucwcnaj awwcwtgd9 }auwjs
hpck` wh wldcu lc~whucnaj }h~cwchk* }auwjs wh
hwldu jcocwawchk~+ Etw wld udajc~w~ hb wh/gas*
oh~w nduwackjs aw aks uawd wld udajc~w aehtw
plho C ao `hck` wh ~}dai* aud jdaukdg ck
ajj wld pc~gho hb wld D`s}wcak~+ Plaw
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 14/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ CC
]uhbd~~hu Ajd|akgdu‗bhu ld c~ wh ed htu
`tcgd‗ghd~ khw ikhp aehtw odwa}ls~cn~*
jh`cn* akg }~snlhjh`s c~* C waid cw* khw phuwl
ikhpck`+%[ Hkd oas ohgd~wjs gcbbdu buho
~tnl a oak9 etw wh wudaw lc~ rcdp~ a~ gtd wh
}lcjh~h}lcnaj ckd|}ducdknd* c~ ~co}js khw wh
ed ghkd+ Akg wldk ~dnhkgjs* aehtw wld
ghnwuckd~ wldo~djrd~+ Ajwlht`l a udajc~o*
akg drdk a }ls~cnaj udajc~o* wlds nhkwua~w
~lau}js pcwl plaw c~ odakw es Oawducajc~o+
Cb wlds aud odakw wh ed najjdg oawducajc~w*
plcnl C gh khw ikhp wlaw wlds aud* cw c~ wld
nhknd}wchk hb oawwdu wlaw la~ pcgdkdg* akg
khw wld kawtud hb udajcws wlaw la~ eddk ntw
ghpk wh bcw ak ae~wuanw oawwdu+ Wld wldhus
aco~ aw whwajcws* aw a bacu akg nho}jdwd udnh`/
kcwchk hb wld phujg a~ pd ikhp akg jhrd cw+
Cw ghd~ ft~wcnd wh wld ~dk~awchk~ hb ~dk~d* akg
wh wld ~dnhkgaus qtajcwcd~+ Akg aw jda~w wld
ghnwuckd plcnl C ao wh gc~nt~~ wh/kc`lw la~
kh bacwl ck a }uduh`awcrd udajcws hb ~}awcaj
}uh}duwcd~+
1+ ^cknd pucwck` wlc~ }a~~a`d* C lard ~ddk % Wld Kdp Udajc~o%
hb wld ~c| atwlhu~+ C nhtjg khw ajwh`dwldu* buho wld }hckw hb
rcdp hb os hpk ~wtgcd~* a}}js wlc~ ftg`odkw wh wldo+ Wlds
~wucid od a~ edwwdu ckbhuodg htw~cgd }lcjh~h}ls wlak ck cw+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 15/88
15 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
Bhu wlc~ uda~hk* ednat~d cw c~ ~h kdp* akg
ck cw~ aco c~ ~h nho}jdwd* akg ednat~d cw c~~td~
buho ~h lc`l a }lcjh~h}lcnaj ~htund* akg
ednat~d wlaw ~htund ot~w ldud ed hb }auaohtkw
ckwdud~w* C }uh}h~d wh waid wld jceduws hb ud/
~wawck` edbhud sht* a~ ~co}js a~ C nak* wld
ghnwuckd hb }ls~cnaj udajc~o* plcnl la~
ednhod baocjcau wh wld Dk`jc~l phujg ck wld
ja~w bdp sdau~ a~ }uhotj`awdg buho wld
Tkcrdu~cws hb Oaknld~wdu+
Bhu wlc~ ghnwuckd nhod~* ~h wh ~}dai* hk
wld wh} hb wld wph ghnwuckd~ pd lard ajudags
ajjtgdg wh+ ^as wlaw Oawducajc~o jh`cnajjs
pck~ wld bcu~w `aod‗C ao khw ~}daick` ck
lc~whucnaj hugdu‗C wlcki wlaw ^tefdnwcrd
' Cgdajc~o ot~w ~h bau ed ldjg wh lard phk
wld udwtuk oawnl+ Etw wld wdo}du plcnl
gdoakg~ a ~djb/d|c~wdkw khk/odkwaj udajcws
oas ed ldjg wh h}dk wld `aod a`ack pcwl
wpdkwcdwl ndkwtus Udajc~o* a rdus gcbbdudkw
wlck` buho Oawducajc~o9 akg pldwldu ak
d|c~wck` hu a btwtud }lcjh~h}ls* plawdrdu cw
oas ed najjdg* nak hknd ohud pck wld udwtuk
oawnl a`ack~w wld udajc~wcn ~cgd* hu‗guh}}ck`
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 16/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 1
wld odwa}lhu‗ae~hue cw~ wdkdw~ ckwh a nho/
}jdwdu rcdp‗c~ ft~w plaw udoack~ wh ed ~ddk+
C }uhnddg wh gd~nuced ck cw~ euhag nlauan/
wduc~wcn bdawtud~ a udajc~w ghnwuckd hb wld
wpdkwcdwl ndkwtus* plcnl c~ }uhotj`awdg buho
wlc~ Tkcrdu~cws+ Pd lard eucdbjs udbduudg
wh a nhknd}wchk ck plcnl* ~h wh ~}dai* wld
tkcrdu~d c~ odkwaj‗c~ ockg hu ~wawd~ hb
ockg‗wluht`l akg wluht`l* akg pd khp
wtuk wh wlc~ udajc~o ednat~d cw c~ }ucoa bancd
wld nho}jdwd~w nhkndcraejd nhtkwdu ~wuhid wh
aks ~tnl abbcuoawchk* akg ednat~d* wluht`l cw~
rdus nho}jdwdkd~~* cw ~t``d~w~ a oddwck` hb
d|wudod~ plcnl wld nhoohkdu ghnwuckd~**
ud~wck` hk a ohud lajb/ldauwdg gdoaunawchk
hb wld }~snlcnaj akg }ls~cnaj }uhrcknd~*
ckdrcwaejs d|njtgd+ Sdw hwldu wpdkwcdwl
ndkwtus udajc~o~* wlht`l jd~~‗oas C ~as
cw8‗jd~~ }auagh|cnajjs wlhuht`l/`hck`* oas
ed ~ddk* ck wld jc`lw hb wlaw plcnl c~ ldud
gc~nt~~dg* wh nhuuhehuawd cw~ btkgaodkwaj
jd~~hk~+
A~ C tkgdu~wakg wld wld~c~* ck hugdu wh C
`ua~} wld gc~wcknwchk edwpddk ockg akg cw~
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 17/88
17 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
hefdnw~* pd ot~w ~wauw buho wld ~co}jd na~d
hb aks wph ehgcd~ edck` wh`dwldu ck ~}and*
jcid a waejd akg wld bjhhu+ Wlc~ c~ wld btkga/
odkwaj udjawchk aw wld uhhw hb ikhpjdg`d akg
}dundf}wchk a~ hb ajj wld hugdu hb wld phujg+
Akg* ck banw* tknhk~ncht~ hefdnw~* ~h bau a~
ck wlc~ udjawchk* C wlcki wld wldhus phtjg ~as*
gh ck }ucknc}jd ikhp danl hwldu* wlht`l a~
wlds }h~~d~~ kh nhk~ncht~ ~djrd~ wldcu
ikhpjdg`d c~ aw a rakc~lck` }hckw+ Etw
aohk` wld~d d|c~wdkw~ plcnl aud ~h wh`dwldu*
wldud aud ~hod plcnl aud ockg~* wlaw c~*
ehgcd~ plcnl lard anqtcudg wld na}ancws hb
nhk~ncht~kd~~+ Pldk wld~d aud wh`dwldu
pcwl hwldu d|c~wdkw wlck`~* pcwlck wld uak`d
hb udanwchk wluht`l wld ~dk~d~* wld nhk~ncht~
wlck` c~ apaud hb edck` wh`dwldu pcwl wld
hwldu wlck`* ck wld raucht~ gd`udd~ hb ~dk~a/
wchk* }dund}wchk* akg wlht`lw hu ikhpjdg`d+
Wlc~ c~ khwlck` ohud wlak wld ao}jcbcnawchk
hu gdrdjh}odkw wluht`l nhk~ncht~kd~~ hb
wld btkgaodkwaj banw plcnl nhk~c~w~ ck wph
d|c~wdkw~ edck` wh`dwldu ck ~}and+ Os ockg
c~ ldud* ck os ehgs9 wld waejd c~ wldud+ Os
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 18/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 1
ockg c~ odkwaj9 wld waejd* cw~ hefdnw* c~
d|wdukaj hu }ls~cnaj* drdk ghpk wh cw~ nhjhtu
a~ C lard ~dk~awchk hb cw+ Wlc~ c~ wld
d~~dkwcaj d|}ducdknd hb nh`kcwchk akg ~dk~d/
}dund}wchk9 akg wlc~ c~ ajj wldud c~ aehtw cw+
Plaw c~ ldud wld jckd edwpddk os ockg
akg cw~ hefdnw8 Lhp otnl edjhk`~ wh os
ockg akg lhp otnl wh wld waejd +''
Wh `ua~} wld udajc~w'~ ak~pdu pd ot~w
ck~c~w hk a gc~wcknwchk plcnl ajj wpdkwcdwl
ndkwtus wlckidu~ anikhpjdg`d* wlht`l khw
ajj agocw wld ~aod gd`udd hb gc~wcknwkd~~
edwpddk cw~ wduo~+ C ~}dai* hb nhtu~d* hb wld
gc~wcknwchk edwpddk wld anw akg wld hefdnw
edwpddk wld anw hb ~ddck` akg wld nhjhtu
plcnl C ~dd9 edwpddk wld anw hb }dundcrck`
akg wld }ud~dkw wlck` plcnl C }dundcrd9
edwpddk wld anw hb wlckick` akg wld wlck`*
cw oas ed* ae~dkw* hb plcnl C wlcki+ H}ckchk~
gcbbdu a~ wh wld a~~c`kodkw hb wld~d hefdnw~*
d~}dncajjs ~tnl ak hefdnw hu nhkwdkw a~ ~ddo~
gcudnwjs }ud~dkw ck ~dk~awchk* wh wld ockg hk
wld hkd lakg* hu wh wld d|wdukaj hu }ls~cnaj
udajcws hk wld hwldu+ Etw wld udajc~w plho
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 19/88
1 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
pd aud bhjjhpck` oaid~ kh nho}uhoc~d+
Anw~* akg anw~ hkjs* edjhk` wh ockg+ He/
fdnw~* ajj hefdnw~* cknjtgck` plaw aud najjdg
nhkwdkw~* aud d|wdukaj* akg pcwl bdp d|nd}/
wchk~* }ls~cnaj+ Ejtd* bhu ck~waknd* c~ a
}ls~cnaj d|c~wdkw+ Cw c~ ak a~}dnw hb }ls~cnaj
udajcws* akg c~ wldud ck ~}and* hrdu a`ack~w htu
ockg+ Kh ghtew* cb pd lag kh ~tcwaejd udwcka
akg h}wcn kdurd* pd ~lhtjg ed tkaejd wh ~dd
cw+ Etw wlaw* ~h wh ~}dai* phtjg ed odudjs
htu jh~~+ Cw phtjg kh ohud abbdnw wld
d|c~wdknd hb ejtd wlak os oc~~ck` wld wuack
abbdnw~ wld d|c~wdknd hb wld wuack+'Z
Ockg* wldk* cw bhjjhp~* c~ ntw ghpk wh wld
kauuhpd~w jcocw+ Cw c~ khwlck` etw a ~s~wdo
hb dbbhuw~ ck raucht~ gcudnwchk~* dbbhuw~ plcnl
nauus pcwl wldo bddjck`~ hb udjawcrd ~tnnd~~
akg cjj/~tnnd~~ plcnl aohtkw wh }jda~tud akg
}ack+ Nhk~ncht~kd~~ c~ khwlck` etw dbbhuw
pcwl cw~ bdjw gcudnwchk wh htu hefdnw* akg wld
abbdnwchk~ plcnl awwdkg ~tnl dbbhuw akg
gcudnwchk+ Wld hefdnw c~ ajpas~ khk/odkwaj+
Wld gcudnwchk akg dbbhuw aud ~tnl a~ sht bddj
c+c aks gd~cud hu rhjtkwaus }uh`ud~~chk‗sht
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 20/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 1
udajc~d plaw cw c~ jcid cb sht aud ~wh}}dg ~lhuw
hb wld hefdnw+ Eudaick` hbb ck a ~dkwdknd
`crd~ a `hhg na~d hb wlc~ bddjck`++
Ikhpjdg`d* wldk* akg wlht`lw* ~h bau a~ cwz
c~ plaw pd wlcki hb* aud khk/odkwaj* hu
[cWs~cnaj+ Wlds aud ~co}js wld d|c~wdkw
wlck`~* hu }auw~ hb wldo* ~h bau a~ pd a}}ud/
ldkg wldo9 kdrdu* hb nhtu~d* nho}jdwdjs
a}}udldkgdg* etw ~h bau a~ htu }hpdu~ `h*
a}}udldkgdg a~ wlds udajjs aud+ Nhjhtu*
~htkg* wa~wd aud khw odkwaj banw~+ Wlds aud
}ls~cnaj udajcwcd~ wh danl hb plcnl wldud c~ a /
nhuud~}hkgck` odkwaj anw* wh ~dd* wh ldau* akg
~h bhuwl+ Etw anw akg hefdnw* drdk anw akg
wld kdaudu hefdnw plcnl ~hod phtjg najj
nhkwdkw* aud khw wh ed cgdkwcbcdg+ Shtu ockg
ghd~ khw ck aks pas oaid kawtud+ Cw ghd~
khw oaid wld hefdnw hb ~dk~d hu }dund}wchk*
hu nhk~wutnw wld hefdnw hb wlht`lw+ Sht aud
ldud9 wld hefdnw c~ wldud+ Cw ~wcu~ shtu ockg
ck a nduwack pas9 akg shtu ockg udanw~ akg
a}}udldkg~* akg bckg~ wld hefdnw a~ cw c~*
annhugck` wh wld gd`udd ck plcnl shtu }hpdu~
hb a}}udldk~chk aud gdrdjh}dg+ Cb sht aud
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 21/88
1 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
nhjhtuejckg* wlaw c~ shtu abbacu+ Wldud c~
wldk a gdbdnw ck shtu hu`ak hb a}}udldk~chk
etw wlaw ghd~ khw ckwdubdud pcwl wld }ls~cnaj
udajcws* plcnl pd ikhp buho edwwdu dqtc}}dg
he~durdu~+ Wlc~ ghnwuckd hb wld9 h}dk gh}u*
a~ C oas najj cw* hu hb wld pckghp pcwl gd`udd~
hb wuak~}audknd* wluht`l plcnl udajcws nhod~
wh sht a~ cw c~* wlht`l pcwl rausck` nho}jdwd/
kd~~* c~ rdus }hpdubtj ck wpdkwcdwl ndkwtus
udajc~o* akg c~ aw wcod~ nhkkdnwdg* ~wuak`djs
dkht`l* pcwl ~hod d|wudod ghnwuckd~ hb hwldu
phujg~+
Cw bhjjhp~‗akg wlc~ c~ jau`djs wld }hckw hb
wld ghnwuckd‗wlaw wld }ls~cnaj udajcws plcnl
c~ wld hefdnw hb ockg c~ wld wlck`* hu }auw hb
wld wlck`* plcnl sht ~t}}h~d shtu~djb wh
a}}udldkg+ C odak* cw c~ ck kh ~dk~d }auw hb
shtu hpk ehgs hu ockg+ Shtu hu`ak~ jdw cw
ck* etw wlds gh khw* ck }ucknc}jd* ohgcbs cw*
d|nd}w ck gd`udd+ YWld qtd~wchk hb duuhu
nak* C wlcki* ed gdajw pcwl buho wlc~ }h~cwchk*
ck a`uddodkw pcwl wld ed~w wlckidu~* aw jda~w
cb pd udag % udaj % bhu % }ls~cnaj+% Duuhu c~
ajpas~ aehtw a udajcws+_ Shtu ockg* wldk*
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 22/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 1
c~ khw* a~ ^}ckhva najjdg cw* wld cgda hb shtu
ehgs* akg hb hwldu wlck`~ hkjs wluht`l wlaw+
Sht h}dk shtu dsd~* akg aud apaud hb a wudd
edbhud sht+ Wlc~ c~ a banw ft~w jcid wlaw hb
a waejd edck` hk wld bjhhu+ Hkjs ck wlc~ na~d
hkd hb wld d|c~wdkw~ c~ a ockg+ Wld hwldu c~*
ft~w a~ wld ockg c~ apaud hb cw* ak d|wdukaj
}ls~cnaj udajcws+
Akg* a~ C tkgdu~wakg wld au`todkw* wld
wudd cw~djb c~ oagd t} hb hefdnw~ nhuud~}hkg/
ck` wh shtu odkwaj anw~ 9 hb plaw sht % ~dk~d*%
hb plaw sht }dundcrd* hb plaw sht wlcki
wlaw c~* hb bja~ld~ hu btj`tuawchk~ hb cw~
qtajcwcd~* hb qtajcwcd~ wldo~djrd~* ~hodwlck`
ohud }duoakdkw wlak wld bja~ld~* akg hb a
tkcrdu~aj kawtud hu udaj jap `hrdukck` wld
nhoeckawchk akg anwchk hb cw~ qtajcwcd~+ Pdlard hb nhtu~d wh ud~c~w edck` jdg apas es
wld ~htkg hb wlc~ ghnwuckd* wh co}twd wh wld
udajc~w ak d|wudod cgdajc~o+ Pldk sht
udag [ wlaw a }ls~cnaj wlck`* a oawducaj ~te/
~waknd* ' c~ oagd t} hb ~dk~a* }dund}wa* akg
wlht`lw~ ' sht lard laug phui wh udodoedu
1+ Au+ ]uhn* 13=3/1=* }+ >5+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 23/88
5= WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
wlaw bhu wld atwlhu ajj wld~d aud wld hefdnw~
hb wld odkwaj anw~* khw wld anw~ wldo~djrd~*
akg aud wldudbhud }ls~cnaj udajcwcd~* akg ck
kh pas ecw~ hb ockg+
Ldknd auc~d wph btuwldu }dntjcaucwcd~* hkd*
cb khw ehwl* hb plcnl nlauanwduc~d oh~w
wpdkwcdwl ndkwtus udajc~o* akg ~ard cw ck a
`udaw oda~tud buho wld gdbdnw~ hb wld hjgdu
dnjdnwcn hu gdoaunawck` udajc~o~* ck a phug*
gtajc~wcn udajc~o~* plcnl kdnd~~aucjs jdakdgwhpaug oawducajc~o+ C gh khw ~as wlaw wld
kdp Udajc~o c~ khw cw~djb ck a ~dk~d gtajc~wcn+
Bcu~w* wld ghnwuckd hb wld h}dk ghhu* a~ C
lard oagd ehjg wh najj cw* gd~wuhs~ wld
~t}du~wcwchk wlaw ~}awcaj }uh}duwcd~ aud gc~wck/
`tc~ldg es edck` ~djb/d|c~wdkw* plcjd ~dk~a/
wchk~ hb wld ~}dncaj ~dk~d~* akg wld~d hkjs*
aud gd}dkgdkw t}hk ockg+ Cw~ awwcwtgd c~
ckgddg wld udrdu~d hb wlaw wh plcnl wlc~
gd~wutnwchk c~ t~tajjs a~nucedg+ Cw ghd~ khw
[ ~as wlaw }ucoaus qtajcwcd~* jcid ~dnhkgaus* aud
ockg/gd}dkgdkw9 etw wlaw ~dnhkgaus* jcid
}ucoaus* aud ockg/ckgd}dkgdkw+ Etw bhu wld
coodgcawd }tu}h~d hb gd~wuhsck` wld gc~wckn/
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 24/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 51
wchk dcwldu hb wld wlhuht`l/`hck` rcdp~ pcjj
~durd+ Cw c~ hkjs wld dnjdnwcn rcdp wlaw c~
ehtkg wh ed`dw ~t}du~wcwchk+ Wlt~ a nho/
}jdwd }ls~cnaj udajc~o* drdk cb cw njaco~ wh ed
oawducajc~o* c~ jau`djs budd buho wld rcnd
ckldudkw ck wld hjgdu ghnwuckd hb wlaw kaod*
wlaw cw gc~nudgcw~ a~ tkudaj wld oh~w }udncht~
djdodkw~ hb wld phujg+ Bhu htu ohgduk
udajc~w* pldwldu uc`lw hu puhk`* wld phujg c~
`dktckdjs a~ cw ~ddo~ wh ed‗euc`lw* pauo*
ud~}hk~crd9 khw a~ drdk Faod~ Lckwhk ~acg
wlaw ~ncdknd ~lhp~ cw wh ed‗
% gaui* nhjg* akg
~laick` jcid a fdjjs+% Ak d|wuahugckaus
nhkbt~chk* wh }ud~t}}h~d wld h}duawchk hb wld
~dk~d/hu`ak~ ck he~durck` wld nhk~dqtdknd~*
hb wldcu hpk ~t}}h~dg ae~dknd ! Wld wduucejd
akg ~ckc~wdu }udftgcnd hb oawducajc~o plcnl
ldud bckg~ d|}ud~~chk c~* a~ pd ~acg* do}lawc/
najjs akg kdnd~~aucjs ud}tgcawdg es wld
ghnwuckd edbhud t~+ Pd aud paukdg hb wlc~
ck gdbckcwd jak`ta`d+ % Wh ~tnl a nhknd}/
wchk*% a~ wlaw khp }uhotj`awdg+ ]uhbd~~hu
Ajd|akgdu he~durd~* % pd h}}h~d htu laecwtaj
khwchk hb oawducaj wlck`~ a~ edck` ~hodlhp
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 25/88
55 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
auuak`dodkw~ hu ohwchk~ hb plawdrdu nhk~wc/
wtdkw~ pd ud`aug a~ tjwcoawd+ Etw cw nakkhw
ed whh hbwdk ud}dawdg* bhu wlh~d plh aud
Tidjs wh bhu`dw wld jd~~hk* wlaw d|wdk~chk akg
ohwchk hu oawducaj ~te~waknd aud ck wldo/
~djrd~ hk wld ~aod coodgcawd bhhwck` a~
nhjhtu~ akg ~odjj~9 wlaw wlds* whh* aud oagd
t} hb ~dk~a akg bdund}wa akg wlht`lw~* akg
d|lcecw wld ~aod }uhejdo hb }ud~dkwck` wld~d
bdawtud~ ck wldcu nhoeckawchk+%[
C ot~w he~durd* lhpdrdu* aw wlc~ }hckw*
wlaw plcjd oawducajc~wcn }udftgcnd c~ wlt~
wlhuht`ljs ud}tgcawdg a~ ud`aug~ wld
~dnhkgaus qtajcwcd~ hb wlck`~* C nakkhw ~dd
lhp wld wduwcaus qtajcwcd~* ~as* bhu d|ao}jd*
wlh~d plcnl pd najj ad~wldwcn* nak lard ft~wcnd
ghkd wldo hk wlc~ }ucknc}jd+ Nak wlds
d~na}d edck` ud`augdg a~ gc~wcknwcrdjs }~s/
nlcnaj akg ~h bau hb ckbduchu udajcws* ~h jhk`
a~ drdk bddjck` c~ ud~durdg a~ ~hodwlck`
edjhk`ck` wh ockg 8 Wlc~ udoaui akwcnc}awd~
htu jawdu au`todkw* wh wld dbbdnw wlaw wlhuht`l
akg ~hjcg a~ wlc~ kdp udajc~o awwdo}w~ wh ed*
1+ Au+ ]uhn* 13=3/1=* }+ >5+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 26/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 5>
cw }uhrd~ wlaw ck wld dkg wldud c~ kh udaT~o
wlaw nak ed nho}jdwdjs ~hjcg akg wlhuht`l9
wlaw c~ wh ~as* wlaw nak ~pdd} ajj nlauanwdu~
hb wlck`~* plcnl aud hk wld ~aod jdrdj hb
hefdnwcrcws* ckwh wld oa~~ hb khk/odkwaj
udajcws+ A wlck` oas ed nlauock` qtcwd a~
udajjs akg wutjs a~ cw c~ udg9 etw cw~ nlauo
annhugck` wh udajc~o* akg drdk annhugck` wh
wld udajc~o edbhud t~* ot~w ed a ockg/&
gd}dkgdkw awwucetwd ,bhu wh ed nlauodg c~ a
odkwaj anw#* plcjd cw~ udgkd~~ c~ }ls~cnaj akg
ockg/ckgd}dkgdkw+
Lhpdrdu* hk wld plhjd wld wdkgdkns hb
udajc~o wh/gas c~ apas buho dnjdnwcnc~o akg
whpaug~ a nho}jdwd annd}waknd hb d|wdukaj
wlck`~* ck ajj wldcu nhknudwd ucnlkd~~ hb d|c~w/
dknd* a~ udajcws ckgd}dkgdkw hb ockg+ Akg
~h bau pd aud gdajck` pcwl a kdp awwcwtgd*
pcwl a }ls~cnaj udajc~o plcnl la~ ck wld oack
~wuc}}dg hbb wld nlauanwdu hb oawducajc~o+
Akg ~dnhkgjs‗akg ldud C wlcki ajj
wpdkwcdwl ndkwtus udajc~o `hd~ wh`dwldu
tkcrdu~aj~ aud agocwwdg wh ed udaj* wlht`l es
kh odak~ odkwaj+ Htu }auwcntjau udajc~w
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 27/88
57 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
drdk najj~ wldo }ls~cnaj banw~+' Aks pas*
wlds aud ldjg wh d|c~w hu ~te~c~w ckgd}dkgdkwjs
hb ockg hu ikhpjdg`d+ [Wld kawtud hb a
wlck`* ck ud~}dnw hb plcnl cw c~ ak hefdnw hb
htu wlht`lw* wld `dkduaj jap hb anwchk akg
nhk~wutnwchk plcnl ghockawd~ cw* c~ ~}hidk hb
a~ a tkcrdu~aj akg a~ nhuud~}hkgck` wh htu
nhknd}w+ A oawducaj hefdnw* pd aud whjg es
hwldu ohgduk udajc~w~* nhk~c~w~* a}auw buho
ockg hu ikhpjdg`d* ck a nhkkdnwchk hb
tkcrdu~aj~+[ A }ls~cnaj udajc~o hb wlc~ ickg
waid~ t~ C coa`ckd ckwh a kdp nhtkwus* plcnl
Udcg }dula}~ rc~cwdg* etw gcg khw d|}jhud hu
~tegtd+ Najj t~ cgdajc~w~ hu plaw sht pcjj*
pd plh bhjjhp wld pawnlphug % Ga~ Palud
c~w ga~ @akvd % oc`lw }ucoa bancd bckg ck cw
otnl hb plaw pd gdoakg9 akg plaw kh
dnjdnwcnc~o hb wld oawducajc~w ws}d nak es aks
}h~~cecjcws abbhug t~+ Cb y9}du co}h~~cecjd* a~
C ~wcjj ot~w lhjg# ajj wlaw c~ }udncht~ akg
~te~wakwcaj nhtjg wutjs ed bt~dg akg bhnt~~dg
ck ak agocwwdg udaj* C aw jda~w ~lhtjg khw ed
`udawjs wuhtejdg aw edck` hugdudg wh najj cw
1+ ]ucnlaug* Iakw'~ %Wldhus hb Ikhpjdg`d*% }+ 57>+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 28/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 54
}ls~cnaj+ Najj wld~d wlck`~ }ls~cnaj hu plaw*
sht pcjj* cb wlds aud wld oh~w udaj hb udajcwcd~*
wldk khockajc~o la~ `hkd es wld ehaug* akg
wld udajc~o hb wld ohgdukc~w c~ fhckck` lakg~
pcwl wld udajc~o hb wld ~nlhhjoak+ Wldud
a}}dau~ wh ed ckgddg a wpdkwcdwl ndkwtus
udajc~o plcnl ntw~ ghpk }ls~cnaj udajcws wh
wld co}dund}wcejd~ hb ~ncdknd‗~hodwlck`
~naundjs edjhk`ck` drdk wh wld phujg hb
}ucoaus qtajcwcd~9 etw wlc~ c~ a lajb/wldhus hb
wld Jhnidcak ws}d* wlht`l cw }t~ld~ ae~wuan/
wchk hkd ~wa`d btuwldu wlak lc~+ Htu udajc~w'~
ghnwuckd hb wld }ls~cnaj phujg `crd~ t~ a bau
btjjdu }cnwtud hb wld udajcws plcnl c~ ck
}ucknc}jd wld ~aod bhu ajj akg annd~~cejd wh
ajj+ C Akg ohudhrdu* a~ C ~acg* ajj wld ohgduk
udajc~w~* C wlcki* a`udd ck udnh`kc~ck` wld
udajcws‗[pldwldu a~ d|c~wdknd hu a~ ~te~c~w/
dknd‗hb tkcrdu~aj~+ F
Wld ckwdud~w hb wld wldhus pd lard eddk
nhkwdo}jawck` la~ jack bhu od ck khwck` plaw
C waid wh ed wld ckdrcwaejd ud~tjw~ hb udgtnck`
wld }jand hb wld ockg ck wld anwtaj phujg wh
cw~ kauuhpd~w nhkndcraejd jcocw~* bWlc~ ud~tjw
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 29/88
52 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
c~* a~ C rcdp cw* wlaw hk wld hkd lakg wld `udaw
ehgs* hu wld nhu}~d a~ C ~lhtjg najj cw* hb
~h/najjdg }ls~cnaj udajcws* la~ eddk ntw hbb
akg ~dw hrdu a`ack~w wld jcrck` kawtud hb
ockg‗[plcnl c~ udgtndg* a~ pd ~ap* wh a
~nldod hb gcudnwchk~ hb dbbhuw aggud~~dg wh
hefdnw~ htw~cgd wldo+ Etw hk wld hwldu lakg*
ft~w ednat~d wlc~ c~ ghkd ~h wlhuht`ljs* cw
es ckldudkw kdnd~~cws ~lhp~ ~c`k~ hb jcbd* akg
ed`ck~ wh d|lcecw pcwlck cw~djb a rcwajcws*
}ucoaucjs jh`cnaj* etw* bhu wlc~ uda~hk* tjwc/
oawdjs akg ck d~~dknd ckrhjrck` nhkwcktcws
pcwl a }~snlcnaj ~s~wdo+#
,c+# Bcu~w* a phug a~ wh wld akajh`s hb wld
wph ~}awcaj wlck`~* hk plcnl wld plhjd }h~cwchk
c~ bhtkgdg+ Hkd nakkhw ed whh naudbtj +aw wld
ed`ckkck`9 akg C ~lajj oaid ak he~durawchk
plcnl oas ed ldjg wucrcaj akg ls}dunucwcnaj*
etw plcnl* C ao cknjckdg wh wlcki* pcjj jdag
t~ ck wld dkg wh qtcwd a gcbbdudkw awwcwtgd
whpaug~ wld plhjd udjawchk hb ockg akg cw~
hefdnw~+
Wld udoaui c~ odudjs wlc~9 wlaw ockg c~
kdrdu nhkbuhkwdg es hkd hefdnw hkjs+ Wld
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 30/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 5(
banw~ aud khw gd~nucedg es ~asck` wlaw pd
~wauw pcwl a }acu hb hefdnw~ banck` danl hwldu*
hb plcnl hkd oas ed a ehgs larck` a ockg+
Wld udjawchk c~ khw wlaw hb a ockg hk hkd ~cgd
akg a wudd hk wld hwldu+ Cb wldud c~ a ockg
hk hkd ~cgd wldud c~ aw jda~w a nho}jd| hb
hefdnw~ hk wld hwldu+
Etw bhu os hpk d|}ducdknd drdk wlc~ ghd~
khw ~ddo wutd+ % Hk hkd ~cgd*% akg % hk
akhwldu ~cgd % aud cknhuudnw d|}ud~~chk~+
^}daick` hb banw a~ C bckg cw* C ~lhtjg nho/
}aud os nhk~ncht~kd~~ wh ak awoh~}ldud* khw
wh a wlck` aw ajj+ Cw~ kawtud c~ wh cknjtgd+
Wld kawtud hb cw~ hefdnw~ c~ wh ed cknjtgdg+[
Pldk C naod ckwh wlc~ lajj* htw hb wld ~oajjdu
uhho ck plcnl pd odw* wld ncuntobdudknd hb
os ockg ~ddodg wh d|}akg+ Wld jcocw~ hb
os nhk~ncht~kd~~ ednaod* aw aks uawd* khw
kauuhpdu wlak wld pajj~ hb wlc~ nlaoedu+
Buho wld ed`ckkck`* wldk* wld akajh`s hb wph
hefdnw~ nhkbuhkwck` hkd akhwldu ~ddo~ wh od
cka}}jcnaejd+ C kdrdu ~ddo wh wlcki ck wld
bhuo* % os ockg c~ ldud* akg wld wudd c~
wldud+% Ockg waid~ cw~djb ae ckcwch a~ a
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 31/88
5< WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
phujg* khw a~ ak hefdnw ck a phujg+ C wlcki
% wld wudd c~ wldud* ck wld }akhuaoa*% akg wld
}akhuaoa c~ d~~dkwcaj wh os ockg* wlht`l
os ockg la~ ohud edbhud cwf d+`+* wlht`lw~ [hb
hwldu }jand~* akg hb ckncgdkw~ aw hwldu wckcd~+
C ao gd~nuceck` banw~+ Z C ao khw oaick` aks
au`todkw wlaw wld d|c~wdknd hb wld hefdnw~ c~
ck os ockg hu c~ ockg/gd}dkgdkw+ C ao
odudjs ~wawck` plaw C ao gcudnwjs apaud hb+
Ck gd~nuceck` os apaudkd~~ wldud c~ ajpas~
ak % akg % hu a % edbhud %‗hu % edlckg % hu
% ed~cgd%‗~hod nhkftknwchk hu }ud}h~cwchk+
Cw c~ kdrdu ft~w hkd hefdnw apaud hb hkd hwldu+ (
Wld ickg hb he~durawchk wlc~ ~t``d~w~ wh
od c~ wlaw ae ckcwch hkd ickg hb wlck` c~ a
plhjd* akg akhwldu c~ a bua`odkw+ A ockg c~
a plhjd* wlaw c~ ck cw~ kawtud akg ckwdkw9 ak
hefdnw c~ a bua`odkw+ Wlc~ banw bhudehgd~ a
gcbbcntjws ck a~~d~~ck` wld udajcws hb hefdnw~
a}auw buho ockg* akg ~h ck guapck` a jckd
edwpddk wldo+ Bhu plaw c~ udaj ot~w ~tudjs
ed a plhjd* plawdrdu dj~d oas ed cw~
nlauanwdu+ Pd ~lajj ~dd uda~hk wh udwtuk wh
wlc~ }hckw+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 32/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 53
,cc+# Ck wld wldhus edbhud t~* ~dk~d/}ud~dk/
wawchk~ nhtkw a~ khk/odkwaj hu drdk a~
}ls~cnaj+
Wld gc~wcknwchk edwpddk anw akg hefdnw* hu*
a~ ~hod waid cw* edwpddk anw* nhkwdkw* akg
hefdnw* c~ ldud wld `hrdukck` nhk~cgduawchk+
Cw la~ eddk ldjg wh udohrd wld }ucknc}aj
uda~hk bhu wlckick` wlaw ~dk~d/}ud~dkwawchk~
aud ~hodwlck` odkwaj+ C edjcdrd wld phug
odkwaj wh ed oc~jdagck`* a~ C ~lajj d|}jack
jawdu hk+ Etw C gd~cud wh ~t``d~w wlaw wlht`l
cw oas ed pdjj wh gc~wck`tc~l njdaujs edwpddk
~ddck` akg wld hefdnw ~ddk* sdw cw c~ khw a
odud bacjtud wh oaid wlc~ gc~wcknwchk plcnl
nat~d~ ~hod hb t~ wh edjcdrd wlaw wld hefdnw
~ddk la~ a nlauanwdu nhkwcktht~ pcwl htu
odkwaj jcbd+ Odudjs udbduuck` wh wld nhkwuh/
rdu~s edwpddk Oaknld~wdu akg ^w+ Akgudp~*
plcnl C cknjckd wh wlcki la~ d~waejc~ldg wlc~
}hckw ~h bau a~ ~dk~d/}ud~dkwawchk c~ nhk/
ndukdg* C dkgdarhtu wh gd~nuced a ohud
`dkduaj au`todkw plcnl ~wuhk`js a}}daj~ wh
od+
Pldk C ao whjg wlaw C ot~w khw nhkbt~d
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 33/88
>= WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
ak cgda a~ a odkwaj anw pcwl ak cgda a~ a
nhkwdkw hb ~dk~d hu ak hefdnw hb wlht`lw* C
wlcki C tkgdu~wakg plaw c~ odakw+ Pldk C
ao whjg wlaw wld nhkwdkw hb + ~dk~d hu hefdnw
hb wlht`lw oas wldudbhud ed ~hodwlck` qtcwd
khk/odkwaj hu drdk }ls~cnaj* C ao* wh ~}dai
}jackjs* cknjckdg wh bddj os~djb wld rcnwco
hb ~h}lc~wus+ Cw ~ddo~ hercht~ aw bcu~w ~c`lw
wlaw a ejtd c~ a~ }~snlcnaj a~ a }ack hu ak
ckbdudkwcaj wuak~cwchk+ Akg wlht`l sht oas
au`td aw jdk`wl wlaw cw c~ khwlck` etw ak
d|wdukaj hefdnw* C bddj ajj wld wcod wlaw C ao
edck` gdbuatgdg+ Sht lard }tw wld rcwaj
nlauanwdu hb a nduwack d|}ducdknd ckwh plaw
sht najj ak anw* akg C agocw wlaw cw c~ ~}dncajjs
he~duraejd ck nhkkdnwchk pcwl a nduwack
btknwchk+ Etw khp sht wdjj od wlaw wld oack
wlck` ck wld hefdnw* plaw C rajtd ck cw akg
plaw C pakw cw bhu* c~ udohrdg akg aehjc~ldg
es wld gc~wcknwchk* akg wld d|}ducdknd a~ ~tnl
c~ jdbw bhu gdag+
Khp cw c~ a `hhg }hckw hk os ~cgd wh ~as
wlaw hefdnw~ hb wld ickg ck qtd~wchk nda~d wh
ed* pcwl wld ockg~ plcnl dkwduwack wldo hu
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 34/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ >
drdk pcwl wld nd~~awchk hb wlh~d ockg~'
awwdkwchk+ Akg cw ~ddo~ hercht~ wh od wlaw
wlc~ c~ ~h+ Etw wld ghnwuckd hb wld h}dk ghhu
gdkcd~ wld banw9 akg ck aks na~d* wlc~ banw
phtjg hkjs ed ak d|wdukaj }uhhb akg khw ak
akajs~c~ hb wld d~~dknd* akg }ucoa bancd
phtjg khw a}}js wh wld hefdnw~ hb wlht`lw+
C pcjj wus wh ~wawd ak au`todkw `hck` gdd}du
ckwh wld oducw~* a~ C ~dd cw* akg pcjj ~t}}huw
os ~wawdodkw es wph a}}jcnawchk~ hb cw+
Wld a~~duwchk wlaw ak hefdnw hu nhkwdkw la~
hu la~ khw a odkwaj nlauanwdu* ht`lw* cw ~ddo~
wh od* cb cw la~ aks rajtd* wh ed ~t}}huwdg
es }h~cwcrd akajs~c~* akg khw odudjs es
d|wuakdht~ }uhhb+ Pldwldu a nduwack hefdnw
c~ nhkwcktht~ pcwl wld kawtud hb ockg c~ kh
qtd~wchk hb odud huc`ck hu nhknhocwakw
raucawchk9 cw c~ a qtd~wchk hb plaw ~huw hb
wlck` wld hefdnw c~* akg plaw ~huw hb wlck`
ockg c~* akg pldwldu hu kh wld hkd c~ nhk/
kdnwdg pcwl wld hwldu es ckldudkw nlauanwdu+
Khp cb C wus wh d~na}d wld ~huw hb kd`awcrd
~hucwd~ hu `uagtaj pcwlguapaj hb nlauanwdu~
es plcnl wld ~h/najjdg % odkwaj % nlauanwdu
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 35/88
>5 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
hb }ud~dkwawchk~ ~ddk[w} od wh ed buatgtjdkwjs
awwanidg* plaw nhod~ wh od a~ ~hodwlck` khw
wh ed uda~hkdg apas c~ ck a phug wld jcbd hb
ockg9 hu* cb pd }udbdu wld hjg wdnlkcnaj
jak`ta`d* cw~ d|}jcncw tkcws+Z[Pdjj* cw oas ed
~acg* etw a eau hb cuhk la~ tkcws* akg sht pcjj
khw ~as wlaw wlc~ c~ a nlauanwdu ckldudkwjs
nhkkdnwck` cw pcwl shtu nhk~ncht~kd~~+( Kh*
C ~lhtjg khw ~as wlaw c~ ~h* gcudnwjs akwc pcwl
udbdudknd wh os ~ck`jd nhk~ncht~kd~~+ Etw
wldk ck wld na~d hb wld eau hb cuhk C nak ~as
hu cb C nakkhw* a }ls~cnc~w nak‗[plaw dj~d c~
odakw es wlc~ tkcws* ck plaw udjawchk~ cw jcd~*
akg hk plaw nlauanwdu~ cw gd}dkg~+ Akg cw
c~* pd wldk ~dd* khw ak d|}jcncw tkcws9 khw hkd
plcnl ~wawd~ cw~djb+ Etw khp nhod wh a nhk/
wdkw hb ~dk~d+ Plaw C ~dd pldk C jhhi aw
a ejtd wlck` la~ tkcws* akg jcbd+ Cw~ }auw~
wlaw c~* wlht`l raucdg* nhkbcuo* ~t}}huw akg
gdwduockd hkd akhwldu es d|}jcncw % nho}ud~/
dknd+% Cw }tj~awd~ pcwl bddjck`* a nhoohk
whkd* plcnl ckrhjrd~ wld }ud~dknd hb a plhjd
ajj aw hknd* udckbhunck` akg ohgcbsck` drdus
}auw es wld ~cotjwakdht~ dbbdnw~ hb ajj+ Plaw
ghd~ a tkcws hb wlc~ ickg nhk~c~w ck 8 Cgdkwcws
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 36/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ >>
hb dwldudaj pard/jdk`wl~8 Khw aw ajj+
Wlaw oas ed }ud~t}}h~dg* etw cw pcjj khw gh
wld phui es cw~djb+ Ejtd c~ a }dntTau
% dbbdnw % 9 dbbdnw* C odak* ck wld auwc~wcn ~dk~d
hb wld phug9 akg pard/jdk`wl~* udndcrdg ~as
hk a }lhwh`ua}lcn }jawd* aud khw wld }dntjcau
dbbdnw plcnl pd najj ejtd* drdk cb a~ a }ls~cnaj
nat~d wlds pdud wh }uhgtnd cw qta }ls~cnaj
dbbdnw+ Lhp gh wld djdodkw~ hb wld dbbdnw
lhjg wh`dwldu8 Plaw oaid~ wld ejtd udck/
bhund hu ohgcbs wld ejtd 8 Wldud c~ kh }t~l
hu }tjj edwpddk wldo+ Wlds phui hk danl
hwldu wluht`l wldcu cgdkwcws akg gcbbdudknd9
hu* wh arhcg gc~}twd~* ldud cuudjdrakw* wluht`l
wldcu jcidkd~~ akg tkjcidkd~~+ Plaw ~huw hb
odgcto ghd~ ~tnl a tkcws ckrhjrd 8 ^tudjs*
wlaw hb nhk~ncht~kd~~ akg kh hwldu+ Ejtd[
wldk* plcjd cw udwack~ wld nlauanwdu~ hb ejtd*
ot~w lard ck cw wld jcbd hb ockg+ ( gh khw najj
cw %odkwaj*% bhu C ao khw ~tud plaw wlaw odak~+
Etw C pcjj najj cw jh`cnaj+ Wlc~ au`todkw* C
ao nhkrckndg* oc`lw ed otnl edwwdu ~wawdg*
etw cw aw jda~w oaid~ ak awwdo}w wh d|}ud~~
a ndkwuaj nhk~cgduawchk plcnl C lard tkda~cjs
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 37/88
>7 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
bdjw wh ed dkwcudjs hocwwdg wluht`lhtw ajj wld
udndkw udajc~wcn nhkwuhrdu~cd~+ C pcjj }ud~~
cw btuwldu es wph a}}jcnawchk~+ Bcu~w* pd ~ap
wlaw wld udajc~w hb wh/gas a~~duw~ wld udajcws
drdk wld }ls~cnaj udajcws
‗hb tkcrdu~aj~+
Wld ohgduk wudawodkw hb ]jawh'~ Cgda~* ck
wlc~ nhkkdnwchk* c~ d|wuahugckaucjs ckwdud~wck`*
etw khw }dula}~ a~ kdp a~ cw oc`lw a}}dau+
ZKhp a tkcrdu~aj c~ a phuick` nhkkdnwchk
pcwlck }auwcntjau~+ A`ack pd oc`lw t~d wld
}lua~d plcnl wh od a}}dau~ ~h a}w* akg ~as
cw c~ wld jcbd hb wld }auwcntjau~+ Cw c~* ckgddg*
aw ehwwho* hb wld kawtud hb a nhkawchk+ Khp
wld hefdnw~ hb ~dk~cwcrd akg }dund}wcrd anw~
aud nlau`dg pcwl ~tnl phuick` nhkkdnwchk~*
plcnl aud d|}ud~~js akg }udnc~djs nhkkdnwchk~
hb nhkwdkw akg hb khwlck` dj~d ck wld phujg+
Kh }h~~cejd lakgjck` hb nhkwdkw~ ae d|wua
es a ockg oagd t} hb }tud nhkawchk~ akg
gcudnwchk~ pcjj `dw htw hb wldo wld gdwduockawd
akg }dntjcau ud~tjw plcnl wldcu ckldudkw kc~t~
wh wld plhjd euck`~ htw* a~* bhu ck~waknd* ck
aks na~d hb udjawcrd ~t``d~wchk+ C bckg
os~djb ckgddg nho}auck` htu wpdkwcdwl ndk/
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 38/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ >4
wtus udajc~o pcwl wld duuhkdht~ ~cgd hb Iakw'~
~skwldwcn tkcws+
Kh ockg nak oaid a phujg ~skwldwcn cb
wlaw phujg c~ khw ~skwldwcn ck cw~djb+ Etw
a`ack9 kh phujg nak ed ~skwldwcn ck cw~djb*
wlaw c~* nak }h~~d~~ tkcrdu~aj~ a~ a }auw hb
cw~ hpk kawtud* cb cw~ djdodkw~ lard khw*
}duragck` wldo* wld jcrck` kd|t~ akg
dkgdarhtu whpaug~ a plhjd plcnl ckgcnawd~
}auwcnc}awchk ck wld kawtud hb ockg~+ C
nakkhw tkgdu~wakg aks awwdo}w wh d|}jack a
tkcrdu~aj plcnl ghd~ khw udnh`kc~d wlaw cw
ae~hjtwdjs nhk~c~w~ ck wld dbbhuw hb a nhkwdkw
wh nho}jdwd cw~djb a~ a ~s~wdo+ Sht oas
~as wlaw cw phtjg khw gh wlc~ hb cw~djb* etw
hkjs es wld ockg phuick` ck cw+ Akg C ao
gc~}h~dg wh a`udd+ Etw wldk sht lard
aeakghkdg wld ghnwuckd wlaw wld tkcrdu~aj c~
a }ls~cnaj udajcws* ~h bau a~ wlaw odak~ a
udajcws wlaw phuick` a~ a tkcrdu~aj nak d|c~w
ckgd}dkgdkwjs hb ockg+ Dcwldu sht wluhp
wld phui hb ockg hk wld ~lhtjgdu~ hb a
}ls~cnaj udajcws* akg wldudes wuak~bhuo wld
jawwdu btkgaodkwajjs* hu sht nhkkdnw cw pcwl
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 39/88
>2 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
wld kawtud hb ockg a~ jcrck` ck wld nhkwdkw~*
akg wldk sht lard aeakghkdg wld ghnwuckd
hb }dwucbcdg hu d|wua/odkwaj tkcrdu~aj~+ Wh
udnh`kc~d wld tkcrdu~aj a~ udaj* plcjd icjjck`
akg ~wtbbck` cw* c~ wh agocw a njaco plcnl sht
udbt~d wh ~awc~bs+ Wld udajcws hb wld tkcrdu~aj
c~ a ~tbbcncdkw }uhhb% wlaw wld hefdnw~ hb ockg
oas ed ajcrd pcwl cw~ rcwajcws+
Wld ~dnhkg }hckw c~ wlaw hb wld wduwcaus
qtajcwcd~* wh plcnl pd udbduudg aehrd+ Cw c~
a bdawldu ck wld na} hb udndkw udajc~o wh lard
`crdk wld ~dnhkgaus qtajcwcd~ wldcu gtd+ Etw
ldud cw~ anlcdrdodkw ot~w dkg+ Cw c~ co}h~/
~cejd hk wld ~aod }ucknc}jd wh gh ft~wcnd wh
wld wduwcaus qtajcwcd~* ~as* edatws hu gdjc`lw/
btjkd~~+ Cb sht ud~durd akswlck` bhu a ockg
~wuc}}dg hb hefdnwcrd nhkwdkw~* sht ot~w* a~
udajc~o agocw~* ud~durd }jda~tud akg }ack+
Etw cb ~h* ajj qtajcwcd~ ckrhjrck` }jda~tud akg
}ack aud ockg/gd}dkgdkw* akg kh }ls~cnaj
udajc~o nak udnh`kc~d wldo a~ udaj+ Akg sdw*
ck wutwl* wlds aud wld oh~w anwtaj* oh~w
}uhbhtkgjs ckldudkw* oh~w hefdnwcrdjs nlauan/
wduc~wcn qtajcwcd~ hb ajj+ Akg pldwldu }ack
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 40/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ >0
akg }jda~tud aud ~dk~d/nhkwdkw~ hu khw* C
wlcki cw la~ eddk }uhrdg co}h~~cejd wh
~d}auawd wldo ck wudawodkw buho ~dk~d/
nhkwdkw~ dcwldu a~ djdodkw~ hb bddjck` hu a~
hefdnw~ hb dohwchk+ Z+ Sht ot~w dcwldu a~~c`k
~dk~d/nhkwdkw~ wh wld ockg* hu ad~wldwcn
nhkwdkw~ wh }ls~cnaj udajcws+ %#
,ccc+# Pd lard eddk }tu~tck` wluht`lhtw
wld cgda hb nhkwcktcws ck ickg edwpddk ockg
akg cw~ hefdnw~+ Cw la~ a}}daudg wh t~ wlaw
a~ jhk` a~ a ~drduaknd }udracj~* a ft~w
d~wcoawd hb udajcws/rajtd~ c~ co}h~~cejd+ Hk
wld hkd ~cgd pd lard a na}tw ohuwtto9 hk
wld hwldu ak do}ws ~skwldwcn btknwchk+
Wld wpdkwcdwl/ndkwtus udajc~o plcnl la~
eddk htu `tcgd la~ nauucdg htw wlc~ cgda hb
nhkwcktcws t} wh wld }dktjwcoawd ~wd}+ @udaw
a~ ~ddodg wh ed cw~ agraknd edshkg dnjdnwcn
hu oawducajc~wcn udajc~o~* cw ~wcjj ~ddodg wh t~
wh bacj ck gc~naugck` wld ja~w wuand hb dnjdn/
wcnc~o+ Akg wldudbhud pd a~idg htu~djrd~ cb cw
pa~ khw* bhu ~hod uda~hk hb }ucknc}jd* tkaejd
wh nho}jdwd cw~ }huwuasaj hb a udajcws aw hknd
~hjcg akg rcwaj+ Akg wld uda~hk plcnl ~t`/
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 41/88
>< WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
`d~wdg cw~djb pa~* wlaw cw kd`jdnwdg wh dkqtcud
ckwh wld nhkgcwchk~ hb ~djb/d|c~wdknd+
Bhu ldud* C ao nhkrckndg* akg khw ck wld
bajjancd~ plcnl lard hbwdk eddk khwdg a~ wld
ea~c~ hb ~tefdnwcrd cgdajc~o* jcd~ wld btkga/
odkwaj `uhtkg bhu }janck` ockg ck wld ndkwud
hb udajcws+ Akg* drdk ck wld na~d hb ~te/
fdnwcrd cgdajc~o* C ao ~tud wlaw wld `dktckd
jh`cnaj ohwcrd c~ wld ~aod ck }ucknc}jd+ Cw
c~ khw wld bacjtud wh gc~wck`tc~l edwpddk ak
anw akg ak hefdnw hb ockg+ Cw c~ khw aks
~co}jd }udftgcnd wlaw ockg nak a}}udldkg
hkjs plaw c~ a }auw hb cw~djb+ Etw cw c~ wld
ck~c`lw‗ak ck~c`lw ~te~wakwcajjs ft~w‗wlaw
a tkcrdu~d ~drdudg bcugo wld jcbd hb ockg
nak kdrdu btjbcj wld nhkgcwchk~ hb ~djb/
d|c~wdknd+ Pd ~ap wlaw wh hrdujhhi wld
nlauanwdu hb ockg plcnl edau~ hk wlc~ }hckw*
pldk ~wawck` wld ~co}jd~w banw~ hb }dund}/
wchk* c~ wh ed oc~jdg ae ckcwch+ Ockg c~ ajpas~
a phujg9 cw~ hefdnw~ aud ajpas~ bua`odkw~+
Wlc~ kawtud* wld kawtud hb edck` a phujg
hu plhjd* c~ plaw C waid wh ed wld nhkgcwchk
hb ~djb/d|c~wdknd+ Cw c~ ak hjg au`todkw bhu
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 42/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ >3
ohkagc~o hu }ak}~snlc~o wlaw khwlck`
nak ~wucnwjs ed wudawdg a~ edck` aw ajj* plcnl
ghd~ khw }h~~d~~ a ~djb+ Htu ghnwuckd
d|wuanw~ wld jh`cnaj }ucknc}jd hb wlc~ au`t/
odkw* a~ gc~wcknw buho a nduwack ~dkwcodkwaj
eca~ ck barhtu hb a ~}cucwtaj ~hncdws+ Nhk/
~cgdu* bhu ck~waknd* ]jawh'~ Cgda~* plcnl htu
udajc~w la~ waidk a~ ws}cnaj hb wld oh~w udaj
akg oh~w co}huwakw hb ajj }ls~cnaj banw~+
Nhk~cgdu* cb wlc~ c~ udajjs wldcu }jand* wld wa~i
wlds lard wh btjbcj* a~ ]jawh ckgddg nhkwckt/
ajjs ud}ud~dkw~ cw‗wld btknwchk hb nhkncjca/
wchk hb ajj nhkwuaucd~* wld ud~hjtwchk hb ajj
}uhejdo~* wld nho}jdwchk hb ajj bua`odkwauc/
kd~~* wld ~s~wdoawc~awchk hb ajj ae~wuanwchk~
ckwh a ohud wlak hu`akcn nhknudwdkd~~+
Ckgc~}dk~aejd nhkgcwchk~ hb wld btjbcjodkw
hb ~tnl a btknwchk aud tkqtd~wchkaejs* aw wld
rdus jda~w* udwdkwchk wh jdw kh djdodkw guh}
htw* nho}ud~dknd wh oackwack d|}jcncw tkcws*
nhkwcktcws wh oaid drdus }auw }duodawd drdus
hwldu* akg nhknudwd hu bhnt~~dg edck` wh
wuak~ndkg ~}and akg wcod+ Akg ajj wlc~
odak~ ockg+ Wldud nak ed kh nhknudwd
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 43/88
7= WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
plhjd etw a plhjd ndkwduck` ck ockg* akg kh
~djb/d|c~wdkw plhjd etw a nhknudwd plhjd+ C
gh khw a}}daj wh wld cgda hb % ~djb*% aw jda~w
ck cw~ ntuudkw ~dk~d+ H}ckchk~ gcbbdu* bhu
d|ao}jd* a~ wh pldwldu ~hncdws la~ a ~djb 9 akg
wldudbhud cw c~ njdau wlaw wld khwchk hb ~djb
c~ whh ckgdbckcwd wh t~d ck d~waejc~lck` wld
khwchk plcnl rdueajjs a}}daj~ wh cw‗wld
khwchk hb ~djb/d|c~wdknd hu hb a ~djb/oackwack/
ck` plhjd hb d|}ducdknd+
Lhp wldk gh pd nho}aud wld udajcws wlt~
nhkndcrdg pcwl wld phujg hb wld }ls~cnaj
udajc~w8 Pd oas cjjt~wuawd es ak hjg
gd~nuc}wchk hb oawwdu a~ odk~ ohodkcakda*
wlaw c~* C ~t}}h~d* a~ plaw udajcws phtjg ed
cb wld nhkgcwchk~ hb cw~ btjj akg d|}jcncw
nhknudwdkd~~ pdud udohrdg* akg cw~ udwdkwchk
akg nhkwcktcws ntw ghpk wh a rakc~lck` }hckw+
Pd lard oh~w hb t~ anwtaj d|}ducdknd hb
~hod ~tnl ~wa`d~ a~ pd }a~~ tkgdu wld
ckbjtdknd hb ak akad~wldwcn* pldk nhkwcktcws
ck ~}and akg wcod* nhknudwd ~s~wdo* udwdkwcrd/
kd~~* aud `uagtajjs pc}dg htw* akg pd bddj
htu~djrd~ ~wa`d es ~wa`d udgtndg buho ockg
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 44/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 7C
wh cw~ rakc~lck` }hckw ck ehgs+ Wld kawtud
hb wld ~djb/d|c~wdkw plhjd c~ wldk edck` es
gd`udd~ d|wck`tc~ldg ck t~+ ^t}}h~d* bdu
cobh~~cecjd* wlaw wld tkcrdu~d nhtjg ed
akad~wldwc~dg9 wldk* ck wld ~aod pas* wld
nhkgcwchk~ hb cw~ nhknudwd udajcws akg ~djb/
d|c~wdknd phtjg ed `hkd+
'Etw* cw oas ed hefdnwdg*Tw~ ae~wuanw udajcws_
a~ a oa~~ hb ck~dkwcdkw oawwdu* phtjg }du~c~w
akg d|c~w khkd wld jd~~ tkabbdnwdg es wld
d|wcknwchk hb nhk~ncht~kd~~+
,Bcu~w* lhpdrdu* pd lard wh nhk~cgdu pldwldu
pd ikhp wlaw ak ae~wuanw udajcws nak }du~c~w
es cw~djb+ {# Wlh~d plh waid wld co}dund}wc/
ejd~ hb ~ncdknd a~ wld ae~hjtwd ws}d hb plaw
c~ udaj oc`lw ldud lard ~hodwlck` wh ~as+
Etw wld }ls~cnaj udajc~o plcnl la~ eddk htu
`tcgd* wh`dwldu pcwl htu hpk awwcwtgd wh cw*
jdag t~ wh a gcbbdudkw }h~cwchk+ Wld udajcws
hb tkcrdu~aj~* a~ aj~h wlaw hb ~dnhkgaus* akg*
ck htu rcdp* hb wduwcaus qtajcwcd~* nhtjg khw
ed ~d}auawdg buho wlaw hb wld oh~w nhknudwd
~djb/d|c~wdknd* c+d+* buho wld kawtud hb ockg
hu d|}ducdknd+ Ak akDd~wldwc~dg tkcrdu~d*
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 45/88
75 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
annhugck` wh wlc~ ghnwuckd* phtjg ed gc~~hjrdg
akg jdard khw a uani edlckg+ Bhu wld
}ucoaucd~* a~ pd lard ~ddk* ~wakg hk wld ~aod
`uhtkg pcwl wld ~dnhkgaucd~ akg wduwcaucd~+
Khp wlc~ nhknjt~chk c~ ck kh pas guapk buho
nhkbt~ck` wld anw~ hb ockg~ pcwl wldcu
hefdnw~+ Cw c~ khw guapk buho wlck`~ edck`
ockg/gd}dkgdkw* a~ nhjhtu oas ed hk wld anw
hb ~c`lw* wlht`l nduwackjs pd nakkhw lhjg
wldo nho}jdwd tkjd~~ ajj wldcu nhkgcwchk~ aud
}ud~dkw+ Cwf®Xguapk uawldu* hkdfoc`lwX~as*
buho wldcu edck` ockg/nho}hkdkw6 wlaw c~*
}h~~d~~ck` a jh`cnaj kawtud hu co}jcncw tkcws*
plcnl bckg~ nho}jdwchk hkjs ck[wld bhnt~;+hb
uocc>0plcnl* ck wtuk* cw nhkgcwchk~+ Wld udaj
tkcrdu~aj* plcnl pd nhk~cgdudg aehrd* akg
htu akajs~c~ hb wld jcbd hb ejtdkd~~* aud na~d~
ck }hckw+
Kd|w* plaw c~ htu nhknjt~chk pcwl ud`aug
wh Odkwajc~o8 Odkwajc~o c~ a baj~d bhuo
hb Cgdajc~o }uhbbdudg a~ cw~ ~t}}huw* pcwl wld
ud~tjw wlaw wld ~aod udbtwawchk c~ ldjg wh
ckrhjrd wldo ehwl+ Wld qtd~wchk a~ ~wawdg
ck wduo~ hb Odkwajc~o ~ddo~ wh ed plhjjs
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 46/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 7>
ed~cgd wld }hckw hb ockg'~ udjawchk wh cw~
hefdnw~+ Wld hefdnw~ hb bckcwd ockg‗ockg
hwldu wlak bckcwd nhtjg laugjs lard ak hefdnw
‗aud* annhugck` wh wldXrcdp fwh plcnl htu
au`todkw la~ jdg t~* kdcwldu ockg~ khuX®uh/
gtnw~ hb ockg* khu ~wawd~ hb ockg* khu ck aks
~dk~d d|nd}w a~ }auw~ ck nhkwua~w pcwl plhjd~*
aud wlds ~dnhkgaus akg jd~~ anwtaj agftknw~
hu agfdnwcrd~'hb ockg~+ Wlds aud kdnd~~aus
wh ockg~* a~ ockg~ aud wh wldo* akg aud
gc~nucockawdg es a nhkntuudkw }uhnd~~ pcwlck
wld ~aod whwajcws+ Wlds aud d|wdukaj* akg
wlht`l udjawcrd wh ockg aud khw odkwaj hu
}~snlcnaj ck ~d+ Wlds aud }auw~ hb plhjd~
hu hb a plhjd* plcnl nak hkjs ed tjwcoawdjs
~djb/d|c~wdkw wluht`l wld btjj/`uhpk kawtud
hb ockg+ Etw wldk* a~ wld kawtud hb ockg c~
aehrd ajj wlck`~ wh ed a plhjd* pldk pd ~as
wlaw hefdnw~ aud }auw~* pd anwtajjs ~as wlaw
~h bau wlds aud khw odkwaj+ Wld ohud aks/
wlck` c~ a bua`odkw hu ak ae~wuanwchk* wld jd~~
cw c~ hu edjhk`~ wh a ockg+ Wlc~ jdag~ wh a
}auagh| plcnl ~ddo~ wh od ajj co}huwakw ck
gdajck` pcwl odkwajc~o+ Waid wld na~d hb
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 47/88
77 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
wld }ls~cnc~w'~ oawwdu+ Cw c~* bhu htu rcdp*
}ldkhodkaj* hu drdk d}c}ldkhodkaj ,C hpd
wlc~ jawwdu d|ndjjdkw }auagh|* C edjcdrd* wh
]uhbd~~hu ^whtw#+ Cw c~ ak hefdnw `ackdg es
cgdaj nhk~wutnwchk akg ckbdudknd* plcnl c~ hb
nhtu~d hkd a~}dnw hb a gc~nhrdus hb wld udaj
banw* ~djdnwdg pcwlck wld tkcrdu~d a~ annhtkw/
ck` bhu ~hod }auw hb cw~ edlarchtu+ Khp ft~w
ednat~d wlt~ ~djdnwdg* nhk~wutnwdg akg gc~/
nucockawdg es wlht`lw* cw c~ cw~djb
‗~as wld
co}dund}wcejd hb ~ncdknd‗a~ bau udohrdg a~
}h~~cejd buho akswlck` wlaw nhtjg ed ldjg
wh ed odkwaj+ Cw la~ kh ~dnhkgaus qtajcwcd~
akg kd|w wh khkd wlaw aud }ucoaus+ C ~t}}h~d
wldud c~ kh uda~hk wh ghtew wlaw cw ud}ud~dkw~
~hod anwtaj edlarchtu pcwlck wld ~s~wdo hb
kawtud9 etw cw c~ hercht~js udohrdg a~ bau a~
}h~~cejd buho wld nhkgcwchk~ hb whwajcws hu
~djb/d|c~wdknd* wlaw c~* hb ockg+ Cb sht waid
}ls~cnaj kawtud a~ htu }ls~cnaj udajc~w whhi
cw* akg khw a~ wld co}dund}wcejd~ hb ~ncdknd*
wlaw a}}uhanld~ ohud kdaujs wh ockg* ednat~d
cw c~ ohud kdaujs nhknudwd+ Etw wh ~as wlaw
wld co}dund}wcejd~ hb ~ncdknd aud udaj* ednat~d
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 48/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 74
wlds ud}ud~dkw a edlarchtu pcwlck wld tkcrdu~d*
akg aud na}aejd hb edck` ckbduudg es wlht`lw
akg hb edck` ak hefdnw hb ockg* c~ hkd wlck`9
wh ~as wlaw wlds }auwaid hb a odkwaj kawtud
akg lard a njaco wh ~te~wakwcrd ~djb/d|c~wdknd
bdu ~d phtjged qtcwd++akQwl+d|*wlck`+
%%Sht nak nhk~cgdu a }huwchk hb wld edlarchtu
hb a ~s~wdo hk cw~ hpk oducw~* pcwl udbdudknd
wh cw~ ~}dncaj btknwchk* pcwlhtw nhoocwwck`
shtu~djb wh wld edjcdb wlaw cw nhtjg ed udaj
a}auw buho wld plhjd ~s~wdo* hu wlaw cw
agdqtawdjs gc~}jas~* pcwlck cw~djb* wld qtajcws
hb wld ~s~wdo+ HeYdnw~ qbXfbckcwdXoogf‛ck
~lhuw* akg bckcwd ockg~ wldo~djrd~* aud ehtkg*
abwdu htu gc~nt~~chk hb }ls~cnaj udajc~o* wh
~wucid t~ a~ gdwacj~[ hb udajcws d~~dkwcajjs nhk/
wcktht~ pcwl danl hwldu akg*[ udnc}uhnajjs
ckgc~}dk~aejd+ Etw sdw aks hefdnw }cnidg
htw akg c~hjawdg pcwlo wld plhjd c~ dh c}~h
khw/odkwaj* bhu sht lard waidk cw a}auw
buho wld jcbd hb wld plhjd* akg lard* es
ae~wuanwchk* icjjdg akg ~wtbbdg cw bhu d|aocka/
wchk+
Wh }tw a }hckw t}hk htu nhknjt~chk a~
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 49/88
72 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
ud`aug~ wld jckd edwpddk ockg akg cw~ hefdnw~*
C oc`lw ~t}}h~d os~djb nlajjdk`dg ck wduo~
hb wld ghnwuckd hb ikhpjdg`d agrhnawdg es
wld udajc~w+ Plaw aud pd wh ~as hb ikhp/
jdg`d8 C~ cw odkwaj* hu }ls~cnaj* hu kdcwldu8
Lard sht* ck wld na~d hb ikhpjdg`d* ldud
wld ockg* oagd t} hb do}ws anw~ akg cknjcka/
wchk~* akg wldud hrdu a`ack~w cw wld udaj wlck`*
~as* a }ls~cnaj hefdnw a~ }dundcrdg hu udodo/
edudg8 Hu lard sht* pcwlck akg a~ }auw hb
wld ockg* ~hod nhkwdkw hu odkwaj btukcwtud*
plcnl* edjhk`ck` wh wld ockg* sdw c~ }auw hb
akg ckbhuo~ sht aehtw wld udaj }ls~cnaj
~}awcaj hefdnw ,wh waid wlc~ ~ck`jd na~d# plcnl
sht aud ~tud c~ wldud akg }jas~ cw~ }auw
ckgd}dkgdkwjs hb plaw sht wlcki aehtw cw8
Hocwwck` wld ~}dncaj na~d hb ~dk~d/nhkwdkw~
hk plcnl C bhjjhp hk wld plhjd wld ^w+
Akgudp~' nhkwdkwchk ,plcjd nhkrckndg wlaw hk
wld wd~w qtd~wchk hb duuhu pd nak ajj ed ~te/
~wakwcajjs a`uddg#* C ak~pdu wlaw a~ a oawwdu
hb }ucknc}jd cw udajjs oaid~ kh gcbbdudknd
buho plcnl dkg sht a}}uhanl wld banw~+ Cb
sht ~as 6 ikhpjdg`d c~ do}ws ockg }jt~
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 50/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 70
}ls~cnaj hefdnw~* akg wldudbhud c~ }ls~cnaj9
wldk sht ot~w ~tefhck* akg htu }ls~cnaj
udajc~w ghd~ oh~w btjjs akg naudbtjjs ~tefhck*
wlaw cw c~ }ls~cnaj hefdnw~ ~h bau hkjs a~ os
hu`akc~o nak udndcrd wldo* ~h bau a~ osjcadohus akg odkwaj ~s~wdo nak udrcrd akg
ckwdu}udw wldo* ~h bau a~ os }du~hkaj
ckna}ancws ghd~ khw waid wldo aw nuh~~
}tu}h~d~ akg oc| hkd pcwl akhwldu+ Cb sht
}udbdu wh ~as* ikhpjdg`d c~ wld ~s~wdo hbudajcws a~ udnhk~wutnwdg akg ~whudg t} pcwlck
os ockg* akg c~ }auw hb os ockg* akg c~ a
odkwaj ~s~wdo 9 wldk sht ot~w ~as ck aggcwchk
wlaw wld kaod hb ikhpjdg`d edjhk`~ wh wlc~
odkwaj ~s~wdo ~h bau hkjs a~ cw }ud~dkw~ wh t~wld phujg akg cw~ nho}hkdkw~ a~ wlds nho/
}jdwdjs akg kdnd~~aucjs aud+ Ck dcwldu na~d cw
c~ co}h~~cejd wh hocw wld %~h bau hkjs*% akg cb
sht udwack cw sht aud khw a ~ck`jd lacu'~ eudagwl
kdauduwh udajcws ck wld bhuodu ~wawdodkw wlak
wld jawwdu* khu wh odkwajc~o ck wld jawwdu wlak
ck wld bhuodu+ Plaw ~}dncaj t~d hu `ack c~
wldud ck ~asck` wlaw ikhpjdg`d c~ }ls~cnaj*
pldk sht lard wh ~tefhck ak djaehuawd
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 51/88
7< WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
d|}jakawchk agocwwck` ckwh wlc~ }ls~cnaj
udajcws ajj wld c`khuaknd* duuhu~ akg cjjt~chk~
wlaw wld bddejd~w hu oh~w bakwa~wcn hb ockg~
nhtjg ed `tcjws hb 8 Hu plaw `ack bhu odk/
wajc~o c~ wldud ck wudawck` ikhpjdg`d a~ a }auw
hb shtu ockg* pldk sht ot~w ~as ck wld ~aod
eudawl wlaw cw c~ hkjs ikhpjdg`d ck rcuwtd hb
wld udajcws wlaw a}}dau~ ck cw8 Wld ghtejd
ckawtud hb ikhpjdg`d* a~ wld nhkwcktcws hb
Yockg akg udajcws* c~ wld tjwcoawd wutwl wh
ck~c~w hk+ Wld gc~wcknwchk edwpddk udajcws
a~ cw c~ akg a~ pd a}}udldkg cw c~ abwdu ajj
ckduagcnaejd* akg dcwldu ~wawdodkw btjjs akg
dqtajjs ck~c~w~ hk cw+
Bckajjs* wldk* sht `ack khwlck` ck }ucknc}jd
es wld wdkdw hb wld g}dk ghhu‗wlaw c~* wlaw
wlck`~ paji ckwh shtu ockg akg hu`akc~o
ft~w a~ wlds aud htw~cgd cw‗akg sht jh~d
khwlck` es cw~ h}}h~cwd* wlaw c~* wlaw shtu
hu`akc~o* plcnl sht nakkhw ~d}auawd buhocw~
ockg* c~ hkd hb wld nhkgcwchk~ plcnl wlck`~
udqtcud bhu wld oakcbd~wawchk hb wldcu nho/
}jdwd edck`+ Wld bhuodu ~ddo~ wh od a
`uawtcwht~ ls}hwld~c~* udnhoodkgdg hkjs es
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 52/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 73
a bajjans plcnl nhkbt~d~ % ckgd}dkgdkw hb%
pcwl % ck ae~wuanwchk buho+% Nhkwcktcws hb
wld udaj phujg pcwl ockg ~ddo~ wh od wld
ckdrcwaejd `haj akg njcoa| hb wpdkwcdwl ndk/
wtus }ls~cnaj udajc~o* a~ h}}h~dg wh dnjdnwcn
oawducajc~o+ Cb wld hefdnw c~ wh ed udaj ck cw~
btjkd~~* a~ cw c~ wld oducw hb wlaw ghnwuckd wh
abbcuo* cw ot~w ed oackwackdg ck nhkkdnwchk
pcwl cw~ nho}jdwd nhkgcwchk~+ Wh wus akg
ls}h~wa~c~d cw a}auw buho hu`akc~o~ pcwl
wldcu ockg~ c~ ck os ftg`odkw ak dra~chk hb
wld wa~i jacg t}hk t~ es wld augtht~kd~~ hb
udajcws+ Udajcws* C tu`d* c~ ajpas~ hk aldag*
pldud wld btjjdu nhkgcwchk~ aud bhnt~~dg+
Ae~wuanwchk c~ aeakghkodkw hb wld qtd~w+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 53/88
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 54/88
^C
A]]DKGC\+
HK ^HOD ]HCKW^CK WLD ODWA]LS^CN AKG JH@CN HB
%WLD KDP UDAJC^O+%
C+
Odwa}ls~cn akg D}c~wdohjh`s+
^cknd* es wld nhtuwd~s hb wld ]tejcnawchk~
Nhoocwwdd* C ao }duocwwdg wh ~tefhck akA}}dkgc| wh os Jdnwtud* C bddj wlaw C ht`lw wh
~as a phug ck d|}jakawchk hb wld bhhwkhwd hk
}+CC+
A~ C lh}d wld Jdnwtud la~ ~lhpk* C ~so}awlc~d
~wuhk`js ck oaks ud~}dnw~ pcwl wld Kdp Udajc~o+
Ohud }auwcntjaujs C pdjnhod wld nucwcnc~o hb %wld
nutgd eucnieaw khwchk hb }ls~cnaj hefdnw* %[ akgplaw C lh}d pcjj }uhrd wh ed wld udnwcbcnawchk
hb ~hod ntuudkw rcdp~ hb co}jcnawchk[ 9 akg*
hb nhtu~d* wld }hckw~ ck plcnl wld atwlhu~
~dduk aw hkd pcwl ]uhbd~~hu Ajd|akgdu+ Akg C
nak ~dd wlaw wlds aud aw lhod ck ud`chk~ hb ~ncdknd
plcnl C nakkhw dkwdu+
1+ >01 bc+
5+ ^dd edjhp hk Jh`cnaj ]uchucws+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 55/88
45 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
Hk wld hwldu lakg* C ao nho}djjdg wh lhjg*
wlaw ck qtd~wchk~ hb bcu~w }ucknc}jd~ wlds lard
khw udajjs oagd wldcu hpk wld ~wakg}hckw akg
ckwdkwchk hb ohgduk odwa}ls~cnaj wldhus +[ Wlc~
~t``d~wchk C ot~w cjjt~wuawd bau whh eucdbjs+ Bhu
C ~lajj `crd `udawdu ~}and* }dula}~ * wlak cw
oducw~* wh a ~wtgs plcnl hkjs ~t}}huw~ wlc~
h}ckchk ck a ~dnhkgaus gd`udd* akg plcnl C
}tu~tdg ck wld bcu~w ck~waknd ednat~d hb plaw
~ddodg wh od cw~ ckwuck~cn ckwdud~w* akg wld
ick~lc} hb wld atwlhu~' rcdp pcwl ak hjg wdkdw
hb os hpk+ Wld ~tefdnw hb wlc~ ~wtgs* plcnl
bhjjhp~ wld }ud~dkw ~dnwchk* c~ %Jh`cnaj ]uchucws+%
Cb akswlck` ck cw~ au`todkw c~ ~htkg* wld atwlhu~'
ghnwuckd c~ kh ghtew ck ~hod gd`udd ~lhpk wh
udqtcud ohgcbcnawchk* etw c~ ckgcnawdg* aw wld ~aod
wcod* wh nhkwack ak co}huwakw djdodkw hb tkud/
nh`kc~dg wutwl+
Wld ndkwud lhpdrdu* hb wld ~c| atwlhu~' }hjdocn
gcudnwdg* a~ C tkgdu~wakg* a`ack~w wld Cgdajc~o
hb wh/gas* c~ nhkndukdg pcwl wld btkgaodkwaj
}h~cwchk plcnl cw c~ ldjg wh a~~c`k wh D}c~wdoh/
C+ C ~lhtjg ftg`d wlaw wldcu }lcjh~h}lcnaj wuackck`*
plcnl c~ rdus jcidjs ohud wlhuht`l wlak htu~* hu* ~as*
wlak ockd* d+`+* ck wld gdwacj hb Iakw* la~ khw gcudnwdg
cw~djb ~h otnl wh wld plhjd wd|w akg nhkwd|w* bcu~w hb
akncdkw* akg ~dnhkgjs hb qtcwd udndkw odwa}ls~cn+
Wldud c~ kh co}uh}ucdws* C wlcki* ck ~asck` wlc~+ Cw c~ a
rdus kawtuaj gcbbdudknd9 akg C ao ae~hjtwdjs nduwack*
khw buho wldcu pucwck` ajhkd* wlaw cw c~ wld banw+ Wldcu
wuackck` la~ dkaejdg wldo wh nhkwucetwd rdus ~t``d~wcrd
khrdjwcd~ wh }lcjh~h}ls+ Wlaw c~ ohud wlak oh~w
}dh}jd lard ghkd+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 56/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 4>
jh`s+[ Wlc~ co}danlodkw c~ ckgcnawdg ck wldCkwuhgtnwchk ,}+ 12* pldud D}c~wdohjh`s c~ ~c`kc/
bcnakwjs nht}jdg pcwl ]~snlhjh`s#* akg tkgdu wld
wcwjd % Wld Doaknc}awchk hb Odwa}ls~cn~ buho
D}c~wdohjh`s% bhuo~ wld ~tefdnw hb Ou+ Pajwdu
Oaurck'~ D~~as plcnl ~wakg~ bcu~w ck wld rhjtod+
Lc~ }ucknc}aj wld~c~* C waid cw* c~ wlc~ 6 %Wld bcu~w
akg oh~w }uhockdkw wdkdw hb wld nucwcnc~w oas ed~wawdg wlt~ 6 Cka~otnl a~ ajj ~ncdknd~ aud na~d~ hb
ikhpjdg`d wld ~ncdknd plcnl ckrd~wc`awd~ ikhpj/
dg`d a~ ~tnl c~ btkgaodkwaj* akg c~* ehwl ck banw
akg ck uc`lw* a nucwcqtd hb ajj ~ncdknd+% ,]+ 41+#
Nho}aud %Wldud ot~w ed a ~ncdknd }uchu wh ajj
hwldu~* drdk wh Jh`cn* plcnl ~lhp~ wld }h~~cecjcws
hb ikhpck`+% ,]+ 2=* nb+ @uddk* ncwdg edjhp }+
40+# Wlc~ }hjdocn C ~t}}h~d wh ed nhkkdnwdg
pcwl wld awwcwtgd waidk t} ck ~tnl a ~wawdodkw a~
wld bhjjhpck` ,Ckwuhgtnwchk* }+ 5=#+ %Wld Cgdajc~w
c~ phkw wh uda~hk wlaw ajj }lcjh~h}ls akg ajj
~ncdknd ot~w ed etcjw t}hk wld hkd banw wlaw kh/
ehgs nak oaid aks tknlajjdk`daejd a~~duwchk
aehtw akswlck` d|nd}w lc~ larck` ak coodgcawd
d|}ducdknd+%
C+ C ~t}}h~d wlaw wlc~ c~ wld % d}c~wdohjh`cnaj duuhu
plcnl tkcwd~% 6 %~tnl pucwdu~ a~ Bcnlwd akg Eduidjds*
Ou+ Euagjds akg ]uhbd~~hu I+ ]dau~hk+% % Kdp
Udajc~o% ,}+ 1=#+ Wld }hjdocn a`ack~w wld a~nuc}wchk
hb a btkgaodkwaj }h~cwchk wh D}c~wdohjh`s c~ gcudnwdg
a`ack~w wld %nucwcnc~w% dh khockd ,}+ 4= khwd#+ Etw C
`awldu wlaw ajj hb t~ plh anikhpjdg`d a nhk~cgduaejd
gdew wh Ld`dj aud jto}dg a~ % nucwcnc~w~*% wlaw c~* C
tkgdu~wakg* a~ ~lauck` pcwl Iakw ak awwdo}w wh d~wae/
jc~l a btkgaodkwaj ~ncdknd* nhk~c~wck` ck D}c~wdohjh`s*
akg }uchu wh Jh`cn akg Odwa}ls~cn~+ Wlc~ cgdkwcbcna/
wchk ~ddo~ wh od qtcwd d|anwjs puhk`+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 57/88
47 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
Wld plhjd odakck` C waid wh ed wlaw +wld
Cgdajc~w hu Nucwcnc~w c~ a ~tefdnwcrc~w* akg ~wauw~
buho %Ikhpjdg`d% ,lhp cw ~lhtjg ed ikhpjdg`d
C nakkhw nhkndcrd# a~ a fto}ck`/hbb }jand wh `dw
anuh~~ a `a} wh udajcws+ Wld }h~~cecjcws hb wlc~
ocuanjd ld c~ nhkndukdg wh gdohk~wuawd es a ~ncdknd
gdajck` pcwl ikhpjdg`d a~ ~tnl Ycw phtjg ed ft~w
khw a~ ~tnl* C ~lhtjg lard wlht`lw_ akg }uchu whlc~ wldhus hb Udajcws+ A wldhus* hk wld hwldu
lakg* plcnl* wudawck` hb bcu~w }ucknc}jd~ hb Udajcws*
cknjtgd~ ck cw~ wudawodkw ak annhtkw hb nh`kcwchk
akg wutwl* c~ khw* a~ C tkgdu~wakg wld qtd~wchk*
d}c~wdohjh`s ck wlc~ cknucockawdg ~dk~d+ Cb C
ao puhk` ck os tkgdu~wakgck` hb wld }hjdocn*
hb nhtu~d
oscoodgcawd nucwcnc~o hb cw nda~d~ wh
a}}js+ Etw os annhtkw hb ohgduk ~}dntjawcrd
}lcjh~h}ls* C rdkwtud wh wlcki* udoack~ wld hkjs
wutd hkd+
Wld }uchucws ajjd`dg wh ed a~~c`kdg wh D}c~wd/
ohjh`s* C ~t}}h~d* c~ waidk a~ nhkkdnwdg pcwl
wld }uchucws plcnl wld Cgdajc~w ,%Nucwcnc~w%# c~
edjcdrdg wh a~nuced wh coodgcawd d|}ducdknd+ Lded`ck~ buho lc~ hpk ockg* akg la~ wh eucg`d a
`tjb wh udajcws+'[
Cb C ao uc`lw ck waick` wlc~ wh ed wld wutd edau/
ck` akg ckwdkwchk hb wld Udajc~w'~ nucwcnc~o a~
gcudnwdg* ~as[ a`ack~w wlh~d hb t~ plh anikhpj/
dg`d a ~}dncaj gdew wh Ld`dj* C ot~w lhjg wlaw
wld nhknjt~chk c~ ckdrcwaejd+ Wld }h}tjau nhk/
nd}wchk hb %}~snlhjh`cnaj cgdajc~o% ,Pajjand'~}lua~d hb ud}tgcawchk# la~ ck wlc~ nucwcnc~o eddk
ck~tbbcncdkwjs gc~wck`tc~ldg buho wld awwcwtgd hb
plaw Ld`dj najj~ Jh`cn* @uddk Odwa}ls~cn~* akgOu+ Euagjds* C wlcki* wld ~wtgs hb bcu~w }ucknc}jd~+
Plaw aw hknd aoavdg od ck wld }hjdocn edbhud t~
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 58/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 44
pa~ wld nhkwcktaj nhjjc~chk edwpddk cw~ ~wawd/
odkw~* akg }a~~a`d~ plcnl nuhpgdg ckwh osockg ck plcnl @uddk* Pajjand* akg Ou+ Euagjds
‗wh odkwchk kh ohud wlak wld~d‗~ddodg oh~w
~lau}js akg ck wldcu plhjd aco akg odwlhgwh gc~~hncawd wldo~djrd~ buho plaw C tkgdu/
~wakg es D}c~wdohjh`s+c Annhugck` wh os
tkgdu~wakgck` akg nhkrcnwchk* wld plhjd ohrd/odkw buho Ld`dj ghpkpaug~* akg oh~w d|}jcncwjs
@uddk'~ nhkwucetwchk wh wld ohrdodkw ck Dk`jakg*
pa~ a udrhjtwchk a`ack~w }~snlhjh`cnaj cgdajc~o
akg d}c~wdohjh`s* larck` otnl ck nhoohk pcwl
plaw wld udajc~w~ aud khp ohud do}lawcnajjs
awwdo}wck`+ Os rcdp hb wld ~cwtawchk pa~ d|/
}ud~~dg ck 1<<4* pldk C ~acg wlaw wld }jak hb wld`udaw oa~wdu~ la~ eddk lakgdg hrdu wh ed nauucdg
htw }cdndodaj es wld fhtukdsodk 9 akg C ~wcjj
edjcdrd wlc~ rcdp wh ed ~htkg+ Cb C nhtjg wuak~bdu*
bhu d|ao}jd* ckwh wlc~ A}}dkgc| a nht}jd hb
}a`d~ buho Pajjand'~ %Ckwuhgtnwhus D~~as~%wh Ld`dj'~ %]lcjh~h}ls hb Ockg*%[ C udajjs
1+ ^dd }udrcht~ }a`d+ C ud}daw wlaw C tkgdu~wakg esD}c~wdohjh`s ck wld ~dk~d plcnl C ud}tgcawd a wldhus
hb ikhpjdg`d plcnl c~ khw ~co}js a }huwchk hb a `dkduaj
wldhus hb Udajcws+ C gh khw* bhu ck~waknd* nhk~cgdu oshpk phui ck Jh`cn wh ed D}c~wdohjh`cnaj* akg lard
kdrdu t~dg wld wduo hu anqtcd~ndg ck cw~ t~d+ C pa~
naudbtj wh d|njtgd wld cgda+ Rhj+ c* }}+ 5 akg >+
5+ ]}+ nccc/cr+ ]uhbd~~hu Ajd|akgdu'~ }hckw aehtw wld
odakck` hb najjck` ak hefdnw ak cgda* bhu ck~waknd* c~
ldud ~wawdg }udnc~djs a~ ld ~wawd~ cw+ C gh khw wlcki
wlaw ck ohgdo Odwa}ls~cn hu Jh`cn cw la~ drdu eddk ck
ghtew+ ^dd* d+`+* os %D~~dkwcaj~ hb Jh`cn*% }+ 15* hu
Euagjds hk % plaw c~ ~hodwcod~ najjdg Cgdajc~o*%
%A}}dauaknd*% }+ 573+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 59/88
42 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
wlcki wlaw btuwldu gc~nt~~chk phtjg ed kddgjd~~+
Wld ~}dntjawcrd }lcjh~h}ldu hu odwa}ls~cncak*
~h bau a~ C ikhp* a~~tod~ khwlck`* ae~hjtwdjs
khwlck`* d|nd}w wlaw* ck wlckick`* ld la~ wh
~awc~bs lc~ wldhudwcnaj pakw+ % Etw a~ wh plaw
pcjj ~awc~bs* C lard hb nhtu~d kh ikhpjdg`d ck
agraknd Wld odwlhg njdaujs c~ d|}duc/
odkwaj+ %[ Cw c~ udajjs ak d|wuahugckaus wlck`wlaw hkd ~lhtjg oddw pcwl ~tnl a ~wawdodkw a~ wlaw
plcnl C ncwdg buho Ckwuhgtnwchk* }+ 5=* aehtw wld
tknlajjdk`daejd a~~duwchk+ C~ cw khw wld pdjj/phuk
akg baocjcau ghnwuckd hb ~}dntjawcrd }lcjh~h}ls*
buho ]jawh akg Ld`dj ghpkpaug~* wlaw ndu/
wackws nhod~ aw wld dkg hb wlht`lw hu nh`kcwchk
akg khw aw wld ed`ckkck`9 a~ wld ud~tjw hb ~ncdkndakg odwa}ls~cn akg khw a~ wldcu bhtkgawchk 8 C~
cw }dula}~ nhkwdkgdg wlaw pd ot~w lard cw ck wld
ed`ckkck` cb pd aud wh lard cw ck wld dkg 8 Cb ~h*
pd aud nhkbuhkwdg pcwl hkd hb wld phu~w hb jh`cnaj
rcnd~* plcnl C pcjj najj %Bhtkgawchkc~o*% akg C
ot~w agocw wlaw C lard ~t~}dnwdg htu atwlhu~ hb
lauehtuck` cw+[ Etw nhk~cgdu bhu ck~waknd Ou+
Euagjds'~ Ikhpjdg`d hb wld Ae~hjtwd‗C }ud/
~tod wld hkjs }uh}h~cwchk~ plcnl ld phtjg nhk/
~cgdu tknlajjdk`daejd 9 wld ud~tjw hb a jaehucht~
dkqtcus ckwh bcu~w }ucknc}jd~+[ A~ ud`aug~ plaw
pd daujs nhod wh edjcdrd ck hk `hhg `uhtkg~*
edck` hkjs htu }ud~dkw d|}ducdknd‗
% lc~ larck`
ak coodgcawd d|}ducdknd%‗Ou+ Euagjds'~ au`t/
odkw a`ack~w ^hjc}~c~o& ~ddo~ wh od wh akkclcjawd
1+ Euagjds* %Ockg*% 1311* }+ >=2+
5+ %Wld Kdp Udajc~o*% }+ 3>* akg ck oaks hwldu
}a~~a`d~+ Nb+ os %Jh`cn*% dg+ 5* cc* 522 khwd akg udbD+
>+ Os hpk %Jh`cn*% ~tnl a~ cw c~* c~ hb nhtu~d ak
awwdo}w wh doehgs wlc~ rcdp ck a gdwacjdg ~s~wdo+
7+ %A}}dauaknd akg Udajcws*% 547 ^+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 60/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 40
wld ~t``d~wchk a~ bau a~ ld c~ nhkndukdg+ Bhu cw
nhk~c~w~ ck }hckwck` htw wlaw pd aud nhkrckndg hb
wld d|c~wdknd hb hwldu ndkwud~ hb d|}ducdknd hk wld
~aod `uhtkg~ akg pcwl wld ~aod uc`lw a~ hb htu
hpk+
Etw sht edjcdrd* cw oas ed udfhckdg ,~dd
ncwawchk aehrd buho }+ 2=#* wlaw wldud c~ a ~ncdknd
}uchu wh ajj hwldu~* drdk wh Jh`cn* plcnl la~ bhu
cw~ wa~i wh ~lhp wld }h~~cecjcws hb ikhpck`+
W+ L+ @uddk ~ddo~ wh lard akwcnc}awdg wlc~
~t``d~wchk* akg cw pcjj ed phuwl plcjd wh nhk~cgdu
cw tkgdu lc~ `tcgaknd+ Akg wldk* abwdu wlc~ oh~w
co}dubdnw ~wtgs hb wld }hckw* ~}and pcjj nho}dj
od wh eudai hbb+
@uddk[ nduwackjs ud`augdg cw a~ nhock` pcwlck
lc~Wa~i wh ak~pdu wld qtd~wchk %lhp ikhpjdg`d
c~ }h~~cejd+% Wlc~* ld }hckwdg htw* %c~ khw wh ed
nhkbt~dg pcwl a qtd~wchk hk plcnl odwa}ls~c/
ncak~ aud ~hodwcod~ ~t}}h~dg wh pa~wd wldcu wcod+
%C~ ikhpjdg`d }h~~cejd8% %Odwa}ls~cn~ c~ kh~tnl ~t}dubjtht~ jaehtu+% Cw c~* ld nhkwcktd~* a
wldhus hb wld ~s~wdo hb wlck`~ plcnl ,~s~wdo#
udkgdu~ cw }h~~cejd bhu wlck`~ wh ed annhtkwdg bhu
hk wld ~t}}h~cwchk hb wldcu udjawchk wh danl hwldu+
Ld nhkwua~w~ wlc~ dkqtcus ck wld oack pcwl
}~snlhjh`s akg }jackjs aj~h pcwl aks wldhus hb
ikhpjdg`d plcnl c~ }h~~cejd pcwlhtw a wldhus hb
wld wlck` ikhpk+ Cw c~ wld ~aod gc~wcknwchk
plcnl Ou+ Euagjds co}jcd~ ck lc~ udbdudknd* plcnl
C ajpas~ whhi wh ed nhkwdo}wtht~* wh % D}c~wd/
C+ % Phui~*% c* >04 bD+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 61/88
4< WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
ohjh`s+%[ Pajjand ,V+ n+# agh}w~ }udnc~djs wld
~aod awwcwtgd*[
@uddk ckwdkgdg* edshkg aks uda~hkaejd ghtew*
a udlaecjcwawchk hb Jh`cn akg Odwa}ls~cn~ a~
a`ack~w ]~snlhjh`s akg Wldhus hb Ikhpjdg`d
nhk~cgdudg a~ ckgd}dkgdkw ~ncdknd~+ Ld }uh/
nddg~* a~ pd ajj gh* khw es }uchu a~~to}wchk~ hb
}udoc~~d~ bhu gdohk~wuawchk‗a odwlhg* C ~lhtjg
nhkwdkg* co}h~~cejd bhu a ~htkg jh`cncak* akg
@uddk pa~ ak d|nddgck`js ~htkg hkd‗etw es
C wusck` wh nhk~wutnw a nhknd}wchk plcnl phtjg
oh~w nho}jdwdjs lauohkc~d pcwl wld banw~[ akg ~h
abbhug wld nho}jdwd~w wldhudwcnaj ~awc~banwchk+
Hb nhtu~d* ld gcg khw gdks wld d|c~wdknd hb
d|wdukajcws* khw drdk hb tknhk~ncht~ d|wdukajcws+&
Ld ldjg* lhpdrdu wld nhkrcnwchk* ck plcnl C
a`udd pcwl lco* wlaw sht nhtjg khw lard a phujg
pcwlhtw nhk~ncht~kd~~ a~ cw~ ndkwud+ Ldud* C ao+
`jag wh tkgdu~wakg* wld kdp udajc~w }ucoaucjs
gcbbdu~ ednat~d ld ~t}}h~d~ aks rcdp jcid @uddk'~
wh ed ak tkpauuakwdg a~~to}wchk ae ckcwch+ Ld
1+ d+`+* %Ockg*% 13==* }+ >3 khwd+ C wlcki ld tkc/
bhuojs ck~c~w~ wlaw wldud nak ed kh wldhus hb ikhpjdg`d
d|nd}w a~ }auw hb akg ck nhkkdnwchk pcwl a nho}jdwd
wldhus hb Udajcws* nb+ d+`+* %Ockg*% 1311* }+ >>0+
>+ C+d+ ~t}ua+ Gu+ OnWa``auw* C ht`lw wh agocw* udbdu~
pcwl ckwdud~w wh D}c~wdohjh`s 9 etw lc~ Cgdajc~o c~
nduwackjs bau buho ^tefdnwcrc~o+ ^dd %^wtgcd~ ck
Ld`djcak Gcajdnwcn*% 15=+
>+ %]uhjd`hodka wh Dwlcn~*% ~dnw+ <5* 107+
7+ %Phui~*% c* ><=9 cc* 12+ Hk wld d|c~wdknd hb
Kawtud edshkg bckcwd }dund}wchk* ~dd Euagjds* %A}}dau/
aknd*% 50> ®D+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 62/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 43
jdard~* ~h wh ~}dai* a bc`lwck` nlaknd bhu ~tnl a
ghnwuckd* abwdu wld kawtud hb wld phujg la~ eddk
nhk~cgdudg+ [ Wlc~ C wlcki c~ bacu* akg C ~lhtjg*
bhu os~djb* annd}w wlaw c~~td9 akg C edjcdrd wlaw
ohgduk odwa}ls~cn* akg @uddk'~ odwlhg* c~
pcwl od+
Hkd ohud he~durawchk edauck` hk os }ucoaus
wld~c~ ck wlc~ ~dnwchk+ C bckg hk }+ 101 a udbdudknd
wlt~ phugdg6 %wld au`todkw ,Euagjds'~# wlaw
aks akg ajj gcrdu~cws* akg ~h aks akg ajj udjawchk~
hb aks akg ajj wduo~ aud ~djb/nhkwuagcnwhus+% Nb+
wld a|cho aehtw udjawchk~* waidk ~ddock`js a~
}dntjcau wh udajc~w~* }+ 700+ C ot~w wlcki wlaw
ldud ck~tbbcncdkw ~wtgs hb a `udaw pucwdu c~ ud/
rdajdg+ Ck wld bcu~w }jand gcrdu~cws c~ }ud~dkw*
annhugck` wh Ou+ Euagjds a~ C udag lco* ehwl ck
}ucoaus bddjck` akg ck wld Ae~hjtwd+ Ck wld
kd|w }jand* lc~ awwcwtgd wh udjawchkaj gcrdu~cws c~
udajjs* cw ~ddo~ wh od* qtcwd ~co}jd+ Ld* hb
nhtu~d* ~h bau buho udfdnwck` ajj gcrdu~cws* pa~
hkd hb wld bcu~w plh bht`lw bhu akg d~waejc~ldg
wld }ucknc}jd hb cgdkwcws ck gcrdu~cws ck Dk`jc~l/}lcjh~h}ls+ Cw pa~ lc~ `udaw nhkwdkwchk+ Lc~
ehhi~ aud btjj hb cw+ Plaw ld ck }ucknc}jd udbt~d~
wh annd}w C tkgdu~wakg wh ed eaud nhkftknwchk [
wlaw c~* wld euck`ck` wh`dwldu hb gcbbdudkw~* pcwl/
htw odgcawchk es aks akajs~c~ hb wldcu nhkgcwchk~
~awc~banwhus wh wlht`lw+ Rdus jcidjs kh ~tnl
akajs~c~ c~ tjwcoawdjs akg nho}jdwdjs ~awc~ban/
whus+ Etw drdus ~ncdknd* ~tudjs* ck gacjs }uanwcnd*
gdoakg~ ajj hb cw wlaw nak ed hbbdudg* akg udfdnw~
C/ ]+ >5+
5+ %A}}dauaknd akg Udajcws*% }+ 2==* nb+ 40= ,dg+ 5#+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 63/88
2h WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
udjawcrdjs eaud nhkftknwchk~* wlaw c~* ~tnl nhk/
ftknwchk~ a~ aud }ud~dkwdg es do}cucnaj he~dura/
wchk~+ C~ wldud aks oak hb ~ncdknd* plh* ck lc~
gacjs phui* akg a}auw buho }lcjh~h}lcnaj nhkwuh/
rdu~s* pcjj annd}w a eaud `crdk nhkftknwchk a~
nhkndcraejs tjwcoawd wutwl 8 ,^dd ]uhbd~~hu
Lhe~hk'~ aggud~~* ncwdg edjhp* }+ 2<+#
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 64/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 2
CC+
Jh`cnaj ]uchucws+
C bckg ~hod gcbbcntjws ck udnhkncjck` pcwl danl
hwldu* akg pcwl wld wuagcwchkaj utjd~ hb Bhuoaj
Jh`cn* wld ~wawdodkw~ pcwl ud`aug wh Co}jcnawchk
wluht`l plcnl wld gdbckcwchk hb Jh`cnaj ]uchucws/
c~ a}}jcdg* ck wld phui edbhud t~* wh gcbbdudkw
na~d~+ C wlcki wlaw wldud c~ aw jda~w a }ucoa bancd
he~ntucws plcnl c~ phuwl }hckwck` htw+ Os }ud/
gc~}h~cwchk c~ barhtuaejd ck hkd ~dk~d wh wld kdp
Udajc~w~* Bhu C ao cknjckdg wh wlcki wlaw wld
oh~w hercht~ gcbbcntjws plcnl C ~lajj ckgcnawd
auucrd~ buho wldcu udnh`kcwchk hb a }hckw ck plcnl
wld wuagcwchkaj utjd~ hb co}jcnawchk aud aw batjw*
ck a pas wh plcnl C lard budqtdkwjs guapk awwdk/
wchk+ Hk wld hwldu lakg* cb C ao uc`lw* wld
ghnwuckd hb Jh`cnaj ]uchucws phtjg ed ck ~hodgd`udd abbdnwdg+'
C waid ckwh nhk~cgduawchk wludd }a~~a`d~ ck wld
ehhi plcnl ~ddo wh od wh a`udd9 akg aj~h wph
}a~~a`d~* nhkwcktht~ pcwl wld bcu~w akg wlcug hb
wld wludd* plcnl ~ddo wh od wh ckwuhgtnd a
gcbbdudkw }hckw hb rcdp* cknhk~c~wdkw pcwl wlaw hb
wld bhuodu }a~~a`d~ akg pcwl cw~djb* wlht`l* C aonhkrckndg* nhkwackck` ak co}huwakw wutwl+
Wld wludd }a~~a`d~ bcu~w odkwchkdg aud ,a# }+
74* buho wld phug~ %Bcu~w* hkd ~ncdknd*% wh }+ 72*
dkgck` pcwl wld phug~ %udqtcudg qtakwcws hb
au~dkcn%9 ,e# }+ 115* %Cw c~ co}huwakw% ghpkwh %wld }udoc~d~ ed baj~d%9 akg ,n# }}+ 5=7/4*
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 65/88
25 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
% Jh`cnaj }uchucws oas ed gdbckdg % ghpk wh
%ajwlht`l nhkrdu~djs* khw+%
Wld wph }a~~a`d~ plcnl C nhkwua~w pcwl wld~d
aud ,g# }+ 72*% Otnl hb oawldoawcn~ % ghpk wh
wld phug~ hk wld ~aod }a`d'
' odnlakcn~ akg
}ls~cn~ ot~w ed baj~d%9 akg ,d# hk }+ 5=4* wld
~dkwdknd ed`ckkck` % Wlt~* a }uh}h~ % akg
dkgck` % }tud oawldoawcn~ ,aucwlodwcn#+% ^dd
aj~h }}+ 55= akg 554* plcnl ~t``d~w ak do}cucnaj
ea~c~ bhu wld ghnwuckd hb ,g# akg ,d#+
]a~~a`d~ ,a# akg ,n# ~wawd wld ghnwuckd hb
Jh`cnaj ]uchucws*[ akg }hckw htw cw~ a}}jcnawchk*
ck }dubdnw a`uddodkw pcwl danl hwldu* akg nhk/
~c~wdkwjs pcwl wld wuagcwchkaj utjd~ hb Bhuoaj
Jh`cn+ Ldud c~ }a~~a`d ,a# 6 % Es Jh`cnaj]uchucws c~ odakw wlaw udjawchk plcnl lhjg~
edwpddk a }uh}h~cwchk akg cw~ kdnd~~aus nhkgc/
wchk+ Wlt~ cb A co}jcd~ E* etw E ghd~ khw co}js
A* wldk E c~ wld kdnd~~aus nhkgcwchk hb A9 bhu
A'~ wutwl gd}dkg~ t}hk E'~ wutwl+ Wlaw c~*
~lhtjg E }uhrd wh ed baj~d* A ot~w ed baj~d 9 akg
wlht`l A ed baj~d* sdw E oas }uhrd wutd 9 bhu pdaud ~asck` odudjs wlaw A'~ wutwl c~ a ~tbbcncdkw
nhkgcwchk hb E'~ wutwl* akg aud khw oackwackck`
wlaw cw c~ wld hkjs nhkgcwchk* hu a kdnd~~aus nhk/
gcwchk+ Bhu d|ao}jd* jdw t~ a~~tod cw wh ed
wutd wlaw cb wld wc~~td~ hb a oak'~ ehgs ae~hue a
nduwack aohtkw hb au~dkcn* ld ot~w gcd9 wlaw wldud
c~ kh }udrdkwck` nat~d dcwldu ikhpk hu tkikhpk+
Wldk drcgdkwjs bhu cw wh ed wutd wlaw wlc~ oak'~
C+ Wld ghnwuckd c~ hkd a}}audkwjs hercht~ wh nhoohk/
~dk~d* akg wld gdbckcwchk oc`lw ed ehuuhpdg buho
Auc~whwjd* O+ < 11* 1=13 a 5+ /cu}hk}a ha/a+ C^d|dWac dwrac*
ardr a\icar* dIdcra <d arcr cIdwrchr (|#f+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 66/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 2>
ehgs la~ ae~huedg ~tnl ak aohtkw hb au~dkcn* cw
ot~w ed wutd wlaw wld oak c~ gdag 9 plduda~ wld
odud banw hb lc~ gdawl ghd~ khw }uhrd wlaw oaksakhwldu }h~~cejd nat~d c~ khw wld anwtaj nat~d+
Ck ~lhuw* ' Wld oak c~ gdag ' c~ jh`cnajjs }uchu
wh wld }uh}h~cwchk* wld wc~~td~ hb lc~ ehgs lard
ae~huedg wld udqtcudg qtakwcws hb au~dkcn+%
,Wlc~ c~ wld plhjd hb }a~~a`d ,a#+ ]a~~a`d ,n# c~
otnl ohud `dkduaj* etw nhkwack~ khwlck` wh nja~l
pcwl cw+#
Drdus hkd ~dd~ aw hknd wlaw pd aud ldud gdajck`
pcwl wld udjawchk hb akwdndgdkw wh nhk~dqtdkw ck
a khuoaj ls}hwldwcnaj ftg`odkw* pldud co}jcna/
wchk c~ ~wawdg annhugck` wh wld wuagcwchkaj utjd
plcnl `hrduk~ ajj co}jcnawchk akg nhkrdu~chk ck
Bhuoaj Jh`cn+ Wutwl hb akwdndgdkw co}jcd~
wutwl hb nhk~dqtdkw9 wutwl hb nhk~dqtdkw ghd~
khw co}js wutwl hb akwdndgdkw+ Cw c~ wld ~aodrcdp hb co}jcnawchk plcnl agocw~ }jtuaj hu ajwdu/
kawcrd nat~d~*[ a~ ckgddg wld aehrd }a~~a`d ck/
~c~w~+
Cb pd khp d|wdkg htu nhk~cgduawchk wh }a~~a`d,e# ,}+ 115#* pd ~dd wlaw* wlht`l wld pucwdu ghd~
khw udoaui t}hk wld qtd~wchk hb Jh`cnaj ]uchucws*
sdw ld wudaw~ }udnc~djs wld ~aod co}jcnawchk~ a~
lhjgck` `hhg* ck annhugaknd pcwl wld hugckaus
utjd* edwpddk wld }acu hb }udoc~~d~ hb a
~sjjh`c~o akg cw~ nhknjt~chk+ Wld wutwl hb
wld wph }udoc~~d~ co}jcd~ wlaw hb wld nhknjt/
~chk+ Wld wutwl hb wld nhknjt~chk ghd~ khw
co}js wlaw hb wld wph }udoc~~d~+ Ck wlc~ ud~}dnw
nhknjt~chk c~ wh }udoc~~d~ a~ nhk~dqtdkw wh
C+ Khwd wlaw hk }+ 115 Nat~aj Gd}dkgdknd c~ a~~todg
wh ed udnc}uhnaj+ Akg nb+ }+ 5>4+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 67/88
27 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
akwdndgdkw+ Cw c~ %wld co}jcdg*% wld kdnd~~aus
nhkgcwchk hb wldcu wutwl+ Wlds aud %wld co}jcdu+%
Cw c~ njdau wldk wlaw es wlc~ gdbckcwchk* a}}jcdg
wluht`l wlc~ ~wawdodkw hb co}jcnawchk~* wld nhk/
njt~chk hb drdus ~sjjh`c~o c~ jh`cnajjs }uchu wh
cw~ }udoc~~d~+
Khp jdw t~ wtuk wh }a~~a`d~ ,g# ,}+ 72# akg ,d#
,}+ 5=4#+ ]a~~a`d ,g# pcjj `crd t~ ajj pd pakw+]a~~a`d ,d# odudjs nhkbcuo~ cw+
Cw aohtkw~ wh wlc~+ Oawldoawcn~ aud jh`cnajjs
}uchu wh Odnlakcn~ akg ]ls~cn~+ YC ~lajj ud}ud/
~dkw Oawldoawcn~* ck wlc~ au`todkw* es Oa9Odnlakcn~ akg ]ls~cn~ es Od+_ Wlaw c~ wh ~as*
Oa ghd~ khw co}js wld wutwl hb Od* etw Od ghd~
co}js wld wutwl hb Oa+ ^h ,c# Od oc`lw ed baj~d,otnl hb cw[# pcwlhtw Oa edck` baj~d 9 etw ,5# cb
Oa pdud baj~d* wldk Od phtjg ed baj~d+
Ldud wld `dkduaj gdbckcwchk hb Jh`cnaj ]uchucws
c~ wld ~aod a~ wlaw btjbcjjdg es Nhk~dqtdkw ck
udjawchk wh Akwdndgdkw akg Nhknjt~chk ck udjawchk
wh ]udoc~~d~* nhk~cgdudg ck annhugaknd pcwl wld
wuagcwchkaj utjd~ hb Bhuoaj Jn[`cn+
C+ Wlc~ ud~durawchk nak oaid kh gcbbdudknd+ Wld
wph udqtcudodkw~ plcnl bhjjhp buho wld jh`cnaj }uchucws
hb Oa wh Od ot~w hercht~js bhjjhp ck ud~}dnw hb wld
~aod djdodkw~ hb Od* rcv+* wlh~d wh plcnl Oa c~ }uchu+
Akg wld~d djdodkw~ hb Od aud gdwduockdg es hkd hb wld
udqtcudodkw~ a~ ud~tjw~ hb ak %d|}jcncw gdgtnwchk% buho
Oa‗ud~tjw~ ~h ~wucnw wlaw wld baj~cws hb wld oawldoa/
wcnaj }udoc~~d~ Oa pcjj ckrhjrd wldcu baj~cws+ Wlt~ sht
nakkhw annhtkw bhu wld udqtcudg }h~~cejd baj~cws hb Odplcjd Oa c~ wutd* es ~t}}h~ck` wlaw ~hod }auw hb Odgd}dkg~ hk a baj~d }udoc~~ ckwuhgtndg ckwh wld nlack
aw a }hckw jhpdu ghpk wlak Oa+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 68/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 24
Etw pd lard wh khwd wlaw pd aud a}}jsck` cw wh
a gcbbdudkw na~d+ Od c~ %ak d|}jcncw gdgtnwchk%
buho Oa ,wlc~ c~ ~}dncajjs kdnd~~aus ck hugdu wh
oaid ,5# lhjg `hhg#+ Wlaw c~ wh ~as* ck wlc~ na~d
wld Jh`cnaj ]uchucws c~ wlaw hb ]udoc~~d~ wh wldcu
Nhknjt~chk+ Akg wld ~aod udqtcudodkw~ hb wld
gdbckcwchk hbJh`cnaj ]uchucws lard wh ed ~awc~bcdg
ck wlc~ na~d a~ pdud ~lhpk wh ed ~awc~bcdg ck wld
udjawchk~ hb Nhk~dqtdkw wh Akwdndgdkw akg hb
Nhknjt~chk wh ]udoc~~d~+ Wlt~ Jh`cnaj ]uchucws
c~ a~nucedg ehwl wh ]udoc~~d~ hrdu Nhknjt~chk
akg wh Nhknjt~chk hrdu ]udoc~~d~+ Hercht~js*
wldk* wldcu udjawcrd co}jcnawchk~ ot~w ed gcbbdu/
dkwjs ~wawdg wh ~t}}huw wld~d wph nhkbjcnwck`
}udwdk~chk~ wh ]uchucws9 akg pd ~lajj ~dd lhpwlc~ c~ ghkd+
Bhu ldud cw c~ a~~duwdg wlaw ,c# wutwl hb ]ud/
oc~~d~ ,Oa# ghd~ khw co}js wlaw hb Nhknjt~chk
,Od#9 etw wlaw ,5# wutwl hb Nhknjt~chk ,Od#
co}jcd~ wutwl hb ]udoc~~d~ ,Oa# 9 ck hwldu phug~*
,~dd ,c# akg ,5# hk }+ 27# wlaw ,c# Nhknjt~chk
,Od# oc`lw ed baj~d* pcwlhtw ]udoc~~d~ ,Oa#edck` baj~d 9 akg wlaw ,5# cb ]udoc~~d~ ,Oa# pdud
baj~d* wld Nhknjt~chk ,Od# ot~w ed baj~d+
Wh abbcuo wld~d co}jcnawchk~ hb Nhknjt~chk akg
]udoc~~d~ ud~}dnwcrdjs c~ bjawjs wh nhkwuagcnw wld
wuagcwchkaj utjd~ hb Bhuoaj Jh`cn* plcnl ~as wlaw
cb wld Nhk~dqtdkw hu Nhknjt~chk c~ baj~d wld
Akwdndgdkw hu hkd ]udoc~~ aw jda~w ot~w ed baj~d*ck hwldu phug~+ Wutwl hb Akwdndgdkw hu ]udoc~~d~
co}jcd~ wlaw hb Nhk~dqtdkw hu Nhknjt~chk 9 etw
wlaw wld baj~dlhhg hb wld Akwdndgdkw hu ]udoc~~d~
ghd~ khw ckrhjrd wlaw hb wld Nhk~dqtdkw hu
Nhknjt~chk* ck hwldu phug~* Wutwl hb Nhknjt~chk
hu Nhk~dqtdkw ghd~ khw co}js wlaw hb ]udoc~~d~
hu Akwdndgdkw+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 69/88
22 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
Akg wld~d wuagcwchkaj utjd~ pdud wldbhtkgawchk
hb a~nuceck` jh`cnaj }uchucws wh hkd na~d hb co}jcdg
}uh}h~cwchk ,Nhk~dqtdkw hu Nhknjt~chk# hrdu cw~
co}jcdu ,Akwdndgdkw hu ]udoc~~d~#+
Wldudbhud cw ~ddo~ njdau wlaw wld utjd~ hb co}jc/
nawchk es plcnl Jh`cnaj ]uchucws c~ a~nucedg wh
Nhk~dqtdkw akg Nhknjt~chk hrdu Akwdndgdkw akg
]udoc~~d~ aud ck bjaw nhkwuagcnwchk pcwl wlh~d esplcnl cw c~ a~nucedg wh ]udoc~~d~ hb gdgtnwchk
hrdu cw~ Nhknjt~chk+
Cw c~ ~tu}uc~ck`* }ucoa fagd* wlaw Jh`cnaj
]uchucws ~lhtjg ed a~nucedg wh Nhk~dqtdkw hrdu
Akwdndgdkw* akg wh Nhknjt~chk hrdu ]udoc~~d~+
Etw wld gdbckcwchk hb Jh`cnaj ]uchucws* akg aj~h
ajhk` pcwl wld utjd~ hb co}jcnawchk wuagcwchkaj
akg Bhuoaj Jh`cn* jdard~ kh d~na}d+
Hk wld hwldu lakg* wh hewack plaw ~ddo~ }ucoa
bancd ohud kawtuaj* wld Jh`cnaj ]uchucws hb wld
]udoc~~d~ hrdu Nhknjt~chk* pd ~ap wlaw utjd~
pdud a}}dajdg wh plcnl gdbs wld wuagcwchkaj utjd~
hb jh`cnaj co}jcnawchk+
C pcjj guap htw wld nhkwua~w edwpddk wld wph~dw~ hb utjd~+
C+ Wlt~ pd lard cw ajjd`dg hk hkd ~cgd* ck
~t}}huw hb Jh`cnaj ]uchucws hb ]udoc~~d~ hrdu
Nhknjt~chk‗hb Oa hrdu Od‗ wlaw wld wutwl hb
wld ]udoc~~d~ ck ak %d|}jcncw gdgtnwchk% kddg
khw co}js wlaw hb wld Nhknjt~chk‗wld wutwl hb Oakddg khw co}js wlaw hb Od 9 c+d+* wlaw wld Nhknjt/
~chk nak ed baj~d plcjd wld ]udoc~~d~ aud wutd+
Hk wld hwldu ~cgd* ck ~lhpck` wld Jh`cnaj
]uchucws hb Nhk~dqtdkw akg Nhknjt~chk hrdu
Akwdndgdkw akg ]udoc~~d~* wld a}}daj pa~ wh wld
hugckaus utjd hb Bhuoaj Jh`cn* wlaw wutwl hb
]udoc~~d~ hu Akwdndgdkw co}jcd~ wlaw hb Nhknjt/
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 70/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 20
~chk hu Nhk~dqtdkw* c+d+* wlaw cb Nhknjt~chk huNhk~dqtdkw c~ baj~d ]udoc~~d~ hu Akwdndgdkw
nakkhw ed wutd+
Ldud wld wuagcwchkaj utjd doehgcd~ hkjs plaw
~ddo~ wld ockcoto d~~dkwcaj wh wld d|c~wdknd hb
ckbdudknd+ Cb aks kd|t~ hu ckbdudkwcaj udjawchk c~
wh ~turcrd aw ajj* co}jcnawchk ot~w ed agocwwdg wh
lhjg buho ]udoc~~d~ wh Nhknjt~chk ck akd|}jcncw
gdgtnwchk+
Wld batjw hu gcbbcntjws ot~w ed ck wld udqtcud/
odkw h}}h~dg wh wld nhoohk utjd+ Sdw cw
hercht~js doehgcd~ ~hodwlck` wlaw la~ a nduwack
ruac~doejaknd 9 akg* ckgddg* wld oack }hckw hb wld
ghnwuckd hb jh`cnaj }uchucws a~ ~tnl+ Cw ghd~ ~ddo
a~ cb sht nhtjg ~wauw pcwl ~djb/drcgdkw }udoc~~d~*
akg `dw ghpk es gdgtnwchk* pcwlhtw ~wucnwjs baj~d
}udoc~~d~*[ wh qtd~wchkaejd nhknjt~chk~‗a~ c~
ldud a~~duwdg hb Oa akg Od ud~}dnwcrdjs+
Hercht~js wld d|}jakawchk jcd~ ck wld gcbbdudknd
edwpddk }udoc~~~d~ plcnl aud eaud nhkftknwchk~
hb do}cucnaj banw* akg }udoc~~d~ plcnl aud
ud~wucnwdg wh banw~ akajs~dg ck ud~}dnw hb wldcu
nhkgcwchk~ akg ~ncdkwcbcnajjs odgcawdg es nhkgc/wchkdg abbcuoawchk~+ Bhu wld jawwdu* wld wuagcwchkaj
utjd‗akg ~hodwlck` ohud a~ pd ~lajj ~dd
udoack~ wutd ck wld jdwwdu akg ck wld ~}cucw+ Wldwutwl hb wld ]udoc~~d~ ck wld gdgtnwchk pauuakw~
wld Nhknjt~chk 9 akg wld baj~dlhhg hb wld Nhknjt/
~chk ckrhjrd~ a baj~cws ck wld ]udoc~~d~ t~dg ck
gdgtnwchk+ Etw cb eaud Nhkftknwchk~‗tkak/ajs~dg ~wawdodkw~ hb ~h/najjdg banw‗aud agocwwdg
a~ ]udoc~~d~* wld oawwdu ednhod~ aoec`tht~*
1+ Wld~d aud bhuecggdk es wld au`todkw hb khwd c*
}+ 27+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 71/88
2< WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
akg pd ~dd wld ruac~doejaknd hb wld kdp utjdplcnl c~ wh ~t}}huw wld jh`cnaj }uchucws hb wld
}udoc~~d~+ Pcwlhtw a bhuoaj eudai ck wld
gdgtnwchk* pcwlhtw ak a~~c`kaejd baj~cws ck aks}udoc~~* pd oas lard `hw buho a ud`chk hb ~djb/
drcgdknd‗~as hb aucwlodwcnaj wutwl‗wh hkd hb
qtd~wchkaejd ud~tjw~ ck aks nhknudwd ~ncdknd+
Akg pd oas d|}ud~~ htu ~dk~d hb plaw la~
edbajjdk t~ ck wld d|wuahugckaus ~wawdodkw wlaw
wld baj~cws hb Nhknjt~chk~ ck ~tnl a gdgtnwchk
phtjg khw ckrhjrd wld baj~cws hb wld ]udoc~~d~
akg ~h wld wutwl hb wld ]udoc~~d~ ghd~ khw ckrhjrd
wld wutwl hb wld Nhknjt~chk+ Pd ot~w ed wd~wck`
wld Nhknjt~chk es wld cgdaj hb ~ncdknd* akg wld
jawdu ]udoc~~d~ hkjs es wld ~wakgaug hb do}cucnaj
banw+ Eaud Nhkftknwchk c~ wlt~ ckwuhgtndg ckwh
wld rdus kdurd hb ckbdudknd*[ akg khw odudjs oagdwld hefdnw hb a }udnatwchk* a~ ck wld wuagcwchkaj
C+ Wld }hckw wlaw a uawchkaj kd|t~ c~ drduspldud
a~~todg es ~ncdknd a~ ck }ucknc}jd }h~~cejd phtjg ~ddo
whh hercht~ wh ed ck~c~wdg hk* pdud cw khw wlaw ~hod
wldhuc~w~ ~ddo cknjckdg wh annd}w wld ~turcraj hb eaudnhkftknwchk ck wld htw~icuw~ hb ikhpjdg`d a~ ud}ud~dkw/
ck` a bdawtud hb wld tkcrdu~d+ Wlc~* C waid cw* c~ Ou+
^}atjgck`'~ rcdp ,}+ 55=#+ Cw c~* c~ cw khw8 wld ghnwuckd
hb nhkwck`dkw wutwl+ Etw nak cw ed oagd nhk~c~wdkw pcwl
wld hwldu }auw hb lc~ rcdp8 ,~dd Gc`ud~~chk* }+ 0=#+ C
wldudbhud ncwd buho ak atwlhucws plh ~laud~ ck oaks
pas~ htu atwlhu~' wdkgdkncd~ ~hod drcgdknd hb wld kddg
plcnl ~ncdknd udnh`kc~d~ wh }h~wtjawd uawchkaj kd|t~*
ck }ucknc}jd* tkgdu drdus do}cucnaj he~durawchk+ %Wld
}dntjcaucws hb @dhodwus c~ wlaw cw ednaod a }tudjs
uawchkaj ~ncdknd daujcdu akg es ohud ua}cg ~wa`d~ wlak
nhtjg ed wld na~d pcwl hwldu gd}auwodkw~ hb }ls~cnaj
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 72/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 23
utjd
plcnl }uhlcecw~ wld udwuh~}dnwcrd ckbdudkndbuho wutwl hb Nhknjt~chk wh wlaw hb ]udoc~~d~* hu
hb Nhk~dqtdkw wh wlaw hb Akwdndgdkw+
5+ Wldk pd lard wld btuwldu nhkwuagcnwchk+
Ck ~t}}huwck` wld Jh`cnaj ]uchucws hb Oa hrdu
Od cw c~ jacg ghpk wlaw baj~dlhhg hb ]udoc~~d~
hb plaw nhod~ bcu~w ck ak %d|}jcncw gdgtnwchk*%
ldud Oa‗ckrhjrd~ baj~dlhhg hb Nhknjt~chk* Od
‗hb plaw nhod~ ja~w ck wld gdgtnwchk 9 ck hwldu
phug~* wlaw wutwl hb Nhknjt~chk co}jcd~ wutwl hb
]udoc~~d~+ Wld hugckaus utjd hb nhtu~d[ c~ wlaw
baj~dlhhg hb Akwdndgdkw hu ]udoc~~d~ ghd~ khw
abbdnw wutwl hb Nhk~dqtdkw hu Nhknjt~chk dcwldu
pas 9 ck hwldu phug~* wlaw wutwl hb Nhk~dqtdkw hu
Nhknjt~chk co}jcd~ khwlck` dcwldu pas aehtw
Akwdndgdkw hu ]udoc~~d~+
C+ Wlc~ utjd* pd ot~w udodoedu* pa~ udjcdg hk wh
d~waejc~l wld Jh`cnaj ]uchucws hb wld Nhk~dqtdkw ,akg
Nhknjt~chk# hrdu Akwdndgdkw ,akg ]udoc~~d~#+
ckrd~wc`awchk plcnl lard khw sdw dodu`dg buho wld
~wa`d ck plcnl do}cucnaj he~durawchk~ bhuo ak d~~dkwcajdjdodkw ck wld }uhnd~~ hb btuwlduck` htu ikhpjdg`d+%
%@dhodwus oas ed ud`augdg a~ wld ws}d wh plcnl drdus
~ncdknd oas ed d|}dnwdg wh nhkbhuo aw wld gc~wakw wcod
pldk cw la~ ednhod nho}jdwdjs uawchkaj+% % Ft~w a~
@dhodwus la~ kh kddg hb btuwldu do}cucnaj banw* nho/
}jdwdjs uawchkajc~dg ]ls~cn~ akg Nldoc~wus* a~ cgdaj
~nldod~* phtjg nhkwack pcwlck wldo~djrd~ drdus
djdodkw plcnl nhtjg ed ~t}}jcdg es }ls~cnaj he~dura/
wchk9 akg phtjg kh jhk`du ed gd}dkgdkw bhu wldcu
btuwldu }uh`ud~~ hk wld phui hb d|}ducdknd+% ]uhbd~~hu
Lhe~hk'~ Aggud~~ wh Oawldoawcnaj akg ]ls~cnaj ^hncdws
hb Tkcrdu~cws Nhjjd`d* Jhkghk* 1315+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 73/88
0= WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
Pd ~lhtjg khwd bcu~w* es pas hb gc`ud~~chk*wld udjawchk hb wld wph udqtcudodkw~ hb Jh`cnaj
]uchucws a~ a}}jcdg ck wlc~ ~aod na~d+ Ck wld
~aod %d|}jcncw gdgtnwchk*% baj~dlhhg hb Nhknjt/
~chk c~ khw wh ckrhjrd baj~dlhhg hb ]udoc~~d~* akg
baj~dlhhg hb ]udoc~~d~ c~ wh ckrhjrd baj~dlhhg hb
Nhknjt~chk 9 ck hwldu phug~* wld wutwl hb wld
]udoc~~d~ c~ khw wh co}js wld wutwl hb wld Nhknjt/~chk* akg wld wutwl hb wld Nhknjt~chk c~ wh co}js
wld wutwl hb wld ]udoc~~d~+ C~ khw wlc~ rdus laug
wh edjcdrd8 Wld d|}jakawchk hb wld wph utjd~
edck` oackwackdg wh`dwldu c~ ~tudjs wlaw ckgcnawdg
aehrd* }+ 20+ Wld bhuodu utjd nhkwdo}jawd~ wld
agoc~~chk hb eaud do}cucnaj nhkftknwchk~ ckwh wld
gdgtnwcrd nlack+ Wld jawwdu co}jcd~ wld agoc~/
~chk hb hkjs ~tnl }udnc~djs nhkgcwchkdg akg d|njt/
~crd ]udoc~~d~ a~ aud uc`lwjs ldjg‗pd ~lajj ~dd
wh ed co}jcdg ck wld Nhknjt~chk~ guapk buho
wldo+ Wlt~ pd nak aw jda~w ~dd a odakck` ck
gdksck` wld khuoaj co}jcnawchk hb wutwl hb Nhk/
njt~chk ck wlaw hb ]udoc~~d~* cb wld bhuodu* a~
doakawck` buho a eaud nhkftknwchk* `crd~ ohud
wlak a ~ncdkwcbcnajjs nhkgcwchkdg ckbdudknd phtjgpauuakw+ Akg pd nak aj~h ft~wcbs* ck a jcocwdg
~dk~d* wld co}jcnawchk buho wutwl hb Nhknjt~chk wh
wutwl hb d|njt~crd ockcoto ]udoc~~d~+ Wlc~ c~
a kdp }uh}h~aj* plcnl C pdjnhod+
Etw* udwtukck` buho wlc~ gc`ud~~chk* pd lard wh
khwd wld nhkwuagcnwchk pcwl wld hugckaus utjd* a~
~wawdg ck wld ja~w }aua`ua}l etw hkd+Ldud C oaid kh ghtew wlaw wld hugckaus utjd c~
puhk`* ck ~h bau a~ cw gdkcd~ ajj co}jcnawchk hb
]udoc~~d~ ck Nhknjt~chk+ Hb nhtu~d sht oaslard wld ~aod Nhk~dqtdknd co}jcdg es a ktoedu
hb ajwdukawcrd Akwdndgdkw~ akg wld ~aod Nhknjt/
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 74/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ 0
~chk }uhrdg es a ktoedu hb ajwdukawcrd }acu~ hb
]udoc~~d~ 9 akg cw oas wldudbhud ed au`tdg wlaw cw
c~ co}h~~cejd bhu wld wutwl hb wld Nhk~dqtdkw wh
co}js wlaw hb aks hkd Akwdndgdkw* hu hb wld Nhk/
njt~chk wh co}js wlaw hb aks hkd }acu hb ]ud/
oc~~d~+ Etw wlc~ au`todkw bhu`dw~ wlaw wld([
a}}dauaknd hb khk/udnc}uhnaj co}jcnawchk c~ ldud
gtd wh ~t}dubjtht~ djdodkw~‗eaud nhkftknwchk~
ck wld ktoduht~ ajwdukawcrd Akwdndgdkw~ akg}acu~ hb ]udoc~~d~* akg wlaw wldud oh~w nduwackjs
c~ ck drdus na~d ~hod Akwdndgdkw* nhoohk wh ajj
wld ktoedu* akg ~hod }acu hb ]udoc~~d~* tkgdu/
jsck` ajj wld ajwdukawcrd }acu~* wld wutwl hb plcnl
c~ co}jcdg ck wld wutwl hb wld Nhk~dqtdkw hu
Nhknjt~chk+ Ck %Cb ld c~ }hc~hkdg ld c~ gdag%/
gdawl ghd~ khw co}js }hc~hkck`* etw cw oh~wnduwackjs co}jcd~ wld bdawtud~ hb }hc~hkck` plcnl
aud d~~dkwcaj wh gdawl* akg nhoohk wh ajj cw~
ohgd~+ Wld a}}dauaknd ldud hb khk/udnc}uhnaj*
co}jcnawchk c~ ~co}js gtd wh wld banw wlaw pd waid
htu utjd~ buho tk~ncdkwcbcn wlht`lw+ Ck drdus
Nhknjt~chk wldud c~ ~hod }acu hb ]udoc~~d~ co/
}jcdg* ck drdus Nhk~dqtdkw ~hod Akwdndgdkw9akg udnc}uhnajjs* a~ pd ~ap* wldud c~ a ~wucnwjs
nhkgcwchkdg Nhknjt~chk co}jcdg ck drdus d|}jcncw
gdgtnwchk ck ud~}dnw hb drdus anwtaj ]udoc~~ wlaw
nak dkwdu ckwh cw* akg cb wldud ~ddo~ wh ed ak
h}dkck` bhu baj~dlhhg buho wutd ]udoc~~d~* cw c~
ednat~d eaud nhkftknwchk* wlaw c~* banw~ ckagd/
qtawdjs nhkgcwchkdg* lard eddk agocwwdg ckwh wld
nlack hb uda~hkck`+ C wldudbhud a`udd pcwl Ou+
^}atjgck`'~ annhtkw hb wld oawwdu ,}}+ 554/2#
d|nd}w wlaw plaw ld waid~ a~ hnna~chkaj banw*
a}}dau~ wh od wh ed a wutwl hb }ucknc}jd+
Wld ~wuak`d nhkwuagcnwchk edwpddk wld~d utjd~
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 75/88
05 WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK
es plcnl wld gdbckcwchk hb Jh`cnaj ]uchucws c~a}}ldg wh gcbbdudkw na~d~* c~ hkjs wh ed annhtkwdg
bhu pldk pd he~durd wlaw ck danl na~d wldud c~ ck
wld }uh}h~cwchk* agocwwdg }uh lan rcnd wh ed %wld
co}jcdu*% ~t}dubjtht~ oawwdu* es plcnl wld wutd
udnc}uhnaj co}jcnawchk c~ gc~`tc~dg* akg wdkg~ wh
}a~~ tkkhwcndg+ Etw wluht`l wlc~ co}jcnawchk*
ck }ucknc}jd ajpas~ }ud~dkw* ak djdodkw hb wld
~h/najjdg co}jcdu‗akg wlaw cw~ h}duawcrd djdodkw
‗c~ co}jcdg a~ pdjj a~ co}jcdu+
Akg wlt~ pd ~dd pls htu atwlhu~' wdkdw~ bhund
t}hk t~ wld ntucht~ ud~tjw wlaw Nhknjt~chk c~
jh`cnajjs }uchu wh ]udoc~~d~ akg aj~h ]udoc~~d~
wh Nhknjt~chk+
Cw c~ wutd* hb nhtu~d* a~ nhoohkjs wat`lw* wlaw
wld ]udoc~~d~ hu Akwdndgdkw co}js wld Nhknjt/
~chk hu Nhk~dqtdkw* plcnl c~ wldudbhud a kdnd~/
~aus nhkgcwchk hb wld hwldu~' wutwl* akg ~h bau
jh`cnajjs }uchu wh wldo+ Etw cw c~ aj~h wutd* a~
c~ khw nhoohkjs wat`lw* wlaw wldud ot~w ed ck
}ucknc}jd bhu drdus Nhk~dqtdkw hu Nhknjt~chk a
nhoohk* ockcoto* akg d|njt~crd Akwdndgdkw hu
}acu hb ]udoc~~d~* plcnl wld Nhknjt~chk huNhk~dqtdkw co}jcd~ a~ a kdnd~~aus nhkgcwchk hb
cw~ wutwl* akg wldudbhud a~ ~h bau jh`cnajjs }uchu
wh cw+ Ldud pd ~dd wld udjawcrd ft~wcbcnawchk hb wld
}tvvjck` ghnwuckd plcnl htu atwlhu~ a}}daudg wh
oackwack‗wlaw Akwdndgdkw akg ]udoc~~d~ hk wld
hkd lakg* akg Nhk~dqtdkw akg Nhknjt~chk hk
wld hwldu* aud jh`cnajjs }uchu wh danl hwldu* danl
wh danl+ Bhu danl la~ ck banw* pcwl udbdudknd wh
wld hwldu* hkd hb wld wph ajjd`dg bdawtud~ hb jh`cnaj
}uchucws* rcv+* wlaw cw c~ co}jcdg es wld hwldu* akg
c~ nhk~dqtdkwjs a kdnd~~aus nhkgcwchk hb wld
hwldu'~ wutwl+ Etw wld hwldu akg kd`awcrd bdawtud
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 76/88
OCKG AKG CW^ HEFDNW^ '_5#
hb jh`cnaj }uchucws* wld whwaj khk/co}jcnawchk hb
wld co}jcdu[ es wld co}jcdg*[ c~ hb nhtu~d cuudnhk/
ncjaejd pcwl wld co}jcnawchk plcnl a}}dau~ hkakajs~c~ wh d|c~w ck ehwl wld na~d~ pd lard gc~/
nt~~dg akg plcnl wldudbhud ot~w ed udnc}uhnaj+
Cw c~ wlc~ ajjd`dg kd`awcrd bdawtud ,gd}dkgck` hkwld agoc~~chk hb cuudjdrakncd~ ckwh wld co}jcdu[#
plcnl c~ wld nat~d hb wld nhkwuagcnwchk edwpddk
wld wph }auw~ hb htu atwlhu~' ghnwuckd+ Pcwlhtwcw* wlc~ ghnwuckd C edjcdrd c~ ehwl ~htkg akg nhk/
~c~wdkw 9 akg ajj wlaw c~ kdnd~~aus wh euck` cw~ }auw~
ckwh d|}jcncw lauohks c~ wh ~te~wcwtwd jh`cnaj
udnc}uhncws* plcnl nak ed a~nucedg wh ehwl ~cgd~ ck
wld akwcwld~c~* bhu jh`cnaj }uchucws plcnl hercht~js
nakkhw+ Wld dbbdnw hb ~tnl a ohgcbcnawcgk hk wld
wldhus hb eaud nhkftknwchk akg a jhh~d/ikcwtkcrdu~d C nakkhw ldud gc~nt~~+
1+ ^as %}hc~hkck`+% ^dd}+ >1
5+ ^as %gdawl+%
>+ Cw pa~ }hckwdg htw aehrd* }+ 20* lhp Ou+ Oaurck
nak oackwack hk wlc~ `uhtkg pcwl ~hod ruac~doejaknd
,}+ 72# wlaw wld wutwl hb wld Nhknjt~chk kddg khw ed
co}jcdg ck wlaw hb wld ]udoc~~d~9ft~w a~ cw c~ nhoohkjs
ldjg hk wld ~aod `uhtkg wlaw wld wutwl hb wld ]udoc~~d~
c~ khw co}jcdg ck wlaw hb wld Nhknjt~chk+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 77/88
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 78/88
]tejcnawchk~ hb wld Oaknld~wdu
Tkcrdu~cws
DGTNAWCHKAJ ^DUCD^
Kh+ C+ NHKWCKTAWCHK ^NLHHJ^ CK DK@JAKG AKGDJ^DPLDUD+ Wldcu }jand ck wld Dgtnawchkaj ^s~wdo hb
ak Ckgt~wucaj akg Nhooduncaj ^wawd+ Es Ocnladj D+
^agjdu* O+A+* JJ+G+* Rcnd/Nlakndjjhu hb wld Tkcrdu~cws hb
Jddg~* akg jawd ]uhbd~~hu hb wld Lc~whus akg Agockc~wuawchk
hb Dgtnawchk ck wld Tkcrdu~cws hb Oaknld~wdu+ Gdos <rh*
}}+ ||rc+ 003+ <~+ 2g+ kdw ,]tejcnawchk Kh+ 53+ 13=0+#
Kh+ CC+ WLD GDOHK^WUAWCHK ^NLHHJ^ UDNHUG+ Kh+
C+ Edck` Nhkwucetwchk~ wh wld ^wtgs hb Dgtnawchk buho
wld Gd}auwodkw hb Dgtnawchk ck wld Tkcrdu~cws hb Oak/
nld~wdu+ Es F+ F+ BcKGJAS* O+A+* ]l+G+* ^aual Bcdjgdk
]uhbd~~hu hb Dgtnawchk+ Gdos ^rh* }}+ rccc+ 152+ c~+ 2g+
kdw+ ,]tejcnawchk Kh+ >5* 13=<+#
Kh+ CCC+ WLD WDANLCK@ HB LC^WHUS CK @CUJ^'
^NLHHJ^ CK KHUWL AKG NDKWUAJ @DUOAKS+ AUd}huw es Dra Ghg`d* O+A+* @cjnluc~w ^wtgdkw+ Gdos ^rh*
}}+ \+ 173+ C^+ 2g+ kdw ,]tejcnawchk Kh+ >7* c`h<+#
Kh+ CR+ WLD GD]AUWODKW HB DGTNAWCHK CK WLDTKCRDU^CWS HB OAKNLD^WDU* 1<3=/1311+ Gdos ^rh*
172 }}+* pcwl 15 }jawd~* c~+ 2g+ kdw* }a}du9 5~+ 2g+ kdw*
njhwl+ ,]tejcnawchk Kh+ 4<* 1311+#
]tejc~ldg ck nhoodohuawchk hb wld wpdkws/bcu~w akkcrdu~aus
hb wld Dgtnawchk Gd}auwodkw+
Kh+ R+ HTWJCKD^ HB DGTNAWCHK NHTU^D^ CK OAK/NLD^WDU TKCRDU^CWS+ Gdos ^rh* }}+ rccc+ 13=+ >~+
kdw+ ,]tejcnawchk Kh+ 21+ 1311+
]tejc~ldg bhu Oaknld~wdu Tkcrdu~cws es ^lduuaww " Lt`ld~
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 79/88
OAKNLD^WDU TKCRDU^CWS ]TEJCNAWCHK^+
DGTNAWCHKAJ ^DUCD^+Kh+ RC+ WLD ^WHUS HB WLD OAKNLD^WDU LC@L
^NLHHJ^ BHU @CUJ^* 1<01/1311+ Es ^aua A+ Etu~wac*!**
O+A+* Ldag Oc~wud~~* ^}dncaj Jdnwtudu ck Dgtnawchk+ Gdos
<rh* }}+ \\+ 517+ pcwl 1< ]jawd~+ 4~+ kdw+
,]tejcnawchk Kh+ 2>* 1311+#
Kh+ RCC+ WLD GDOHK^WUAWCHK ^N]CHHJ^ UDNHUG*Kh+ 5+ Dgcwdg es F+ F+ Bckgjas* O+A+* ]l+G+* ^aual Bcdjgdk
]uhbd~~hu hb Dgtnawchk+ YCk wld ]ud~~+
JDNWTUD^Kh+ C+ @AUGDK NCWCD^ ,Pauetuwhk Jdnwtud#+ Es Uaj}l
Kdrcjjd+ I+N+ 2g+ kdw+ ,Jdnwtud Kh+ c+ 13=4+#
Kh+ CC+ WLD EAKI HB DK@JAKG AKG WLD ^WAWD,A Jdnwtud#+ Es ^cu Bdjc| ^nlt~wdu+ 2g+ kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 5+ 13=4+#
Kh+ CCC+ EDAUCK@ AKG CO]HUWAKND HB NHOODUNCAJWUDAWCD^ CK WLD WPDKWCDWL NDKWTUS+ Es ^cu+
Wlhoa~ Eaunjas+ 2g kdw+ ,Jdnwtud Kh+ >* 13=2+#
Kh+ CR+ WLD ^NCDKND HB JAK@TA@D AKG WLD ^WTGS
HB WLD @UDDI WD^WAODKW ,A Jdnwtud#+ Es Faod~Lh}d Ohtjwhk* O+A+* Jcww+G+ 2g+ kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 7* 13=2+#
Kh+ R+ WLD @DKDUAJ ODGCNAJ NHTKNCJ6 CW^
]HPDU^ AKG CW^ PHUI ,A Jdnwtud#+ Es Ghkajg
Oanajc~wdu* O+A+* O+G+* E+^n* G+N+J+* JJ+G+ 2g+ kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 4* 13=2+#
Kh+ RC+ WLD NHKWUA^W^ CK GAKWD ,A Jdnwtud#+ Es wld
Lhk+ Pcjjcao Pauudk Rdukhk* O+A+ 2g+ kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 2* 13=2+#
Kh+ RCC+ WLD ]UD^DURAWCHK HB ]JAND^ HB CKWDUD^W
HU EDATWS ,A Jdnwtud#+ Es ^cu Uheduw Ltkwdu+ 2g+
kdw+ ,Jdnwtud Kh+ 0* 13=0+#
]tejc~ldg bhu Oaknld~wdu Tkcrdu~cws es ^lduuaww " Lt`ld~
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 80/88
OAKNLD^WDU TKCRDU^CWS ]TEJCNAWCHK^+
JDNWTUD^+Kh+ RCCC+ HK WLD JC@LW WLUHPK ES UDNDKW CKRD^/
WC@AWCHK^ HK DJDNWUuncWS HK WLD UDJAWCHKEDWPDDK OAWWDU AKG DWLDU ,Agao~hk Jdnwtud#+
Es ^cu F+ F+ Wlho~hk* H+O+* G+^n* B+U+^+ 2g+ kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ <* 13=<+#
Kh+ C\+ LH^]CWAJ^* ODGCNAJ ^NCDKND* AKG ]TEJCNLDAJWL ,A Jdnwtud#+ Es ^cu Njcbbhug Ajjet|w* I+N+E+*
O+G+ ,Nakwae+# 2g+ kdw+ ,Jdnwtud Kh+ 3* 13=<+#
Kh+ \+ DK@JC^L ]HDWUS AKG @DUOAK ]LCJH^H]LSCK WLD A@D HB PHUG^PHUWL ,Agao~hk Jdnwtud#+
Es A+ N+ Euagjds* Jcww+G+ 2g kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 1=* 13=3+#
Kh+ \J WLD DRHJTWCHK HB ^TU@DUS ,A Jdnwtud#+ EsPcjjcao Wlhuetuk* B+U+N+^+ 2g+ kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 11* 131=+#
Kh+ \CC+ JDCEKCV A^ A ]HJCWCNCAK ,Agao~hk Jdnwtud#+
Es A+ P+ Paug* Jcww+G+* B+E+A+ 2g+ kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 15* 1311+#
Kh~+ \CCC akg \CR+ HJG WHPK^ AKG KDP KDDG^* es
]atj Pawdulht~d* O+A+* B+U+C+E+A+* akg WLD WHPKD\WDK^CHK ]JAK* es Uasohkg Tkpck* B+U+C+E+A+
,Pauetuwhk Jdnwtud~ 1315#+ c rhjtod+ Cjjt~wuawdg* c~+kdw+
,Jdnwtud~ Kh~+ 1> akg 17* 1315+#
Kh+ \R+ TKCRDU^CWS DGTNAWCHK BHU PHODK ,A
Jdnwtud#+ Es Ou~+ Ldkus ^cg`pcni* Jcww+G+ 2g+ kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 14* 131>+#
Kh+ \RC+ WLD GC^WCKNWCHK EDWPDDK OCKG AKG CW^HEFDNW^ ,Agao~hk Jdnwtud#+ Es Edukaug Eh~akqtdw*
O+A+* B+E+A+ ]a}du c(/ kdw* njhwl 1(2 kdw+
,Jdnwtud Kh+ 12* 131>+#
>7 Nuh~~ ^wuddw* Oaknld~wdu* akg >> ^hlh ^qtaud* Jhkghk* P+
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 81/88
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 82/88
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 83/88
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 84/88
cwo
cc'O+'cFfwccccccc!+
+*+c*f*O©c(*''&9'cF'+%c9'R (
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 85/88
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 86/88
Nhukdjj Tkcrdu~cws
Jceuaus
Wld huc`ckaj hb wjcc~ ehhi c~ ck
wckd Nhukdjj Tkcrdu~cws Jceuaus+
Wldud aud kh ikhpk nh}suc`lw ud~wucnwchk~ ck
wld Tkcwdg ^wawd~ hk wld t~d hb wld wd|w+
lww}6((ppp+aunlcrd+hu`(gdwacj~(nt>1357=3=<0213<
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 87/88
NHUKDJJ TKCRDU^CWS JCEUAUS
> 1357 =3= <02 13<
8/3/2019 Bernard Bosanquet THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN MIND AND ITS OBJECTS Manchester University Press 1913
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/bernard-bosanquet-the-distinction-between-mind-and-its-objects-manchester-university 88/88