8/13/2019 Berk Aff Wiki

1/5

CONTENTION 1: INHERENCY

CTBT Passage is inevitable Indonesian ratification created momentm!imball 1"#$(Daryl, "Indonesian Ratification of the CTBT Provides New Momentum for ntry Into!orce," Proect for the Com#rehensive Nuclear Test Ban Treaty, www$#roectforthect%t$or&'Indonesian

RatificationoftheCTBTProvidesNewMomentumforntryInto!orce)

CTBT %ill &ass' Obama is &s(ing %it( )N s&&ort'*a(l+ Fredrik. ",1- ("UN chief ups pressure on nuclear test ban holdouts."Reuters. Reuters , 2/17/2012. eb.!http//in.reuters.co#/article/2012/02/17/nuclear$test$ban$id%N&''1)0F*20120217+.-k

Crrent CTBT is not verifiable garantees c(eatingBaile. and /c(eber 11(athleen aile, senior associate at the National %nstitute forublic olic (N%, and ho#as 3cheber, 4ice resident of the N%, 5he 6o#prehensie

est an reat8n 8ssess#ent of the enefits, 6osts, and Risks9, National %nstitute for ublic olic, :/11/11,http//;;;.nipp.or

8/13/2019 Berk Aff Wiki

2/5

T5O /CEN3RIO/:

/CEN3RIO 1: R)//I3 6O*ERNI73TION

3 non#verifiable CTBT cases Rssian vertical &roliferation leads to8a&anese &rolif6edalia+ 9(>onathan, 3pecialist in National &efense Forei

8/13/2019 Berk Aff Wiki

3/5

Rssian lanc( ensres &lanetar. e=tinction

Caldicott 9"+ Founder of hsicians for 3ocial Responsibilit AGelen, The new nucleardanger, p. 7$12C

8/13/2019 Berk Aff Wiki

4/5

/CEN3RIO ": IR3NI3N PRO;I2

Crrent I6/ cannot verif. Iranian ndergrond nclear tests6edalia+ 9(>onathan, 3pecialist in National &efense Foreior

8/13/2019 Berk Aff Wiki

5/5