BEPORE THE UNITED STATES DEPARTW/BIENT OF … · 2020. 5. 8. · BEPORE THE UNITED STATES...

BEPORE THE UNITED STATES DEPARTW/BIENT OF AGIEPHCULTURE

AGMC11TILTtJRAL iJMRKETHEsTG SERWCE

In the Matter of

Milk In The Mideast

Marketing Area

: Docket Nos.

: AQ- 166-A77;

: IDA-08-09

MAPS, CHARTS, TABLES, AND RELATED DATA SUBMITTED ON BEHALF OF PROPONENTS PN SUPPORT OF PROPOSAL 1

August 19,2008 Cincinnati, Ohio

C EXHIBIT 1

Hauler Name: Consun Food 5053 Elyria, Ohio

Route Nos: 53

CP: 41.199n,-82.231 w ACTUAL ROAD MILAGE

/ MILES / P E R F 1 PAYLOAD ( (ONE WAY) 1

LESS

Exhibit The Cooperatives

Hauler Name: Consun Food 5053 Elyria, Ohio $2.20 45,000

Route Nos: 53 PAYLOAD

CP: 41.199n,-82.231~ ACTUAL ROAD

CP: 41.199n,-82.231~

Jul-03

1 (ONE WAY) I ACTUAL ROAD

J LESS

Hauler Name: Consun Food 5053 Elyria, Ohio

Route Nos: 53

36 MILES

$2.20 PER LOADED

MILE

45,000 AVERAGE PAYLOAD

Hauler Name: John McCann 5490 Mount Vernon, 0 45,000 MILES

Route Nos: . 490 PAYLOAD CP 40.376n,82.483~

ACTUAL ROAD

Ruhihir The Cooneratives

Hauler Name: John McCann 5490 Mount Vernon, 0 45,000

MILES Route Nos: 490 PAYLOAD

CP 40.376n~32.483~ ACTUAL ROAD

E x h i b i t - The Cooperatives

MILES Route Nos:

PER LOADED 490

CP 40.376n,82.483~ 1 1 MILE

(ONE WAY) ACTUAL ROAD LESS

Hauler Name: John McCann 5490 Mount Vernon, 014 Jul-03

AVERAGE PAYLOAD

36

Exhibit - The Cooperatives

$2.20

4502 May-03 Hauler Name: Schafer Dairy Farm Russia, OH $2.20 45,000

Route Nos: 308 MllAGE FROM PAYLOAD 40.129n,83.338~ (ONE WAY)

ACTUAL ROAD MILAGE TO HANDLER TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER

NO. HANDLER Z I P TO HANDLER LESS36MILES PER LOAD C WT.

0093 Holmes Cheese 44654 99.9 63.9 $140.58 $0.312

0095 Smith

0214 Trauth

0224 UDF 45212 111.8 75.8 $166.76 $0.371

0230 Wayne 47374 93.6 57.6 $126.72 $0.282

0288 Best Ever - Prairie Farms 46015 155 119.0 $261 3 0 $0.582 0445 Dannon 45865 75 39.0 $85.80 $0.191

221 7 Meyer Dairy 4521 5 101.3 65.3 $143.66 $0.31 9

3075 DFA-Louisville

3104 Flav-0-Rich

3301 Brewster

3445 Reiter -Springfield 45504 36.3 0.3 $0.66 $0.001

3446 Sunshine Biscuit 43420 107.4 71.4 $157.08 $0.349

3633 Kroger-Winchester 40392 205.5 169.5 $372.90 $0.829

5514 Deans Louisville 4021 8 21 3 177.0 $389.40 $0.865

8009 DFA-Goshen 46526 197.7 161.7 $355.74 $0.791

8031 Toft 44871 109.2 73.2 $161.04 $0.358

8049 DFA-New Wilmington 16142 204.2 168.2 $370.04 $0.822

8091 Southern Belle 42502 268.6 232.6 $51 1.72 $1.137

8109 Kroger-Springdale 45246 100.5 64.5 $141.90 $0.315

81 13 Kroger Crossroad 4621 9 157.5 121.5 $267.30 $0.594

81 14 Kroger Tamarack 43058 53.2 17.2 $37.84 $0.084

8202 Spray Dry 42141 306.6 270.6 $595.32 $1.323

8345 DKH 46540 202.3 166.3 $365.86 $0.813 Exhibit The Caooeratives

4502 Jun-03 Hauler Name: Schafer Daiw Farm Russia. OH I 36 1 52.20 1 45.000 1

Route NOS: 308 MILAGE FROM PAYLOAD 40.129n,83.338~ (ONE WAY)

ACTUAL ROAD MILAGE TO HANDLER TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER

NO. HANDLER Z I P TO HANDLER LESS36MILES PER LOAD CWT. - -

0093 Holmes Cheese

0095 Smith

0214 Trauth

0224 UDF

0230 Wayne

0288 Best Ever - Prairie Farms 0445 Dannon

2217 Meyer Dairy

3075 DFA-Louisville

3104 Flav-0-Rich

3301 Brewster

3445 Reiter -Springfield

3446 Sunshine Biscuit

3633 Kroger-Winchester

5514 Deans Louisville

8009 DFA-Goshen

8031 Toft

8049 DFA-New Wilmington

8091 Southern Belle

81 09 Kroger-Springdale

81 13 Kroger Crossroad

81 14 Kroger Tamarack

8202 Spray Dry

8345 DKH

4502 Hauler Name: Schafer Dairy Farm Russia, OH

Route Nos: 308

40.129n,83.338~ ACTUAL ROAC

ACTUAL ROAD PER LOADED MILAGE FROM I MILE

(ONE WAY) I

0093 Holmes Cheese

0095 Smith

0214 Trauth

0224 UDF

0230 Wayne

0288 Best Ever - Prairie Farms 0445 Dannon

2217 Meyer Dairy

3075 DFA-Louisville

31 04 Flav-0-Rich

3301 Brewster

3445 Reiter -Springfield

3446 Sunshine Biscuit

3633 Kroger-Winchester

5514 Deans Louisville

8009 DFA-Goshen

8031 Toft

8049 DFA-New Wilmington

8091 Southern Belle

8109 Kroger-Springdale

81 13 Kroger Crossroad

81 14 Kroger Tamarack

8202 Spray Dry

8345 DKH Exhihit The Cnnner=r i . roc

MILAGE TO HANDLER TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER NO. HANDLER Z I P TO HANDLER LESS36MILES PER LOAD CWT.

$140.58 $0.312

Hauler Name: Jay Neff 5703 New Martinsville, WV 45,000 MILES


CP 39.772N,80.112W


Hauler Name: Jay Neff 5703 New Martinsville, wv 45,000 MILES


CP 39.772N,80.112W

Hauler Name: Jay Neff 5703 New Martinsville, WV MILES


CP 39.772N,80.112W

Exhihi t The C n n n ~ r m t i ~ ~ ~ ~

6902 Hauler Name: CLIFFORD STUTZMAN Somerset, PA


CP 40.324n,78.774~

Ruhihir Thn Pnnnnr=ri..nr

6902 Hauler Name: CLIFFORD STUTZMAN Somerset, PA $2.20 45,000


CP 40.324n,78.774~

Exhibit The Coonerntivps

6902 Hauler Name: CLIFFORD STUTZMAN Somerset, PA 45,000


CP 40.324n,78.774~

Kxhihi t The C n n n ~ n r i ~ , ~ ~

3565 May-03 Hauler Name: Mayfield Somerset, KY $2.20 45,000

MILES PER LOADED AVERAGE Route Nos: 566 PAYLOAD

CP: 37.95711,-84.891~

NO. HANDLER Latitude 0214 Trauth 39.0853 0224 United Dairy Farmers 39.1518 0230 Wayne Dairy 39.8462 0228 Best Ever 40.1205

Ideal American Meyer Dairy Dean Louisville Brewster Minerva Reiter Springfield Winchester Flav-0-Rich DFA Goshen DFA New Wilimington Southern Belle Kroger Springdale Crossroads Farms Tamarack Dairy Glasgow Spray Dry

MILAGE 36 'OTAL DOLLAR RATE PER

NO. - - 0214

3565 Hauler Name: Mayfield Somerset, KY 45,000


CP: 37.957n,-84.891~

HANDLER

Trauth United Dairy Farmers Wayne Dairy Best Ever Ideal American Meyer Dairy Dean Louisville Brewster Minerva Reiter Springfield Winchester Flav-0-Rich DFA Goshen DFA New Wilimington Southern Belle Kroger Springdale Crossroads Farms Tamarack Dairy Glasgow Spray Dry

Latitude

39.0853


NO. - 0214

3565 Hauler Name: Mayfield Somerset, KY v Route Nos: 1 MILES 566 CP: 37.957n,-84.891~ 1 ACTUAL ROAC LESS

Jul-03 $2.20 45,000

PER LOADED AVERAGE PAYLOAD

NO.

0214

Hauler Nam Moore's Milk Hauling Dillsboro. IN 45,000 MILES


CP: 38.884n,-85.175~ ACTUAL ROAD

HANDLER

Trauth United Dairy Farmers Wayne Dairy Best Ever Ideal American Meyer Dairy Dean Louisville Brewster Minewa Reiter Springfield Winchester Flav-0-Rich DFA Goshen DFA New Wilimington Southern Belle Kroger Springdale Crossroads Farms Tamarack Dairy Glasgow Spray Dry

Exhibit The Coooeratives

CP: 38.884n,-85.175~ I (ONE WAY) I

ACTUAL ROAD LESS

Jun-03 Hauler Nam Moore's Milk Hauling Dillsboro, IN

NO. HANDLER

0214 Trauth

Route Nos: 589

United Dairy Farmers Wayne Dairy Best Ever Ideal American Meyer Dairy Dean Louisville Brewster Minerva Reiter Springfield Winchester Flav-0-Rich DFA Goshen DFA New Wilimington Southern Belle Kroger Springdale Crossroads Farms Tamarack Dairy Glasgow Spray Dry

36 MILES

$2.20 PER LOADED

MILE


NO.

0214 0224 0230 0228 0355 2217 3091 3301 3397 3445 3633 4104 8009 8049 8091 8109 8113 8114 8202

Exhibit

Hauler Nam Moore's Milk Hauling Dillsboro, IN MILES


CP: 38.88411,-85.175~ ACTUAL ROAD MllAGE 36 OTAL DOLLAR! RATE PER

HANDLER Latitude Longitude TO HANDLER MILES PER LOAD Trauth

C w r . 39.0853 -84.489 67.1 31.1 $68.42 $0.1 52

United Dairy Farmers 39.1 51 8 -84.4627 71.1 35.1 $77.22 Wayne Dairy

$0.172 39.8462 -84.9039 92.2 56.2 $123.64

Best Ever 40.1205 -85.6784 $0.275 104.3 68.3 $150.26 Ideal American 38.0282 -87.5346 $0.334 185.8 149.8 $329.56 Meyer Dairy 39.21 84 -84.4508 $0.732 69.7 33.7 $74.14 Dean Louisville 38.1 965 -85.6864 $0.165 75.1 39.1 Brewster 40.7063 -81.5981 $86.02 $0.191 294.4 258.4 $568.48 Minewa 40.7319 -81.1005 $1.263 317.6 281.6 $619.52 Reiter Springfield 39.9357 -83.8437 $1.377 132.0 96.0 $21 1.20 Winchester 38.0121 -84.1777 $0.469 103.5 67.5 $148.50 Flav-0-Rich 37.1438 -84.097 $0.330 159.9 123.9 $272.58 DFA Goshen 41.5721 -85.8265 $0.606 234.3 198.3 $436.26 $0.969 DFA New Wilimington 41.127 -80.3644 362.2 326.2 Southern Belle

$717.64 $1.595 37.0836 -84.6019 165.3 129.3 $284.46

Kroger Springdale 39.2824 -84.4748 $0.632 67.1 31.1 $68.42 Crossroads Farms 39.7637 -86.0404 $0.1 52 81.6 45.6 $100.32 Tamarack Dairy 40.0407 -82.4613 $0.223 197.8 161.8 $355.96 $0.796 Glasgow Spray Dry 36.9886 -85.9347 167.6 131.6 $289.52 $0.643

The Coonerntives

Ma -03 Hauler Name: Richard Martin 6914 Volant. PA $2.20 45.000

MILES PER LOADED AVERAGE Route Nos: 914 PAYLOAD CP 41.044n,80.144~ (ONE WA

ACTUAL ROAD LESS MilAGE 36 TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER

Z I P TO HANDLER NO. HANDLER MILES PER LOAD CWT

0093 Holmes 44654 135.2 99.2 $218 24 $0.485

0095 Smith 44667 114.4 78.4 $172.48 $0.383

0246 Guggisburg Cheese 44654 135.2 99.2 $21 8.24 $0.485

0521 Reiler - Akron 44314 93.2 57.2 $125.84 $0.280 0543 Poilio 14821 257 221.0 $486.20 $1.080

1 2 Dairymens 44111 115.2 79.2 $174.24 $0.387

3301 Brewster 44613 112.3 76.3 $167.86 $0.373

3394 Middlefieid Cheese 44062 78.3 42.3 $93.06 $0.207

3397 Minema 44657 74.1 38.1 $83.82 $0.186

3412 Broughtons-Marietta 45750 193.3 157.3 $346.06 $0.769

3678 Dietrich's Middlebury Center 16935 208.4 172.4 $379.28 $0.843

3769 Leprino Waverly 14892 283.2 247.2 $543.84 $1.209

3805 Friendship Dairy 14739 193.7 157.7 $346.94 $0.771

3815 Empire 14727 186.2 150.2 $330.44 $0.734

3950 United Dairy Valley Bell 25302 269.5 233.5 $513.70 $1.142

5076 Turner Dairy 15235 62.3 26.3 $57.86 $0.129

8003 Superior 44708 99 63.0 $138.60 $0.308

8006 Consun 44035 131.2 95.2 $209.44 $0.465

8008 Deans - Sharpsville 16150 34.4 0 $0.00 $0.000

8009 Goshen 46526 339.8 303.8 $688.36 $1.485

8049 Farmers Cheese 16142 15.1 0 $0.00 $0.000

8054 Miceli Cheese 441 04 105.4 69.4 152.68 $0.339

8072 Uniled- Mariins Ferry 43935 100.7 64.7 $142.34 $0.316

8084 Fikes-Uniontown 15401 104.7 68.7 $151.14 $0.341

81 14 Tamarack-Newark 43055 202.7 166.7 $366.74 $0.815

8125 Meadowbrook 1651 0 84.3 0.0 $0.00 $0.000

6171 LOL Holly Carlisle 17013 232.3 196.3 $431.86 $0.960

8177 Fairview Swiss 16124 26.5 0 $0.00 $0.000

8216 Sorrento Cheese 14220 166.3 130.3 $286.66 $0.637

8300 Dietrich's Reading 19605 295.8 259.8 $571.56 $1.270

6503 Eagle Family Foods 16901 231.1 195.1 $429.22 $0.954

8607 Schneiders 15227 58.8 22.8 $50.16 $0.111

Jun-03 Hauler Name: Richard Martin 6914 volant, PAW $2.20 45.000

MILES PER LOADED AVERAGE Route Nos: 914 PAYLOAD CP 41.044n.80.144~ ONE WA

ACTUAL ROAD LESS MllAGE 36 TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER

NO. HANDLER Z I P TO HANDLER MILES PER LOAD CWT.

0093 Hoimes 44654 135.2 99.2 $21 8.24 $0.485

0095 Smith 44667 114.4 78.4 $172.48 $0.383


0521 Reiter - Akron 44314 93.2 57.2 5125.84 $0.280 0543 Poiiio 14821 257 221.0 $486.20 $1.080

2212 Dailymens 44111 115.2 79.2 $174.24 $0.387

3301 Brewster 44613 112.3 76.3 $167.86 $0.373

3394 Middiefieid Cheese 44062 78.3 42.3 $93.06 $0.207

3397 Minerva 44657 74.1 38.1 $83.82 $0.186



3769 Leprino Waveriy 14892 283.2 247.2 $543.84 $1.209

3805 Friendship Daily 14739 193.7 157.7 $346.94 $0.771

3615 Empire 14727 186.2 150.2 $330.44 $0.734

3950 United DairyValley Bell 25302 269.5 233.5 $513.70 $1.142

5076 Turner Dairy 15235 62.3 26.3 $57.66 $0.129

8003 Superior 44708 99 63.0 $138.60 $0.308

8006 Consun 44035 131.2 95.2 $209.44 $0.465

BOO8 Deans - Sharpsvilie 16150 34.4 0 50.00 $0.000 8009 Goshen 46526 339.8 303.8 $668.36 $1.485

8049 Farmers Cheese 16142 15.1 0 $0.00 $0.000

8054 Mimii Cheese 44104 105.4 69.4 152.68 $0.339

8072 United- Martins Ferry 43935 100.7 64.7 $142.34 $0.316

8084 Fikes-Uniontown 15401 104.7 68.7 $151.14 50.341

8096 Alpine Cheese 44690 121.7 85.7 $188.54 $0.419

8114 Tamarack-Newark 43055 202.7 166.7 5366.74 $0.815

8125 Meadowbrook 16510 84.3 0.0 $0.00 $0.000

6171 LOL Holly Cariisle 17013 232.3 196.3 $431 86 $0.960

8177 Fairriew Swiss 161 24 26.5 0 $0.00 $0.000

8216 Sorrento Cheese 14220 166.3 130.3 $286.66 $0.637

8300 Dietrich's Reading 19605 295.8 259.8 $571.56 $1.270

8503 Eagle Family Foods 16901 231.1 195.1 $429.22 $0.954

8607 Schneiden 15227 58.8 22.6 $50.16 $0.111

Jul-03 Hauler Name: Richard Martin 6914 voiant, PA^ $2.20 45.000

MILES PER LOADED AVERAGE Roufe Nos: 914 PAYLOAD CP 41.044n.80.144~ ONE WAY)

ACTUAL ROAD LESS MILAGE 36 TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER

NO. HANDLER 2 I P TO HANDLER MILES PER LOAD CWT.

0093 Holmes 44654 135.2 99.2 $218.24 $0.485

0095 Smith 44667 114.4 78.4 $172.48 $0.383


0521 Reiler - Akron 44314 93.2 57.2 $125.84 $0.280

0543 Poliio 14821 257 221.0 $486.20 $1.080

2212 Dairymens 44111 115.2 79.2 $174.24 $0.387

3301 Brewster 44613 112.3 76.3 $167.86 $0.373

3394 Middiefield Cheese 44052 78.3 42.3 $93.08 $0.207

3397 Minerve 44657 74.1 38.1 $83.82 $0.186



3769 Leprino Waverly 14892 283.2 247.2 $543.84 $1.209

3805 Friendship Dairy 14739 193.7 157.7 $346.94 $0.771

3815 Empire 14727 186.2 150.2 $330.44 50.734

3950 United Dairy Valley Bell 25302 269.5 233.5 $513.70 $1.142

5076 Turner Daily 15235 62.3 26.3 $57.86 $0.129

8003 Supem 44708 99 63.0 $138.60 $0.308

8006 Consun 44035 131.2 95.2 $209.44 $0.465

BOO8 Deans - Sharpsville 16150 34.4 0 $0.00 $0.000 8009 Goshen 46526 339.8 303.8 $668.36 $1.485

8049 Farmers Cheese 16142 15.1 0 $0.00 $0.000

8054 Miceli Cheese 44104 105.4 69.4 152.68 $0.339

8072 United- Martins Ferry 43935 100.7 64.7 $142.34 $0.316

8064 Fikes-Uniontown 15401 104.7 68.7 $151.14 $0.341

8095 Alpine Cheese 44690 121.7 65.7 $188.54 $0.419

8114 Tamarack-Newark 43055 202.7 166.7 $366.74 $0.815

8125 Meadowbrook 16510 84.3 0.0 $0.00 $0.000

8171 LOL Holly Cariisle 17013 232.3 196.3 $431.86 $0.960

8177 Feirview Swiss 16124 26.5 0 $0.00 $0.000

8216 Sorrento Cheese 14220 166.3 130.3 $286.66 $0.637

8300 Dietrich's Reeding 19605 295.8 259.8 $571.55 $1.270

8503 Eagle Family Foods 16901 231.1 195.1 5429.22 $0.954

6607 Schneiders 15227 58.8 22.8 $50.16 $0.111

Route Nos 1401 I I ~ L E I F

1401 May-03

1 I P N E W A V 1 ' I CP43.509n.63.050w ACTUAL ROAD

MllAGE TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER NO. HANDLER Z I P TO HANDLER LESSBEMILES PER LOAD C W .

Hauler Name: Mendilh BAlbrechl Snover. MI

0063 Hoimes

0095 Smith

0215 Dean's Roche&!

0224 UDF

36 MILES

0230 Wayne

0298 Best Ever-Anderson. IN

0445 Dannon

0521 Reiter-Akron

$2.20 PER LOADED

2212 Dairymen

2217 Meyer

2330 Parmalot

45.000 AVERAGE

3445 RNler - SpnngField 3446 Sunshine Blscuil

3465 GenemlMillr

3560 Vemdale

8008 Dean Sharprville

8009 oFA-Go~hen

8113 Cmssmadr Farms

9114 TBmarack

9125 MeadowBmok

8129 Schenkle

9144 MMPA-Ovid

6146 Diehl-MI

6256 Dean Liberty

9257 Country Fresh GR

6345 DKH

Rl23 2004

2005

I 1 IONEWAYJ I 1 CP 43.509n.63.050w ACTUAL ROAD

MIUGE TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER NO. HANDLER Z I P TO HANDLER LESS36MILES PER LOAD CWT.

1401 Jun-03

0093 Holmer 276.3 44654 240.3 9526.65 51.175

HeulerName: Meredith BAlbrecnl Snwer. MI

Roule Nar: 1401

0095 SmiIh

0215 Dean'sRosherler

0224 UDF

0230 Wayne

0286 Best Ever-Anderson. IN

0445 Dannon

0521 Reiter-Akron

2212 oa1Pimen

2217 Meyer

2330 Parmalot

3301 arewster

3346 Bareman

3358 E m b a

3392 Lepiino-Allendale

3394 Middlefileid

3397 Minerva

3445 Reiter- Sptinglleld

3446 SunrNne Bircuii

3465 General Mills

3560 Vemdale

6006 Dean stmrpsvlne

BOW DFA-Goshen

6049 Farmer Cheese

5054 Mlceii Cheese

8056 MMPA-Constanline

8113 Cmsmads Farms 372.2 4621g 336.2 5739.64 $1.644

8114 Tamarack 306.2 43055 272.2 $586.84 51.331

6125 Meadow Brook 382.6 lG5l0 326.6 5718.66 51.603

36 MILES

6146 Diehl-MI

6255 Dean Libeiiy

6267 Countw Fresh GR

6345 DKH

Rt23 2004

2005

52.20 PER LOADED

MILE

45.000 AVERAGE PAYLOAD

1 I (ONEWAY) I 1 CP43.5090.83.0YJw ACTUAL ROAD

MILAGE TOTAL DOLLARS RATE PER NO. HANDLER 2 I P TO HANDLER LES536MILES PER LOAD CWI.

1401 Jul-03

0095 Smllh

0215 Dean's Rochester

0224 UDF

0230 Wayne

0285 BertEver-Anderson

0445 Dannon

Hauler Name: Meredilh B Albracht Snover. MI

RouleNor: 1401

0521 Reiler-Akmn

2212 Dairymen

2217 M q e r

3397 M l n e ~ a

3445 Reiler- Springfield

3445 Sunshine Blscuil

35 MILES

3455 General Mlllr

3560 Vemdale

BOOB Dean Sharpsville

6049 Farmercheese

6054 Miceil Cheese

$2.20 PERLOADED

MILE

6113 Crossroads Farms

6114 Tamarack


6125 Meadow Brook

8129 Sshenhle

5144 MMPA-OvId

5256 Dean Liberty

6267 Counlry Fresh GR

8345 DKH

RI 23 2004

2005

0095 Smith 0215 Deans-Rochester 0246 Guggisberg 0230 Wayne 0288 Best Ever Prairie Farms 0445 Dannon 0521 Reiter - Akron 2212 Dairymen 2217 Meyer 2392 Leprino Allendale 3301 Brewster 3348 Bareman 3352 Embest 3394 Middlefield Cheese 3397 Minerva 3412 Broughton 3445 Reiter - Springfield 3446 Sunshine Bisquit 3465 General Miiis 3560 Vemdale 3633 Kroger Winchester 3723 Michigan Dairy 8003 Superior 8008 Deans - Sharpsville 8009 DFA-Goshen 8113 Crossroads 8031 Ton 8035 Pearl Valley 8040 Allen 8049 Farmers Cheese 8054 Miceli 8056 MMPA Constantine 8084 United - Uniontown 8096 Alpine 8104 Michigan State Institute 8109 Kroger Springdale 81 14 Tamarack 8117 Sterling 8125 Meadowbrook 8129 Schenkle 8144 MMPA Ovid 8146 Diehl - Adrian 8256 Dean Liberty 8267 CF GR 8325 McCartyviile Reload 8345 Deutsch-Kase-Haus 8366 Ragersvilie cheese 8406 Quality Dairy

R t 127 2004 2005

4382 8 1883 Hauler Nam Wadsworlh

Jun-03 Petersburg, MI $2.20 45.000

MILES Route Nos: 382 8 NFO 183

PER LOADED AVERAGE PAYLOAD

41.963n.84.319~ ONE WAY)

ACTUAL ROAD

HANDLER Holmes Smith Deans-Rochester Guggisberg Wayne Best Ever Prairie Farms Dannan

0521 Reiter - Akron 2212 Dairymen 2217 Meyer 2392 Leprino Allendale 3301 Brewster 3348 Bareman 3352 Embest 3394 Middiefield Cheese 3397 Minerva 3412 Broughton 3445 Reiter- Springfield 3446 Sunshine Bisquit 3465 General Mills 3560 Verndale 3633 Kroger Winchester 3723 Michigan Dairy 8003 Superior BOO8 Deans - Sharpsville 8009 DFA-Goshen 8113 Crossroads 8031 Toft 8035 Pearl Valley 8040 Allen 8049 Fanners Cheese 8054 Miceli 8056 MMPA Constantine 8084 United - Uniontown 8096 Alpine 8104 Michigan State Institute 8109 Kroger Springdale 8114 Tamarack 81 17 Steriing 8125 Meadowbrook 8129 Schenkle 8144 MMPA Ovid 8146 Diehl - Adrian 8256 Dean Libelty 8267 CF GR 8325 McCartyville Reload 8345 Deutsch-Kase-Haus 8366 Ragersville Cheese 8406 Quality Dairy

R t 127 2004 2005

pmmb

pmmb

pmmb

pmmb

4382 8 1883 JuI-03 Hauler Narr Wadsworth Petersburg, MI

$2.20 45.000 MILES PER LOADED AVERAGE

Route Nos: 382 8 NFO 183 PAYLOAD

41.963n,84.319w ONE WA

ACTUAL ROAD

HANDLER Hoimes Smith Deans-Rochester Guggisberg Wayne Best Ever Prairie Famls

0445 Dannon 0521 Reiter - Akron 2212 Dairymen 2217 Meyer 2392 Leprino Allendaie 3301 Brewster 3348 Bareman 3352 Embest 3394 Middiefield Cheese 3397 Minerva 3412 Broughton 3445 Reiter - Springfield 3446 Sunshine Bisquit 3465 General Mills 3560 Verndaie 3633 Kroger Winchester 3723 Michigan Dairy 8003 Superior 8008 Deans - Sharpsville 8009 DFA-Goshen 8113 Crossroads 8031 Toft 8035 Pearl Valley 8040 Allen 8049 Farmers Cheese 8054 Mlceli 8056 MMPA Constantine 8084 United - Uniontown 8096 Alpine 8104 Michigan State Institute 8109 Kroger Springdale 8114 Tamarack 8117 Sterling 8125 Meadowbrook 8129 Schenkie 8144 MMPA Ovid 8146 Diehi -Adrian 8256 Dean Liberty 8267 CF GR 8325 McCariyvilie Reload 8345 Deutsch-Kase-Haus 8366 Ragersvilie Cheese 8406 Quality Dairy

R t 127 2004 2005

pmmb

prnmb

pmmb

pmmb

US On-Highway Fuel Prices

Midwest Number 2 Diesel

Energy information Administration

CY 2000 -date

2 Dlmlml

1 O t l l i i O t

A 01-3

5 OIMBl

B ~ 0 1 1 0 1

I OU1M1

B WlBml

B UmM?

10 o > m m I1 WlMI

12 OYlWmt

I S m W 0 1

11

15 lllm8m1

15 Ml1Ml1

I 7 (YIUIOt

l B ( Y n D m

TB nsmm< 20 W t l l D <

21 1mm 22 ornms 21 n1mm

Z I mmmt

26 O W < B m

PB F I N I O >

27 4

28 07-1

IS i l7l lWl

SO mRllOl

1 3 W3IYOt

11 DBiUDt

31 D W M I

4 I I I rn>

15 O m R t

36 osnrulll

11 ilnilOl01

38 OYWM

38 O P R 1 0 1

40 10Dll01

41 >MIID?

42 WIM~

d l 4-3

u 40asm1 45 l(lOM1

48 lil32Dlt

a7 w ,sw Is IIRMII 49 , m m , SO W1mt

51 12117m1

SZ ,-, 51 i?iJVOI

l l.UD(I 1 1.4840

S ?Sill@ r t l l K S 1 S B 0 1 1.5110

l lSlX 1 1.5240

1 ? s m ldmO 1 ,.6,00 I l.SW0

8 ? A S 1 1 q.4100

l t l S l S 1 . 4 1 1

' ,,,20* s ,2340 1 1.40&0 1 39110

l l.IS2LI 1 1_1-0

S (JlSO 6 l J I B 0

l l.mlD I I.3BBO

l 3^1S70 1 1>1W

l 1.4110 i l . l l l 0

I (A418 S M W 0

t ( U 2 O I 3 . 4 Y O

s r n w r um I 310"W

s I. lBii0 1 1.40.11 l 31%0 6 1.3680

1 n s m s ~ 1 0 I I . 3 - L 1132811

I ,,,m 1 1.1110 1 1.2sl# S ?>DO0

l (28DO 1 11700

% 11120 r tmm I I ?>DO

r 1.1MO s ,.,*.a 1 1.1730 1

US 0n.Highway Fuel Prices Midwest Number 2 Diesel

Energy information Administration

CY 2000 -date

US On-Highway Fuel Prices

Midwest Number 2 Diesel

Energy Information Adminletratlon

CY 2000 -date

oint-8oPor'nt iQes Matrix 41

11 Mileage based on calculations generated from PC Mller version 21.0 ALK Technologies

Supply Points


EasLsid~ Smltll Krogcr Co Traulh UDF Mcycr Railer Tamarack Broughlon Unilcd

aeeling Cost Matrix

I Supply Points Smith Krog~r Co TmuUl UDF Meycr Rclter Tamarack Broughton Unllcd

Ease Rale Per Mlls $2.20

Fuel Adluslor 47%

Fuel Adlusted Rale $3.23

Tank Size 48,000


Hauling Cost minus Location Adjustment

Elkhan County. lndtana

JarperCounty. Indiana

MemerCounty. Ohlo

Wayne Counh: Ohio

Eastsldc Smill l Krqcr t o . Traulir UDF Mcycr Reitcr Tamarack Broughlon Unilcd

~ ~ d ~ ~ ~ ~ n Rlchmond Indmnapol~s Ncwport C~ncinniil, Ctncannou Spnngl~cld Newark Marleila Cliarlcalon

IN IN IN IKY OH Oi l 01-i OH OH WV

52.00 52.00 52.00 $2.20 62.20 62.20 52.00 52.00 $2.00 $2.20

$ 1.39 $ 1.50 $ 1.63 $ 1.89 5 1.81 $ 1.78 $ 1.53 $ 1.72 $ 2.32 $ 2.41

$ 2.22 $ 229 $ 2.46 $ 2.27 $ 2.20 $ 2.17 $ 1.92 $ 2.11 $ 2.71 $ 286

$ 1.04 $ 1.24 $ 1.28 $ 1.22 $ 1.14 $ 1.12 $ 0.87 $ 1.06 $ 1.66 $ 1.60

$ 2.18 $ 2.29 $ 2.43 $ 2.67 $ 2.53 $ 2.56 $ 2.31 $ 2.50 $ 3.10 $ 3.25

$ 1.45 $ 1.86 $ 1.48 $ 2.01 6 1.99 $ 1.99 $ 2.15 $ 2.26 $ 286 $ 3.01

$ 0.71 $ 0.95 $ 0.96 $ 1.29 $ 1.21 $ 1.19 $ 1.10 $ 1.41 $ 2.12 $ 2.12

$ 0.70 $ 0.95 $ 0.56 $ 1.09 $ 1.07 $ 1.07 $ 1.35 $ 1.92 $ 2.54 $ 2.33 - $ 0.55 $ 0.45 $ 0.88 $ 0.73 $ 0.65 $ 0.63 $ 0.62 $ 0.00 $ 1.59 $ 1.59

$ 1.72 S 1.34 $ 1.77 $ 1.24 $ 1.10 $ 1.16 $ 0.97 $ 0.45 $ 0.80 $ 1.17

$ 3.01 $ 2.63 $ 3.06 $ 2.53 $ 2.46 $ A + $ 225 $ 1.85 $ 2.02 $ 2.35 $ 275 $ 2.37 $ 2.80 $ 2.27 $ 2 . 2 1 ~ 2.19 $ 2.00 $ 1.59 $ 1.61 $ 2.02


Miles to Miami

MA Mileage Rate (5 1 cwt / mile)

Gross haul cost

Reduction factor

Adjusted haul cost

Class I Differential

Southeastern Model Model for determining what Class I differential should be in Miami

ACQUISITION COST

Hopkins Jasper County County Texas !r&&

Wayne County

1,176

$0.0044

$5.174

80.00%

$4.140

$2.000

Franklin County

Pennsvlvania

1,128

$0.0044

$4.963

80.00% - $3.971

$2.800 -

$ 6.77

Lancaster County

Pennsvivania

1,164

$0.0044

$5.122

80.00%

$4.097

$2.900

$ 7.00


Calculation of the 2008 Mideast Order Cost Per Hundredweight per Mile

Diesel price per gallon average

Base fuel per gallon

Divide by MPG

Fuel Adjustor

Base Rate

Fuel Adjusted Rate

Divide hy Load Size Per C W Rate Per Cwt - Per Mile

11 2008 Year to Date EIA Average

21 May 5 -July 28,2003 period

31 Mideast Milk Marketing Agency Standard

41 Mideast Milk Marketing Rate for the Base Period

51 Mideast Milk Markeling Agency Standard

61 For Reference the most recent Federal Order 5

and Order 7 calculation for ihe month of August

i s 50.00521

Exhibit - The Cooperalives

Southeastern Model

Class I Differential Calculation based on Milk Procurement Cost Model: Calculation of Value at Charleston WV

Potential Supply Areas - -- Huron Elkhart Lenawee County County County

Mlchiqan lndiana lVlichinan

Miles to Charleston, WV 483.2 374.0 327.1

MA Mileage Rate ($ / cwt 1 mile)

Gross haul cost $2.658 $2.057 $1.799

Reduction factor 8o.oo% 8o.oo% 80.00%

Adjusted haul cost


ACQUISITION COST $ 3.93 $ 3.45 $ 3.24

Current Class I Differential @ Charleston, VW - 52.20 $2.20 - 52.20 Difference $ 1.73 $1.25 $1.04

Wayne Mercer Crawford County County County Ohio - PA

Exhibit- The Cooperatives

Southeastern Model

Class I Differential Calculation based on Milk Procurement Cost Model: Calculation of Value at Cincinnati, Ohio

-- Potential Supply Areas Huron Eilthart Lenawee Wayne Mercer Crawford County County County County County County

Michisan lndiana Michiaan - Ohio I I

Miles to Cincinnati, Ohio 381.0 235.3 224.9 202.0 122.6 ( 340.5 i I

MA Mileage Rate ($ I cwt I mile)

Gross haul cost $2.096 $1.294 $1.237 $1.111 1 $0.674 ( $1.873 Reduction factor

Adjusted haul cost

Class I Differential W $2.000

ACQUISITION COST $ 3.48 $ 2.84 $ 2.79 $ 2.89

Current Class I Differential @Cincinnati, OH - $2.20 $2.20 I

Difference $1.28 $0.64 50.59 $0.69 $0.34 1 51.30


Southeastern Model Class I Differential Calculation based on Milk Procurement Cost Model: Calculation of Value at Indianapolis IN

Potential Supply Areas -- -- Huron Lenawee Wayne Mercer Crawford County County County County County County

Michiqan Indiana Michiqan - OH - PA I

Miles to Indianapolis, IN 400.6

MA Mileage Rate ($1 cwt I mile)

Gross haul cost $2.174 1 $0.943 1 $1.211 $1.446 $0.716 $2.203 Reduction factor 80.00% 80.00% 80.00%

Adjusted haul cost $1.739 1 $0155 1 $0,969 $1.157 $0.573 $1.763 Class I Differential $1.80D $2.000 $2.100

ACQUISITION COST $ 3.54 ( $ 2.55 1 $ 2.77 $ 3.16 $ 2.57 $ 3.86 Current Class I Differential @ Indianapolis, IN $2 $2.00 $2.00 $2.00

I I Difference $ 1.54 $0.55 ( $0.77 $1.16 $0.57 $1.86


Southeastern Model Class I Differential Calculation based on Milk Procurement Cost Model: Calculation of Value at Marietta. OH

Potential Supply Areas -

MA Mileage Rate ($ / cwt / mile)

Gross haul cost $2.375 $1.893 $1.517 I $0648 1 $1.291 $1.235 Reduction factor

Adjusted haul cost


ACQUISITION COST $ 3.70 $ 3.31 $ 3.01 1 $ 2.52 1 $ 3.04 $ 3.09 Current Class i Differential @ Marietta, OH - $2.00 $2.00

I I Difference $ 1.70 $1.31 $1 .O1 $0.52 1 $1.04 $1.09


Southeastern Model

Class I Differential Calculation based on Milk Procurement Cost Model: Calculation of Value at Newark, OH

Potential Supply Areas

MA Mileage Rate ($ I cwt 1 mile)

Huron Elkhart Lenawee County County County

Michiqan lndiana Michiqan

Miles to Newark, OH 343.0 239.0 187.0

Gross haul cost $1.887 $1.315 $1.029 1 $0,369 1 $0715 $1.221 Reduction factor 80.00% 80.00% 80.00%

Wayne County - Ohio

67.0

Adjusted haul cost $1.509 $1.052 $0.823 I $0.291 1 50.572 $0.977

Mercer Crawford County County - OH - PA 130.0 222.0


ACQUISITION COST $ 3.31 $ 2.85 $ 2.62 1 5 2.29 1 $ 2.57 $ 3.08 Current Class I Differential @ Newark, OH $2.00 $2.00 $2.00 $2.00 -

I I Difference $ 1.31 $ 0.85 $0.62 $0.29 1 $0.57 51 .08


Southeastern Model

Class I Differential Calculation based on Milk Procurement Cost Model: Calculation of Value at Sprinqfield, OH

MA Mileage Rate ($ I cwt I mile)

Gross haul cost $1.727 $1.128 $0.869 $0.792 1 $0.506 1 $1.546 Reduction factor 80.00% 8o.oo% 80.(10%

Adjusted haul cost $1.382 $0.902 $0.695 $0.634 I $0.405 I $1,236 Class I Differential fL&@ $1.800 $1.800

ACQUISITION COST $ 3.18 $ 2.70 $ 2.50 $ 2.63 1 $ 0 1 $ 1.31


Current Class I Differential @ Springfield, OH - $2.00 $2.00 - - $2.00 Difference $ 1.18 $ 0.70 $0.50 $0.63

- $2.00 $0.40

$2.00

$1.34

Comparison of Current, Alternative and Proposed Differentials


Custom Territorie $1.80

$2.00

52.10

$2.15

$2.30

52.40

$2.60


All Milk Marketings By Selected States May 2007 (Pounds of Milk)

DFA et nl Request 2-B -, -

Prepared By The Midcnst Marlict Administrator's Ollicc

- TI

BEPORE THE UNITED STATES DEPARTW/BIENT OF … · 2020. 5. 8. · BEPORE THE UNITED STATES...

Documents

Transcript of BEPORE THE UNITED STATES DEPARTW/BIENT OF … · 2020. 5. 8. · BEPORE THE UNITED STATES...