Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

155
Ben Hamilton Baillie Ben Hamilton Baillie Associates “Delivering Better Places” Design Skills Symposium 2011, Tollbooth, Stirling

description

A presentation given by Ben Hamilton-Baillie at the 2011 Design Symposium which was held in Stirling and organised by Architecture + Design Scotland and Historic Scotland.

Transcript of Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Page 1: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Ben Hamilton BaillieBen Hamilton Baillie Associates

“Delivering Better Places”

Design Skills Symposium 2011, Tollbooth, Stirling

Page 2: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Streets, networks & public space

Ben Hamilton-Baillie www.hamilton-baillie.co.uk

Design Skills Symposium Scotland

Page 3: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Exhibition Road, London

Page 4: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 5: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 6: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 7: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 8: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 9: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 10: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 11: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 12: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 13: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 14: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 15: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 16: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

O’Connell Street, Dublin

Page 17: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 18: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 19: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 20: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 21: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 22: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 23: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 24: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 25: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 26: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 27: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 28: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 29: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 30: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 31: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 32: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 33: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 34: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 35: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 36: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 37: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 38: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 39: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 40: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 41: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 42: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 43: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 44: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 45: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 46: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 47: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 48: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 49: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 50: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 51: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Siena, Italy

Page 52: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 53: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 54: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 55: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Traffic in Towns. The Buchanan Report 1963

Page 56: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 57: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Eugène Hénard Proposals for traffic circulation Paris 1905

Page 58: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

“Traffic segregation should be the keynote of modern road design”

Ministry of Transport (1966)“Roads in Urban Areas”

QuickTime™ and aTIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 59: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 60: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 61: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Published Nov 2010

Page 62: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 63: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 64: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

CABE Better Streets Studies

Liverpool

Manchester

Newcastle

Nottingham

Bristol

Bideford

Kensington

Devizes

Dublin

Harlow

Page 65: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 66: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 67: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 68: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Birmingham New Street

Page 69: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 70: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 71: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

“The swings are packed away at night because kids might climb the fence and use them unsupervised and hurt themselves.”

Rubberized mattingbarriers

No swings

No children

Page 72: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 73: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Kensington High Street - before

Page 74: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 75: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Before: average annual rate between March 98 and February 2001

After: average annual rate between September 2003 and March 2005

Drop in casualties from 1999 to 2004

-22

-26

-14

-18

-43

-25 -26

-35

-64

-18

-35

-44

-70

-60

-50

-40

-30

-20

-10

0

Pedestrian Cyclists Motorcycles All%

London

RBKC

KHS

Kensington High Street Casualty Review

Page 76: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

INSTITUTION OF CIVIL ENGINEERS

Dispelling myths and misunderstandings amongst highway engineers

Stresses professional judgement over convention and simple application of guidance

Reviews the realities of legal liability and corporate risk

Page 77: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

The Highway• Regulated

• Impersonal

• Linear

• Single Purpose

• Consistent

• Predictable

• Systematic

• State controlled

• Signs and markings

The Public Realm• Culturally defined

• Personal

• Spatial

• Multi-purpose

• Constantly changing

• Unpredictable

• Contextual

• Cultural / social rules

• Eye contact

Page 78: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 79: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Context timeSystem time

Page 80: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 81: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Hans Monderman1946-2008

Page 82: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Makkinga, Friesland

Page 83: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 84: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 85: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 86: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 87: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Noordlaren, Groningen

Page 88: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 89: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 90: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 91: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 92: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 93: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 94: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Petersfield, Hampshire

Page 95: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Shrewsbury High Street

Page 96: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

St. Armel, Brittany

Page 97: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Drachten, Friesland

Page 98: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 99: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 100: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 101: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

De Kaden, Drachten

Page 102: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 103: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

QuickTime™ and a decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 104: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 105: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 106: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Poynton, Cheshire

Page 107: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Aachen, Germany

Page 108: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 109: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Norrkøpping, Sweden

Page 110: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Skvallertorget

before after

Page 111: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 112: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 113: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 114: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 115: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 116: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Portishead, BristolTraffic light switch-off

Page 117: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

New Road, Brighton

Page 118: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 119: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 120: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 121: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 122: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 123: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 124: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Ashford Ring Road, Kent

Page 125: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 126: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 127: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 128: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 129: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 130: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 131: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 132: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 133: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 134: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 135: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 136: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Lost O

Page 137: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

St. Gallen “Stadtlounge” Switzerland

Page 138: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 139: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 140: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 141: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 142: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 143: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 144: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 145: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 146: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 147: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 148: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

Seven Dials, Covent Garden

Page 149: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 150: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 151: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 152: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space

QuickTime™ and aYUV420 codec decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 153: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 154: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space
Page 155: Ben Hamilton-Baillie - Streets, Networks and Public Space