Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear...

22
Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning? Anatole Kaletsky Co-Chairman and Chief Economist GaveKal Dragonomics

Transcript of Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear...

Page 1: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Beginning of the end -

or end of the beginning?

Anatole KaletskyCo-Chairman and Chief Economist

GaveKal Dragonomics

Page 2: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Churchill after Alamein, 1942

1

“This is not the end.

“It is not even the beginning of the end.

“But it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning.”

Page 3: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Dead-cat bounce?

2

Page 4: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Or breakout from 13-year bear market?

3

Page 5: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Structural growth obstacles

4

1. Bad public policy – fiscal and monetary uncertainty

2. Credit bubbles in China and EMs

3. Deleveraging by banks and households

4. Inequality > underconsumption

5. Environment and commodity constraints

6. Underinvestment etc > weak productivity

Page 6: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Structural growth drivers

5

1. End of communism > global single market

2. Three billion new producers and consumers

3. Information and computer technology

4. Unlimited fiat money

5. Alternative energy

6. Moore’s law, robots etc > accelerating productivity

Page 7: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Is it a rabbit or a duck?

6

Page 8: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

… US job growth sets all market trends

7

Page 9: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

US “New Normal” may be 3.5%-4% growth

8

Page 10: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

US housing rebound will continue

9

Page 11: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Household leverage has normalised too

10

Page 12: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Europe and Japan recovery hardly begun…

11

Page 13: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

12

Page 14: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

US and EU now only 45% of global GDP

13

Page 15: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

China’s reforms still a major risk

14

Page 16: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

“New Normal” - same as the Old Normal

15

Page 17: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Investors need to discriminate among EMs

16

Page 18: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

Necessary conditions for euro’s survival

17

1. Fiscal union (1): joint control of fiscal policy

2. Fiscal union (2): joint responsibility for debt

3. Banking union: joint resolution and guarantees

4. Monetary union: sovereign lender of last resort

5. Political union: democratic legitimacy

Page 19: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

18

Page 20: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

The biggest story in China and EMs

19

Page 21: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

A Brief History of Global Capitalism

20

0. 1776-1800 American and French Revolutions, Napoleonic Wars

1800-1848 Pre-Capitalism struggles with Post-Feudalism

1. 1848-1865 European Revolutions, US Civil War

1865-1929 Global Capitalism: Economic and Political Liberalism

2. 1929-1945 Great Depression, World War

1945-1974 Keynesian Golden Age: Government-Led “Mixed Economy”

3. 1974-1980 Great Inflation, Cold War

1980-2007 Thatcherism-Reaganomics: Market Fundamentalism

4. 2008-2013 Global Financial Crisis

2013-???? “Capitalism 4.0”: Sceptical, Evolutionary, Experimental

Page 22: Beginning of the end - or end of the beginning?...Dead-cat bounce? 2. Or breakout from 13-year bear market? 3. Structural growth obstacles 4 1. Bad public policy –fiscal and monetary

What’s Next?

21