Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
-
Upload
atrasicarius -
Category
Documents
-
view
214 -
download
0
Transcript of Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
1/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
POLICEANDCRIME !OUDECIDE
Since 1982, the United States has been engaged in what has been called a Waron Drugs among other things, this War is a strategy to deal with the rise ocrac!"cocaine use in urban communities# $ne o its lasting eects has been anincrease in %olice %resence in &merican cities#
&t the same time, not unrelated, urban communities in the United States ha'eseen a continuing tide o 'iolence and crime, and many ha'e turned to increasedunding or %olice as a solution to this 'ery serious %roblem# (ut the 'iolencedoes not only ha%%en within communities) in some cases this 'iolence is%er%etuated by those assigned to %rotect such communities the %olicethemsel'es leading many to *uestion whether %olice might actually ma!e%roblems worse#So, what should be done? Should we maintain and increase funding forthe police, or direct our resources to other programs?
+he &irmati'e lan is a %olicy %ro%osal to reduce police presence in urbancommunities throughout the United States. +his side o the debate claims toma!e a %ositi'e dierence through three main ad'antages- clearing the way oryouth %rograms) creating .obs) and ma!ing it %ossible or communities to bandtogether to %rotect themsel'es#
+he negati'e argues that reducing the %olice %resence in urban communities willonly lead to more 'iolence and the ta!eo'er o gangs in urban communities# /talso argues that community %olicing is a %ositi'e strategy in reducing %oliceabuse and ma!ing our cities more sae#
Who is right and who is wrong0 +he answer is u% to you#
1
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
2/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
"ELCOMEAND#O$$IPS
"elcome to De%ate&
Debate is an o%%ortunity or you to build your 'oice and be heard#
When you debate, you will ha'e the chance to s%ea! your mind on to%ics rom/ra* to %o'erty in the inner city, and to %ro'e your s!ills against young %eo%lerom all o'er the bay# Debate is a s%ort- it calls on you to .oin a team, re%resentyour school, and win tro%hies, cham%ionshi%s, and %ries# / you commit yourselto this s%ort you will ha'e much un) most im%ortantly, you will gain the tools tobetter yoursel, to earn college scholarshi%s, and to s%ea! u% or your entirecommunity#
"'at i( De%ate)
Debate is a com%etition between two teams, each with two debaters# $ne teamta!es the &irmati'e, %ro%osing a %lan to change the world and e%laining why itis a good idea# +he other team is the 3egati'e, who attac!s the %lan and tries to%ro'e that it will do more harm than good#
+here are 8 s%eeches and 4 cross"eaminations in a debate round# 5ou and your%artner will each ta!e the lead on 2 s%eeches 61 7onstructi'e and 1 ebuttal and1 cross"eamination#
2
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
3/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
:
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
4/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
#O"$OUSE$#ISPAC*
;'ery %age o this %ac! ollows a ormula designed or two %ur%oses- to gi'e youthe su%%ort you need to ma!e solid arguments, and to challenge you to ma!ethese arguments creati'e and com%elling#
$'e (et+,-&
+he bo at the to% o each %age gi'es anintroduction to what the %age
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
5/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
reerring bac! to in all your s%eeches# Some cards ha'e the most im%ortant %artsunderlined already, and some you will ha'e to underline yoursel#
;n.oy and remember that the key to debate is your creative voice#
>
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
6/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
BAC*ROUNDANDFAC$S
Crime and Sa3et
4&45o all high school students eel too unsae to go to school, 165re%ortcarrying a wea%on, 74&45were in a %hysical ight# 6Deborah rothrow"Stith, =D 2??9
=ore than 8209000young %eo%le ages 1?to 24 were treated inemergencyde%artments or
in.uries sustained rom'iolence in 2??@#6Deborah rothrow"Stith, =D 2??9
$'e Co(t
=edical and lost %roducti'ity costs associated with 'iolence range rom
more than :80 %illion to :146 %illiona year# 7riminal .ustice costsaccount or more# Aor eam%le, criminal .ustice costs related to gang'iolence in Bos &ngeles 7ounty alone total :1&14 %illionannually 6Deborahrothrow"Stith, =D 2??9#
$a!land s%ends 4?C o its city budget on %olice 6SA 7hronicle 2?1?) SanArancisco s%ends C 635 +imes 2?1?#
Pri(on( and Arre(t(
/n 2??:, there were an estimated 2&2 millionarrests o youth in the USwere White) 285were (lac!) 25were &sian) and 15were &merican/ndian# 6USD$E 2??@
&rican &mericans ma!e u% only745o the total %o%ulation in$a!land, but re%resented morethan 885o the homicide 'ictimsin the years 2??2"2??4 6&lameda7ounty ublic Fealth De%artment2??>#
@
Police Mi(cond,ct;NPMSRP20111 Uni*ue re%orts o %olicemisconduct trac!ed
>9>17 " 3umber o sworn lawenorcement oicers in'ol'ed 6:>4were agency leaders such as chies orsheris
>962> " 3umber o alleged 'ictimsin'ol'ed
2=8 3umber o atalities associatedwith trac!ed re%orts
:7=>94129600 ;stimated amount
Crime( -er100* Re(ident(;in 200>1 88@ 2?@
A((a,lt :2@ 9?@ ::Larcen $'e3t :2?2 2188 2@?2$otal 467= 2>=4 ==60
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
7/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
+he ollowing are the rates o %eo%le currently in %rison 6&7BU 2?1?-
Men "omen
"'ite 1 in 1?@ 1 in :>>#i(-anic
1 in :@ 1 in 29
Black 1 in 1> 1 in 1??
cos s#
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
8/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
EVIDENCE
FORTHE
AFFIRMATIVE
8
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
9/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC
Brooks9 1???9 @Fear and 3airne(( in t'e cit Criminal en3orcement and-erce-tion( o3 3airne(( in minorit comm,nitie(& So,t'ern Cali3orniaLa. Reie.
Blacks in central city neighborhoods are more likely than any other group to perceive crime as a
problem. They have the highest rates of violent crimes victimization and they are seven times morelikely to be murdered than whites. Grim statistics like these, along with impassioned personalaccounts of violent encounters and heroic daily efforts to avoid such encounters, have led race and
criminal law scholars, such as Randall Kennedy, to epress a seemingly natural though
unconventional claim! "rustrated and overwhelmedby gangs, drugs and crime, blacks in high crimeneighborhoods welcome disproportionately tough criminal sanctions and epanded police
discretion. This claim, which # label the $urban frustration argument,% remains unconventional
because &frican &mericans are broadly viewed to perceive law enforcement with suspicion anddistrust. This perception of distrust has been significantly bolstered by recent reports of etreme
9
In'erenc
Ri/'t no.9 -eo-le in ,r%an comm,nitie( 3ear criminal actiit9 %,t t'eal(o 3ear t'e -olice& $'i( create( a (it,ation t'at cant %e 3ied .it'o,t
Use an eam%le or a%iece o e'idence to
show why %eo%le earcrime and the %olice#
TagIt:
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
10/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
police misconduct in ma'or urban areas such as (hicago, )os &ngeles, *ew +ork (ity, andhiladelphia.
1?
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
11/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC
ichie and =ogul, 2?? /n the shadows o the war on terror- ersistant olice(rutality and the abuse o %eo%le o color in the United States#
11
#arm(
What %roblems with%olice are going on
here and now in the(ay0
Police in(tit,tion( 'ae done more 'arm t'an /ood 3or more t'an a
TagIt:
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
12/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC
$',( .e o33er t'e 3ollo.in/ -lan
7ity go'ernments in the United States should substantiallyreduce %olice %resence in urban communities#
We will clariy our intent#
12
+ell more about the what iswrong with %olice systems now#
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
13/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1:
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
14/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC SOLENC!
ane((aBarker 9 2010& @E-lainin/ t'e reat American Crime Decline AReie. o3 Bl,m(tein and "allman9 old%er/er and Ro(en3eld9 andimrin/& Law & Social Inuiry9 ol,me 749 I((,e 29 -a/e( =6?41>9S-rin/ 2010
<hough these ma'or changes in policing coincided with falling crime rates and public officials- claimsabout police efficacy, researchers are skeptical about the degree of relationship between the two trends.ost analysts do not think that the larger police forces lowered crime rates, but some proffer that certain
innovations may have had an effect.
Two skeptics, /ohn 0ck and 0dward aguire 123345, in Blumstein and 6allman-s 2334 edited volume,The (rime 7rop in &merica, provide one of the most thorough reviews on policing research to date. 0ck
and aguire conclude that there is no empirical evidence to support claims that increased manpower led
to a decrease in violent crime, pointing out that crime rates fell dramatically in many big cities like 8an
7iego, 8eattle, and 7allas without significant increases in policing.23 Taking a close look at twenty9seven studies 1with eighty9nine dependent variables5 of the effects of police strength on violent crime,
0ck and aguire found that in :; percent of the analyses there was no effect< in 30 percent, an
increase in the nu!er o" po#ice per capita $as associate% $ith an increase in the reporte% crierate< and in 23 percent, more police strength was associated with a decrease in the reported crime rate
10ck and aguire 2334, Table =.>, 2>>?>@5.2>
Gerry Shih, 2?1?# &s (udget Ga%s Widen, San Arancisco olice Salaries Grow#3ew 5or! +imes, =arch 2@# etrie'ed rom'tt-GG...&ntime(&comG2010G07G2>G,(G2>(3(a3et&'tml#
$6hen # sit down with my constituency,% said 8upervisor 7avid (ampos, who was on the policecommission before running for district office, $the feeling # get is they want the police, but they donAtwant the police being the best compensated in the country when weAre shutting down gyms and pools.%
e added! $There are violence9prevention programs, after school programs, programs for youth, they
are all critical components of the policing. 8hould they be the best compensated in the country at a timewhen weAre cutting all these servicesC # donAt think that should be the case.%
14
More -olice are not t'e an(.er to t'e -ro%lem&
TagIt:
TagIt:
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/26/us/26sfsafety.htmlhttp://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/26/us/26sfsafety.html -
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
15/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC SOLENC! SELF+PRO$EC$ION
He((ica Retti/9 2010& @Nei/'%or'ood "atc'e( #el- Local Police& US Ne.( "orld Re-ort& Retrieed 3rom'tt-GG...&,(ne.(&comGne.(Garticle(G2010G12G1=Gnei/'%or'ood+.atc'e(+'el-+local+-olice
)ast fiscal year, more than half the police departments in &merica had budget cuts, averaging = percent,
and overall there was a @ percent decrease in sworn officers, according to a survey by a nationalorganization of police eecutives. This coming year, the ma'ority of those departments plan to trim their
budgets further. 6ith fewer officers on the streets, municipalities nationwide are calling on volunteers tohelp keep their residential areas safe. By starting or 'oining a neighborhood watch program, citizens can
play a pivotal role in reducing crime in their areas.
D6hen resources are tight, it-s more important than ever,D says ichelle Boykins, communications andmarketing director for the *ational (rime revention (ouncil. Dolice can-t be everywhere 2:E=. &nd
we-ve seen that where neighborhood watches eist and are viable in their community, we have a lowerincidence of crime.D
1>
"it' 3e.er -olice9 comm,nit mem%er( can %ecome moreinde-endent and -rotect eac' ot'er 3rom crime&
Why would less %oliceencourage %eo%le to%rotect themsel'esagainst crime0 Fowwould this wor!0
TagIt:
http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2010/12/14/neighborhood-watches-help-local-policehttp://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2010/12/14/neighborhood-watches-help-local-policehttp://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2010/12/14/neighborhood-watches-help-local-policehttp://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2010/12/14/neighborhood-watches-help-local-police -
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
16/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1@
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
17/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC SOLENC! !OU$#PRORAMS
&ter School&lliance, =ay 2??2# etrie'ed rom'tt-GG...&a3ter(c'oolalliance&or/Gi((,eJ%rie3(Gi((,eJ(a3eJ8&-d3
&fterschool programs provide safe places for youth after school in addition to improving academicachievement and helping working families. &fterschool programs provide youth a safe, supervised
environment that reduces their risk of committing or becoming a victim of violent crime. & recent
report from "ight (rime! #nvest in Kids has found that violent 'uvenile crime is most likely to occurbetween @ p.m. and 4 p.m., and that youth are more likely to smoke, drink or do drugs during these
hours. oreover, the F.8. /ustice 7epartment has found that murder rates among >:9>= year olds
has increased >4H from >;I to >;;.&fterschool programs promote safety by preventing youthviolence, providing safe places afterschool and educating youth about the dangers of drug and
alcohol abuse.
1
Mone 3rom -olice %,d/et( co,ld 3,nd o,t' -ro/ram(like de%ate t'at 'ae a %etter c'ance at red,cin/ crime
TagIt:
Use eam%les rom yourown lie or other e'idence to show how youth%rograms can reduce crime#
http://www.afterschoolalliance.org/issue_briefs/issue_safe_7.pdfhttp://www.afterschoolalliance.org/issue_briefs/issue_safe_7.pdf -
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
18/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC SOLENC! !OU$#PRORAMS
Hame( Die/o i/il and il%erto K& Conc'a(9 2010& @Sto--in/ an/( .it' aBalanced Strate/ Preention9 Interention9 and S,--re((ion& From!hanging "laces: #ow !ommunities $ill Improve the #ealth of %oys of!olor
Regardless of how many 'ails we build or how many cells are set aside for each new gang cohort,
eisting antigang strategies have failed. They have had limited success because they are not based onfacts, on science, on human development, or on common sense. 8ociety needs to be honest inrecognizing this fact and must institute bold new policies to chart a healthier course for vulnerable
youth. & focus on the roots of the problem will generate logical solutions that aim not merely to stem
the worst violence, but to begin the long, hard effort to regain social control within gang9prone
impoverished communities. <hough punishment may play a role, programmatic emphasis must shift tointroducing rewards early in a personAs life.
18
Police dont /et to t'e root o3 t'e -ro%lem .e need
What is the root o the%roblem o 'iolence0 Whydo youth %rograms get to
this root better than %olice0
TagIt:
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
19/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
19
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
20/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC SOLENC! NEI#BOR#OODRE+INES$MEN$
Mark Ma,er9 2011 ;Sentencin/ Re3orm Amid Ma(( Incarceration(,arded O-timi(m
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
21/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
1AC SOLENC! NEI#BOR#OODRE+INES$MEN$
H,(tice Polic In(tit,te9 Octo%er9 2008& @Em-loment9 "a/e( and P,%licSa3et&'tt-GG...&,(tice-olic&or/G,-load(G,(tice-olicGdoc,ment(G08J10Jre-Jem-lomentand-,%lic(a3etJac&-d3
Researchers have found a relationship between unemployment, crime and incarceration.
#mproving employment opportunities encourage reinvestments in one self, as well as in thecommunity, ostensibly creating an environment for improved public safety. & study by the
*ational Bureau of 0conomic Research found that places that rely most heavily on incarcerationreduce the employment opportunities in their communities compared with places that rely on
alternatives to incarceration. &reas with the most rapidly rising rates of incarceration were the areas
in which youth, particularly &frican &merican youth, have had the worst earnings and employment
eperience.
21
More nei/'%or'ood ine(tment and le(( -,ni('ment
TagIt:
Sum it u%# Why will your %lan ma!e a%ositi'e im%act on the world0 Whatare the s%eciic im%acts it will ma!e,and why do they matter0
http://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/07_10_rep_employmentandpublicsafety_ac.pdfhttp://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/07_10_rep_employmentandpublicsafety_ac.pdfhttp://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/07_10_rep_employmentandpublicsafety_ac.pdfhttp://www.justicepolicy.org/uploads/justicepolicy/documents/07_10_rep_employmentandpublicsafety_ac.pdf -
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
22/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
2AC E$ENSIONS #ARMS
Criminaliin/ $'e Cla((room $'e Oer+Policin/ O3 Ne. !ork Cit Sc'ool(&P,%li('ed Marc' 2008 + N!CLU
(itizensA distrust of the police is a weighty topic. Jfficers often enlist the help of neighborhoodresidents in the performance of their duties, and citizens are more likely to assist when they view the
police favorably and with legitimacy 17ecker, >;I>5. oreover, because of the high visibility ofpolice officers in disadvantaged communities, which are disproportionately composed of &frican9
&merican residents, citizensA perceptions of the police may impact how they ultimately feel aboutformal systems of 'ustice. #n particular, unfavorable views of the police may contribute to community
residents acuiring an overall lack of faith in the criminal 'ustice system.
Because &frican9&mericans constitute a substantial portion of victims and witnesses, citizensAmisgivings about police may compromise crime9control efforts in their communities. "or instance,
detached black citizens may decide not to testify as witnesses in criminal proceedings andE or whenserving as 'urors, they may refuse to convict &frican9&merican defendants 1see Butler, >;; for a
discussion of 'ury nullification5. #n addition, secondary deviance may result from individual
community membersA accumulated negative police eperiences. "inally, a lack of confidence in the
'ustice process may increase the likelihood that residents will feel compelled to settle disputes on theirown, thereby increasing levels of community violence 1&nderson, >;;;5.
22
Police a%,(e oer decade( 'a( ca,(ed mi(tr,(t& $'e
%e(t (ol,tion i( to red,ce -olice -re(ence&
What is the im%act o beingcriminalied0
TagIt:
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
23/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
2AC E$ENSIONS #ARMS
3ational olice =isconduct Statistics and e%orting ro.ect 6NPMSRP
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
24/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
24
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
25/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
2AC SELF+PRO$EC$ION
Pri(on Re(earc' Ed,cation Action Proect 1?8>& @In(tead O3 Pri(on( A#and%ook For A%olitioni(t(& C'a-ter 6
The military model for crime prevention should he abolished. #t is clear that neither punishment by
prison nor training police for a community combat role can solve the problem of street crime, in the long
range, nothing less than social restructuring will accomplish the goal of greatly reducing poor peoples-
economic crimes, but in the interim, communities must be made safe and the victims protected and
cared for. This reuires that funding be diverted to those services and resources communities identify asvital to their efforts to create a safer society and to bring relief to the victims.
(ommunity people can empower themselves to turn away from their fortress eistence and transform
their streets into real neighborhoods where all are safe and welcome. #n hiladelphia, a small number of
concerned citizens have organized to make their streets safer from crime, building a sense ofneighborhood at the same time. #ts program. ()&8, provides an opportunity for communities to take
more power over their own lives, and has significantly reduced crime.
2>
Comm,nit em-o.erment red,ce( crime
Why does reducing %olicema!e more room orcommunity em%owerment0
TagIt:
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
26/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
2AC !OU$#PRORAMS
A3ter Sc'ool Alliance 2011& @A3ter+Sc'ool All+Star( $'ree #o,r( CanC'an/e A Li3e& Retrieed 3rom'tt-GG...&a3ter(c'oolall(tar(&or/G(iteG--&a(-)cenHH*MN-Fm%64=>64
#n &merica today, millions of young people are alone and unsupervised in the hours after school, before
parents return home from work. This situation places children and teens at grave risk for 'uvenile crime,substance abuse, teen pregnancy, and other problems. #t means students are wasting precious time when
they could be learning. &nd it leaves millions of working parents worried about their children when theyshould be focused on their 'obs. This unproductive, untenable and unacceptable situation would be
remedied if our nation invested more fully in the after school programs that keep kids safe, supportworking families, and help young people succeed in school and in life.
Teens who do not participate in after school programs are nearly three times more likely to skip classes
or use mari'uana or other drugs< they are also more likely to drink alcohol, smoke cigarettes and engage
in seual activity. 1+(& of the F8&, arch 233>5
2@
A3ter (c'ool -ro/ram( 'el- o,t' aoid
Why does reducing %olicema!e room or more andbetter youth %rograms0
TagIt:
http://www.afterschoolallstars.org/site/pp.asp?c=enJJKMNpFmG&b=854685http://www.afterschoolallstars.org/site/pp.asp?c=enJJKMNpFmG&b=854685http://www.afterschoolallstars.org/site/pp.asp?c=enJJKMNpFmG&b=854685http://www.afterschoolallstars.org/site/pp.asp?c=enJJKMNpFmG&b=854685 -
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
27/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
2AC !OU$#PRORAMS
Mai Aernande;Eec,tie Director o3 t'e National Center 3or ictim( o3Crime( Ma 10 2?11#'tt-GG...&t'ecrimere-ort&or/Gie.-oint(G2011+04+(to-+t'e+ccle+o3+iolence+a/ain(t+o,n/+-eo-leand+(
"irst, we have to start by changing how enforcement views youth, particularly urban youth of color.#nstead of seeing urban youth as thesource of the problem, law enforcement agencies need to
understand and acknowledge the normalization of violence in urban environments.
7eveloping leaders who understand the uniue dynamics of urban communities can help improverelationships between youth and law enforcement. &nd while urban neighborhoods have a strong police
presence, they often lack youth9oriented community policing programs that have culturally competent
law enforcement with the tools, education, ties to community9based organizations, and the will to serve
youth victims of crime in urban communities.
2
&outh pro'ras that a%%ress the root o" the pro!#e ha(e to coe "irst
TagIt:
What in your %ersonal e%erience canshow the %ower o youth %rograms0
http://www.thecrimereport.org/viewpoints/2011-05-stop-the-cycle-of-violence-against-young-peopleand-shttp://www.thecrimereport.org/viewpoints/2011-05-stop-the-cycle-of-violence-against-young-peopleand-shttp://www.thecrimereport.org/viewpoints/2011-05-stop-the-cycle-of-violence-against-young-peopleand-shttp://www.thecrimereport.org/viewpoints/2011-05-stop-the-cycle-of-violence-against-young-peopleand-s -
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
28/55
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
29/55
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
30/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
:?
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
31/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
2AC ANS"ERS$O C#AOSDISADAN$AE
Ha%itan and Schulte 2??2 6+omis and ;rich, +homas ro o hiloso%hy I 3/llionois U, and ;rich , Eournal o olitical and =ilitary Sociology Jol# :? /ss# 1,2??2, %%# 12K, Luestia EG
The prevalent rhetoric of -terrorism- has not provided an intelligent response to the problem of
terrorism. To the contrary, it has shut off any meaningful eamination of causes or debate onpolicies and has left only the path of violence to solve differences. Rather than promoting a free
and open eamination of the grievances of the group from which terrorists emerge, the -terrorist-
label nips all uestioning and debate in the bud. Terrorists are DevilD9as the F.8. &dministration
has repeated on numerous occasions since 8eptember >>, 233>9and are therefore to beeradicated.
This upshot of the book is that a terrorist is portrayed as a carrier of Doppression and
enslavement,D lacking moral sense, and Da perfect nihilistD 1pp. 2;9@35. Given that the
overwhelming number of eamples of terrorism are identified as coming from the &rab and
#slamic worlds, and that DretaliationD against terrorists is repeatedly urged even at the epense ofcivilian casualties, then one begins to see the point of 0dward 8aid-s assessment of the book as
nothing short of Dan incitement to anti9&rab and anti9oslem violenceD 18aid >;II!>=5.>=
:1
$rin/ to (care ,( .it' t'reat( o3 terrori(m ca,(e(raci(m
Why would it bedangerous to hy%e u%ears o terrorism0
TagIt:
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
32/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
:2
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
33/55
Police and CrimeStarter Pack
BAUDL
Fall 2011
2AC ANS"ERS$O COMMUNI$!POLICIN
(ec!er9 Dr& #arold A-ril 2???Cali3ornia State Unier(it Lon/ Beac'Princi-al Ine(ti/ator& Can Comm,nit Policin/ Preent !o,t' Crime);USA:
What are your own originalarguments against their youth%rograms %osition0
!o,t' iolence -reention -ro/ram( can %e 'arm3,l&
TagIt:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK44295/#A13079http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK44295/#A13079 -
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
54/55
-
8/14/2019 Baudl Novice Pack 2011 2012
55/55