Baud_Environmental Governance in Latin America- Towards an Integrative Research Agenda

8/13/2019 Baud_Environmental Governance in Latin America- Towards an Integrative Research Agenda

1/10

!"#$%&'( *&+,&- $. /'0,( 12,3'( '(4 5'#,66&'( 70"4,&8"#$ %&'() *#++ , -".//

012)(3456 27 89:;% < 85=>'5 ?@' ;A>(= %B5'(CA= D535A'C4 A=6 :@C1B5=>A>(@= , 85=>'@ 65

93>16(@3 7 :@C1B5=>AC(E= ;A>(=@AB5'(CA=@3$ %B3>5'6ABF GHHI #"*J.#K#/F LLLMC56)AM1NAM=)

9O&)@'AC(@=53P9O&)@'A>(@=3

9=N('@=B5=>A) Q@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CAR

S@LA'63 A= G=>5T'A>(N5 D535A'C4 %T5=6A9,3:,&; (= %B5'(CA &)A73 A= (B&@'>A=> (=>5'=A>(@=A) '@)5 L(>4 '5TA'6 >@ 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5M

U=@L)56T5 T5=5'A>56 27 5B&('(CA) A=6 >45@'5>(CA) 3>16(53 @= 5=N('@=B5=>A) C4A))5=T53 CA= 31&&@'> >45

'5=5L56 5??@'>3 (= >45 '5T(@= >@ AC4(5N5 5V1(>A2)5 A=6 313>A(=A2)5 =A>1'A) '53@1'C5 135M %)>4@1T4 )(=W.

AT53 25>L55= 3@C(A) A=6 5=N('@=B5=>A) 6(B5=3(@=3 4AN5 255= ACA65B(CA))7 5O&)@'56 3(=C5 >45 +""#3$

=5L >'5=63 (= 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA 6535'N5 A C@B&'545=3(N5 A=A)7>(CA) A&.

&'@AC4M S4(3 9O&)@'A>(@= &'535=>3 5B5'T(=T '535A'C4 >@&(C3 A=6 &'@N(653 A 2'(5? @N5'N(5L @? '5)5NA=>

5)5B5=>3 A=6 XC'@33@N5'3Y ?@' A= (=>5T'A>(N5 A=A)73(3M S45 A1>4@'3 A'T15 >4A> (= @'65' >@ 5=4A=C5 X;A>(=

%B5'(CA= &5'3&5C>(N53Y >@ 3@)N(=T 3@C(@.5=N('@=B5=>A) 6()5BBA3$ 35N5'A) '535A'C4 3>'5AB3 =556 >@ 252'@1T4> >@T5>45' (= (=>5T'A>(N5 ?'AB5L@'W3 >4A> CA= A66'533 C@B&)5O V153>(@=3 '5)A>56 >@ (=>5'AC>(@=3

25>L55= 3>A>5$ C(N() 3@C(5>7 A=6 BA'W5> AC>@'3 @= B1)>(&)5 3CA)53M % C@=3@'>(1B @? >5= ;A>(= %B5'(CA=

A=6 91'@&5A= (=3>(>1>(@=3 A(B3 >@ C@=>'(21>5 >@ >45 65N5)@&B5=> @? 31C4 ?'AB5L@'W3 >4'@1T4 >45 &'@Z5C>

9=N('@=B5=>A) Q@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA A=6 >45 8A'(225A=R :5N5)@&(=T ['AB5L@'W3 ?@' H13>A(=.

A2)5 A=6 9V1(>A2)5 IA>1'A) D53@1'C5 \35 ]9IQ^_`M B&C-$#48A 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5$ 5=N('@=.

B5=>A) &@)(>(C3$ 5=N('@=B5=>A) Z13>(C5$ =A>1'5$ 313>A(=A2()(>7M

G= '5C5=> 75A'3$ ;A>(= %B5'(CA= C@1=>'(53 4AN5 C@B5 >@ @CC1&7 A W57 '@)5 (= T)@2A)

652A>53 @= CA1353 A=6 3@)1>(@=3 >@ 5=N('@=B5=>A) &'@2)5B3 A=6 C)(BA>5 C4A=T5M

aA356 @= (=6(T5=@13 A=6 @>45' 3@C(A) B@N5B5=>3Y N(5L3 A=6 3>'1TT)53$ A 35'(53 @?

=5L &5'3&5C>(N53 A=6 &@)(C(53 4AN5 255= (=>'@61C56M G= *##/$ 9C1A6@' 25CAB5 >45

?('3> C@1=>'7 (= >45 L@')6 >@ T(N5 C@=3>(>1>(@=A) '(T4>3 >@ =A>1'5 L4()5 a'Ab() &'@B.

(356 >@ '561C5 %BAb@= 65?@'53>A>(@= A=6 3>A'> >45 ?('3> =A>(@=A) &'@T'ABB5 ?@' '5.

61C(=T 8^*5B(33(@=3 ?'@B 65?@'53>A>(@= A=6 65T'A6A>(@= ]D9::`M G= :5C5B25'

*##"$ 35N5'A) ;A>(= %B5'(CA= 65)5TA>53 >@@W ?('B &@3(>(@=3 A> >45 \=(>56 IA>(@=3

]\I` 8)(BA>5 84A=T5 8@=?5'5=C5 (= 8@&5=4AT5=$ '5?5''(=T >@ >45 X5C@)@T(CA)

652>Y @? I@'>45'= C@1=>'(53 >@LA'63 >45 H@1>4M 0'53(65=> c@'A)53 CA))56 >45 8@.

&5=4AT5= %CC@'6 ())5T(>(BA>5 A=6 A==@1=C56 >4A> a@)(N(A L@1)6 @'TA=(b5 A= A)>5'.

=A>(N5 5N5=>$ >45 d@')6Y3 05@&)5 8@=?5'5=C5 @= 8)(BA>5 84A=T5 A=6 >45 D(T4>3 @?

c@>45' 9A'>4$ L4(C4 >@@W &)AC5 (= %&'() *#+# (= 8@C4A2AB2AM %> >45 \I 8)(BA>5

84A=T5 8@=?5'5=C5 (= 8A=C1= (= :5C5B25' *#+#$ a@)(N(A A)3@ @&&@356 >45 8A=.

C1= %CC@'6 A=6 c@'A)53 LA'=56 >4A> (> C@1)6 CA135 A= X5C@C(65YM %=@>45' (=>5'53>.

(=T A==@1=C5B5=> 4A6 C@B5 (= %1T13> @? >4A> 3AB5 75A'R >45 9C1A6@'(A= T@N5'=.

B5=> 4A6 AT'556 L(>4 >45 \I :5N5)@&B5=> 0'@T'ABB5 >@ C'5A>5 A= (=>5'=A>(@=A)S'13> [1=6 >@ &'@>5C> eA31=f$ A B5TA.2(@6(N5'3(>7 &'@>5C>56 A'5A (= 9C1A6@'M %).

>4@1T4 (> (3 1=C5'>A(= (? >45 eA31=f.GSS (=(>(A>(N5 L()) BA>5'(A)(b5 A3 &)A==56$ (> (3

(==@NA>(N5 (= @??5'(=T (=613>'(A)(b56 C@1=>'(53 A= @&&@'>1=(>7 >@ ?(=A=C(A))7 C@B.

&5=3A>5 9C1A6@' ?@' =@> 5O>'AC>(=T >45 @() 25)@L eA31=(M [(=A))7$ >45 9C1A6@' C@1'>

65C(3(@= @? [52'1A'7 *#++$ @'65'(=T 845N'@= >@ &A7 \Hg/MK 2())(@= ?@' >45 &@))1.

>(@= CA1356 (= >45 9C1A6@'(A= %BAb@= 27 845N'@= A=6 S5OAC@ 3(=C5 >45 +"K#3$


2/10

/# , *&+,80' !"#$%&' 4& !80"4,$8 /'0,($'2,3'($8 C 4&; 5'#,6& "#$ A2'() 65 *#++

4A3 255= ?15))(=T 652A>53 @= 476'@CA'2@= 5O>'AC>(@= A'@1=6 >45 L@')6 A=6 (3 )(W5)7

>@ A??5C> 3(B()A' C@1'> CA353 5)35L45'5M

S45 '5T(@= A)3@ 4@)63 A W57 &@3(>(@= (= &473(CA) >5'B3R (> 4@3>3 =5A')7 4A)? @?

>45 L@')6Y3 >'@&(CA) ?@'53>3$ @=5 V1A'>5' @? >45 L@')6Y3 &@>5=>(A) A'A2)5 )A=6$ @=5

>4('6 @? ?'534LA>5' '535'N53$ A=6 A 'A=T5 @? (B&@'>A=> B(=5'A) '535'N53$ (=C)16(=T

476'@CA'2@=3M H(B1)>A=5@13)7$ >45 '5T(@= ACC@1=>3 ?@' @=5 >4('6 @? >45 L@')6Y3

CA'2@= 5B(33(@=3 ?'@B )A=6 135 C4A=T53M I5O> >@ >45 T)@2A) '5)5NA=C5 @? >4535

C4A'AC>5'(3>(C3 A=6 >'5=63$ =A>1'A) '53@1'C53 A'5 5N(65=>)7 C5=>'A) >@ >45 65N5)@&.

B5=> &5'3&5C>(N53 @? >45 '5T(@= A=6 >45 V1A)(>7 @? )(?5 @? (>3 (=4A2(>A=>3M S45 '1'A)

A=6 1'2A= &@@' (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA= C@1=>'(53 ?AC5 (=C'5A3(=T N1)=5'A2()(>(53 615 >@

C)(BA>5 C4A=T5 31C4 A3 ?)@@6(=T$ )A=63)(653$ 41''(CA=53$ 6'@1T4>$ &53> @1>2'5AW3

A=6 T)AC(5' '5>'5A>M c@'5 >4A= 5N5' 25?@'5$ ;A>(= %B5'(CA= C(>(b5=3 65BA=6 A=6

5O&5C> >4A> >45(' T@N5'=B5=>3 ?(=6 LA73 >@ AC4(5N5 5V1(>A2)5$ 313>A(=A2)5 A=6 &'@.

61C>(N5 65N5)@&B5=>M I5O> >@ L())(=T=533 A=6 C'5A>(N(>7$ 4@L5N5'$ AC4(5N(=T =5L

B@653 >@ T@N5'= >45 135 @? =A>1'A) '53@1'C53 '5V1('53 @N5'C@B(=T &5'3(3>5=> 2A''(.

5'3 31C4 A3 4(3>@'(CA) (=Z13>(C53$ 3@C(A) (=5V1A)(>(53 A=6 5C@=@B(C (=5??(C(5=C(53M

U=@L)56T5 T5=5'A>56 27 5B&('(CA) A=6 >45@'5>(CA) 3>16(53 @? 5=N('@=B5=>A)

T@N5'=A=C5 CA= &'@N(65 3C4@)A')7 31&&@'> ?@' 31C4 5=65AN@1'3$ 53&5C(A))7 (? >457A&&)7 A C@B&'545=3(N5 A&&'@AC4 >4A> )(=W3 >45@'7 A=6 &'AC>(C5M [@' >4(3 &1'&@35 L5

&'@&@35 A= (=>5=>(@=A))7 2'@A6 65?(=(>(@= @? 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 A3 2@>4

.$#2'; A=6 ,(.$#2'; &'AC>(C53 @? 135 A=6 BA=AT5B5=> @? #&(&-'6;& A=6 ($(D

#&(&-'6;&=A>1'A) '53@1'C53 A=6 (>3 >'A=32@1=6A'(53 (B&)(CA>(@=3M+S4(3 (B&)(53 A

?@C13 @= 4@L >4535 &'AC>(C53 A'5 &5'C5(N56$ C@=>53>56 A=6 '534A&56 (= >45 C@=>5O>

@? 'A&(6 A=6 C@B&)5O 3@C(A)$ &@)(>(CA)$ 5C@=@B(C A=6 5=N('@=B5=>A) C4A=T53 A>

;$3';= ('0,$(';= A=6@;$6';)5N5)3M %)>4@1T4 )(=WAT53 25>L55= 3@C(A) A=6 5=N('@=.

B5=>A) (33153 4AN5 255= 5O&)@'56 ACA65B(CA))7 3(=C5 >45 +""#3$ >45 =5L >'5=63 (=

5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA A'5 5B256656 (= A C@B&)5O A=6

C4A=T(=T B1)>(.3CA)5 C@=>5O> L4(C4 6535'N53 B@'5 A>>5=>(@=M GB&@'>A=> =5L >'5=63

(=C)165 5=N('@=B5=>A) C(>(b5=34(&$ >45 X'5>1'= @? >45 3>A>5Y A=6 >45 5B5'T5=C5 @?=5L T)@2A) &@L5' '5)A>(@=3M

G= >4(3 9O&)@'A>(@= L5 T(N5 A 2'(5? @N5'N(5L @? '5)5NA=> 5)5B5=>3 A=6 XC'@33.

@N5'3Y ?@' A= (=>5T'A>(N5 A=A)73(3 @? 5B5'T(=T '535A'C4 >@&(C3 >4A> 6535'N5 3&5C(A)

A>>5=>(@=M G= @'65' >@ 5=4A=C5 X;A>(= %B5'(CA= &5'3&5C>(N53Y >@ 3@)N(=T 3@C(@.

5=N('@=B5=>A) 6()5BBA3$ 35N5'A) '535A'C4 3>'5AB3 =556 >@ 25 2'@1T4> >@T5>45' (=

(=>5T'A>(N5 ?'AB5L@'W3 >4A> CA= A66'533 C@B&)5O V153>(@=3 '5)A>56 >@ (=>5'AC>(@=3

25>L55= 3>A>5$ C(N() 3@C(5>7 A=6 BA'W5> AC>@'3 A> B1)>(&)5 3CA)53M % C@=3@'>(1B @?

>5= ;A>(= %B5'(CA= A=6 91'@&5A= (=3>(>1>(@=3 4@&53 >@ C@=>'(21>5 >@ >45 65N5)@&.

B5=> @? 31C4 ?'AB5L@'W3 >4'@1T4 C@))A2@'A>(N5 5??@'>3 (= >45 &'@Z5C> 9=N('@=.

B5=>A) Q@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA A=6 >45 8A'(225A=R :5N5)@&(=T ['AB5L@'W3

?@' H13>A(=A2)5 A=6 9V1(>A2)5 IA>1'A) D53@1'C5 \35 ]9IQ^_`M

!"# %&'()*)&'+ ,'( -.)/()'0 &' "1)+*)'0 23'/"(0"+4

9=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA 4A3 T@=5 >4'@1T4 BAZ@' >'A=3?@'BA.

>(@=3 (= >45 )A3> 65CA653M ['@B >45 B(6.+"/#3 @=LA'63$ (> LA3 A T5=5'A) >'5=6 >@

>1'= ALA7 ?'@B C5=>'A)(b56$ 3>A>5.2A356 (=3>(>1>(@=A) A''A=T5B5=>3F L(>4 >45 5B.

&4A3(3 @= &'(NA>(bA>(@= A=6 65C5=>'A)(bA>(@=$ >45 =5L A&&'@AC453 >@ =A>1'A) '5.


3/10


4/10


5/10

!"#$%&'( *&+,&- $. /'0,( 12,3'( '(4 5'#,66&'( 70"4,&8"#$ %&'() *#++ , /h

6(3>'(21>(@= @? ACC533 A=6 25=5?(>3$ B1)>(&)5 135 A=6 BA=AT5B5=> A''A=T5B5=>3M

:5?(=56 A3 312>'AC>A2)5 '53@1'C53 L4@35 &@>5=>(A) 135'3 A'5 6(??(C1)> >@ 25 5O.

C)1656$ >45 3$22$(8 6(??5' ?'@B ]5OC)13(N5` &'(NA>5 T@@63 @' ]=@=.312>'AC>A2)5`

&12)(C T@@63 ]^3>'@B 5> A)M *##*`M 8@B2(=(=T A 'A=T5 @? BA'W5> A=6 =@=.BA'W5>

NA)153 A=6 B1)>(&)5 1353 A> )@CA)$ =A>(@=A)$ A=6 (=>5'=A>(@=A) )5N5)3$ (=C5=>(N53 >@

@N5'135 @' C@=35'N5 >45 3$22$(8L()) NA'7 AB@=T AC>@'3$ 65&5=6(=T @= >45 3@C(@.

5=N('@=B5=>A) ?5A>1'53 (= &)AC5M

S45 6(3>'(21>(@=$ BA=AT5B5=>$ A=6 NA)15 @? >45 3$22$(8&)A7 A BAZ@' '@)5 (=

@1' 1=65'3>A=6(=T @? 3@C(A) &'@C53353 A=6 C@))5C>(N5 AC>(@= (= ;A>(= %B5'C(A 21>

A)3@ >5=3(@= A=6 C@=>53>A>(@= @N5' =A>1'A) '53@1'C53M S4(3 1'T53 A= A=A)7>(CA) A&.

&'@AC4 >4A> >AW53 (=>@ ACC@1=> >45 ?5A>1'53 @? =A>1'A) '53@1'C53$ @? >45(' 135'3$ A=6

@? >45 (=3>(>1>(@=A) A''A=T5B5=> ?@' >45(' ACC533 A=6 C@=>'@) (= @'65' >@ 1=65'3>A=6

>45 5B5'T5=C5$ &5'?@'BA=C5 A=6 '534A&(=T @? 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5M 8@=C5'=3

'5TA'6(=T T)@2A) C)(BA>5 C4A=T5 )(=W )@CA) AC>(@=3 >@ T)@2A) @1>C@B53 A=6 N(C5

N5'3A$ A=6 )5A6 >@ (=C'5A356 N1)=5'A2()(>7 @? >45 &@@' A=6 5=N('@=B5=>A) '(3W3 @?

?'AT()5 5C@373>5B3 ]\I90 *##"$ 93C@2A' *##/`M

5'*"06,*)'0 ,',/7*)%,/ 86,9"#&63+

:53&(>5 >45 )A'T5 =1B25' @? ACA65B(C 3>16(53 @= =A>1'A) '53@1'C5 135 A=6 5=N(.

'@=B5=>A) C4A))5=T53 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA$ >45'5 (3 A &'533(=T =556 ?@' (=>5T'A>56

?'AB5L@'W3 >@ &'@B@>5 6(A)@T15 AB@=T 6(??5'5=> 6(3C(&)(=53 A=6 '535A'C4 C@BB1.

=(>(53 31C4 A3 3>16(53 @? AT'A'(A= 65N5)@&B5=>$ (=6(T5=@13 &5@&)53$ 1'2A=(bA>(@=$

?@'BA) 5=N('@=B5=>A) &@)(>(C3 A=6 (=?@'BA) &'AC>(C53 @? )@CA) '53@1'C5 135M D5.

C5=>)7$ A )A'T5 A''A7 @? (=(>(A>(N53 ?@' >45 313>A(=A2)5 135 @? =A>1'A) '53@1'C53 4A3

5B5'T56$ (=C)16(=T '5?@'B3 (= 5=N('@=B5=>A) )5T(3)A>(@=$ 65C5=>'A)(b56 BA=AT5.

B5=> &'@C561'53$ 3@C(A) A=6 5C@=@B(C &A'>=5'34(&3$ ?(=A=C(A) C@B&5=3A>(@=

3C45B53$ A=6 [email protected]=AT5B5=> (=(>(A>(N53M i@L5N5'$ >45 TA&3 25>L55= 6(3C@1'35 A=6

W=@L)56T5 21()6(=T A=6 25>L55= (=3>(>1>(@=A) 653(T= A=6 AC>1A) (B&)5B5=>A>(@=A=6 B@=(>@'(=T A'5 @?>5= 2'@A6 A=6 '5&'535=> BAZ@' C4A))5=T53 ];5B@3 A=6

%T'ALA) *##K`M

S45 C@B&)5O(>7 @? 3@C(@.5=N('@=B5=>A) &'@C53353 A=6 >45 =556 ?@' A6A&>(N5 A=6

5??(C(5=> BA=AT5B5=> 373>5B3 34@L >45 (B&@'>A=C5 @? A6A&>(N5 A&&'@AC453 A=6

&A'>(C(&A>@'7 B5C4A=(3B3M G= >4(3 '5TA'6$ >45 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 &5'3&5C.

>(N5 A(B3 >@ (=>5T'A>5 >45 6(N5'3(>7 @? BA=AT5B5=> 373>5B3 (=C)16(=T >45 )A'T5

'A=T5 @? 3@C(A) AC>@'3 A=6 5C@)@T(CA) 373>5B3M !(+,#$(2&(0'; @$+('(3&$ L4(C4

5B5'T56 A3 A =5@)(25'A) C@=C5&> @? =@=.3>A>5 A&&'@AC4$ 4A3 255= '5L@'W56 27 3@.

C(A) 3C(5=>(3>3 >@ &'@&@35 =5L (=3>(>1>(@=A) &5'3&5C>(N53 @= =A>1'A) '53@1'C5 BA=.

AT5B5=>M 9=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 >AW53 (=>@ ACC@1=> >45 C@))5C>(N5 &'@2)5B.

3@)N(=T CA&AC(>(53 @? 6(??5'5=> AC>@'3 (= @'65' >@ 1=65'3>A=6 3@C(A) (=>5'AC>(@=3 A=6&@33(2)5 C@=?)(C>3 25>L55= >45B (= A C@B&)5O A=6 67=AB(C &'@C533 ]U@@(BA= 5> A)M

*##l`M S4(3 &5'3&5C>(N5 (3 C@==5C>56 >@ >45 C@=C5&>3 @? &(+,#$(2&(0'; E"80,3& F

L4(C4 &)AC53 6(3>'(21>(@= @? 5=N('@=B5=>A) 25=5?(>3 A=6 C@3>3$ 5B&@L5'B5=> @?

BA'T(=A)(b56 T'@1&3$ T5=65' (=C)13(@=$ A=6 &@N5'>7 '561C>(@= (= >45 C5=>'5 ]8A'.

'1>45'3 *##/` < A=6 &(+,#$(2&(0'; %$;,0,38= L45'5 >45 &@3(>(@= @? >45 3>A>5 4A3 255=

T'A61A))7 '565?(=56 ]9AW(= A=6 ;5B@3 *##K`M

8@=3(65'(=T >45 )@=T >'A6(>(@= @? 3@C(@.5=N('@=B5=>A) '535A'C4 A=6 >45 '5C5=>


6/10

/J , *&+,80' !"#$%&' 4& !80"4,$8 /'0,($'2,3'($8 C 4&; 5'#,6& "#$ A2'() 65 *#++

>45@'5>(CA) 65N5)@&B5=>3$ >45 >(B5 (3 '(&5 >@ 65N5)@& A B@'5 (=C)13(N5$ A6A&>(N5$

A=6 (=>5'6(3C(&)(=A'7.@'(5=>56 ?'AB5L@'W ?@' 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(=

%B5'(CAM :53&(>5 3@B5 NA)1A2)5 5OAB&)53 @? 3>AW54@)65' (=N@)N5B5=> (= 3C4@)A')7

&'@Z5C>3 A=6 (B&@'>A=> '5T(@=A) ACA65B(C =5>L@'W3$ >45 '535A'C4 5??@'>3 '5TA'6(=T

=A>1'A) '53@1'C5 135 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA A'5 )(B(>56 27 35N5'A) 2A''(5'3 (= W=@L)56T5

T5=5'A>(@= A=6 34A'(=TM

[('3>)7$ >45'5 4AN5 255= =@ 373>5BA>(C '5T(@=A) 5??@'>3 >@ A=A)735 >45 &'@2)5B3

@? 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 A=6 =5L 5=N('@=B5=>A) C4A))5=T53 ?'@B A T5=5'A)

;A>(= %B5'(CA= &5'3&5C>(N5M %3 A C@=35V15=C5$ 31CC533?1) &'@&@3A)3 ?@' A66'533(=T

3@C(@.5=N('@=B5=>A) 6()5BBA3 (= >45 '5T(@= 4AN5 255= )(B(>56 1=>() =@L >@ 312.

'5T(@=3 ]5MTM$ >45 %BAb@=$ %=653$ c53@.%B5'(CA$ >45 8A'(225A=` @' B@'5 )@CA)

C@=>5O>3M H5C@=6)7$ A)>4@1T4 B@'5 (=>5T'A>(N5 A=A)7353 4AN5 255= 65N5)@&56 (= >45

)A3> 65CA65$ '535A'C4 @= =A>1'A) '53@1'C5 135 '5BA(=3 6(N(656 (=>@ '53@1'C5 1=(>3

]5MT$ B(=(=T$ )A=6$ LA>5'$ ?(34$ @' ?@'53>`$ 3@C(A) T'@1&3 ]5MTM$ 35>>)5'3$ 3V1A>>5'3 A=6

>'A6(>(@=A) &@&1)A>(@=3` A=6 &@)(C7 35C>@'3 ]5MT$ C@=35'NA>(@=$ 65N5)@&B5=> A=6

&@N5'>7 A))5N(A>(@=`M S4('6)7$ B@3> @? >45 3@C(@.5=N('@=B5=>A) '535A'C4 (= ;A>(=

%B5'(CA 4A3 255= CA''(56 @1> ?'@B >45 &5'3&5C>(N5 @? 3(=T)5 6(3C(&)(=53M S45 (=>5.

T'A>(@= 25>L55= =A>1'A) A=6 3@C(A) 3C(5=C53 4A3 65N5)@&56 @N5' >45 75A'3$ 21>('@=(CA))7 >45'5 (3 3>()) )(B(>56 C'@33.?5'>()(bA>(@= AB@=T >45 2'@A6 'A=T5 @? >45 3@.

C(A) 3C(5=C53 A=6 41BA=(>(53M %2@N5 A)) 4(3>@'(CA))7 T'@1=656 A&&'@AC453 4AN5

4A'6)7 255= (=C@'&@'A>56M [@1'>4)7$ '5C5=> =5L T@N5'=A=C5 (=(>(A>(N53 (=(>(A>56 27

&@3>.=5@)(25'A) T@N5'=B5=>3$ >45(' (B&)(CA>(@=3 ?@' 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5$

&@N5'>7 A))5N(A>(@= A=6 3@C(A) A=6 T5=65' 5V1A)(>7$ A=6 >45 (=?)15=C5 @? A C4A=T(=T

(=>5'=A>(@=A) C@=>5O> 4AN5 =@> 75> '5C5(N56 >45 =5C533A'7 3C4@)A')7 A>>5=>(@=M [(.

=A))7$ B1C4 3>()) =5563 >@ 25 6@=5 >@ 5=C@1'AT5 A= @=T@(=T 6(A)@T15 25>L55= ;A>(=

%B5'(CA= '535A'C45'3 A=6 ;A>(= %B5'(CA=(3>3$ &@)(C7.BAW5'3 A=6 @>45' 3>AW5.

4@)65'3 (= >45 ?(5)6 @? 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (= >45 '5T(@=M

G= @'65' >@ A6NA=C5 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 '535A'C4 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA$ A

'5T(@=A) &5'3&5C>(N5 T@(=T 257@=6 5O(3>(=T A&&'@AC453 >@ 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=.A=C5 (3 =55656M I5L (=3(T4>3 CA= 25 T5=5'A>56 ?'@B C@B&A'A>(N5 A=A)73(3 AB@=T

'53@1'C5 1=(>3 L4()5 '5C@T=(b(=T >45 5N(65=> 6(??5'5=C53 (= >45 &473(CA)$ 5C@=@B(C

A=6 3@C(A) 135 @? 6(??5'5=> =A>1'A) '53@1'C53 (= 6(??5'5=> '5T(@=A) 35>>(=T3M [1'>45'.

B@'5$ (=>5T'A>(N5 A=A)73(3 C@B2(=(=T )A=63CA&5 C@=?(T1'A>(@=$ B1)>(&)5 )@CA) AC.

>@'3$ A=6 B1)>(&)5 (=3>(>1>(@=3 CA= '5=65' A 25>>5' 1=65'3>A=6(=T @? 4@L >45 135 @?

6(??5'5=> '53@1'C53$ 3@C(A) T'@1&3 A=6 &@)(C(53 BA7 25 '5)A>56M S4('6)7$ 2'(=T(=T

>@T5>45' 6(??5'5=> 6(3C(&)(=A'7 A&&'@AC453 >@ 5=N('@=B5=>A) C4A))5=T53 A=6 T@N5'=.

A=C5 L()) '5=65' 25>>5' 1=65'3>A=6(=T @? >45 67=AB(C &'@C533 ?'@B A= 5O&)(C(>)7

B1)>(.3CA)5 A=6 6(AC4'@=(C &5'3&5C>(N5M [@1'>4)7$ ?@C13(=T @= '5C5=> &@)(C(53 C@B.

2(=(=T &@N5'>7 '561C>(@=$ 3@C(A) (=C)13(@=$ A=6 5=N('@=B5=>A) C@=35'NA>(@= L())

3456 )(T4> @= 4@L 3>AW54@)65'3 (=>5'AC> >@ A66'533 B1)>(.3CA)5 5=N('@=B5=>A) C4A).

)5=T53M [(=A))7$ (=>5'=A>(@=A) ACA65B(C W=@L)56T5 34@1)6 (=C@'&@'A>5 A T'@L(=T

'5T(@=A) )(>5'A>1'5 @= 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 2A356 @= 3@)(6 5B&('(CA) '535A'C4

]C?M Q167=A3 *##"F m4@1'( A=6 ;A3C45?3W( *#+#`M G= >4(3 LA7$ >45 6(A)@T15 25.

>L55= '535A'C45'3 A=6 &@)(C7 BAW5'3 (= 6(??5'5=> &A'>3 @? >45 L@')6 L()) 25 (B.

&'@N56$ 4@&5?1))7 )5A6(=T >@ A C@BB@= )A=T1AT5 '5TA'6(=T 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=.

A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA A=6 >45 '@)5 @? (=>5'=A>(@=A) C@@&5'A>(@=M


7/10

!"#$%&'( *&+,&- $. /'0,( 12,3'( '(4 5'#,66&'( 70"4,&8"#$ %&'() *#++ , /l

:,6(+ ("";"'"( ("-,*"+< &/( =."+*)&'+> '"# %&''"%*)&'+

9=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 CA= 253> 25 A&&'@AC456 A3 A 67=AB(C &'@C533 2A356 @=

(=>5'AC>(@=3 AB@=T 6(??5'5=> 3>AW54@)65'3 C@=3(3>(=T @? ?@1' BA(= &4A353R +` 6(3.

C@1'35 A=6 W=@L)56T5 21()6(=T$ *` 653(T=$ h` (B&)5B5=>A>(@= A=6 J` B@=(>@'.

(=TP5NA)1A>(@=M c@'5 >4A= A &@)(C7 C7C)5$ >4535 ?@1' &4A353 5=C@B&A33 2@>4 ?@'BA)

A=6 (=?@'BA) &'@C53353 A=6 B5C4A=(3B3 L4(C4 @N5')A& A=6 C@=3>A=>)7 C4A=T5 AC.C@'6(=T >@ 3&5C(?(C 4(3>@'(CA)$ 3@C(A) A=6 5=N('@=B5=>A) C@=>5O>3$ A=6 4@L >45 3@.

C(A) C@=?(T1'A>(@= (3 34A&56 AB@=T 6(??5'5=> AC>@'3M ^?>5= (=>5'53>3 A=6 &@)(>(CA)

&'5331'5 CA= @N5''(65 &A'>(C1)A' G($-;&4@&8$ @' 65?(=5 L4(C4 >7&5 @? W=@L)56T5 (3

>@ 25 1356M S4(3 B1)>(.3CA)5 &'@C533 BA7 )5A6 >@ >45 5B5'T5=C5$ 5'@3(@= @' '534A&.

(=T @? 3@C(@.5=N('@=B5=>A) C@=?(T1'A>(@=3$ L4@35 &5'?@'BA=C5 BA7 3L(=T 25>L55=

L4A> (3 )533 @' B@'5 3@C(A))7$ 5C@=@B(CA))7$ A=6 5=N('@=B5=>A))7 5??(C(5=>M S45

'535A'C4 AT5=6A ?@' 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 5O&)@'53 4@L >45 (=>5'&)A7 25>L55=

6(??5'5=> ?@'B3 @? &@)(>(C3 A=6 @>45' 3@C(A) (=>5'AC>(@=3 < ?'@B 5N5'76A7 )(?5 &'AC.

>(C53 >@ C@))5C>(N5 AC>(@=3$ A=6 ?@'BA) &@)(>(C3 < CA= 65?(=5 A )A'T5 'A=T5 @? @1>.

C@B53 A> 6(??5'5=> 3CA)53M

S45 (=C'5A3(=T &5'B5A2()(>7 @? 3&A>(A))7 A=6 (=3>(>1>(@=A))7 53>A2)(3456 2@'65'3A3 L5)) A3 >45 '5C@T=(>(@= >4A> C@==5C>(@=3 '5V1('5 B1)>(&)5.3CA)5 3>'A>5T(53 T(N5

LA7 >@ A=A)7353 @? >45 >'A=3=A>(@=A) 6(B5=3(@=3 @? 5C@=@B(C$ &@)(>(CA) A=6 3@C(A)

(=>5'AC>(@=3M G= >4(3 '5TA'6$ 313>A(=A2)5 A=6 5V1(>A2)5 135 @? =A>1'A) '53@1'C53 4A3

25C@B5 A ?(5)6 @? C'@33.2@1=6A'7 3>167$ (= 3@ ?A' A3 A 'A=T5 @? =5L B1)>(6(3C(&)(.

=A'7 A&&'@AC453 A'5 2'@1T4> >@T5>45'M :'AL(=T @= >45 NA'(@13 3@C(A) 3C(5=C5 ?(5)63

5=A2)53 A 25>>5' 1=65'3>A=6(=T @? >45 C@B&)5O 3@C(A) '5)A>(@=3 A=6 &'@C53353 )(=W56

>@ =A>1'A) '53@1'C5 135 A=6 BA=AT5B5=> (= ;A>(= %B5'(CAM G= >45 3AB5 N5(=$ 4(3>@.

'(A=3 BA7 653C'(25 A=6 A=A)735 4@L 2@1=6A'(53 C@=>(=1@13)7 34(?> A=6 C4A=T5 @N5'

>(B5 ]C?M aA16 *###`M 0@)(>(CA) 3C(5=>(3>3 A=6 &@)(>(CA) 5C@=@B(3>3 4AN5 A=A)7356

>'A=3=A>(@=A) &@)(>(C3 < (=C)16(=T >'A=3=A>(@=A) A6N@CAC7 =5>L@'W3 A=6 &@)(C7 =5>.

L@'W3 < A=6 5C@=@B(C >'A=3=A>(@=A)(bA>(@= ]i@C43>5>)5' A=6 U5CW *##-`M 0@)(>(CA)A=6 41BA= 5C@)@T(3>3 5B&4A3(b5 >45 (=>5'&)A7 25>L55= )@CA) A=6 2'@A65' 3@C(@.

5=N('@=B5=>A) &'@C53353 (= =A>1'A) '53@1'C5 BA=AT5B5=> 373>5B3 ]8A3>'@$ ?@'>4.

C@B(=T` L4()5 3@C(@)@T(3>3 A=6 A=>4'@&@)@T(3>3 A66'533 4@L C1)>1'5$ (=?@'BA>(@=$

A=6 >5C4=@)@T7 (=?)15=C5 C4A=T53 (= BA>5'(A) A=6 37B2@)(C NA)153 @? =A>1'5 AC'@33

3@C(A) T'@1&3 ];A>>A A=6 d(>>BA= *#+#`M

X;A>(= %B5'(CA= &5'3&5C>(N53Y >@ 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5$ >45'5?@'5$ 34@1)6

5=C@B&A33 >L@ BA(= C@B&@=5=>3R >45 &'@61C>(@= 373>5B ]L4(C4 '5V1('53 BA=.

AT5B5=> B5A31'53` A=6 >45 3@C(A) C@=>5O> (= L4(C4 =5T@>(A>(@=3$ 3>'1TT)53$ A=6

65C(3(@=3 >AW5 &)AC5M S45 ?@'B5' (=C)1653 (33153 &5'>A(=(=T >@ >45 3@C(A) A=6 5C@.

)@T(CA) C4A))5=T53 >@ 313>A(=A2)5 &'AC>(C53$ ?@@6 35C1'(>7$ 3>'5=T>45=56 '53()(5=C5$

655&5=56 &A'>(C(&A>(@=$ A=6 5=N('@=B5=>A) Z13>(C5M S45 )A>>5' >AW53 (=>@ ACC@1=> >45

4(3>@'(CA)$ 3>'1C>1'A)$ @'TA=(bA>(@=A) A=6 (=?@'BA>(@= C@=>5O>3M %= (=>5T'A>(N5 &5'.

3&5C>(N5 L()) &5'B(> A= 1=65'3>A=6(=T @? >45 '5)A>(@=34(& 25>L55= C@=>5O>1A) ?AC.

>@'3 A=6 6(??5'5=> &'@61C>(@= A=6 C@=31B&>(@= &A>>5'=3 1=65' 3@C(A) A=6 5=N('@=.

B5=>A) C4A=T5M

S45 C1''5=> 3>A>5 @? 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA &'@N@W53 A

35'(53 @? V153>(@=3 < A=6 A= (=N(>A>(@= >@ 5=TAT5 (= A=3L5'(=T >45BM c@3> @? >4535

V153>(@=3 A'5 @)6F (= ?AC>$ >457 4AN5 255= T1(6(=T >45 652A>53 @= 5=N('@=B5=> A=6


8/10

/K , *&+,80' !"#$%&' 4& !80"4,$8 /'0,($'2,3'($8 C 4&; 5'#,6& "#$ A2'() 65 *#++

65N5)@&B5=> 3(=C5 >45 +"-#3M \=?@'>1=A>5)7$ 653&(>5 5O>5=3(N5 ACA65B(C$ 3@C(5>A)

A=6 &@)(>(CA) 5??@'>3$ BA=7 @? >45 X@)6Y C@B&)5O(>(53 @? 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5

6()5BBA3 '5BA(= N5'7 >@&(CA)M i@L CA= L5 @N5'C@B5 >45 &A'A6@O 25>L55= (=.

C'5A356 &'@61C>(@= A=6 &@N5'>7 T'@L>4 615 >@ )A'T5 3CA)5 &'@61C>(@= 373>5B3n

i@L CA= L5 3@)N5 >45 (=C@B&A>(2()(>7 25>L55= 6(??5'5=> &'@61C>(@= 373>5B3n i@L

CA= L5 C'5A>5 3>'1C>1'A)$ )@CA) 65N5)@&B5=> 3>'A>5T(53 A=6 5??5C>(N5)7 &'@B@>5 5=.

N('@=B5=>A) Z13>(C5n %=6 4@L CA= L5 >1'= T)@2A) C)(BA>5 C4A=T5 (33153 (=>@ A=

@&&@'>1=(>7 ?@' 5C@=@B(C A=6 3@C(A) 65N5)@&B5=>n

8)5A')7$ 3C4@)A'3 CA= C@=>'(21>5 3@B5 (=T'56(5=>3$ 21> ?@'B1)A>(=T 135?1) A=.

3L5'3 >@ >4535 V153>(@=3 (3 A >A3W (= L4(C4 A NA'(5>7 @? @>45' AC>@'3 L()) 4AN5 >@ 25

(=N@)N56R )@CA) C@BB1=(>(53$ C(N() 3@C(5>7 @'TA=(bA>(@=3$ &@)(C7.BAW5'3 A=6 5=>'5.

&'5=51'3 A3 L5)) A3 7@1=T T5=5'A>(@=3$ &'(NA>5 (=N53>@'3 A=6 (=>5'=A>(@=A) (=3>(>1.

>(@=3 < A)) CA= C@=>'(21>5 '5)5NA=> 5O&5'(5=C5$ W=@L)56T5$ N(5L3 A=6 &'@&@3A)3M

8@=>'A3>(=T (=>5'53>3 A=6 &5'3&5C>(N53 6@ =@> 4AN5 >@ (=4(2(> 25=5?(C(A) B1)>(.AC>@'

C@BB1=(CA>(@= @= 5=N('@=B5=>A) (33153M 9N5= CA353 @? C@=?)(C>$ >45 C'5A>(@= @?

C@==5C>(@=3 ?@' @=T@(=T (=?@'BA>(@= ?)@L3 A=6 5OC4A=T53 @? (65A3 BA7 25 45)&?1)

A=6 31CC533?1)M H1C4 C@==5C>(@=3 B(T4> =@> '561C5 >45 >5=3(@=3 21> >457 BA7 @&5=

=5L 3&AC53 ?@' 65)(25'A>(@= @= >45 135 A=6 BA=AT5B5=> @? =A>1'A) '53@1'C53$ A=6A3 31C4 C@=>'(21>5 >@ 655&5=56 652A>53 A=6 >45 65B@C'A>(bA>(@= @? 5=N('@=B5=>A)

T@N5'=A=C5M [1'>45'B@'5$ >4535 W(=63 @? (=>5'AC>(@=3 25>L55= G($-;&4@&8 A=6

&'AC>(C53 A=6 AB@=T 6(??5'5=> AC>@'3 CA= &)A7 A C5=>'A) '@)5 (= >45 65N5)@&B5=> @?

?'AB5L@'W3 L45'5 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (3 A66'53356 A3 X&@)(C7 (= >45 BAW.

(=TY$ (= L4(C4 @)6 A=6 =5L ?@'BA) A=6 (=?@'BA) A''A=T5B5=>3 A'5 A=A)7356 A3 B1C4

A3 A= @1>C@B5 @? A 67=AB(C &'@C533 @? 3>'1TT)53$ >5=3(@=3 A=6 C@@&5'A>(@= (=

W=@L)56T5.21()6(=T A=6 5OC4A=T5 A3 >457 A'5 X>'(TT5'3Y ?@' =5L 3>'1TT)53 A=6 =5.

T@>(A>(@=3 (= (>3 (B&)5B5=>A>(@= A=6 B@=(>@'(=T &'@C533M

o o o

?)%@)"/ A,.(> B,-)& (" C,+*6& A=6 A,6-,6, D&0"'-&&9 A'5 '535A'C45'3 A>

89:;%$ L4(C4 C@@'6(=A>53 >45 9IQ^_ &'@Z5C>M 9IQ^_ (3 ?1=656 27 >45 91'@.

&5A= 8@BB(33(@= A=6 (=N@)N53 >45 C@))A2@'A>(@= 25>L55= 8@=35Z@ ;A>(=@AB5'(CA.

=@ 65 8(5=C(A3 H@C(A)53F 85=>'@ 65 :535=N@)N(B5=>@ H13>5=>jN5) < \=(N5'3(6A65

65 a'A3f)(AF \=(N5'3(6A6 %1>E=@BA c5>'@&@)(>A=A < p@C4(B()C@ ]cqO(C@`F G=3>(>1.

>@ 65 93>16(@3 %NA=bA6@3 < \=(N5'3(6A6 65 HA=>(AT@ 65 84()5F G=3>(>1>@ 65 G=N53>(.

TAC(@=53 Q(=@ Q5'BA=( ]%'T5=>(=A`F \=(N5'3(6A6 %=6(=A H(BE= a@)fNA' < H565

r1(>@F G=3>(>1> 65 8(s=C(A 7 S5C=t)@TA %B2(5=>A)3 < \=(N5'3(>A> %1>t=@BA 65

aA'C5)@=AF G=3>(>1> 65 D5C45'C45 &@1' )5 :qN5)@&&5B5=> ]['A=C5`F 85=>'5 ?@' :5.

N5)@&B5=> A=6 >45 9=N('@=B5=> < \=(N5'3(>5>5> ( ^3)@$ A=6 89:;%M S45 &'@Z5C>Y3

C5=>'A) @2Z5C>(N5 (3 >@ 1=65'3>A=6 4@L 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (3 34A&56 (= ;A>(=

%B5'(CA A=6 >@ 65N5)@& A =5L A=A)7>(CA) ?'AB5L@'W ?@' 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5

(= >45 '5T(@=M c@'5 (=?@'BA>(@= L()) 25 &'535=>56 @= LLLM5=T@NM51 A=6

LLLMC56)AM1NAM=)M

ukMcMaA16vC56)AM=)w u[M658A3>'@vC56)AM=)w uaMaMi@T5=2@@BvC56)AM=)w

E%3'/"(0"9"'*+(N5

'535A'C4 &'@Z5C> @= 5=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CA A=6 >45 8A'(225A=


9/10

!"#$%&'( *&+,&- $. /'0,( 12,3'( '(4 5'#,66&'( 70"4,&8"#$ %&'() *#++ , /-

]9IQ^_`M d5 A'5 T'A>5?1) ?@' >45 N5'7 135?1) C@BB5=>3 A=6 31TT53>(@=3 >@ >45

&'@&@3A) ?'@B >45 A=@=7B@13 '5N(5L5'3 ?@' >45 91'@&5A= 8@BB(33(@=Y3 [0- CA))$

L45'5 >4(3 &'@&@3A) 4A3 255= 312B(>>56$ A=6 ?'@B >45 C@))A2@'A>(=T '535A'C45'3R

%)25'>@ 8(BA6AB@'5$ k@A= cA'>f=5b %)(5'$ c(=A U)5(C45$ a5=56(C>5 a1))$ :@=A)6

HAL75'$ :AN(6 aA'W(=$ k1)(A= 0A'W5'$ iqC>@' H5Z5=@N(C4 A=6 0A2)@ %=6'A65M S45

'53&@=3(2()(>7 ?@' >4(3 9O&)@'A>(@= )(53 3@)5)7 L(>4 13M S4(3 L@'W 4A3 255= 31&.

&@'>56 27 >45 91'@&5A= 8@BB(33(@= L(>4(= >45 ->4 ?'AB5L@'W &'@T'ABB5 1=65'

T'A=> AT'55B5=> =@M [0-.HHi.8S.*#+#.*KK-+#M

!&*"

+M 9=N('@=B5=>A) T@N5'=A=C5 A66'53353 3@C(@.5=N('@=B5=>A) &'@C53353 2@>4 (= '1'A) A=6 1'2A= 35>.

>(=T3$ A=6 (= &'@61C>(@= A=6 C@=31B&>(@= &A>>5'=3M G= >4(3 9O&)@'A>(@= L5 5B&4A3(b5 >45 '@)5 @?

&'@61C>(@= 373>5B3 (= '1'A) A'5A3 (= >45 ;A>(= %B5'(CA= C@=>5O>M

F"8"6"'%"+

aA16$ cM ]*###` XH>A>5.21()6(=T A=6 a@'65')A=63 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CAYM G=R 0M NA= :(ZW$ %M ^1L5=55) A=6%M m@@B5'3 ]563` >#$(0'8A H$-'#48 ' 5'6ABR 89:;% ;A>(=

%B5'(CA= H>16(53 /-$ &&M J+./*M

8A''1>45'3$ :M_M ]56M` ]*##/`!(+,#$(2&(0'; I"80,3& ,( /'0,( 12,3'A J#$6;&28= J#$2,8&= '(4 J#'3D

0,3&YM 8AB2'(6T5R cGS 0'533M

8A3>'@$ [M ]?@'>4C@B(=T` X;@CA) A=6 Q)@2A) 9=N('@=B5=>A) 8(>(b5=34(&R 8@=>'A6(C>(@=3 (= >45 c1)>(&)5

0@)(>(CA) 0@3(>(@=3 @? S'A6(>(@=A) 0@&1)A>(@=3 (= >45 a'Ab()(A= %BAb@=YM G=R %M ;A>>A A=6 iM d(>>.

BA= ]563`!(+,#$(2&(0 '(4 5,0,K&(8:,% ,( /'0,( 12,3'A 7,0&8 $. 70#"@@;&= J$,(08 $. L&%'#0"#&M

:(ZCW$ 0M NA= ]56M` ]?@'>4C@B(=T` H:& M2%'30 $. 0:& MM*71 *$'4 M(.#'30"30"#& J#$@#'22& $( 12'K$(,'N

9AW(=$ iMF A=6 cM8M ;5B@3 ]*##K` X%6A&>A>(@= A=6 >45 H>A>5R ;A>(= %B5'(CA A=6 >45 84A))5=T5 @? 8A.

&AC(>7.a1()6(=T 1=65' Q)@2A)(bA>(@=Y$ O;$6'; !(+,#$(2&(0'; 5:'(@&+K]+`R -.+/M

93C@2A'$ %'>1'@ ]*##/` XH#,0$#,&8 $. L,..&(3&A J;'3&= 9$+&2&(08= /,.&= *&4&8YM :1'4ABR :1W5

\=(N5'3(>7 0'533M

[(3C45'$ 9M[MF A=6 0M a5=3@= ]*##K` A) 7 B5>A.C(16A6A=fA3 5C@)ET(CA3R D5N(3(E= 7 A)>5'=A>(NA3 5=

%Bq'(CA ;A>(=AY$L&8&(+$;+,2&(0$ & 9&,$ 126,&(0&+"R lh.-*M

i@C43>5>)5'$ UF A=6 cM9M U5CW ]*##-` O#&&(,(@ 7 0'533M

i@T5=2@@B$ aMF A=6 %M9M [5'=j=65b k()25'>@ ]*##"` XS45 I5L ;5?> A=6 c(=5'A) 0@)(>(C3R d4A>Y3

I5LnY$!"#$%&'( *&+,&- $. /'0,( 12,3'( '(4 5'#,66&'( 70"4,&8/-R "h.+#*M

U@@(BA=$ kMF cM aAN(=CW$ HM k5=>@?>$ A=6 DM 01))(= ]563` ]*##l` >,8: .$# /,.&A M(0'30,+& O$+('(3&

.$# >,8:,&8M %B3>5'6ABR %B3>5'6AB \=(N5'3(>7 0'533M

;A'3@=$ %McM ]*##h` X:5C5=>'A)(bA>(@= A=6 [@'53> cA=AT5B5=> (= ;A>(= %B5'(CAR S@LA'63 A d@'W(=T

c@65)Y$J"6;,3 142,(,80#'0,$( '(4 L&+&;$%2&(0*h]h`R *++.*KM

;A>>A$ %MF A=6 iM d(>>BA= ]*#+#` X9=N('@=B5=>A) 8(>(b5=34(& (= ;A>(= %B5'(CAR % I5L 0A'A6(TB ?@'

S45@'7 A=6 0'AC>(C5Y$!"#$%&'( *&+,&- $. /'0,( 12,3'( '(4 5'#,66&'( 70"4,&8/"R +#-.+KM

;5B@3$ cM8MF A=6 %M %T'ALA) ]*##K` X9=N('@=B5=>A) Q@N5'=A=C5Y$1(("'; *&+,&- $. !(+,#$(2&(0 '(4*&8$"#3&8h+R *"-.h*lM

;(N5'BA=$ :McMF A=6 HM _()A3 ]*##K` XI5@)(25'A)(3B A=6 >45 9=N('@=B5=> (= ;A>(= %B5'(CAY$ 1(("';

*&+,&- $. !(+,#$(2&(0 '(4 *&8$"#3&8h+R h*-.hKhM

cA'>(=5b.%)(5'$ kM ]+""+` X9C@)@T7 @? >45 0@@'R % I5T)5C>56 :(B5=3(@= @? ;A>(= %B5'(CA i(3>@'7Y$

I$"#('; $. /'0,( 12,3'( 70"4,&8 *h]h`R K*+.h"M

c())5'$ HMdM ]*##-` 1( !(+,#$(2&(0'; ?,80$#C $. /'0,( 12,3'A P&- 1%%#$'3:&8 0$ 0:& 12,3'8M

8AB2'(6T5R 8AB2'(6T5 \=(N5'3(>7 0'533M


10/10

// , *&+,80' !"#$%&' 4& !80"4,$8 /'0,($'2,3'($8 C 4&; 5'#,6& "#$ A2'() 65 *#++

^3>'@B$ 9MF SM :(5>b$ IM :@)3AW$ 0M8M H>5'=$ HM H>@=(C4$ A=6 9M\M d525' ]563` ]*##*` H:& L#'2' $. 0:&

5$22$(8M dA34(=T>@=R IA>(@=A) %CA65B7 0'533M

0A(=>5'$ cMF A=6 dMiM :1'4AB ]563` ]+""l` H:& 7$3,'; 5'"8&8 $. !(+,#$(2&(0'; L&80#"30,$( ,( /'0,(

12,3'N %== %'2@'R S45 \=(N5'3(>7 @? c(C4(TA= 0'533M

05>W@NA$ 9MF %McM ;A'3@=$ A=6 0M 0AC45C@ ]*#++` X[@'53> Q@N5'=A=C5 A=6 D9::R 84A))5=T53 ?@' 0@)(.

C(53 A=6 cA'W5>3 (= ;A>(= %B5'(CAY$>$#&808*$ H&5C(A) G3315M

\I90 ]*##"`/'0,( 12,3' '(4 0:& 5'#,66&'(A !(+,#$(2&(0 Q"0;$$GN \=(>56 IA>(@= 9=N('@=B5=>A)

0'@T'AB$ Q9^ ;%8 hMNA= :(ZCW$ 0M ]56M` ]?@'>4C@B(=T` H:& M2%'30 $. 0:& MM*71 *$'4 M(.#'30"30"#& J#$@#'22& $( 12'K$(,'N

m4@1'($ %MF A=6 UM ;A3C45?3W( ]563` ]*#+#` L&8&(+$;+,2&(0$ & 5$(.;,0$8 126,&(0',8M a5)@ i@'(b@=>5$

a'A3()R \[cQM

Baud_Environmental Governance in Latin America- Towards an Integrative Research Agenda

Documents

Transcript of Baud_Environmental Governance in Latin America- Towards an Integrative Research Agenda