Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
-
Upload
patrologia-latina-graeca-et-orientalis -
Category
Documents
-
view
230 -
download
1
Transcript of Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 1/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 2/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 3/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 4/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 5/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 6/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 7/108
TEXTS AND STUDIESCONTRIBUTIONS TO
BIBLICAL AND PATRISTIC LITERATURE
EDITED BY
J.
ARM1TAGE ROBINSON D.D.HON. PH.D. GOTTINGEN HON. D.D. HALLE
NORRISIAN PROFESSOR OF DIVINITY
VOL. V
No. 2. CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA: QUIS
DIVES SALVETUR
CAMBRIDGE
AT THE UNIVERSITY PRESS
1897
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 8/108
Eotrton : C. J. CLAY and SONS,
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS WAREHOUSE,
AVE MARIA LANE.
ffilasgoto: 263, ARGYLE STREET.
ILeipjtg: E. A. BROCKHAUS.
$rto lorft: THE MACMILLAN COMPANY.
Bombao: E. SEYMOUR HALE.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 9/108
CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA
QUIS DIVES SALVETUE
RE-EDITED TOGETHER WITH AN INTRODUCTION
ON THE MSS. OF CLEMENT'S WORKS
BY
P. MORDAUNT BARNARD M.A.
CHKIST'S COLLEGE CAMBRIDGE
CAMBRIDGE
AT THE UNIVERSITY PRESS
1897
[.!// Rigkti reserved]
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 10/108
©ambrtoge:
PRINTED BY J. AND C. F. CLAY,
AT THE UNIVERSITY PRESS.
THE INSTITUTE OF MEDIAEVAL STUDIES
10 ELMSLEY PLACE
TORONTO 5, CANADA.
DEC 17 1931
2 67<?
CRiKTBO i«» 4B.PCAT, BRITAIN
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 11/108
PKEFACE.
npHE Quis Diues Saluetur has met with less than justice at the
J- hands of the editors of Clement of Alexandria : all editions
hitherto have been founded on Ghisler's very inaccurate copy
printed from Vat. Gr. 623 (16th century). It is now edited for
the first time from the Escurial MS. H III 19 (11th century), the
parent of the Vatican MS.
It was at first arranged that an investigation of the text of
the Gospels and Acts used by Clement should accompany this
edition of the QDS: for this purpose I examined all known MSS.
of Clement's writings that are of any importance, and the general
results of this examination are given in this number. The
Syndics of the University Press have kindly allowed me to
defer the publication of the examination of Clement's Quota-
tions from the Gospels and Acts, which will therefore appear in
a separate number of Texts and Studies.
I have to thank the Editor of this Series for his continual help
and advice : without it this book would probably never have been
begun, and would certainly never have been finished. I have
alsoto thank Prof. J. B. Mayor and Dr Henry Jackson for many
valuable notes and hints.
To my friend Dr Otto Stahlin I am under peculiar obligations,
as will be seen by any one who reads my Introduction. As he
had intended to edit the QDS, and is also collecting materials for
the edition of Clement in the Berlin Corpus, we have been working
on parallel lines. We have kept each other continually informed
of anything new which we found ; and I can scarcely calculate the
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 12/108
VI PKEFACE.
extent to which I have benefited by our correspondence. He has
been good enough to go over my proof-sheets for me ;and as the
original collations of some of the MSS. quoted are in his possession,
and he has independent collations of others, the value of this
service is obvious.
Lastly it is my pleasant duty to acknowledge the unfailing
kindness I have received from the Librarians of the libraries
which I have visited.
MlCKLEHAM,
Dorking.
May 1897.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 13/108
CONTENTS.
Preface
Introduction on the Text of Clement's Works .
I MSS. of the Protrepticus and the Paedagogus
II Text of the Stromata, Excerpta ex Theodoto, and Eclogae
Propheticae ....III Text of the Quis Diucs Saluctur .
IV Florilegia
The Text of the Quis Dives Salvetur
Notes on the QDS
Appendix on some Clementine Fragments
Index of Scripture Passages .
Index of Greek Words ....
PAGE
V
i\
i.\
XX
xxviii
1
39
47
53
55
BQi
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 14/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 15/108
INTRODUCTION.
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENT'S WORKS.
§ 1. MSS. OF THE PllOTREPTICUS AND THE PAEDAGOGUS.
By far the most important of the MSS. of the Protrepticus and
the Paedagogus is the well-known Arethas Codex in the Biblio-
theque National e at Paris (Gr. 451 : quoted as P). It was written
in the year 914 by the scribe Baanes for Arethas, Archbishop of
Caesarea in Cappadocia. This codex has been so often described1
,
that it is needless to give a description here. The note of the
price paid for the MS. is correctly printed in the Melanges Qr<mxt
p. 750 ;it is easily legible with the aid of a glass and runs : NN k
7r€pyafi NN r that is vov/xfjuoi^ k Trepyafjbrjvai vov/jLfiofs r ; the price
paid for the parchment is kept separate from the cost of writing.
Five quires (8 to 12) of eight leaves each have been lost, containing
the first ten Chapters of Paed. I and the beginning of Chapter xi
as far as jrpos Se teal rrjs €7tltl/jli]...
Mutinensis, Gr. 126 (also marked in D 7;quoted as M)-, was
copied from P before these five quires were lost. It belongs to fche
10th or 11th century. The two hymns, which are not in 1\ are
added after Paed. Hi; a short fragment has also been inserted
here headed 'Ek rrj? iv xaX/cnSovi aylas avvohov.
1 See Montfaucon, Palaeogr. Qraeca, pp. 274—277 (with facsimile); von Otto,
Corpus apolog. Gr. in. p. xxxiii. ; Dindorf, Clem. .11,. r. i. |>p. v. IT. ; ami more
especially Harnack, Textc und Untertuckungen, i. i. pp. 24 it., and von Qebhardt,
ibid. iii. 1G2 ff. A fjood facsimile in Omont, Fac-iimilti de$ MSS. greet dattt </<
la Bibliotheque Nationale <1u i.rr<ui rirr sicslr, pi. n.
2 For description see T. W. Allen, Note* on Qr. MSS. in Italian Librariet, pp.1:'- 1.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 16/108
X INTRODUCTION.
This MS. is undoubtedly the Codex Carpensis of Victorius, the
editor of the Editio Princeps1
of Clement, which has been supposed
to be lost. The evidence is as follows2
.
Victorius in a letter to the Cardinal Marcellus Cervinus, pre-
fixed to his edition of Clement (p. 4), speaks of a uetustissimum
exemplar Protreptici et Paedagogi lent by Rodulphus Pius antistes
Carpensis from his ancestral library to Cervinus for collation3
.
Moreover, Hervetus in a letter addressed to Rodolphus Carpensis,
prefixed to his Latin translation of Clement's works4
, describes what
is evidently the same codex in a passage which seems to have
escaped notice in this connection. On page 4 he says : "A te
autem amplissime Cardinalis benigne est suppeditatus is liber qui
dicitur irporpeiTTiKo^.... Qui cum nuper editus esset, et aliquot
meis amicis visum esset facturum me operae pretium si eum
Latine verterem, earn ego provinciam eo suscepi confidentius, quod
a tuo exemplari antiquissimo et permultis in eo adiectis Scholiis
illustrato adiutus sim." At the end of the Protrepticus and of
each book of the Paedagogus Hervetus gives a Latin translation of
some of the Scholia found in MP 5.
Cardinal Rodolfo Pio had inherited many valuable MSS. from his
uncle Alberto Pio, Principe di Carpi, and among them many which
the latter had bought from the heirs of Giorgio Valla for 800
zecchini : the most valuable of these MSS. came into the Estense,
probably through the Cardinals Ippolito and Luigi at Rome 6.
There is therefore a considerable probability that the present
1 Florentiae, 1550.
2 Allen, p. 3, thinks it probable that the Mutinensis and the Carpensis are
identical, but it is perhaps worth while to prove the fact.
3 The passage is quoted by Dindorf, i. vii.
4 dementis Alexandrini omnia quae quidem extant opera Gentiano Herveto
Aurelio interprete. Florentiae, 1551.
5 Dr Stahlin, who had also observed the evidence afforded by Hervetus, writes
to me with regard to these Scholia: "Nun findet sich unter denselben keine
Bemerkung die nicht in M stiinde, aber verschiedene die nur in M stehen, d. h.
Scholien von M rec. z. B. die bei Dind. i. 422, 10—12 und ibid. 25—28 mitgeteilten
Scholien."
6 For further details about these MSS. see Coelestinus Cavedoni, " Notizia Let-
teraria di alcuni codici...che gia furono di Alberto Pio Principe di Carpi," in the
Memorie di Religione, di Morale, e di Letteratura, Serie terza, Tomo xvii. Modena,
1854, and Heiberg, Beitrage zur Geschichte Georg Valla's und seiner Bibliothek.
Leipzig, 1896.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 17/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENT S WORKS. XI
Mutinensis, which so exactly suits the description of Victorius and
Hervetus, is the Codex Carpensis. But Dindorf says1
that it is
clear the Mutinensis is not the codex mentioned by Victorius, as all
the MSS. of the Biblioteca Carpensis which passed into the Estense
are marked with the note 'AXfteprov Ulov koX twv (f>i\o)v, which
is not found in this codex. He continues :—
" ex quo satis certo
colligi posse hunc codicem non ex libris Carpensibus, sed ex
Estensibus esse recte monebat Coelestinus Cavedoni, Bibliotecae
Palatinae praefectus, qui hujus codicis usum liberalissime mihi
concessit." This negative argument is obviously inconclusive.
The Protrepticus begins at the top of fol. laof the original MS.
the table of contents and the concluding pages of the Greek trans-
lation of extracts from Firmianus Lactantius de Sibyllis, which end
the MS., are in a very late hand, on rather different sized parchment,
and are certainly later additions ; the MS. has been rebound within
the last 200 years, and these pages were perhaps added then; there
is therefore no possibility of finding the name of Alberto Pio
either at the beginning or end of the MS. in its present state
Positive evidence, however, that it did come from the Bibl.
Carpensis is fortunately to be had. Cavedoni, in his tract already
referred to2
, says "Tutti questi codici (i.e. those bought by Alberto
Pio from the heirs of Giorgio Valla) portano segnato in principio
tra due lineette nel sommo margine il numero delle carte di che
componesi ciascuno di essi." Now our MS. has on the top margin
of fol. lathe note "292 cart." The Librarian of the Estense and 1
compared this note of the number of pages with the similar notes
in several other MSS. bearing the names of Alberto Pio and
Giorgio Valla, and coming from the Bibl. Carpensis; we were both
of opinion that these notes were in the same hand and ink. It
is therefore, I think, quite certain that this is one of the MSS.
inherited by Rodolfo Pio from his uncle, and that it is the CodesCarpensis of Victorius. This conclusion is further supported by
the fact that Giorgio Valla published at Venice in 1498 a Latin
translation of Athenagoras de Resurrect imw, a tract which is con-
tained in the Mutinensis.
There is one other point of interest concerning this Ms
Schwartz8 speaks of "nonnulla de Sibyllis," which conclude the
1 Vol. I. pp. vii f.-
|>. '227, note 17.: TtXU mi, I I'nt, if*., iv. i. p. iv.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 18/108
Xll INTRODUCTION.
codex, as being written by two more recent hands. The last two
pages, as stated above, are in a very late hand, but the main part
of the extracts i/c rwv <fiip/juavov Xa/CTavrlov rod pco/juaiov irepl
<tl/3v\\7]<; teal rwv \olitwv is in a hand which does not occur in other
parts of the MS., but is written on exactly similar parchment, and
begins in the middle of a page. This hand cannot, I think, be
placed later than the 11th century, and is, I am convinced, the hand
of the scribe of Med. Laur. PL v. c. 3, the only authority for the
Stromata. I saw both MSS. within 48 hours, and also compared
this hand of M with Bandini's facsimile of the Laurentian codex.
If this identification of hands is correct, it shows that in the 11th
century there was a library containing the Protrepticus, the
Paedagogus and the Stromata: this would account for extracts
from the two latter works being found in the four closely related
MSS. Neap, n aa. 14, Ottob. 94 and 98, Monac. 4791
. Ottob. 98
also contains other extracts from Protr. and Paed. Stahlin (p. 17)
shows that these were not copied from any MS. now known to us,
and thinks it not impossible that they sprang from the same
source as the extracts from the Stromata. He concludes :" es
ware dann der Riickschluss auf eine Handschrift zu machen, in der
sowohl Protrepticus und Padagogus als die Stromata standen."
If the scribe of theade Sibylla" in Mut. 126 was really identical
with the scribe of the Florence codex of the Stromata, all these
works were to be found near each other in the 11th century2
.
The Florence MS. Bibl. Medic. Laurenziana, PI. v. c. 24, (F)
contains the three books of the Paedagogus and the two
hymns. It is assigned to the 11th century, and is composed of
32 gatherings of 8 leaves each (size 9J in. x 8| in.; vellum; 19 lines
a page ; letters hang from lines ruled with blunt point : Scholia
written in same hand and ink as text, but with a finer pen).
The two centre leavesof gatherings 7 and 16 have been lost,
1 See Stahlin, Beitrdge zur Kenntniss der Handschriften des Clemens Alex-
andrinus, Niirnberg, 1895, pp. 12 ff.
2 With regard to these two MSS. Dr Stahlin writes to me: " Dass Mut. und
Laur. einmal in derselben Bibliothek waren, is ganz unzweifelhaft dadurch, dass
die Kandbemerkungen, welche sich im Laur. von f. 221a an finden (cf. Dind. in.
67, 6. 12 u. s. w.), von derselben Hand herriihren wie die mit griinen Tinte in Mut.
in d 7 (that is, M rec). Dass die Hand identisch ist, kann keinem zweitelhaft sein,
der beide Schriften gesehen hat."
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 19/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENTS WORKS. Xlll
owing to the binding string cutting through them : the first
pair of leaves contained the words /3i\r) fiov to avrrjv piovdha
(Paed. I viii; Dindorf I 180. 16—182. 21 ; Potter 138—140) ; the
second pair from aro-^aareov yap to ipbfyaivei Beairo- (Paed. II
vii, viii; Dindorf I 2G6. 1—268. 8; .Potter 204, 205). The same
lacunae occur in the following MSS„ proving that they are de-
rived from F :—Bodleianus 39 (B), Brit. Mus. Reg. 16 D xvii (R),
Paris Bibl. Nat. Gr. 452 and 587 \ Vat. Palatinus Gr. 86 (Pal.),
Neapol. II AA 14, Venet. Marc, xi 4 (formerly 652)2
, and possibly
the excerpta in Vat. Palatinus Gr. 3023
.
In considering the relations of F and M to P the work done by
Harnack and von Gebhardt is most important. Harnack cleared
the way by showing that Tatian's Oratio ad Graecos, which
occurs in M, was once contained in P 4: von Gebhardt then
examined the MS. and arrived at the following conclusions5
.
In the scholia in the margin, two hands can be distinguished
one the hand of Baanes, the scribe of the text ; the other the
hand of the person who wrote the long scholion beginning
Seor/juevcov irpo^ dpureXov on the last two pages of the MS. (printed
in Dind. I xiv £). This scholion is written in FM opposite the
place to which it refers (Paed. I v 15 (106)), and is headed "Aped
dp^ieiTLdKoiTov. Von Gebhardt thinks that Arethas made a
rough draft at the end of his MS., and then copied the scholion
out in the margin opposite Paed. I v 15, which was in the part
1 One of these two is no doubt the MS. referred to by Nourry, Apparatus ad
Bibl. max. vet. Patrum, col. 659.
2 See Villoison, Anecdota Graeca, Venetiis, 1781, torn. ii. pp. 97 and 249.
3 On these four MSS. see Stiihlin, Beitr&ge, pp. 7 ff. In Paint. Gr. 302 Btahlin
says an extract from Paed. II. viii. is headed £v ry dKecpdXip Xoyy. As the heading
of chapter viii. is lost in F, he concludes that these extracts are derived from
that MS. But the New College codex (N) (see below, pp. xv. f.) omits the beading
of chapter viii.; it seems to me, therefore, quite possible that they are derived from
a MS. related to N.
4 Texte u. Unt. i. i. 25 f.
5 Texte U. Unt. i. iii. 102 ff. When I examined the Paris MS. in May, L894,
von Gebhardt's work was unknown to me, and I made the following note, whieh
agrees with his conclusions in every point. "In the scholia common to FMP, kWO
hands can be distinguished in P: one a very neat, fine, small half-uncial, probably
by the text-scribe; the oilier a larger, rougher half-uncial, more like the band on
fol. 402 (i.e. the scholion beginning decr/xevou -rrpbs a/xTreXoi'). It is thus pertain 1 1 1it
the seholia in FM must have been copied from V."
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 20/108
XIV INTRODUCTION.
of P now lost : judging from differences in the size and style
of the writing, he thinks that the scholia in the second hand
were written in the margin by Arethas at various times. It
follows of course that F and M, which contain both the text-
hand and the Arethas scholia of P, derived these scholia from
that MS. 1
It is a natural inference that the text also of these two MSS.
springs from P. As far as regards M this can hardly be doubted.
Dindorfs imperfect and often incorrect collation of M has ob-
scured its relation to P. The texts of the two MSS. are practically
identical 2 , and it may be considered certain that M was copied,
probably directly, from P, though the two hymns must have been
added from another source.
With regard to F the case is by no means so clear. Dr Stahlin
now considers that it is descended from P 3. Against this it can
be urged that a scribe might very well take his scholia from
a different MS. from that which supplied the text4
; further, it is
strange that F should have deliberately omitted the Protrepticus5
.
In very few instances does F preserve a good reading not found
in P : the following are the principal variants in the portions
of Paed. II, in, which I collated myself 6.
Dindorf I 204. 26 (Potter 155) earl /aov 6 u/o<? P iariv 6 vlo?
fjiov F (perhaps corrected according to Gospel text) 215. 17 (165)
1 Dindorf, Clem. Al. i. 439—450, gives several scholia as occurring in FM and
not in P. This need, however, cause no difficulty, for a later writer, who inserted
several tracts of Hesychius and Maximus in the margin of P, frequently erased
the original scholia to make room for himself. In all cases I had time to look
at, where scholia in FM were not quoted from P, traces of the writing could be
seen in that MS. under the Hesychius or Maximus. This late writer sometimes
recopied in another place what he erased.
2 In the portions of Paed. u., in., which I collated for the Gospels and Acts
quotations, M varies from P only 10 times, and always in very small points. See
further the readings of M, which I communicated to Dr Stahlin, in his Beitrdge,
pp. 5 f.
3 Beitrdge, p. 6.
4 F does not contain by any means all the scholia found in P.
5 Dindorf (i. viii.) speaks of F as "amplioris, quantum ex similitudine codicum
supra descriptorum colligi potest (i.e. M and P), voluminis fragmentum." I know
of no reason for thinking this surmise of Dindorfs to be correct.
6 Unfortunately Dindorfs collation of F is quite unreliable.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 21/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENTS WORKS. XV
fieya P /jueyav F (probably rightly) 216. 10 (106) dprov P dptarov F
224. 15 (172) QvXdgei P <f>v\a\v F 16 fypi 8' a* P 2%e« Se F
245. 19 (189) Kvpw P o xvpio^F 247. 9 (190) rpv/Skia PF**
rpv/3Xtov F* 268. 18 (206) efe to rpvfiUov P eV ra rpvfrdy F
301. 3, 4 (231) (raXa/io)^ (bis) P* aaXo/iap (bis) F 18 (232)
jjL€T6(opi^€a6€ P /&i) /jL€T€(op%e(T0€ F 302. 27 (233) oVoyita P
ovofiart F 320. 16 (246) — tcw irXovaiov F* 328. 27 yvvaitco*; a
(a blank space) e/>a<? P yvvcuicos, dU' iralpas F 354. 12 (274)
€^6vptaK€C P e^evprjcret F 18 dviapa)? P dviapos F 359. 7
(277) -o F 390. 11 (301) TroXirevrnfieda P woXirevofieOa F.
Some of the readings of F are mere errors, others are such
as might easily have been introduced by conjecture. Considering
the strong probability that a scribe would take his text from
the same MS. from which he took the scholia, there is not
sufficient evidence to show that the text of F is independent
of P : we must therefore conclude that this MS. is descended
from P, though considerably altered by conjectural emendation,
or possibly by correction from another MS.1
In the first ten chapters of Paed. I, where P fails us, the text
depends on FM : it is therefore important to prove that these
two MSS. are independent of each other. In all the readings
quoted above M agrees with P against F ; we may therefore
reasonably conclude that where P is lost M represents it far more
nearly than
Fdoes. In
myopinion
Mis older than F, but in
any case the above readings prove that the former was not copied
from the latter: the following readings show that the converse
was not the case. Dindorf I 206 12 (Potter 157) evXvrov FP
evXouTov M* 300. 23 (231) rfj ^1>XV ^A"""] v/jlcov FP y/xoov M302. 18 (232) %dpiTi FP x^n M '
316. 16 (243) co? aeavrhv
FP (oo-eavrov M 365. 6 (282) e&Oev FP efo> M.
Another MS. which has attracted a good deal of attention is
Cod. Oxon. Coll. Novi 139 (N)2
. It is a paper MS. of the
15th century made up of 272 leaves bound in irregular gatherings.
1 As the entire dependence of F on P has not yet been proved, the readings of
F should still bo quoted.
2 The Librarian of New College kindly sent this MS. to the Cambridge Uni-
versity Library in July 1895, that I might examine it at leisure. For a farther
description see Stiihlin, Observ. Crit. in Clcinentem .11, .r., Erlangae, 1890, pp. L8 f.
B, b
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 22/108
XVI INTRODUCTION.
The contents are : ff. la—45a Clement's Protr. : ff. 45 b—47
bblank :
ff. 48a—118b Paed. II and III: ff. 119a—122bblank: ff. 123a—27l b
Anastasius et9 rrjv irvevpbaTiKrjv dvaywyrjv rrjs efjarj/jLepov KTiaeaiS.
Fol. 272 is bound outside the last gathering, and appears to have
belonged to another MS. : it contains a fragment from Paed. II
v and vi (Dind. I 255. 10—158. 16 : Potter 196—198): incipit e£?
avTcov Bel explicit TraiBaywyrjaeLS, al puerd. The writing appears to
be of the same date as N, but it is not in the hand of any of the
three scribes who worked at the MS. (Quoted as N fr
.)
I propose to deal first with the text of N fr: the following
readings show that it is closely related to N. Dind. I 255. 12
(Potter 196) - 6 NN fr 16 KaOappoviav NN fr255. 20 /w^W^o?
NNfr P** tax^KMTfjLos FP* 256. 24 (197) wavra NN fr waW?FP: %v NNfr
elirelv FP 257. 12 (198) icef. e NN frKe<j>. r FP
(this mistake has put all the remaining chapters of book II one
wrong in N) 258. 11 if NN frij FP.
That N fr was not copied from N is proved by the fact that the
latter omits eiciropeveaOw—dylots /jut) (258. 6, 7 : Potter 198),
whereas N fr does not. N was not copied from the MS. to which
N fr belonged, for (255. 10 : Potter 196) N has with all other MSS.
fjuerpov avrols zeal icaipbv, while N frhas fierpov /cal icaipov avrols.
It is safe, however, to conclude that N and N fr had a near common
ancestor.
The facts that N omits Paed. I, of which chapters i to x have
been lost in P, and that, like P, it does not contain the two hymns,
which are found in F and M, naturally suggest that its text is
derived from P. This is fully borne out by the similarity of the
texts of the two MSS.
Further, N embodies most of the corrections made in the text
of P by later hands : witness the following readings, in which P**
differs from
Mand F
Dind. I 18. 12 (Potter 15) 4- dppVro(f>6pia NP** 20. 17 (16)
0prj(7K€vecv P* OprjaKelav NP** 33. 1 (27) ixdpinacra P* /JbdpTr^aaa
NP** 34. 16 (29) Idacovo V* laaovi NP** 68. 6 (54) 6p%ev0ai
P ipya&(r0ai N and P margin 263. 10 (202) rtov F rbyrcov P
omit altogether N (evidently thinking the whole word was
cancelled) 267. 14 (205) dfiavrai FP* d^levrai NP** 273. 16
(210)hrj
FP*prj
NP**274. 19
(211)direppee FP* awape P**
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 23/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENT'S WORKS. XVli
atraipe N 301. 3 (231) aaXa^v P* ao\o^v NP** but line 4
aaka/jLoov NP the correction not having been made in the second
instance in P 304. 3 (234) 7rapa\v7ra>r) FP* irapaKviroit] NP**
314. 19 and 315. 2 (241) ocrrptov FP* Lrpeov NP**Only five very short scholia are found in N : they all occur also
in F and P : but 15 times N has arj in the margin, only occasionally
in the same places as similar notes in FP.
That a type of text was current derived from P and omitting
Paed. I altogether is proved by a 16th century codex in the Biblio-
theque Nationale at Paris, numbered Suppl. Gr. 254 1. A comparison
of this MS. with P shows that as far as regards the Protrepticus
and books II and in of the Paedagogus it is certainly descended from
P, as the tracts of Hesychius and Maximus, which have been written
in the margin of P by a 15th century hand, are found in it by the
first hand : the margin of Paed. I, however, shows no trace of any
connection with P. That this book was added from a MS.2
of the
F group, is proved by the lacuna in ch. viii (Dind. I 180. 16
182. 21 ; Potter 138—140) occasioned by the loss of two leaves in
F. (See the account of that MS. pp. xii f.)
That the whole of book I, and not merely the chapters missing
in P, has been supplied is evident, as all through this book only
the short scholia written in red in MSS. of the F group are found,
and the subscription is written in a style not at all resembling the
subscriptions to the other books, but recalling those in R.
A MS. presenting exactly similar features, and no doubt
connected with Paris Suppl. Gr. 254, is Ottobonianus 94, described
by Stahlin (Beitrage, p. 9). It has the long lacuna in Paed. I, but
not the one in Paed. II3
.
1 This is no doubt the MS. of which Nourry says on col. 634 of the Apparatus
ad Bill. max. vet. Patrum, Paris, 1703 :—" Posteriorem ex Parisini RR. PP. socie-
tatis Jean collegii Bibliotheca R. P. Harduinus pro more suo nobiscum perquam
lmmanissime communicavit." Suppl. Gr. 250 is known to have belonged to the
Jesuit College.
- That this MS. was closely allied to Mus. Brit. Bibl. Reg. L6 D xvii. (R) is
proved by the following instances where a blank space is left in both MSS. Dind.
I. 150. 10 (Potter 117) - ry KvpLy kclI, 17 - Truev/xan, 20 - clvtwi> iKelvuv, 21 - or 8iv-
Xiafiov /j.ei>, 22 - Kpeltt6vwv elvai, 23 - dirb ttjs - tQv xeLpt>VU)v, 21 space left blank
after dvdyicrjs, 151. 1 - -q /xerduota ij. Potter states that similar lacunao occur in
Bodleianus 39.
3
Afew readings from the Protr. and Paed. i. are
givenin
Dind.i.
p.x.
(>2
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 24/108
XV111 INTRODUCTION.
I think I have shown that there was a type of text derived
from P, which altogether omitted Paed. I, and that N shows signs
of very close connection with P : a comparison of N with N fr has
proved that there were one or more intermediate steps between
them and P, giving plenty of opportunity for the introduction of
divergencies and corrections. We may therefore conclude that Nis derived from P corrected, a view with which Dr Stahlin, who
has collated N, now agrees1
. I have collated all the quotations
from the Gospels and Acts in N, but as it affords no variants of
any interest I do not intend to quote its readings.
Dr Stahlin mentions as closely allied to N a 15th century MS.
preserved at Genoa in the Biblioteca della Congregazione della
missione urbana di S. Carlo, and numbered 28. It contains the
Protr., Paed. II, III and also the Philocalia of Origen 2.
MSS. of Protr. and Paed.
XVI tffMonac. 97 , p ,,
'Valicell. F. 33r ™fr- onI>' Paris Suppl. Gr. 254
Neap. II. aa. 14Ottob. 94
Ven. Marc. 652
Pal.
Paris 452
„ 587
Bodl. 39
Mus. Br. R. 16 D. xvii
1 Beitrage, p. 10.
2 Stahlin, Beitrage, p. 11, speaking of this MS., says: "die Verwandtschaft mit
N zeigt nicht nur das Fehlen des ersten Buches des Padagogus, sondern auch das
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 25/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENTS WORKS. XIX
Dr Stahlin also mentions 1 two 16th century MSS. containing
the Protrepticus, namely, Monacensis 97 and Valicellianus F. 33.
Of these he says " die jedenfalls auf P zurlickgehen."
To sum up : where extant, P is the sole authority, though
there is a possibility that F may have an independent value
where P is wanting (Paed. I i—x and beginning of xi), the text
must be based on FM, but it must be borne in mind that M is a
very faithful copy of P, while F (if a copy of P) has undergone
considerable alteration. Fortunately the collation of P prepared
by Diibner for Dindorf is very fairly accurate : Dindorfs readings
from F and M I have already stated to be incomplete and un-
trustworthy.
§ 2. Text of the Stromata, Excerpta, and Eclogae.
These works are preserved only in the 11th century Florence
MS. 2, Medic. Laur. PL V c. 3 (L), of which the 16th century Paris
MS. Suppl. Gr. 250 is a copy. On MSS. containing extracts from
these works see Stahlin Beitrdge, pp. 12 ff.
In Strom. VIII vi 17 the words At rcov ^Tjryaecov ecfroboi, zeal
apyal irepl ravra zeal iv tovtols elaiv are written in L so as to
form a heading to what follows, and are not joined to what goes
before. At the end of book vm as at present printed L has
the subscription At rwv frryaecov €(po$oi teal dpxaL irepl ravra
zeal iv rovrots : then an ornamented line, followed by the heading
'E/e rcov ©eoSoTou /ere. §§17—33 should therefore be considered,
not as part of book vm, but as an independent treatise on the
Zusammenstimmen in Kleinigkeiten wie in der Stelle Dind. i. 328. 27, wo beide ov
yap yvvaiKbs fyas lesen." M and F have ov yap ywaiKbs a tpas. [Since the
above was written Dr Stahlin has again examined the Genoa MS. and has obtained
ample proof that N was copied from it. The conclusions I have reached concerning
the text of N may therefore be taken to apply to the Genoa MS.]
1 Beitrdge, p. 11 f.
2 For description see Dindorf i. p. xvi. f. A facsimile is given in Bandini'fl
Catalogue; in the Palaeographical Society's Facsimiles, Series n. vol. i. pi. 107;
and in Vitelli e Paoli, Collezione Fiorentina di faerimili paleogrcflci, Fuse. i.
tav. x. This MS. was fairly well collated for Dindorf by Joseph Midler. I col-
lated all the Gospels and Acts quotations in April, 1804.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 26/108
XX INTRODUCTION.
same footing as the Excerpta and the Eclogae. This was the
opinion of le Nourry 1 and Bunsen 2. Zahn 3 rejects this view,
taking the words at tgov %VtV (T€0)V kt* m § "^ to be " eme denvorigen Abschnitt abschliessende Formel " : this is of course
rendered impossible by the words occurring again as a subscrip-
tion at the end of § 33, a fact which has not, I think, been before
pointed out. Zahn remarks, however, that in a Syriac MS. of the
8th or 9th century of Theological Extracts (Brit. Mus. Add. 14,533
fol. 137a
: quoted by Zahn, p. 28) an extract from Strom, vm v 16
is introduced by the words " at the end of the eighth book." It
seems reasonable to think that Clement never finished Book viil,
ending with § 16, and that at the end of this incomplete book a
scribe or editor copied matter found among Clement's notes and
possibly collected with a view to the completion of the Stromata.
§ 3. Text of the Quis Dives Salvetur.
Manuscripts.
Michael Ghisler first printed the QBS (in his Li Jeremiam
prophetam commentarii, Lugduni 1623 vol. ill, pp. 262—282) very
inaccurately from a 16th century MS., Vaticanus Gr. 623 (V) ; and
all subsequent editors reprinted his text, without again examining
V, which remained till recently the only known MS. of this homily.
Dr Stahlin and I had both arranged to re-edit this homily from
V, which we had both collated, when he noticed, and kindly
communicated to me, the. fact that E. Miller, Catalogue des MSS.
grecs de I'Escurial, p. 485, mentions a homily commencing 0/ ^ev
tovs ijKcofjLuicrTLfcovs \6yovs, the first words of the QDS. Through
the generosity of Dr Stahlin it was arranged that he should give
up his projected edition, contenting himself with writing an
article 4 showing how far the text could be improved from V and
1 Apparatus ad Bill. max. vet. Patrum, col. 1291.
2 Analecta Antenic. 1. p. 184.
3 Forsch. in. 116.
4 See his Beitrlige, pp. 21—35, where a description of V will be found. Dr Stahlin
now agrees with me in assigning it to the 16th, not the 15th century.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 27/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENTS WORKS. XXI
other sources, and that I should collate the Escurial MS. This I
did in Aug. 1894. A brief examination was sufficient to show
that V was copied from the Escurial MS. ; the last page but one
of the latter has been all torn away except a small strip at the
top : the scribe of V carefully copied all the words and letters
which remained, leaving blank spaces for what was torn away.
I give here a description of this MS., Scorialensis fl ill 19.
Old Class-marks, in ® 12 (cancelled); 138 B ; iv @ 2 (can-
celled), in the hand of Nicolas de la Torre 1. Early Escurial bind-
ing of reddish-brown calf, stamped with gridiron with six2bars.
Parchment: 11th century: 344 pages in gatherings of eight:
three extra pages, numbered I, II, III, respectively have been added
at the beginning : only in two places can traces of original quire
signatures be seen : two numberings of pages ; the older, in the
bottom right-hand corner, makes 351 pages; it was previous to
the last rebinding, during which the numbers were clipped in
many places, but subsequent to loss of part of the last page but
one, which it does not reckon ; the more recent, in the top right
hand corner, probably by Nicolas de la Torre, does count the strip
left at the top of the last page but one, and makes 345 pages,
through numbering two consecutive pages 276, 278 3.
Size ofpage 10f\ in. x 7£ in. ; of written part about 8-Jin. x 5| in.
28 lines on a page. The pages were only very slightly clipped in
the last rebinding, as can be seen where corners have been turneddown ; but the margins must originally have been a good deal
bigger, as only occasional traces of the quire signatures can be
seen.
Three hands can be distinguished (a) ff. 1—224 (6) ff. 225—
254il
(c) ff. 254b—end 4; all of the same date, as far as I can judge.
1
Afavourite copyist of Philip II.,
whoheld the office of "Greek Writer" at tho
Escurial.
2 After the time of Philip II. seven and, later still, ten bur gridirons are stamped
on the bindings.
3 This more recent numbering is given in the margin of my text, and is all
through the QDS one in excess of the true number.
4 Miller, who examined the Escurial MSS. very hurriedly, only noticed the
first of these changes: p. 485, note 1, he says, "Depots le Fol, 226 jusqn'i la tin,
l'ecriture est plus moderne ct appartient au xii° siecle." I am rn tain that (c) is
not later than (<t); (b) has a more modern look, which has misled .Miller.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 28/108
xxil INTRODUCTION.
The writing hangs from lines ruled with a blunt point on one side
only of the parchment.
There are very few corrections : one corrector filled up short
lacunae in the Origen, and made one emendation in QDS § 31.
The contents are as follows : I blank ;na Table of Contents in
Greek by Nicolas de la Torre ; an older one in Latin ;and a recent
Latin note pointing out that the 19 homilies on Jeremiah are by
Origen. HbITI blank. ff. l
a— 90a
tov ev ayioLS Trps rjfivv
KVpiXkov ap^ieirtaKoirov aXe^avhpeias etc rrjs epfirjvelas rfjf; et?
tov 7Tpo(j)r)Tr)v rjaatav. incipit rd ev rah ia^draL^ rj/jbepais ificfxi-
vh to opos leu... explicit rjfid^; Be tovtcov dirdWa^oi 6 %?. St ov
Kai /ne6' OV...TG0V alcovcov dfirjv\ ff. 90a—129
aepfirjveLa eh tov
irpo^r)T7)v BavirjX2
. ff. 129b—208
aepfirjveia ek tov Trpo^r/rrjv
l€^€KL7]X3
. incipit koX eyeveTO ev too Tpia/coo~TG) eVet ktL (Ez. i. 1)
(ad marg. deohwpiTOv) Tialv e'Sofe to rpia/coo-Tov eVo<? tov Icofir/X.
explicit ev etcdaTco TfJurj/juaTt Tpeh' diravTa Se tov kvkXov oktw
Kai8e/ca
x^dBav tyy.ff. 208b
—326b
(really 325b) lepe/jLias, is
the only heading to the 19 homilies of Origen on Jeremiah 4,
ff. 326b—345a
(really 325b—344a), the QDS with the heading
'OjAiXia. At the bottom of the last folio, recto, is written in
a 15th century hand elcrlv ev Trj&e rrj fitfiXico TerpaS'ia \e
<j)vX\a Tfju.
This MS. belonged to Don Diego Hurtado de Mendoza, whose
signature (D. Di°. de Ma
.)
5is found at the bottom of fol. l
a
,and
1 This appears to be an abbreviation of Cyril's work on Isaiah, and is not
divided into Books and Orations. The incipit occurs vol. iii. col. 68a of Migne's
edition (Lib. i. Orat. ii.); the explicit is the same as in Migne.
2 This anonymous commentary on Daniel was printed by Cotelerius from this
MS., and assigned to Chrysostom, among whose works it is now printed ; the title
of Cotelerius' book is: S. P. n. J. Chrysostomi quatuor homiliae in Psalmos, et inter-
pretatio Danielis. Opera nunc primum edita ex MS. codice Regiae Bibliothecae
S. Laurentii Scorialensis. Lutetiae Parisiorum ap. L. Billaine.
3 This is a catena on Ezechiel, drawn mostly from Theodoret, whose name,
among others, occurs several times in the margin. The incipit is found in Migne,
Theodoret ii. col. 816 ; the explicit, col. 1248.
4 Printed from this MS. by B. Corderius with the title: S. P. n. Cijrilli
Archiepiscopi Alexandrini homiliae xix. in Jeremiam Prophetam. Antverpiae,
1648. Corderius' transcript was very carelessly made: in Homily i. alone he
omitted 19 lines of the MS., and introduced a mass of changes, emendations
and errors.
5
Afacsimile of
Mendoza's signature is given at the end of Graux, Essai sur
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 29/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENT'S WORKS. xxiii
passed with his other books into the Escurial in 1576. There is
some Greek scribbling on the last page and in other places in a
late hand : this points to its being one of the MSS. which Mendoza
obtained from the East while Ambassador at Venice ; and it was
probably while his library was in that city that the copy of the
Origen and Clement, now in the Vatican, was made.
I distinguish this MS. by the symbol S, but in the apparatus
criticus to those parts of the QDS where there is no fear of con-
fusion with other authorities its readings are given without any
symbol.
Those portions of § 42 which are gone from S, through the loss
of nearly a whole page, can be to some extent recovered from
other sources. Euseb. HE. in 23 quotes the story of St John and
the young robber, beginning "Atcovaov /jlvOov ov puvdov, and end-
ing rpoiraiov dvaardaews ftXeirofievris1
. Maximus Confessor in
his Scholia 2 on Dionysius the Areopagite, Epist. x, addressed
'l(odvvrj
OeoXoyw diroaroXa), says: MefjLvijTat, Be rfjseirl
Aofxe-Tiavov el;opia<; tov dytcoTarov ^lcodvvov...Kal K\>;/<t?79 6 'A\e£ai/-
Bpevs ev to) Xoycp tw irepl Tt? 6 aw^o/jLevos tt\ov<tlo<;. It appears
that some one was led by this remark to refer to his Clement, and
copied out at the end of his MS. the story referred to ; and this
extract, preceded by the extract from the Letter of Polycrates to
Victor quoted by Euseb. HE. ill 31, 3, and followed by several from
Philo 7T€pl TOOV i/C 7T€plT0/jLrj^ 7rUTT€V<jdvT<j£>V 6V AlyU7TT(p XpHT-Tiav&v, is preserved in many MSS. of the Scholia of Maximus,
with or without the text of Dionysius3
: in all these the extract
begins with the words ha Be eiridappr/arj^, that is, a line before
the quotation of Eusebius, of whom it is thus proved to be inde-
les origines da Fonds Grec de ISEscurial, in the Bibliothlque de V6coU de$ haute*
ttudes, vol. 46: in which book a full account of Mendoza's life and library is given,
pp. 103 if.
1 Several writers who tell or refer to this story apparently depend on Eusebius.
For references see Harnack, Oetchichte der altchristlichen Litteratur, i. p. 816. I
have extracted the readings of the MSS. of Eusebius as best I could from the
editions of Burton, Laemmer and Pleinechen, using the notation of the latter;
but it is of course well known that the text of Kitsch, is in an unsatisfactory State.
See Harnack, Oeschichte, i. pp. 501 f.
2 Ed. Corderius, Antverpiae, L684, vol. n. p. 181.
:f In AFK the extracts preoede, in all other MSS. follow, the Dionyaiua or
Maximus.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 30/108
XXIV INTRODUCTION.
pendent. I am in possession of collations of the following MSS.
of this extract
Brit. Mus. Add. 18, 231, fol. 12a
;
parchment ; A.D. 972 (A)1
.
Florence, Medic. Laurent, v. 32, fol. 2l7 b;paper; century
xv (B).
Vienna theol. graec. 65 olim 49, fol. 117* ; vellum; century
xiv (?) (C).
Milan, Ambrosiana H 11 Sup. 2, fol. 212; bombycinus; cen-
tury xni (D).
Oxford, Coll. Corp. Chr. 141, fol. 2b
;
parchment; century
xii (F) 2.
Vatic, gr. 374, fol. 242;paper ; century XIII or xiv (G).
Vatic. Regin. 38 fol. 321;parchment ; century XI (H).
Florence, Conv. Suppr. 202, fol. 190b; century x as far as ical
/juera tovto vfyrjice (32 19) (I), the rest being supplied by a 15th
century hand (Isppl
).
Ottob. 362,fol.
1 ;
paper;
century xvi(K).
Vienna, theol. graec. 110, fol. 197 b; century x (L).
Oxford, Canon. 97, fol. 221a
;parchment; century xiv (O).
Paris, Bibl. Nat. gr. 440, fol. I77 a
;parchment ; century xii (P).
Florence, S. Marco 686, fol. 214a;parchment ; century xii (Q).
Vatic, gr. 504, fol. 76;parchment ; century XI or xii (R).
Of these I have collated ABDFOPQ ;for collations of GHIKR
I am indebted to Dr Stahlin, of C to Dr F. Wallis, now Bishop ofWellington, N.Z., and of L to Dr Weinberger, of Vienna, through
Dr Stahlin.
Dr Stahlin also mentions 3 as containing the extract Coislin
86 century xii, Moscow 36, century x, and Jerusalem 414, cen-
tury xvi, but neither of us has obtained collations of these.
About A.D. 8604Johannes Scotus Erigena translated, by order
of Charles the Bald, the works of Dionysius together with the
1 Facsimiles of this MS. are given in the Palaeogr. Soc. Facs. Series 11. vol. 1.
pi. 28, and in Wattenbach et von Velsen, Heidelberg, 1878, pi. 7 ; the latter plate
is also given in Wattenbach, Scripturae Graecae Specimina, Berlin, 1883.
2 Owing to the loss of two pages, this MS. now only contains the heading, and
the first few lines as far as 7-775 Hdr/xov 7-775 v-qcrov.
3 BeUriige, pp. 31 f. Vat. Gr. 1553 is, I believe, inserted there through a mis-
understanding.
4 See Th. Christlieb, Leben und Lehre des Johannes Scotus Erigena, Gotha,
1860, p. 27.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 31/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENTS WORKS. XXV
Scholia of Maximus ; in this translation he included the Extracts
from Polycrates, Clement and Philo, though they are not given in
the printed editions of his version. I have used two MSS. of his
translation :
Oxford, Ashmolean 1526; vellum; early 14th century.
Cambridge Univ. Library, Ii—3—32, parchment ; century XIII.
That Erigena translated from a MS. very nearly akin to the
following readings show :
Heading, avrov HKO lat. 33 6, 7 Sea /xeyeOos (f>vaeo)<; e/co-rd-
creo)? per
magnumnatura recessum lat. 34 4 drraiTw] direaTw
Orestitue lat. 5 — /ecu en HO lat. 7, 8 — /cal to /cecpaXacov Xy-
aT7]<; O lat. 35 1 eiriXaOofJuevo^ eiriXaj36fjievo^ O accipiens lat.
5 v7rofjL€va) (accent) AHO sustineo lat. The cases where the Latin
agrees with other evidence are very rare and unimportant : we
need not, therefore, trouble further about Erigena's version ; but
its evidence gives the 14th century O the authority of a 9th
century MS.All these MSS. introduce the extract with the heading:
K\tJ/jL€vto<; [k\7J/jl7)vto<; GHIR] 7rpea/3vrepov 'AXefaz^opeta? [-Spea?
H : -Spias Q] r/yov/jLevov [pr. /cal F] rfj<; 0-^0X179, [+ irepl rov dylov
(ittogtoKov Kai 6eo\6yov evayyeXtarov Iwdvvov P] e/c [et? C] rov
€7riy€ypa/jLfjL€vov avrw [avrov HKO : omit G] XoyoV Tt? 6 aco^o-
/jl€vo<; irXovcrios ; At the end the following note is added by
ABHLOQ:
Tavrr}<; [+ 8e L] Trj? laropla^ fiefiv7]Tai [+ koX L]
Rvae/3io<; 6 UafMpiXov /cal 'Iwaw^? 6 [om. Q] e7nWo7ro? Kcou-
GTavTivoviroXews [+ 6 XpL/crocTTOyLto? Q]. This note is omitted in
CDPR ; I have no information on this point about GIK.
Of these MSS., ABCDL form a closely allied group, as is shown
by the omission in all five of (34 9—n) he—TrXrjgdfievos. Compare
also the following readings 32 8 — tw ABCDILP 34 5 /cal erc
/cal] ere /cal ABCDLP 35 5 av herf\ dp he ACDLO avros B10 rjhvvaro ABDLOP. BD appear to have had a near GOmmOD
ancestor (cp. 32 7, 17, 33 14, 34 9, 35 5, 6) and C goes closely with
them (32 15, 33 12, 34 12). L agrees sometimes with A (34 17,
35 8 AIsp,)1LQ 36 1), sometimes with other members of the group
(32 8 aVp,aiv6fievov BL*utui,l P 33 12 BCDL againsl AP and all
other evidence) and sometimes agrees with other .MSS. against
ABCD (32 20 -to KLQR 33 15).
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 32/108
XXVI INTRODUCTION.
P presents a somewhat curious problem : it is certainly closely
allied to the above group (32 2, 8, 10, 15, 20; 33 14, 35 10), but the
text has undergone considerable alterations, partlyby
additions
and conjectural emendation (Heading; 31 27, 34 i, 6, 9, 35 9, 36 3),
and partly, it appears, by corrections taken from a codex of
Eusebius perhaps akin to Paris Gr. 1437 (Eb)
a
. That the scribe
of one of P's ancestors had looked up the quotation in Eusebius, a
marginal note in the Scholiast-hand at the beginning of the
extract in P shows clearly : /celrai tovto ev tw /3 (lege 7) {3l/3Xl(0
7-779 ifc/cXrjo-LacmfcrjslaToplas evcreftiov. The following are the
places where these corrections occur : 33 3 eOahes PS Eus.
34 9— 11 ABCDL omit Be to irXri^ajxevo^ ; in P -evo? to fieydXr}*;
and KaXov <ye is written over an erasure, and ol/uLcoyr)*; irXrjtjdfjLevos
ttjv /ce<f)a\r)v is added in the margin : it seems probable that the
words missing in the archetype have been supplied from a codex
of Eusebius : this probability is increased by the readings in the
words supplied:
Be GHIKOQR Eus. cdd. GHO:
ofo Eus. cdd.BCDFaFb
: omit particle P Eus. cdd. AEaEb6 diroaroXos tt]v
eadrjra GHIKOQR Eus. cdd. BCDFaG : ryv eaO^ra 6 diroaroXo^
P Eus. cdd. AEaEbFbHO. 35 4 ikirlSas P (? added later but
perhaps 1st hand) and most MSS. of Eus. including AEaEb
35 14 i/cfc€fca6apfjL€vr)v P (but e/c/ce- over erasure) Eus. cod. Fa.
A text thus altered can have but little weight.
The ancient part of I appears also to belong to this group(32 8, 10 but 32 6 Karaarrjaov IQ).
IBPpl KQR form another group (32 20, 33 13, 35 2, 13, 15; see
also passages quoted below in which GH join this group or part
of it).
jsppi agrees in many readings2with Q ; and, if it were not for a
few variants difficult to explain (32 4, 9, 16, 33 16, 35 13) K would
appear to be copied from R.
G and H incline towards this group (32 15, 16, 33 13, 35 1, 10, 12,
1 A collation of this MS. is given at the end of Burton's edition of Eusebius.
2 Stahlin {Beitrage, p. 33) thinks the missing leaves in I were supplied from Q,
but the following readings render this almost impossible : 32 20 - to KLQR, but it
is in Ppp1 and all other MSS. 33 n avrbs KQ, auroi>$ Ppp1 and all other MSS.
34 15 <t>v\aK7Js Q, TrpocpvXaKTJs Ppp1 and all other MSS. 35 10 Q with some other
MSS. inserts /ecu before airoXoyoufxevos, but not Isppl
.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 33/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENTS WORKS. XXVI
36 i): H agrees with R in two noticeable readings (32 ifi, 3.5 i)
and has several readings not found elsewhere (32 7, 33 15, 34 1,
35 n,36 1).
appears to be quite independent, and its text is of some
importance.
The importance for the study of the text of Eusebius of
settling the reading of the archetype of these MSS. is obvious, and
this is my reason for recording their readings so fully. Owing to
the shortness of the extract it is impossible to reach definite
conclusions about the relations of the MSS., but the cases in
which the reading of the archetype can be considered uncertain
are few and unimportant.
1 now give the readings on which the relations of S, Eusebius,
and the extract must be determined.
31 27 gtl 0appf}<? S €7rL0appr](rr)s Ex.
32 1 fA€v et? crcoTTjplas S /xevei (norrjpia^ Ex.
1, 2 fjuvdov ov p,v0ov S Eus. ov fivOov Ex. (best MSS.).
4 voaov S vrjaov Eus. Ex.
9 /cal eirl S — /cal Eus. Ex.
13 TraparlOe/jLac S and a few MSS. of Eus. Trapa/caraTL-
0€p,cu Ex. and most MSS. of Eus.
16 hiereivaro S BcerelXaTO Ex. HR. SieXeyero Eus.
Ex. other MSS.
—elra S — aTrjjpev S.
33 2 — /cal (iTreppwyoTes S.
3 i0d8e<; S Eus. ^a8e? Ex.
TTOWOOV 7T0\VTe\(0V S — 7ToWo)V EuS. Ex.
4 avrov VTrdyovrai S avrov iirdyovTai Eus. eirdyovrai
avrov Ex.
7 — eWTa? S.
it dTroXcoXev S cLTroXcoXet Eus. Ex.
15 eTretSrj S iirel (or eirl) Eus. Ex.
17 (TODTTjp S XpMTTO? EuS. Ex.
35 11 fjbovrjv S Eus. fxovov Ex.
12 — €yyv(t)/uL€VO<; S.
A consideration of these readings suggests thai (lie three
authorities are independent of each other: that S is inclined t<>
omit syllables and words and to dittograpb letters and words; and
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 34/108
XX Vlll INTRODUCTION.
that, where S is wanting, the text of Eusebius is slightly more
to be trusted than that of the extract.
We have now to calculate how much of § 42 is lost. Fol. 344b
(really 343b) of S begins [diro\\o<yovfizvos rah olficoyai^, and
the last word left is ov at the end of line 7 (ov irporepov aTrrj\6ev).
There are 28 lines a page, the average number of letters in a line
is 55J : so that after ov 21 lines of S have been lost, equalling
about 1155 letters; of these only about 145 are preserved in
Eusebius and the extract : so that about 1000 letters, equivalent
to about 22 lines of this edition of the QDS, have been lost be-
tween /3\€7TOfjLevr)<; and <f>cuSpol<; yeywOores.
§ 4. Florilegia.
Extracts from the QDS are preserved in :
Melissa Antonii, ed. C. Gesner, Tiguri, 1546.
Maximi loci communes, ed. C. Gesner, Tiguri, 1546 and
Fr. Combefis, Paris, 1675, torn. II pp. 528 ff. I have collated the
Clementine quotations in the Florence MS. (Med. Laur. PL vii
c. 15, ff. 103b fF.) of this collection (See Appendix on Some Clementine
Fragments).
Sacra Parallela, commonly ascribed to Johannes Damascenus.
These exist in several recensions, which Professor Loofs has shown
to rest on a work in three books \ of which Book I is preserved in
a Paris MS., Goislin. 276, with the title 'Icodvvov irpeo-ftvrepov zeal
ixovayov tu>v itcXoyoov fiiftXiov Trpdorov, and Book II in Vaticanus
Gr. 1553 with the title Aeovriov irpeo-fivrepov teal '\codvvov rcov
lepwv fitfiXiov hevrepov. Dr Stahlin has very kindly collated for
meall
the passagesfrom the
QDSpreserved in Coislin. 276, and
my friend H. Rackham, Esq., Fellow of Christ's College, was good
enough to copy out or collate all those in Vat. Gr. 1553 which are
noticed in Mai's index to the Authors and Works quoted in this
MS. (Script, net. nou. Collectio, Romae 1825, vol. I part iii pp.
69 ff.).
1 Studien iiber die dem Johannes von Damaskus zugeschriebenen Parallelen,
Halle, 1892.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 35/108
ON THE TEXT OF CLEMENTS WORKS. XXIX
Of the Sacra Parallela three main recensions are known
(a) One printed from Vat. Gr. 1236 (century xv) by
Lequien in his Opera S. Joannis Damasceni, Paris 1712, vol. II
pp. 279—790. I have collated all the Clementine passages from an
Escurial MS. of the Parallela, which is in almost exact agreement
with Lequien's text. (Escurial 12 ill 9 ;parchment ; century
xi; size, 10-j-jfx8-jk; gatherings of 8 folia; now 243 ff., but two
gatherings have been lost between fF. 38 and 39, as is shown by
the original signatures ; lost pages contained Lequien 340c rakac-
TroopLais to 369d rov 8i8do~/ca\ov avrov.) These two Iquote as
Parall. Vat. et Scor.
(b) One preserved in the Codex Rupefucaldinus (now
Berol. Phill. 1450). The Clementine fragments preserved in this
MS. are printed by Harnack, Geschichte der altchr. Litteratar, I
pp. 317 ff. (Parall. Rup.).
(c) A third recension is found in Paris reg. 923 : for a col-
lation of the QDS passages I am indebted to Dr Stahlin (Parall.
Paris). A similar recension exists in Marcianus 138, and, as far
as I could judge from a somewhat hurried examination, in Matri-
tensis O 5. I had only time to collate a few of the QDS quota-
tions in this MS.1
(Parall. Matr.). Baroccianus 26 (see Hearne,
Curious Discourses, vol. II p. 399) contains two fragments from
§ 40 which appear to be derived from this recension of the Sacra
Parallela.
One fragment preserved in various Florilegia may conveniently
be noticed here. Maximus 661 KXr/fievros. MdXtara rrdvrcav
XpLariavols ovk enteral ro irpos ffiav eiravopOovv rd rcov dfiaprm)-
fidrayv irraiafMara. ov <ydp toi)? dvdytcrj t//<? /catcia<s dire^oiievovs
dWd rovs rrpoaipecrei arefyavol 6 #eo?. In Leontius Vat. Gr.
1553 f. 119 this fragment has the lemma rov avrov, and follows an
extract correctly assigned to the QDS (Ovk dva<yicd%ei 6 6eb$ /ere
QDS §10). In Paris 923 f. 89athe fragment lias the lemma
K\r)/jL€vro<; etc rod Tt<? 6 crojfo/^e^o? irXovaLos. In Escurial fl III 9
f. 52b (= Lequien 393) this fragment is preceded by one commenc-
ing ro re fieftiaanevov (Zahn, Forsch. Ill 53); both are under
1 Holl, Sacra Parallela (Texte u. Unters. xvi. 1), pp. 73 f., shows that Matr.
5 is a copy of Marc. 138.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 36/108
XXX INTRODUCTION.
the lemma tov OeoXoyov. The same MS. has to re (3e(3iao-/j,evov
again on f. 191 b, but this time assigned to SeoTifio*; (so Lequien
643). Rupefucaldinus f. 118a (Harnack, Geschichte, I p. 318) gives
both fragments with the lemma KXijfievros tov arpco/jLaria)';. In
Lequien 393 the lemma to the two fragments is omitted, but in
the errata it is given as KXtJ/ul. arpco/n.
The evidence that the fragment is really Clementine is thus
very strong, and the way it is introduced in Vat. Gr. 1553 renders
it probable that it belongs to the QDS, as the scribe of Paris 923
assumed.
Now, as it exactly sums up the teaching of the story of
St John and the young robber, the conclusion is almost in-
evitable that it comes from that part of § 42 which has been lost
between /3\e7r0/^77? and (f>cu8poU yeyrjOore^, and in that place I
have accordingly printed it.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 37/108
KAHMENTOS AAEHANAPEQ2
AOTOS
TI2 O 2QZOMEN02 IIAOYSIOS.
(35 1. 01 fjbev tou? eyKW/jLiaaritcovs Xoyovs tois irXovalois
2^b
8copo(f)opovvT€<; ov /jlovov tcoXarces /cal dveXevOepot Si/catco*;
av efiocye KpiveaQai Botcoiev, &)? eVl woXXS irpoairoiovpuevoi
\aplaaaQat ra dydpiara, dXXd teal daefteis teal €7TLf3ovXor
S dae(3el<; l^ev, on Trapevres alvelv teal So^d^ecv rov /jlovov ef. Mt \ \s
reXetov kcli ayavov ueov, e£ oi> ra iravra kcli ot, ov ra ct. Roxi3<;
iravra teal eh ov rd irdvra, irepidirTovai to
to yepas dvOpcoiroLS ev da fti<p /cvXlvSov/jL6vol<;
to K€(f)dXaiov viro/cel/jLevov rfj icpiaei rod 6eov'
io€7rl{3ovXot, Be, on teal avrf}?
rf}<;
irepiovaias tcaO^ avrrjv27a
i/cavr)s ovarjs yavv&aai rd<; yjrv^ds roov k€/cttj/h€V(dv\teal
BiacpOetpat kcli aTroarrjaac t?}? 6Sov, Bt rjs eirirvyelv eari
aa)T7)pLa<z, o'tSe irpoaeKirX^aaovai rd? yvao/ias r&v irXovaucov,
raU rjSovats twv d/juerpcov eTralvcov eivaipovTes teal KaOdira^
15 tgov oXwv TTpayfidroiv irXr/v tov ttXovtov, 6Y ov dav/id-
>36 ^ovrac, Trapaatcevd^ovres virepcppovelv, to Srj rov Xoyov irvp
Titulus in codice abest : praemittitur tantum '0/j.iXta.
2 8opo(popovi>Tes 7—9 irepi&TrTovcri—t6 KeQaXatov] S e codice mutilo ut
uid. ductus hunc locum sic habet : TrepiairTovei to (lacuna fere 11 litt.) rd ytpas
dvoisI
iuaa (lac. 12 litt.) fi'ap kv\lp5oi>/j.^ols (lac. 7 litt.)|to Ke<p. quae lacunae
sic expleri possunt : TreptdTTTovcn t6 <6avp.aaTbu ko.I> t6 ytpas avOpwwois ev
da < u)Ti$ Kal i(pr)/j.tp(p> fi'up Kv\iv8ovfx^ois, < 8v (Lyovcri > t6 Ke<p. 10—10 tirl-
fiovXoi— vrreptypoveiv] Leontius Vat. Gr. 1558 f. 190 10 irepiovcrias] ovalas
Leont. £clvtt]v Leont. 13 ol 5t S Leont. irpoaeKirX^o-ovo-iv Leont.
B. 1
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 38/108
Z CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
eVl irvp ixero^erevovre^, Tvfycp Tv<pov iiravrXovvres teal
oy/cov ttXovtw irpoaavaTiOevTes ftapel <pvaei (popriov fiapv-
repov, ou fidWov e^prju dcfraipelv teal irepiKoirreiv, go?
cf. Mtxxiii acfyaXepov voar}p,aTO<; teal Oavarrf^opov tw yap v^ov/xevw
teal pbeyaXwoixevcp dy^iaTpoc^o^ rj 7rpb<> to raireivov fiera- 5
/3o\r) teal tttwgls, &)? o 0€LO<; BiBdcrKet \o<yo?. e/xol Be
fyaiverai fiatcpfp ^tXavOpconroTepov elvai tov Bepaireveiv . .
tovs irkovTovvras eirl icaicw to
crvvaipeaOai T7)v crcoTrjpiav avTois
. . . airavra tov BvvaTov rpoirov, tovto fiev e^aiTov/mevovs 10
irapd 6eov rod fieftaiws teal rjBecos tcu? eavTod tckvok; ra
Totavra irpoiefievov, tovto Be \eyco Sea t?;? ydpiTOS tov
o-Q)Tr}po<; Icofievovs t<x? yjrv%d<; avrcov, (fxoTi^ovTas teal irpoa-
ayovTas eirl ttjv ttjs dXrjOeias tcTrjoriv, ??? 6 tv^gov teal
cf. Phil iii 14 epyois dyaOols eXXaparpwofxevos fiovos ovtos fipafteiov r?}? 15
alcoviov £0)77? dvatprjaeTai. Beliai Be teal 7) ev%rj ^v^tj^
evpcoaTov teal Xiirapovs d\pi Trjs ecr%«T?79 r)fiepa^ tov /3iov
0-v/jL/jLefjL€Tpr)/jLev7)<; teal < r\ > iroXiTeia BiaBeaecos XPrl<7TV($
teal /jlovl/jLov teal irdaais Tat? evToXals tov awTrjpos eiretc-
T€LV0fieV7}^. 20
2. KivBvvevei Be|ov% dirXovv tl elvai to aiTiov tov f. 32
T7)V awTrjpLav %aXeircoTepav tols itXovtovo-i Botcelv rj toI<$
dyprj/jbaTOL^ tcov dvOpcoircov, aXXa iroi/ciXov. 01 fiev yap
avToOev teal irpoxelpcos dtcovaavTes tt}? tov acoTfjpos (frcovfjs,
cf. Mcx25lll qTL paov KafjLTJXos hid Tprj/jiaTOS patyiBos BietcBvaeTai 7725
irXovaios els ttjv ftao-iXeiav toov ovpavcov, diroyvovTe?
eavTovs a>? ov fSiooaopLevoi, too /coa/uup irdvTa yapi^byuevoi
teal t?}? evTavOa fa)?;? co? fAOvr) 1
? eavTois viroXeiirojuievrjs
etctcpefjiaaOevTes direcrTrjaav irXeov tt)<z itcei 6Bov, firj/ceTi
1 Tixpov 2 jSdpet 3 expw 4—6 r£ yap—\670s] Ant. Mel. 140
4 om. yap Ant. 5 /ueya\vuo/u,fru)] + TrapaTr^Tnjyev Ant. avTiarpcxpos S
7—10 depairetieiv—airavTa] nunc locum ita habet S: depaircieiv (lacuna 12 litt.)
tovsI
TrXovTovvras (lac. 11 aut 12 litt.) en-t Kaicy to avvaipeadai\
(lac. 10 litt.)
ttjv ao>TT)piav avroh (lac. 15 litt.)|aizavra. quae lacunae ita expleri possunt
Bepaireveiv ^aveXevdipws (Fell) > tovs irXovrovvras <nai eiraiveiv {kol wpoa-
eiraivelv Fell) > iwl KaK<£ to avvaipecrdai, <^7r' ayadig Kal> tt\v auTrjpiau avroTs
<o-vyKaTepya£eadai (Segaar) > airavTa 12 \£yu forsitan delendum est.
16 7} ei)%7j] ijavxv (sed a ex e factum ut uid.) 17 Xnrapas 18 <^> addidi
25 forsitan legendum SieAei/o-ercu (cf. §§ 4, 26, et Strom. 11 v 22 (440))
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 39/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 6
7ro\v7rpayfj,ovr)(TavT€<; fjur/re rivets rovs irXovatovs 6 Beo-irorrj^
Kai BiBdaKaXos Trpoaayopevet fir/re ottcos to dBvvarov ev ef. Mc x 27
dvOptoirco rj Bvvarov ylverai. aXXoL Be rovro fiev avvfj/cav
6p6(os Kal irpoariKovrws, Tcov Be epycov twv €69 Ti)v acoTrjptav
5 dvafyepovrtov oXcycoprjaavres ov irapeaKevdaavro rrjv Be-
ovcrav irapaatcevrjv eh to t&v eXiri^oixevwv rvyelv. Xeya Be
ravra eKarepa [direp] eirl twv irXovaiwv Kal T/79 8vvd/j,ea)<;
rod o-(OTf/po<i Kal Tr}$ eTTMpavovs aoyrrjptas TjaOrj/ubevcov, tqov
he d/jLvrJTG)v rrjs dXrjOeias oXiyov fioi fteXei.
10 3. X/ot} toivvv tovs (f)iXaXr)dco<; Kal (fnXaSeXcfrco*;
, Kal fir/re KaTaOpaavvo/jievovs avOdBcos tcqv
TrXovalcov kXtjtwv /Jbr/re av iraXuv viroiriiTTovTas avrols Sid
oiKeiav tyiXoKepBetav, irpwrov /nev avrwv e^atpelv rep Xoycp
rr)v Kevrjv diroyvwcnv Kal BrjXovv fierd 7-779 Beovarjs e^rjyr}-
)*37 creft)9 rcov Xoyicov rod Kvptov Scon ovk diroKeKoiTTai reXeov
avroZs rj K.Xr)povo\xia rrjs ftacnXeias rcov ovpavcov edv
328a vTraKovcTMai rats evroXals'|eW" oirorav fjuddooaiv ct>9 dheh
BeBlaat 8eo? Kal on fiovXo/Aevovs avrovs 6 o-corrjp dafxevw^
Several, rdre Kal irpoBeiKvvvat Kal pbvo-Taywyelv 07r&>9 dv
20 Kal hi oIlcov epyoiv re Kal BuiOeaecov eiravpaivro t?;9 eKirlBos,
&)9 ovt dfirj^dvov KaOeo-rcoarjs avrols ovre rovvavrlov el/crj
7repLyu'0/jL6vr)<;. d\\* onrep rpoirov €%€i to rwv dOXrjrcov,
Xva fiLKpd Kal eir'iKripa pLeyaXocs Kal dfyddprois irapa-
PdXwpbev, tovtI Kal i<j>
J
eavrcp 6 Kara Koapuov ttXovtcop
25 Xoyi^eaOco. Kal yap eKelvcov 6 jiev on Bvvrjaerat vlkclv Kal
o-Te<f>dv(DV Tvyydveiv direXirlo-as ovB' oXros eVl rrjv dOXijaiv
direypd^aro, 6 Be ravrrjv fiev epbftaXoiAevos rf} yvco/jurj rrjv
eXTriBa, ttovovs Be Kal rpo(f)d<z Kal yv\xvdcna fit) Trpoaiefievos
7rpocr<f)6pov<;, do-re(f)dv(OTO<; Bueyevero Kal Biyjfjbapre rcov eX-
30 ttlBcov. ovtws T69 real rrjv eiriyeiov ravrrjv 7repi(3e{3Xr)/jLevo<;
TrepiftoXrjv, (jo^re rrjv dpyrjv eavrbv tcov aOXcov rod acoTtjpos
lKK7]pvo-aera), ttio-tos ye wv Kal to fieyaXelov avvopcov T//9
tov Oeov tyiXavOp coirlas' /z>;t€ /jltjv avOis dvda/crjTos KOi
2 irpoaayopevr) X^ojj/ 7 [direp] iirl] forsitan logcndum
irepl 10 post 0t\a5A0ws lacuna fere 15 litterarum ; diaKeifx^vovs addidit
Fell 11 avdaSQs I 1 Kei>i]i>] Kaii>i)i> 24 t0' iavrov coni.
J, B. Mayor 30 irepijSe^XTjix/ji^pos
1—2
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 40/108
4 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
cf. iCoix25 dvaywvterror pelvas aKovtrl KaviBpcorl rwv are<f>dvcov rrjs
d(f)0ap(rla<; eXirt^erco peraXa/3elv' aXX' avrov vTroftaXero)
(f>epo)v yvpvaarfj [Jtev tw Xoycp, dycovoderrj Be rS XptcrTW*
cf. iCoxi25 Tpo(f)rj Be avrw real irorbv yeveadco reraypevov tj icaivr)
Siadijfcr} rod KVplov, yvpvdata Be at evroXal, eva^poavvrj 5
cf.iCoxiiii3 Be Kal Koo-pos at KaXal BiaOeaet^, dydirrj, irians, e'A,7rl?,
yvooats dXrjOelas, irpaorr)?,\
evcrirXayyvia, f. 32£
o€pv6ri]s' lv\ orav eo~ydrr\ crdXirty^ viroarjprjvr] rov Bpopov
real rrjs evrevOev i^bBov, Kaddrrep Ik araBiov rov ftiov
per dyaOov rov avvecB6ro<; rw dOXoOerrj irapaary vtKrj(f>6po^ 10
(bfioXoyrjpevos rrjs dvco irarplBo^ d^tos, eh rjv perd are<f)dvcov
. teal KTjpvypdrcov dyyeXtKwv enravepyerat.
4. AotT] TOivvv rjplv 6 awrr/p evrevOev ap^apevois rov
Xoyov rdXr)0fj teal rd irpeirovra teal rd awrripta avp/3a-
Xecrdat rots dBeXcfrois, 777)09 re rrjv eXirtBa irpcorov avrrjv, 15
Kal Bevrepov 777)0? rrjv rrjs e\7rlBos nrpoo~ayoyyr)v. 6 Be
yap'tQerai Beopevots Kal alrovvras BiBdcrKet, Kal Xvei rrjv
dyvoiav Kal rrjv diroyvwcrtv drroaeierai tovs avrov? irdXtv
eladywv Xbyovs rrepl rcov rrXovatcov, eavrwv epprjveas ytvo-
pevovs Kal e^rjyrjrds do~(j>aX€t<;' ovBev yap olov avrdov avOis 20
aKovorai rcov prjroov, airep rjpas ev rot? evayyeXtots d^pt vvv
Bterdpaaorev d^aaavtarca Kal Birjpaprripevod^ inrb vr)7rio-
Mcxi7ff rrjro^ aKpooopevovs. ^K7ropevopevov avrov et? 6Bbv irpoa-
eXdoov Tt? eyovvirerei Xeywv' AiBdcrKaXe dyade, ri iroLrjaa)
iva ^corjv aloovtov KXrjpovoprjaco ; Be 'Irjaovs \e<yet* TV pe 938
dyaOov Xeyew ; ovBels dyaObs el prj eh 6 #eoV t<z? ivroXds
olBas' M?) pot^evarj's, M?) (frovevcrys, Mrj KXeyfrj]^, Mr/ tyevBo-
paprvprjerys, Ttpa top irarepa gov Kal rrjv ptrjrepa. 6 Be
aTTOKptOels Xeyei avru>' Udvra ravra ecj)vXai;a. 6 Be 'I?;cro{)?
epftXeyjras r/ydirrjo-ev avrov Kal elirev'(/
Ev goi varepel'- el 30
deXei,? reXetos elvat, ttooXtjctov bcra e%6^9 Kal BidBos irrco'yol^,|
Kal e£e£<? 6r]aavpbv ev ovpavw, Kal Bevpo aKoXovdet pot. 6 f. 32(
Be o-rvyvdaas errl tc3 Xoy<p djrrjXde Xvrrovpevos' rjv yap
1 d/cwj'etrai, Kav IdpQri. emendationem Ghislerii in textum recepi.
7 7vwcrets post aXydeias lacuna 12 litterarum: iirtelKeia addidit
Fell 15 TrpdoTTju 23 aurw 29 i<pv\a£a] recte monet Segaar hie
excidisse librarii incuria ck v€ott)t6s fiov, quae uerba agnoscit noster infra § 8
et§10
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 41/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 5
eXt0V XPV/xara 7roX\a real dypovs. irept/3Xe\jrd/jLevo<; Se o
'Irjaovs Xeyeo roh /naOrjrats avrov' IIw? SvctkoXcds ol rd
yprj/xara eyovres elaeXevaovrat eh rrjv ffaatXelav rov Oeov.
ol Se fiaOrjral eOayufiovvro iirl roh Xoyocs avrov. iraXiv Se
5 o Irjaovs diroKpcOeh Xeyec avroh' TeKva, 7rco? Svo~koXov
ecrrt, roi)<; ireiroiOoras eirl ^prj/juaaiv eh rrjv /3aat,Xelav rov
Oeov elaeXOelv' \evKoXwsf Std rfjs rpv/xaXLas rrj<; fteXovrjs
fca/jbr)\o<; elcreXevaerai rj irXovatos eh rr/v /3aatXeiav rov
Oeov. ol Se irepcaacos e^eirXrjcraovro teal eXeyov' Th ovv
io Svvarai o-coOrjvat ; 6 Se e/i^Xeyfras avroh elirev on Ylapa
dvOpcoiroi? dSvvarov, irapd Oeco Svvarov. rjp^aro 6 JJerpos
Xeyeiv avrcp' 'iSe r}/j,ei<; dcpr/Ka/jbev irdvra Kal rjKoXovOijo-ap,ev
aoi. diroKpiOeh Se 6 'I^croi)? Xeyet' 'A/xrjv vfilv Xeyco, o? dv
d(j)f) ra ISia /cal yoveh Kal dSeXcfrovs real yprj/jbara eveicev ifxov
15 Kal eveicev rov evayyeXiov, diroXtfyfrerat eKarovrairXaatova
vvv ev rco Katpco rovrw dypovs Kal ^prj/xara Kal otKia^ Kal
dSeX(f>ov<; eyecv /juerd Sioyy/xcov "feh irovf' ev Se rep epyofievw
^corjv feartv alcovco?' ev Sef eaovrat ol irpwroi ea^arou, Kal,
ol ecryaroi irpdyroi.
20 5. Tavra /xev ev ra> Kara M.dpKOv evayyeXlw yeypairrai'
Kal ev roh aXXois Be irao-tv dvcd/JboXoy^jjievois oXlyov fiev
co-cos eKaarayov rcov prj/jidrcov evaXXaaaei, irdvra he rrjv
avrrjv rr)s yvaj/jbrjs crv{A(f>coviav eiriSeiKwrat. Set Se aacf>cos|
329b elSoras cos ovSev dvOp coirivcos 6 acorrjp dXXa irdvra Oela
25 croc])iq Kal fJbvartKfj SiSdaKeu rovs eavrov, /.crj aapKtvcos
aKpoaaOac rcov Xeyo/juevcov, aXXd rov ev avroh KeKpv/xfievov
vovv fjierd rrjs d^ias ^rjryaecos Kal crvveaecos epevvqv Kal
Kara/JuavOdvetv. Kal yap rd vir avrov rov Kvpiov BoKovvra
r)ir\(oaOai 7T/90? rovs fiaO^rd^ ra)v rjviy/jLevcos vireiprijxevoav
30 ovSev rjrrovo^ dXXa irXeLovos ere Kal vvv t/}? emardaeco's
evplvKerai Seofieva Sid rrjv virep/3dXXovcrav rrj^ (fypoinjaecos
ev avrols virepftoXi'iv. oirov Se Kal rd vopu^ofjieva vir avrov
SiwyOai rols ecrco Kal avrol$ rols rrj^ jBaaiXeias T€KVOl$ of.MtxiiiSS
vir avrov KaXovfievols ert yprj^ei (frpovriSoi irXeiovos, 17 irov
35 ye rd So^avra fiev dirXws e^evriveyOai Kal Scd rovro /jL?)Se
939 Siripwrrjfieva irpbs rwv aKovadvroyv, eh oXov Se ro reXos
3 xPVHa 17, IS conf. §§ 25, 26 21 hi> w/j.o\oyii/j.£vois BO tyr-
touos] + <!ti Kal vvv 33 5io?x^at •'' 7) 7ro^
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 42/108
6 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
avrb t?)? acoTrjpLas BtatyepovToov, eaKeiraafjuevcov Be 6avfiaaru>
Kal virepovpaviw Biavoia? ftddei, ovtc eiriiroXaiws Be^eadac
Tals a/coais irpoo~r)K6V, dXXd /cadtevras tov vovv eir avTO to
irvevfia tov o-coTrjpos Kal to ttjs: yvGOfAr)? airopprjTOv.
6. 'HpojT7]Tai /xev yap r)Bea)<; 6 Kvpios rjfiwv Kal acoTrjp 5
epooTrj/jia KaTaXXijXoTaTOV avToo, rj ^corj irepl ?o>>$9, 6 awT7]p
irepl o-coTrjpuas, 6 BiBdaKaXos irepl K€(paXalov twv BoBaaKO-
fievcov Boy/juaTcov, <r}> dXrjOeta irepl T17? dX7)0Lvr}<; dOavaaias,
6 Xoyos irepl tov iraTpcpov Xoyov, 6 TeXecos irepl Trjs TeXeias
dvairavaecds, 6 d<$>0apTO<; irepl tt}? /3ej3ai,a<; d(f>0apo-la<;' 10
TjpojTTjTaL irepl tovtcov virep gov Kal KaTeX^XvOev, d iraiBevei,
a BtBdaKei,\a irapeyei> wa Bei^rj ttjv tov evayyeXiov viro- L 330!
Oeaiv, OTi Boats earlv alwvlov ^corjs. irpooiBe he C09 Oeos
Kal d fxeXXei 8iepcDT7]0r}o-ecr0ai Kal a fieXXeo T£? avTO) diro-
Kplveo-0ai' Tt? yap Kal /juaXXov rj 6 irpocfrrJTr]? irpo(j)7]Ttov 15
Kal Kvpcos iravTOS irpo(j)7]TLKov irvevfiaTos ; KXrj0eU Be
dya06<>, dir avTov irpooTOV tov prjjjLaTOS tovtov To evBoaifjLOv
Xaftoav evTev0ev Kal t^? BiBaoKaXias dpyeTai, eiricrTpe^xov
tov ixa0Y)Tr\v eirl tov 0edv tov dya06v Kal irpooTOV Kal (jlovov
cf. Jn v 26, &VS coIcovlov Ta/juiav, rjv 6 vlbs BiBcoatv rj/jblv irap eKeivov 20
xvii 2 ,
Xapoov.
7. Ovkovv to ixeyio-Tov Kal Kopv^aioTaTOv tojv irpos
ttjv £cor)v /jba07]fjudTOJV dirb r>J? a/0%^7? ev0vs iyKaTa0ea0ai tj}
cf. Jnxvii3 ^VXV ^ e^ yvcovai tov 0e6v tov alooviov Kal BoTrjpa aiwviwv
Kal irpooTOV Kal virepTaTov Kal eva Kal dya06v. 0ebv eo~Ti 25
KTr)aao-0at Sod yvoocreax; Kal KaTaXr]-\jrea)<;' avTt) yap aTpeirTOs
Kal dadXevTo? dpyr\ Kal Kprjirls f&)^9, eirco-Tr/fir) 0eov tov
ovtcos ovtos Kal Ta ovTa, TovTeaTt Ta alobvia, ScopovfMevov,
eg oh Kal to elvai toi$ aXXots virdpyei Kal to /xelvai Xafietv'
7] jxev yap tovtov dyvoia 0dvaTOS eaTtv, rj Be eirlyvcoo-is 30
avTov Kal OLKeicocTLs Kal r\ irpos avTov dydirr) Kal ei;op,oi(ojn<;
JJLOVr) £(07).
cf. 1 Tim vi 8. Tovtov ovv irpooTOV eiuyv&vai tw %r]o-ofieva) ttjv
ovt(o<; farjv irapaKeXeveTai, bv ovBeU eiriyivoiGKei ei fMy o
uto? Kal to av 6 uio? diroKaXv^y' eirecTa to fxeye0os tov 35
1 forsitan legendum duMpepoura, ive<TKeira(T[xiva 5e H. Jackson 5 <ruT7)p]
<xp% 7 K€(pa\aiov] + ov 8 <^> addidi 13 TrpooWe 30 adavards
19
Mt xi 27
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 43/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 7
o-coTrjpos puer e/ceuvov ical ttjv Kacvorrjra tyjs x(lP lT0($
puaOelv, on 8r) Kara tov dirocrroXov O vopuos 8ud Meocreet)? Jn i 17
i860T], rj yapis zeal fj dXrjdeta Sid 'Irjaov XptcrTOi)' ical
ov/c tcra ra Sid 8ovXov ttccttov 8i86pueva tous vtto tov vlov c f. He iii r,
5 yvrialov 8copovpevous- el yovv l/cavos r)v 6 Mtocrea)? vopuos cf. Ga ii 21
330b^corjv
I
alcovcov irapaa^elv, pudrriv puev 6 au>Tr)p avTos irapa-
yiverat teal irda^ei 8C rjpuas diro yeveo-ea)? puexpi T0^ o-rjpueuov cf. Phil ii 8
tt]v dv6pwiroT7]Ta hiarpexw, pudrriv 8e 6 irdaas Treirour]ic(os cf. Mcx20
940 e/c veorriTOS Tas vopuipuovs evToXds irapd aXXov alrel yovv-
10 Trertov dOavaalav. ov8e yap 7re7rXrjpco/ce puovov tov vofiov,
aXXa Kai evOvs otto irpooTrjs r)Xi/cuas dp^dpuevos' eirel teal
tl pueya rj virepXapLirpov yrjpas dyovov d8ufcrjpudTQ)v wv
eiriOvpjiai tu/ctovgi veavc/cal rj opyr) £eovo~a rj epcos XP7/'
pbdrayv ; aXX* et Tt? ev a/ctpTrjpuaTL veorrjauw ical tQ> /cavcrcovc
15 Trjs rjXu/cias irapeax7)TaL typovrjpua ireiravbv /cal irpearftvTepov
tov xpovov, davpuaarbs ovtos dywviarr)^ /cal 8ia7rpe7rr)s /cal
Trjv yvcopurjv iroXucoTepos. dXX' opucos ovtos 6 touovtos
d/cpi/3(ios ireireio~Tai 8lotl avrS irpos puev Bc/caiocrvvrjv ov8ev
iv8el, farjs 8e oXr]s 7rpoa8eu' 81b avrrjv alrel irapd rov 8ovvai
20 puovov 8vvapuevov, /cal irpbs puev rov vopuov dyei irapprjuLav,
rov 6eov 8e tov vlov i/ceTeveu' i/c Trio-Tews els ttuotiv puera- cf. Ro i 17
TaaaeTai- d)s acf>aXepocis ev vbpuw aaXevwv /cal eTru/civSvvcos
vavXox&v els tov o-corrjpa puedoppul^eTat.
9.f
O yovv ^Irjaovs ov/c eXeyx^u puev avTov d>s irdvTa tu
25 e/c vopuov pur) ireirXripw/coTa, dXXa ical dyaira /cal virepao-ird-
^erai Trjs ev ols epiadev evireiOeias, «Te\»; 8e elvai (prjaiv
a)? TTpos Tr)v alwviov £cor)v, ft)? ov TeXeia ireirXripco/coTa., ical
vopuov puev epyaTrjv, dpybv 8e for}? dXr]6ivfjs. /caXa puev ovv
/cd/celva' tis 8' ov (prjcriv ; f) yap evToXrj dyla cixpi irai8a- Ro vii 12
30 ywylas tlvos pieTa (froftov /cal TrpoTraiSeias eirl Trjv tov of. Ga iii 24
"\rjaov vopoOeaiav Trjv d/cpav /cal X (lP lv 7rpox(t)P v°~a'
TrXrjpoypua 8e vopuov XpcaTos els 8iKauoavvrjv iravTi tio ,i. Bo ii
7rcaTevovTL, ovyl 8e 8ovXovs ttouwv d>s 8ovXos, dXXa ical vlois of. Boviii^1 1 ff
v
2 Set 3 rj 2°] supra lin. a pr. man. 4 too. (Ghisler)] cts
4, 5 tov vlov yvrjaiov] aut tov oniittoiidiun, ant BOribenduiD tov yvrjalov vlov rum
Ghisler 9 ahel (J. A. Robinson)] £ti 15 irapio-xnTai H. JaoksOB
TrapdaxVT<xl S iranraudu 31 irpoxwpovvTa '.Y.\ 51Jaut omit li'inluni
esse aut in 5rj mutamlum monet J. B. Mayor
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 44/108
8 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
cf. Mt xii so Kal dBeXQovs Kal avyfcXrjpovofiovs -701)9 errcTeXovvTas to
OeXrjfia tov 7rarp6<;.
Mo*si(«fc 10. Et 6eXei$ TeXeios yevecrdai. ovk dpa tto) TeXetos
rjv' ovBev yap Te\Xelov reXeiorepov. Kal Oelcds to' Et f. 331 a
deXew to avre^ovcnov rrjs 7rpoaBtaXeyopievrj<; avroj ^jrv^rj^ 5
eBrjXcjaev' eirl tgD dvdpcoTTG) yap r\v r] aipetri? &)? eXevdepw,
eirl 0ea> Be rj Boats 009 Kvpioy. BlBcoac Be (SovXop,evoi<; teal
VTrepecnrovoaKocrL Kal Beopuevois, lv ovtoo? IBiov avrwv rj
o-Q)T7)pia yevrjTat,. ov yap dvay/cd^ei b 6eb<$, ftia yap e^dpov
cf. Mt vii 7 ; dea), dXXa tols ^rjTovai iropi^ei Kal toIs alrovat irapkyei, Kal 10
Tot? Kpovovatv dvoiyei. el OeXets ovv, el ovtcos OeXeis, Kal
firj eavTov i^arraTa?, KTrjaai to evBeov.r/
Ev aou Xeirrei' to
ev, to i/Jibv, to dyaObv, to rjBrj vrrep vbpuov, oirep vofjios ov
BiBcoaiv, oirep vopuos ov ^copel, b tgov ^oovtoov IBlou €o~tiv.
d/meXec 6 irdvTa Ta tov vbfxov irXrjpooaas 6K veoTr)TO<z Kal tcl 15
virepoyKa (f>pva^dpbevo<; to ev tovto irpocrdelvat tols oXocs ov
BeBvvrjTai, to tov acoTrjpos egaipeTov, Xva Xafirj ^wrjv alcovcov,
7]v irodel' dXXa Bvo"%epdva<$ dirrjXdev d^Oeadels toj irapay- 941
yeXfjuaTi 7779 fft>?79, virep 779 l/eerevev. ov yap aXr}dco<; %<crjv
ij6eXev, ft)? k(j)ao-K€v, dXXa B6%av irpoaipeaews dyadrjs pubvrjv 20
irepteftaXXeTO, Kal irepl iroXXa puev 0609 Te rjv ao-^oXelaOai,
to Be ev to Trjs £0)779 epyov dBvvaTo? Kal dirpbOvfio? Kal
cf. Lcx.wf dadevrj^ eKTeXelv' birolbv tl Kal irpbs ttjv M.dp0av elirev b
o-Q)Tijp acr^oXovfievrjv iroXXa Kal irepceXKOpLevrjv Kal irapa-
Tapaao~ofxev7)v BiaKOviKoos, tt)v Be dBeX<§>r)v oLtkd/mevrjis otl to 25
virrjpeTetp diroXtirovaa Tot9 iroalv avTOv irapaKadijTai fxaOy]-
Lcxiif tcktjv dyovaa o-^pXyv' Si) irepl iroXXa Tapdaay, Mapla Be
ttjv ayaOrjv p,eplBa igeXegaro, Kal ovk d<f>ai,pe6rjcreTat avTrjs.
o{/Tft>9 Kal tovtov eKeXeve Trj<; TroXvirpay/xoo-vvys d^epuevov
evi 7rpoaTeT7jKevai Kal TrpocrKaOe^eaOai tj) yapiTi tov farjv 30
alwVLOV TTpOGTlQeVTO^.
3 a/ra 4, 5 et 0e\ets] edtXecs 6—11 eirl rep avdpuiry—avotyei]
Leontius Vat. Gr. 1553 f. 56 Parall. Vat. et Scor. 315 6 yap rjv] phLeont. Vat. Scor. om. r/ Vat. 7 deep] pr. r£ Leont. 5e 1°]
om. Vat. supra lin. habet Scor. 8 'Iva Vat. Scor. aurQv] avrou
Leont. Vat. Scor. 9, 10 ov yap—dey] Leont. Vat. Gr. 1553 f. 119
9 o\> yap] ovk Leont. 119 om. 6 Leont. 56 et 119 exQpbv] aiaxpov
Leont. 56 10 ^rovo-i] fr)Tov<Tii> avrbv Leont. alrovatu Leont.
24, 25 waparaaaofxevrju
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 45/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 9
f. 331 b 11. Tt Toivvv r)v to irpOTpetydpLevov\avrov els (pvyrjv
Kal Troifjcrav diravTO/jboXrjcrai tov BiBacrKaXov, rrj<; i/cere'ias,
Trj$ eXTTiBos, T17? £o>?7?, toov irpoireTTOvqfjbevwv ; UcoXrjaov rd Mtxix2i
vtrdpyovTa gov. tl Be tovto Sgtlv ; ov% o 7rpo%elpco<;
5 BeyovTai Tives, rrjv virdpyovaav ovaiav drroppl^aL irpoG-
rdaaei kj-1 aTroarfjvac tcov ^pTj/xaToyv' aXXd rd Boy/Jbara
<rd> irepl j£pr)p,dTwv e^oplaai T/j? ^rv^fjs, rrjv wpos avrd
av/jLirdOeiav, rrjv virepdyav eiriOvfilav, rrjv irepl avrd tttoiclv
kol voaov, t«? /xepl/jivas, ra? dicdvQas rod (3iov, at to cf. Mcivi9in
10 airepfxa rfjs £a)>?? gvpurveyova iv. ovre ydp fxeya Kal ^rjXcorbv
to tt)v aXXcos diropeiv ^prjfiaTcov fir) ovk eirl Xoyw fco/;?*
ovtco \xev y dv r)aav ol pirjBev e^ovTes pbrjBafJir) aXXd eprjpioi
Kal fieTalTat toov e<f> r)/jiepav, ol KaTa Ta? 6801/$ eppipLpievoi
7TTO)^ot, dyvoovvTes Be Oeov Kal BiKaioGvvrjv Oeov, KaT avTo cf. Eoi3
15 fAovov to ciKpcos diropelv Kal dfjirj^aveiv fllov Kal tcov
eXa^iGTCov Giravi^eiv piaKapicoTaToi Kal OeocpiXeaTaToi Kal
fiovot %tor)v e^ovTes alcoviov ovTe Kaivov to direiTraGOai
itXovtov Kal %apiaaaOai tttco^ois rj iraTpiGiv, iroXXol
irpb ttjs tov acoTrjpos KaOoBov ireiroi-qKaGiv, ol fiev Tr}<; eh
20 Xoyovs a%oXr}s Kal veKpd? Gocpia? eveicev, ol Be <j)rj/j,r]S Kevr}<;
Kal KevoBo^las, 'Ava^ayopai Kal Ar/pioKpiTOi Kal KpaTijTes.
12. Tl ovv C09 Kaivov Kal iBiov Oeov TrapayyeXXei Kal
fiovov ^coottoiovv, b tov<; irpoTepovs ovk eacoaev ; el Be eljai-
peTov tl r) Kaivrj ktlgis, 6 vlos tov Oeov, /Jbrjvvei Kal BiBdaKei,
25 ov to <f>aiv6/jievov, birep aXXoi TreiroiyKaGi, irapeyyva, dXX' e-
Tepbv tl Bid tovtov arj/maivo/uievov fiei^ov Kal OeiOTepov Kal
TeXeooTepov, to t?)v ^Irv^rjv avTrjv Kal Trjv BidOeaiv yvfivcoaai
tcov vttovtcov iraOcov Kal irpoppi^a tci dXXoTpia t^<> yvcopurj^
eKTepieiv Kal eK/3aXeiv. tovto ydp IBiov fiev tov ttlq-tov to
30 fidOrifjia, d^iov Be tov aa)Trjpo<; to BlBayfia. ol ydp tol
3TrpoireTTovqixivuv']
wpo supra lin. additum, sed a prim, manu3
—10iru-
\t}<tov—avfAirvlyovcrii>] Parall. Vat. ct Scor. 502 Paris 18Ga 4 aou post
jnbXTjaou habent Vat. Scor. Paris tI dt—wpoxeipus] tl ov (ovre Scor.)
7Tpoxe^pws Vat. Scor. Paris 5 twos Paris airoptyai Paris 5—7 0111.
TrpoaTaaaeL—^vxys Vat. Scor. Paris 7 <r&> addidi irpbs ai'-rd] nf>bs
ai>T7)i> Scor. Paris 8 irtpl clOto.] irepl avrrju Vat. Trroiav] aypvwvlav V;it.
Scor. Paris [) Kal] ttjv Vat. 10 KaTairi>l-yov<nv Paris 11 t6t' rp> &\\us
airoppeiv 17 aiwviav Kaivov (Ghislor)] koivov 1^ Trarplcriv (Ghisler)J
Trarpdaiv 20 uvckcv 23 faoiroiuv 24 ktIo~ls (Ghislor)J irHpriS 28 w^bpL^a
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 46/108
10 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
irporepoi, /cara(f)povTJ(TavT€S t&v i/cros, ra /xev KTij/Mara 942
d(f>r]Kav teal TrapaTrcoXeaav, ra Se|irdOr) tmv ^v^wv olpbat t 332a
ori zeal irpoaeTTereivav' ev virepo^la yap iyevovro /cai dXa-
^oveia /cat KevoSo^ta fcal irepttypovrjaei tcov aWoov avOpoo-
7T(dv, ft)? avrot tl virep dvOpcoirov epyaadpuevoi.t
ir&s dv 5
ovv 6 acorrjp rrap^vei to?? et9 del fiiwcropLevois ra /3\dyjrovra
teal \vfjLavov/LL€va 737)09 ttjv ^(orjv, rjv iTrayyeXXerai ; teal yap
av Kaicelvo earn' Svvaral rt? a7ro(f)opTi(rd/jL€vo<; rrjv kty\<jiv
OvZlv 7]TT0V €TL TTJV e7n6u/JblaV Kal TYjV Ope^LV TCOV ^prj/JbaTCOV
e)(6iv evT6T7]icvlav Kal av^odaav, Kal tyjv fxev y^pyjaiv diro- 10
/3ef3\r)KevaL, diropoov Se dfia Kal ttoOoov enrep eenrddr^ae
onrXfj XvirelaOai, Kal rrj r^? vTrrjpeo-las dirouaia Kal rfj rrjs
fjueravoias avvovaia. dve(j>tKTOv yap Kal d/jurj^avov oeojxevov
tcov 7T/909 to fttoTeveiv dvayKaicov fxrj ov KaTaKKaaOai rrjv
yvco/xrjv Kal da^oXiav dyeiv dirb tcov KpeiTTovcov, bircoaovv 15
Kal odevovv ravra Treipco/xevov eKiropl^etv.
13. Kal iroacp xprjcri/jLcoTepov to evavTtov, iKavd k€Kttj-
puevov avTOv re irepl rr/v KTrjatv /jltj KaKOiraQelv Kal 0I9
KaOrjKev eiriKovpelv ; rls yap dv Koivcovia KaTaXeiiroiTo
irapd dvdp lotto is, el fJL7)8el<; ^X0i A67? ^; 7rco9 S' dv tovto to 20
Soyfia 7roXXot9 dWois Kal KaXols toO KvpLov $6yp,aaiv ov^l
Lcxvi9 cf>avepco<$ ivavrLovfievov evpio~KOiTO Kal \xayo\xevov ; Hoirjcrare
eavTols (f)i\ovs €K tov fjua/ncova T179 dSiKtas, Xv orav eKKiTry
Mtvi20 Setjcovrai vfias et'9 rd<? alcoviovs crKrjvds. K.T7]aaa0e dt)CTav-
povs ev ovpavco, oirov /jurjre 0-779 ixrjre ftpcocrLS dcpavl^ec juLTjre 25
cf. Mtxxv KXeirrai hiopvcraovcTL ircos dv Tt? ireivcovTa rpefyoi Kai
hu^rcovTa itotl^ol Kal yv/xvov GKeird^oi Kal dareyov avvdyoi,
d Tot9 /A?) nroi^aaaiv direuXel irvp Kal gkotos to i^oorepov, el
7rdvr(ov avros eKaaros <f)0dvoi tovtcov varepwv ; d\Xa firjv
cf. Lcxix6; auT09 re eiri^evovTai Zavala) Kal Aevel Kal M.ardalo) to?9 30MtixlOlll
, .•
, x x > 1 > \
7t\ovo~loi<; Kai TeXoovaw, Kat ra /Jiev %pr]p,aTa avrovs ov
KeXevei fieOelvat, rrjv Se hi\Kalav Kplcriv eiriQel^ Kal rrjv f. 332b
Lcxix9 doiKOV dcj)eXoov KarayyeWei' Xrf/jiepov acorrjpla tw oXkw
tovtg). ovrco Tr)v yjpeiav avTcov eiraivel, ware Kal fxerd rrj?
7rpoo-6r)Krj<; Tavrr)<; rrjv KOLVwviav eiriTaacrei, irorl^eiv tov 35
Sc^rcovra, dprov hihovai toj ireivoovTi, viroheyeo-Qai tov dareyov,
19 /caraXet7rerat 30 /cai Aevel coniecerunt J. A. Robinson et P. Koetschau
(uide adnot.); /ceXei;et S
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 47/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 11
dficpcevvvvac tov yvfivbv. el Be rd<; p^peta? ovk olov re
eKTrXrjpovv Tavras fir) diro ^prffiaTcov, roov Be Xprj/iaTcov
d^lo-raadac KeXevet, rl dv erepov elrj itoiwv 6 KVptos <>)>
rd avrd BtBovac re teal fir) BtBovac irapacvoov, Tpecpecv Kal
5 fir) Tpecpecv, viroBe^eaOat, Kal diroKXeleiv, Kocvcovelv Kal fir)
KOivoovecv, oirep airdvTwv dXoycorarov.
14. Ovk dpa diroppiiTTeov rd Kal rot)? TreXa? axpeXovvra
XprjfiaTa' tcrr/fiara yap eart KT-qrd ovra, teal ^prjfiaTa XPV~
943 crifia ovra teal ek y^prfcriv dvdpooirwv viro tov 6eov wapeo-tcev-
io aarfieva' a Br) irapaKetrat teal v7ro/3e/3X7jraL tcaOdirep vXrj
rt9 teal opyava 7rpo? ^prjacv dyaOrjv tols elBocn. to op-
yavov, edv xpy Te^t/eco?, Teyyitctv eartv' edv vcrTepfjs t?7?
re^vr]?, diroXavei T779 crrjs dirovaia^ ov dvaiTLOv. tolovtov
teal 6 ttXovtos opyavov eari' Bvvaaac ^pf/crOat Bitcaicos
15 avT<p ; 777)09 BcKaioavvrjv Kadvir^perel' dBiKco^ rt? avToo
Xprjrai, ; iraXiv virrfpeTr)? dBiKta^ evpLo-tcerai' 7re(f>VKe yap
vTrriperelv, aXX' ovk apyeiv. ov %pr) tolvvv to ef eavrov fir)
e^ov firjre to dyaObv firjre to Kaicbv dvaiTiov ov atTLaaOai,
aXXa to Bvvdfievov ical KaXoos tovtols ^prjaOaL ical fcatcoos,
20 d(f> gov dv eXrjTai' ical av\b tovto 6° ScttI vovs dvOpGoirov,
Kal KpcT-rjpLov eXevOepov eyjav ev eavTa) ical to avTe^ovaiov
TJ79 fieTa^eipio-ecos tgov BoOevtcov' coaTe fir) Ta KTtjfiaTa tls
dcpavL^eTO) fidXXov r) Ta 7rd0rj Tr)$ tyv^s, Ta fir) avy^copovvTa
Trjv dfieivco %pfjcriv tgov virapyovTwv, Xva KaXo? ical dya0o$
25 yev6fievo<; Kal tovtols tols KTrj/iaat ^prjaOac BvvrjOfj KaXoo<;.
f. 333a to ovv diroTa^aaOaL ira\ai tols virdpyovai Kal ircoXijaat of. Lc xiv S3
irdvTa Ta virdpyovTa tovtov tov Tpoirov eKBeKTeov go? eirl
twv yfrvxtKoov iraQwv Bieiprffievov.
15. 'E7C0 yovv KaKelvo <j>?]<raifi civ' e7reiB)) tu fiev evTos
30 eaTL Trjs ^V^fj% T(i Be cVto?, Kav fiev r) yjrv^r) %p7JTai KaXws
KaXa Kal TavTa BoKel, edv Be TrovrjpcZs trovypd, 6 KeXevcor
diraXXoTpiovv Ta virdpyovTa iroTepov TavTa TrapaiTeiTai tov
dvatpeOevrcov eTi Ta irdQr) fievei, 1} eKtlva fidXXov gov dvaipe-
devTcov Kal Ta KTy/iaTa ^ptjatfia ylveTat ; 6 tolvvv airo-
3 <^> addidit Ghialei 7 dpa 13 airovaias] d/j.ov<xias coniccit Segaai
20 Kal] Kar' 25 Krla/xaai (scd i 1" super rj scriptuni esse Dictator)
20 dirord^adai 32 Trpbrtpov
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 48/108
12 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
j3a\o)v rrjv zeoapuzerjv irepiovaiav en hvvarat irXovrelv ro3v
Tradojv, zeal tt}<; tfXr)*; pu?) irapovarj^' r) yap rot hidOeau^; ro
avrr/s evepyel zeal tov Xoyicrpuov
ayx60 Kai 7rte
?6t ^a\ <$>Xey-
ficuvei rats avvTp6(j>OL(; iiridv/nlaLS' ovhev ovv irpovpyov
yeyovev avrep irreoyevtiv xprjpsdrcov rrXovrovvri roov iraOayv 5
ov yap rd diroftXrjra direjSaXev, aXXa rd dhid(f)Opa' zeal reov
p,ev V7rr)p€TL/eQ)V eavrbv irepteKo^rev, e^ezeavae he rrjv vXtjv
rf}<; zeazeia<$ rrjv epufivrov rfj rwv i/eros diropla. diroTazereov
ovv tol$ VTrdp^ovac rol$ j3Xa(3epol<;, ov^l T0Z9 (edv eTriarTjraL
Ti? rrjv opdrjv XP^iv) /ecu avvcocfreXeiv hvvapuevois. oocpeXel 10
he rd puerd (fypovrjereeos zeal acotypoavvris zeal evo-e/3eLa<;
OLKovofjLovjxeva, diroiarea he rd hrityj/ua' rd he e/eros ov
^Xdirrei.
16. Ovrcos ovv 6 zevpios zeal rrjv rcov ezerbs XPe'
LCLV
elcrdyec, zceXevcov diroQecrdai ov rd fiiconzed, aXXa rd rovrois 944
zeazecos xpeo^eva' ravra he r}v rd rfjs yjrvxvs dppcoarrjpLara
zeal 7ra6rj. (16.) O rovreov 7tXovtos irapcov puev diraat Oava-
T7](j)opo<;, diroXofAevos he o-corrjpLos' ov hel zeaOapevovcrav,
rovrean irreox^yovaav /cal yvpuvr)v, rrjv tyvx^v Trapaaxb-
Mcx2i pevov ovtcds rjhrj tov crcoTrjpos dzeoverai Xeyovro^' Aevpo d/eo- 10
cf. Mtv8 XovOei fJLOL. 0S09 ydp avrbs tfhr) rS zeaOapep rrjv /eaphiav
yiverai, eh he diedOaprov yjrvxrjv 6eov %a/n9 ov irapahverai'
dzedOapros he rj irXovrovaa rwv eiriOvpbiwv zeal\oohlvovaa f. 333b
TToXXols epa)o~L zeal /coapLizeols. fiev yap e^fov zerrjpara zeal
Xpvabv zeal dpyvpov zeal olzelas 009 6eov hcopeds, zeal rep re 25
hchovn 0ea) Xeirovpywv air' avroov eh dvOpooiroov aoorrjplav,
zeal elhobs on ravra zeezerrjTaL hid rovs dheXcfrovs puaXXov rj
eavrbv, zeal zepelrroov vTrdp^oov rrjs zerr}crea)<z avroov, pur) hovXos
<cov> oov zeezerr\Tai, pSrjhe ev rfj tyvxfj ravra 7repi(j)ep(ov,
/JLTjhe ev rovrois opl^cov zeal irepLypd<f>oc>v rrjv eavrov %a>r)v, 30
aXXa n zeal zeaXbv epyov zeal Oelov del htaiTovwv, zedv drro-
o~repi]Qr]vai hey irore rovreov hwd/xevo^ XXew rfj yvcofir) zeal
rrjv diraXXayrjv avrolv eveyzeelv ei; icrov zeaOdirep zeal rrjv
Treptoveriav,—ovros eartv 6 piazeapi^opbevo^ virb rod zcvpiov
cf. Mtv3 zeal 7rT&)^09 roo Trvev/man zeaXovpuevo^, zeXrjpovopuos erot,p,o<; 35
ovpavov fiao-tXelas, ov irXovcnos ^rjaai pur) hvvdpuevos' (17.) o
18 5e?] 8r] 29 <o)j'> addidit J. B. Mayor 36 ovpavov] ovpaviov
coniecit Segaar
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 49/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 13
Be ev rfj -tyvxjj tov ttXovtov (pepcav, Kal dvrl deov TrvevfiaTos
ev rfj KapBia y^pvabv (\>epwv rj dypbv, Kal rrjv KTrjouv afxerpov
del ttolgov, Kal eKaaTOTe to TrXelov fiXeirwv tcara) vevevKoos Kal
Toh tov fc6a/jLOV 6r)pdrpois TreTreBrjfxevo^, yrj wv Kal eh yrjv ct. Geiiii9
5 aTreXevaofievos, iroOev BvvaTai {3ao-i\ela<; ovpav&v eTndvp,rj-
aai teal (ppovTiaac avOpwrros ov KapBlav dXXd dypbv rj fie-
raXXov cjyopwv, ev tovtols evpeOrjaofievos eirdvayKes ev oh cf. § w
eiXero ; "Ottov yap 6 vovs tov dvOpwirov, i/cel Kal 6 8r)aav-j
Uvi. :.
1;
pd<? avrov.
io 17. ®r)(ravpov<s Be ye 6 Kvpcos olBe Bittovs, tov puev
dyadov' 'O yap dyadov dvOpcoTros e/c tov dyadov drjaavpov
T7]<; KapBlas 7rpo(f)epec to dyadov' tov Be irovrfpov' 'O yap Lc vi \:>
rea/eds etc tov /ca/cov drjaavpov Trpocpepec to tcatcov' oti etc
TrepiaaevfiaTos T179 KapBlas to cfto/ao, XaXel. coarrep ovv Orj-
15 aavpbs ov^ eh Trap avTar, Kadb /cal Trap tj/jllv, 6 to altyvlBtov
fxeya /cepBos ev evprjaec BlBov^, dXXd real BevTepos, 6 aKepBrjs
/cal a^rjXos Kal Bvo-kttjtos koX iirifyfiio?' oi/toj? ical ttXovtos
6 fjuev Ti? dyadwv, 6 Be fcatccov, ecye tov ttXovtov Kal tov
0T)aavpdv ovk aTT^pTriiievov^ la/juev dXXrjXcov Trj (jyvaet. Kal
f. 334a 6 fiev T£?I
ttXovtos kt7)to<; dv eXt) Kal Trepl(3Xr)TO<;, 6 Be
945 aKTr)TO<; Kal aTroflXrjTOS' tov avTov Be Tpbirov Kal TTTW^eia'
fiaKapio-Tr/ fiev r) TTvevfiaTiKrj' Bob Kal irpoaeOrjKev 6 Mar-
datos' MaKaptoi 01 TTTtoyoi 7TW9 ; Tw TrvevfiaTf Kal MX i •:j
irdXtv' MaKapiot ol TreivcovTes Kal BttywvTes t?}v Bitcaio-MtvQ
25 avvrjv tov deov' ovkovv ddXioi ol evavTioi tttco^oI, deov fiev
d/Jboipoi, d/jLOLpoTepoi Be Trj<; dvdpwTrlvr)*; KTr'/aeo)<;, dyevaTOi Be
BiKacoavv7](; Oeov.
18.r/
rio"T€ toi)? TrXovaiov? fiadrjfiaTiKoos aKovaTeov, toi)?
BvaKoXox; elaeXevaofievov^ eh Trjv /3aaiXelav, fi)) o-Kaido$ /xrjBe
30 dypoLKax; /jirjBe aapKLvo)<;' ov yap ovtcos XeXeKrai, ovBe e-rrl
Toh €ktos 1] acoTTjpla, ovTe el TroXXa ovt€ el oXlya TavTa 7)
pbiKpd rj fxeydXa i) evBo^a i) dBo^ai) evBoKt/ia rj dBoKifia,
aXX' eVt Trj T179 tyvxrjs dpeTrj, TTiGTei Kal eXTrlBi Kal dyaTrrj
Kal (f>iXaBeX(f)la Kal yvcoaec Kal irpaoTr/TL Kal drvtyia Kal
1 deov] forsitan legendum dclov 7 tordraynet (Ghialer)] in d^/ccus S
iv oh et'XeTo ante iv toOtols poncnduni esse putat J. B. jMayci 10 po-t
Orjaavpoiis 5i rasura duarum litt. sed manet signuin compeudii. BoripttUD
esse uidetur 5^ ics 28 irXovalw
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 50/108
14 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
aXr)0ela, gov <\0Xov r) acorrjpLa' ovBe yap Bid KaXXos aGOfiaros
^rjaeral res i) rovvavrlov diroXelrai' dXX* 6 fiev rS Bo0evTt
cf. iCoiiii7 awfiari ayvws Kal Kara 0ebv ^poj/xevos tyoerai, 6 Be (f>0elpcov
rbv vabv 0eov (fiOaprjaerai. Bvvajai Be ris Kal ala^pbs daeX-
<yaiveiv kcli Kara KaXXos crGotypovelv' ovBe io")(V$ Kal fxeye0os 5
aGo/jiaros faoTroiei, ovBe tgov /xeXcov ovBevla diroXXvei,, dXX* r)
tovtols ^jrv^y) xpcofievr} rrjv alriav e<$> eKarepa rrapeyerai.
MtLC
39
i2!); V7r°4>6Pe jovv, (f)7]al, iraLo/ievos rb Trpoacoirov birep Bvvarai
teal la^vpos ris gov teal eveKTGov viratcovorat, Kal rrdXiV daOe-
vlkos res gov afcpacrla yvGo/jLr)S 7rapa(3r)vai. ovrcos real diropos 10
res gov Kal dfiios evpe0elrj iror dv juueOvcov rals e7ri0vfilais,
icai xpr)fiacr l irXovcrios vt/^gov ical rrrGoyevGov rjBovGov, Trerrei-
a/jLevos, avverbs, Ka0apbs, KeKoXaajjuevos. el toIvvv eart to
^rjcrofjuevov fidXtara /cal irpciorov r) ^v^r), /cal rrepl ravrrjv
dperr) fiev ^vopevt) aw^ei, tca/cla Be Oavarol, BrjXov rjBr) 15
cra(f)Gos on avrrj /cal rn,
ru)yevovo~a gov dv ris iiirb rrXovrovj
Bia(f)0aprj aoo^erat, /cal irXovrovaa tovtcdv gov errri'rpLfteL f. 334b
irXovros 0avarovrat' /cal fju^Keru ^rwfxev dXXa^ov rrjv alriav
tov reXovs 7rXr)v iv rjj rrjs yfrv^V^ Karaardaei /cal Biadeaei
irpbs re vira/corjv 0eov Kal /caOaponjra rrpbs re rrapdfiaoiv 20
evroXdov /cal KaKias avXXoyrjv.
19. O fxev dpa dXi)0Gos /cal koXgos ecrrlv 6 tgov dpercov
irXovcnos /cal irdarj rv^rj %pr)cr0at baiGOs /cal ttlotgos Bvvdfievos,
6 Be vb0os irXovauos 6 /card adp/ca ttXovtgov ical rrjv %wr)v
el<; < ttjv > efeo KTrjatv /jLerevrjvo^aos rrjv Trapep^o/nevrjv /cal 25
(f>0eipo/uLevr]v>
ical dXXore aXXov yivo/jbevrjv /cal ev tgo reXei
/jL7]Bevbs fX7]BafJirj. irdXtv av Kara rbv avrov rpoirov /cal yvr)- 946
aios 7rra)^o? kcli vq0os dXXos TTTw^bs KCLI ^evBGOVV/JLOS, 6
fjiev /card Trvevfia 7tto)^09 to lBlov, 6 Be Kara koo~/j,ov to
dXXoTpiov. T(p Br) KaTa koo~/ulov tttgo^go koX irXovalw Kara 30
rd ird0r) 6 Kara irvevfia [ov\ TrTco^bs Kal Kara 0edv ttXovglos
'Att bo'77]6h tgov virapyovTUiv ev ry tyvxf} gov KTrj/jLarcov
cf. Mtv8 dXXoTpicov, iva Ka0apbs rfj KapBla yevofievos IBrjs rbv 0ebv,
oirep Kal BC erepas <j>(Dvr}<; earlv elcreX0elv els rrjv ftaaiXelav
o
6 ovde via 11 iiridv/xias 13 KadapQs rolvw] rbiv
16 tt\o{itov (sic Combefisius)] toijtov 17 duupdeipei 18 davovrat
22 apa 25 <t?;i'> addidit Ghisler. 31 ov delendum esse putauit
Segaar
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 51/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 15
roiv ovpavcov. Kal 7Tft)? avrdov d7roarfj<; ; TrcoXr/aas. ri ovv ;
Xprj/jLara avrl fCTrj/jLarcov Xdftrjs ; dvTiBoatv ttXovtov 7Tpo?
ttXovtov TroirjadfjLevos, e^apyvpiaas rrjv <j>avepav ovalav
ovhafjLoos' dXXd dvrl tojv irporepov evvirap^ovTcov rfj ^f%i?,
5 rjv acoaat TroOeis, dvTetcrayofxevo^ erepov ttXovtov Oeoiroiov
Kal £0)17? ^oprjiydv alcovlov, rds Kara ttjv evToXrjv rod deov
BtaOeaet^, avG" gov croi Trepiearac pacrOb^ Kal tl/jLt), Bir)veKr)s
acoTrjpia Kal aloovLO*; d$Qapo~ia. ovrco KaXdos TrcoXels rd
VTrdp-^ovra, rd iroXXd Kal ireptaad Kal diroKXeiovTa aoi rovs
10 ovpavovs, avTiKaraXXacro-o/jLevo*; avrwv rd awaat Bwd/xeva.|
f. 335a €K€?va i^ercoaav ol crdpKivoi TTTwyol Kal tovtojv Beofievoi,
av Be tov TTvev/jLariKov ttXovtov dvTiXa(3o)v e^ot? dv rjBr) cf.Mcx2illl
Orjaavpov ev ovpqvoh.
20. Tavra fir) avviels Kara rpoirov 6 TToXv^prj/jLaro*;
IS Kal €VVO/JLO<; dvdpOJTTOS, /jLTjBe OTTO)? 6 aVTO? Kal 7TT&)^09 cf. 1 Co vii
Bvvarai elvai Kal irXovaio^, Kal eyeiv re ^ptjfiara Kal fir)
eyeiv, Kal xpfjaOac toj k6o-/juw Kal fir) ^pqaOat, aTrrjXOe
arvyvb*; Kal KaTrjcprjs, Xlttojv rrjv rd^tv rrj<; £W/9, ?/<? eTTiQvjielv ef. He x 28
fiovov aXX' ov^l Kal Tvyelv r)BvvaTO, to BvaKoXov Troujaas
20 dBvvaTov avros eavroj' BvaKoXov yap r)v pur) TrepidyeaOai
pur/Be KaraaTpaTrreadat rrjv tyvxw v^ t&v irpoaovTcov dflpoov
toj TrpohrjX(p ttXovtg) Kal dvdrjpoov yorjTevpLaToov' ovk dBvva-
tov Be to Kal iv tovtco XafteaOai awTrjpla 1
;, el tls eavTov
diro tov alaOrjTOv ttXovtov iirl tov vorjTov Kal OeoBtBaKTov
25 fjueTaydyoL, Kal fidOot Tot? dBia<f)6pois y^p^o-Oai KaXcos Kal
IBlcos Kal oj? dv eh ^ojrjv alcovcov opfirjaa*;. Kal 01 fiaOijTal
Be to TrpcoTov pbev Kal avTol TTepiBeels Kal KaTaTrXrjyes
yeyovacnv aKovaavTes. ti BywoTe ; dpd ye otl ^p^jxaTa Kal
avTOi eK€KTrjvTo TToXXa ; dXXd Kal avTa TavTa Ta BiKTvBia
30 Kal dyKiGTpa Kal tcl vTTTjpeTiKa o-KacplBca d<bf)/cav TrdXai,
direp rjv avTols /xova. tl ovv (£o/3?;#eWe? Xeyovat' Tfc Bvva- M<' 1 M
Tau acodrjvai ; KaXws rJKOvaav Kal <w? fiadijTal tov irapa-
ftoXiKws Kal acra^w? Xey^OevTOS vtto tov Kvpiov Kal rjaOovTO
947 tov ftdOovs tojv Xoyojv. eveKa fiev ovv xprifxaTcov dxTijfio-
35 Gvvr\<$ eveXTTiBes i)aav 7rpc? acoTrjplav, eiTeiBij Be crvvyBeaav
25 adia<p6pois (Ghisler)] dia.(f>6pus xP^^aL - () op/xrjo-as (0. Stiililin)]
op/xaaai 29 SiKTv<t>ia '.Yd Kal acupQs
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 52/108
16 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
eavrots firfTTO) ra iraOrj TeXeov an07 tOepivots {dprifxaOeh yap
rjaav kcll v€co<ttI 77-/909 tov o-wrrjpos yvBpoXoyrj/jLevoi), irepia-
<r&»? €^67r\rjaaovro teal direyivwcrKov eavTovs ovBev tl tjttov
€K€lpov tov iroXv^pri/jbdrov /cal BeivGo? rrjs KTrjaews irepieyo-
fievov, 7]v ye irpoe/cpive £cor)s alwvLov. d^tov ovv tjv tol?5
paOrjrais <f>6(3ov iravros, el ical 6 ^pr/fiara|/ce/cTTjfievo'; /cal 6 f. 335'
twv iradaw eytcvo? d)p iirXovTovv, < fxrj> /cal avrol irapairXr)-
ctlcds aireXacrO^aovTai ovpavcov' diraOwv yap ical KaOap&v
\jrvxGov iarlv r] acorrjpla.
Mcx27 21. O Be fcvpios diroKplverat Blotl To ev dvOpoo- 10
7rot? dSvvarov, hvvarov 6eS. irdXiv /cal tovto fjueyaX^
crocpias fiearov iartv, on /cat)' avrov fxev daKcov /cal Bca-
7rovovfievos dirdQeiav dvOpanros ovBev dvvet, eav Be yevrjrat
BrjXos virepeiriQvpuwv rovrov KaX Bieo-7rovBa/co)<;, rfj irpoadrj/cr)
rrjs irapd deov Bwd/xecos irepiyiverai,' /3ouXop,evai<; fiev yap 15
rats -tyvyals 6 Oeds avveirtirvel, el he airoaralev 7-779 irpo-
uvfuas, teal to BoOev e/c deov irvevjia avveardXr)' to fiev yap
dfcovTas aw^etv £o~tI ffta^o/jLevov, to Be alpov/jLevovs yapi^o-
fievov. ovBe tcov /caOevBovTwv ical ffXa/cevovTcov early rj
cf. Mtx'112 ftaatXeia tov 6eov, «XV 01 ftiaaTal apira^ovo-iv avTrjv' 20
avTT) yap jiovov flla tcaXr), Oedv /3idcrao-0ai /cal irapd deov
^corjv dpirdaai, 6 Be yvovs 7-07)9 /Se/8awo?, jxaXXov Be ftiai&s
2 rjp8pofj,o\oyr]fj.hoi 7 < ixt]> addidit J. B. Mayor 8 sq. diraOQiv—awnipla] Parall. Vat. et Scor. 570 Paris f. 223a
: Ant. Mel. 149 (cum lemmate
evaypiov) om. yap Parall. Ant. 9 om. \pvxuv Ant. 15—17 PovKopiivais—ovvearak 77] Leontius Vat. Gr. 1553 f. 56: Coisl. f. 252a
: Parall. Vat. et Scor.
315 et 684 Paris f. 325a 15 om. yap Coisl. Vat. Scor. (utr. loc.) Paris
16 6 debs ante reus Leont. Coisl. Parall : cdd. omn. \f/vxcus] pr. ^werfycus
Leont. Coisl. Vat. Scor. 684 epvpei Coisl. airo<TT7)ei> Scor. 684
diroo-Teev Paris 17 deov] pr. tov Vat. Scor. 315 aweardXei Paris (et ex
rj factum) 17, 18 to fxev—xapifafiivov] Leontius Vat. Gr. 1553 f. 56 17 om.
yap Leont. 18 ecTlv Leont. 19 p. 16—2 p. 17 oide—rjTTw/uievos] Coisl.
f. 133b. Parall. Vat. et Scor. 383, 612 et 712 Eup. f. 126b
et f. 212b Paris f. 98b
et f. 363a 19 oide] ov Coisl. et Parall: cdd. omn (sed Eup. 212bovtco Kadetfv-
rtav) /cat] + tuv Eup. 126b Paris 98b j3\aKevofihwv Scor. 612 Eup. 126b 212b
om. {<ttIp Coisl. Vat. Scor. 383, 712 Paris 98b 20 dXX* ol] &W01. Paris 98b
21 fidvov] fxdvy Vat. Scor. 383 nov-q i] Coisl. Vat. Scor. 612, 712 Eup. 126b
212b Paris 98b 363a Ka\^] Ka\ei Paris 98bpiafadai Vat.
712 deov] 6e$ Scor. 383 22 piaiovs (pudus Scor. 712 Paris 363a)
fxaXXov 8e (om. 5^ Paris 363a)pepalus Vat. 612, 712 Scor. 712 Eup. 212b
Paris 363a
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 53/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 17
avreyopuevov^ avve^ooprjaev Kal el^ev' yaipei yap 6 deb? rd
roiavra r]rro)/Jievo<;. roiydproi rovrcov aKOvaa^ 6 fiaKaptos
Tlerpos, 6 etcXefCTos, 6 e^aiperos, 6 irpcoros rcov puad^rcov,
virep ov fxovov kal eavrov rov cfiopov 6 acorrjp eKreXel, raykw^; of. Mt xvii
5 rjpirao-e teal avveftaXe rov XoyoV Kal ri cfirjcriv ; 'ISe rjfxeh Mcx28
d(f)T]fca/u,€V irdvia Kal rjKoXovOrjaafxev croi. rd Be Tldvra el
fiev rd Krr]fiara rd. eavrov Xeyec, reaaapa^ 6/3o\ov<; lacos
<rb> rov Xoyov KaraXiircov pueyaXvverai, teal rovrcov dvraljlav
dirocfraivcov dv XdOoi rrjv fiaatXeiav rcov ovpavcov' el Be/direp
io d^pt vvv Xeyo/juev, rd iraXaia vorjrd Krrj/xara Kal yfrv^LKa
voar)fxara drroppi^ravre^ eirovrai Kar l%vo<; rov BiBacrKaXov,
rovr dv dirroiro rjBr) Tot9 ev ovpavol^ eyypacfrrjcrofievois. ff He xii
ovrco? yap dicoXovOeZv <evi> ovroos rco acorr)pi dvafiaprr)-
aiav Kal reXetorrjra rrjv eiceivov /aerep^b/uLevov, /cal irpb?
15 eKelvov coairep Karoirrpov Koapbovvra Kal pvO/ni^ovra rrjv
yjrv^rjv ical irdvra hid irdvrcov 6/jlolcos BianOevra.
948 22. 'AiroKptdeU Be 'lr)aov<; 'A/jltjv v/jliv Xeyco, 09 dv d(f>r) Mcx29
rd IBta Kal yovels ical dBeXcfiovs ical ^prjfiara eveicev €/jlov\
33Ga Kal eveicev rod evayyeXlov, diroXrjyjrerai eKarovrairXaai-
20 ova. dXXa /xrjBe rovO' rj/juas eircrapaao-erco, /irjBe rb en
rovrov aicXrjporepov dXXa^ov rats tycovals eijevrjvey/juevov'
,v
O? ov fuael irarepa Kal /jbrjrepa Kal iratBas, irpoaert Be Kal Lc xiv 98
rrjv eavrov yjrv^rjv, e'yito? /jbaOrjrr)^ elvai ov Bvvarai. ov yap
elurjyelrai ploos Kal BtdXvaLv dirb rcov cj)iXrdrcov 6 rr}<;
25 elpr]vr]^ Oebs, 6 ye Kal toi)? i^Opov^ dyairav irapaivcov. el ^ Jj*^ :;;,
:
Be rovs e^dpovs dyairrjreov, dvaXoyov air eKeivcov dviovrt
Kal toi)<? eyyvrdrco yevovs' r) el /Jbiarjreov rov? 77736? alfjuaro^,
iroXv /jbdXXov toi)? ej^dpoix; irpoftdXXecrdai Karicov 6 Xoyos
BiBdcTKei, war dXXrjXovs dvaupovvres eXey^ocvr dv 01 Xoyoi.
30 dXX' ovB' dvaipovaiv ovB> €771)?, dirb yap ri}^ ourf)? yvcopa)<i
Kal BcaOeaeco<; Kal eirl rco avroo bpoo irarepa fiiaoirj Tt? dv
e^dpbv dyairoov, b f^r)re ey^Opbv d/jLvvbfievos, ^)re irarepa
Xpio-rov irXeov alBov/juevos. ev eKeivoo fiev yap rco Xby<o
1 (Tvvexupwe Vat. Scor. 383 Hup. 126b 212'' ora. Kal S el^e Vat.
383, i'A'2 Rup. 126b 212b d£ev ex fj&u factum Coifll. >}:<; Boor, abique om.
6 Oeds Vat. Scor. 712 8 <to> addidit Segft&l 9 4»ep] ad mi
additiun a pr. man. 10 potjto.] forsitan legendum di^T/ra .1. B. Mayor
13 <fr/i> addidi 15 Koa/xQura 31 <?7ri rb atrb bpCfr J. 1*. Mayor
B. 2
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 54/108
18 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
jjuaos eKKoirrec zeal KCLKOirodav, ev rovrco Be rrjv irpb<; tci
avvrpocpa Bvacorrlav, el ftXairroi 777)09 acorrjpiav. el yovv
dOeos ecr) rtvl rrarrjp rj 1//09 rj dBeX<f)b<;, zeal zccoXvfxa rrjs
iriarecos yevotro zeal epuroBiov T179 civco %cofj<;, rovrco fir) ctv/jl-
efyepeaOco /jbrjBe ofjuovoeirco, dXXd rrjv aapzcizcrjv olzeewrrjra Bui 5
rr)v 7rvev/JLaTtfcr)v eyOpav BiaXvadrco.
23. No/jLutov elvai ro irpdypba BiaBizcaalav. 6 fjuev Trarrjp
aoi Bozeelrco nrapearcos XeyeiV 'Eyco ae eaireipa zeal eOpeyfra,
dzeoXovOei /jlol zeal avvaBizcet ical fir) nrelOov rco Xptarov vofico'
/cat oiroaa av eliroi j3Xda<pr)fios dvOpcoiros zeal vezepos rfj 10
cf.
iPeis epvaet. erepcoOev Be a/cove rod acorrjpo^' 'Eyco ere dveyevvrjaazeazecos virb zcoafiov 777)09 Odvarov yeyevvrj/ievov, r)XevOepcoaa,
laadfir)v, eXvrpcoadfirjv' eyco croc irape^co ^cor)v drravarov,
clJnx\v8Uctla)VLOV, vireptcoafxtov' eyco croc Bel^co Oeov rrarpcx; ayaOovMt xxiii9/ v/^. «/»<«« \\cf.Mtviii22
;irpoacorrov' fir) zcaXet aeavrco rrarepa em 7779' 01 vezepoi rov<$ 15
ve/epovs Oairrercoaav, av Be fioi dzeoXovOet,\
dvd^co yap ae f- 336b
1 Co ii 9 6t9 dvdrravaiv dpprjrcov zeal dXezcrcov dyaOcov, a firjre 6cf>0aX-
/Lt09 elBe,firjre
ovs tj/eovae, firjre errl /eapBiav dvOpcoircov dvifSr),
1 Pe i 12 et'9 d eiriOvfiovaiv dyyeXoi rrapazev^ai, zeal IBelv direp rjrol-
fiaaev 6 Beds rols dyiois dyadd zeal to?9 (piXovacv avrov 10
cf. Jn vi 50f Te/evoi,<;. eyco aov rpoefrevs dprov ifiavrov BlBovs, ov yevad-
fjuevos ovBels en irelpav Oavdrov Xafif3dvec, real irofia tea® r)-
fiepav evBcBovs dOavaalas' eyco BiBdazcaXos vrrepovpavicov
iraiBevfidrcov vrrep aov 777)09 rbv Odvarov Birfycoviadfirjv, zeal
rbv aov etjertaa Odvarov, ov coepeuXe^ errl Tot9 rTpot))iaprr)- 25
fievois Ka\ rrj 777)09 Oeov cmtarLa. rovrcov rcov Xoycov e/eare-
pcoOev Bia/covaas vrrep aeavrov Bi/caaov, zeal rr)v ifrrjcpov
dveveyzee rfj aavrov acorr)pia. zedv dBeXcfros oy^oia Xeyrj zcclv
rezevov zedv yvvrj zedv oanaovv, nrpo rrdvrcov ev aol Xpoaros 949
vizecov earco' vrrep aov yap aycovi^erai. 30
24. Avvaaai zeal rcov xprj/jbdrcov eiriirpoaOev elvai ; eppd-
aov, zeal ovzc arrdyei ae Xpiaros rr}<; zcrrjaecos, 6 zevpeos ov
(frOovel. dXX* opa9 aeavrov r)rrco/jLevov vrr avrcov zeal dva-
cf. Mt v 29 rperroixevov ; depes, ptyov, filarjaov, dirora^ai, cf>vye' zedv
8e^to9 aov depOaX/jLOs azcavBaXi^r] ae, ra^eco<; ezczeotyov avrov' 35
8 &r7ra/)a] ad marg. additum a pr. manu 10 birbaa (H. Jackson)] on
8o~a 17 avdwavaiv] Segaar dirbXavaiv coniecit 31 etvai ;] ehar
31, 32 eppdaov] forsitan legendum <pddoov (i.e. (pddaas Troirjaov) J. B. Mayor
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 55/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 19
alpercorepou erepocpdaXpLcp ftao-iXela Oeov rj bXoKXrjpcp to irvp'
K(iv XetP Kav >7T0V^ K&v V tyvXV* p*Lo~r)aov avrrjv av yap cf. Lc xiv 26
evravOa airoK/qrai virep Xpcarov <itc€L ao)Or]aeTat>. of. Mcviii35
25. TavTrjs Be bpoloas e^erat rrjs yvoSpirjs Kal to eiro-
5 pevov' NO*/ Be ev tc3 Kaipcp tovtm dypovs Kal ^prjpLara kcli Mc x 30
olfcias teal dBeXcfrovs eyeiv/JL€T^ Btcoypcov "fel? nov\. ovre
yap d^pypbdrovs ovre dvearLovs ovre dvaBeXcfrovs errl rrjv
%(or)v KaXel' eirel ical TrXovaiovs KeKXrjKev, aXX' bv rpbirov
irpoeiprjKapev, teal dBeXcfrovs /car avrbv, wcrrrep Uerpov
lo puerd 'AvBpeov real 'ldfcctiftov perd ^Jcodvvov, tovs ZefteBalov
337airalBas, d\\
y
bpuovoovvras|
dXXi]Xoi<; re real XpiaT(p' to Be
puerd Bicoypwv ravra e/caara eyeiv diroBoKip^d^ei. BiwypLO?
Be, b puev tl<; etjcoOev ireptyU'erai, tgov dvOpwirwv i) Bl eyOpav
7) hid <j>0bvov rj Sid (piXoKepBecav rj tear evepyeiav BiaftoXiKr)v
15 tovs Tnarovf; eXavvbvrcov' 6 Be ^aXeTrcoraros evBoOev ecrn
Bicoypbs e£ avrrjs i/cdo~T(p rrjs tyv^s itpoirepurbpuevos Xvpuai-
vopbivr)^ vtto iiriOvpuioov dOecov /cal rjBovwv ttolkIXcdv teal
(pavXcov iXTriScov teal cfyOaprwv bveipoTroXrfpLdrcov, orav, del
T(£tv irXeibvcov opeyopuevr) Kal Xvaawaa virb dyplcov epcorcov
20 Kal (pXeyopuevr), KaOdirep Kevrpois rj pLiKtiyfri, tols irpoKetpbevoLS
avrfj irdSeaiv e^aip,dao-r]Tai, irpbs airovBd^ p,aviooBet<; Kal
%o)r)s diroyvwGiv Kal Oeov Kara(f>pbv7]o-tv. ovtos 6 BtcoypLOs
fiapvrepos Kal ^aXeircotepos, evBoOev oppLcopuevos, del o-vvcov,
ov ovBe €K(f>vyeiv 6 BuoKOpLevos Bvvarai' rbv ydp e^Opbv ev
25 eavrS vepidyec iravrayov. ovtco Kal irvpwer ts , r) p,ev e^coOev
Trpoo-TTLTTTOvaa SoKipiaalav Karepyd^erac, 7] Be evBoOev ddva- cf. ICoiiilS
top Biairpdaaerau' Kal wbXepLos, b puev eiraKrbs pqBiws
KaraXverat, 6 Be ev rf) ^vxv ^XP L @avdrov TrapapLerpelrai.
pera Btcoyp,ov tolovtov ttXovtov edv €^9 tov aladr/rbv, Kav
30 dBeX(f)ov<; rovs Trpbs a'tpLaros Kal rd dXXa eveyypa, KardXnre
rrjv tovtoov irayKTrjalav rr)v eirl KaKQ), elpi')V7]v aeavrco irapd-
a-^69, eXev8epda6t)TL Bicoypov piaKpov, d7roaTpd(f)7]6i 7T/309 rb
evayyeXiov dn eKeivwv, eXov rbv acoTrjpa irpb iravrayv, top
Tt}<; arJ9 o~vvi)yopov Kal irapaKX^rov ^f%^9, rbv T/J9 direipov
3 <iKei au)dr)(r(:Ta.i> addidit Segaar (5 cf. § 4 7 dva5A0ot's] forsitan
l*6vovs addendum est, J. B. Mayor 14 (f>i\oKepSlcu> 16, 17 \oiiJ.aii>oiJ.^vi]s
20 fiolu)\f/i 27 dtaTapdo-aeTai ((rltisler 8iairpa.TT€Tai) 29 tolovtov (Gliish'i)]
TOIOVTOV
2—2
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 56/108
20 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
2Coivis irpvravLv £0)^79. ra yap ^Xeirbpieva Trpocricaipa, rd Be fxrj
(SXenro/JLeva aloovta' /ecu ev /jlcv tw irapovTi XP°VfP oiKVfjiopa 950
Mcx.30 teal afteftaia, ev Be rw ep^o/ieva ^corj eo~Tiv alwvLOs.
McxSi 26. "Kaovrai, 01 irpwroi ea^aroi Kal ol ea^aroi irpcvroi.
tovto iToiXv^ovv fiev €<ttl\Kara Tip vttovoiclv Kal tov aa<f)r)- f. 337 1'
VMT/JLOV, OV fJLl)v €V J6 Tft) TTapOVTL TTJV ^tJTTjaLV diraLTel' OV
yap /jlovov penrei irpb<i tovs 7ro\v/CTr)/JLovas, a\\' dirX&s 777)09
('nravTas dvOpcoTrovs Toil's ir'tarei Kaddira^ eavrovs cttlBl-
Sovras. ware tovto fiev avaiceicrOw tcl vvv' to Be ye irpo-
Kei/xevov rjfuv olfxai /uLrjBev ti dBeeaTepov 7-779 eirayyeXias to
BeBetyOaL, oti tovs irXovtriov? ovBeva Tpbirov 6 aa)Tr}p ko.t av-
tov ye tov itXovtov teal ttjv 7repL/3oXr)v tt)? KTrjaew cltto-
KeicXeiKev, ov& avTol? diroTeTa^pevicev tt\v o~coT7)pLav, elye
BvvaLVTO Kal /3ovXolvto viroKviTTeiv tov deov Tat? evToXais,
Kal twv irpoo-Kaipcdv TrpoTi/JLcpev ttjv eavT&v ^(orjv, Kal (3Xe- 15
Troiev 7rpo<? tov Kvpiov ciTevel t£ (3\efi/jLciTi, /caOdwep et9
dyaOov KvfiepvrjTOV vev/xa BeBopKOTes, tl /3ov\eTCiL, rl irpoa-
Tao-o-et, tl o-rjfialvei, tl BlBcoo-l tol<; clvtov vclvtclis to avv-
Orj/jLCL, itov Kal iroOev tov op/nov eirayyeXXeTai. tl yap
d$L/ce2 Tt?, el TrpoaeyuiV ttjv yvoo/uLrjv Kal (p>eL$6/A€vo<; irpb 7-979 20
7r/<7Te&)? /3lov iKavbv avveXe^aTO ; rj Kal <to> tovtov paXXov
dveyKkrjTOv, el ev6ii<$ V7ro tov 6eov tov ttjv yjrv^rjv vejiovTOS
€t9 oIkov tolovtwv dv6p(07rcov elawKLaOr) Kal yevos d/jL(f)L-
A,a<7J>e9, Tot? Xpr/fiacrLV lor^vov Kal tw irXovTCp KpaTovv ; el
yap Bid ttjv aKovcnov ev ttXovtw yeveaiv direXr/XaTai ^corj<i, 25
dcjLfceLTaL fiaXXov virb tov yeLva/jLevov 6eov, irpoaKaipov fiev
r)$v7ra6eLa<; KaTrj^Loo/jLevos, dlhlov Be fft)?}? direaTep^ixevo^.
tl 8' #\&)9 ttXovtov eyjpr\v e.K 7^9 avaretXai iroTe, el xoPVyo<:*
Kal Trpoljevos eo~Ti OavaTov ; a\X' el BvvaTal tls evBoTepco
to)v virap'XpvTtov KafjuirTeLV tt)9 e^ovo-Las Kal fieTpLa cf>povelv 30
Kal acoeppovetv Kal 6ebv jjlovov %t)T€lv Kal 6ebv avairvelv Kal
6e£> avfjLTroXLTeveadai, tttw)(P^ ovtos 7rapeaT7]Ke Tals evTO-
X.at9, ekevOepos, dr)TT7)TO<;, dvoo~os, aT/oa)T09 vtto xP71lJb<̂ Ta)v
'
Mcx25 el Be fir), Oclttov Kafirfko? Blcl j3e\6vr)<; elcreXevaeTaL 17 o
tolovtos tt\ovctlo<;\
iiri T7)V ^acTLXelav tov deov irapeXevcreTaL. f. 338
3 fa-qv (cf. § 4) 21 < to > addidit Ghisler 26 yeiua/j.£vov (Ghisler)]
yivojxevov 30 tt)s ifrvaLas] forsitan glossema ad twv virapx&Twv , J. B. Mayor
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 57/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 21
arj/jLcuveTO) fxev ovv ti Kal v^rrjXorepov rj KdfATJXos Bid arev7]<; ef. Mt vii u
6Bov Kal TedXififjuevr)? (f>6dvovo~a rov ttXovgiov, oirep iv rfj
irepi dpywv Kal OeoXoyias e^rjyrjaet fjbvarijpiov rod crwrrjpos
virdpyei puadelv. (27.) ov p,rjv aXXa to ye (patvo/jievov
5 TTpwrov Kal 8£ b XeXeKrai r?}? Trapa(So\rj<$ irapeyeaOw.
8i8a<TK€TQ) tovs eviropovvTas ft)? ovk dp,eXr}Teov rrj<; eavrcov
<T(i)T7)pLa<> ft>? rj8r} 7rpoKareyvcoafievov<;, ovBe Karairovriareov
951 av irdXiv rov irXovrov ovBe KaraBiKaareov ft)? rfj<; fftn/? farir
fiovXov Kal iroXepLiov, dXXd /xaOrfreov riva rpoirov Kal 7r&)?
io ttXovto) %pr)crT€ov Kal tt)v forjv KTT)Teoi>. eTretBr) yap ovre
€K iravrbs diroXXvrai Tt?, on irXovrel BeBtcos, ovre €k Travrbs
aa)%erai dappcov Kal TTtarevcov ft>? acodTjaerac, <pepe GKeirieov
r/VTLva tt)V iXirlBa avrot<; 6 crcorrfp viroypafyet, Kal 7r&3? av to
/juev dveXTTiGTOv e^eyyvov yevotro, to Be iXiriaOev et? KTrjacv
15 d(j>LK0CT0.
27. <£>r)alv ovv 6 BtBdcrKaXos, Tt? r\ /jbeylarr) tgov evro-
Xoov r)pcoT7]ixevo^''
Kyairrjaet^ Kvpiov rov deov aou ef 0X.179 Moziiao
rrj<; ^v^r}? crov Kal e'f oXrj? rfj<; Bvvdfiecos crov' ravTrjs
fiei^oi fjLTjSe/jLiav evroXrjv elvai, Kal fidXa etKorco^' Kal yap
20 Kal irepl rov irpcorov Kal irepl rov /jbeylo-rov 7rapr]yyeXrai,
avTov rov deov irarpos t^/jlcov, 81 ov Kal yeyove Kal eari of. Ro xi 96
Ta irdvra, Kal ei? bv rd aqy^o/jueva irdXiv eiravep^erai. virb
tovtov Toivvv irpoayair^Oevra^ Kal rov yevecrOai rv^ovra^
ov% octlov aXXo tl irpeafBvrepov dyeiv Kal rcfiiajrepov, €K-
25 Tivovras \xbvr\v rrjv \dpiv ravrrjv \xiKpdv eirl ixeyiaroi^, aXXo
he /jltjSotlovv e^ozrra? a^e^Seet Kal reXei'a) Oeco irpbs dfioififfv
ewLvorjaat, avro Be to dyairav rov irarepa et? oiKelav la^vr
Kal Bvva/ubLV dcpOapaias ko/jli^o/jL6vov^' oo~ov yap dyaira rt?
debv, roo~ovT(p Kal TrXeov ivSorepco rov Oeov irapaBverai.
i,o 28. Aevrepav Be rdtjec Kal ovSev ti fiiKporepav ravrrjv
elvai Xeyei to' 'A7airrjcrew rov irXyalov aov cJ? treavrov * Lex 87, 88
ovkovv rov Oebv virep aeavrov. irvvdavofxevov Be rov irpoa-
f. 338b Bta\Xeyofjuevov Tt? eariv nrX^aiov ; ov rov avrov Tpoirov
'lovBaioi? Trpocoplaaro rov 7T/90? aiyLtaTO? ovBe rov iroXlri)v
35 ovBe tov 7rpoo-y]Xvrov ovBe rov oyLto/aj? irepiTCTflffflivop ovBt
2 <t>9<xvov<Tav 2, .'* ry irepl apxwv mi] Of. Zahn, FoTBCkungen iii. -^
5 816 8 oi>5£ (J. 13. Mayor)] otire l\) fxelfav 84 dXX' 5n 84, MS
iKTdvovres
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 58/108
22 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
cf. Lc x 30 ff tov evl /cal TavTco vo/jlco ^pcopuevov aXXd dvcodev /cara-
/3alvcov dirb ^lepovaaXrjfx dyec tco Xoyco Tivd elsy
]epi%co, /ecu
TOVTOV BetKVVCTlV VTTO XtJCTTCOV avyK€KeVT7]/Jb€V0V}
eppi/JLfieVOV
r)fjLi6vr)Ta iirl Trjs 6Bov, vtto iepecos TrapoBevo/xevov, vtto
AeviTov Trapopco/xevov, vtto Be tov Xa/xapeLTov tov e^covec- 5
Bia/xevov /cal d(f>copiafxevov /caTeXeovjxevov, 09 ot>%l kcltcl Tvyjqv
ft>9 e/celvoL TraprfXdov, aXX! 77/ce avvea/cevaa/xevo<; cov 6 klv-
Bvvevcov eBeoTO, olvov, eXaiov, iiriBecr/xovs, /cttjvos, /xiaObv
tco iravBo^el, tov /xev rjBrj BcBo/xevov, tov Be Trpoavirio-'xyov-
fxevov. TV?,€<f>7),
tovtcov yeyove TrXrjcriov tco to, Beivd ira- 10
66vtl; tov Be diroKpivapbevov oti O tov eXeov Trpos avTov€7TiBei^d/jLevo<;' Kal o~v tolvvv TropevOels ovtco Tcoiei' cos 7-775
dyd7rr)<; {3XacrTavovcr?]s eviroiiav.
29. 'Ez; d/xcpoTepats /xev ovv Tat? evToXals dydiryv elarj-
yetTac, Tagei S' avTrjv Biyprj/ce, /cal oirov /xev Ta irpcoTela 7-775 15
dydirris dvdirTet tw Oeco, oirov Be Ta BevTepela vejxet tw
irXrjaiov. Tt? £' dv aXXo<; ovtos ecrj irXrjv avTo<; 6 acoTrjp; rj
cf.
Ephvi
12 Tt? fxdXXov tf/xcis eXerjcras e/ceivov, tov<; vtto tcov /coa/xo/cpa- 952Topcov tov ctkotovs bXiyov TeOavaTCQ/jbevow; tois ttoXXols
Tpav/xaai, (j>6/3oi<;, eiri6v/xiac<;, opyais, Xvirais, diraTais, r/Bo- 20
vais ; tovtcov Be tcov Tpav/xaTcov fxovos laTpos ^Itjctov^, e/c-
kotttcov dpBrjv Ta irdOrj irpoppi^a, ov% cocrirep 6 vo/jlos yjrcXd
Ta diroTeXecr/xaTa, tov<; /capirovs tcov irovrjpcov cpvTcov, dXXd
cf. Mtiiiio; ttjv d^lv7]v Trjv eavTov irpbs Ta? pi^as T775 ica/cias irpocra-
cf. Didache yaycov.ovtos <6>
tov olvov, to al/xa Trjs dpLTreXov 7-775
25
AafflB, etcxeas rjpicov iirl tcis TeTpcofievas ^u^a?, tov eic
o-irXdy)(vcov iraTpbs eXeov irpocreveyiccov\tca\ eTziBa'^fCXevop.e- f. 339
:<
z/05' ouTO? tovs ttJ? vyelas /cal o-coTrjpta^ BecrfAovs aXvTov<;
cf. Heii4; eVtSet^a?, dyd7r7iv. tticttiv, eXirlBa' ovto<$ 6 Btaicovelv dyye-
Eph iii 101 \ t / \
'
Xovs /cal dp^as /cat e^ovaias rjp2v eiriTa^as eiri fieyaXco 30
cf. Ro viii puadco, Blotl Kal avTol eXevOepcoOrjaovTai airo ti)<; fiaTaio-
tt/to? tov Koapuov irapd Trjv aTro/caXvyjnv t^5 B6%r)<; tcov
v'tcov tov 6eov. tovtov ovv dyairav Icra ^prj tco deep' ayawa
Be XpicrTov 'Itjctovv 6 to OeXr/pia avTov ttoicov /cat cfivXdcr-
Mtvii2i acov avTov ra? ivToXd<;. Ov yap 7ra? 6 Xeycov /jlol Kvpie 35
1, 2 forsitan legendum Kara^aivovTa. 7 cSv 22 irpbpi^a 25 <6>
addidit Ghisler
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 59/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 23
icvpie elaeXevaeTaL et? rrjv ftaaikeiav tcov ovpavcov, dXX' 6
ttolcov to 6eXr)p,a tov irarpo^ pbov' fcai' TV pue Xiyere Kvpie Lc vi 46
KVpie, teal ov iroielre a Xeyco; kcli'r
Tp,e2<; paKapiot o/jjj1*™*
opcovTes kcli a/covovres a pbrjre hiKCLioi p,rjre 7rpocf>TJTaL, edv cf. Jn xiii 17
5 wocyre a Xeyco.
30. UpcoTos fiev ovv ovtos eariv 6 Xptardv dyaircov,
Sevrepos Be 6 rovs e/celvco ireiriarevKora^ rtfiwu Kal irepie-
ircov. o yap civ tls els puadrjTrjv epydar/Tai, rovro et? eavrbv
o icvpios etcSexerai Kal irdv eavrov iroielrat. Aevre, ol evXo- Mt xxv 34 ff
io yr/pevoL tov irarpo^ fiov, KXrjpovoprjaaTe rrjv r/TOLfiacrfievrjv
vplv /3aaiXeiav airo KaTa(3oXr)<; Koapuov' eireivaaa yap Kal
eScoKare /jlol cfrayeiv, Kal eSlyjrrjaa Kal eScoKare poL irLelvy
Kal %evos rjp,rjv Kal avvrjydyere pue, yvpuvos fjpLrjv Kal eveov-
aare pue, r}adevrjaa Kal eireaKes^aaOe p,e, ev cpvXaKrj rjpurjv
15 Kal rjXdere wpos pie. rore diroKpiOrjaovTaL avrco ol BtKaLOL
Xeyovres' Kvpte, irore ae elhopuev TreivcovTa Kal eOpe^apLev,
f) OL^covTa Kal eiroriaapiev ; ttotc he ecSopiev ae £evov Kal
avvrjydyopiev, r) yvpuvov Kal 7repLej3dXop,ev ; rj irore ae ecSopuev
daOevovvra Kal eireaKetydpLeOa, rj ev cpvXaKrj Kal rjXdopuev
20 7T/50? ae; diroKpiOels 6 ftaaLXevs epel avrols' ^Apurjv Xeyco
vplv, ecf) oaov eTTOLijaare evl tovtcov tcov aSeXcpcov p,ov tcov
eXa^larcov, epLol eiroLijaare. irdXiv eK tcvv evavrlcov tov$ cf. Mt xxv
L 339b ravra p,r) irapaayovTas avrols|eh to irvp ep$d\Xei to alco-
vlov, cos avTco pLr) irapea^rjKOTa^. Kal dXXa^ov' O vpLas Mt x 10
25 he^bpievos ipue Se^eTat, 6 lipids pur} Se^opuevos ep,e dOeTel. cf. Lc 1 Lfl
31. Tovtovs Kal TeKva Kal iraihla Kal vi)iTLa Kal cpi-
Xov<> ovopud^eL Kal puKpovs evOdhe a$? irpb? to peXXov dvco
953 pueyedos avTcov, M// KaTacppovy'jarjTe, Xeycov, ev6$ tcov pLiKpcov Htxviiiio
tovtcov' tovtcov yap ol dyyeXou Sid iravTos (SXeirovaL to
30 TrpoacoTTOv tov iraTpos puov tov ev ovpavols. /cal eTepcoOb' Xh) LcxiiSS
cpoffelaOe, to pLLKpbv Troipbviov' vplv yap rjvBoKyaev 6 TraTi)p
irapahovvai T))V /SaaiXelav tcov ovpavcov' KaTci Ta avTa Kal
tov pueylaTov ev yevvr)Tol<$ yvvatKcbv Icoavvov tov eXa^iaTov cf.Ml \ LI;
ev Trj fiaaiXela tcov ovpavcov, TOVTeaTL tov eavTov pLaOi]T))i>,
35 elvaL pei^co Xeyet' Kal irdXiv' O Se^o/xeros" SUaiov t) irpo- Mt \ n r
<j)y')TT]V et? ovopba SiKaiov 1; 7rpocf>>JTov tov eKeivcov pLLaObv
G ovv supra Lin. acMitum a pr. nruiu '11 tWaxtcrruv X> iWdxurTov
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 60/108
24 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
Xijyjrerai, 6 Be fjuaOrjTrjv Troricras et? ovofia fiaOrjTov iroTrfpiov
\jrv^pov vSaros tov fiiaObv ovk diroXecreL. ovkovv ovtos fiovos
Lcxvi9 o /jligOos ovk diroXXvfievos iari. Kal avOts' TLoir/aaTe eav-
tol<; (fiuXovs i/c tov fia/uucovd Tr}s dBiKias, iva, orav eKXiirrfTe,
Be^wvTai vfjbas et? rdq alwviovs aKrfvds' cpvaei fxev diraaav 5
KTYjatv, r)v clvtos Tt? e<f> eavTOv Ke/crrjrai w? IBiav ovaav
teal ovk els kolvov tols Beofxevois KararWrjcrLv, dBiKOV ovcrav
dirofyaivayv' ire Be ravrrj^ rrjs dBiKias evbv Kal irpdyfia Bi-
kcliov epydcracrdai Kal acoTtjpiov, dvairavaai ruva tcov eyov-
tcov alcovcov (TKrjvrjv irapa toj nrarpL 10
32. (31.) 'Opa irpwrov fjuev w? ovk diraiTelo-Qai aeKeKeXevKev ovBe evo'^XelaOai irepifxeveiv, dXXa avTov ^rjTecv
tovs ev ireio-ofievovs d%iov<; re ovras tov acoTr}po<; /jLadrjrds.
2Coix7 KaXbs fiev ovv Kal 6 tov diroaToXov Xoyos' 'lXapbv yap
cf. 2Coix6 Bottjv dyaira 6 debs, yaipovTa tg3 BiBovac Kal fir) (jieiBbfievov 15
(w? cnreipovTa, Iva fjurj o'vtcd? Kal depiar), Bfya yoyyvafxwv
Kal BiaKplcrecos ko\ Xvirr/s ical KocvcovovvTa, oirep eo~Tiv
evepye\o~la fcadapd. KpeiTT(ov B' earl tovtov 6 tov KVpiovf.
310
a
Levi 30 XeXey\xevo<$ ev aXX<p ywp'ujs' TlavTi toj alrovvri ae BlBov.
6eov yap ovtcos r) TOiavrr] <piXoB(opi,a' ovToal Be 6 X070? 20
virep airaadv iari Oeorrjra^rjBe alrelaOai iTepLfieveiv,dXX! av-
rbv dva^rjrelv oaris d%io<; ev waQelv, (32.) eireira ttjXi-
kovtov [MLcrdbv bpiaai rr)<; Koivajvias, alobviov o-fcrjvrjv. <w
KaXr}<; ifjLTropLas' w Oeias dyopas' oovelrat, ^prffiaTcov T£<?
d(f)dap(TLav,Kal Bovs rd BioXXv[xeva tov koo-/jlov p,ovr)v tov-
25
tcov aloovLov ev ovpavols dvTiXaixftdvei. •nXevo'ov eirl TavTrjv,
cf. Mtxxiii av o-(D(ppovfj<;, tt)v TravrjyvpLP, w irXovcne' kclv Bey, irepieXOe
yr)v oXrjv, fir) tye'iay klvBvvchv Kal ttovwv, iv ivTavOa /3ao~L-
Xelav ovpdviov dyopderr)^. ti ae Xidoi Bta(f>avei<; Kal o-fid-
payBot togovtov evfypaivovai Kal otKela Tpocf^r) irvpbs rj 30
Xpovov iraiyviov rj aeiafiov irdpepyov rj v$pio-p,a Tvpdvvov
eirtOvfjirjo-ov ev ovpavois oiKr)o~ai Kal fiao-iXevcrai /jueTa Oeov'
TavTrjv aoc Tr)v (3aatXeiav dvOpomros Bcoaec Oebv airofit\xovfie-
ld ev] ov, sed ad marg. a manu xv ut uid. saeculi tVws ev 15, 16 0«5.
cbs] legendum forsitan cum Segaar 0a5o,ueVws 18 Kadapa (Segaar)] Kadd
20 0tAo5wped (correxit Segaar) 21, 22 avrbu (J .B. Mayor)] avrbs 28 yrjv
(Combefisius)] tt)v 30 rpocpbs J. B. Mayor (uide adnot.)
15
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 61/108
QULS DIVES SALVETUR. 25
z>09* evravOa /ju/cpa \a{3oov, i/cei 8Y oXcov alwvcov avvoiKov
954 ae TrocrjaeTat. i/cerevaov Xva Xd/3rf' airevaov, dywvlaaov,
(j>of3r)dr)Ti, /jltJ ae drL/jbdarj' ov yap K€Ke\evaTat Xaftelv, aWdav irapaayelv. ov firjv ov& elirev o Kvpios A09, rj Tlapda^e^,
5 rj Fjvepyirrjo-ov, rj RorjOrjaov <£>l\ov he irolrjaac' 6 he g/h'A,09 cf. Lc xvi y
ovk etc fjbtd<; hoaeax; yiverau, dW' ei; o\?79 dvairavaecos Kal
awovala<; fiaKpa^' ovhe yap r) ttigtls, ovhe r) aydirt), ovhe r]
tcaprepia /Atas r)fxepa^, aX\' O viropbelva<; eh Te\o9, ovtos Mi z 2S
acoOrjaeTat.
to 33. IIw? ovv 6 dvdpcoTros ravra hihwatv ; otl hud rrjv
e/ceivov tl/jltjv kcu evvoiav ko\ oIk61(D(TLV 6 Kvpio? hlhcoac'
hcoaco yap ov /Jbovov rols (J)l\oi<;, aWd teal tols (f>i\oi<; rwv
(f>l\o)v' teal Tt9 outo9 eartv, elirois dv, 6 cfriXos rov Oeov ; av
fjuev /jut) Kplve tls a£t09 Kal tis dvdgtos' eV8e^eTcu yap ae hta-
15 fxaprelv Trepl rrjv hofjav &>? ev dfjL(f>i/36Xo) he 7-779 dyvoias
f. 340'' dfieivov fcal tou9|
dvatjiovs ev irotelv Sid 7-01)9 aglow; rj
<fiv\aaa6/j,evov tovs rjaaov dyadovs /nrjhe Tot9 a7rovhaioi<;
irepareaelv i/c fiev yap rod <pelhea6at /cal TrpoairoielaQai
hoKifjud^eiv 7-01)9 evXoycds rj fir) revgo/juevovs evBe^eral ae Kal
20 0eo(f>i\ooi> dfieXrjaal tcvcov, ov to eTrtri/JLiov Ko\aat<; efiirvpos
aiwvios' e/c he rod irpoteadai irdaiv egrjs rot9 xprj^ovaiv
dvdy/cr) 7rdvTco<; evpelv Tivd koI tgov awaat, irapd Oeu> hvva-
/jLevcov. Mr) Kplve tolvvv, iva /jur) tcpiOrjs' co fMerpa) /Lt€T/>€t9, Mt vii 1 f
tovto /cal avTCfMeTprjOrjaerat aot' fierpov koXov ireTTiea^evov Lc vi 38
25 Kal aeo-aXev/jbevov, vizepeKyyvop,evov, dirohoOrjaeTai aot. ird-
aiv dvoitjov rd airXdy^ya TOt9 rov Oeov fiaOrfrals diroye-
ypa/A/juevoLS, p,r) irpos acS/xa dirihwv virepoirrw^, p,y) 777309
r)\iiciav «yLteXw9 StareOels, /jlijo' el ns dtcrrj/JLCdv 1) ovaeifKov
rj 8vaei8rj<; r) daOevrjs tyaiverai, 777909 tovto tt} ^t%ty Sva-
30 %€pdvr)<; Kal diroaTpacfyfji;. ayf)p,a tovt eaTiv egcoOev ijfilv
4 av (sc. KCKeXevaai) (J. B. Mayor)] <rt 7 ov5t...oi>te...ovU (Potter)]
ov8L..ovt€...o{}t€ 13—23 kuI tIs—Svvanivw] Parall. Rup. L69- 13 0111.
rj
eiiroLs hv S ora. 6 Hup. 11 Kal] Kal S avd^os] ovk ct^tos Hup. tv8^x €Tai]
+ [lev Hup. diafxaprdveiv Hup. 10 tois avai;Lois Hup. 17 <pv\ao~o~oiiUi'ovs B
eiv
18 ev fxkv yap t<^ Hup. 1(
.) 8oKifxafc<j0ai S ev\6yovs Hup. 20 rivtov]
tl/xCjv S, Tiuibu Hup. 21 wpoiecrOaL Hup. wpoaleaOai 8 22, 23 bwa/xtv^v
trapb. t2 (hep Rup. 24 roOro] foraifeao Legendum rotiry cum Vat, dv. 62S
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 62/108
26 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
7repi/3ej3Xr)p,evov rr)<; els fco&fjLov irapoBov 7rp6cf)acri<?, iv eh to
cf. Jn xiv 23 koivov tovto 7ratBevT7]pcov elaeXOelv BwrjOcbpuev' aXX' evBov
o /cpV7TTo<; evoiKel 7rarrjp Kal 6 tovtov irai? 6 virep rjpuwv cltto-
Oavtov Kal pbeO* rjpiwv clvclcttcls.
34. Tovto to a^rjp,a ftXeiropuevov e^airaTa tov Oclvcltov 5
teal tov BcdftoXov' 6 yap evTos 7tXovtos Kal to tcd\\o<; clvtoIs
aueaTos io~TL' Kal puaivovTai irepl to o~apKiov> ov KaTa(f>po-
vovcriv co? dadevovs, twv evBov ovTes TV(j>Xol KTrj/xaTow, ovk i-
cf. 2 Co iv 7 TTLCTTa/jievot, irrjXiKOV tlvcl drjcravpbv ev 6o~TpaKLv<p aKevei
j3ao-Td£ofi€v, Bvvdp,ec Oeov iraTphs Kal a'tpuaTi Oeov iraihos 10
Kal opoaa)TTvevfiaTOS dyiov TrepiTeTei^iapievov. dXXd crv ye
/nrj €%airaTr)6f)<$ 6 yeyevpuevo? dXrjOelas Kal KaT7)%L(op,evo<;
T179 pueydXrjs XvTpouo~ea)<? dXXd to evavTiov to?9 aXXou? dv-
OpcoiroLS o~eavT& KaTaXe^ov GTpaTov aoirXov, diroXepuov,
dvaifjuaKTOv, dopyrjTov, dfxiavTOv, yepovTas Oeoaeftels, opefra- 955
vov<; OeocfccXeis, Xtjpas irpaoTr^TL|
0)7rXiapbeva<;, dvBpas dyd-rrr) f. 341a
K€Koo-/jL7)/j,evov<;. toiovtovs KTrjaai, tc5 crep ttXovtw Kal tw
acofiaTt Kal ttj "^rv^rj
Bopv(f)6povs,<*>v crTpaTrjyet 6 #609, Bi 01)9
Kal vavs fiaTTTi^ofievr] Kovcpi^eTat p,6vai<; dylcov ev^a-ls
KvftepvwfJLevri, Kal voo-os aKpud^ovaa Bapbd'^eTat ^ecpcov iirt- 20
ftoXals SicoKOfxevrj, kol TrpoaftoXr) XrjaTo3v dcfioirXi^eTai eu^ois
evae^eaL aKvXevopevrj}Kal Baipuovcov fila OpaveTat irpoaTa-
yfiaac o-vvtovoi^ eXeyyop,evr\.
35. 'Ez/ epyois ovtol nrdvTes 01 o-TpaTtcoTai Kal <j>v-
XaK€<; fiefiatoi,, ovBeU dpybs, ovBeU d%peio<;. 6 puev ifjai- 25
TrjaaaOai ere BvvaTai irapd Oeov, 6 he irapapuvOrfaaaOai
xapuvovTa, 6 Be BaKpvcrai Kal crTevd^ac crvpuraO00^ virep crov
TTpOS TOV KVpiOV TWV oX(OV, 6 Be SlBd^ai TV T(t)V 7T/0O9 TT)V
crwTTjpiav ^prjai/jLoyv, cr Se vovOeTrjcrau pueTa irapprjo-ias, 6 he
avp,j3ovXevo-aL pueT evvola<;, irdvTes Be <f>cXelv dXrjdcos, dB6- 30
\&>9, ac/)o/3o)9, dvvTTOKpLTcos, aKoXaKevTa)<;, dirXdorTws. w yXv-
Kelat Oepaivelai (fycXovvTcov, co puaKapioi BiaKovLai OappovvTwv,
(6 itIcttls elXtKpcvr)<; Oeov puovov BeBtoTcov, co Xoycov dXr)6eia
7 ov 13—18 to ivavrlou—deos] Parall. Vat. et Scor. 480 Rup. f. 169a
Paris f. 179a 13 to] tov S 14 eavT<p Rup. Paris KaToKtj^ov
Paris 16 0eo<pei\rjs Paris xetpas Scor. dirXia/xevas Scor. 17, 18 Kal
rrj \pvxv Kal t£ awfiaTi Rup. ry o-&[j.<xtl\ to a<J)/xa.Ti Paris 18 6 0e6s] ora. 6 S
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 63/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 27
irapd tol? yfrtvcracrOai, fMr) Swafievoc?, w KaXXo? epycov irapd
toZ? dew BtaKovetv ireireiar/nevoL?, ireiOeiv debv, dpecnceiv Oeoj'
ov (rap/cos ttj? o~fj? dirreadai BoKovatv, dXXd Trj? eavrov
^yXV? ^fcaaTO?, ovk dBeXcpw XaXelv, dXXd tw ftacnXel twv cf. 1 Tim
5 alwvcov ev crol /caroi/covvTL.
36. Havre? ovv oi ttmttol KaXol Kal Oeoirpeirel? teal
tt)? irpoar^yopla? d^iou, rjv wairep SidSrjjjia 7repi/ceii>Tai. ov
fjLTjv aXX' elalv rjBr] Ttve? teal tcov eKXeKrtov eKXeKTOTepoi,
Kal roaovro) fidXXov rjrrov eiriai^fxoi, rpoirov riud eic tov
\o kXvSwvo? tov koct/jLOV veooiXKOvvTe? eavrov? Kal i-rravdyovre?
eV aor^aXe?, ov j3ovX6fJ>evoi Botcecv dycoi, Kav etTrrj ti?
alayyvb^evoi, ev /3d6ei yvcofjurj? diroKpVTTTOvTe? rd dveicXd-
Xrjra /Avarr/pia, Kal ttjv avrwv evyevecav vireprjcfiavovvTe? ev
f. 341'' Koafjbfp /3Xe7reo~0ai, ov? o Xoyo? (f>co? tov koct/jlov teal|aXa? Mt v is f
15 tt)9 yrj? KaXel. tovt ean to airepfxa, ei/coov Kal 6/xoi(oaL?
Oeov, Kal tSkvov avTov yvr/crtov Kal KXrjpovo/jiov, wenrep eiri
Tiva tjeviTelav evTavda irefiTrofxevov virb fieyaXr]? olKovofiia?
Kal dvaXoyta? tov 7raTpb?, St' ov Kal Ta (f)avepd Kal Ta dcf>avrj
tov Koa/xov Se&rj/LUOvpyrjTai, Ta fiev el? SovXelav, Ta Se el?
20 do-K7]o~iv, ret Se el? fxaOrjaiv avTaJ, Kal irdvTa fjue^pi? dv
ivTavOa to airepfxa fievr) avve^eTat, Kal avva^OevTO? ai>Tov
TavTa Tay^icrTa XvOtjaeTai. cf - 2 Pe in 10
95G 37. Tt yap eTt 8el; 6eo3 rd Trj? dya7nj? (xvaT^pta, Kal
Tore iTTOTTTevaei? tov koXttov tov iraTpb?, ov /novoyevij? cf. Jn i is
25 0eb? fjuovo? e^rjyqcraTo. ecrTi Se Kal avTo? 6 deb? dydirij Kal of. Univs,
hi dyaTrrjv rjfjuv e0ed0rj. Kal to fiev dppr\Tov avTov TraTrjp,
to Se el? fjfJLCL? av/xTraOe? yeyove {ir)Tr)p. dyainjaa? 6 TraTi)p
idrjXvvdr], Kal tovtov fxeya arffjuelov, bv avTo? eyevvr\aev e£
avrov, Kal 6 Te%0el? ef dydirr)? Kapirb? dya7nj. 8ul tovto
30 Kal avTo? KaTrjXOe, hid tovto dvOpcowov eveSv, 8id tovto tci
dvdpanroov ckgov eiraOev, tva wpb? ttjv i)p,eTepav daOevetav
ov? rjydirrjo'e p,eTpr]6el? rjfid? irpb? ttjv eavTov Bvva/jLiv uvti-
fxeTprjcrr). Kal fjbeXXwv airevheaOat Kal XvTpov eavTov eiri- of.STimiTfl
ScSov? KaivrfV y/xlv 8ta0t]K7]v KaTaXifnrdvef ^\yivnrjv vfjuv(,f
'-
J " xil• 7
18 avrwu 15 Tovrian 23 0u 26 idedOrj (Jiilichcr)]
cdrjpddr) 29 avrov
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 64/108
28 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
BlB(OfjLC T7)V €/Jb7]V. Tt? Be eCTTLV CLVT7) KOI 770(77) ,' VTTep T)/jUO)V
e/cd(TTov Kari6r]K6 tt)p yjrv^r)u rrjv avra^iav ro)V oXcov' Tavrrjv
97/xa? virep dXXrjXcov avTairanel. el Be Ta? i/ru^a? o^eiXo/xev
Tot9 dBeXcftol? ical TOiavTrjv rr)v crvvOrjicr/v irpbs tov acorrjpa
dvOwfjLoXoryrjjjbeOa, en rd tov Koafiov, rd irToaya ical dXXo- 5
Tpia ical irapappeovTa, Kadeip^ofiev TafxievofJievot; dXXi)Xwv
diroKkeio-ofxev, d iierd fxiKpbv e^et to irvp ; Oeioos ye ical
1 Jn iii 15 eiTLTrvods 6 'Icodvvrjs, 'O /JL7] (faXwv, (jyrjal, rbv dBeX(f)bv dvOpw-
ttoktovos earl, crirep/jba tov Kaiv, Ope/jUfxa tov BiaftoXov, Oeov
crirXdyyyov ovk ex6i> e'^
7r^a KpetTTovcov ovk e%ei, aairopo*; 10
cf. Jnxvsf eoTiv, dyovos ecrTtv, | ov/c ecTTL /c\r)/j,a t?)? del ^obarjs virepov- f. 342a
pavlas dfiireXov, eKKOineTai, to irvp dOpovv dva/uuevet.
cf.iCoxii3i 38. Xv Be fxdde tt)v <fca0^> virepftoXrjv 6Bbv,rjv BeUvvo-i
iCoxiiio IlaOXo? eirl crcoTr/plav' 'H dydirr) Ta eavTr)<$ ov f^Tet, aXV e-
irl tov dBeXtybv eicKeyyTai' irepl tovtov eirTorjTai, irepl 15
1 Pe iv 8 tovtov acocf)p6vco<; fJuaiveTai. 'Aydirrj KaXviriei irXrjdos dfiap-
1 Jn iv is tlcov' r) TeXeia dydirr) ifcftdXkei tov cj)6/3ov' ov irepirepeveTai,
6 ff
ov (frvo-tovTciL, ovk hriyaipsi T7] dBiKiq, crvyyaipei he ttj
dXrjdela' irdvia aTeyet, irdvTa irccrTevei, irdvTa eXirl^et,
irdvTa virofjuevei. r) dydirr) ovBeiroie eKiriirTei. irpo^rjielai 20
KciTapyovvTai, yXwaaat iravovTai, idaeis eirl 777? KCLTaXeL-
iCoxiiii3 TTOVTdi. fxevet Be Ta Tpia TavTa, irians, eArri?, dydirr)'
fiel^cov Be ev tovtois r) dyairr). Kal Bc/calo)?, ttIgtis fiev yap
direpxeTai, oTav avToyjrlq ireco-Qcofiev IBovTes Oebv, ical eXirls
d(f>avi£eTaL tcov eXiricrOevTcov diroBoOevTwv,dydirr) Be
eh 25
irXrjpco/jia crvvep^eTai /cal fidXXov av^eTai t&v TeXelcov irapa-
BoOevToyv.
39. (38.) 'Eai/ TavTr/v e\x$akr)Tai ti$ Tjj ^v^rj, BvvaTat,
cf. Jnix3i kolv ev d/jbapTrj/jLao-iv r) yeyevvrj/jLevos, tcdv iroXXd twv /cetccoXv-
fxevav elpyao-fievos, av^rjaa<; tt)v dydirrjv ical fieTavoiav 30
/caOapdv Xaf3a)v dvafjua^ecrao-dai Ta eirTaca/jieva. fAt)Be yap 957
tovto et9 aTToyvcoalv vol ical dirovocav /caTaXeXetyOco, el ical
tov irXovacov /j,d6oL<; octtis eo~Tlv 6 yd>pav ev ovpavois ovk e-
X<°v> Kal Tiva Tpbirov to?? overt %pd)/jLevo<; (39.) dv rt? to tc
eirippr/Tov tov itXovtov ical %<zA,e77w eh farjv Biacfrvyot ical 35
2 KaredtjKe (Segaar)] Kadijice 8 ewnrvws (J. B. Mayor)] eiwrovos
12 adpovv 13 <Kad,
> addidit Combefisius 31 fjarjde (Dindorf)] /x-qre
35 impprjTov (Segaar)] ewippe? tov
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 65/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 29
Bv vatro tgov alcovtcov, ro3v dyaOo3v, eiravpaaOai. el r)v Be
T€rvxVK^ V$*' dyvotav rj BS daOeveiav r) Treplaraaiv clkovgiov
fierd rrjv acjypaytBa Kal rr)v Xvrpcoaiv TreptTrerrj<; tktlv a/jbaprrj-
puaaiv rj TrapaTTTcofiacrcv, &)<> vTrevr\veyOai reXeov, outo? Kare-
5 yjrr}(j)icrrat iravrairaaLv vtto rov Oeov. iravrl yap tw fier d-
\rj6eias ei; oXrjs tt}? KapBuas iirtarpeyjravTL irpbs rov Oebv
dveajyaaiv al Ovpai Kal Beyerat rpiada/xevo^ Trarrjp vtbv
dXrjOcos fieravoovvra' r) 8' dXrjOivr) /uuerdvoia to /jLrjKerc roh
342b avroh evoyov elvat, aWa\
dpBrjv eKpi^coaai tt)? ^^X*??,
ro €(p* oh eavrov Kareyvo) Odvarov dpaprr/fjiaatv' rovrcov yap
dvaipeOevrcov avOis eh ae Beds elaoiKiaOr^aeTat' /jbeydXrjvJ'(
f
(
- L( ' xv "
yap (j)7]o-i Kal dvvirep^XrjTov elvai yapdv teal eoprrjv iv
ovpavoh tu> rrarpl real Tot? dyyeXois ei'o? dfiapTcoXov eiri-
GTpey\ravTOS real /jLeravorjo-avTos. Bib Kal /ce/cpayev "EXeov BosviB;
i* deXo) Kal ov Ovaiav Ov SovXoaat rov Odvarov rov aixap-(,
rcoXov, aXXa, rrjv fxeravotav' 1&av watv at afxapTiaL v/jlwv Is » 18
oj? (f)otvL(covv epuov, a)? yjubva Xev/cavo3, tcdv /xeXavrepov rov
gkotovs, &)? epiov XevKov eKvtyas Trotrjo-a). Oeu> yap /jlovo) cf. Mc ii 7
Bvvarbv dfyeaiv dfxapjiwv irapao-yeaOai Kal fir) XoytaaaOat
20 TrapairTajfiara' oirov ye Kal rj/ilv irapaKeXeverai rrj<; r/fiepas cf. Lc xvii
eKacTTr)*; 6 KVpuos d(f>cevac tols dBeX(f>oh p,eravoovaiv. 66 cf.Mtviin
Be rjfieh Trovrjpol ovres icr/iev dyaOd Bbfiara BtBbvai, irbao)
fidXXov 6 Trarrjp tgov olKTtpfiwv, 6 dyaObs Trarrjp 7r«cr?/<? c f. 2 Co i s
TrapaKXrjo-ecos, b TroXvcnrXayyvo*; Kal iroXveXeos, < o? >
25 Tre<pVKe fxaKpoOvpielv, rov? eTriarpeyjravTa<; TTeptfievet ; eVt-
arpe^rat Be iartv ovtcos dirb rwv dfiapTrj/jbdrcov to TravaaaOai
Kal /jbrjKerL (3XeTTeiv eh rd ott'io-(o. cf. Lc ii ta
40. Twv fiev ovv Trpoyeyevrj/jbevcov ^eo? BlBcoaiv dcf)eaiv,
tcov Be eTTLovrcov avrbs e/cao-TO? eavTw' Kal tout earc
1 el rjv] et-rj i viravr]vixdo.L 4, 5 Ka.Te\J/r)(pi<TTcu] pr. 01' Ghisler ad marg.
8_10 i) d'—afiaprrifxaaiu] Parall. Vat. et Scor. 594 Paris f. 386b Matr. f. 118"
Ant. Mel. 22 8 om. 5' Parall. Ant. Mel. ^77/cM] /u??re Paris fii) Matr.
9 aureus] toiovtols Matr. elvai] evpedrjuaL Parall. Ant. Mel. dXXa]
d\X Parall. Ant. Mel. dpSew Scor. 11 avaipeddvTuv 17 /xeXav-
rbrepov : forsitan scribendnm /xeXavibrepov 24 <6s> addidi 26 ittl-
aTptyavTes 25—27 tiruxTptyai—oiriaw] Parall. Vat. et Scor. 594 Paris i'. :5s.")1 '
20 5^ £<ttiv oVtws] oVtws £<jtii> Parall. om. rwc Vat. a/xapTiuv Parall.
to] Tip S
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 66/108
30 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
fJL€Tayvwvai, to fcarayvwvai rwv Trapper)fxevcov Kal aiTr)-
aaaOcu tovtcov dfivrjo-Tiav irapd 7rarpd<;, o? /jlovos twv
airdvTa>v 016$ re eariv airpaKra iroirjaai rd ireirpayfieva
eXecp to) irap avrov real Bpoaw irvevfiaro? dnraXetyas rd7rp07j/iaprrj/jL6va. 'E</>' 0Z9 yap dv evpco vfid<i, (ftrjalv, evl 5
tovtols kcl\ Kpivw' teal Trap' eKacrra ffoa to reXos Trdvrcov'
ware /cal toj rd /jbeytara ev TreTroiTjKort Kara tov fiiov, iirl Be
tov TeXovs i^oiceiXavTL 7r/)o? /ca/ciav, dvovrjTot irdvTes 01
irpoaOev irovot, iirl rfj Kara(TTpo(f)fj tov Spdfiaros efjddXa)
yevojxeva)' ru> Be yelpov Kal iiriaeavpfjievw^ fiiutaavTi irpo- 958
repov ecTTLv varepov [Aeravor)cravTi iroXXov \povov iroXiTeiav
Trovrjpdv ifCViKrjaai tw fierd tt)v fxerdvoiav \pova>'\dtcpif3eia<; f. 343a
Be Bel TroXXrjs, coo-irep roU fia/cpa voacp ireTrovr^Koat awfiacn
cf. Ephiv 28 Biairr)<; XP6^a Kat irpotroxfjq irXeiovos. 6 /cXcttt?;?, d(f>ecrcv
ftovXet Xafielv ; /jLTjKert Kkeirre' ixoiyev<ras> poteen ttv- 15
povcrOo)' 6 iropvevaas, Xoinrbv dyveverco' 6 dpTrdaas, airoBlBov
teal irpoaaTToBlBov' 6 yjrevBo/jLdpTVS, dXrjOeiav daKt)crov' 6
eirlopicos, p,r}KeTi opuvve' Kal rd aXXa irddr] avvre/ie, opyrjv,
€7ri6v/jLiav}Xvtt7]v, (f)6ftov, Xva evpeOfj? eirl t?J? e^oBov wpos
cf. Mty25; Tov dvTiBiKov evTavda BiaXeXvaOat (bOdvwv. earcv aev ovv 20Lc xn 58
~ n
5—14 £</>' oh—irXeiovos] Parall. Vat. et Scor. 594 Matr. f. 118a : cod.
Baroccianus 26 5—10 e</>' ens yevo/xevu)] Parall. Vat. 343 (hiat Scor.)
Rup. f. 213a Matr. f. 128b Paris f. 84a 5 om. yap Parall. cdd.
omn: Bar. dv] £dv Vat. 594 Scor. om. v/xas Scor. om. (prjalv
Parall. cdd. omn: Bar. 6 Kal Kpivw] om. /cat Vat. 594 Scor. Matr. (utr. loc.)
Paris: Bar. /cat Trap'] om. /cat Bar. reXos] ZXeos Paris diravTcov
Parall. cdd. omn: Bar. (Hunc locum Bunsen ita emendauit: irap' i<dffrov fiiov
to WXos dwaiTuv.) 7 om. ry Vat. 343 fieyia-Ta] /xakurra Rup.
om. Matr. 118a : Bar. Kara tov fiiov Matr. 118a : om. Kara ceteri omn. et S
iirl 5e] XftavTos 8e Matr. 118a : Bar. 8 tov reXos Bar. t£ reXet Matr. 128b
e^oKikavTi. Scor. igtaicCkapTi Matr. llba Paris g&KTjKaPTT) Bar. e^w/ctXairos Matr. 128b
dvorjToi S Rup. Bar. dvuvr]T0i Matr. 118a om. irdvTes Matr. 118a : Bar.
9 vpoade Bar. iirl 7-77] oi eVi Matr. 118at?)s KaTao-Tpo<pi}s S 9, 10 e£-
ddXuv yevop-tvuv Vat. 343 Matr. 128b 10 t<2 de] tw tc Scor. totc Matr : Bar.
Xet'pwi/ Scor. xet/owvws Matr. jSttuo-a^rt] ftios dvTi Matr. irp&Tepov Scor.
irpoTtpwv Matr. 11 om. ^cttii' Vat. Scor. 13 om. U Vat. Set] <5etVat
Parall. cdd. omn : Bar. coenrep rots fxaKpg. voo-lo] virep tt)s fiaKpav ocro) Bar.
vrrep tt)s els p.aKpdv ws 6 Matr. TreTroviKoo'L Scor. TreTrotrjKdo't Bar. 7re7rot7;/cws
i) Matr. o-w/uart Matr. 14 5ta£reis Matr. xp^a Matr: Bar. 7rpo<r(oxr)s
Scor. 30. 20—31. 4 'Iotiv—KaTopdovrai] Parall. Vat. et Scor. 594 Matr.
f. 118a : Baroccianus 26 20 tvTi Vat. Scor. om. ovv Parall. cdd. omn: Bar.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 67/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 31
dBvvarov ro"o>? aOpocos diroKb"s\raL itclOt] avvrpo^a, aXXa
fxera Oeov Bwdfiews /cal dvdpayrreias i/cealas /cal dBeXfycov
/3or)0eia<; /cal elXi/cpLvovs /j,eravoia<; ical avveyovs fieXerr)^
KCLTOpOoVTCLl.
5 41. Aid Bel irdvTws ae rov aoftapbv /cal Bvvarbv teal
irXovauov eiriarriaaaOai eavrco rivd avOpcoirov Oeov /caOdirep
dXeiiTT'qv /cal /cvfiepvijTrjv. alBov Kav eva, <(>of3ov Kav eva,
/neXerrjaov aKoveiv Kav evbs irapprjaLa^ofxevov /cal arvcfyovTos
dfia real Oepairevovros. ovBe ydp tols dcfiOaXfiocs av/MJyepei
ro rov del yjpbvov aKoXdaroLS fievecv, dXXa /cal BaKpvaat /cal
Brj^Orjval Trore virep tt)? vyeias ttjs irXetovo^. ovtcj /cal'y
lrvXV BurjveKOvs rjhovrj? ovBev bXeOpccbrepov dirorvcfyXovrai
ydp dirb Trjs T^feo)?, edv d/civr)ro<; tco Trapprjaia^o/jLevQ) Bca-
/jbeivrj Xoyw. rovrov /cal bpyiaOevra (f>o^r)07]TC, ical arevd-
15 gavra "fXvTrrjOrjrof, /cal 6pyr)v iravovra alBeaOrjrt, /cal icoXa-
aiv irapaiTov\xevov <\>0daov. oSto? virep aov TroXXas vv/cra<$
dypv7rv7]o-dr(o, irpeafievcov virep aov 777)09 Oeov /cal Xiravelais
avvrjOeai fiayevcov rov irarepa' ov ydp dvreyei rolsre/cvois
avrov rd airXayxya Beo/JLevocs. Be^aerai Be /caOapcbs virb
70 aov TTpoTLfjico/jLevos ft)? dyyeXos rov Oeov /cal fMr)Bev virb aov
Xvirov/jbevos, aX\' virep aov' tovto eari /j,erdvoLa dvvrro-
icpiTos. 6eb<$ ov /jLV/CTTjpL^erai, ovBe irpoae^ei Kevols prjfJLaai' cf. Gal vi 7
fjLovos ydp dva/cpivei fiveXovs /cal vecfrpovs /capBlas, /cal tojv
ev irvpl /cara/covei, ical rebv ev koCXicl /crjrovs Uerevovrcov
!. 343bei;atcovei, /cal iraaiv e'77^9 earc
rowiriarevovai ical ir6p\p(o
to?? ddeois dv /jirj fjLeravorjaayaiv.
42.r
'\va Be eTuOapprjays, ovtoj /jLeravorjaas dXrjOoos, on
1 dwarbv Parall. cdd. omn : Bar. Lam] pr. ydp Matr: Bar. ddpdm]
evdem Matr. irddr) avarpocpa Matr. irddys rpo<p Bar. 2 dvOpwirlas
Scor. Matr. dvdp. Ik.] avdpoo... Kaunas Bar. ct5e\$6j> Matr. 8 avuexys
Scor : Bar. 4 KaropOovvrai S 7 dXdwTeiv 15, K> tcdXaaiv
TrapaiToup.evov (Segaar)] KoXdcreiu irapaiTOv/xiuio 31. 27—30. 3 'iva 5£
p\eTrop.ti>7is] Haec habent cdd. plur. operum Dionysii Areopagitae ; loctiones
dedi quae in archetype- horum cdd. exstitisse uid., apposito symbolo Ex:
infra uariae lectiones istorum cdd. notantur 27 tri dapprjs S
De superscriptione cf. Introd. p. xxvii 27 om. 5iv C ixidapfafaat V
twiOapprjs L fxeravo-qaris P
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 68/108
32 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
(rot fxevei <T(t)Tr)pias iXTrls d^Lo^peox;, d/covaov puvOov ov
fivOov, aXXd ovra Xoyov irepl ^Ytodvvov rod (ittocttoXov irapa- 959
BeBofievov Kal fivrji^r) ire^vXay/xevov. eirecBr) yap rov tv-
pdvvov reXevrrjaavros diro t% Holt/jlov rrjs vrjaov pueTrjXOev
eirl rrjv "Rcfreaov, dirrjeL irapaKaXovfievos /cal eirl to, ttXt}- 5
crioywpa twv eOvcov, oirov fiev iiricncoTrovs Karaarrjacov, oirov
Be oXas etcKXTjcrlas dpfioawv, oirov Be /cXrjpov, eva re tlvcl
KXrjpuxrwv rcov viro rov irvev/JLaros arj/uLaivo/jLevcov. eXdcov
ovv eirl Ttva rcov ov /xa/cpav iroXecov, 179 teal rovvofia
Xeyovaiv evLoi, /cal rd aXXa dvairavaras tovs dBeX(fiov$, eirl ro
irdai rep /cadearcori irpoo-fiXeyfra? eiriG/coirw veavla/coviicavov t£ acoLian koX ttjv oyfriv darelov teal Oepfxbv rrjv
yfrv^rjv IBcbv, Tovrov, e<f)rj, aol irapaKaraTidefxai /xerd irdar]?
airovBrjs iirl Tr)$ e/c/cXrjclas ical rod Xpicrrov \idpTVpov rov
Be Be^o/xevov Kal irdvff virio-yyov[xevov /cal irdXtv rd avra 15
Biereivaro /cal Biep,aprvpaTO. elra 6 fiev dirrjpev eirl rrjv
"Q(f>eorov, 6 Be itpea/3i>tepos dvaXaffcov oc/caBe top irapa-
Bodevra veavicrKov erpecfye, ovvelyev, edaXire, to reXevralov
i(f)coTto-e' Kal Lierd tovto vcprj/ce rrjs irXeiovos iirifieXelas /cal
irapa^>vXaK7)s, 009 to reXeov avrw fyvXa/CTiqpiQv eiriarrjcras 20
1 /xev els aioTrjpiav S 32. 1—36. 3 aKOvaov ixvdov—fiXeTro/xe'vTjs Euseb. H. E.
iii 23 1 ixvdov pr. loc] om. Excdd & 4 vdaov S 5 eirl pr. loc] eis
Euscdd Pi 7 K\jjpii} Euscdd ali<» re] 7eEuscddaliq 9 ovv] + /cat S 12 rrj
8\J/ei Eus^p1 13 irapaTide/xai S Euscdd Pauc 15 /cat 2° forsitan omittendum
16 SteretWo] dtereiXaTO Vat. Gr. 623 dteXeyero Eus Excddpldie/xaprtpeTo
EusEx^p
1 om. elra S om. dirijpev S 20 riXeiov Eus Excdd P'
1 av fxeveis F d£tox/>eos AHL 1, 2 ixvdov ov pt-vdov] ov ixvdov A (ov supra
lin. add. ) GHKOPQR ixvdov BC*D** (erasis post ixvdov 7 litt.) FIL ixvdov ov ixvdov
0**D* ut uid. 2 dXX' ABDP 3 om. Kal /xv. ire^vX. L 4 TeTeKevTrjaavTos G
T77S HaT/xov] om. 7-77S HKOPQR 5 arrlei OQ direifi L 6 KaTaarrjaov IQ
7 om. 6'Xas I K\r)puv H om. eva ri H re] ye Cut uid GPR om. BD nvas G
8 om. twv ABCDILP om. rod av/xaivo/xevov BL* ut uid P 9 ovv] + Kal KP
10 TaXXa ABCDILP iirl] ivh 11 KadeKao-rCon Q TrpopXtyas 1*0
iirio-Koirov AI*0 12 acriov IL 13 irapaKarideixai C react) C 15 om.8e GKR irdvTa GHQR /cat tt&Xiv] om. /cat BCDP irdXiv] irdvra G
om. avTd K 16 SteretXaro HE iXiyero G dieXtyero rell. die/xapTvparo HO**QR
-etro C -ero rell. dirripev] eirripev L dTr-qpus A 17 irpeafivTr)? H irapaXafitov
BD 18 erpe(pev Q om. avvelx^ fdaXirev ACQ 19 e<p<J)Tiaev AQ
v<prJKe BKPR v<l)k(TTt]Ke A*GHLO v^earr] Kal A**CDIQ tt)s wXelovos]
hie incipit in I manus saecl. xv. 20 om. to KLQR rtXeiov ABCDLOPQ
tiriKTrjO-as
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 69/108
QULS DIVES SALVETUR. 33
rrjv a<f)paylBa rod KVpiov. rco Be dveaecos irpb wpas Xa(3o-
fieva) irpoatyOeipovrai rives rjXaces dpyol /cat direppwyores,
eOdBes kclkmv' Kal Trpcorov fiev BC e<nido~ewv TroXvreXaJv
avrov 67rdyovrac, eJrd irov Kal vv/crcop eVt XwiroBvaiav
5 i^iovres avveirdyovTat, elrd ri teal fxel^ov o-v/jbTrpdrreiv
r)%iovv. 6 Be tear oXiyov irpoaeiSi^eTo teal Bed fieyeOos
(f>vaea)<; i/cards wairep dcrrofios Kal evpeoaros lttttos opOrjs
6Bov Kal rbv ^aXivov evBaKcov /ubei^ovcos Kara tgov ftapdOpcov
e<f>epero. diroyvovs Be reXecos tt)v ev 6eS acorrjpiav ovBev
io en /ju/cpov Bievoelro, dXXd /xeya tl wpd^as, e-rreiBrjirep aired*
airoXooXet,, ccra rols dXXots iraQelv rj^iov. avrovs Brj tovtovs
dvaXaftwv Kal XjjaTtjpiov avyKporrjaas (-'tol/jlos Xyarap^os
f. 344a r/v, fiiatoraros, /niaKpovcoraros,|
%aXe7rwTaT0?. %poz/o? *v
fiecTG) Kal twos €7ri7re<Tov<rr)<; -)(pelas dvaKaXovai rbv 'Icodvvrjv.
15 Be, eirel rd dXXa &v %dpiv rJKev Karearijcraro, "A^ye Br), e(prj,
<w eirlcrKOire, rrjv TrapaKaraOvKrjv diroBos r)puv, rjv eyco re Kal
6 X/kctto? (tol 7rapaKare6e/j,e6a eirl rrjs eKKXrjaias r)s irpo-
2 om. Kal aTeppioyores S 3 rjdddes Ex TroXvreXQv] pr. 7roXXQv S
4 iTrdyovrai avrbv Ex avrbv virdyovrat S 6 TTpoaeO'ifrro Excddpl7 om.
AcotAs S 10 irpd^ai Euscdd alii 11 &t6\u\& S -rradeiv] irpdrreiv EuscddaIi('
14 ifxireaovarjs Excddaliq 15 iireidr] S Karearrjaa-] periit in S, maxima huius
folii parte auulsa 16 TrapaKarad-qKrjv Eusodd| '' irapadr)- S, fluctuat Ex
-K7)v aw. i). fji>] periit in S re] ye S 17 Xpiarbs] aiorrjp S
-aredc'fJLeda— 17s] periit in S
1 icvplov (et K**)] Xpiarov K* 2 irpoatpde'iovrai Q* Trpo(X(p0ivovTal P',pl
Trpoa<pdripoi>Tal H iirKpOelpovrai C aTreipurybres aTreppoydres C direp-
prjybres I81'
1'1 3 idddes P rjdddes rell. KaK&v] pr. cvvqdas G ecrdidaewv
iroXvTeXCov] pr. ttoWujv K (e sil.) 4 iirdyovrai avrip CD iTrdyovrai avrbv rell.
XojTTcodvalav R \(t)Tro8ve?av 5 crvveirdbovTai. om. elrd tl—rji-lovv O om.
ti C /xeifrva L o-fJ.rrpdTT(iv Q 6 irpoo-tdi^TO ADGI S1,|,1LQ Trpoedi^ero C
Tpoo-eidifrTO HPRstTrpoo-ndlfcTo BKR I)ind
irpo<Tedl{eTe 6—9 «:ai did—iftpeTo
in marg. habet A 7 eWras] om. DH ^o-Tacrews etiptoros B etfpoo-Tos H9 reXetas DO eV] ^Tri G 10 in] iirl G 11 aTrwXciXet DI'^'O at^ros
KQRmnd «QB(esil.) 12 \afiuv BCDL Xt/o-t^oi/] ffr^oi/ K
13 /3tatwTaros H fjuaupovdraTOS L om. /uLiaMpovwraTos (!HP ,1'
1KOQR
XaXe7rit>T<XTOs] pr. Kai GI"''plKQR xa.Xe7r6raTos L xaXcu7r 6t<xtos 13, 14 i/^/xto-ip
AH 14 i/xireaovLTrjs ACI^'LOPQ om. BD dvaKaXovaiv CLQ dvaKaXovai.] +
oi tt)s TOta6T7]S irdXeos oUeral C (oiKeral supr. lin. a sec. ut did. nimiu scriptuni)
15 iwel] M AP^'OQ raXXa ABCDP rJKe BDOP KaTa<m)aaTo C
om. ((j>t) H 10 wapaKaraOriKTjv GKI,iP irapaOrjKrjv rell. i-^iJoye O
17 TrapfKaTedineOa CIII"',
'1LQ irapedl^Oa B
b. :*
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 70/108
34 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
fcaOeZy fidprvpos. 6 Be to fiev irpcoTOv e^eirXdyr], ^prj/jbara
oiojievos direp ovk e\a/3e avKOcpavTelaOai,, teal ovre irtareveLV
el^ev virep wv ovk el%ev ovre diziaTelv Icodvvrj' ft>? Be Tov 960
veavia-KOVy elirev, airan go kcl\ ttjv tyvxfjv tov dBe\(j>ov,
CTTeva^as KarcoOev 6 irpeafivTr)*; teal en Kal eirtBaKpvaa^, 5
'Efcetvos, e<f)7), Tedvrjtce. lift)? Kal iroTe Kal Tiva OdvaTov
(*)e&> TeOvrj/cev, elwev' dire^r) yap rrovrjpbs teal e^ooXrjs /cal to
K€(f)d\aiov \r)aTr}<i, Kal vvv clvtI ttjs eKKkricrias to bpos irpo-
KaTe[\i)(f)6 fieO' o/jlolov aTpaTMOTiKOV. Karapp7]^d/jLevo^ Be 6
diroGToXo 1; ttjv eaOrjTa Kal fieTa pbeydXr)^ ol/jLcoyfjs 77X77- 10
^dfJLevos tt)v Ke(f>a\r)v, ¥La\6v ye, e<f>r), ere (f>v\a/ca rrj? TaBe\(f)ov
^fX*7? fCCLTeXiirov' d\\J
Xtttto^ t]Btj fjuoi TrapeaTw /cal qye/JLcov
yeveadco /jlol rt? ttjs 6Bov. rjXavvev cco~7rep elyev avToQev
dirb Trj<; eKK\r]aia<i' eXdwv Be eh to ywplov vtto Trjs irpo-
<j)v\aKrj<; twv XrjaTwv d\icr/ceTai firJTe (frevycov fi^Te irapai- 15
Tovfxevos, dWd jSooov 'E7rt tovto e\r/\vda, iwl tov apyovTa
vfiwv diraydyeTe fie. 0? Teft>? wenrep (oirkicrTO dve/xevev' 009
Be irpoaiovTa eyvoopio-e tov 'lcodvvrjv, eh fyvyrjv alBecrOels
1 -vpos—x/97?Atarct]periit in S. 2—35, 10 -p ovk tXafHe—-wep^Xa^ev diro-\
periit in S 3 etxev 2° loc] toxev Euscdd Pauc 4 om. tov Excdd p» 5 /cat tn
kcli) fluctuant Eus et Ex : vide infra. 6 /cat irbre Eus edd HO Ex : om. EusreI1
8, 9 KareiXyjcpe Eus 9 8e] odv Euscddi'auc
: om. Euscddali(i 10 ttju ead. 6 air.
hoc ordine Euscddpanc 11 ye tyr) <pvX <re Eus edd BFa ae tcpy </>vX. Eus edd
GHO ye tyr] cpvX. Eusre11 13 yiviadu) Euscdd p1 17 aydyere" Euscdd p1
re'ios] ye Ex
1 6] u? H 6 5£] + d/coi/cras supra lin. P irpiora C 2 e"kafiev ACGQR
4 d7rairw] airiarw tov &8e\<pov] T&5e\<pov BHKPR &5e\<pov rell. 5 /cat '4ti
koL GPpp'Q (Eus 0) /cai in KR (Eus AEaE b) in /cat ABCDLP Kal HO (Eus Fb
)
(ical tl Kal Eusre11
)6 rtdv-qKev ALPQ wQs] pr. 6 8e ~P 7 i£6\ris Ppp'LQ
7, 8 om. /cat rb Keep. X^crr^s 8 X^crrr/s] + KadeffTrjKev H 8,9 TrpoKaTei\r]<pev AQ
7r/)o/care/Xi0e H KareiXyjcpe BK 9 yaer' Karappr)^.] pr. 6 5£ BD : pr. /cat P
9—11 om. 5£ irX^dfjiepos ABCDL: -evos ttjv ead.—/neyaXrjs super rasuram, et
ol/jLO}yijs—Ke(paXT]v ad marg. scriptum habet P:
unde mihi persuasum est arehe-typum huius codicis eadem quae ABCDL uerba omisisse, quae scriptor ex
Eusebio ut uidetur postea addidit: confirmat hanc sententiam quod P d£ omittit,
et tt]v ladrjTa ante 6 d7r6crToXos ponit cum edd AEa Eusebii 11 om. ere LP
12 /careXetTroj/ AHPpp'OQ r,^] 8$ BCD 13 wo-rrep] 8wep A cis P
14, 15 <pvXaK7)s Q 16 tovt C roiJTip BDH rb A 17 dydyeri A avdyeT^ L
6s] ws AL t^ws] ye Excddomu wXtcrrw Q* <hXl<jdu 1^ avfyeivev COQ ave'fj.e-
vov L 18 TrpoibvTa ABCDL eyvwpicev ALQ
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 71/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 35
irpeirero. 6 Be eBLwicev dvd /cpdros e7uXa96p,evo<$ rrjs eavrov
rjXiKLas, K6Kpaya)<;' Tl fxe cfrevyeis, reicvov, rov aeavrov irarepa,
rov yv/Jbvbv, rov yepovra ; iXirjaov fie, t&kvov, firj (f>of3ov'
e%€£? ert £&)?}9 eXiriBa' iya) X/chcttg3 Bcocrco Xoyov wrrep aov'
5 dv her), rov o~6v Odvarov e/cobv viro/JLepco ct>? 6 icvpios rov virep
tj/juoov' virep crov rrjv ^vyrjv dvriBcoaco rrjv ifxf)v' arrjOc,
iriarevcrov, XpicrTos fie direareiXev. 6 Be dfcovo~a? irpwrov
fiev earrj fcdrco fiXeTrcov, elra eppitye rd oirXa' elra rpe/icov
etcXace 7n/cpQ)s. TrpoaeXOovra Be rov yepovra TrepteXaftev
f. 344bd7ro\Xoyovfjt,evo<; rals olficoyals &>9 eBvvaro Kal tols BaKpvat
ftaTTTityfievos etc Bevrepov, fiovrjv diroKpviTTwv rrjv Be^idv. 6
he eyyvuf/jLevos, eTrofivv/ievos, &>9 dtyeaiv avrcp irapd rov
acoTrjpos evprjTai, Beofievos, yovvTrercov, avrr/v rrjv Be^cdv &>?
viro rrjs fieravolas fcefcadapfievrjv Kara^tXSiv, eirl rrjv e/CfcXr}-
15 o~tav eiravrjyaye teal BayfriXeo-c fiev ev%al<; e^airovfievo<;,
avve^eac Be vrjaTelais ovvaywvi^ofievos, ttolkiXcus Be prjaeai
Xoywv fcaTeirdBwv avrov rrjv yvwfirjv, ov Trporepov dirr)X6ev,
1 iTp&Trero Euscddpi
I
1, 2 tt?s r/X. rrjs eavrov Eus sed cdd al om.
T7js 2° loco 4 iXirldas Eus cdd AEabGHO Xbyov 5i6tra; Euscddpl 8 tarr)
Htv Euscddpl 10 oi/iwycus S 11 jSairWfrv Vat. Gr. 623; in S legebatur ut uid.
PawTi£6\/xevos 4k sed litterae £6 vix legi possunt, et /xevos 4k membrano scisso
perierunt : non ^airrl^v scriptum esse clarum est, quod 1 accentu caret
8evr4pov] rod iripov Euscddaliq(ibvov Ex 12 om. 4yyvu)p:€vos S (membrano
hie integro) iiroixvvwv Vat. Gr. 623 ; in S periit -/xevos cos &<pe<nv 13 rjvprjrai
Ex -vvtt€tu)v -ws abscissum in S, in quo codice ab hoc loco usque ad 36, 8
(paibpoh yeyrjdbres pauca tantum uerba ad finem uersuum seruantur: virb
tt}$ fJL€Tavo[as K€Ka\ 4-iravqyaye Kal 8a\ ayo)vi£bp.evos|
ov|
perierunt
uersus 21 16 prjo-eo-t] <x€iprj<n Euscddpauc
1 irpdireTo HKR iSluKe Kara. Kpdros GIBpl,1KQR iTri\apbp.€i>os
2 om. t4kvov I"pplKQR 3 ytpovra] yeyovbra V* 4 far}*
in G iXirtSas V** 5 b\v 84V] &" 5^ ACDLO cu'rd? B
om. 4kwi> BD vwo^voi AHO 6 om. tt\v 4ix-qv BD 7 om.6 8eG 8 tppi\f,ev AI»pp,LQ 9 ZK\aiev ACLQ tic\ae H**Bwrf 7rpo<re\-
duv P y4pov B 7repiAa/3e R 10 airoXoy.] pr. Kal GHKQR otfuyms L
rjdvuaro ABDLOP 8aKpv<xiu ALQ 11 KaTa^aTTT^bixevos P p.bvqu] 6
/xev H jxbvov rell. dir4KpvirT€ G 12 4yyvbp.evo% L (Trdj/upv/j-evov 4irwfivvTO
GIB"plKQR om. plane P averts BP 13 crwr%)os] irarpbs I'pplOQR
evprjrai CP evpoiro G rjvpTjrai rell. 14 4KK€Ka0ap/x4i>rju P (sed 4kk€- BUpei
rasuram) (ita et Eus cod Fn) 15 t'7ra»'7;7a7cj' ALQ 8a\pi\4<ri /xci>] Saxf/iXiatv
PpplKQR 16 avvayovitfucvos BP'^'L
3—2
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 72/108
36 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
W9 <f>aai, TTplv avrov aTroKarearrjae rrj eKKXrjata, SiSovs fxeya
•napdheiyfia fxeravola^ d\r)divr}<; teal ixeya yvaopLcrfia rraXiy-
yevecrla<;, rpbrraiov dvaardaea)<; /3Xe7ro/jLevr)<;
.... /xaXicrra nravratv ¥s.picrTiavols ov/c enteral to trpbs /3lclv
erravopdovv rd rc2v d/juapravovrcov 7rraio~fiara' ov yap tou? 5
dvdy/cr) rr)<; tcatcias drre^ofievov^ dXXa T01/9 irpoaipeaei are-
cpavot 6 deos.
43. (42.)I
(paiSpois yeyrjOores, f. 34;
v/ulvovvt€<;, dvoiyvvovres tov<s ovpavovs. irpb be rravriov
avrbs 6 crcorrjp rrpoarravra he^iovpLevos, c£a>? opeycav acr/ctov, 9G1
diravcrrov. bhrjywv eh rovs koXttov? rod rrarpb^, et? rrjv
alcoviov farjv, et? rr)v ftaaiXeiav roov ovpavoov. mo-revera)
ravrd Tt9 ical 6eov /jLa0r)Tal<; kcl\ eyyvrjrf) deep, 7rpo<fir)reiaLS,
evayyeXiois,X6yot,<; diroaroXiKoh' tovtols av^wv teal rd wra
virej^cov xal rd epya do-fc&v eir avrfjs rrjs ei;6Bov to reXo? 15
Pas^simix KaL TVV iirlBet^LV rwv Boyfidrcov oyjrerai. 6 yap evravOa33 et alibi.
T\
y ftryryekov rrjs fjueravoias 7rpoo-te/jL€VO<; ov p,eravor)o~ei rbre
rjviKa dv KaraXirrr) to ado/xa, ovSe Karaca^vvdrjcreraL rbv
acorrjpa rrpoaibvra /juerd rr}<; avrov 8of?7? teal arparias IScov'
ov BeBte to rrvp' el Be ris alpelrai fieveiv en e^afxaprdv cov 20
efcdo-rore eVt rals rjhovals teal rrjv evravOa rpvcprjv rrjs
alcoviov ^(or)<; rrporipbd ical SiBovros tov aayrrjpos depeacv
dirocrrpe^erai, /jurjre tov 6ebv en, firjre tov ttXovtov juLrjre rb
1 diroKar.] iTrifffrjffai Euscddpau0 3 pXeiro/jLevrjs] hie fmiuntur Eus et Ex
4—7 fidXiara— 6 0e6s] De hoc fragmento cf. Introd. p. xxix. Leontius Vat. Gr.
1553 f. 119 Parall. Rup. f. 118a Vat. 393 Scor. f. 52b Paris 923 f. 89a Maximus
661 4 xpurrtapous Leont. a<plercu Rup. 5 dp.apTavbvTwv'] dfiapT7]/j.dTcov Rup.
Vat. Scor. Max. d^aprL/xdrcov Paris TTTaLO-fidrcov Leont. 6 tovs irpoaip.] rots
irpoaip. Paris 8 (paidpofc] hie rursus incipit S 9 dvotyvovvres S dvoiyvtivTes
Potter 19 arpareias Ghisler et edd. male 20 ov SiSie] ovde 8e8ie
J. B. Mayor (xiveiv ko! ^afxaprdvetv Ghisler et edd.
1 u>s (paai] ws 5^ (prjaiu H dTroKCLT4o~T7]<T€(v) BDG dweKaT^aTrjaeiy)
ACLO diroKaTaaTrjo-aL HIsppIKPQR 2 irapa8iy/j.a Q 2, 3 TraXipyeveaias ADO
3 Tpbireov C pr. /cai P (sed super rasuram). De subscriptione cf. Introd.
p. xxv.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 73/108
QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 37
irpoirecreZv alrLciaOo), rrjv Be eavrov ^v^rju kicovcriais diroXov-
fjuevrjv. to) t)e iTTi^XeTrovTi tt)v acorrjpiav teal itoOovvtl ical
/xera avai-Beias ical ftlas alrovvrt, irape^eu rrjv dXr)6Lvr)v
icdQapcriv ical rrjv arpeirrov farjv o Trarrjp 6 dyadu<; 6 iv
5 rots ovpavols. w hid rov 7rat8o<? 'Irjaov Xpiarov, rov Kvplov
^(ovrcov ical veicpwv, ical hid rov dylov irvevp.aro's ecr) Sofja, cf. Clem
Tifj.7], icpdros, aioovios /jueyaXetoTij^ ical vvv ical eZ? yeveas lxv
« \ > v > « •> , •> , cf. ibid, lxi
yevewv icai et? tou? atwva<; twv aicovcov. ap,r\v.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 74/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 75/108
NOTES ON THE QUIS DIVES SALVETUR.
p. 1, 11. 7— 9. It is useless to record here the different suggestions that
have been made for filling up the lacunae in this place and in other places in
the first three sections. For iv do-coro) <a\ ecprjpepco fiiw (suggested in the
App. Crit.) cp. Paed. n i 7 (168) sub Jin. The scribe of S appears to have
copied from a MS. in which certain letters and words were illegible; but it
is by no means certain that he correctly represented the length of the lacunae.
The incorrectness with which the lacunae of S are represented in V shows
how little confidence can be felt in the accuracy of scribes in this matter,
p. 1, 1. 7 S leaves space for 11 letters, V for 16 1. 8 S 12, V 11 1. 9 S 7,
V 17 p. 2, 11. 7, 8 S 12, V 19 1. 8 S 12, V 15 1. 9 S 10, V 19 11. 9, 10 S 15,
V 19 p. 3, 11. 10, 11 S 15, V 30 p. 4, 1. 7 S 12, V 12. It is quite possible
that the first two lacunae are exaggerated in S, and that this passage may
originally have stood somewhat as follows : nepicnrTovai to<vto> to yepas
dvdpconois iv ao"<a)7-o>> j3lco KvXivdovpevois, <Cov (iyovo~i> to Kc(pa\aiov.
1. 8 KvXivdovpivots] cp. Protr. X 92 (75) ol fie crKcoXrjKcov diKrjv nepl TiXpaTa
Koi (3opj36povs to. r)8ovrjs pevpara tcaXivftovpevoi dvovrjTovs ko.1 dvorjTovs i<(36-
aKOvrai Tpv(pastvwdcis rives (iv0poo7roi.
p. 2, 1. 3 ov is a partitive genitive depending on dcpaipdv km tt(plk6ttt(lv.
I. 5 dyxio-rpo(pos, preserved in Antonii Melissa, is much more forcible
than the dvTio-Tpocpos of S. Clement was perhaps thinking of Thucyd. ii 53
ayxio~Tp()<pov rr)v p€Ta(3o\r)v opcovres to>v t evdaipovcov ko.1 alcpvidiais 6vrja<6vTu»v
KCLl TO)V KTC.
II. 7— 10. These lines make good sense without any supplement at all.
It is possible that the scribe of S was misled by spaces left blank in his
archetype on account of flaws in the parchment.
11. 10, 12 tovto pev...TovTo Sc] cp. Strom. IV xvi 101 (608). Af-yco is not
wanted ; it may have slipped in owing to the frequency of the phrase tovto
8e Xc'yco, which has a meaning that is not in place here.
11. 16—20 tj (i>xi) refers to the clause introduced above by tovto pear, r;
TroXtrem to that introduced by tovto Se. The insertion of the article before
noXiTeia appears to me to be the simplest way of restoring the parallelism of
the sentence, the construction of which was still further obscured hv Qhisler'fl
alteration of the genitive avppepfTprjpivrjs into the nominative. "But prayer
requires a soul that remains strong and earnest till the last day of life, and a
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 76/108
40 CLEMENT OE ALEXANDRIA.
man's life requires a good and steadfast disposition stretching forward to all
the commandments of the Saviour." €7T€KT€ivopivr)s was probably suggested
by Phil, iii 14.
11. 26 f. Cp. Paed. II i 7 (168) rbv icprjpepov 8io>kovt€s fiiovy cos ov
p. 3, 11. 2 f. firjTe oncos xre] As the text stands these words seem to
mean :—
" No longer troubling themselves...how the impossible or the possible
arises in the case of man.5' The easiest alteration is to read dvdpconois for
dv6pcoirco rj (oic becoming coh). Clement nowhere else uses the singular
avdpa>ira> in referring to this verse, nor is there, so far as I know, any evidence
at all for it. Cp. p. 16, 11. 10 f.
I. 9 dp.vr)T(ov is the reading of V as well as of S. Ghisler printed dvorjTw,
but Segaar restored by conjecture the true reading.II. 14 f. egrjyrjo-eoos tcov Xoyicov r. *.] This phrase recalls the title of the
well known work of Papias (tcov) Kvpiaiccov Xoyicov etjfjyrjcris (or egrjyrjcrcis).
1. 17 effi onorav fiddaxriv] V has these words quite clearly, but Ghisler's
copyist seems to have been thrown out by the first o of onorav not being
closed at the top and by the use of an ordinary ligature for rav. The result
was that Ghisler provided eW vno Tavp-drcoo-iv as a puzzle for scholars. Segaar
conjecturally restored the right reading, but subsequent editors were unable
to see the excellence of his conjecture, which is not mentioned by Dindorf
(except iii 516 among the extracts from Segaar's notes) or by Koster.
p. 4, 1. 5 yvp-vdaria de at evToXai] cp. Strom. VII xiii 83 (882) yvpvd£cov
kavrov did tcov cvtoXcov.
I. 7. Again it is by no means necessary to assume that a word has been
lost.
II. 8 f. The dative aaXmyyi, (Edd.), which spoils the construction, was a
correction of the scribe of V, in which MS. the last two letters are over an
erasure.
1. 23. It seems best to alter avTco to agree with eWopeuo/zeVov andso restore the reading of Mc. Ghisler printed both words in the dative.
Throughout the whole of this quotation Ghisler and subsequent editors have
added and omitted words in order to bring the quotation nearer to the
traditional text of Mc.
1. 33. The scribe of V added ttXovo-ios after rjv yap, but placed dots under-
neath it to cancel it.
p. 5, 11. 17—19. I have printed this corrupt passage exactly as it stands
in S. An opportunity for discussing it will arise when we come to consider
the Gospel text of Clement. Quite provisionally I suggest that eis ttov may
mean "up to a certain point" : on similar phrases see Lobeck's Phrynichus,
pp. 45 ff. £0)771/ is perhaps due to the scribe's familiarity with the ordinary
text of Mc, which led him to put the ace. for the nom. ; but it is strange
that the same mistake recurs on p. 20, 1. 3. The words iv 8i before ea-ovrai
have probably been introduced from the previous line : they are omitted on
p. 20, 1. 4, where the quotation is repeated.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 77/108
NOTES ON THE QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 41
I. 22 eVaXXuo-o-et] [Intransitive as in Euseb. H. E. vi 16, 1. "There is a
slight change perhaps here and there in the words, but all of them give the
same general sense." J. A. R.]
p. 6, 1. 1. biacfiepovTcov, €<TKC7rao-fjL(v(ov] Probably genitive absolutes, asSegaar thinks, referring somewhat loosely to ra 86£avTa. [I am inclined to
insert rwv after StcKpepovTOiv and omit the Se, translating " since the things
hidden with marvellous depth of wisdom are of importance for the very end
of salvation." J. B. M.]
II. 1—3 €o-K€iraarii€voiv...dKoa7s] [There is a curious parallel in Greg.
Thaum. Paneg. in Orig. p. 5, 11. 17 tf. ed. Koetschau (Lomm. Orig. vol. xxv
344, 8),. perhaps merely verbal and accidental. That passage Koetschau
compares with Orig. Comm. in Jn. xxxii 6 (Lomm. ii 402, 17). J. A. R.]
p. 7, 1. 7. For to crijfxdov, meaning ' the cross/ cp. Strom, v vi 35 (667) ;
vi xi 84 (782) ; ibid. 87 (783) ; vn xii 79 (880) ; Exc. ex Theod. § 42 (979)
ibid. § 43 (979).
I. 9. The correction alrel, instead of Ghisler's lyrei, is supported by alrel
in 1. 19 below.
II. 12—14 fov—xPWu-tmv ;] These words were altogether omitted in
Ghisler's edition. Other cases in which he omitted a line or so of his MS.
are p. 9, 11. 7 f. ttjv npos—iiriOvplav^ p. 18, 11. 13 f. €ya> o~oi nape^co—vnep-
Koapiov, p. 23, 11. 23 f. civtoIs—7rapeo~x T]'C()Tas >p. 24, 1. 7 ncii—ovcrav, p. 27, 11. 3 f.
8okov(tiv—XaXeii/.
11. 14 f. e'i Tis...7rapeo-xr)Tai] The MS. reading TrapdaxqTaL might perhaps
be paralleled by Strom, in xii 79 (546) el de imepfias bv fi'Xero <avova els
p.ei(ova fi6£av, cireiTa diroTrear] irpbs rrjv e\7rlda... VI vii 57 (769) El yovv tis
to7s peptKols cos rols KaOokiKols \pcopevos tv)(t) Koi to SovXov COS KVpiOV KCll
rj-yepLovclTcii, acpdWeTai ttjs dXijOeias. But both these passages seem to be
corrupt. I have to thank Prof. J. B. Mayor for drawing my attention to
them.11. 24 f. Cp. Strom. IV vi 29 (576) avTiKa top Kav\a>p€vov reXa'coy tii e< tov
vop.ov TrpoaTaypaTU 7TC7r\r]pcoK(V(U fiiZ/Xcy^e, prj tov Tv\rjaiov dyairrjo-avTa.
1. 31. Perhaps we should read <a\ ttjv a<pav x«PLV - There may be a
reference to Jn i 16 x illnv "VTi x (lPLTOS>
" New Testament grace in exchange
for Old Testament grace."
1. 32 7r\r]p(opa 8e vopov Xpio-Tos] Rom. x 4 rcXos yap, and so also Strom.
ii ix 42 (451). In Rom. xiii 10 we have nXrjpcopa odv vdpov f) dydnrj.
p. 8, 1. 13. The reading of the MS. to ipbv is certainly right. Cp. below,
1. 17 TO TOV 0-(iiTljpOS (£(lip€TOV.
1. 16. npoadelvai.] V has irpodi)vai: for this Ghisler printed irpaBrjvcu^
which has given so much trouble. Stiihlin (ObaervcUionea Critxcae, p. 43)
suggested npoadelvai, which proves to be the reading of S.
toIs okois] [Perhaps translate "to his perfection of Life"«frayra rd tov
vdpov. J. B. M.]
p. 9, 1. 5 diropply^ai] The i of pirrra appears to have been shortened in
later Greek. See llort, Introduction to New Test. p. 311. Westcott and Hort
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 78/108
42 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
accent ptyav (Lc iv 35). I have therefore left the MS. accent here and
elsewhere.
1. 17. Westcott and Hort print alaviav in II Thess. ii 16, Hebr. ix 12.
1. 18 Trarpia-iu is a certainly right correction: cp. Orig. Comm. in Matth.
XV 15 (Lomm. iii 358) KpdTr)Ta...<paalv dnodopevov iravav rrjv ovaiav rw
Orjflalaiv cjrjpco dedoiprjaOai.
1. 23 ff. The MS. reading el 8e (for Ghisler's ri de) with the necessary
alteration of the punctuation restores sense to this passage. "But if the
new creation, the Son of God, reveals and teaches something special, he does
not command that which appears at first sight, which others have done, but
something else which is signified by this."
1. 24 fj.Kaivrj ktio-is] Segaar compares Protr. xi 114 (88) tovto tj kt'ktls f)
Kaivrj (3e{3ov\i]Tai.
1. 25 to cpaivopevov] " The obvious and literal meaning." Cp. § 26 (27),
p. 21, 1. 4.
1. 28 tg>v vTTovroiv'] Ghisler printed from V toov virb tcov. Segaar con-
jectured what proves to be the reading of the MS.
irp6ppi£a\ The MS. has irpopi^a here and again in § 29. In Protr. ii 19
(16) MSS. have 6\6pi£ov and Esther xiii 6 (Swete B 6) NA have oXopi£et.
See Hort, Appendix to New Test. p. 163.
p. 10, 1. 19 av...KciTa\ei7roiTo] With the MS. reading ai/...KaraXa7rerai
cp. Paed. ii i 18 (176) ovbeis ttot av...8vvarai (where the Edd. restore dvvairo
from Plato) ; Strom, vi xvii 159 (823) ovk eariv av kukcov (where Dr Jackson
emends ovk earn 7rayKa<S)v) : VII ii 7 (832 sub Jin.) ouSe.../<aTaXei7ret itot av
and two lines lower tto>s 8' civ eort...(in both which places Dindorf restores
the optative).
1. 30 icai Aevei] This emendation was made independently by Prof.
Robinson, and also by Dr P. Koetschau in a review of Stahlin's Beitrage
(Theologische Literaturzeitung, 1896, Nr. 4). Compare the passage of
Heracleon quoted by Clement, Strom, iv ix 71 (595)...e£ hv Mardalos, &i\nriros,
Q(op,as, Aevis koX aXXoi 7roAAoi, and Orig. c. Gels, i 62 (Lomm. xviii 111).
p. 11, 1. 11 rols eldoo-i. to opyavov~\ [I think on has been lost after ddoai
and that there should be no stop before to opyavov. J. B. M.]
1. 13 airovaias] Segaar's dpovo-las is very tempting : but perhaps dirovo-ia
can stand in the sense of vo-Ttp-qcns. It denotes in fact the opposite of
7T6piovcrta, for which cp. p. 12, 1. 34.
p. 13, 1. 7 iv tovtois ktc] This is certainly an allusion to the unrecorded
saying of Christ quoted in§40
(p.30, 1. 5). See the notes there, iv oh
et'Xero as it stands seems impossible;yet Prof. J. B. Mayor's transposition
is not quite convincing.
1. 8 onov yap kt€~] Quoted with the same inversion Strom, vn xii 77
(878).
p. 14, 1. 6 ovdevia] Ghisler printed ov8e, Segaar conjectured ovdiveia.
1. 16. Dr Stahlin suggests to me the omission of ns.
1. 22 KaXais] Wendland, in the Berliner Philologische Wochenschrift,
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 79/108
NOTES ON THE QUIS DIVES SALVETUR. 43
1896, No. 13, suggests the insertion of <7r\ovcrios> after koXcos. But, as
Segaar says, the word is easily supplied.
11. 30 f. There can be no doubt that Segaar was right in expunging the
negative before tttcoxos. The whole discussion is about the man who hascast away his worldly wealth and not his passions. Lauchert, in a review of
Roster's Quis Diues in the Revue internationale de Theologie, 1893, p. 727,
has seen this. Jiilicher, however, in a review of the same book in the
Theologische Literaturzeitung, 1894, Nr. 1, wishes to insert ov before nrcoxco
in 1. 30 ; he takes the person speaking to be Christ, and the person addressed
to be the rich young man : but it is clear from the previous lines that the
yvrjcrios 7TT(t>x6s is addressing the v66os a\\os tttcoxos kol yjsevdcovvpos.
1. 32. For the omission of the verb of saying cp. § 22, p. 17, 1. 17.
p. 15, 1. 21 KaTao-TpaTTTeo-OaC] For this expressive word Ghisler substi-
tuted the tame Ka.Tao-Tpe<P(o~6ai.
1. 26 cos av...6pjjLr)(ras] In suggesting to me this almost certain correction
Dr Stahlin refers, for the use of cos dv with the participle, to Strom. I v 31
(334) ; ibid. 32 (335) ; ibid, xxi 132 (399).
1. 27 KdTcnrXTJyes] Ghisler gratuitously altered this to KaTaTrXrjyels. The
form Kara7r\r]yr)s may now be struck out of Liddell and Scott. In the MS.
the word is accented proparoxytone, as it is by some grammarians ; cp.
Chandler, Greek Accentuation, § 726.
p. 16, 1. 21 jSi'a] Cp. Tertullian, Apol. § 39 Haec uis deo grata est.
p. 17, 1. 10. [Perhaps we should read dvorjra for vorjTa. I doubt whether
the latter word would be used in any but a good sense. J. B. M.]
1. 28 7rpofidX\€a6ai] Ghisler's alteration to a7ro/3dXA<ro-0ai is needless.
Trpo(3d\\co-0ai is used with the meaning "cast away" in Soph. Phil. 1017.
p. 18, 1. 10 onocra.] The last stroke of the tt must have got a little
separated from the rest of the letter in one of the ancestors of S, and thus
the reading on oaa was produced. Somewhat similarly p. 19, 1. 27 n hasbecome ra.
I. 17 els avairavcriv kt4] This can, I think, mean "to the rest (characterised
by) inexpressible and unspeakable good things"; but Segaar's conjecture
a7r oAauoni/ is much easier to translate.
11. 17 ff. Cp. Resch, Agrapha, pp. 102, 154 ff. and 281; Ropes, Die Spriiek*
Jesic, pp. 19 fF. It is noteworthy that the two passages, 1 Co ii 9 and 1 Pe i
12, are again combined by Clement in the Exc. ex Theod. § 86 (989). Cp.
Resch, p. 301, Ropes, pp. 50 f.
II. 31 f. "Art thou able to get the better even of money? Say so, and
in that case Christ doth not draw thee from thy possessions...'' [Heeychius
gives the gloss (ppdaov = \eye. J. B. M.]
p. 19, 1. 3 <€Kfl o-co8r)o-€Ttu>] This addition of Segaar's gives exactly the
sense wanted;probably, however, a whole line has been lost.
1. 9 kcit avrov] The words do not seem right. Prof. J. 15. Mayor suggests
Kara <tov> avrov sc. rponov : this is perhaps better than Segaar's rotA
tuvto simid uel codem tempore.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 80/108
44 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
1. 12 a7ro§o<a/xd£ei] ' but it is the having these things with persecutions that
He disallows.'
p. 20, 1. 8 eViStSoi/ray] Segaar's suggestion enibovras is perhaps right.
1. 20 irpb rrjs nicTTecos] [" Before his conversion." J. B. M.]
I. 22 rr)v yjrvxrjv] Segaar's correction ttjv rvxrjv, though perhaps un-
necessary, is not improbable.
II. 29 f. €v8oTepo) t5>v virapx^vTOiv KapnTciv Tijs e^ovaias] [A metaphor
from the race-course, "to confine himself within the limits of what is
allowed by his possessions." I have sometimes thought that r^s e£ovo-ias
might be a gloss on tow virapxovToav. J. B. M.]
p. 21, 11. 2 f. iv tt} Trepi dpx&v] IQ Strom, in iii 13 (516) and ibid. 21 (520)
Clement speaks of this work as only contemplated. It follows that he wrote
the Quis Dines after the Stromata and other works.
11. 24 f. cktivovtcis] The phrase etcriveiv x <*PLV occurs also Strom, vn vi
34 (851), where the MS. has eKreiWv.
p. 22, 11. 1 f. dvoidev KaTaj3alvcov\ Ghisler corrected to Kara/3aiVoi>ra, but
the nom., though bold, is perhaps possible in this graphic passage.
1. 8 olvov] Ghisler from V olov. Segaar here again conjectured the true
reading.
1. 9 [For 7rpo(rviri(rxvovp,evov, which has been assimilated to 8i86pevov, read
the nominative. J. B. M.]
1. 27 eXtov] For the play on e'Xeos and eXaiov cp. Paed. II viii 62 (205)
u.v(ttiko)s TavTrj voovuL to eXaiov, b avTos €(ttiv 6 Kvpios, d(p oi) to eXeos TO
ecf)' T]p.as.
I. 28 vyeias] This late form occurs again § 41, p. 31, 1. 11 and is the pre-
vailing form in MSS. of Clement.
p. 23, 11. 23 f. avTots—irapeo-xv^oTas^ Ghisler accidentally omitted these
words, and subsequent editors filled up the gap thus made from Mt xxv 45,
so that the passage assumed quite a fresh appearance.
p. 24, 11. 21 f. civtov] This correction of Prof. J. B. Mayor's is also made
by Dr P. Wendland (Berliner Phil. Wochenschrift, 1896, No. 13).
II. 30 f. ol<eia Tpo(pr) nvpos] [This and the following words seem to be
taken from some poem or panegyric on an emerald or other jewel. But
Tpocprj can only mean " food of flame," i.e. fuel, whereas emeralds were among
the aicavo-Ta, cf. Theophr. vol. III. p. 51 (Teubner) Tpocptjv del ^rei to rriip.
Read Tpocpos " nurse of flame " i.e. scintillating. What follows may be trans-
lated :—" sport of time " (cf. lusus naturae used of fossils), " incident of an
earthquake"
(cf. what is said by Pliny and Theophrastus of gems being foundafter violent storms), " a tyrant's insolence " (cups etc. of precious stones)
cf. the story of Cleopatra's pearls ;also Paed. n iii 39 (191). J. B. M.]
A line of such a poem as Prof. J. B. Mayor speaks of is preserved Paed.
nxiill8(241)
o-p,dpaydos, ep,7r6\r)pa Tcp.rj€crTaTOu.
Just previously in the same place KepawlTai occurs evidently as the name
of some sort of precious stone.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 81/108
NOTES ON THE QULS DIVES SALVETUR. 45
Possibly rpocpr) might be kept in the sense of " nursling of fire." Cp. Eur.
Cycl. 189 dpvcov rpocpai.
Combefisius and Potter read ol<ia "houses," and Segaar took oUeia (or
olKcla) in the same sense.
p. 25, 1. 6 yiverai—avairavaems] These words are omitted in V, and a late
hand has corrected the following kcu into dXXci.
11. 10 f. otl—ma><n] Omitted in V.
11. 12 f. ddoaco yap—cplXcov] These words must be a quotation, but the
source is unknown. Julicher (Theolog. Literature. 1894, Nr. 1) classes it
among "sonst unbekannte Herrnworte."
11. 13—23. In several cases in these lines I have restored the right reading
from the Parall. Rup. Perhaps therefore its readings should be preferred to
those of S in this passage where internal evidence is indecisive.
p. 26, 1. 4 ped' rjpwv dvaa-Tdsl Segaar compares Hilary, cle Trinitate L vi
No. 43 resurgens de mortuis assumpsit nos. He prefers, however, to read
bi fjpds dvaards comparing Polycarp, ad Philipp. § 9.
1. 24 iv epyois] Segaar pointed out that these words belonged to the
beginning of § 35 not the end of § 34.
p. 27, 1. 8 tcov €k\€kt<ov € k\cKTOTepoi] Perhaps a reference to an "unwritten
word " of Christ. Cp. Strom, vi xiii 107 (793) <a\ f) e£ dpcpdlv eKXnyr) ^'n kcu
tcov €kX(k.tcov, (prjcrlv, e/cAfKrdre/jot kt£.
1. 9 tjttov] Klotz insertsfjbefore tjttov.
1. 20 aura)] SC. tco cnreppciTi.
1. 21 crvvaxdevTos civtov] Cp. Exc. ex Theod. § 26 (975) kcu to o-irippa.
crvvucrepxeTai civtco els to TrXrjpcopa did ttjs Ovpas avva^Oev kcii clcra^Biv. Cp.
also Mt iii 12HI ;
'
Didache §§ 9 f.
I. 23 Oeeo] Segaar's simple alteration from 6to of the MS. is obviously
right.
II. 24 f. 6 povoyevrjs 6ebs] In V the second hand gives the correction
vlbs for 6e6s in the margin. Hence Ghisler and the Editors have 6 p.ovoyem)s
vlbs $ebs. For a similar corruption in the MSS. of Origen see Brooke's
Fragments of Heracleon (Texts and Studies I. 4), p. 8.
I. 26 i6cd6r)\ With Jiilicher's emendation (given in the Theol. Literature.
1894, Nr. 1) cp. Strom. V iii 16 (654) otciv 6 Xdyos aap£ yevrjTcu, Iva kcu 8ea6jj.
p. 28, 1. 8 enLTrvcos] This emendation can hardly be wrong. Clement
uses the corresponding adj. Strom, n ii 7 (432) ol cirinvoi eV 6eoi>.
II. 25 f. dydirT) de els nXrjp.
awepx-]Cp. Exc. ex Theod.
§26
(975)quoted
in the note on p. 27, 1. 21.
I. 30 av£r)(ras] Segaar's conjecture da-Krja-as hardly serins necessary.
p. 29, 1. 3 o-foayl&a] " Baptism," cp. § 42, p. 33, 1. 1.
II. 4 f. KaTfyf/rjcfiUTTdi] There is little doubt that a negative must be in-
serted to go with this verb. Segaar would read <w rikeov otros Karvfyifyumu.
With the whole passage cp. Strom, n xiii, xiv 56 61 (459, 460). Sense can,
however, be made of the text as it stands by taking TeXeuv with vnc-i'i]vt\thu :
"if a man allow himself to be completely mastered by sins at first committed
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 82/108
46 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
ignorantly or involuntarily, this man is altogether condemned by God." Therest of the section must then be looked on as parenthetical, the main argu-
ment being resumed in § 40.
I. 25 Trepifxevei] Ghisler's TrepifjLfveiv is very harsh : it is easier to keep the
MS. reading, and insert <6?> which would have been easily lost after
TroXveXeos.
II. 28 f. Cp. Ed. Proph. § 15 (993).
p. 30, 11. 5 f. e<£' oh kt{] Cp. p. 13, 1. 7. See also Resch, Agrapha, pp.
112, 227 f. and 290 f., Ropes/Ztte Spruche Jesu, pp. 137 ff.: [also Apophthegmata
Patrum, Cotelier, EccL Gr. Mon. I 821 f. (and his note : reprinted in Migne,
P.O. 65. 403 ff.). J. A. R.].
1. 19 evpeBfjs] Wendland's suggestion (Berliner Philol. Wochenschrift, 1896,
No. 13) evOapo-fjs "oder etwas ahnliches" is needless. Cp. Origen, Comm.in Mt. xiv 9 (Lomm. iii 287), (quoted by Tisch. on Lc xii 58).
1. 20 cpddvcov] [Should it not be (pBdaas 1 J. B. M.]
p. 31, 11. 14 f. Ka\ o-Tcvd^avra \vTrr)6r)Ti\ This can hardly be right. Prof.
J. B. Mayor and Dr P. Wendland independently suggest arevd^avros, but the
genitive seems out of place among so many accusatives. Segaar's evkafir)6r)Ti
is the best suggestion I know of.
p. 32, 11. 6 ff. "In one place to appoint Bishops, in another to set in
orderwhole
churches,in another (to set in order) the clergy, and to ordain
individuals among those pointed out by the Spirit." Thus K\^jpov is opposed
to okas eKK\r)o~ias. If eva ye riva be read, it seems to be necessary to adopt
also the very slightly attested reading xX^pw "ordaining to the ministry" : for
KXrjpos means " the body of ministers " and not a single minister.
1. 9 ^y Koi rovvopa kt£~] Smyrna, according to the Chron. pasch. ed. Bonn,
p. 470 (Migne, Series Gr. vol. 92, col. 608).
p. 37, 1. 3 perd dvaidelas] Perhaps there is here a reminiscence of Lc xi 8.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 83/108
APPENDIX ON SOME CLEMENTINE FRAGMENTS.
1. The following fragment occurs in a MS. in the Escurial
Library now bearing the class-mark Y in 19. This is a paper
MS. consisting now of 260 leaves ; the pages measure 8^ by 5J
.inches ; it belonged to the well-known Antonius Augustinus, and
on fol. la
at the left-hand bottom corner is the number 86,
which it bore in his library (see Graux, Essai sur les origines
du Fonds Grec de L'Escurial, pp. 298 ff.). It contains a mis-
cellaneous collection of theological writings and extracts. Our
fragment occupies fol. 246b to 248% and with it ceases the
writing of the regular scribe : it is followed by the date ctovs
C\o)^rj fjLTjvl (f>l =1360 a.d. I feel almost convinced that this
date is not in the hand of the scribe himself, but it agrees
very well with the apparent age of the MS. The remaining
pages have been filled up with various theological extracts by
former possessors. The concluding pages have been lost. The
heading of the fragment in the MS. is KAi/xevros irapayyeXixara,
but in an apparently contemporary table of contents the name
is written KA^/aci/to?.
K\rj/jievTO<; 7rapa>y<ye\/j,a,Ta.
'Ho-vy/ai/ /xcv Aoyots kiriTrjhevi, rjo-vyjiav Se cpyots, uuravrtts 8e
iv yXwTTrj /cat ^aoUT/Aarc* (TfpohpoTrjra 8e a7ro<£euy€ TrpoTrerrj' ovtoj?
yap 6 vovs 8tap.€V€L /3c/?ato9, ko.1 ov)( vtto tt}s cr(po8p6Tr)TO<; rapa-
5 ^(08179 yevo/xci/05 ao-dev^s carat kou /Jpavvs irepl <pp6vt]aiv kgu
ctkotclvov opiov ovSk rjTTTjOrj ctat p.cv yacrrpipLapyias, tfTTrjOijaeTai
Sc €7Tt^€OJ/TOS OvpLOV, 1]TTr)07](T€TaL Sfi T<OV aAAa>l> TfaOwV £TOip.OV
carrot? apnaypia irpoK£ip.tvo<i. tov yap vovv Set twv iraOwv zirLKpaTtiv
v\pfj\bv iirl r}(rv)(ov Opovov KaOyjpavov dcpopiovTa 7rpos Oeov. /xr;8ci'
1 KXi/uLevTos 2 uhjclvtlos 4 diafiivei GKOTCivbv bpwv
(J. A. Kobinson)] <tkot€ivwv opuv 9 dpovov
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 84/108
48 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
6i;v)(o\ia<; avd-rrXcos ecro trcpl opyas, toySe vco#pos iv Xoyot?, fxrjSk
iv /3aStcrp,acriv okvov 7r€ir\r)po)pL€vo<;, tva ctol pv6p,6<; dya06s rrjv
iqo-v^tav Koa/xfj kuI #€iooSe<j tl kou Upov to (TxfjpLO. cf>aivr)Tai. cfivXar-
tov ok Kal T175 v7T€pr)(f>avLa<s to, o~vp,/3o\a, a^rjfxa vxf/avvcvovv Kal
K€cf>a\r}v ifyppLtvrjv kou /3rjp,a ttoSiov d/3pbv Kai pceTewpov. rjirid crot 5
7rpo5 tovs a.7ravT(j)VTa<; ecrTto ra pyjpLara, Kal Trpoo~r)yopiai yXvKCtat*
ai8to 8e 7rpos ywatKas <dcrK€i> kcu /3Xe/xp.a T€Tpap.piivov ets y^v.
XdXet 8e 7repteo-Ke/x,p,evcos aVavTa, Kai T77 cfnovfj to xpyjo-Lpcov olttoSlSov
TrjX/°
€tV Tt^ l/ dKOvcWooi/ to c/>#ey/xa /xerpoi/, a'xpt 877 Kai e^aKOVO-Tov
€t>7, Kat p/>7T€ 8tac/>evycov ttjv aKorjv twv vapovToiV vnb afxiKpoTrjTOS, 10
/xT/re v7rep(3dW(i)v p.et£oit Try Kpavyfj. <f>v\d.TTOv 8k oVws p,rj8ev
7tot€ XaX^cr^s o p.ry 7rpoecr/<ei//co Kai 7rpo€v6r}cra<;- pcr)8k 7rpo^€tpo)<s Kal
pi€Ta£v <T(Sv> tov erepov Xoyuw iVo/SaXXc tovs olvtov' 8ct yap ava
/xepos aKOvetv Kat 8taXeyecr#ai XP°Vi? pep^ovra Xoyov Kat annTrrjv
p,dvOav€ 8k do-/xevo}<;)Kat d<p66vu><i 8i8ao~Ke, p.r]8k vno <f>66vov ttot\ 15
croc/>tav diroKpvTTTov 7rpo? tovs frepovs, pirjSe fJLaOtjcreuiS dc/>tcrTacro
01 atSw. v7T€tK€ 7rpeo-j3vT€poi<; tcra iraTpdo-w' Tttia OepdirovTas Ocov'
KaTapyz o-o^)tas Kai apeTrjs. par]8k eptoTtKos ecro 7rpos tovs cpiXovs,
pv^Sex^-
euao"
T*?<; KaT' auTwv Kai y€X(0TO7rotoV i^cvSos Te Kai 8oXov
Kat vftpiv lo-xyP^s Trapairov' crvv evcfarjpiia 8k c/>ep€ Kat tov v-irept]- 20
<f>avov Kat v(Spio-T7)v 7rpads tc Kat tteyaXoi/fUxos dvrjp. KetcrOo) 8e
crot irdvTo. ets #eov Kat tpya Kat Xoyot, Kat iravTa dvd<f>epe XptcrTw
ra era urov, Kat 7ti;kvws e7rt t^cov rp€7T€ t^i/ ^rv)(y]VyKat to vot]p\a.
€7repetSe tit) XptcrTov Svvdpcei wenrep iv At/xevt Ttvt T(3 c^€to> c/)a>Tt tov
craiTrjpos dv<nrav6fi€vov d-irb 7raV^s AaAtas tc Kat 7rpa^€(os. Kat 25
iie#' ypLepav pXv di/^pco7rois kolvov tyjv creavTOV <f>p6vr)cnv, Ocw Sc 7roA-
XaKts /xer eTrtTrXetcrTOV <8e> cv j/vkti 6/xot(os Kat ev ry/xepa* tt^ yap
vVvos ere €7rtKpaT€tTa) 7roXvs T(3j/ 7rpos 0eoi/ ev^wv tc Kat vtti/a>V
OavaTio yap o piaKpbs v7rvos ec/>a/xiXXos. p.€TO)(o<; XptcrTov act Ka-
OicrTacro <tov> t^v c^ctai/ avyrjv KaTaXdp.7rovTOS e^ ovpavov' ev<j>po- 30
crw/?7 yap 4'ctto) crot SirjveKrjs Kal a.7ravaTO<s 6 Xpto"TO?. tt^Se Xvc tov
tt^s ^^X7? 5 tovov iv eutoxia Kat 7totcGv dvecret, tKavov 8c ^yov t<3
1 eVw (occurrit forma ^o-o infra bis (48 18, 49 5) et Plut. (Apophth. Lac).
241) dpyas] opya fxrjde vwdpbs] /at] 8ei> cedbs 3 KOCfioi 6 airav-
rcDiras (J. A. Robinson)] airarCovTas y\vKvai 7 <a<TK€i> addidi,
quod inter -as et /cat facilius omitti potuit 8 airebibov 8, 9 dirodidov,
Trj xpelq- ixerpQiv J. A. Robinson 11 vTrep^aXXwv (J. B. Mayor)] viro-
jSdXXwj' 13 <tGjv> addidi avrov dva] eva 14 %p6vwj/
17 vireUov 20 inrepifyavov 21 7r/o£os re] forsitan addendum wj/
27 <5£> addidi 30 <tov> addidi 32 evoxeia
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 85/108
APPENDIX ON SOME CLEMENTINE FRAGMENTS. 49
awfxoLTi to xp€ia>S€9. Kai fir] irpocrQsv eVeiyou 7rpo5 Tf>o(f)a<; irpiv rj kou
0€L7rvov irapeir) xaipos' apros 8e cotcd o*oi to Scittvov, Kai 7roat yi^s
Trpo(T€(TT(D(rav Kai to. €k 8eV8pa>v oopata' laOi 8e €7ri ttjv rpo<f>r]v
aVa0to? kou fir] XvcrawSr) yao-Tpi/xapytW eVtc^atVtoV firjoe aapKO-
5 fiopos fxrjok c/>t'Xoii>09 ecro, 07roTe firj vocros Tts taowv cVi tcivt^v ayol.
aXX' ai/Tt T(3i/ cV tovtois 77801/0)1/ Tas eV Xoyots 0etots /cat v/jtvotg
€vcf)po(Tvva<; alpov rfj irapa Otov aoi ^oprjyovfxevrj croc^ta, ovpdVtog Te
act o"€ c/>povTt5 avayeTw 7rpo? ovpavov' Kat tols 7roXXa<» 7rcpi o-w/xaTOS
avtci fiepifivas TiOaparjKoiS iXirt(TL Tats 7rpos 0eov, 6Vt o-ot yc to.
ro aVayxata 7rape£et oiapKrj rpocf>rjv re tyjv eU t,(iir)v Kat KaXv/xfxa
cnofiaTOS Kat ^ct/xcptvov i/a^ous dke^rjTrjp ta' tov yap 877 croi) fSaaiXeo)^ cf. Ps xxiii
y?7 tc a7racra Kat ocra €Kc/>v€Tat" ws //.eXr? 8e avToij <Ta o-a>/xaTa>
to>i/ auTOu depairovroiv V7T€p(3a\X6vT(i)<s irtpiiirtL KaOdircp tepa Kat cf. 1 Co vi
i/aou? avTOv. 8ta 877 totjto /x^Se voo-ovs V7rep/3a\ov(ra<; oeoiOc firjoe
15 yrjpuis ec/>o8oi/ vyx* 1'^ irpoaSoKw/xevov' Tra.va-i.rai yap Kai voVos oTav
6Xoi//vyw irpoOicrei iroiw/xev Tas avTOv evToXas. TavTa etSa>s Kai
7rpo<> vocovs l&xypav KaTao-K€va£e tt)i/ ipv-^rjv, evOdpcrrjcrov wairep Tt<>
ai/^p ev o"Ta8tots apto-Tos aVpeTTTU) T77 8uj/a//,et toijs 7rovovs v<£io"Tacr#ai.
Ixt)o€ virb \virr}<; Trdvv Tni^ov Ty)v ^vyrjv, ctT€ voVos lirLKiifXiVq
20 /Sapvvti €tTe aXXo Tt avfiTTLTTTei 8vo"^€p€s, aXXa yei/i/atws dvQio-ra
rots ttoVois to vorj/JLa vaptTas avayooi/ #€(3 Kat eV yu.eo"Ois Tots €7ri7r6Vot9
7rpay/>tao"t aT€ 8>) o"o<^wTepa Te dv6pu>Triov <f>povovvrt Kat aVcp ov
8waT0i/ ovSc pdoiov dvOpw-rrois tvpelv. cXect 8e KaXov/xeVovs, Kat
T^i/ irapa tov Oeov fiorjOetav Itt av^pco7rot9 atTOv* €7Ttvevo-€t yap
25 atTovvTt t<3 <£iXa) tt^v \apiv, Kai Tots KaXov/xeVois €7rtKovptav 7rape^€t
tt;v avToi) 8wa/xtv yviopifxov av^pa>7rots Ka^tcrTaVat (3ov\6fX€vos, tus cf. Ro ix 23
av €t9 iirLyvaxTLV iX.66vr€S e7ri 0eoV avtOMTtV, Kai T17S atwrtov fxaKa-
Plottjtos aTro\av<r(i)o-iv €7rct8ai/ 6 tov 0€ot) vtos irapayiviqTaL dyaOa.
tois t8tots a7roKa^to-T(i3i/.
The title of this extract is certainly very vague, and its
character is such that it is impossible to build much on the style,
but there can be no doubt that the ideas are just what we should
expect from the Alexandrian Clement. Now Eusebius (//. E.
1, 2 wpivl Kai bdirvov iraper) 3 forsitan Wi J. B. Mayor 4 a7ra0w5]
daraOws 5 (piXiuos Zero] taw sec. man. vo<xov 7 fpou 9 dvlov
redapaiKus 10 Stap/cet 12 < rd crw/xara > addidi 14 8t5i]0i
15 €tf(f)o8ov irpoaboKojxivov 22 ao(pOT€pd 23 KaXov/x^vois
23, 25 KaKovfihovs ct /ca/cou/i^ots 0. Stiihlin 26 t?7 aiVrou Si-yd/ift /Soi;-
\op.tvois 27 a»>iw<r?7 (sed inter ?; et ty interdum in hoc codice uix distingui
potest)
II. 4
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 86/108
50 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
vi. 13) mentions among his works 6 TrpoTpcn-TiKos eis v7rofiovrjv 7}
7rpo? tovs veaxTTl /?€/?a7TTio-ueVovs. Surely it is at all events a
probable conjecture that our extract belongs to this tract.
2. The following fragment was kindly pointed out to me by
one of the assistant Librarians at the Ambrosian Library in
Milan. In a tenth or eleventh century MS. (H 257 sup. fol. 10b)
occurs an extract1
headed'
'kvavrao-iov ©eowroActos Ik twv 7rpos
ireva-Lv kou diroKpLcriv, in which comes the following passage :
vEv0€i> cprjalv 6 'Pw/xatos KA77/X179 cv tw 7rcpt 7rpovotas Aoya>'
Bpax/xavoi eVopctoi/ olkovvtcs koI KaOapdiTarov a.7roXavovT€<s aepos
£a5o*t tcAciov Kal Tr\y)p£<TTaTov \povov rrjs t,o)rj^ ran/ avupwrruiv' €t ovv
e£ aepo? vyeta Kat irapdracn^ yiverai £00179, cv&rjXov otl kou vogtol kou
OdvaToi Ik twSc tooV o-toi^ciW Kara rti/as avrwv TrAeovaoyxous Kat
eAarrworcis a5s cipr/Tat crvp./3aLvov(TLV.
It is clear that Anastasius confused the two Clements, and
that this fragment is really from the Alexandrian. On Clement
of Alexandria's work 7rept irpovoiaq see Zahn, Forschungen III. 39.
The Brahmins (Bpaxfiaves) are three times mentioned in the
Stromata 1 xv 68 (355) ; ibid. 72 (360) ; in vii 60 (538).
3. In a Madrid MS. (0 15, paper, cent, xvi) in a collection of
opot Sidcpopoi occurs an extract headed tov ayiov KX^firj' /xaOrjrov
tov aytov Hirpov' wept ervfioXoyCas. Incipit 'HrvjuoAoyta arrtV,>J
rfjs Svvdpmos tov ovofiaros tt}<; (lege SpOory?) i£ avrov tov ovopaTOS
€pp:r)vevop.€vq' olov Kara, ri eiprjvit] ; Kara to €ip€p.r]v (lege ypefxcLv) tov
vovv. Explicit o-^oAetov etprjrai 8ta to KaTao-xoA^v (lege kara (rxpXrfv)
irapaTiO €<r$at wpos cracpeaTepav epfirp/etavT<ioV
Svo-vorjnov vorjfxdTiavrj
prjp,dT(DV.
This extract is of some length : it consists entirely of absurd
popular derivations, and is not worth printing here, being
evidently spurious. A very similar collection to the one in this
codex is printed among the Spuria of St Athanasius (Montfaucon,
vol. 11, pp. 242 sq.) under the title of Liber de Deh'nitionibus.
The heading is "Opot 8id<f>opoi Kara Trjv 7rapa8oo-ti> Kat irloriv t^s
KaOoXiKrjs eKKA^o-ta?, o-vAAcye'vTcs aVo tc KXtjfi€VTO<s Kat frepuiv 6<riW
dvSpuv Kat p-aKaptW TraTepuv. On p. 250 without any special
heading come the first few lines of one extract, and after them
1 Mai in his Scriptorum Veterum Nova Collectio (Tom. I, pars 1, p. 369)
prints from a Vatican MS. an extract of Anastasius for the most part
identical with the Milan one, but it does not contain the Clementine
fragment.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 87/108
APPENDIX ON SOME CLEMENTINE FRAGMENTS. 51
Kal iv to7<; Xoi7rots 6/AOUD5, which looks as if the scribe had the rest
of the extract before him, but was tired of copying such nonsense.
A similar collection is printed in Anastasius Sinaiticus, Viae dux,
ch. ii (see Zahn, Forschungen in 43), and occurs also in a Lau-
rentian MS. (Plut. ix, cod. 8, see Zahn, loc. cit.), and in Codex
Sinaiticus Graecus 453 (see Harnack, Litt. Gesch. i 778). The
Madrid Codex differs from the other recensions in assigning the
different extracts to their supposed authors, and makes it clear
that nothing can be added to our knowledge of Clement's writings
from this source, as Zahn seems to hope 1.
4. In a Florence MS. (Med. Laurenziana Plut. vn. cod. 15,
f. 105b) is found in a mutilated form the Gnomologia of Maximus.
This MS. was examined for Zahn by Prof. Italo Pizzi (Zahn,
Forsch. in 8). I give here the variants from Dindorf
f. 105bwcnrep Zolkcv—<f>avrj = Strom, vi xii 102 (Dind. in 201.
14—18). Collation with Dind. wg] wcnrep|om. ovv
|io-Tiv
\
om.
irdvTodiv|tiro^f)
|
x°^*vovaa|
om. re.
f. 160b €7reT<u—o-/aa = Strom, vii xiii 82 (in 323. 27 sq.).
Collation, om. yap|
rrj yi/wcret ra epya.
f. 184a oca 7repi v7rvov—rjTTOv = Strom. IV xxii 141 (ii 398.
28—399. 1). Collation, om. 8' av|airocrTacriav.
id. irao-L—a7roT€/xi/o/u.eVots = Paed. II ix 81 (i 285. 12—18).
Collation, om. ypifxa— kOi^ovcriv|
om. kirirpk-Ktiv\om. eh
|
iypr]-
yop&cnv.
f 202aavviroTTTov
—7rpc7rovTos = Strom, ii xxiii 146 (ii 240.
21—23). Collation, om. Se|
8i/?oXiKr)i/|to] tw.
f. 22 b. With the lemma NctAov is quoted the sentence
/xaKapios 6 tov /3lov vij/rjXov t\u>v, rairtivov 8e to (f>p6vr)/xa, which is
referred to Clement (by a rov clvtov) in the Parall. Rup. f. 264*
(Harnack, Litt. Gesch. I p. 321).
f. 234aovx rj
—dXiKpLvua. Quoted by Zahn, p. 55, but this
codex has ayfxiyrj for a7ro)(r].
f. 241 ,a
k\y) : 6 tois oVeipois 7rpoo-c^oov ioiKc t<2 ti]v o-klolv avrov
Sliokovtl. (This extract has apparently escaped the notice of
Prof. Pizzi.)
1 Forsch. in 42. Es ist vielleicht erlaubt, mit dieser Schrift (De
dogmatihus ecclesiasticis) eine lteihe mehr odor weniger unsieherer Angabon
zu verbinden, welche zum Theil den Scheiii erwecken, als ob CI. oino
besondere Schrift iiber gewisse fur die Theologie wiohtige Begriffe verfessl
batte.
4—2
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 88/108
52 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
£. 251 al KaOoXov—-otKelo? co-Tiv = Paed. ii vii 60 (i 266. 26 f.).
Collation. om. yap|
-qcrv^ta^ kou tfpep.ia<s.
id. (same extract continued), ov /xovov—cVaj/ryp-^/xcVw = Strom.
I x 48 (ii 41. 13— 15). Collation, ov p.6vov €vt€\tj.
id. <pi\ocro(pia eortv TjOatv KaropOoxri*; p-era. 8o^r/5 Trjs 7rcpl twv
OVT(i)V €V(T€(3oVS.
The Maximus 2is preceded by the Gnomologia of the Monk
Georgidius, which contains one extract marked Clement.
f. 86bto wept—KaprepU = Paed. II vi 52 (i 259. 18—20).
Collation, om. Sej
d<r/c€tv o-uxppovciv|
Aayvcias Z<tt\ Kaprcpcs.
5. The following extracts occurring in the Parall. Rup. arenot referred to their places by Harnack, Litt. Gesch. I 317 ff.
f. 72a ok ZoLKe— trefivij = Strom, vn xvi 100 (Dind. in 339.
25—27).
f. 109bov ircpl—o-Tpeirreov = Strom. VI xvii 151 (ill 237. 4f.).
id. eKSe';(€Tai KaTaX-qTTTiKrjv - Strom. VIII i 2 (ill 351. 28
352. 4). Zahn gives the reference on p. 28.
f. 200b tw TcXetw hiKaioavvT) = Strom, vi xv 125 (in 217.
23—25).
f. 201 a oTav fjirj—oSevei yeVos = Strom, vii xii 73 (ill 315.
17—20).
6. In the MS. of the Sacra Parallela, Paris 923, f. 98b
,
occurs the fragment aroirov Io~tlv Shokovtcl t<xs tijaos <ptvyuv (lege
<p€vy€tv) tov5 7rovovs $l wv at rt/xat with the lemma ck tov tis 6
o-w£o'/x€vos 7rAovo-ios. In Parall. Vat. Lequien 713 this fragment
has the lemma Evaypiov. In both cases it follows the extract
from QDS § 21, beginning ov t&v KaOevSovruyv. It is not to be
found in the QDS, but may perhaps be meant for a summary of
the teaching of § 3.
1 The extracts on this page are without any lemma : the last is no doubt
from some other author.
3 The other Clementine extracts in the Maximus are f. 105b17 tup
kolkwv—dpxv Zahn P* 55. f. 130a Kh-qfxevTos puj/xrjs —ov diKaiov £gti tov 8e-
5w/c6ros £yK<XTa\ei(pd€UTos ra SodevTa wapa/xiveip tois ayvtafioaiv. i. 142b several
fragments from Nilus and others under the heading kXtj/acptos. f. 22 b
ToaovTov tl%—elvai Zahn p. 62. f. 226b irdvTwv— 7rp6s clvtop and dddvaToi—tyfivvut Zahn p. 63. f. 230b el /3otf\ei o-eavrop Zahn p. 63. This extract
gives the sense of Paed. in i 1 (Dind. 1 324. 5 f.).
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 89/108
INDEX OF SCRIPTURE PASSAGES IN THE QUIS
DIVES SALVETUR.
TJie numbers refer to the pages : those marked icith an asterisk contain an
allusion only.
GENESIS xii 7 29
iii 19 13*..
50,
8*
xiii 16, 17 23*
38 5*ISAIAH xvii 27 17*
i 18 29 xviii 10 23
xix 21 9
EZEKIELxxiii
jj18 *
xviii 23 2915 24 <
xxv 34—40 23
HOSEA 41, 42, 43 10*, 23
vi 6 29
S. MARKii 7 29*. MATTHEW
iii 10 22*
v 3 12*,
6 13
8 12*,
13, 14 27
25 30*
29, 80HI
18*
39 14*
44 17*
48 1*
Vi 20 10
21 13
vii 1, 2 25
7 8*
11 29*14 21*
21 22
viii 22 18*
ix 10HI
10*
13 29
x 22 25
40, 41, 42 23
xi 11 23*
12 16*
27 6
13
iv 19!||
9*
viii 35 19*
x 17—31 4
14* 18|| 1*20 7*
2L 8, 12
21|,i
15*
22 15*
25 20
25HI
2*
26 15
27 3*, 16
28, 29 17
30 19, 20
31 20xii 30 21
S. LUKEiii 9 22*
v 21 29*
vi 27 17*
29 14*
30 24
35 17*
38 25
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 90/108
54 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
S. LUKE II CORINTHIANSvi 45 13 i 3 29*
46 23 iv 7 26*
vii 28 23* 18 20
ix 6018*
ix 6 24*62 29* 7 24
x 16 23*
27, 29 21 GALATIANS30--37 22*
ii 21 7*
39, 40, 41, 42 8*iii 24 7*
xi 9 8*vi 7 31*
13 29*
xii 32 23 EPHESIANS34 13
iii 10 22*58 30*
iv 28 30*xiv 26 17, :L9*
vi 1222*
33 11*
xv 7, 10 29*PHILIPPIANS
xvi 9 10, !
25*
xvii 3, 4 29* ii 8 7*
xix 6
9
10* iii 14 2*
10I TIMOTHY
S. JOHN i 17 27*
i 17 7vi 19 6*
18 27*
v 26 6* II TIMOTHY
vi 50, 51 18* iv 6 27*ix 34 28*
xiii 17 23* HEBREWSxiv 8, 9 18*
I 14 22*23 26*
iii 5 7*27 27*
xii 23 17*xv 5, 6 28*
xvii 2, 3 6*I PETER
ROMANS i 3 18*
12 18i 17 7*
iv 8 28vii 12 7
viii 14, 15, 17 7* II PETER19,
x 3
20, 21 22*
9*iii 10 27*
4 7*I JOHN
xi 36 1*, 21*iii 15 28
I CORINTHIANSiv 8, 16
18
27*
28ii 9 18
iii 13 19*
17 14*
vii 29--31 15* AGRAP 13*ix 25 4* 25
xi 25 4* DIDACHE § 9 22*
xii 31 28* CLEM. AD COR. lxi, lxv 37*
xiii 4, 5, 3, 7, 8 28 HERM. PAST. Sim. ix 33 et
13 4*, 28 alibi 36*
30
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 91/108
INDEX OF GREEK WORDS IN THE QUIS DIVES
SALVETUR.
d^aaauiarojs, aKpoaadai 4 22
d/3e'/3cuos 20 3
d/3ios inoj)* 14 11
d/3pd, t& 15 21
d77e\t«:d, K-qpvy/xara 4 12
a77e\os, r^s fieravoias 36 17
#7ev(rTos, 8tKatocr6v7)s 13 26
ayKLarpov 15 30
a7*'et;eii' 30 16
a7(wos 28 11 d. d8tKr]fj.dTO}v 7 12
a70/)d, 0ei'a 24 24
dypoixcos 13 30
dypvirvelv 3117
ayx€LViT0V Xoyta/xdv 12 3
ayxiCTpcxpos 2 5
a7u»'tdfeiJ' 25 2
ayoovLfcadat. 18 30
d7w»'i<rr77S 7 16
dywvoderrjs 4 3
adid(popa, rd 12 6 15 25
d56Xu>s 26 30
det :
top d. xpovov 31 10
d^T/Xos 13 i 7
dr)TT7)TOS 20 33
ddavaaia 6 8 7 10 7roua ddavaaias 18 23
dtfeaTos 26 7
dfleos 18 3 19 17 31 26
ddXrjais 3 26
ddXTJTTjS : to twj/ d. 3 22
ddXodtrrjs 4 10
ddXov 141
rd a. roO (XcjTijpos 3 31
adpow adv. 28 1
ddpous 31 1
d/'Stos 20 27
afyia : to af. t??s d/xw^Xov 22 .-5 at. tfeou
7rat56s 26 to V. irpbs
a'ipeais 8 6
ai<T0T]T6s, 7rXo?TOS 15 24 19 2y
alaxpos deform is 14 4
airidadai, rivd on 8 25 causari 11
37 !
ai<pvidios 13 15
aiwvLa, rd 6 24, 28 29 1
anavda: ai a. rod /3tou 9 9
dK.ep5r}S 13 16
d/cwd^eij/ : j/ocros dx/ia^ovcra 26 20
d/co?7 : rats d/coats 5e'x«r#ai 6 3
aKoXaKivrcos 26 31
dKoXacrros 31 10
d/coJ>iTi Kdvidpwri 4 1
d/epacri'a, yvujx-qs 14 10
d/cpt/3eta 30 12
dxpodadai 4 23 5 26
d/c/xos 9 15
dKT7)IJ.0(JVVT}, X/3?7/xdTWJ> 15 34
dKT7]/AU)V 25 28
&KT7]TOS 13 21
dXa^eia 10 4
dXet7TT77S 31 7
dXeKTOS 18 17
dX-qdeia, 77 de Christo 6 8
dXXoTpiou, to 14 30 rd d. 9 28 28 5
dXo7WTaTos 11 6
dXuTos 22 28
dixeXei 8 15
dixeX-qriov 21 6
d/AeXws 25 28
&fxerpos 1 14 13 2
d[xrixave1v c. yen. 9 15
dfj.ia.vTos 26 15
dfxvrjo-Tia 30 2
dfAoifir) : 7r/;6s dixoifiyv 21 26
aixoipos, Oeov 13 26
d/xireXos : 7? d. r/ Aafiid 22 25
dui'7/Tos : ot d. tT/s dXr]6eias 3 9
dixvveoOou c. OCC. pen. 17 32
d/x0t/ioXos : u>s eV d. 2">1
dfX(piXa<pris 20 23
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 92/108
56 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
dud Kparos 35 i
dvayevvav 18 n
dvayi<d£ei.v 8 9
avaywvKjTos 4 1
duddeXcpos 19 7
ava^r/reiv 24 22
dvaiSeia : //era d^cuSeias 37 3
dpaL/xaKTos 26 15
dvaipeiu : dXX^Xous a. oi Xbyoi 17 29, 30
dvaiTtos 11 13, 18
dvaKeladai 20 9
dvaXc^ia, roO Trarpbs 27 18
dydXc^op 17 26
dvafxaprrjcria 17 13
dva/jidxeadai reparare 28 31
'Avai-ayopai homines A. similes 9 21
d»'a7rai;ei{' c. ace. pe?-s. 24 9 32 10
dvairavcns 6 10 18 17 25 6
di'a7n'e«', foo^ 20 31
avdiTTetv, rd Trpwreia ry 0eaj 22 16
dvdaKTjTos 3 33
dvartWeiv intrans. 20 28
dvatytpeiv 3 5
'Aj/fyx?as 19 10
dpSpoAoYea/ 16 2
dveyK\r)Tos 20 22
dv€K\d\r)Tos : rd d. (jt,v(TT7)pia 27 13
dveXetidepos 1 2
dviXTTlCTTOU, to 21 14
dve^Se^s, 0e6s 21 26
aveais 33 1
dveartos 19 7
dvt(pl.KTOS 10 13
dvdrjpbs 15 22
avdofAoXoyetadai, awdrjKTju irpbs tlvol 28
dvdpdb-mvos 13 26 -^tos 5 24
dvQp(j3TTOTt]% 7 8
dviivcu a fortiori ratiocinari 17 26
dj>6v?7T0? 30 8
dvoo~os 20 33
dprd£tos 17 8 d. ra^ oXwy 28 2
dvTawaLTeiv 28 3
dvTeicdyecrdai 15 5
dPTexeadai absol. 17 1
dvriSiSoi'cu, rt u?re/) t«/os 35 6
dvrldocnv irot.ei<jdai 15 3
dvTLKaraXXdcrtxeadaL, t'l tlvos 15 10
avriXafx^dveLV 15 12 24 26
dvTLfxeTpelu, rivd irpbs tl 27 33
d^l/7TO/C/)lTOS 31 21 -TtoS 26 31
dfcofxoXoyrjfxeuos : eua77Aia d. 5 21
d£t6x/oews 32 1
do7r\os 26 14
dbpyriTos 26 15
dirddeia 16 13
d7ra#?7S 16 8
diraLpeiv absol. 32 16
diraiTeTadai 24 n
dTraXei<peii> 30 4
a7raXXa7?7 12 33
diraXXoTpiovv 11 32
dwapTaadai, dXXrjXwv rrj (pvaei 13 19
d7raucTTos 18 13 36 n
diravTOfioXeTu c. gen. 9 2
dweiirao'dai, irXovTov 9 17
aweipos, fa-q 19 34
dTreXatipecdou, ovpavQu 16 8 £w*7S 20 25
d7reX7rtfetv 3 26
dtreppwy&s perditus 33 2
aTripxccrdai absol. 28 24
d7rXdaTws 26 31
dirXodadai 5 29
drXcDs 5 35
dirbfiX-qTOS 13 21 rd d. 12 6
dTroycvuxTKeLv, iavrdv 2 26 16 3 T7jf <ra;
r-qpiav 33 9
d7ro7J'wcris 3 14 4 18 19 22 28 32
diroypdcpeadai med. 3 27 j?ass. 25 26
d7ro5o/a/id£e«> 19 12
diroKadiardvai, rtvd rrj iKKXrjaiq, 36 1
dTTOKXeletv, rt twos 28 7
dwoKOTTTea6at 3 15
d7roXaivet// 11 13
diroXe/xos 26 14
dTrofxifAelcrdai, 6ebv 24 33
aTroj'Oia 28 32
dtropetv c. gen. 9 ix, 15 absol. 10 n
dtropia 12 8
dirbppy\Tov '. to ttjs yvw/xvs d. 6 4
diroaeiea'dat, ttjv dirbyvoxiiv 4 18
diroo'ToXiKol Xbyoi 36 14
diroGTpe<peo-dcu 19 32 25 30 36 23
diroTaKTiov 12 8
dTTOTdao-opuu 18 34
diroTCUppevet-v 20 13.
dTroTeXecrp.a 22 23
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 93/108
INDEX OF GREEK WORDS. 57
dworldeadou 16 i
airoTV<p\ou<Tdai, dirb rrjs r^'ecos 31 12
aTrovala, r\ rijs vTrrjpeaias 10 12 diroXavet
ttjs <rrjs d. 11 13
diroQalveiv 24 8
dirocpoprt^eadai tt)v kttj<tiv 10 8
airpaKTOv Troieiv 30 3
dirpbdvjxos 8 22
a,7TT€cdai c. dat.congruere 17 12 c.fjen. 27 3
dTTWO-T^OS 12 12
d/ry65 26 25 33 2 d. £w?7s 7 28
apSrfv 22 22 29 9
ap/uLofeiv, 6'Xas eKKXrjcrias 327
ap-rrd^eiv, rbu \6yov apprehendere 17 5
dppTjTOS 18 17 to a. 0eou 27 26
appuxxTTjfia : rd tt}s ij/vxvs &• 12 16
apTi/xadrjS 16 1
dpx^ • 7"V d. ady. 3 31 d7rd r^s d. eutfus
6 23 d. £wt7$ 6 27 77 7rept dpx&v kcli
deoXoyias ^£777770-15 21 3
dcrdXei'Tos 6 27
dcracp&s 1533
daeXyaiveiv 14 4
a<rd(vtKos 14 10
a<TK€iv, dirddeiai/ 16 12 dXrjdeiav 30 17
rd £070. 36 15
&<tkt}<tis 27 20
acrKLos 36 10
&<nropos 28 10
daTe7os 10 27, 36
d<TT€(pdvO)TOS 3 29
daro/xos 33 7
d<rxo\eicr#cu 8 21, 24
dtrxoXiai/, (^eiy 10 15
dreXTjs 7 26
dre^s 20 16
drLfid^eiv 25 3
drpewTos 6 26 37 4
drpioTos 20 33
drvcpia 13 34
at'/fldSajs 3 u
aure^oi/cxioi', to 85 11 21
avrbdeu 2 24 34 13
avroxpia 28 24
dcpaipeiv 2 3
dc^a^s : rd d. toO nbffnov 27 18
dcpdapaia : 6 10 15 8 21 28 24 25 o£ 0-7-^-
0cu/oi 7-775 d. 4 2
d(pf)apTos 3 23 6 10
d(pLKPe1a0ai, els KTrjatv 21 15
d0i(rracr0cu : diroarrival, 7-775 680O 1 12 2 29
KTrjfxdTuv 14 32 15 1 7-775 wpodvfdas
16 16
d<po(3u)$ 26 31
d(p07r\i£ecrdcu 26 21
dcpopgZv, 77-065 25 27
dxd/Horos 1 4
dxOeadai c. dat. 8 18
dxpeios 26 25
dx/>^M<""os 2 23 19 7
fiddos, diauoias 6 2 twj/ X67UH' 15 34 eV
/3. yv<J)fj.7js 27 12
(3<nrrL£e<rdai : uavs ^aTTTL^o/xevr} 26 19 rots
ddupvat /3. 35 11
fidpadpov : /card twj/ )S. (ptpeadai 33 8
p€(3aiw 16 22
pidfradai abs. 16 18 0e6v 16 21
(SiaioraTos 33 13 /Siatas 16 22
piorefciv 10 14
/SioOj/ : cl>5 ou (3iu)<t6/j.€vol 2 27 01 eis det
fiiuxjofxevoi 10 6
fiLWTLKd, rd 12 15
(3\aKeveii> 16 19
(SXaardveiv, euirouau 22 13
/3Xd(T0r;/Aos 18 10
j8X^/xa 20 16
yeivaadat. 20 26
yiveais : d7rd 7. 7 7 77 d/coi/crtos ev 7rXo(--
ry 7. 20 25
76/NXS 1 8
yiveadai, iv vwepo\J/La 10 3
7^?7(Ttos, w6s </e Christo 7 5
yvwpifeiv c. ace. agnoscere 34 is
yt>u)pi<Tfxa 36 2
7^ui(riS 6 26 13 34 7. dXrjOdas 4 7
yor)T€v/.ia 15 22
7i'/x^dcrta 3 28 4 5
yv/xuaarrjs 4 3
717A1/0O1', W tu>os 9 87
Aa/fto* 22 26
5ai/u.6»'a;»' /S/a 26 •
daKPftrltat </<' oculis dictum 81 ti
Sa/idi'ecr^at 26 20
8a\f/iXi)<; 85 15
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 94/108
58 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
5eideii> 3 iS
de^iouadai 36 io
devrepeia, rd 22 16
drjfMovpyeiffdat. 27 19
Arj/moKpLToi homines D. similes 9 21
8ia(3o\iKos 19 14
didpoXos 26 6 28 9
dia-yowtfecrtfai 18 24
dcadiKaaia 18 7
5td0e<rt5 2 18 9 27 12 2 14 19 17 31 dca-
0e(ms 3 20 4 6 15 7
5iadr]KT] : 7) KCUVT) 5. 4 5 KCLlVr] 5. 27 34
diatra 30 14
dicLKOviai 26 32
5taK0J>iKws 8 25
didxpuns controuersia 24 17
5ta\iW0at, 7r/)6j xtm 30 20
5tdXf(Tts 17 24
81.afjt.apTa.uetu c. gen. 3 29 Trepi 25 14
diafiapTvpeicrdai 32 16
5ia7ro^e?^ 12 31 dt-airouetadai dtrddeiau
16 12
diairpaaaeadai, dduarou 19 27
5ia7rpe7n7j 7 16
5ia<nrovSd£eiv 16 14
8iarapdaaeiu 4 22
diareiueadat, rd avrd 32 16
8iaTL0euai 17 16 Stare^^ai 25 28
Siarpex^v 7 8
Sia<pauets, Xidoi 24 29
Siacpepeiv, eU ti 6 1
8ia(f>deipeiv 1 12 diacftdapijuat. 14 17
dieipijadai. 11 28
5ie/c5i/ecr0cu 2 25
diepwrau 5 36 6 14
dirjfxapTTjfxevufS, dxpoaadai 4 22
5ir)ueK7}s 15 7 31 12
5iktv5iou 15 29
dLoiyuvadai explicari 5 33
5t6A\i;cr0ai : rd dtoW^/ueca tou Koap.ov
24 25
5/xa c « #e >*- 24 16
doyp-ara 6 8 36 16 rd 7re/n xPy)^Tb3v 9 6
roD Kvpiov 10 21
5oKip.d£eiu 25 19
5oKip.aoia 19 26
56|a species Trpoaipeaecos dyadijs 8 20
opinio 25 15
5o£dfcti' 1 5
dopvcpopos 26 18
8oTvp, aiuiu'iwv 6 24
5/wos, 7ruev/xaTos ayiov 26 n 30 4
Sweid^s 25 29
dvcreipuov 25 28
5U(TKT?7T0S 13 17
Svax^poiiveiv 8 18 25 29
dvauwia 18 2
dwped 12 25
dwpetcrdai 6 28 pasff. 7 5
Swpocpopelu 1 2
eyypd<peadai 17 12
eyyvdadat 35 12
eyyvrjrrjs 36 13
eyyvrdru) : 01 e. 7ei'ous 17 27
eyKaradeadai, rrj \pvxv 6 23
tyicvos, rdu iradQv 16 7
eyKcvpLiaaTiKoi, \6yoi 1 1
e#ds, KaKu>u 33 3
idtXeiu, farju 8 20
eUibu, deov 27 16
eiXiKpivrjS 26 33 31 3
efj/ai : to el. 6 29 v. all'
eladyeiu, Xoyovs 4 19
eia-qyelixdai, pucros 17 24 a7d7r?7i> 22 14
eiaoudfrcrOai pass. 20 23 wed. ei's rt^a
de Deo 29 »
eKaara : Trap* e. 30 6
e/cacrraxoO 5 22
enarepwdeu 18 26
eKdeKT^ou 11 27
&ce? : 17 e*et 656s 2 29
ennaieiu infiammare 12 7
eKKrjpvcrcreiv, eavrov c. gen. 3 32
eKKdwreiu 18 1 22 21
eKKpep.duuvcrdat 2 29
exXeKTOt de Petro 17 3 raw e. eicXeKTOTe-
pot 27 8
esuiKau c. acc. rei 30 12
entropi^eiu 10 16
tKpifrvu, tl tluos 29 9
eKreXeiu 8 23 toj> (popou 17 4
enrlueiu 18 25 X^P"' 21 24
eKcpepecdai pronuntiari, dirXCos 5 35 reus
<puvai$ 17 21
AaiVetj/ exagitare 19 15 <'</mo ?fe/a 34 13
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 95/108
INDEX OF GREEK WORDS. 59
iXevdepovadat c. yen. 19 32
eWafXTTpvuecrdai 2 15
€/x(3a\\ea$ai, rrj yvuifxr) tt\v eXnida 3 27
rt tji ipvxv 28 28
ifxirodios c. gen. 18 4
ifxiropia 24 24
^/u.7rupos, /co \acu 25 20
£></>utos 12 8
eua\\d<T<rei absol. 5 22
iuSdxveiv, tov xaXti'di' 83 8
ivdelv : ouSei' ^. 7 19 to evteov 8 12
evSexerai wipers. 25 14, 19
^i/dW : ra £. KT-q/xara 26 8
evdoai/AOv : to i. Xa^elu 6 17
evdorepu) 20 29 e. roO 0eoO 21 29
ivdveiv, a,v6p<j)irov 27 30
ivepyua : /car' e. dia[3o\u<r]i> 19 14
evepyelu : 17 5id0e<ris to aur^s evepyel
12 3
euixvpof 19 30
frvofios 15 15
ivoiKew, (udov 26 3
e^bV ataoi. 24 8
t'j>oxXeto"0cu 24 12
^oxos c. rfaf. 29 9
evravda : -7 e. £w?7 2 28
il>T€T7]Khai 10 10
cptos : 6 e. ttXoDtos 26 6
ivvwapxeiv c. dat. 15 4
*|a0Xos 30 9
e^aL/j,a.aa€(rdai 19 21
i^alperos 9 23 to toC awTrjpos i. 8 17 rfe
Petro 17 3
i^aireiadai 2 10 26 25 35 15
t^airarq.v 26 5 eavrov 8 12 e£a7rarao-0cu
26 12
e^apyvpL^ecu, Tr\v ovoiav 15 3
^£777770-15 3 14 i'. apx^
t^7)yr]Tr]s 4 20
ei-l<XTa<xdai : eKo-TTJvat tt}s 65ou 33 7
££o5os : 77 (.vrevdev i, 4 9 ^tti ttJs e. 30 19
36 15
£i;OKt\\€ll>, irpos 30 8
i^o/jLoluxris 6 31
f.i;Opl£€lU 9 7
t £16X77? 34 7
ewalpeiv 1 14
tVaKTos, 7roXe/ios 19 .7
iwavdyeiu, itr' da<paXes 27 10 tVi rijp>
eKKK-qalav 35 15
iiravepxtoQa-1 4 12 21 22
tiravopdovv 36 5
evavrXeiv 2 1
tiraupaadai. .3 20 29 1
eireidrjxep 33 10
eireKTfiveadai 2 19
eire^afxaprdveLv 36 20
^7rt ?ToXXy 1 3 e?u /xeydXip pxadip 22 30
eVi X67V $0*775 9 11 penes eVi to; di/-
dpuTTii), ewl deep 8 6, 7 oi)k e7ri rots
e/CTOs r/ croiTrjpia 13 30
ewLpXeireiv c. ace. 37 2
ewifioXal, xetpujf 26 20
eTriftovXos 1 4, to 7-775 fw^s 21 8
eTrLyeios 3 30
e-rriyvucris 6 30
e-TTidaKpijeiv 34 5
eTridaxj/iXeijeadcu 22 27
eTTideiKvvixxi 5 23
e'?Tt5ei£is 36 16
tirideap-os 22 8
iirtdidovai, eavrov iri<XT€i 20 8 eavrov Xv-
rpov 27 33
eTTL^rjiuLios : Ta ^. 12 12 drjcravpbs e. 13 17
emdappelv, otl 31 27
ewiKrjpa, t& 3 23
einvoelv 21 27
iirlopKOS 30 18
eiri^evovadaL c. dat. 10 30
e7rt7rj'ws 28 8
e7ri7roXcu'ws 6 2
eiriirpocrdev, tlov xp tlfx<̂ TU}1' clwu 18 31
twippriTos : t6 e. toG ttXoutou 28 35
eirLcxeovpiihus 30 10
iiriaKOTros 32 6, n 33 16
iirndaffeiv C, ace. pers. ct iiijin. '2'2
iTTlTip.lOl>, to 25 20
tTriTpifieiv 14 17
^TTtTiryxaVftJ' 1 1
tTrt<pai>r)$ 3 8
iw6p.vvo$ai, d>s 86 1
tVon-ret'eiy 27 24
epydrrjs, vo/xov 7 28
fyryoy : oudec wpovpyov IS .4
t.pevvq.v 5 27
tp/j.r]i>(v$ 4 19
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 96/108
60 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
tpus, xpv^tojv 7 ij L kogixikoL 12 24 L
dypioi. 19 ig
&rw, oi 5 33
€T€p6<pda\/AO$ 19 I
ertpwdev 18 n
eroifios, K\rjpov6fxos 12 35 Xfiarapxos
33 12
eueKTet*' 14 9
etfe\7rts 15 35
e^Xdyws 25 19
evirddeia 7 26
evTroda 22 13
etfpuxTTos 2 17 33 7
evairXayxvla. 4 7
eiKXXVWttvr] 4 5
"E0e<ros 32 5, 17
eX^yvos 21 14
^X«": otf/c £. C. ?n/i«. 34 3 uio-irep dxev
34 13 ^xe<T^aL TV* yvibfx-qs 19 4
drjpaadai (Jiilicher Oeaatiai) 27 26
d-qparpov : to, toO Kocrfiov 0. 13 4
Orjcravpol, 8ittoI 13 10
0pavec0ai 26 22
0p^fx,fia }tov SiajSdXou 28 9
Td/cu>/3os 19 10
ida0ai 18 13 ras xf/vxds 2 13
i'Sios : i'. avrQv 8 8 i. tw {uvtuv 814 i'.
0eoO 9 22 to t'Stoi' proprio sensu 14 29
-ws 15 26
Te/)iXu> 22 2
'lepovaaXrifj. 22 2
i'Xews : t. ttj yvcifiy 12 32
iVos : e£ ?o"ou Ka0direp Kal 12 33 i'tra </(/v.
22 33 33 11
I'XJ'oj: /car 1. €ireo0ai 17 11
'Iwdi'j'T;? Apostolus 19 10 28 8 32 2 33 14
34 3, 18 Baptista 23 33
ZaKxatos 10 30
ZejSeScuos : ot ZejSeSaiou 7ra?5es 19 10
^eiJ' : opyr) ££ovo~a 7 13
^Xwtos 9 10
fa-fj, i) €vrav0a 2 28 de Christo 6 6 i)
ovtus f. 6 34 7/ avw f. 18 4
£wo7rotetV 9 23 14 6
7]dvjrd0€ia 20 27
TjXiKia 7 15 25 27 35 2 ct,7rd rrpdiTijs 7).
7 11
77X4.^ 33 2
i)ixipa : ra e0' ij/xepav 9 13
i)/xi0vrjs 22 4
7j^t7/j(.ei'ws 5 29
i]TTd(X0ai, TCL TOiaUTCL 17 2 i>7rd tij>os L8 33
0avarrj(p6pos 2 4 12 17
0ai/a.Tvva0at 22 19
0eaa0cu 27 26
0€o8L8aKTos, ttXovtos 15 24
0eoXoyia v. dpxv
0eoTroi6s, ttXovtos 15 5
0eoTrpeirr)S 27 6
0€OTri$ 24 21
0eo<piXr)s 9 16 25 20 26 16
0epa.Treiai 26 32
0r)X6ve<r0ai 27 28
K<t0apeveiv c. gen. 12 18
Ka0apoT7]% 14 20
Ka0apais, i) &Xr)0ivr] 37 4
Ka0€ipyi>6vai c. ace. rei 28 6
Ka0iivai, tov vovv eiri 6 3
/cd#o5os, 17 toO aurrjpos 9 19
Ka0virripeTeiv 11 15
Kafr 28 9
KatvoTiis : 17 k. t^j x»/°tT0S 7 1
KaKOTra0etv, irepl tt)v KTrjcriv 10 17
KaKOTTOUCL 18 1
Ka/xTTTeiv 20 30
KapTepia 25 8
KaTayytXXeiv 10 33
KaTayLvuxTKeiv, eavTOv 0o.vo.tov 29 10 c.
#ew. criminis 30 1
Ka.Ta.8iKaaTeov 21 8
Ka.Ta0pa.(njveo~0ai 3 n
KaTaiax^ue<J^aL e - p&Ttic. 36 18
/cara/cXaa^ai, r^ yvu/xriv 10 14
KaTaX-qxpLS 6 26
KaTaXi/xTrdveiv 27 34
KaraXX^XoraTos 6 6
KaTa/iav0dveiv 5 28
Ka,Ta£iovo-0ai c. gen. 20 27 26 12
Kara7rX77£ 15 27
KOLTawOVTlffTeOV 21 7
KaTappT]yvv<r0ai, tt)v eo~07)Ta 34 9
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 97/108
INDEX OF GREEK WORDS. 61
KaravTaais 14 ig
KaraaTpaTTTeadaL 15 21
KaraarpocpTfi : 77 k. tov SpdfjutTos 30 9
KaraTidtvai, ets kolvov 24 7 T7ji> xpvx^' 28 2
Ka,Ta<pCkeiv 35 14
Kara\pr}(f>l^eadai 29 4
/careXeeiadai 22 6
KaT€Tra8etP 35 17
Karepyd^ecrdat, doKifxacriau 19 26
KaripxeadaL de Christo 611 27 30
KaT7](p7jS 15 18
Kariivai'. koltiuv 6 Xoyos 17 28
KOLToiKetv, %v tlvl de Deo 27 5
KOLTOTTTpOU 17 15
KciTopdodadat. 31 4
Kavaiov 7 14
KeicoXa.o-p.evos modestus 14 13
K€vo8o^ia 9 21 10 4
K€(pd\aiov, tCov 8oy/j.a.T(i)v G 7 to k. adv.
19 34 7
KripvyixaTa, dyyeXiKa 4 12
Kivdvveuei 2 21
fcXrjpovofxos adj. 27 16
kXtJpos 32 7
KXrjpovv 32 8
kXv8uv : 6 /c. toD koo/xov 27 10
KOLvuvdv pauperthus dare 11 5 24 17
Koaravta liberalitas 10 19, 35 24 23
ko\o£ 1 2
Kopv<pai6raTos 6 22
Koafxe'iu, 7-771/ \f/vxvv 17 15
koo-/j.ik6s: 77 k. irepiovcia 12 1 «•. fywres
I224
k6o-(xos ornamentum 4 6
Kov(pi£eo~9ai'. vavs k. 26 19
K/t)dT7?re$ homines C. similes 9 21
KpeiTTwv, vwapxew rijs KTrjcrews 12 28 rd
KpeiTTOva. 10 15 e\7ris Kpeirrbviov 28 10
Kprjiris, £wr)s 6 27
Kpicns 1 9 77 SiKaia 10 32
KplT7)plOV 11 21
Kpuirrds: 6 k. Trarrjp 20 3
KTaadai, debv 6 26
KTrj/j-ara, earl KTTjTa. 6vra 11 8
KTrjre'ov 21 10
ktt)t6s 11 8 13 20
ktIvis, 77 Kaiy77 </e Christo 9 24
KvfUepvJirrjs 20 17 31 7
/ciAiv5e?a-^at 1 8
Kib\v/j.a 18 3
Xiyeadai : t6 6Y 5 XeXetcrai 21 5 6 toP
Kvpiov XeXeyp.i"vos 24 19
XfiToi'/ryftV 12 26
Aevei 10 30
AeuiT77j 22 5
Xycrrapxos 33 12
\r)0-T7)piOV 33 12
\idot, 8ia<pave?s 24 29
Xnraprjs 2 17
XiTavda 31 17
\6710j' : ra X. toO Kvpiov 3 15
Xoyiafios menu 12 3
X670S: to toO X. 1 16 17 8 X670J' Std'oi'cu
U7T^p Tl^OS 35 4 6 X. [77pU>T77TCu] 7Tfpi ToC
irarpi^ov X. 6 9
Xtfeti/, tV ctyvoiav 4 18
Xv/xabea-daL med. 10 7 jw/s.s. 19 16
Xtxro-pi' 19 19
Xorpwais 26 13 29 3
XurroSvata 33 4
fxayeveiv, tov irarepa 31 18
p.ddr)p.a : to. irpbs ttjv faty p.. 6 23
p.a07)p.aTLKQs 13 28
p.adr)TiKOS : yit. #761*' axoX-qv 8 26
p-aKaplfcadai 12 34
p.aKapios : 6 /i. N^rpoj 17 2
fxaKapicrrdi 13 22
p.aKpodvp.e'iv 29 25
fxavubdr)? 19 21
Mdp0a, Mapta 8 23, 27
Map/cos : rd et5a77Atoi' to Kara M. 5 20
Marflatos 10 30
/i67aXf?os : t6 /a. 3 32
/ue7aX«6T77s 37 7
iue7aXi/j/ecr0cu 2 s 17 8
fj.(dopp.lf€(r0ai 7 23
fjLedvwv, rats irtdvfdcus 14 u
/tetfoi'ws 33 8
/xeTaftoXr) 2 5
p.€TalTT)s c. gen. 9 13
yU^TClXXoJ' 13 6
p.eTa<pe"peiv 14 25
p.€Taxeipiffis 11 22
/J.€TOX(Tei'fll> 9 1
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 98/108
62 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
fierpe'icrdai, irpbs tl 27 32
/AT] ovk nisi 9 11 cum infill. 10 14
/j,iai(povu)TaTos 33 13
fxovy) 24 25
fMOVl/JLOS 2 19
fivdos 32 i
fxvcrTayojyeiv 3 19
fivarripLov 21 3 dye/cXaX^ra /x. 27 13 rd
7-77S a7d7r7;s /x. 27 23
/xvaTLKT], crocpia 5 25
fivw\p 19 20
Months 7 2, 5
yauXoxe"' 7 23
veoTTjcrios 7 14
yetfeu/, /cdrw 13 3
vedfxa 20 17
yewX/cetV, eavrbv 27 10
vecoari 16 2
vTj7rta infantes 23 26
VrjTTldTTjS 4 22
vncFTeia 35 16
vucrjcp'bpos 4 10
votjtos, wXovtos 15 24 I>. KTTjfXaTa 17 10
v6fju.fj.os: at v. evroXai 7 9
vofjodeaia, t) toO'It/ctou 7 31
vbanp-a 2 4 \pvx<-Ko\ v. 17 n
yous, 6 K€Kpvp.p.evos 5 27
viJKTWp 33 4
i-eviTeia 27 17
6/3oX6s: Tecraapes 6. 17 7
67/cos 2 2
OlK€l6TWS, 7] CapKLKT) 18 5
olKeiwcns 6 31 25 11
olKovofieladai : rd oiKovop.ovfj.eva 12 n
oiKovofila 27 17
6Xt7wpe«' 3 5
oKbicKnpos 19 1
b/xoiuo-is, deov 27 15
bfxovoelv 18 5 19 n
dv€ipoirb\np.a 19 18
bT\l^eadai 34 17 metaph. 26 16
5pyavov 11 11, 14
oplyeiv, 0ws 36 10 optyecrdai, t&v rr\eib-
vuv 19 19
6pe£is 10 9
bpi£eiv 12 30 24 23
0/3/xos 20 19
6'pos : e7rt tw ai)rcj o. 17 31
ovdevia, t&v fieXQiv 14 6
oiVia, 77 <pavepd 15 3
irayKT7}(Tia 19 31
iraiyviov, XP°V0V 24 31
TrcuScryuryi'a 7 29 .
7rat5ej^e<i' 6 u
Traidevfia 18 24
wcudevTripiov 26 2
7ra?s : 0eos 7r. 26 10
iraXiyyeveaLa 36 2
travrfyvpts 24 27
7rai'rd7ra(rii' 29 5
trapafioKiKws 15 32
7rapdyye\fxa: to it. ttjs farjs 8 iS
Trapddetyfxa 36 2
irapadveadai 12 22 21 29
irapaiTe'io-dai c. ace. rei 11 32 31 16 absol.
34 15
TrapaKaTadrjKV 33 16
irapaKaraTideadat 32 13 33 17
irapaKeladai suppetere 11 10
7rap&K\r)Tos 19 34
Trapafxerpe^adai 19 28
Trapafxvdeio-dcu 26 26
7rapairoWvvai 10 2
irapappdv : rd wapappeovra 28 6
irapaTapdaaeadai 8 24
wapacpvXaKr) 32 20
irapeyyvav 9 25
irdpepyov, aeicFfxov 24 31
Trapobevecrdai 22 4
Trdpodos, i} els Koap-ov 26 1
7rapot'xe<70cu : rd TrapipxV/J-^va 30 1
Trapopdadai 22 5
Tcapprfcria: it. dyeiv 7 20 iterd irapp-qcxias
2629
wapprjatd^eo-dai 31 8, 13
7rds: ^/c 7raj>r6s omnino 21 n
ndrtios 32 4
TraTpis 9 18 17 dl'W 4 II
TTClTpyOS, X67OS 6 9
ITaPXos 28 MTreSa^ 13 4
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 99/108
INDEX OF GREEK WORDS. 63
irelpav, davdrov Xap-fidveiv 18 22
ire'iravos : (f>p6vqixa ir. 7 15
Keireio-fxhos absol. 14 12 c. infill. 27 2
irepidyeiv 19 25 -eadcu 15 20
•nepidineiv 1 7
irepifidXXeadai med., irepipoXrjv 3 30 So^ay
8 21 j>O80. <rx^a TrepifiefiX-rinhov 25 30
TrepiftXyTos 13 20
irepiylveadat 3 22
irepiypdcpeiv 12 30
7repi5e77? 15 27
rrepieXKecrdat. uexari 8 24
wepUireLV 23 7
ir€pux e<JQaL c' P e>1 ' 16 4
jrepiKelcrdai, irpocrrjyopLav 27 7
vepLKOTTTeiv 23 7r. eavrbv c. gen. 12 7
irepiXanfidveiv amplecti 35 9
Trepifxeueiv c. infin. 24 12, 21 c. «cc. 2>^vs.
29 25
irepiovaia 12 34 dinitiae 1 10 77 Kocrp,iK7]
7T. 12 I
irepLTrcTrjs c. dat. 29 3
irtpLw'nrTHP c. dat. pel's. 25 18
TrepicTTaais, aKovaios 29 2
7repiT€tx^eo'^ai 20 11
irepupepeiv 12 29
irepuppovrjcns 10 4
Ile'rpos 17 3 19 9
7rt^tiJ', Xoyicr/x6v 12 3
wiaris: irpb rrjs ir. ante quam crcdidit
20 21
7r\aW: rd 7r. ftXeweiv 13 3
irXripupia 28 26 7r. yo/iov Xpitrros 7 32
7rX77<ri6xw/)o$ : rd 7r. 32 5
iroietadai, vav eavrou 23 9
7ro\t6s : tt)v yv<J}/J.T]v iroXubrepos 7 17
7ro\treia 2 18 30 1
7ro\fAeos 29 24
TroXvKTrjuuiu 20 7
iroXvirpayp.ove'iv 3 1
TroXvirpayfxcxjvvT) 8 29
7ro\i/<T7rXa7X'/os 29 24
7to\ut6\t7S 33 3
fl-o\t5x<> l'S 20 5
7ro\^xp^MaT°s 15 14 10 4
wd/xa, ddavaalas 18 22
irpeofieveiv 31 17
irpea^vTfpos : <Pp6yr]/j.a w. rod \pbvov
7 15 7T. rt #7«l' 21 24 SS iirloKOTTOS
32 17
irpeofivrris 34 5
jrpoayairaadaL 21 23
Kpoalpedis, dyadrj 8 20 irpoaipeo~ei 30 6
irpoap.apTdv€iv : rd TrpoyixapTrip.e'va. 18 25
30 5
irpoairavTq.v 30 10
irpo/3dXXe<rdai abicere 17 28
wpoyiveadai : rd irpoyeyevT)p.eva 29 28
TrpodeiKVvuai 3 19
irp6dr]\os, irXovros 15 22
7rpoet5eVat 13
Trpo'tecrdou dare 25 21
7rpoKadefecrOai, eKKXrjcrias 33 17
TTponaTaXapLfidveiv 34 8
7rpoKeta 'at 19 20 20 9
irpoKpivetv, t'l twos 10 5
irpb^evos, davdrov 20 29
Trpoopi^eadai med. 21 34
7rpo7rcu5eta 7 30
irpOTTLTTTeiV 37 1
irpoirovelv. rd irpoireirovr)fxiva. 9 3
irpdpptfa 9 28 22 22
7rp6s : 6 7r. aifACLTos 17 27 21 34 d5e\<pot
oi 7T. cu/xaros 19 30
wpoaayopeveiv 3 2
Trpoaaycjyfj, 17 tt}s eXirib'os 4 16
npoo-avaride'vai 2 2
7rpocra7ro5i56j'cu 30 17
Trpoa(3oXr), XriarCjv 20 21
irpoadei, ^wtjs 7 19
wpoabiaXiyeadai. 85 21 32
Trpoo~edl£eo-da<. 33 6
TrpoaeKxXrjaaeiv 1 13
TrpoaeTTiTeiveiu 10 3
Trpoa^x€ll/ TV" yv&iiriv 20 20
irpoo-qyopia 27 7
TrpoarjXvTOS 21 35
irpood-qKt) 10 35
Kpoaleo-daL 30 17
irpoo-Kad£$eo-6a.i, rrj X°LPlTL 8 3°
irpoaoxv 30 14
irpoa iroieTa6ai 1 3
irpbo~ra.yp.a 20 m
irpoaTeTrjK^vai 8 30
TTpoo-TiBi'vai. 8 16, 31
it poavirio'xvt'ioQai- JMM, 'J'29
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 100/108
G4 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
irpo<j(j>deip€<jdai c. dat. 33 2
TTpOTlfiq.U 31 20 36 22
irpoTptTrecrdai, rtva el's tl 9 1
jrp6<pa<Tis
261
irpO<p7jT7]$: 6 IT. TrpOCpTJTiOU 6 15
TrpocpyTiKos 6 16
n-poxelpcos 2 24 9 4
irpoxup&v 7 31
irpvTavis 20 1
irpwreta, t& 22 15
Trraleiv: ra eirroucrixeva 28 31
TTTCuviia 36 5
TTToia 9 8
7rTcD(ris 2 6
7rDp 67Tt 7r0p pL€TOX€T€V€l]> 1 16
TTvpovadcu 30 15
Trupwais 19 25
peireiv 20 7
p-qaeis, tQv \bywv 35 16
pTjTct, rd 4 21
pvd/xifav, T7)t> xpvxvv 17 15
craXeuetv ad ancoram consistere 7 22
0-d\7rt7£, i<Txo-T-q 4 8
"ZafxapeiTrjs 22 5
crapKLKos 18 5
adpKiPos 15 11 -ws 5 25 13 30
aapidov 26 7
<ra<f>rivi<r[x6s 20 5
<T€UT/JI.6s 24 31
<n)IAaiveadcu 9 26
(Trjfxeiou, to crux Christi 7 7
(TKCUWS 13 29
(TKa(f>i8iou 15 30
(T/ce7rdfc«', yvpcubv 10 27 rd eaKeiraa/xha
c. dat. 6 1
CKiprrj/xa, veorrjcnov 7 14
07ci;\ei5ecr0cu 26 22
cr/A&paySos 24 29
Gofiapos 31 5
(TO0ia 16 12 0eia 5 25 I'e/cpd 9 20
0-iradq.v 10 11
a-rrip/xa, tt?s fw^s 9 10 to o\ de Christi-
anis 27 15, 21 o\ toO KcuV 28 9
(T7r\d7X,/0,/ ^^ 27 ^ IO *^ T 9 Ta ""• ®-V0L ~
yvbvoa. 25 26
(TTO.bl.OV 4 9
CTpaTid 36 19
GTpaTLWTlKbv 34 9
o-T{)(p€Lv
absol. metapk. 318
crvyKevTeiadai telis confodi 22 3
o-vyKpoTeTis, \rjo~Tripiov 33 12
o-iryxw/)"" c. ace. 11 23 afrso/. 17 1
o-v^ijv 10 10 36 14
crvKocpavTeTadai, xpVIJ-aTa 34 2
0-1AAO777, /ca/ci'as 14 21
<Tv/jLJ3d\\et.v, top Xbyov interpreter* 17 5
-eadai 4 14
avfj./x€Tpe?adaL 2 18
o-v/unradeia 9 8
av/xTradrjs : to ets T^yuas o\ ^eoO 27 27 -us
2627
avfjLTTo\iT€ij€0'dai, deu) 20 32
o-vfuptpecrdai 18 4
crvfKpCjOvia 5 23
o-vvayecrdcu 27 21
o-vvayuvifaadai 35 16
cwaSi/ceii' 189
avvaipeadai 2 9
Gvveib'evo.i, eaurois 15 35
cru;>ei56s, r6 4 10
crui'e7rd7ei»> 33 5
ffvveiriirveiv 16 16
avvkx^v secum habere 32 18 -eo~0at con-
stare 27 21
(tup777000s 19 34
o-vurjdrjs 31 18
avpdrjKr} 28 4
o-Ovd-nfjia tessera 20 18
auvoiKos 25 1
(Tvvovaia, 7) ttjs fjLeravoias 10 13 o\ /xa/cpd
25 7
o-iWopos : irpo<TTdy/xaTa o~. 26 23
o~iJVTpo<pos: iiridvfxiai a. 12 4 rd 0*. 18 2
7rd0?7 o\ 31 1
avvuxpeXelv 12 10
0WKeud£e(r0cu 22 7
o~vcrTa\7)vai contrahi 16 17
<r0aXep6s 24 -ws 7 22
o~<ppayis baptisma 29 3 33 1
o"X^/ia 25 30 26 5
oxoM}, /j.adr]TiKif) 8 27 ^ ets \670us 9 20
ra/itas, £"an}s cUtavlov 6 20
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 101/108
INDEX OF GREEK WORDS. 65
Tdfueueadai 28 6
rd£ts: i) t. rrjs farjs 15 18
reXevTcjv mori 32 4
Te"Xos: rb r. avrb tt)$ cnoTrjpias 5 36
T€Tpcx)fj,ei>ai, i/svxaL 22 26
rex^i/cos, -ws 11 12
rr\v aXXoos 9 n
T7?£iS 31 13
TOVTO fxh...TOVTO M 2 10, 12
rpiada/j.evos 29 7
irpbiraiov 36 3
rpbiros : 6vwep rpbirov %x€L ^ 22 fctrd
roi^ clvtov t. 1427
/card rpbirov rite
15 14
rpocpevs 18 21
rpocpr) 4 4 o'lKeia r. irvpbs 24 30 rpcxpal
3 28
rpvcpr), 7] evravda 36 21
rtipavvos 24 31 32 3
rvcpos 2 I
vfipio-fAa, rvpdvvov 24 31
iryei'a 22 28 31 11
u\?7 materia 11 10 12 2 7/ u. tt}s ica/cias
12 8
vireivat : rd virbvra irddr) 9 28
virepdyav : 7/ u. eindvixla 9 8
virepaaird^ecrdaL 7 25
virep(3dXXet.v : 77 virepftaXXovaa rrjs (ppovr)-
crecos virep(3oXrj 5 32
virepeiridvfxelv 16 14
vireprjcpaveiv 27 13
vTrepKocr/Juos 18 14
inrepXa/uLirpos 7 12
uirtpoyKa, rd 8 16
virepbwTOJS 25 27
virepovpdvios: u. Siavofas fiddos 6 2 v. irai-
devfxara 18 23 u. dfxireXos 28 12
virepo\pia 10 3
virepairovSd^eiv 8 8
virep(ppove?v 1 16
i>ir£xeLV iT<* a,TOt ^6 x 5
vw-qpiTtis ddiKlas de pecunia 11 16
U7rr//3ert/c6s : rd u. 12 7 rd 6. oxacpidia
15 30
viro(3dXXecTdcu, naddirep vXtj tls 11 10
viroypdcpeiv, eXirida tlvI 21 13
virbdecns, r) rod evayyeXiov 6 12
B.
VTTOK€?adai 1 9
VTTOKVTTTeiV, reus &>ro\cus 20 14
viroXeiiretv 2 28
virbvoia 20 5
viroirLiTTeiv 3 12
vttoar)/Active iv 4 8
VTrocpe'peo-dcu 29 4
vcrrepelv c. gen. carere 10 29 11 12
v\j/ovcr9ai 2 4
(paidpbs 36 8
(patvofievov, t6 9 25 21 4
tpeidb/ievov, ws (Segaar (pei8op.evios) 24 15,
0^/oe 21 12
<p9dveiv c. infin. 30 20
(piXaXridcos /cat (piXadiXcpcos 3 10
(piXavdpcoiria, i) rod deov 3 33
cpiXavOptoTroTepos 2 7
cpiXodupLa 24 20
(piXoKe'pdeia 3 13 19 14
(piXraTOi, oi 17 24
(pXiyecrdcu 19 20
(pXey/xaLveiv 12 3
<pope iv 13 7
(poprlov 2 2
(ppdfciv: (ppdcrov absol. 18 31
(ppvdcraeadai 8 16
(pvXa.KTr)piov 32 20
(pvXdcraeadac, fxvr)/j.7j 32 3
(piori^eiv 2 13 baptizare 32 19
Xapt£€o~8ai : rd axd/wra 1 4 r£ nbo-pap
TrdvTCL 2 27 beofxe'vois 4 17 7rr(i>xor?
9 18 ab.soZ. 16 18
Xawoui' 1 11
Xopyybs adj. £ojr)$ alwvlov 15 6 flayaroi'
20 28
xpeta 33 14 ratio pecuniae utendae 10 3,
ai x- (?woe °P"S *w«* 11 T r - 0«w. qpu«
cs* 30 i 4
XpVfxard (art xpMwa ovra 11 8
Xpr]criy, 17 dfieivtov 11 24
Xupeiv c. ace. 8 14
Xwplov in libro 24 19
\J/ev8o/AapTvs 30 17
\f/evdu)vv/j.os 14 28
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 102/108
6(3 CLEMENT OF ALEXANDRIA.
^70os 18 27<bic6fu>pos 20 2
^
i^iXos 22 22wf : 6 oVrws c3y ko.1 ra ovra 8u)pov/j.ei>os
^i;Xt/f6s: t<x ^. 7rd07? 11 28 xp. poarjfxaTa 6 28
]7 IO (jjveiadai 24 24
wpa: irpb wpas 33 1
*&5keu> 12 23"s <*" c
- Partic -ut 2wi 15 26
cambbidge: pbinted by j. and c. f. clay, at the univebsity pbess.
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 103/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 104/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 105/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 106/108
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 107/108
U t>
©
©> TJ•H ^
© U•H <tf
55
E OF MEDIAEW
VISLEV PLAi
-
.
O 6, CANADA,
267?
8/4/2019 Barnard. Clement of Alexandria. 1897.
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/barnard-clement-of-alexandria-1897 108/108