Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ®...

23
Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes Sanjoy Kundu MD, FRCPC, RPVI, FCIRSE, FSIR

Transcript of Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ®...

Page 1: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

Bard Life Stent ®& The RESILIENT Trial:

Two-Year Update of Outcomes

Sanjoy Kundu MD, FRCPC, RPVI, FCIRSE, FSIR

Page 2: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

3

LifeStent® Vascular Stent System

• The LifeStent®Vascular Stent is intended for primary stenting of de-novo or restenotic lesions of the peripheral arteries.

• Up to 170 mm length

Page 3: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,
Page 4: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

5

LifeStent® offers Multi-Dimensional Helical Architecture

Page 5: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

6

How Does Multi-Dimensional Helical Architecture Address SFA Forces?

Page 6: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

RESILIENT: What does it mean?

A Randomized Study Comparing the Edwards Self-Expanding

LifeStent vs. Angioplasty-Alone In LEsions INvolving The SFA

and/or Proximal Popliteal Artery

(An FDA approval protocol)

Page 7: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

LifeStent® NT Self-Expanding StentHelically-Designed, Nitinol Self-Expanding Stent

Sizes Used in the Study

Diameters Lengths6 mm 40, 60, 80 mm7 mm 40, 60, 80 mm

Delivery System Used in the Study

®LifeStent is a registered trademark of C.R. Bard, Inc. or an affiliate.

1st Generation Coaxial System

RESILIENT: Study Device

Page 8: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

RESILIENT: Trial Overview

• Lesions: SFA and/or Proximal Popliteal Artery• Lifestyle-Limiting Claudication: Rutherford Category 1 – 3• Lesion Length: <15 cm • Test Device: LifeStent® NT Stent & Delivery System

PTA Control n = 72

LifeStent®n = 134

• 43 PTA Only• 29 Bailout Stents*

*Intention-to-Treat Analysis: Bailout stents analyzed as randomized

206 Randomized Patients - 24 Sites (U.S. & Europe)

Page 9: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

RESILIENT: Baseline Demographics

p-valueTest Group(Pts. =134)

Control Group(Pts. =72)

RutherfordCategory:

Control

Testp=0.10 ˆ

35.8%

41.7%

61.2%

50.0%6.9%

3.0%

Rutherford 1 Rutherford 2 Rutherford 3

1.00 #0.88 #0.09 #0.49 #0.14 #0.11 +0.53 ˆ

83.6%91.7%Hypertension

38.1%38.9%Diabetes56.0%54.2%Coronary Artery Disease71.6%83.3%Smoker (current / quit past 6 mo)

78.4%73.6%Hypercholesterolemia

68.4 ± 9.9 66.1 ± 9.2Age, (years) µ ± S.D.70.9% / 29.1%66.7% / 33.3%Male / Female

^ = Chi Square Test+ = t-test for Equality of Means# = Fisher´s Exact Test

p=0.17

Page 10: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

p-value+Test Group(Lesions=153)

Control Group(Lesions=81)

Characteristics(mean± S.D.)#

PTA Group LifeStent® Group

p=0.44 #

Lesion Calcification†

60%

32%

8%

none/mild moderate/severe no data63%

35%

2%

† = Core Lab Analysis+ = t-test for Equality of Means# = Fisher´s Exact Test

RESILIENT: Lesion Characteristics

Mean Lesion Length (per pt.): 6.4 cm ± 4.0 7.1 cm ± 4.40.33

0.490.64

72.7% ± 17.674.5% ± 18.2Lesion % Diameter Stenosis5.2 mm ± 0.85.1 mm ± 0.7Target Vessel RVD

Page 11: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

Bailout Stenting

• Data from the bailout stenting cases were included in the Control Arm (as randomized)

• Bailout stenting was considered a target lesion revascularization (TLR) & patency failure:– Immediate need for additional intervention, and– Loss of flow (residual stenosis > 30% after repeated inflations)

• The need for bailout stenting was confirmed by:– Angiographic core lab and clinical events committee

(93%), or– Study site documentation in two patients (7%)

Page 12: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

Bailout Lesion Characteristics*

Mean Lesion Length (mm). Mean Lesion Length / Patient (mm)

52.0 ± 38.2 70.5 ± 44.3

47.7 ± 32.6

70.3 ± 38.8

p=0.05+ p=0.001+

61.8 ± 42.5

p=0.27

p=0.17

82.8 ± 37.8

* = Site Reported + =Statistically Significant

Bailout lesions were significantly longer than the PTA-only lesions

Page 13: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

Bailout Lesion Characteristics

Lesion Calcification

PTA Only Bailout Stent

68%

23%

9%

none/mild moderate/severe no data

45%48%

7%

31.0%

48.8%9.8%

3.4%

Bailout lesions tended to be more heavily calcified than the PTA-only lesions

Page 14: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

Bailout Patient Characteristics

Rutherford Classification

PTA Only

Bailout Stent 31.0%

48.8%

61.2%

39.5%9.8%

3.4%

Rutherford 1 Rutherford 2 Rutherford 3

Bailout stenting patients tended to have more severe claudication than the PTA-only patients

Page 15: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

96.3% (131/136)

LifeStent®

Group

.0087#85.5% (59/69)Lesion Success†(%)

residual stenosis < 30%

p-valuePTA GroupMeasure (per lesion)

95.8% (114/119)

LifeStent®

Group

.0092#

p-value

83.9% (52/62)Procedure Success†(%)

residual stenosis < 30% andno peri-procedural complications

PTA GroupMeasure (per patient)

†Core Lab Analysis: 119 test and 62 control patients had angiograms that could be evaluated by the core lab

# Fisher´s Exact Test; p-values based on two-sided test

RESILIENT: Peri-Procedural Results

Mean Stented Length: 9.9 cm (± 5.0)

Page 16: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

Target Lesion Revascularization (TLR): “Clinically-driven” repeat intervention of the target lesion

Major Adverse Clinical Event (MACE): Death, stroke, MI, significant distal embolization, emergent surgical

revascularization of the limb, thrombosis, and Rutherford category worsening post-procedure.

Patency: DUS Peak Systolic Velocity (PSV) ratio < 2.5. Failure of primary

patency is a TLR or restenosis greater than 50% (PSV > 2.5).

Clinical Success: An improvement of baseline symptoms by at least one Rutherford

category and sustained through follow-up (with no additional intervention).

RESILIENT: Endpoints

Page 17: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

24 Months

Kaplan-Meier Survival Analysis; p-value from log rank test

0

20

40

60

80

100

12 Month 24 Month

PTA

LifeStent

45%

87%

42%

78%

RESILIENT: Freedom from TLR 24m

p<.0001 p<.0001

Page 18: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

24 Months

Kaplan-Meier Survival Analysis; p-value from log rank test

RESILIENT: Freedom from MACE 24m

0

20

40

60

80

100

12 Month 24 Month

PTA

LifeStent

86% 86%82% 79%

p=.91 p=.60

Page 19: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

24 Months

Kaplan-Meier Survival Analysis; p-value from log rank test

0

20

40

60

80

100

6 Month 12 Month

PTA

LifeStent

47%

94%

37%

81%

RESILIENT: Primary Patency*

*Ultrasound Data Not Recorded Beyond 12 Months

p<.0001 p<.0001

#Primary patency: Continuous blood flow through the treated area assessed by duplex ultrasound (DUS):

Page 20: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

3.8%

11

MMMMMP--

MMMMD

Locations^

Type IType IIType IIIType IV

Fracture Type

3 of 5--

4 of 6

Lesion Moderate -

Severe Calcification

6--5

Total0-18

months

4 of 6--

1 of 5

2 or more overlapping

stents

Fracture Rate#

Fractured Stents

0-18 months

* Per Core Lab Analysis at 6, 12, & 18 Months^M=Mid SFA; D=Distal SFA; P=Popliteal

6 of 6--

1 of 5

Stent Elongation at deployment

# fractures / 287 stents evaluated by the angiographic core lab

Stent Fractures: 18-Month Analysis*

0-12 months

9

3.1%

Page 21: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

24 Months

Fisher’s Exact Test; p-values based on two-sided test

0

20

40

60

80

100

12 Month 24 Month

PTA

LifeStent

32%

72%

24%

68%

RESILIENT: Clinical Success

p<.0001

p<.0001

#Clinical Success: Sustained improvement of a least one Rutherford category above the pre-treatment value. Also, a repeat intervention was considered a loss of clinical success.

Page 22: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

• “Longer” and/or “more calcified” lesions

did not respond sufficiently to a PTA-only strategy:

The bailout stenting rate in the Control Group was 40.2%

• A low fracture rate: 3.8% at 18 months

Observed fractures may be partially explained by elongation of the stent at deployment.

A “One Stent” strategy is recommended when possible.

RESILIENT: Study Observations

Page 23: Bard Life Stent - Canada Vascularcanadavascular.com/Lifestent_Kundu_CIRA.pdf · Bard Life Stent ® & The RESILIENT Trial: Two-Year Update of Outcomes. SanjoyKundu. MD, FRCPC, RPVI,

RESILIENT’s Level 1 evidence illustrated:• In claudicants with SFA/ proximal popliteal lesions < 15 cm, primary

stenting with the LifeStent® Self-Expanding Stent was superior to a PTA-only strategy

At One Year: evidenced by primary patency & freedom from TLR

At Two Years: evidenced by freedom from TLR & sustained clinical success

The LifeStent® Self-Expanding Stent did not lead to a higher rate of Major Adverse Clinical Events than PTA alone

• A PTA-only strategy has a role in patients with less complex lesions (e.g., shorter, less severely calcified)

RESILIENT: Study Conclusions