B ROADBAND USA CONNECTING AMERICA’S COMMUNITIES Digital Inclusion CAIs and the Digital Divide...

BROADBANDUSACONNECTING AMERICA’S COMMUNITIES

Digital InclusionCAIs and the Digital Divide

Schools, Health and Libraries Broadband Coalition Conference

Washington D.C.

May 7-9, 2014


2

Introduction

Session #1: 2:15 – 3:15 p.m. Panelists:

– Jon Gant, Professor and Director of the Center for Digital Inclusion (CDI) at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

– Helen Milner, Chief Executive of Tinder Foundation

– Karen Mossberger, Professor and Director of the School of Public Affairs at Arizona State University

Session #2: 3:45 – 4:45 p.m. Panelists:

– Samantha Becker, Research Project Manager at the University of Washington Information School

– Rodney K. Hopson, Professor, Division of Educational Psychology, Research Methods, and Educational Policy, College of Education and Human Development at George Mason University

Setting the Context– Laura Breeden, Program Director for Public Computer Centers and Broadband Adoption,

NTIA/OTIA– Francine Alkisswani, Telecommunications Policy Analyst, NTIA/OTIA


3

Setting the Context: Background and Rationale for Meaningful Metrics

The idea for the Meaningful Metrics initiative originated from discussion after the evaluation session at the 2013 SHLB meeting.

Concerns: – What are the appropriate metrics for assessing and evaluating BTOP (and other ICT)

projects? – How can we develop a common set of definitions and lexicon to discuss broadband

adoption, access, applications, acceptance?

Issues: – Future metrics must go beyond the BTOP NOFAs so that terms and definitions achieved

through consensus and operationalized with meaningful metrics can guide future program design, implementation and evaluation.

– The initiative should be meaningful to the research and evaluation community, community stakeholders, practitioners, funding organizations and policymakers.


4

Why NTIA?

As part of its larger mission, NTIA can begin and promote this initiative because:– NTIA is the Executive Branch agency principally

responsible by law for advising the President on telecommunications and information policy issues

– NTIA is vitally interested in grounding policy in good data– BTOP evaluation reports, data collection methodologies, data

collection instruments, state broadband plans and mapping data serve the nation as rich and valuable resources to facilitate the expansion of broadband communication services and infrastructure


5

Meaningful Metrics will be a collaborative effort by NTIA, external stakeholders and other Federal agencies

NTIA has started discussions with evaluation practitioners on next steps– The Metrics Affinity Group discussed the advantages and disadvantages of metrics

standardization and potential next steps for the project– The group also discussed the necessity of a framework to guide the resources, activities,

outputs and overall goals of the Meaningful Metrics project

Webinars – NTIA is conducting a series of webinars designed to stimulate discussion around the use

of common terminology and the development of common metrics for research and evaluation of BTOP projects.

– Webinars provide a forum to discuss approaches to measurement and review the data and tools created, collected and analyzed as part of BTOP projects, as well as other resources in the field


6

NTIA’s Meaningful Metrics project aims to develop common metrics to advance future evaluation for policy and practice The affinity group identified an urgent need to define metrics so that digital divides may be

identified and addressed promptly and effectively– The current state of data collection is fragmented and limited by the definitions of the

2009 legislation– Concepts and units of measure should be clearly defined and operationalized, to include:

digital divide, impact, broadband adoption, broadband, types of people impacted, and areas of use (e.g., education, health, employment, social, small business)

– People’s use of technology and the Internet to improve their lives—jobs, health, finance, small business development, etc.—should be measured over time


7

The common metrics can be developed from existing reports and research

The basis for common metrics for broadband deployment, adoption, and use, and associated short- and long-term social and economic impacts, can be supported by BTOP grantee evaluation reports– At closeout, many BTOP grantees submit final evaluations that use a variety of data

collection instruments that measure and analyze different aspects of broadband use and adoption

– As a leader in information and communications technology (ICT), NTIA can collaborate with BTOP grantees and other external stakeholders to build consensus around metrics that will later inform research and evaluation around future programs and policy


8

The Meaningful Metrics logic model outlines the resources, activities and products needed for project implementation


Introduce Speakers


10

Samantha Becker

Current: Research Manager for the U.S. IMPACT Study at the University of Washington Information School

Primary focus areas: How people use public library computers and other technology, and how new adult users gain the skills to use information and communications technology

Prior experience in public policy research, serving as a lead investigator for evaluation projects, and facilitating productive dialogue between diverse stakeholders

MA, Library and Information Science and Public Administration, University of Washington


11

Jon Patrick Gant

Current: Professor at the Graduate School of Library and Information Science at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and founding Director of the Center for Digital Inclusion (CDI)

Primary focus areas: Internet access and use, broadband adoption in minority communities, and digital literacy

Prior experience with e-government, geospatial information systems, strategic planning, and information systems

PhD, Public Policy and Management, Carnegie Mellon University


12

Rodney Hopson

Current: Professor, Division of Educational Psychology, Research Methods, and Education Policy, College of Education and Human Development at George Mason University

Primary focus areas: Educational evaluation, culturally responsive evaluation/assessment, and the role of culture and cultural context in evaluation

Prior experience in educational foundations and leadership, qualitative research, and as the 2012 President of the American Evaluation Association

PhD, Curry School of Education, University of Virginia; post-doctoral/sabbatical studies, University of Namibia, the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health and Centre of African Studies, and Cambridge University


13

Helen Milner

Current: Chief Executive of Tinder Foundation, a UK social enterprise and staff-owned mutual

Primary focus areas: Education and online learning

Prior experience in developing internet education content and services for children and schools, online education in Australia and Japan, and helping to create learndirect – the UK online learning network

MA, Public Policy, Claremont University


14

Karen Mossberger

Current: Professor and Director of the School of Public Affairs at Arizona State University

Primary focus areas: Digital inequality, e-government, information technology and civic engagement, local governance, and urban policy

Prior experience with the multi-year evaluation of the Smart Communities BTOP program in 9 low and moderate-income Chicago neighborhoods, a 5-year citywide study to track changes in technology use across Chicago’s community areas

PhD., Political Science, Wayne State University

B ROADBAND USA CONNECTING AMERICA’S COMMUNITIES Digital Inclusion CAIs and the Digital Divide...

Documents

Transcript of B ROADBAND USA CONNECTING AMERICA’S COMMUNITIES Digital Inclusion CAIs and the Digital Divide...