Avoiding the Dangers of Linear Thinking? - MITweb.mit.edu/psgleadership/pdf/1_required_reading/China...
Transcript of Avoiding the Dangers of Linear Thinking? - MITweb.mit.edu/psgleadership/pdf/1_required_reading/China...
Partha S Ghosh
Avoiding the Avoiding the DangersDangersof Linear Thinking?of Linear Thinking?
A Strategic PerspectiveA Strategic Perspective on on China & China & The World in the 21The World in the 21stst CenturyCentury
Partha@ParthaGhoshPartha@ParthaGhosh
May 5May 5thth 20072007
Partha S Ghosh
Pearl River DeltaHK,Macao,Shenzhen, GZ
Bohai Delta:Tianjin, Qingdao, Dalian
Yangtze River DeltaShanghai, ZheJiang,JiangSu
Pockets of metropolitanAreas in Western China
The Real Challenge
The Challenge: How to use the power centers for the development of new economic models
enabling distributed wealth Creation ?
Partha S Ghosh
How do you sense the “State of Health” of our Planet?
Increasing Significance of China
Partha S Ghosh
Global Population 650 Years = US today: 300M
Note : Each dot represents 1 million peopleBoston Analytics Research1. “Energy Consumption and Sources of Renewable Energy”, Amitabh Lath, (www.physics.rutgers.edu/~lath/Piscataway_2003.ppt)
Partha S Ghosh
Population Hundred Years ago : 1,600 Million
Note : Each dot represents 1 million peopleBoston Analytics Research1. “Energy Consumption and Sources of Renewable Energy”, Amitabh Lath, (www.physics.rutgers.edu/~lath/Piscataway_2003.ppt)
Partha S Ghosh
The Recent Past, 20 Years back 5,000 Million
Note : Each dot represents 1 million peopleBoston Analytics Research1. “Energy Consumption and Sources of Renewable Energy”, Amitabh Lath, (www.physics.rutgers.edu/~lath/Piscataway_2003.ppt)
Partha S Ghosh
And Near Future 2020: 8000 Million
Note : Each dot represents 1 million people Boston Analytics Research1. “Energy Consumption and Sources of Renewable Energy”, Amitabh Lath, (www.physics.rutgers.edu/~lath/Piscataway_2003.ppt)
Partha S Ghosh
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
1980 1990 2003 2010 2020 2025 2050Boston Analytics Research1. Energy Information Administration (http://www.eia.doe.gov)
World Carbon Dioxide Emission in Million Metric Tons(1980 to 2050*)1
Mill
ion
Met
ric T
ons
Slow Pace of Dangerous Change : CO2 emission
65 Billion Tons by 2050
Year
Partha S Ghosh
-16,184
-8,415
-8,053
-804
-661
211
1,538
-20000 -15000 -10000 -5000 0 5000
Annual Change in Forest Area (000 ha per year) 1990 to 2005)1
Boston Analytics Research1. “Extent of forest resources”, (http://www.mongabay.com/deforestation.htm)
Annual loss of Forest land 16.2 Mn Hectares
Asia
Europe
Oceania & Australia
North & Central America
South AmericaAfrica
World
Partha S Ghosh
• Loss of vegetation
• Decrease in no. of species
• Increasing infestation
• Decrease of pollinators & seed dispersers
• Loss of human diversity
• Less CO2 taken in
• Burning Trees adds even more CO2
• Less photosynthesis takes place
• Increased risk of fire
• Soil Erosion
• Increase in Flash Floods
• Aquatic Habitat Degraded
• Flow of Water Changes
• Less Oxygen in the waterways
Dynamics of Deforestation and Ecology: Require Repurposing our Knowledge
DEFORESTATION1
ATMOSPHEREHYDROSPHERE
GEOSPHERE BIOSPHERE
Boston Analytics Research1. “The Choice: Doomsday or Arbor Day”, (http://www.umich.edu/~gs265/society/deforestation.htm)
Partha S Ghosh
The Essential Points:
1. Indeed Challenging & Interesting times ahead
Partha S Ghosh
Changing Ecology
Finite Resources
Increasing Sea Level
65 Billion Tons of CO2
Rising Temperature
Increasing Population
Powerful Forces at Work?
Equity
Deforestation
Partha S Ghosh
Changing Ecology
Finite Resources
Wall Street Expectations
Increasing Sea Level
65 Billion Tons of CO2
Rising Temperature
Increasing Population
Powerful Forces at Work: Clash of Perspectives?
Digitization requirements
Equity
Deforestation
CO2
Partha S Ghosh
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000 40000 45000GDP / Capita (US$)
Ene
rgy
Con
sum
ptio
n (‘0
00 K
WH
r / C
apita
)
Energy Consumption per Capita vs. GDP per Capita (2004)1
Boston Analytics Research1. Energy Information Administration - EIA (http://www.eia.doe.gov/)
Most of the world is still in the early stage of Economic development
Ukraine
Russia
US
Kazakhstan Czech Republic
Malaysia
TurkeyBrazil
RomaniaThailandChina Egypt PhilippinesIndonesia
India
Italy
FranceGermany
UKJapan
Canada
80% of Global Population
Partha S Ghosh
Overview of Energy Scenario
685565473391288Total230198173153139Other Asia
5143372820South Korea119108999179Japan142102745428China143114906522India
20252020201520102001Country
(In BCM)
Future Natural Gas requirement of Asia
Partha S Ghosh
The Essential Points:
1. Indeed Challenging & Interesting times ahead
2.Emerging Economics must make the difficult choice: Adapt or Advance?
Partha S Ghosh
R2 = 0.8631
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000 40000
Old Path or New Path: Time to Choose?
Plastic Consumption per capita in Selected Countries vs. GDP per capita (2003)1,2,3
Boston Analytics Research1. http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=story_11-9-2003_pg5_122. Poland and its investment opportunity – BCG Report3. http://www.eia.doe.gov/
SingaporeGermany
Canada
JapanUS
Malaysia
ChinaIndia
Thailand
IndonesiaPoland
Hungary
Developing and Moderately Developed
Countries
Highly Developed Countries
GDP per capita (in US$)
Plas
tic C
onsu
mpt
ion
per c
apita
(in
kg)
Partha S Ghosh
Cleary we are at the End of a Long Era?Pr
oduc
tivity
of S
ocie
ty
Economic Development Curves
Industrial Revolution 1 (Steam Engine)
Industrial Revolution 2 (Internal Combustion
Engine)
Information Revolution
Low
High
Time
2005 ~2010
Mega Challenge = Managing a Mega Transition to avoid Mega disruption
Era of Extraction & Mono dimensional Value Creation
• “Unconstrained” Processing of Earth’s resources• New Relationship of Space & Time• Supply to Fuel Unidirectional Demand
Next Era Paradigm?
Role of Emerging Economies?
1350 20501900
1. Concentrated Economic Growth
2. Ecological disequilibrium
3. Complex Politics of Supply Chain
2005 ~2010
Partha S Ghosh
Holistic Approach?
Renewable and Clean Energy
SourceEnergy
Ecology Equity
Holistic Approach
Energy ,Food and Health for All
Sustainable Economic Developed
PROBLEMS ≈ OPPORTUNITIES
Partha S Ghosh
Scope of the Field?
Point Solution
Industry’s Future (?): Two Strategic Vectors
Perspective?Holistic/Integrative Solution
Conservation driven
Consumption driven
Future Business Models
Balance?
Bal
ance
of E
colo
gy
Balance of Economic Advance
Partha S Ghosh
Expanded Field?
Point Solution
Industry’s Future (?): Two Strategic Vectors
Perspective?Holistic Solution
Conservation
Consumption
Future of Business Models
Balance?
Today
Bal
ance
of E
colo
gy
Balance of Economic Advance
Systems Approach to Energy & Transportation Management
New Chemistry for the Car
Recycling of Waste
Agro based Chemical Industry
Carbon Free Energy System
Lighter Products
Process Intensification
Recycling
Improved functionalities
Partha S Ghosh
Stage 3: Market Driven
Stage 3: Market Driven
15001500 17001700 18001800 19001900
Stage 2: Resource DrivenStage 2: Resource Driven
oWealth CreationoBrand Creation
Raja Ram Mohan Ray
European Renaissance
Chaitanya MahapravuSocial Reforms
In search of Raw Materials•Cotton•Minerals
20002000→→
Historic Perspective is necessary: 2500 of Globalization
500 500 BCBC
Silk Road
Merchants of Venice
Stage 4: Skill, Scale, ScopeDriven
Stage 4: Skill, Scale, ScopeDriven
Stage 5:Digitization Stage 5:Digitization
Sources of Competitive Advantage
Colonization Decolonization
Empowerment Neo-Renaissance?
Stage 1: Venture-Trade DrivenStage 1: Venture-Trade Driven
Partha S Ghosh
The Essential Points:
1. Indeed Challenging & Interesting times ahead
2. Emerging Economics must make the difficult choice: Adapt or Advance?
3.China is an unique position to lead the Paradigm Shift?
Partha S Ghosh
China’s Unique Status?
World:Approaching Limits
US/EC victims of significant momentum & Aging
Negative trade balances
Concentration of Oil & Gas Wealth
China:New level of Confidence
Possibilities of early stage growth
Rapidly Increasing Financial Power
Relevance of Ancient Wisdom
Partha S Ghosh
R2 = 0.578
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000 35000 40000
Perc
enta
ge o
f Lab
or F
orce
in
Agr
icul
ture
GDP* per Capita ($)
JapanUSUK
CanadaGermanyFrance
Italy
MexicoMalaysia
BrazilSouth Africa
ChinaIndia
Indonesia
Pakistan
Nigeria
Bangladesh
Boston Analytics Research1. Energy Information Administration (http://www.eia.doe.gov)2. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (http://www.fao.org/)3. “World Bank list of economies, April 2006”, World Bank (http://www.worldbank.org)
Percentage of Labor Force in Agriculture Across Various Countries v/s GDP per Capita (2003)1,2,3
Note : * Real GDP with base year 2000
Countries with high GDP per capita and low % of labor force in agriculture: G7 Countries
Countries with low GDP per capita and high % of labor force in agriculture:
Upper-middle income countries and Lower-middle income countries (Brazil)
Opportunities to create new Economic Model
Mega Challenge = Managing a Mega Transition to avoid Mega disruption
Era of Extraction & Mono dimensional Value Creation
• “Unconstrained” Processing of Earth’s resources• New Relationship of Space & Time• Supply to Fuel Unidirectional Demand
Multi Multi –tier Strategic Initiatives
1350 20501900
1. Concentrated Economic Growth
2. Ecological disequilibrium
3. Complex Politics of Supply Chain
2005 ~2010
Partha S Ghosh
The Promise of Chemical Industry has to be applied in Multiple Scales
Scal
es o
f Eng
agem
ent
Holistic /Tera Scale Perspective
Microscopic Perspective
Three Scales of Knowledge Application
Large Scale Systems Dynamics Issues •Global Ecological Balance ?• Energy Balance ?• Social Structures ?
Raw materials
Cellular /Nano Level functionalities
Tera Scale
Current Scale
Micro Nano Scale
1. Efficiency 2. Conservation
3. Recycling
1
2
3
Partha S Ghosh
Upstream Downstream
Biotechnology
Information Technology
10011000101110
Process Industry Reconfiguration
New technologies could indeed trigger a New Era
Nano Technologies
Opto Technologies
Partha S Ghosh
Large Scale Engineering systems thinking is essential
The Virtual Power PlantAggregates the output of thousands of micropower technologies Peak shaving becomes power trading on the wholesale marketCoordination and control through a new communications infrastructure
Residential
Rooftop PVs
Fuel Cells
Reciprocating engines
Stirling Engines
BioEnergy
PV Array
CommercialMicroturbines Fuel Cells
IndustrialReciprocating enginesMicroturbines
Transmission andDistribution
Wind Farm
Fuel Cells
Partha S Ghosh
Basic Mechanisms of Solar Energy Conversion1
Boston Analytics Research1.”Global Energy Perspective”, Nathan S. Lewis, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA
Solar Energy has the potential to address our growing energy needs in an environmentally-friendly way
LightFuel
Electricity
Photosynthesis
Fuels Electricity
Photovoltaic
H O
O H
2
22
sc M
e
sc
e
M
CO
Sugar
H O
O
2
2
2Semiconductor/Liquid
Junctions
Partha S Ghosh
Equipment Efficiency vs. Equipment (2004)1,2,3,4,5
Boston Analytics Research
Equipment efficiency?Eq
uipm
ent E
ffici
ency
Equipments
Thermodynamic Efficiency=100%
35% improvement
20% improvement
10% improvement
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
LightingDevices
IC Engines AirConditioners
Heaters Boilers
Partha S Ghosh
0100200300400500600700
2025 2025
15.2
Reduction in energy intensity could reduce world energy demand by 14% to 20% in 2025
World Energy Demand in Quadrillion Btu (2025)1 :If Energy Intensity is Reduced in Selected Regions
Projected Energy Demand
Reductionin India
Reductionin China
Reductionin WesternEurope
Reductionin US Projected
Energy Demand afterReductionAssumptions:
•Energy intensity is reduced by 35% for India and China•Energy intensity is reduced by 20% for Western Europe (WE) and US
10.3 38.2 26.5
Qua
drill
ion
Btu
554.8645.0
Partha S Ghosh
Macro Socio-economic
Macro Socio-economic
Multiple Perspectives is necessary “Synthesize Perspectives
to be Effective“Synthesize Perspectives
to be Effective
MarketMarket
Need to understand the "Big Picture“ to
deal with the “nuts & bolts”
perspectives
Need to understand the "Big Picture“ to
deal with the “nuts & bolts”
perspectives
Cultural & Environmental
Cultural & Environmental
Historic/Geo Political
Historic/Geo Political
TechnologicalTechnological
Partha S Ghosh
Last 5,000 Years… …..Future Possibilities..
Economics of Economics of Linear Linear MechanicsMechanics:: Extraction, Extraction, Exploitation & ExperimentationExploitation & Experimentation
Economics of Economics of Closed Closed Loop HarmonyLoop Harmony
Knowledge for Knowledge for Recovery/RecycleRecovery/Recycle
New Technologies
AgroAgro
Energyand PowerClean Clean
WaterWater
Bio MassBio Mass Solar , Wind Solar , Wind Fuel CellsFuel Cells
BroadbandBroadband Clean EnergyClean Energy
Partha S Ghosh
Five Point Agenda:1. Emphasis on original thinking to advance progress of
civilization as opposed to extension of Western Models
2. Develop Village centered Economic models with heavy use of Convergence, Bio Engineering and new Systems thinking
3. Use China’s success with Land and Manufacturing productivity to think of new avenues of Knowledge Productivity (Boston Analytics story)
4. Develop universal approach to Geo potential issues building on Ancient wisdoms – Holistic approach to problem solving
5. Renew education system to enable Next Renaissance