Austrians back to Austria

24
Bringing the Austrians Back to Austria Remberto Latorre-Artus

description

Austrian School of Economics

Transcript of Austrians back to Austria

Page 1: Austrians back to Austria

Bringing the Austrians Back to Austria

Remberto Latorre-Artus

Page 2: Austrians back to Austria

Main Contributions

Subjective Theory of Value

The Marginal Revolution

Business Cycle Theory (Capital-Based Macroeconomic Theory)

The Economic Calculation Problem

Page 3: Austrians back to Austria

The underlying causes behind:

The Great Recession

The European Sovereign-Debt Crisis

The Euro Crisis

Page 4: Austrians back to Austria

Questions (Audience chooses):

Will the Fed lose monetary policy sink the US dollar?

Will the Euro survive Portugal, Italy, Greece and Spain sovereign-debt crises?

Should Germany Lead or Leave!?

What is the Austrian recipe?

If Mises and Hayek were alive today what would they recommend? (And where do they differ?)

Page 5: Austrians back to Austria

What is the Austrian paradigm?

It places individuals at the center (purposeful actions of individuals)

Marginalism.

Incentives matter.

Solution based on Human Action (not Human Design) and thus,

AE is down to earth, easy to understand and based on common sense.

Page 6: Austrians back to Austria

How to understand the global crises?

Macroeconomic Propositions have Microeconomic Foundations

Austrian Business Cycle Theory (Capital-Based Macroeconomic Theory)

Böhm-Bawerk built upon the TIME PREFERENCE ideas of Carl Menger there is always a difference in value between present goods and future goods of equal quality, quantity, and form. Moreover, the value of future goods diminishes as the length of time necessary for their completion increases.

Austrian Economics understand that “K” is never homogeneous.

Inter-temporal consumption.

Page 7: Austrians back to Austria

How to understand the global crises?

*This is the key insight of the Austrians: you cannot pretend to massage Aggregates and expect a perfect “trickling down.” Instead, if you interfere, you will create market distortions.

What distortions? Mainly interfering with the market signals of the price system (Supply and Demand for Money).

Therefore, booms and bust cycles are NOT a normal feature of a market economy

Page 8: Austrians back to Austria

Money Market

The market process plays itself out differently depending upon whether the increased supply of loanable funds derives from increased saving by individuals or from increased credit creation by the central bank.

Page 9: Austrians back to Austria

And the Proof is in the Pudding:

Page 10: Austrians back to Austria

And the World follows suit:

Page 11: Austrians back to Austria

The most dangerous: Toxic Assets

Page 12: Austrians back to Austria

Moving to the Crises

The Great Recession

The European Sovereign-Debt Crisis

The Euro Crisis

Page 13: Austrians back to Austria

The Great Recession

Page 14: Austrians back to Austria

The European Sovereign-Debt Crisis

Page 15: Austrians back to Austria

Source: Jagadeesh Gokhale, Measuring the Unfunded Obligations of European Countries Policy Report No. 23 January 2009, National Center for Policy Analysis

THE TRUE DEBT OF EUROPE(Official + Pension + Health + Welfare; as % of GNP)

Greece 875%

France 549%

United Kingdom 442%

Germany 418%

Italy 364%

EU 25 434%

Page 16: Austrians back to Austria

Youth Unemploymen

t in Europe

German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble warned that failure to win the battle against youth unemployment could tear Europe apart, and dropping the continent's welfare model would spark a revolution. (Reuters, May 28, 2013)

Page 17: Austrians back to Austria

The Euro Crisis

Page 18: Austrians back to Austria

The Euro Crisis

Page 19: Austrians back to Austria

Conclusions

Market intervention creates “white noise” distorts real signals (masking agent)

Market intervention creates Moral Hazzard “Too big to fail” Too big to Jail

Market intervention creates backward Social redistribution Privatize the profits and socialize the losses (the poor pays the rich)

Page 20: Austrians back to Austria

Conclusions

The Keynesian “Trickling Down” solution doesn’t work in the long-run.

Injecting liquidity to help jump-start the economy offers the phony appearance of prosperity, which makes things all the worse (instead of a mild recession we get depressions).

Page 21: Austrians back to Austria

The Austrian Recipe:

Stop the Madoff Scheme (QE) right now, before it’s too late!

Allowing an organic correction, i.e. allow markets to do the job and liquidate malinvestments.

Allow people to figure out where are the sectors of the economy starving for new resources.

It is people (risking their own capital, and using information closer to them and the signals of the price system) who can figure out better where, how and in which ways the new money should go. 

Page 22: Austrians back to Austria

The Austrian Recipe:

There is no non-arbitrary way for a central planer to figure all this out on his own.

Trust in the power of Human Action vs Human Design.

The private sector has a lot to be blamed for, but they reacted to incentives emanating from the central authority and thus…

…Don’t blame the pig, blame the one scratching his back!!!

Page 23: Austrians back to Austria

Panel Discussion